Latest / MetroNews Talkline / Talkline for Wednesday, August 16, 2023
Transcript
- 0:20Good morning, Welcome to talk Line on the Metro News Radio Network. Decision
- 0:26You're surrounded. We in the ligital Una million Mini emergency book on radio.
- 0:33Turn On. From the studios of w VRC Media and the Metro News Radio
- 0:38Network, the Voice of West Virginia comes the most powerful radio show in West
- 0:44Virginia. This this here is Metro News Talk Live with the Hobby kirch of
- 0:50Activated Switch Network Chill from Charles Dared Bye you, Hoppy. You're on Metro
- 0:58News. Talk Line with Hoppy kirch Of is brought to you by in COVID
- 1:00Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visiting
- 1:06coovid dot com to learn more. Good Morning, Ethan Collins is our producer
- 1:11Jack Carlson with a video's stream helped by Luke Rousing. This is talk Line
- 1:15on Metro News from me and COVID Insurance Studios Phone number one hundred and seven
- 1:19six five eight two five five, Text me three oh four, talk three
- 1:23oh four. So on this sum major shift at WVU the elimination the proposed
- 1:27elimination of thirty two programs out of more than three hundred that would affect one
- 1:33hundred forty seven undergraduates, two hundred eighty seven graduate students, one hundred sixty
- 1:37nine faculty reductions. And this is obviously a very very significant story, and
- 1:44it has reached a national level. The Chronicle of Higher Education is the publication
- 1:49covering higher education in this country. Dan Bowman has done an extensive piece on
- 1:56the WVU situation. He joins us on Metro News talk line, Dan,
- 1:59good morning, How are you good? Good? Thanks for having me,
- 2:01Thanks for coming on. What makes this a national story in higher ed?
- 2:07It's emblematic. I think of this pre COVID belief and expansion, that expansion
- 2:14would save institutions, And obviously after COVID, many institutions are facing the reality
- 2:20that plans to grow just simply aren't going to happen, and that a lot
- 2:25of institutions are now making a lot of tough choices about which programs the cut,
- 2:30which units to keep available on campus, and h you know, it's
- 2:37all happening in bits as you've written about, you know, the a very
- 2:40shallow labor labor pool and a very different economy than the one we had pre
- 2:46COVID. Dan, So is this a story that from what you say,
- 2:51is not just about w VU, It's about what's happening nationally. In WVU
- 2:54is emblematic of what's occurring nationally. Is it fair? Yeah? Absolutely,
- 3:00I think Uh, certainly wv user all as a flagship makes so much more
- 3:05prominent. But obviously we've seen this current not just at h places like Nebraska,
- 3:10but also at small private colleges in Pennsylvania. Everyone's u dealing with the
- 3:16same choices and h realities that WBU is. Dan Bowman is with this reporter
- 3:23for the Chronicle of Higher Education and a very conferensive peace on what is happening
- 3:25at w VU. Dan, did WVU and these other schools did they just
- 3:30miss it? Did they Did they miss the democratic demographic cliff? Did they
- 3:35miss the type job market? No one could have foreseen the pandemics certainly,
- 3:38But did did they miss other signs? I'm certainly. I think there was
- 3:45a sense that we're different, uh, and that you know, the way
- 3:51you know, into some fairness to them. You know, it's it's much
- 3:54easier to say we're going to grow our way out of a problem as a
- 4:00too facing the reality that, uh, you know, you need to cut,
- 4:03you need to cut drastically, uh, to potentially right size your institution
- 4:08for for new realities. Right. Uh. And so I certainly known about
- 4:14the demographic cliffs for a decade, right, you know, we had birth
- 4:18rates coming out of the recession. We knew this was this was coming.
- 4:21Uh. The reality is I think a lot of institutions were like, well,
- 4:27maybe we're different. This will happen to others, but not to us.
- 4:30And obviously, you know, that sort of wishual thinking, uh became
- 4:36harder and harder, harder and harder reality to justify as time went on.
- 4:43I certainly became almost uh you know, full hardly after the after the COVID
- 4:48nineteen pandemic. John Bowman is with this reporter for the Chronicle of Higher Education,
- 4:54and I think I'm sorry, Dan, I'm I apologize, Dan.
- 4:58And I think one of the points, one of the many points you raise,
- 5:00which is very interesting, is that higher ED has seen itself as different
- 5:05and it has been different, Dan, But look through COVID, the private
- 5:11sector, other institutions went through the wayoffs and higher ED has has often seen
- 5:15itself as insulated from that. This is evidence that it's not fair, certainly
- 5:20going back decades, you know, you don't see the same sort of layoff
- 5:28levels that you see in the broader economy and in specific sectors like manufacturing,
- 5:33what have you. I think to the extent that higher ed is has some
- 5:40reason to be to be skeptical that we simply haven't gone to this sort of
- 5:44societal period now of like there's an older generation. You know, we've historically
- 5:48since the World War two, been a population that is growing, and now
- 5:53we are a much older population, the population that is uh and the population
- 5:58that is reconsidering the role of of higher education. You know, it's also
- 6:04been a a labor a labor market that has demanded more, more education,
- 6:11more skilled and now is not necessarily one that you know, you need to
- 6:16have a bachelor's degree in order to get a simple secretary's job. You know.
- 6:21Now now you're can into the workforce and potentially, you know, the
- 6:25trade off is, oh, you know, these these entry level jobs are
- 6:28actually I make a lot more money, or about the same money as if
- 6:32I had got him a bachelor's Don Bowman Is with his reporter for the Chronicle
- 6:35of Higher Education, has done an extensive piece on what's having a WVU.
- 6:39I think there's a follow up piece too in the Chronicle on this situation.
- 6:44Don keep calling you Don Dan, I'm I apologize, Dan Is. Let's
- 6:48talk about the as you reported, the conditions that are maybe unique to West
- 6:55Virginia, maybe they're not. And that is a stagnation of the state funding
- 7:00of the flagship university, a greater debt load taken on over the last few
- 7:05years at w BU. Can you speak to those issues, Dan, Yeah,
- 7:10absolutely, Uh, as you say, you know, sort of coming
- 7:14out of the recession, the West Virginia was well aware of that it stayed
- 7:17legislature might not always be so willing to fund the institutional levels that it wished,
- 7:26and so created this plan to uh, you know, target enrollments,
- 7:30you know, to sort of grow its way out of out of whatever budget
- 7:33issues might arise in the coming decade. Those plans, you know, since
- 7:40I'm extended, you know, achieved, achieved satisfactory levels, but certainly not
- 7:44to the levels that that w D a good wish you know who they stayed
- 7:48around thirty thousand would never achieve the sort of thirty two forty thousand counts that
- 7:56administrators that had promise to the public, as you say, you know,
- 8:01and sort of to build itself to be this institution that would be able to
- 8:05accommodate UH, this growing pairs of students. H it nearly tripled its to
- 8:13to achieve those ends. And with that game UH a tripling, a tripling,
- 8:20you know, in terms of the debt services needed to UH annually needed
- 8:26to be paid annually to UH achieve those ends. And you reported this.
- 8:33You're reporting is very straight, So I'm not sure how far you want to
- 8:35go on this. But as you might expect, and you've probably read,
- 8:37there's a lot of pushback from W faculty and staff of saying that W leadership
- 8:43did not was not on the ball here, that it not only missed some
- 8:50of the demographic UH data but just overbuilt, just made mistakes. What can
- 8:58you say if you're comfortable saying about the criticisms of how the W leadership tried
- 9:03to manage this going forward, and if you don't want to alf an opinion,
- 9:05because again I think you're a pretty straight reporter, that's fine, but
- 9:07maybe just make some observations if you're comfortable with that. Yeah, yeah,
- 9:11absolutely, yeah. No. I In talking to Factuy, I think certainly
- 9:16there's a sense that you know the fact the administration has a lack of credibility
- 9:20on this issue right too. And then sort of whip lash of the moment
- 9:26of talking about you know, uh reaching historic growth you know, uh two
- 9:33or three years ago and now talking about we're going to be an institution half
- 9:37that size. Uh. There there's a sense like, you know, we're
- 9:41the same groups that was telling us uh, you know, uh tall tales
- 9:45before, why should we believe these tall tales now? And the the sort
- 9:50of uh, you know, Gordon gears and upfront about this if he prefers
- 9:54a sort of rapid response, he doesn't want this to be a multi year
- 9:58sava. He wants to to sort of, you know, whatever cuts need
- 10:01to be made to be made all at once and uh and so yeah,
- 10:05I think I think those two things, you know, uh lead to a
- 10:11sense of sort of whiplash among faculties who who asks, you know, could
- 10:15things have been different? And also you know, asking who is the right
- 10:18team that they certainly understand that there there are budget cuts, but uh it
- 10:24rings somewhat hollow coming from the same people who were who were forecasting such extraordinary
- 10:28growth you know, uh still in twenty nineteen. Then also, as you
- 10:35know, and you've reported that World Languages is being eliminated. This proposal to
- 10:41be eliminated, I mean, the whole whole shebang to be eliminated. And
- 10:43as I did a little research on this, that is it is, if
- 10:48you're going to cut, it is not terribly surprising that is number one on
- 10:50the chopping block. Other schools are doing the same. Fair Yeah, it's
- 10:56you know, schools are are making a decision about like what majors are possible
- 11:00or are popular, I should say, uh, and so you know,
- 11:03just the legal language of majors, and then those themselves are not as popular
- 11:07as it's say, you know, as a business major or a or a
- 11:13video game major. You know, that's sort of the hot news thing.
