Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / 🚨 Buffett Indicator at 110% ‼️ Shiller PE at 38 ‼️ Housing Reveal All! Markets Are Screaming Overvaluation ⚠️
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the deep dive. You know, it feels like we're
- 0:02constantly swimming in this ocean of financial news, doesn't
- 0:06it? Headlines.
- 0:07Predictions, endless chatter. It really does.
- 0:10Information overload is a real thing.
- 0:11Exactly. So how do you, our listener,
- 0:14figure out what actually matters?
- 0:16How do you find the real signal and all that noise?
- 0:20Well, that's kind of what we're here for, right?
- 0:22To cut through some of that static.
- 0:23Precisely. That's our mission today.
- 0:25We've gathered a whole stack of recent sources, and we're going
- 0:29to do a deep dive into the signals the pros are really
- 0:32watching right now, the metrics that might give us a clearer
- 0:34picture. Yeah, trying to decipher that
- 0:36language of market valuation of economic health, which can often
- 0:39feel pretty complex. Totally.
- 0:42We want to give you a shortcut to feeling genuinely well
- 0:44informed. Maybe find some of those aha
- 0:46moments but without drowning you in data.
- 0:49Makes sense? So today we're focusing on three
- 0:51big ones, the Buffett indicator, the Schiller PE ratio you often
- 0:54hear that called KPE and the Case Schiller home price index.
- 0:58And rates, of course. Can't forget the latest on
- 1:00interest rates. Absolutely.
- 1:02We need to talk about rates. So this is all tailored for you
- 1:05to hopefully boost your financial awareness, give you
- 1:08some actionable understanding. But before we jump right in,
- 1:12it's really important to set the stage correctly.
- 1:15You know, frame what these indicators are and what they
- 1:17aren't. Good.
- 1:18Point a bit of context first. Exactly.
- 1:20These tools, they give us incredibly valuable snapshots.
- 1:24Fantastic insights into market health, no doubt.
- 1:26But crucially, they're diagnostic tools.
- 1:29They're not crystal balls. Right, they don't predict the
- 1:31future with perfect certainty. Precisely.
- 1:34And you know, our source material is very clear on this,
- 1:36and we need to be too. All the analysis we're
- 1:39discussing, it's based on publicly available data.
- 1:41And that data, well, it can be revised.
- 1:44Interpretations can differ, new information comes out.
- 1:46It's dynamic. So things can change.
- 1:48Things can change, which leads to the main point.
- 1:51This deep dive is purely for educational purposes.
- 1:54It's about gaining insights, understanding these complex
- 1:56ideas. Definitely not investment
- 1:58advice. Absolutely not.
- 2:00We want to empower you with knowledge, give you a
- 2:02foundation, but the decisions, those are yours.
- 2:06You have to conduct your own thorough due diligence.
- 2:08Always. Maybe talk to a financial
- 2:10advisor too. Always a good idea, That
- 2:12critical thinking, that diligence, it's just paramount
- 2:14in today's world, especially with how complex things are.
- 2:17OK, excellent groundwork, essential stuff.
- 2:20So let's get into our first major signal.
- 2:22And this one, well, it carries the weight of maybe the most
- 2:25famous investor ever. The Oracle himself.
- 2:28Exactly. We're unpacking the Buffett
- 2:30indicator. You hear that name, Warren
- 2:31Buffett, and it just lends a certain gravity, doesn't it?
- 2:35It really does, and he famously called it.
- 2:37What was the exact quote? Something like probably the best
- 2:40single measure of where valuations stand at any given
- 2:44moment. Pretty high price.
- 2:45Indeed shows his belief in its, well, it's simplicity and power.
- 2:49So what is it, fundamentally? It sounds complex, but the core
- 2:52idea is actually pretty straightforward.
- 2:54Surprisingly so, yeah, it's essentially a ratio.
- 2:56Right, you take the total value of the US stock market, all the
- 3:00publicly traded companies, often proxied by something broad like
- 3:04the Wilshire 5000. The whole market cap.
- 3:07And you compare that to the US Gross National Product, or GNP.
- 3:11Sometimes people use GDP Gross Domestic product, but GNP is
- 3:14maybe a slightly better fit theoretically.
- 3:17Yeah, includes that income from abroad, so market value versus
- 3:20national economic. Output.
- 3:21Exactly. We came up with this analogy
- 3:23earlier. Think of the entire stock market
- 3:26as this huge pie. OK, I like pies.
- 3:28And the entire U.S. economy, all the goods, services, everything
- 3:32produced. That's the giant kitchen where
- 3:34the pie gets baked. The economic kitchen, right?
- 3:36So the Buffett indicator just asks how big is that stock
- 3:40market pie compared to the size of the whole economic kitchen?
- 3:43Makes sense. Is the pie getting way higher
- 3:45than the kitchen seems to warrant?
- 3:46Precisely, its whole purpose is to give you this high level
- 3:50macro view. Is the market overall looking
- 3:53overvalued, undervalued, or maybe reasonably priced compared
- 3:56to the actual economic engine driving it?
