Latest / The Vegan Report / Finding Nemo & Saving Philip: Stories of Fish Rescues. With Gwendolyn Church | Ep. 29
Transcript
- 0:00Back in 2003, the highest grossing movie was Finding Nemo.
- 0:12And that year, Finding Nemo was competing with Pirates of the Caribbean, The Matrix
- 0:16Reloaded and the third Lord of the Rings movie.
- 0:20And it is understandable, the Pixar animation work is genius.
- 0:25The characters are funny and touching at times.
- 0:28The storyline is thoughtful and speaks to a wide audience.
- 0:32But what really compels me about the story of Finding Nemo is its animal rights dimension.
- 0:38For the first time ever, we had a movie depicting fish and other sea life as individual sentient
- 0:45creatures.
- 0:46Of course, they were anthropomorphized to a certain degree, but still, for once, they
- 0:51were represented as more than food.
- 0:55Other than that, the whole plot of the movie revolved around an act of animal abuse, the
- 1:01capture and captivity of Nemo in an aquarium, the habit humans have of turning marine life
- 1:09into indoor decoration.
- 1:12And this is the topic of today's episode.
- 1:15To discuss this issue, I have with me Gwendolyn Church, the founder of Friends of Philip,
- 1:21a fish and aquatic animal sanctuary based in Reno, Nevada in the United States.
- 1:27Gwendolyn, thank you so much for being here.
- 1:29Hi, thank you so much for having me.
- 1:32So most people were completely blunt about the animal rights message in Finding Nemo,
- 1:39so much so that there might have been a spike in clownfish sales after the release of the
- 1:45movie.
- 1:46And I feel like it's a symptom of how fish is still viewed as nothing more than food.
- 1:52It is so hard for people to consider fish as being sentient.
- 1:58So Gwendolyn, do you share that observation?
- 2:01And do you have an idea of why it is so hard for people to care about fish?
- 2:07I do share that view.
- 2:10And I think a huge part of why it's difficult for us to connect to fish is because we live
- 2:16in such different worlds.
- 2:19Most of us in our lives will interact with terrestrial farmed animals in one way or another,
- 2:24whether it's meeting a cow or just driving past a field of sheep or something like that.
- 2:28We see them day to day.
- 2:30And we don't have anything even close to that with fish.
- 2:34For most people, the way that they will interact with a fish most often is through eating them.
- 2:41And then we may or may not encounter fish as, you know, quote unquote, pet animals kept in
- 2:46aquariums, either in the home or in the pet store or visiting an aquarium or something
- 2:49like that.
- 2:51And I think that kind of inherent separation that comes with just the very different environments
- 2:58that we live in makes it a bit more difficult for people to connect to fish.
- 3:03And on top of that, fish aren't what many people would consider kind of classically
- 3:07cute the way a dog is or a cow or many of the terrestrial animals that we also love.
- 3:14And so it can be really hard, I think, for people to look at a fish and connect to that
- 3:18animal as an individual and recognize that they really are an individual.
- 3:23And I think what compounds that is when we do meet fish in captivity, it's either as
- 3:28a very kind of passing moment in an aquarium, you know, like going to visit a big aquarium
- 3:34or something like that, or as a basically decoration, like you said, in someone's home.
- 3:39And we don't spend the time looking at that animal and interacting with them as an individual.
- 3:42We just say, oh, wow, what a pretty fish and kind of move on.
- 3:47And even more so, you know, we'll encounter a fish who is maybe not being treated very
- 3:52well.
- 3:53And most of us don't recognize what that looks like.
- 3:55So if I meet a dog and I can see that the dog is thin or sick or not doing well, like
- 4:01a lot of people, I think, can recognize that pretty easily.
- 4:04And it's harder for most of us to see that when we look at a fish.
- 4:07So people might encounter a fish in a bowl and say, wow, fish are so boring when the
- 4:12takeaway should be, wow, that fish is very mistreated and they're not feeling well.
