Latest / Sex Within Marriage Podcast : Exploring Married Sexuality from a Christian Perspective / SWM 096 – Why men being submissive is problematic
Transcript
- 0:44Hello and welcome to the Sex Within Marriage podcast. My name is JD and I blog over at UncoveringIntimacy.com and today we're going to tackle a question that I received from our Have a Question page a while ago, but I wanted to write its own post about it because I'm seeing this come up more and more.
- 0:58And the question was, I wanted to know if there is any reason that the man can't be the submissive part sometimes during sex. I feel like I want to be submissive from time to time, but I don't want to ask my wife because it's an awkward topic.
- 1:12And questions like this are becoming more common because there's been this war on masculinity for some time now. Our society has long been telling men not to be men. We've had an entire generation of men grow up confused about how they're supposed to act, their purpose, and who they're supposed to be.
- 1:29Also, definitions continue to expand to mean things that they never did and ideas conflate to confuse issues. So this one in particular I think needs to be clarified for a few reasons.
- 1:40The first is that our society has completely changed the meaning of submission. We used to understand that all people submit in a variety of ways. I submit to my boss at work, we all submit to God, I submit to others when they're correcting me, and vice versa, as per Ephesians 5.21.
- 1:56We can even ask people to correct us and submit ourselves to them for correction. Submission is not a shameful thing. It's a valuable, humble thing that is appropriate in various situations.
- 2:06For example, if you have a sports team, the team usually either has a captain or a coach or both.
- 2:12They might all have ideas about what the strategy should be, but the teammates will submit to the captain, and the captain will submit to the coach if there is one.
- 2:19Not because the teammates' strategies could be better or because the coach is more valuable. It's because someone has to be the leader or else you have chaos.
- 2:29And in marriages, this should be husbands.
- 2:31Our biology has been linked to it. I have a whole post on that, which I think is why God tells us that this is the way it should be.
- 2:38And I have a post on that as well, which I'll link to in the show notes.
- 2:43And like the players of the soccer team, that doesn't mean I think women should be silent.
- 2:47I want my wife to bring her best ideas.
- 2:50And like the soccer team, in which the coach doesn't get to make decisions outside of the sphere of the sport,
- 2:56I don't think all men are authoritative over all women.
- 2:59I'm talking about marriage here.
- 3:01And you're welcome to disagree with me on those posts if you like.
- 3:04Like I said, links are in the show notes. Have at her.
- 3:07It's not a popular or politically correct opinion these days.
- 3:10Quite the opposite.
- 3:12Our society seems to want to demonize men so often that we forget this calling to lead in our homes and be protectors of God's creation.
- 3:20Sadly, we're also seeing this adopted inside many of our churches.
- 3:24I even see large, prominent Christian marriage bloggers and podcasters joining this agenda in demonizing men.
- 3:30I saw a tweet just this week that categorized all men as monsters and all women as their victims.
- 3:35But I think women want a man who will lead, a man who will protect, a man who will provide.
- 3:42They want a capable and safe man like a lion who has decided not to eat you.
- 3:47Not safe like a cute kitten who tries to attack you but poses no threat to anyone.
- 3:51It reminds me of this quote from The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe from C.S. Lewis
- 3:54where he's talking about Aslan the lion and the beaver asks, is he safe?
- 4:00And he says, no, he's not safe.
- 4:01He's a lion, but he's good.
- 4:03And I think that's what men should be aspiring to be.
- 4:07The problem is that men, women want a lion, but they're also scared of it.
- 4:11A kitten feels a lot safer, but kittens aren't sexy.
- 4:14They're cute.
- 4:15And I repeatedly hear and see from wives about what turns them on is adventure and excitement
- 4:21and, yeah, a little bit of fear.
- 4:24They want to be safe, but not too safe.
- 4:26Because too safe is comfortable, and comfortable isn't sexy either.
- 4:30It's boring.
- 4:31And that's why some of the printable games that we have in our shop work so well.
- 4:35There's an element of sort of danger.
- 4:38You don't know what card will come next.
- 4:40And so it's exciting.
- 4:42And because you're not in control, you enjoy it.
- 4:44And also, it's not your fault.
- 4:46I've learned most women love to have plausible deniability when enjoying sex,
- 4:50especially more taboo, adventurous activities.
- 4:54And I repeatedly see women push their men to do something that they're not okay with.
