Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Art of Graceful Defeat: How to Recover, Regroup, and Recharge
Transcript
- 0:03Hello everyone and welcome to the art of graceful
- 0:07defeat, professional and ethical rules. My name
- 0:11is Wendy Patrick and I am a career prosecutor
- 0:1530 years, but I've also been heavily involved
- 0:19in the field of ethics for almost all 30 of those
- 0:23years, if not the entire time. And it is in that
- 0:26capacity that I have become interested in presenting
- 0:30over the last three decades in the field of ethics.
- 0:34And over the years that I've been trying cases
- 0:37like many of you, you try enough, you don't win
- 0:40them all. So this program you're going to hear
- 0:44today is going to give you one coveted hour of
- 0:47ethics credit. But I'm hopeful it's also going
- 0:50to hit one of the practical realities of being
- 0:53a career trial lawyer or even being a career
- 0:56lawyer, whether or not you ever go to court or
- 0:58go to trial. And that is the art of graceful
- 1:02defeat as a sort of a personal matter. All of
- 1:07us have been there and it is not a very fun place
- 1:10to be. It's not very comfortable and would rather
- 1:12not lose. But it also calls into question some
- 1:17of the ethical rules that govern our behavior
- 1:20when we do lose anything, whether it's a motion,
- 1:24a court trial, a jury trial. an appeal and everything
- 1:28in between. So let's talk a little bit about
- 1:30that. But first here is your important notice
- 1:34that accompanies each one of these programs.
- 1:37Our talk here today does not establish an attorney
- 1:39standard of care for any particular situation.
- 1:42You can read these on your own. You will also
- 1:45have written materials that you can also look
- 1:49at on your own. They are going to mirror the
- 1:51slide deck I'm going to be presenting today.
- 1:53So you don't have to be furiously scribbling
- 1:56notes or taking screenshots. You're going to
- 1:58have this in PDF format. And then the last thing
- 2:01I'll say is I do have a set of Google images,
- 2:05usually all Wikipedia comment, Wikimedia Commons.
- 2:08But nonetheless, they are not used for distribution.
- 2:12They are used according to the fair use language.
- 2:15under the USC. All right. So with that, with
- 2:20the legalities of the ethics presentation out
- 2:24of the way, gosh, I wish I was in person right
- 2:27now to see your reaction to this slide. How does
- 2:31it feel to lose a big case? Now, many of you
- 2:35might be thinking, well, I'm too new. I haven't
- 2:37actually lost a big case yet. But how do you
- 2:40define big? You know, when I was a new lawyer,
- 2:42every case was a big case and every every loss
- 2:44was a big loss. And one of the things we learned
- 2:48through the years when it comes to the art of
- 2:51graceful defeat is if you are as practiced, polished
- 2:57professional as you can be and you still lose,
- 3:01it is a lot. easier to weather. It is those cases
- 3:05where we absolutely second guess ourselves and
- 3:09blame ourselves for not being overly prepared.
- 3:12When we lose a case like that, sometimes we are
- 3:16harder on ourselves than we need to be. And that
- 3:19is one of the reasons we're going to work through
- 3:21not just the ethical rules, but how the ethical
- 3:25rules really apply to some of the more cognitive
- 3:29emotional strategies of overcoming loss. Now,
- 3:34overcoming loss is a part of practicing law.
- 3:36You know, as a prosecutor, occasionally my friends
- 3:39will ask me, well, isn't it true that you and
- 3:41your colleagues get promoted based on your win
- 3:45loss record? Now, of course, all of you are savvy
- 3:47enough to know, of course, that's not true. But
- 3:49over the years, sometimes I've become fond of
- 3:51thinking, thank God that is not the case or I
- 3:54would have been fired in the 90s because having
- 3:57almost a steady stream of domestic violence,
- 4:00sexual assault cases, we don't win all those
- 4:03cases. In fact, we lose a lot of those cases.
- 4:05So no, it's about being prepared and doing justice.
- 4:08And it's the same thing no matter what kind of
- 4:11law you practice. But this slide remains relevant.
- 4:14It never feels good to lose. So we're going to
- 4:20talk about the art of graceful defeat in three
- 4:23areas today. Recovery is the first one. I don't
- 4:27just mean recovering cost and fees from a client.
- 4:30I mean also recovering the cost of that client
- 4:33relationship. Regrouping. how teamwork builds
- 4:38trust or sometimes rebuilds trust and then recharge.
- 4:41Boy, each one of these could be a standalone
- 4:43program and presentation because we're focusing
- 4:46on the future. And when it comes to looking at
- 4:50these three items, these three areas we're going
- 4:53to cover today, I know that each and every one
- 4:56of you goes through each of these prongs at your
- 4:59own pace. Sometimes I say the saving grace of
- 5:03loss. is the amount of cases you have queued
- 5:06up for the future. Because there is nothing like
- 5:08being busy to sort of get through the sting of
- 5:12defeat. Sitting at council table, listening to
- 5:16a clerk read through that verdict. First, she
- 5:20reads the case number. Here, she reads the case
- 5:22number. And it just seems like that takes forever.
- 5:25And then when you finally get the verdict, whether
- 5:27it's a relief or a kick in the stomach, We've
- 5:31all been there. You know what I want to know
- 5:33is why after 30 years does your heart still beat
- 5:35as fast as it did in year one as you're waiting
- 5:38for that verdict to be read? Can't be good for
- 5:40us. But in any event, we do move through these
- 5:43three stages differently. And we're going to
- 5:46talk about that along with the ethical rules
- 5:49and some psychology as to why that is true each
- 5:53and every time we go through this. So let's start
- 5:57at the sort of the beginning, but also we're
- 6:00going to talk a little bit about which is easier
- 6:02to get through when it comes to recovery and
- 6:05resilience. So this is the first thing I want
- 6:07you to think about. And I noticed there's a chat
- 6:12going. Let me just see if anybody's made any
- 6:14comments there. OK, so it's a link to program
- 6:17materials. Excellent. OK, good. So you are going
- 6:20to be having that at the end. But think about.
- 6:23In which of these areas you find it easier to
- 6:28recover? I would be looking at a lot of raised
- 6:30hands in a physical room if we were doing this
- 6:32live right now because I know there's a big difference
- 6:35in split of opinion as to how long it takes in
- 6:39each one of these areas and there's an ethical
- 6:41rule for each of these that we'll go through.
- 6:43But one of the reasons I became interested in
- 6:45learning a little bit more about the research
- 6:47of this is some of you know that I went back
- 6:50to school mid -career to get a master in divinity
- 6:54degree and then a PhD. And part of that has been
- 6:57my love of research. And in researching the legal
- 7:00field and lawyers, there's a lot of research
- 7:02that's looked at why we feel the way we do. going
- 7:06through the life of the case, the highs, the
- 7:09lows, the ups, the downs. And these are some
- 7:12of the areas in which we struggle after a loss
- 7:15and in which we have to develop this resilience.
- 7:20We internalize loss to the extent that it's physical
- 7:23now. I know we've all been to programs on legal
- 7:27PTSD We've all been to programs on vicarious
- 7:30trauma so you already know a lot about the science
- 7:34that explains why we feel the way we do and That
- 7:38has to do with both physical and mental but also
- 7:42these other three prompts. There's an emotional
- 7:45component as to the way a loss actually sort
- 7:47of bleeds into the other areas of our life. Now,
- 7:50hopefully we have a great home life, a great
- 7:52social life, and a great support system in the
- 7:56legal community. We'll talk about that when we
- 7:58look at some of the ethical rules regarding supervision.
