Latest / And Now For Something Completely Machinima / S6 E232 Machinima News Omnibus: AI Ghosts, Game Worlds & Creative Futures (June 2026)
Transcript
- Phil Rice 01:00 and welcome to And Now for Something Completely Machinima, the podcast about machinima virtual production and related technologies. My name is Phil Rice, and I'm here with my co-host Tracy Harwood. Tracy Harwood 01:12 Hello, Phil Rice 01:13 and Damian Valentine. Hello, Ricky Grove is off somewhere. I've run out of ideas, but he'll be back. Speaker 2 01:24 Well, Phil Rice 01:25 back soon. Tracy Harwood 01:25 Hang on. Is he not in Pittsburgh for Phil Rice 01:32 Lisa's thing? Tracy Harwood 01:33 Yeah, so Lisa, Ricky's wife, is receiving a lifetime achievement award for her contribution to horror writing, so well done, Lisa. That is awesome. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Congratulations. Tracy Harwood 01:50 So he has a legitimate excuse for not being here with us tonight, Phil Rice 01:55 and we see where his priorities are, Speaker 2 01:57 of course, Tracy Harwood 02:01 typical. All Phil Rice 02:03 right, we've got, we've got some news. That's what the theme is for today. So, a little bit of news to catch up on. Damian, why don't you start off with some items? Damien Valentine 02:12 All right, I've got a couple of things. First off, I'm going to start with the an AI thing, which I feel like this is possibly one of the okay, so people know I'm not a fan of AI, and stuff like this really does not help. It's a contract was signed between 11 labs and several different corporations who own the sound and likeness of Stan Lee, the Marvel comic book writer with the idea that you can use 11 labs to basically generate his voice and his image and incorporate them into anything, and it's open up to fans to do it. I believe it has to be non-commercial, but you know it's there, and I saw this. I thought, well, he's been.. he's passed away many years ago, and now some businesses who aren't even his family have just signed away that his voice and image, his face, to be used. And I feel like just let him rest in peace, because this is.. this is. this is not a nice thing to have done, and I've looked at some of the reaction from his, from the Marvel fan community, and they're not particularly thrilled about the idea either. I mean, he was quite famous, not just for the writing he did, but in the Marvel, he had a little cameo in many Marvel films, like you'd see him, like he'd be in the background, or he'd say one line of dialog to one of the characters, or something. It was just there, that's the Stanley cameo there, and it's just a little nod to have him incorporated, and of course, when he passed away, that was no longer possible. So it feels like now they're giving fans a chance to do that, but it's just I know, just feels really tasteless and horrible. Phil Rice 04:06 Was that, was that deal, Damian? Do you know, was it made with Stan's surviving family, or was it with Marvel? Damien Valentine 04:16 It wasn't with Marvel, it was I read it, and it wasn't his family, and it was two different corporations, but it wasn't Marvel or Disney, it was the Stan Lee something or other, I forget the title of it, because I read it to understand what was happening, and I did not want to absorb all of the information long term, but it was just two corporations that had the rights to his sound to his voice and his face, who had signed up with 11 labs to do this, and you know, I just didn't really like it that much, so I feel like this is a something I wanted to share, because you know it's, it's, it's a whole. Will use for AI. I know that there are.. I understand why the people do like AI for some reasons, even if I don't share those views myself. But this feels.. just.. I don't know. I didn't. Phil Rice 05:12 Yeah, it's creepy territory when you're dealing with, particularly when you're dealing with someone who's passed on, and this is.. it's.. it's something that's been been brought up as a concern a while ago, and now we kind of like to some sense, would we all knew that this day was coming when people would start to do this, and it is a little, it's a little on the creepy side. Yeah. Tracy Harwood 05:38 Do you think there's a question, though. Do you think, given what you've just said about Stan Lee himself actually wanting to be cameoed in various films, and what have you, do you, do you feel that these companies have done this for money or done this because they respect the way he popped up and desired to pop up in a, in a bunch of works, and maybe this is a way of carrying on that sort of approach and legacy. Damien Valentine 06:11 So, the article I shared has some quotes from some of the executives from these companies, and the way they were talking, it was that they're kind of patting themselves in the back for how clever they are. They can bring people back to life digitally, so I think it's more about the money and not about respecting what he would want to do, because you know they say, look at this technology, we can bring the dead back to life, and they can still fans can create stuff with them and things like that. It's not necessarily a. they didn't say we're doing it for money, because if they did that, that's not, yeah, they can't say that, Phil Rice 06:46 right? Yeah, but Damien Valentine 06:47 you could just, just reading it, you know, that's what was going through his mind when he was saying it, not he wasn't doing it because he thought this is something that Stan Lee would have really wanted, he was doing it because he saw a chance to make a load of money, interesting, yeah, Phil Rice 07:03 yeah, and he wouldn't have really been able to mean he passed away before he would have been able to really express much of an opinion on that, I would think, I mean, generative AI is going on, yeah, generative Damien Valentine 07:15 AI as we know it now did not exist when he passed away, so he wouldn't have had a chance to even say that these don't do my do this Phil Rice 07:26 right, Speaker 2 07:27 yeah, Phil Rice 07:29 yeah. Without his involvement, it does kind of, it kind of has a feel of like a grave robbing type of Tracy Harwood 07:38 exploitation. Yeah, Phil Rice 07:39 right, right. That doesn't, that that feels weird. Speaker 2 07:43 Yeah, he Phil Rice 07:44 very well may have said, you know, that was great, you know, but, but he didn't, yeah, he didn't. Right, right, huh. Damien Valentine 07:53 Well, it's, it's kind of similar, though. Um, James Earl Jones actually did agree to having his voice, he recorded things so AI could be used to create Darth Vader's voice after he passed away, and he has tints passed away. This is spoilers for anyone who hasn't seen the show yet, but Darth Vader shows up in Darth Maul, the Darth Maul animated show. He doesn't say a single line of dialog, because I think the creators of the show, they knew they had that option. They decided not to use it. He's there, he could have said things, and they gave some - they gave an explanation of why I didn't talk about saying, "Well, Darth Vader doesn't really care enough about the characters he's in the world with in this story to bother speaking to