Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Therapist Questions and Abusive Couples in Therapy
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserved listeners. As a part of continuing the spring cleaning, in
- 0:04which I will finally get to all of your emails that you've been sending in
- 0:08over the last number of months. I thought I would continue doing that right
- 0:11now. And a lot of these emails are pretty technical geared towards therapists,
- 0:16So if that will bore you, you might want to skip this episode.
- 0:20This first email is from annual patron Meagan from Arizona. She says, Hi,
- 0:24doctor, I'll just summarize what she's saying in this email. She sent
- 0:28me an article, a journal article about evidence based therapy and CBT, and
- 0:34it's critical of it. So I thought I would read that article and talk
- 0:37about it here. So the article is written by Jonathan Schedler, published in
- 0:42twenty eighteen, titled where is the Evidence for Evidence based Therapy? So,
- 0:47just reading one of the introductory paragraphs, here, Behind the evidence based therapy
- 0:52movement lies a master narrative that increasingly dominates the mental health landscape. The master
- 0:59narrative goes something like this, in the dark ages therapist practiced unproven unscientific therapy.
- 1:04Evidence based therapies are scientifically proven and superior. That master narrative has become
- 1:11a justification for all out attacks on traditional talk therapy, that is, therapy
- 1:15aimed at fostering self examination and self understanding in the context of an ongoing meaningful
- 1:19therapy relationship. Just chiming in here. Yeah, absolutely, there will be
- 1:23people that will say that humanistic therapies and Freudian therapies are complete hogwash and are
- 1:32a thing of the past, like when medical doctors used to bleed people to
- 1:36try to cure certain ailments. Right, So that is the narrative, and
- 1:42I've heard people say that the facts are that, and I don't know what
- 1:46the rest he gets into in this article. The fact is is that there
- 1:49is a lot of evidence that quote unquote Freudian types of therapies are psychodynamic,
- 1:55relational, psycho analytic therapies, and certainly human stick therapies. There's a ton
- 2:01of evidence, mountains and mountains of evidence that demonstrate that these forms of therapy
- 2:07do work for certain conditions. If, for example, you have a phobia,
- 2:12then Freudian therapies do not work, and humanistic therapies aren't necessarily going to
- 2:17work. If you have a phobia, you want to use exposure therapy,
- 2:21which is a form of behavioral therapy. So with phobias, you want to
- 2:24use that. But if someone comes in after a major breakup like a divorce,
- 2:30or they just got dumped by their long term partner and they're sad about
- 2:35it, then behaviorism, you know, the exposure therapy is not indicated for
- 2:42that presentation and therapy and in that presentation, humanistic therapies are definitely shown through
- 2:47evidence, you know, thousands of studies showing that it is helpful in that
- 2:52situation. By humanistic, I mean reflective listening, compassion, self exploration,
- 3:00being in here and now, allowing someone to get in touch with their needs,
- 3:04emotional expression, experiences that are meaningful to you know, finding meaning in
- 3:09one's life. Existential therapies that kind of thing. So for sure, and
- 3:15if that individual complains that they've had half a dozen or a dozen relationships that
- 3:22all seem to end the same and tend to be with the same sort of
- 3:25person, then psychodynamic oriented therapies and our personal therapies, insight oriented therapies are
- 3:32evidence shows that they do help. Transference based therapies definitely do help personality disorders.
- 3:39For example, with borderline being one person disorder, it has been shown
- 3:44through evidence through empirical research research. These are sound studies, These are not
- 3:50just dubious studies by dubious Researchers have found that transference based therapies or relationship based
- 4:00therapies between therapists and client do show positive long term outcomes. There are two
- 4:05reasons why in my field you will hear therapists say that CBT is basically the
- 4:10only form of therapy that works. One is this because as well, there
- 4:14are a lot of reasons why they come to mind. One is that CBT
- 4:17is much easier to understand than the other forms of therapy, especially if you're
- 4:23a very concrete minded individual, and they're very concrete minded therapists out there,
- 4:28believe me, and so for them, CBT is very easy for them to
- 4:30understand. I'm not saying that these people are stupid or anything. I'm just
- 4:33saying that therapy is very complicated. Humanistic therapies, psychodonamic therapies are extremely complicated.
- 4:40You can spend your entire career studying these things and basically only halfway understand
- 4:45them. Systemic therapies, family systems therapies are very hard to understand. Really
- 4:48at its core, people lack like they get it, but my experiences for
- 4:53myself, for example, I had to teach these things for basically fifteen plus
- 4:57years before I really started to get it. So because of this reason,
- 5:00you have a lot of people that enter graduate school and they get exposed to
- 5:04a few different theories and they just gravitates towards CBD because it reduces their anxiety
- 5:11about learning about the field. And they have a disdain for certain kinds of
- 5:16theories, certain kinds of therapies that are confusing to them, and so as
- 5:19a way of expressing that frustration with the confusion, they'll just say it's discountable.
- 5:26I've heard people say, like everything that Freud ever said was ridiculous,
- 5:30and that is a ridiculous statement, because Freud said a lot of things.
- 5:33Yes, some of the things he said in today's light we see them as
- 5:39being a little ridiculous, But he said a lot of things that we operate
- 5:43from as if it's just a known truth. The fact that we have a
- 5:46personality, the fact that talk therapy even works. Freud basically invented. There
- 5:51are people before him that kind of introduced the idea, but not in the
- 5:55way that he did, and certainly not in the way that he proliferated through
- 5:59Western colure and we have him to think for a lot of different things.
- 6:02Doesn't mean that you have to be Freudian. No, doesn't mean that it's
- 6:05stupid if you specialize in CBT. No, absolutely not. But to denigrate
- 6:10other forms of therapy and to claim that they're not evidence space, it's just
- 6:14factually wrong. It's just scientifically wrong statement to say that there's no evidence that
- 6:19humanistic or psychodidamic therapies work. And I can diamor about this forever about I'll
- 6:25stop after just saying this final point, which is that there is a culture
- 6:30that just gets perpetuated in our field. If you, as a trainee,
- 6:34as a psychology student, as a psychotherapy student, go to a program that,
- 6:39for whatever reason, is just dominated by professors that adhere to the false
- 6:44notion that CBT is the only form of therapy, then you're going to get
- 6:48a lot of propaganda for CBT and a lot of propaganda against the other kinds
- 6:53of therapy. So you will emerge from graduate school basically have been brainwashed.
- 6:58You've been brainwashed by people that don't know what they're talking about, or they
- 7:01or they were taught by people who were braidwashed as well, and the psycho
- 7:05just continues. But really, okay, that'll be just continue talking a little
- 7:10bit, because I think this will apply to everyone. To be clear,
- 7:12I some people will will they'll email into me and they'll be like, yeah,
- 7:15Kirk, I know you hate CBT. I do not hate CBT.
- 7:17I want to be clear. I love CBT. I love all forms of
- 7:20therapy. I just don't believe that CBT is the only form of therapy.
- 7:25You know, there's a wide variety of wonderful therapies that I adhere to in
- 7:31every session. I adhere to feminist theory. I adhere to systemic theory.
- 7:36I adhere to humanistic ideas, and that's a very broad topic. I adhere
- 7:40to existential ideas, experiential ideas, psychodynamic ideas, relational therapy ideas, interpersonal
- 7:46intersubjective. I adhere to structural and strategic and gestalt and I mean it's all
- 7:54great, including behaviorism and cognitivism. These things are very important ideas to under
- 8:00stand. They're pretty universally understood. I mean, everyone basically adheres to the
- 8:03idea that your perspective does matter. Right if you look at things in a
- 8:07negative way, then you're going to feel negative about it, and if you
- 8:09look at it in a positive way, you're going to feel positive about as
- 8:11well. Understood, everyone gets that. Also, if you do things by
- 8:16habit that cause you problems, breaking out of that habit is important. That's
- 8:20another pillar in the behaviorism idea of therapy. I'm simplifying it, of course,
- 8:26but so I want to be clear. I absolutely love I love cognitive
- 8:31therapy, I love behavioral therapy. I use it all the time. I
- 8:35just don't think it's the only thing. And when I as a therapist,
- 8:37if I were to exclude those other schools of thought, I would definitely be
- 8:43not serving my clients well. And I see other therapists doing this sometimes.