- 8:01But it's also true that professionally, sometimes
- 8:05we over exaggerate the extent to which a loss
- 8:09governs or or impacts one way or another our
- 8:13reputation. And by the way, that can be positively
- 8:16or negatively. It's sort of like those news stories
- 8:19you hear where there's some kind of a scandal
- 8:22that involves a particular elected official or
- 8:25somebody that's running for office. And everybody
- 8:28talks about it for about a week. And then next
- 8:30week, we're talking about somebody else. And
- 8:32then a year from now, we can't really even remember
- 8:34what scandal with what elected official or. famous
- 8:38person or celebrity or politician or whatever
- 8:40it was. Guess what? There's a lot of that that
- 8:43goes on with the art of graceful defeat. We may
- 8:47worry that our reputation is going to be forever
- 8:50impacted by a particular loss in a particular
- 8:53case. That's just not true. And to to to begin
- 8:57with, we're probably on a short list of people.
- 9:01Maybe the other people are your your boss and
- 9:03your your spouse. that even remember it. So thinking
- 9:07about putting loss in context is always good
- 9:12news for us. And the last prong here is communally.
- 9:16And what I mean by that is many of our cases
- 9:18have to do with our partnerships with other community
- 9:21organizations. And even then, we are never defined
- 9:24by one particular loss in our career, even if
- 9:29it's a mistake. We're not defined by any particular
- 9:32mistake. You show me someone who hasn't made
- 9:34a mistake and I'll show you somebody that's never
- 9:36tried a case. I mean, we all call balls and strikes
- 9:41differently. You know, it's not just judges that
- 9:43have to make those decisions. We make them too.
- 9:46Sometimes we're the one that asks the question.
- 9:48Too many that we worry. contributed to an adverse
- 9:51verdict where we all know at the end of the day,
- 9:53that is usually not the case. But it's also true
- 9:56that each of those areas on the left, it takes
- 9:59us a little different amount of time to recover.
- 10:02Now, I do want to say that as we go through talking
- 10:07about loss and how to process loss, each of us
- 10:11has at one point on another during the course
- 10:13of our career, worked with someone that doesn't
- 10:17internalize loss, at least not publicly, they
- 10:20blame. They point the finger. And nobody wants
- 10:24to be on a team where after a loss, everybody's
- 10:27doing this. Everybody's playing the blame game,
- 10:29you know, pointing at somebody else. We learned
- 10:31that in law school that that's not the way to
- 10:33handle loss. But it's also true that you never
- 10:36really know whether or not somebody who's publicly
- 10:38trying to blame shift isn't personally actually
- 10:42blaming themselves. All right. So along those
- 10:47lines, as we talk through how a team works together
- 10:50in processing loss, because that's going to be
- 10:53a healthy way to remain competent, I want to
- 10:56talk about victory, yes, but also the other things
- 11:00that could happen after a case, whether it's
- 11:03to a trial, whether it's to a jury, whether it's
- 11:05to a judge. or whether it's just some sort of
- 11:09a huge motion that's dispositive in terms of
- 11:12what's gonna happen with the case. But you look
- 11:15at the receptivity to feedback. Now, managers,
- 11:18supervisors on the line, we've got our own ethics
- 11:21rules that apply to this. You've got 5 .1, 5
- 11:24.2, 5 .3, they're all in your materials, we're
- 11:26gonna get there. But think about this, if you
- 11:30are in a position of wanting to provide feedback,
- 11:34to a lawyer that has just suffered a win or a
- 11:38loss. Subordinate lawyers, be thinking about
- 11:41how you're going to respond to feedback from
- 11:44your supervisor or even from your colleagues.
- 11:49Victory, you're going to have a different kind
- 11:52of feedback that you're probably going to be
- 11:54receiving. then defeat. If it's a mixed verdict,
- 11:58you're going to have a mixed response. And then
- 12:00of course, if it's a mistrial, everybody's just
- 12:02talking about, oh, I cannot believe we have to
- 12:04do this again. Do we really have to, can we settle,
- 12:06et cetera. But my good friend Brian reminded
- 12:11me. that you will each have victories, where
- 12:17you will have a supervisor that is wise enough
- 12:19to not let you bask in glory for too long, before
- 12:23he or she reminds you, hey, don't you have a
- 12:27couple of depositions you have to schedule on
- 12:30the next case? Have you put out that discovery?
- 12:32Don't you have a motion you should be writing?
- 12:34So we all have to get over ourselves, usually
- 12:37fairly quickly, because we have a heavy case
- 12:39load. So sometimes we also think through the
- 12:44way in which different types of people respond
- 12:47to winning and losing. There may be some that
- 12:50have a little bit of pride and isn't pride something
- 12:53that we can at least enjoy for a minute after
- 12:57a hard -won fight goes our way. We think we've
- 13:01earned that. I've earned the right to prance
- 13:03around in the hallway. for 15 minutes, haven't
- 13:07I? Only to get home and our spouse and kids were,
- 13:09you know, they probably, we don't get five minutes
- 13:12there, but at least we should get something around
- 13:14our colleagues. But we want to always make sure
- 13:18that we're not resistant to negative information.
- 13:21Don't each and every one of us know that peer
- 13:24who won a case and we think to ourselves, but
- 13:27for the grace of God, that jury did the right
- 13:31thing in spite. of perhaps mistakes being made.
- 13:34We've all been there. We also want to make sure
- 13:38that when we're demoralized after a defeat, that
- 13:42we are also in the same position as if we won.
- 13:46We don't want to ever be in a position where
- 13:48we're resistant to negative information because
- 13:51we can always get better. You learn something
- 13:54new every day. We're lifelong learners as lawyers.
- 13:57So you always want to make sure that we remain
- 14:00attuned to information and feedback. So again,
- 14:05if I were there in person, I would ask you, tell
- 14:07me when you think is the ideal time to provide
- 14:12feedback to your peers after a case. So I've
- 14:18received a couple of very intriguing answers
- 14:20to this question. One of them has been between
- 14:25closing arguments and the verdict. Some people
- 14:28have said, you know, you're on pins and needles.
- 14:30You know, you're not eating or drinking. You're
- 14:32just sort of in this, you know, altered state
- 14:34of reality as you wait in anticipation for the
- 14:38verdict. Then I've heard some other people say,
- 14:40you know, I'm always a mess between, you know,
- 14:43the closing argument and the verdict. That would
- 14:45be the last time when you would expect me to
- 14:47really internalize anything valuable about how
- 14:49I've done. So some people wait to laugh to the
- 14:51verdict. But you know, some people also say,
- 14:54you know, give give him or her a week and then
- 14:56come back. So it all depends on your style. Have
- 15:00that conversation with your supervisors beforehand
- 15:04so that everyone reminds you and keeps that information
- 15:08ready to remember. Because guess what? You know,
- 15:11even in a week people forget. So you want to
- 15:13make sure you have the benefit of the best feedback
- 15:16possible while it's fresh. in the other person's
- 15:19mind. So these are some ways in which we can
- 15:23help our colleagues, our peers, those we supervise
- 15:27in dealing with loss. Even if you haven't lost
- 15:30the whole thing, maybe the verdict is a mixed
- 15:32bag. That would be a good way to make sure you
- 15:35are able to provide valuable feedback when they're
- 15:37ready to receive it. OK, so this is what my friend
- 15:41Brian Roers was telling me. Response to victory.
