Latest / On the Path / Insight Brief - Aug 21, 2026
Transcript
- Steven: Well, greetings and salutations. Welcome to On the Path, the official podcast of Concilium. I'm your host, Steven, and we are delighted to have you with us today. It is Friday, August twenty first, if you can believe that or not. And joining me is Concilium's co founder and vice president over our insight team, JD. JD, welcome and how are you doing? J.D.: Stephen, I'm doing well. It's good to be on the podcast with you. I'm excited that we're getting this program relaunched. Steven: Awesome. Well, I'm really glad to have you with us today. And for our new listeners who this might be the first time tuning in, do you mind doing a quick share of what you and your team do with Concilium? J.D.: Sure, Steven, thank you for asking that. The Concilium Insight team helps organizations and churches understand threats, probabilities of threats and the impacts of conflict, terrorism and crime specifically. We explain and we forecast incidents and trends and we answer questions for Christian organizations of what just happened in the world, what happens next and why does it matter? Steven: Awesome. So the world's pretty static, obviously. It doesn't change much. So this is J.D.: Ha ha. Steven: what ten minutes for you guys? J.D.: No, it it takes a bit longer than that. we produce a weekly global summary every Thursday and then we write what we call standalone reports in between as needed. And we use watch warning language in creating the titles and headers for those documents. So we're usually looking at incidents and trends and evaluating them by their urgency, their complexity, and their relevance. to Christian organizations, specifically gospel workers, Christian expatriates around the world. And then we also create a monthly list of incident reports about crimes occurring at churches in the United States. So we're also focused on the needs of US churches domestically as well as the the workers that they themselves send globally, whether short term or long term. So we serve both churches and sending organizations. Steven: All right, so constantly new stuff, as well as changes and updates to ongoing situations. All right, so I was about as far off from ten minutes as one could be. So all right. Well, for our new listeners, our podcast typically does three different kind of kinds of podcasts. While all of them are equipping in spirit, each has a different flavor. Some of them are more targeted to single topics that we try to unpack. Another is potentially more narrative form stories from our front lines that we want to relay to our listeners. And there's the one we're standing up today. It's our an an insight brief where we take a high level tour of what's happening around the world and hopefully helping our listeners better understand the environments where ministry's taking place, you know, recognize emergent concerns and even identify potential opportunities. JD, I think the easiest way to do that is maybe just to literally do a know, work our way around the globe, just walk around the the different regions. So we'll break things down in that fashion, I think. obviously we're not gonna cover everything happening in every country. We'd be here all day, but but we'll through the region we'll highlight a few of the developments that we think are worth having on the radar for churches, mission orgs, and people serving internationally. So to kick things off, why don't we start closer to our regional home here in the Americas? J.D.: Yeah, I'd be glad to do that. And you said working our way around the globe. But if you were a if you listeners out there are subscribers and if you were looking at the written paper here, you'd see that we have the items arranged, starting with the Americas and then moving westward across the Pacific. So we're just gonna start in the Western Hemisphere with the Americas. And this week we covered a couple of items out of Haiti and it's just Very briefly here, it's very important to realize that the Haitian government is trying to set up elections in December, just four months from now. And that's very controversial. Maybe you pick that up in the tone of my voice, even just now. There's a lot Steven: Mm-hmm. J.D.: of controversy as to whether that is at all a realistic goal and if it should even be attempted right now, giving the security environment. And it does appear that the Vivan Sam gangs in the Greater Port-au-Prince area, as well as related gangs in other parts of the country are willing and very capable of disrupting those election timetables and using that disruption to discredit the government, to continue discrediting discrediting the government. So we are expecting more violence in Haiti over the next few months, and there's a there's also a great deal of public controversy, public opinion in Haiti just distrusting an electoral process that is set up amid a security crisis Steven: Mm. J.D.: that the government just has not yet been able to solve, even with international support. a more specific tactical indicator is a movement of a couple of gangs called Cocorat San Ras and Grand Grief in Arta Benite department that are moving through the mountains deeper into central Haiti towards a place called Saint Michele de la Adelaye. And that is a potentially a very strategic location, a a road junction. And if that town, if Saint Michel were to fall to gangs, and the and there's no particular timetable that we're looking