Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Elizabeth Eurgubian: Behind the Curtain at NCUA’s Communications Office
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker: Hey everyone welcome to another episode with Flying Colors.
- 0:02I'm excited to be here today with e Elizabeth, er Gian Elizabeth.
- 0:08How are you doing today?
- 0:09Speaker 2: I'm doing great.
- 0:10Thanks for having me.
- 0:11Speaker: Yeah, my pleasure.
- 0:12I'm gonna give a little bit of your background.
- 0:13You can kind of fill in the blanks if I miss anything, but you're currently.
- 0:17A partner at Atlas Advocacy you and is in that role.
- 0:21You, one of your clients is DCUC.
- 0:23That's right.
- 0:24Um, and you, before that, you were the director of the Office of
- 0:28External Affairs and Communication and an advisor to the chair.
- 0:32I had to look at my notes on that.
- 0:33'cause in my mind that's, PAA used to always be Public
- 0:35and Congressional affairs.
- 0:37And even what, when I was there, they changed the name, but it,
- 0:39for me, it'll always be paca.
- 0:40Yep.
- 0:41Then before that, you were the Deputy Chief Advocacy Officer at cuna.
- 0:46And before that, a vp of at ICBA.
- 0:49So a lot of, trade association work, uh, and then you pivoted
- 0:53to working, uh, for a regulator, which I'm sure we'll get into here.
- 0:57But any of any steps along the way I, that you wanna highlight there
- 1:00that I missed in your background?
- 1:01Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah.
- 1:02Um, well, I started out actually, you know, went to law
- 1:05school, did that whole thing.
- 1:06I started out as an attorney at the Federal Reserve.
- 1:09So that's another, uh, so I sometimes will compare the Fed to the NCUA,
- 1:14uh, on occasion, 'cause I did, I did work there as well as an attorney on
- 1:17consumer financial services regulations.
- 1:20A lot of the stuff that I worked on there.
- 1:22Then moved over to the CFPB when that became an agency.
- 1:26And then after I worked at the Fed for about four and a half years, I
- 1:30wanted some in-house experience, which, you know, I wish more folks in DC
- 1:34on the policy side had and I worked.
- 1:37At Sally May when they were, you know, fortune 400 company, and, and I, I
- 1:42helped with their private student loan products, you know, the loan agreements,
- 1:46the marketing, um, the, if there were problems with the a PR, the, the
- 1:51operational issues, that sort of thing.
- 1:53So I was, that was in my legal portfolio while, while I was there.
- 1:56And then I.
- 1:57Because I loved advocacy so much.
- 1:59I did a little bit of that working at Sally Mae, and I
- 2:02thought, this is really fun.
- 2:04That's when I transitioned over to ICBA to work more so on the advocacy side.
- 2:09Speaker: Okay, got it.
- 2:10And then you had the opportunity at cuna and then, uh, you, you the where we didn't
- 2:15pat, our cross didn't pass pass because I had left NCA by the time you came in.
- 2:20Yeah.
- 2:21And uh, as I said, uh, public and congressional affairs.
- 2:25The people who helped get our message across is how I always viewed it as.
- 2:29But you were in charge of that for Chairman Harper, correct?
- 2:32Speaker 2: Yes.
- 2:33Yes.
- 2:33Uh,
- 2:34Speaker: So walk through a little bit, uh, about your
- 2:36experience at NCUA in that role.
- 2:40Speaker 2: Sure.
- 2:40And it, in that, that role, the Office of External Affairs and
- 2:43Communications, we call it oac, it was paca before I was there.
- 2:48It pretty much oversees all of the.
- 2:51Lobbying for the agency the relationships with members of Congress because as
- 2:56you know, there's all these annual reports that the NCA has to submit.
- 2:59Um, whenever members of Congress have questions on legislation
- 3:04that they're working on, like they need technical assistance, the
- 3:07O EAC office will oversee that.
- 3:10That process.
- 3:11And that's really important from a trade association standpoint because you want,
- 3:15because folks on the hill don't understand credit unions, they don't understand
- 3:18the model like we think they do.
- 3:20And when NCUA can be very active in their communications with members and
- 3:25their staff to educate them on things, that is critical because it's very
- 3:29easy to get something wrong on the hill, especially when things move fast.
- 3:33So that's another function of oac.
- 3:35Any kind of relationships with the members of Congress?
- 3:38Of course, you know, the chairman usually testifies twice a year.
- 3:41We help them through that process.
- 3:44If there's ever other staff members that testify, which we did have a few
- 3:47others when I was there we work with them through that process, and that's a
- 3:52whole, that's kind of like a show when someone's testifying before Congress and
- 3:56we do, you know, mooding Sessions where we pretend we're members of Congress and
- 4:00ask them questions and make sure that they're really prepared for that because.
- 4:04That's a pretty intimidating process to go through.
- 4:07Uh, in addition, we work a lot on the interagency communications
- 4:12with other agencies, F-D-I-C-O-C-C, you know, the Federal Reserve.
- 4:16There's a lot of interagency efforts through the FFIC and the Financial
- 4:20Stability Oversight Council.
- 4:21I was chairman Harper's plus one at some of those FS o meetings.
- 4:27We do the external affairs, so you know, if a lead comes to town, who's
- 4:31organizing, who's gonna talk to that?
