Latest / Film And Whiskey / Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl / Sam Houston 15 Year Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:00In 2003, director Gore Verbinski and star Johnny Depp gave the
- 0:04world a rip roaring adventure featuring pirates, curses and
- 0:09all sorts of early 2000 CGI. In 2024, we wonder if a Barton
- 0:15by any other name will smell as sweet.
- 0:18The film is Pirates of the Caribbean, Curse of the Black
- 0:21Pearl. The whiskey is Sam Houston 15
- 0:24year bourbon. And we'll review them both.
- 0:27This is the Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 0:49Welcome to the Film and Whiskey podcast, where each week we
- 0:51review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 0:54I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 0:57Brad, I am very excited for this week's movie, which is called
- 1:00Pirates of the Caribbean Colon, the Curse of the Black Pearl.
- 1:06And I'm excited for it, Brad, for a number of reasons.
- 1:08But this feels like in a lot of ways, a turning point for this
- 1:13season of the podcast. And folks, if this is your first
- 1:16episode with us, welcome aboard. This season, what we're doing is
- 1:19we're reviewing movies that were the highest grossing films of
- 1:23each year from 1988 to 2019. We are in the smack dab in the
- 1:28middle of the early 2000s here. And we've been teasing or I
- 1:33guess foreshadowing what is to come with the Disney and Marvel
- 1:37vacation of everything. And this feels like the first
- 1:41real foretaste of what is in store for us, Brad.
- 1:44But it's also like a really interesting cross section of a
- 1:49movie because there's very little CGI in this movie
- 1:53comparatively, you know, to what is to come for us.
- 1:56Oh yeah. There's a lot, I mean, there's
- 1:57there's hand to hand combat, there's swashbuckling like it,
- 2:01there's old school movie making here, but it's also a Disney
- 2:05film based on Disney IP. And so it just really feels like
- 2:11we're kind of situating ourselves like at the at the
- 2:15apex here and we're going to tip down into Disneyville from here
- 2:18on out. Brad.
- 2:20Yeah. I mean, the thing that I noticed
- 2:22that felt like a foreshadowing of what was to come was the
- 2:25bloodless violence. This is a incredibly violent
- 2:30movie, Bob. Oh, yeah.
- 2:32I mean, they are getting it in the fight scenes, which I love,
- 2:37really, truly enjoyed. But there's no blood.
- 2:41And like when there is, it's like a, oh, I just pulled my
- 2:44sword out of somebody and I'm cleaning it off, right?
- 2:47And it's like very obvious, like stage blood.
- 2:51But there's no actual like, blood spatters all over the
- 2:53decks of these ships, which, man, these things would be
- 2:56painted red because wow, Gore gets after it in this man.
- 3:01Yeah, I mean, this is a movie in which you see people get hit by
- 3:04cannonballs. And fun fact, Brad, I never knew
- 3:07this about cannonballs. All they really do is kind of
- 3:09lift you up off your feet and carry you across the room.
- 3:12They don't actually blow you apart.
- 3:14No, that's it, man. They're.
- 3:15Just transportation devices. Really somewhat ineffective for
- 3:20how they're portrayed in most other films.
- 3:24Oh, man. OK, let's do this.
- 3:26Even before we get into the meat of our episode here, Brad, I
- 3:29want to situate ourselves in the year of Our Lord 2003, where the
- 3:34highest grossing film of the year was actually The Lord of
- 3:37the Rings, The Return of the King.
- 3:39But we've already reviewed that film.
- 3:41Are you sure we can't review that again?
- 3:43I would be happy to because. What a movie.
- 3:45It's a it's better than this movie.
- 3:47This is a good movie, but like, come on, folks, it's the Lord of
- 3:50the Rings we're talking about here.
- 3:51It. Sure is.
- 3:53I think this is kind of a good comparison point to Return of
- 3:57the King, though, and and here's where I was going to go.
- 4:00It was a really big deal at the time this movie was released
- 4:04that a Disney movie under the Disney banner.
- 4:07It was not just something Disney distributed under like Buena
- 4:10Vista, which is like their their like video marketing team or
- 4:16Touchstone or anything else that Disney had their hands in.
- 4:20It was a Disney labeled movie that was PG13 and I remember
- 4:24like this is big. This is new for Disney.
- 4:27They never do PG13. And I think that as you watch
- 4:32the movie, there's definitely like some tension between how
- 4:36family friendly this wants to be and also how violent of a movie
- 4:40it is. And I think you've already kind
- 4:42of pinpointed they try to get around it with the bloodless
- 4:45violence. But I I, I definitely felt that
- 4:49tension kind of in the tone of the movie throughout the whole
- 4:52thing. Brad, do you remember where you
- 4:54were when this movie came out? And I mean, do you remember how
- 4:59big of a deal it was that it was APG 13 movie?
- 5:03No and no. I am like the best podcast Co
- 5:09host you could have. Asked for?
- 5:10Well, that just means you have to take my word for it, which is
- 5:12even better. There's no questioning my
- 5:16knowledge it. Means that I have to I I will
- 5:20because it's not a point I feel. Strongly about, sure.
- 5:23Yeah, sure. I mean, I, I remember this movie
- 5:27coming out because I saw it in theaters and thought it was
- 5:29freaking rad. Like this movie ruled in 2003
- 5:35and that, and that's in a year where Return of the King was
- 5:37like far and away the best movie of the year.
- 5:41I think everybody still absolutely loved this movie.
- 5:45We've done quite a few movies from 2003, Brad.
- 5:47I mean, we've done Return of the King, we've done Mystic River.
- 5:51What else? What else came out this year
- 5:53that was rad? The the third Matrix movie that
- 5:56people don't really like came out this year.
- 5:59The School of Rock, 2003, baby. What a year.
- 6:02Perfect seven point O movie. Speaking of perfect Seven Point
- 6:07O movies, let's talk about Pirates of the Caribbean some
- 6:10more, Brad. And in order to do that, we're
- 6:12going to throw over to our first segment of the day, which we
- 6:16call Brad explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 6:19movie plots with only 60 seconds ticking on the clock, so let's
- 6:22go ahead and hear your take with this little segment that we
- 6:25call, Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 6:29show where Brad breaks down the plot of the movie that he has
- 6:32just seen, often for the first time.
- 6:35Brad, how long has it been since you last saw Pirates of the
- 6:38Caribbean? I think Haley and I watched it
- 6:41maybe like five or six years ago, so this is probably my
- 6:46third or fourth time watching the film.
- 6:49This is a movie that, you know, I've watched, I don't know,
- 6:52three of the sequels, 2, and then kind of gave up.
- 6:55I don't think I saw the last one that came out.
- 6:57But I don't know that I've actually gone back and watched
- 7:00this movie since 2003. Like, it's a movie that I've
- 7:04always liked and I'm familiar with, but I literally cannot
- 7:08remember the last time I saw it. So I think it may have been in
- 7:11the theater, you know, 21 years ago.
- 7:14Sheesh, that's a long time, Bob. Out of all the movies that
- 7:18you've returned to, why is this not on that list?
- 7:24I don't know. Hey, man, this is not called
- 7:25Brad interrogates. This is called Brad explains.
- 7:27What are you doing? I'm.
- 7:28Just I'm curious, you, Bob, you return just so many movies.
- 7:34You have movies in your catalog that you've watched 20 times
- 7:38that are terrible movies like School of Rock.
- 7:40So what has kept you from watching Pirates of the
- 7:44Caribbean again? I don't know.
- 7:45And, and I was really, really excited to return to it this
- 7:48time because this film has kind of garnered A reputation over
- 7:51the last ten years or so. People have really re evaluated
- 7:54Gore Verbinski because it's been a long time since he's made a
- 7:56movie as, as this great Workman, like director of the early
- 8:002000s. And so I remember loving this
- 8:04film. I was super pumped to revisit
- 8:05it. I, I don't think there was ever
- 8:07a reason for me not revisiting it.
- 8:09It just, you know, just didn't happen, man.
