Latest / Shades of Jade Podcast / Why Foreign Aid Can't Be Abandoned: A Conversation with USAID Veteran Clifford H. Brown
Transcript
- 0:10Hey everyone, my guest today is Clifford Brown.
- 0:14Clifford gave up his career as a partner in a Beverly Hills
- 0:17commercial law firm and his dream home over the ocean to
- 0:20pursue what became a 27 year adventure in foreign aid, both
- 0:24as a legal adviser and then senior manager.
- 0:27His tales of USAI DS work during civil chaos in Haiti, Honduras,
- 0:32Nicaragua and Guinea, his first hand views of the dilemmas USAID
- 0:37lawyers deal with, the difficulties in persuading
- 0:40farmers to grow cocoa instead of coca, and the bureaucratic rain
- 0:44dance required to start new programs provide an enlightening
- 0:48overview of the world of international foreign aid.
- 0:51As he puts it, at a time when spirituality is at an all time
- 0:55low in human history, foreign aid reflects our better angels.
- 0:59All right, welcome to the show Clifford.
- 1:02I want to thank you for being here today.
- 1:04And for? Having me, I'm I'm happy to talk
- 1:06about. Yeah.
- 1:08State and anything else you want to talk about.
- 1:11Perfect. Yes.
- 1:12I was wondering if you could tell the audience a little bit
- 1:15about yourself and what brings you here today, what you're
- 1:20working on and what's driving you right now.
- 1:25Well, early in 2000, I'm a retired Foreign Service officer.
- 1:29I was a mission director for USAID.
- 1:33That's the US Agency for International Development.
- 1:36It used to be called AID, the Agency for International
- 1:40Development. That was a cute pun because it
- 1:42didn't mean aid, although that's what we did it.
- 1:45It was our fault aid agency and it was, it was the agency that
- 1:49was created in the 60s by John F Kennedy.
- 1:52And I, I was a, a lawyer in Los Angeles in the late 80s when I,
- 1:59I worked on a big case. And when it ended, I, I saw an
- 2:03ad they wanted attorneys that had a foreign language And I
- 2:06spoke Spanish at the time and still do.
- 2:08But I flew back to DC and I interviewed with them and I saw
- 2:12this big map on the wall and they had little pins all over
- 2:15the world on the maps. And I said, what are those?
- 2:17And he said, that's where our attorneys are.
- 2:19And I said, well, I got to have that job.
- 2:20So I literally gave up 2/3 of my income.
- 2:23I was a partner in a Beverly Hills firm.
- 2:26I joined the foreign aid agency. I went overseas.
- 2:29I was overseas for almost 27 years working on a huge variety
- 2:34of programs. About halfway through my career
- 2:38I was converted to full scale diplomat.
- 2:40When I first joined one of my my son had a had a heart issue.
- 2:45He couldn't get a full clearance.
- 2:47So I wasn't an official diplomat until about halfway through my
- 2:50career. But I rapidly rose them to the
- 2:53level of mission director, which is as high as you can go in the
- 2:56field. And I spent most of those years
- 2:59overseas. I was in Africa for three years
- 3:02to start with. Then I spent nine years in Latin
- 3:08America, Central America, Colombia.
- 3:10Then I went to Central Asia and I was the mission director in,
- 3:16in, well, the country representative they called it in
- 3:18those days. And to Kyrgyzstan.
- 3:20I was there for the Tulip Revolution.
- 3:23And then I, I became the director for programs in West
- 3:29Africa, Guinea, Sierra Leone. And after that I, I, I retired
- 3:35in 2009, but I got bored in retirement and I went back
- 3:38overseas as AI went to Peru and I was there from 2013 to 2016.
- 3:47I came back to the, to the DC area.
- 3:49That's where I am now. I'm retired, but I, I was
- 3:53totally offended earlier this year when, well, last year when
- 3:57Elon Musk and Donald Trump said it was a bunch of crooks and
- 4:01they were corrupt people who were, who were wasting our
- 4:05money. So they, they fired everybody.
- 4:08Most of the people got fired were not Americans.
- 4:10They were overseas staff. Most of our missions had far
- 4:14more locals working for us than, than Americans.
- 4:17But it's, it was a tragedy in my view.
- 4:21And I can, I can get into why. Why?
- 4:24Yeah. I could do.
- 4:25I'm trying to get the word out about what a what a terrible
- 4:28thing that was to destroy that agency.
- 4:30Yeah. So, so from we, we kind of
- 4:35discussed this before recording, but from, from my understanding
- 4:38is that there was fraud that did exist, but there are also a lot
- 4:42of good programs that people really relied on.
- 4:47And I know Elon Musk himself later said that we something
- 4:51along the lines of we approached this with a hatchet and moving
- 4:56forward after they started getting criticized for being so
- 5:01aggressive. You know, you said moving
- 5:03forward, we'll we will be using a chisel instead of hatchet
- 5:07basically. But it was kind of too late for
- 5:12a lot of things like that was months later.
- 5:14And I'm wondering what got cut that shouldn't have been, you
- 5:21know? Well, let, let me just spend a
- 5:24few minutes saying what what it was that we did.
- 5:26And, and I'll just by saying that we didn't cook up these
- 5:30programs. These were things government,
- 5:33the Congress wanted us to do overseas.
- 5:36The executive branch wanted us to do these, these projects and
- 5:39the State Department always had approval rights and they got to
- 5:43weigh in on what it was we were going to do.
- 5:46And many times the congressmen themselves would, would write
- 5:49earmarks that said, you said we'll do this or that.
- 5:52Now what did we do? It spans the entire range of
- 5:57human activity between the military and what an embassy
- 6:01does, an embassy primarily there to, to to establish, set up
- 6:05meetings and, and pass information back and forth.
- 6:07And you all know what the military does, but everything in
- 6:12between. Let me just give you just a few
- 6:14examples so that you get a sense of the variety of what we did.
- 6:19People know about the humanitarian responses.
