Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / The OCC's Risk Report and What It Reveals for Credit Union Exams
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark TriCal with another
- 0:02episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:04If you're watching on YouTube, you can see a different
- 0:06background I haven't used before.
- 0:08The WFC of course is with flying colors, and we're calling these
- 0:12types of new episodes, quasi new episodes, the Credit Union Round table.
- 0:18And if you're an old fan of ESPN sports reporters, that font if
- 0:23you're looking on YouTube might bring trigger some memories of Mike Luka.
- 0:28Jeremy Schapp Jeremy Schapp son, and some other reporters that used to
- 0:32talk sports every Sunday used to be my favorite show, so I stole their font.
- 0:37All right.
- 0:37Today other than this new format with with the the Credit Union Roundtable
- 0:42approach we're adding a new guest, which we'll get to here shortly.
- 0:45But first we're joined by Steve Farr, Todd Miller, and Dennis Bauer.
- 0:50Steve and Todd have been on the podcast before but, and this is Dennis's first.
- 0:56But if someone's listening or watching for the first time, could you gentlemen,
- 1:00give me a brief summary of your credit union and or NCA experience?
- 1:04We'll start with you, Steve.
- 1:07Farrar: Okay.
- 1:07If I'm trapped in an elevator and have to tell you really quickly
- 1:10where, what I've done for my career, it's I break it into three.
- 1:14Three phases.
- 1:14The first, basically 15 years at NCUA was in the field as an examiner.
- 1:20Most of that was as a problem case officer predominantly on the west coast, but got
- 1:26to be involved in resolutions involving conservatorships assisted mergers.
- 1:32We used to take credit unions from actually negative capital and
- 1:37restore capital in there with some forgiveness and stuff involved.
- 1:40But some of those are gone from negative capital.
- 1:43They're still in business today.
- 1:45So that was a fun part of the career.
- 1:47Then I when Mark went to the central office, I kinda followed him and
- 1:51did, worked remotely there for almost another 15 years in the division of risk
- 1:56management work that I really did enjoy getting to see help with resolution
- 2:01of problems in all of the regions.
- 2:03My favorite thing that I did was I taught I cost on problem
- 2:07resolution that focused on.
- 2:10Communications and I think that was probably my favorite bit there.
- 2:13But inside of there, we got to be involved in the corporate
- 2:16resolution and many issues.
- 2:19Towards the end of the career, I wrote the risk-based capital rule
- 2:23and served as the vice president of the central Liquidity facility.
- 2:28And then in retirement I joined mark, and now we've got a number of
- 2:32years behind us with the consulting.
- 2:34And shortly after retire retiring, I did do a stint as a CFO in a
- 2:39conservatorship in New York City, which was a nice experience to be switched
- 2:44over to the other side rather quickly from regulator to being regulated.
- 2:48So that's my career in a nutshell.
- 2:50Treichel: That's a great summary.
- 2:51You mentioned working remotely in the central office and if there's any NCA
- 2:56folks, listening or watching Steve and I created that opportunity for you all.
- 3:01It was a situation where we couldn't get people to apply
- 3:04for jobs in the central office.
- 3:05And I went to then I was the deputy executive director and suggested Dave
- 3:10Marquee announce his job remotely.
- 3:13I said, you might get people like Steve far to apply.
- 3:16And and lo and behold he did.
- 3:17And ever since then, NCUA has been able to supplement their regional
- 3:21offices with these remote positions.
- 3:23And of course in the current administration right now, that whole
- 3:26remote thing is I don't know if taboo's the right choice of words, but it
- 3:31they're trying to reign that in a little bit, but obviously in the right
- 3:35situations, it makes perfect sense.
- 3:37But I am I'm going down a rabbit hole on Oh and Todd, I'm not gonna
- 3:40be able to introduce you right now 'cause you just stepped away.
- 3:43You must be moving your cat or something.
- 3:46Exactly.
- 3:47I closed the door so he couldn't come interrupt us.
- 3:50No cats.
- 3:50No cats on the round table yet.
- 3:52We'll introduce them next quarter.
- 3:54All right, Todd.
- 3:55Let's a little bit of your background for those who may not
- 3:58have watched or listened before.
- 3:59Miller: Keep my elevator pitch a little bit shorter than Steve's.
- 4:03I was with NCUA for 34 years.
- 4:05The first seven of it or so was probably spent with Steve in the
- 4:09SE group and as PCO together.
- 4:11And then I diverged a little bit, but I can break my career
- 4:14down into about three parts.
- 4:15That first decade or so, I was either an examiner, problem case officer.
- 4:21The second decade I spent it as a capital market specialist in the Western region.
- 4:26So there's a lot of n NCAA's interest rate, risk policies
- 4:29and procedures and things.
- 4:30I helped develop, did a lot of teaching with that examiners in that area.
- 4:36Even helped Steve once or twice with problem case type communication classes.
- 4:40The last third of my career I spent it as a director of special actions in
- 4:45the western region, supervising problem case officers, regional capital market
- 4:49specialists, and some regional lending specialists for part of that time as well.
- 4:54Like Steve, it was a very gratifying career.
- 4:57I was involved in a number of credit unions that received special
- 5:00assistance that are still there today.
- 5:02I conserved a couple credit unions, returned them to the
- 5:05members, they're still there today.
- 5:07Those were pretty rewarding parts of the career, but I
- 5:10enjoyed my 34 years with NCUA.
- 5:13I retired in June of 2021, I think Mark called me up about August and
- 5:19I started helping him and looking through my folder really quickly here.
- 5:22I had helped you out with 68 different credit unions in the last four years.
- 5:28Treichel: Wow.
- 5:28Amazing.
- 5:29Amazing.
- 5:29Yeah, it's been a lot of fun.
- 5:31And I've known both Steve and Todd a very long time, but I've actually known
- 5:35Dennis just a touch longer 'cause we were examiners in the same supervisory
- 5:40examiner group in Minneapolis before before he went out to the real world.
- 5:44Dennis yeah, gimme, gimme your background.
- 5:47Bauer: Yeah.
- 5:47I've been in the credit union industry for 38 years.
- 5:51I just recently retired from Ideal Credit Union, located in St.
- 5:55Paul, Minnesota.
- 5:56However, my career started out with.
- 5:58As Mark said with NCOA back in 1986, mark and I were in Group A in region five, I
- 6:04think it was region five back in 1986.
- 6:07Yeah, so I spent six years with the NCOA, both as a, obviously a field
- 6:12op, a field examiner and then finished my last part of the, my career
- 6:16with NCA as a problem case officer.
- 6:19However, in 1992, mark was approached by a credit union.
- 6:23I was looking for a VP of finance, VP of operations.
- 6:26He wasn't interested, so he passes my name along to that credit union ideal
- 6:30or postal credit union back in the day.
- 6:32And I interviewed with them and after that interview, I took a job as the VP
- 6:38of, I think it was VP of operations, but I oversaw the finance and some of the
- 6:42operational aspects of the credit union.
- 6:45And then I've grown along with the credit union.
- 6:46We were about a hundred million back in 19.
- 6:4992, and as I mentioned, I just recently retired in September of
- 6:53this past September of last year, and we were just over a billion,
- 6:57so a billion dollars in assets.