- 8:11You got to make room for School of Rock for the 20th time, I
- 8:15guess, man. All right, before you start your
- 8:18Brat Explain segment here, one point of clarification, and I
- 8:21think we are in agreement on this, Brad.
- 8:24The region that they are sailing around is called the Caribbean.
- 8:29But when you refer to this movie, you have to say Pirates
- 8:32of the Caribbean. You cannot call it Pirates of
- 8:35the Caribbean. Yeah, no, that's that is like
- 8:38not kosher, Yeah. Now you have to mispronounce it
- 8:41on purpose just because that's how this movie is pronounced.
- 8:45I don't make the rules though. Do you want to inform the the
- 8:49listeners about your views on Reese's?
- 8:52No, there is no views on Reese's.
- 8:55The man's name was Reese. He made a peanut buttercup.
- 8:59They added an apostrophe S Reese's peanut Buttercup.
- 9:02There is no Reese. He did not make PCs.
- 9:06This is not even a discussion that needs to be had.
- 9:08I don't understand how people mispronounce it.
- 9:11I don't know. It sounds like you want to have
- 9:13a conversation about this, Bob. Brad, you have one minute on the
- 9:17clock to break down the plot of Pirates of the Caribbean, The
- 9:21Curse of the Black Pearl, and go.
- 9:24Pirates of the Caribbean The Curse of the Black Pearl is a
- 9:27film about pirates. Who would have thought, Bob?
- 9:32In the Caribbean. Yeah, they are in the Caribbean.
- 9:37This movie follows a trio of characters played by Johnny
- 9:42Depp, Keira Knightley and Orlando Bloom, all of whom unite
- 9:46on an adventure to return a lost Spanish cursed coin to a chest
- 9:53so that a bunch of pirates can be freed of their curse.
- 9:58And And that's it. Yeah, I mean, pretty much.
- 10:02Yeah, I, I don't know. I don't know how to like get,
- 10:06get more granular without really getting into the weeds.
- 10:09So I think I'll just leave it there.
- 10:12So I'm not, I'm not going to lie to you, man.
- 10:14Sometimes when you do, Brad explains.
- 10:16I take that opportunity to check my phone and make sure I don't,
- 10:19I'm not missing something more important than Brad explains
- 10:22Rude. And I typed in my passcode and I
- 10:25had Facebook open and there was a Facebook ad waiting for me as
- 10:29I scrolled from Peacock TV. And it's for a new television
- 10:34show called Orlando Bloom to the Edge.
- 10:38Orlando Bloom goes on a physical, mental and spiritual
- 10:41journey as he attempts extreme sports in this Peacock original.
- 10:46Let's go, dude. And the very first comment
- 10:49underneath that says thank goodness he can play himself.
- 10:52He certainly can't act as a different person.
- 10:59And man, oh man, am I grateful for that comment because that is
- 11:03the perfect jumping off point. After Brad explains, we usually
- 11:07talk about performances. I would like to start with
- 11:09Orlando Bloom. We have seen him now in This is
- 11:12the fifth Orlando Bloom film we have reviewed on this podcast
- 11:15after The three Lord of the Rings and Elizabethtown.
- 11:19Say, not the worst movie we've seen him in.
- 11:22But maybe his worst performance. And I got to be honest with you,
- 11:25man, I as Legolas, he is like perfectly cast because he has
- 11:31just this this softness to his demeanor.
- 11:35And he's also like the 11th lead of that movie.
- 11:38Yeah, there's no personality. I'm gonna be honest with you
- 11:41dude, Orlando Bloom is not a good actor and I think it showed
- 11:44up pretty strongly here. He has great facial hair in this
- 11:48movie but other than that he is just a walking goatee and it's
- 11:54pretty bad dude. I am in like 80% disagreement
- 12:00with you. What?
- 12:01I I think he's like solid in this movie.
- 12:04I like he is as solid as he can be because fun fact folks,
- 12:11Orlando Bloom not a good actor. I think that this movie covers
- 12:17up for a lot of his flaws by allowing him to be very
- 12:24self-righteous throughout this movie.
- 12:26And I think that like playing self-righteous is probably one
- 12:29of the easier things to do where he's just very sure of himself
- 12:33throughout the film. And I think that the little
- 12:36moments they give him where he's kind of questioning who he is
- 12:40and the things that he believes he gives like just enough with
- 12:44his eyes and with his body language that I'm like, OK, I, I
- 12:49kind of believe that you're going through something right
- 12:51now. So I, I, I think it's like a
- 12:54solid B minus performance. Here yeah, I think you know if
- 12:58you've ever looked at advanced statistics for sports, there's a
- 13:02there's a statistic called VORP which is value over replacement
- 13:05player, which is basically measuring how much value are you
- 13:09providing to your team above and beyond what we would consider
- 13:13like an entry level player at your sport.
- 13:16So like the. Last guy off the bench.
- 13:19I think about that all the time for replacements for you as my
- 13:22Co host. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 13:24Luckily I'm knocking it out of the park in my podcast VORP.
- 13:28Usually Orlando Bloom is like right on the edge man of of
- 13:32being replacement level. I think you could slot in any
- 13:35number of young up and coming actors in 2003 into this role
- 13:40and it's roughly the same or better.
- 13:43You know what I mean? Like we've, we had a long
- 13:45conversation last week about Hayden Christensen.
- 13:48I don't know that you couldn't put Hayden Christensen here and
- 13:52it would be pretty much the same.
- 13:53He, you know, Orlando Bloom is just very, very pretty.
- 13:56But I don't really think there's much else going on there.
- 14:00And you're right in this movie, you don't really need that much
- 14:02else because there are huge characters elsewhere.
- 14:06But. I mean, even even, like, the
- 14:08character of Norrington in a weird sense has a bigger
- 14:12personality than him, right? Like, yeah, like obviously he's
- 14:15this very restrained British commandant, but like, he, like
- 14:21the way he presents himself. I I love the performance of
- 14:25whoever plays Commander Norrington because he's
- 14:30incredible. I like how you couldn't be
- 14:32bothered to look up like the 4th lead of this movie.
- 14:35I love the performance of whoever plays him.
- 14:38Uninterested, Bob. His name's Jack Davenport, by
- 14:42the way. Yeah, Jack Davenport gives a
- 14:44great performance. Here's how little I remembered
- 14:46this movie. In the sequels to this movie,
- 14:50Tom Hollander plays like the evil British commander that is
- 14:54chasing Jack Sparrow. And he's so good.
- 14:56He's so good I thought that he was in this.
- 14:58I don't even remember Norrington.
- 15:00Like I don't remember this character at all.
- 15:02The guy was fine. Jack Davenport is fine.
- 15:05But I was a little bummed out when at no point in this movie I
- 15:08saw Tom Hollander. Yeah, I mean that that's an
- 15:10example of VORP in movies, right?
- 15:12Like like, Jack Davenport does a solid job.
- 15:16I think he's like a solid BB plus performance with a decently
- 15:20well written character. Tom Hollander is going to knock
- 15:24it out of the park. Like, come on, man.
- 15:26Now, the reason that I bring up Orlando Bloom so quickly, I
- 15:30don't usually jump in with like, here's my least favorite person
- 15:33in this whole movie. Let's crap on him for 10
- 15:35minutes. But it's because his counterpart
- 15:38in this movie, Keira Knightley, is so good in this movie, Brad.
- 15:41And I think that I don't know that we've ever talked about,
- 15:45well, we did Pride and Prejudice.
- 15:46So we've talked about Keira Knightley, I think one time on
- 15:48the podcast. I really think she is one of our
- 15:51best working actresses and she has been at it for decades and
- 15:55decades now. We've become so used to her that
- 15:57we barely talk about her anymore.
- 15:59And I think her her good roles are starting to become few and
- 16:02far between. But every time I watch a movie
- 16:05with Keira Knightley in it, it's like, how was she not the
- 16:09biggest movie star in the world for at least 10 years there?