- 15:43We have to really temper this also. Think about
- 15:47what's involved in responding to victory. First
- 15:50of all, if it's a high profile case, you're going
- 15:52to have some kind of a statement. It's a statement
- 15:55that maybe you prepared right from the beginning,
- 15:57hoping it would become a self -fulfilling prophecy.
- 16:00Maybe it is a list of statements that you have
- 16:03in your pocket. You've heard me talk about this
- 16:05before because that's part of what I do is consulting
- 16:08is you have a safe list of things you can say
- 16:11ethically that hopefully when you can pull them
- 16:13out and say them on the air or say them in public,
- 16:16say them in front of people, say them to the
- 16:18victim, say them to your client, they'll be ready
- 16:21to go. So you think about those professional
- 16:23statements. And then you think about the way
- 16:27in which you respond to victory personally. I
- 16:30know a lot of people that say, you know, when
- 16:31I win a case for I don't go out to grab a drink,
- 16:34I go home and I grab my surfboard. There are
- 16:37different ways in which people respond to victory,
- 16:41that they allow themselves a little bit of time
- 16:44to enjoy it before they go right on to the next
- 16:47case. Some people joke that they don't have the
- 16:49time to respond one way or another because those
- 16:52cases are breathing down their neck. But supervisors,
- 16:55supervisors have a support system role in the
- 17:00process that maybe they have already thought
- 17:03through how they can express gratitude to a job
- 17:07well done, especially if you've been involved
- 17:10in preparing the case as well. Let me tell you
- 17:14how not to respond when you have a peer or a
- 17:19subordinate lawyer, a colleague, or even a supervisor
- 17:22that has lost a case. Silence is not golden when
- 17:27you are on the losing end of a case. I can tell
- 17:31you exactly why psychologically. You probably
- 17:33already know. It's sort of like that supervisor
- 17:36when you were a young lawyer that says, can you
- 17:39come down and see me in my office without any
- 17:42explanation? I mean, is there anything that creates
- 17:47more fear in a young lawyer than being called
- 17:50down to a supervisor's office and not being told
- 17:54the reason why? You know, one of the things I've
- 17:56noticed as the years have passed, and many years
- 18:00have passed, is that supervisors get savvy to
- 18:03this sort of technique. And what they'll say
- 18:05is, can you please come see me? No, you're not
- 18:08in trouble. Happy Basie Moticon. So we knew that
- 18:11now as supervisors. But after a loss is really
- 18:16the time that you can shine as a supervisor,
- 18:20as a peer, as a mentor, as a role model. You
- 18:24can be there quickly and say something like,
- 18:29when you're ready, you know, let's talk about
- 18:32the case. I have a list of things you did right.
- 18:36I mean, you know, you talk about raising kids,
- 18:38catching doing something right. I would say the
- 18:40same philosophy. builds a strong presence in
- 18:43the law firm. Even if you're a solo, you have
- 18:46colleagues, you have friends, you have people
- 18:48that you work with that know you've been in trial.
- 18:51And the very worst thing you can do is not speak
- 18:55up and make everyone that has lost a case worry
- 18:58that they've been ostracized. It's sort of like
- 19:01I have a close family member that is battling
- 19:04cancer. And she always says to me, you know,
- 19:06when I mentioned that there's these people that
- 19:09never said a word to me. Silence is not golden
- 19:12when somebody is not feeling good about a circumstance
- 19:15in their life. So too when it comes to something
- 19:17so near and dear to our heart as losing a case.
- 19:22Here are some of the reasons we lose cases. Now,
- 19:24a lot of these have nothing to do with a lawyer's
- 19:27advocacy skills. And that is really important
- 19:31because when we lose cases, we internalize all
- 19:34the reasons we lost. They can be lost due to
- 19:37witnesses. Maybe there's a lack of evidence.
- 19:39The evidence evidence here, rulings didn't go
- 19:41our way. There was too much pretrial publicity,
- 19:44all right? And some of you may remember that's
- 19:46rule 3 .6, trial publicity. It has to make sure
- 19:49you do it in a fashion that it doesn't unfairly
- 19:51jeopardize one side of the case. There may be
- 19:54loopholes in existing law. We're going to talk
- 19:56about meritorious claims, 3 .1, and everything
- 19:59that you have to work within the boundaries of
- 20:02the law. Zealous advocacy is something you may.
- 20:05hear about in the movies, but actually, you know,
- 20:07we've got that duty of candor, 3 .3. All this
- 20:10is going to be in your materials. But sometimes
- 20:12it's just as simple as an evidentiary problem,
- 20:15not necessarily be because you weren't fulfilling
- 20:18your duty of competence, 1 .1. We're going to
- 20:20go through all of that. But these are some of
- 20:22the reasons cases are lost that have very little
- 20:24to do with you. You do the best job you can,
- 20:27and then sometimes that isn't good enough for
- 20:29a judge or jury. So after the mourning period,
- 20:34This is why we have those three prongs. You refocus,
- 20:37you regroup, you re -strategize, you decide whether
- 20:41or not you're going to evaluate second guessing
- 20:45on the current case. What can you do? Is there
- 20:47any grounds to appeal, whether it's the verdict
- 20:50itself, whether it's a judgment, the amount,
- 20:52or are you going to shift your focus to new cases?
- 20:55We're going to talk about all of this also with
- 20:58also the communication with your clients. in
- 21:00mind too. That's of course 1 .4. Don't forget
- 21:031 .2 again all in your materials allocation of
- 21:06authority. We'll talk about how ethically the
- 21:09client does call a lot of the shots but not the
- 21:11ethical shots. That's you. That's why I create
- 21:15these programs on your ethical duties. So having
- 21:18that preface let's dive right in and talk about
- 21:22how only in California as we like to say we have
- 21:26our own version of the model rules that we adopted
- 21:30in 2018. So we're going to talk about a little
- 21:33bit of that. I want to tell you that in California,
- 21:37we have a lot of places where we can look. Some
- 21:39are mandatory ethical rules. Some are persuasive
- 21:43ethical rules, but we really do have. An abundance
- 21:47of riches, shall I say, loving the ethical rules.
- 21:51And as many of you know, I'm one of the former
- 21:53chairs of the California State Bar Ethics Committee
- 21:56called COPRAC. And in that capacity, you know,
- 21:59we're involved in writing those ethical opinions
- 22:02that break down the rules that make it easier
- 22:04for you to understand. And I always say, you
- 22:07know, if you look at the rules and you can't
- 22:08find what you need, remember what our own rule
- 22:121 .0 comment four says. regarding looking all
- 22:15these other places for guidance. I'll show you
- 22:18that comment in a second. But just look at this.