them? But that feels, yeah, it Phil Rice 08:43 seems kind of thin, doesn't it? I think it's more Damien Valentine 08:45 case of they didn't want to do the AI routes, even though they had the volition and everything they could needed to do it, they just didn't want to, Phil Rice 08:54 and it also makes me wonder, was there a reason for, let's say, that they did consider the option, and ruled it out, like we're assuming that it wasn't just that the script never had any lines for them in the first place, but let's assume that they did consider it. I wonder if what they were considering was personal feelings about it or potential backlash. Tracy Harwood 09:18 Yes, the backlash I would think that can be Phil Rice 09:21 fierce right now, yeah, Tracy Harwood 09:23 yeah, so it's almost illogical, I think. A lot of the backlash, actually, because we've had recorded voices of people in many other different forms that have been included in all sorts of things. I mean, you have home recordings of family members that have passed both image and sound, and you, you know, if you're gonna pull, you know, if you're gonna, you know, it's not uncommon, for example, for a parent who's passed away to leave a message for a child on their wedding day, so these are not uncommon things to use. It's more a case of what is the additional way that it's being used, and how is it being, how is the, how is the value of that character or that person being portrayed in whatever the new content Phil Rice 10:14 is. Yeah, who's cashing in on it? Tracy Harwood 10:17 I know exactly, and how is that being exploited? I think, yeah, Damien Valentine 10:20 because a parent who knows they're not going to make it to their child's wedding day, recording a message, they're recording a message for their child and Tracy Harwood 10:29 family, and you know, because it's usually shared at a wedding or something, isn't it? Damien Valentine 10:34 So, whoever's attending the wedding is going to see that, that's that's the audience, but it's different from, Tracy Harwood 10:40 yeah, Damien Valentine 10:41 having a recording of Stan Lee taking all those recordings he's done over the years, put them into training and AI on it, so that people can have him say whatever they want, that's that's that's a very different thing. Tracy Harwood 10:54 Yes, yes, yeah, I get where you're going with that. Yeah, I understand that. Damien Valentine 10:59 Yeah, right. So we'll leave that behind, because it's kind of a grisly subject to start with, and onto some more exciting things. So, as the weekend we record this, the Summer Gamers Fest is going on, and it's a series of live streamed events or pre-recorded events that are broadcast at specific times for various gaming platforms, we had the Sony PlayStation one. There's an Xbox one happening right now. There was the actual one called Summer Games Fest, which is on Friday, which is.. there's a lot of them. Anyway, I picked out a couple of games I saw news about that I thought were worth mentioning. So, first off, Dune Awakening, which is a game that we have talked about before, because it's actually available now, it's getting a console release. There's also getting a single player mode. Now, previously, this is a multiplayer online survival game set on Arrakis, and we've looked at it, and you know, you can create environments, you create your base, and customize your character, and build things up, and we've talked about how this could be a potential mission of a platform, because of the creativity that this game allows, but then there's also element of, yeah, but it's online, so when you go offline, your stuff is still out there for someone to come and blow up or steal, or whatever, and so you may find it's all gone, and I think Phil and I, we both agreed at one point that we like the sound of the game, but we don't like that element of someone that can mention our stuff. Well, they're adding a single player mode, and my understanding is they're also having it's not necessarily single player mode, but a closed group mode, so you can have a, like, a private server with yourself and fight. Yeah, I think that might already be available, but the single player mode is coming in, I think it's September, so you know it's only a couple of months away, and but both of those options make it a lot more appealing as a machinima platform, because you don't have to worry about the trolls or anything else, so you've got this June game, which is a sandbox environment with creative tools, and I hope to see people use these new features for making machinima, so I'll be keeping an eye out on it in September onwards to see what people do. Speaker 2 13:26 Cool, Damien Valentine 13:27 two game announcements I saw, and the trailers for Tracy. You, you will love this one. It's Alien Isolation Two. Speaker 2 13:35 Oh Tracy Harwood 13:38 no, Damien Valentine 13:39 I, I doubt this game is going to be of any use for Miss Shinera, because the first one really wasn't, but it's worth checking out just to look at or listen to, Speaker 2 13:52 or not Damien Valentine 13:53 the way they built the environment and the world, the sounds and everything in it is so much detail in it. They capture the atmosphere of the first alien film perfectly. They tell a very different story, but it feels like that world that they've got the corridors, the sound effects lifted from the film, or even the new sound effects they've had to add from the game. They feel like they belong in that world it's kind of got that retro sci-fi feel that from the 70s with like the video displays and there are things like to make the computer displays look trying to think of the right word here but to make it look like they weren't in good shape on the videos that they're being shown on it, like actual video footage, what they did is they would render it out and they would put it on a, they transferred the footage onto a VCR, and then they damaged the tape, and then scan that back in, so it look really, Phil Rice 14:57 wow, grimy, gritty, Damien Valentine 14:58 and obstacles. Yeah, that's what ended up being in the game, is after they gone through that process. So that first game is worth exploring, just to examine if you want to learn about atmosphere and world building sounds. Played that game, it's a terrifying game, so you have to keep that in mind, but that is one of the good things about it, is the amount of effort they put into, into the sounds and visuals and everything. So, I imagine the second game, it's the same company, the people who left Creative Assembly have gone back to it to work on this game, they're going to put the same amount of effort into this new game, so I'm excited for it, just for that, and even though this trailer is only like a minute or two long, you can tell that they're putting that kind of effort into it. And when I was watching the actual stream, it was on stage, and they had Lucy James, who's a games journalist, she came out on stage to introduce it, and she said, "You've been waiting 10 years for this, suddenly all the lights go out, and you hear this thunder clap, and the lights on the stage flash, and then the trailer starts. And even just doing