Latest / The Afterwife Hours / Every Explanation You Send Is Oxygen
Transcript
- 0:01Hello, welcome back to the Afterwife Hours.
- 0:03I am Kerrie your host, and today we're going to talk about why you keep explaining yourself and no matter how well you've explained it, you always end up in a fight.
- 0:14It's because every explanation that you send to your high-conflice is oxygen.
- 0:21So it's 11 o'clock at night, and you're writing the long one, the text that finally explains it.
- 0:26You even have the timeline in there, the thing he said last Thursday, the reason you were late, the part about your mother.
- 0:32You read it twice because this time you're fair.
- 0:35He always says that you're not fair, so you're trying to be reasonable.
- 0:37You're trying to explain it.
- 0:39He has to see it, but he's not going to see it.
- 0:43And I want to tell you why.
- 0:45Here is the instinct we have to talk about because it is the single most expensive habit I've seen in the women that I work with.
- 0:51The instinct is to over-explain yourself, to clarify, to correct the record, to make sure he finally understands what happened.
- 0:59In a healthy relationship, that instinct is correct.
- 1:02Explaining it is how two people who both want the truth get the truth.
- 1:06That's why you have it.
- 1:08You're not doing anything wrong by having it.
- 1:10But in a high conflict divorce, that instinct is the thing that keeps you.
- 1:15in the fire.
- 1:16It's what keeps you fighting because explanations are oxygen.
- 1:21Every long response you send is air blown straight into the flames.
- 1:27Every defense keeps you in the arena, and the arena is where he does his best work.
- 1:33Think about what actually happens to that 11 o'clock message.
- 1:37He's not reading it to understand you.
- 1:39He's reading it for material.
- 1:41He's reading it to understand how he can rebuttal it.
- 1:44Every extra sentence you wrote is another sentence that can be quoted back to you out of context, forwarded to his family.
- 1:51or attached to a filing.
- 1:53You wrote six paragraphs to be understood.
- 1:56You handed him six paragraphs to work with.
- 1:59And notice the shape of it.
- 2:00He sends one line that costs him four seconds.
- 2:04You send 400 words that cost you two hours and your whole evening.
- 2:09That is not a conversation.
- 2:10That is a machine for draining you and it runs on your willingness to be understood.
- 2:14So here's the shift.
- 2:15You are not writing to him anymore.
- 2:17You are writing the record.
- 2:19There is a difference between the explanation mindset and the documentation mindset.
- 2:24Explaining is aimed at his understanding, which is not available.
- 2:28Documentation is aimed at everyone who reads this later.
- 2:32The mediator, the attorneys, the guardian ad litem and possibly a judge.
- 2:36Those are the people that are going to read a stack of messages one day and form an impression of two people.
- 2:41And I want you to be the calm one in that stack.
- 2:45Not because it's fair that you have to be, but because that is the one that's actually going to hold up.
- 2:52Which brings me to the method I teach the clients that I work with.
- 2:57It comes from a person whose name is Bill Eddy, who taught this method at the High Conflict Institute.
- 3:05He's a clinical social worker and a family lawyer, which is a rare combination and exactly why the man understands both both halves of your problems.
- 3:14He calls it a BIFF response: brief, informative, friendly, firm.
- 3:20Let me take those one at a time because most people need to hear the acronym, not a long, and then still sometimes send the long one.
- 3:30Brief.
- 3:32A paragraph.
- 3:34It's two sentences.
- 3:36And here is the reasoning that made it click for my clients.
- 3:40Length is a signal.
- 3:43Length is a long reply that tells him you're still willing to engage and it gives him more surface to attack.
- 3:50Short is not rude, short is a closed door.
- 3:54He is most likely not used to this, but that is okay.
- 3:58Informative.
- 3:59Facts only, and only the facts are really the only thing that's needed.
- 4:03Not your feelings about the facts, not the history, not the correction of his version.
- 4:08This is the hardest one because there's almost always something false in his message that you definitely
- 4:13Desperately want to fix in yours.
- 4:16But what I want you to hear is this: leave it there.
- 4:19You are giving him straight information, you are not litigating his account of reality.
- 4:23And I promise you the record will show the difference.
- 4:26Friendly.
- 4:27This is the one that makes women flinch, so let me be clear about what it means.
- 4:30It does not mean warm, it does not mean pretending, it means neutral.
- 4:35It's a neutral opening and a neutral close.
- 4:37Thank you for letting me know.
- 4:39That is all.
- 4:40And the reason is strategic.
- 4:41It's not emotional.
- 4:42It's a neutral tone that gives him nothing to react to.