- 4:32That goes through the O EAC office as well.
- 4:35If there's other meetings that we think the chairman should
- 4:38be at, our chair should be at.
- 4:41We sort of work their calendar and make sure they're present at certain
- 4:44functions throughout the country as well as other members, um, other staff
- 4:48members at nnc UA and all the comms.
- 4:51So you're talking, you know, anything that goes external,
- 4:55any anytime of communication that goes to the outside world.
- 4:59Goes through oac and actually OAC ran a lot of internal comms as well.
- 5:04But really, the letters to to, to credit unions, we would, you know, look at those.
- 5:09We all the press releases, all of the, uh, messages that folks get by email.
- 5:14All of that went through OAC as well as when I was there.
- 5:17The website.
- 5:18I think that's since moved to another department.
- 5:20But when I was there, we were really, uh.
- 5:23We really focused on the website.
- 5:24We did a lot of work on that and social media, making sure we
- 5:28communicated very regularly with the industry via social media.
- 5:31So it was a huge portfolio to have a very important office.
- 5:37I'll also highlight for folks that don't know, the OAC office is the
- 5:42only office in the N two A that.
- 5:44Is somewhat political in that the director and the assistant director when
- 5:49I was there were political appointees.
- 5:51And that's typically the way it works.
- 5:53So we only report to the chairman and the chairman's chief of staff.
- 5:57We don't report to, you know what, what your position was.
- 6:00Uh, Larry Fazio when he was there, Larry we had meetings with him.
- 6:05Uh, we don't report to him though.
- 6:06We report to the chair and we only report to the chair.
- 6:09Again, we don't report to the full board.
- 6:11So we could, you know, interact with the other board members and
- 6:15help 'em with things here and there, but O EAC served the chair.
- 6:19Speaker: Yeah, it's a very, it's a very u unique position that, you know, 98%
- 6:24of the people at NCA don't actually understand how it's different, let
- 6:27alone, uh, the, the credit union world.
- 6:29And, um, I, I might get part of this wrong, but, so with three
- 6:32board members, each of them have two Schedule C appointees.
- 6:36For their chief of staff and their office assistant, uh, executive
- 6:40assistant, which, so that's six.
- 6:43And then there were two or three others that were additional Schedule
- 6:46Cs that were the purview of the chair.
- 6:49Right.
- 6:49Like you said, they report to the chair.
- 6:51So, um, correct.
- 6:52The other, the other board members could interact with you, but uh,
- 6:57again, your supervisor was the chair.
- 7:00And then when there's a change in chair, those positions move.
- 7:03With the new chair, right.
- 7:04And then typically what happens is if it goes from D to R in particular, there's
- 7:09a change in those positions and they bring someone in that they either knew or
- 7:13want to get into the, to, to consistent with what their beliefs might be.
- 7:17Anything to add to kind of what I said there?
- 7:20Speaker 2: No, I, I think that's, uh, maybe a couple things like,
- 7:23yeah, so, so you know, whereas, uh, chairman Harper had his, two folks
- 7:28that worked within the board office.
- 7:30Those folks would technically they would go with him if he
- 7:33stayed and moved to become a board member at a new administration.
- 7:36But the OAC folks, they go, uh, the top two are, they say goodbye
- 7:40to everybody and have a nice, you know, cake and go on their way.
- 7:45Because like you said, those are political appointees.
- 7:48And the new chair is gonna come in and they're gonna want somebody with
- 7:51their vision to run that office.
- 7:54And the other point about that, the reason behind that too is because
- 7:57if you look at the statute federal Credit Union Act, the chair is the
- 8:01spokesperson Exactly for, for the agency.
- 8:04So O EAC serves that function of helping the chair become the spokesperson.
- 8:08And that's with Congress.
- 8:10That's with, an interagency communications.
- 8:13The chairman could go to the OR chair, could go to an FSOC meeting.
- 8:17And represent a position for NCUA that the other two board
- 8:20members don't agree with at all.
- 8:21Correct.
- 8:22And they're perfectly within their statutory authority to do that, as well
- 8:26as testifying they could testify, saying this is what we'd like the agency to
- 8:29work on and talk about all these things.
- 8:31The other two board members are, are thinking, well, I don't
- 8:34necessarily agree with that.
- 8:35And that's the way it is because of the function of the chair as
- 8:38the spokesperson for the agency.
- 8:40Speaker: Sure.
- 8:40You know, and as you're describing your role there, and of course
- 8:44Todd was the director of.
- 8:46Paca, which is now oac.
- 8:48And I think back to one time in my career, I was in the Western region new director
- 8:52of special actions, and my boss was the previous director of special actions.
- 8:57And the other, a RD used to be considered himself to be the best director of
- 9:01special actions ever to walk the earth.
- 9:03And the regional director also had been a director of special action.
- 9:06So I had three bosses that previously thought they were
- 9:10the best at doing the job.
- 9:11I had.
- 9:12And so there the, the unique flavor of that is and I'll give you my perspective,
- 9:17I, Todd is a really good writer.
- 9:18He wants everything to be written extremely well, wants the
- 9:22communication to be extremely strong and built that up a little bit.
- 9:26Built the program up when he was there as an as the director and
- 9:30then I think did even more of that.
- 9:32As the chair.