- 3:58It cuts through the noise of individual stocks, gives you
- 4:01that big picture. Exactly.
- 4:03So let's connect that to now. Where does this indicator stand
- 4:06today according to our sources? Well, this is where it gets.
- 4:09It's pretty interesting. As of July 2025, the sources we
- 4:13looked at put the Buffett indicator at around 200.
- 4:15And 10 percent, 210%, OK, is that high?
- 4:18High doesn't quite capture that 210% figure marks a new cycle
- 4:23high A. New cycle high.
- 4:24Wow. How does that compare
- 4:26historically? Well, think about the major
- 4:28peaks we've seen. Only two other periods really
- 4:30came close or briefly went higher.
- 4:32Let me guess dot Tom bubble. That's one around the year 2000.
- 4:35That period just, you know, wild exuberance.
- 4:38And the other was more recent that liquidity fueled surge in
- 4:412020 and 2021. The post pandemic stimulus
- 4:44effect. Exactly.
- 4:45Massive fiscal, massive monetary stimulus pushing assets up while
- 4:48the economy was still finding its feet.
- 4:50So 210% puts us in very rare company.
- 4:53Extremely rare. To put some stats on it, our
- 4:55sources highlight this is 1.8 standard deviations above the
- 4:58historical average. OK, 1.8 standard deviations for
- 5:03those not super into stats. What's that really mean?
- 5:06It means we're way out on the tail of the distribution.
- 5:09Think of a bell curve of all the past readings.
- 5:12We're deep into the unusual zone.
- 5:14It's not just a little overvalued, it strongly suggests
- 5:17the market is significantly stretched.
- 5:19Stretched compared to the underlying economy, prices have
- 5:22run much faster than economic output.
- 5:24That's the core message. It's a pretty strong caution
- 5:27signal just on its own. That statistical context is
- 5:30really helpful. And you know the real power here
- 5:32I think is looking back, right, seeing how this indicator
- 5:34behaved around big market turning points.
- 5:37Absolutely. History provides crucial
- 5:38context. So let's do that.
- 5:40Let's take a little trip back, say 1995.
- 5:43OK, mid 90s. What was it then?
- 5:44Around 60%, which was seen as pretty fairly valued, kind of a
- 5:48baseline normal before things got, well, bubbly.
- 5:51Rightbeforethe.com mania really took hold.
- 5:53Exactly. Then Fast forward just five
- 5:55years to 2000. That peak.com craziness.
- 5:58Where is the indicator. Then it soared, didn't it?
- 6:00It absolutely soared, peaked around 150%.
- 6:04Now think about that. Everyone was caught up in the
- 6:07new economy hype. Irrational exuberance, as
- 6:10Greenspan famously called it. Right, but this indicator,
- 6:13relatively simple, was basically flashing bright red extreme
- 6:17overvaluation before the crash came.
- 6:19That's a powerful historical lesson right there, a signal
- 6:22cutting through the sentiment. It really is.
- 6:24Now let's jump ahead again. What about after the next big
- 6:26crisis, the 2008 financial meltdown?
- 6:29So post crash when fear was everywhere.
- 6:32Yeah, the cater plummeted, dropped to around 50%. 50% so
- 6:35the opposite. Extreme deep undervaluation.
- 6:37Exactly indicating the market was, you know, on sale relative
- 6:40to the economies potential huge buying opportunities looking
- 6:44back. If you had the stomach for it
- 6:45then. Indeed, nerves steel required.
- 6:47OK. One more recent very unique
- 6:50period, 2020, the pandemic onset.
- 6:53Ah yes, that was a weird 1. The indicators spiked.
- 6:55It did jump to about 180% and it was this strange mix, right?
- 6:59The market recovered incredibly fast thanks to stimulus while.
- 7:02GDP, the denominator, actually shrank sharply because of
- 7:06lockdowns. Exactly.
- 7:07So the ratio got pushed up by both sides.
- 7:09Mark it up. Economy temporarily down a
- 7:11complex signal. Showed resilience, but also
- 7:15maybe detachment from the immediate economic reality.
- 7:17Right. And that brings us back to
- 7:19today, July 2025, sitting around 200%, maybe even 210% based on
- 7:24the latest numbers. So firmly back near those
- 7:27historicpeaks.com levels post COVID surge levels.
- 7:31Which definitely suggests caution is warranted.
- 7:33It certainly does. So that brings us to the big
- 7:35question. With this indicator flashing
- 7:37200% plus, what are the real implications for you, the
- 7:41listener? Right.
- 7:42What does it mean practically? Well, generally speaking,
- 7:44anything over 100% starts signaling over valuation, but
- 7:47200%? That puts us in the
- 7:49stratosphere, historically speaking.
- 7:50Only seen it a couple of times before like we said.
- 7:52Exactly. And the strong suggestion is
- 7:54potential for significantly lower future returns from
- 7:57stocks, maybe over the next say 7 to 10 years or potentially a
- 8:01higher risk of a market correction, a sharp downward
- 8:03move the. Air gets thin up there.
