Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When Your Role Has Grown
Transcript
- Lucas: So a Gartner survey from earlier this year found that 60 percent of employees say their responsibilities have expanded significantly in the past two years without a corresponding change in title or pay. That's a huge number. Luna: Sixty percent? That's basically the majority of the workforce. And I bet most of those people are quietly frustrated, not sure how to bring it up. Lucas: Exactly. And the default instinct is either to stay silent and hope someone notices, or to walk in and just say 'I'm doing more, I deserve a raise'. Both are risky. The key is to frame it as a market adjustment based on actual role change, not just 'working harder'. Luna: Right. So how do you do that? What's the first step? Lucas: First, you need to document what your role actually looks like now versus what you were hired for. I mean literally write down your original job description—bullet points—and then a parallel list of what you're doing today. Include specific projects, scope, any managerial duties, revenue impact, cross-functional work. Luna: So you want to show a gap, not just complain. That makes sense. Lucas: Exactly. Then the second step is to benchmark. Look up what similar roles at other companies pay for that expanded scope. Use sites like Levels.fyi or Glassdoor, but also talk to peers if you can. You want a number that reflects the market rate for the job you're actually doing, not your current title. Luna: And if your company doesn't have a formal title for that hybrid role? Like a designer who also manages the project? Lucas: Great point. You may have to invent a composite title. For example, 'Senior Designer with Project Management Lead'—then find benchmarks for both components and average them. The goal is to be reasonable and data-driven. Luna: So you've got your evidence and your market number. Now how do you actually start the conversation with your manager? Lucas: You schedule a dedicated meeting—not a drive-by chat. Say 'I'd like to discuss how my role has evolved and talk about compensation alignment.' Then in the meeting, open with appreciation: 'I really enjoy the work and the new challenges. I want to make sure my compensation reflects the value I'm bringing now.' Then show your comparison. Luna: And what if the manager pushes back and says 'We don't have budget' or 'That's not in your job description'? Lucas: That pushback is common. If they say 'no budget', ask when the next budget cycle opens and what you can do between now and then to strengthen the case. If they say 'it's not in your job description', you can gently point out that you've been doing it for months or years—and it's clearly valued because they haven't asked you to stop. Luna: So you're basically saying: the job description is outdated, not the work. Lucas: Exactly. And if they still resist, you may need to consider whether it's time to look externally. But let's be honest—most managers want to retain good people. They just need a structured argument to take to HR or leadership. Luna: I'm thinking of a listener story. A graphic designer wrote in—her role expanded to include project management, client meetings, and even some strategy work. She prepared exactly the way you described, documented everything, and asked for a 15 percent raise. She got it. Lucas: That's great. And 15 percent is substantial. But what was the key? She didn't just say 'I'm busy'. She showed that her role now matched a 'Creative Project Manager' title which paid more. She made it easy for her boss to say yes. Luna: Another thing: timing. When's the best time to have this conversation? End of quarter? After a big win? Lucas: Ideally, after you've delivered something tangible—a completed project, positive client feedback, a metric improvement. That gives you leverage. But don't wait forever. If your role has been expanded for more than six months, you're overdue. Luna: You know, Lucas, I think a lot of people are afraid they'll seem greedy or ungrateful. Especially in this economy. Lucas: That fear is real, but it's misplaced. Asking for fair compensation isn't greedy—it's professional. And the data is on your side. If you're doing more, you should be paid more. It's that simple. Luna: And that's exactly why we do this show. We give straight advice without any fluff or hidden agenda. Lucas: Yeah, we deliberately keep these episodes ad-free. If you find this kind of practical advice useful, you can support that choice at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It helps us keep the show independent and focused on what matters to you. Luna: Absolutely. Even a small contribution goes a long way. Now, back to negotiation tactics—one more point I want to ask about: what if your manager is new and doesn't know your full scope? Lucas: Great question. With a new manager, you have to educate them first. Don't assume they know what you've been doing. Schedule a 'role orientation' meeting—lay out your history, your expanded responsibilities, and then make the case. Frame it as 'I want to help you understand the full picture so I can continue to deliver value.' Luna: So it's almost like onboarding them onto your value. Lucas: Exactly. And if they're still hesitant, ask for a three-month trial with specific milestones. If you hit them, then you revisit the raise. That shows confidence and good faith. Luna: All right, let's wrap with a quick checklist. Step one: document your current role vs. original job description. Step two: benchmark market pay for that new role. Step three: schedule a meeting and present your data. Step four: handle objections professionally. Step five: if no go, consider next steps. Lucas: Perfect summary. And remember, you're not asking for a favor. You're asking for fair market value. If your company values you, they'll find a way. If not, you know where you stand. Luna: Good luck out there. We'll be back tomorrow with another question. Lucas: Until then, keep growing your role and your worth.