- 22:21Look at how many places you can look. You can
- 22:23look at the rules themselves. You can look at
- 22:27how the State Bar Act has codified certain ethical
- 22:31rules. So I'm talking about 60 -68 duties as
- 22:34a lawyer, 15 duties. Only three of them are to
- 22:37your client, the rest are to the system. I'm
- 22:39talking about 61 -06, which is the duty of honesty.
- 22:43So I'm sort of paraphrasing some of this, but
- 22:45these are the places that you look for mandatory
- 22:49ethical guidance. The bottom three are advisory.
- 22:53But guess what? If we don't have a rule in California
- 22:55that directly speaks to your issue, a state bar
- 22:59court is going to do what you should be doing.
- 23:01Well, where can I look for guidance? That is
- 23:04where the ABA rules come in. That is where state
- 23:08bar opinions or county bar opinions or ABA opinions
- 23:12come in. That's also where even things like ABA
- 23:16standards come into play. You know, if you go
- 23:19to the ABA website, it's all good in terms of
- 23:22providing guidance and persuasive authority.
- 23:26Now I can tell you why this is also a good idea
- 23:28as a sort of a self -help reason, and that's
- 23:32because state bar courts cite from. the advisory
- 23:35rules in coming to a decision if they can't find
- 23:39something they need. So if it's good enough for
- 23:41the state court to use to make a ruling, we should
- 23:44be looking there as well. All right. Here is
- 23:47that comment I was telling you right in the first
- 23:49rule, inviting you to look elsewhere for guidance.
- 23:54And this is especially important when it comes
- 23:56to your behavior in losing a case, because you're
- 24:00going to be looking through a lot of what we're
- 24:02going to be talking about and responding in a
- 24:05fashion that calls into question, you know, where
- 24:07are the parameters? Where are the guardrails
- 24:10in what you can say about losing a case? And
- 24:13I'll just give you a sort of a spoiler alert
- 24:15here. You may have heard colleagues bad mouthing
- 24:19judges, bad mouthing juries talking about, well,
- 24:23if they had only heard about this, that and the
- 24:26other, those are the kinds of things that get
- 24:28us into trouble. And they're also the kinds of
- 24:30things we're more likely to do. in the heat of
- 24:33passion before we've had an opportunity to calm
- 24:36down, which is why round -tabling a case, talking
- 24:39about a loss with trusted peers, colleagues,
- 24:43and supervisors is really the best practice before
- 24:46you say anything in advance that you're going
- 24:50to wish you hadn't. The big piece of pseudo legal
- 24:54advice I'll give you here is a closed mouth gathers
- 24:57no foot. If you are feeling very upset about
- 25:01a loss, that is the worst time to make public
- 25:05statements, just take a minute and collect your
- 25:07thoughts. Or better yet, have a collection of
- 25:11safe sound bites available to choose from. And
- 25:13I'm gonna give you some examples of that in this
- 25:15program as well. Okay, so here's our competence
- 25:18rule in California. Now, why do I say only in
- 25:21California? Because even though we've adopted
- 25:25many If not a majority of the ABA rules sometimes
- 25:31wholesale without changes, there are a lot that
- 25:34we haven't. And wouldn't you know, competence
- 25:36is one of them. Now, you probably didn't need
- 25:39a presentation to explain this part of competence.
- 25:43We shall not intentionally, recklessly, with
- 25:47gross negligence, or repeatedly fail to reform
- 25:50legal services with competence. So you lose one
- 25:53case due to one particular mistake. you probably
- 25:56won't make that mistake again. But in California,
- 26:00competence is more than that. It also means,
- 26:04in addition to providing and applying the learning
- 26:08and skill, this is also part of your duty of
- 26:12competence, the mental, emotional, and physical
- 26:17ability reasonably necessary for the performance
- 26:20of your services. So how do you like that? It's
- 26:24not only about knowing that area of the law It's
- 26:28also about the way you feel the way you feel
- 26:32mentally the way you're feeling emotionally Physically,
- 26:37you know, I don't know how many lawyers I've
- 26:39heard come into court complaining about a terrible
- 26:42physical injury that they're nursing, that they're
- 26:46in physical pain, that they're taking painkillers.
- 26:48I mean, there have been so many cases that arguably
- 26:53have brought up this second problem, that that's
- 26:56not the right time to be doing heavy lifting
- 26:59in the courtroom. I mean that figuratively, of
- 27:01course, because it's cognitively challenging
- 27:04and taxing to try a case to begin with, much
- 27:09less doing it when we're not at our best. So
- 27:13those are the types of things that we think about
- 27:15when it comes to our competence in California.
- 27:19Now, how about this one? Part of the, let's say,
- 27:25processing loss and dealing with loss has to
- 27:28do with breaking the news to your client. Now,
- 27:32how do you suppose this is done with the least
- 27:36resistance, with the... with the least amount
- 27:39of contention. What would make a client accept
- 27:43loss the best? How do you let them down the easiest?
- 27:48Well, of course, the answer to that is if you
- 27:51have meticulously fulfilled your 1 .4 ethical
- 27:54duty of communication, you are going to be in
- 27:58the best position to be able to break the news
- 28:01to your client. And by the way, you're going
- 28:03to do it immediately. You are not going to have
- 28:05them if they're not sitting in court. with you
- 28:07listening to the verdict. If somehow they're
- 28:10not able to be present, and even if they are,
- 28:13you're going to have to give a little bit more
- 28:14explanation. The best way we do that is by already
- 28:19having that golden relationship under 1 .4. Now
- 28:23I'm not reproducing all the sections, only the
- 28:25ones that are relevant to artfully dealing with
- 28:28defeat. If you have along the way, every step
- 28:33of the way, reasonably consulted with your client
- 28:36about how you're going to move forward, how you're
- 28:39going to be accomplishing the objectives, how
- 28:42you are dealing with the representation. If you
- 28:45have also fulfilled your duty to keep that client
- 28:49under 1 .4 subdivision 3 reasonably informed
- 28:53about significant developments every step of
- 28:57the way, you've promptly complied with reasonable
- 29:00requests for information. Notice how many times
- 29:03the word reasonable, by the way, shows up in
- 29:04this rule. But if you've done all of that, you've
- 29:09got a client that is going to be able to absorb
- 29:12that loss mentally and emotionally a lot better
- 29:17than if you haven't been fulfilling your one
- 29:19point for a two and three duties. This makes
- 29:22it easier on you in working through a loss with
- 29:27your clients. And I will share. Just one example
- 29:31over the years that illustrates why this is true.
- 29:34Now, you may think you're a prosecutor. What
- 29:36do you know about having clients? Well, some
- 29:37of you know I wasn't always a prosecutor. I actually
- 29:39was a criminal defense attorney. But I'll also
- 29:42say that as a prosecutor, I have victims that
- 29:44are devastated when I lose cases. And that has
- 29:49been true for 30 years. I don't think I've ever
- 29:51been in an assignment where it's only easy cases.
- 29:54And I can tell you one example that I remember
- 29:57to this day is if it just happened yesterday.
- 29:59was about losing what was to me a big case having
- 30:03to do with a domestic violence related scenario.
- 30:07And the day after losing the case, which I considered
- 30:10a big loss, I get to work and there's a gift
- 30:12basket with my name on it at the front desk from
- 30:16the victim. And in it, I remember the card, like
- 30:20I just opened it, it said, I've never had anybody
- 30:23fight so hard for me. So it was one of those
- 30:26cases where It was a communication that was so
- 30:30solid every day, all day, weekdays, weekends,
- 30:35that the very last thing this victim did is blame
- 30:37me for the loss. And I'll always remember that.