- 6:59Most of that was organic growth.
- 7:01I don't think we had much in the way of mergers along that way, so I simply
- 7:04grew along with the credit union.
- 7:05So a lot of experience, obviously on the finance side.
- 7:08I ended up was, I was the C-F-O-E-B-P, so I had other areas report into me.
- 7:13Risk management obviously accounting, finance, it.
- 7:17I think I had HR at one point.
- 7:19I think when I first started too, I think the tellers reported into me back
- 7:22when we were a bit smaller credit union.
- 7:25Wow.
- 7:25That is, that's my story.
- 7:27Treichel: So you, yeah, so you bring a little bit of the NCUA
- 7:29things from back in the day.
- 7:31Ironically, we were all in special actions at different times in different
- 7:34positions but a lot of real world having been out there for so many years at
- 7:38your credit union and yeah, I remember you wanted to get off the road and yep.
- 7:42And I had just accepted to move to Texas to be a supervisory examiner,
- 7:45so that that worked out pretty good for the credit union too yeah.
- 7:49Yeah.
- 7:50Appreciate it.
- 7:51Yeah.
- 7:51Very cool.
- 7:52Very cool.
- 7:53With NCUA in, in a unique situation, I guess is the way to put it.
- 7:57They have one board member, they're going through a major restructuring.
- 8:01We have the administration who is discouraging regulations,
- 8:06discouraging new guidance.
- 8:07There's not a lot coming out from NCUA and historically we've always taken a look
- 8:12at the other banking regulators 'cause they issue some things that are very.
- 8:16Very detailed Sometimes that can help credit unions.
- 8:19And in this instance, today's topic is going to be the OCC Spring 2025
- 8:24risk report that just came out.
- 8:27It's the June data.
- 8:28I'll put a link to it in the in the show notes.
- 8:31But we're gonna talk through the top topics of that risk report and how
- 8:37they might relate to credit unions.
- 8:38And there's, the it's, there's a lot of rhythm between banks and
- 8:42thrifts and and credit unions.
- 8:45With that we'll just jump into the top topics.
- 8:47And the first item that I wanted to bring up here that was outlined in the risk
- 8:52report is the commercial credit risk and the fact that there's some risks
- 8:57that are re rising relative to that.
- 9:00Any of you wanna jump in and gimme your thoughts relative to commercial credit.
- 9:08Miller: Seeing Dennis and Steve's lips not moving.
- 9:11I'll jump in.
- 9:12Bauer: It's my first time, so I'll let you guys kick it off
- 9:15and I'll jump in occasionally.
- 9:17Miller: Perfect.
- 9:18There's a couple things.
- 9:19The commercial credit risk, it's been on the kind of a horizon or in the bullseye,
- 9:26so to speak, of all the regulators pretty much since COVID started and you had this
- 9:31work from home and vacancies appearing.
- 9:34So I think the commercial credit risk, it's been at the top of the
- 9:37mind for all the regulators or we're going on five years now.
- 9:43There has been some rising delinquency in that, in both the
- 9:46credit unions and the banking industry over the last couple years.
- 9:50It's not.
- 9:52What you would call a severe level of delinquency.
- 9:55It's still under 1%, but it has been going up.
- 9:59And I think that kind of catches everyone's highlights.
- 10:02We had the low interest rates during COVID.
- 10:04A lot of people refinanced their properties during that
- 10:07time at low rates, two, 3%.
- 10:10A lot of those are variable rate type loans.
- 10:13They're coming due for resets in the coming years.
- 10:16Of course, rates are up in that six, 7% range now.
- 10:19So some of these borrowers are looking at three, 400 basis point stocks and there's
- 10:25concerns are they gonna be able to pay.
- 10:27And what's gonna happen with, future losses and delinquencies.
- 10:31So that's a, it's been the center of the bullseye for all the regulators.
- 10:36We've seen it at NCUA.
- 10:38They some of our clients, they've been asked to stress
- 10:41test their commercial borrowers.
- 10:43They've been asked to stress test their ability to handle payment shocks.
- 10:47And I think we'll continue to see more of that.
- 10:50It's somewhat interesting when you read through that whole risk
- 10:54report from the OCC, they almost seem optimistic and surprised at
- 10:58how well banks are performing.
- 11:01But man, they are uncertain and totally worried about which
- 11:05direction things might go.
- 11:09Treichel: Great points.
- 11:10Steve or Talk, or Steve or Dennis, anything you wanna add on this topic?
- 11:14Bauer: Yeah, I think, commercial loans, it's a broad, right?
- 11:17It's a broad category.
- 11:18Within commercial loans there's different types of commercial loans.
- 11:22Obviously.
- 11:22I think what's getting the most press is obviously real estate values,
- 11:25particularly in like city center types of locations, where I think,
- 11:29as Todd mentioned, the whole remote work, the high interest rates, right?
- 11:33There's a lot of vacancies occurring in those types of of properties.
- 11:38Just in the city of Minneapolis, for example, I think real estate values in
- 11:42the city center area, I think they're down since last year, almost 22, 20 5%.
- 11:47So right.
- 11:48That's where the concern or the concern lies is in those, I
- 11:51think in those types of more in those types of commercial loans.
- 11:55And I know in our credit we didn't, our, ours was.
- 11:58Our commercial loans were fairly small in nature for the most part
- 12:02spread out either residential types of multifamily dwellings, and those seem
- 12:07to be those seem to be handling economic environment we're in pretty good.
- 12:13So I think where it gets challenging not only for commercial loans but also retail
- 12:18and consumer loans, is how do then, do you forecast this as Todd mentioned,
- 12:23what's your forecast for the future?
- 12:25Because that all has to be somewhat incorporated now into Cecil.
- 12:28So particularly as it relates to unemployment and real estate values.
- 12:34So it'll be interesting to see going forward with the current environment,
- 12:38what type of impact, those Cecil types of factors how that comes into play.
- 12:44Based on what I've seen.
- 12:45Trending for both commercial, just overall loans.
- 12:48It appears that Cecil since was enacted in 2023.
- 12:55It's increased, but probably not at the same rate that we've seen
- 12:58delinquency and charge offs increase.
- 13:01So I know there's different flavors of Cecil out there.
- 13:04Not everyone treats Cecil the same, but that could be a big, that could
- 13:07be a big impact I think to the credit union performance down the road.
- 13:13Miller: You bring up an interesting point with Cecil Dennis, 'cause
- 13:16you would expect provision expense to grow at about the same rate
- 13:20that loan portfolios are growing.
- 13:21Yeah.
- 13:23And for the last couple years for the credit industry, their provision
- 13:26for loan losses has grown much faster than their loan portfolios,
- 13:29much faster than delinquency.
- 13:32But for the first quarter here of 2025, Cecil charges, a provisioning
- 13:38actually shrank when you still have loan growth and rising delinquency.
- 13:42And it's like you ask yourself, did they get ahead by Overfunding in
- 13:46the past or are they just getting behind because of earnings pressure?
- 13:51Like I said, just the way Cecil works, you would expect provisioning to grow at
- 13:56about the same pace that loan growth is.
- 13:58And for the first quarter anyway of 2025, it's behind.
- 14:03Yep.
- 14:03Treichel: And as you tell, it could be behind because they're trying
- 14:06to manage earnings a little bit.