- 11:15And so uh in that way, may it may still be part of the
- 11:18curriculum, but it's far more cheaper for the institution to uh find find ways
- 11:24to reduce costs by hiring adject faculty, by by embracing you know, as
- 11:30wbau is talked about different technologies and extracting greater you know, profits from that
- 11:35as opposed to fully staffing a major with tenure professors, and uh, you
- 11:43know, the sort of all the all the infrastructure that comes along with with
- 11:48offering a full major. Hey, Dan, finally is as again national publication.
- 11:52Everybody can higher ed reads this, especially at the administration level. I
- 11:56would think that at college and universities across the country, they should not read
- 12:01your story and then go whistling past the graveyard. No. No, And
- 12:05I think the sort of uh, as you say, whistling past the grave
- 12:09yard has has sort of come to an end. You know, every but
- 12:13every you know, flagships, US, a large privates, everyone is sort
- 12:18of coming, you know, after after the COVID release funding. I think
- 12:22every institution is coming, uh, you know, uh really really realizing how
- 12:30how different this time is going to be going forward, right, you know
- 12:35that's they won't you won't be able to rely on state funding. You won't
- 12:39be able to raise tuition rates given how competitive the market is, and so
- 12:43it's just yeah, I think I think, as you say, every institution
- 12:46is is is realizing that what is happening at WZU may may be coming.
- 12:54Uh maybe they maybe may may having to make the same decisions you know here
- 13:00in months years. What have you Dan Bowman, reporter for the Chronicle of
- 13:03hier Education. Really good, detailed reporting about the situation of w VU Dan,
- 13:07great job, appreciate you coming on today. Thank you, Yeah,
- 13:11thanks for having me. All right, thank you. Talk line continues.
- 13:13We'll be right back. Are you tired of joint pain or muscle injuries holding
- 13:16you back? Trust the experts at CMC Orthopedics and CMC Orthopedic Trauma for personalized
- 13:24treatment options tailored to your needs. CMC offers comprehensive orthopedic treatment for all types
- 13:28of pain and injuries. Our specialists provide tailored options from diagnosis to rehab with
- 13:35state of the art facilities for top quality care. Visit CMC dot org slash
- 13:39Orthopedics to learn more. Metro News talk Line with Hobby Kirchibill is brought to
- 13:56you by in Coca Insurance and circling you with coverage to attecht What do you
- 14:00care about most? Visit incovid dot com to learn talk line from me and
- 14:03COVI Insurance Studios. Let's go to Jared hopperd Fox News Radio in Washington,
- 14:07d C. Good morning, sir, How are you? I am well?
- 14:09How are you? I'm well? Thank you. So the President is
- 14:13out and he's pitching the Inflation Reduction Act Today is the one year anniversary the
- 14:18Sonic Inflation Reduction Act. Is that a tough cell or easy cell? Or
- 14:22does that depend on where he goes? Well, it depends on where he
- 14:24goes. And today's not really a cell as much as a celebration of the
- 14:28Joe Mansion Inflation Reduction Act, the j M I r A. You know,
- 14:33I was remember was I in the was I in the room when that
- 14:39bill was saying he gave the pen the Mansion like right away? Yeah,
- 14:43yeahs that made that the TV hads there in Uh it will if it hasn't
- 14:50yet, but you know, to digress, Uh, I guess if it
- 14:56is in a drawer somewhere. But look, Mansion is I ask you about
- 15:00that banal way, and I mean Mansion is kind of alone in West Virginia
- 15:07of trying to ensure that voters know the benefits that are in that for West
- 15:13Virginians, whether healthcare issues or money for economic development projects, that kind of
- 15:18thing, because it's so heavy criticized. Not only that, but he also
- 15:20I mean that that included the virgin Yeah, the pipeline, Yes, pipeline
- 15:26was remember he got that in the Inflation Reduction Act. Over nearly that nearly
- 15:31torpedoed in the House. Yes, a lot of progressives were really angry at
- 15:35that, and Spuker Pelosi kind of had to, you know, bring that
- 15:41across the finish line. It also h spent a lot less money than President
- 15:46Biden had wanted it to becus of Joe manship, if you recall, that
- 15:50was his sticking point, he said, but he wasn't going to go over
- 15:52a trill. It kind of moved, the number kind of moved. But
- 15:54at the end of the day, you know, the final product was not
- 15:58what was proposed the initial proposal that President Biden, but would have included universal
- 16:03pre K education, a lot of money for community college. I think there
- 16:10was even more money in there on some of the climate initiatives. And one
- 16:14thing that Mansion was able to do was ensure that a lot of that climate
- 16:18money and energy money, uh you know went the projects in West Virginia.
- 16:22Yeah, and that's why I think and listen, I do think he's going
- 16:26to be talking about that. Oh yeah, absolutely was on the show,
- 16:30you know, a week or so ago talking about that. Here here is
- 16:33a fundamental problem in my opinion, Jared, I'll get your take on this
- 16:36with with the Inflation Reduction Act. That is the name, and you go
- 16:38out and talk about the Inflation Reduction Act, and even even the President has
- 16:42said that maybe it should have been called that because that, yes, the
- 16:47annual inflation rates down from nine percent to three point two or three point four
- 16:49or something like that. But you know what, if you go to gas
- 16:52prices are volatile, food prices are volatile. You go buy a gas go
- 16:56on it's three sixty year gallon in West Virginia where you go to the grocery
- 16:59store and look at my grocery bill, So it doesn't feel like inflation is
- 17:03down right, That's what I think is going on. But you know,
- 17:07I think, listen, I think that that's fair because you know, people
- 17:11are still the the way that sort of I think consumers and Americans are and
- 17:19listen, this is human nature. I mean, the economy is not good
- 17:23until you sort of see it, and that's always the lagging indicator. And
- 17:26prices are still higher than they were before the pandemic. Right, they're probably
- 17:30going to be higher than they were before the pandemic. And so that's the
- 17:36the hard cell. You know, the President talks a lot about these macro
- 17:38economic trends that are moving in the right direction. Unemployment historically low, inflation
- 17:47moving downwards, business investments are up right. All of these things are very
- 17:52good indicators of a growing, improving economy. But if you're still strug going
- 18:00to buy groceries or put food in your car, take the family out for
- 18:06a weekend, what's it matter exactly what the trends are. Yeah, yeah,
- 18:11you can talk about macro trends, but is the average Is the average
- 18:14person reading the business section of the Wall Street Journal, We're clipping coupons for
- 18:18the Kroger and you know that's that's That's what I think the challenge is,
- 18:22real quick before I let you go. So Nevada is now moving up in
- 18:26terms of its primary early voting. What are they doing? Yeah, so
- 18:30Nevada. So this is helpful because I think we now know the first four
- 18:36states. So Nevada's presidential caucuses. We're doing a caucus on the Republican tacking
- 18:40in the state legislature pass the bill saying that they were going to do a
- 18:42primary on February eight, So that jumps ahead of South Carolina for the first
- 18:48time since nineteen eighty eight. It also now tells us where everything's going to
- 18:52be. The Iowa caucuses are set. We believe that the New Hampshire primary
- 19:00will be January twenty third because they kind of a state law dictating it.
- 19:04And then you're gonna have Nevada on February eight, and then South Carolina not
- 19:11until the twenty third. And so what had been a kind of sprint in
- 19:22the first four states historically, right, like you had four contests in like
- 19:26three weeks. Now it's kind of over six weeks. That's a new challenge
- 19:30for candidates, right. You have to keep viability up for a much more
- 19:36sustained period of time, and that six weeks is going to feel like an
- 19:41eternity if you fell short in one or two of those early primaries. Yeah,
- 19:45exactly. Jared Hopper and Foxing's Radio in Washington. Where are you today?
- 19:48I'm at the White House for the Inflation Reduction Act. Oh okay,
- 19:52very good. He's doing an event today here. Former Spircal Pelosi, a
- 19:57bunch of Democrats are going to be here. I don't think Joe mash is
- 20:00not going to be there. Is He's not showing up. He don't.