- 4:18So what makes a fish sentient?
- 4:22Can we make if someone is listening to this and they are not convinced that a fish is
- 4:28sentient?
- 4:29What would you say to that person?
- 4:32I think that that person should probably read up a bit more on our scientific understanding
- 4:38of fish and fish's experiences.
- 4:41You know, there have been all kinds of studies, some horrible experiments done to fish that,
- 4:48you know, let us know that we scientifically know that fish are sentient.
- 4:51We know that they feel pain.
- 4:53We know that they want to avoid pain.
- 4:55We know that they remember places and faces.
- 4:58We know that they remember individuals.
- 5:00We know that there are some species of fish who can recognize themselves in a mirror.
- 5:05So we know all of that scientifically.
- 5:07But I think even more importantly, I would encourage that person to find a way to interact
- 5:12with fish on an individual level, because all you have to do is meet one fish who is
- 5:18happy and healthy and treated well.
- 5:20And it's just so apparent that they're sentient and that they're an individual.
- 5:25So is it the solution to resolving this wrong view about fish?
- 5:32Is the solution to encourage interactions with marine life?
- 5:38I think it is in a certain sense, as long as we're doing it responsibly.
- 5:43You know, I don't think that the way that we should strive to connect with fish is by
- 5:47purchasing them as pets and bringing them into our home.
- 5:50I don't think that the way that we should interact with fish is by pulling them out
- 5:54of their homes so that they can live in aquariums.
- 5:57I think the way that we should best interact with fish is the way that we should interact
- 6:01with all animals, which is meeting them on their terms and being respectful of them as
- 6:07individuals.
- 6:10And what do you think about people who, I guess, have that interaction but still hold
- 6:19that view about fish?
- 6:21For example, fishermen.
- 6:24I cannot think of someone who spends greater time with fish than a fisherman.
- 6:32And they see that when they pull out the fish from the water, they see that the fish is
- 6:38struggling, but still that connection is, I guess, absent from their minds.
- 6:44How do you explain that?
- 6:47That's a really good question.
- 6:48I think that it's kind of similar to hunting.
- 6:52If you talk to hunters and fishermen, they'll talk about the connection that they feel to
- 6:55the animals and the connection that they feel to nature.
- 6:59And I think that it's kind of falling into that trap that we do a lot, which is focusing
- 7:05on our human-based experiences.
- 7:08And yes, you can feel very connected to nature by interacting with a hurt animal, but you
- 7:13can also feel very connected to nature by observing that animal from a distance and
- 7:18watching them live their lives and seeing the majesty and the beauty of them being left
- 7:23alone and free in their lives and their world.
- 7:27And so I think that a lot of the context of fishing is that same thing.
- 7:34People want to connect with nature.
- 7:36They want to connect with animals and are maybe not thinking of ways that they could
- 7:41do that that don't require the suffering of another individual.
- 7:46And I want to address some of the maybe prejudices or lies we tell ourselves about fish.
- 7:54A lot of those fishermen say, you know, they practice a kind of fishing where they pull
- 8:00out the fish and then they put it back in the water and they think of it as being compassionate
- 8:06and not harming the fish.
- 8:08What do you say about that?
- 8:10I mean, at its most blunt level, I would ask them if they'd want someone to come into their
- 8:17home, dunk them underwater for two minutes and then shove them back in and call that
- 8:23compassion.
- 8:24I don't think that there's a way to frame that as a compassionate act.
- 8:28You know, compassion is not inflicting unnecessary harm on someone else.
- 8:32It's respecting someone else's autonomy in their life.
- 8:35And I think that if someone really wants to interact with fish and they're already in
- 8:40the position and have the privilege to be able to spend money to go by fishing equipment,
- 8:45maybe they should spend that money on a camera.
- 8:47Maybe they should spend that money on a GoPro that they can stick underwater and watch the
- 8:51fish and see them in their environment.