- 6:21You say it was the Home for the Office of Foreign Disaster
- 6:24Assistance. So every time there was a
- 6:25disaster, we had people and, and supplies and other things posted
- 6:31in different places around the world where we could go in with
- 6:34water, with tents, with, with portable bathrooms and, and food
- 6:39supplies and whatnot. And we could respond to
- 6:42earthquakes and, and tsunamis and forest fires and you name
- 6:47it. And smoke was coming into Texas
- 6:50from Florida and I'm coming into Texas and Florida from forest
- 6:54fires in Central America. You said got the call when the
- 6:59Colombian or most of the governments in Central America
- 7:01wanted to train their judicial systems to do trials instead of
- 7:06the way they did it in the past, which is all basically just
- 7:09paperwork. They would agree with us that we
- 7:12would bring in people that could train them how to do jury
- 7:15trials. When the legislators in the
- 7:18former Soviet Union wanted to set up laws that would regulate
- 7:23commercial activity, since central planning was no longer
- 7:27what they did, then they they asked you say, to bring in the
- 7:30accountants, bring in the people to train the businessman to, to,
- 7:34to set up modern accounting systems.
- 7:37When we were working in in Central America, we created
- 7:43entire industries down there. We, for instance, we sent a
- 7:46shipment of onions that we grew as an experiment in Honduras to
- 7:50Miami. And we proved that you could
- 7:53grow onions in the mountains of Honduras and you could market
- 7:58them in the US at a time when we didn't have fresh onions here.
- 8:02And 10 years after we did that, we had half a million people
- 8:06making their livings, growing onions.
- 8:08And then we did that with flowers in Costa Rica and
- 8:11Colombia. We did it with melons and
- 8:13cantaloupes. We did it with shrimp farms,
- 8:15strawberries, with snow peas. We created entire industries
- 8:20that employed many people who otherwise, you know, seek to
- 8:24emigrate to the US to come up here to to live.
- 8:27But we also in doing that created a lots of jobs for
- 8:31Americans right here, products that wouldn't be available now.
- 8:37When the Ebola broke out in Africa, it was you say it got
- 8:42the call to go down there and, and it, you know, investigate
- 8:48the method of burying the bodies and, and, and give protective
- 8:51clothing to the health workers. Ice prices shot through the roof
- 8:56in 2007 in West Africa where I was.
- 8:59We facilitated the delivery of emergency food supplies to these
- 9:03people. We would investigate tropical
- 9:06diseases. We would teach teachers how to
- 9:09teach kids how to read. We would introduce new systems
- 9:14to prevent corruption in the procurement systems in these
- 9:17governments when they asked for that kind of help.
- 9:20And I could go on and on. I could spend days in the kinds
- 9:25of things we did. The other thing we did is we
- 9:28collected information over something like since the 1960s,
- 9:32we had a vast trove of information about these projects
- 9:36and about conditions in these countries centered in something
- 9:39called the Center for Development Information and
- 9:42Evaluation. That higher library is gone.
- 9:47Yeah. All of that information is no
- 9:49longer available to academics. We've got websites now that
- 9:54track the number of kids who are dying from malaria, from other
- 9:58diseases that we were combating and we were fighting.
- 10:01So, you know, it's, it's, it's hard to describe the scope of
- 10:09what it was that we did, but it's all done.
- 10:12And, and the way they did it was crazy because when you terminate
- 10:16programs, you got people out there, you got supplies and
- 10:19route, you got other things. You create a lot of claims
- 10:22against the US government that are going to get paid right.
- 10:26As for the fraud and the waste, it's absolute nonsense to say
- 10:31that the usage staff was corrupt there.
- 10:34We had bad actors here and there like every agency does.
- 10:38And they there are people that did go to jail for different
- 10:41crimes they committed. I mean, it was a was a big
- 10:43operation over many years in many countries.
- 10:46So, yeah, there were a few examples, but it's no more than
- 10:49any other federal agency. I was so offended.
- 10:54I gave up 2/3 of my income to join that age.
- 10:57Most of the staff were, some of them, they were very idealistic
- 11:01folks. They, we had a lot of former
- 11:02Peace Corps volunteers. These people could have made a
- 11:05lot more money in the private sector, but they used to work in
- 11:08this area. So that's what inspired me to.
- 11:11I wrote this this book about it that called Inside You Say.
- 11:14But yeah, my basic message is that was a tragedy.
- 11:18I hope it gets reversed. Yeah.
- 11:22So, OK, so I'm going to work backwards a little bit.
- 11:27You mentioned information disappeared and I remember
- 11:31reading about that. How do we know how that
- 11:33disappeared? The website shut down, it was
- 11:36all stuff available online and you can't get into that website.
- 11:40Hopefully that data is out there somewhere.
- 11:43And if, if we have a, a different, a change of heart
- 11:46within our own government, we can, we can set it up again.
- 11:50I, I did want to say a little bit about Elon Musk.
- 11:53And, and perhaps because I, I'm a personal friend of the guy
- 11:57that was the mission director in South Africa in the early 90s
- 12:01when the anti apartheid movement, that was a movement
- 12:04that we supported. I mean, that was one of the many
- 12:07things we did. We supported NGOs and other
- 12:10people there who were fighting the apartheid movement.
- 12:13While Elon Musk was a young white man in, in South Africa at
- 12:17that time, My friend was the he later became the director of the
- 12:22Peace Corps. But at the time he he was there
- 12:24when Nelson Mandela got out of jail, he met the man and
- 12:28apartheid did come to an end in South Africa.
- 12:31And his theory is that Musk had a personal bone to pick with
- 12:35against USAID because he didn't appreciate our work to to fight
- 12:40apartheid. That's very, I don't know that
- 12:43for a fact, but I do know that we did.
- 12:46We did support that anti apartheid movement and it was
- 12:50the white S Africans who basically lost control of the
- 12:53country. And it's run by the majority,
- 12:56the black. Pop Yeah.
- 13:00And so also at the beginning, you, you had mentioned that the
- 13:04stuff that you, that you guys do, a lot of it is approved by,
- 13:09by Congress and other politicians.
- 13:11So to me it, it sounds like you say it as being the is, is being
- 13:21placed the scapegoat on certain things.
- 13:23Like if they if they didn't think that some of that spending
- 13:28was appropriate, then then why was it approved by Congress?