- 8:48And another thing, I find that a lot of lay people will like CBT.
- 8:52I think partially because it's easier to understand, but also because it inadvertently
- 8:58plays into a lot of our cultural notions of anti emotion. CBT is depending
- 9:03on how you know. The thing is is to call yourself a CBT therapist.
- 9:07Can you know a wide variety of things? It could mean that you
- 9:09are very pragmatic and very brief, meaning that you only want to treat people
- 9:15for five to ten sessions total. But I know other CBT therapists that are
- 9:18not like that. They're much more likely to create space for emotion and this
- 9:24sort of thing. So I don't want to paint it as if it's a
- 9:26monolith. But when you describe CBT to the lay public, for some people
- 9:31it appeals to them, I think because it appeals to common notions in our
- 9:35society that dolay that downplay emotions. Our society already is terrified of emotions and
- 9:41shames emotions, and CBT plays into that. CBT does not shame emotions,
- 9:46but CBT doesn't emphasize them, and CBT will say that your emotions. It
- 9:52kind of depends on how you take it, but CBT could be interpreted as
- 9:58a form of therapy that basically says your emotions are a bit of a nuisance.
- 10:01Not every CBTU therapist would operate that way, but it can be.
- 10:05It can look that way to some therapist and to some lay people. Whereas
- 10:09when you talk about psychodynamic theory or humanistic theory, you cannot avoid emotions.
- 10:13These forms of therapy are very focused on emotions usually, and again I can't
- 10:18paint it as a monolith as a monolith either. But these theories are much
- 10:24more long term. They tend to be much more interested in self reflection,
- 10:28much more validation, much more expression of emotion. And because our society hates
- 10:35emotion, then our society hates those forms of therapy. That that's just an
- 10:39opinion, of course, but I think that it's true. And because we
- 10:43live in a society that is sexist and misogynistic, and we have been for
- 10:48quite some time, one could consider CBT to be more manly and the other
- 10:52forms of therapy d be more womanly that with CBT, it's much more pragmatic.
- 11:00You got to pull yourself up by your bootstraps and you have to get
- 11:03back out there and make it happen. And we don't want to wallow in
- 11:07telling stories and talking about emotions and expressing emotions. You've got to do a
- 11:13job here, you know. Again, not every CBT therapist is like this,
- 11:16but it can be at least seen that way, whereas the other forms
- 11:20of therapy could be thought of as this weak endeavor of indulging yourself and feminine
- 11:31problematic emotions, and of course that's not what it is. But I think
- 11:35that's another influence, all right, sixteen mails from anonymous patrons. He writes,
- 11:39I am a first year student in a CFT graduate program. CFT stands
- 11:43for a Couple and Family Therapy. I've been watching and listening to your podcast
- 11:46for two years now, and I'm a huge fan. My boyfriend and I
- 11:50watch your videos as a couple and we find them super helpful. Just chiming
- 11:54in here, Yeah, I love it when I hear about couples watching my
- 11:58videos because I just imagine that my reaction videos when people are couples are watching
- 12:05them at prompts conversations or at least thoughts about their own relationship with the person
- 12:09they're sitting next to you, you know, because that show will highlight the
- 12:13shows that I react to, highlight relationship dynamics and misunderstandings that people have.
- 12:18And I just imagine that it would be fun to watch reality TV while this
- 12:24therapist watch, but also to know I could imagine it being useful in prompting
- 12:28conversations going on here. In fact, your podcast is the reason why I
- 12:33decided to pursue a Marriage of Family Therapy degree. Just jamming in here.
- 12:37Yeah, when I hear that, I am just so overjoyed to hear that
- 12:41I could be a catalyst for someone entering the field and having a rich,
- 12:46wonderful life as a helper, as a person who was out there at the
- 12:52ground level helping people. It's it's just really great to hear we need more
- 12:54therapists in the world going on here. I wanted to reach out because I've
- 12:58had a bit of confusion around my degree and license, and I was wondering
- 13:01if you could clear some things up for me, being that I've watched your
- 13:05videos for the past two years and I've been heavily influenced by your views and
- 13:07practices when it comes to therapy, therapy models, theories of change, etc.
- 13:13And when I entered my program, I incorrectly, I incorrectly expected my
- 13:16professors to reflect what you spoke about in your videos. While the systemic portion
- 13:22of what you talk about is in the Marriage of Ambi therapy program that I'm
- 13:26in, most of my program has a less diagnostic approach, and their theories
- 13:31for change seem like it's about spinning things in the most positive light. Just
- 13:35jam me in here. Yeah, So maybe I should say this occasionally that
- 13:43if you have a very similar point of view that similar to me and Bob,
- 13:50following in my footsteps career wise and training wise won't necessarily lead you into
- 13:56programs that will have my point of view. In fact, my point of
- 14:01view is unique in psychology, but also specifically in marriage of family therapy.
- 14:09For example, in my program, as far as I know, I mean
- 14:15last I knew maybe they have some new professors now that I don't know of,
- 14:18and I don't know their specialty. But I was one of the only,
- 14:22if not the only professor in my marriage of Family therapy program that had
- 14:26any sort of working knowledge of psychodynamic therapies of object relations, and that people
- 14:35would reach out to me. Sometimes professors would even have me guest lecture when
- 14:41the chapter or the module came up in their class about say, object relations
- 14:46therapy, they would actually have me come in and teach that section because they
- 14:50just didn't feel competent enough to do so, because it's it's pretty complicated.
- 14:54So it doesn't surprise me that you are in a program, whether it's to
- 15:00your otherwise, that has a much different point of view, and that there
- 15:05might not be a single professor that talks about the things that I talk about.
- 15:09So you know, Like I said earlier in this episode, I think
- 15:15we're heading kind of in a bad direction overall as a field. I don't
- 15:18want to be a doomsday seer, but it kind of feels that way to
- 15:24me. At the very least. I think it'll be very hard for our
- 15:28clients to find a good enough therapist, and I think hard for trainees to
- 15:33be trained well with the kind of philosophies and the kinds of therapies that have
- 15:39really got our field into the public awareness. I mean, the fact that
- 15:46people know what talk therapy is is because of Freudian therapies and humanistic therapies.
- 15:50There's a reason why people loved those things in the past, therapist and clients
- 15:54included. And I feel like it's all just being pushed aside. But anyway,
- 16:00Yeah, that makes me sad that you feel. The other thing that
- 16:03you're saying here, anonmost patron is that the systemic portion is there, but
- 16:08you're saying most of the program has a less diagnostic approach, and just cham,
- 16:12Yeah, most family therapists do not emphasize personality or diagnosis, or sometimes
- 16:21they'll literally just issue it all together. They will reject the notion that there
- 16:25are personalities and that there are diagnoses. They'll just say, well, we
- 16:29have to live in that system because we have to build insurance, but we're
- 16:33not going to believe those things that we don't think that those things are real.
- 16:37And I understand the foundation of their argument, and I've had similar kinds
- 16:42of ideas in my head as well. But to just throw it all out
- 16:48is I think, ignoring the reality of humans and also ignoring an opportunity to
- 16:53help people in a variety of ways. So there's that. But also you
- 16:57also say here that you see to be getting this notion that your professors are
- 17:03teaching a form of therapy that seems to be just spinning things in a more
- 17:06positive light. Yeah, that is what CBT can be reduced to. CBT
- 17:11is when it's done right, it's it's pretty great. But a lot of
- 17:15people, because they don't understand what it is, they will interpret CBT.