- 9:33So you, you walked into to filling a role serving a chair who used to have
- 9:38that role, which is a unique, unique, it's an unique opportunity, but also
- 9:42creates, you know, some, some, uh, some synergies, but also some challenges.
- 9:49Speaker 2: Yes, absolutely.
- 9:51It is difficult in regard because they're gonna be looking at the
- 9:54position with a different eye that maybe somebody else went and be
- 9:57like, well, gee, I did it this way.
- 9:59How come you, exactly, yeah.
- 10:00So they have
- 10:00Speaker: con, yeah, they have context that other typical board members wouldn't.
- 10:04Speaker 2: Absolutely.
- 10:05I could say I loved working for Todd Harper.
- 10:07He is just a joy to work with.
- 10:10I loved working with Catherine Gia, the chief of staff, extremely
- 10:14intelligent person, and, and it was, I learned so much from both of them.
- 10:19And there were times, you know, it, it, it does.
- 10:24Raise certain issues because there's certain things I think are extremely
- 10:27important and there's certain things that, you know, maybe Todd
- 10:30thought was extremely important.
- 10:31And most of the time we were in alignment, I think.
- 10:34But every now and then, there might've been the time that we weren't.
- 10:37And my job is to.
- 10:39Do what the chair wants.
- 10:41Sure.
- 10:41And so that's, uh, that's what I would do.
- 10:44Um, and even times I had to be reminded.
- 10:46Well, that's a good idea, Elizabeth, but you're not the chair,
- 10:49you're the director of Oh yeah.
- 10:51So, but I, I gotta respect Todd.
- 10:55And, and Catherine both in that.
- 10:57They really did seek my guidance a lot and respected it.
- 11:01And, even when we didn't agree, they always asked for it.
- 11:04And I can say I've not had that in other positions where, you know,
- 11:09my, my opinion and my thoughts on something were valued so highly.
- 11:14Um, just to have that perspective.
- 11:16Even if you didn't maybe go my direction or what you wanted to.
- 11:19They always wanted my perspective.
- 11:21So I really, that's the sign of great leadership, I think.
- 11:24Sure.
- 11:24And, you know, I commend them for that.
- 11:26But yeah, it's always difficult when, uh, someone comes in.
- 11:30And you used to do that job because
- 11:33Speaker: Yeah.
- 11:33Yeah.
- 11:33It's a, it's a, it's a, like you said, it's an opportunity to learn
- 11:36more because they know some things, you know, and I, I think of my time
- 11:39with Todd educated me one time.
- 11:41'cause as you know, I came from, uh, Sarbanes office, Senator Sarbanes.
- 11:45And he used to tell, you know, we'd talk about, you know, what's the
- 11:48chances of this happening, taxation, or different things before Congress,
- 11:53you know, and he'd say, you know, when he started helping Sarbanes
- 11:56and he needed to get a vote through.
- 11:58They'd have the left, the right, and those in the middle, and it
- 12:01was those in the middle that would decide how you'd get a bill through.
- 12:04And that over time, while he was doing that, the, the, those in the middle
- 12:08the, the moving parts to get a vote done were less and less each year.
- 12:13And now you can extrapolate that today there's, there's maybe one or two on
- 12:16each side that might be swing votes.
- 12:18Yeah.
- 12:19But Todd came from a very collaborative role in Senate and I get the sense he did
- 12:25that when I saw him as a board member.
- 12:27Speaker 2: Absolutely.
- 12:27And, and I get
- 12:28Speaker: the sense, and like you say, that the chair can be can
- 12:31be collaborative or not, right?
- 12:33They can say PACA works for me.
- 12:35The letters to credit union can come from me.
- 12:37I'm the chair.
- 12:39And there were board members that I've dealt with who would just issue the
- 12:43letter and the other board members would see the letter would come out the same
- 12:46time staff and credit unions would.
- 12:48And I, I know just from the way I've seen what has come in, in some letters
- 12:54while he was chair, that he was collaborative, like he was in Congress.
- 12:57Any takes on that?
- 12:58Speaker 2: Yeah, I can give insight like that.
- 13:00So these are times actually too, where.
- 13:03Where my vision might not align with Todd's because there were times
- 13:07I thought Todd was collaborative when I didn't think he should be.
- 13:11He didn't need to be.
- 13:12You know what I mean?
- 13:12So that shows you how collaborative he is.
- 13:14Right.
- 13:14I mean, especially when the majority was on the Democratic side, the last
- 13:18year he was chair he didn't necessarily need to be as collaborative as he was.
- 13:23And he was, and there were times I sat back and was like, who ca Why
- 13:27are we taking the time to make sure.
- 13:29We have these conversations, just get this thing through.
- 13:32Who cares if someone's unhappy with it or not?
- 13:34You have the votes.
- 13:35And then I realized later why that was such a smart approach that
- 13:40he took with making sure everyone had investment in the decision.
- 13:44Because as you see now, when you have regulatory issues that swing
- 13:48back and forth, if you're invested initially in decision making on
- 13:53policy, even when you don't have to be.
- 13:56When things swing to the other side of the policy, of the aisle
- 14:01or whatever you wanna call it, when they swing to the other side.
- 14:04There's less likelihood that policies will be changed because all members
- 14:08were invested in the policy initially.
