Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the IKEA Effect Works in Office Politics
Transcript
- Lucas: So we all know someone at work who is obsessed with a project they built from scratch, even when everyone else can see it's a train wreck. That's the IKEA effect in action, and it's one of the most underrated forces in office politics. Luna: The IKEA effect — that's the one where we overvalue things we've put effort into, right? Like the furniture. Lucas: Exactly. The name comes from a famous study by Dan Ariely and his colleagues at Harvard. They had participants build IKEA boxes, origami, and LEGO sets, and then asked them how much they'd pay for their own creations versus identical pre-made ones. People consistently valued their own work as much as five times higher. Luna: Five times? That's wild. But how does that play out in the office? Lucas: Well, think about the colleague who spends months building a custom spreadsheet to track client data when the company already has a perfectly good CRM. They're convinced their tool is superior, and they'll defend it to the death. The effort they put in blinds them to its flaws. Luna: And that effort also creates a kind of ownership, so any criticism feels personal. Like you're attacking their baby. Lucas: Right. And that's where the political dimension kicks in. The person who owns that pet project has a stake in making sure it's seen as valuable, so they'll push for resources, defend it in meetings, and sometimes even badmouth alternatives. It's a classic power play. Luna: So what do you do if you're the one with the pet project? How do you get perspective? Lucas: First, you need to actively seek outside feedback. Not just from people who will tell you what you want to hear, but from someone who has no stake in the project. Ask them, 'What am I missing?' And be prepared to hear that it's not as good as you think. Luna: That takes a lot of humility. But what if you're the one watching someone else's pet project derail a team? Lucas: That's trickier. You have to approach it carefully. Instead of saying, 'Your project is a waste of time,' you could frame it as, 'I'm wondering if we've considered all the options.' That respects their effort while opening the door to better solutions. Luna: And there's actually a strategic side to this, too. You can use the IKEA effect to your advantage in negotiations or when you want buy-in. Lucas: Exactly. If you let someone contribute to your idea, they'll feel more invested in it. It's the same principle behind co-creation and crowdsourcing. You get people to build with you, and they'll champion the result as much as you do. Luna: That's a real insight. So the IKEA effect can be a tool for building alliances. Lucas: It is. But it's a double-edged sword. The same bias that makes you overvalue your own work can also make you blind to your blind spots. So you have to balance confidence with humility. Luna: And speaking of balance, we talk a lot about these biases on the show, and we do it without ads. That's a choice we've made — we want to keep this content free and accessible. If you find it useful, you can support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a simple way to keep the podcast going. Lucas: Yeah, listener support really matters. It lets us keep digging into these topics without any commercial pressure. So if you've ever gotten something from the show, that's the place to go. Luna: Alright, back to the IKEA effect. One thing that strikes me is how it connects to the endowment effect. Are they different? Lucas: They're related but distinct. The endowment effect is about valuing something more just because you own it, even if you haven't put any effort into it. The IKEA effect specifically involves effort. You could own a pre-assembled table and not feel the same attachment as one you built yourself. Luna: So the IKEA effect is like the endowment effect plus a dose of effort justification. Lucas: Exactly. And effort justification is a powerful driver. When we invest time and energy, we tell ourselves it must be worth it, because otherwise we're admitting we wasted our effort. Luna: That explains why people stay in bad relationships too. But let's stay at work. Lucas: Another angle is the not invented here syndrome, which is basically a group-level IKEA effect. Teams that develop something internally often reject external solutions, even if those are objectively better. It's like they're saying, 'We built this, so it's better.' Luna: And that can be a huge problem in tech companies, where the latest open-source tool might be far superior to a homegrown solution. Lucas: Right. I remember reading about a company that spent millions building a custom database system when they could have bought a commercial product for a fraction of the cost. But the engineers were so proud of their creation that they fought the change for years. Luna: So how does a manager break through that? How do you get people to let go of their IKEA projects without killing morale? Lucas: You have to acknowledge the effort first. Say, 'I know you've put a lot into this, and I respect that.' Then shift the conversation to outcomes: 'What's the best result for the team?' That way, you're not attacking them personally. Luna: And maybe you can repurpose their work. Like, 'You've learned a lot from this that can be applied elsewhere.' Lucas: That's a great tactic. You're validating their effort while redirecting it. It's a win-win. Luna: What about using the IKEA effect on yourself? For motivation, I mean. Lucas: Oh, that's interesting. You can deliberately put more effort into a task to increase your own commitment. For example, if you're leading a project, write a detailed summary of your vision by hand. The act of writing it out makes you more invested, which can help you push through challenges. Luna: But isn't that also dangerous? You might end up overcommitting to something that isn't working. Lucas: That's the line you have to walk. The IKEA effect can be a motivational boost, but you have to pair it with regular reality checks. Set milestones and be willing to kill the project if it's not meeting them. Luna: So it's about using the bias to your advantage without falling into the trap. Lucas: Exactly. And there's another subtle political play: letting someone else claim ownership of an idea. If you want buy-in from a powerful colleague, let them take the lead. They'll feel the IKEA effect, and they'll become your biggest champion. Luna: That's Machiavellian but smart. Do you see that happen a lot? Lucas: All the time. You see it in companies where senior leaders take credit for junior employees' ideas. The clever junior employees actually engineer that by seeding the idea and letting the boss run with it. It's a way to gain influence. Luna: So the IKEA effect isn't just a bias to be aware of, it's a tool you can wield. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's the key takeaway. The IKEA effect is present in every office, every team, every project. Recognizing it in yourself and others gives you a real edge in navigating office politics. Luna: So next time I see someone fiercely defending a mediocre spreadsheet, I'll think, 'Ah, the IKEA effect.' Lucas: Exactly. And maybe you'll know how to handle it a little better. That's the goal. Luna: Great. Well, thanks for joining us on this episode of The Office Politics Podcast. We'll see you next time. Lucas: And remember, if you enjoyed this, you can support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It helps us keep doing what we love. See you soon.