- 8:05Less room to go up, more room to fall.
- 8:07That's a good way to put it, and our sources also bring in the
- 8:09interest rate factor here, which is crucial.
- 8:11How do rates play into this? Well, when interest rates are
- 8:14relatively high, especially on safer things like government
- 8:17bonds, those bonds start looking pretty attractive compared to
- 8:20stocks. Because you get a decent return
- 8:23with less risk. Precisely, if you can get a
- 8:25solid, predictable return from a bond, why take on the extra risk
- 8:29of buying into a stock market that already looks historically
- 8:32expensive according to this indicator?
- 8:34So higher bond yields act like gravity, pulling money away from
- 8:38potentially overvalued stocks. So it's a definite headwind.
- 8:41Yeah, it makes the hurdle rate for stocks higher.
- 8:43OK, that makes sense. But no indicators perfect,
- 8:45right? Are there criticisms or nuances
- 8:47we need to consider sitter with the Buffett indicator?
- 8:50Oh absolutely. It's powerful, but it's not
- 8:52infallible. There are definitely critiques.
- 8:54Like what? Well, one common argument is
- 8:57that it doesn't fully capture the effect of very low interest
- 9:01rate environments like we had for much of the 20 tens.
- 9:04The idea being that low rates justify higher valuations.
- 9:08Theoretically, yes, lower borrowing costs, future earnings
- 9:12are worth more today, etcetera. So maybe the fair value level of
- 9:16the indicator itself shifted higher during that period.
- 9:19OK, that's one point. Anything else?
- 9:21Another big one is global capital flows.
- 9:23The US stock market attracts huge amounts of money from all
- 9:27over the world. Right.
- 9:28It's not just funded by the US economy.
- 9:30Exactly. And that massive global demand
- 9:32for US assets can push valuations higher and
- 9:35potentially keep them there longer than if it were just a
- 9:38closed domestic system. The indicator doesn't explicitly
- 9:41account for that global factor. So foreign money buying U.S.
- 9:44stocks could keep the ratio elevated.
- 9:46Potentially, yes. So while it's a fantastic macro
- 9:49tool, you have to see it as one piece of a bigger global puzzle.
- 9:53Read the signals, but be aware of the context and limitations.
- 9:56Great points. Context is everything.
- 9:58OK. Let's move to our next major
- 9:59valuation tool, one designed specifically to deal with market
- 10:03volatility. It's moving out the bumps.
- 10:05Exactly. We're talking about the Shiller
- 10:07PE ratio, or as it's often called, the cheapy ratio.
- 10:11Yeah. Developed by Nobel laureate
- 10:12Robert Shiller. A very influential metric.
- 10:15So it's full name is the cyclically adjusted price to
- 10:18earnings ratio. What makes it unique?
- 10:20What's the the secret sauce here?
- 10:21The secret sauce is that 10 year look back, unlike a regular PE
- 10:25ratio which just uses the last year's earnings which can be
- 10:28really volatile. Yeah, earnings can jump around a
- 10:31lot year to year, right? The cheapie ratio takes the
- 10:34current S&P 500 price and divides it by the average
- 10:37inflation adjusted earnings over the past 10 years.
- 10:40OK, 10 years. That's the key.
- 10:43That's the key. It smooths out the business
- 10:44cycle, the booms, the busts, the good years, the bad years.
- 10:48Gives you a much clearer, more stable long term picture
- 10:51evaluation. I like the analogy you used
- 10:53earlier, like looking at your own income over several years,
- 10:56not just last month's paycheck, to understand your real
- 10:58financial health. Exactly.
- 11:00It avoids getting thrown off by a single good or bad year for
- 11:02corporate profits. It's a more robust long term
- 11:05signal. Makes sense.
- 11:07So where does this more robust, smoothed out indicator stand
- 11:11right now? Well, its current reading is
- 11:13also quite attention grabbing. As of July 2025, our sources
- 11:17have the KPE ratio at approximately 37.97, let's call
- 11:21it 30. 838 OK again need context is 38 high for the KPE?
- 11:25It is significantly high, yes. It's over 40% above its twenty
- 11:28year average, which is around 2740.
- 11:31Percent above the average. Wow.
- 11:33And maybe even more stark, the long term historical median for
- 11:36the KPE is way down around 16. 16 versus nearly 38.
- 11:39Now that's a huge. Difference, It's a massive
- 11:41difference. Puts us in very elevated
- 11:43territory historically. So similar message, the Buffett
- 11:46indicator, but arrived at differently.
- 11:47What does a KP near 38 imply for you know, for your expectations
- 11:52as an investor? The implication, according to
- 11:54the research behind KP and what our sources highlight, is pretty
- 11:57sobering for future returns. So a KP at this level near 38
- 12:02historically implies a long run real return expectation.
