Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Reporting Psychiatrist, Splitting, Labor Rights, and Gilmore Girls
Transcript
- 0:00Heyes. Ever, listeners, I thought I would answer some patron emails.
- 0:04This first email is from Middle Tier anonymous patron. She says, my psychiatrist
- 0:10recently attempted to initiate a sexual relationship with me. Yikes. You've talked a
- 0:17lot about what it looks like when a psychologist is crossing the line, but
- 0:22in this case, I have a very explicit, very graphic expressions in writing
- 0:28about what he wanted. Okay, just chiming in here. Yeah, I
- 0:32talk about a crossing line or boundary violations or boundary crossings, but I've also
- 0:38made episodes in which clinicians mental health clinicians have had sex with their clients or
- 0:45tried to have sex with their clients. It's been a little bit of an
- 0:50odd theme that I've had throughout the years on this podcast, going back many
- 0:54years, and very alarming to me. I think it's in part because it's
- 1:00a problem, obviously, but there's not a lot of places that people can
- 1:03go when they have these experiences because of a lot of reasons. I think
- 1:08one is that there's a general stigma against therapy in general, right, and
- 1:12so people don't necessarily want to come forward with even acknowledging that they're in therapy
- 1:18at all. Of course, that's changing in recent years, but it's still
- 1:22kind of a problem at least, and probably more of a problem in some
- 1:23communities. Also, people don't necessarily know what to do, and there's not
- 1:30a lot of talk about this, so a lot of victims of this won't
- 1:34know where to turn and where they are told to turn, even if they
- 1:38remember being informed about this or were informed about it. Are the licensing boards,
- 1:44and those in licensing boards aren't there necessarily to emotionally take care of the
- 1:49victims. They're there to take the report and do something about it, and
- 1:55they might take months, if not years to do anything about it, very
- 2:00good at necessarily communicating with the victims, and a lot of the licensing boards
- 2:04don't know what the fuck they're doing and don't do anything, So there's not
- 2:08a lot of options for people. And I imagine other clinicians who are online
- 2:15can sometimes become these lightning rots or this sort of thing, and we just
- 2:22need to raise awareness if this happens at times it's not usual, but it
- 2:27does happen, and that they deserve to get help and they deserve to have
- 2:32a safety net or some sort of group of people that will be able to
- 2:37support them as they go through it. Years and years ago, I created
- 2:39a Facebook page called Clients Harmed by Therapists I believe something like that, and
- 2:47I was advertising it as a place for people who were harmed by therapists to
- 2:53congregate and to talk about their experiences and their feelings. And it was a
- 2:59closed group, meaning that you had to apply to get in right and over
- 3:05the years it grew, you know, kind of slowly over time, but
- 3:08eventually it just got to be too much for me to manage, and so
- 3:12I handed it over to admins and cut complete ties from the Facebook page.
- 3:22But occasionally the admins, who are doing wonderful work and are very wonderful people
- 3:30to volunteer their time, are doing a lot of work to keep it a
- 3:35place that is safe for people to come forward, you know, to look
- 3:38at the applications of people coming in. You know, it can get very
- 3:43hard to talk about these kinds of things, and it can be very fraught
- 3:47with a lot of issues. So I guess I'm saying that this is a
- 3:54big issue, and Patroon, I'm just so sorry that that happened. I
- 3:59mean, it's such a violation. We hand ourselves over in so many ways
- 4:04to our mental health clinicians, and to have someone violate us, I mean,
- 4:10to be violated like this from anybody is traumatic, but to be violated
- 4:15by someone that has been given the mantle of authority and of care that we
- 4:21give these people like myself. For those people to violate that, and for
- 4:27the system to fail the client such that someone like this could be trained or
- 4:31allowed to be this way is it's very upsetting. So I'm sorry it happened
- 4:35to you. Going on with your email, it threw me for a loop
- 4:41because I feel like this is a recurrence of past issues that I have with
- 4:46older people in authority, And I admit I probably didn't respond in the negative
- 4:50as forcefully as I should have initially, just chiming in here. Well,
- 4:59I wouldn't feel bad about yourself. I hope you're not beating yourself up about
- 5:02that. There are a lot of reasons why a client wouldn't respond in the
- 5:08negative as you put it. One is intimidation or confusion. Another is is
- 5:13that you might actually want to entertain it right. There might be some level
- 5:16of well maybe maybe I don't know what your situation was, but at the
- 5:23very least you know that you're in danger and the clinician has a lot of
- 5:30the privilege and power. Oh, that's another reason why it's a problem.
- 5:33It is because when it comes down to a debate or an evaluation as to
- 5:41who's telling the truth, whether you know it is the client telling the truth
- 5:44or is the mental health clinician telling the truth, A lot of time society
- 5:46and licensing boards and the justice system will believe the clinician over the client,
- 5:51particularly if the client has some sort of diagnosis, right, And that's a
- 5:57problem, right that it's a further of the oppression of clients and people with
- 6:02disorders that is very, very unfair. So I don't know your situation,
- 6:09but I wouldn't blame yourself for not responding forcefully right up front, because that's
- 6:15not usual that people will do that because of the reasons I was saying going
- 6:19on with email. But after a week or two, I cut off contact,
- 6:23and I transferred my prescriptions to my primary care physician and I found a
- 6:27new therapist. I'm going to spend some time trying to figure out how it
- 6:30is that this particular situation seems to come up seems to be coming up for
- 6:35me. So I'm not sure what you're saying there, Patron. And you're
- 6:40saying that this sort of thing happens to you occasionally, I'm not sure.
- 6:45But going on, however, I'm not sure what I should do about my
- 6:47ex psychiatrist. I wish I was the kind of person who could gather enough
- 6:54outrage to report him, but I really really don't want to do anything about
- 6:58it. I feel a shame, aim and guilty that I even left the
- 7:01door open for such overtures. I know, I know, you always say
- 7:06that it's not the client's responsibility, but still, and it's not like I
- 7:12didn't know better. I'm middle aged and I've been around the block multiple times,
- 7:17just jumming in here. Well, yeah, Patron, so you know
- 7:21that I'm going to say it's not the client's responsibility because it isn't the client's
- 7:26responsibility. It is a very firm principle of treatment. The ethical codes do
- 7:35not apply to the client. They apply to the clinician. Now, of
- 7:41course, as a client, you can't break the law. For example,
- 7:44you can't like shoot your therapist. There are, you know, is a
- 7:46line regarding your behavior. But the line is very broad, or the range
- 7:54is very broad for a client. You know, I've had clients full on
- 7:57hit on me sexually, not physically, but they will proposition me, and
- 8:03that is fine. I'm not excited about it. But if a client is
- 8:07going to do that to me, now, I'm a man, so I
- 8:09have the privilege of being able to not feel terrified in a situation like that.
- 8:16But that is not against the rules. It's fine. If a client
- 8:20wants to do whatever they want to do within a certain broad range of options,
- 8:26then that's the material that the client is providing me. There's a reason
- 8:30why the client is doing it. There is a clinical reason for these things.
- 8:35Now, the clinician is supposed to keep an eye on themselves and have
- 8:41training in supervision. I mean, it didn't come out of nowhere, in
- 8:43all likelihood for the psychiatrists. It's not like it was. You know,
- 8:48it didn't go from seed to sapling to tree in one session. It probably
- 8:52was something that was growing over a long period of time. And for this
- 8:58clinician to just let that happen without any guardrails, without any uh, you
- 9:05know, measures taken, which in all likelihood were not taken because they usually
- 9:09aren't. Is you know, abhorrent and completely against the standard of care.
- 9:15So when we look at your psychiatrist's behavior versus yours, I mean you're saying
- 9:20that you just weren't particularly negative about it. But then you say shortly after
- 9:24that that you you quit after one or two sessions. But even if you
- 9:30hadn't quit after one or two sessions, I wouldn't blame you or think of
- 9:33you as as even you're not even zero point one percent of the problem.
- 9:37Is the is the thing. So even if you were entertained, you know,
- 9:41you say, I feel ashamed and guilty that I even left the door
- 9:45open for such overtures. I don't want to break you, patron, I
- 9:50feel like I am, but leaving the door open, I mean, so
- 9:54for me, if I had a client who quote unquote left the door open
- 9:58for me to have sexual overtures with the client, what does that even mean?
- 10:05I mean, what a client I don't know, dresses a certain way
- 10:09or is entertaining certain boundary violations? You know, if I were to text
- 10:16a client at nine pm at night and then my client tech. You know,
- 10:20if I text something friendly like I say, oh I just saw Star
- 10:26Wars did you see it? And then the client says, oh, I
- 10:28saw it too, I liked it. I guess you could argue that that's
- 10:31quote unquote leaving the door open. The client is leaving the door open for
- 10:35me to text more. But that is not the client's problem. That is
- 10:41the fucking therapist problem. And like, even if you were to convince me,
- 10:48patron, that you were like actively seducing this psychiatrist, that is still
- 10:52not your responsibility. It is the clinician's responsibility. To be a therapist is
- 10:58a very very high responsibility on so many levels, and we have systems to
- 11:05help us with that responsibility. We're not on our own. We have training,
- 11:09we have research, we have colleagues, we have consultants, we have
- 11:13supervisors. There's resources, and if someone doesn't avail themselves of that, then
- 11:18that is on them and not on you. So, okay, going on
- 11:24with your email, do I have an ethical responsibility to do something? Right?