- 14:10And I know I'm saying this in a strange No,
- 14:12Speaker: no, I I no, that you said that very well.
- 14:15So
- 14:15Speaker 2: Todd was, and many times playing check chess
- 14:18and I was playing checkers.
- 14:20So I, I re and you know, when, when I saw how that played
- 14:23out later, I thought, okay,
- 14:25Speaker: that's what he was doing.
- 14:27Speaker 2: I see, I see that.
- 14:27And
- 14:27Speaker: he's just, he's just naturally collaborative.
- 14:29But it's a good way.
- 14:31Or organizationally and organically, uh, to get buy-in
- 14:36Speaker 2: Yes.
- 14:37And right because be buy-in isn't just about the, I guess it's a
- 14:40short way of saying, a longer way of saying buy-in isn't just about
- 14:43the vote, it's about the investment.
- 14:45'cause you're not gonna destroy something you were initially invested in.
- 14:48Speaker: Right.
- 14:48Yeah.
- 14:49Very well said.
- 14:49You know, and, and going back to a couple things, you, um.
- 14:53What, what we used to call them were murder boards, right?
- 14:56When you prepare Yes.
- 14:57Prepare a board member, uh, uh, you might have been involved in prepping
- 15:01ska to get confirmed and Yes.
- 15:03And staff sits out there and asks the hard questions.
- 15:06The goal being, we're gonna ask you harder questions than Congress
- 15:10does, but they what they could ask you if they decide to get feisty.
- 15:13Right.
- 15:13Right.
- 15:13So that if those come up, you're ready.
- 15:15Uh, that was, to me, was a fascinating process and fun process to be involved in.
- 15:20You know, in, I, I actually do sometimes.
- 15:24I took the murder board concept and I'll have credit union clients where I'm
- 15:28helping them saying, okay, well if NC a's, let's walk through what NCA might say to
- 15:31you relative to these issues on your exam.
- 15:34What's your answer gonna be?
- 15:35No, that's not a good answer.
- 15:36Uh, you need to get your, you know, you need to, to work on that.
- 15:39But, um, any comments or thoughts on that murder board process?
- 15:43Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 15:43In fact, I, and I think that's a great approach to take with your
- 15:47clients to kind of take what you got from the murder boarding.
- 15:49Uh, Todd did not like the term murder boarding, so we tried to
- 15:53try to find out another term.
- 15:55I, I don't know.
- 15:55That's the only term I know.
- 15:57It's, uh, mooding.
- 15:58I don't know.
- 15:59I mean, yeah.
- 15:59So, but it actually was one of my favorite things that I did at the NCUA.
- 16:04I really, I mean, it was, it was stressful, uh, to prepare for these here.
- 16:08S but I, at the, you know, it's kind of like running a race.
- 16:12You, you hate preparing for it, but after the race is done,
- 16:15you think, God, that was great.
- 16:17I kinda wanna do it again.
- 16:18It, that's what I felt like the hearings were.
- 16:20And of course we had great people to work with in that, Todd and some of the others,
- 16:26some of the NCOA staff members who had never done this before and had to, to
- 16:30testify at hearings, did an excellent job.
- 16:33Of course, Tanya.
- 16:34One of the best I've seen in terms of, uh, preparation for this sort of thing.
- 16:38Of course, she worked in the Senate.
- 16:40She had some perspective there, but it is very interesting because you
- 16:44do want to prepare them as much as possible in getting really tough
- 16:51questions, especially when it's the chairman or the chair testifying.
- 16:55So yeah, we would have to.
- 16:56We want him prepared as much as we could.
- 16:59And sometimes it's uncomfortable to have to ask your boss these questions
- 17:03that are really aggressive and have to do it in an aggressive way.
- 17:07And also the way you ask the question.
- 17:09'cause you don't just always ask the question and then wait for their answer.
- 17:12You interrupt them, you're rude.
- 17:14You ask a five part question that they don't even know where to to
- 17:17begin with, and they kind of have to be a good support about it.
- 17:21Right?
- 17:21Yeah.
- 17:21Yeah.
- 17:22It's fun.
- 17:23I actually brought one of the mooding sessions we did with
- 17:26Todd, I brought my sons in.
- 17:28They had like, it was like parent, they were off for the day.
- 17:32Oh, cool.
- 17:32So I brought two of my kids in to watch it and Todd was nice enough to let
- 17:36them sit in the back and watch this.
- 17:38And, you know, afterwards they told me he did a really good job.
- 17:40I'm like, oh, I'm glad you, I'm glad you think that, but it, you know, just
- 17:44preparing for that is a lot of work.
- 17:46You know, you have to have a binder.
- 17:48All of the things that the chair or whoever's testifying has to
- 17:51know about and has to absorb.
- 17:54They have to know who all of the members are, things about the members, uh, to
- 17:58have some perspective into the questions.
- 18:00They're gonna ask what the members that you know on the
- 18:02committee, what legislation they've supported and not supported.
- 18:06All of this has to be absorbed and any question could come up.
- 18:09I, I, I remember working for Kuna.
- 18:11And I think it was the nicest lady ever, Martha Nek testifying.
- 18:16And I had them place a Cecil question, you know, 'cause the
- 18:19trades are placing, they dropped.
- 18:21Yeah, they dropped
- 18:21Speaker: questions, right?