- 8:53Maybe they should learn how to scuba dive and be able to interact with fish in a peaceful,
- 8:59nonviolent and truly compassionate way.
- 9:03And so what do you think about the media around fish?
- 9:06I talked a lot about Finding Nemo, but there are so many documentaries out there which
- 9:13highlight the lives of fish.
- 9:19Is it useful or is there like a bad, negative impact to that media like Finding Nemo, which
- 9:31the whole plot of the story is about saving this fish, but then people have watched the
- 9:39movie and felt the need to go to a pet store and adopt a clownfish?
- 9:48This was not planned, I think, by people who made the movie or thought about its effects
- 9:55on the viewers.
- 9:59So what do you think about the whole media ecosystem around fish?
- 10:06I think it's a little hard to say in one answer because there are so many different types
- 10:12of media.
- 10:13I think a lot of the documentaries are generally beneficial.
- 10:19I think it's very sad to see in many documentaries that our impacts on fish and their environments
- 10:25are prioritized as an environmental issue.
- 10:29I would never in a million years say that the environment and our impact on the environment
- 10:33isn't huge, but I think that there's also room in that conversation to talk about our
- 10:37impacts on individuals and the fish who live there.
- 10:42But for a movie like Finding Nemo, I think it's really fascinating because, like you
- 10:47said, the movie is entirely based around this story of a fish who was like unwillingly separated
- 10:54from his family who was pulled forcibly from his home.
- 10:58And I will say I love Finding Nemo.
- 11:01I love that movie.
- 11:02I'm a huge Pixar person.
- 11:03I love animated movies and I love Finding Nemo.
- 11:06And I think it's so interesting and kind of typical that we watch a movie like Finding
- 11:16Nemo where the dentist very early on, he says, oh, I found this little guy struggling for
- 11:22life out in the reef.
- 11:23And all of us as the viewers were like, no, you didn't.
- 11:26You did not.
- 11:27You weren't struggling for life.
- 11:28He was doing great.
- 11:29He had his family.
- 11:30He had his friends.
- 11:31He was fine.
- 11:32And you pulled him out of his home and that's wrong.
- 11:36And I think it's unfortunate that we can watch a movie like that and recognize that and then
- 11:40still feel the desire to go to the pet store and buy a fish who was also pulled out of
- 11:46their home away from their family and away from everything they've ever known so that
- 11:50we can keep them in an aquarium in our house.
- 11:53You know, most saltwater fish that you could buy in a store today were wild caught.
- 11:58Not necessarily in the way that Nemo was.
- 12:01It's more of like an industrial capture kind of scale.
- 12:04It's not wouldn't typically be just an individual diver.
- 12:07It's more people do dive in and they'll catch the fish individually but on a massive scale.
- 12:14And you know, then freshwater fish are captive bred, but they go through their own whole
- 12:18horrible start to life of transport and difficult things.
- 12:23And I think that a movie like Finding Nemo gives us the opportunity to recognize that
- 12:27our treatment of these animals is wrong.
- 12:31And I think it's unfortunate that many of us watch it and take away the kind of human
- 12:35focused message of, oh, but isn't it fun to have a fish in an aquarium?
- 12:42I want to talk about the pet stores.
- 12:44But first, let's go back to what you said about climate change.
- 12:51Because that is also something I have noticed.
- 12:54How the highlight is, you know, we often hear environmental conservation or conservation
- 13:04of fish population.
- 13:06And it is always said with like the idea that we want to continue fishing those populations,
- 13:16but in a responsible way and in a sustainable way.
- 13:22There are a lot of those buzzwords used in order to justify human exploitation of animals.
- 13:31And I never heard anyone in those documentaries or public commentators talk about the suffering
- 13:41it causes on the fish population.
- 13:45And it's such a, when you think about the scale, the number of those fish populations
- 13:53just getting annihilated by human exploitation, it's crazy.
- 14:00It's maddening.