- 30:40She probably doesn't even remember the case anymore.
- 30:41It was decades ago. But I always thought, doesn't
- 30:45that make loss easier if you have that kind of
- 30:48a relationship with your client? And that's one
- 30:52of the reasons that I just love rule 1 .4. Because
- 30:55if you're ever in doubt about how much engagement
- 30:59you should have every step of the way with your
- 31:02clients, read through 1 .4 again and don't cheat
- 31:05yourself by not reading the comments because
- 31:07the comments bring the rule to life and really
- 31:12give you that idea as to how much communication
- 31:15really not only makes for a good ethical duty
- 31:19and fulfilling all of that, but also a good client
- 31:22lawyer relationship. So with that, I'm also going
- 31:26to tie in the ethical rule on meritorious claims.
- 31:30This is probably more relevant today than it
- 31:33has ever been, because we live in a social media
- 31:36savvy world where no matter what kind of case
- 31:38we're trying, jurors and even judges are just
- 31:42being bombarded in the news media with cases
- 31:46that everybody is saying, oh, how did that case
- 31:48even get out of the gate? Why was that case even
- 31:51filed? Why would a lawsuit like that ever see
- 31:54the light of day? And it reminds us that because
- 31:58if we're following 3 .1, we're allowed to file
- 32:01lawsuits, even if it is testing the boundaries
- 32:05of an existing law. I mean, this is what the
- 32:07rule said. It prohibits us not from filing lawsuits,
- 32:10but look at the way it's raised, bringing or
- 32:14continuing an action, having a defense, supporting
- 32:17a position in litigation, taking up an appeal
- 32:20without probable cause. if it is done for an
- 32:23improper purpose. And here we're given the examples
- 32:26of harassing, maliciously injuring another person,
- 32:31or presenting some kind of a claim that's not
- 32:34warranted under existing law, unless it's a good
- 32:39faith argument for an extension, a modification,
- 32:44or a reversal of existing law. Now, this should
- 32:48be a sigh of relief to somebody that is sort
- 32:51of forging a path that hasn't been forced before.
- 32:53There's nothing that says that you can't do that.
- 32:56It is the improper use of the judicial system.
- 33:01It is being a vexatious litigant. It is filing
- 33:05lawsuits for improper purposes that gets you
- 33:08into trouble. And then, of course, there's also
- 33:12additional subdivisions when you're talking about
- 33:14what if it's a kind of lawsuit that could resolve
- 33:18in some type of a confinement or commitment.
- 33:22Okay, so looking at all of those rules, I have
- 33:25to give you one of my favorites, and that is
- 33:30rule 2 .1 regarding being a client advisor. Most
- 33:34people really haven't looked at this rule in
- 33:36context. I have a whole program designed around
- 33:39rule 2 .1, advisor, because it talks about all
- 33:43of the other different ways you can involve your
- 33:47client in the process of working through a case.
- 33:50And when you do involve your client in engaging
- 33:53in all the different factors that go into winning
- 33:56or losing a case, they and you will appreciate
- 34:00how to deal with loss and how in our current
- 34:03climate, there are just some causes and types
- 34:06of lawsuits. that are more popular than others.
- 34:10And that could be relevant to why cases are lost.
- 34:15You may think to yourself, I worked up this case
- 34:18every bit as much as I did when I had a similar
- 34:21case 20 years ago. And it was the exact opposite
- 34:24result. So 2 .1 talks about, first of all, how
- 34:29you have to exercise your independent judgment
- 34:31and render candid advice. But candid advice can
- 34:35also mean Hey, even if we meet all the elements,
- 34:38I can't promise you we're going to win this case
- 34:40because look at the way comment two to rule two
- 34:45point one is phrased. It doesn't preclude a lawyer
- 34:49this rule from referring to considerations other
- 34:53than the law. Now, I want to go through these
- 34:55one by one because I know some lawyers that have
- 34:58said, well, I'm afraid of sort of veering off
- 35:01the path, going out of my lane. if I involve
- 35:06more than just the law in counseling a client.
- 35:10But that's not what comment two of two point
- 35:12one says. Look at this. It says you can refer
- 35:16to considerations other than the law, moral,
- 35:20economic, social and political factors may be
- 35:26relevant to the client situation. How do you
- 35:29like that? And this list is, by the way, is not
- 35:32exhaustive. It's illustrative. So this just illustrates
- 35:36several things you can think about when you're
- 35:39when you're talking to a client. Now, this also
- 35:41means that consider your jury pool, consider
- 35:45your jurisdiction. Do you practice in front of
- 35:49a bench that is bent one way or another or a
- 35:54jury pool that is more defense oriented or more
- 35:56plaintiff oriented? You can think about these
- 36:00things in determining how to present a case.
- 36:03And this is the kind of thing that really makes
- 36:06it easier to deal with loss. If right from the
- 36:09beginning, you and your client are talking through
- 36:12different aspects of the case that may arguably
- 36:15be relevant to the way in which you're going
- 36:17to put it on. OK, so let's talk about the other
- 36:23pressures that go with losing a case. I call
- 36:27this post verdict press. Also understanding that
- 36:32any kind of focus on your case is a source of
- 36:36pressure. We worry about this when we lose a
- 36:38case, even if we've done our best. That makes
- 36:42it really tough. So I'm hoping to make this a
- 36:44little easier for you. First, I want to tell
- 36:48you that our rule 3 .6 is very similar to the
- 36:52ABA. This is, of course, trial publicity. And
- 36:56trial publicity also governs what you can say
- 37:00in response. And I'm going to tell you how I
- 37:02sort of make that connection in a minute. But
- 37:05think about the reality that you've already been
- 37:07talking about your case, if it's a big case.
- 37:09And that goes without saying that there are,
- 37:13as ABA 3 .6 Comet 1 points out, vital social
- 37:17interests that are served by talking through
- 37:20a case and not talking about the confidential
- 37:22things or something that is prohibited by Rule
- 37:253 .6. But basically, there are lots of ways in
- 37:29which discussing legal proceedings benefits the
- 37:32public. So that is one of the things we think
- 37:35through right at the beginning. It's not true
- 37:37that you shouldn't say anything ever because
- 37:39your opposing counsel is probably going to be
- 37:41talking about if it's a big case. So you just
- 37:43have to make sure you are following the law.
- 37:47But sometimes after losing a case, there are
- 37:51the hardest questions of all. It's almost easier
- 37:55to answer questions on the front end than after
- 37:58a loss. And I'm going to give you some examples,
- 37:59some real examples, by the way. Why was this
- 38:03lawsuit filed? So you're going to have answers
- 38:06to this, and it's best to think through, God
- 38:08forbid, how you would come up with a question,
- 38:11an answer to this question on the fly. It's better
- 38:14to think through your answer on the front end,
- 38:16just in case. Was your investigation vindictive
- 38:20or just careless? How do you like this? Now,
- 38:23I've had all these questions, but when you lose
- 38:25cases over the years, you get savvy as to what
- 38:29kinds of questions are going to be asked. Even
- 38:31if it's not anything that has to do with a trial
- 38:34publicity issue, maybe there's cases that are
- 38:36asked by somebody in your office or by the victim
- 38:38or by somebody that is an interested party impacted
- 38:43by the verdict. You'll get these false choice
- 38:46questions. So be ready for those. What do you
- 38:49say to those that were harmed? These are the
- 38:51real hard balls, and it doesn't even need to
- 38:53be at a press conference. These could be a question.