- 18:22Yeah.
- 18:22Speaker 2: And I'm like, Martha's not gonna, like, she doesn't work on cec.
- 18:25So, but we wanted that, that point raised in the hearing.
- 18:29We wanted airtime on Cecil at the time.
- 18:32So they ask her this, this question and you know, you gotta prepare the folks.
- 18:36To get these questions that are, have nothing to do with, their portfolio or
- 18:41they don't have the answer at the time, and, and prepare them to provide an answer
- 18:45that says, I'm gonna have to get back to you on that when I talk to my right.
- 18:48You know, my,
- 18:49Speaker 3: Yeah.
- 18:49Speaker 2: Uh, so all of these scenarios you have to prepare them for, and, and
- 18:54then in addition, you gotta do your.
- 18:56Your intelligence where you find out what members are gonna ask what,
- 19:00because sometimes they'll leak those questions to you ahead of time, right?
- 19:03Yeah.
- 19:03Uh, and sometimes the trades will leak 'em to you, you go to the trades,
- 19:06Hey what questions are you planting?
- 19:08And if you have good relationships there, they'll say, okay, Elizabeth, I'll
- 19:11tell you we're gonna plant these five.
- 19:13And you could prepare, the chair whoever's testifying for, you know, to be, to
- 19:18have a good answer for those questions.
- 19:19Now this goes to the overall point.
- 19:22That the number one most important thing if you're a lobbyist, a trade association
- 19:26person, or you work for oac, is the relationships you have with people,
- 19:30Speaker 3: right?
- 19:30Speaker 2: I, you don't have to like them personally.
- 19:33Who cares?
- 19:34You gotta have as many good relationships as humanly possible with everybody.
- 19:39Because there's always gonna be time.
- 19:41You're gonna need to ask them, Hey, can you gimme those questions?
- 19:44Hey, can, there's something I can do for you?
- 19:45So you're always making friends, you're always helping people out.
- 19:49If they need something for you, you give it to them because you
- 19:51wanna establish that capital there.
- 19:54You gotta have that good will
- 19:55Speaker: because you might need it.
- 19:56Yep,
- 19:57Speaker 2: yep.
- 19:57And I you, you're gonna have to call 'em a favor sometime.
- 20:00There are so many folks I've met that I'm like, God I don't like that person.
- 20:03But I'm like, later I had to call in a favor from them.
- 20:06So me not liking them, I don't have the the privilege of not liking them.
- 20:11I gotta like everybody,
- 20:13Speaker: if that makes, it's a lot like being executive director.
- 20:17Yeah.
- 20:19But so, um, you know, as we're talking about all these things that the office
- 20:22did and, and, uh, you know, you and I recently chatted online a little
- 20:26bit about NSU a's budget, right.
- 20:28The Trump administration put the hiring freeze in, asked for people to ask for
- 20:33agencies to come up with reorganizations.
- 20:37NCUA came up with a, a plan that was prolifically successful in getting people
- 20:42to take the opportunities to leave.
- 20:44Right, right.
- 20:45And, uh, different offices are impacted differently, but it looks like OAC got
- 20:49hit pretty hard in the budget as far as.
- 20:52The number of FTEs that were there and the number of FTEs
- 20:55that are still in the budget.
- 20:56And the challenge NCUA has right now is if people did leave, there's
- 21:02still a hiring freeze, right?
- 21:03So in their budget, they're gonna have their budget briefing, and then
- 21:07they're gonna have their final budget.
- 21:09They have, they've built in some flex, I don't know if it's 20 or 25 positions,
- 21:13where they, they're saying we'll add some positions back as needed in 2026.
- 21:19When the freeze comes off, but I think OAC was down to like three
- 21:22people, which was a, probably in the top two or three offices.
- 21:26Uh, that's gonna be a challenge to, to do all those things that you, you know,
- 21:31the examiners are gonna be challenged.
- 21:32E and I is gonna be challenged.
- 21:33Gc iss gonna be challenged.
- 21:35But putting the agency's best foot forward when new board members come in,
- 21:39getting them doing the murder boards to get them on, on board if something
- 21:43happens where there's legislation.
- 21:46You know, fighting, taxation, whatever threes.
- 21:48Three.
- 21:49Some might argue that the number it was at was more than needed.
- 21:52You could argue that in any office, but I think everybody would argue
- 21:55that three is probably not enough.
- 21:58Speaker 2: Yeah absolutely.
- 21:59And it's not one of these offices you would intuitively, you know, say, oh,
- 22:03this has to have a lot of folks, because a lot of, you know, like you said, even
- 22:09within NCUA, even within the folks that worked there, a lot of people didn't
- 22:12understand what OE Act did because it's kind of in a bubble in, in terms
- 22:16of only reports to the one member.
- 22:17It does everything for the one, the chair and everything it
- 22:20does is outside of the agency.
- 22:22So maybe not everybody within NCUA is seeing.
- 22:25The type of workload there is.
- 22:27Uh, yeah, we had 16 people.
- 22:29I would've had, to do a good job, 26 people because I wanted to do
- 22:34good work, and that comes from.
- 22:37My time working for trade Association.
- 22:39So ironically, when you have folks saying, well, we want, we want a lean
- 22:43budget, and I, I agree with that.