- 14:08It could be a little bit of architecture of earnings there.
- 14:11Miller: Yep.
- 14:13Treichel: So a couple one other thing on commercial loans not related necessarily
- 14:17to the risk report, but the things we've seen in our discussions with credit
- 14:21unions is NCA being hyperfocused on the annual review process that's required
- 14:27in the commercial loan portfolios.
- 14:28And oftentimes recently some credit unions have not kept up with that.
- 14:34And that's something that definitely gets written up.
- 14:36And then the, the discussion about office buildings being empty and the
- 14:40return to, to the workplace and how that might reinvigorate some of these
- 14:45office spaces near where NCA is at.
- 14:47Patent and trade is right, right across the street from NCA and
- 14:51they used to rent three or four buildings in addition to the one.
- 14:55That they own.
- 14:56And they've let leases go on two or three.
- 14:59And then across the street from that, there's a, another agency that was
- 15:04renting the building right next to that.
- 15:06And their lease is up in a year and it's been vacant for four years.
- 15:10And they have guards that walk around it just like the patent and trade offices.
- 15:14And they actually did a public notice that they're trying to convert that
- 15:17to either a condo or apartments.
- 15:19And then when you think about, when you think about the rate situation
- 15:23that, I think you both mentioned that, and that's mentioned in the report.
- 15:26And there's the, a lot of those loans are structured with five-year
- 15:31balloons where those can get repriced.
- 15:32So what happens when that happens if you can't reprice it?
- 15:36Reminds me of some or all of you may have gone to the School of Banking of
- 15:39the South for commercial lending class.
- 15:41Yep.
- 15:42I've seen, I'm seen some nods.
- 15:44There was a guy there, professor Willie Stotts, he looked like Groucho Marx.
- 15:47And he coined the phrase, or first time I heard the phrase
- 15:51a rolling loan gathers no loss.
- 15:53So you get to that, you get to that rewrite date.
- 15:56You wanna rewrite to a new, to the new rates, which is why you put that in place.
- 16:01But can they do it?
- 16:02Can they not?
- 16:03You might see some pressure on delinquency in that regard.
- 16:06Steve, did you wanted to add on this topic before we move?
- 16:10Farrar: Yeah.
- 16:11The commercial lenders you're always dealing with you kind of new issues
- 16:15that your borrowers are dealing with.
- 16:17Whenever I am out talking with people who own businesses and stuff, the conversation
- 16:23anymore always goes to insurance.
- 16:25They are really being surprised.
- 16:28This is just in, in property and casualty insurance, that they're being
- 16:32very surprised and some of 'em are even being counseled by institutions
- 16:38they've been with for 20 some years.
- 16:40So I think that's gonna be a new problem.
- 16:41And then you look at, just the state of some of the, the
- 16:44flooding and that kinda stuff.
- 16:45Insurance is gonna continue to be a new and more dramatic issue for
- 16:50a lot of your commercial borrowers.
- 16:53Within the
- 16:54Miller: fine print of the report, they actually mentioned that
- 16:57rising insurance costs, that are increasing expenses for these folks.
- 17:01Just turn this into credit unions too, and something we're seeing with some of
- 17:04our clients, as Dennis mentioned earlier, there's different types of commercial
- 17:09loans, but we're seeing NCUA is asking credit unions that are involved in the
- 17:15commercial lending business to really set concentrations on those different types of
- 17:19loans, the different types of properties.
- 17:21Before it was a concentration limit on commercial loans.
- 17:24Now they want concentration limits on hotels, on office
- 17:28buildings, on, just a variety.
- 17:30Go through the whole N-A-S-I-C codes and want concentration limits, very
- 17:36detailed for the different types of commercial lending they're doing.
- 17:40Raising the bar on expectations for credit risk management, for card unions
- 17:44that are involved in commercial lending.
- 17:47Treichel: Great.
- 17:48Great point.
- 17:49I that's a nice pivot.
- 17:50We touched a little bit on commercial credit, but another
- 17:53storyline is the retail credit.
- 17:55Performance remains stable despite headwinds.
- 17:58And that's a little bit, I think, Todd, you might have touched on
- 18:01the headwinds that the report seems to talk about the past and the
- 18:04future a little bit differently.
- 18:06Any thoughts on retail credit performance?
- 18:08Gentlemen?
- 18:10Bauer: One, one thing I've seen that's changed recently is right
- 18:13during the last administration and a lot of student loan debt.
- 18:18You could stop making payments, but I think that with the current
- 18:21administration now that's back on.
- 18:23So it'd be interesting to see I forget how, what the millions of dollars
- 18:26in student loan payments that are in arrears, how that might impact consumer's
- 18:32ability to make other payments depending upon where they prioritize where
- 18:36they prioritize making loan payments.
- 18:38All right.
- 18:38With inflation, the cost rate, that could be a challenge and that could impact
- 18:42I think credit unions delinquency and potentially charge offs in the future.
- 18:47I, again, the trend seems to be for credit unions, delinquency and
- 18:52charge offs seem to have leveled off.
- 18:54Maybe even down a little bit for this first quarter, but Right.
- 18:57There's always with that student loan potentially hanging out there, that
- 19:00could be an, that could be a concern.
- 19:02I think that credit unions need to address.
- 19:06Treichel: Good point.
- 19:07Good.
- 19:07Miller: Todd?
- 19:09I think the student loan thing is gonna be a huge one in the future.
- 19:12I don't know how that impacts, our accrediting people.
- 19:15It definitely hits your borrowers in those younger age demographics.
- 19:19It's just somewhat interesting.
- 19:20The, they talk about headwinds and, which way is our economy going?
- 19:26And Trump jumps this way then that way with tariffs and this and that.
- 19:30Delinquency levels are really manageable.
- 19:33There definitely seems to be a pullback in consumer spending are in bank credit
- 19:38union lending standards because for both banks and credit unions, auto loan
- 19:42portfolios have shrank a little bit.
- 19:45And I don't know how often that happens.
- 19:46Maybe it was just because there was a huge spike in purchases during COVID,
- 19:51but auto lending numbers did shrink.
- 19:53I tracked unemployment by states and if you look from December to May, 24
- 19:59states had higher unemployment, but 26 of them had lower unemployment levels.
- 20:04So everything is mixed and muddled.
- 20:06And if you look at the FDS quarterly reports, they break
- 20:10things down by their five regions.
- 20:13There's a lot of performance differences across regions.
- 20:16There's all these risks that are generic to, our credit unions.
- 20:20But there's certainly different economic zones in different parts of the
- 20:25country are performing very differently than other parts of the country.
- 20:31Treichel: We had the sand states in oh 8, 0 9, right?
- 20:34That's what at NCUA it was, where there was sand, there was a problem, whether
- 20:38that was Florida Las Vegas, et cetera.
- 20:42Any, when you look at the 24 versus the 26 that had up or down any, anything
- 20:47pop out at you on an individual state?
- 20:50I
- 20:50Miller: didn't
- 20:51Treichel: PO
- 20:52Miller: look at individual states or I didn't look at NCA's
- 20:56performance by region or states.
- 20:58But when you look at the banks, basically your coast, your San Francisco,
- 21:01New York thing are struggling more than the heartland of the interior.