- 11:28So you are asking that you don't want to report it, and so
- 11:31you're asking do I have an ethical responsibility? Again, you have no ethical
- 11:35written. Now, if we're talking about just general human ethics, then I
- 11:39think what you're asking is do I have a moral slash ethical slash societal responsibility
- 11:48to report this psychiatrist, such that the psychiatrist might not be able to do
- 11:54this again, or if there are other reports, maybe they need one more
- 11:58report in order to take action against this psychiatrist. And what I'll say to
- 12:03that is, no, you do not have a responsibility to do something if
- 12:07you don't want to. I guess you could argue that if there weren't any
- 12:11kind of barriers to you internally or externally to reporting, then you could argue
- 12:18that, well, it would be a greater good for society if you did
- 12:24make that report. But the way you phrase it, I really really don't
- 12:28want to do anything about it. I don't know why you don't want to
- 12:31do it, but I can imagine a lot of reasons why you wouldn't want
- 12:35to do anything about it. It's a pain in the ass. You potentially
- 12:37have to see them again. There could be a court hearing down the line.
- 12:41You might have to write out a report. You might have to make
- 12:45public statements in front of random people like judges and lawyers, that you might
- 12:48be cross examined. You might take action, and then nothing happens that your
- 12:54psychiatrist could bring up things against you that you don't want to be out there.
- 13:00I mean, there's a lot of reasons why you wouldn't want to report,
- 13:03so you know it. But if there isn't any kind of concern along
- 13:07those lines, then yeah, I suppose someone might say that, but in
- 13:13no way what I fault anyone. In fact, most people don't report for
- 13:18a lot of valid reasons. And the problem is is that we have a
- 13:22society that will punish victims and situations like that through the system. Right,
- 13:26you know, the things that I said that could happen to you, like
- 13:31cross examination and that kind of thing is a part of the systems such that
- 13:37it punishes victims, right in the same way that people who are assaulted by
- 13:43a police officer or a teacher or even their own spouse or something. There's
- 13:48the elements in the system are punishing of victims. Now, there are certain
- 13:54elements of the system that need to be in place, like a legal hearing
- 13:58and this kind of thing. But there are things that can be done to
- 14:01protect victims, like allowing them to write a statement or allowing them to respond
- 14:07maybe to cross examination in writing or something instead of having to be on the
- 14:13stand, Right, I don't know, but there are things that they do,
- 14:16like with children. For example, during hearings involving the parents, they'll
- 14:22have the kid be questioned on videotape and then the videotape will be presented in
- 14:28court. Right, there are things you can do. But do I fault
- 14:33you for not doing anything? No? Absolutely not. You're the victim.
- 14:35You went through something horrific that you might be dealing with for the rest of
- 14:39your life. Even though you say that you've been around the block a few
- 14:43times. You also say you got out relatively unharmed, which I'll take your
- 14:48word for that. You say you know I got out relatively unharmed. What
- 14:50you know? Again, I'll take your word for that. I'm not gonna
- 14:54say that you're not accurate there, so I'll take you. But you say
- 14:58you know, do an ethical responsibility to do something though? Or can I
- 15:03just move on with my life? Yes? Would I be complicit in any
- 15:07future indiscretions if I don't do anything? No, you're not complicit. If
- 15:13and when he does anything in the future to another client or anyone else for
- 15:16that matter, you are not an accomplice to the crime. And this line
- 15:22of thinking is driving me fucking nuts. By the way, the amount of
- 15:26public blaming and shaming of people today is just out of control. I have
- 15:33been targeted recently about things that you could imagine what those would be, and
- 15:37I just want to tell everyone, like, I'm just a human being,
- 15:41and you, Patron, are just a human being. You're just trying to
- 15:45live your life, and there are consequences to taking action. It's not easy
- 15:50necessarily to take action, and everyone needs to just stick to their own lane,
- 15:54you know. I don't shame other people for not taking action and situations
- 16:00like this, you know, or in other kinds of public discourses. I
- 16:04just think everyone has to figure it out for themselves. And now should we
- 16:11all think about our social responsibility, absolutely, including in situations like this,
- 16:15like Patron is mulling over. But this automatic notion that somehow, by not
- 16:22reporting, you're an accomplice or complicit or you're a part of the problem.
- 16:26I just things are more complicated than that. People sough. So no,
- 16:33Patron, you're fine. In fact, you're golden. You're the victim,
- 16:41and you don't have to do shit. And if anyone or any internal voice
- 16:47tells you otherwise, tell that voice or that person to go to hell.
- 16:51All right, take a break, all right, back from the break,
- 16:56let's do an opp These people became patrons all the about in twenty twenty one.
- 17:02These are all monthly deserving listeners. We have Christine from Columbus, Ohio.
- 17:07JS from Delonco, New Jersey, Danielle from Detroit, Michigan, Marcel
- 17:14from the Netherlands, John or Jan from Escondido, California, Elba from Eugene,
- 17:19Oregon, Stephanie from Illinois Gailsburg, Illinois, Catherine from Glen Allen,
- 17:26Virginia, and YopE from Hillsboro, Oregon. And Iyana from the Netherlands.
- 17:36Sorry for butchering your name there, Ioanna or Yana, I'm not sure.
- 17:41Rachel from Honolulu, Beautiful Honolulu. I'm jealous. Rachel Oliver from Hudson,
- 17:48New York. Reino from Jersey City, New Jersey, Amy from Jonesboro,
- 17:55Georgia, Julia from Las Vegas, Nevada, and Devin from Lockport, New
- 17:59York. Or thank you y'all for being a patron and staying a patron for
- 18:03over two and a half years. Ish. I also want to remind everyone
- 18:07that this business of psychology in Seattle is almost carbon neutral. You could argue
- 18:14we are completely carbon neutral as a business. I don't know if that matters
- 18:18to you. It certainly does to me. One, I spend a lot
- 18:22of money on getting very expensive solar panels from my house, which is a
- 18:30bit of a farce since I live in Seattle, in which there's not very
- 18:33much sun. But every photon helps, and our business is at home,
- 18:40so a lot of our photons and electrons come from the sun. Also,
- 18:47Washington State has a lot of its energy provided by renewable sources hydro and nuclear.
- 18:56Of course, there are problems with hydro, but in terms of carbon
- 18:59it is wonderful on that front. And I just wanted y'all to know that
- 19:04because I want to do what I can, and if you're consuming this podcast,
- 19:12listening to it, or contributing monetarily, I just thought, you know,
- 19:18it's one of those things that you kind of look for, right Like
- 19:21you want ethical you want to spend your money on ethical practices, and I
- 19:26would like to think that we're doing our best here. Also, I want
- 19:30to remind patrons of the charities that we give to. We have given thousands
- 19:34of dollars to scholarships and art grants but mainly scholarships. And we've given a
- 19:41lot of money to Petfinder, which helps animal shelters and rescue groups care for
- 19:47homeless pets and helps them to connect with homes and need. And Plymouth Housing
- 19:52Group, which helps provide transitional housing for those in need, mainly in the
- 19:57Seattle area. Camp in Trees, which is a camp that provides a safe
- 20:02place for queer youth here in Washington. The Trevor Project, which is a
- 20:07national or international charity that helps to prevent suicide. I'm on Queer Youth,
- 20:11the Special Olympics, the National Alliance on Mental Illness, the Animal Aid and
- 20:18Rescue Foundation or RF, the Prevent Child Abuse America organization, Animals Lebanon,
- 20:26which rescues pets in Beyrout and connects them with loving homes. I've two of
- 20:32my cats came from Animals Lebanon. They're from the streets of Beirut. If
- 20:38you remember my cats that are no longer with me because they grueled and unfortunately
- 20:45died. The Environmental Defense Fund. All these charities are money that you give
- 20:52to as patrons. I should say the patrons give money and part of your
- 20:59and I guess you YouTube members as well. At the Asian American Legal Defense
- 21:03and Education Fund. We also give money to Wikipedia and also to Doctors Without
- 21:08Borders. I give money to Wikipedia because I find it to be a wonderful
- 21:14resource. The you know, the more technical pages aren't super reliable, but
- 21:21you know, it's free, and it I think exhibits the original mindset of
- 21:30the Internet, which was to level the playing field and to democratize information and
- 21:37not you know, I hope you get my point. So I like the
- 21:44mission and what they accomplish. But as I said, it's not always reliable,
- 21:49but it's more reliable than a lot of other resources. All right.
- 21:52This next email is from good old middle tier patron Joscelyn G. She says
- 22:00Kirk's conceptualization of avoidant attachment being preoccupied underneath has really helped me parse my borderline
- 22:07personality sort or splitting, all right, Just chiming in here to explain a
- 22:11little bit about the complicated but very competent sentence that Joscelyn just laid out there.
- 22:18So, the avoidant attachment meaning that for some people they develop a way
- 22:25of reacting to attachment threat, attachment loss by avoiding or dismissing, sometimes preemptively
- 22:34right, and then saying, you know, my consentulation that avoidant attachment being
- 22:41preoccupied underneath, meaning that I will point out that for every you know,
- 22:49often what people will say is that, you know, you have preoccupied people
- 22:52who are very oriented towards relationships and very concerned and worried about losing attachments.
- 23:00Then you have avoidant people who avoid But I think the way that people think
- 23:06of avoidantly attached people is that they don't care about attachments. But that couldn't
- 23:11be farther from the truth. They deeply, deeply care. Of course,
- 23:17they've just turned themselves off to that caring depending on the degree of avoidant attachment.
- 23:22And so a way of trying to quickly demonstrate that or explain it is
- 23:26that underneath every avoidant person is a preoccupied person, but they just don't have
- 23:32access to it. At least preoccupied people have access to their desperation and an
- 23:37avoidant people don't. You could argue that avoidant people have a muted version of
- 23:41preoccupation underneath, because they're perhaps neurologically different because of their development in a neglectful
- 23:52attunement space, such that they don't feel emotions quite as big and their desperation
- 23:59might be you did because of that. But like I said, at least
- 24:03preoccupied people are hyper vigilant to gain at least some attachment security in bursts,
- 24:11right, they fall in love quickly and they get some fulfillment, whereas avoidant
- 24:15people they might just avoid chronically and never act on their need for attachment.
