Latest / Insights Now / The regional bank crisis and its implications for bonds
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to insights.
- 0:03Now,
- 0:04a series of conversations designed to shine a light of clarity on the complex world of investing.
- 0:10A lot of things have happened since our last episode,
- 0:12Silicon Valley Bank collapsed.
- 0:14Credit suisse has taken over by U Bs and several other pressures emerge among regional banks.
- 0:19These last few weeks have taken investors through a lot of twists and turns and raised questions about the risk of us recession and the extent of further fed tightening.
- 0:27We entitled this season of Insights.
- 0:29Now a bond's eye view of investing because we wanted to try to through the lens of bond markets examine what these kinds of events mean for the economic outlook,
- 0:38the fed outlook and portfolio implications.
- 0:41On today's episode,
- 0:42I'm joined by Kelsey Barrow portfolio manager on our global fixed income currencies and commodities group for a broad ranging conversation on these issues and how it shaped both the outlook going forward and the opportunities in fixed income.
- 0:54So Kelsey,
- 0:55welcome to insights now.
- 0:56Hi David,
- 0:56thanks for having me.
- 0:58So as I mentioned,
- 1:00we've seen significant banking turmoil in recent weeks and this has raised some uncertainty regarding the economic outlook and the path for the Federal Reserve.
- 1:07Now,
- 1:07before this banking turmoil,
- 1:09recession risks were already elevated.
- 1:12So how does all of this changed your view and the economic outlook?
- 1:14Right.
- 1:15So as you mentioned,
- 1:16recession risks in our view were already elevated before the collapse of uh Silicon Valley Bank.
- 1:25So maybe to take a step back in terms of what we were thinking before.
- 1:29Um and that will help understand how we're thinking.
- 1:31Now.
- 1:32Um as part of our process,
- 1:34we have uh an investment quarterly where our senior investors meet.
- 1:38Uh and they underwrite our views and outlook on the economy in the market for the upcoming 3 to 6 months.
- 1:44And coincidentally,
- 1:46our last meeting was held on Wednesday,
- 1:49March 8th,
- 1:50which was the day before all of the headlines about outflows in Silicon Valley Bank started to pop up.
- 1:59So heading into that meeting on March 8th,
- 2:01we had just spent the last three months preparing portfolios for recession,
- 2:06which we judged as the base case.
- 2:09And essentially we felt that the cumulative and lagged impacts of monetary policy were really going to start hitting the economy hard.
- 2:17And as we walked into that meeting on March 8th,
- 2:19we were honestly impressed by how resilient the US economy was to the fastest pace of rate hikes since the 19 eighties.
- 2:29We saw that there were some parts of the economy that were clearly being impacted by higher rates,
- 2:34particularly the housing market.
- 2:36So we noticed that residential investment has been contracting for seven straight quarters and home prices have been lower month over month for the last seven months according to the case Schiller index.
- 2:49But but then at the same time,
- 2:50we saw that the unemployment rate was still extremely low,
- 2:54the jobs market was very strong and corporate fundamentals were also very robust.
- 3:00So it essentially felt like we were preparing for a recession.
- 3:03But so were companies in terms of reducing their leverage,
- 3:07turning out their debt and keeping their cash balance balances elevated.
- 3:11So essentially,
- 3:12we walked out of that meeting on March 8th by acknowledging that the tighter policy uh was showing up in the real economy a bit slower than we originally anticipated,
- 3:24but it was prudent to maintain that recession outlook as our base case.
- 3:29So with all that said,
- 3:31when the banking stresses did come along just a day later after that investment quarterly,
- 3:36it didn't cause us to materially change our out outlook.
- 3:40Um in terms of the data we've seen since all of this stress,
- 3:44it's only been two weeks.
- 3:45So it's not really available in the economic data,
- 3:49but we can say that it has significantly increased our uncertainty um around the outlook,
- 3:55it increase the probability of a hard landing and it's pulled the timing of recession forward.
- 4:00That's about the fact that credit conditions are expected to tighten um more materially than we had already seen heading into this.
- 4:10And so that's what we're going to be watching particularly closely.
- 4:14And what we think is most challenging for this outlook is that small banks contribution to lending in the in the post pandemic recovery has been uh very outsized.
- 4:27And so it stands to reason as credit conditions tighten,
- 4:30particularly for small banks,
- 4:32this could have a more material impact on growth and inflation going forward.
- 4:37Of course,
- 4:38the Federal Reserve was thinking about all of this as they met last week.