- 21:06Last time the sand states I, my first four or five years as a DSA,
- 21:12right through that last recession, it was all spent in Utah and Arizona.
- 21:15And I closed a lot of credit unions in Utah and so did the FDIC.
- 21:21Treichel: Steve Dennis.
- 21:22Any anything to add here?
- 21:24Farrar: The one thing that I kinda observe is there's this big differences
- 21:28in the with all the generations in terms of how they view a borrowing and how
- 21:33they're doing their own finances, which will affect future retail loan growth.
- 21:38And to see how credit unions are able to adjust their marketing for
- 21:44the, the borrowing type generation.
- 21:46We'll see how that behavior is in the future, but it's something they
- 21:49definitely should be looking at in the Yeah, that's one of the key.
- 21:52I agree with you.
- 21:52Treichel: That's one of the keys to long-term survival, figuring
- 21:55out where the borrowers how they're gonna react so that you can make good
- 22:00loans and add to the bottom line.
- 22:02It's how do
- 22:03Miller: you capture them as depositors too, because Yeah.
- 22:06They move their money around.
- 22:08How do you get them to use your debit card when you know, a lot of 'em use
- 22:12Venmo and PayPal and Apple paid now.
- 22:15So like the whole payment systems are, circumventing the general credit union in
- 22:21banking industry with these third parties.
- 22:23And, it'll come up later maybe with fraud because the OCC risk
- 22:28report mentioned some of that.
- 22:30But like Venmo, people under 40, I had a thing the other day I looked it up, how
- 22:35many accounts there were people that are using Venmo, most of them are under 40.
- 22:41If I go through my history here on copilot, I can probably
- 22:44find it again really quickly.
- 22:47So Venmo's transactions are up 80% just over the last three years.
- 22:522025 first quarter here, Venmo did $342 billion in payment
- 22:58transfers between people.
- 23:00Wow.
- 23:00And you think of the industry, that's not a lot.
- 23:03And they're not the biggest one.
- 23:05They're just the fastest growing one.
- 23:07But it says 85% of their users are under 40.
- 23:12Treichel: So I'm one of the, I'm one of the fif, I'm one of the 15% not,
- 23:17Miller: I've used it maybe twice in the last couple years when
- 23:20I've sold stuff to other people and got an account just for that.
- 23:23So it's like, how do Fred gather up and get these people to become members
- 23:31for their transaction services, for those checking accounts and
- 23:34for those deposits, it's gonna be somewhat of a challenge, I think.
- 23:38Treichel: And by the way, here's my Venmo tip.
- 23:40If you are on Venmo and you don't know that you have to set some privacy
- 23:45things up so that you can't, so that your friends or contacts don't see.
- 23:50Every time you send a Venmo, you might wanna look at your privacy 'cause,
- 23:54because my kids tip me off to that.
- 23:56And then there are some other connections I have that are constantly
- 24:00or frequently having payments to or from.
- 24:02And it it's something that you wanna make sure is not toggled in the wrong way.
- 24:07So interest rate, environment created is creating mixed opportunities.
- 24:11One thing that popped into my head is, Todd, I think you mentioned
- 24:15the Trump tariffs and it's should we stay or should we go now?
- 24:19The Clash song?
- 24:21But the Fed came out.
- 24:22The fed chair came out saying, yeah, one of the reasons I haven't reduced.
- 24:26Rates is because of the tariff situation.
- 24:29So that kind of feeds into the interest rate environment that we're having.
- 24:32Any general thoughts on the interest rate environment for banks and how
- 24:36it might apply to credit unions?
- 24:39Bauer: One Oh, go ahead.
- 24:42Okay.
- 24:42Yeah.
- 24:43One thing I've noticed, and I followed this quite a bit, and as
- 24:45a CFO as the yield curve, right?
- 24:47The yield curve was inverted for so many years, and then right in, I think at
- 24:52the end of last year, it finally, if you look at the 10 year and the two year rate
- 24:56was inverted, you had negative spread.
- 25:00But now and I think that's why we're starting to see margins improve is that
- 25:04yield curve is not between the 10 and two year now it is plus 50 basis points.
- 25:09So that makes it a little bit easier to work in an environment where the longer
- 25:12term rates higher than shorter term rates.
- 25:15Back in September of 24, it was a negative 35 basis points.
- 25:20Today it was about 50, so that's a 85 basis point swing in a
- 25:24fairly short period of time.
- 25:26So yeah.
- 25:26I think mark was talking depending upon Fed that could influence that.
- 25:30Maybe not so much the tenure, but the short end of that curve might come down
- 25:33even farther, thereby hopefully allowing credit unions to continue to maybe
- 25:37drop their cost of funds a little bit faster rate than on their asset side.
- 25:41And we actually did see a drop in cost of funds in the credit union world in Q1
- 25:452025, similar to, I think in that article in the LCCI think banks saw that as well.
- 25:51So that rate, that's all helping improve margins.
- 25:53For credit unions, we're up about 20 basis points.
- 25:56If you go back to pre COVID or around right when COVID started, we're up about
- 26:0020 basis points from the Q1 of 2020.
- 26:03So that, that looks positive from that perspective, just we're, the environment
- 26:06that we're in, the yield curve is getting back to maybe a more normal.
- 26:09That, that could have an impact.
- 26:11And then also the mix, right?
- 26:13A mix of deposits has changed dramatically, which also could have an
- 26:16impact on cost of funds and margins.
- 26:19Back in 2022, right before rates started to jump, we were sitting
- 26:23only with 13% of, in credit unions.
- 26:2613% of our deposits were in CDs.
- 26:29Today, that's 28%.
- 26:31So we got a lot of high cost CD money sitting out there with the Fed,
- 26:35most likely dropping rates for sure.
- 26:37Or hopefully by September.
- 26:38All of that will start to reprice.
- 26:40And again if that yield curve stays positively sloped, that should be good
- 26:44news for, I think the credit union world.
- 26:48Treichel: Todd, go ahead.
- 26:48I know.
- 26:49Todd, in the past you've talked about CDs being at all time lows and going back to
- 26:54new normal are we at normal or is it gonna swing back a little bit or any other?
- 26:59I think we're,
- 27:00Miller: I think we're back close to normal.
- 27:03It's been pretty stable for the last two or three quarters, and it's about
- 27:07back to where we were in prior to the last recession in 2008, 2009.
- 27:13Back then CDs, money markets together were running around 40,
- 27:1745% of credit union deposits.
- 27:19And then we had those long periods through COVID were interest rates were flat,
- 27:23where there was really no difference in pricing in the industry between a
- 27:26regular share account and a money market.
- 27:28And you maybe got five more basis points for a cd, hot money.
- 27:33Was mixed with regular money.
- 27:35Once rates started coming up out of COVID, you started seeing a reversion
- 27:39to mean where people are putting money to where it fits their lifestyle.
- 27:43I'm willing to tie money up.
- 27:44I want a little bit more for my money market.
- 27:47Both credit union and banks improve their net interest margin in 2024.
- 27:53So I would say what's really going on is they're adapting to the new normal.
- 27:57And even now it's hard to make money 'cause rates are really flat.
- 28:01Monday fed funds were 4 33 and a 10 year treasury was 4 32.