- 24:22And so in the same way that I say for every narcissistic person, they
- 24:29have a borderline person underneath that, which is very true. If you actually
- 24:33get to know people with legit narcissistic personality deep down, they are exactly the
- 24:40same as a borderline person. They are they have a very hard time knowing
- 24:45who they are, or what they want, or what their emotions are,
- 24:48or that they matter. They can become unglued very easily anyway. So that's
- 24:55what I'm saying about that. And then what Joscelyn is talking about about borderline
- 25:00splitting is that it's a term that we use not only in psychoanalysis but also
- 25:06in describing borderline in which for people suffering from borderline personality, they will tend
- 25:14to have these vacillations between desperately loving someone and it's not it doesn't always play
- 25:21out this way. But sort of a classic presentation is the person with borderline
- 25:25will We'll just say with me, say a borderline client comes in my office.
- 25:29I don't know the client has borderline, and they're being very receptive to
- 25:33my therapy. They really enjoy my therapy. They seem to exhibit a lot
- 25:38of positive client traits, like they do their homework and they're very pleasant in
- 25:44therapy, and they compliment me a lot or something. And then I do
- 25:49something that hurts the client's feelings, like say I'm a little late to a
- 25:55session, which would never happen, of course, because I'm aggressively anal about
- 26:00that, as y'all know, which doesn't make me a lot of friends,
- 26:07because people are like, Kirk, calm the fuck down, and I'll say,
- 26:10okay, sorry, And but let's say I'm late in this weird universe
- 26:15and the client is hurt by that, naturally, but because of the abandonment
- 26:22and betrayal that the client has been through the traumas, the client very quickly
- 26:27becomes very very hurt and will split into this other part of themselves where they
- 26:34become very angry and dismissive of me and blaming of me. And I'm suddenly
- 26:41not only just someone that hurt them, but I'm the worst person on the
- 26:45planet and they believe that to be true and they embody this split off part
- 26:51of themselves or they that's where the or well, there's a lot of there's
- 26:56a lot I could say about splitting. Maybe one day I'll do. I
- 26:57mean, I do plan on doing a deep dive on defense mechanisms, of
- 27:03which you could argue splitting is one of them, and each one of the
- 27:07defense mechanisms would require maybe its own deep dive. But I do want to
- 27:11do it for y'all, but also kind of for my own sake, because
- 27:15I know a lot of these terms, and I've used them over the years,
- 27:17but it'd be nice to have like a real formalized understanding of it.
- 27:21That's that's the beauty of being of a podcaster that y'all are patrons for,
- 27:26is that I get paid to spend like a month learning about something like splitting
- 27:33and then I can regurgitate it to y'all. But anyway, so, and
- 27:38by the way, I'm currently working on this on the Skeezoid deep dive that
- 27:42should be out shortly, I hope, and I've been working on it off
- 27:48and on for months now. But with splitting, the idea, one version
- 27:53of it, if you will, is that the individual will have a split
- 28:00in their personality, not in that they have multiple, multiple personalities, but
- 28:04it's a different mode. One way to think about it for you internal family
- 28:08systems, folks, is that there's different parts of the self, right and
- 28:14when the client is with me and being very solicitous to me and being very
- 28:18nice to me and maybe even worshiping me, it's a part of them that
- 28:22is say, I don't know how they would phrase it to themselves, but
- 28:26a client might phrase it as well, this is my inner child that is
- 28:30very desperate for love and attention from an authority figure and is very innocent and
- 28:36trusting. But I have another part of myself in this internal family system of
- 28:41the fighter, the you know, the sergeant who comes forward to defend that
- 28:47little girl on the inside of me. And so these two parts of the
- 28:51self becomes split and not integrated and become very pronounced and the individual, when
- 28:59push comes to shove, they won't just you know, in a perfect world
- 29:03or in a healthy recovered personality, the individual. We all have these aspects
- 29:11to ourself, you know, I have that inner girl inside of me.
- 29:14I also have that sergeant inside of me. But the hope is is that
- 29:18eventually you get to an what we call integrated place where I have access to
- 29:23all those parts of me and all those feelings and all those thoughts relatively.
- 29:29You know, it's impossible to have access to everything all the time, but
- 29:33that I don't have to completely go full sergeant. You know, I don't
- 29:37have to go completely full inner child or completely full sergeant. I can notice
- 29:44my inner child while also noticing my sergeant, while also noticing five other kind
- 29:48of impulses that I have, and in a differentiated way kind of look at
- 29:52it all and figure out what I want to do with it. Whereas with
- 29:56people who go through, you know, siting different traumas and neglects growing up,
- 30:00they either retain, you could argue, or develop this splitting aspect where
- 30:06they are one or the other. And the idea is is that early in
- 30:11development all children are like this. You might notice your child is like this
- 30:17that when they're two years old, you know, they just they love you,
- 30:22They love you if things are going well, and then say you frustrate
- 30:26them somehow, like they have to go down for a nap, or you
- 30:29have to say, okay, it's time to walk away from the playground,
- 30:33or we have to leave grandma's house, that child will just turn on you.
- 30:37You know, they're just just like you are the devil now. It's
- 30:41so normal and it's so expected and so kind of cute or I don't know,
- 30:48depending that we don't look at it like the child is you know,
- 30:52completely splitting, but it is. You look at the child, you're just
- 30:56like, come on, there's limits in life. And I'm not the devil.
- 31:03I was the one. It was my idea to come to grandma's.
- 31:06We wouldn't be at Grandma's if it weren't for you. So you know,
- 31:10cut me, eat some slack here. But some kids, you know,
- 31:12particularly before a certain age, we'll just you know, all bets are off.
- 31:17You're the devil. Now, you're horrible. So for people that are
- 31:22abused or neglected growing up, you could argue that they never grow out of
- 31:26that of that. So that's what I think Jocelyn's talking about with borderline splinning.
- 31:30So for borderline individuals, they will you know, split. Those two
- 31:34aspects are what we call splitting off of those two modes because they can't tolerate.
- 31:41You know, another way of looking at it is that for the borderline
- 31:47client that is idealizing me, they can't tolerate any threat to that idealization because
- 31:55that client believes that if they stray from idealization, even a hair's width,
- 32:01then everything bad will happen and they will lose me. And so they split
- 32:06off all of their negative feelings and all their criticisms and all of their misgivings
- 32:12about me. But they don't they don't go away. They just get split
- 32:15off to the sergeant, if you will, and then as soon as there's
- 32:20enough reason for the sergeant to emerge then and again, it's not multiple personality,
- 32:23it's not alters, it's not associative identity. It's just different modes that
- 32:27people go into. Then that sergeant will come forward and ruin things right,
- 32:32because if it's just the sergeant, then the sergeant just is like a bull
- 32:37in a china shop and just completely destroys all relationships instead of just mildly trying
- 32:43to modify them. You know that that's anyway, so Josin's talking about that.
- 32:47My splitting feels like snap avoidance after fierce preoccupation. But the preoccupation was
- 32:55always there, and the avoidance is just a way to try to cope.
- 32:59Just chime me in again, very sophisticated bit here. What she's saying is
- 33:05for me with my borderline, when I split, it feels like because I
- 33:10think what Joscely is talking about is one of the things I talk about is
- 33:15that a lot of preoccupied or borderline individuals will come to me and they'll be
- 33:19They'll say that they don't feel like they're completely preoccupied. They'll say, you
- 33:24know, I'm both avoidant and preoccupied because sometimes I avoid, and sometimes with
- 33:30investigation, I will conceptualize the person as being partially one and partially the other.
- 33:37Like for me, I am partially I'm mostly secure, but I am
- 33:43also avoidant and I have a dash of preoccupied. So I you know,
- 33:50that's not counter to the way I see things and not counter to the research.
- 33:52But what I will sometimes find, though, is that when I hear
- 33:57that from someone that, particularly if they are moderate to severe preoccupied or borderline,
- 34:02I will I will find after an investigation that they're not actually avoidantly attached.
- 34:09They don't tend to react that way. They just avoid as a as
- 34:15an offshoot from their preoccupation when things become so bad and so distressful that they
- 34:20just have to run away from an individual or from relationships in general. But
- 34:27but the theme throughout the whole thing is preoccupation. You know, for people
- 34:30who are avoiding, who have you know, sort of classic dismissive avoidant attachment,
- 34:37they wouldn't word it that way. They would they would just say like,
- 34:40yeah, you know, I just don't really need people, or I
- 34:43don't know, people get on my nerves. So yeah, they don't word
- 34:45it like things just got so bad, I was just so desperate, so
- 34:50I just I just had to completely just end my life dating, and I
- 34:55just they it's a different way of wording it because it's a different experience,
- 35:00you know, the preoccupied individual who avoids, you know, because I've had
- 35:05clients come to me who are very preoccupied in my conceptualization, but say they
- 35:08had five years where they didn't date anybody, and that would look like an
- 35:14avoidant person. But throughout every day perhaps of that preoccupied it particularly fit's moderate
- 35:20to severe. There's a lot of preoccupied themes and feelings and thoughts that are
- 35:24running through that individual's head even though they aren't dating. You know what I
- 35:28mean. So what Jocelyn is saying is, you know, my splitting when
- 35:34I go from from you know, preoccupied to avoidant. I think that's how
- 35:38Jocelyn is using it that it feels like my snap avoidance is after a lot
- 35:46of fierce preoccupation, meaning a lot of fear, and a lot of hypervigilance,
- 35:51a lot of pain, and the preoccupation, so going on, the
- 35:54preoccupation was always there, and the avoidance is just a way to try to
- 35:58cope, right going on, I separately wonder about this. Might disorganized attachment
- 36:04feel like simultaneous and fierce preoccupation. I just got a very complicated Joscelyn,
- 36:09let me slow down here. Might disorganize attachment, okay, feel like simultaneous
- 36:15fierce preoccupation and avoidance, so fierce preoccupation and fierce avoidance at the same time,
- 36:22such that they cancel each other out and all that's left is despair.