- 14:03So can you comment on that?
- 14:05Yeah, it is maddening.
- 14:08That's a good way to describe it.
- 14:10I think that one of the areas that the animal rights and vegan movement is really lacking
- 14:21is in our conversations around fish.
- 14:25We all know the numbers around terrestrial farmed animals, that billions are killed every
- 14:31year.
- 14:33And what we don't talk about in that context is that there are trillions of fish killed
- 14:37every year.
- 14:38That's completely incomprehensible numbers of fish who are killed.
- 14:44And I think it's overwhelming and it is hard to take those trillions and turn it into an
- 14:54individual conversation, especially when, as we talked about earlier, people already struggle
- 14:59to connect to fish.
- 15:02So I think a lot of times it's maybe a little bit easier to get non-vegans and people who
- 15:09are outside of the animal rights world to connect to the environmental issues.
- 15:16Because you say things like, oh, we're going to have fishless oceans by 2048.
- 15:22And people go, wow, that sounds terrifying because what are we going to eat?
- 15:26And we talk about sustainable fishing and all these things, like you said.
- 15:30And I think a lot of those are just frankly buzzwords and things like you said to help
- 15:35us feel better about the atrocity that is ongoing in our treatment of fish and the environment
- 15:43as a result.
- 15:45There's not a kind way to fish and there is not a compassionate way to do any kind of
- 15:51the farming that we do.
- 15:54And so I think maybe because we struggle to connect to fish, it's a little bit easier
- 16:01to pull in that environmental conversation and get people to connect on that level.
- 16:05But I think that really is an area that we're kind of failing to fish specifically, that
- 16:11we need to talk about them more.
- 16:14Yes.
- 16:15And we often, everyone I think who is listening to this podcast has seen pictures of birds
- 16:24struggling with a piece of plastic around their neck or plastic that they tried to eat
- 16:33and it's stuck.
- 16:37But I think about it as if the birds are marine birds who fish for surviving are struggling
- 16:49with human presence to this extent.
- 16:55What is happening under the sea with smaller fish and smaller aquatic life?
- 17:02Yeah, it's hidden but it doesn't make it less valid of a cause or the pain is still
- 17:14there.
- 17:15It's just hidden.
- 17:16That's the thing.
- 17:17Yeah.
- 17:18Absolutely.
- 17:19I mean, like you said, we've all seen the videos like the birds or the sharks or the
- 17:23seals or even the fish who are caught even like in nets underwater and divers cutting
- 17:28them free and things.
- 17:30And if you look at some of the reactions to those videos, it's always people saying, wow,
- 17:33it's so amazing that you rescued that shark or whatever.
- 17:37And there's no acknowledgement of the fact that that shark needed to be rescued because
- 17:40we eat fish and they were trapped in fishing equipment because most of the plastic in the
- 17:46ocean is discarded fishing equipment.
- 17:48And so if we weren't fishing, the amount of plastic that we need to remove from the
- 17:53ocean and the just environmental catastrophe that is happening because of that would be
- 17:58such a smaller scale.
- 17:59It would still be a problem, of course.
- 18:02But fishing is such a disaster for that.
- 18:06I am so happy to hear you say that because I hear friends and people debating plastic
- 18:15straws and their impact on the ocean.
- 18:19Meanwhile, it's fishing that is causing all of that plastic in the water.
- 18:25Yeah, I think I've seen it before.
- 18:28There is, I don't know, something I've seen online that it basically said like you'll
- 18:31stop using plastic straws to save fish, but you won't stop eating fish to save fish.
- 18:37And I think that's, you know, there's no better summary of it than that because that really
- 18:43is the leading cause.
- 18:44Truly.
- 18:46And what about the mercury?
- 18:50I have mentioned a few times in this podcast how in the Mediterranean diet, if you eat
- 18:58fish, it's considered healthy, but there is the mercury inside the fish.