at for this, because the gangs can move very slowly and then suddenly they can just move like lightning down the road and attack a new area. but if they were to reach that road junction, they would then have access to to roads taking them further into central Haiti. further towards northern Haiti, so places such as Pinon or Capation that are very important to Christian ministries since Port-au-Prince has become so dangerous. so we really want to watch that gang activity in Artabanite departments in the in that larger context nationally of the government pressing towards elections, but not even close to solving the security conditions that are threatening the viability of those elections. Steven: That's a lot of instability it sounds like in which to do your ministry. So J.D.: It it is. Yeah. Steven: goodness. All right. Well how about we we keep moving on over. Let's h head over to the the Pacific area. J.D.: Okay, so what I'm gonna highlight out of our Asia Pacific coverage from yesterday's Thursday briefing is the is the Philippines. there was a school shooting on August eighteenth at a at a university in Zamboanga. This is in far southern Philippines. This follows a school shooting at a high school in Tacloban City, which is on the island of Leyte. so different island, different part of the country. both generally south, but but far apart from each other. The first attack on June twenty second was linked to an online organization you may have heard of from US media coverage called seven six four. This is a global online organization associated with a growing trend of what's called nihilistic violent extremism. And to put it very succinctly, we've written about this for our our church security readers in the US. We've written about it for our global insight readers too at length already, but nihilistic violent extremism is essentially a a promotion online of violence. It's very sadistic and it it promotes violence for its own sake. It it and it has almost created an ideology of its own. In fact the Canadian government has defined nihilistic violent extremism as terrorism, bec because the Canadian Steven: Well. J.D.: government sees it as ideological. And I and I can understand that. It it is it is Because nihilism is a is a philosophy. Neilism is not nine non ideological. It is a rejection of ideology, but it is it has created its own ideology in the place of all others. And that is basically the the the belief in nothing, the trust in nothing, and the the belief that the glob that global structures need to be torn down and that all authority needs to be torn down. So it's beyond anarchy. And it is and and as it relates to the radicalization of youth online across borders, across the whole globe, we are seeing incidents popping up, often in the form of school shootings, often more often historically in the brief history of this as being related to self harm. Kids around the world being goaded. shamed into harming themselves for the sake of gaining some sort of notoriety and acceptance in these online communities. But at any rate, nihilistic violent extremism is is growing. It's not entirely new. If you've followed any anything involving the the so-called Columbiner movement, that this sort of online cult following of the Columbine shooters from 1999. these these are kind of old ideas, but they're manifesting in new ways in in more diverse and connected internet communities. And so we don't know if the second attack in Zambawaga is is related to 764, but 764 has been linked to the Tacloban high school attack. And this is this is happening in the Philippines. These are school shootings happening in parts of the world where that are just not familiar with that. dynamics. Steven: Yeah. J.D.: So this is not a North American problem. It's not a European problem. It is becoming a global problem, including in the Asia Pacific. Steven: That is I several of the things you laid out there I had not even heard about yet. And that whole online component, you know, just J.D.: Mm-hmm. Steven: it it really is freeing to have messages spread that are damaging like that. Thanks for highlighting that. So moving on again, how about we go to the Middle East and see what's happening over there? J.D.: Sure. We wrote yesterday a summary of the situation in the Gulf states. So the Persian Gulf, Arabian Gulf, pick your preference there as as to what it should be labeled on the map. but in in the Gulf states specifically, we're seeing multiple factors and developments pointing almost certainly to the persistence of conflict into the next through the next six months. I this is this crisis is not going away anytime soon. But it is shifting this week towards increased economic coercion of Iran. With the most probable threat to Christian expatriates being occasional commercial air travel disruptions. this is a dynamic conflict that could go kinetic, and that's that's a term that we use for things that blow up. Missiles, rockets, Steven: Hmm. J.D.: airstrikes, those get involved. That's that's kinetic action. That's kinetic military action. it can go it can go kinetic again at any time. from either side, from the from the US side, from the Iranian side, even from the Israeli side. but generally it's moving towards a more economic phase where the US is planning to roll out new sanctions targeting Iran. The United Arab Emirates has cut off all trade with Iran, which is a very significant, very significant development. And then of course the US