Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Raising Times Square: The Engineering Marvel of TSX Broadway
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome to Engineering Influence, the podcast from the American Council of Engineering
- 0:09Companies coming to you from our 2025 Annual Convention and Legislative Summit.
- 0:13So that event is only part of the whole event here in D.C.
- 0:19Because after this, we go into the Engineering Excellence Awards,
- 0:23which is our annual celebration of engineering. And I'm joined today by Art Alzamora.
- 0:30He's with Langan, Engineering, Environmental, Surveying, Landscape,
- 0:33Architecture, and Geology. Pretty much, you guys are the soil people.
- 0:37That's right. And we're talking about the project TSX Broadway,
- 0:40which is a National Recognition Award winning project.
- 0:43But we want to go beyond that as well, because you've been involved in a lot
- 0:47of projects that are either EEA related or just really cool stuff in New York City.
- 0:52So TSX, I mean, this is a, you have the historic palace theater that the mission
- 0:59was to raise it up 30 feet from ground, create retail, kind of a new environment there.
- 1:06But while it was being raised and the structural guys were doing their thing
- 1:11and all that, your job was to make
- 1:13sure that everything below ground could happen. That's correct. Right.
- 1:18And as we were talking earlier, you know, before we started,
- 1:21it's, it's kind of that thing about your job is to get in,
- 1:25make sure everything under the surface happens and you knew your job was well
- 1:31done if no one knew you were there. Right. That's right. Yeah.
- 1:34So, I mean, explain that process, the project and kind of, uh,
- 1:37you know, what kind of set it apart in your mind.
- 1:39So to think about this, the complicated part about the TSX project is that this
- 1:46was actually, if you look at it, this is the third development of this site.
- 1:50Yeah. So the Palace Theater is built at the turn of the century, right?
- 1:54And back in the mid 80s, the Silverstein
- 1:56organization came in and did an overbuild of the theater already.
- 1:59So there's already four mega columns building a platform over top of the theater.
- 2:05So part of our job was how do you tear down an existing 50-story hotel that's
- 2:11built over a landmark, keep that stabilized,
- 2:14keeping the mega columns and the foundation stabilized, and then building a
- 2:19system underneath the theater to raise it and then excavate a bunch of rock
- 2:24and build foundations underneath to create some of the most expensive retail
- 2:29space in the world. And you're not doing this in a field.
- 2:33You're doing this in one of the most heavily trafficked areas of the world.
- 2:37With a subway, with underground utilities, with...
- 2:41Every foot is a step back in history.
- 2:45That's correct. I mean, how far back in time do you think you guys went?
- 2:50So, well over 100 years. I mean, you look at the age of the subway,
- 2:54the age of the theater itself.
- 2:56We're talking multi-structures are well over 100 years, which I get it.
- 2:59In Europe, these are considered infants.
- 3:02But in New York City, lot line construction, this type of work is extremely complicated.
- 3:08And every time that we go in the ground, you're finding something that you were
- 3:14not expecting or nobody knew existed because there's no records that go back that far.
- 3:19What's the biggest thing that stuck out in your mind for a discovery or a challenge
- 3:23when you got to a point going, that's not supposed to be there or look at this
- 3:28little piece of history? Yeah.
- 3:30I mean, in reality, I know it sounds kind of small, but thinking that all the
- 3:34buildings next to us are built perfectly straight and within their property limits.
- 3:39Which is amazing when you think about it for like, you know,
- 3:42in a city like New York that over so many years building. Right.
- 3:47I mean, the technology has gotten better.
- 3:49We're a lot more precise and exact than we were a couple years ago.
- 3:53Engineering is an experience-based industry. So you build it one way,
- 3:56you try it, you move on and build it a different way. So sometimes what right
- 4:01now we're allowed to build within very strict tolerances that,
- 4:04again, a hundred years ago you couldn't.
- 4:07So they were using maybe less accurate ways. So they might be a couple inches over the property line.
- 4:13That couple inches is very difficult to contend with when you have a neighboring
- 4:17structure that's 30 stories tall that you're trying to support while supporting
- 4:21your 50-story building that you're working underneath.
- 4:23So, you know, one of the things that is interesting is the fact that no,
- 4:29there's one project could have a ton of different specializations working together.
- 4:34From the engineering side, you have the architecture side, but then you have
- 4:38the business side. Right. And the thing that a lot of people don't,
- 4:41who may not be involved with the industry.
- 4:43May not realize is how involved the engineers are with the developers,
- 4:48with the planners, with the banks.
- 4:51Kind of explain that side of the, you know, when you went into engineering,
- 4:55did you actually think, well, yeah, I'm going to have meetings with,
- 4:58you know, investment bankers or, you know.