- 19:05So it's bad for your health, but it's also bad for the health of the fish.
- 19:11For starter, I mean, and I guess they're suffering from all of those chemicals we dump in the
- 19:20water.
- 19:21Do we have any data or anything about how fish is suffering from aquatic life in general
- 19:30is suffering from, I don't know, like chemical burns or things like that?
- 19:36I would assume that there must be.
- 19:38I honestly don't know.
- 19:40I assume that there is.
- 19:42I think though that like something we maybe don't take into account a lot when we think
- 19:48about fish and pollution and kind of water is the way that fish interact with their environment.
- 19:55You know, we all have had the experience of breathing in smoke and how unpleasant that
- 20:01is.
- 20:02You know, I have lived in an area affected by wildfires for a long time and the smoke
- 20:08from the wildfires is very intense sometimes.
- 20:11Or if you don't live near that area, you're lucky, but maybe you've experienced trying
- 20:16to start a campfire and getting the face full of smoke and just your eyes burning and your
- 20:20nose burning and your lungs burning.
- 20:23For a fish, if they're living in water that's polluted, it's not just their eyes and their
- 20:30gills because their entire body is surrounded by it in a way that we just kind of don't
- 20:36experience as much with air.
- 20:38We can stick our hand in smoke and we're not going to, as far as I know, we're not going
- 20:42to really feel like a smoke burn.
- 20:45But for fish, if they're living, I see most frequently with rescued fish, things like
- 20:49ammonia burns.
- 20:51You'll see this too in intensively farmed animals like chickens will have ammonia burns
- 20:56and things on their bodies because of living in an area of such concentrated pollution.
- 21:02And so when fish are living in that, it's burning their skin, it's getting pulled into
- 21:09their bodies and into their lungs and things.
- 21:13We know that mercury is an issue.
- 21:15We know that microplastics are an issue.
- 21:18There's all kinds of things that we have put into the ocean that fish are now having to
- 21:23take into their bodies and they don't have an escape from it.
- 21:27And so then of course, when we eat the fish, we're taking in anything that they have inside
- 21:32of their bodies too.
- 21:34It's a great analogy.
- 21:36Like a wildfire.
- 21:37Yeah, I love that analogy.
- 21:42So I want to get back to the pet stores because I feel like this is what the interaction people
- 21:50have with live fish is true.
- 21:53A pet store usually, that's the most common interaction they have.
- 22:01And pet stores are kind of weird in a way because here you are in your hometown in the
- 22:10middle of North America and there's this place which has in captivity some creatures from
- 22:19all over the world, including fish from oceans at kilometers away, worlds away from where
- 22:30you are.
- 22:32So where do they find the fish?
- 22:36How is the fish brought to the pet store?
- 22:40And why is it allowed?
- 22:41How is this legal?
- 22:45All good questions.
- 22:47So for where the fish come from, it's really going to vary.
- 22:52And I think to kind of get into that, we should back up just half a step and say that fish
- 22:58are the most numerous pet animal.
- 23:02And so for all the dogs and the cats that we see through our days interacting with people
- 23:06that they can take their dog out with them or you see a cat outside or something like
- 23:10that, there are so many more fish.
- 23:14And they're all kept in these little tanks either in our homes or in pet stores.
- 23:18And so I think it's great that you're asking this because a lot of people don't think of
- 23:22like, well, how did they even get here?
- 23:23I mean, a dog, we can all understand stray dogs, but you don't encounter like a stray
- 23:28fish that you take home and have as like, oh, I found this stray fish and now they're
- 23:33my friend.
- 23:34That doesn't happen.
- 23:35It should because people dump fish, but that's a whole other problem.
- 23:39But the fish from the pet stores, it really comes down to either wild capture or captive
- 23:46bred.
- 23:47So the majority of saltwater fish, about 90% of saltwater fish are wild caught, which means
- 23:53that they're captured from places like Hawaii, the Philippines, all the areas that have beautiful
- 24:04saltwater reefs.