that as a presentation was kind of getting the getting people excited, the atmosphere of it. So I wanted to talk about that. It's not machine at all, but it's something you can learn from. Then the next game is one I'm very excited for, probably to the point that I'm going to be really annoying people between now and the 23rd of August. It's a Star Wars game called Zero Company, and it's in the style of XCOM. Some of the same developers who left for Axis to create their own studio to make the Star Wars XCOM game, so you have customizable characters, you take them on missions, and it's kind of turn-based, so you have them there, you get your turn, you can move them whatever number of squares it is, I don't know, because you know they said that yet, but you can shoot something, and then the other side takes over, and you do that, but it's also going to be very cinematic, so when one of your characters does take aim, the camera is going to move down, and you're going to see them, and they're going to do that, and you might get shot from the other side, whoever they're shooting at is reacting, so it's you got that as a kind of cinematic, I don't think you can control the camera when it's doing those cut scenes, but you're going to get a lot of action there combined with the customizable characters, and I thought, well, you know, there's potential here for Mission Road, because you can create the characters you want, and you capture the footage, and you can put in your own dialog, or whatever you want to do, but I like XCOM style games. I like Star Wars, so I'm just excited for the game, but you know that cinematic thing is making me think, well, can maybe I can do something with this. So I wanted to mention that. And now there is one other game, new piece of news I have not put on the board yet, because I wanted to see reaction. But as we've been recording this, the Xbox stream has been going on. I've had it muted, so I don't necessarily know all the context, but I'm sure we'll all be very delighted to know that there's a remake of the very first Halo game coming. Tracy Harwood 18:19 Excellent, I Well, that will please. Speaker 2 18:29 Okay. Phil Rice 18:31 Oh man, my head was spinning. Like, what is it? What could it Damien Valentine 18:41 be? Sorry. I Phil Rice 18:44 wouldn't have guessed that. Yeah, that's that's not what I haven't guessed. Damien Valentine 18:48 As soon as I thought that was coming, I need to make sure that it's a genuine thing. I thought it's going to be on recording, I need to bring it up on the news report. Speaker 2 18:57 Okay, okay, Damien Valentine 19:00 so that's the conclusion of my news. Is Hado is coming back. Phil Rice 19:06 Thank you, Damien. Damien Valentine 19:08 I found following that. Phil Rice 19:09 You don't have, you don't have to pin that to the board. It's okay. Okay, so we've got some, we've got some mayhem coming, and that would be in the form of the Machinima Mayhem Contest, which is put on by Crowbar Productions. I'll just read a little bit from their sort of press release here, but Crowbar Productions is proud to present our third annual Machinima Mayhem, a three-month-long film festival showcasing the creativity and talent of the Bishop McComy. It runs from june 1 to August 30-first. So, at the time of that, we recorded this, it just started. Whenever you hear this episode, you still got plenty of time. Choose any game and forge your cinematic master. Piece within this year's genre, which is war. Now, it doesn't have to be just about war, but war needs to be the primary theme of it. But you can use any game. It does need to be a game, actually. There was one person on their Discord who asked, and I don't know if they were trolling or if they were sincerely asking, but hey, can I? I made a.. I'm working on a stick figure animation, can I submit that? And honestly, I don't know if it was a sincere inquiry, but no, you cannot, cannot enter a stick figure animation. You probably can't just.. you probably can't use iClone. This would. this is. this is specifically focused on game-based cinema. Yeah, Crowbar Productions, a lot of the, a lot of them work within Source Filmmaker, doing Half Life stuff, and Gary Spot as well. But I've been spending some time on their Discord, because I'm actually a judge. Speaker 2 21:00 Yes, Phil Rice 21:01 contest, yeah, Logan, the coordinator of it, reached out to me and asked me to do that, and yeah, so I'm going to, I'm going to be part of the judging there, so, but people are posting just kind of just their work to share with each other, not part of the contest, and there's people making stuff, of course, with GTA, and with, with some of the Call of Duty games, so there's.. I'm going to be watching that for possible picks to bring, bring here for us to look at for the show. Tracy Harwood 21:30 Oh, I look forward to seeing what gets submitted. I'm sure they'll get loads of exciting stuff. We've shown some of their work, their selections in previous years as well, so I'm really excited to see an actual contest being being run, and I really like the format that they've put together for this, this sort of, you know, extended period of time in which you can absorb the content, and I'm guessing it's an audience vote as well as a judge's vote, I Phil Rice 22:00 don't, I don't know, I know for sure that there's a judge vote, maybe they'll have like an audience favorite as well, but there is a prize pool, Tracy Harwood 22:07 yes, Phil Rice 22:08 of $1,000 which I assume gets split somehow between the first, second, and third place picks, so, and I've seen the, they actually showed a sample of what the judging form looks like, it's all very detailed and very well thought out. This is not their first year, obviously. This is Tracy Harwood 22:27 the third or fourth year, the third. Yeah, brilliant. Phil Rice 22:31 So, anyway, that's that runs from June 1 to August 31 If you have trouble remembering that, just remember that that is also the dates that the Reillusion character creator contest for 2026 runs june 1 to august 31 They're basically that is a character design contest. They have quite a bit in the way of prizes, as well. It is considerably more than $1,000 but the competition for this one is quite, quite stiff. Yeah, but hey, it's free to enter, so if you've got skills in that regard, go for it. Do something. I would recommend doing something innovative, something that you know is out of the ordinary, just just making a, you know, a imitation of a celebrity or something like that, that's probably not going to even, not going to rise to the top in this, the, you know, this is going to have some people who have fully designed their characters within Character Creator, and it's going to have some people who start it in Z Brush or a more advanced tool, and bring that in, so there's a lot going on there. All the details are available at a page on their site, which will link, but that's this is again this contest has been going on for several years, and it's kind of amazing some of the stuff that people make. So, yeah, if you've got, if you've got skills in that regard, give that a shot, and see how that goes. What else we got? Also, from