- 4:41Um And then we heard from them in various ways after their March F MC meeting,
- 4:46how would you assess the response to the banking turmoil?
- 4:49Do you think they've done enough to calm market worries about perhaps a much bigger issue?
- 4:53That's a great question.
- 4:54So the speed at which this problem occurred has required a essentially a very quick response.
- 5:01And we think that the Fed and the FDIC and the regulators have been effective at providing that quick response.
- 5:08Ultimately,
- 5:09it was a reactionary response,
- 5:11but it's one that buys them time to ultimately find a longer term solution.
- 5:17So when we look at what happened over the week of March 15th,
- 5:21we saw over 100 billion in deposits flow out of the small banks.
- 5:27So the non top 25 banks and we know that the Fed um when they were formed in 1913 was meant to be a lender of last resort and a backstop in these types of periods.
- 5:39So this is exactly in their wheelhouse in terms of having the tools,
- 5:44liquidity tools to address this and the announcements they made on March 12th,
- 5:49um which were to backstop uninsured depositors of Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank as well as create uh a new funding facility called the bank Term Funding program.
- 6:02We think were pretty powerful signals and quick signals that have helped stabilize the market.
- 6:09And I would say the structure of the bank term funding program was particularly clever because one of the things that banks have been struggling with is that during the last few years,
- 6:20they've been buying bonds,
- 6:21treasuries and agency mortgages when rates were low rates have now risen and they are,
- 6:28they have mark to market losses on those bonds.
- 6:31And the way that the new funding facility works is it actually allows the banks to lend at par rather than the market value.
- 6:39So we think going forward what the fed has done while it was reactionary has bought them some time to further assess what is going on.
- 6:48And we think looking forward,
- 6:50the focus should be turning less from the liquidity crunch and more to assessing asset quality of the banks and profitability.
- 7:00So our analysts are focused on looking at the cost of funding particularly for smaller banks net interest margins,
- 7:06the performance of their existing loan books.
- 7:09We think that there may be headwinds for banks generally on these top.
- 7:14But all the more reason um to have a deep team of research and portfolio managers that can assess the banks.
- 7:22And also most importantly,
- 7:23what we learned from this crisis is assess where you sit in the capital structure and make sure that you understand or being compensated for those risks.
- 7:32And of course,
- 7:33all of these assessments and calculations depend to some extent on what do you think the Federal Reserve is going to do?
- 7:39And they seem,
- 7:39they seem very determined in their communications to keep rates at a high level all year.
- 7:44But markets seem to have a very different expectation.
- 7:47So do you think that the fed will be forced to cut rates before the end of the year?
- 7:51It is our expectation that the fed will cut rates before the end of the year.
- 7:56But I would agree with,
- 7:59with those who say that it is too soon to cut rates now,
- 8:03particularly because inflation uh as it stands today is too high high.
- 8:08So the hurdle for them to cut rates in the very short term is high.
- 8:12But we do think as the year evolves,
- 8:14uh they will be cutting rates to address a weaker uh economic backdrop and inflation that has come down further.
- 8:23And the way we view it,
- 8:25if the fed stops at four and 7/8 and holds the policy rate at those levels for one or two quarters,
- 8:32we don't view that as abandoning the fight,
- 8:35the fight on inflation.
- 8:37In fact,
- 8:37we view that as maintaining restrictive policy and letting the work of QT and the 475 basis points of rate hikes so far play out and,
- 8:49and do that work for them.
- 8:52So in our view,
- 8:53one of the biggest things that we took away from the press conference in March was an important observation that Chair Powell made about the impact of tightening credit conditions as equivalent to rate hikes.
- 9:06So there's a lot of uncertainty about how many rate hikes and and how much credit conditions are going to tighten on the back of this.
- 9:15Um But we do think that the balance of risk is shifting and the fed is acknowledging that particularly on the inflation side.
- 9:23So there are 19 FO MC participants that submit forecasts 17 back in December saw the risks to core P CE as weighted to the upside that's come down to just 11.
- 9:37So the consensus is moving from risks to the upside to broadly balanced.
- 9:42And we see it in the survey data as well.
- 9:44We really like to look at something called the uh NFIB Small Business survey which asks businesses about what they expect to do in terms of their prices over the next three months.
- 9:55And that survey is at some of the lowest levels since the first quarter of 2021.
- 10:02And it tends to correlate actually fairly well with core P CE um and suggests that inflation will be coming down and,
- 10:09and that will be less of a headwind that's per will prevent the FED from easing policy later in the year.