- 28:06So really a flat curve still exists.
- 28:11The OCC report throws out that volatility of those longer term rates
- 28:17is higher than it was in the past.
- 28:21And, credit unions and banks, and it sounds like from the OCC report, banks
- 28:26are in worse shape than credit unions on this, but they still have investment
- 28:29portfolios that are way underwater.
- 28:31The credit unions here in the first quarter, their a FS
- 28:35stuff was about 6% underwater.
- 28:39Their I have it right here somewhere in front of me.
- 28:43On their HTM portfolios, it's about 6% under their water.
- 28:46Let me correct that.
- 28:47Their a FS portfolios were still 7% underwater, so they still got some
- 28:52liquidity in pricing challenges in that they're still sitting with investment
- 28:56portfolios that are not yielding market rates and there's unrealized losses there.
- 29:03I.
- 29:04They mentioned this in the risk report.
- 29:07They expect GDP growth to be really flat this year.
- 29:11Like you said, the fed doesn't know which way to go on rates and, because
- 29:16of this uncertainty, what we're seeing from examiners with our clients is
- 29:20they want way more stress testing on interest rate risk and liquidity.
- 29:24And they want different yield curves and they want different shapes of
- 29:28things and they want credit stresses combined with liquidity stresses.
- 29:32So there's it's uncertainty on their part.
- 29:36And when you do all these stress tests of this nature and scenario analysis
- 29:41is, it's to inform decision making.
- 29:43And I think we're seeing a lot of regulators.
- 29:46Imposing this stuff on credit unions, not necessarily to inform the credit
- 29:50union's decision making, but Yeah, maybe somewhat that, but I think a
- 29:54lot of it is the examiners want to see this to inform their own decision
- 29:58making so they can apply appropriate risk ratings to their credit union
- 30:02for liquidity and interest rate risk.
- 30:04And it does help the credit union, but this whole uncertain market, it
- 30:09shows up in that your examiners want enhanced scenario analysis of what
- 30:15might happen under different scenarios.
- 30:18And that's a burdensome request at sometimes.
- 30:21'Cause all the scenario analysis, it isn't easy to put together.
- 30:26It's costly, it's time consuming.
- 30:28Then when you end up with results from 6, 8, 10 different scenarios, how
- 30:32do you communicate that risk level?
- 30:35To your board and what should you do about it?
- 30:38So it's things that can inform decision making, but it's things that can just
- 30:44lead to more, how would you put it?
- 30:47Confusion amongst the board or uncertainty.
- 30:49Some of the scenario analysis increases uncertainty rather than lowering it.
- 30:55But for our credit union listeners, you can expect that from your examiners.
- 31:00They want more scenario analysis around interest rate risks and liquidity and
- 31:04cash flow forecast, in part due to the uncertainty of where things might go.
- 31:10Treichel: And theoretically that should happen.
- 31:12It, if you're, if this is the simple credit unions and you get
- 31:16more complex going up my arm here, if you're listening, you can't
- 31:19see the visual I'm creating, but.
- 31:21A plain vanilla credit union should need less.
- 31:23A very complicated credit union with different sources and uses
- 31:27of funds or unique loan programs should expect to see more of that.
- 31:31And that continuum doesn't always necessarily work for examiners.
- 31:35'cause examiners will see something cool that they learned that one, one
- 31:38examiner made a complex credit union do, and then they'll apply it in situations
- 31:42that might not necessarily make sense.
- 31:44And Todd, as you touched on you didn't say it this way, but one of the things
- 31:48NCA is not very good at is figuring out what actions they ask to be done
- 31:55compared to how much it costs the credit union to do that compared to
- 31:58what the actual value of that is.
- 32:00And you can see some disconnects in that.
- 32:01We've seen it amazing disconnects, I would say, over, over the five
- 32:05years in general, but in particularly over the last short period of time.
- 32:09Steve any thoughts on this topic?
- 32:11Farrar: Very item you talked about in that, be able to, if when asked to do some
- 32:18of these additional stress testing, have some knowledge of how much that's gonna
- 32:23cost and share that with the examiner.
- 32:25'cause they don't tend to think that way,
- 32:28Treichel: then they beat 'em up on profitability.
- 32:30Yeah.
- 32:30So we tiptoed into unrealized investment.
- 32:33I think we co we may have covered that next topic.
- 32:35Any more thoughts on the upside down nature of investment portfolios?
- 32:39Bauer: Just the comment that's been so volatile, right?
- 32:40The 10 year treasury rate alone, in, I think this year it's been as high as 4.8%
- 32:48and as low as 4%.
- 32:50So that'll, that raises havoc on that unrealized investment
- 32:53losses and on health to maturity.
- 32:55Types of investments we're currently it's at 4 35, so hopefully that
- 32:59stabilizes and that those portfolios can get a little relief, but that's
- 33:04a big swing right in, in a less than six, seven months 80 basis points.
- 33:09So that's all I wanted to say on that.
- 33:12Treichel: Got it.
- 33:13Farrar: Yeah, we had some of our, a number of credit unions that ended up with in
- 33:17the COVID times, taking all that in inflow of funds and investing at long term.
- 33:22And now we're starting to see the effects of that.
- 33:26The negative effects of that are starting to dissipate out of the balance sheets.
- 33:32Treichel: No, good point.
- 33:32Good point.
- 33:34Next up the general topic in the the risk report was operational risks
- 33:39being elevated across multiple fronts.
- 33:42Any thoughts on that broad topic?
- 33:46Bauer: Yeah, the only thing I wanted to add or talk on is cyber right?
- 33:51Cyber risk.
- 33:52We spent a lot of time obviously developing our incident response plan.
- 33:57And I think that is so key for every credit union is to have a incident
- 34:01response plan that is ready and tested.
- 34:05And probably the most important part of that is just your communication plan.
- 34:10So you take the, we took the approach that we're gonna have a
- 34:13cyber incident, something's gonna happen, we're gonna get hacked, we're
- 34:18gonna have some kind of exposure.
- 34:21So we took that approach in developing our incident re response
- 34:25plan, and we spent a lot of time.
- 34:28All the different aspects involved with that.
- 34:30But the hard part, I think at the end and is it's not the technical part
- 34:34of cyber, but it's communication.
- 34:36How do you communicate to all the stakeholders, to your board, to your
- 34:39staff, and most importantly, how do you communicate this to your membership?
- 34:42'cause that's so critical because you can, if you mess that up, then
- 34:47you could have a huge reputation risk 'cause social media will explode.
- 34:51And you're gonna have bigger issues.
- 34:53So that to me is the most important part of dealing with with cyber.
- 34:57And then obviously having proper cyber insurance in
- 35:01place, understanding your risks.
- 35:04You might have to have multiple cyber policies to get the coverage you want.
- 35:08But that to me is so key for for accrediting today.
- 35:12Treichel: Great points, Steve.
- 35:15Todd.
- 35:17Miller: Just kinda one thing they point out in the risk report along
- 35:20this line and operational risk, they talk about legacy technologies
- 35:25creating competitive disadvantages.
- 35:28We've seen this with a couple of our clients.
- 35:30They try and upgrade systems so they can keep up with the rest of
- 35:35the world and they end up having conversion issues and members lose
- 35:39access to payment systems and they get accounts that can't be reconciled.