Reillusion, they have kind of put out their, their video for this year, that is, it's kind of like a look-ahead video of, hey, here's what's what, here's what we're working on, here's what to expect to see, and this, this, this won't make Damien's day, but a lot of the emphasis, surprisingly, this is your payback Damien Valentine 24:30 for value thing, isn't Phil Rice 24:31 it? Is how AI is going to, you know, be available as something to enhance their tools. Now, actually, this use of AI is the most interesting of all to me, versus just generative make something without any effort, kind of thing. This, this is trying to leverage some of that tech within the context of these tools that we use to sculpt and create and craft, so I think. That's interesting, and maybe the maybe a thing that at some point you know people who feel the way Damian do might actually warm to it eventually, you know, because it doesn't detract, it doesn't take away a creator's job or role, and it doesn't make us less creative in the work, so that's worth looking at. If, if that's your bag, none of it is going to be mandatory, as far as I understand, that you can still continue to craft things the way that you do. These are just new enhancements that are going to be available. One such thing they're calling the AI AI Creator Studio, I think is what it's called, which is kind of a separate, kind of separate add-on app that, from what it looks like to me, it looks like a its main use would be in the realm of like a style transfer that you build your scene in Character Creator or iClone, you build it out completely, and then run it through this almost as if it's a filter, and it can enhance the style in different ways and turn it into a different look, that kind of thing. Transformative, basically. So that's interesting. If it would work on video, then it's. it's. How is that drastically different Speaker 2 26:22 from building Phil Rice 26:23 an iClone and rendering in Omniverse or in Blender or an Unreal, where you're going to do further enhancements, so it's one of those that kind of, it kind of starts to blur the line a little bit, so that'll be interesting to see what becomes of that. Speaker 2 26:37 Well, I can Phil Rice 26:38 go ahead, I can say Damien Valentine 26:39 I can add to that, it's actually already available. Phil Rice 26:42 Okay, Damien Valentine 26:42 between when this ad was added and now they released that, I haven't tried yet. I'm sure my understanding is if you try it now, you get like 1000 credits or something for free to give it, so I don't know what the deadline is on that, so by the time this goes out, that may have already passed, but yeah, if you do want to try it, do it quickly, because you can do some rendering with it for free before to buy the credits. Phil Rice 27:14 My understanding, too, is that the primary emphasis and use case for right now is leveraging rendering of still images, supposedly, Tracy Harwood 27:25 since Phil Rice 27:25 they've built their tool to latch on. You remember we didn't talk very much about Voice Box here, but I did a, I did a review of Voice Box, which is a local offline answer to 11 Labs, where you can, you've got a program you run on your computer, and then you can attach it to any one of several different text to voice engines, right? This seems like the same concept. The program, the AI Studio, is going to be there, but you choose whether or not to use.. I don't know, I don't use them enough to even know all of them by name, but mid journey or things like that, that you can latch into those things, so the challenge I think for it to be useful to to me, who doesn't necessarily have like a native objection to, you know, what I would consider proper non detracting uses of AI is the fact that it's always, I think, going to be credit-based, and so if it takes however many credits to render one still image, and I like to render my films in 60 frames a second, that's never going to be affordable for me, like it's not that's I don't want to add a new expense to my ledger, and I don't see how rendering a video, whereas I can render a video out through Blender or Unreal Engine or Omniverse, it doesn't cost me anything, and if then I just try it again, or I tweak something, I go back, I re-render to me, there's no matching that, so if it's going to always be the cost that we've come to associate with AI-generated or style-transferred images. Then, for me, that's just that's a non-starter. But we'll see how it goes. Damien Valentine 29:12 There was the other rendering option that they're going to add, which is I was hoping that was the one that's going to come first, whether they've struck up a deal with Nvidia to do the ray tracing rendering within, yeah, so you won't have to use Nvidia Omniverse anymore. You can just do it straight from iClone. Yeah, I'm really excited for that one. Phil Rice 29:34 I am too. I think that that's mentioned in the video that I've got here, where they're kind of laying out the roadmap, and that one was much more exciting to me too, yeah, yeah. Tracy Harwood 29:43 So, is Omniverse going then? Because I think I thought that was a key kind of platform that they're, Damien Valentine 29:51 no, Omniverse, as far as I know, Omniverse is still going to continue, but it's take the way I think it's going to work, because all we have to go on is the like. Many seconds in this video, it sounds like they've taken the rendering from Omniverse, and it's a plugin that's going to be it's for free. They've mentioned that, so you can render Omniverse within iClone without actually having to install Omniverse as a separate thing, which is good because they've changed the way Omniverse works, so you now have to download the code and compile it yourself before you can use it, which is a pain. So I'm still using a very old version of Omniverse, because I didn't want to have to mess with that. Sure. Speaker 2 30:33 Okay. Phil Rice 30:34 Yeah. Omniverse has kind of moved into, into the direction I think, just because that's where the demand is for like production houses and stuff, where they're actually going to be latching it on to their rendering pipeline, and yeah, so for solo creators like, like Dami and I, that's just not a Speaker 2 30:49 yeah, yeah, I get much Phil Rice 30:51 trouble to be worth it. So this is great to Tracy Harwood 30:53 me. The benefit of it always was team-based development of stuff, you know, because it sort of knits everything together, and everybody's contribution is in a pipeline, yeah. So that was always how I saw the benefit of that. So if that's going, that would be a real shame for studio, but Damien Valentine 31:13 it's still there, but you have to take the code and compile it to make it the piece the platform you want it to be. Yeah, and I did do that once, and it was such a hassle, and I couldn't figure out how to make it save the compile, so it seemed like every time I wanted to load up the software, I would have to compile it first. I'm just going to stick this old version that works just fine, not have to do that every time I want to load up the software, and I find it actually works best that because it's such a