- 16:12She is so magnetic. And this performance in
- 16:15particular requires so much of her in terms of being, you know,
- 16:20demure and deferring to propriety, but then also like 10
- 16:25minutes later, kicking ass. Like she has to be both Pride
- 16:29and Prejudice and she has to be Marian in Raiders of the Lost
- 16:33Ark. And I think go ahead.
- 16:35She. She does it at age 17.
- 16:38That was my next point. When this movie comes out, she
- 16:40is 18 years old and she, more than perhaps anybody I can think
- 16:46of in the last 30 years, benefited from looking like she
- 16:50was 27 for 15 years. Like from the time she was 17 to
- 16:55the time she was 30 something, she looked like she was about 27
- 17:00years old. So she could reasonably play the
- 17:03young romantic love interest in any movie.
- 17:07And I don't think people realize like when we've, you know, she
- 17:10was working in the 90s, but we didn't really see her in a
- 17:13breakout role until Bend It Like Beckham the year before this
- 17:16movie comes out. And she's 17 years old when that
- 17:19movie comes out. And so that means that she's, I
- 17:22think she's 38 now, right? Am I doing my math correctly?
- 17:25She's either 38 or turning 39. She's not even 40 years old and
- 17:29she's been in our lives for over 2 decades as a leading lady.
- 17:33The only other person, the only other person I can think of that
- 17:37did that is Scarlett Johansson, which we talked about that with
- 17:40Lost in Translation. It's just, you know, I, I don't
- 17:43think we talk about Keira Knightley enough.
- 17:44She's one of my favorite actresses and she's so good in
- 17:48this role that she makes Orlando Bloom look even worse by
- 17:52comparison, I think. I I mean, I think she elevates
- 17:56everyone in this movie. I she's stunning.
- 18:01Keira Knightley. We need to watch more of her
- 18:04movies. Bob.
- 18:05I've never seen a movie that she's in and not walked away
- 18:08been being blown away by her performance.
- 18:11She's. So good, dude.
- 18:12Yeah, and, and honestly, as you were talking about her, Scarlett
- 18:15Johansson was my like direct analogue for her.
- 18:19I, I, I feel like we have such a similar career pathway, but you
- 18:25know, Keira Knightley got her big break in a Disney film and,
- 18:30you know, Scarlett eventually gets into Disney films.
- 18:33So I I don't know if there's something to be said there for.
- 18:36It all comes back to the mouse, is what we're saying.
- 18:38Yeah, it sure does. No, but I'm even thinking now
- 18:41about like, OK, Scarlett Johansson and Keira Knightley
- 18:44kind of coming of age at the same time. 2 very different
- 18:47career paths, I feel like, but what separates them as
- 18:50actresses? And I think Scarlett Johansson,
- 18:53I think about a movie like Marriage story and what's so
- 18:56good about the way Scarlett Johansson acts in Marriage Story
- 18:59is that she's not trying to suppress emotion, but she tries
- 19:03to keep her emotions under control.
- 19:05And so when she finally cries, it's like it's not just like the
- 19:08dam breaking, but it's you can see a person struggling to try
- 19:12to tamp down their emotion. And where's Keira Knightley?
- 19:15I've always felt like she just kind of nakedly wears her
- 19:18emotions out there like she always does the gasping for
- 19:21breath kind of cry and she's just she she's much more suited
- 19:26for material like this. And I think that's why we've
- 19:28always seen her in period pieces.
- 19:30She's so good in Jane Austen, the movie Atonement, maybe my
- 19:34favorite performance of hers. But there's something that seems
- 19:38like a throwback actress about Keira Knightley.
- 19:41I think she could have been the exact same kind of actress in
- 19:44like the 1930s and 40s and it would have fit so well.
- 19:49I don't think her acting style is over like oversized, but I
- 19:55just think that there's like there's so much more emotion
- 19:57worn on her sleeve and I really like seeing that.
- 20:01It's kind of refreshing. Bob, I I think that brings up
- 20:04the the bigger question on everybody's minds why are Brits
- 20:08so much better at acting than Americans?
- 20:11Listen, man, it's times are tough over there.
- 20:13It's always Gray. It's cold their their food has
- 20:17no seasoning. That this makes them better
- 20:20actors and actresses. They've experienced the depth of
- 20:22human drama and emotion just in their everyday lives, and so
- 20:26yeah, it's easier to call that back up again.
- 20:28Because it's still the 1800s industrial revolution over
- 20:32there, and Keira Knightley was a poor child in the coal mines,
- 20:36barefoot and penniless. I'm pretty sure that you're just
- 20:39reading directly off of her IMDb bio at this point.
- 20:42That's that sounds right to me, yeah.
- 20:44That's exactly what I was doing. All right, man, so Keira
- 20:47Knightley A+ plus plus in this movie.
- 20:50And I think, Brad, that this is another one of those
- 20:52performances that if we had talked about this movie in like
- 20:56the early episodes of film and whiskey, we'd be talking a lot
- 21:00more about Johnny Depp because that's the big showy performance
- 21:02here. And and we will and he's great.
- 21:05But I think we have, we've developed an appreciation for
- 21:09not just what I would call supporting characters, but lead
- 21:12characters who are like the straight man for the big
- 21:16outsized funny guy. You know what I mean?
- 21:17Like if Keira Knightley's not this good in her role, and even
- 21:21Orlando Bloom I think to a lesser extent in his role,
- 21:24Johnny Depp doesn't shine because no one is like tossing
- 21:28up the lob for him to knock out of the park.
- 21:31Yeah, well, and that's the issue they run into with the later
- 21:33movies, right? They slowly force everyone out
- 21:37and now it's just Johnny Depp being asinine and ridiculous as
- 21:41Jack Sparrow and it it becomes way less charming when you don't
- 21:46have an Orlando Bloom playing this super earnest, pirate
- 21:50hating, justice loving, idealistic young man like that.
- 21:56Makes Depp so much more complex as a character because you you
- 22:02have him in between the character of Will Turner and
- 22:07Barbarosa. Like Barbarosa is the epitome of
- 22:11like the evil pirate and Jack Sparrow's, you know, somewhat in
- 22:15between there. But you you need those extremes
- 22:19on either side of him to make his character endearing and
- 22:23funny and believable as he kind of waffles between those two
- 22:27edges. I mean, I think as with most
- 22:30comedic characters, the character gets more and more
- 22:33broad as the movies go on to the point where, you know, like
- 22:36Brad, you and I are are big fans of How I Met Your Mother, like
- 22:40season 8 and Season 9, Barney is it?
- 22:44It's like a little much. At that point, you're like, this
- 22:46isn't even a human anymore. It's like every time I
- 22:48accidentally stumble upon an episode of The Big Bang Theory
- 22:52and it just like it. It's just it makes me cringe
- 22:54because it's like, what? In what world do people think
- 22:58these characters are funny? These don't even resemble humans
- 23:00anymore. That's Jack Sparrow.
- 23:02Like he gets to a point where it's just the drunken swagger is
- 23:06it takes over everything. There's just nothing there
- 23:08anymore except Johnny Depp trying.
- 23:11Really hard. And to be clear, like you are
- 23:13talking about the later films, not this one.
- 23:15Yeah, I think that you can see the seeds of it a little bit in
- 23:18this film too. But then every time that I'm
- 23:20like, this is 'cause I'm watching this movie again for
- 23:23the first time in 20 years, remembering that I'm.
- 23:26I'm pretty sure Johnny Depp gets an Oscar nomination for this
- 23:29movie, which is like huge. Like, I couldn't believe it.
- 23:33And so I'm going back to it now, like, OK, did we get caught up
- 23:37in the hype a little bit? Is this performance good?
- 23:39And every time that it would tip towards, OK, hey, in that scene
- 23:43he was a little too drunken rock star Johnny Depp.
- 23:47Then they would they would throw in a scene where he kind of
- 23:49dropped the ACT a little bit and you could see like, once his
- 23:53eyes kind of focus in on the person that he's talking to.
- 23:56And it's like, Oh, yeah, Johnny Depp is killing this dude.