- 13:33Well, exactly, I don't. See what I'm saying?
- 13:35More of a political stunt it was.
- 13:37A Yeah. Give me one example.
- 13:38People in the US have always had an inflated view of how much we
- 13:42spend overseas on foreign aid. Foreign aid was a drop in a very
- 13:48big bucket. One year there were two planes
- 13:51that went down. AB1 bomber crashed in Montana
- 13:55and AB1 bomber crashed in Texas. Now I remember that year I
- 13:59looked at each of those planes. Each one cost more than $500
- 14:02million That's that number is more than all of our foreign aid
- 14:08to all of sub-Saharan Africa in each of those years.
- 14:11So each plane was more than what we gave what and when I, when I
- 14:16say Gabe, what we would do is hire Americans to go there and
- 14:22teach people there were there was stuff provided, yes,
- 14:26certainly big infrastructure projects, but those were in
- 14:30places like Afghanistan and Sudan and where we, I mean, Iraq
- 14:35and Afghanistan, Pakistan, where I work, most of our budget was
- 14:40for staff and the staff were they were Americans that went
- 14:43out there to work on these projects.
- 14:45We had implementers, you know that they were NGOs, they were
- 14:48universities, they were there. And there's also a lot of
- 14:53consulting firms that got in on that too.
- 14:55I mean, it's a big, it's a big business.
- 14:57Frankly, it's not nearly as big as a military industrial
- 15:00complex, but it was a big employer of a lot of Americans,
- 15:04so we didn't hand money away. Yeah.
- 15:08And, and you said that you mentioned the Peace Corps, They,
- 15:11they work with you too, or worked with?
- 15:13We are well they, they're a separate agency and the
- 15:16volunteers in most of the countries I was posted, yes, we
- 15:20had a Peace Corps program and the volunteers actually very in
- 15:25a way they were the farm club for.
- 15:27Long. Times we needed contractors and
- 15:31the Peace Corps volunteers would often apply to us for for jobs.
- 15:35It was a different lifestyle for them because they were out in
- 15:38the villages working with families and local communities.
- 15:43We were in the capital cities, at least our offices were I
- 15:47mean, obviously we got out in the field a lot.
- 15:50We did a lot of field trips and whatnot and the peace for
- 15:52volunteers were quite useful to us sometimes because they they
- 15:55knew these communities, they were living there already so
- 15:59they could interview us to people and, and we could fund
- 16:02things that they didn't have the budget for so.
- 16:04Yeah, one of my, one of the people I went to school with,
- 16:09she was in the Peace Corps and I know she was in Africa teaching
- 16:13them how to farm and be sustainable.
- 16:18And I believe that had to get shut down for COVID because she
- 16:22was not there the entire time. And it was everything was just
- 16:25crazy back then. But I do, I do think that those
- 16:30those programs are important, are important to me.
- 16:33And it's I think that they get ignored where, you know, there
- 16:40are there's people on the right will say, like, we don't want to
- 16:44be sending money to other countries.
- 16:46We don't want to do, you know, blah, blah, blah.
- 16:48Well, if we can help these other countries to be to farm to to
- 16:55provide their own resources or, you know, then then they won't,
- 17:01I guess, rely on people as much. But what you mentioned too, was
- 17:06that they, they have stuff to offer us as well, like the
- 17:09growing crops that we can't grow year round here in the United
- 17:13States, or at least in certain areas.
- 17:17I think, I think there's too much of a mindset of, again, I,
- 17:23I, I do like our country to be fiscal, but I do want our
- 17:27country to have a heart, you know, And I think that there's
- 17:29too much of A mindset now where it's almost like it's, I don't
- 17:38want to call it selfish, but I think people are kind of
- 17:42forgetting what we have and how we can benefit from working with
- 17:47other countries, help them. They might be able to help us
- 17:51and it's just a good thing to be doing.
- 17:54I, I guess I, I mean, I, I don't really know if I've left you off
- 17:59with something to say with that. That was just kind of my input,
- 18:01my thought about it while you're talking of.
- 18:03Course, I totally agree with you on that.
- 18:05I mean, foreign aid, I say in the book it it's a reflection of
- 18:09our better angels. You know, they're there was an
- 18:12old Chinese philosopher that said there isn't a person on
- 18:15earth who sees, if they see a child, a small child sitting on
- 18:18the edge of a well about to fall in of this natural impulse to go
- 18:23try and save that child, say whose kid is it or what is this
- 18:28or her nationality you want to help?
- 18:31And I think foreign aid is a manifestation of the concern
- 18:35that we have for our neighbors, but it's also in our own
- 18:38interest. I mean, every every great world
- 18:42religion will tell you that the giver benefits as much as the
- 18:46receiver in the foreign aid world.
- 18:48That is, that is true. I mean, when we help these other
- 18:51countries, two things happen. We help ourselves in the sense
- 18:55that it doesn't do us any good to have extremely poor desperate
- 19:00neighbors near us. And the world is getting
- 19:03smaller. So everybody's really near us.
- 19:05And that's these days. I mean that it's, it's not just
- 19:10our immediate neighbors or central, but we also get wiser.
- 19:15We understand what's happening in those countries and that
- 19:21helps us adjust our own programs.
- 19:24We learn from what we do. What I'm seeing now in the US is
- 19:28that we have a breakdown of trust and and that was so often
- 19:34the problem in the third world. You had people that they would
- 19:38trust us more than they trusted themselves.
- 19:42And. They would trust the Americans
- 19:44to, to help run a program or set up a program when they wouldn't
- 19:47trust. You really saw this in Africa
- 19:50where you had the different tribal groups, you know, the
- 19:52borders in that were all drawn by European.
- 19:54So they, they encompass, in many, many cases they encompass
- 19:58groups that just don't get along with each other.
- 20:02But we, we could see that distrust just right up, right up
- 20:07in front. The other thing we we learned or
- 20:09I saw the fragility of the social consensus.
- 20:15It is a very fragile thing and it's, I don't think the US
- 20:19really appreciates how fragile it is.