resource-heavy piece of software. After each render, I like to close it and start it up again. So, every time I do that, I don't have to compile it and then start it up again. I don't want that, because it's not a quick process. Speaker 2 31:59 It doesn't sound like it Tracy Harwood 32:00 suits your workflow at all, does it? Really, Damien Valentine 32:02 no. So this plugin, it's a free plugin where it does the ray tracing rendering within iClone, is making me very happy. I'm also hoping that it will allow things that don't necessarily transfer very well to Omniverse to work again. I'm thinking the soft cloth fabric and hair. I figured out to do it. It creates massive files because you have to export this model, and it does every single frame as saved, and so you get hundreds of gigabytes of just one object. So, I'll render the footage. Hope it's all right. Make sure it is now delete that object, because I, you just can't keep it Phil Rice 32:44 sure, Damien Valentine 32:44 so I'm hoping this means I don't have to do anything like that again, because it's all just done straight through iClone, and the other thing is the icon has a really nice particle effect system, I was using it for explosions and things before switching over to NVIDIA Omniverse, and those don't transfer to Omniverse, because I tried it, and you just get the little cube icon, little cube, where that's where the effect spawns from, but that's it. It doesn't do anything. Omniverse does have some nice effects in it, but you have to take some time to figure out how they work and position them, and all of that. So, again, it'd be nice to not have to deal with that. Tracy Harwood 33:25 Fair enough, but Phil Rice 33:26 I don't know about you, but like, when I'm, when I'm designing a scene in iClone, I like to, to light it as I go, sometimes, you know, because sometimes how it's going to be lit makes a lot of difference in, in how things are going to be laid out, you know, and the fact that whenever you take it to two omniverse, you basically, whatever you, whatever lighting you've done in iClone, it doesn't directly transfer, you have to, you have to do it differently, because lighting works different in there, and it's the same when you go to Blender, it's the same when you go to to Unreal, that you almost, I think, like people who you like Ben Tuttle, uses Unreal Engine for his outputs, and I'm pretty sure he does his set design and lighting and all that, all just in Unreal. He doesn't even bother doing it in iClone, but I wouldn't be able to do all that in iClone. I think that would be nice. So, Damien Valentine 34:13 yeah, I just.. and I'm working in iClone ever since I made the switch, I just light it enough so I can see what I'm doing, and that's it, and then soon as it goes over to Omniverse, I delete those lights and light it again from scratch. I should actually like doing that, because it's nice to see it coming together in the ray trace thing. But yeah, you can Phil Rice 34:32 build that, there's nothing extra at all. Yeah, well, then the result you get is, look, it looks really great. So yeah, whatever you're doing is working for you, Damien Valentine 34:39 but there are some limitations of that, like it's harder to animate lights and things like that, like if you wanted a flashing light, let's say on the bridge of a starship, and you get red alerts, so you want the lights to be flashing red on and off, icon, that's easy, you can do it in Omniverse, but it takes a lot more effort, you have to go to each frame, you have to keyframe. Each light, and say, well, here it's going to be at full strength, and then half a second later it goes back down to zero, and then half a second later it goes back to four, and so on. But you have to do that every single frame with iClone. You can just, you can do it once, and you just copy the keyframe moments, key Phil Rice 35:18 frames, right? Right, Damien Valentine 35:19 the end. So yeah. Yeah, all Tracy Harwood 35:25 right. So I'll close with just an article. Oh, go ahead. Go ahead. Well, I was gonna say I have got a couple of things I want to air, not least because I won't be around to discuss the pick that you made, Phil, where with which you're going to discuss with Ricky and Damon, Damian, when I, when I'm not around, but there's, there's a couple of things I want to sort of just touch on in relation to it, which I think I'll, I'll, I'll mention, and it has to do with some of the decisions that one or two governments are making about the availability of social media platforms now, without putting a spoiler on the discussion at all, that you're going to have what what Phil's picked for his choice this month is a compilation of TikTok shorts, some of which have been put together based on game engines, and some of which are riffs and memes and compilations of different things, and bits and pieces, and what have you, and you know, there's a couple of observations I'll make about it. One is because the compilation video that you've shared is separated from the platform on which it was created, it's kind of difficult to judge the, you know, the content in the round, shall we say, but the other is the implication that we seem now to face with the way that government's talking about we must ban social media platforms now the quality of the work that you are showcasing, and the discussions that we've had around content that has been created on platforms like TikTok over the last couple of years, I think has grown in quality exponentially. I mean, we touched on TikTok stuff a couple of years back, and we kind of concluded that actually it's rubbish. Generally, there was really, you know, there really wasn't a lot there to be enjoyed. The quality was naff, you know, there was nothing, nothing kind of going on. But what you've put together shows a different level of quality of work all together, and yet it's only available on TikTok now. I don't know who the creators of that work are, but my guess is there's an awful lot of younger people involved in that kind of creation. Now, TikTok, I think, has a sign-up audience of around 14, and a lot of the games that you might actually be making content from would have sign up ages suitable for younger people, and now he got government saying no, you can't access these kinds of platforms until you're at least 16 or 18 or 21 or whatever it is, because they're not suitable for your age group. Now, the question I raise with this is, and bearing in mind we talked about this young man's astonishing achievement a couple of weeks ago, is the example of King Parsons, who this summer is going to release probably the most successful film release that we will see over the summer. The back rooms, yeah, a back room. I'm gonna Damien Valentine 38:46 go see that on Tuesday. Speaker 2 38:47 Okay, yeah. Phil Rice 38:48 If, if Obsession, another film made by a very young YouTuber, Speaker 2 38:55 yeah, Phil Rice 38:55 doesn't beat it out at the box office. Speaker 2 38:58 Well, those are the Phil Rice 38:59 two leading films right now, it's astounding. Yeah, Tracy Harwood 39:02 I can't believe this, but Kane Parsons is what is he, is he, is he 20 yet? Yeah, Damien Valentine 