- 23:58Like, there's a reason that this character became iconic that
- 24:02people still dress up as Jack Sparrow for Halloween.
- 24:04Like, it's just it's a great performance.
- 24:08And I think more often than not, he knows how to walk the line
- 24:12and it doesn't tip too far into caricature.
- 24:16Yeah, yeah. I mean, he loses to Sean Penn in
- 24:18Mystic River, which is wild. That was that was a great
- 24:23performance. Is that my daughter in there?
- 24:28Come on dude, it's so good. Oh man, would Sean Penn have
- 24:34made a good Jack Sparrow? Is the question here.
- 24:37Oh. I think he takes it too
- 24:39seriously. Yeah, I don't.
- 24:41I don't think he does, actually. Let's let's put all of the
- 24:45actors in a leading role from 2004 Oscars.
- 24:48Would Ben Kingsley make a good Jack Sparrow?
- 24:51No, but he would have made a great Barbarossa Ben Kingsley.
- 24:56Is a great actor all right? Next, would Jude Law make a good
- 25:01Jack? Sparrow.
- 25:02No, but he would have made a good will.
- 25:03Turner. Yeah.
- 25:05Oh, he would have made a hell of a Will Turner.
- 25:07So much more charming. All right.
- 25:10Last one. And I think the answer to this
- 25:12is unequivocally yes, for all the wrong reasons.
- 25:16Would Bill Murray make a good Jack Sparrow?
- 25:21I want that movie right now I. Want that movie?
- 25:24So bad. All right, man, maybe this is a
- 25:28good point for us to talk about Jack Sparrow's counterpart in
- 25:31Barbarossa, played by Oscar winner Geoffrey Rush.
- 25:34Now, here's the great thing about Barbarossa.
- 25:37He gets more and more villainous as the movie goes on, like when
- 25:41he first kidnaps, like quote, UN quote kidnaps Elizabeth and
- 25:45they're kind of conversing over an apple in his office.
- 25:48You're like, oh, I understand this guy's motivations totally.
- 25:51And then as the movie goes on, they need him to be more of a
- 25:54Dick. So they kind of just make him
- 25:56more of a Dick. This is not even though he has
- 26:01like a monkey on his shoulder and is speaking with a piratey
- 26:05growl and says yar and stuff. It's actually not like a big
- 26:09scene chewing performance like he actually moderates and and I
- 26:14guess modulates would be the better word, his performance to
- 26:18allow Johnny Depp to be even more wild than he is.
- 26:21And I think by comparison, it seems very grounded.
- 26:24And I just want to say like, that's why Geoffrey Rush in this
- 26:27movie and in all the later movies works so well is because
- 26:31he doesn't. He's not competing against
- 26:33Johnny Depp in who can have the bigger performance.
- 26:37And that's the only reason that things stay balanced here.
- 26:40Dude, I came in here ready to say I think that Geoffrey Rush
- 26:45might be the best agreed actor in this movie.
- 26:47Agreed. Like he is incredible.
- 26:51And I I think that he's technically, I think he's in the
- 26:54second movie, he's replaced by the one and only Bill Nighy in
- 26:59the second film, which is feels like the perfect succession,
- 27:06right? Like Geoffrey Rush just has this
- 27:09talent for staying grounded in the midst of the most, like,
- 27:15performance you have ever seen in your life.
- 27:17And I don't, I think I need to watch the movie about eight more
- 27:21times to figure out how he does it because there were so many
- 27:26movements where, you know, the the trailer fodder.
- 27:30When he's like this, you know, this isn't a bedtime story
- 27:33anymore. You're in one.
- 27:34Yeah, and it's like so over the top.
- 27:37And yet he's always holding something back.
- 27:42And I, I don't know how he does it.
- 27:44Bob it. It's an incredible performance.
- 27:49Man, I'm so happy that we're in agreement on that one because I
- 27:52like, do I think Johnny Depp deserved an Oscar nomination?
- 27:55Sure. I don't think it's like it's
- 27:57certainly not an egregious looking nomination, but it's not
- 28:01the best performance in this movie.
- 28:02It's the showiest performance. And I think what Geoffrey Rush
- 28:05is doing is actually much more dialed in and much more complex.
- 28:11Like it's it's hard to do this character without just becoming
- 28:15like a John Malkovich villain from like the late 90s and just
- 28:19going completely over the top with, you know what I mean?
- 28:20Like they he could have just said, I'm going to sink my teeth
- 28:23into this thing and we're I'm going to get a shouting match
- 28:26with Johnny Depp and we'll see who comes out on top.
- 28:28And he, he just, he zags. And I really like it man.
- 28:32Yeah, when you when you're saying it could have been an old
- 28:36villain performance, it almost feels like it.
- 28:38He could have gone the Tim Curry route and just been so
- 28:43ridiculous in the role. But man, like you said, it is
- 28:47such a grounded performance and he gives you all of the reasons
- 28:53for why he's doing what he's doing.
- 28:56I I think what it made me think of was how our actions have
- 29:02consequences for our souls, unlike.
- 29:06Oh, you mean like the actual the character?
- 29:09The character. I thought you were like Geoffrey
- 29:10Rush's performance made me realize that, yes.
- 29:13That is exactly. You had a spiritual experience
- 29:16watching this movie, man. I'm sorry.
- 29:21Please continue. Yeah.
- 29:22I just mean, I mean, the performance is a huge part of
- 29:25it. The his ability to stay grounded
- 29:28is what kind of helped me realize that the slide into
- 29:32being more and more villainous isn't a result of the scripture
- 29:36saying, hey, we need him to be villainous.
- 29:38It it feels like an honest character arc of, yes, we're
- 29:43just trying to get back to being real human beings.
- 29:46And that seems like a good motivation.
- 29:51But then you realize as the movie goes on, like he's also
- 29:55spent the past 1020 years murdering, raping, pillaging,
- 30:01like all of the evil things that the the skeletal interior of his
- 30:07soul is who he truly is at this point.
- 30:10Yeah, it's just it's a great, it's a great character and it's
- 30:13a great performance. All right, man, I think we're in
- 30:16a really good spot to press pause here.
- 30:18I want to talk a little bit about the fact that this movie
- 30:21is based on a roller coaster, like the the existing story was
- 30:25just roller coaster and they made this movie out of it.
- 30:29We'll talk about that when we get back from break.
- 30:31But what do you say we try some Sam Houston 15 year?
- 30:35Let's get to it. All right, today we are checking
- 30:43out Sam Houston 15 Year Bourbon. Now, I was trying to think of
- 30:48something clever to connect the Caribbean to Texas, where Sam
- 30:52Houston famously is from, and I can't think of a single thing.
- 30:56So Brad, we're going to pretend like I had some clever
- 30:58connection, but honestly, it was just time for us to drink some
- 31:02Sam Houston. This juice is from Barton
- 31:06Distillery. It's distilled under a different
- 31:09label, similar to the Calumet that we've been having for the
- 31:12last few weeks, Brad, and also similar to those.
- 31:16This is a very well aged bourbon.
- 31:18We have gone on record saying that generally speaking, we
- 31:21don't love bourbons that are aged beyond, say, 10 years
- 31:24because they get really, really, really oaky and I'm a little bit
- 31:28nervous about that today. Yeah, this is a heck of an aged
- 31:33product, coming in at only 103 proof, which is usually a pretty
- 31:38good sign. Well aged products in the
- 31:41bourbon category that come in a barrel proof have a chance to
- 31:45just like, leave oak on your palate for the next four days.
- 31:51Yeah, when I see that this is only 103 proof, I like two
- 31:54thoughts come to mind immediately.
- 31:56And one is like, is this just too much flavour wise at barrel
- 32:01proof and or was so much of it lost to the Angel share over 15
- 32:07years that they had like physically had to dilute it to
- 32:10have enough product to distribute?