- 20:21I mean, we may find out, but I was in places that fell apart
- 20:28just overnight. I was in Kyrgyzstan when the
- 20:31Tulip revolution happened. And then nobody expected that.
- 20:34But there were some young men who there were rented crowds, I
- 20:37call them to rich hired crowds. And then the crowds were
- 20:41fighting with each other and some of these young men got over
- 20:45the fence. The presidential guard had been
- 20:48told don't load your rifles, we don't want any deaths here.
- 20:51Well, the men into the to the White House, their version of
- 20:55it, started stealing things, lit fires and the president fled the
- 20:58country and that nice full society, just the police
- 21:02disappeared. And these these mobs raged
- 21:05through the city, burning the place up.
- 21:06And we were working all night to protect our staff and, and other
- 21:11people in the, in the city. Similarly in, in Guinea, I was
- 21:15there when the, the, the president, the long standing
- 21:18president, Lasana Conte died and the army couldn't agree on who's
- 21:22going to take over. So where there were battles
- 21:24going on, we weren't, we couldn't go to work.
- 21:27We had to hunker down in our homes.
- 21:29And I, I visited later, I visited some of our grantees
- 21:33where the staff who had been lying on the floor and I saw the
- 21:36holes in the holes where the bullets were passing above them.
- 21:40I was in Guatemala when the president ordered the military
- 21:43to surround the Congress and surround the Supreme Court and
- 21:46arrest the members of the in court in Congress.
- 21:52I could go on and on, but the social consensus is fragile.
- 21:57And we with them up close and personal sometimes.
- 22:01And I, I really, what's going on in the US right now, we, we
- 22:06don't really appreciate how fragile society really is.
- 22:10Yeah, yeah, it's, I don't. If it makes you feel any better,
- 22:15I don't think anyone knows what's going on in the US right
- 22:17now. It's.
- 22:20Times are looking dark, yeah. What do you think the USAID got
- 22:28wrong about working with religious groups?
- 22:32Oh, well, that's a battle I fought unsuccessfully for 20
- 22:35years. And a lady came up to me in
- 22:39Haiti in 1989, and she said, Cliff, they're saying prayers in
- 22:43these buildings that we built. And I said, I don't care.
- 22:46I mean, what's the soul? And she said, well, isn't that
- 22:49an infringement on, you know, that's mixing government with
- 22:52religion, free exercise. The 1st Amendment says that
- 22:56Congress will pass no law limiting the free exercise of
- 23:00religion in the states. Now they say prayer is down in
- 23:03that building. Does that limit our ability to
- 23:05choose whatever faith we wish? No.
- 23:08And it also says that Congress will pass no law respecting an
- 23:12establishment of religion, which meant I'm we are not going to
- 23:16have a state religion. Well, that's not either.
- 23:19So what? What's the problem?
- 23:21And that was before the War on Terror.
- 23:23OK. Now in the 1970s, there was a
- 23:26Supreme Court decision that said you will do nothing that will
- 23:30excessively entangle you with religion.
- 23:33And that has been, in my view, misinterpreted to mean that we
- 23:37can't work with faith group, faith-based groups overseas.
- 23:42We can debate what is or is not excessive entanglement, but
- 23:45whatever it is, that phrase does not show up in the Constitution.
- 23:49And at the time it was a five to four decision.
- 23:52And Justice Scalia later called it brain spawn.
- 23:56It's not something the Constitution says.
- 23:58But in any event, whether we're we were entangled or not by
- 24:02doing any of that once we had a War on Terror underway, I figure
- 24:06we're entangled, right? Because they got us entangled.
- 24:10And so I'm in I'm in Kyrgyzstan and the University of Montana
- 24:13comes to town and they want to translate parts of the Quran
- 24:16that say suicide is a sin, which it is to Islam.
- 24:20You can't even buried in a in a Muslim cemetery if you commit
- 24:24suicide, let alone if you commit suicide and take out a couple
- 24:28hundred other innocent people at the Yeah.
- 24:31So I thought, well, that's a great idea.
- 24:32Let's translate the portions of the Quran that say, you know,
- 24:36suicide is, is wrong. And let's take them out of
- 24:40Arabic, which they can't read and put them into Kirgis and
- 24:43Uzbek so that we can at least have some effective diplomacy
- 24:47here that that would combat those groups.
- 24:50And the lawyers in aid. And I had been one, they said,
- 24:53no, can't do it. And that's where it stands.
- 24:57They will not touch it. So what's happening now is it's
- 25:00legal to use U.S. government funded equipment to shoot
- 25:03somebody, but you can't use a simple book to to to that we pay
- 25:09for, to persuade that terrorist that he's got it wrong.
- 25:13His own religion really doesn't sanction what they're doing.
- 25:17The Wahhabi faith is a perverted version of Islam.
- 25:22And I think completely nuts. I wish we would.
- 25:26And I know that there are people in the in the military that have
- 25:32gone so far as to even build mosques, for instance, to win
- 25:36parts of a certain community and in places like Afghanistan or
- 25:40Iraq happened. But you say which was our soft
- 25:45power initiative was, I called it pre emptive capitulation.
- 25:50We just said no, we're not going to touch it.
- 25:52If it has anything to do with theology, well, if you're in a
- 25:57war against an extreme version of that religion, must I in my
- 26:03view, talk about their misunderstanding of their own
- 26:07faith? And if anybody who says, well,
- 26:10no, it's going to be too much entangled, but I say my answer
- 26:13is, hey, we're already entangled the issue.
- 26:15Now is. Unentangled.
- 26:17Yeah. And it's not, it's not like
- 26:21you're you're preaching it or, you know, you're just, hey, you
- 26:27got this wrong and helping. It's it's helping.
- 26:33Yeah, I do see that religion and politics is, is tricky.
- 26:39You know, it's, I don't like to see things get passed based on
- 26:46religion, but obviously everyone has their right to their
- 26:51religion. It's just I just don't think law
- 26:53should be passed based on it. But.