- 36:27End of email. I mean you could see it that way, That's not
- 36:30how I see it, if I'm understanding you right. With disorganized attachment,
- 36:36it's almost like a completely different thing. It often is framed as this combo
- 36:43between avoidance and preoccupation or dismissed and anxiously attached. But that doesn't describe it
- 36:52in my mind. And it actually took me a while to kind of comprehend
- 36:55this when I did the deep dive on attachment years ago, I didn't,
- 37:01in my estimation, understand disorganized attachment really until I don't know, maybe like
- 37:09a few months after I did the deep dive. We you know, Stacy
- 37:14recently re ran the deep dive and I was listening back to it, and
- 37:16I was kind of cringing at what I was saying about disorganized. I mean,
- 37:22it wasn't wrong wrong, but it wasn't right right. So the right
- 37:27right, or what I believe humbly to be the right right way of describing
- 37:32disorganized attachment is that with preoccupied folks, when they have an attachment threat,
- 37:39when they feel like they're going to lose someone, or they are lonely,
- 37:44or they're hurt by someone, they at least have a way of reacting,
- 37:47which is to lean in and to be hyper vigilant, or to get angry,
- 37:52or to be desperate or to cling or something and avoidant people when they
- 37:57feel attachment threat, they have a way of reacting. They avoid they shut
- 38:01down. They say they're independent and they don't need anybody. They drink or
- 38:10do something that's compulsive, like masturbation or porn or drug abuse or working too
- 38:17much or something. You know, they have a way. They're both suffering,
- 38:21and particularly with severe avoidant and severe preoccupy, there's tremendous suffering on the
- 38:28level of severe personality disorders perhaps, but with disorganized folks, they don't have
- 38:34any way of dealing with it. When they feel attachment threat, which can
- 38:39be frequent, they don't know what to do. There's nothing to do.
- 38:45They will do something because humans can't help but to do things, but there's
- 38:50no pathway, there's no habit of how do I get out of this problem?
- 38:57You know, to preoccupied person that if you ask him, okay,
- 39:00how do you repair your relationship? They'll they'll say things along the lines of,
- 39:06well, I just need to get him to therapy, or I just
- 39:08need to get him to understand my feelings. You know, there's an orientation
- 39:13towards the other person of it. I just need to orient I need to
- 39:16gain the system. I need to figure out how to tinker with me or
- 39:21this other person such that we can finally get to that great place, and
- 39:24to the avoidant person, you know, there'll be an orientation of just like,
- 39:28well, I just need to get my life in order, or I
- 39:30just need to take a break from humans for a while, or I just
- 39:35need to improve my personal coping with emotions. Not that that's a bad thing,
- 39:40but it could be a part of a bad thing. There'll be something
- 39:45that they'll say to disorganized person, they'll just say, you know, they
- 39:47might say things, but there's they don't feel confident in anything that they're doing.
- 39:52Not that preoccupied people necessarily feel confident, but at least they they have
- 39:57a compulsion in a direction, and there's a chance that it actually might work
- 40:01for preoccupied people and for avoidant people, particularly for avoidant people. Research shows
- 40:06that for avoidant folks, their life tends to go a little better, which
- 40:10is I think a result of our culture being kind of fucked up and privileging
- 40:15of avoidant people. Not quite sure, but anyway, but for disorganized folks,
- 40:22it's a constant level of distress. They move away from the pain and
- 40:28they're alone and they're in distress. They move, they move towards the relationship
- 40:34and the pain, and they feel increased pain and fear, and they move
- 40:37away and they feel fear, they move towards they feel fear. They don't
- 40:40know. They can't depend on themselves as well. There's nowhere to turn.
- 40:45They can't go any direction, and it's very very unsettling and very very distressing.
- 40:52So to say that, you know, you're describing it as and I
- 40:57don't know exactly what you're saying, Joscelyn, but from the way it looks
- 41:00you're saying, you know, it might disorganize attachment, feel like simultaneous fierce
- 41:05preoccupation and fierce avoidance at the same time that they cancel each other out.
- 41:09I mean, I mean, maybe you could word it that way, but
- 41:13I find that once I landed on the way I just described it earlier,
- 41:19it all made sense to me. That it even makes sense in terms of
- 41:24childhood development. When the child is twelve months old and they are being abused
- 41:30and they want they have an instinct to run to their parents, but their
- 41:36parents are the ones abusing them, so they have an instinct both to run
- 41:38toward and away from the parents, so they don't know what to do,
- 41:42Whereas in the for the preoccupied kid, they at least have some little bits
- 41:50of safety at times if they do run toward and cling to their parents,
- 41:54that there's at least some you know, some oasis that happens at times.
- 42:01It's very infrequent, but it happens at times. To the avoidant person,
- 42:04there's at least some safety in moving away and shutting down eye contact and trying
- 42:10not to signal that they have needs. You know, there's the child is
- 42:15essentially rewarded either direction. The avoidant child is rewarded for being avoidant and for
- 42:22lacking eye contact and being independent because the parent no longer is distressing the child.
- 42:29The preoccupied child that is rewarded at times for clinging and being desperate and
- 42:35asking or demanding or something. You know, there's some there's bits of reward
- 42:37to the disorganized kid. There's no reward any direction they go. You're fucked
- 42:43no matter which direction you go. And you know, it's you can see
- 42:46how it would be a very very distressing place to be, which it is.
- 42:52But there's treatments. You know, I've talked about it a lot with
- 42:54Bob. All right, let's take another break. All right, back from
- 43:00the break, let's do another opp These people became patrons all the way back
- 43:05in twenty twenty one we had These are all monthly deserving listeners. We have
- 43:09Christina from London. We have Zena from Longmount, Colorado or long Mont.
- 43:16Makato from Lynnwood, Washington, just north of here, Joanna from also Lynnwood,
- 43:22Makato and Joanna do you know each other? Joanne from Melbourne, Australia,
- 43:28Emily Emily from Merrill, Michigan, Mars from Miami, Florida, Sofia
- 43:32from Milwaukee, Wisconsin. I've been there, and Miami, Amanda from Nellisford,
- 43:38Virginia, Mackenzie from Texas, Julia from Newport, Oregon, Vicki from
- 43:45California, Connor from Oakfield, New York, Elizabeth from Olympia, Washington.
- 43:50Go to Olympia, Jesse from Omaha, Nebraska, and Anonymous from Palmdale,
- 43:55California, and John from Plano, Texas. Thank you so much for being
- 44:00a patron and staying a patron for so long. It is the wind beneath
- 44:06my wings figuratively but literally, it is you pay my bills. You literally
- 44:13pay my bills, you literally pay my mortgage, because I wouldn't you know
- 44:17if you didn't do that. Patrons and peek behind the curtain. You're the
- 44:23main source of my bill paying, by the way, patrons, and if
- 44:29you didn't do that, I'd have to go back to my various other jobs,
- 44:32and I would have to go back to making one shitty podcast episode every
- 44:38two or three weeks, which is the way things used to be. So
- 44:45thank you so much. All right. This next email is also from Joscelyn,
- 44:49but it's a quick one, so I'll just get to this real quick.
- 44:52Jolin says, what can I do to reassure myself that things won't fall
- 44:54apart at work while I'm away? I frequently feel things are not done up
- 45:00to standard at work, and I dread the thought of work getting done improperly
- 45:05or inefficiently by others when I'm out on vacation. I compensate by creating copious
- 45:10document documentation, manuals, and notes for processes to be helpful during my absence,
- 45:16but I can't know if people will actually read them. Thank you so
- 45:19much, end of email, she wrote, end of email. So yeah,
- 45:24Well, there's a lot I can say to this one. Is I
- 45:28get it because I'm like that as a perfectionist. I would feel that way
- 45:35when I worked at the university full time, and it would drive me nuts.
- 45:39So yeah, that's just a personal issue that maybe needs to be worked
- 45:45on. But another factor is that managers, of course want us to believe
- 45:51what you believe, Joscelyn. They want us to have this feeling because what
- 45:55it does to us is it makes us have to work much harder and much
- 46:00more, many more hours outside of vacation so that management can get the most
- 46:07out of labor for the least amount of money, which is unfair. Right.
- 46:12So I, personally, when I hear this from you, Jocelyn,
- 46:15I think, this isn't your fault. I mean, unless you're the business
- 46:19owner, I suppose, But if you're not, this isn't your fault.
- 46:22This is the manager's fault or the owner's fault. You know, whoever is
- 46:25above you, whoever could hire more people, because this is a hiring more
- 46:30people or hiring better people problem, it's not a you problem. And this
- 46:35is something that I am frequently talking about to advocate for labor, that there's
- 46:39a cultural shift, particularly in Seattle. I think that that I it's different
- 46:45than before. When I was younger, there was a pretty strong ethic around,
- 46:50at least in my circle, of you work for forty hours a week
- 46:53and no more than forty because of laws. And when you take vacation,
- 47:00you just take vacation. You don't have to do anything, maybe a little
- 47:04bit of prep to you know, get everyone up to speed before you go
- 47:08out of town. And when you're on vacation, you don't need to have
- 47:13access to email or text or anything. You're just gone, right because of
- 47:16course in the past they didn't have that. And then when you get back,
- 47:21you don't have to do extra work because that's the definition of a vacation.