- 17:18And even within a family therapy program which you're in, which isn't traditionally supposed
- 17:23to adhere to CBT, but I feel like it's becoming more and more part
- 17:27of it. Plus there are schools of thought within FAMI therapy, like structural
- 17:33family you know, reframes this kind of thing. If you're in the know
- 17:36about those terms that they will just interpret that. A lot of people,
- 17:41professors and students will just interpret all that all that. All that stuff is
- 17:45great. Reframes are great. Thinking positive is great. But if you only
- 17:48focus on that, they basically just reduce all of talk therapy to that.
- 17:53And you go to therapy, and some of you might have had this experience.
- 17:56You go to therapy and your therapist basically just tries to convince you to
- 18:02think more positively, and that's basically all that they do. They're just like,
- 18:06well, is there another way of looking at that? Or huh,
- 18:08maybe you shouldn't think that way, you know. And if it was that
- 18:11easy, then all we'd have to do is just give someone a pamphlet and
- 18:15say, don't go to therapy, just think positively. And the pamphlet would
- 18:19be one page long with just like fifteen words on it. If it was
- 18:23that simple, then wow, right, And of course things aren't that simple.
- 18:27Even cognitive behavioral therapy isn't that simple. But yeah, I've seen this
- 18:32before as well. Basically, you have the blind leading the blind. You
- 18:34have professors who were trained poorly and they're poorly training their students as well.
- 18:41I've seen it before. Going on here, I feel that I am not
- 18:44learning about why people do things, but from your content I find the why.
- 18:49You know, you answer the question why people do things to be very
- 18:52important for understanding and an acting change. Just Jemmy in here, Yeah,
- 18:56completely agree. When you understand why people are doing something, definitely gives you
- 19:00a direction with therapy, right, and that can be very varied. And
- 19:04of course we can never know exactly why people are doing things, but if
- 19:07we have a conceptualization, that can help for sure. Going on, I
- 19:11am wondering if you could provide some resources, books or podcasts from someone in
- 19:17my position, any words of encouragement. Also, I am curious to know
- 19:19what informs your practice, what are the models that you follow. I am
- 19:22thinking of pursuing a doctorate, but I am undecided on whether I want to
- 19:26continue pursuing a doctorate in MFT or if I want to get a CD end
- 19:32of email. Yeah, so the first thing I'll answer is resources. I'm
- 19:37terrible about keeping track of resources, so I don't have any resources to offer
- 19:41you, and I apologize for that. People ask me for a and it
- 19:45just seems like the sort of thing that I should have on hand, that
- 19:48I would have podcasts or books or training programs or something. But I don't
- 19:52know. There's something about me that makes it hard for me to notice that
- 19:56or retain it or jot it down or something. I just don't have of
- 20:00anything for you, And I apologize for that also you, But I get
- 20:03it that you're like, my program doesn't seem to be giving me what I
- 20:08want. What I'll say to that is in So, when I got my
- 20:12master's degree in marriage of family therapy, everything I was learning was new to
- 20:15me, and so everything was mind blowing to me. I was a twenty
- 20:18four year old dirt bag who knew nothing about anything, and everything was mind
- 20:23blowing and it was just so eye opening. And the two years I was
- 20:26in graduate school getting my masters, I was totally transformed. When I went
- 20:32back to school ten years later to get my doctorate, I had already been
- 20:37a professor. Actually was thirteen years later, and I was a professor.
- 20:41I was a podcaster, and I knew a lot more so. When I
- 20:45was in my doctorate program, which involved another master's and a doctorate, I
- 20:51would be in class learning about things or being taught things that I already knew.
- 20:56In fact, there were sometimes when I was being taught by professors that
- 20:59knew far or less than I did about the topic they were talking about.
- 21:02And that's just natural, you know. I was already practicing. I was
- 21:04a professor myself, and sometimes I'm just particularly in the areas of psychotherapy,
- 21:08the psychotherapy courses I took were extremely rudimentary and actually extremely boring to me.
- 21:15I mean, it was just like really hard for me to get through those
- 21:18courses because as I'm just like, I've been practicing for fourteen fifteen, sixteen
- 21:22years and I've been a professor. I teached this stuff, and at the
- 21:25very even if the professor did the class well, it would still be boring
- 21:29to me. Now, there were classes and my doctorate that were mind blowing,
- 21:33things like forensic psychology, statistics research, those kinds of things I hadn't
- 21:38had really any instruction on. So that was interesting and it helped me to
- 21:41fine tune my writing skills and also my teaching skills because I would observe the
- 21:47teachers as they're teaching a class, and I'd be like, Okay, I
- 21:48like that. I don't like that like that. I don't like that,
- 21:52and I would. It helped me to refine my own teaching skills, but
- 21:56it was hard to always feel motivated to go to graduate school because of this
- 22:02reason, because some of the classes felt kind of worthless to me. So
- 22:04what I did was I just made it useful to me. For example,
- 22:08there was this one course and I won't go into details as to how stupid
- 22:11it was, but it was a good subject, but it was extremely the
- 22:15class was structured in a very let's just say, boring way to me,
- 22:21and I wasn't going to learn anything if I just went through the motions.
- 22:25And so what I decided to do is when it came time to work on
- 22:29a project, because we all had to work on a project, I decided
- 22:33to lean into that project heavily, even though I was pretty sure that the
- 22:37professor didn't care. Like I was pretty sure that professor was just gonna,
- 22:41you know, kind of skim through my paper or something and consider it like,
- 22:47yeah, it's fine, and then she would just pass me. But
- 22:49instead, what I did is I'm like, Okay, I'm going to really
- 22:52dedicate myself. I'm going to make use of this class and the way that
- 22:55I want to So for you, anonymous patron, that might be My suggestion
- 22:59is, undoubtedly there are some things in the class that you're learning, but
- 23:03you can maybe really lean into it and say, okay, well, for
- 23:07my project in this class, I'm going to go in a direction that the
- 23:11professor isn't necessarily offering to me, and I'll ask them, is it okay
- 23:14if I go down this road? But I'm going to make this useful to
- 23:17me. The other thing you can do is after hours or maybe even in
- 23:21class, just ask your professor some of these questions. Just say hey,
- 23:26I don't know, but it kind of seems like the main intervention that you're
- 23:30recommending in my words, it just seems like you want me to spin things
- 23:33in a more positive light. But I could be wrong. So could we
- 23:37talk about that? Do you? What is? Because family therapy is extremely
- 23:41complicated and there's a lot of avenues, there's a lot of depth, there's
- 23:45a lot of corners to it that often don't get talked about. The Other
- 23:48thing is that you say, I'm curious as to what informs your practice?
- 23:52What models do I follow? Well to answer that question, I think I
- 23:56already did earlier. Everything informs my practice. I'm of the belief if in
- 24:00research demonstrates this. There's important research by John Norcross that demonstrates that therapists who
- 24:06incorporate a wide variety of therapies into their practice and tailor the treatment to the
- 24:11client instead of the other way around, have very positive outcomes with clients.
- 24:17For example, if a client comes in talking about a phobia, then I
- 24:21use behaviorism with that client. I don't just shoehorn my particular approach to them.
- 24:26I figure out what's wrong, and then I utilize something in my repertoire
- 24:33to use with that client. If another client comes in and they have borderline,
- 24:37then I'm not going to just use behaviorism, right, I'm going to
- 24:40use a variety of other things. I'm gonna use transference based, mentalization based,
- 24:44attachment based therapies, motional regulation, which you could argue as a CBT
- 24:48thing. I'm gonna use humanistic therapies to make the client feel safe and comfortable
- 24:52and heard and understood, and I will utilize those therapies when needed, and
- 24:57I'll make the judgment. The problem with that is that to know the theories
- 25:03well enough to use them in therapy, it can take you literally decades of
- 25:07study. I mean it has taken me. I would say that it was
- 25:11probably fifteen years into my career as a professor and as a therapist before I
- 25:19basically grasped the different theories of therapy, before I could actually use them.
- 25:26And before that point, I was kind of focusing on a few different theories.
- 25:30So that's one thing to do, is to focus on a few different
- 25:33theories than the beginning and then slowly start to acquire competence in these other theories.