- 26:56Sorry to interrupt, I just wanted to tell you about my
- 26:58sponsors real quick. Sometimes I get on a roll
- 27:02cleaning or gardening and I need a boost but don't have time for
- 27:05a meal. Big Fork Brands Pork Jerky is
- 27:08the perfect choice to keep my momentum, offering high protein
- 27:11snacks for on the Products come in a variety of delicious
- 27:23flavors, including Thai green Curry and Maple and brown sugar
- 27:26for the meat options and Gangster and Chicago Fire for
- 27:29the. Sauces.
- 27:30I personally think the original flavor of the pork jerky, it's
- 27:33just right after tackling a big chore.
- 27:36It's a little salty and very flavorful.
- 27:38My discount code gives you 20% off your entire order and it's
- 27:42currently the best deal available.
- 27:44Just visit bigforkbrands.com and enter in my promo code JADE.
- 27:48That's JADE at checkout. Are you looking for a gift for a
- 27:55music lover? Or maybe some apparel to show
- 27:57off your quirky side? Old Glory has you covered.
- 28:00With over 300,000 officially licensed items covering music,
- 28:03sports, entertainment and pop culture, you're guaranteed to
- 28:06find the perfect item. They even have seasonal gear.
- 28:10My husband enjoys The Beatles and Led Zeppelin apparel and I
- 28:13love the Billy Idol apparel. I even found items for my fellow
- 28:16plant enthusiasts. This family owned superstore is
- 28:19known for their quality and customer service.
- 28:22Offers free standard shipping on all orders and orders are
- 28:25shipped the same day you purchase.
- 28:27My discount code gives you 15% off your entire order and it's
- 28:31currently the best deal available.
- 28:33Just visit oldglory.com and enter in my promo code JADE.
- 28:37That's JADE at checkout. Looking for a game changing way
- 28:42to improve your health? Zevo Life is the world's most
- 28:45nutrient dense whole plant, packed with over 50% plant
- 28:49protein, essential amino acids, fiber and antioxidants.
- 28:53Harnessing the best nature has to offer, Zeva Life nourishes
- 28:56your body while driving your performance, vitality and
- 28:59overall well-being. Each serving is a concentrated
- 29:03source of clean, well balanced nutrition designed to support
- 29:06modern lifestyles. And just one teaspoon a day
- 29:09supports your gut, boosts energy and promotes healthier skin and
- 29:12tear. It's no wonder that it's
- 29:14receiving rave 5 star reviews. Step into a healthier future
- 29:18with a 30% discount and a 30 day risk free guarantee by visiting
- 29:23DIVO dot Life and using my promo code to support my show and to
- 29:28receive 30% off your entire order.
- 29:30Enter in my promo code JADE. That's JADE.
- 29:34At checkout, I also saw that you have some information on
- 29:40trafficking in and out of Africa.
- 29:43Yeah, that's it's. I'll just warn you, this is not
- 29:47a subject for young children. But during some of that chaos
- 29:53that I described earlier in Guinea, when the military was
- 29:56fighting each other, that's out of shade, was downtown Conakry
- 30:01in a bar and two Asian women approached him.
- 30:05They did not speak French and they did not speak Susu, but
- 30:07they had enough English to communicate their their
- 30:10situation to him. Both of them had been smuggled
- 30:13on to a freighter. It was a Mariskline freighter
- 30:16that's a big shipping company and it, the cruise ships are
- 30:20primarily men from South Asian countries like Indonesia,
- 30:24Thailand, Vietnam, Philippines. And they had duped these ladies
- 30:30and coming on board thinking they were going to Europe or the
- 30:33United States, but instead they took them to West Africa.
- 30:37They took away their passports. They forced them into sex
- 30:42business. And it's it, I mean you that is
- 30:46a phenomenon that's terrible enough all by itself.
- 30:50There's hundreds of women around the world and it and it and it
- 30:53goes in both directions. There are African women who
- 30:56think that they they're getting a free trip to Europe, but in
- 30:58fact they're taking somewhere and forced into the sex trade.
- 31:03What's going on now? And we documented this to the
- 31:07point where we had, we, we filmed some of these.
- 31:11The ladies worked in each of the major shipping lines, had these
- 31:14homes in the capital city where these ladies were, were housed.
- 31:18And they would go out to the ships on little perogues.
- 31:22Those are like large canoes. They call them perogues.
- 31:25And I don't know what the English term is.
- 31:28Dories, I guess is one word for it.
- 31:31Dories would take these ladies out to the ships and that's
- 31:34where they were engaged in their trade, if you want to call it
- 31:37that. And because the sailors were
- 31:40apparently afraid to come ashore because of HIV AIDS, they
- 31:43thought if they came ashore, they had a worse, a better
- 31:46chance of getting infected. So they have these homes and I
- 31:50guess the, the women were I, I don't know, but I, we, I assume
- 31:54that somehow the sailors thought they was safer that way because
- 31:57perhaps these were being checked out for, for diseases or
- 32:00whatever. But in any event, the trade, the
- 32:04business occurred out on the ships, right.
- 32:06And I was a sailor once a ship is a big, it's a mini city in
- 32:12some of them. And then I know you can smuggle
- 32:15things onto a ship, sometimes under the noses of the officers
- 32:18because I saw people do it. Not, not people, but a big, a
- 32:23big freighter is a, is a great big vessel.
- 32:27And now what happens now, because there's also so many
- 32:31Chinese construction projects under way in Africa, and the
- 32:34Chinese import the laborers. They bring entire teams there to
- 32:37build a railroad or build a an iron mine or something.
- 32:41They don't use the locals. They bring their laborers in and
- 32:44then they have charter flights to go back and forth.
- 32:46So what's happening now in some cases, if the women object to
- 32:50what their their situation is, the nicest way to say this, they
- 32:55become involuntary organ donors. That means if you can, you can
- 33:01infer. And I, I saw a video that was
- 33:07provided to my friend Jason Hatch.
- 33:10He was the defense out of shape of a, it was an African woman
- 33:14because as I say, the trade goes in both directions.
- 33:18She was she was surrounded by a group of men speaking
- 33:21Portuguese. You couldn't see their face.
- 33:23We don't know that this was Guinea Bissau, could have been
- 33:25Mozambique or Angola. She's told we're not going to
- 33:29hurt you put this hold this metal plate up on your head.