- 22:45You know, you wanna make sure things are streamlined and
- 22:47efficient because credit union are ultimately paying for all of this.
- 22:51And you have to be very sensitive to that.
- 22:54You also wanna put your best foot forward as an agency, like you said, and with.
- 23:01Externally, how the agency looks.
- 23:02Having three, a staff of three, that's gonna be very difficult.
- 23:07So that's one place where I saw that and I flagged and thought, oh man,
- 23:11that, that's gonna be tough because there's just so much that office does.
- 23:16We were understaffed when I was there.
- 23:18That it is just gonna be really a, a challenge.
- 23:21And I, I, I want credit unions to sort of think about that because.
- 23:26If your agency doesn't represent itself well in interagency meetings with
- 23:31the others, you have some of these interagency rulemakings that come down.
- 23:34Like with Genius Act, you don't want credit unions to get the shaft when
- 23:39those things are put together, you wanna make sure you have the brain
- 23:42power and the representation in those meetings and the right people in
- 23:46those meetings, and enough of them that they could absorb the workload.
- 23:50I working at the Fed in dealing with the NCUA.
- 23:53I, we used to kind of joke about it at the Fed that the NCUA did not have
- 23:58the teams working on these interagency rulemakings that the rest of us had.
- 24:02Like we'd have 10 people working on an interagency rulemaking.
- 24:06They'd have the same one person working on it, and one person could only do so much.
- 24:10And that means that the credit union voice and the model and the difference
- 24:15isn't gonna be as represented in those meetings as it should be.
- 24:18And that only hurts credit unions.
- 24:21All of these things need to think about Like, like Todd, you gotta play chess.
- 24:24You can't play checkers, so where are you gonna put the investment?
- 24:27You gotta put the investment in some of these other offices,
- 24:30like, oh yeah, even though it has nothing to do with examinations.
- 24:33It's how the agency's putting its face forward when dealing with all these
- 24:37outside entities, members of Congress, they could write legislation that
- 24:41they don't realize harms credit union, you know, how many bills have talked
- 24:45about the deposit fund and didn't mention the share insurance fund.
- 24:48We had to go back and say, you gotta mention the share insurance fund too.
- 24:51Or they, they would talk about, they'd use a definition of financial institution
- 24:55that didn't include credit unions because.
- 24:58The NCUA wasn't at the table to tell it, Hey, you've gotta put
- 25:01this other statutory definition that has credit unions included.
- 25:05If you don't have the people to do that, mistakes get made and credit
- 25:08unions get left out of critical policies and things that could really
- 25:13help them innovate and develop.
- 25:15And I can't tell you how many times that's happened.
- 25:17So when I see these numbers, that concerns me.
- 25:22Speaker: No.
- 25:23Great.
- 25:23Very well said.
- 25:24You know, and, and, um, when I was the executive director and, and we would
- 25:28get ready, you know, I would prep the CFO and I would prep the board for
- 25:32the budget briefings and the budget approval, and the trades would come
- 25:35in and say there's less credit unions.
- 25:38Uh, you, your budget's gone up and it shouldn't.
- 25:40And then CA would say credit unions are more are more complicated.
- 25:43There's more assets, and we have to educate our staff and we need
- 25:46to do this, and then we get these other things that come in from
- 25:49elsewhere, et cetera, et cetera.
- 25:50So there was always.
- 25:52There was always this balance, but I, I, I would look at, you know, if you, a,
- 25:56a stat I remember was the training that credit unions do for their own boards
- 26:02and the travel that they do, whatever percentage that was compared to their,
- 26:06of their assets or their gross income.
- 26:09Was roughly equivalent to the cost of the exam program.
- 26:12If you took the NCA program and the state of program and divided, you know,
- 26:15had the same denominator compared to those other costs, it's like, you know,
- 26:19you're, you're training your staff, you're doing travel to go do that, that
- 26:23training, that's what your exam costs.
- 26:26Even though it's grown.
- 26:27And to me you your spot is perfectly spot on.
- 26:30If, if you're, if N two A doesn't have staff at the table to say what
- 26:34credit union's interests are or what the agency's interest is, things can
- 26:38change, uh, like law and sausage, right?
- 26:41They happen at midnight.
- 26:41And if nobody was there to talk about it because we saved one or
- 26:45two FTEs for a year and a half, uh, that could be cataclysmic.
- 26:50Speaker 2: Absolutely.
- 26:50And now some might come back and say, well, that's what the
- 26:53trend associations are for.
- 26:54We could, we could do that and we have the resources to do that.
- 26:57But here's the thing.
- 26:58NCA is the credible agency.
- 27:00You know what I mean?
- 27:01Right.
- 27:01They're the, they're the governments.
- 27:03There's a credibility that comes with, I mean, I work for trade associations,
- 27:06I love 'em, you know, whatever.
- 27:08But there's a credibility that comes from having that government
- 27:11regulator saying, no, this is how this would actually play out.
- 27:16And having that, that consultation that is different than just
- 27:20getting it from a lobbyist.
- 27:21Speaker: Sure.
- 27:22Yeah.
- 27:22And, and even like when you say that, I think of treasury, right?
- 27:25When NCA would.
- 27:26Say, our position on the CLF is need, the powers need to be expanded.
- 27:30And then treasury would say, we agree with NCUA.