- 25:38The other thing is is graduate school is not where you learn most of
- 25:44what you will know. People think you go there's this notion in society that
- 25:48somehow you go to graduate school and it teaches you everything, and then you're
- 25:51ready, You're ready to practice, You're ready to be whatever it is that
- 25:53they're trying to train you to be. No, no joke. I would
- 25:56say about one percent of what I know about therapy and human beings and how
- 26:00to be a therapist and how to be a human being myself, but particularly
- 26:03how to be a therapist. One percent of that was from graduate school.
- 26:07And I have one, two, three, four or five, six seventy,
- 26:11I don't know. I have like eight nine years of graduate school intensive
- 26:15graduate school, and about one percent of what I know about how to help
- 26:22people in the office of Psychotherapy was acquired in that graduate in those graduate school
- 26:26experiences. Maybe maybe it's a little bit more than one percent, but probably
- 26:30not much, especially if I just absorbed what the professors were telling me and
- 26:34didn't extend myself into the subject so that I could go deeper myself. You
- 26:40know, if I just relied on professors to teach me, as if I
- 26:44was this passive sponge of information, certainly it would be even less than one
- 26:51percent. So that's that's one thing to do. But yeah, I follow
- 26:55all the all the models because they're all good, all the models that are
- 27:00evidence based, and there are several, you know, all the ones that
- 27:03I've mentioned, all the important ones going on here. I'm thinking of pursuing
- 27:08a doctorate, all right. So you ask about You're just like, I
- 27:12don't know if this is where it's coming from an honest patron. You're like,
- 27:15I don't like my current program, so and I'd feel like I'm not
- 27:18learning a lot. So is it that I should just do what Kirk did,
- 27:25which is also go back and get a C I d is that where
- 27:27he got the way that he is. And the answer to that, as
- 27:30I said earlier, is no. So if you want to get a c
- 27:34i D, that's fine, but it would be unfortunate because it would the
- 27:41c i D does not recognize your MFT though there too, I won't go
- 27:45to weeds on that, but you'd basically be starting over as if you didn't
- 27:48have any education in your master's program. I mean, maybe some of the
- 27:51courses would be transferred over, but maybe not, and at most it would
- 27:56just be like a few courses usually anyway, So it's not true. I
- 28:00mean, psychology programs, you know, training you to be a psychologist can
- 28:06be even worse in this respect. So not always, and it's just anecdotal
- 28:10or my experience, but if you really want to learn the things that we
- 28:14talk about in this podcast, you need to find a mentor and a supervisor
- 28:18like that that knows these things and can walk you through it. And that
- 28:22person might be in your program, they might be outside your program. So
- 28:26you want to find a supervisor, and you can go to double AMFT,
- 28:30the Marriage Family Therapy Association and search for supervisors and you can literally just ask
- 28:34them a few questions you know, what do you think about attachment based therapies?
- 28:40What do you think how would you describe family therapy or something? Or
- 28:45in my program, it seems like all they want us to do is to
- 28:49spin things in a positive light. What do you think about that? And
- 28:52then you would gage the response from a supervisor, because I'm guessing that I
- 28:56don't know one out of ten supervisors would respond in a way that would inspire
- 29:00you to want to work under them, And so you know you'd want to
- 29:03hire that person or befriend them or something. All right, let's take a
- 29:06break. We'll get back more emails. All right. Back from the break,
- 29:12we have an email from patron Lauren from Texas. She says, Hi,
- 29:15doctor Kirk, I often hear people saying things like I'm not their therapist
- 29:21when they are talking about their partner, and I'm wondering what your thoughts are.
- 29:23I understand that couples are in a two sided relationship, whereas a therapeutic
- 29:26relationship is one sided and only meant to help the client. However, where's
- 29:32a line between couples taking care of each other emotionally and something unhealthy and one
- 29:37sided? Thanks for all you do and an email. Yeah, that's good
- 29:40question. And on one hand, if someone said I'm not their therapist,
- 29:45I could get on board with it. And the other hand, I could
- 29:48see situations where I would not on the situation is where I could get on
- 29:52board with it. It's when you have a couple and one you have an
- 29:57underfunctioner, and that under functioner is relying too much on the other partner and
- 30:03the underfunctioner is not taking It's not reciprocal right overall, the under functioner is
- 30:11a drain on their partner. Is you know, you just can fill in
- 30:15the blanks in terms of details. So in that situation, and I've literally
- 30:18said that myself. I'm not in my marriage, but in other relationships,
- 30:22other sorts of relationships, I'm like, look, i'm not their therapist.
- 30:26Or you've actually heard me say things like when I get an abuse, when
- 30:32I have a relationship that is abusive and someone's abusing me, I understand that.
- 30:37And sometimes I know exactly where their behavior comes from. I know their
- 30:41history, I know their relational traumas, I know why they are abusing me,
- 30:45and I have compassion for that and I care about that. But I'm
- 30:51not their therapists. So I'm not going to just stand by and let them
- 30:56abuse me. Right. In fact, I might completely get rid of them,
- 31:02that's a funny way to put it. But I'll distance myself from them.
- 31:04I will try to get away from them. And I even know that
- 31:08by doing that, I might be adding to their relational traumas, which will
- 31:11make them more even perhaps more likely to abuse people in the future. I
- 31:15don't know, but I'm not their therapist, and I'm not gonna sacrifice myself,
- 31:22you know, entirely in this relationship just so that they can get helped.
- 31:25If they want help, they can go to a fucking therapist, right.
- 31:27So, in some situations, saying I'm not their therapist is a very
- 31:33important thing to say and think. But there are other times when I think
- 31:37you're talking about, which is you have a couple and both people have relational
- 31:45traumas as we all do, that get triggered and get acted out in the
- 31:48relationship, and you might be asking your partner. You might be like,
- 31:53hey, I just wanted to talk about the fight we had last night,
- 31:56and I wanted to talk about it, and also I just wanted to explain,
- 32:01like why I got triggered last night it's because my mom treated me this
- 32:07way and that, and then your partner says, look, I'm not your
- 32:10therapist. In that situation, that is someone that is acting in an unfair
- 32:16way because probably because they're afraid of the conversation, or they feel like they're
- 32:24supposed to cure you, or they're just angry at you and they just don't
- 32:30want to talk to you or so. I don't know, but in that
- 32:31situation, the way I laid it out briefly, in general, I would
- 32:36say that the person saying I'm not your therapist, they're just avoiding, all
- 32:42right. This next email is from anonymous annual patron from California. She says,
- 32:47how do I find a couples therapist for an abusive relationship? Since you
- 32:52are one of the only psychologists I've heard say that a couple therapy is appropriate
- 32:59for abusive relationship, could you please tell me how to find a therapist willing
- 33:02to work with an abusive relationship. It is demoralizing to call therapists over and
- 33:07over and be rejected because of abuse and of email. Well, two things.
- 33:10One not a psychologist, I'm a marriage of family therapist. I'm trained
- 33:14as a psychologist and could be a licensed psychologist, but have chosen not to
- 33:17for variety of reasons. The other thing is that you say that you've heard
- 33:22that I say that couple therapy is appropriate for abusive relationships. That's not the
- 33:28way I would frame it, and I hope I didn't say it like that.
