Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When You Were Just Hired at a Lower Band Than Peers
Transcript
- Lucas: So Luna, we got a question from a listener named Priya, and her situation is one that I think a lot of people have been in but are often too nervous to talk about. She was hired three months ago at a salary that she now knows is on the low end of the band for her role, and she's found out that two peers who started around the same time were offered more—like, several thousand more. Luna: Oof, that's a tough spot. And I bet the first instinct is to feel resentful, maybe even think about leaving. But she's asking if there's a way to approach this without burning bridges. Lucas: Yeah, and the short answer is yes, but it's going to require careful timing and a really solid data-backed case. The first thing I'd say is don't bring this up in your first ninety days. You need to build some credibility and show that you can deliver in the role before you start asking for more money. Luna: So you're saying she should wait? That feels like it could be frustrating, especially if she's already doing great work and knows she's underpaid. Lucas: Totally—and I get that. But the reality is that a manager is much more likely to advocate for a raise when they see tangible results, not just a complaint about equity. A good time to have that conversation might be around the six-month mark, or maybe right before your first formal performance review, whichever comes first. Luna: And what kind of data should she bring? I mean, she knows what her peers make, but that's usually not something you want to lead with, right? Lucas: Right—leading with 'I know what so-and-so makes' is a fast way to get shut down. Instead, she should focus on market data. She can pull salary surveys from sites like Glassdoor or Payscale, or even look at recent job postings for similar roles with salary ranges. The goal is to show that her current pay is below the market midpoint for her experience and location. Luna: So it's about positioning it as a market adjustment, not an internal comparison. That makes sense, because if the company has a strict band, they might say 'we hire at different levels' and that's that. Lucas: Exactly. And that's actually another angle—she should also check if her title is the same as those peers. Sometimes companies bring people in at different levels even if the title looks the same, and that can explain the pay gap. But if she's confident that it's the same level and same responsibilities, then she has a stronger case. Luna: I also think she needs to be prepared for the possibility that the answer might be 'no'—not because she doesn't deserve it, but because the budget cycle just doesn't allow it. So what's the smart way to respond then? Lucas: She should ask for a clear path to a review in the next performance cycle. Something like, 'I understand the budget might be tight right now, but can we schedule a follow-up in three months to revisit this based on my performance and any market changes?' That way you get a commitment, not just a brush-off. Luna: And she should document everything—not just the conversation, but her contributions, any wins, even informal praise from colleagues. That way she has a file ready for that follow-up. Lucas: Absolutely. And one more thing—she should also consider how she frames the ask. Instead of saying 'I deserve more money,' she can say 'I'm excited to be here and I want to make sure that my compensation reflects the value I'm bringing and the market rate for this role.' It's a much more collaborative tone. Luna: That's a good script. But I'm curious—what if she finds out that the band actually does allow for a higher salary, but her manager just isn't empowered to give raises outside the cycle? What does she do then? Lucas: Then she could ask if there's flexibility for a one-time adjustment or a sign-on bonus as a bridge. Some managers have discretion for that kind of thing even if they can't change the salary band right now. It's worth asking, but she should be prepared that they might say no to that too. Luna: And if it's a hard no, at least she's planted the seed. And she knows that if the market doesn't correct within a year, she has a decision to make. Lucas: Right. And honestly, this is a situation where the long-term play might be to focus on getting a promotion or a title change that naturally comes with a bigger pay jump. She can ask her manager what skills or achievements would make her a candidate for a senior role in twelve to eighteen months. That shifts the conversation from 'pay me more' to 'help me grow into a role that pays more.' Luna: That's a really smart reframe. It shows ambition without coming across as entitled. Lucas: Exactly. Now, I will say—there is one scenario where she might want to move faster, and that's if she discovers that the pay gap is an HR violation. Like if she's being paid less because of her gender or ethnicity. In that case, she shouldn't wait. She can go to HR or an employment lawyer, but that's a much more serious step and she should be careful. Luna: Good point. But for most people, it's not that—it's just a negotiation miss on their part. They accepted an offer that was lower than they could have gotten. And that happens. I remember a friend who took a job and later found out that she left money on the table because she didn't counter. She was kicking herself for months. Lucas: Yeah, and that's a lesson a lot of us learn the hard way. But the good news is that it's not a life sentence. With the right approach, you can correct course. Luna: So, to wrap this up—what's the one key takeaway you'd want Priya to remember? Lucas: The key is to be strategic and patient. You don't want to be the person who complains about pay three months in. You want to be the person who delivers results, brings market data, and asks for a conversation at the right moment. And if the answer is no, you ask for a timeline and a plan. Luna: And that's a solid playbook. I think Priya has a real chance of getting a raise if she approaches it this way. Lucas: I do too. And you know, it's funny—this kind of advice is exactly why we started this show. We want to help people navigate real career situations without the fluff. And we deliberately keep the show ad-free because we think you shouldn't have to sit through commercials to get useful advice. Luna: Yeah, and if that's valuable to you, the best way to support us is to grab a coffee for the team. You can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Right, that's the only ask. And it genuinely helps us keep doing this. But back to Priya—I'd say the biggest mistake she could make is to do nothing. Even if she doesn't get the raise right away, starting the conversation sets a precedent that she's aware of her worth and she's not afraid to advocate for herself. Luna: And that's a great note to end on. Thanks for being here, everyone. Lucas: We'll talk soon.