- 5:00So I will, yeah, I mean, that's a good point. I spent a considerable amount
- 5:05of time talking to college students and I tell them, if you're good at your
- 5:08job, you won't be doing engineering for too long.
- 5:10And I'll say, when I first started my career, I spent a lot of time in the math
- 5:15and science of things and doing analysis.
- 5:17And then as you attend more project meetings, the client, the financial side
- 5:22of the client, they start to show up more at the meetings.
- 5:25But a project of this magnitude, because it was such a financial endeavor,
- 5:30let alone an engineering endeavor, that you had the financial aspects part of it the whole time.
- 5:36There was plenty of presentations that I was part of where I had to explain
- 5:40how the project works to a financial partner, whether they're lending on a project
- 5:45or they're doing the checks and balances on a project to make sure the project pencils out.
- 5:50And obviously, this project spanned COVID, right? So it started before COVID
- 5:55and it finished after COVID.
- 5:58So when you start seeing those sort of things and maybe it seems crazy,
- 6:02but a hotel in Times Square, there's a lot of them, But this was not just a
- 6:07hotel. This was a retail expansion.
- 6:11This was a performative arts, like there's a theater aspect to it.
- 6:16But then there's also things that they put in the LED screens and things for
- 6:20the performance issues or performance items that they're going to have in Times
- 6:24Square as part of part of the ball drop and the New Year's Eve and things like that.
- 6:28I mean, it's really a transformative. And you made the point of,
- 6:30you know, this work happened below ground over the course of four ball drops, right? Easily, yeah.
- 6:37Maybe a little bit more. You have all these people who are coming in and out.
- 6:41I mean, it is tourist central. Right.
- 6:44There's a lot of risk there, and there's a lot of potential for something going wrong.
- 6:50As a testament to the engineers who are doing all the work underground to make
- 6:55sure that everything that can happen there supports everything above ground, what people see.
- 7:01I mean, it does go back to that idea that an engineer's job done well is one that's not seen.
- 7:08And the only time that you actually realize the engineer was involved is if
- 7:11something terrible were to happen.
- 7:13It is this.
- 7:16For people out there who may not know, well, what do the engineers do?
- 7:20It's like, well, they make everything that you could possibly do possible.
- 7:23Right. And if done well, you're not actually going to actually notice it actually
- 7:26happened at all. Right. Right.
- 7:28You know. I mean, it's funny. I tell folks that, especially for what I do in
- 7:33soils, I have x-ray vision when I walk the street.
- 7:37I don't see a concrete sidewalk and a roadway, especially if there's a subway underneath it.
- 7:42Yeah. I picture girders, beams, you know, concrete, steel. I picture the utilities.
- 7:48We don't just look at it as, because we understand that, you know,
- 7:53you can't just remove a piece of sidewalk and expect to dig down and not disrupt
- 7:57a utility service, disrupt access to that building, things like that.
- 8:01So we deal with that every day. And frankly, that's where the experience and
- 8:06the understanding comes in.
- 8:07And that's where we really show our value. Yeah.
- 8:10And I make the joke, talking again about the financial aspects of it.
- 8:14If the job was to stop for a week, the financial implications of just stopping
- 8:21and having to pay- Massive.
- 8:23Massive. So, again, we're trying to see where the problems are,
- 8:27have that thousand yard stare, and look down and mitigate any potential issues
- 8:34that come out later. So, a lot of it is weighing that.
- 8:37It's a chess game. It's so many different things. And a project of this magnitude,
- 8:41we're meeting as a team four or five days a week.
- 8:44We're talking every day, and you have a lot of professionals in a room.
- 8:48I mean, some of the meetings are probably more expensive than you would believe.
- 8:52I can imagine in New York, definitely.
- 8:55It's everything on steroids, right? But the other thing is just your firm has
- 9:01been involved in a lot of projects that have significance to the city of New
- 9:06York, but also to America.
- 9:09I mean, we were talking about...
- 9:12The work on the slurry wall for the 9-11 Memorial. Yes. We're talking about Trinity Church. Right.
- 9:17Which, you know, I was personally down in lower Manhattan.
- 9:21I was there, you know, during 9-11, and Trinity Church was definitely a landmark,
- 9:29definitely the kind of thing that for people who know where it was,
- 9:32the fact that it even survived is amazing.
- 9:35Right. And then bringing it back to where it was, the work that was done on
- 9:37the slurry wall. The work that was done at St. Patrick's Cathedral. Right.
- 9:41You and I were there. We realized we were at the same place at the same time
- 9:45when Pope Francis came. That's right. The late Pope Francis came to St. Patrick's.
- 9:48Having that mark on things, you know, personally, what does it mean to you to
- 9:53be able to say, you know, yeah, you know, I worked on the revitalization of
- 9:58St. Patrick's Cathedral.