- 33:30What I would say is it's not inherently inappropriate, meaning that there are
- 33:35some couples that one person is being abusive or they're both being abusive, in
- 33:39which a couple of therapy can help. And to I always feel like I
- 33:45have to reiterate exactly why I say this, because I get a lot of
- 33:47gasps from therapists. So let me explain. So let's say a couple comes
- 33:52into my office and there's a wide variety of presentations, but this is just
- 33:54one of them, and a couple. Over time, I start to assess
- 34:00that let's say the husband is verbally overpowering, and let's say I decide to
- 34:05meet individually with each person, and I ask the wife and she tells me,
- 34:08yeah, he will lecture me for two hours. He kind of scares
- 34:13me with how angry he gets, and I get shut down, and sometimes
- 34:19he'll call me names, he'll get really worked up and it hurts my feelings
- 34:22and I don't feel safe. Okay, So in this presentation, it's a
- 34:28particular kind of abuse and shouldn't be downplayed. It's severe, but it's not
- 34:32physical, right, and so there's not a physical safety issue, or at
- 34:37least it doesn't appear that it's likely that the abusive partner is going to throw
- 34:45their partner down the stairs because there's not a pattern of that kind of behavior
- 34:49because and if there was, it would be a different presentation and I would
- 34:52react differently to it. So in this scenario, and let's say I have
- 34:57a conceptualization of the husband as having relational traumas that lead to them having distortions
- 35:02and triggering that lead to the abusive behavior. And then I go to the
- 35:07husband and it might take me a few sessions, it might take me just
- 35:09one session, but I introduce the at least the idea of abuse. I
- 35:15might even use the word abuse. And I've done this before, and I
- 35:19believe that he will work with me on this, and so I talk with
- 35:23him about his abusive behavior and how I understand where it comes from, but
- 35:29it needs to stop, and it's a learned behavior, probably from their parents
- 35:34or something like that. And I get that in the moment, it feels
- 35:37justified, but it is not. It is one hundred percent not justified.
- 35:39And I know that's going to be painful to hear and it will be painful
- 35:43to acknowledge. But I'm here to help. And if you're here to work
- 35:46on your relationship with your wife, then you will endeavor to change this and
- 35:52you will work with me and your wife so that you can communicate in a
- 35:57different way, in a non abusive way. Okay, so I'm condensing a
- 36:00lot of conversations into a little bit of time. But if I believe that
- 36:04I can do that successfully, then that is the course that I will take.
- 36:08Now, what people will say from the outside is abusive relationships should never
- 36:15be in couple of therapy. And if I presented this case, and I've
- 36:19had cases like this before, and I say, so, I should have.
- 36:22So you're telling me that as soon as I figured out what they were,
- 36:25ten fifteen sessions into the couple therapy relationship, maybe longer, and I
- 36:30figure out that the wife is being verbally abused emotionally abused, I need to
- 36:35immediately terminate with them and refer them to individual therapy. So let's play that
- 36:39out. So I talk to them immediately in the next session, and I
- 36:44say, so, I've observed some concerning behaviors in this relationship that tell me
- 36:50that there's abuse happening, and maybe i'd even identify it of just like there
- 36:54are signs that you husband are abusing your wife verbally, and thus it is
- 37:00inappropriate for me to continue a couple of therapy. And so I'm going to
- 37:04refer you wife to an individual therapist to work on recovering from the abuse and
- 37:10drawing boundaries. And you husband, I'm going to refer you to an innimate
- 37:15partner violence program or an abusive treatment abusive partner treatment program, and I need
- 37:22you to do that, Okay, So if I did that, would that
- 37:25be wrong? No, it could be very helpful if they complied, But
- 37:30abusive people are not likely to do that. In my experience, they almost
- 37:35never do it. They almost never comply with that recommendation, and there's no
- 37:38core order to do so, and there probably won't be because that kind of
- 37:42abuse doesn't typically get the individuals some sort of criminal status, you know,
- 37:46some sort of convicted situation. So what would happen, Well, what would
- 37:52happen, you know, and I've seen this happen many times, is that
- 37:54the wife will go to individual therapy maybe, and the husband will never go
- 37:59to therapy again because he doesn't want to be talked to like that, because
- 38:01it's very triggering to him, because his relational traumas are being triggered at that
- 38:06moment, right rejection, judgment, criticism, blame. And the wife sometimes
- 38:12will also never go to therapy again because if she even let's say she even
- 38:15indulges and she goes to five sessions, well she's sitting there talking to an
- 38:20individual therapist and she's like, well, yeah, I mean it's great that
- 38:23you're supporting me, but my real problem is someone needs to change my husband.
- 38:27And since the couple therapist rejected us and my husband refuses to go to
- 38:32the innimate partner violence program, then I don't know why I'm in therapy,
- 38:37so the whole thing will fall apart. Whereas if I do the first scenario,
- 38:42we're actually engage with them, I can actually fix the problem and I
- 38:45have before. Now, if I thought that he would engage in an intimate
- 38:51partner violence program and I let's say he's very interested in therapy and he's done
- 38:55it before, then I might be more likely to refer them out. But
- 39:00at the very least what I would do is I would say, husband,
- 39:01I need you to do this thing. Will keep couple therapy together. Okay,
- 39:05So why do people why are they so terrified? Why is this?
- 39:08Why is this panic about couples going to therapy when there's abuse in the relationship.
- 39:14Well, because there are cases and there is research demonstrating this that when
- 39:19you continue in couple of therapy, the victim will be encouraged to report and
- 39:25complain about the abusive partner, all right, and what can happen and has
- 39:30happened, is the abusive partner will go home and use that information to abuse
- 39:37the victim even further, maybe even kill the victim. And that's happened.
- 39:40So because of those cases, there's this panic that just says, never do
- 39:45couple therapy when you have abuse in the relationship, and you don't find a
- 39:50lot of people will will provide the other point of view. You know,
- 39:53everyone just accepts that as dogma. Whatever you hear anything that's that's supposed to
- 39:59be dogma, Like it's always supposed to be this way in therapy, you
- 40:04should be highly skeptical unless it's something like you should never have sex with your
- 40:07client past, present, or future. That is an absolute, But the
- 40:12other things, it's not so much. You know, when you hear say
- 40:15you should never accept a gift from a client, that's not true. That
- 40:19is not true according to evidence. Even ethical experts will not say you should
- 40:23never accept a gift from a client. There are situations where you might actually
- 40:28do your client better by actually accepting a gift, a small gift to this
- 40:31kind of thing, or a gift that they know they drew a picture for
- 40:34you or something. So these kinds of absolutist notions should be you should be
- 40:39skeptical of. And this absolutist notion that in all situations, if there's any
- 40:45kind of abuse in a couple, they should never be in couple therapy.
- 40:49It's ridiculous. Now, there are situations that I've been in where I would
- 40:52not do a couple therapy. I've had clients where I can't remember a couple
- 40:58that was like this. But let's say that, well, I did,
- 41:01in the distant past have a family where under circumstances where there wasn't any abuse.
- 41:09But so it's hard for me to remember the details, but my vague
- 41:14memory was that the parents were abusing each other. It was mutual, mutually
- 41:19abusive. And for those people who think that there is no such thing as
- 41:22mutual abuse, there is, and it's nuanced, and it's hard to tell
- 41:24because how do you tell difference between defensive violence and mutual abuse? But to
- 41:31me, once you get into it, and especially if you can get a
- 41:36clear, honest recall from the individuals in question, you can tell the difference
- 41:43between a defensive violent act by a victim versus an abusive act. And sometimes
- 41:51it's more of like a thirty seventy sort of thing where one person is anyway.
- 41:54Point is is I seem to remember there was violence going both ways in
- 41:58the couple, and it was extreme, like there was choking, and it
- 42:01was chaotic, and there was barring of doors, meaning that one member of
- 42:08the couple was not letting someone leave the room, and then they got in
- 42:12an altercation and things were broken in the house and it was pretty severe.
- 42:16And so I remember in that situation, I did not recommend couple therapy.
- 42:22In fact, my main focus was to help who I believe to be the
- 42:27main victim. Now that I remember, I must have identified one of them
- 42:30as being the main victim. So I remember I went down a road of
- 42:32connecting that individual, the person I saw as the main victim with an advocate
- 42:37to Bestley finance advocate, and it was and I shepherded that relationship so I
- 42:44could help the victim get out of the house. And Yeah, anyway,
- 42:45point is is like, there are situations where it would be inappropriate because of
- 42:51not only the reason that if I engaged in a couple of therapy and nothing
- 42:54else, at the very least, the abuse would be very likely to continue,
- 42:58but it would also be an opportunity for the abuser to be triggered and
- 43:02thus cause more violence. I think another reason why people will be so dogmatic
- 43:08about this is that they have a false notion that couple therapy is about being
- 43:14neutral, that couple therapists just agree with both sides and never confront one person
- 43:21over the other, And that is a gross misunderstanding and simplification of what couple
- 43:25therapy is. There are times, for example, with abuse that I will
- 43:29absolutely quote unquote take sides. I'm not taking sides, but I am calling
- 43:32it like it is, and I'm saying, hey, you are being abusive
- 43:36and you need to stop that, and your partner has nothing to do with
- 43:39what you are doing. Or if someone cheated on someone, I do not
- 43:43consider that a systemic issue. I do not blame the victim of the cheating.