- 33:33And the next thing you show, she's knocked out.
- 33:35And they immediately start massaging her arms and legs to
- 33:39keep the blood flowing. I couldn't watch the rest of it,
- 33:42but that they're harvesting organs and then they those
- 33:46organs are put into coolers and those charter flights back and
- 33:49forth to Southeast Asia carry those organs back to the the Far
- 33:55East where they are then sold, as, you know, valuable
- 33:59commodities in the medical business.
- 34:02It's it's an outrageously horrific phenomenon that's going
- 34:07on. And this is this is if they
- 34:13fight against what China is doing in Africa.
- 34:17Did I understand that correctly? Well, there's a lot of people
- 34:20involved in it. It starts with the, the women
- 34:23who are, it's a, it's a side business run by the crewmen on
- 34:27these freighters. They, they dupe these ladies
- 34:29into going in One Direction. The other you, they, they fool
- 34:32Africans into thinking they're going to Europe when they're in
- 34:34fact going to Odessa and the airport and in Europe for the
- 34:39exotic sex business up there or they are women in South Asia
- 34:45that are fooled into coming to Africa.
- 34:47Now, the crews on these ships are the ones that are, I'm not
- 34:50indicting every crewmen, obviously, but this is under the
- 34:54noses of management of these freighters And they, the, the
- 34:59women are brought to wherever the, their trade will be
- 35:04conducted. And then the, the, the body, the
- 35:08body parts trafficking is a phenomenon that may involve more
- 35:13than simply Chinese. It may involve other, other
- 35:16nationalities or, or airlines and whatnot.
- 35:20But it, it's the, the body parts are going back to, to places
- 35:25where they can be sold, where they're not tracked.
- 35:27And I'm hoping that there will be a book that's coming out
- 35:33soon. I, I and I think it's death to
- 35:38order. I think it's what it's called
- 35:40and it's I, I, I saw an announcement of this book that's
- 35:46about to come out that may be talking about the same
- 35:48phenomenon. But to my knowledge, I went back
- 35:52to work for a whole year specifically to try to interest
- 35:56donors and and multilateral organizations in this
- 36:00phenomenon. But the challenge is it's hard
- 36:03to know who has jurisdiction. You know a lot.
- 36:05Of this. Place on the open seas and so it
- 36:09you it it's very hard to get donors to understand the first
- 36:15challenge is getting them to believe that it's real and even
- 36:19if they do then the then it's well then what can we do about
- 36:22it and how we're not going to stop every vessel at at sea and
- 36:27start searching them. So the only thing I can suggest
- 36:31is that people just be made aware of it so that in those
- 36:36countries where these women are recruited, they become a little
- 36:39more cognizant of the risks and that's going to take journalism
- 36:44and and, and more publicity. But that I was not able to, to
- 36:49get any money dedicated to try and solving that problem.
- 36:54I, I, I talked and talked and talked to a lot of different
- 36:58organizations in the year that I work.
- 36:59I, I took a job with the American Bar Association.
- 37:03This is AID and I spent a year being responsible for their
- 37:08programs in the DRC, which is it used to be Zaire.
- 37:12It's the Democratic Republic of the Congo and also Iberia and
- 37:16the Sahel region in in in Africa, but I've gotten over
- 37:20with it. Yeah.
- 37:25You know, every time I talk to somebody who does work with
- 37:28other countries or are from from another country, it just really
- 37:33puts into perspective how some of the things here in the United
- 37:37States that were just throwing huge fits over are really not
- 37:43that big of a deal compared to what people in other countries
- 37:47are dealing with. We we forget how lucky we are
- 37:51really. That's that's quite true.
- 37:54We're we're pretty lucky here so far.
- 37:57Yeah, I mean, it's not perfect, but so did you, did you said
- 38:04work with to prevent bride kidnapping?
- 38:10Yes, that's another. Sorry I bounced around from
- 38:13topic to topic. In the book too, in rural
- 38:18Kyrgyzstan, well before the before the Soviet Union, this
- 38:21practice has been around for hundreds of years in Central
- 38:25Asia. The Soviets kind of suppressed
- 38:29it. But when the Soviet Union fell
- 38:31apart, the practice got revived in Central Central Asia.
- 38:37And I had we financed the film. I didn't start our work in this
- 38:42area. But before I got to Kyrgyzstan,
- 38:43we had engaged the University of Central Europe to do a film on
- 38:48bride kidnapping. And what they did is they went
- 38:50out into the countryside and they got four families to agree
- 38:53to let the the film crews film the entire process.
- 38:59And So what happens is young men, they don't date.
- 39:03So the, the way the men get their brides is they literally
- 39:08go out on the street and kidnap them.
- 39:09They, they, they the first scene in one of these in the film was
- 39:14a young man in his house. He's getting dressed up in a
- 39:17suit and his grandmother is telling him, don't get a pretty
- 39:201. I don't want a pretty one.
- 39:22I want you to get one that's going to work.
- 39:24And so the car with his buddies and they go to a bus stop and
- 39:27they wait until the school bus up.
- 39:30And then they get out and they grab one of the girls.
- 39:33It's about to get on the school bus and they drag her back in
- 39:35the car. She's kicking and screaming at
- 39:37them. And they force her back to the
- 39:40groom's home. They put her in the corner.
- 39:42And then all of his elder female relatives get around that girl,
- 39:46the grandmas, the ants, they get around her and they say, come
- 39:50on, honey, you got to put the scarf on.
- 39:51This is how it happens. And if she puts the scarf on,
- 39:56her family will not take her back.
- 39:59That means she's married. That that's how.
- 40:03And if if she resists enough, in some cases the man is told you
- 40:07go in there and do what you have to do.
- 40:08And it's community sanctioned rape.
- 40:12Personally, sat in college classrooms with young women
- 40:17dressed in western attire. And I've had 19 and 20 year old
- 40:21women tell me this is how we do it.
- 40:23This is our tradition. Since we don't date, how else
- 40:25are we going to get married? And I have young men tell me
- 40:29this is the wisdom of our ancestors.