- 47:25The way it's dealt with today is culturally speaking, and management just you
- 47:30know, is giggling themselves asleep every night because we're doing this to ourselves,
- 47:37is that we take all the work that we aren't doing while we're on vacation
- 47:42for that week or two weeks, and we're just piling it up before and
- 47:45after the vacation. That is not a fucking vacation. That is unpaid leave
- 47:51because you're you're working twice as hard before and after the vacation, so you
- 47:55can take time off that's just unpaid leave, that's not paid vacation. And
- 48:01for all of us as labor to just go along with that is anti American.
- 48:07For me America, at least in the past century. In the twentieth
- 48:13century, after labor laws were put into effect, we are a country of
- 48:17labor. We are a country of labor rights and unions and fucked the man.
- 48:22You know, there was a time when the industrialists and the capitalists exploited
- 48:29labor and children and killed all sorts of people with unsafe work conditions. And
- 48:37we the people employed our politicians to push back on that, and we the
- 48:45people joined unions, and we the people did all sorts of things to advocate
- 48:49for us against the capitalists. And for us to just give into that right
- 48:53now and to have no awareness that we're doing this to ourselves, is we're
- 49:00harming ourselves, you know. So, because the equation is that in order
- 49:07for you to just work for forty hours and just casually take a vacation and
- 49:14then casually come back to work. In order for that to happen, the
- 49:16equation is that the ownership and the capitalists they have to lose some of their
- 49:22profit. They'll still be profitable. Otherwise they should just go out of business
- 49:27because they don't have a workable business, but because their business shouldn't be dependent
- 49:30on exploiting labor. So for you to just be able to casually go on
- 49:37vacation and come back and ramp up normally to your job. For that to
- 49:40happen, they typically they have to hire more labor, or they have to
- 49:44hire a tempt or somebody. And what that means is that the capitalists have
- 49:47to lose profit, which is the way things should be. It should not
- 49:54be on us to carry that burden so that the rich can get richer,
- 49:59which is what's happening right And we the people have to fight back. We
- 50:02have to speak out, We have to organize. We can't just say to
- 50:07ourselves, I'm not gonna do that, because if you don't do that,
- 50:10you will be fired or you'll be ostracized or marginalized somehow. We as a
- 50:16group have to say no to Microsoft, no Amazon, no Starbucks, no
- 50:22Boeing, or no Costco. I'm just naming all the Seattle businesses. No,
- 50:29we will not do that, and you can't make us. And if
- 50:32you hire scabs, we will all quit. You know, you will make
- 50:38either you will make a little less money Jeff Bezos, or you will make
- 50:43no money, because that is the American way. So when I hear you,
- 50:49Jocelyn, talking about that you're stressing out before going on work because you
- 50:55have to create all of this oversight that you're coworkers or your underlings or whoever
- 51:01have to follow, and you don't even know if they will, and it
- 51:06like really stresses you out before and after and during a vacation. That is
- 51:12on the capitalists, that is not on you. And that's another philosophy to
- 51:15take on that. I tell people, it's like, look, why are
- 51:20you on this planet? Are you on this planet to earn money for the
- 51:22capitalists who own your business? And I don't know, Joscelyn, maybe you
- 51:27literally own the business. Maybe you are the capitalist. I don't know.
- 51:30The way you're wording it doesn't sound that way to me. But the point
- 51:34is is that why are we on this planet? You know, we're not
- 51:37We're not put on this planet to, you know, to put more money
- 51:42in rich people's pockets. And so you know, I'm just not going to
- 51:47do that. And this is the way I have tried to live my life.
- 51:51I don't know where I got this from. I certainly wasn't taught it
- 51:54growing up. I just I don't know. I just I think It's part
- 52:00of just my general entitlement. I feel entitled to a life, and when
- 52:06I feel pressure to pull away from that life, I don't like it,
- 52:09and so I look into like, well, what's happening exactly? And over
- 52:14time I just started to cobble together this idea. And so when I worked
- 52:17at the university, I would call upon these principles and push back on my
- 52:24boss and on administration, particularly as a way of saying, no, you
- 52:30can't. You can't do that to us. I'm not going to do it.
- 52:35And so many people would do it because they wanted to be seen as
- 52:39good employees, and I just thought, look, if I get fired,
- 52:43I get fired. I'm just not going to live in a system like that.
- 52:45The other thing is is that I had a good boss. Paul was
- 52:50my boss and would fight to the death for me, and often would Sometimes
- 52:57I'd have to not tell Paul, my boss and mentor about ways I was
- 53:02being mistreated because I didn't want him to go after these people. He would
- 53:07I would tell him because you know, I was often the new guy,
- 53:12and so funny that I could be working at a university for fifteen years and
- 53:15be consider the new guy. That's the way things were back then. Now
- 53:19the professors at Antioch are all you know, newly hired or a lot of
- 53:22them are, but back in the day, it was this set of professors.
- 53:28Anyway, I'm rambling, but I recommend that I don't know, Joscelyn
- 53:35if that's part of it. But like I said earlier, I get it
- 53:38as a perfectionist. It's just one of those things that it's just hard,
- 53:44I don't know, maybe telling the people around you before you go on vacation
- 53:47and be like, hey, if you care about me at all as a
- 53:51human being, y'all are gonna do your best to try to uphold the standards
- 53:57that we have here that I'm usually carrying the weight of it. And maybe
- 54:00that's another thing, Like you know, in between vacations, you can raise
- 54:07the topic of Hey, coworkers, I feel like I'm carrying the burden of
- 54:10quality assurance in this workplace and I like that, but it's too much.
- 54:16So because in a system, if you end up being that person, other
- 54:21people can feel like, well, Jocelyn's taking care of that, so I
- 54:23don't need to. And so maybe if you start ramping that down, other
- 54:28people will have to pick up the slack there. I don't know. I
- 54:30don't know if that's another thing to think about, right sext emails from middle
- 54:35Tier anonymous patron. She says, I'm sure it's more complex than this,
- 54:40but I was reading about the difference between shame and guilt and so just chumming
- 54:46in here. There's a lot of talk online and I think it's been around
- 54:52for a while about the difference between shame and guilt. And I'm not opposed
- 54:55to it, but I think that it's more complicated often for people what do
- 55:01we mean by shame? What do we mean by guilt? And there's a
- 55:06lot of absolutist talk about shame. You might hear me talk about this sometimes,
- 55:10that shame is always bad and guilt is can be good and can be
- 55:16bad, or something like that, because shame is when you feel like you
- 55:22are bad, whereas guilt is when you think that you did a bad thing
- 55:25and it there's a lot of nuance to that. And I also think that
- 55:30at times, feeling like you are bad is probably a good idea. I
- 55:36want ted Bundy to be ashamed of himself. I want someone who is abusive
- 55:42to be ashamed of themselves. I don't want them to hate. But then
- 55:46it leads to this other conversation of like, well, what if you think
- 55:51you have something inherently wrong with you and your personality. I mean, I've
- 55:54thought about that myself, and so I'll just speak for myself that when I
- 56:00was in my twenties mid twenties and I was training to be a therapist,
- 56:04I asked around. I'd been at therapy before, but I was looking for
- 56:07a new therapist, and I asked for a therapist that would quote unquote kick
- 56:10my ass. And boy, did I find a therapist in Seattle that would
- 56:15kick my ass. And he confronted me, you know, not in an
- 56:20abusive way, but in a very pointed way throughout my time with him,
- 56:23which was I don't know, two or three years, and I, over
- 56:28time would develop this cringe, sweaty feeling on the way to therapy that I
- 56:35could absolutely describe as shame because it had that it didn't have. I didn't
- 56:39feel guilty when I was driving to therapy. I felt shame. I felt
- 56:46like there was something wrong with my personality. And I felt bad about a
- 56:53lot, not just about you know, a small set of things that emerged
- 56:58from that personality trait. But I felt bad for my entire life, the
- 57:05things that had emerged from that personality trait that I was investigating and that he
- 57:09was confronting me on. I felt cold sweats and that sinking feeling in my
- 57:15chest as I was driving to therapy. I would frame that absolutely a shame.
- 57:20The difference is is that I had a way forward, and my therapist
- 57:23was not rejecting me as a human being, and I was not rejecting myself
- 57:28as a human being. So shame in itself is not, in my book,
- 57:32a bad thing. It can be a bad thing because, of course,
- 57:37if someone if someone doesn't have that support or those inner resources, or
- 57:42the differentiation, or they don't have a history that I have, which is
- 57:47one of mainly secure attachment and self esteem, if they don't have those things,
- 57:53then the shame will run deep and run wild and will destroy the individual
- 58:00will fall deep in the shame. They will have no way out. They
- 58:02will fall into addiction or self hatred or some other destructive path, maybe even
- 58:08suicide. So for some people, and I'm not saying and I'm not saying
- 58:14I'm particularly rare, but it's not uncommon for someone to have a really hard
- 58:21time with shame, right, And for me, I can absolutely develop a
- 58:24problem with shame, and I have I have things that I have frequent shame
- 58:29about today, like with my OCPD, right with my worry about having flaws,
- 58:37and thus that's a reason for me to be completely rejected as a human
- 58:42being. That is shame as well. So to me, it's complicated and
- 58:47nuanced guilt and shame, and for others they don't necessarily see it that way,
- 58:53and that's fine. But what I have a problem with is when people
- 58:58tell me that I'm wrong for the way that I frame and linguistically word things.