- 32:12And so like, I mean, it's probably a little bit of both,
- 32:14but I'm also glad to see that it's not like 118 proof or
- 32:18something because honestly, I just think diluting it a little
- 32:21bit might help kind of tamper down some of those insanely Okie
- 32:25notes we get. Yeah, but I, I think, I think
- 32:28it's worth just jumping in here, Bob, as I got into the nose on
- 32:32this, I got some really nice dark cherry notes.
- 32:37The vanilla really came through strongly.
- 32:40There's caramel. It had a really nice, like fresh
- 32:43bread kind of vibe to it. A a little bit of, I don't know,
- 32:47cacao. Like it's a It's a relatively
- 32:51nice complex nose that I gave an 8 out of 10 to.
- 32:56Yeah, Brad, similar to a couple of those calumettes.
- 32:58This doesn't have any wheat in the mashbill, but it reminds me
- 33:02of a weeded bourbon on the nose. And I think that might be like
- 33:05the interplay between the rye grain and the oak and how much
- 33:09oak we're getting on this. But I definitely get those notes
- 33:12of cherry that you're talking about.
- 33:13It reminds me of those cherry cola notes that we get on some
- 33:17of our favorite Rebel products. For instance.
- 33:20I get a lot of red apple peel on this as well.
- 33:22But other than that, I think your notes are spot on.
- 33:25There's a ton of vanilla here. The oak is nice and it it is
- 33:28more of like a toasted oak than a charred oak, but it comes
- 33:31across softer and it's not it doesn't have that sort of soured
- 33:34oak scent to it. I like this a lot and I'm hoping
- 33:39that it portends good things here.
- 33:40I'm going to give it an 8 out of 10 on the nose.
- 33:43When I got into the palate, it stays in that kind of fruity
- 33:48vein for me. It turned into like a bit of a
- 33:51BlackBerry currant kind of flavor, but the, the cacao stuck
- 33:56in there that that was a notable note for me.
- 34:00But other than that, Bob, it is oak on oak on oak and there's
- 34:07enough other flavors going on here that I, I enjoyed it.
- 34:10I think it's a solid whiskey, but I, I came down a little bit
- 34:13from the nose. I'm at a 7.5 in the palate
- 34:16category. I kept trying to piece my
- 34:20thoughts together and I thought I'd landed on something and then
- 34:23it kept going. The flavor, I mean, it kept
- 34:26going and then I had to revise my thoughts and then the flavor
- 34:29kept going. And that's not a good thing
- 34:32here, Brad. So like I took a sip and I'm
- 34:35with you. It was like really nice, really
- 34:37pleasant. Still that red apple peel for
- 34:39me, like a red delicious apple. I went to swallow and it had
- 34:42that nice dusty kind of sawdusty flavor to it and a pleasant
- 34:47amount of oak. When I swallowed it, it was
- 34:50like, it was a little smoky and a little bit bitter, but it was
- 34:54almost like the bourbon equivalent of a peated Scotch.
- 34:57I was like, OK, I can still rock with this.
- 35:00It's not my favorite thing. But, you know, sometimes we like
- 35:03the fruitiness on a peated Scotch and then we swallow it
- 35:05and then there's the peat and it just is what it is.
- 35:08And then it just kept going. It turned really bitter.
- 35:12It got really ashy. There's like a cigarette ash
- 35:15kind of thing going on. And then it got more bitter and
- 35:17more herbal and like vegetal almost.
- 35:21And man, I just wish that they look.
- 35:24I wish I could have put a hard cut off on when my tongue
- 35:27stopped tasting because it was going really well and then it it
- 35:31definitely tapered off. I'm going to give it a 6.5 on
- 35:34the flavor. Oh man, yeah, I I think that the
- 35:39finish for me is is going to be at the 6.5.
- 35:43It just there's some there's some stuff going on on the
- 35:46pallet that just slowly dissipates into the black hole
- 35:51vortex that is oak like that. Like this is what Matthew
- 35:57McConaughey got stuck in in in Interstellar.
- 36:01Like, like it. It's just the oak from all of
- 36:06these 1520 thirty year bourbons. Yeah, man.
- 36:11And I have to be honest with you, I think that the 1st 60% of
- 36:16this tasting experience was the best one of these that we've had
- 36:19so far. I really liked where this was
- 36:21going. And then it was just like it, it
- 36:24would kept piling on itself. And I just want to be able to
- 36:28shake this Burbin and say like, quit while you're ahead.
- 36:30You, you had a good thing going here.
- 36:33I'll give it a 6.5 again on the finish.
- 36:35It's not terrible. And once you know what you're
- 36:38getting, the 2nd 3rd sip are not unpleasant, but it's just it
- 36:42could have been so much better. Yeah, I gave it A7 on balance.
- 36:47I I think that this is a well made whiskey that has lots of
- 36:52good qualities. It's just overwhelmed by the
- 36:55age. So I, I don't know where are you
- 36:59at on balance? This is hard because I don't
- 37:03think that the nose tipped me off about how oaky this was
- 37:06going to get, but the oak was definitely there, you know what
- 37:09I mean? Like I don't think a nose can
- 37:11tip off how sour the oak is going to taste.
- 37:14So like is it well balanced? I think it might be pretty well
- 37:17balanced and it's a 15 year bourbon like this.
- 37:20This all everything we've said makes sense for a 15 year
- 37:24bourbon. Nothing seems out of the
- 37:25ordinary here. It's just something that we
- 37:27don't personally love. I think I'll give it an 8 out of
- 37:3110 on balance. Like I I can't hold it against
- 37:34the whiskey that it does what it is supposed to do at this age.
- 37:38Sure. I can, however, hold it against
- 37:40this whiskey that it costs a whole bunch of money.
- 37:44I think MSRP on this Brad is around $160.
- 37:48I'm seeing 16999. And then when you're actually
- 37:52trying to find the particular batch we're drinking, which is
- 37:54the Indiana batch #2 I mean, it's like at least $300.00 at
- 37:59this point. So I don't know if you want to
- 38:02consider it our in our new premium category or not.
- 38:06Yeah. Bob, Bob, this is you are not
- 38:10going to find this for less than $200.
- 38:12Yeah. It's not worth $200, Brad.
- 38:14No, no, in in the category of premium, I think I would give
- 38:21this about a four and a half like I like.
- 38:26I think it's decent. I don't think it's a terrible
- 38:28value for a premium whiskey. I just think that there's so
- 38:33many better options out there for you in that premium
- 38:36category. We were just talking to the
- 38:39owner of this bottle of whiskey who generously sent us a sample
- 38:42of it, our friend Wes, and he was basically saying that the
- 38:46way that he likes to price out things he buys on the secondary
- 38:49is the $10 per year rule. So at 15 years old, $150.00 for
- 38:56this bottle would be about right.
- 38:58So I think that if we are pricing it at 150, I'd give it a
- 39:01better score. The fact that you can't get it
- 39:03for less than at least 200 now, it's just not worth that much.
- 39:07I'm going to give it a yeah, I'm with you, man.
- 39:08I'll give it a 4.5 on value and that takes me to a 33.5 out of
- 39:1550. Are you in the same place as me?
- 39:18Yeah. I sure am exact same score.
- 39:20I love it, man. So yeah, that was a pretty easy
- 39:24one. Brad, we're at a 33 1/2.
- 39:26If you were just scoring out like what's in the glass, does
- 39:31this drink like a 35 out of fit? Like would you recommend the
- 39:34juice itself, Brad? Oh yes, I, I think that what is
- 39:41here in the glass is unique and interesting and somewhat complex
- 39:46on the nose and then slowly that that complexity just it's a
- 39:50black hole, man. I I, I think that it's solid
- 39:55whiskey, but it gets lost in the age statement.
- 40:00I have nothing else to say, man. Wes, thank you again for your
- 40:03insanely oaky aged bourbons. But Brad, if I can just be frank
- 40:09with you, man, this is just not my.
- 40:11This is not my wheelhouse. No, no, nor mind Bob.