- 40:31This we estimated like 60% of the rural marriages in
- 40:37Kyrgyzstan were as a result of of these kidnappings.
- 40:41Now, in some cases, the kids agree to, to make it look like a
- 40:45kidnapping already. They got to know each other and
- 40:50in some cases they want it to happen, But, and most of them
- 40:54are not that way. Most of them are.
- 40:56The guy's got his eye on somebody and he kidnapped her.
- 40:59And that's how, that's how they do it.
- 41:02So we, the film showed case studies of four different
- 41:06families, right? And they filmed the whole
- 41:09process at the beginning. And then they went back to each
- 41:11family a year later when they got to the fourth family, this
- 41:16is the last scene in the film. They went back to interview the
- 41:19the the the bride. She had committed suicide.
- 41:23Yeah, I. Had a one of my staff was a
- 41:27teacher in Kyrgyzstan and before he worked for for us, he was a
- 41:33he was a university teacher. He said he had a woman in his
- 41:36classroom try to commit suicide by jumping out the third story
- 41:40of her classroom window. She didn't want to go back down,
- 41:43didn't want to go back to her husband.
- 41:45I had a, one of my staff members was a former Peace Corps
- 41:48volunteer, an entire apartment that was filled with the some of
- 41:56the girls who had escaped those marriages and they were living
- 41:59with each other because the their families wouldn't take
- 42:01them back. It's, it's just, it's a mind
- 42:05boggling phenomenon, frankly, But it's still illegal in the
- 42:10in, in Kyrgyzstan. And they're the government, I
- 42:12guess is taking steps to try and suppress it now.
- 42:14But you were, we were, you know, showing that film and then we
- 42:18would have discussions with the college students afterwards.
- 42:21We were trying to raise awareness of the phenomenon.
- 42:24And when they told me that let that this is our tradition, I
- 42:28said, well, look, slavery was a tradition Once Upon a year too.
- 42:31Does that make it right? Right, it's.
- 42:35Crazy I. Mean, yeah, I can't I mean, if
- 42:40you want to stick with tradition, why can't they just
- 42:42be accepting of the the, the performative part of it, like
- 42:46the OK, let's let them date and then they can just pretend to
- 42:50kidnap and and whatever, you know, I, yeah.
- 42:54No, it's, it's hard to believe, but I, as I said at the
- 42:58beginning, you know, some of the programs we work on, they just
- 43:01make us wiser in the sense, yeah, realize there's stuff goes
- 43:05on out there that you really can't imagine all the different
- 43:09practices that are happening around the world in different
- 43:12societies. But it's, yeah, it's a crazy and
- 43:16yeah. Where do you hope to see you?
- 43:21I guess you USAID is gone. Do you hope that?
- 43:26Do you know if there's anyone working on trying to get it
- 43:30brought back or under a different name or in a different
- 43:34capacity at all? I know that most of the former
- 43:41Foreign Service officers who lost their jobs are all doing
- 43:46what they can to promote at least public awareness of it.
- 43:50And that's what I'm trying to do right this moment.
- 43:52But we can only hope that at some point Congress is not
- 43:58ignorant of what you say. It was a lot of, you know, I
- 44:02spent a lot of time, if I have any criticism of you say,
- 44:05sometimes it was basically that we spent far too much time
- 44:09entertaining Congress people who would come down to visit.
- 44:11When I was in Columbia one year, I think we had 32 congressional
- 44:16delegations come to town and a lot of them clearly just
- 44:20boondoggles, but they would go out and they would visit our
- 44:24projects or they would least listen to us come and give
- 44:27presentations as to what we were doing.
- 44:29So there's a lot of Congress people that know what we were
- 44:32and what we and, and there's a lot of people that are writing
- 44:35about it to this day. I just think this particular
- 44:38administration is not interested in reviving it.
- 44:41Now, if and when it is revised, are there ways we can improve
- 44:45it? Of course.
- 44:45I mean, there's always, there was, I don't think we needed as
- 44:51many lawyers overseas. And I was one of them when I was
- 44:54living in Guatemala. I said I didn't need to move
- 44:57down here to do this. I could have done it from the
- 44:58phone up in Washington, DC. It costs money to put a family
- 45:03overseas and, and, and give them home leave and R&R and pay for
- 45:08schooling and, and housing and whatnot.
- 45:11So yeah, there are ways we can save money.
- 45:13And I, I'm sure when they, if and when they revive the agency
- 45:18known as AID or, or what I'm sure that we will try to stay
- 45:23engaged with the rest of the world.
- 45:25Somehow. I don't think it's, it's that
- 45:29it's going to be gone forever. Now, whether it comes back in
- 45:32the same form or not, I don't know.
- 45:34There are things we can do to improve it.
- 45:36I, we could certainly speed up the procurement process so we
- 45:39don't spend a year fussing with, you know, I mean, sometimes it
- 45:44was just crazy that the, the time it took to get a, to get a
- 45:47contract or a grant in place, because we had so many hoops to
- 45:51jump through to follow all these bureaucratic rules that we had.
- 45:55But there are ways to make it more efficient for sure.
- 45:58And then that's true for every agency in the federal
- 46:01government. It doesn't mean that what we did
- 46:05was predominantly corrupt. It doesn't mean that it wasn't
- 46:09helping the US achieve its objectives.
- 46:12It was. And as I said before, it wasn't
- 46:16just our objectives. These were objectives of the
- 46:19executive branch and Congress and State Department.
- 46:22So we were the tool. That's that's the really the
- 46:25message I'm trying to convey is that we were the tool that
- 46:30allowed the US to influence overseas events where the
- 46:35military would be inappropriate and where diplomacy, pure
- 46:39diplomacy wasn't enough. That tool is gone.
- 46:43I'm sure that we will somehow re establish it sometime in the
- 46:47future, but it right now it's not being used.
- 46:52It's gone and the people, and this is the real tragedy.
- 46:55It's all those people who learned how to do it.
- 47:00And, and it is learn how to do, yeah, put these instruments in
- 47:04place and and reach agreements with those governments.
- 47:07Those aren't there anymore. They're gone.