naval blockade, which is occurring at some distance from Iran. And compared to airstrikes, is very efficient in the use of munitions and in in the use of ships and aircraft. It's it's a heavy lift. A naval blockade requires a lot of effort, a lot of resources, but it's much less expensive than waves of airstrikes against Iran. And and that I believe is the most potent military tool that the US has And its purpose is almost entirely economic. so we're gonna continue to watch that naval blockade, we're gonna continue to watch this conflict, but in regards to the Gulf states, it's it's tending towards stalemate, but is still dynamic and dangerous, mainly in terms of military infrastructure and civilian critical infrastructure. And that can include airports. We've seen it include Iranian attacks on airports, especially in Kuwait. but Other other types of infrastructure could be attacked as again, civilian residential areas, retail areas, commercial areas, not as much. And the Iranians have not demonstrated a lot of intent, a lot of desire to cause that kind of destruction in previous Steven: Mm-hmm. J.D.: exchanges of fire. Looking at maybe you all have heard in the in the media about Israel conducting an airstrike in northern Syria. At an air base where the Israelis said that the Turks are planning to set up a military presence, which Israel does not want in Syria because of very bellicose statements in the last few months by Turkey's president against Israel. The Turks are insisting they have no such plans, no such designs, and no Turkish troops were ever at this base. The Syrians admitted that a Turkish delegation had just visited the base. I think that this was a calculated strike by the Israelis to send a message. They knew that there were no Turkish forces at the base at the time that they attacked it. They would not have done that. that would have been too provocative. but they also knew, as the Syrians have admitted, that there w had been a Turkish delegation there. we do not see a direct military confrontation breaking out between Israel and Turkey in the in the foreseeable future, but that Turkish rhetoric is something to watch. it is it is concerning. to see turkey becoming more agitating in the region as its regional ambitions throughout the Middle East and in Africa expand. And yet it's also important to realize that the Turks are are quite opposed to Iranian aggression here. The the Turkish Persian Arab triangle is is filled with distrust, disdain, if not outright hatred. especially between the Persians and Arabs, but also between the Turks and the Persians. Steven: Well, we appreciate you helping us try to make some heads and tails of of all those complex relationships. My goodness. All right. Well, last and certainly not least, let's pivot over to to Africa. J.D.: Okay, so y yesterday we did cover some political developments in Madagascar that are slowing the transition to a new constitutional framework after the coup last year, coming up on about one year since since the coup in Madagascar and and these slow the slow rolling of the transition is going to make the the conditions more conducive for further unrest. so we did cover that. yesterday. but the main thing I want to draw attention to in Niger, another country, this is in West Africa, where there was a coup about three years ago. And Niger has broken ties with France and has somewhat embraced Russian support, has formed an alliance, an economic and military alliance with Mali and Burkina Faso, who have also gone through similar processes, similar coups and realignments. but Niger is now facing a rebel movement. within its borders. It's called the MPLJ. And they conducted two coordinated attacks in Agadez region on the fifteenth of August. And so we are watching that group and its viability and and its effect on the security landscape in Niger. But then just south of Niger in the country of Nigeria, this is one very familiar to to Christians, we we Cover a spate of activity and plateau state. Nigeria is very difficult to cover. There's a security crisis in practically every corner and every state of Nigeria, and they're not all related. They're Steven: Mm-hmm. J.D.: not necessarily related, and even the ones that get bundled together in in generic media coverage as being related to Islamism and jihadism, even those. involve different organizations in different parts of the countries that are are loosely associated with each other, that have very similar goals but are geographically mostly geographically separated with some linkages. And even that is I feel like I I had to oversimplify things very massively there. but it's it's more than what's known as Boko Haram. It's more than Boko Haram. It's more than the Islamic State. It includes banditry, it includes bandits who happen to be Islamists. It includes bandits who kidnap for ransom just to get money. It includes bandits who kidnap for ransom because they're Islamists and they also want money. It includes Steven: Mm-hmm. J.D.: Fulanis who raid villages of of Christians who are the Fulanis being cattle herders who are always trying to expand into new areas and persecute Christians as they go. Or maybe in some cases they're just looking for grazing land. And then there are communities of non-Fulanis that push back against them. And and this week we came across an incident in Plateau State. In in one instance there was a massacre by Fulani bandits or attributed to Fulani bandits in one part of