- 40:15I And that's crazy because like, you're the one who loves bourbon
- 40:19and I, I wish that I could say better things about this, but
- 40:23here I am. It's fine 33.5 I will not
- 40:27recommend it if you find it at a bar and you know what you're
- 40:30getting into like go for it spend your money but I I
- 40:35wouldn't. Go for it, Spend your money.
- 40:37I love it, man. All right, let's get back into
- 40:39talking about Pirates of the Caribbean.
- 40:41What do you say? Well, let's get to it.
- 40:48All right, everybody. That was Sam Houston 15.
- 40:52Should have been Sam Houston 8 and I think that they would have
- 40:56had a hell of a product. Oh, it would have been great,
- 40:58man. The end.
- 41:00Yeah, I'd have nothing else to say there.
- 41:01That's it. That's all folks.
- 41:03You know what is a great product, Brad?
- 41:06Is it Canada's favorite segment? 2 facts and a falsehood. 2 facts
- 41:11and a falsehood. Brad is going to try to stump
- 41:14your ball 2 all right. And what is wrong?
- 41:212 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts and a Falsehood is the part of
- 41:24the show where Brad presents me with three items as fact about
- 41:28the making of this movie, one of which is a complete lie.
- 41:32Brad, right now I am sitting at 10:00 and 6:00 on the season
- 41:36because I got 2 unfortunate losses a few weeks ago when our
- 41:40guest LED me astray. This is our 16th episode of
- 41:44Season 8, so after today we're halfway.
- 41:46Through the season, halfway through, it always kind of jumps
- 41:49up on me by surprise. I didn't realize we were already
- 41:52that far into the Season 8. What are your thoughts on on the
- 41:55first half of season 8? Think that I've had a movies
- 41:58we've watched. Yeah, I the 90s were a wild
- 42:02time. Like for a few years there I was
- 42:05just kind of like above average on an Independence Day.
- 42:08Men in Black, but like man, true lies the fugitive.
- 42:13Come on man, it was a hell of a decade.
- 42:16I can't remember exactly where I heard it, but there's a a writer
- 42:20named Chuck Klosterman and he was on a podcast once and he was
- 42:23talking about this idea of kind of like how with increasing
- 42:28technology, culture actually doesn't change as much anymore.
- 42:32Like you think that things speed up now, but things that were
- 42:35made 20 years ago feel pretty much the same as they do now.
- 42:39Whereas in in prior generations, things accelerated so rapidly.
- 42:43Think about movies from the 40s versus the 60s versus the 80s.
- 42:48And I think that this is kind of what I'm seeing here.
- 42:51Like we got distinct phases of movie making between the Rain
- 42:56Man's and the Batman's of the world to even The Fugitive.
- 43:00And then in the late 90s, your Independence days, your men and
- 43:03blacks. And now it kind of feels like
- 43:05this is the last gasp of old movie making and pretty much
- 43:09everything from Transformers through End Game is going to
- 43:12feel like the exact same thing. And so like, I will miss the
- 43:16variety. I think that's what that's
- 43:17what's been really nice about the first half of this season is
- 43:20we've gotten a ton of variety here.
- 43:23You do you want to hear my my theory, Bob?
- 43:25Let's hear it. I think that the Internet has
- 43:29homogenized humanity. And like, we thought that it was
- 43:33going to be this great thing that allowed us to discover each
- 43:36other's uniqueness. But at the end of the day,
- 43:39advertisers were like, oh, you mean I can get dad on all these
- 43:42people and figure out what the most amount of people are
- 43:46attracted to so I can make money off of them?
- 43:49Like, those are the things we're going to make.
- 43:51And like, that's that right there.
- 43:54Death of creativity, Bob. Yep, as we review a movie based
- 43:58on a roller coaster, Brad, hit me with your two facts and a
- 44:02falsehood. Fact #1 When casting for the
- 44:06role of Will Turner, it was down to Orlando Bloom or Heath
- 44:10Ledger. They made a mistake.
- 44:14No commentary here Bobble, just the facts.
- 44:18Verbinski chose Bloom because he knew that he was in the Lord of
- 44:21the Rings trilogy and felt that he would be a more bankable
- 44:24choice. Fact #2 In the scene where Keira
- 44:28Knightley sets fire to the rum on the deserted island, the
- 44:31smoke rose so high that the Grenadine Coast Guard came to
- 44:35investigate. Fact #3 When returning home from
- 44:40a night shoot on one of the I was Is it Caribbean or
- 44:45Caribbean? What are we going with?
- 44:48Yeah, dealer's choice, man. No, I'm just going to start
- 44:51start over. Fact #3 When returning from a
- 44:54night shoot on one of the Caribbean islands, Keira
- 44:56Knightley's boat struck a reef and went down.
- 44:59The only people aboard were Knightley, her mother and the
- 45:02boat skipper, all of whom escaped unharmed and were
- 45:05rescued within a few hours. I think it's either two or
- 45:11three. And I say that because like I'm,
- 45:14I'm just going to assume that what I said earlier is correct
- 45:16that you could slot in anybody for Orlando Bloom.
- 45:20So I have to assume they were looking at a number of different
- 45:23actors for this part. Heath Ledger makes sense based
- 45:26on his age. So then it's like, OK, did the
- 45:31fire signal call people over to investigate?
- 45:34One would think that when they're burning trees, they
- 45:36would have gotten some permits. So I don't know #2 seems
- 45:39suspicious #3 is also like, I, you know who, like, cool story,
- 45:45bro, You know what I mean? So that seems like it could be a
- 45:48Brad G special. Brad G Original.
- 45:52I was gonna say #3 is the falsehood.
- 45:53That one just kind of stuck out to me, is the falsehood.
- 45:55But the more I think about it, the more it doesn't really make
- 45:58sense that people would come to investigate.
- 46:02So I'll go out on a limb and I'll go against my gut and I'll
- 46:05say #2 is the falsehood, Brad? Bob, you have done it again,
- 46:12proving to yourself that your gut is a terrible, terrible
- 46:15thing to follow because #2 is the falsehood.
- 46:19All right, yeah, I just don't think Disney would mess around
- 46:23with like, let's burn Caribbean islands and see what happens
- 46:28without a permit. Just seems like the worst
- 46:31lawsuit waiting to happen. Be a good time.
- 46:38That's funny. All right, so tell.
- 46:39Me that you haven't heard of Dumber things happening on the
- 46:42set of Hollywood movies. Oh 100% man.
- 46:44Then them not getting a a permit, I mean heck one of my
- 46:48favorite movies of all time, charade didn't file their
- 46:52patents properly. And so the moment the movie came
- 46:56out and hit public domain like, and that wasn't in like 1920,
- 47:00that was 1965. I was just reading a a fact,
- 47:05man, I wish I could remember the movie, but it was like a movie.
- 47:09It was Lawrence of Arabia. And I think it was like, maybe
- 47:12it was the costumer, you know, remember how beautiful those
- 47:15robes on Lawrence were? And it was like the costumer
- 47:19wasn't nominated for an Oscar on Lawrence of Arabia because
- 47:22somebody forgot to file the paperwork on time and so they
- 47:25missed the deadline. And it's like that movie won
- 47:28every other Oscar, was nominated for, and the costumer just
- 47:32didn't get nominated. Dude that you?
- 47:35Can you imagine how mad you would be?
- 47:37Oh my gosh. Come again?
- 47:39I spent all that time and effort and I'm not going to get
- 47:41recognized by my peers because you didn't file paperwork.
- 47:45Crazy, dude. All right, let's get back into
- 47:47talking about Pirates of the Caribbean.
- 47:49Brad, very famously, this movie is based on a roller coaster.
- 47:54Now my first question to you, have you been to either Disney
- 47:59World or Disneyland and have you ridden the Pirates of the
- 48:01Caribbean ride? As I said earlier, Bob, no and
- 48:06no, I don't. Remember you saying that?
- 48:07I'm sorry, I must have been scrolling and looking at the
- 48:09Orlando Bloom. Reality show.
- 48:12It was a answer to a different question that you asked.