- 10:16This particular economic situation and the fed's response to it has left us with a pretty sharply downwardly sloping yield curve.
- 10:26And so I guess my question,
- 10:28question is two fold one,
- 10:30what's the this downward sloping yield curve telling us?
- 10:33And what would it take to make it positively sloped again?
- 10:36So I think when talking about the yield curve,
- 10:40uh we have to acknowledge that in the very short term,
- 10:44there has been a ton of rate volatility um and particularly in the front end of the yield curve.
- 10:50So that's been whipping around the yield curve steeper and flatter on any given day given the risk sentiment.
- 10:56And in fact,
- 10:57rate volatility is measured by the move is at some of the highest levels since the pandemic and actually also since the great financial crisis.
- 11:06And so there's a difference uh as a portfolio manager in terms of talking about the day to day moves in the curve and what we think over the medium term.
- 11:16So,
- 11:16you know,
- 11:16talking about the medium term,
- 11:18we do believe that we are shifting from a regime of curve flattening to one of curve steepening.
- 11:24And the way that happens first is you have to move from an inverted curve to a flat curve.
- 11:30So what we're seeing right now is the curve becoming less inverted as the market anticipates rate cuts.
- 11:37Now,
- 11:38you don't tend to see that aggressive steepening and inversion or move back into positively sloping territory until the fed actually starts to cut rates.
- 11:49So there is a bit of uncertainty here in terms of the timing.
- 11:52If you,
- 11:53you look back historically,
- 11:54once the fed stops hiking rates that period of time of waiting before the fed cuts can be anywhere between one month or two years.
- 12:04But in our view,
- 12:06what the FED has done in terms of QT and rate hikes being fairly aggressive in this cycle means that that waiting time between the last hike and the first cut is going to be shorter this time.
- 12:19Another question I've got is that with all this concern about the banking system,
- 12:24it sort of reminds me a little bit of 2018 that a lot of people are asking me,
- 12:28you know,
- 12:28what's the next shoe to drop?
- 12:30What else could go wrong here?
- 12:31So,
- 12:31do you have any other potential areas of concern?
- 12:33That is absolutely the question that we're asking ourselves as well.
- 12:38Um And I would start by saying that we have a deep research and portfolio management team of over 300 professionals around the world.
- 12:46And what we're doing right now is we're stress testing all of the bonds in our portfolio against adverse scenarios and cleansing the ones from the portfolio that don't stand up to those adverse scenarios.
- 12:59So there's a couple things that we have our eye on.
- 13:02One is private credit and two is commercial real estate.
- 13:06So I'll talk quickly about both.
- 13:08On the private credit side,
- 13:11we don't directly invest in private credit.
- 13:13Of course,
- 13:13we're public market debt investors,
- 13:16but there's a few reasons why it matters to us.
- 13:20First,
- 13:20the size of the market alone is something that catches our eye.
- 13:25So the private credit market has gone from one that was just a fraction of the size of the US high yield market to uh essentially the same size.
- 13:34So at the end of 2022 you saw the US high yield market was at 1.4 trillion in value.
- 13:41The private credit market is also at 1.3 trillion in value.
- 13:45And what we've been observing is that deals that public investors weren't willing to sponsor in the private market or in the public market went into the private market and those deals tended to be of weaker credit fundamentals.
- 14:00And we're seeing that borne out in the default data.
- 14:03So if you look at where private credit defaults peaked in COVID,
- 14:08it was around 8% that was about 2% points higher than the US high yield market.
- 14:14And if you look at defaults,
- 14:15now,
- 14:16private credit defaults are around 2% and that's also uh higher than what the default rates is in the public market currently.
- 14:25So our concern here is public investors is if the private credit markets tend to take losses because it's a more a liquid market.
- 14:35The selling pressure as investors look to derisk could come from selling a public high yield rather than that private credit that they can't get rid of.
- 14:45So that's the first thing we're thinking about.
- 14:47The second one is the commercial real estate market.
- 14:51So I first want to say that the commercial real estate market is a very large market and I don't want to lump all of it together.
- 14:58There's a number of different categories.
- 15:00You have multifamily,
- 15:02you have office space,
- 15:03you have industrial,
- 15:05most of the headlines and concern is coming out of the office space,
- 15:09but there are some headwinds more broadly for real estate as you can imagine that have been growing for a while.