- 9:59Yeah. You know, that that is something that is going to be there for generations
- 10:02to come and being able to say that, yeah, I had I left a mark on that.
- 10:07What does it mean personally to you as an engineer? So, I mean,
- 10:10as a geotechnical engineer, we have a small part of larger projects.
- 10:15So we get to work on, maybe other engineers might work on two to three projects in a given year.
- 10:23We might be working on 20 to 30 projects.
- 10:25So I get to have this expansive, whether it's a new tower or revitalizing St.
- 10:31Pat's or working on something like
- 10:32that. One of the things that I was particularly happy or proud of at St.
- 10:37Pat's, which is also another EEA award-winning, was we did the laser scanning of St.
- 10:42Pat's back in 2008-ish time when scanning and surveying was still fairly new.
- 10:50It was done, but it was fairly new. We brought this to a project where,
- 10:55frankly, we did it kind of at cost to show people what's possible.
- 11:00And then using that technology to build models or then finding out when in and
- 11:07scanned some other aspects of...
- 11:10Decorative type of things with the cathedral and seeing that.
- 11:13And then going in as far as scanning the roof structure and stuff like that.
- 11:17And now you see laser scanning, bin modeling, and all this being done everywhere.
- 11:22It's a project necessity.
- 11:24So you would say to yourself, like, why?
- 11:27I made the argument, like, I think we should scan all institutional churches
- 11:31and stuff and make an immersive visual aid that you can walk through.
- 11:35So it's funny, although that was, It's not geotechnical per se,
- 11:39but coming in and seeing our surveying group do that and now seeing this technology
- 11:43just implemented everywhere and talk about engineers, we're in data, we're in all this.
- 11:49So it's really good and taking that and building it to other institutions,
- 11:54whether it's the Met Museum or the Museum of Natural History in New York.
- 11:59Federal Hall, Trinity Church, scanning all these things.
- 12:02It's also great and then doing all that. You're also creating a historical record
- 12:06now. You're creating the 3D models of things that are intrinsic to America.
- 12:13And I'm sure that you've discovered some things in those scans that the people
- 12:17who operate the churches or never even realized were there or identified some things.
- 12:25I mean, one of the funny, I'd say it's funny, but one of the funny stories that
- 12:29I look at is, and I never thought about this as an engineer,
- 12:31But when the renovation at St.
- 12:33Pat's was occurring, there was stone that was being cleaned and fixed.
- 12:38And then you realize because it was dirty and seasoned that it didn't match
- 12:42the historic stone that was there.
- 12:44So seeing the architect spent a lot of time with the structural engineers to
- 12:48go and find the correct quarry to repurpose some of those stones.
- 12:53And stuff that you're seeing with the rebuilding of Notre Dame,
- 12:55they're having the same issues. We're trying to match stones and match.
- 12:59And this is stuff that we do. And we're talking about from geotechnical matching
- 13:03the retaining wall that surrounds the cathedral and items like that.
- 13:07And then using that knowledge to, when you're talking about stabilizing the
- 13:12Palisadeur and TSX, you're working with that team.
- 13:15Believe it or not, we had a lot of the same landmark consultants that were working
- 13:19on TSX also working on the cathedral.
- 13:22And it's amazing to see that. And then we know the landmarks process.
- 13:26We know how to deal with these things. And we take this very serious because
- 13:31we understand that to, to mess with a landmark like that or disrupt it can have,
- 13:36we're not talking, it's not stuff that could be replaced. Yeah,
- 13:39exactly. Yeah. So, yeah.
- 13:40And it's, it is, it's also that.
- 13:43You don't have a, it's not a huge group of people. It's, it's,
- 13:46it's that relationship building and it's that community of people who can actually
- 13:50work on these projects. Right.
- 13:51Right. As being part of that larger team, which. Yeah. And, or look at the workmanship.
- 13:57Like I mentioned the quarries and the stones.
- 13:59Some of these processes are gone. Yeah. There's nobody that does this type of stone mason type work.
- 14:05Like these are sort of things. So to, to capture this and be part of these teams.
- 14:10And I will say my kids and my wife get tired of me saying, Hey, I worked on that.
- 14:14We can't walk around Times Square without pointing to all the projects.
- 14:17And then, you know, my kids are still young enough to where they'll be like,
- 14:20oh, that's great, dad. My wife is kind of like, she was in the industry as well.
- 14:23So she's like, I know. I know. I know.
- 14:25I have to remind her sometimes that she worked on these as well. Yeah. Yeah, exactly.
- 14:29You know, we talked a little bit also about, you know, the next generation trying
- 14:34to get kids involved, excited about this stuff.