- 12:05That's after inflation of only about 1% to 2% per year from
- 12:08stocks. 1 to 2% after inflation. That's the historical
- 12:12correlation, yes. Unless the caveat is unless
- 12:15corporate earnings suddenly accelerate dramatically and
- 12:18sustainably from here. Wow.
- 12:19One 2% real return, that's a well that's a lot lower than the
- 12:23historical average. People often quote like 7% real.
- 12:26It is. It's a stark reminder of what
- 12:28high starting valuations can mean for future gains.
- 12:31It suggests much more modest returns ahead, mathematically
- 12:34speaking, unless something fundamentally changes in
- 12:36earnings growth. That really recalibrates
- 12:38exectations. OK, let's look at the KP's
- 12:41history too. Has it flagged previous bubbles?
- 12:44Oh, absolutely. Its track record is arguably
- 12:46even more famous or infamous than the Buffett indicators in
- 12:50this regard. Really.
- 12:50Let's walk through it back to 1995 again.
- 12:52OK, 1995 the KP was around 20, a bit above the long term median
- 12:56of 16, but not extreme stable. Rightthenthe.com.
- 12:59Boomthenthe.com boom happened and by the peak in 2000 the KP
- 13:03ratio hit an unbelievable 44.2. 44.2 That's even higher than
- 13:07today's 38. It is that four 4.2 remains the
- 13:11highest rating ever recorded for the KP ratio.
- 13:13It was screaming irrational exuberance louder than almost
- 13:16anything else. An undeniable red flag before
- 13:19the crash. Undeniable.
- 13:20In hindsight, yes. Then let's look at the other
- 13:22end, the 2008 crisis aftermath. OK, the bottom in 2009 or?
- 13:26So right around then, yeah, the KP ratio fell all the way down
- 13:29to 13.3. 13.3 below the median of 16.
- 13:33Way below it was a 20 year low at the time, signaling deep
- 13:36undervaluation, a major potential recovery point.
- 13:38Opposite signal just as strong. What about the 2020 pandemic
- 13:42period? During that volatile time, with
- 13:43the market rebound and weird earnings, the KP rose to around
- 13:4633. Still high butnotquite.com peak
- 13:49levels. Not quite 44, no, but still well
- 13:52into elevated territory. Reflecting that, swift recovery,
- 13:55even as earnings took a temporary hit, showed market
- 13:57resilience but push valuations up quickly.
- 14:00And that leads us back to today, July 2025, CPE at 37.97.
- 14:05Right, firmly in the top decile historically.
- 14:07Reinforcing that same theme, we keep seeing significant market
- 14:10overvaluation based on long term historical patterns.
- 14:12OK, so another strong signal. What are the implications here
- 14:16if Cape stays above 30? Say, what does that really mean
- 14:21for someone investing for the long haul?
- 14:23Well, as we touched on, it primarily suggests lower
- 14:26expected returns over the next 10, maybe even 20 years.
- 14:30That one 2% real return figure comes up again.
- 14:32And the historical track record, it's pretty compelling.
- 14:36It's very compelling. High KB ratios like the ones we
- 14:38saw before 1929, before 2000 and before 2008, they have
- 14:42consistently preceded major market downturns.
- 14:45So it's acted as a reliable, if often ignored, warning sign.
- 14:49Exactly. History doesn't repeat
- 14:51perfectly, but that pattern is hard to ignore.
- 14:53It suggests that when valuations get this stretched relative to
- 14:56smooth earnings, the market becomes much more vulnerable.
- 14:59But. Again, are there counter
- 15:00arguments, Criticisms of the CPU ratio we should know about?
- 15:03Yes, definitely. Just like the Buffett indicator
- 15:05is not perfect and there were valid points raised against it,
- 15:07such as one major critique often associated with Jeremy Siegel is
- 15:11about changes in accounting standards, Cap accounting today
- 15:14might be more conservative than decades ago.
- 15:16Meaning reported earnings might look lower, which artificially
- 15:19pushes the PE ratio higher. That's the argument, yeah, that
- 15:22it might overstate how expensive the market truly is compared to
- 15:26the past because the E is calculated differently.
- 15:29OK, accounting changes. What else?
- 15:31It can also get skewed if you have a period of genuinely
- 15:34unusually depressed earnings within that 10 year window, even
- 15:37if prices aren't crazy. Right, A temporary earnings
- 15:40slump could inflate the ratio. Potentially, and similar to the
- 15:43Buffett indicator, there's the argument about interest rates.
- 15:46Does it fully account for a world where maybe structurally
- 15:49lower rates justify higher baseline valuations?
- 15:53That low rate justification, again, the rates aren't exactly
- 15:55low right now. They certainly aren't, which
- 15:57adds another layer of complexity.
- 15:59Maybe the low rate argument held more water a few years ago than
- 16:02it does today. Good point.
- 16:03So again, a powerful lens, but one that needs to be viewed
- 16:06alongside other data and with these nuances in mind.
- 16:09Precisely. It's part of the mosaic, not the
- 16:11entire picture. OK, excellent.