- 20:03I don't believe he is. I don't think he's gonna be there. We're
- 20:06also going to hear from the steam of director, and we saw that in
- 20:07this morning. The White House annunced that Biden in the first later traveling to
- 20:11Maui on Monday. I got it. Yeah, okay, hey, Jared,
- 20:15appreciate it. Thank you. We'll follow your reporting. Jared Alfred,
- 20:17Fox News Radio at the White House tech toppy with all the cuts in programs,
- 20:21faculty and staff positions, the student numbers dropping, What cuts are being
- 20:25taken in the administrative level? My I was, I'm efforting that trying to
- 20:30get some numbers. My understanding is there have been cuts and consolidations at the
- 20:33top administrative level. I don't have all those figures, but I am trying
- 20:38to track those down, but I believe there have been some reductions. It's
- 20:41just talk line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia talk line from
- 20:57me and COVID Insurance Studios in the Miller Building. Kino Go offers a new
- 21:02game every three minutes, seven days a week. You choose how many numbers
- 21:04you want to play. The more numbers you play and match, the more
- 21:07you could win. Up to one hundred thousand dollars and the ten spots add
- 21:14bonus for a chance to win up to ten times your prizes. Playing as
- 21:18easy as one, two three, keino go. So you just heard the
- 21:23comment from daily president West Virginia Education Association about his expectation as many as seventeen
- 21:30hundred there'll be as many as seventeen hundred vacancies of certified teachers in the classrooms
- 21:36as the school year gets underway. What about the all important staff positions?
- 21:40Joe White's executive director of the West Virginia School Service Personnel Association, Joe,
- 21:45good morning, Good to talk to again. How are you, sir,
- 21:47I'm fun hopping. Good morning to you, Thank you, sir. What
- 21:49are you hearing about? Bus drivers, maintenance folks, cooks, etc.
- 21:53What are you hearing? Well, it's the same story that we had last
- 21:57year, hopping. They were running short, gist about everywhere. Bus drivers,
- 22:04especially mechanics, cooks, a lot of aids shortages were running short everywhere.
- 22:12I can give you some prime examples. Sure, go ahead, go
- 22:15ahead. Kanaal County alone already fifteen drivers short, no substitute. One garage
- 22:22has one substitute. About all you can get for substitutes anymore's or tiree's.
- 22:29People used to line up to get these jobs. Now they're not. We
- 22:33got one school in particular, of course, Jefferson Counties hit hard, short
- 22:38on staff, short on drivers. One school in particular should have their four
- 22:44custodians short in the building, four custodians. Jefferson County and other counties as
- 22:49well. Last year we had aids and ects teaching classes for two to three
- 22:56weeks at a time because there was no teacher in a classroom, no additional
- 23:00pay for these folks. In most situations, we're just one cook cooking.
- 23:06They couldn't take a break, couldn't take lunch break because nobody was there,
- 23:10didn't have any help, And for days and days and days, she was
- 23:12only cooked, doing the work of two and a half folks. So how
- 23:17do they how do they get by the mean? Like, let's talk about
- 23:19bus drivers, because that's a chronic condition. So do buses. Some busses
- 23:23just don't run. Some busses don't run. Some of them they double up.
- 23:29We have a lot of issues where they go and say we need your
- 23:32help, drivers, we need your help, and I will be honest with
- 23:33you, I'll be service personnel is the first one is to step up and
- 23:37say, yes, I will help, but let's not take advantage of them.
- 23:40And I'm saying that in a nice way. But a lot of them
- 23:44they don't compensate them, you know, they just ask them to help and
- 23:47step up. So some areas they absolutely do not run. In some areas
- 23:52they double up runs. They you know, put some of them eighty kids
- 23:56on the bus, make multiple trip to get them there, and they try
- 24:02their best to get them to school one time. And it's it's a job.
- 24:07It really is a job. Joe whitswith is. He is executive director
- 24:11of the West Virginia School Service Personnel Association. So is it is it just
- 24:15a pay issue or is it availability of a workforce? Or is it the
- 24:19fact that instead of driving a bus somebody can drive for a private company and
- 24:23make twice as much or what is it? It's all three And I'll be
- 24:27example. One of the number one things we've heard, and I even post
- 24:30the question this morning, one of the number one things we hear here in
- 24:34this office is the lack of respect, you know from administration and folks,
- 24:40they just so many humping. I'm sure you've heard this before. So many
- 24:44people are retiring. They're just saying, listen, I'm out of this.
- 24:47I've had enough. We have to do this, this, this, this
- 24:49and this. But they don't respect us. They don't pay enough. Pay
- 24:52us a big thing. And I've said this before and I'll say it again,
- 24:56and I'll keep saying it till somebody listens. Until our leaders ship decides
- 25:00to take education employees seriously and pay them for what they deserve, we're going
- 25:07to have a shortage. And it's also a lot of them, you know,
- 25:11will say, well, we're having a problem with discipline. We can't
- 25:14really do anything about the discipline. They can get a job. Bus operators
- 25:19can get trained, get a job driving a rock truck, water truck.
- 25:22Mechanics can go to their local car lots and get jobs and paid double what
- 25:27they're getting paid to be a mechanic. If you can find a mechanics is
- 25:32almost extinct in our bus garagers. They're making them drive buses on me instead
- 25:37of doing mechanic work. It's just an issue. And I don't mean to
- 25:41be the person to cry wolf, but we have to start. They have
- 25:45to start listening to what's going on. Would make a difference. Would I
- 25:48know that service personnel don't make a lot? What would make a difference.
- 25:52Give me a number, Tell me what a cook makes, Tell me what
- 25:55a bus driver makes, and tell me what would make a difference. Well,
- 25:59cook's cooks fall on the the lowest paid in the system. Cooks of
- 26:03the lowest paid in the system, so they start out low right now.
- 26:07The average salaries about twenty eight nine or twenty eight six, something like that.
- 26:11But you've got to remember when they say that average salary, that means
- 26:15half of the employees make less than that. So that's not it's a fair
- 26:19statement, but it's not really a fair statement. We had a bill that
- 26:22we worked on with the legislature and the chairman about a five thousand dollars pay
- 26:27increase that would get it comparative to the surrounding states. The service personnel.
- 26:33Would that help? It would? I believe that would also bring folks that's
- 26:36decided to leave and go somewhere else. It's a combination, but I think
- 26:41if the pay would help. And I'm going to drop this year and forgive
- 26:45me for doing it, but we have to stop using our legislative offices and
- 26:52political offices as a stepping stool for campaigning. If we're going to get elected
- 26:57to a position, let's literally take seriously and do the jobs that we need
- 27:03to do and listen to the folks. All they got to do is listen
- 27:07and they can get to it. They can come up with a plan that
- 27:08would help. So, Joe, so is you said it's system watch.
- 27:12So is nearly every county because I know you check them around and talk to
- 27:15these folks. Is nearly every county facing some or multiple shortages in staff,
- 27:19whether it's maintenance or cooks or bus drivers. Yes, most of them are.
- 27:25If they're not running short, they're just right on the number. In
- 27:27other words, they don't have anybody to replace them. Like I said,
- 27:30most of them. They might if they have thirty drivers, they've got thirty
- 27:34positions, but they have nobody to step in. Cooks the same way they
- 27:38have no subs to step in on somebody's seek or gets hurt. But most
- 27:42of them are running shortage? Is that all you gotta do is driving down
- 27:45a major road and you're we'll see a bus parked on the side of the
- 27:48road. We're hiring, you know, and yeah the spot, Yeah,
- 27:52I've seen those, Joe White, executive Director, West Virginia School Service Personal
- 27:56Association. Joe, thanks for the update. I hope conditions improve. Can't
- 28:00have school without staff, can't have school without the bus drivers, can't have
- 28:04school without the cooks. So I hope the thing gets better, all right,
- 28:07John, Thank you, Take care of talk Line continues right back Metro
- 28:23News talk Line with Hobby Kirchiblas brought to you by in COVID Insurance, encircling
- 28:29you with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visit incovid dot com
- 28:33to learn more. Talk Line from the and COVID Insurance studios in the Miller
- 28:36Building Networks. Security is serious business, and city net is serious about protecting
- 28:41your business and your employees from today's constant barrage of cybersecurity threats. Let's city
- 28:48Neet be your cybersecurity hero. Learn more city net dot net. So we've
- 28:52talked a lot about and there's been a lot of reporting about the proposed cuts
- 28:56at WVU, the thirty two reprograms, the one hundred and sixty nine faculty
- 29:03members. There is an appeal process. There's a process that schools and faculty
- 29:07members and directors of particular programs can go through. I'm not going to go
- 29:11through all of that, but I want to find out how this is generally
- 29:17going to work. WVU Associate Provost Louse Slimak joins us on menting his talk
- 29:21line, Lou, good morning, how are you sir? Thanks for joining
- 29:23us, Good morning Hobby, thanks for having thanks for coming on. So
- 29:27what And I'm not gonna go because I know there's steps, has to be
- 29:30a filing and then review that kind of thing. But take me right to
- 29:33the point where faculty or deans or administrators particular departments can make their pitch.