- 27:33We would be dancing, going, we have treasury on our side, right?
- 27:36Because of their credibility.
- 27:38And the same you can stack the different regulators relative to credibility,
- 27:42but NCO a's nimble is well respected.
- 27:45They're, you know, they're not treasury, but.
- 27:47There is a respect that the Senate gives consideration.
- 27:52But if you're not, again, if you're not at the table, uh, or you're, you're too
- 27:55busy doing X because you can't do y.
- 27:57Bad things can happen as a result of that.
- 28:00Speaker 2: That's absolutely right.
- 28:02Speaker: Trades time at NCA time at the Fed.
- 28:05And then the trade association side, is it, was there one or two things you
- 28:10learned about NCA and the government side?
- 28:13I mean, you, you'd obviously been at, at the Fed before, but compare and contrast.
- 28:17What, what do the trades need to know about NCUA and then what does
- 28:20NCUA need to know about the trades?
- 28:22Putting both your hats on.
- 28:25Speaker 2: I would say what the trade should know about NCUA is that.
- 28:29Their letters, the comment letters really do make a difference.
- 28:33I think.
- 28:34You know, when you write to the CF PB and they get thousands of letters, it's easy
- 28:38to feel like, I don't even know if this is gonna, you know, make an impact here.
- 28:42But the NCA doesn't get thousands of letters.
- 28:44Sometimes.
- 28:44We got 10 comment letters on something, sometimes 35.
- 28:47Uh, we didn't get the, huge numbers on issues once and very, very rarely.
- 28:54And even then.
- 28:55The staff looked at all, all the letters, and I know Todd read all the letters.
- 28:59Uh, so I think that it's really, I think the meetings are important.
- 29:03They're great to have the hike the hill and meet, meet the members and,
- 29:06and, you know, meet, uh, the staff and the board and to engage that way.
- 29:10But I think the comment letters are very important and as, as much
- 29:15effort as can, even on the individual credit union side is, is important.
- 29:19And I think credit unions think, well, I can't, I only have one issue here.
- 29:23I can't like.
- 29:24Dissect this whole fr notice.
- 29:26And I would say to them, just write your one issue.
- 29:29Uh, say this issue stood out to us.
- 29:32We defer to the trade associations on everything else, but really this
- 29:36is the one that we wanna point out to you and the impact it has on our
- 29:39credit union so that, you know, when you go into the final rulemaking.
- 29:43I think that's a really influential way to, to, to make
- 29:47your mark and to, and to show.
- 29:49What policies will work best for the, the industry and to
- 29:52really influence the board.
- 29:54Uh, the second I would say is follow up.
- 29:59I don't know if you had this experience, but you know, when you work for the
- 30:02NCA, when you work for the board, you meet with so many entities.
- 30:07And I think sometimes the, you know, you have these hike the
- 30:10hills and you have these coalitions of credit unions that come in.
- 30:13They really prepare for these meetings.
- 30:15You know the chairman's there.
- 30:17I'm there, other folks are there.
- 30:19Uh, we listened to this wonderfully prepared, articulate meeting with
- 30:25all of these points that are so.
- 30:27Interesting and thought provoking and we're thinking, yeah, this is great.
- 30:31And then I get up to walk back to my office after that meeting and I have
- 30:35literally forgotten the entire meeting on the walk from there to my office
- 30:38because there's so many meetings I go to.
- 30:41Sure, sure, sure.
- 30:41And I'm sure it's the same for others.
- 30:43So I tell folks the meeting is just the taste.
- 30:46It's just the appetizer.
- 30:48Don't think you come in for this meeting, you show this you, you have
- 30:51your position and then you're done.
- 30:54No, you're never done as a lobbyist.
- 30:56You're done when you're dead, when you're a lobbyist.
- 30:58So follow up, have a reason.
- 31:00That's great
- 31:01Speaker 3: advice.
- 31:01Yeah.
- 31:01Have
- 31:02Speaker 2: a reason to write back and say, you know, maybe have them ask a question.
- 31:05Say, oh, we'll get back to you.
- 31:06Now you have an excuse to follow up.
- 31:08Oh, per your question, we looked into that and blah, blah, blah.
- 31:11You know, you could, you follow up with emails, follow up with letters.
- 31:14That's just the first taste you, the rest of the meal.
- 31:18Has to come later.
- 31:19So don't let that be a one and done.
- 31:21'cause then it's just worthless.
- 31:23All that time you put into that meeting, you could have put it into something else.
- 31:27Great.
- 31:28So that's my advice for trade.
- 31:29Speaker: That's fabulous.
- 31:31And, and, and so thinking about that.
- 31:33You know, NAFCU, Kuna are now America's credit unions.
- 31:35I, I'm a big believer in the wisdom of crowds, right?
- 31:38One of the things you heard about those two groups merging is that's
- 31:41one less letter that goes into Congress, that goes into nnc, right?
- 31:45Speaker 3: Yeah.
- 31:46Speaker: But I, you know, I've kind of seen, I think DC uc has kind
- 31:49of stepped their game up, right?
- 31:51Saying, Hey, there, the, the, there's only one other.
- 31:55Huge voice.
- 31:56DCUC is getting bigger and gaining momentum and putting more energy into
- 32:00being commenting on, on everything, coming up with ideas as it relates to military,
- 32:06uh, related credit unions, et cetera.