- 38:56This could be a question that you get in the
- 38:57grocery store. You know, I've had cases that
- 39:00were high profile and I would be in the grocery
- 39:03store, which is where people will recognize you
- 39:04if they know you have a case. Everything from,
- 39:07you know, what were you thinking to you better
- 39:10get these guys? I know how it is. Many of you
- 39:13have had questions like that from maybe somebody
- 39:16in your own law firm or maybe somebody in the
- 39:18legal community that passes you in the hallway
- 39:20at the courthouse. So keep in mind, these are
- 39:23the types of things to think about. Then you'll
- 39:26get the question about the jury system, the judicial
- 39:29system, the justice system. How does this verdict
- 39:32reflect upon that? So think about this. These
- 39:36are the hardball questions. So let me give you
- 39:40some caveats here before we think through some
- 39:44sort of general safe responses. Now you probably
- 39:48already know we have that duty of confidentiality
- 39:511 .6. There's also a 6068E duty of confidentiality,
- 39:56which by the way is referenced in the comments
- 39:58to 1 .6. It's a beautiful thing. Our current
- 40:02rules are almost this one stop shop of cross
- 40:06referencing other relevant rules. So celebrate
- 40:09that. We do have a great set of rules right now.
- 40:12But we also have to remember what was and wasn't
- 40:16entered into evidence after we've lost a case.
- 40:19After we've won a case, it doesn't matter. Once
- 40:21a case is over, these are the kind of things
- 40:24sometimes we forget. And I'll tell you where
- 40:26this gets tricky. You may have a case where right
- 40:30from the beginning, you were talking about the
- 40:33evidence. And then during trial or during a motion,
- 40:37if it's a case that's settled, during the course
- 40:39of the proceedings, different things were excluded.
- 40:43So at the end of the case, after you lost a case,
- 40:46it isn't true that your comments are going to
- 40:49be the same. So you have to be very careful about
- 40:51what you talk about. And then we also want to
- 40:54be careful. We are not injecting personal knowledge
- 40:58of underlying facts that never came out in evidence.
- 41:02This is the same rule we abide by when we're
- 41:05talking to jurors in the hallway after losing
- 41:09a case. There is this great temptation. in the
- 41:12face of loss, to saying, well, you didn't get
- 41:16to hear about X, Y, and Z, which of course is
- 41:18a big no -no. We can't tell them about inadmissible
- 41:22evidence. Now, there's lots of rules that talk
- 41:24about not saying anything that might unduly influence
- 41:28their willingness to serve in the future. But
- 41:31there's also a school of thought that what they
- 41:33didn't get to hear, what ruling shouldn't have
- 41:35gone which way would almost inevitably, at least
- 41:38as an argument, fall within that category. This
- 41:43is a less is more philosophy when it comes to
- 41:46what can you say about the case. OK, so this
- 41:50is what it feels like after loss when you're
- 41:53facing these really tough questions. So let me
- 41:56give you some ideas as to your post loss sound
- 42:01bites that you might want to think about. You
- 42:04want to make sure you're not saying anything
- 42:06that was hearsay, that wouldn't have been admissible
- 42:09under the evidence code. You want to make sure
- 42:11that we're not really sort of adopting any false
- 42:15facts or allegations. You always want to make
- 42:18sure you're not falling into any of those false
- 42:20choice categories where you're reckless or just
- 42:23vindictive. You were neither. You did everything
- 42:25you could to win the case. You don't want to
- 42:28call for speculation as to why a jury may or
- 42:30may not have found your way or why a ruling may
- 42:33not have gone your way. So you're, again, not
- 42:36going into anything that you don't know the answer
- 42:39to. You're not playing the blame game, even though
- 42:42we've all seen people to do that. Instead, think
- 42:46positive. Think about some of those prepared
- 42:48sound bites. Deliver them with open body language,
- 42:52demeanor, tone of voice. One example some of
- 42:56you may have heard me share before is that if
- 42:58you're always speaking Graciously with a pleasant
- 43:03tone. It's well -moderated It's not shrill. It's
- 43:07not defensive. It's not too high. It's not too
- 43:10low It's almost as if you're reporting on the
- 43:14case instead of talking about your own loss It's
- 43:17the voice I sometimes use when I'm asking very
- 43:20argumentative questions of an expert witness
- 43:22in front of a jury Because I know that if I'm
- 43:25talking like this, it's more likely I'm going
- 43:28to have an objection overruled and sustained
- 43:31because everyone is sort of being carried along
- 43:33with the cadence, with the tenor, with the tone.
- 43:37So too, when you're explaining a loss. Now, you
- 43:41may be thinking, that is hardly the mood that
- 43:43I'm in when I'm talking about having lost a case,
- 43:46but you can cultivate that kind of a mood. You
- 43:50probably can't cultivate it easily. right after
- 43:54the jury verdict. You're probably in the back
- 43:56room breathing into a bag or something, right?
- 43:59Trying to stabilize your heart rate and your
- 44:02blood pressure. But you will compose yourself.
- 44:06And it is at that point, you're ready to think
- 44:09through some of these sound bites I'm going to
- 44:11suggest. Before you do that, you're going to
- 44:15want to know what the audience knows, what was
- 44:19revealed in social media. Once you know the answer
- 44:22to that, having lost a case, you are in the best
- 44:26position of delivering some of those sound bites.
- 44:30Now, you don't want to wait for a long time because
- 44:32you want the facts of the case to be fresh in
- 44:34your mind. You don't want to forget anything,
- 44:37and you want to get this out of the way. Frankly,
- 44:38isn't that true also? Let's just say what we
- 44:41need to say, answer the questions, and move on
- 44:44to the next case. We're either going to go out
- 44:46and have dinner with our family. We're going
- 44:49to go to the gym. We're going to go in our man
- 44:52or woman cave at home and furiously play a video
- 44:56game for an hour, however you decompress. And
- 44:59I know people that do all of the above. Then
- 45:01when you're ready to talk about your safe responses,
- 45:03you don't have to reveal anything about your
- 45:06facts. You can say, you know, in cases like this
- 45:07generally, the response was whether it's response
- 45:11to the community or the respond the way the jury
- 45:14responded, ongoing investigation reveals. if
- 45:18you're being asked about why you changed your
- 45:20strategy. The most important thing now is now
- 45:24all of these are going to be acceptable if you
- 45:27are being interviewed by the news because you're
- 45:29not second guessing, doubting, saying no comment.
- 45:32You're actually delivering something that is
- 45:36ethical, effective, and doesn't jeopardize your
- 45:40post defeat duties of not saying anything you're
- 45:44not allowed to say about the case. All right.
- 45:48So you'll have all these in your written materials.