- 14:38You know, it's beyond the math and science. What we're talking a lot about here
- 14:42is the cultural stuff, the, the, the, the business stuff, talking to people, the soft skill stuff,
- 14:47you know, I mean, what do you think we should be doing as an industry better
- 14:51to, to get those next generation kids who are like, okay, yeah,
- 14:55math and science, but boy, that's really cool. I'd like to get involved with that.
- 14:58So I'm the type of person I, I, I mean, I'm talking a little,
- 15:01I'm being selfish for a moment.
- 15:03I don't waste any minutes in a day. So if I see an opening, I try to fill it with something. Yeah.
- 15:09I think there's a lot more unused space in the mentoring and going to speak
- 15:16to schools, going to speak with your alma mater, and that our firms could be doing more of. Yeah.
- 15:23Whether it's like some firms are represented in parts of their state or country
- 15:27where maybe they don't have a big university nearby.
- 15:31But guess what? They have a community college nearby. Yeah.
- 15:33Are they interacting with that college? They got high schools nearby. Are they interacting?
- 15:37We're not talking about much. like just a little bit of involvement can
- 15:40move the move that that temperature
- 15:44yeah in a in a great direction and i'll tell
- 15:47you a lot of what i got interested in was someone taking a chance with me on
- 15:51an internship someone coming in and telling me what they do for a living yeah
- 15:55and me going wow that's pretty interesting i would really like to be involved
- 15:58with that yeah and then like really enjoying what i'm doing if you truly love
- 16:03what you do and you go speak to a school a high school,
- 16:06a middle school, an elementary school, and they see that type of energy.
- 16:10And then you kind of relate to them. I was speaking to my daughter's school, who's a fourth grader.
- 16:15And I started talking about a project and they're all, TSX actually,
- 16:18and they're starting to, oh, all right.
- 16:20But then when I showed them the video of the theater raising and I got to tell
- 16:23them, hey, who likes to play in soil?
- 16:25And they're all raised their hand. And I said, I get paid to do that. They're like, no way.
- 16:29They didn't even know what a geotechnical engineer was. And now they're going
- 16:33around and saying, maybe I can get, if I can get one.
- 16:36That's a win. Yeah. So I think, I think industry wise, we should be.
- 16:40The leaders of the firm should be pushing the younger emerging leaders of the
- 16:44firms to do more, a little bit more.
- 16:47We're not asking much, but maybe once a week. Yeah.
- 16:50Get out there. Get out there. It will all, and, and they'll,
- 16:54they're building the workforce that they're going to be directing.
- 16:57Yeah. Right. 20 years in their career. These are the people that are coming
- 16:59to work. So this is, they're only helping themselves. Yeah. And it's, I mean, I.
- 17:04Like you said, you were at the onset of laser scanning. Yep.
- 17:10You know, who knows what it's going to be by the time the next generation gets out there.
- 17:14I mean, with the way the AI is doing things and the way that just everything's
- 17:17going digital. I mean, we have drone scans.
- 17:20You have all this, like, AI is enhancing our business.
- 17:24The mathematical modeling and stuff that we're enhancing our business.
- 17:28Yeah. We're able to get more accurate.
- 17:30We're building. I mean, look at the exponential increase in the height of buildings all over the world.
- 17:36I mean, you have areas of the world that didn't have a single building over
- 17:4010 stories that are now having blocks that have 40 or 50 skyscrapers over 30, 50 stories tall.
- 17:47So this is what we should be emphasizing. And if you want to be part of this
- 17:51and especially with, you know, the way that we're building everything and it's,
- 17:56it's good to see some of this work come back to the United States,
- 18:00do a lot of, you know, scene development, not just in the major metropolitan
- 18:03areas, but more of the rural areas.
- 18:05Like there, there's positions out there for everybody. Yeah, absolutely.
- 18:10I mean, it's a great project. I mean, truly, I mean, taking an historic building.
- 18:17Raising it, doing all the work to actually allow it to happen.
- 18:20I mean, it truly is something, and I'm glad that it's going to be recognized in the awards program.
- 18:25You guys are no strangers to the awards program, and it's good to be celebrated
- 18:29again this year. So I look forward to seeing you on Tuesday at the event and
- 18:34look forward to having you back on.
- 18:35We got to talk about some other things. We got to talk about some other projects.
- 18:38That'd be great. Yeah. You got an open door to come back. Yeah.
- 18:41Sounds good. I would love to. This is, as my mother always said,
- 18:44I'd probably talk to an empty room.
- 18:46Hey, listen, you know, it was the
- 18:49joke about, you know, the engineers are usually, you know, introverted.
- 18:53Right. So, hey, if you want to talk to, you can come here and talk to us anytime
- 18:56you want. Sounds good. Outstanding. Love to.
- 19:00Fantastic. And again, this has been...
- 19:02Music.