- 43:49I do not say, well, everyone needs to work on things.
- 43:51No, the cheater cheated and needs to stop. They took an act,
- 43:53They took thousands of actions to go down a road that they knew that they
- 43:58knew was going to harm the partner, and they did it anyway. Now,
- 44:01there are reasons for that, there are reasons for abuse, there's a
- 44:05reason, there are reasons for cheating that we can work on. But those
- 44:08individuals are still responsible for their behavior bottom line. So I think that's another
- 44:14reason why people are dogmatic, because they're like, well, you don't want
- 44:15to send it to a couples therapist because a couple therapist will just validate the
- 44:22abuser, And it's just like that, that's not the case. Now,
- 44:24can that happen? Are there some bad couple therapists out there that will do
- 44:28that? Yeah? Sure. Now to finally get to your question, you're
- 44:30saying that, how do I find a couple therapists that will take us even
- 44:36though there's abuse in the relationship. And the answer is, I don't know.
- 44:40I mean, there's a chance that you if you looked for ten years
- 44:45in your area for a therapist that would take you, there's a chance you
- 44:47could literally not find a signal one that had an opening spot. So I
- 44:52don't know, But you don't need couple therapy necessarily, right, if you're
- 44:57really trying to change the relationship, well, one thing you could do is
- 45:04if you're part I'm assuming that your partner is the abusive one. I don't
- 45:07know, but let's just say that that's the case. If somehow you if
- 45:10your partner is willing to go to a couple of therapy, then maybe they're
- 45:14willing to go to individual therapy. And so I think you'd find a greater
- 45:17chance of a couple of therapists taking you on if they knew that the abusive
- 45:22individual was in individual therapy, especially if that individual therapy was working on the
- 45:28abuse. So I don't know, Maybe that's a strategy, all right.
- 45:30This next email is from Patron Kieran from England. She says, would you
- 45:36liken the therapeutic relationship to a foster parent because the therapist is like a foster
- 45:42home, and that is rehabilitating the client or child to a healthy adult and
- 45:49environment and helping heal past abuse by being consistent and safe, setting new boundaries,
- 45:53and relating more compassionately to the client or child in foster care then the
- 46:00previous life. Yeah, the answer is I suppose for sure that is an
- 46:05analogy, but I don't usually think about it that way. But yeah,
- 46:07sure, that's a way to look at it. All right, it's take
- 46:09a break, we get back more emails. All right, we're back from
- 46:16the break. Let's do an opp These people became patrons in twenty twenty and
- 46:21have stayed patrons, loyal patrons ever since. We have Annual Uppertier patron Young
- 46:24from Chicago. Annual Uppertier patron Nard from Vancouver, BC. We have patron
- 46:30Jasmine from Anchorage, Alaska. We have Paris from Arlington, Virginia. Megan
- 46:35from Aurora, Colorado. We have Lisa from Austin, Texas, Jenna from
- 46:38Brooklyn, New York. We got Dan also from Brooklyn. We have Lise
- 46:43or Liss or Liz from Buffalo, New York. We have Natalie from Switzerland.
- 46:46We have Aaron from Chicago. Also Chicago, another Chicago person, Clayton
- 46:52from Chicago, Diana from Cincinnati. We have Selina from New York State,
- 46:57and Jess from Covington, Entucky. Thank you for being a patron and staying
- 47:01a patron through thick and thin. Thank you so much, all right.
- 47:05This next email is from anonymous patron. They say I experienced an emergency level
- 47:10months months long, seven months long manic episode last year. During the time
- 47:15leading up to it, I was in contact with my therapist. She knew
- 47:20what was going on, and I was extremely volatile. I was in an
- 47:23extremely volatile environment and situation during a moment of crisis. I repeatedly tried to
- 47:29get in touch with her by calling her, but she never called me back.
- 47:31I was emergency hospitalized the next day. Her failure to communicate led to
- 47:37me erratically going through my contacts, calling and texting friends instead. I had
- 47:43to send out multiple apologies later down the road to my friends, which still
- 47:46feels so humiliating. I don't want her to be in trouble, but it
- 47:51does feel like she majorly let me down. She also never checked on me
- 47:53when I missed my next appointment. I went on to be hospitalized two more
- 47:58times before finally getting the mania contented. It goes without saying I ended up
- 48:00finding a new therapist after this happened. Anyway, Am I wrong to think
- 48:05that a therapist has a responsibility to be there during an emergency or at least
- 48:08check on an at risk client. What is the standard when it comes to
- 48:12this end of email? Well's a good question, and I'm sorry you went
- 48:15through that. It sounds really, really, really awful. It's just so
- 48:20awful to go through a manic episode like that and to not have the support
- 48:23that any The thing I'll say is that the standard is that therapists need to
- 48:30take reasonable actions to address this issue. Now. For me, for example,
- 48:37if I had a manic client who I was working with and I knew
- 48:40that their symptoms were escalating, I would actually tell the client that I needed
- 48:46to pass this off to someone else. I would still be their therapist.
- 48:50But I am not set up to be a therapist that is on call or
- 48:55a therapist that can help in situations like that. I don't have the resources
- 49:00and I don't have the desire as a professional to do that kind of work.
- 49:04I did in the beginning of my career, but not anymore. And
- 49:07so I would say, I'll be here for your sessions when you come,
- 49:13but I'm not going to be there in between sessions. And if you text
- 49:15me and you're an emergency, you need to call the crisis line or nine
- 49:20to one one. I'm not going to be an on call therapist, Okay,
- 49:23So I disclose that to clients and situations like this, and therapists need
- 49:29to be clear about this. A more common situation is to say, if
- 49:31you had a client who was thinking about suicide and was having an increase in
- 49:37thinking about it, the therapist needs to be very clear as to what their
- 49:42role will be in between sessions, because it's rational for a client who has
- 49:46an increase in thinking about suicide to reach out to the therapist for help.
- 49:50Right, But if you're the sort of therapist that doesn't want to provide that
- 49:52kind of service, then you don't. Now, if you do want to
- 49:55provide that kind of service, you might charge for it, right. You
- 49:58might even charge extra for the main sessions as a way of making up for
- 50:01that extra time that you're even just being available. Because in order to be
- 50:06available, you need to be sober the entire time. You need to be
- 50:09available, you need to check your phone twenty four seven. You know,
- 50:12it's a thing. And I don't recommend that therapists do this because if you're
- 50:15in private practice, it's really hard to have that level of responsiveness. So
- 50:22I don't know what your therapist told you. It sounds like your therapist might
- 50:24not have said anything to you and just reacted to this situation, which is
- 50:30not the standard. That is not what you should be doing. If you
- 50:34give the impression or you leave it open to interpretation, and a client going
- 50:37through a crisis has enough reasons to believe or not enough reasons to disbelieve that
- 50:43you are available twenty four seven, especially in a crisis like that, then
- 50:49that's irresponsible. As a therapist, you just need to be clear. So
- 50:52I don't know what the situation is. But I would also say that most
- 50:58therapists, at least anecdotally for me, are not going to be available in
- 51:02a situation like that. You know, if they're in private practice, they
- 51:07have other clients, they have their social life, their own private life,
- 51:12and they wouldn't have the capacity to deal with that. What are they supposed
- 51:15to do just drop everything and drive to your house or what you know,
- 51:21what I mean, it's it's not a viable situation, whereas if you have
- 51:24an on call therapist that is trained to do that, that knows what they're
- 51:28doing in charges, and has all the appropriate disclosures, then maybe they can
- 51:31do that. Now, there are different degrees of this. You know that
- 51:35you could be, for example, kind of on call, like if it's
- 51:38a major crisis, you might be available by phone for fifteen minutes, but
- 51:43you're not going to drive out to the house, or you're not going to
- 51:45hand hold the client as in a good way. Handholding isn't necessarily a bad
- 51:49thing, but you're not gonna escort or help the client go to a hospital
- 51:53or whatever. So you know, there's different degrees to this. But it
- 51:58sounds like your therapist at the very least left the impression that they might be
- 52:00available, and so when you reached out to them and they weren't available,
- 52:02then yeah, that's an irresponsible act, all right. The sext email is
- 52:07from anonymous patron. She says, Hi, doctor Kirk, I recently got
- 52:09back into therapy after trying a couple out and not liking them very much.
