Latest / Her Journey: Real stories of women, courage & change / The Awkwardness of Reconnecting With an Old High School Crush | Her Journey
Transcript
- I stared at his name in my phone contacts and realized I had no idea who I was supposed to be when I finally typed hello. It started with a notification. Just a simple ping, the kind that usually means a package delivery or a spam email, but this time it was a message from someone I haven’t spoken to in fifteen years. His name popped up on my screen, and for a second, I didn’t recognize it. Then the memory hit me like a wave of warm water—the smell of floor wax in the hallway, the specific shade of blue he wore to our junior prom, and the terrifying, electric silence between us when we stood too close by the lockers. We weren’t together. We never really were. But in the high school ecosystem, we were close enough to matter, close enough to leave a mark on your nervous system that decades couldn’t quite erase. Now, sitting here with my lavender tea cooling beside me, I’m staring at those three words he sent: 'Hey, long time.' And I am paralyzed. Not because I don’t want to reply, but because I have no script for this. Who am I to him? And more importantly, who is he to me now? There is something profoundly disorienting about reconnecting with someone from your past, especially a crush. You carry these two versions of them in your head simultaneously. There’s the boy or girl you knew at seventeen—fragile, hopeful, maybe a little awkward, full of potential and fear. And then there’s the adult they’ve become, a stranger wearing the face of someone you used to know intimately. When I look at his profile picture, which I couldn’t help but click on out of sheer panic, I see lines around his eyes that weren’t there before. I see a life that happened without me in it. A career, maybe a marriage, definitely a collection of choices I didn’t witness. It feels like walking into a house you used to live in, only to find strangers living there, rearranging the furniture, painting over the walls you once leaned against. You feel like an intruder in your own history. That’s the first layer of the awkwardness. It’s not just social anxiety; it’s existential vertigo. You’re trying to bridge the gap between the person you imagined him to be and the person he actually is, and the space in between is vast and quiet. Let’s breathe through this. Because underneath the awkwardness, there’s often a sharp, hidden fear. The fear that the magic was real back then, but it was just chemistry and proximity. Or worse, the fear that it wasn’t real at all, and I’m projecting a fantasy onto a stranger. I remember thinking about him for years after graduation. In college, when things got hard, I’d imagine what it would have been like if I’d said something different at that party senior year. If I’d stayed longer, if I’d laughed louder, if I’d just asked him for one more dance. Those little moments became anchors in my mind, weights that kept me tied to a timeline that never existed. Reaching out feels like cutting those anchors. It risks turning a beautiful, safe fiction into a messy, complicated reality. What if he’s boring? What if he’s rude? What if he remembers me as the girl who tripped over her own feet during the talent show? The stakes feel impossibly high, even though logically, we are just two adults sending text messages. But emotionally, we are standing on the edge of a cliff, looking down into the pool of our younger selves. Then there’s the performance. We spend so much time curating our current lives, trying to present a version of ourselves that is put-together, successful, and calm. When you reach out to an old crush, you can’t hide behind the filter. You have to send a plain text. No Instagram story, no subtle hint in a podcast mention. Just words. Raw and direct. I found myself drafting and deleting messages for an hour. 'Hey! How are you?' Too casual. 'Long time no see!' Too cliché. 'I saw your post and thought of you.' Too intimate, too revealing. I wanted to sound cool, like I hadn’t spent the last week obsessively refreshing his social media feeds. I wanted to sound like someone who moves through the world with ease, not someone who is slightly terrified of rekindling a spark that might just fizzle out into polite small talk. That pressure to perform adulthood is exhausting. We forget that everyone else is also faking it. He’s probably staring at his phone, wondering how to start, worried that he’s reaching out too soon, or too late, or too weirdly. We are both just people, hoping not to be rejected by a ghost. But here is where I found the surprise. When I finally hit send, and he replied, it wasn’t fireworks. It was… nice. It was mundane. We talked about work, about the city we both still lived in, about how fast time moves. And slowly, the armor came off. The awkwardness didn’t disappear, but it transformed. It became a shared language. We were both admitting, implicitly, that we were stepping out of our comfort zones. And in that shared vulnerability, there was a strange intimacy. It wasn’t the fiery passion of adolescence, but it was a deeper, more grounded connection. I realized that I didn’t need him to be the romantic ideal I’d built in my head. I just needed him to be present. To listen. To be human. That’s where the growth hides. In the realization that you don’t need to recapture the past to appreciate the present. You can let go of the fantasy and enjoy the reality of another person who has also changed, also struggled, also grown. The crush fades, but the curiosity remains. And that curiosity is a gift. If you are currently staring at a phone screen, heart pounding, wondering if you should send that message, please know that you are not alone in this shift. We all have these ghosts. They sit in the corners of our memories, waiting for us to acknowledge them. Maybe it’s a friend you drifted away from. Maybe it’s a mentor who inspired you. Maybe it’s a lover who left without explanation. Reaching out is scary because it requires us to accept that we are different now. It requires us to admit that we are not the same people who made those mistakes, or had those dreams. But it is also brave. It is a declaration that we are still capable of connection. That we still have something to offer, and something to learn. So take the breath. Type the words. Send the message. Whether it leads to a new friendship, a closed chapter, or nothing at all, the act of reaching out is a victory. It proves that you are alive, that you are open, and that you are willing to risk a little bit of awkwardness for the chance of a little bit of truth. Thank you for sitting with me today. Take care of that heart of yours. Until next time.