- 45:50You also want to make sure that you don't run
- 45:53afoul of the ethical rules that govern what you
- 45:56can and cannot say about judges. Now, I always
- 45:59like to have a little bit of drum roll before
- 46:01I go into rule 8 .1, 8 .2, the rules about what
- 46:05you can say regarding the judiciary, because
- 46:07most people think, oh, yeah, those are the rules
- 46:09that say you can't say anything negative about
- 46:11judges. But is that really what they say? Let's
- 46:15have a look. A lawyer shall not make, what, a
- 46:20statement, a truthful statement? No, a statement
- 46:23of fact that you know is false or with reckless
- 46:28disregard to truth and falsity concerning the
- 46:31qualifications or integrity of a judge, it goes
- 46:33on. But this portion of the rule in this rule
- 46:36is dealing about false statements of fact. Now,
- 46:41however, remember I told you how our current
- 46:43rules are one -stop shops referencing other code
- 46:47sections? This is a beautiful example of what
- 46:49I mean. One of my favorite rules, and I have
- 46:53lots of favorite rules, is business profession
- 46:56code section 6068 and subdivision B. Subdivision
- 47:00B goes further than 8 .2. Doesn't just say you
- 47:05can't say anything untruthful about a judge.
- 47:07It says you have to treat judges with respect.
- 47:11And it talks about maintaining the respect due
- 47:14to courts of justice and judicial officers. And
- 47:18I have to say, if you find yourself on vacation
- 47:20and you've forgotten what you were planning to
- 47:23read, whether it's a crime drama or a harlequin
- 47:26romance or anything in between, pull up the section,
- 47:30the annotations to 6068B. you will be mesmerized.
- 47:34If you ever see me at the pool at a conference,
- 47:37I'll be the one sitting there fully dressed,
- 47:40nylons and pumps, reading the annotations to
- 47:43one of these really interesting code section
- 47:46subdivisions because you can't make this stuff
- 47:48up. When you read through subdivision B, you
- 47:53won't want to make an off -color statement. Off
- 47:55-color, I don't mean racially off -color, but
- 47:57I mean disrespectful in any respect about a judge.
- 48:01You can make it go home and talk to your family
- 48:04members or talk to your good friends, but don't
- 48:06make it anywhere public. OK, so we're quickly
- 48:09going to talk about the last two prongs, which
- 48:13really the first prong was the biggie. These
- 48:15are just kind of a gravy and sort of positive,
- 48:18positive aspirational statements at the end.
- 48:22You want to rebuild your team. You want to take
- 48:24a minute to regroup. And that's important because
- 48:27supervisors. This is what I was talking about
- 48:29earlier. It's up to you to make sure that your
- 48:32troops know the rules. It is also up to you to
- 48:36make sure you have reasonable efforts to ensure
- 48:39that these people can learn the rules. I do have
- 48:43to say this is more relevant today than it ever
- 48:45was before because you have younger lawyers that
- 48:48are coming to your firm, whether you're a large
- 48:50firm, a small firm, and they're not coming intending
- 48:53to spend the rest of their career with you. They're
- 48:55building a portfolio. They're trying different
- 48:57types of law and you may have sort of a revolving
- 49:01door of associates that are coming. They're great.
- 49:04They're ready to go. They're hitting the ground
- 49:05running. They're on boarding with a lot of, you
- 49:08know, gusto, but they're not going to be staying
- 49:10there forever. So you may be going through training
- 49:14new associates more likely, more often than you'd
- 49:17probably like to make sure you know what Wolf
- 49:205 .1 says about that. Also make sure that everyone,
- 49:26no matter who you are, if you are any kind of
- 49:29a supervisor, you notice that this is phrased
- 49:31a little bit differently. If you have any direct
- 49:34supervisor authority, you also make those reasonable
- 49:37efforts to ensure that other lawyers comply with
- 49:41the rules and with the State Bar Act. That's
- 49:44the business of the profession code. Okay, so
- 49:47here's where I wanna get a little interesting
- 49:50and practical with you. I can't find you a rule
- 49:54that says you are supposed to bring a trial lawyer
- 49:58coffee when they don't get a Gregson court, but
- 50:01I don't need to, do I? Because part of being
- 50:03a supervisor is delivering that kind of support.
- 50:08So this is one of my favorite mugs in Hobby Lobby.
- 50:10I like to take my own pictures as I travel around
- 50:13because that way I can use them very easily.
- 50:15But we've all survived a meeting that should
- 50:19have been an email. If you're the boss, maybe
- 50:22you think about having meetings that could be
- 50:26done by email. Now, don't get me wrong. I think
- 50:28one of the parts of the pandemic that many lawyers
- 50:32had a tough time with is they felt like they
- 50:36wanted FaceTime with their support staff. I don't
- 50:39mean support staff being the people that are
- 50:40typing your motions or serving your subpoenas
- 50:43or putting out your discovery. I mean your peers,
- 50:46your colleagues, your supervisors. We really
- 50:50craved that ability to brainstorm a case in person,
- 50:54especially if it was a case we were worried we
- 50:56were going to lose. It's also true that part
- 51:00of our most memorable moments when we've lost,
- 51:04have been returning to the office and having
- 51:07our peers be there applauding for our efforts.
- 51:12I just overcome every time I think about that
- 51:15because I know you're thinking, gosh, does this
- 51:17lady win anything? Yes, but when you try a lot
- 51:20of cases, you also lose. And there's just nothing
- 51:24better than supportive peers, colleagues and
- 51:26supervisors that are waiting for you at 6 p .m.
- 51:30to come back from court to tell you how proud
- 51:33they are at the job that you did, regardless
- 51:36of the verdict. So we want to be that kind of
- 51:39a supervisor, that kind of a friend, that kind
- 51:41of a colleague to others. So back to the slide.
- 51:45Hopefully you don't recognize that that's your
- 51:48role after somebody has lost a case. You want
- 51:51to be the one that's on email or on text message
- 51:54saying, can I bring you a sandwich? over the
- 51:58lunch hour, because we all know where we're in
- 52:00trial. We don't get breaks. What's the lunch
- 52:01break for a trial lawyer? Counsel, you have until
- 52:051 .30 to write and file that motion. You've got
- 52:08the whole lunch hour to find your next witness.
- 52:11In other words, trial lawyers don't need to eat.
- 52:14So maybe you are that supervisor that says, hey,
- 52:16can I run down to Jersey Mike's and get you something?
- 52:18Can I bring you a cup of coffee? All right. I
- 52:20call that courtroom service. And then this is
- 52:23the other thing. If you really want to be a great
- 52:26supervisor, and fulfill your five series ethical
- 52:29duties, 5 .1, 5 .2, 5 .3. By the way, some of
- 52:33that has to do also with subordinate lawyers,
- 52:35but that relationship also requires good communication.
- 52:41I always say when it comes to loss, one of the
- 52:44things we wanna keep our eye out for is that
- 52:47loss doesn't turn into burnout. Lady justice
- 52:51is blind, supervisors are not. Make sure you
- 52:55know what burnout looks like because God forbid
- 52:59it Your firm happens to be one of those silences
- 53:03golden firms. Maybe you don't want to bother
- 53:05somebody right away You think well, they may
- 53:08need some time to themselves to process loss.
- 53:10Guess what? Then you're the one saying I would
- 53:13love to speak when you're ready. You let me know.