- 52:14With this new therapist, I'm only three sessions in, but I feel like
- 52:16my therapist talks way too much. She talks over me, and she self
- 52:21discloses war than she asks about my situation. Today, I was explaining to
- 52:25her about my relationship, and before I finished giving her a full history and
- 52:31dynamic of our relationship, she says that she thinks that he is grooming me.
- 52:36My partner is grooming me. I don't believe this is the case at
- 52:39all, given them many years we've been together. Regardless, I felt it
- 52:44was irresponsible of her to come to such a conclusion based on how little I
- 52:46spoke to her about my boyfriend. She then went on a rant about her
- 52:51own relationship that took up most of the session. What are your thoughts on
- 52:53this end of email? Well, my thoughts are is that this therapist sounds
- 52:58like, at the very least a bad fit for you, and at worst
- 53:01a terrible, terrible, terrible therapist. I can never know that these descriptions
- 53:07are accurate, but if this is anything close to accurate as to what happened
- 53:13in this session, yeah, I have no idea what this therapist is doing.
- 53:16I have no idea how they even have a practice, So I would
- 53:21probably look for a different therapist and I'm sorry that you went through that.
- 53:24Again, I can't know that your description could be distorted. If the therapist
- 53:29were here, they could maybe defend themselves and say, no, that's not
- 53:31what was happening. There's a lot of things that could have been happening that
- 53:35could explain this kind of like one scenario, and I'm guessing this is not
- 53:39the case, but you know, who knows. Is that anonymous patron you
- 53:43yourself might have misinterpreted the grooming thing. I'm guessing that wasn't the case,
- 53:47but that could be Another thing, is that anonymous patren You might have been
- 53:52not talking very much, and the therapist thought, well, maybe if she
- 53:55talked a lot, it would help you to feel more comfortable, and so
- 53:59she started talking about her own life as a way of trying to prompt you
- 54:02to talk. Again. It doesn't sound like that, but I can't know.
- 54:07But basically, in your description, yeah, huge, yikes. See
- 54:09you've only had three sessions, she talks way too much. She talks over
- 54:13you, I mean, yikes. She self discloses more than she asks you
- 54:17about your situation. So would you tally all the conversation that you have in
- 54:22a session? According to you, she's talking about her own life more than
- 54:28you're talking about your life and my God, and then she says that your
- 54:32boyfriend is grooming you based on very low information, and you're like, no,
- 54:37he's not. And even just the term grooming is a red flag of
- 54:42someone that doesn't know what they're talking about. There are The term grooming is
- 54:46a well understood clinical concept that has been in the literature for I don't know,
- 54:52I'm guessing decades, you know, probably fifty years ish, I'm just
- 54:57guessing, but a long long time. So it's a phenomenon. Abusers will
- 55:00groom, and it's important to recognize the science and help people to get out
- 55:05of those relationships. However, in today's internet mil you you have a lot
- 55:08of people, including fucking therapists, that are throwing around the word grooming for
- 55:14extremely dubious scenarios where someone is you know, it's like gaslighting. People will
- 55:20just throw around this term when they just don't like a situation or they're interpreting
- 55:24it in a certain way, and they just say like, oh, he's
- 55:27grooming you. Oh he's a gaslighter. Oh he's a malignant narcissist, And
- 55:30you're just like, oh, my God. People lay people fine, they
- 55:34don't know what they're talking about, but clinicians come on all right. Sext
- 55:37emails from anonymous patrons, she says, Hi, doctor Honda, I'm entering
- 55:39my second year in a clinical psychology PhD program, which is when students start
- 55:45seeing clients. I was feeling anxious about this because we have only taken one
- 55:50class in psychotherapy, where we briefly went over therapy techniques and did three practice
- 55:54demonstrations. I did not get to shadow, I did not get to observe,
- 56:00not get to watch a tape from other students. And despite all this,
- 56:02I was the only student assigned a client. I do not feel trained
- 56:06or well prepared to start giving therapy. I feel like I'm going in blind,
- 56:09and I feel angry and disappointed at my program. Is this a normal
- 56:14experience? End of email? Is this a normal experience? Well? Maybe
- 56:19unfortunately. So There's two things I'll say. One is is that it's possible
- 56:23that your program has Like in my university, there are two different models for
- 56:30when someone would start to see clients. The model that we follow in my
- 56:35program, or at least the way it used to be. I'm not up
- 56:37to date on things at any Huk anymore. But the way that we did
- 56:40it was we waited a long time before we had students actually seeing clients.
- 56:47There were a lot of prerequisites and a lot of courses and a fair amount
- 56:52of time that the student needed to spend before they actually saw their very first
- 56:57client. Now, what I'll say also to that as clients or the sorry
- 57:01the trainees, the students, they always felt inadequate and they never felt ready
- 57:07to see a client. They were always terrified, so you know, and
- 57:10some students would be like, I don't feel ready, you know, maybe
- 57:13I should wait another quarter, and I'm like, you'll never feel ready.
- 57:16You could be in school ten years and you still won't feel ready. There's
- 57:21there's no amount of education that we can give you that will make you feel
- 57:24ready to do it. You just have to do it, and then eventually
- 57:28you'll realize that it's not as scary as you're making it out to be and
- 57:31you have more support around you than it feels like you do anyway. So
- 57:36there's that. So that that was our model, But there were other programs
- 57:39at my university that had a different model of training where you would actually start
- 57:44seeing clients fairly early. At a limited capacity. Sometimes we called it like
- 57:49a pre internship practical that kind of thing. So the regular internship was far
- 57:54into the program, when you had a lot of classes under your belt.
- 57:58But there was this other thing where you would see maybe just a handful of
- 58:02clients, maybe even just like one or two clients at a time, and
- 58:07you would start seeing clients very early in the program, maybe even after you
- 58:10only took one class on psychotherapy. So in those situations, what needs to
- 58:16happen is those students need to be limited in terms of how many clients they
- 58:21see, and they need to be heavily supported. They need people to be
- 58:24their right away, because we can't depend on their education level to allow them
- 58:30to be very independent. Right they need to be overseen very heavily. Now,
- 58:36interns later on in the program also need to be overseen, but to
- 58:38a lesser extent. Right, they still need to be very much monitored,
- 58:42but to a lesser extent. So I don't know if your program is like
- 58:45that where they start very slow with just a few clients and you're just experiencing
- 58:51that normal jitters that every student has when they start seeing a client. I
- 58:55don't know the other possibility is that the program doesn't know what they're doing and
- 59:00they are just throwing students to the wolves without taking proper precautions or without having
- 59:08enough support for you. I suspect it's kind of in that direction based on
- 59:13your email, because like, I could see a scenario where the program is
- 59:17actually doing the right things, but you, you and your supervisor don't have
- 59:21a very good relationship or something, or your supervisor is overstressed or something.