39:08 like 22 now. All Tracy Harwood 39:10 right, well, he would have started using, you know, developing this sort of content, because we've been talking about that for what, three or four years at least, and it's, it's been around for several years, anyway. My point is, you know, the I think governments, when they talk about limiting the use of platforms for younger audiences who are incredibly creative, I don't think they've got any idea of the impact that this is likely to have on the development of creative practice going forwards, and yet they're quite happily saying, oh yeah, there's such a lot of bad stuff on it, we need to ban it. They're like throwing the baby out with the bath water, thinking about it in this way, and I'm disgusted that this is the kind of approach that they have to it. I really hope. That this does not get legs, and that you know young people can kind of pick up the tools, some of which you've demonstrated in that pick you have, and you know showcase the kind of creative talent that we've talked about for the year, you know, 20 odd years we've talked about the creative talent that's emerged from the likes of the machinima community, where whole new ways of creative practice have evolved, which are now informing, you know, established industries who are falling over themselves to try and develop work that you guys have been working on for years. It absolutely infuriates me that, you know, that they're thinking about it in this very narrow-minded way, so that's that's just really what I wanted to say. I don't know what other people think about that. I'm just, I just want to throw that out there, because I'm not happy about what what is being talked about. Damien Valentine 40:53 It's the latest incarnation of video games, teach teenagers how to go around shooting people, Tracy Harwood 40:58 absolutely. Damien Valentine 40:59 Or rock music goes is teaching people to be violent, or you know, it just goes on. It's just the latest version of that. I really hope it doesn't happen either. I do understand there's been some tragic incidents, so do Tracy Harwood 41:11 I, but I mean, I don't want to Damien Valentine 41:13 downplay that. I want to acknowledge that it's there, but I don't think blaming all of social media and limiting it for everyone is the answer. I mean, I've been online since I was 10 years old. Yes, I've had friends that people are still friends with, like I was talking to someone last night. I've known her since I was 12 years old, and she was 11. We're still friends now. We're really good friends, and we've worked on videos together. I've helped her develop a website. We've met in person many times, and that's she's a lifelong friend, and I hope that continues for many other years. I've learned about other countries from friends, like I didn't know anything about Finland or Sweden until I met some, made some friends from those countries, and they were telling me things about what it's like to live there, and you know, we grew up with watching the same TV shows, but they, they were translating to Finnish, and things like that, and you know, it's great being able to have that as an option to make friends online. I, yeah, there are horrible people online, but also plenty of really nice people online as well. And I think it's up to the parents themselves to keep an eye on what the child's exposing to. It's not up to governments to say what's suitable for the children. Tracy Harwood 42:25 Yeah, here, here. Anyway, I wanted to share that. Speaker 2 42:28 Yeah, Phil Rice 42:28 I mean, if you think about, like, you know, just the four of us on this show, we probably have combined close to a century of Tracy Harwood 42:39 small than a century fill of exposure Phil Rice 42:42 to video games. Right, well, I'm, I'm, I'm being, yeah, Tracy Harwood 42:46 generous. Phil Rice 42:47 Yeah, so let's say a century, a solid century of exposure to video games, and between the four of us, we've only killed less than 10 people, so it's really, yeah, the whole argument is just bunk, you know. Tracy Harwood 43:03 It is crap, so Tracy Harwood 43:04 it really is crap. Phil Rice 43:05 Yeah, anyway, yeah, I'm looking forward to.. so I'll leave that, you know, feed that Tracy Harwood 43:10 one into your discussion with Ricky, because I'm bummed that I can't join in that, because I think you've got some fabulous examples there, I'm, I'm, I think we've really got to start looking at TikTok more and seeing what folks are doing on that, because if that's the quality of what's coming out of it, I'm dead impressed with it. So, there you go, there's a teaser there, Phil Rice 43:35 and I had probably twice that many videos before I, before I called it down, yeah. It's, it's, there's no shortage of the content, so yeah. Damien Valentine 43:45 So basically, there's a second volume coming at some point. Phil Rice 43:48 I don't know, I kind of wanted to see what do you guys even think of this, you know, in the first place as an idea, because it's, and it's a little bit, little bit more laborious than just pinning a YouTube to our, yeah, our board. I kind of had to download all those and then edit them into and put them on Vimeo and stuff, so, but it was worth it, you know. Like, I just wanted it to where you can't really link to a playlist on TikTok, and not everyone uses TikTok, or can use TikTok, and I just wanted these to be able to be seen, you know. So, without taking anything away from the creators, I think that the way I did it, the attribution is pretty clear that if someone wanted to go look up that that creator on TikTok, they can from what's in the video, so we'll see. Tracy Harwood 44:32 Yeah, Phil Rice 44:32 so there's been a, there's been an article, or actually a collection of articles that have been compiled compilation over on Substack, the author's name or the compiler's name Alberto Romero, Romero, and it's basically how AI affects your brain, according to the studies, which basically the numbers are starting to come in as we're starting to get. A sense of what is the effect of this, these, you know, Chat GPT, and the like being out there and among us, and there's, you know, all kinds of theory about, you know, does it, is it making people dumber, is it making people, is it making people smarter, is it going to take away all the jobs in the world, all that kind of thing, and well, they're actually starting to do some real studies on on the measurable effects of regular use of AI for these things on the brain, and the result is actually not like many scientific studies, it would seem not terribly surprising, not terribly far off from what common sense would tell you, which is, and I love this quote, which was pulled from that AI can make what you produce better while making you worse at producing it. I think that that's actually now Damien would probably argue with the making what you produce better, but I think you get the notion right that Damien Valentine 46:08 it is Phil Rice 46:09 possible to make something pretty with with AI, which is a that's already a step forward from three years ago, when all you could say was it's possible to make something pretty weird with AI, and now it's