- 48:15Oh, OK. But my answer to most of your
- 48:17questions whenever you ask two in a row to me are no and no.
- 48:22You've never been to Disney? Not a single time in my life,
- 48:25no, no, when, when I was growing up, my dad worked in the
- 48:30construction, in the trades and in Cleveland, you pretty much
- 48:35get laid off from like December to like late February, early
- 48:40March. And so our vacation, you know,
- 48:43everybody else would come back in the fall from summer break
- 48:47being like, yeah, we went to like Hilton Head or Disney.
- 48:50And I would come back from Christmas break and be like, I
- 48:53went to Iowa to visit family and it was like 20° colder and like
- 49:0120 more inches of snow. So that was my vacation.
- 49:06OK, so the answer is no, you've not been to Disney The.
- 49:09Answer is no, but the story. That's both, man.
- 49:13The the real pirates were the friends we made along the way.
- 49:16I think that's what you're saying here, am I right?
- 49:19All right, so I've never ridden Pirates of the Caribbean.
- 49:21That might be one that's only at Disneyland, if I if I remember
- 49:25correctly, anyway, it's very famous.
- 49:27You go on the thing. The pirates are animatronics,
- 49:29but they're also spooky. I don't know how much story they
- 49:32give you when you're riding the ride.
- 49:34Like, is there a narrator? Are they telling you about this
- 49:36curse? Who's to say?
- 49:38But apparently Disney in the early 2000s thought this is a
- 49:41great idea for adapting into a fully fledged movie.
- 49:46And I remember thinking, this is the dumbest idea for a movie
- 49:49I've ever like. Even as a early teenager, I was
- 49:52like, this seems desperate. Like, what are we doing here,
- 49:55folks? And then the trailer came out
- 49:57and I was like, huh, maybe that's not going to be so bad.
- 50:00And then I remember opening up the the movie.
- 50:03I used to look at the movie reviews like every week in the
- 50:05newspaper, and it got 3 1/2 out of four.
- 50:08And I was like, oh, this might end up being a good movie.
- 50:13And you know, fun fact it was, it was a good movie, but I just
- 50:18can't believe like we talk now about how soulless and hollow
- 50:23the adapting all the IP stuff is.
- 50:26Disney's been doing this for a long time, folks.
- 50:29And like, I just, it's so funny to me that we now forget that
- 50:32they just based a whole movie off of like what if roller
- 50:35coaster was movie? I mean, it is that man.
- 50:41I I am loathe to say it, but I might defend Disney a little bit
- 50:45here. Like, is that the worst thing to
- 50:48do when coming up with a movie? No, I don't think so.
- 50:51I do think, though, that like, it's a really, it's a balancing
- 50:56act. And it's one that that Gore
- 50:57Verbinski really nailed and all the writers on this movie too.
- 51:00Because you want to replicate, I guess what I'd say is like the
- 51:04feeling of being on a roller coaster.
- 51:06You want this to be like a rollicking adventure, but it's
- 51:10not really related to like you are on a roller coaster.
- 51:14There's not like a lot of POV shot like this could be filmed
- 51:17like a first person shooter, you know what I mean?
- 51:19And I'm really glad they didn't do that because they took the
- 51:22experience of like, why do we go on a roller coaster?
- 51:25Why do we want to go on a roller coaster that's kind of spooky?
- 51:27And they're like, let's expand that into a movie going
- 51:30experience rather than just like we have to actually replicate
- 51:35what it's like being on a ride because I, I feel like there's a
- 51:38version of this movie that is that and that would have sucked.
- 51:42Well, and and that's the beautiful thing about what we
- 51:44got here is that I don't know if I have seen many action
- 51:51adventure movies that have perfect pacing the way that this
- 51:56film does. Like walking away from this
- 51:59viewing of the movie. I kept, as the movie went on, I
- 52:04kept waiting for the slow part where it dragged right, 'cause
- 52:08every action adventure movie has the slow part in the middle
- 52:11where it drags a little bit and you have to put up with a little
- 52:14bit of exposition or like explaining why the bad guys are
- 52:19doing what they do. And even when those things kind
- 52:24of come around in this movie, they are so well done and
- 52:29they're so action oriented and they they thrust you through the
- 52:33movie at such a fast, breakneck pace that it feels like you are
- 52:39on a roller coaster without any of the gimmicky things a lot of
- 52:44directors would do if they were told make this like a roller
- 52:48coaster. Yeah, they replicate it through
- 52:50good movie making, not through gimmicks.
- 52:53Yep. Yeah, man, it's so nice to be in
- 52:57agreement with you, Brad, but I wonder what kind of what kind
- 53:00of. The heartburn Is that because of
- 53:02the heartburn that you get when we disagree?
- 53:05I do wonder, like, what kind of audio are we producing today?
- 53:07Because we're both just like, Yup, Yup.
- 53:09And then there's five seconds of silence and then we're like, oh,
- 53:12I guess we have to move on to the next thing now.
- 53:14We're not arguing. It's like Skip Bayless and
- 53:17Stephen A Smith, just like agreeing for a whole episode.
- 53:20Yeah, that would be incredible. Worst first take episode of all
- 53:24time. All right, man, So what?
- 53:27What else have we not hit yet about this movie that you want
- 53:29to make sure we discuss, because I'm pretty much tapped out.
- 53:33It's a really good movie. It's fun.
- 53:35I'm not sure if it's the classic that it's been re evaluated as,
- 53:39but I'm also not going to I'm not going to say many words
- 53:42against it here. So Brad, you know, I think
- 53:45you're a little bit higher on this movie than me.
- 53:47What am I missing here still? The soundtrack, Bob.
- 53:52My guy, Hans. Dude.
- 53:55Well First off, technically credited.
- 53:58I don't think Hans is credited as the composer for this movie.
- 54:03'Cause he steals everything, man.
- 54:05Well I've I've heard that said to be true.
- 54:09What I do know is that the entire like Pirates theme is
- 54:16based off of like 1 little bar from Gladiator.
- 54:21You know what I'm talking about, yeah.
- 54:24'Cause he mentioned it in the Gladiator episode.
- 54:26Yes, he and he took that and he gave it to his minions and they
- 54:30turned it into the entire pirates soundtrack and it
- 54:35freaking rocks. I like any good action movie
- 54:41adventure movie needs great music and like I'm I'm even
- 54:45thinking about like the theme to spider man from 2002.
- 54:49Yep, like that theme freaking rocks and it makes that movie
- 54:54incredible. And I think the same thing is
- 54:56true here. Yeah, this this has this really
- 55:00charming, I don't want to call it cheesiness to it because it's
- 55:04like, it's like this big bright, percussive, almost like
- 55:08overbearing soundtrack. And I think that if this movie
- 55:11was being made today, the soundtrack would sound very
- 55:14different. A it would have no recognizable
- 55:16themes because that's just how movies get made now.
- 55:18But like, it'd be much darker. It would be much kind of more
- 55:22ambient and in the background. And this movie's like, no, every
- 55:26time you see British soldiers punching skeletons in the face,
- 55:30we're going to throw in like, it's just, it's so big and brash
- 55:38that you you have to respect the 2003 Ness of it and like it.
- 55:44I miss movies like that. I miss when movies were like fun
- 55:48swashbuckling adventures that did not take themselves too
- 55:51seriously and didn't feel like they had to double down on being
- 55:55grounded or gritty or realistic. This is a movie about a roller
- 55:59coaster where pirates turn into skeletons.
- 56:02Like, what are we? Like just have fun.
- 56:04And, and I think the soundtrack embodies that.
- 56:06It's not taking itself too seriously.
- 56:08It is a really cool theme, but like it's a little cheesy and I
- 56:13love that about it. Yeah, it, it's cheesy in all the
- 56:16right ways. And I think that the same, like
- 56:20that can be said for the whole movie.
- 56:25Like when I think about Geoffrey Rush's performance, it's cheesy,
- 56:29but like in all of the right ways, hitting all of the right
- 56:32notes. I I think the same thing for
- 56:35Orlando Bloom and Keira Knightley.