- 16:13Let's shift gears now. We've looked at the overall
- 16:15stock market valuation from a couple of angles.
- 16:18Now let's turn to something tangible, something huge for the
- 16:21economy, the housing market. Right, bricks and mortar.
- 16:25Let's talk Case Shiller. The Case Shiller Home Price
- 16:28Index. Everyone hears about it,
- 16:29especially if you're buying or selling.
- 16:31But what is it exactly, and why is its method so important?
- 16:35Well, the full name is the S&P CoreLogic Case Shiller U.S.
- 16:39National Home Price Index. Bit of a mouthful.
- 16:41Just rolls off the tongue. Yeah, but the key thing, the
- 16:44really clever part, is its methodology, the repeat sales
- 16:48method. Repeat sales.
- 16:50What does that mean? It means instead of just looking
- 16:52at the average price of all homes sold in a month, which can
- 16:55be skewed if say, a bunch of luxury homes sell.
- 16:58Right, making the average jump even if normal home prices
- 17:00didn't change. Exactly.
- 17:02Case Shiller tracks the price changes of the same individual
- 17:05houses over time each time they're sold.
- 17:07OK, so it compares apples to apples tracking the same
- 17:10properties value change. Precisely.
- 17:12It filters out that makeshift noise.
- 17:14It gives you a much cleaner inflation adjusted picture of
- 17:17actual home price appreciation or depreciation.
- 17:20So it reflects genuine market trends better.
- 17:22Much better. Its purpose is to give us that
- 17:25robust pulse of the housing market which is so critical for
- 17:28household wealth, consumer confidence, the whole economy
- 17:31really. Makes sense.
- 17:32So what's the pulse reading right now?
- 17:34How's housing doing in mid 2025? Is it still red hot?
- 17:38Well, it's fascinating. It seems to be defying gravity
- 17:41to some extent. The latest data we have for June
- 17:442025 puts the national index at about 335.49. 335.49 that's an
- 17:50index number. Baseline is 100 in the year
- 17:522000. Correct.
- 17:53And it's seasonally adjusted now.
- 17:55This number is up from 330.22 back in March.
- 17:58So still going up, are these record highs?
- 18:00They are. This confirms we are still
- 18:02hitting record national home prices.
- 18:03The market hasn't rolled. Over WOW despite higher mortgage
- 18:06rates. Despite higher mortgage rates,
- 18:07however, there's a subtle but important detail in the latest
- 18:11number. What's that?
- 18:12While prices hit a new record, the monthly gain actually slowed
- 18:15down. It was less than .4%.
- 18:18Less than half a percent gain month over month, so still
- 18:21rising, but the pace is slowing like it's losing some steam.
- 18:25Potentially, yes. It suggests some deceleration
- 18:29even if the overall level is still peak.
- 18:31It's like climbing a hill, still going up, but maybe the slope is
- 18:33getting less steep. Interesting nuance.
- 18:36And there's a lag with this data too, right?
- 18:38Crucial point, Yes, the Case Shiller data is lagged.
- 18:42That June print actually reflects sales that likely
- 18:44closed in April, maybe even earlier.
- 18:46So what we're seeing now is a picture from a couple of months
- 18:49ago. Exactly.
- 18:49So while April confirmed record prices, the conditions right now
- 18:53in July might be slightly different as the market
- 18:55continues to digest interest rates and everything else.
- 18:58It's always a look in the rearview mirror.
- 18:59Good to remember. OK, let's do the historical trip
- 19:01again. Housings had its own wild rides
- 19:03back to 1995. 95 housing pretty calm wasn't.
- 19:06It yeah, the index was around 80.
- 19:07Stable, modest growth, pretty much in line with incomes calm
- 19:10before the storm. The storm being the housing
- 19:13bubble. Precisely, which peaked around
- 19:152006. Remember that LAX lending
- 19:18flipping shows everywhere. Oh I remember prices seem like
- 19:21they could only go up. And the index reflected that it
- 19:23surged to about 185 by 2006, more than doubled in about a
- 19:27decade. And then the bust.
- 19:29And then the bust. The 2008 crisis hit and the
- 19:32index fell sharply. Bottomed out around 1:30 by
- 19:352012. A huge drop wiped out years of
- 19:38gains for many. A critical historical marker
- 19:40indeed. Absolutely.
- 19:41Now more recently, the pandemic boom, 2020 to 2022.
- 19:45What happened then? Unprecedented surge fueled by
- 19:48rock bottom interest rates, people wanting more space,
- 19:50limited supply. Yeah, perfect storm for price
- 19:52increases. And the index shot up, went from
- 19:55around 2:10 to about 310 in just a couple of years.
- 19:57Just incredible acceleration. Faster than even the bubble
- 20:00years in terms of pace. In terms of sheer pace, yes,
- 20:02it's extraordinary. And that brings us to now July
- 20:052025 index at 335.49, still near those all time highs even with
- 20:10higher rates. Reflecting that persistent
- 20:12demand, but maybe, just maybe starting to feel the effects of
- 20:15those higher rates with that slowing monthly gain.