Plateau State. In another part of Plateau State, the army prevented, or at least it says it prevented, a bandit attack on a non-Fulani community whose youth had rustled cattle from some of the herders. And then so there was going to be this retaliatory attack. The army found the rustlers, recovered a large amount of weapons from those rustlers, and then the claim is that they diverted or prevented that retaliatory attack because they found the rustlers. Very complex stuff as far as one incident to the next. you know, what what actually is going on. but again, like like I just said, there's this one event that's a outright massacre, and then another one that's this very muddled chain of action and reprisal and prevention and military intervention and it's just it's extremely dynamic, very y I don't want to say localized in the sense that I mean, I mean, I just said Nigeria has nationwide security problems, but these Steven: Mm-hmm. J.D.: incidents occur in each incident occurs in a very local area, and there are many factors involved in each incident. And it's just it's a very challenging place to cover, and we try to get down to the to the essential truth as much as possible. Steven: Mm-hmm. J.D.: the and looking at trends, there are trends in Nigeria that are very old and there are trends that are newer. And what we try to do with Insight is provide intelligence warning of emerging threats of parts of the country that are s that are new to the violence, where the violence is new to them. Steven: Yeah. J.D.: the expansion of banditry, the expansion of outright jihadist terrorism. those are the the trends that we are tracking the most in our products. Steven: That's really helpful to know about in that region. I think oftentimes kind of just hear one motivator, but you impact the reality that there's like it's like there's layers. There are numerous motivators that are are contributing to the instability all over that that country. That's really insightful. All right, JD. Well, we've covered a lot of ground there. Before we wrap up, is there anything else that's kind of maybe a number one thing that you would wanna just point out before we close out today? That's a lot of things we talked about there, but Not sure if there's anything you you people should be paying attention to right now beyond that. J.D.: Well, just top of our minds right now is keeping our eyes on Iraq over the next couple of months as the US finalizes its withdrawal of a of a the small number of remaining troops in the Kurdistan region being pulled out. In of of all of that that's happening in the Middle East, obviously you have Hezbollah and Israel in direct confrontation on the ground in Lebanon, ground forces engaged with each other. The only other place in the Middle East right now where there are ground forces that could potentially fight each other are in Iraq with the Iran backed Shiite militias, Iraqi government forces, and Kurdish Peshmerga. And so the big question is when the US pulls the last of its troops out, those troops are not holding territory. Those American troops are not holding territory. They're not holding the country together. But when they're all finally gone, does that remove some constraints that these different actors see, especially the Shiite militias in the Iraqi government. The Iraqi government is trying to pull those militias away from the Iranians. And and so what's going to happen as the Iraqi government tries to do that and the Shiite militias do not seem interested in complying. so that is that is one of our big projects even today as we we work on that analysis. Steven: Definitely on the horizon, huh? So goodness. J.D.: Yes, for sure. Steven: Well, JD, thanks for walking us through all that information. And obviously this is J.D.: Yeah, you're welcome. Steven: like a it's like a 20 minute podcast, right? Higher level flyover, it's tough to give really down in the down in the weeds. Does Consilium provide any kind of resources or services that may dive deeper or provide you know additional intelligence and awareness for all of these organizations serving abroad? J.D.: Absolutely. Churches and organizations can subscribe to our reports and you can you can find our insight page on our website. If you go to our services tab and select threat analysis, that is what we do. We do threat analysis. So just look up threat analysis there and you can find more information about Concilium Insight. And then we also have the the monthly subscription that that focuses on church security issues that are specific to the US and we could I understand we're gonna talk about that in a future episode later on this year. Steven: Yeah, absolutely. All right, JD. Well, we thank you for your time here. I know you got a lot that you're working on, so we'll go ahead and let you go. but once again, we want to thank our listeners for stopping in. And as a reminder, you can find us on Facebook, LinkedIn, or on our website at concilium.us. Also wanna remind that we would be glad to field any questions that our listeners may have. so if you you got any regarding mission and miss missions and ministry. you can submit those to us via email by writing to info at concilium.us. Again, that's info at concilium.us. Just put podcast question in that subject line for us. And that's all we have for this week. And we will definitely want to see all of you further down the path. And as always, may your ministries be faithful, resilient, and effective.