- 4:58They want to see that lion, but if he caves, they're momentarily happy
- 5:02because they got what they wanted, but then they lose respect for him.
- 5:07And maybe not a lot.
- 5:08It depends on what the ask was and how far she had to push.
- 5:11But after you repeat this pattern several times, that respect dwindles to very little.
- 5:16I believe God warned us about this in Genesis 3, verse 16.
- 5:19The verse says, this is after the fall, and God is talking to Eve.
- 5:22And he says, your desire shall be contrary to your husband, but he shall rule over you.
- 5:26And that word in Hebrew for desire is used in this context.
- 5:30It isn't sexual desire.
- 5:31It's a desire to consume and control.
- 5:34It's the same word used a chapter later when God is talking to Cain before he murders Abel.
- 5:38He says, if you do well, will you not be accepted?
- 5:40And if you do not do well, sin is crouching at the door.
- 5:43Its desire is contrary to you, but you must rule over it.
- 5:47We see a lot of similarities here because the struggle between a wife and a husband
- 5:50and the battle between sin and a believer has some similarities.
- 5:54I'm not saying women are evil, or at least any more evil than men.
- 5:57We all have a sinful nature.
- 5:59Only that there's a similar struggle here.
- 6:02As men, we need to be strong and stand for what we believe and fulfill our role to protect,
- 6:06to provide, and to safeguard.
- 6:08And in the same way that Christians need to stand firm against sin.
- 6:11Because if you cave in, you're not going to achieve what you thought you would.
- 6:15It looks good, but then if you accept it, things start to fall apart.
- 6:20And now, I'm not talking about when the wife makes a good argument for something,
- 6:23and he sees a new perspective and agrees.
- 6:25My wife's perspective is an incredible asset to me.
- 6:28Sometimes, I don't like to hear her ideas if they conflict with mine, like we all do.
- 6:32You know, if you have an idea and someone butts up against it, that's uncomfortable at first.
- 6:36But often, she's right.
- 6:38And other times, she's not.
- 6:40However, when a husband gives in to his wife just to try to keep the peace,
- 6:43rather than to stick to his beliefs or try to find the best path forward,
- 6:47he ceases to be that lion and instead turns into that kitten.
- 6:50Living by happy wife, happy life will result in neither, in my experience.
- 6:54And the experience of a lot of men that I talk to, and wives too, for that matter.
- 6:58I've talked to many of them who get very upset and frustrated that their husband will not stand
- 7:03up for them and just caves in.
- 7:04It's the same as if you have a pastor who makes a mistake.
- 7:06If you go to the pastor and show him his error, and he, of his own volition,
- 7:09goes to his congregation, apologizes, repents, and changes, you'll have respect for him.
- 7:14If he doesn't, if you force the issue, make him apologize, force him to submit.
- 7:18Even if he apologizes, you won't respect him anymore,
- 7:20because you made him submit to you, and he's supposed to be leaving.
- 7:24So, my question to ask you is, are you sure you want to be submissive?
- 7:29It could be that you're looking for something else.
- 7:31Many men who think that they want to be submissive may wish to be on the receiving end of pleasure.
- 7:36Ideally, both spouses are active in the marriage, inside, and outside of the bedroom,
- 7:40providing love and pleasure to each other.
- 7:41But when that doesn't happen, it seems that, more often than not,
- 7:46men are the more active participant during sex.
- 7:48As a result, they tend to give a lot more pleasure than receiving it.
- 7:52They get pleasure at the same time, but it's different getting pleasure from your own actions
- 7:55than from someone giving it to you.
- 7:58Incidentally, I think that's why many men make a big deal out of getting oral sex,
- 8:02because it's an act where they receive pleasure without any personal action,
- 8:06which is rare for a lot of men.
- 8:08Many men don't even give gifts often.
- 8:10We tend to buy our own presents, we pay for our own entertainment,
- 8:12we court the women we want, and we take the emotional risk to initiate sex.
- 8:17We go and get things we desire.
- 8:18To have someone say, just sit back, I'm going to do this for you, is rare.
- 8:24And that could be what you're looking for, someone to focus 100% on you for a time.
- 8:29Sometimes it's nice to relax while the co-pilot handles the stick, as it were.
- 8:34And the other thing I'll often hear is that husbands wish their wives would tell them what they want,
- 8:38especially regarding sex.
- 8:40Christian wives tend to be, again, not all, but some, many, reserved when discussing sexual desires.