- 20:17So what does this sustained record high level, even with
- 20:21slight slowing, mean for people right now?
- 20:23Buyers. Owners.
- 20:25It means the market's shown remarkable resilience, but our
- 20:28sources are pretty consistent. It looks potentially overvalued
- 20:32due to high prices relative to incomes and interest rates.
- 20:36Affordability is the keyword here, isn't it?
- 20:38Absolutely. For buyers it means continued
- 20:41significant affordability challenges.
- 20:44Homes just cost a lot relative to typical incomes and what
- 20:48people can borrow at current rates.
- 20:49Big hurdle. But why haven't prices fallen,
- 20:52and more significantly then, if affordability is so stretched?
- 20:55That's the other side of the coin, supply constraints.
- 20:58There just aren't enough homes for sale in many.
- 21:00Areas the inventory issue. Exactly, lack of new
- 21:03construction for years, people locked into low mortgage rates
- 21:05not wanting to move. It creates this fundamental
- 21:08supply demand imbalance. Plus maybe inflation and
- 21:10building costs. That too.
- 21:12Materials, labor, it all adds up.
- 21:14So these factors might be putting a floor under prices,
- 21:16preventing a sharp crash even with affordability issues.
- 21:19So a tug of war between stretched affordability and
- 21:22tight supply. That's a great way to describe
- 21:24it, but the risk of a correction is still there.
- 21:27If rates go higher or the economy we can significantly,
- 21:31demand could drop off. It's a delicate balance.
- 21:34And we need to watch the upcoming data releases, right?
- 21:36Like the one mentioned for July 29th.
- 21:38Yes, keeping an eye on the freshest data is key because of
- 21:41that lag and the source specifically highlights that
- 21:44mortgage rates staying above 6% for conventional 30 year loan
- 21:48have definitely tightened affordability even more since
- 21:51the spring data we're seeing now.
- 21:53So the pressure is building. How much more can prices rise if
- 21:57borrowing costs stay high or go higher?
- 21:59That's the $1,000,000 question. It really is.
- 22:01The index reflects trends. It doesn't predict the timing of
- 22:04a potential turn perfectly. Got it.
- 22:06OK. Let's pivot to something that
- 22:07influences everything we've talked about interest rates.
- 22:10The underpinning of it all, really.
- 22:11Let's unpack this rates narrative, specifically focusing
- 22:14on the yield curve. We hear about the 210 spread all
- 22:17the time. What is that simply?
- 22:19Simply put, it's the difference in the interest rate or yield
- 22:23between the 10 year U.S. Treasury bond and a two year
- 22:26U.S. Treasury bond. 10 year yield -2
- 22:29year yield. Why is that specific difference
- 22:31so important? Why does everyone watch it?
- 22:33Because historically, it's been one of the most reliable
- 22:36recession predictors we have. A recession predictor.
- 22:39How? When the two year yield goes
- 22:41higher than the 10 year yield, meaning the spread turns
- 22:44negative or the curve inverts, that is almost always preceded
- 22:47in economic recession in the US, often by about 6 to 18 months.
- 22:51Wow, so short term rates being higher than long term rates is a
- 22:55bad sign? Like the bond market is worried
- 22:57about the near future. Exactly.
- 22:58It signals pessimism about the short to medium term economic
- 23:01outlook. It's a powerful, historically
- 23:03validated signal. OK, so what's the latest news on
- 23:06this 210 spread? Has something significant
- 23:08happened? Yes, something quite
- 23:10significant. According to our sources, the 10
- 23:12year yield has been around 4.35% while the two year yield has
- 23:15actually dipped down to around 3.9%.
- 23:17So the 10 year is now higher than the two year again.
- 23:20Correct, which means the 210 spread has turned positive for
- 23:24the first time since October 2023.
- 23:27So the yield curve has uninverted.
- 23:28It's back to a normal upward slope.
- 23:30That sounds like good news. Economy is safe.
- 23:33Well, this is where it gets counterintuitive and really
- 23:36interesting. On the surface, yes, uninversion
- 23:38sounds positive. But historically?
- 23:40Uh oh, there's a but. There's a but historically these
- 23:44uninversions, the curve going from inverted back to positive,
- 23:47often happen months before recession actually starts, not
- 23:51after it's over. Wait, say that again.
- 23:52Uninverting happens before the recession hits.
- 23:55Why? The thinking is the bond market
- 23:57starts anticipating the Federal Reserve will have to cut
- 23:59interest rates soon because the economy is slowing down are
- 24:02heading into recession. Those anticipated rate cuts push
- 24:05longer term yields up relative to shorter term ones, causing
- 24:08the uninversion. So the uninversion itself might
- 24:11be a signal that the market expects trouble ahead, leading
- 24:14to future rate cuts. Precisely, it's a very new on
- 24:17signal, so the key take away from our sources is emphatic
- 24:20cyclical risk is not off the table just because the curve
- 24:23uninverted. Wow, that's a critical nuance.