- 29:41When is that and how is that going to work? Sure? At the
- 29:45appeal hearings, those will start August twenty feet and run through September fifth,
- 29:51they will have an hour long to make their case. Typically that's a chair
- 29:56like you said, or a division director, but that can be someone else
- 30:00if need be. If they have an hour to make their case, restate
- 30:03what they've said in the self study, present a new way to offer the
- 30:07program or programs under review. Present a different way to reduce costs in the
- 30:11department that they haven't yet talked about to a group of seven folks that are
- 30:17constituted by our board of Governor's rules, a committee of peers, and a
- 30:21different essentially a different adjudicating body. So, not to be flippant, but
- 30:26to paraphrase the line from Dumb and Dumber, So you're saying there's a chance,
- 30:30I mean, so there is an opportunity for some of these programs or
- 30:36positions to be to be kept fair. Of course, yes, that's the
- 30:41entire point about the appeal process and really the entire self study process. These
- 30:45decisions were taken with utmost seriousness by every level of administration, senior administration,
- 30:52provost office, Dean's office, and obviously the chairs and faculty affected. We
- 30:56know that this will impact people, both faculty and students, and no matter
- 31:00what the recommendations are, we have to make sure that those decisions are carefully
- 31:06considered and then all options have been considered and all the implications of those decisions
- 31:10have been considered. So the appeal process is absolutely going to have give faculty
- 31:15one last chance to present something different or new that we haven't yet considered and
- 31:19alter the decision that is thus far been recommended. W B Associate Provost A
- 31:22Louis Slimak on the appeal process. I'm going to guess that it would not
- 31:29work for an administrator or a dean or department head whoever's making an argument,
- 31:33to come there and restate why nothing should happen. I don't think that would
- 31:41fly. Agree. No, We've been very clear from the beginning Hoby,
- 31:45in the self studies and now the appeal process that we are after a reduction
- 31:49in cost of these units, and that is primarily through a reduction in personnel.
- 31:53So saying nothing should be done is not likely an effective strategy. I
- 31:59do think there are certain programs in these units that are appropriately staffed, and
- 32:04making the argument that some movements on faculty in this particular program and a range
- 32:08of programs within the range of programs then offers is acceptable. But saying this
- 32:13unit can accept any change is not likely to be a successful strategy. Then
- 32:17what then, who that pitch is made to? What body? And who
- 32:22are these folks? And then what do they do? Sure? The appeal
- 32:24committee itself has a few standing members and then a few different members depending on
- 32:30each appeal. Vice pro Vice Provost Paul Krider chairs every committee. I am
- 32:36on every committee as the program review Officer for the institution, and then either
- 32:40Evan Whitters the associate provosts from Undergraduate ED or Richard Thomas the associate provosts from
- 32:45Graduate ED. We will also have then have four additional members the Faculty Senate
- 32:52Chair elect or act officio chair, so last year's chair will be on every
- 32:57committee, one or the other a representative from the dean office of the program
- 33:00being impacted the unit under review at the appeal and then two other deems offices
- 33:06will have representatives at that appeal hearing, and those are selected for our units
- 33:09that offer similar programs or have been forced to have similar kinds of decisions made
- 33:15at their college. And then they'll take this pitch and the previous information and
- 33:20decide what will be their criteria and how quickly will this group that you'll be
- 33:25part of a make a decision. We take into account, to your point,
- 33:30all the previous information, the data, the self study deliberations, the
- 33:35appeal hearing itself, any additional information that faculty wants to give us. We
- 33:39have thirty minutes to deliberate after the appeal hearing. If we feel that we
- 33:44need more time or additional information that we can't make it a vote on at
- 33:47that point in time that day, we will then take two additional business days
- 33:52to track that down. So the latest and appeal hearing will be wrapped up
- 33:57fully would be two business days after it ends. Is where we feel we
- 34:00have all the information we need that day we can then vote after the full
- 34:04deliberations over lou With all due respect, how what can you say or how
- 34:10can you reassure those who will come before this committee to make arguments, in
- 34:15some cases people trying to save their jobs or save programs or save departments,
- 34:21that this will be a fair that they will get a fair hearing, that
- 34:23it won't be a dog and pony show. Again, I say that with
- 34:27all due respect, but you understand I'm sure that some of these folks will
- 34:30be will be concerned that they're not going to get a fair hearing. But
- 34:36address that please. Of course I do understand that, hobby. I can't
- 34:43you can't ever fully assure anyone ever anything. Our intent is to have a
- 34:47process that is fair and transparent and has been established in university rules, and
- 34:52to follow that to the letter. I'm working with all the chairs, still
- 34:57individually and in groups, all the way through their app hearings, on what
- 35:00I think are effective strategies based on what I have seen in previous appeal hearings,
- 35:05based on what I'm hearing in conversations in the pro post office on the
- 35:07deliberations I've had the Dean's offices, and the fact that their presimina recommendations are
- 35:13what they are. I'm trying to give them the best information to present the
- 35:17best appeal they possibly can. They've got a fair selection of peer of peers
- 35:23on that hearing, including someone from their college, including a faculty member.
- 35:29You know, those are all the things the institution can do to guarantee what
- 35:32looks, you know, what is a fair process. If someone wants to
- 35:36say that's still you know, not fair, that it is a dog and
- 35:40pony show, I don't have anything additional, say that's just paranoia. I
- 35:44don't know what else we could do. But whoever is presenting, whatever department
- 35:51or they're going to have to I want to be clear by this, in
- 35:53your opinion, they're going to have to come with savings. Correct, Yes,
- 35:58Yes, I mean we've been clear. Is this is all We always
- 36:01have a process of program review hobby. It's what I've overseen since I've been
- 36:05at WVU, So this process is nothing new itself. However, it is
- 36:10in parallel now with the university needs to address its structural budget deficit, so
- 36:15we have to reach some kind of goal through this and other processes. These
- 36:22programs specifically have been identified because we believe they have to have some kind of
- 36:27cost reduction in the way they operate, which again is mainly through personnel reduction.
- 36:32I don't think it is possible for any of these units to come and
- 36:37say no reduction is possible. I do think there are creative ways, different
- 36:43ways than what we've recommended to deliver their programs, and that's what we're hoping
- 36:46the faculty will bring to us. W B Associate Provost Louise Slimack. Lou
- 36:51thank you for coming on. I appreciate it. Good to talk to you
- 36:52today. Thank you, Thank you, Hobby. All right, talk line
- 36:55continues. We'll be right back. Talk line from me and Cove Insurance Studios
- 37:15Text three or four Talk three or four. Hoppy schools need the ability to
- 37:17privatize transportation services like some other states have done. Let me ask you this,
- 37:27who thinks that's a good business Who thinks that's a good business model to
- 37:30have thousands of buses or hundreds of buses that are expensive, try to find
- 37:37drivers to run routes up the hills and hollows of West Virginia to pick up
- 37:44students. I think that I don't think you could find a business that would
- 37:49be interested in doing that, thinking that they could make money on that.
- 37:52That would be I mean, here's a parallel. Why why is it going
- 37:58to take billions of dollars of subsidies to extend broadband to rural parts of West
- 38:05Virginia Because it's expensive to do it and there aren't enough people up to hollow
- 38:12there are enough customers. And it's the same way with schools. I mean,
- 38:15you know what it's like out there. I mean you can imagine trying
- 38:19to have a private business that says, oh, yeah, we're gonna run
- 38:22buses, are gonna run up this road, ru that road, up that
- 38:24road, up that road, and we're gonna pick up three students, gonna
- 38:28pick up two students, going to pick up five students, And just there's
- 38:31something. There are some things. If you believe that it is the state's
- 38:37responsibility to get children to and from school, which I do. If you
- 38:45think it's the state's responsibility to do that, there are some things that only
- 38:49the state can do, because you'll not find anybody in the private sector who's
- 38:52interested in doing it because it's a it's a it's a money loser. I'll
- 38:59be how many hours does a bus driver work? Let's see. I know
- 39:02that some have jobs outside of driving, Yes they do, but obviously it's
- 39:09not terribly attractive. I mean, I know that bus drivers sometimes have other
- 39:14jobs. Bus you gotta get up early, you got a driver out,
- 39:15and then you got a few hours in the middle of the day. Then
- 39:17you got to start back again. So it's that split shift. That split
- 39:22shift makes it tough, right, split shift makes it tough, hoppy.
- 39:28I helped coach a sport as a volunteer at a high school for eight years.