- 56:37Like they're all over the top in just the right ways that keep
- 56:42you at the edge of your seats and engaged.
- 56:45This is one of the true summer blockbusters.
- 56:50And I, I know that you might not put this movie in the, the
- 56:53classic category, but I, I think you should because it, it falls
- 56:59in that perfect. Like this is just a summer
- 57:03blockbuster that you could go see like 3 months in a row once
- 57:08a month and be more than happy that you went to see it three
- 57:11times. No, I'm with you, man.
- 57:14And I think that that's kind of what I was trying to get at at
- 57:16the beginning of the episode, talking about how this is a
- 57:19cross section of a lot of different groups of moviegoers.
- 57:24Like it. It appeals to your weird Disney
- 57:26adults who are just big on all Disney IP.
- 57:29It appeals to like movie critics who just like to say stuff rules
- 57:33sometimes. It like this is, for all intents
- 57:36and purposes, it's like a modern classic.
- 57:38I don't really know many people who talk down on this movie.
- 57:41It's just a fun movie. I mean, there there's even some
- 57:45horror elements to the start of the film that like had that
- 57:48aren't like incredibly well done, but they're they're like
- 57:52just effective enough that I like I'm in.
- 57:54It's scary. Well, Brad, I think that that's
- 57:57actually a really good jumping off point to get to our last
- 57:59segment of the day, which we call let's make it a double.
- 58:03We're near the end of the episodes.
- 58:05Oh, thanks for listening to the film and Whiskey Show.
- 58:07Let's pair another film with this one, even if it's
- 58:10struggling. It's a final segment of the day.
- 58:12Now let's make it a double. Let's Make It a Double is the
- 58:15part of the show where we pick a movie to pair up with this one
- 58:18to make the perfect double feature.
- 58:20Brad, would you like to go first today?
- 58:22Oh, I think I will, Bob. I am going to stick in the same
- 58:27realm of film, action, adventure and I am going to go with a a
- 58:34little known movie. Not many people saw it that
- 58:37definitely not as good as Pirates of the Caribbean, but I
- 58:40think you'd have a fun night with a double feature. 1998's
- 58:44The Mask of Zora. I love it dude, what a fun
- 58:50movie. Yeah, like, like both movies,
- 58:53just really fun, really earnest movies that I think anybody
- 58:56could enjoy. I'm kind of similar to you.
- 58:59I'm I'm waffling between 2:00 and I I'll give the one that's
- 59:03like the more film guy first. There's a movie that came out
- 59:08the same year that I think was nominated for best picture
- 59:10called Master and Commander. It's a Russell Crowe movie about
- 59:13him sailing on a ship as part of the British naval fleet.
- 59:17It freaking slaps. It's so good.
- 59:20And I haven't seen Master and Commander I think probably since
- 59:23the same time I saw Pirates of the Caribbean.
- 59:25I'd love to revisit it. Did not get a chance to before
- 59:28recording today, but I think based on the tone of the movie I
- 59:32actually just watched, I'm going to pair this up with 1999's The
- 59:37Mummy, a movie that is equal parts rip roaring good time and
- 59:43goofy masterpiece like. And that's kind of the tone that
- 59:47this is going for. It's it's goofy.
- 59:49It's just a fun little movie that's PG13.
- 59:53So when you see it when you're 11, you feel like you're
- 59:55watching a movie for grown-ups and then you watch it as a 30
- 59:58year old and you're like, oh, this is a movie for 11 year
- 1:00:00olds, but it's still good. Like that's that's The Mummy and
- 1:00:04that's this movie. And I would have such a blast
- 1:00:07watching both of those movies together.
- 1:00:09Yeah 100% man I have never seen the mummy but everything I've
- 1:00:14heard about it would confirm what you are saying.
- 1:00:16It's so good, man. I might prefer The Mummy to this
- 1:00:19just a little bit, but they're like, if you've seen this movie,
- 1:00:24you have an idea of what it's like to watch The Mummy.
- 1:00:26Just a just a fun time dude. Yeah, no, I'm, I'm in man.
- 1:00:30I would 100% watch that. All right, let's get to final
- 1:00:34scores here. I think I'm going to be just
- 1:00:36slightly lower than you. I was really looking forward to
- 1:00:39revisiting this because I've seen so many people talk about,
- 1:00:43hey, I went back and watched Pirates of the Caribbean and
- 1:00:45that movie holds up like crazy. And I went back and watched it
- 1:00:48and I loved it. Like I had such a fun time
- 1:00:50watching it. But I did have a little bit of
- 1:00:53that. This is a movie for 11 year olds
- 1:00:56that was marketed to like grown-ups.
- 1:01:00And that tension between it, it doesn't quite want to embrace
- 1:01:03being a violent film for adults, but it also doesn't quite want
- 1:01:07to embrace being a bloodless film for kids.
- 1:01:10It didn't always work together. It felt like those two things
- 1:01:13were at odds, you know, a few times in the movie for me, and I
- 1:01:16think that's what brought it down just a little bit in my
- 1:01:19estimation. But overall, man, what, what can
- 1:01:22you say negatively about this movie?
- 1:01:24It's an 8 out of 10 for me, Brad.
- 1:01:26I yeah, I'm at a 9 1/2 out of 10.
- 1:01:30Wow 9.5. And I, I think a large reason
- 1:01:34for that is how entertaining this was.
- 1:01:38Like if we scored this out in categories like cinematography
- 1:01:43and sound and entertainment value and things like that, it
- 1:01:47would get a 10 out of 10 on entertainment for me.
- 1:01:49I like, like I said man, I kept waiting for it to get boring and
- 1:01:55it never did. It kept me absolutely glued to
- 1:01:59the screen. I was exhausted and was planning
- 1:02:02on watching it over two nights and couldn't stop watching and
- 1:02:06watched it all in one night. Like that's how much I enjoyed
- 1:02:09this movie. I I think this is a modern
- 1:02:12classic and I I think that Pirates of the Caribbean
- 1:02:15deserves all of the the laudatory reviews that has
- 1:02:19gotten. All right, so there it is.
- 1:02:22I gave it an 8, Brad gave it a 9.5, which puts us out at an
- 1:02:278.75 out of 10. But we'd like to know what you
- 1:02:31think is, first of all, we're in agreement here, Brad.
- 1:02:35This is the best of the Pirates movies, right?
- 1:02:37Oh, far and away. I think the second one has
- 1:02:39cooler effects, but this is the best movie.
- 1:02:42Folks, you can disagree with me if you want, but let us know
- 1:02:44what you think of The Curse of the Black Pearl.
- 1:02:47You can find us on all of our social media accounts, Facebook,
- 1:02:50Twitter, Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube at Film Whiskey.
- 1:02:56Yeah, or you can follow us on Discord.
- 1:02:57We are on there every single day talking to you guys, fans of the
- 1:03:01Film and Whiskey podcast. So if you'd like to join the
- 1:03:03conversation, you can find a link to the Discord at the end
- 1:03:06of every single one of our show notes.
- 1:03:09I don't know that there will ever be a harder pivot, A
- 1:03:11weirder left turn thematically. Then this week to next week in
- 1:03:17our podcast, Brad, because next week we, I don't even want to
- 1:03:22say it, man, it feels weird. Next week we're watching Mel
- 1:03:25Gibson's 2004 film The Passion of the Christ, and boy oh boy,
- 1:03:31is that is that different than than Undead pirates?
- 1:03:35It's basically the same movie, yeah.
- 1:03:37I mean come on, you know, fun fact, there is not a roller
- 1:03:40coaster dedicated to this event at Disney.
- 1:03:44Yet could you, could you imagine that roller coaster?
- 1:03:48The same people who built the Ark down in Kentucky are going
- 1:03:52to build that roller coaster. The resurrection roller coaster.
- 1:03:55All right, folks, join us next week for the Passion of the
- 1:03:57Christ. Until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 1:04:00I'm Brad G. And we'll see you next time.