- 47:11Right. Are there any political leaders
- 47:16that you know of that are working on this, working on
- 47:20getting this back? I can't name them off the top of
- 47:24my head. I know a lot of Democratic and
- 47:28also Republican congressmen certainly aware and they
- 47:31appreciated what we were doing. I assume that at some point
- 47:35within Congress there will be pressure to revive what it was
- 47:39that we did. And I know, you know, they've
- 47:41tried to take some of the programs, a very small portion
- 47:45of them, and to the State Department and say, please run
- 47:49these programs. Now, for the most part, those
- 47:51are those are some of the more obviously good for us kind of
- 47:56programs, the monitoring epidemics overseas, that sort of
- 48:01thing. But it's a fraction of what we
- 48:03were doing before. And the people that are doing in
- 48:06the State Department, they don't have experience running these
- 48:09programs. In some cases they are actually
- 48:11reaching out to former laid off usage staff and they're bringing
- 48:15them on to the State Department and they they're programs that
- 48:18are actually, you know, getting funding now, but it's a small,
- 48:21small percentage of what was going on before.
- 48:24Yeah, OK. Yeah, I.
- 48:28Maybe I did. I did share the example of the
- 48:30two planes that went down. And yeah, yes.
- 48:33Finish that thought. I think we've done surveys and
- 48:36most Americans thought that we were spending like 10 or 15% of
- 48:39our budget on foreign aid. Really, it's under 1%.
- 48:42Under 1%, Wow. Yeah.
- 48:47I mean, you look at, I think the way it came out like right away
- 48:55with with the start of the new administration and all the
- 48:59numbers that were being put out there, it seems like a lot.
- 49:03But then you look further into our defense spending, which is
- 49:08billions and billions of dollars.
- 49:10And in other, you know, like basically what you said was that
- 49:15there is a lot more money going towards other things then what
- 49:19was going toward you. USAID and I yeah, I can't
- 49:24imagine the State Department could handle all of that on its
- 49:29own to take over. So something, something will
- 49:35need to be recreated in whatever capacity at some point.
- 49:40Hope hopefully soon while there's still people who know
- 49:44how to do the job right. Yeah, it's, well, as I said,
- 49:49it's a it's a tragedy. I'm glad you've given me this
- 49:51chance to at least event about it, yeah.
- 49:54Of course. Yeah, that was very interesting.
- 49:58Is there anything else that you want the audience to know?
- 50:02Well, if they want to, if they want to read more about it, you
- 50:05know, this is the book inside you say, I don't know if it
- 50:08shows up on the. It does, yeah.
- 50:10I was going to ask you to do that.
- 50:12So. And it's, it's there for the
- 50:18reader. It's more of a story of my own
- 50:19career. It tries to say, you know what
- 50:21it was like to work in, in the, in this business overseas.
- 50:25But it in so doing, I, I cover the, the, the places I was in
- 50:30and the, and the, the events that happened in those
- 50:32countries. So it's not a, it's not an
- 50:34academic look at you say by any means, but it is we'll give
- 50:39people a flavor for what, what foreign aid at least what you
- 50:42say did. And there are other donors out
- 50:45there that are still doing it. So that's the part I didn't
- 50:48really talk about. But it most of these countries,
- 50:51there were always other donors there.
- 50:53We were the biggest, typically we were the biggest.
- 50:56But I hope the slack is taken up by some of the other agencies
- 51:00because almost all the Western European and the Canadians and
- 51:04the Japanese, they all have their foreign aid agencies, but
- 51:07they just, they weren't as big as you say, but they're still
- 51:11there. Yeah.
- 51:13And do you think other countries that are better developed could
- 51:16be helping a little bit more, just a little random side, Yeah.
- 51:21The Scandinavians give a much higher percentage of their GDP
- 51:25to foreign assistance and we had the biggest budget in just an
- 51:30absolute size, but as relative to our GDP, it was probably the
- 51:34smallest of the of the big donors.
- 51:38And there still are international organizations like
- 51:40the World Food Program and the United Nations Development
- 51:44Program and whatnot, but a lot of them depended heavily on the
- 51:48US portion of of their own budget.
- 51:50So it all suffered from this general pullback in, in, in the
- 51:55US engagement overseas. I can only hope that you know
- 52:00they will continue to support and even beef up their programs
- 52:03given the the the fact that ours are are over most of them.
- 52:08Yeah, right. It's just it's something
- 52:12interesting to think about and I can't, I wish we had a pie chart
- 52:16that would show us what our country spends our money on.
- 52:20I don't know, maybe there is one out there, but I, I think it
- 52:23would bring insight to a lot of the things that we're reading
- 52:27online and probably contradict what what we're hearing about,
- 52:32you know. So as I said it, it was not a
- 52:35corrupt organization, that we had bad actors like all agents.
- 52:39Yeah, but in general, it was it was trying to do something that
- 52:44the US thought the US Congress and executive branch and State
- 52:47Department thought was useful. Yeah.
- 52:51And I think I feel like that's the most important point, was
- 52:54that it it was approved by. Yeah, by the government.
- 53:00It's not like you guys were just running crazy.
- 53:03So. All right.
- 53:05Sounds good. Well, I I want to thank you for
- 53:09being here today. And where can everybody get your
- 53:12book? Well, it's on Amazon, Barnes and
- 53:15Noble. There's an e-book, I think the
- 53:17e-books. There's a it's, it's, it's, it's
- 53:20for sale now. The e-book is there's a special,
- 53:23I think it runs through March 4th.
- 53:24There's a 299, OK, as they used to say on the Mad magazine,
- 53:28that's cheap. But yeah, it's not Barnes and
- 53:32Noble too. You can get on their platform.
- 53:34OK, print on demand. So it'll come out.
- 53:37You order it so perfect. It's not off the shelves, but
- 53:40it's it's they'll send it to you.
- 53:42I have a sub stack too. It's a
- 53:44clifford.brown@substack.com where I post assorted articles
- 53:51and thoughts that I have about development, but it's a it's a
- 53:53wider topic than just you say it's.
- 53:55OK. People are interested.
- 53:57Yeah, I'll make sure to put that in the show notes as well.
- 54:01So yeah, I'll be in touch.