- 39:30It was hell. I was used and abused. I used all my
- 39:35vacation volunteering. I would never do it again. The school and the coaches
- 39:38metaphorically threw me under the bus every chance they could get well. I don't
- 39:43know about your specific circumstance, but the point is, whether it's certified teachers
- 39:46in the classroom, whether it's school bus drivers, whether it is cooks,
- 39:51whether it's maintenance people. There are shortages that continue to worsen every year.
- 39:57We're got to take a break and come back on Metro News talk Line.
- 39:59When we come back, Chris Stirewalt, he's been absent for a while.
- 40:02He'll join us here at eleven o six. It's coming up just in a
- 40:06few minutes. This is talk Line on Metro News. Metro News is the
- 40:09voice of West Virginia. Welcome back our number two of talk Line on the
- 40:34Metro News radio network all across the great state of West Virginia. Text me
- 40:38three or four, talk three or four full number one hundred seven six five
- 40:42eight two five five, Please welcome to the broadcast. Haven't talked to him
- 40:45a while. Chris Stirewalt, Politics, editor of News Nation, contributing editor
- 40:49for The Dispatch, author of Broken News, While the media rage Machine Divides
- 40:52America and how to fight back. He joins his via Skype from his palatial
- 40:57basement department in Washington, DC. Good morning, sir, how are you.
- 41:00It's good to be home. It's good to be with you. Yeah,
- 41:01you've been all over the place. You've been traveling because people want to
- 41:05hear what you have to say. Well, I'm gonna tell them whether they
- 41:07want to or not. Hey, I want to get to something that you
- 41:13wrote in the in the Dispatch. But first, and you mentioned this too,
- 41:16and your and your writings. But last week Joe Mansion was in the
- 41:22news for about twenty four hours because he said on a popular statewide broadcast that
- 41:30to the Dean of West Virginia that he was seriously considering becoming an independent.
- 41:37You know, Joe Mansion, Well, because of your days in West Virginia,
- 41:40what was your take on all that? Well, I don't know whether
- 41:44that would change the Senate race in West Virginia. Who would them? Who
- 41:50would the Democrats nominate? Well, I'll give you my take is that there's
- 41:54a small but but uh energized portion of the Democratic part of that progressive they'd
- 42:04be so honked off they would put up somebody. And that's somebody, even
- 42:07if it's just a body, would get the would get some of those votes.
- 42:12Okay, So let's say, what's their best case scenario. They nominate
- 42:15who's the most prominent Democrat in the state right now? Probably somebody in my
- 42:22neighborhood. I'll have to come up with somebody. Let me think about that.
- 42:28Whether it's Amy a good one, Mike Pushkin, uh Sean Hornbuckle,
- 42:36I'm leaving people out. But you know, people, let's say let's say
- 42:39it's Mayor Goodman, okay, and you nominate her, Democrats nominate her.
- 42:45What does she get twenty percent of the vote, twenty two percent of the
- 42:50vote, and what does Jim Justice get Jim Justice get? You talk about
- 42:55of all the votes of the of the general electorate, what percentage of the
- 43:00vote is he going to get? Is and mansions in you're just as well,
- 43:05I'm saying, you're asking me to say whether Justice wins or not?
- 43:09Is he not? Do you think he's not going? Well, what are
- 43:13we talking about? And take stop stop uh stop uh depose it, stop
- 43:22deposing me, and just answer the question. Well, I need the info,
- 43:25Okay. I guess it looks to me as as somebody who follows West
- 43:30Virginia politics, but not obviously with the depth and intimacy that you do.
- 43:35Uh. It looks like that the Mooney threat is not materialized in in the
- 43:40way that I and many people thought it would, and that Justice seems to
- 43:45be rolling right uh to the to the Republican nomination, and he's despite the
- 43:52resistance from uh the Club for Growth, he has both basically magas support support
- 44:00and institutional support from Team Mitch McConnell. So that's how it looks. And
- 44:07he's popular. So if he does go on to the Republican nomination, what's
- 44:10his floor? Right, forty five percent? I don't, you know,
- 44:15I don't. I don't know what his floor is like. Uh. And
- 44:17the floor for a even the most successful Democratic candidate is or even the least
- 44:23successful Democratic candidate is fifteen twenty percent of the vote. Okay, I don't.
- 44:28I don't see Mansion's path that way, right, if that, if
- 44:31that's what happens, I don't because there's plenty of teachers union members and liberal
- 44:39progressives in the Eastern Panhandle and Charleston who would not vote for Joe Mansion if
- 44:45he leaves the Democratic Party. And as much as he would like to imitate
- 44:47Kristen Cinema, who also who might get beat, She might get beat,
- 44:53but she she there's a there's a there's a story I can tell you about
- 44:57how Kristen Cinema gets re elected in in Arizona as a independent, and that
- 45:04is that the Arizona Democratic Party or an Arizona Republican Party is goofy and that
- 45:10the Democratic Party's pretty goofy too, and that there is she can as a
- 45:15as a cold trucks as a West Virginia could truck driver does she can take
- 45:17her half out of the middle in West Virginia. Whatever you think of whatever
- 45:22anybody thinks of Jim Justice, he's popular and the party seems pretty unified and
- 45:30the Democratic Party is very weak, is it? You know, Joe Manchon
- 45:35has benefited in West Virginia by being a one man party right much like Archmore
- 45:38did when the Republicans were you know, there was no Republican Party, there
- 45:43was just Archmore. Well, there is no Democratic Party in West Virginia to
- 45:45speak of as a political force. There's just Joe Manchion. But if he
- 45:49leaves that party, he goes from uh starting with forty percent of the vote
- 45:54to starting with twenty percent of the vote, and it's a lot harder to
- 45:59get home. I think this move has more to say about Joe Manchin's chances
- 46:04to be the No Labels pick for president in twenty twenty four than a Senate
- 46:10run. Because if you if you want to be in position to get the
- 46:14blessing of this movement, then you being an independent would would speak to that
- 46:21right, But I thought that No Labels was going to do We're gonna have
- 46:23one Democrat and one Republican. Well, No Labels don't doesn't know what it's
- 46:28gonna do right, And the situation, to say the least, has been
- 46:31fluid, and I think Joe Manchin is in a competition with whether it's Larry
- 46:39Hogan from Maryland, maybe Cinema, maybe former Ambassador to China and Utah Governor
- 46:46John Huntsman. I think there's a bunch of people who have had the same
- 46:50idea that Joe Manchin has, which is, let's do this right. Maybe
- 46:53maybe lightning will strike the general electorate will be so disgusted by the major party
- 46:59offers that something might happen here and for Mansion and for this No Labels group,
- 47:07deciding what kind of nominee they want a Field, I think is a
- 47:10very open question at this point. Chris Drywall is with us. Your latest
- 47:14post in the Dispatch says the following. As we slog on into a third
- 47:17consecutive presidential campaign dominated by claims and counterclaims of criminal conduct, let's consider the
- 47:22much embroidered story of Treasury Agent Elliott Ness and his squad of untouchables. That's
- 47:30the one about how they found a way to bring down a murderous villain,
- 47:34not for murdering villainy, but for tax evasion. Talking about al Capone,
- 47:37So please tell me how you made the al Capone eliot Ness analogy work.
- 47:45In this case, we're metaphor. I always I never can remember which is
- 47:49which. So the story of American public life, certainly in the past thirty
- 47:57years, is a story about growing corruption, right more and more and more.
- 48:05Certainly, we have had periods of extreme corruption. One hundred years ago,
- 48:08when Calvin Coolidge took over as president from More and when Warren Harding died,
- 48:14the corruption was a extraordinary problem in terms of the public's confidence in the
- 48:19government and all of those things. What has happened in the past thirty or
- 48:23forty years is that. And there's a lot of we could explain a lot
- 48:28of reasons we could We could we could expound on those that relate to the
- 48:31media, that relate to our terrible, stupid primary election system, that relate
- 48:37to a lot of things. But Democrats who believe that criminal prosecution is sufficient
- 48:47to end the scourge of Donald Trump's corruption are mistaken. Republicans who believe that
- 48:55criminal prosecution is sufficient to bring down the House of Biden and the obvious corruption
- 49:02of Hunter Biden and change that are mistaken because what has happened, and in
- 49:09that piece I trace a lot of roots back to it. Bill Clinton,
- 49:14no one. I call him the Vasco da Gama of corruption because he If
- 49:21you think about the generation between Watergate and Bill Clinton, when Republicans went to
- 49:28tell Bill to tell Richard Nixon that he had to resign, they were bringing
- 49:32with them, not the authority of prosecution. They were bringing with them the
- 49:37authority of the public has rebelled. Right, We're not with you anymore,
- 49:42and but the voters are not with you anymore. You have been found to
- 49:45be lying, You have been found to have betrayed the public trust, and
- 49:49the country's opposed to you, and we are their messengers, and you have
- 49:52to go. Twenty five years later, what did Democrats do, Robert Byrd,
- 49:58most effulgently, what did they do? Well, sure, it's bad
- 50:04to diddle the twenty one year old intern and lie about it, and marshal
- 50:09all of the powers of the Office of the Presidency and all of your cronies
- 50:14to try to avoid accountability for these things are bad. But we gotta let
- 50:19that slide. See, we gotta let that slide because these Republicans who are
- 50:22going after him, they're actually worse. It's actually worse that they are being
- 50:27so mean to Bill Clinton and so cruelly prosecuting him. And Bill Clinton got
- 50:30away with it because the electorate said, hey, you know what, who
- 50:34cares? Who cares? He did? You know whatever? Sometimes you know,
- 50:37into every life a little, a few interns must fall, and what
- 50:42are you going to do? And sure he lied about it, but people
- 50:45lie about sex all the time. Who cares? And when Democrats, when
- 50:47Bill Clinton demonstrated that the electorate was on his side in the nineteen ninety eight
- 50:52mid terms, the message was very clear. Vice, corruption, abusive off
- 51:00was not sufficient, right if you knew how to spin it, if you
- 51:02knew how to manage it. So he tested the limit and found that it
- 51:07wasn't there. What we have observed since then rampant dishonesty, rampant corruption,
- 51:15and again because of our primary system. Just think about it this way.