- 35:45And so while all these upgrade paths are very important, it's
- 35:50like you need to have good plans and testing before you go through
- 35:53conversions of some of these older.
- 35:55Legacy systems, the cost of doing a conversion improperly is
- 36:00pretty significant and sometimes it drags you for a couple years.
- 36:05Back to Dennis's whole thing about having a plan for when something like this does
- 36:10happen, you had the big credit union in the news last year on the West coast
- 36:14where members couldn't access their funds for where to drag on for a week or more.
- 36:19Those are pretty significant risks.
- 36:22NCUA has been really good about how they handle this with credit unions.
- 36:26They have their information security officers, they rarely write doors,
- 36:31but they're really good about findings and they issue a lot of findings.
- 36:36And I think their whole attitude is amongst their information security
- 36:40officers is they are there to help you and improve your security profile.
- 36:46That's generally the course of action they take.
- 36:48Some of this gets back to a cost thing.
- 36:51Again, what can you afford?
- 36:53So I would just say, for the cranes out there, when you get multiple findings
- 36:56in your information security, ask your examiner, prioritize them for you.
- 37:02Because some of the stuff is very expensive and you know what
- 37:07has to be done today versus.
- 37:10What kind of residual risk can I take if I don't spend that money, for six months?
- 37:16So ask them to prioritize.
- 37:19I don't think operational risk and cybersecurity risk will ever
- 37:24leave the top three or four risks from our regulators ever again.
- 37:30And the AI fraud tools, there's, you can go on the dark web and find
- 37:34AI tools to help you commit fraud.
- 37:37So it's just gonna be an ever growing kind of a race to the top or race to the bottom
- 37:45depend if you're a criminal or a credit.
- 37:47You trying to keep criminals out.
- 37:49Plan on spending money in this area.
- 37:52Treichel: Forevermore, Steve?
- 37:55Farrar: No, I think we covered it.
- 37:57'cause I had wr written down and Todd covered it was you that we, are surprised
- 38:01that, the conversion issue has become.
- 38:05Something that's when it rears its head, it is just so ugly.
- 38:09Yep.
- 38:10Bauer: Yeah, that's one thing.
- 38:12We did a pretty much a wholesale change back in 2018 through 2022.
- 38:18We upgraded core digital debit card.
- 38:22We did a lot in a in a three year period of time.
- 38:24But just the core itself, take the time to do the necessary data cuts.
- 38:30I think we did three or four before we were comfortable.
- 38:34Before we moved to our core, we, so then when it came to conversion
- 38:38weekend, it went without, incident.
- 38:41And then o other thing I've seen out there is you credit unions purchase a new a new
- 38:46core system, and they don't necessarily know a hundred percent what they purchase.
- 38:50It's too much.
- 38:51They don't have the expertise.
- 38:53So I think understanding exactly what you're getting into before what's all
- 38:58involved, particularly at the end as, as far as generating the necessary
- 39:02reports that you need, how the report writers work how the accounting
- 39:06function's gonna work, how that's gonna maybe integrate with a third a
- 39:10third party type of accounting system.
- 39:12Making sure that's all tested.
- 39:14So that's so key.
- 39:14Taking as, as Todd and Steve said taking your time and spending
- 39:18the money to do it right.
- 39:19And if you've gotta overspend a little bit to get it right I think it's well
- 39:22worked out so you don't have issues with your membership at the end of the day.
- 39:26Treichel: As someone once said, if you don't have time to do it right,
- 39:28you don't have time to do it over.
- 39:31Miller: Exactly.
- 39:33Treichel: All right.
- 39:33Fraud schemes targeting traditional payment methods and otherwise, Dennis,
- 39:37I know you and I were chatting a little bit about a generic situation from
- 39:40a member that, that you worked with.
- 39:42But any thought, anything you wanna share about that example or anything
- 39:46else on, on what you're seeing and hearing about fraud or what you
- 39:49did at your credit union to it?
- 39:51Bauer: Yeah and this was a, at the end of my career, is just all
- 39:54the fraud that post the elderly.
- 39:57That's, that, that happens quite a bit.
- 39:59Particularly, and this one happened to be a timeshare resale fraud
- 40:03scenario where where we get a member.
- 40:06Wants the wire off 25,000.
- 40:09I get wind of it.
- 40:09I was contacted saying, Hey, we think there's something wrong here.
- 40:13This doesn't really fit the member's profile.
- 40:15She's a retired school teacher.
- 40:18This doesn't fit her profile.
- 40:20So then we do a little bit more digging.
- 40:22Give her a call, ask her what's going on, and she talks about I can sell
- 40:26my timeshare for a million dollars.
- 40:29I forget the number.
- 40:30That's not how, there's no way you're gonna sell a timeshare
- 40:33for a million dollars.
- 40:34It just doesn't work like that.
- 40:35Maybe there are some, but not for us.
- 40:37Not for her.
- 40:38Not for that type of individual.
- 40:40She's elderly.
- 40:41We're trying to talk to her and saying if you take a look at some
- 40:43of the latest scams, that's a big scam going out there right now.
- 40:46Go to the Attorney General's site.
- 40:49We can show you that information.
- 40:52'Cause this person wants to send, wants you to send them 25,000.
- 40:56You're probably not gonna get that money back.
- 40:58So they call her, they, it was an uns, probably unsolicited
- 41:01type of offer that she received.
- 41:03Say, Hey, we can sell your timeshare for a million bucks.
- 41:07All you gotta do is we'll just need to wire us 25 grand and then you
- 41:10can collect that back at closing.
- 41:13And she was convinced right, that it was the real deal.
- 41:16So tried to talk to her, got her on the phone with attorney General.
- 41:19So we went well beyond, 'cause I was right.
- 41:22It was an elderly individual don't want her to lose 25,000.
- 41:25'cause once a wire is gone or is out, it's gone.
- 41:28You can't get that back.
- 41:29I think finally at the end we were able to maybe talk to her and maybe
- 41:33a daughter of hers to have her stop.
- 41:36'Cause we weren't gonna, we weren't gonna do the wire.
- 41:39We said if you want this, you're gonna have to, you're gonna have to take,
- 41:42you're gonna have to do it someplace else.
- 41:43'cause we know this is a, this is fraud.
- 41:46Oh, that's great.
- 41:47You're gonna be out 20 grand.
- 41:48There's a lot of that stuff.
- 41:49Not only that, right?
- 41:50You got the male bride.
- 41:51We've seen those where, it's crazy what goes on out there in, in the, for our
- 41:56members, what they're facing as far as as far as these types of incidents.
- 42:00So I just wanna share that one.
- 42:02Miller: Yeah.
- 42:02I have a question for you, Dennis.
- 42:04Yeah.
- 42:05Had you heard about ATM Jack potting before?
- 42:07I never heard that term till I read this risk word.
- 42:09I have.
- 42:10Bauer: Yep.
- 42:10I've heard of that.
- 42:11That, yeah, I haven't seen that happen in our area.
- 42:15Maybe it has, but in our area where we've seen a lot of ATM fraud was
- 42:19on skimming and it's gotten a lot.
- 42:21It was, there was a ring here about two or three years ago.
- 42:25I don't know.