actually, you know, okay, so that's not the argument anymore. It's not that all the hands have six fingers, six fingers, that's not the problem anymore. Now it's okay, it's actually getting better at what it does. I think that's good, because now we can take that off the table. That wasn't ever the problem, that wasn't ever the the moral conundrum we need to deal with with this, it's where is this going to fit, you know, into our lives, and how much of our creative capacity, or creative crafting, if you will, should we be outsourcing to a machine, you know, and that's something that I think each creator has to contend with, you know, and this is an interesting study in that regard, Tracy Harwood 47:05 of you drawing it on a pad hundreds and hundreds of times and flicking it in front of a camera like the old-fashioned animator, you're using machines all the time. Yes, Phil Rice 47:18 yes, but none of those machines are making my ideas, Tracy Harwood 47:22 okay. So it's purely the idea. They're not, Phil Rice 47:25 I think, the ideas is where it's the most controversial, if you will. You know that there's something to be said for, even for drawing one's own storyboards. You know that there's something to be said for that human interaction of whether you're doing digital or on paper, whatever, even there's something about that process that's important, and there's something about the process of creating that is the process itself is the reason to make art, you know, not the clicks, not the views, that doesn't give you anything lasting, you know, that's a little dopamine hit, maybe, or or a cause for extreme depression when nobody clicks or likes, you know, you can't, you can't hinge your, your emotional well-being on that, but if, but enjoying the process, you know, getting something out of the process, and that's the part that we're talking about. Well, let's just outsource that, you know. So now we just sit and, you know, lounge on a sofa, and we don't even do the create part. So that's the part that I think where it can be dangerous, but on a practical basis, it's that getting AI to do that, working on art makes you better at art. That's like a hard and fast formula. Working on it makes you better. It doesn't guarantee to turn you into, if you're painting a Michelangelo, it doesn't, it doesn't guarantee that outcome. But what it does say is that you will get better at it by working on it, and I think what this is, is calling some attention to is that using that, not working on it, makes you worse at it. If that makes sense, that just letting someone else make the music, or make the image, or make the film, you get no better at anything doing it, and I think that with its, with, with regards to its role in education research, that that's something to be aware of as well, that I think AI is a tremendously valuable research tool, but, but we can't let it do our thinking for Tracy Harwood 49:38 us. Oh no, it doesn't, Phil Rice 49:39 or we get dumber, right? And, but the tendency is to, well, why not? It's offering to do that. Let's just, yeah, why not? That's why not. Tracy Harwood 49:49 It's, it's a co-creative tool. I mean, I use it, obviously, and I use it fairly regularly, but it's more of a conversational. Real agent for me, where I'm exploring concepts, and I'm looking for different, different perspectives, but because it, so it doesn't write anything for me, Phil Rice 50:13 right, Tracy Harwood 50:14 but it, it helps me question what I'm thinking in some ways, but it doesn't give me the answers, if that makes sense. Phil Rice 50:25 Yes, and even if it did, we shouldn't be taking the answers without Tracy Harwood 50:31 no, no, no, without Phil Rice 50:32 verifying, right? Yeah, no, I agree, that's how I use it as well. Tracy Harwood 50:36 Yes, that's exactly every day, but I will tell you that I have colleagues who have been working in computational processes in art. I mean, obviously you're aware, and the director of the Art AI Festival here in the UK, and have been for over five years, but a lot of the people that we showcase within that environment are established artists who adopt the tools, and they will argue many of them will argue that the tools enable them to explore a greater range of potential options, from which they then make a selection to develop their work, and so they're using the tools in a range of different ways, but it's not to replace them in any way, shape, or form. It is purely as a tool set to help them explore their own practice, and that's been a theme that's been very common among those, and you know, a lot of the artists that I'm talking about would be people, for example, Ernest Edmonds, who was one of the founders of the computer arts movement back in the 1960s and he's very clear that that's how these tools operate best, they're not replacing him in any way, they're tools that he harnesses that give him new ways of looking and exploring the options that he cannot himself possibly generate enough of in order to come up with the same ideas, Speaker 2 52:13 that's how he does it. Damien Valentine 52:15 I've been looking at that quote, Phil, and what comes to mind is taking a piece of paper and a pencil and drawing a stick figure as some actual art, comparing it to typing into an AI. Say, I want, let's say you have the two stick figures and they're holding hands or something, that's like a very basic romantic scene. You go to an AI image generation tool and you tell it, I want this two people holding hands, and then it generates an image, photo realistic, all the details, everything is a big nice sunset in the background, or something, but you didn't create that, you just typed it in, whereas the stick figure you drew yourself, even though it's not as visually impressive as the AI-generated image, but that's what's coming into my, it's a very extreme example of that, but yeah, and but if you keep drawing those stick figures, you'll start thinking, well, actually, maybe I could do something in the background, and then your next one, okay, I'm getting better at this, maybe I'll some color, and you do the sunset as a sky, and over time you'll get better at it, but if you just type it into the AI, you'll get obviously better than what you're starting out with, but you'll never get better at drawing the stick figures yourself. Phil Rice 53:32 Yeah, that's the bare bones, that's that's that's what it is. Yeah, I think also, though, a case could be made for if I have a musical idea, and I pick up a guitar, or I sit down at a piano, and I work out on the piano, what the idea is, was I off, was I offsourcing my creativity to the strings and pedals and pans and keys on the piano, it's just a tool that I was using. I can't make the sounds of a piano, no matter how hard I try, no matter how much I practice. If I don't use that piano, I'm not going to get a piano sound. And I think that what Tracy's saying is that there are artists who are learning to wield AI as a musical instrument, so to speak, that it is something that they have learned how to play it, you know, so as a thing that they, they know how they've learned how it works, so that they can get it to make a sound. I'm