- 59:25But I'm going to take a guess and say that if you had a supervisor
- 59:29that was there for you and you felt safe and securely attached to, and
- 59:32that supervisor knew you well, that you probably wouldn't have emailed me as my
- 59:38guests. So I don't know, it's hard for me to tell, but
- 59:42yeah, there are programs that will have extremely low levels of education and guidance
- 59:49regarding how to be a therapist even by the time you graduate. You know,
- 59:52there are I won't get into specifics, but there are programs. I've
- 59:55heard from graduates from programs where they've told me that they graduated with basically almost
- 1:00:04no education on how to be a therapist. And some of these people have
- 1:00:07even come to me, and this is back in the day when I still
- 1:00:10offered private supervision, and they would hear about me, or they would know
- 1:00:15me as a professor, and they would say, I need you to make
- 1:00:19up for the education that I never got in my program. I mean,
- 1:00:22my program in theory educated me, but I feel like I didn't learn anything,
- 1:00:29and so I need you to start from the beginning and teach me everything
- 1:00:32that I need to know. And so I would do that with students,
- 1:00:36and you know, it's unfortunate. It's a disservice to the students, obviously
- 1:00:39because they're spending upwards of fifty sixty one hundred thousand dollars and years of their
- 1:00:45time on the program, but it's also a massive misservice, disservice to the
- 1:00:51clients involved. I mean, imagine being a client and you're like, is
- 1:00:55my therapist even trained at all? I mean, they have a master's,
- 1:01:00they have a doctor degree, but you know, you just think that should
- 1:01:04mean something, but it doesn't always mean something, all right. Sexy emails
- 1:01:07kind of along those lines, Patron Deborah. She writes, I just wanted
- 1:01:12some suggestions as to how to decide which type of therapy to use in my
- 1:01:15practice, since there are so many, There are so many different types of
- 1:01:19therapy, and I am confused as to which focus to be certified in just
- 1:01:22jim you in here. Yeah, Well, the thing that I say with
- 1:01:27students is just pick one and know that it's just the first one you picked.
- 1:01:30But I recommend eventually learning all of them, or at least five of
- 1:01:36the major ones. You know that the five major umbrellas that you would really
- 1:01:38want to absorb, and these are not just things you learn, they're paradigms
- 1:01:43that you absorb. And the ones that I would recommend are the cognitive area,
- 1:01:52and I guess you could say behavioral area is near there, but you
- 1:01:55definitely want to understand cognitive therapy. You definitely want to understand behavioral therapy.
- 1:02:00You definitely want to understand the basics of humanistic psychotherapy, not just the surface
- 1:02:07level rasiian a thing that you'll get in graduate school, like active listening,
- 1:02:12and that's that's good, But you want to understand humanistic therapy here and now
- 1:02:16existential therapy. You want to understand within humanistic therapy phenomenlogical listening, getting in
- 1:02:23touch with yourself and emotions, pushing back on cultural indoctrination. This kind of
- 1:02:30stuff. You also want to understand as well as you can within your lifetime,
- 1:02:36how culture affects people and affects their narrative of the self and the meanings
- 1:02:42in their life, and how it can oppress and internalize oppression, how that
- 1:02:45works out with people in a variety of different domains. You also, I
- 1:02:50think, need to know about systems theory. And again, knowing the premise
- 1:02:54of systems theory is one thing, but actually understanding it is a completely different
- 1:02:59thing. It takes a long time. You should also understand attachment theory and
- 1:03:04psychodomamic theory, how the past, how relationships in the past effect in the
- 1:03:07present, that kind of stuff. I think those are the major areas that
- 1:03:12I would recommend. And you're not gonna know all those things. You know,
- 1:03:16you're not going to all those things in the beginning, So would I
- 1:03:22recommend just picking one and getting to know it as much as possible, and
- 1:03:24then when you feel ready, like start incorporating another umbrella to your path of
- 1:03:30learning. Oh, actually another umbrella that I'm leaving off. His brief therapies
- 1:03:35and collaborative therapies, solution focus, narrative, this sort of stuff. These
- 1:03:39are powerful ideas. And again, it's not just a technique, it is
- 1:03:44a paradigm, it's a philosophy. It is a way of thinking, a
- 1:03:47way of seeing the world that once you get really helps occasionally in therapy going
- 1:03:53on here, Do I have to be certified in each of them to use
- 1:03:58them with my clients? Just Jiman Ye, No, I don't have a
- 1:04:01single certification in anything. I heard you say that with trauma therapy that you
- 1:04:06need training and supervision and of email. Yeah, so with trauma therapy,
- 1:04:13you would how do you become competent enough, in my book, to actually
- 1:04:17treat someone with trauma? Well, you have to work with either a professor,
- 1:04:23a setup professors, an organization, a supervisor that really gets it.
- 1:04:29And that's how it was for me. I was taught about trauma throughout my
- 1:04:33career, but it wasn't until I actually had a mentor about I don't know,
- 1:04:39ten years into my career that walked me through all the research and the
- 1:04:45therapies and how to interpret association, how to interpret trauma, how to do
- 1:04:50it ground level, because I before that point would have said, yeah,
- 1:04:56I specialize in trauma, or I know enough about trauma, I know enough
- 1:04:59about PETE to treatment. But I didn't really and it's so complicated, and
- 1:05:02there's so many nuances that you have to learn, and so many exceptions to
- 1:05:08the rules, and so many different presentations that you have to experience yourself.
- 1:05:13You know, if if I just describe to you Pete, if you if
- 1:05:15you don't have PTSD or you don't know anyone who has PTSD, when I
- 1:05:18describe PTSD two, you'll you won't know really what it is. You'd have
- 1:05:24to see it firsthand, maybe even experience it yourself to really get it,
- 1:05:29to really understand everything involved in it. Right, So it's it's it's that's
- 1:05:35what I mean. I could go on and on about how to become and
- 1:05:39that's just trauma therapy, right. So, but that general guideline that I
- 1:05:43laid out for trauma therapy probably applies to every single area. To become actually
- 1:05:47competent in brief therapies is the same. You have to have a mentor or
- 1:05:51a group of professors that really know how to get you to challenge your paradigm
- 1:05:58and get you out of a certain way of thinking and into the brief therapy
- 1:06:01way of thinking. It's really hard and it's complicated, and there's a lot
- 1:06:08of nuances and you have to practice it and iterate on your knowledge and go
- 1:06:12back to your mentors and say this happened, and they're like, oh,
- 1:06:15that's interesting. Let's look there, let's talk about this. And you need
- 1:06:18to read the research and you need to see how it works in therapy.
- 1:06:21When you know it's it's experience with education. So even just becoming certified in
- 1:06:29something isn't in my book, enough to be competent. You know, if
- 1:06:33if I met someone that was certified in exposure therapy, I would know that
- 1:06:36they probably had the baseline education, which is great, But by no means
- 1:06:43would I just be like, yeah, they're fully able just by that detail
- 1:06:46to treat everyone with traumas. That's not necessarily true. It's complicated, you
- 1:06:51know, to become a therapist, it's a lifelong journey, and it's an
- 1:06:56active journey you have to take. You have to participate in cobbling together your
- 1:07:00own educational program. When you're in graduate school, you don't have to do
- 1:07:04that. They just walk you through the courses and they tell you what you
- 1:07:06need to know. But beyond that, you got to take it by the
- 1:07:11reins and you got to make it your own, and you have to get
- 1:07:13out there and read the books and find those those mentors, find those supervisors,
- 1:07:18find those people, those colleagues. You know that doesn't like to become
- 1:07:23competent trauma therapy, you could just have a colleague that knows everything about it
- 1:07:28and they just you know, they don't mentor you, but they teach you
- 1:07:30everything and they help you with it. Right. So that's what I would
- 1:07:34recommend. And that's why it's so important that when you're in graduate school that
- 1:07:39you network a lot. That not only for colleagues to eventually stay in contact
- 1:07:43with after graduation, but also with professors and other sorts of people that are
- 1:07:46connected with your program, because if you connect with them, then they can
- 1:07:50be lifelong a part of your education and growth. All right, Well,
- 1:07:56that is it for that set of emails that related to therapy and training and
- 1:08:00that sort of thing. Let me, don't you think Email in if you
- 1:08:02want comment below if you want it. Everyone, please take care of yourself
- 1:08:06because you deserve it, You really really do