- 42:25There are a lot of financial institutions that got hit.
- 42:28It was pretty sophisticated.
- 42:30So with skimming, they put a device at the ATM and they read the card, make stripe,
- 42:35and then they have a little camera.
- 42:36Up above getting the pin number, and then they create these cloned cards.
- 42:40Then four or five days later, we get these phone calls right from our members
- 42:44saying, Hey, here, we got money we got money leaking out of our account.
- 42:47What's going on?
- 42:48Then you, we take a look at our cameras, sure enough, you see the individuals
- 42:52messing with our ATMs generally at two or three in the morning.
- 42:55So no one's necessarily is paying attention.
- 42:58And so we've seen that.
- 42:59But yeah, I've seen it.
- 43:00I've heard of ATM jackpot jack potting, but the skimming thing I've seen that
- 43:06part, that type of situation maybe should be maybe diminishing just because of
- 43:10the types of cards we're using today.
- 43:12But those types of things happen I think quite often to financial
- 43:16institutions skimming and possibly jack potting as well.
- 43:19Treichel: What is ATM jack potting.
- 43:23Miller: So they actually get control of the, a TM using
- 43:25a universal key or whatever.
- 43:27And they install software to let them just push a bunch of buttons and it just
- 43:31spits out all the cash in the machine.
- 43:32Oh my.
- 43:34Farrar: So they're
- 43:34Miller: actually getting into the operating system of the ATM quite
- 43:38often with Universal Keys, which means there's probably somebody from inside
- 43:43the credit union or somebody inside the, the bulk or the money transfer people.
- 43:48Wells Fargo, the people that pick up money and stuff.
- 43:51Armored car services.
- 43:52There we go.
- 43:53They have Universal ATM keys.
- 43:55Treichel: That's just reminded me of, it's like a different version of stealing
- 43:58the key from the post postmaster to, so you can go right, go to the corner
- 44:04mailbox and then take all the checks.
- 44:06And wash off wash off the ink and rewrite 'em and all that.
- 44:10Yes, I hopefully have good tampering
- 44:11Bauer: types of tools on your ATMs that would, detect that someone's
- 44:15messing around with your ATM and, get some kind of notification.
- 44:18So
- 44:18Treichel: Yep.
- 44:19Add another layer
- 44:20Miller: of cost
- 44:20Treichel: to protect it.
- 44:21Yep.
- 44:22Miller: There's a lot of times they'll hook a laptop or a palm like raspberry
- 44:26to 'em and they'll put 'em in like a supervisor mode or like almost your super
- 44:31user, like you're, altering the software and they literally take over the a TN.
- 44:38That's wild.
- 44:39That's wild.
- 44:40I said I didn't even know it was an issue until we read this risk report and
- 44:43I guess it's an ever-growing big issue big enough that they spend a paragraph
- 44:48talking about it in this risk report.
- 44:51Good point.
- 44:51Good point, Steve.
- 44:54Treichel: Nothing to add.
- 44:55Nothing to add.
- 44:56He's very good.
- 44:57Alright B-S-A-L-M-A-A-L-M-A-M-L compliance burdens are increasing
- 45:04is the theme of the report.
- 45:05Any general thoughts on that?
- 45:09Farrar: Hire experts.
- 45:11Treichel: Hire the experts.
- 45:12I like that.
- 45:13Yeah.
- 45:14Bauer: Yeah.
- 45:14To me it's a burden.
- 45:16It's a burden.
- 45:18More for the smaller, maybe under a billion.
- 45:20So we always had a challenge, how do you staff BSA when it's necessarily
- 45:25not a full-time, not necessarily a full-time position because of
- 45:29maybe your risk profile, but you still gotta comply with all that.
- 45:32So that that's a challenge for smaller credit unions.
- 45:35And when you have a department of one maybe and they leave, then you got issues.
- 45:40So trying to work around that, how do you how do you staff, how do you create a BSA.
- 45:46Department, if you will, or an office of BSA.
- 45:48So that's what we did is we as a smaller credit union, I, and I say smaller,
- 45:52under a billion we some more created an office of BSA where we had a BSA officer,
- 45:57but that was not their full-time job.
- 45:59And we collaborated right with, throughout the credit union.
- 46:02So someone left, we, we had that work spread out throughout the organization
- 46:07and we had a BSA committee that dealt with it on a monthly basis.
- 46:11We get together, talk about what's going on.
- 46:13So I think that's the biggest challenge.
- 46:15I think for smaller credit unions, Saudi staff, it in my opinion
- 46:19Treichel: makes sense.
- 46:20I'm going the next topic we have in order on the list I put together was
- 46:25the economic outlook remains cautious.
- 46:26I'm gonna jump over that for the sake of time.
- 46:30But if you have a thought on that.
- 46:32You can weave it into one of these other two topics that I do wanna
- 46:35make sure we give time to get to.
- 46:37It talks about low loan growth weakening, which kind of links
- 46:40into the economic outlook and deposit competition continuing.
- 46:45Any general thoughts on that topic, gentlemen?
- 46:49Miller: Loan growth was slow for both banks and credit unions last year.
- 46:52Of course, you had that huge loan growth when we had the
- 46:54inflation coming out of COVID.
- 46:56Deposit growth has been somewhat slow, but a little bit better than loan growth.
- 47:03So all the liquidity that credit unions were getting beating
- 47:05up over the last couple years, that's mitigating a little bit.
- 47:09For the credit unions, they're doing a better job than the banks are at growth.
- 47:13I track that deposit concentration and and piece of it in credit unions,
- 47:18they've been managing to increase their market share for deposits versus
- 47:22banks pretty much on a steady basis since, oh, the third quarter of 2022.
- 47:27Even continuing to now.
- 47:29So our credit unions are doing a little better job than the banks
- 47:31are which is a positive thing.
- 47:33It's just all with the flat yield curve.
- 47:36Credit unions are adjusting pricing.
- 47:39Consumer, like I said, loans are going down a little bit
- 47:43especially the auto loans.
- 47:45So I think it's back to the uncertainty thing.
- 47:47People are just starting to become more cautious and that leads to some
- 47:50of the economic uncertainties, but it is nice to see the credit unions
- 47:53actually getting some share growth again.
- 47:56Bauer: We'll see how things play
- 47:57Miller: out.
- 47:57Bauer: Yep.
- 47:59The only thing I wanted to add is I think the deposit growth will be a
- 48:02little bit easier since money supply is.
- 48:05Is increasing as A-C-F-O-I, I pretended to be an economic economist,
- 48:11so I play one at, I played one at work, but I'm way no expert at it.
- 48:15But I started falling M1 and M two, the whole money supply.
- 48:18So more money's available.
- 48:21Deposits should be easier to come by.
- 48:23And that was very easy to see when all that COVID money came in.
- 48:26It, I think it peaked at 22 trillion in 2021.
- 48:31And then right then we saw a big drop.
- 48:33Not a big drop, but a drop.
- 48:34It dropped down to about 20 trillion in money in July.
- 48:39And credit unions were struggling right during that period
- 48:40of time to grow deposits.
- 48:42But since then, it's almost back up to what it was when it hit its peak in 21.
- 48:47So with the increase of money supply that should tell a credit union a few things.
- 48:51It maybe a little bit easier to come by deposits, you still obviously gotta
- 48:54promote, but you might not have to pay as much 'cause there's more supply out there.
- 48:59So I think you gotta be cautious of how you're pricing now because of that factor.
- 49:04So I think taking that into consideration, I think we'll see credit unions
- 49:07deposits most likely increasing un unless the money supply starts to dip.
- 49:12But right now it's on a, it's on a trajectory upward since
- 49:1520, like second quarter of 2023.
- 49:19Miller: I'm not as sophisticated as a dentist.
- 49:21I just tend to look at personal income and debt service and saving rates.
- 49:25Saving rates actually improved in 2024, over 2023 and 2022.
- 49:31Yeah, and part of that's people probably being cautious too, and saving more money.
- 49:36Now that money they save doesn't always go into your credit union or bank.
- 49:39It goes into their IRA and, the stock market and bond market.
- 49:44But people are saving a little bit more money again here in 2024 versus
- 49:49what they were doing in 2022 and 2023.
- 49:52Bauer: Yeah, I still, I think there's a lot of money still sitting
- 49:54in retail money market accounts, which is included in money supply.
- 49:58So we'll see if that actually stays in, if that stays or moves into the market.
- 50:03It's hard to tell,
- 50:04Farrar: good
- 50:04Treichel: point,
- 50:04Farrar: Steve.
- 50:05Nope.
- 50:06Nothing more to add on that one.
- 50:07Treichel: The only thing I'm gonna add is, Dennis, you've mentioned being,
- 50:10playing an economist at work, so I'm gonna, one of my favorite economist
- 50:14jokes, you know how an economist gets out of a hundred foot hole in the ground?
- 50:20No.
- 50:21That he assumes he has a rope and he climbs out.
- 50:26Bauer: That works.
- 50:27Treichel: That works.
- 50:29All the, before we wrap AI and technology adoption is accelerating
- 50:33the good and the bad and the ugly of ai and technology adoption.
- 50:38General thoughts, gentlemen.
- 50:41Miller: Freddy Unions need to learn this.
- 50:42They need to learn how to validate these models especially if they're
- 50:46gonna be doing the lending side of ai.
- 50:50Some credit unions have had some bad experiences with this
- 50:52already, but a lot of people are using 'em for customer service.
- 50:56They're taking members calls.
- 50:58I think the big thing, and they point this out.
- 51:01Several places in the occs Risk reports forge.
- 51:05You're responsible for the risk related to all of this, and and how
- 51:09do you control that when you sign up for a third party vendor that's
- 51:12using AI to do something critical?
- 51:15With your members' data or making credit decisions how you validate
- 51:20those models is very challenging because the models change every day.
- 51:23They're a self-learning thing, and there's ways to do it, but credit union,
- 51:28you just need to educate yourself.
- 51:29When you go down this path, it's gonna be one of those competitive advantage things.
- 51:34You are probably going to have to go down this path for some pieces of it.
- 51:39Dennis mentioned, BSA and a LM, anti-money laundering compliance.
- 51:44There's a lot of AI type models coming out nowadays to help with that type of stuff.
- 51:50So maybe you need less people than in the past.
- 51:53So it's a very challenging thing, and to see where these things
- 52:00are going to go in the future.
- 52:02Mark uses ai.
- 52:03He used it to figure out our whole process today, what we're gonna talk about.
- 52:07Treichel: That's right.
- 52:07That's right.
- 52:08To me, AI is a, a.
- 52:11A team of summer interns and you're gonna get some good data back and
- 52:15you're gonna get some dad bad data back.
- 52:18And if you're researching a topic, a lot, it can just save you a lot of time.
- 52:21That's the my big takeaway on on, on ai.
- 52:24I've got one other general comment on ai, but Steve and
- 52:27Dennis any thoughts before I,
- 52:30Farrar: mine's just on the technology adoption accelerating I think some
- 52:34of that is going to result in more merger and acquisition activity as
- 52:40people, just, I can't afford it.
- 52:42I can't get the staffing to do it.
- 52:43My customers are demanding it.
- 52:46So I think mergers and acquisitions will probably continue to accelerate.
- 52:52Treichel: Got it.
- 52:52Got it.
- 52:53Dennis?
- 52:54Bauer: No I was gonna talk on model validation to ensure accuracy and then
- 52:58you're not being biased and then you can explain, you gotta understand why.
- 53:02It kicked out this answer, so you gotta be able to explain the decision.
- 53:05So model validation can help with all that.
- 53:08Treichel: Great point.
- 53:09The, so ai I have a second podcast, credit Union Regulatory Guidance, which uses an
- 53:15AI voice and we'll it's audio book style.
- 53:18Which is where I started to learn some of the nuances of ai.
- 53:21And I will also do some AI summaries of bigger documents with the host
- 53:26Samantha shares which is Samantha's the name of the AI voice and
- 53:30shares, of course, for Credit Union.
- 53:31So if you haven't listened to that, check that out.
- 53:34And my final comment is a pivot to something on AI
- 53:38related to N-C-A-N-C-A Board.
- 53:39Chairman Halman has talked about how he wants to be able to embrace it.
- 53:43Conversations that I've had indicated to me that NCA and government
- 53:48agencies are not allowed to use it.
- 53:52And in my keeping up with stuff at NCUA, I downloaded some recent IG
- 53:57reports to Congress and they talked about so they have to report on anybody
- 54:03over a certain pay level if there were any actions taken against somebody,
- 54:07and there was a reference in there.
- 54:10Got caught that fly too.
- 54:12Multitasking.
- 54:13There, there was a reference in the document to somebody.
- 54:17One person resigned and another person wa decided to retire because
- 54:22they had used their personal computer and sent private NCA information
- 54:27to their personal computer.
- 54:31And I later learned when I asked somebody who, when I pointed this out to somebody
- 54:38who was either at NCA or recently left NCAI posed the question, did you see that?
- 54:44And what I learned was.
- 54:47That individual had sent it over to their personal machine because their machines
- 54:52are locked down from using ai, and they wanted to use AI to create some of their
- 54:58presentation that I'm interpreting a little bit there, but I know it definitely
- 55:02they used AI when they sent it over or I was told that's what they did.
- 55:06And then they denied, and you can see that in the report, they denied
- 55:10having done it, which the coverup was as bad as the crime as they say.
- 55:14The chairman at NCA wants to embrace ai.
- 55:17I think that's smart.
- 55:18Government agencies have to be careful.
- 55:20I think that's smart because you don't know you don't know
- 55:23what that AI can open you up to.
- 55:26It's here to stay.
- 55:27Embrace it but don't overuse it.
- 55:29And if you're at a credit union, just be very careful about building out those
- 55:33systems as you guys discuss discussed.
- 55:35All right, guys, we got a call to get on.
- 55:37Some of us have a call with a client here coming up.
- 55:40Any last ten second elevator pitch comments before we wrap?
- 55:44Our first with flying colors, the Credit Union Roundtable.
- 55:51I don't.
- 55:53Very good.
- 55:54Steve, Todd, Dennis, appreciate your time as always, listeners,
- 55:57I want to thank you watchers.
- 55:58I want to thank you.
- 56:00I for watching.
- 56:01This is Mark TriCal signing off with flying colors.