- 15:15We know that rates are rising,
- 15:17that cap rates were too low and certainly in the office space,
- 15:21there's a lot of uncertainty about what we're going to be doing in the future about um working from home versus working in the office.
- 15:28Now,
- 15:29what has really changed here and brought a new level of stress and scrutiny to this market has been the stress in the regional banking system.
- 15:38And that's because the regional banking system is an extremely important part of the ecosystem for commercial real estate.
- 15:45So about 70% of the commercial real estate loans um are in the non top 25 banks.
- 15:53And so it stands to reason if these smaller banks are to cut back.
- 15:59There are certain sectors that are going to be more impacted by that cutback in lending and that commercial real estate uh is going to potentially be one of those places.
- 16:08Now,
- 16:09it's not a blanket statement.
- 16:11We do think there's a lot of uh property that is going to continue to do well.
- 16:15But again,
- 16:16it speaks to the need to have a very deep research team that is going to be,
- 16:20be able to look through every single individual property,
- 16:23find out which ones are going to be challenged by this tighter credit conditions and liquidity standpoint and,
- 16:31and those that are going to make it through because um they have the proper characteristics to thrive in this new world.
- 16:37And I suppose those issues that you raised and I think they're the great issues to think about uh along with the just the general macroeconomic uncertainty has led to a backup in spreads in the high yield market.
- 16:50But now that we've seen some backup and spreads,
- 16:52do you think that high yield looks more attractive or do you think we still need to see a little more widening of spreads?
- 16:57Yeah,
- 16:57David,
- 16:57I'll give you the quick answer,
- 16:59which is we think we need to see more widening in spreads.
- 17:03Um How much widening is up for the debate.
- 17:07So we know that the high yield index is of higher quality than it has been in the past.
- 17:13And also there's been a lot of high yield issuers that have already defaulted out either in the pandemic or um in the energy uh issues back in 2015 and 2016.
- 17:25But historically,
- 17:27high yield spreads tend to widen in recession to 600 or 800 basis points over treasuries.
- 17:33And we're still not even close to some of those levels.
- 17:37So we do still feel that there's a bit of complacency here.
- 17:40And ideally what we want in our portfolios is liquidity and to stay high quality so that we have the dry powder when spreads do widen out to take advantage of that.
- 17:51So,
- 17:52ok,
- 17:52given that I I get what you're saying about how is pretty clear,
- 17:55but where are you seeing opportunities within fixed income?
- 17:58So as I mentioned,
- 17:59high quality fixed income is where we're focused.
- 18:03So there's a number of sectors that fit that bill,
- 18:05you have government bonds,
- 18:07of course,
- 18:08fit that bill,
- 18:09investment grade credit also fits that bill.
- 18:12You know,
- 18:12despite the recent banking stress,
- 18:14there's plenty of well positioned industrial and non cyclical companies that are going to perform well and provide a yield advantage to government bonds.
- 18:24You know,
- 18:24another area that we are looking at is agency mortgage backed securities.
- 18:29So the advantage there is that it's fully guaranteed by the US government and it does come at a decent spread to treasuries.
- 18:37The one thing that you need to be aware of though with agency mortgage backed securities is that they,
- 18:43they have something called uh negative convexity or prepayment risk,
- 18:47which makes them not always perform as well in periods of high rate volatility.
- 18:53So,
- 18:53the way that we're approaching agency mortgage backed securities is with a lot of attention towards security selection and where we uh invest in the coupon stack to make sure that,
- 19:04you know,
- 19:04we're protected and,
- 19:05and compensated for some of that negative convexity risk.
- 19:10One other area,
- 19:11I'll give a shout out to,
- 19:12you know,
- 19:13outside the core,
- 19:14high quality fixed income is em,
- 19:16local debt.
- 19:17You know,
- 19:18this has been an area that we have been focused on so far in 2023.
- 19:22The story here is that central banks and em started hiking well before developed markets and at this point,
- 19:31they have very high real yields and central banks are looking to pause there.
- 19:36Now,
- 19:36what's different about em local now than in the past is that there's a lot of their debt is domestically held.
- 19:43So it's not as driven by the whims of uh tourists and hot money.
- 19:49And finally,
- 19:50one of the other tailwinds we see for the em,
- 19:53local debt space is the weaker dollar,
- 19:56which we think is going to be a trend that continues throughout the year as the fed turns away from hiking and towards and cutting.
- 20:04So one other sort of broader question is last year,
- 20:07of course,
- 20:07was a very difficult year for balanced investors because you saw this huge sell off in the stock market.