- 24:27Eemingly, good news might actually reinforce the
- 24:29underlying risk that demands careful interpretation.
- 24:32It really does. Don't just take the headline
- 24:34uninversion as an all clear signal.
- 24:37History suggests caution is still very much warranted.
- 24:40OK, so we've walked through the Buffett indicator, Schiller, PE
- 24:43Case Schiller, and now this tricky rates narrative.
- 24:47Let's try to tie it all together.
- 24:48What's the combined message here?
- 24:50When you pull back and look at the whole picture, the signals
- 24:53on valuation are remarkably consistent, aren't they?
- 24:55They seem to be both the Buffett Indicator way up at 200% plus
- 24:59and the Schiller PE near 38. Both strongly suggesting the
- 25:03stock market is significantly overvalued compared to
- 25:06historical norms. And the implication there again
- 25:09is potentially lower future returns or higher risk of a
- 25:11correction. Right then you layer on the
- 25:13housing market context, Case Shiller at record highs.
- 25:16But maybe showing signs of slowing and facing that
- 25:18affordability crunch, our sources called it potentially
- 25:21unsustainable if economic conditions tighten.
- 25:23Exactly. So you have elevated prices in
- 25:25stocks, elevated prices in housing, a picture of expensive
- 25:29assets across the board. So what does this mean for
- 25:31market pricing overall? What are investors expecting?
- 25:34Our sources use a phrase that really captures it.
- 25:36Risk assets are priced for perfection, while risk free real
- 25:40yields remain solidly positive. Priced for perfection, meaning
- 25:44the market expects everything to go exactly right.
- 25:46Pretty much expecting continued strong earnings growth.
- 25:49Inflation cooling nicely, the Fed navigating this perfectly.
- 25:53No room for error. While at the same time safe
- 25:55bonds are offering a decent positive return after inflation.
- 25:58Right. So the market seems to be
- 26:00demanding very little extra compensation or risk premium for
- 26:03holding risky assets compared to safe ones.
- 26:05Even though valuations are high, It implies, as one source put
- 26:09it, a thin cushion. A thin cushion against what?
- 26:12Bad news. Exactly against any
- 26:13disappointment, the source elaborated, if corporate
- 26:16earnings guidance softens, if companies start warning about
- 26:19future profits, or if the Fed signals fewer rate cuts than
- 26:22markets hope, the equity valuation cushion is thin.
- 26:24So the market is vulnerable. Any negative surprise on
- 26:28earnings or Fed policy could hit hard because prices are already
- 26:31so high. That's the risk highlighted.
- 26:33Very sensitive to news flow when you're priced for perfection at
- 26:37historically high valuation levels.
- 26:39But we also need to remember the caveats, right?
- 26:42Why aren't these indicators necessarily predicting imminent
- 26:45doom? Absolutely crucial caveats.
- 26:47First, remember they are fundamentally backward looking.
- 26:50They tell us where we have been, not precisely where we're going.
- 26:53His history doesn't always repeat exactly.
- 26:54It doesn't. Second, these metrics maybe
- 26:57don't fully capture structural changes in the economy and
- 27:00markets like like the long term impact of potentially lower
- 27:03global interest rates. Even with recent hikes like
- 27:06those massive global capital flows into the US we discussed,
- 27:09like the persistent housing supply shortages, these things
- 27:12might mean the old rules don't apply perfectly.
- 27:14So maybe high valuations can last longer now.
- 27:17That's a key insight from the sources.
- 27:19High valuations can persist for years, as seen in the 20 tens.
- 27:22It's not an automatic trigger for a crash.
- 27:24Right, Overvalued doesn't mean we'll crash tomorrow.
- 27:27It means potential for lower future returns and increased
- 27:30risk, but the timing is unknown. Exactly, it requires patience
- 27:34and managing risk, not necessarily panic selling based
- 27:37on one reading. And looking back at how these
- 27:39indicators behave together during past crises really drives
- 27:42this home doesn't. It it does, seeing them in
- 27:44concert is eliminating. Let's quickly recap those key
- 27:47moments. the2000.com bubble Buffett indicator hit 150%.
- 27:51CPE hit a record 44, both screaming over valuation before
- 27:55the tech crash. Clear signals of excess.
- 27:57Then the 2008 financial crisis after the crash, Buffett
- 28:00indicator down near 50%. CPE hit a 20 year low of 13,
- 28:04both signaling deep undervaluation case.
- 28:06Shilo bottomed around 1:30 after the housing bust.
- 28:09Opposite extremes signaling opportunity amid fear.
- 28:12And the 2020 COVID pandemic rapid drop than rapid recovery.
- 28:15Buffett indicators spiked to 180%, CPE hit 33.
- 28:19Case Shiller surge towards 3/10 showed resilience but also how
- 28:22quickly valuations could stretch again, especially with stimulus.