- 32:08I think that's important.
- 32:09I, I know you're, you're, you work with DE in some ways, but then
- 32:12you're also doing your own own work as part of the Atlas advocacy.
- 32:16Let's talk a little bit about, about that and or what you're doing.
- 32:19Post NCUA.
- 32:21Speaker 2: Yeah, so I'm taking all the experience I learned from the, my
- 32:25agency side, the fed side, the, uh, the trade association, and then also
- 32:29working in house, um, and understanding how, how regulations actually play out
- 32:34when you have products and services.
- 32:37And representing clients.
- 32:39I, anything on the regulatory side I'm happy to work with, uh, I have
- 32:43some limitations on meeting with NCUA folks until, yeah, for a while.
- 32:46Yeah, I think for another few months.
- 32:48And then once that limitation goes away, I could, you know, have
- 32:51more engagement with that agency.
- 32:53But I've done a lot of engagements with other agencies and also speaking
- 32:57about what it was like to work at the NCA and what I think credit
- 33:00unions should sort of focus on, particularly on the advocacy side.
- 33:04What expectations I see, um, in the coming years and then talking a lot
- 33:08about cybersecurity, because that was one thing I learned at the NCA that.
- 33:12Is such a significant issue that we really we're just, we don't have as
- 33:19the big, the grasp on it that we all should, and we're living and we're
- 33:24fine today, but once a breach happens, they could be absolutely catastrophic.
- 33:28So I'm trying to communicate some of the lessons that I learned with
- 33:31the with the NCH to the industry.
- 33:33And I, I've been doing that.
- 33:34And then of course, DCUC is, uh, one client that I have.
- 33:38They're just a fabulous client because they really care about these issues.
- 33:43They wanna get it right, and they do bring a lot of interesting ideas
- 33:48on the regulatory side that can help policy makers and, and they
- 33:52just engage with everybody so well.
- 33:55So it's, it's been a pleasure working with them as well as some of the other
- 33:58leagues that I've worked with as well.
- 34:00That's great.
- 34:01On the agency side, I, I think.
- 34:04Like I had said, I, I, I know you had asked before, what, what do the agencies
- 34:10need to learn about the industry?
- 34:12And I wish more folks that worked in government had worked for a company at
- 34:18one point, or worked for credit union or a bank or something at one point.
- 34:22Because how policies actually work in the every day is not always what
- 34:28you think when you're writing them.
- 34:30So as much of concrete examples that they could learn from the
- 34:35industry and the industry has to, you know, communicate that to them.
- 34:39I think as much of that as possible, because even as a consultant
- 34:43there's only, I have to constantly talk with credit unions and with.
- 34:47Financial institutions on what they're facing because I'm
- 34:50not in it every day anymore.
- 34:52So I'm not seeing those issues.
- 34:54But I know the right questions to ask.
- 34:55'cause I used to be in that position.
- 34:57Sure.
- 34:57And I think agencies should probably have a little bit more of
- 35:01the industry folks there so they know the right questions to ask.
- 35:05'cause that's the key too.
- 35:07Really understanding what issues might be present with certain policymaking.
- 35:10So,
- 35:11Speaker: yeah.
- 35:11Yeah.
- 35:11The un unintended consequences of a, of a policy that, that, uh, that
- 35:16NCA might think is perfect, uh, that meets all the needs of the three board
- 35:19members and meets the needs of the Federal Credit Union Act, and takes
- 35:22into consideration what the trades said.
- 35:25Uh, then it gets out there and, and, um, and the, the, the credit unions themselves
- 35:29go, wait, you didn't think about x right?
- 35:31So that's, I see that in some of, I see that in some of the consulting
- 35:35that I, I've learned a lot about that, I'll say since I left NCA
- 35:38Speaker 3: to the real
- 35:39Speaker: world.
- 35:40So, Elizabeth, if, if, uh, this has been great if, um, if a listener or a
- 35:44watcher would like to reach out to you and touch base with you about anything
- 35:48that you've chatted with about here, what's the best way for them to reach you?
- 35:52Speaker 2: Uh, de my, my email, Elizabeth dot Reubin,
- 35:55E-U-R-G-U-B-I-A n@atlasadvocacy.com.
- 35:59It's a great way to reach me, email me anytime.
- 36:01You could also reach me on LinkedIn.
- 36:02I'm always checking my LinkedIn, uh, and lots of clients have reached me through
- 36:07that, just emailing me on LinkedIn.
- 36:09So, those are the best ways to reach me.
- 36:11Atlas advocacy.com
- 36:12is our website.
- 36:13I do a lot of speaking, uh, to boards just on my perspective and also.
- 36:19Consultation with credit unions.
- 36:21So that's a good way to get in touch with me.
- 36:22I'm happy to chat with anybody.
- 36:24Speaker: Fantastic.
- 36:25And I'll put those in the show notes.
- 36:26And Elizabeth, I wanna thank you for your time today.
- 36:28This has been a lot of fun catching up, uh, with you and about NCA.
- 36:33Speaker 2: Thank you.
- 36:34Thanks for having me.
- 36:35Speaker: You got it.
- 36:35And listeners, I want to thank you for listening and or watching.
- 36:38I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 36:40This is Mark TriCal signing off with flying colors.