- 51:21I've heard so much talk from Republicans about these prosecutions of Donald Trump. Well,
- 51:23actually the reco Act is done. No, no, no, no,
- 51:25no, well and actually you need the men's ray for January six and
- 51:30actually blah blah blah blah blah. But he did it right. There's no
- 51:35there's no substantial disagreement on the facts of the case. Donald Trump selfishly,
- 51:40egregiously mishandled classified documents at risk to national security. Donald Trump tried to steal
- 51:47a second term. He used the power of the presidency to try to steal
- 51:51a second term. These things are holly rotten, right, This is bad
- 51:55business. Democrats know that what Hunter Biden did is corruption, and his father
- 52:04abetted it. Now why his father abetted it? Why his father, who
- 52:07as sitting vice president, should have told his son, you will never put
- 52:13me on the phone with any of these people. I will never meet them
- 52:15at a golf tournament. I will never say hi to them. Your business
- 52:19is illicit, it's wrong. You're pretending to sell access to control United States
- 52:25policy. I will not be part of it. I don't care your personal
- 52:30struggles. I don't care about those things. I feel bad about it,
- 52:31but this ends. Now, that's corruption and that Democrats can't look at that
- 52:37and say what Hunter Biden did was corrupt and what Joe Biden did was wrong.
- 52:43This points to the thing which is okay and I mentioned in the column
- 52:47about Hillary Clinton, she did. What she did with classified documents was equally
- 52:53as profoundly selfish as Donald Trump. She was more interested in her personal secrecy
- 52:59than she was in state secrets. And do you know what Democrats said,
- 53:01where's a smoking gun? Basically, unless you can put her in prison,
- 53:07then it doesn't count. It doesn't matter. And I'm here to tell you
- 53:10that the law is an insufficient custodian of virtue. The law is there as
- 53:16a final last trigger at the end. It's the last hope. It's the
- 53:22final guard rail against political corruption. But if the people countenance corruption, if
- 53:27they tolerate corruption, if the Republican Party renominates Donald Trump, if Democrats turn
- 53:32a blind eye to Hunter Biden, then where what hope does virtue have?
- 53:37Even if those people face criminal consequences for their actions. Is it naive to
- 53:42think that we still value virtue to that level? I don't know, And
- 53:47we're getting ready to find out a country that will not defend itself. You
- 53:54know, the analog between what Democrats did for Bill Clinton and what Republicans did
- 54:04for Donald Trump and his second impeachment is very obvious, right. They knew
- 54:08the truth. And by the way, when the Republicans did it, the
- 54:12stakes were much much higher. And if you would just think of it this
- 54:15way, if you had had a secret ballot for senators after January sixth,
- 54:22Donald Trump would have been convicted and barred from seeking public office ever again.
- 54:27But those same Republican senators who in private knew the truth, said something different
- 54:32publicly because they were afraid of primary voters. They were afraid to do the
- 54:37thing. And what they were doing was supposed to be stand up for the
- 54:42United States Senate. You're supposed to stand up for the division of powers.
- 54:45You're supposed to stand up for Congress against the tyrantically the tyrannical impulses of a
- 54:50crazed executive who's looking to steal a second term. And they couldn't muster the
- 54:55courage to do it because the public had become not an enforcer of virtue,
- 55:01but it had become mandatory vice. I guess the thought of returning to virtue
- 55:08would be, to paraphrase one of Hemingway's novels, wouldn't be pretty to think,
- 55:13so, I mean that. I don't know. People get tired,
- 55:17people get people could do they do and look, and there's a lot there's
- 55:22a lot of polling that shows that people are they don't want Biden, they
- 55:24don't want Trump. But if the system, if the system sort of wants
- 55:32Trump and Biden, then what are people what are real people supposed to do
- 55:37about that? I mean, that's and that kind of gets back to the
- 55:38old Joe Manson thing of is there a great middle? Is there another way?
- 55:44So that the system is to blame, certainly as it relates to the
- 55:49primary electorate, right where you have fifteen percent of the country gets to choose
- 55:52the candidates that then compete to get fifty one percent of the vote. That's
- 55:57that. So the system is that. But Donald Trump is popular with Republicans,
- 56:01right, and Democrats don't care about Hunter Biden. Those things are true.
- 56:07What I use Eliot nest because and by the way, The Untouchables with
- 56:12Kevin Costner and Sean Connery is one of the great movies ever made. I
- 56:15love it. I made my son's watch it recently. Fabulous. But I
- 56:21can tell you that al Capone was not unpopular in Chicago and the residents of
- 56:27Chicago were not in support of prohibition, and they were partaking of al Capone's
- 56:32wears. And that after al Capone was taken down on tax evasion, Wow,
- 56:37can you believe it? They got this murderous thug for tax evasion.
- 56:39Well what happened after he left? Frank Nitty kept running the Chicago Outfit,
- 56:45and thirty years later, when Sam Giancanna and Mayor Daily were rigging elections in
- 56:51Chicago, that was still the Chicago Outfit. You need a virtuous people to
- 56:57demand virtuous leadership, and the tour interconnected. And I'm not saying that what
- 57:02the top does doesn't affect the bottom, but I am saying that the real
- 57:07mover on civic virtue is the demand of a public that they will not tolerate.
- 57:12And if the Republican Party, I'm here to tell you, if the
- 57:15Republican Party cannot find it within itself to say Donald Trump. And by the
- 57:20way, we had a town hall on News Nation with Vivek Ramaswamy and he
- 57:24articulated he is articulating a sort of a gateway drug for Republicans away from Trump,
- 57:31which is to say, I, like many did many good things.
- 57:35Thank goodness for Donald Trump Comma. However, we probably should not do that
- 57:39again. We probably should not do that again. So I don't know what
- 57:43Republicans are going to do, but I can tell you that if these two
- 57:46parties continue to countenance corruption in this fashion, it will be the end of
- 57:51us. Chris Starwalt, politics editor for News Nation, contributing editor for The
- 57:54Dispatch, author of Broken News, one of the media rageing Machine divides America.
- 57:58How to fight back? Good to see if friend, heck yeah,
- 58:00talk to you? Metro News talk Line with Hobby Kirchibile is brought to you
- 58:16by in Coca Insurance and circling you with coverage to protect what do you care
- 58:21about most? Visit Incoca dot com to learn more. Talk line from Me
- 58:24and Coventure and Studios. Are you ready to advance your career? Workforce West
- 58:29Virginia is here to help you take the next step toward more fulfilling employment.
- 58:34With their customized training programs, you can enhance your skills and your knowledge,
- 58:37aligning yourself with high demand industries. But that's not all. Workforce West Virginia
- 58:43connects you with employers who value your expertise. It will help you showcase your
- 58:47talents and secure that dream career advancement opportunity. So if you're ready to start
- 58:52advancing your career, start with Workforce West Virginia. Visit Workforce wv dot org
- 58:59to learn more. Workforce wv dot org to learn more. This outreach campaign
- 59:02is financed by federal funds. Techt Hoppy on this bus drivers shortage. That's
- 59:08what happens when you consolidate all these schools. Kids probably walked or head shorter
- 59:14bus routes. Now they have thirty or forty five minute bus rides. True,
- 59:16but it's a chicken or the egg because if you didn't consolidate schools and
- 59:22you had more, you had more schools, then you'd need more teachers and
- 59:25more custodians and more cooks. So that Hoppy, look up what's happening in
- 59:37South Carolina they have a private school bus company. Happy great commentary today.
- 59:44I lived down the street from where you are and feel the same. The
- 59:47commentary today is different, and I I had It's just something that's been going
- 59:55on with me and where I work for some time now, and I just
- 1:00:01felt compelled to write something about it. And it has to do with the
- 1:00:07drug issue, which is very very evident right next to where I work.