- 28:25Right. Each period had its unique
- 28:27drivers, but the indicators consistently reflected the
- 28:30underlying valuation pressures up or down.
- 28:32Comparing those to today really highlights where we stand, OK.
- 28:36So given all this high valuations, rates, uncertainty,
- 28:39historical context, what's the practical take away, What kind
- 28:43of investment strategy do our sources suggest makes sense now?
- 28:46The general theme leans towards being more defensive and quality
- 28:49focused inequities. Defensive and quality focused?
- 28:52Meaning what exactly? High valuations suggest maybe
- 28:55tilting away from the most speculative high growth stocks
- 28:58and focusing more on high quality stocks.
- 29:00Which are companies with? Strong balance sheets,
- 29:03consistent earnings, maybe reliable dividends, stable
- 29:06business models, companies that are potentially more resilient
- 29:09if the economy slows down. And diversification remains key,
- 29:12always. Spreading your bets.
- 29:14Absolutely don't put all your eggs in one potentially
- 29:16overpriced basket, the source specifically said portfolios
- 29:20tilted toward quality balance sheets, reasonable cash flow
- 29:22yields and a liquidity buffer still look prudent.
- 29:25Let's break that down quickly. Quality balance sheets means low
- 29:29debt, good cash reserves. Exactly.
- 29:32Financial strength, reasonable cash flow yields means the
- 29:34company generates good cash relative to its stock price,
- 29:37right? Cash they can use for dividends,
- 29:40buybacks, paying down debt, weathering storms and the
- 29:43liquidity buffer just means keeping some cash handy, yes?
- 29:47Having some cash or easily sold assets gives you flexibility.
- 29:51Flexibility to ride out downturns, meet unexpected
- 29:54needs, or even take advantage of opportunities if markets do
- 29:58correct. OK, that makes sense For stocks,
- 29:59what about housing? For housing, the message is
- 30:02caution for buyers due to those affordability issues.
- 30:05Prices are high relative to incomes and rates.
- 30:07So maybe wait if you can, or be very careful about stretching
- 30:11your budget. That seems to be the implication
- 30:13for buyers, but for existing homeowners or the market
- 30:16overall, those supply shortages might limit big price drops.
- 30:20It's still a tight market in terms of inventory.
- 30:21That tension again challenging for buyers, maybe more stable
- 30:25for owners due to supply. It's a complex picture requiring
- 30:28careful thought about your own situation.
- 30:30OK, so as we wrap up this deep dive, what's the main thing you
- 30:33want our listeners to walk away with?
- 30:35I think it's that you now have a much richer understanding of
- 30:38what these key signals are telling us.
- 30:40Right, the stock market showing multiple signs of significant
- 30:43overvaluation, Housing still hot but facing headwinds, rates
- 30:47sending complex signals. Exactly.
- 30:49And the critical take away isn't necessarily alarm, but
- 30:52awareness. Awareness that valuations are
- 30:55high, risks are present, and future returns might be lower
- 30:59than in the past. So the need for caution,
- 31:01prudence, adaptability, and a nuanced view.
- 31:04Perfectly put. Avoid simple narratives.
- 31:06Understand the complexities, the caveats, the historical context.
- 31:10That's what being truly well informed is about.
- 31:12Makes sense And maybe. Just maybe it leads to a final
- 31:15thought for you, our listener, to chew on.
- 31:17OK, hit us with it. Given this environment, we've
- 31:19discussed this price for perfection market.
- 31:21How might your own definition of perfection need to evolve when
- 31:25even good news, like an uninverted yield curve might
- 31:28carry hidden risks? How does understanding these
- 31:31deeper currents change how you approach your financial
- 31:34planning, or even just how you consume financial news?
- 31:38That's a great question, looking beyond the headlines, demanding
- 31:42more context, thinking about what perfection really means in
- 31:45a complex world. Something definitely worth
- 31:48pondering, hopefully. Well, we really hope this deep
- 31:50dive gave you that valuable shortcut to feeling genuinely
- 31:53well informed, armed with insights from these crucial
- 31:56market signals. We covered a lot of ground.
- 31:58We certainly did, and if you found this valuable, please do
- 32:01consider supporting us. You can like and subscribe on
- 32:03Apple Podcasts, Spotify or our YouTube channel.
- 32:06Just search for deep value investing.
- 32:08Your support really helps us keep doing these deep dives.
- 32:11It absolutely does. And hey, if you want to explore
- 32:13value investing further, don't forget to check out the book
- 32:16list we've put in the episode description.
- 32:17Some great resources there. Good stuff in there.
- 32:20And one last thing, we're actually working on a project to
- 32:22create a Buffett indicator app, turning his wisdom into a daily
- 32:26tool for investors. If that sounds interesting, you
- 32:29can learn more and support the mission via our Go Fund Me link,
- 32:31also in the description. That would be a cool tool to
- 32:34have. We think so too.
- 32:36Thank you so much for joining us on the Deep Dive today.
- 32:38We hope you feel more informed and empowered.
- 32:41Thanks for listening.