- 4:46And neutral is what a stranger reading it will later register as reasonable.
- 4:51Firm.
- 4:52End it.
- 4:53State the information and stop.
- 4:56You don't need to go on and explain.
- 4:57There are no open questions.
- 5:01I don't want you to think that the more you explain things, it's going to help him understand it because the more you explain things, they are open invitations and he will
- 5:11accept every single one of them.
- 5:13Firm means the message ends and there is nothing to grab.
- 5:18And then the part I think that is most useful is the acronym itself.
- 5:23The person that I spoke about who is a clinical social worker and a lawyer in one, his name again is Billy Eddy.
- 5:31And he says to leave out the three A's, advice, admonishments, and apologies.
- 5:39What do I mean by that?
- 5:40No advice, because telling him how he should be handling this reads as superiority and he will make you pay for it.
- 5:48No admonishments, meaning, no, you always, no, I have told you a hundred times, no, reminding him of what he did, and no apologies.
- 5:58Not because you should never apologize, but because in this dynamic, a reflexive, I'm sorry, gets stored and used.
- 6:05Save.
- 6:05your apologies for people who do not get receipts.
- 6:09Let me show you the difference and what it looks like in real time.
- 6:14here's what he sends you.
- 6:15He sends you a text message that says, You made the kids late again.
- 6:18You are completely unreliable and everyone sees it.
- 6:21Here is the eleven o'clock version you want to send.
- 6:24I was not late.
- 6:25You're the one who changed the pickup time on Tuesday without telling me.
- 6:27And if you actually looked at your own text, you would see that.
- 6:30And honestly, it's exhausting to be accused of this when I am the only one who does every single run while you are traveling.
- 6:38Every word of that might be true, but it's also a gift to him.
- 6:42Because you're giving him more information than what's needed.
- 6:45And he's going to use it against you.
- 6:47Here is the biff version of that.
- 6:50Thanks for letting me know.
- 6:52Drop off on Tuesday was at 8:15.
- 6:54Going forward, I will confirm any schedule changes by email so we both have them in writing.
- 6:59Kerrie.
- 7:01Four sentences.
- 7:02It corrects the fact without arguing the fact.
- 7:05It puts a system in place and it closes.
- 7:07And if the message ends up in front of a judge.
- 7:11You don't have to say a word about which of you is easier to co-parent with.
- 7:17The last piece, and this is the one women need permission for, not every accusation requires a response.
- 7:26Silence is sometimes one of the best things that can be used, and especially for someone like this.
- 7:33Because no one is really keeping a tally where an unanswered text becomes a confession.
- 7:39In fact, in a stack of messages, a person who does not take every piece of bait is often read as the stable one.
- 7:48So here's the filter I give my clients.
- 7:50Before you reply, ask whether this message requires a decision about the children, the money, or the schedule.
- 7:56If yes, then answer it briefly with the biff.
- 8:00If no, it does not require a response at all.
- 8:03It needs a screenshot and a folder.
- 8:05That's it.
- 8:06Decisions get answers, everything else gets documented.
- 8:10And I want to name what this is going to cost you because I'm not going to pretend that it's going to be easy.
- 8:16When you stop explaining, you have to
- 8:18To sit with being misunderstood on purpose by someone who is actively misunderstanding you and telling other people about it.
- 8:26And if I'm the first to tell you this, I'm sorry, but he might actually try to bring your children into the mix.
- 8:35And say that you are being unreasonable and you are not answering questions, and you are not explaining things in a way that he understands.
- 8:46And sadly, the hardest part about this is often being misunderstood by your children, and them telling you this as well.
- 8:54This is genuinely hard.
- 8:56And if you've been the person who fixes things by talking through them your whole life, it will feel like giving up.
- 9:01But it's not giving up.
- 9:03You are just done spending your evenings trying to convince someone who decided a long time ago not to be convinced.
- 9:09That energy has somewhere better to go, and honestly, so do you.
- 9:16If any of these things today stood out in terms of wow, I see myself inside of this marriage.
- 9:24This is something that lives inside of high conflict marriages every single day.
- 9:29And so if anything, if you don't book a call with me and if you don't want to start working with me and working alongside the very things that would help get you back to a
- 9:41place of happy and healthy, that's fine, you're not there yet.
- 9:45But at the very least, take some of what I taught you today and instill these communication methods because at the very most, you do deserve to get your voice back and
- 9:56you deserve to be respected in relationship.
- 9:59I'm Kerrie, Thank you for listening, and I will see you on the next one.
- 10:03Thank you.