- 53:16I would love to talk about You know, let's brainstorm
- 53:19what happened. I've got a lot to tell you about
- 53:23what went right Gosh, isn't that the way to get
- 53:26somebody interested in going through loss and
- 53:29thinking about how can we maybe shore up some
- 53:32areas for the next time? So on that note, let's
- 53:36talk about what burnout actually looks like.
- 53:39Now, during the pandemic, we really couldn't
- 53:41tell who was burnout because nobody was in their
- 53:43chair. Nobody was at the office. But we'd also
- 53:46learned a little bit more about what is quiet
- 53:48quitting look like. And I wouldn't be really
- 53:52giving you a full presentation on loss if we
- 53:55didn't at least touch on what to look for. You
- 53:59know, the response to rise and grind, always
- 54:02doing more than you're supposed to be doing.
- 54:05Some people feel, whether it's true or not, that
- 54:08they work in a workplace where expectations can
- 54:11never be met. Now, a lot of the time we put those
- 54:15expectations on ourselves. That's not coming
- 54:17from our boss. That's coming from ourselves.
- 54:18That's internally motivated expectations that
- 54:22we can never meet. But that is even exacerbated
- 54:26more if that's possible after a loss. Let me
- 54:29tell you one other thing that we have to be very
- 54:31careful about as managers. We acknowledge excellence
- 54:36occasionally to the extent that sometimes it's
- 54:40demoralizing for people that think they can never
- 54:41meet that standard. So we do recognize, you know,
- 54:45you're passing a trophy around the office or
- 54:48whatever it is, however we recognize wins. But
- 54:51we also want to make sure, and we all know this,
- 54:54that we recognize hard work. And sometimes that
- 54:58means you're recognizing somebody that graciously
- 55:01lost a case after having worked as much as they
- 55:05could. You know, sometimes you hear bosses say,
- 55:08good bosses, if so and so couldn't win that case,
- 55:12Nobody could. That is a compliment. And that's
- 55:15a good boss. Now, it's also true that we all
- 55:18know people that lost cases because maybe they
- 55:20dropped the ball. Maybe there are things that
- 55:22they didn't do. Maybe they were juggling too
- 55:24many cases. You know what? That's a learning
- 55:27experience that many lawyers will make sure never
- 55:30happens again. Many good self -motivated trial
- 55:33lawyers, you know, I keep saying trial lawyers,
- 55:36no matter what you're doing, whether you go to
- 55:37trial or whether you're filing motions, or working
- 55:40to settle cases behind the scenes, you still
- 55:43can deal with loss and victory differently. And
- 55:47sometimes we respond to pure excellence by recognizing
- 55:49no two cases are the same. And a lot of that
- 55:52actually has to do with research. But one of
- 55:55the ways in which we notice somebody might need
- 55:57a little help dealing with loss is they are no
- 56:00longer trying as hard as they once did. They
- 56:03may be actually not trying hard enough all of
- 56:06a sudden. And that's where we really talk about
- 56:09recharging, focusing on the future. So these
- 56:13are the ways in which we can turn a loss into
- 56:16a positive path forward. We are not motivated
- 56:22by our loss in terms of just beating ourselves
- 56:25up for doing the wrong thing, making mistakes.
- 56:28We're internalizing, we're taking into account
- 56:30what could have gone better. We're mixing it
- 56:32with what we did do right, and we're focusing
- 56:34on the future. Tangible, positive. improvement
- 56:37oriented goals. Here is where we can actually
- 56:41use loss to promote future opportunities to win.
- 56:46We're updating. We are using different methods
- 56:49of information sharing. I cannot tell you how
- 56:52many cases get compromised because of discovery
- 56:55disputes, because we're not 100 % sure that the
- 56:59other side has everything that they should have
- 57:02that we've produced. in a fashion that they're
- 57:05able to receive all the discovery we've had to
- 57:08produce. We want to make sure we don't defensively
- 57:12overcorrect in the face of loss. We don't want
- 57:15to go so far off the deep end that now we're
- 57:18turning over things that we shouldn't turn over.
- 57:20We're disclosing confidential information accidentally
- 57:23or intentionally without reading through all
- 57:26the comments to rule 1 .6 confidentiality. We
- 57:30want to make sure we refresh existing strategies
- 57:33to an extent that's reasonable and not overkill.
- 57:37So we're reviewing policy in light of loss. We
- 57:41often don't review policy in light of win. We
- 57:44don't look after a win. You know what? We go
- 57:46straight down. Did we have a party to celebrate
- 57:49the win? We don't think about did anything in
- 57:52our current policies contribute to that loss.
- 57:56So in a sense, you might say the silver lining
- 57:58of loss is having an opportunity to re -examine
- 58:01the process. So that's true too. We also want
- 58:07to make sure as we examine loss and we move forward
- 58:10confidently that we have clear expectations as
- 58:15to what our subordinates need to do to ethically
- 58:17and effectively try their cases. We regularly
- 58:20check in with them. Do you have what you need?
- 58:22Do you know which staff member does what? If
- 58:25you're switching units or if you're doing a kind
- 58:27of case you don't often do, you may not instinctively
- 58:30know how to interface and engage. with different
- 58:33people on your team. So you're not going to ask
- 58:36because you may be thinking, what am I going
- 58:38to look like? I'm in violation of rule one point
- 58:40one competence. If I ask that question, what
- 58:42a silly question. I should know the answer as
- 58:44a supervisor. You can constantly check in to
- 58:47make sure you are over communicating the answers
- 58:50to questions that that subordinate lawyers might
- 58:54not want to ask. So that's the way in which you
- 58:56can communicate those clear resources. You want
- 58:59to promote collaborative decision making. You
- 59:01want to answer questions and issues immediately.
- 59:04You know, I always say incorporate attorney interests
- 59:07and skills. Why not have the luxury of actually
- 59:10working on cases that engage the skills you have?
- 59:14You enjoy using and that you're good at. I often
- 59:17say it's like on boarding new employees asking
- 59:21questions that sadly are sometimes only asked
- 59:24during exit interviews like. What would you like
- 59:26to be doing? What kind of cases do you want to
- 59:28work on? Tell me about the best boss you've had.
- 59:30Tell me about the worst boss you've had. Wouldn't
- 59:32it be great to know that at the beginning you
- 59:34might be working better together? And then I'm
- 59:37going to sort of bring it home. I always like
- 59:39to end on a high note. Let's return to the reason
- 59:42we wanted to be lawyers to begin with. Not a
- 59:45single person on this call took their attorneys
- 59:48oath thinking they were never going to lose a
- 59:50case. So we can continue to move forward. I also
- 59:54want to extend a personal invitation to any of
- 59:57you who would like to connect with me personally
- 1:00:00to talk about individual strategies to overcome
- 1:00:03loss, because I can tell you over the now over
- 1:00:0730 years I've been practicing, it has gotten
- 1:00:10easier and it has gotten easier because you practice
- 1:00:15for 30 years, you lose cases consistently and
- 1:00:19you learn to rebound, regroup. refresh, refocus,
- 1:00:24and continue moving forward. And that is what
- 1:00:27I would like to have happen for each and every
- 1:00:30one of you. So I hope you've enjoyed this program.
- 1:00:33Thank you so much for joining us, and best of
- 1:00:36luck to each and every one of you.