- 1:00:12So it's and I think that some of you can relate to it, so
- 1:00:16if you're interested, it's posted today at WV Metronews dot com WV metro news
- 1:00:22dot com. This is talk line on Metro News. Metro News is the
- 1:00:24voice of West Virginia Wow talk line for me and COVID Insurance Studios. Keno
- 1:00:47Go offers a new game every three minutes, seven eights a week. You
- 1:00:52choose how many numbers you want to play. The more numbers you play in
- 1:00:54match, the more you could win up to one hundred thousand dollars with the
- 1:00:58ten spot add bonus for a chance to win up to ten times your prizes.
- 1:01:02Playing as easy is as easy as one, two three Keno Go.
- 1:01:07So today is the one of your anniversary of the Inflation Reduction Act. And
- 1:01:10I know that many of you listening cringe at that because you don't like it
- 1:01:15and you think it's a waste of money and all there's green energy money,
- 1:01:19and it's a Joe Biden thing and it's the Joe mansion thing. But you
- 1:01:22know, funny thing about it, and that is also West Virginia lotstimes.
- 1:01:25We like free stuff or we like reduce price stuff, especially when it comes
- 1:01:30to healthcare. And in fact, there is a lot in the Inflation Reduction
- 1:01:35Act which saves you some money on your healthcare. Joining us on Metro and
- 1:01:39News talk line is Ellen Allen. She's the new executive director of the West
- 1:01:44Virginians for Affordable Healthcare and one good morning. How are you hi, I'm
- 1:01:47great, happy, good morning to you. Thanks for coming on. One
- 1:01:51of the things, well, let's run through some of the savings on the
- 1:01:54healthcare front that are in the Inflation Reduction Act. I want to start with
- 1:01:58the out of pocket cost for insulin for Medicare recipients. I think that's huge
- 1:02:02in West Virginia, so you go, yes, thank you, absolutely.
- 1:02:07That's a key point into healthcare. Really lies at the heart of the Enplacement
- 1:02:13Reduction Act, and this has been overlooked broadley. So I'm really glad to
- 1:02:15have the opportunity to talk about this. Capping insulin costs at thirty five dollars
- 1:02:21per months is really meaningful. The average West Virginia on Medicare, Hobby and
- 1:02:25Part D, they average out of pocket costs of five hundred and fifty one
- 1:02:31dollars a year, so this will dramatically save money for them. That's just
- 1:02:37one area, but that's just a just a point that that's only for Medicare
- 1:02:39recipients. Correct, Yes, okay, that's for Medicare recipients. Okay,
- 1:02:44I interrupted, Jo, I'm sorry, go ahead, that's okay. I
- 1:02:46think a really key point where West Virginians have an extraordinary impact on healthcare here
- 1:02:53is over three hundred nineteen thousand West Virginians will benefit with Medicare being power to
- 1:03:00negotiate drug prices. I mean, why would we not want to do that?
- 1:03:04I mean that's very significant. Now let me all right, let's let
- 1:03:07me ask you about that, because my understanding is that the way the law
- 1:03:12is written, that it starts out with only negotiating the price on I think
- 1:03:16ten drugs, and it doesn't start to what twenty twenty five or twenty twenty
- 1:03:20six? Help me on that, yes, and then I'm more added along
- 1:03:24the way, So it's it's kind of incremental. Do you have any idea
- 1:03:29what those ten drugs will be and how West Virginians might then see lower prices
- 1:03:34on certain drugs? Any idea or what can West Virginians expect when that finally
- 1:03:37kicks in. I do not know what those drugs are, but there's eighty
- 1:03:42prescription drugs that will have Medicare price negotiations by the year twenty thirties. Okay,
- 1:03:49all right, So what else is in the IRA that would have a
- 1:03:52healthcare benefit in your opinion? Well, out of pocket costs from prescription drugs
- 1:03:59will be capped to thousand dollars per year beginning twenty twenty five. And that's
- 1:04:03very significant to you. I have a mother who's ninety years old and her
- 1:04:08out of pocket prescription drug costs can be very, very significant, So that
- 1:04:14that's key. Another area is lowering health insurance premiums for over twenty one thousand
- 1:04:21West Virginias. Those are the West Virginians who are probably accessing the Affordable Care
- 1:04:27Act? Is that right? Yes? And this will save a family,
- 1:04:30a middle class family, a four over eighteen thousand dollars and yearly premiums.
- 1:04:36I mean that, I mean that's life changing, and that is money that
- 1:04:41will go back into it to our economies. Why do you why do you
- 1:04:45think people do people know this or they do they not know what they do?
- 1:04:49I don't think they do, Hoppy, And that's going to be my
- 1:04:51goal every day to talk to as many people I can, to talk to
- 1:04:55people like yourself, so this information gets out there. I mean, the
- 1:04:59Affordable Care Act, with the increased subsidies, has made healthcare so much more
- 1:05:03affordable for everyone, I would imagine. I want to go back to the
- 1:05:08insulin issue, and we've done some segments here on insulin costs, and it
- 1:05:13can be very difficult for folks when they have because insulin, even though it's
- 1:05:18been around forever and ever, tends to tends to be very expensive. And
- 1:05:21uh so Medicare recipients they probably thought, if they weren't paying that close tension
- 1:05:27to the news, they thought, Wow, all of a sudden, my
- 1:05:28insulin costs aren't as high as they were, right, right, But there's
- 1:05:34there's just so much more and all of this. Yeah, I don't think
- 1:05:40people generally understand how affordable access to healthcare conveyed through the market place now,
- 1:05:45particularly for someone who doesn't have employer based insurance. I mean, you can
- 1:05:50have a pretty significant income and still get subsidies that make healthcare very affordable.
- 1:05:57Okay, anything else you want to add about elements of the of Inflation Reduction
- 1:06:00Act that affects healthcare. Give you free, an open opportunity there. Well,
- 1:06:04I think recognizes this cuts call for rural America and it really decreases the
- 1:06:12disparities between urban and rural America and healthcare calls. It's helping more people of
- 1:06:16color becoming sured and that's a real key point. So that's very important,
- 1:06:21all right, Ellen Ellen, executive director of the West Virginians for Affordable Healthcare.
- 1:06:26The one year anniversary of the Inflation Reduction Act and some of the elements
- 1:06:29of that that benefit West Virginians when it comes to healthcare. Ellen, good
- 1:06:33to speak with you. Thank you very much, Thank you for coming on.
- 1:06:35Thank you, You're welcome, Thanks so much. Sure text three oh
- 1:06:39four talk three oh four, Text toppy. My brother is a bus driver.
- 1:06:44There's training, testing, attending meetings, conducting bus safety checks, cleaning
- 1:06:47the bust, and of course dealing with unruly kids. Not as easy as
- 1:06:50you might imagine. I don't imagine it's not easy. Happy forty thousand dollars,
- 1:06:58teaching eighty thousand dollars looking for a chemical company. Tell me again,
- 1:07:00why why we cut taxes instead of raising salaries for teachers bus drivers at c
- 1:07:08Well, one's is a private sector and one's one's a state job. Hoppy,
- 1:07:14let's change the state constitution. It's not the socialist government's job to educate
- 1:07:18your kids. Homeschooling works, Christian school works. The Liberals can go to
- 1:07:23trans schools as the texture. I disagree the states. I believe the state
- 1:07:29has a response. Look, I support the idea that children not only idea,
- 1:07:34but in practice that people can. Parents can send their kids to charter
- 1:07:40schools, to Catholic schools, to whatever they want to do. I think
- 1:07:43parents should have, and are gaining here and across the country, more power
- 1:07:48over how their children are educated. I think that's fine. However, I
- 1:07:51also think as per the constitution, I think I think it's right. I
- 1:07:55think the state has a responsibility. Not everybody's going to do that, and
- 1:07:59so I think the state still has a responsibility to provide for a thorough and
- 1:08:03efficient system public education to the children. I think that is a reasonable and
- 1:08:09not only reasonable, a necessary investment that the state makes. Happy Gay County,
- 1:08:16Maryland, their school buses are contracted out to local people who own the
- 1:08:19buses. Sometimes individuals have several buses. Also understanding, Maryland has a lot
- 1:08:26more money than West Virginia. Does they do the same thing with snow removal?
- 1:08:30All right, I'll have to check on that. Happy one could make
- 1:08:35the argument that brick and mortars schools are obsolete evolving into online studies in the
- 1:08:41future. If you're talking about college and universities, then certainly that is becoming
- 1:08:48a more viable option for college age individuals or individuals who are contemplating college.