- 20:12But that was actually made worse by a big sell off in the bond market,
- 20:15which is very unusual occurrence.
- 20:17Um with the fed now nearing the end of its tight cycle.
- 20:20Do you think that the negative traditional negative stock bond correlation is going to reassert itself?
- 20:25So this is definitely the good news.
- 20:27Uh We do think that that right way correlation between stocks and bonds is reasserting itself and also has reasserted itself during the month of March.
- 20:39Um We've seen uh bonds perform well this month while we've seen stress in risk assets and in equity markets.
- 20:49And I think it's important to understand why uh bonds didn't work so well as a diversify or as a hedge last year to understand why we think they're going to work this year.
- 20:59And the real factor there was inflation and the central bank's response,
- 21:05we saw high inflation,
- 21:06the central banks needed to respond.
- 21:09What we're seeing now uh in our view is the market starting to anticipate those trends going in reverse.
- 21:16And so as the economy um weakens the market can expect incremental policy,
- 21:23easing and bonds will work as a diverse fire again in your portfolio.
- 21:28OK.
- 21:29All right.
- 21:29Last question.
- 21:30And then,
- 21:30and thank you very much Kelsey for all these,
- 21:32these uh very insightful answers.
- 21:35Um But we are seeing some pretty outside outsized flows into money market funds.
- 21:40Um Do you think this is a sign that investors are uncertain about the future and how should they manage that uncertainty?
- 21:45So we would agree,
- 21:46uncertainty is very high right now and we would admit that we don't have all the answers.
- 21:52So what we've been doing is positioning portfolios conservatively to manage this uncertainty.
- 21:59And we have noticed the flows into money market funds.
- 22:03We do think that that is uh a signal that people are uncertain.
- 22:09Um But we would note that when you think about the yield in a money market fund,
- 22:15you know,
- 22:15currently around 4.5 or 5% while that does look attractive in the short run,
- 22:22what you will face in the future is reinvestment risk.
- 22:26So,
- 22:27if rates are only at five,
- 22:295% for the next three months,
- 22:31you're not actually going to receive or return 5% you're only going to return one and a quarter percent.
- 22:38You only get that 5% if rates are at 5% for the next 12 months.
- 22:43So what we're encouraging uh investors to look at and consider is a diverse portfolio that does have some of those long duration bonds as well to lock in the higher rates while you can.
- 22:57And the question we're really being get,
- 22:59getting asked right now by clients is,
- 23:01did we miss the opportunity to get into bonds given the large move lower in yields?
- 23:07You know,
- 23:07over the past few weeks?
- 23:09And our answer to that would be no,
- 23:11you haven't missed the opportunity.
- 23:13Yields are still significantly higher than they were a year ago.
- 23:18Real yields for instance,
- 23:19are near their highest levels.
- 23:21In 15 years.
- 23:22We went from a period where there was 18 trillion in negative yielding debt to very little today outside of Japan and investment grade yields.
- 23:32Just for an example,
- 23:33on a global scale are about 3% higher than they were in December 2021.
- 23:40So the way I would see it is at the start of 2023 we were saying bonds are back now.
- 23:47It feels like bonds are here and we expect them to stick around um for the rest of the year.
- 23:53That's good to hear.
- 23:54Well,
- 23:54listen,
- 23:54thank you so much for joining us,
- 23:56Kelsey and thank you all for listening.
- 23:59Please tune into our next episode where I'll be joined by Ian Steely,
- 24:03our chief Investment Officer for International Fixed Income to discuss bond opportunities outside of the US,
- 24:08the outlook on global central banks and what this might mean for the US dollar.
- 24:12Until then I invite you to read or listen to my notes of the week ahead podcast where every Monday I share commentary,
- 24:17the latest in markets and the economy to help you stay in a form for the week ahead.
- 24:21For even more timely insights you can also follow and subscribe to my content on linkedin.
- 24:25This content is intended for information only based on assumptions and current market conditions and are subject to change.
- 24:31No warranty of accuracy is given this content does not contain sufficient information to support investment decisions.
- 24:37It is not to be construed as research,
- 24:39legal regulatory tax accounting or investment advice investments involve risks.
- 24:45Investors should seek professional advice or make an independent evaluation before investing the value of investments and the income from them may fluctuate including loss of capital,
- 24:53past performance and yield are not indicative of current or future results forecasts and estimates may or may not come to pass.
- 25:00Jpmorgan Asset Management is the asset management business of JP Morgan Chase and Company and its affiliates worldwide.