- 8:46And I've heard from untold husbands who are so frustrated that their wife won't tell them their fantasies,
- 8:51what positions they like, what turns them on, what gets them close to orgasm,
- 8:55even if they've had an orgasm, when they're in the mood, what activities to try on.
- 8:59So sometimes when men say they want to be submissive, it's because the fantasy dominant woman in their head
- 9:05is straightforward in her communication and desires.
- 9:08She tells them what she wants from him, and then he does it.
- 9:10She expresses her passion, sets expectations, and then vocalizes her pleasure.
- 9:14In short, she tells him what she wants.
- 9:16There's no mind reading involved.
- 9:18And that could be what you're looking for.
- 9:21And lastly, I often see that men are afraid to be men.
- 9:25Many of us have been so beaten down in our society that it's sometimes hard to stay standing.
- 9:30When everyone tells you that women don't want you to protect them, to provide for them,
- 9:34that masculinity is toxic, that society doesn't need you,
- 9:37that men are monsters like what I saw in that tweet this week,
- 9:40some men just give up.
- 9:41And if you have a wife who has adopted these same ideas,
- 9:44it's challenging to stand up and follow God instead of society's desire for you to lie down and die.
- 9:49At best, that desire is understood figuratively, and they just give up.
- 9:53At worst, some men take it literally.
- 9:55Suicide is the leading cause of death for men aged 15 to 44,
- 9:58other than accidental injury, according to the National Institute of Health in the U.S.
- 10:03It accounts for nearly three times as many deaths as COVID did in that age range.
- 10:08And it's going up.
- 10:09And I think it's going to get a lot worse.
- 10:11Because our government here in Canada has joined this war against men,
- 10:16and they just legalized government-assisted suicide for those who are depressed.
- 10:21I worry that they're going to be targeting depressed men
- 10:23and suggesting that they just remove themselves from society,
- 10:27since society doesn't feel that they're needed anymore.
- 10:30So if you're depressed because the world has been beating you down
- 10:33and you have a wife who's been pushing in that same direction,
- 10:35I can see why this might tempt you to step down and say,
- 10:38I give up.
- 10:39Someone else take control.
- 10:41I don't want it.
- 10:41But it's not the answer.
- 10:43In fact, our example of life is to be like Christ.
- 10:47And so the answer then is to keep standing tall, even when they ridicule you,
- 10:52when they call you a liar and a fake, when they spit on you and beat you and you stand up,
- 10:58you carry that burden and you ask for God for the strength along the way.
- 11:01So to the person who is asking, what do you mean by submissive?
- 11:05If you want to be on the receiving end of pleasure, ask for that.
- 11:08If you want your spouse to be more straightforward when it comes to sex, then ask for that.
- 11:13If you think your wife wants this, I'd say think again.
- 11:16She may think she does, but I doubt it will end well.
- 11:19And if you feel like you can't keep going the way that you are, ask God for help and get support from other men.
- 11:24And I've recently been connecting with the guys at lionwithin.us who are all about helping men be godly men.
- 11:32Maybe check them out, get some support, figure out how to turn this stuff around.
- 11:36And that's it for today and this question.
- 11:39And if you have a question of your own, you can submit it on our have a question page.
- 11:42There'll be a link in the show notes and I'll be releasing more questions soon, just as soon as I have time to write responses and record a podcast.
- 11:54If you submit a question and you don't want to wait a long time, consider joining our support forum.
- 12:00We have a few people do that.
- 12:01They submit a question, they join the forum, and then they jump in and they see the conversation.
- 12:05They can answer questions, give us more context.
- 12:08Sometimes they leave after that and sometimes they stick around.
- 12:10Either way, it's awesome to have that.
- 12:12Back and forth so that we can gain a lot more context and help more directly.
- 12:16Lastly, if you're a wife that's listening to this and you have a husband that you want to uplift and you like him being masculine and you don't want to beat him down, you want to lift him up, check out our advent calendar.
- 12:27There's still a week left until Christmas, so you can still do seven days of it.
- 12:31A lot of people do that because they feel like the whole 25 days is just too much.
- 12:34But seven days leading up to Christmas, you will make his year.
- 12:39I guarantee it.
- 12:41So check it out.
- 12:42There'll be a link in the show notes.
- 12:43If you have any questions, feel free to email me.
- 12:47And that's it for today.
- 12:48Talk to you next time.