- 1:08:55Public schools not there yet, not even close, certainly learned that during the
- 1:09:00pandemic, Hoppy, the standard to revive a program at w VU is quite
- 1:09:09high. Yeah, I would imagine it is. Let's see text three h
- 1:09:16four talk three oh four. Okay, let's see Hoppy. When you pay
- 1:09:26seven hundred thirty seven thousand dollars for these new electric busses instead of three hundred
- 1:09:29thirty four thousand dollars for a gas powered bus, I think we're using our
- 1:09:32resources foolishly, says the texture. Don't think the issue is the cost of
- 1:09:39buses. That that is, I guess an issue. But the issue is
- 1:09:42the drivers. Hoppy. Of course, school transportation is a money loser.
- 1:09:48Otherwise, how could you explain the almost entire absence of public transportation in the
- 1:09:54state. All right, take a break and be back. Talk like continues.
- 1:10:00Economic development announcement by the Governor today. What was it? Brad mclinney's
- 1:10:03next Metro News talk line with Hobby Kirchiblas, brought to you by in COVID
- 1:10:19Insurance encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visiting coovid
- 1:10:25dot com to learn more, talk line for me and cove Insurance studios.
- 1:10:28Governor Justice with an economic development announcement today. Brad mclinney joins his Vias skype.
- 1:10:32Brad, what was the announcement? Hey, Well, this might have
- 1:10:36been one that you heard about last week because it was delayed. This is
- 1:10:40a new project to produce clean hydrogen from natural gas at a point Pleasant facility,
- 1:10:46depositing greenhouse gas emissions beneath state owned wildlife areas. The company is Houston
- 1:10:53based Fidelist New Energy, and a couple of things. This morning, the
- 1:10:58state Economic Development of the already got together and approved up to sixty two point
- 1:11:02five million dollars in forgivable loans through the state's High Impact Development Project program.
- 1:11:10Governor Justice participated in that and in fact led the meeting. Secondly, the
- 1:11:15Governor and representatives of the company Fideli's New Energy appeared at the State Culture Center
- 1:11:20and declared blast Off said they are ready and they intend to do a responsible
- 1:11:27and expansive project, and the West Virginia has just seen the beginning. Brad
- 1:11:31I certainly don't want to throw cold water on any economic development announcement. However,
- 1:11:38this probably has a lot of hurdles to clear when you think about trying
- 1:11:44to sequest something underground, right for sure. So one issue is the amount
- 1:11:54of state money, the sixty two point five million dollars. The other issue
- 1:11:58is the although the nation has long had aspirations toward carbon capture and sequestration,
- 1:12:06it has been to this point not economically feasible. The third thing is we're
- 1:12:13talking about public lands, we're talking about forests, and there are questions about
- 1:12:18whether the injection of this carbon underneath public lands is going to be responsible and
- 1:12:26feasible. So all of those were questions that were raised mostly by folks from
- 1:12:30the environmental community during the EEDA meeting. During the public comment period, the
- 1:12:35governor himself acknowledged that there have been questions about the feasibility of all this and
- 1:12:42he nodded to these things. He said, the governor did, You'll never
- 1:12:46bat a thousand, indicating all right, well, some projects are not perfect,
- 1:12:51but on this one, Governor Justice said, this is cutting edge,
- 1:12:56an opportunity beyond belief, he said, he said, this is opportunity like
- 1:13:00nobody's business. Brad. There is so much money out there now. The
- 1:13:05state has money for these projects, billions and billions and billions of dollars from
- 1:13:12the Inflation Reduction Act flowing into every state for projects like this. And I
- 1:13:17go back to what something the governor said, You're never going to bat a
- 1:13:20thousand, but you have to wonder. You hope, but you have to
- 1:13:24wonder realistically, how many of these projects that are coming to West Virginia and
- 1:13:29other states will reach fruition. It's a legitimate question, isn't it. It
- 1:13:32absolutely is. You know, people's memories are shorts, and so you declare
- 1:13:36victory today and then in a couple of years you explain what has happened,
- 1:13:43and you know, it's up to us in the public to hold state officials
- 1:13:46accountable for whether the project came to fruition or not. In this case,
- 1:13:50it is a potentially exciting project. As you mentioned it, it's the one
- 1:13:55year anniversary of the Inflation Reduction Act, which has a lot of clean energy
- 1:13:59ass efects to it, and one of those is incentives for carbon sequestration.
- 1:14:03All right, Brad, thank you. Brad MACKLINNY Metro News Statewide correspondent on
- 1:14:06the announcement today by the governor. And again I am all in on these
- 1:14:13economic development projects and these clean energy projects, and West Virginia is benefiting tremendously.
- 1:14:18I've never heard so many announcements. But in fairness, you have to
- 1:14:23be cautious here because I would hope that the State Development Office and the Governor's
- 1:14:29office are doing their due diligence here. But there is so much money available,
- 1:14:33and the state has a good chunk of money, and there's so much
- 1:14:38money from the Inflation Reduction Act, you have to wonder at some point,
- 1:14:41I'm not singling out this announcement today by Fidelis, I'm not singling that out,
- 1:14:45But you have to wonder at some point that when you start pushing all
- 1:14:47this money out, are you going to get others some bad deals out there?
- 1:14:53And you hope there aren't West Virginia, but you gotta figure. The
- 1:14:56math indicates there's going to be some bad deal. There's gonna be some bad
- 1:15:00deals out there, all right, thank you, Brad. Text Toppy to
- 1:15:03Styrewalt just pick random bad takes and then act like it's an intellectual analysis.
- 1:15:09Yep, all corruption goes back to Democrats and Clinton. President Biden abetted Hunter's
- 1:15:14scams. There's no proof President Biden knew anything, says the Texture. In
- 1:15:17fact, every witness with personal knowledge stated President Biden didn't know about the business.
- 1:15:23Also, when did we elect Hunter Biden for any political office? Asked
- 1:15:27the Texture text toppy. If Michelle Obama threw her hat in the ring,
- 1:15:31this election is unfortunately over for the GOP text Toppy. I think ranked choice
- 1:15:39voting is the way to go in our current political climate. Text Toppy,
- 1:15:44please get rid of that lottery commercial. No, they are a paid I
- 1:15:49like all our commercials. I am a supporter of capitalism, and I am
- 1:15:55a supporter of the commercials that we run on our stations. We don't ask
- 1:16:00you for any money. We do not ask you. We do not have
- 1:16:03to We do not say to you you have to pay to be a subscriber.
- 1:16:08We do not say to you we don't have pledge drives. We don't
- 1:16:12say that you have to pay, you have to go to a paywall.
- 1:16:15We are free to you. We are free to you to do as you
- 1:16:18please with us. We are free to you. But in order to be
- 1:16:23free to you, we have to on our own pay our bills and support
- 1:16:28what we do. And that means sell advertising. And I'm all in on
- 1:16:30advertising. And here's some right now talk cline from me and COVID Trance Studios.
- 1:16:44WWU Medicine Dermatology offers conference of services for adults and children. Board certified
- 1:16:48dermatologists treat a variety of skin conditions, from acne to complicated skin cancers.
- 1:16:54Self schedule and evaluation online at my WWU chart dot com, my wuchar dot
- 1:17:00com or call eight five five w VU care eight five five WVU care,
- 1:17:06Text, Hoppy Starwalt hit it right. If we become the virtuous electorate instead
- 1:17:14of being diverted by rage politics, I think we could have a statesman rather
- 1:17:18than self serving politicians, says the texture text three oh four Talk three oh
- 1:17:27four, running through texts, running through texts. Happy. Each side is
- 1:17:36willing to condone illegal, immoral or unethical behavior because of extreme hatred of the
- 1:17:42other. How can this cycle be broken? I don't know. I think
- 1:17:47that Starwalt was onto something. It can be broken, or maybe only can
- 1:17:50be broken if more people, if a majority of people, deside that virtue
- 1:17:56is more important than just power. And right now power and I understand the
- 1:18:01exercise and use of power, but right now each party is primarily concerned about
- 1:18:06power, how to attain it, and how to keep it, and not
- 1:18:10as worried about the consequences. Let's see angry text, angry text, angry
- 1:18:21texts happy. When I was a child, I walked two miles to school,
- 1:18:27uphill both ways and in three feet of snow. You know, when
- 1:18:30I was a youngster in Charlestown, and well, first I went to Summit
- 1:18:39Point Elementary and I rode the bus. I think it was Bus thirty seven.
- 1:18:44It was only a mile. Then in Charlestown, I would often walk
- 1:18:47two blocks and seventy degree weather to get to school. And it was two
- 1:18:51blocks and seventy degree weather both ways. All right, I gotta run keep
- 1:18:57up with the news and sports of the day at our website at w VI
- 1:19:00metronews dot com. Thank you for listening today. We'll regroup tomorrow morning at
- 1:19:04ten o six ten h six usual time tomorrow morning. All right, thank
- 1:19:10you. Luke Rowsy, who is training to replace Jack, see tomorrow.
- 1:19:15This is talk Line on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia.