Latest / Newcomer Pod / Extremely Online (w/ Taylor Lorenz)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome Sally. Hey everybody it's Eric newcomer
- 0:15here with Tom Dayton. We've got guests.
- 0:18We've been trying to get on the show for a while.
- 0:21Taylor Lorenz is here, she has a new one of her stories where she
- 0:27smartly put has a word. That maybe like one percent of
- 0:32the population knows and then blast it out to the readers of
- 0:37the mainstream media. Now, her latest is Nim, sell
- 0:41famous for propagating to Gigi before, and I'll let her tell us
- 0:49the back story on this story in a second.
- 0:51I also have to say Taylor is like I've experienced.
- 0:54I've seen other people say this on Twitter, but is genuinely
- 0:58amazing at seeing new Cool things, take off the ground.
- 1:02I feel like as soon as I announced, my sub Stacks using
- 1:05my DMs like excited about it. Like giving me audience, which I
- 1:08can see sort of having experienced it.
- 1:10Firsthand how important it is to a Creator when somebody like
- 1:14especially sort of a kingmaker, you know, Creator reporter says
- 1:18oh this is interesting. I'm going to follow this from
- 1:20the beginning, so before we get into, Nims, on all that, like
- 1:23what is your strategy? And don't talk about me.
- 1:26Because I'm, that was two complementary of myself.
- 1:28But how do you, how do you sort of like, And I ball things on
- 1:31the come up or what's your sort of or you just like talking to
- 1:34everybody or like, what's your strategy for watching this
- 1:37stuff? Yeah, I just kind of like
- 1:39consume as much as possible and I just kind of spend all day
- 1:43absorbing content finding new people.
- 1:46I love to go down rabbit holes and kind of finding, you know,
- 1:49interesting new people to talk to in all different types of
- 1:52sort of tech, industries and content creators.
- 1:56I'm a big supporter of Independent Media and believer
- 1:58and Independent Media. So You know, I anytime I see
- 2:03like a new content creator entered the new space, that's
- 2:05really exciting for me, you know, I think if I had started
- 2:09later in my career, I probably would have gone that route by
- 2:11self. Maybe we'll do it one day but
- 2:14it's so hard. I don't know.
- 2:16I'm gonna it's kind of nice to have you know Healthcare.
- 2:19I will everybody stop stack World wonder is like, on some
- 2:22level. You're the natural, you know,
- 2:23independent. I know he was always trying to
- 2:26get me to do that. Sometimes what I really I mean,
- 2:30my whole like stick is just trying to get the mainstream
- 2:33audience to care and to kind of understand the world.
- 2:37The way that I feel like I see it online every day and so I
- 2:42kind of you know I like writing for a more you know Boomer.
- 2:46Like if I'm going to stay up all night reading Twitter they the
- 2:51world at least needs to understand what's happening on
- 2:55it. Well, the description I always I
- 2:56always kind of have a view Taylor is is that you know and
- 3:00Easy on people probably use is that you're like the great
- 3:02chronicler of Internet culture of our age.
- 3:05But then I always think that's a bit of a lazy way to describe it
- 3:08because there really is no defining line between internet
- 3:10culture, and culture, more broadly.
- 3:12And so to kind of segment the to in saying, you know, one is
- 3:16siphoned off into a certain group of people or listeners
- 3:19just doesn't really explain what's happened over the last
- 3:22couple of decades and so actually yeah I'm expanding what
- 3:26I think of your Horizon and as like an example of this since
- 3:29we're all just about implementing each other is is
- 3:34you know as a sign of you know the crossover.
- 3:37I have some friends that I'm in a book club with and the
- 3:39information wrote a profile of you.
- 3:41This is a couple of months ago and they were like oh can you
- 3:44send me that Taylor profile that was in the information?
- 3:47And I was like, well when I don't work there anymore to
- 3:50yeah, sure. This was from people that don't
- 3:53work in Tech. And so, I think, kind of, the
- 3:55great thing about internet culture reporting as you sort of
- 3:58approached, it is that you've shown the Check that it has
- 4:00beyond that and people do care beyond those that are you know
- 4:04it's a dated term now but like extremely online.
- 4:06Oh, I've written well, extremely online is the title of my book
- 4:10coming out next year from 70. But yeah, I mean, I wrote a
- 4:17piece on that crypto book schedules, right?
- 4:21Don't get me. Started on years for these
- 4:22things to reach the light, but, no, I wrote a piece on that
- 4:26platform, mirror, that was like some crypto blogging platform,
- 4:29but I wrote About kind of how I hate the term internet culture
- 4:32so much and I do use it sometimes because it is
- 4:34effective shorthand. But yeah I mean I just think the
- 4:37internet is is our lives and world only getting more and more
- 4:41you know, it's sort of embedded within it.
- 4:43So yeah, I consider what I cover very mainstream culture and I
- 4:46think it's a window into what the world will be like, right?
- 4:51So I like yeah, I like to cover shifts and in that and obviously
- 4:54covered the Creator world really early and have stayed on that.
- 4:57And I just it's fun and exciting.
- 5:00Cover and kind of like as a as a media nerd myself and attacked
- 5:04lover, like it's, you know, there's just so much happening
- 5:07in the space and there's so much to cover and I like to cover it
- 5:09in a way that gets helps people kind of understand shifts that
- 5:13are happening in Tech media culture, but in an accessible
- 5:17way, you know, or in a knot in a condescending way, he's one of
- 5:20your strategies for engaging audiences.
- 5:22Now, finding a single word or like we have qg, we have new.
- 5:27So is there another story that fits in there?
- 5:37I thought about writing about that, I, you know, there's so
- 5:40many things I don't, you know, I do I like to write about
- 5:44language especially, I mean I don't know if you read it not
- 5:47piece about nature at micro celebrities but like I wrote
- 5:49this whole history of the word Creator itself, which I've also
- 5:52written about. I wrote, I love there's this
- 5:59great book called Has internet by this linguist named Gretchen
- 6:02McCulloch who wrote about how the internet has impacted
- 6:06language. And I just think that the words
- 6:08that we use in the phrases that we use to describe the world
- 6:10around. Us can often reveal really
- 6:13interesting shifts in Tech culture.
- 6:15Whatever. And so I like, I like doing
- 6:18those stories because I think they're kind of just like using
- 6:22a phrase or a word as a peg to talk about some broader shift.
- 6:26All right? This is classic for this podcast
- 6:28where we talk around the subject before.
- 6:30Telling people what we're actually so Niche, internet
- 6:33micro celebrity name cell, give us the like, you know, 60
- 6:37seconds feel like how did you get onto this story?
- 6:40What is it? I was so late to the story.
- 6:43I meant to write about it since last spring.
- 6:44It's like one of those ones has been on my list for ever.
- 6:47And then I and then I finally wrote a huge condemnation of the
- 6:49other people on the beach and they didn't do no one on this.
- 6:57Just to be clear. It's such a crazy.
- 7:00Like there's almost no one on it and it's I think that it's super
- 7:05under resource for every place has like the one person that
- 7:07covers everything and you know we all cover things from
- 7:10different lenses and so I know I love everyone on my beat and
- 7:16none of us have time to get to all the stories that we want to
- 7:18get to. There could be a hundred more
- 7:20reporters on the beat and they'd still be so many great Scoops to
- 7:22get out but yeah, I would himself anyway.
- 7:25I know one of her like she's never going to let you Like slot
- 7:31like sniping. No, I would never I don't know
- 7:35if you that are on your behind and they're great.
- 7:38I am on it to honestly I mean he gets to the story that I wrote
- 7:42later but yes, the so many people.
- 7:45Well, when will, you know it kind of it was it was VidCon
- 7:48that really made me want to write about this and I think it
- 7:50was Amanda Pirelli or somebody at Business Insider rotary
- 7:53competed. Khan is this, it causes it.
- 7:56Yeah. Online convention, for, for
- 7:58online video stars. Kind of that whole industry like
- 8:02the influencers Comic-Con, you can think of it like that.
- 8:05And this year was the first year that Tick Tock was the title
- 8:08sponsor. YouTube has sponsored it for 10
- 8:09years and really pioneered it and tick tock tick over.
- 8:12And one thing I noticed is just kind of like the way that Fame
- 8:14has shifted like early VidCon and you know previous vidcon's
- 8:18that I was at sort of more towards the beginning like you
- 8:21could get all of the famous people on the internet into a
- 8:24room. And now I just think we live in
- 8:25such a networked world. There's that famous post of like
- 8:29we're all going to be famous too. 100 people and it's very
- 8:31true. Like, there's a lot more.
- 8:34Well, the term that I wrote about is like Niche, internet
- 8:36micro celebrities, which is a very tongue-in-cheek term to
- 8:39call yourself and himself. But it speaks to this thing of
- 8:42like micro Fame and sort of like being known to people, but that
- 8:46doesn't necessarily mean commercial success or like, fame
- 8:50fame. You know what I mean?
- 8:51Like, a lot of it's just knowing I'll tell us about the lead.
- 8:54You had sort of a lead character who is super compelling price
- 8:57woman. Yes, one of my favorite Nimbus
- 8:59Al's. So Bryce is this guy in South
- 9:03Dakota that just had like he's like The Unofficial mayor of
- 9:07Sioux Falls. And he just has like designated
- 9:09as such by the mayor actually doesn't need to him as The
- 9:13Unofficial mayor. He just has this loud and fun
- 9:16internet personality. That kind of everyone in that
- 9:18area, five thousand Twitter followers.
- 9:21So the key here is that deep deep in that world known by sort
- 9:25of the key people, but then it's sort of a tiny following
- 9:28somebody called it like context. July's micro thing in a
- 9:31different era and I wonder if this is some of the pushback, if
- 9:34there has been on this piece is that it's the concept of a local
- 9:37celebrity, right. I mean the idea that if you live
- 9:40in a town, like I grew up in a Suburban town, the guy that
- 9:42worked at Subway Del everybody knew about Dell and like he was
- 9:47kind of like a joke that we all had in high school of like, oh
- 9:49yeah, you're gonna go hang out with Dell later and that meant I
- 9:51go in a Subway. So that sort of thing has
- 9:53existed for. I mean, probably hundreds of
- 9:55years but it sounds to me like what you're getting at in this
- 9:57piece, is there something in terms of Being online and
- 10:02connecting to, you know, communities, that are not
- 10:04physically where you are, that changes, the kind of nature of
- 10:07this kind of celebrity. Yeah, exactly.
- 10:10So the big difference now is that it's not localized like
- 10:13these. I mean, of course, it is a very
- 10:15local thing right there. Tons of local people like that.
- 10:17Like you said that I think are kind of like the Online
- 10:19Evolution of those types of people.
- 10:21And then you have like just, you know, the most Niche internet
- 10:25micro celebrities for every little random thing, right?
- 10:28Like a really popular Facebook group or like a chip Person
- 10:30that's really into chips or whatever like or they're just
- 10:33really known for their like, weird Tick-Tock lives and they
- 10:36only have 10,000 followers like but they're very known to people
- 10:38that kind of vibe with them or care about what they are posting
- 10:41about. Like, in terms of the topic,
- 10:44it's just about sort of how famous becoming more distributed
- 10:47I guess. And there's less likely internet
- 10:49a-lister. I mean, I joked online on
- 10:51Twitter that I was in nam cell that monetizes.
- 10:53Well, there's a level that that's not really true, I mean,
- 10:58but it gets it is sort of question in the Use which is
- 11:00like do Nim cells monetize or like the sort of being the, the
- 11:05sort of sense that you're like, an influencer or this small
- 11:08micro celebrity, but you're not really making money off of it.
- 11:11Or how did you try to draw that line or how do you think about
- 11:14him? Well, so, you know, I think
- 11:17influencer is this, like, capitalistic notion where they
- 11:20used to be like, oh you got an online following your an
- 11:22influencer, but these people are not influencers and sense that
- 11:25like they're not looking to Brand themselves, they're not
- 11:27looking to have that broader cultural impact.
- 11:30Of them really have that broader relevance outside their own
- 11:33Niche, social group, they're just kind of known.
- 11:35So I think like not being able to monetize is is the story of a
- 11:40lot of these people because their audiences are too small
- 11:42and they're not really going into it for that goal so they
- 11:45say it's yeah exactly. That make it a little bigger.
- 11:47Maybe try to pose is certainly to not want to monetize and
- 11:51then, you know, someday your top selling TJ.
- 11:53If at first, you strike out with the Brand's, you might as well.
- 11:56Reposition yourself as a name cell.
- 11:57I do this, I purely cynical but there has to be a Of people that
- 12:01kind of like didn't quite make the cut in terms of number of
- 12:04audience that you need to be relevant to Brands and they're
- 12:07just like actually you know what I really was going for Niche
- 12:11internet. My yes a lot of them do is like
- 12:12pivot it into careers in XYZ right.
- 12:15Like you're known Melissa McDevitt you know like known as
- 12:18this kind of like Nation are at Microsoft ever T in the tech
- 12:21world for sounding this Facebook group, used it to get a job.
- 12:25I think she worked at Google or something like that.
- 12:26So it's a good way to like, kind of get attention and use that.
- 12:30Attention. Okay, this part got cut from my
- 12:32story. I'm going to give you the
- 12:33highlights because it was way too Niche, Media stuff.
- 12:37I think the media then part of like a lot of sometimes I write
- 12:40pieces because I'm just so annoyed by how like bad media
- 12:43coverage elsewhere. I think certain Publications in
- 12:46New York cannot distinguish between a niche in and at micro
- 12:51celebrity in their own little media.
- 12:52Jason universe and an actual influencer AKA everyone in Times
- 12:56Square. So this is a long day.
- 13:00Ugly. He's we actually mentioned sort
- 13:02of you criticizing the obsession over dime Square out another
- 13:05episode. Axford, it's not like no hate to
- 13:08them but like let's not act like these people have any kind of
- 13:11broader cultural relevance and I think like that and again, zero
- 13:16hate to them. I just think, like the way, the
- 13:17media covers it is like you see these Legacy Publications, want
- 13:21to cover online culture. But they don't have an
- 13:25understanding of the nuances of the internet enough to like
- 13:28recognize like WhatsApp. Actually culturally relevant.
- 13:31I pushed back, you know, was just the like Old Guard media,
- 13:35my imagination. By the way, I work for Old Guard
- 13:37me. Yes, I'm like you know, I don't
- 13:39have it but just like media, Prius like there was a sense
- 13:43that like, whatever the media talked about was sort of like,
- 13:45what people were chattering about and sometimes it was sort
- 13:49of elitist and like, it's not like they're running a poll of
- 13:52the country and saying, like, what is that on?
- 13:54Everybody's Miller like a snake. The thing is, is that now I'm
- 13:59used to always being Like what is a trend?
- 14:01A trend is something that your editors kids started talking
- 14:03exactly. But no, but you guys, this is my
- 14:06whole thing is the past 15 years have been about dismantling that
- 14:10and so I think we just see right like the New York Times, you
- 14:13know, style section think as a long and I work there, I love
- 14:16it. No hate.
- 14:17But like, you know, the definitely I'm sure in the 90s
- 14:19was publishing some crazy stuff. The point is, is now that now we
- 14:23see how out of touch specific coverage is and it's so like,
- 14:28you know, it's so it's so kind of transparent.
- 14:30So, I think if you write about culture and use continued to
- 14:33write in that 90s style, without acknowledging the Internet, it's
- 14:37like, we can see the numbers, right.
- 14:39We can see those following. We can see cultural relevance.
- 14:42So clearly that it's just, it's just out of touch.
- 14:45Do you think some reader to me, some readers?
- 14:47Miss that, like, well, of course, really understand that.
- 14:50And that's your leading people to be misinformed.
- 14:53Like, even you see sub sex? Even really like, I was
- 14:55Googling. So I think like, some of these
- 14:57subjects are talking about Times Square like people want like a
- 15:00No one step stick is talking about it.
- 15:02He covers it relentlessly, which is fun.
- 15:04I, and by the way, again, I'm not saying don't cover the niche
- 15:07internet, my properties. Okay.
- 15:09I love covering these people. You literally just wrote an
- 15:11article about just admit that they're like, you know, five
- 15:13people care. So, important to contextualize
- 15:16did not act like that is the monoculture are because it's not
- 15:20right. But what is the monoculture now?
- 15:22I mean that's what's so interesting about, you know, the
- 15:24internet as an audience is that it's literally worldwide.
- 15:27And so like podcasting is so interesting to me about It
- 15:30because you can have podcast that have a hundred thousand
- 15:33listeners that I would bet. Most of my friends have never
- 15:35heard of I, you said, what is internet monoculture?
- 15:38There is still right. There is still mass culture on
- 15:40the internet. There are still people that rise
- 15:43from the internet, especially in music and entertainment, right?
- 15:46That are that that are mainstream Lucas.
- 15:49Shock keeps a list of them, I think you, you know.
- 15:53But I mean, like, look at the rise of like, so many pop
- 15:56artists are constantly like, and a lot of celebrities are, you
- 15:59know, you could look at People like Addison Ray or some of
- 16:01these like internet, you know, famous.
- 16:03I know she's probably dropped out popped off but like, you
- 16:07know, she's putting, you know, definitely 2019, 2020.
- 16:09We're arguing about our parents. Like, it's, it isn't me like
- 16:12what Joe Rogan, you know? There's, there's these, there's
- 16:15these people that break out of their niches, right?
- 16:18And rise to mainstream Fame but that's not the nation at
- 16:22Microsoft. All right.
- 16:23Well I love that. This was a subtree of Dimes
- 16:25square that you weren't allowed to make.
- 16:29I wanted to add a A line I wanted to have a line in and
- 16:31matter is like this is like Niche between and I'm with your
- 16:36grievances but I'm no, no, no, no, I'm not, it's not Grievous,
- 16:40it's not. He, I just you don't want to, I
- 16:42feel like Taylor, you're the best when you have fuse, but
- 16:44you're actively, like, I don't want to be dragged in any feuds
- 16:47here, like arguing about these things.
- 16:52I love starting debates online. I just, you know, I don't want,
- 16:56I have no, like, I think it's all fun.
- 16:58It's all of your pro air. In your aunt.
- 17:00I know you once had a strong. Oh God I'm very antsy and I got
- 17:03can't bear if he can't bring that up.
- 17:06You need drum. Anyway.
- 17:07Next I want it. Speaking of fighting I don't
- 17:10actually know if you guys did. I don't know where this stances
- 17:12are here and I certainly don't have one but play out the the
- 17:15influencer Creator debate. I don't know if one can I read a
- 17:18section of Your Story Taylor? Because I think I read a whole
- 17:21story about this by the way. Okay, the Atlantic okay, okay.
- 17:25Well let me just read the paragraph that I thought was
- 17:27pretty succinct and got to the point It in, in your post piece.
- 17:32So this is from your story because the term Creator quotes
- 17:35with. So, synonymous with YouTube for
- 17:37years, people didn't know what to call those who were gaining
- 17:39attention on other apps. It's just funny, you say creator
- 17:42with students with YouTube and there is a term for them called
- 17:44YouTubers. So I'm interested, why?
- 17:46Yeah, sort of and they were it didn't transfer because YouTube
- 17:49itself, I have a whole section on this, in my book I actually
- 17:51wrote a whole piece about this specifically.
- 17:55Yeah I'll stop playing a couple years ago.
- 17:58I met I write this piece like you Again, I love talking about
- 18:01language, so I'm sure you guys remember, originally YouTubers
- 18:04were called Partners. Do you guys remember that?
- 18:07Well, that relates to the YouTube Partner program.
- 18:09Yes, exactly an initiative. Right?
- 18:11And so then they bought next new networks and and next new kind
- 18:14of coined this term Creator and that became so synonymous with
- 18:17YouTube because YouTube pushed that term, right?
- 18:19They had the whole ad campaign. It was all creators.
- 18:21I'm sure. Mark, Bart Bergens book gets
- 18:23into this to really go after you.
- 18:27She's awesome. So, you know, it It was people
- 18:31who were Vine stars and influencers on Instagram.
- 18:35Remember, they were called Instagram Stars.
- 18:36People didn't even use that word.
- 18:37Influenza there was these like, weird words that people and blog
- 18:42Tumblr, you know, Tumblr, I blood pretty or whatever.
- 18:45It wasn't until marketers who had always use the term
- 18:48influencer. Since the early 2000s, you know,
- 18:50put marketing dollars into the industry and the marketing
- 18:53industry was dominating. The monetization of that
- 18:56industry, that that term influencer became popularized.
- 18:58Also the fall of Vine People needed a word, like, Logan Paul
- 19:02became so platform agnostic and he became more of a YouTuber.
- 19:05So anyway and then it didn't flip back and talk to creators
- 19:08until in the past year. Really, but really 2021 when
- 19:12tack, when the tech industry came and I think part of that
- 19:15was because the tech industry is always preferred that term.
- 19:19And also, because I think a lot of VCS want to distance
- 19:22themselves between from their bad takes about influencers,
- 19:25which they spent, you know, everything shitting on his
- 19:28interests. And also Creator is such a A
- 19:30good capitalist sort of like, yeah, well, not as good as
- 19:32influencer though, right? And then I got the greatest one
- 19:35because that means you can influence other people to buy
- 19:37products, which like you said earlier is a capitalist arrived
- 19:40term. I mean, it's as pure As It Gets
- 19:42In terms of what function they serve to the people that care
- 19:45about them, which is that these people can push product, which
- 19:48is how the, you know, the market moves but it but the way that
- 19:52that people started to monetize has shifted as you guys know,
- 19:55right? So, it was about pushing
- 19:57products. So I think influencer was the
- 19:59best term but I I think as people have relied on more
- 20:01direct monetization, I think a lot of people that term Creator
- 20:06is stuck, a little bit more like is used by platforms, like
- 20:09pushing that or like, no hate for procreator or what's your
- 20:12preferred. What term do you prefer?
- 20:15Oh, I love all of them. I loved the web pretty.
- 20:17Do you guys remember that one? Yeah, that was in your piece and
- 20:20it was a little Elmer Fudd for me.
- 20:22Oh my God, I was such a thing in like the Julia Allison.
- 20:26If Fame ball people used to go, I just think it's, you know,
- 20:29people are always always trying to kind of articulate this term
- 20:33for, for you. No more distributed media
- 20:35environment. I don't have a preference
- 20:37preference, I mean, Creator and influence are interchangeable.
- 20:40And a lot of times when you hear people hating on the word
- 20:43influencer, they it's a little bit of a like misogyny you type
- 20:47of energy because influence her because the right, you know, you
- 20:52have to remember the pioneers and the Pioneers that pioneered,
- 20:55the whole quote unquote Creator, economy were women and people of
- 20:58color and lgbtq Unity. And again, a lot of VCS were, I
- 21:04think, like to like distance themselves from the roots of
- 21:06that, which is a shame, but Creator, you know, I think it
- 21:09all works out. It's, it's how you wear it
- 21:12right, that matters, right? And what you mean to your
- 21:15audience? Yeah, we back to the platform's
- 21:17specifically. I don't know how much you you
- 21:20want to make this point in your piece but like the Nim cell
- 21:24concept, seems intrinsically married to tick tock, I
- 21:28understand that there are named cells that Are on and you
- 21:30mentioned there on, whatever Reddit boards are, you know,
- 21:32Discord or twitch and all other kinds of things.
- 21:35But just from my read of it though, nature of the
- 21:39algorithmic feed. And, you know, these kind of a,
- 21:42i derived entertainment channels would push people towards.
- 21:46I mean, everything is curated for your particular interest as
- 21:48the app understands. And so the NIMS cell idea just
- 21:51seems like it fits so perfectly with that because this is about
- 21:55Niche interests and this is about an app that is trying to
- 21:58do its best to cater to what it thinks.
- 22:00Your interests are which are inherently Niche, I mean, what
- 22:02do you think like how much how much of a name cell is Tick-Tock
- 22:05versus the other platforms that you kind of describe in the
- 22:08piece? Yeah so it actually emerged in
- 22:10the Instagram meme Community for Niche meme Pages which are so
- 22:16popular but I think you're right.
- 22:17Tom 100% like this term would not exist without the rise of
- 22:21tick-tock I think because you, you wouldn't have seen and I
- 22:24think with people getting more online during the pandemic and
- 22:26kind of becoming more networks themselves and knowing more
- 22:29online people, But yeah it's completely tied to that because
- 22:32I you know like famous so distributed on Tick-Tock exactly
- 22:35what you just said the algorithm is like spoon-feeding you
- 22:37content right in your Niche. I mean like Tick-Tock has been
- 22:40so good at like the long tail whereas Facebook has sort of
- 22:44seem to shovel everyone to like Ben Shapiro ultimately or like
- 22:47these big big Pages. Whereas Tick-Tock and so quickly
- 22:52Zoom you into whatever, like small Niche, you're interested
- 22:55in. I want to go to the end of your
- 22:57piece to because you have a bit of a like dystopic Quote from
- 23:01from, from one of your one of your characters.
- 23:04This is at the end of it. You say it's fun to be part of
- 23:06this wave said Peter, whatever it is and start.
- 23:08Who's Peter again, Alex Peter. He's he's like a lawyer.
- 23:12Yeah he blocked me. I don't know what I don't like
- 23:16him. I don't know.
- 23:17I feel okay I'll tell him to unblock you I'll talk to him.
- 23:20Oh I want to know more about that if you're if you're on the
- 23:24outs with lawyer Twitter he's great though he okay he's
- 23:28definitely more of a you know Ray Aging anti-capitalist.
- 23:31I do run a VC newsletter but okay, okay, it's been, here's
- 23:36the quote, it's fun to be part of this waste of Peter, whatever
- 23:38it is. I think some people think it's
- 23:40the decline of society and maybe they're right, but it's
- 23:42interesting. Let's, let's unpack that a
- 23:45little bit here. I mean, why would people think
- 23:47that this type of character is in some way like reflective of a
- 23:50social and societal decline. Yeah.
- 23:53That is very tongue-in-cheek quote that I included kind of as
- 23:56a joke. Like it's a nod to like these
- 23:59hate these people. That I think do feel like it's a
- 24:01downfall of society and the heat on the internet a lot, it's
- 24:04definitely not the downfall of society.
- 24:06I am very, I mean, I think I'm very Pro these shifts.
- 24:11I think that are happening and media Purity to it, right?
- 24:14I mean, like, yeah, the things that the internet has gone
- 24:16through is, you know, in the origins of YouTube in the first
- 24:19people that were successful on it, the claim that these people
- 24:22always had was like, hey I was just posting this so my friends
- 24:24could see it. It was just a way that we could
- 24:26host these things and there was kind of like a Homespun
- 24:28earnestness to it. It.
- 24:30And then, once it became, you know, people got huge, If people
- 24:33could see there's a business, the whole like, you know,
- 24:36capitalistic Community got involved in it, it obviously
- 24:39shifted and to be like as uncynical as possible, it seems
- 24:42like the Nim cell idea is kind of a return to those roots,
- 24:45right? I'm not making me crazy, it's
- 24:47just me doing the things that I love to do and finding, you
- 24:50know, a large enough audience for me to feel like I'm reaching
- 24:52people, right? Know 100%, you're 100% right?
- 24:56And that's I think the beauty of this and what's really Read
- 25:00about it. And so.
- 25:01Yeah. And Alex.
- 25:02I think Alex knows it agrees, obviously, being an imbecile
- 25:05himself, but I just thought it was a funny Queen have to be
- 25:08sort of arch about the whole thing because part of it is
- 25:11you're not trying to be this big Creator but now you're in the
- 25:14post. So you have yeah right I wanted
- 25:17to and we I really like the themes of this part of the
- 25:21conversation will carry over to the next but Tom I mean you have
- 25:24a story sort on YouTubes. I don't know if it's that they
- 25:28just fell backwards and To being great at podcasting or or if
- 25:32this was a strategy or how much credit you give YouTube or they
- 25:35just have lists Juggernaut that they locked out with or like,
- 25:40what, what is your take on why? Well, first prove to us, I guess
- 25:44the YouTube is ascendant and podcasting, and then why did
- 25:47that happen? Sure, I don't even know how much
- 25:49I have to prove. Yeah, as I'm moving on to the
- 25:51YouTube video, I was talking to some of my media sources back
- 25:54with that was, you know, my racket and I was like, oh, I'm
- 25:57covering YouTube. They're like, you know, they're
- 25:59huge and Thing and I'm like, what do you mean?
- 26:01Huge and podcast? I mean, like they're literally
- 26:03the largest platform of podcasts and distributor podcasts out
- 26:07there. Like there was a survey, they
- 26:08came out to surveys, I found earlier this year, that showed
- 26:11that more people, listen to podcasts on YouTube than they do
- 26:14on Spotify or apple. And so, and the fact that I
- 26:18didn't know this was something that I realized I was reporting
- 26:20the Pieces Just because I'm old, I was gonna say I listen to all
- 26:24podcasts on YouTube that's like the place to go for podcast.
- 26:27Yeah. And like the more I think about
- 26:29it. I uh, Obviously Listen to, It's
- 26:30not on YouTube to so it shouldn't have been a surprising
- 26:32to me as it was. But yeah, the fact is, you know
- 26:35where is Spotify? For example, when they went into
- 26:37podcasting there were like we're going to fucking spend hundreds
- 26:40of millions of dollars were going to sign exclusive deals.
- 26:43We're going to make it clear to people that this is the place
- 26:45that you should, you know, list to subscribe and listen to all
- 26:48of your podcast and apple is starting to do that now and you
- 26:51know Stitcher got bought by iHeartRadio and there was like a
- 26:53huge cash infusion into this space to make different
- 26:57platforms, the podcast Hub and then you too.
- 26:59Because it is I think as I described in the piece it's like
- 27:02a massive star just that because of its gravitational, pull can
- 27:06just like absorbed various things into its orbit that it
- 27:11didn't intend to. And like the example that
- 27:14happened before this was music, right?
- 27:16YouTube is through the single largest music platform out there
- 27:18not because YouTube there YouTube's actual music efforts.
- 27:21They fucking suck. They fail every time you know
- 27:24that they make like YouTube red and YouTube music subscription
- 27:26Services, no one likes them. Well, the Bergen book which
- 27:29we're going to talk about Much more about, but sort of gets to
- 27:30the point that whenever Google tried to like, do these contract
- 27:34things, like from the beginning, that was sort of the failed
- 27:36strategy and when YouTube Just leaned into like let the masses
- 27:39do what they want. They've been wildly successful
- 27:41and so the negotiated strategy the business development
- 27:45impulse. But if but you know, like the
- 27:47Taylor's old beat, it's just been sort of let it to the
- 27:50consumer and the creators and that's a more powerful force.
- 27:54Yeah. And and so, like a lot of the
- 27:56basic features that we expect of podcasting players as like
- 27:59Catchers ourselves. We're like, well, he needs an
- 28:01RSS feed so we can just auto upload or episode when it's
- 28:04done. It needs to be able to like
- 28:07fucking play when it's in my pocket so that it doesn't just
- 28:11turn off every time it's the YouTube app.
- 28:12Does I mean like basic basic features they don't even have
- 28:15right? But because it's like this, an
- 28:18incredible as you like written about so many times, Taylor like
- 28:21this incredible audience, aggregator and the algorithm has
- 28:24this insanely powerful. May be dangerously powerful
- 28:28recommendation tool. It gets people keyed into
- 28:31different podcasts, which is always been this huge issue for
- 28:34podcasting, which is like, how do I find out about a new show
- 28:36to listen to the apps? You know, like Spotify and all
- 28:39those guys suck at it, but YouTube is the best at it.
- 28:42And so for all these reasons, it's become this thing.
- 28:45And you know like Spotify that they consider them their number
- 28:48one threat a YouTuber. Is, you know, it's like I guess
- 28:51with the piece as I was like, reporting it out, like tried to
- 28:54raise is like, what does it even mean to make a podcast at this
- 28:57point? Like if it's, you know, if you
- 28:59Something like Joe Rogan, right? He's like, my lead example in
- 29:02the story, he was huge on YouTube, obviously a tons, like
- 29:04millions and millions of subscribers to his audio show
- 29:08but he would have probably more people on YouTube that we just,
- 29:12you know, listen in on our watch and listen on his and it on his
- 29:15whole show. And so you know, I think this
- 29:17whole world you think it's one thing and then it becomes
- 29:19something else which I guess is like the core of sort of what
- 29:22you write about Taylor. But but yeah, that's essentially
- 29:25like the YouTube podcasting story and no one really knows
- 29:27yet like how much they're going to invest.
- 29:29To like take it on or it's just going to continue being you know
- 29:32the side project that also is the most powerful thing in the
- 29:35industry. I'm wondering Tom like how much
- 29:38of it is, you know, Spotify keeps trying to get you to like,
- 29:42watch these video podcasts, like, do you think that's trying
- 29:46to compete with YouTube and like ad?
- 29:48Because I've heard that, you know, they're just trying to get
- 29:50everyone to create video content for their podcast 100%.
- 29:53And actually, in the story, I was saying that the reason that
- 29:56they have a video player is because of Joe Rogan I mean they
- 30:00were going to do it regardless but like as they were signing
- 30:02the deal for him and his team was like look this guy's got
- 30:06millions of viewers on YouTube. You do want to just lose that
- 30:09they like had secludes together really quickly.
- 30:11This video player to kind of appease those kinds of people
- 30:14and so I guess like the fine line here is between like a
- 30:17podcast versus a talk show because that's all it is right,
- 30:21you know, it's like what we're doing is a talk show.
- 30:22If we posted this, which we want.
- 30:24I guess on YouTube, we technically made a pot.
- 30:27No, it's embarrassing to have you.
- 30:29You say no, the most powerful podcast platform in the world is
- 30:32YouTube platform that we do not publish to.
- 30:36Yeah. But I mean it's much more
- 30:37production obviously. Right is podcasting, sort of a
- 30:40thing of the Elites in some way or the sort of part of our
- 30:44blindness. I guess to the YouTube issue
- 30:47would seem to be that, you know, someone like me like I want
- 30:50podcasts like multitask. Marty busy.
- 30:52It's hard for me to imagine like sitting listening to like Joe
- 30:55Rogan talk for like hours on end.
- 30:58Just like dedicating my Attention to that.
- 31:00It feels like the biggest like waste of time even though I can
- 31:03see why he's an Entertainer. It's just like getting your full
- 31:06attention. That is hardly also you can put
- 31:08any place on YouTube, right? I don't find that way because
- 31:11like I put on the H3 podcast, which is really long.
- 31:14And I just like what happened on double speed and just kind of
- 31:17like which one is H3? H3, H3 podcast.
- 31:20Wait, are you serious? See, this is what I'm talking
- 31:24about. The probably has like hundreds
- 31:25of thousands of listen. What is it?
- 31:27Has no clue about its massive. Of.
- 31:29Yeah, it's like those Ethan Klein.
- 31:32Do you guys know the H 3 H, have you ever?
- 31:35Yeah, they have almost 3 million Subs but like it's one of the
- 31:37bigger, the higher castes never heard of it.
- 31:41Okay. Well there's, you know, there's
- 31:43a lot like that. I mean, only recognize this guy,
- 31:46I guess. I I've seen The chopped-up
- 31:48Tick-Tock of it. I guess I see a lot of these
- 31:50things now on just like Tick Tock, like hits of it.
- 31:53Yeah, here's a podcast with Hassan as well.
- 31:55Yeah, I mean I think that there's so many podcasts I feel
- 31:58like every No, sort of nation at Microsoft research, Society,
- 32:02country, two dudes in a room decide.
- 32:06I'm trying to fuck us to. I'm not hating.
- 32:08I'm trying to get back in there. I love podcasts.
- 32:12I think I think audio is a compelling format and like you
- 32:14said video, I mean the video component just kind of adds to
- 32:18it. Different podcasts have
- 32:20different levels of production but I think a lot of YouTubers
- 32:22also have pivoted. I mean look at what Logan Paul
- 32:24did that's like his whole business now.
- 32:26Right right. Yeah and I was like as video as
- 32:29it could get Get. But his show is really just him
- 32:31and his buddies, you know, sitting behind a desk.
- 32:33You know, you know, just talking shit.
- 32:35The pandemic also seem to play a part in it.
- 32:37I'm, I'm curious for you Taylor. Like, as you, you know, we're
- 32:42consuming you to podcasts. I don't know if you were always
- 32:44a work from home person or that obviously, you know, was a
- 32:48product of, you know, the pandemic.
- 32:50But as people were telling me, you know, because you could just
- 32:53have a tab open at home, listening to a podcast in the
- 32:56back room, maybe click over and listen to and Watch it a few
- 33:00times. That kind of helps accelerate
- 33:02that Trend was that was that your situation as well?
- 33:05Or you just have always liked YouTube for any other reason to
- 33:09be your podcast place. The podcast that I listened to
- 33:13were on YouTube, like I listen to a lot of YouTuber podcasts
- 33:16and I think like as somebody that covers the beat I'm just I
- 33:19also spend a lot of time watching YouTube videos or like
- 33:23listening to them really like listening to video essays on
- 33:25YouTube. So for me, you know, I feel like
- 33:29that was just The easiest one and add the Apple podcast player
- 33:32is so bad. You know that.
- 33:33I feel like I got into YouTube priest Spotify.
- 33:36I definitely the pockets that I listened to on Spotify or like
- 33:39the Wall Street Journal daily podcast.
- 33:41You know, it's like the news one, you know.
- 33:43But the other ones, do you listen to All In?
- 33:46We got everyone tells me to listen to that.
- 33:49I have listened to few times. They talk about meteors you have
- 33:52a take. Let us say, it's full of people
- 33:54that have at certain points in their lives like gone after you.
- 33:57So I don't know how excited I really loved your well, You know
- 34:00it's drama queen you and Jason I thought have like front of me
- 34:04your end of it along sometimes Frenemies I'm not enemies with
- 34:07anything. Yeah they like to like well I
- 34:09think in 2020 I think what happened is the VCS all decided,
- 34:14you know. I mean Jason to be fair.
- 34:15Jason was Jason's been in like the influencer, like he's always
- 34:19been on my beat, he's not who I'm talking about.
- 34:21But you know, people that injuries and other people that
- 34:24like had always kind of ignored my space and influencers pays
- 34:28forever suddenly now decide I'd that they want to be in it.
- 34:31I think they felt very threatened.
- 34:33Well, they need Viagra. I don't know.
- 34:36I'm die love debating Tech. I love it Anderson.
- 34:40I had me on their podcast twice and didn't release either of
- 34:42that bus. Oh my God.
- 34:43What, what what would you like to say something about to piss
- 34:49off, Mark, and then he was like, fuck this girl, what did you
- 34:52say? They're really sensitive people.
- 34:54Yeah. Oh, they're babies.
- 34:56They're babies babies. I just like, it's so like People
- 35:00who are such die-hard like free speech.
- 35:02People the amount that they're nervous system Beach at all,
- 35:05they're not, you know, they that's their pose, but then they
- 35:09there they like scare everybody. In Silicon Valley that like, if
- 35:12you say something about us, we're like watching you.
- 35:14They're very aware of like what people are saying.
- 35:17I feel like it's, it's really bad.
- 35:20One thing that I have to say that I love is discovering new
- 35:24little like really highly preventional kind of groups on
- 35:28the internet like media Twitter is very much like that,
- 35:30especially New York media, and I never was on Tech Twitter mostly
- 35:33because those people kind of, didn't they weren't relevant to
- 35:36my beat, like, I talk to people at YouTube, maybe the platforms,
- 35:39but like, definitely not the PCS other than, I mean, see, what is
- 35:42it tpg or the churn and group? There they were, they were might
- 35:47and, and light speed, and some other, you know, I talked to
- 35:49them sometimes, but the, like a reason, whatever.
- 35:52And 2020, I think they all just decided to get involved.
- 35:55And I, that's the first time that I discovered Tech Twitter
- 35:57and I love it. The story.
- 36:01I feel like it's been maybe a year and a half that VCS were
- 36:06just like trying to will consumer investments into being.
- 36:09I mean, there really haven't been a lot.
- 36:11I mean, you could argue. Some people will say, like,
- 36:12coinbase, Robin Hood given, but like, I feel like a true like
- 36:16consumer company hasn't really hit.
- 36:19Obviously injuries to went all in on clubhouse.
- 36:21You know. Haha, sub stock is sort of
- 36:23consumer. I mean, be real.
- 36:27I mean, what not? I don't know.
- 36:28Like, Are you? Yeah.
- 36:31Are you optimistic about any like the new sort of startups?
- 36:35Well, I think it's cool and I like to see new.
- 36:38I mean, we need more and more competitive landscape in terms
- 36:41of social, but yeah, they do try and will things into existence
- 36:45and they're just so there's a lot of drama and pettiness in
- 36:48that world and obsession with image, which I find so fun to
- 36:52watch. I think that's what I love about
- 36:54covering it influencer world and like, they really want that it.
- 36:57They want influence so badly. So It's fun.
- 37:00It's always satisfying to see that.
- 37:02No matter how wealthy people are.
- 37:04They still end up having like many of the same concerns that
- 37:08everyone else has. It's like I'm petty feuds on
- 37:10Twitter like I. Yeah, well certainly filtering
- 37:13any of that through Twitter. Yeah, I mean I gotta say Taylor
- 37:16and you're like, you know, the real cultural Anthropologist of
- 37:20the internet. So I may be out of my league
- 37:22here. But like I think Twitter 2020
- 37:25around the time that this sort of thing was happening that
- 37:27these guys are all getting up one of the worst times.
- 37:29Times on Twitter. I just felt like people are so
- 37:32disjointed and unhappy and just like, spewing out left and
- 37:36right, anything? I mean we may be terrified
- 37:38because of the pandemic and, you know, stuck at home and they
- 37:41people were just losing their minds, but that whole period
- 37:44just awful. Well, we got any Trump I think
- 37:46that helped in some ways. Tom, you're totally right.
- 37:49Like I think a lot of there was a lot of like rage and
- 37:53frustration that was like pent-up and it kind of came to a
- 37:56head and I think, especially in the tech world.
- 37:59Yeah, it was so vicious. I was so surprised because I'm
- 38:03such a and I think this is why none of these tech people have
- 38:06been able to like you know they wanted to paint me as this like
- 38:10in SeaTac data dot when it's like Kara Swisher was had
- 38:13something on Twitter. It's like you could not pick a
- 38:15worse, right? Person to kind of like try and
- 38:18apply those labels to, cause it's like, just counterfactual
- 38:21to, like, literally everything I right?
- 38:23And so yeah, it's funny. And I ate and now they've moved
- 38:27on. I think two different things.
- 38:29Eggs and sugar and it's kind of diffuse now.
- 38:31And you know, kind of thinking about this.
- 38:33I don't even know Eric's thought about this in a way that period
- 38:36and like you're being a central character to that is almost the
- 38:40inspiration for this podcast. Wow.
- 38:43No. Because there was so much it
- 38:45wasn't just about you. It was also about this
- 38:47generalized feeling. Yeah, that's right.
- 38:49Yes. I met a conversation about it.
- 38:52I mean, part of what's frustrating about Twitter is
- 38:54that it's so short that it feels like.
- 38:56You can't really have the actual debate.
- 38:59And that these tech people have their own built-in audience so
- 39:02they can get super validated. They act like what we're the
- 39:06cathedral right? Where are the reporters that are
- 39:08so powerful? So they act like, we're the
- 39:10elites even though they often have like bigger following than
- 39:13us, certainly way more money and people their fans have a
- 39:17financial incentive to suck up to them because these are the
- 39:20people that might give them funding but then they act like
- 39:22they're the victims and then reporters who, I mean, this is
- 39:25the most, you know, complimentary of us.
- 39:27You could be, we wanted to Beat It.
- 39:29It out where the suckers for like, oh yeah, you disagree with
- 39:32me, let's have like this substantive debate, so it's easy
- 39:35to and I think as somebody that loves Tech and like, you know,
- 39:42good products people, I, I find when I, it's like, they like to
- 39:45kind of, like, think of think about things in an interesting
- 39:48way, right? And like feel like, hey, like
- 39:50let's take a look at this product and how it's being used
- 39:52and emergent user behavior and think about it.
- 39:54And I think it's, you know, but I will say it every time, I
- 39:57criticize Tech Twitter or VC is People like not all you know not
- 40:01and it's true. It is more like Normie.
- 40:03Sort of only the normal ones are just not doing the feuds but I
- 40:07think it's fun. I mean I think it's fun to cover
- 40:09as a journalist and that's I agree.
- 40:11That's the benefit of podcasting, right?
- 40:13You can like go a little deeper and it's more obvious is if
- 40:17someone isn't engaging on a podcast or whereas on Twitter
- 40:20that you can just say your thing I mean we talk about this
- 40:24endlessly but Marc Andreessen like the fact that he invested
- 40:27in real estate thing after the whole Be incident and never even
- 40:31has to like these where the circle he never even has to say,
- 40:35oh yeah, this is why I wrote the letter because we live in this
- 40:38media environment where you can just do two contradictory things
- 40:41and never really have to answer which is it the contradictions,
- 40:44right? Like that is like classic
- 40:46YouTuber, Behavior, never apologize.
- 40:48Never could sleep. You write your own narrative,
- 40:51right? And I think that, you know,
- 40:53yeah, Mark has learned that I just was dying because like,
- 40:56Mark wants to be you on so badly and he's just not Just like
- 41:03you're like Netscape wasn't huge.
- 41:05Like what have you built? Like I think he's desperately.
- 41:07Wants that wider cultural relevance and he wants to be an
- 41:10influencer. He's just not like uses Twitter
- 41:12audience but like no normal person knows or cares about him
- 41:15and he's really increasingly out of touch and it's just so funny
- 41:19to like, watch him scramble. One of the show where enablers
- 41:23the show is named after Marc Andreessen Mark Zuckerberg
- 41:27exchange. Yeah, mark injuries and I assume
- 41:30we have enough new people that is good to refresh but Marc Marc
- 41:34Andreessen messages, look in a sort of text to come out in a
- 41:38lawsuit where and reasons like the cat's in the bag and the
- 41:41bags and the river over like some shareholder thing and and
- 41:45Zuckerberg is like does that mean the cat's dead?
- 41:47And so that's anyway. Yeah, the whole concept of
- 41:52influence is such an interesting thing and this again goes back
- 41:56to your Nim cell idea because there seems to be a huge But
- 42:00passing Trend among everyone in involved in all of these about
- 42:04who really has influence and you know who deserves power.
- 42:08And, you know, I mean, that's why everyone wants to play the
- 42:10victim because if you're the victim, that means you have no
- 42:13influence that, you were the subject of larger forces that
- 42:16are causing you, your unhappiness or worse.
- 42:20He so, like, in the case of Marc Andreessen him, wanting
- 42:23influence, the man has a huge amount of influence.
- 42:25He is the commander, doesn't have cultural relevance?
- 42:29Evans, he doesn't. He's not a, he's not a
- 42:33culturally relevant, like he's culturally relevant in Tech.
- 42:36But I think what he wants is like Normie people.
- 42:39When I'll never forget, I was doing this documentary about
- 42:42this all black content House in Atlanta.
- 42:44One of the first, all black tick tock houses in the fall of 2020
- 42:49or winter of 2020. And these one of these kids was
- 42:52like, oh yeah, I have Clubhouse. I love Clubhouse.
- 42:55The only thing is I hate when you get on and they force you to
- 42:58follow these, like, Random old white guys at Mark Anderson and
- 43:02they're all, oh, that guy. That's so yeah.
- 43:04Yeah, you gotta block him immediately.
- 43:06Anyway, like I just was like guy because I'm like, these people
- 43:08have no idea who he is, but he wants.
- 43:10He wants so badly like but of course, they're all fragile.
- 43:14I mean, all these billionaires are so fragile.
- 43:16Looks like anyone right now even though he's like the Paragon of
- 43:19like, what these people want to be, the guy is claiming
- 43:21victimhood constantly on Twitter.
- 43:23I mean, he's buying the company and still thinks he's a victim.
- 43:26Of course. What's your?
- 43:28Yeah. What's the one we Haven't talked
- 43:29about maybe you love the most, but what's your view on Balaji
- 43:33these days? Like he put out a huge book, but
- 43:35it feels like his me blocked me. So I tried to get an interview
- 43:38with him and he blocked me. But of course he said I don't
- 43:41see him at all. Like I he doesn't penetrate her
- 43:43like, is he not here relevant? Yeah, he's just not relevant.
- 43:46Like he's not relevant, I think and I think also you know, I
- 43:49loved that part in Cade metz's story from a year and a half ago
- 43:54where he got that email from biology, where he's talking
- 43:56about targeting about her post. It just shows how Desperate and
- 44:00how hard these people are trying to work to attack.
- 44:03People that like, guys, we don't give a fuck about you like
- 44:06you're so Random like me, I'm sure there's definitely, no, I
- 44:12mean, definitely, they don't believe in democracy, that's one
- 44:15of those. I mean, it's the classic sort of
- 44:16all right, tactic where it's out there, but they won't just like,
- 44:19say, I'm against democracy. What would actually let can.
- 44:23We could have any that when you mean by that, why do you think
- 44:25they don't believe in democracy? I mean, they basically say that
- 44:28ball. CCP New York Times Like Bitcoin
- 44:33sort of try I mean, yeah, they oh no sure.
- 44:36I understand that. I mean look I need you read the
- 44:38books that Marc Andreessen tweets.
- 44:40It's like the Machiavelli, like supporting like Blake Masters
- 44:43and stuff people that are like saying like, you know, only men,
- 44:46like it's obvious. They don't or, yeah, I guess if
- 44:50you want to extend the idea that anyone who supports the current
- 44:53Republican party, I mean, I'd argue any version of it.
- 44:55I don't think it's just that. I think it's their whole like,
- 44:57you know, Right? I think they've talked about
- 45:01this. Like they talked about, like,
- 45:04their whole thing with a II mean, people like Natasha
- 45:06Teague, my colleague and, like, speak to this, because I'm not
- 45:08deep in Silicon Valley lure, but they're definitely all
- 45:11reactionary and kind of weird have weird political beliefs.
- 45:14This is sort of a tag on this but are you are you free to like
- 45:19have opinions of any sort? Now like you're a calmness or
- 45:22what sort of the former columnist, sorry do you have
- 45:26like political opinions on Twitter or do you try now
- 45:28Minotaur? Political opinions on Twitter.
- 45:31Are you crazy or it's just it's not allowed or like what
- 45:35something? I know.
- 45:37I, you know, I feel personally like Twitter, I just kind of go
- 45:42to share like news and stuff on my beat.
- 45:44I really I used to tell my like, when I was a running social
- 45:47media for news companies, I would always say like tweet your
- 45:50beat, which I find you because I feel like people subscribed to
- 45:53me for news about influencer stuff.
- 45:54They don't want to hear me talk about abortion or student debt
- 45:58or whatever like those are there.
- 45:59Qualified people to talk about that.
- 46:00The one thing I do talk about is chronic illness and and covid
- 46:03stuff because it's affected me. So personally, but that's that's
- 46:07about as political as I get online and sometimes I would
- 46:11retweet, you know, just that we live in like hellscape of
- 46:15environment. Broadly.
- 46:16But I'm pretty. I mean, I'm, I'm, I don't,
- 46:19that's another thing. I think these people are always
- 46:21like, oh, you know, tell around soda.
- 46:23I'm nobody knows. I'm not, I'm never open about my
- 46:26political beliefs really well, but to be fair, Although you did
- 46:30write that article about the person who was out there,
- 46:33tweeting about all of the trans teachers and, you know,
- 46:37different types of tags that. Yeah.
- 46:39Yeah. Hi.
- 46:40Rachel has a huge influence, right?
- 46:43No, I cover I cover policy, I cover political stuff all the
- 46:46time and I was a political reporter for two years.
- 46:48I cover politics but I'm just saying like I'm not came at that
- 46:53with, you know, the angle which I and I think any normal person
- 46:56should agree with that. This person is also bad.
- 46:59What Doing anything bad thing. I think you can read a story and
- 47:02if you read it I mean it's funny that you say that Tom because
- 47:06the story, the story says basically like, you know, this
- 47:09woman is responsible for doxing and harassing people and has
- 47:12gotten several gay people fired and wants gay people out of
- 47:16schools. I think you read that you and I
- 47:19would take away the physician of like that's bad.
- 47:21Right. Right.
- 47:22But other people they read that and they say this is a brave
- 47:25truth-teller they need to support her.
- 47:26So you know it's the piece doesn't say My opinion of her.
- 47:30But it's very clearly lays out her ideology which I think the
- 47:35majority of Americans would find reprehensible, right?
- 47:38But yeah, and by the way like I you know I think that story what
- 47:43it was about as much of sort of her.
- 47:45And the woman behind it was about talking about the way that
- 47:49the right-wing media ecosystem works.
- 47:51And how this this influencer is basically acting as an
- 47:54assignment editor for the right wing, right?
- 47:56Media cycle, and that's important.
- 47:59Honestly, I'm getting at this last leg interrogating your
- 48:02politics, but more just sort of in the journalists Creator sort
- 48:07of overlap. Like I think from my personal
- 48:09experience, when I was free to be more of a Creator, you know,
- 48:12I in my first story said, like I thought supporting Donald Trump
- 48:15was like, against the pale and there is a degree to, which like
- 48:18creators have like a brand an authentic brand where I mean,
- 48:22you do, expose only parts of yourself.
- 48:25But like, politics like clearly see through, I mean, even the
- 48:27Barstool guy came out on the abortion.
- 48:29Something. So I'm just interested in like,
- 48:32you know. Yeah.
- 48:33Do you see reporters being much more open with, like their
- 48:36opinions sort of, as we continue to move into a sort of a Creator
- 48:40World? Definitely.
- 48:42I mean, I think these are things and by the way, I think that
- 48:44it's important to stand for values.
- 48:46I mean, I care deeply about equality and, you know,
- 48:50representation and things like that.
- 48:53I think what news companies don't generally, like, is when
- 48:58reporters. Speak to specific pot, like
- 49:01specific bills and issues and votes and things like that.
- 49:04And again, I say this is somebody that had to manage and
- 49:06be the one in The Newsroom, like, hey guys that he's sending
- 49:09you the your Tweet emails. It's also funny because
- 49:12newsrooms they only care about Twitter like you can be honest.
- 49:16Talk saying anything. I feel like sometimes yeah but
- 49:18yeah I do think I mean I think what what has been really laid
- 49:21Barren and you know people like Wesley Lowery have have spoken
- 49:25really well about this and these nuances is this this concept of
- 49:28quote unquote. Objectivity and how, you know we
- 49:31all bring our backgrounds and identities to our beads and we
- 49:36can't be expected to leave that at the door.
- 49:39And you know, just there's no such thing as having no beliefs
- 49:43and no ideology. It's just not your human in this
- 49:46world and you have your own experiences.
- 49:47And so I think it's really important to newsrooms recognize
- 49:50that and II support people. I mean, when I say I had to, you
- 49:55know, when I was running social media bunch of media
- 49:57organizations, like I really support Porter's doing that.
- 50:00I just feel like me, personally, I don't, I don't have people
- 50:03following me for my political beliefs drive, people following
- 50:05me because they want to know about Creator, economy news, or
- 50:08they want to know, funny, you know, I like to share funny
- 50:11memes and things like that. Like, it's more of that.
- 50:13So I think different reporters, however, the built themselves
- 50:17like anything, social media account user, you're like, I
- 50:19know it. My accounts for like.
- 50:21Yeah, right. I feel like I'm not, I need two
- 50:25different things, right? Like I use my Instagram account
- 50:28for promotion. I have a I'm account.
- 50:30I have a tick tock for other things but that's key to me
- 50:34because I think part of this idea of, you know, reporters
- 50:36showed her shouldn't Express, their political opinions to me.
- 50:39Like, the key aspect of it is that most of their political
- 50:42opinions are not that interesting.
- 50:43And I don't really care, you know, if any New York Times
- 50:47political reporter or watch a food court has started just
- 50:49tweeting out, you know, I think that this particular Bill unless
- 50:52it's like, factually informed, I don't really care what they have
- 50:55to say. I don't think their political
- 50:56opinions with that meaningful, so knowing your audience, Is a
- 50:59huge part of having a presence on.
- 51:01I do think there's this phenomenon with like view from
- 51:03nowhere stories. I certainly don't think Taylor
- 51:06does this, but we're a lot of you for nowhere stories where
- 51:09like the piece can almost lead you to the opposite conclusion
- 51:12that the reporter might hold. Or there are lots of there are
- 51:15lots of stories that effectively with you.
- 51:18Here's the thing. You have to consider how, you
- 51:21know, there are people, there are specific writers, write that
- 51:24frame things in a specific way. I think that make it very clear.
- 51:29The takeaway right York Times has reported this clearly
- 51:31worried about cancel culture, whoever, but like, that's his
- 51:34beat. It's like, can't we just, but
- 51:36wouldn't it be more enjoyable content?
- 51:38If he just like, said I'm very, they would get more engagement
- 51:41if he was like I'm very concerned with cancel culture
- 51:44and like that sort of my be right but they want.
- 51:47Oh I thought you were going to say someone else.
- 51:48That's somebody. I know you are you know, Michael
- 51:53covers campus culture? Sure.
- 51:55You know, I think I think right. I think like I think all of
- 51:58these things are things that media These are going to have to
- 52:00work out. I think it's also interesting in
- 52:01terms of hiring and recruiting which I don't have to do anymore
- 52:04and my current job. But I used to have to do a lot
- 52:05of is you you know, people can be very outspoken activist and
- 52:09like that was the issue with the girl from the AP, right?
- 52:11Like she's done something in college, I think to certain
- 52:15terms of activism and then that was like held against her for a
- 52:17job interview. So media companies are going to
- 52:19need to get over this whole idea of everyone being an old quote
- 52:23unquote reasonable white man. Hey, there's no one that there's
- 52:26no you know what you consider a mainstream.
- 52:29Like yeah, it's just we need to we need to take.
- 52:31We need a more diverse media ecosystem and means think about
- 52:34just need to be about Gathering facts and Reporting them to
- 52:37people. But if there's some transparency
- 52:39and like their history or their personal views, I feel like.
- 52:43And also, when you make those kinds of decisions, not letting
- 52:45someone join the AP because they were somewhat and of an activist
- 52:48and in college. I feel like you're also.
- 52:51You gotta recognize the macro environment of the way that
- 52:53people view media organizations now.
- 52:56And it's the one reason why I'm a little bit sympathetic to the
- 52:59Is that attack us? And you know even you
- 53:02specifically is like they are reflective in a certain way of
- 53:05the way, a lot of Americans view media organizations.
- 53:08The fact of the matter is we are held in a lower esteem than we
- 53:11have been in decades and they've done it to themselves.
- 53:14They've done it to themselves. Let's be honest.
- 53:16Because I hate this whole rumor, you're saying, no, maybe the
- 53:19media organizations have done it to themselves.
- 53:22Like I think that they did not aptly recognize the rise of that
- 53:27sentiment and they have If not a lot, you know, a lot of them
- 53:31have not effectively been able to counter that again.
- 53:33West Lowry as really spoken so effectively on all of this and I
- 53:37am not as prolific as him so I would encourage people to follow
- 53:40him. But yeah and I think that's
- 53:43something that I care. I care a lot of, I think it's
- 53:46important to have institutions but sometimes media companies
- 53:50write some really dumb stuff and I'm like, you know what?
- 53:51You're making yourself irrelevant fine, you know like
- 53:54you're just this is dumb this is why people turn away from
- 53:58Legacy. Is Outlets.
- 54:00Sometimes it feels like the times the posts are more
- 54:02important. I mean, there are huge.
- 54:04I mean, The Newsroom, we need a thriving in journalism is a
- 54:09really important check on Power and democracy.
- 54:11And there's a reason, people want to dismantle it.
- 54:13I think news leaders across industry, need to recognize that
- 54:16and not buy into these bad faith attacks.
- 54:19Like, that's yeah. Do you have anything?
- 54:22You're eager to get on the record about or anything you
- 54:25wanted to talk about before we sort of wrap up, sometimes
- 54:28people on the record. Yeah.
- 54:29Yeah, they just want like, I just posted on Twitter.
- 54:46No One Is Safe. No One Is Safe.
- 54:47No, I'm not a, I'm not a hater. I'm not about that.
- 54:50I don't participate in that kind of thing.
- 54:53Well, I would just say please. Subscribe to my son, exact.
- 54:56I was up stack. Follow me.
- 54:58Reach out, anytime if there's Then you think that I should
- 55:00write about? I would love to hear it over a
- 55:02good source reporter move. It's like I just want more
- 55:04resources like sources. Please find me, please listen to
- 55:07me the VC people, by the way, got me so many sources when they
- 55:10were like canceled. Oh my God.
- 55:13I mean, I never knew anyone in the VC world before and now I
- 55:15have like, I mean, so many people were like, hit me up
- 55:19because of that and gave me news.
- 55:20But like, where you were, you leveraging that to be in like
- 55:22all right, what's the valuation of the next Cloud kitchens
- 55:25around? I mean, who is this?
- 55:26Like can you can you get in on, you know, like The the
- 55:30particular bitchiness and fights that happened in the VC.
- 55:33Well I'd love to read. I mean I guess that's partly
- 55:34Eric's sub stack you don't really go too much into the
- 55:37personal drama. I don't have Ari.
- 55:38No, I don't cover Silicon Valley.
- 55:40I know you can give me free scoop sings.
- 55:42I'm like look at looking out like five years from now I don't
- 55:45know any predictions about social media or like I mean you.
- 55:50Yeah you're the sort of whisper on this thing, I mean we didn't
- 55:54end up really talking about be real.
- 55:55Are you like optimistic on that or is there anywhere where
- 55:58you'll sort? Layout sort of a prediction
- 56:01about where where we're heading. Yeah, I was going to write
- 56:04something about summer apps and how there's always kind of these
- 56:07viral apps during the summer and how hard it is to kind of like
- 56:12the summer, like Pokemon go or let you see these things like
- 56:14the Khan, these viral phenomenons and they don't
- 56:17always stay. And so with be real I mean I
- 56:20know they're putting a ton into like marketing it and stuff like
- 56:24that, I don't know that the next not to say that it won't be
- 56:27successful. And by the way, I love front
- 56:29back. Back.
- 56:29So I was a big you know, proponent of the whole format.
- 56:33This is this is no no. I was the biggest loser ever.
- 56:43I don't think like the next like game-changing up is going to be
- 56:46a photo app. So I think if be real is going
- 56:49to be a lasting product it needs to evolve beyond what it is but
- 56:54it's so fun to write. I mean I've been on that app
- 56:56since like the third week it launched and I I think it's cool
- 57:00and funny and I've all push notifications turned off.
- 57:03So I just post it when I want. And I don't really post it very
- 57:06often. It really does kind of defang
- 57:07the app. And I also wants to take had all
- 57:09my notifications turned off because I reset my phone and I
- 57:11completely forgot about be real and it is be hearing about it
- 57:14immediately. Yeah, it just lives entirely on
- 57:16the back of that. Be real is kind of the Nim
- 57:18selves social media Clubhouse. Clubhouse should have learned
- 57:21that lesson Clubhouse, got addicted to the place where so
- 57:23much and they'd screw. I think that's part of the
- 57:25reason that the company flop. You think, are we in the
- 57:27beginning of the tick-tock? Wave or we at the top of it or
- 57:31like where we're not even close to the top right now.
- 57:35I loved how. Oh my God, I had to do Tech
- 57:37predictions in like 2019 on Sam busy or something.
- 57:40And I was like, yeah, like Tic, Tacs going to be the new Domino
- 57:43session at work. And somebody was like, oh, how
- 57:44did you predict that? It's like, it's literally on by
- 57:46like, a multi billion-dollar Tech Chinese Tech conglomerate
- 57:50that spent a billion dollars in marketing.
- 57:51And one year, like does, it's not, you're not a genius to
- 57:55think that it might do well. So I don't have any real wisdom.
- 57:58I don't know. I mean You know, you can spend a
- 58:00ton of money trying to push something.
- 58:03Sure. He doesn't tap into some sort of
- 58:05Basil, elements of human nature that causes you to go crazy
- 58:08because of the you're addicted to it.
- 58:10I think I'd have been so successful around the world to
- 58:12that it. Yeah.
- 58:13But no you're 100%. Right?
- 58:14I mean Facebook. Does that every six months
- 58:16before you right? Right.
- 58:17Yeah I mean what is the best thing you think to come out of
- 58:22tick-tock? I mean what do you think has
- 58:23been like the most heartening aspect of the culture that it is
- 58:27created over the millions of cultures is Adorn its user
- 58:30interface or make me feel good about Tick-Tock.
- 58:33Yeah we can close on that sense of it make me feel good about
- 58:36Tick-Tock. Yeah I mean I what I think is
- 58:38really interesting is it's broken this whole like follow
- 58:41based system of social media and it's really I think they've just
- 58:45nailed Discovery so well, right? And I think that's that's what's
- 58:49exciting about it. Like you can really go down
- 58:50these rabbit holes. I hate the video for you know I
- 58:54don't want video to be like I'm not a video person so I think
- 58:57like that parts. Little bit of a I don't want
- 59:01video to be the dominant mode of expression.
- 59:03I do think that like, that's something I like about Twitter
- 59:05is being able to write but Tick-Tock has such incredible
- 59:08creative tools and the stuff. The way that it's kind of like
- 59:11allowed people to be creative is pretty cool.
- 59:13This actually may be circles back to the first thing we
- 59:15talked about on this and we can maybe end here.
- 59:18I mean, do you worry that the follow base culture going away
- 59:21and being purely about Discovery does kind of dissociate,
- 59:24people's connection to the creators are influencers that
- 59:27they watch? I mean like VidCon.
- 59:29As an example of this, The Tick-Tock creators didn't have
- 59:31the YouTuber lines of years past because people one could argue
- 59:36didn't feel as emotionally invested, para socially
- 59:38connected to, you know, the people that they were watching
- 59:41on Tick-Tock I mean, is there something alienating about this
- 59:45format of, of consuming content versus following it?
- 59:49That does sort of, you know, reverberate in a negative way.
- 59:52No, I think 100% which I love that Business, Insider piece
- 59:55that got into this because I would have written the same
- 59:58thing. And kind of tried to in that one
- 1:00:01paragraph of my story. But like, yeah, it's also just
- 1:00:04the rate at which, you know, you spend so much more time with
- 1:00:07YouTubers, like you're sitting down.
- 1:00:09You're watching long form content and it takes time to
- 1:00:12kind of subscribe and find people.
- 1:00:14Whereas Tick-Tock you're just getting barrage with new people
- 1:00:16every day and you don't form up on do you don't have that same?
- 1:00:21I think that can be kind of good too.
- 1:00:23I think like the whole pair of social thing is really
- 1:00:25unhealthy. I'm crazy about keeping my life
- 1:00:28off the internet. No one knows anything about my
- 1:00:30life. And I think it's very scary for
- 1:00:33the creators and I think it's not a great like that parrot
- 1:00:36that deep parasocial bond can be harmful for the creators and
- 1:00:38harmful for the audience. So I think it's, I don't know,
- 1:00:41it's kind of good to have a little bit less of that
- 1:00:43interesting, but I do see lots of sad tick talkers, who are
- 1:00:47like I have a million followers in my videos are getting like
- 1:00:5110,000 views and there is. It does feel like, I mean the
- 1:00:54beauty of like sub stack is like once I have you, it goes to your
- 1:00:57inbox whereas ticked Is literally the opposite where
- 1:01:00they sort of like, don't really care.
- 1:01:02What people say they're following is, pure is purely a
- 1:01:04vanity metric and you know, I know that because I have half a
- 1:01:08million followers and they're all people that just mostly
- 1:01:11think. I might be with a famous
- 1:01:12Tick-Tock ER and they followed me for that reason.
- 1:01:15But yeah, it's I think it's but that decoupling I think is very
- 1:01:18jarring for people. Right?
- 1:01:21Totally. All right well I'm sure we'll
- 1:01:23have you back on. Thank you so much for coming on
- 1:01:25the show. We really appreciate it.
- 1:01:26Thanks Taylor your yeah everyone should.
- 1:01:29Others work if they haven't already which I'm sure they do,
- 1:01:31she really is the best at this thing, and it's fascinating.
- 1:01:34So I highly recommend people, keep keep reading.
- 1:01:36Thank you. I'm such a fan of your guys work
- 1:01:39and Tom. I've read your stories for years
- 1:01:41and XO it's cool to get to chat. Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye,
- 1:01:58goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:01:59Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:01:59Goodbye.