going way metaphorical here, but you get the it's an instrument, and without that, you know, without that musical instrument, I can't sit here and make a guitar sound. I mean, I could, I'd sound really stupid, but it's never going to be like a guitar, you know. So, it's even, it's even at a more fundamental level than just getting good at guitar or getting good at writing. A story or getting good at drawing a stick figure, it's about I think that we're where it actually matters is in that stick figure analogy that you were talking about. AI is the pencil, AI is not Tracy Harwood 55:16 the absolutely, Phil Rice 55:17 and drawing, you can't draw that without something to draw with, but you have a lot of choices of what to draw with. You could use a marker, you could use a Crayola crayon, you could use a pen, you could use blood, you know, you could use dye. You know, people have been drawing for how many 10s of 1000s of years? Maybe you could Tracy Harwood 55:36 use a camera, Phil Rice 55:38 or you could use a camera. Speaker 2 55:39 Oh, Phil Rice 55:40 so I get the, I get where that's coming from. What makes AI different is that there's no way for a camera Tracy Harwood 55:51 to make it to Phil Rice 55:51 invent or to simulate invention, right? There's no way for a film camera to do that. There's no way for a piano to invent or to simulate invention, you can have a player piano that will take a human performance and play it back for you, but that's not the same thing, right? And what AI does is it goes out and steals all the player piano performances that have ever been done and improvises on it and calls it creation, that's a problem, right? It may end up being a really interesting result, like, oh, wow, I haven't heard that sound before, and if you try it enough times, hey, try that again, eventually it spits out something that, wow, that's actually a little bit melodic, and so then that's that's what Suno is, you know, it's just that it's gotten really good at guessing what sounds good from all the feedback that they farmed from us. So, yeah, I think I think AI, what it's going to come down to is that we understand it as a tool in, in our toolbox, Speaker 2 56:58 and not, not as Phil Rice 57:00 a neural interface, so to speak, Tracy Harwood 57:02 I agree, but also what it will come down to, I believe, is the ethical and moral stance that is instilled in each of us as creative practitioners, and that I think is where we're having to play catch up at the moment, because it's very easy to use these tools as the means end, and in fact, an ethical stance, responsible stance, is to use it as a tool, and there's a lot of folks that are not well, Phil Rice 57:30 and they're being, they're being, they're being marketed as a means end. Tracy Harwood 57:34 Absolutely, Phil Rice 57:35 people are being totally encouraged to do that, and to pay money for the privilege of doing that, Tracy Harwood 57:40 but people have got to wake up about that, I think, and right, that's the bit where I think there's the learning to be Phil Rice 57:46 done. Yeah, I agree. I think maybe my theory is that a lot of the distaste that is built up around AI for Damien and for others is the end result of that marketing of these tools as an end and encouraging people to do that, and that's what has generated what we all refer to as AI slop. That's what thoughtlessness will.. that's what it looks like, you know. And yeah, I doesn't mean that the tool isn't good, it's that, you know, you don't use a saw to bang in a nail. Tracy Harwood 58:22 We've got a bunch of lazy and bad actors that we're dealing with, is what you know. Speaker 2 58:26 Yeah, Tracy Harwood 58:27 we get that with everything, don't we? Speaker 2 58:30 Yeah, Tracy Harwood 58:31 so yeah, I think there's a lot of lessons to be to be learned, and I think actually the machinima community is actually the really good community on which to, you know, from which to draw in terms of thinking about this, because they've learned the hard way about how to be creative, they've learned the hard way about what authenticity and originality is, because of the way the content has been drawn from games, which is not, you know, we've long debated the IP and the copyright issues around the creation of transformative kind of works, and I think there's a lot to be taken from that learning into the this domain that we're looking at now. It's not a straight shift, but I think I think there's lots of merit in thinking about it. Phil Rice 59:24 Well, even on a metaphorical level, if you think about making machinima in games in a simulated world, and you know the Sims behave in a way that you didn't expect them to, they seem to kind of have a mind of their own, and they improvise, they hallucinate. How is in what sense is that not AI really? Speaker 2 59:48 Yeah, Phil Rice 59:48 as in terms of its effect on the creative process, you know, if you're, if you're filming machinima in a GTA city, there's a lot of elements. That are just there is an intelligence of programming behind them that they're behaving in this way, and things go unexpectedly, and stuff. So, there's a comfort level with leveraging other people's IP to make your own stuff. We all have done it. Anyone in Machinima has done it at some point, you know. And then also some of the behaviors that are going on are not all neat and controlled like they would if you built it all yourself in iClone, you know, so yeah, I think machinima is a place where people have cut their teeth on and built their craft while being surrounded by issues that are very analogous to what AI is, yeah, and that maybe they'll lead the way on, or be some of the leaders of the way on how to properly integrate this, and you know, Tracy Harwood 1:00:57 I miss Hugh's voice in this conversation, oh yeah, Speaker 2 1:01:03 because he was really Phil Rice 1:01:03 interested to hear what he had to say. He Tracy Harwood 1:01:05 would have really been fascinating to listen to on these debates, I think. Yeah, anyway, Phil Rice 1:01:12 well, yeah, that's our news. So we kind of, we, we started on a really down and we kind of ended on a down note somewhat, but I think there's reasons to be optimistic, and if nothing else, the films that we keep seeing come through our boards on this show are a reason to be optimistic. There's a lot of great creativity going on out there, and it's exciting. If Damien Valentine 1:01:37 you want to end on a positive note, the Halo remake is getting released on the 28th of July. Speaker 2 1:01:44 Great. Oh, I Damien Valentine 1:01:49 just looked at the release date, just for so we could end on that. Thanks for sharing that. Tracy Harwood 1:01:54 I really Phil Rice 1:01:54 let me look down. What do you think about topics? Yeah, what do you think about Halo and these other topics? Let us know with a comment wherever you're watching or listening to this, or drop us an email, talk at Completely machinima.com My name is Phil Rice, and on behalf of my co-hosts, Damian Valentine and Tracy Harwood. We will see you next time. Bye, bye, Speaker 2 1:02:19 bye. Speaker 3 1:02:23 and now for something completely and 1:02:25 now for something completely and