- 59:05I have a problem with that. Plus in the research, it's not
- 59:08the way that people talk about it, you know, in the clinical research
- 59:13in psychology, the research on emotion on shame and guilt, it's not simplified
- 59:17the way that the Internet tends to do it. And a lot of people
- 59:22think that when I say shame can be okay. Sometimes they think that I'm
- 59:24saying y'all should hate yourself, and I just find that to be odd considering
- 59:30the fact that I yam or so much. I don't. It's pretty rare
- 59:34if I just say something off the cuff and just expect y'all to understand what
- 59:37I'm saying. If anything, I over explain things, You know what I
- 59:39mean. So anyway, but Middlitier and anicipatrioon you saying, I'm sure it's
- 59:47more complex than this. But I was reading about the difference between shame and
- 59:52guilt, and it just made me wonder whether survivor's guilt rather than shame is
- 59:57functional because by overestimating, So I think this is one long sentence, so
- 1:00:05I got to take this in parts. It made me wonder whether survivor's guilt
- 1:00:12meaning that if, for example, you were in a family that had a
- 1:00:16lot of abuse fround the parents and you actually weren't abused very much. For
- 1:00:22people that watched Loves Blind season five, JP, I think had this kind
- 1:00:25of survivor's guilt, unfortunately, because you know, he didn't deserve to feel
- 1:00:30guilty for that as a child that grew up in an abusive family, but
- 1:00:35he witnessed his sisters being abused according to him. Anyway, So made me
- 1:00:40wonder whether survivor's guilt rather than survivor's shame is functional because so survivor's guilt being
- 1:00:49functional because by overestimating your capacity to predict events and act based on these predictions,
- 1:01:00you predict that if the situation were to reoccur, you would have the
- 1:01:02capacity to avoid the same outcome if you were just willing to do so,
- 1:01:07not selfish, just worked on yourself. Okay, that's the end of that
- 1:01:12sentence. Okay. I don't know if we're using the same definition of survivor's
- 1:01:16guilt Anonymous Patron. Maybe it sounds like you're talking about self blame of trauma
- 1:01:27or self blame of someone else's harm of you, because you say by overestimating
- 1:01:31your capacity to predict. Because I think what you're saying, Patron, is
- 1:01:37is self blame functional, because what it does is it makes us try to
- 1:01:42learn how to avoid situations that would recreate this in the future, and that
- 1:01:47if we don't at least somewhat blame ourselves, we might be susceptible to haphazardly
- 1:01:54walking into harm in the future. You know, like if someone said,
- 1:01:59I mean, this is a horrible example, but if someone a woman dressed
- 1:02:04in a very revealing dress or something not very but somewhat revealing dress, and
- 1:02:09she is going to the clubs by herself, which should be completely fine by
- 1:02:15the way, because it's not inherently some sort of ticket to abuse her right.
- 1:02:22So she goes to a nightclub by herself, and then she walks to
- 1:02:25her car and someone attacks her, and she is irrationally blaming herself, at
- 1:02:31least to some extent, saying I shouldn't have worn that, or I should
- 1:02:36have parked closer, or I should have had a buddy or something like this.
- 1:02:42And you know, there's a difference between noting the factors that led to
- 1:02:46one's harm, you know, that resulted in harm to oneself. There's a
- 1:02:53big difference between that and self blame or what I think you're calling a survivor's
- 1:03:00guilt. But I think you're talking about self blame. I don't know,
- 1:03:04maybe I'm wrong. There's a big difference between shame and guilt. You know,
- 1:03:09if that woman were to say, hmm, well, of course I'm
- 1:03:14not to blame because I should be able to wear a dress and go to
- 1:03:17a nightclub and walk to a car. It's not anywhere even close to my
- 1:03:22fault that that happened, it'd be hard. I can't imagine a woman saying
- 1:03:25that to herself in today's society. But she deserves to say that to herself.
- 1:03:30But at the same time she says, and unfortunately, I have to
- 1:03:35deal with this bullshit. So in the future I will do X, Y
- 1:03:38and Z instead of what he did. That's different, right, That's not
- 1:03:43guilt or shame. That's just noting the factors and the context. Whereas if
- 1:03:46she were to say, I can't believe I wear that dress. I should
- 1:03:51have known better. I'm so stupid, I'm so irresponsible. There's something wrong
- 1:03:59with me. Everyone one always tells me that I shouldn't be so slutty.
- 1:04:03I shouldn't what was I even doing at a nightclub trying to meet people?
- 1:04:09Like I should do? I should go to church more often. That is
- 1:04:14a that's very different. And the difference is not only in the way I
- 1:04:17describe it, which is, you know, learning from an experience versus complete
- 1:04:24self destruction based on internalized voices, but also that shame and guilt often will
- 1:04:30prevent the individual from actually learning from the scenario, or they learn the wrong
- 1:04:34lesson right, they learn that they can't ever wear a dress, or that
- 1:04:40they deserve to be harmed in this way. Right, So the shame and
- 1:04:45guilt based if I were to answer your question if I understand what you're saying,
- 1:04:50I think you understand what I'm saying, which is that the guilt and
- 1:04:54the shame that is completely unjustified. Not only is it not necessarily helpful,
- 1:05:01but it could be very unhelpful. Could and there's a very helpful version of
- 1:05:08just noting what you know. Like another way to frame it would be that,
- 1:05:14well, maybe a little bit of like a little bit of trauma is
- 1:05:17actually helpful to us, which seems likely. It seems we likely evolved a
- 1:05:23capacity for trauma reactivity to guide us in future behavior, to help us be
- 1:05:30safe. I always give the example of the sabertooth tiger coming out at us.
- 1:05:34I'm not even sure if I remember if sabertooth tigers were around when early
- 1:05:40humans were. I certainly hominids were other primates that were similar to us,
- 1:05:44but so we evolved from those folks on the tree of life and the now.
- 1:05:51The example I'll give is we're walking in the jungle and we hear the
- 1:05:58snap of a twig, we hear the breathing of an animal that sounds a
- 1:06:01little strange, and then all of a sudden rustle of leaves and a saber
- 1:06:08tooth tiger jumps out at us and attacks our brother and kills him, and
- 1:06:13we get away, and then we encode all of that information, not only
- 1:06:16the tiger, but that little breath we heard, the snapping of a twig,
- 1:06:20the wrestling of leaves, such that in the future, whenever we hear
- 1:06:25snap of twig and wrestling of leaves, even though it's just a rabbit,
- 1:06:30we have a reaction right now. If we don't develop PTSD, at the
- 1:06:33very least, we have some level of trauma reactivity that will you know,
- 1:06:38it's better safe than sorry. Okay, fine, it was a rabbit,
- 1:06:41but what if it was a saber tooth tiger. It serves us in terms
- 1:06:45of our survival to have that mechanism that is automatic, that doesn't stop at
- 1:06:50the exit. You know, that system of trauma reactivity, doesn't check in
- 1:06:55with our executive functioning, with our pre funnel cortex. It it just goes
- 1:06:59straight to reaction. It's like, it's not exactly like this, but you
- 1:07:04know that neurological tests that they say it's like you put your hand on a
- 1:07:09hot plate and the signal goes up your arm into your spine and then it
- 1:07:15doesn't even have to go to your brain to be evaluated. There's a mechanism
- 1:07:17neurologically locally in your spine that will pull your arm back. Right. I
- 1:07:24don't know if I'm inscribing it exactly right, but at least it's a faster
- 1:07:27process, right, And with trauma, it seemingly we evolved that to help
- 1:07:32us. Of course, it can be over utilized by our brain if we
- 1:07:40have chronic trauma, or we don't have aftercare, or we don't have a
- 1:07:45system to get to safety afterwards, if we don't have support these kinds of
- 1:07:49things, or we're prone to that kind of thing, or we've had you
- 1:07:54know, genetics that led to us being susceptible that sort of thing. I'm
- 1:07:59rambling, but yeah, sometimes I'm in the middle of rambling. I'm just
- 1:08:05like, where the fuck am I? And I think I'll just end the
- 1:08:09episode right there now. No, I'll do a couple more emails. Ooh,
- 1:08:15I like this email. This is from patron Esmend from Minneapolis. He
- 1:08:17says, hello, doctor Kirk, what a wonderful year for psychology in Seattle.
- 1:08:23I hope you and the podcast family and listeners are doing well well,
- 1:08:28Esmond. We are, I think going on with the email. If you
- 1:08:31had three adjectives or labels to apply to Lorali Gilmore's parenting of Rory Gilmore,
- 1:08:39what would they be and why? So just chiming in here. So this
- 1:08:42is of course from Gilmore Girls, the show that I have watched I think
- 1:08:46two are I think maybe two and a half times. I've watched all the
- 1:08:50seasons, maybe three and a half, I don't know. I watched it
- 1:08:54a lot more back in the day when it was on the air, and
- 1:08:57then I watched it on DVDs afterwards, I think, and then Netflix got
- 1:09:00it, and then the Netflix did like an eighth season that I sort of
- 1:09:05enjoyed. But anyway, yeah, I love that show. And incidentally,
- 1:09:12when I first started watching it, I didn't like it because I didn't like
- 1:09:16how fast they talked. I thought it was really unnatural and disturbing. And
- 1:09:21I also didn't like Lorili the mom. I didn't like her parenting of Rory.
- 1:09:27It seemed too permissive or lax or something. But once I got used
- 1:09:32to the rhythms of this writer, you know, because the same showrunner she
- 1:09:39makes that show The Marvelous Miss Mabel or whatever, and it's a very similar
- 1:09:45kind of aesthetic of quick talking people. Anyway, once I got used to
- 1:09:48it, I really love the show. And the three adjectives I would say
- 1:09:55about Lourli gilmour and her parenting Rory is that LOURAI was very loving, very
- 1:10:01very loving, very attentive. You know, Lorli really knew what was going
- 1:10:09on with Rory, not all the time. And there were of course some
- 1:10:12personality issues and trauma issues, relational trauma issues of LAURAAI that made it harder
- 1:10:16for her to see Rory at times. And that was a theme of the
- 1:10:20show, that LAURAAI would be imposing certain life choices on Rory, and Rory
- 1:10:29given her way, would have not necessarily the assertiveness to push back on it.
- 1:10:33But what eventually or might push back in a dysfunctional way to Rory's life,
- 1:10:39which you know, is what it's like to be a human, I
- 1:10:42suppose. But and the third adjective I would say loving, I would say
- 1:10:46attentive, and I would say somewhat enmeshed in my opinion now as men,
- 1:10:54I don't know what words you would say, but I would guess most people
- 1:10:57would look at Laura Lai and think she had bad boundaries. Definitely enmeshed,
- 1:11:02self centered, narcissistic, this kind of thing, and that is not depicted
- 1:11:08on the show. Because one Rory is a very well adjusted kid. She
- 1:11:13goes through some hard times, but for the most part, she's very well
- 1:11:15adjusted. And that's not entirely necessarily an indication of laura Life's parenting, but
- 1:11:21it is a strong indicator of good parenting. You know, parenting is about
- 1:11:27outcomes. It's not about the way you do it. It's about the result.
- 1:11:30And Rory is a wonderful kid in high school, wonderful kid and college,
- 1:11:35develops well, has normal issues, you know, but is doing pretty
- 1:11:42well. Any parent would be proud of Rory. For Laura, l I
- 1:11:47also, yeah, her parenting style is more And for the record, I
- 1:11:54will also say that it's a fictional TV show, of course, so you
- 1:11:59could argue, well, Laura is a terrible parent, but the writers made
- 1:12:02Rory good because they just wanted the plot to be that way. But I'll
- 1:12:06say that in my observation, I've seen parents like Loralai who did work well
- 1:12:14with kids. You know, parenting is complicated, as I always say,
- 1:12:18and it's not necessarily what you do, but how you adjust to the individual
- 1:12:23child, So there's that. But with Rory or with Loralai the mom,
- 1:12:29what I'll say is that, yeah, on the scale of things, she's
- 1:12:33pretty permissive, she's pretty boundary crossing with Rory. She treats Rory like a
- 1:12:43sister at times instead of her own child. For sure, those are all
- 1:12:47things you could say, but and there were consequences of that. You know,
- 1:12:51we could go season my season or episode by episode and point to problems.
- 1:12:57But the overall theme though, you know, the thing to ask is
- 1:13:02would you want Lauraai to be your mom? And I would answer that to
- 1:13:08be yes. I mean, I'd rather have my mom, But if I
- 1:13:12didn't have my mom, Laurie would Laura I would be a great mom.
- 1:13:15She's very caring, like I said, very attentive. A lot of parents
- 1:13:19they're in their own worlds. They they have their own issues and they don't
- 1:13:25necessarily know what their teenage kids are going through or care. Laura I deeply,
- 1:13:30deeply cared about Rory and really wanted the best for her, and involved
- 1:13:36Rory in a lot of conversations. Some people might say inappropriately, but you
- 1:13:42know, not really, you know, they're inappropriate things that you can involve
- 1:13:45your kids in right, and like if like the fact that Laura I shared
- 1:13:50a lot of her dating life with Rory is you know, it's a red
- 1:13:56flag, but it's not necessarily a problem. And you know, to my
- 1:13:59it's been a while since I've watched all the seasons, and maybe some of
- 1:14:00y'all that know the story more recently, you might you might be screaming into
- 1:14:05your device right now saying like no, and I'd concede to your expertise on
- 1:14:12this. But from my memory, Lorelai was, you know, overall just
- 1:14:16really really attentive, very loving, very warm. Would when push comes to
- 1:14:26chef shove Laura la I would protect Rory and let Rory be Rory. So,
- 1:14:32uh yeah, can we point to problems, sure, but I think
- 1:14:36it's overshadowed by the positives. Then your next question, esmen, is do
- 1:14:41you have any insight into the family dynamics between Emily, Laurelai and Rory end
- 1:14:45of email. Wow, that would be a whole dissertation. I wonder if
- 1:14:53anyone's ever written a dissertation on Emily Loreli. So Emily is the grandmother,
- 1:14:58So you got Emily and then the daughter Laurai, and then the daughter,
- 1:15:01Rory, and so in a nutshell, Emily was someone that was very high
- 1:15:12class and very stuffy and judgmental and critical and not warm and not very attentive,
- 1:15:19but really wanted a connection with Lourai. But because Loralai had a rebellious
- 1:15:29teenage year, there was a real break in Lourali's relationship with Emily, and
- 1:15:36you could argue that Loralai, you know, was rebelling against Emily's dominant,
- 1:15:44dominant parenting style. And then when Laurai had Rory young, I think as
- 1:15:49a teenager, then Lorlai swung the other direction. But to Lourai's credit,
- 1:15:57she was able to build strong attachment with Rory. You know, I think
- 1:16:01most people would say that Rory and Loralai had had a good attachment, had
- 1:16:06a good safety and a good amount of attunement and love between the two of
- 1:16:11them, whereas with Emily and Lorlai it wasn't there. Now with the triangle,
- 1:16:17though with Rory, she didn't have that history with Emily and the grandfather,
- 1:16:24she liked them and they the grandparents treated Rory a lot better than they
- 1:16:30treated Laura Lai sometimes in the same scene, and Rory really liked that,
- 1:16:38and I think also Rory once, particularly once she entered a teenager, she
- 1:16:45wanted the resources that the grandparents had, you know, because Loralai. Although
- 1:16:50when you look at Loralai's house, I mean, it's just a beautiful,
- 1:16:54beautiful house. It's probably worth a couple million dollars if stars hollow, but
- 1:17:01she's at least written. Laurai is written as someone who isn't super rich at
- 1:17:06the very least anyway. But I think that Rory and Laurai for that matter,
- 1:17:13kind of depended on Emily financially and for connections, and I think Emily
- 1:17:16might have used that to some extent. But Emily had a you know,
- 1:17:21especially as a season progressed, Emily had a real vulnerable side on a very
- 1:17:26a real soft hurt side. So you just got the suppression that Emily the
- 1:17:29grandmother had her own history. I'm forgetting if they ever went into that Emily's
- 1:17:34childhood. You've got to figure they must have talked about it at some point.
- 1:17:39But there was triangulation in that Emily and loura I had an ongoing conflict
- 1:17:46between the two of them since Loralai was a teenager and they both triangulated Rory
- 1:17:49that, you know, Lorelai would indicate or talk shit about Emily to gain
- 1:17:58Rory's agents to Loralai and Emily and the grandfather would kind of do the same.
- 1:18:04And what was really happening between the family members was that the grandmother,
- 1:18:12Emily and Loralai were still resenting each other and still hurt by each other.
- 1:18:18They were both very, very hurt, and they developed a way of coping
- 1:18:26with that by just avoiding the topic and by having these surface level dinners every
- 1:18:34Sunday night or whenever it was, and by just existing and trying not to
- 1:18:42make any waves. But occasionally something would flare up and the old resentments would
- 1:18:47start to come out between Emily and Lorali, and often Rory would have to
- 1:18:51suffer from that. Right, I could go on and on, but that's
- 1:18:57me off the top of my head. Right. Sex emails from patron Janis,
- 1:19:00She says, I just want to thank you for doing this podcast and
- 1:19:02for answering people's questions. I don't know you, but I respect you and
- 1:19:08I feel safe with you, which is weird, right, And my favorite
- 1:19:12thing to fall asleep to is your podcast, not because it's boring. I
- 1:19:16take meds that make me sleep, and I love the safety and security that
- 1:19:20your voice represents. I always listen to the podcast again later so that I
- 1:19:25can actually learn from it. You should totally record sleep stories with Calm or
- 1:19:30some other app. Thanks for lulling me to sleep every night. Good night,
- 1:19:36Janie, end of email. Yeah, absolutely, well, it's quite
- 1:19:44honestly, if my podcast did one thing, I would take it if that
- 1:19:51was to help people sleep, because sleep is so important and feeling safe is
- 1:19:57so important. So I'm honored by that. And don't ever feel bad that
- 1:20:02you fall asleep to me, because that's, like I said, it's quite
- 1:20:06an honor and not what I set out to do, but I'll absolutely take
- 1:20:13it. And I do that too. I don't listen to things to fall
- 1:20:17as well. Sometimes I do if I'm taking a nap. Sometimes I will
- 1:20:21want to listen to something and I will choose something that will and that I
- 1:20:27can predict it won't have any loud sudden noises, you know, And sometimes
- 1:20:32I even engage how long I was asleep by how many minutes went by in
- 1:20:36the podcast episode that I'm listening to. So yeah, that's great, and
- 1:20:45I guess it's also double great that you listen to it again so that you
- 1:20:47can actually learn from what I'm talking about. And then you say I should
- 1:20:54do sleep stories with the comap or something. I didn't even know that that's
- 1:20:59what they did. I didn't know that this app was. Is it some
- 1:21:03sort of thing that anyone can submit to. I thought it was like the
- 1:21:10com app had all their employees or someone like that that would do the different
- 1:21:15calm or sleep aids. But that's interesting. Yeah, you know who should
- 1:21:21do this really is Bob because people really love his voice. So maybe I'll
- 1:21:28put him up to it. But you know, in the meantime, just
- 1:21:30listen to one of my episodes and fall asleep, just like my wife does
- 1:21:34when I am or. This next email is from anonymous middle tier patron.
- 1:21:39She says, Oh my god, I relate to this so much. Just
- 1:21:42Chimian he or. She was referring to a reaction video that I was talking
- 1:21:46about criticism trauma going on. Oh my god, I related is so much.
- 1:21:51It's interesting to see how the constant criticism from my mom led to a
- 1:21:56spectrum of the defensive schema among me and my siblings. My brother found escapism
- 1:22:01in video games. I found it in reading my sister Binge watches shows and
- 1:22:05doom scrolls on Instagram. It's so confusing because my mom grew up always saying
- 1:22:11that she needs to stay with us our whole lives because we don't speak up
- 1:22:15for ourselves. End of email. Yeah, so I think what you're talking
- 1:22:18about, Patron, is that your mom would both criticize you then and break
- 1:22:26you down, and then would sweep in and say, I'm here to save
- 1:22:30you. I'm going to speak for you. And it's similar to the mafia
- 1:22:36from at least the movies. They would come to a business on the corner
- 1:22:41and they would say, boy, it'd be a shame if someone destroyed your
- 1:22:45windows that are in the front of your business. You know, if you
- 1:22:50give us one hundred bucks a week, we will protect your business and make
- 1:22:55sure that no one breaks your window. And the business is, you know,
- 1:22:59guys, I don't need that's okay, And then the mafia proceeds to
- 1:23:01break the windows right in front of them. They say, are you sure
- 1:23:03you don't need someone to protect your whindowls? And then the business coughs up
- 1:23:08one hundred bucks. And that's what you're describing what your mom would do.
- 1:23:12She would break you down and criticize you, say you're incompetent, you're stupid,
- 1:23:15you're worthless, you're dumb, or whatever, and then she would say,
- 1:23:18oh, good thing, I'm here because I will protect you and I
- 1:23:24have to speak for you. So it has this kind of gaslighting effect over
- 1:23:29time where you start to think, oh, I guess I do need this.
- 1:23:32I am incompetent because your whole world is your mom, right, your
- 1:23:38parents, what they think of you. Then that's how we think of ourselves
- 1:23:42one hundred percent, and then you feel grateful that she's here, and it
- 1:23:45just creates this ongoing dependency that is very hard to get out of, right
- 1:23:53because whenever you have an impulse to step out from underneath the umbrella of your
- 1:23:58mom, because you haven't had a lot of experience with independence, and you
- 1:24:02have a lot of internalized voices saying that you're going to screw things up.
- 1:24:06Whenever you do screw things up, which is going to happen, it just
- 1:24:10happens in life, then you immediately have all these voices saying look, and
- 1:24:15you might even have your mom literally is telling you that you're stupid, and
- 1:24:17then you run back under the umbrella, and at least it's safer, it
- 1:24:24feels better underneath the umbrella. But the answer to differentiation and health and getting
- 1:24:32your life the way that you deserve to have it, which is where there's
- 1:24:36a balance and you get your needs met, is where you're able to break
- 1:24:43free of that bond and that will not bond, but that control and system
- 1:24:49that your mom has you under, and you're able to have another mentor or
- 1:24:56parent or someone to help you to guide you. Right. And so that's
- 1:25:01where therapy comes in, because what often happens is again either the person stays
- 1:25:09underneath the overfunctioner or they find another overfunctioner. Right. These individuals that were
- 1:25:15describing are very prone to being abused later on because an abuse of controlling,
- 1:25:20overbearing person fits very well with someone like this obviously, So it's a really
- 1:25:28hard thing to get out from under. And like I said, because the
- 1:25:32individuals don't have practice doing things on their own, they are actually incompetent,
- 1:25:38and so when they try to be independent, they do screw things up in
- 1:25:43an age inappropriate way. For a fifteen year old for example, I'll just
- 1:25:48use myself. When I was a teenager, I at times was a very
- 1:25:55responsible employee. I would show up on time and I would do my work
- 1:26:00various jobs as a teenager from thirteen to nineteen, But there were some times
- 1:26:05when I was very irresponsible. Like there was a time when I was eighteen
- 1:26:10and I went to It was summer after my senior year, and I went
- 1:26:14to a party at my friend's house for Fourth of July and I had California
- 1:26:18wine coolers, if you remember, a two leader, which was the drink
- 1:26:25of choice back then, and I had not drank alcohol, maybe but once
- 1:26:31before that. I don't know. But I woke up late the next morning,
- 1:26:35naturally, and I was supposed to work that day, but I forgot.
- 1:26:42I was supposed to work at Ernst, which was kind of like a
- 1:26:44home depot in the Northwest, and for those who are keeping track, I
- 1:26:47worked there with Lita Liita, the one of the other first co hosts of
- 1:26:51the podcast fifteen years ago. And the business called my home called my parent
- 1:27:00said, like, where's Kirk. He's supposed to be here at eight or
- 1:27:02ten or something. And my parents didn't know where I was because I didn't
- 1:27:06tell them because at that age, I just would kind of walk out the
- 1:27:11door, not because I hated my parents, but I just had a lot
- 1:27:13of independence, and so they started calling around to the usual suspects and couldn't
- 1:27:18find me because I was sort of at a friend of a friend's house in
- 1:27:21a sense. And by the time they got a hold of me, I
- 1:27:26called my boss and I was like, oh, and I'm sorry, I
- 1:27:30forgot And my boss was really upset at me. And it's funny, looking
- 1:27:34back, he was probably like twenty two years old or something, maybe twenty
- 1:27:38he wasn't, but he seems so old to me, and he's like,
- 1:27:42ah, you know, he was, and he was real angry, and
- 1:27:45in my head, I'm like, you have dozens of employees, it's not
- 1:27:47like everything hinges on me being there. But still it was irresponsible. It
- 1:27:51was bad, and you know, he was upset, and in my head,
- 1:27:55I'm like, okay, fine, enough of the chastising. I don't
- 1:28:00you're not my dad like tell me that I did something, fire me or
- 1:28:03something, but I don't need to listen. So he's kind of getting into
- 1:28:08the realm of berating me unnecessarily, and I, you know, at first,
- 1:28:15I felt I felt genuinely bad, and I felt bad, particularly to
- 1:28:17my parents having to call all over Kingdom come to find me. But I
- 1:28:23he you know, so he's laying into me. He's laying into me.
- 1:28:26And then I just I saw the future and I was like, Okay,
- 1:28:30how is this going to play out? So I have to go back to
- 1:28:32work and I have to be all begging for his forgiveness and I have to
- 1:28:38deal with him like being a dick to me for a while and I and
- 1:28:41I didn't like the job very much anyway, and so on the spot,
- 1:28:45I just said, yeah, I quit. I just you know that.
- 1:28:50And I was going to college and like a month so I wouldn't have been
- 1:28:55able to work there anyway. And I just thought, yeah, I quit
- 1:29:01because I just I just thought, you know, I don't want to deal
- 1:29:03with this right now. I don't. This is just the summer job.
- 1:29:06I don't need the money necessarily. There's probably another job I could get.
- 1:29:13And so for me, I made that mistake. And that is an eighteen
- 1:29:20year old sort of thing to do. I didn't do it all the time,
- 1:29:24but I did do it. The issue is is that if you are
- 1:29:28being criticized all the time, and you're made to be very dependent and almost
- 1:29:32childish in your competence level and your confidence level. Then you could be thirty
- 1:29:39five and heading to a job and make a mistake like that, but it
- 1:29:44looks much worse and people will frame it as much worse because you're thirty five
- 1:29:47and you made an eighteen year old mistake at the age of thirty five,
- 1:29:53because you were never allowed to be independent. At eighteen, My parents let
- 1:29:58me choose where I would going to work. They let me, you know,
- 1:30:00they they told me I was going to get a job, but they
- 1:30:03didn't tell me where, and they didn't really even tell me where to go.
- 1:30:08I just had to look around, right, And of course, if
- 1:30:11you look back in the time scale when I was thirteen, it was different.
- 1:30:16I got a job and it was completely overseen by my parents. They
- 1:30:20literally would drive me. It was a Chinese restaurant that my sister worked at,
- 1:30:25by the way, so I worked with my older sister, and it
- 1:30:29was Sun's Sun Chinese restaurant in downtown a sequause like, one of the only
- 1:30:32three restaurants in town at the time. And at the age of thirteen,
- 1:30:39it was a different set of independences that I was expected to exhibit, and
- 1:30:44I learned from that. So at eighteen. I had progressed, you know,
- 1:30:47through other jobs, but I was still incompetent and immature and as reflective
- 1:30:58of my age, you know. But I learned from it. I learned
- 1:31:02something when that happened. I learned I shouldn't do that, and I should
- 1:31:06plan ahead, and that if I'm going to drink alcohol, I need to
- 1:31:11know that I might forget things or something. But when you are made to
- 1:31:17be incompetent and you're criticized, you have all this criticism trauma. Then all
- 1:31:24of that learning gets pushed into the future. So when you're thirty five,
- 1:31:29you're learning lessons that you should have learned when you were fifteen. It's not
- 1:31:31your fault that is happening, but you were denied that opportunity to learn those
- 1:31:38lessons from a parent that pushed you to be a little bit independent within reason
- 1:31:44and was there for you when you made a mistake. Right, and at
- 1:31:48thirty five, it's very hard to deal with such that you might immediately run
- 1:31:55to an overfunctioner because of how humiliating it is and how scary it is,
- 1:31:59you know what I mean. So when I work with people in this situation
- 1:32:01with this kind of criticism, trauma. I start from the beginning. I
- 1:32:05might even frame it like I'm framing it now now, Anonymous military patron.
- 1:32:11I don't know if what I'm describing is reflective of your experience. You might
- 1:32:15actually be talking about something else, But it sounds like what you and your
- 1:32:19siblings do is you tend to kind of avoid, maybe, and you escape
- 1:32:25through these different things that you're talking about. So I don't know if I'm
- 1:32:29understanding what you're saying, which would mean that my entire yammering would be completely
- 1:32:33off base, which is always possible. All right, Well, that's enough
- 1:32:38out of me, and everyone, please please, please, please please please
- 1:32:42take care of yourself truly because you deserve it, you really really do.
- 1:32:45And get sleep.