- 24:05There's probably some level of captive fishing going on.
- 24:08A lot of it is in kind of the Southeast Asia area from my understanding.
- 24:12It's been a minute since I looked at all these statistics.
- 24:15So these fish are wild caught.
- 24:19There's a few different methods, a semi-common one or a very common one actually is called
- 24:23cyanide fishing.
- 24:26That's technically illegal in most places, but there are ways you can test to see if
- 24:31a fish was captured using cyanide fishing.
- 24:33And there have been studies that have shown that a substantial number of the fish in the
- 24:38aquarium trade were captured using cyanide fishing.
- 24:41So what this means is that a diver goes into a reef with usually like basically a squeeze
- 24:47bottle of a cyanide poison that they'll use to spray onto the fish in the reef.
- 24:54It'll stun the fish, basically kind of paralyze them, and then they'll collect all the fish.
- 24:59As you can imagine, a massive number of these fish die as a result of cyanide toxicity.
- 25:07It's incredibly toxic.
- 25:08It's incredibly dangerous for the fish and for the diver, and it's hugely destructive
- 25:12to the reef.
- 25:14Coral is a living organism that is also impacted by cyanide toxicity, and the coral can't swim
- 25:20away.
- 25:23And so it's hugely destructive to the reefs.
- 25:26It's hugely destructive to the fish.
- 25:29And I think it's something like 90% of captured saltwater fish will die within their first
- 25:34year.
- 25:35A huge amount of that is because of the stress of capture and transport.
- 25:41So most saltwater fish come from those kinds of scenarios.
- 25:46There is a smaller portion.
- 25:47I think there's been some success with breeding like clownfish in particular in captivity
- 25:53to kind of reduce that, but that comes with its own problems.
- 25:57Then the flip side of that is that most freshwater fish are bred in captivity.
- 26:03So this is like your goldfish, your bettas, your tetras, your Corydoras, just the whole,
- 26:08most of the fish that you see in the pet store will have been captive bred.
- 26:14And in those cases, it's essentially factory farming.
- 26:21It's very reminiscent of what people call puppy mills.
- 26:27And if anything, it's worse because there's no legal regulation.
- 26:31There's no protection for fish.
- 26:33A lot of these fish are bred in tropical areas like Thailand and then would be imported to
- 26:40other countries.
- 26:41The United States is the largest importer of fish.
- 26:43We have the largest number of pet fish.
- 26:47And there are some breeding facilities here.
- 26:49I believe a lot of goldfish are bred somewhere in the south.
- 26:53So it really just kind of depends on the species.
- 26:58But for captive breeding, it's very similar.
- 27:00You get a lot of loss, call it loss, as if that's a thing to write off in transport or
- 27:08at the facilities themselves and then of course more at the stores.
- 27:13And so it's really just this kind of mass production of fish for sale in pet stores.
- 27:23And as with any kind of mass production of anything, there's these losses that are accepted
- 27:30on some level.
- 27:31But in this case, it's not that, oh, you had some amount of scrap for your manufacturing
- 27:35process.
- 27:36It's that some number of individuals died because of this process and because of the
- 27:41drive for profits.
- 27:43Yeah, I think I'm sorry.
- 27:47You had another question and I kind of forgot what it was.
- 27:50I don't remember.
- 27:52I think I asked about pet stores.
- 27:57How is it, it is weird to have those strange species in the middle of North America.
- 28:03It's so weird.
- 28:05It's so weird.
- 28:06I think another thing that people don't really recognize with fish is that there's over 33,000
- 28:13known species of fish.
- 28:15And so that's more than 60% of the known vertebrate species on earth.
- 28:20It's a massive number of species.
- 28:23And of course, not nearly that many numbers, thank goodness, are kept in captivity or sold
- 28:28as pets.
- 28:29But, you know, if you go into a pet store, you'll see hamsters, rats, mice, a few species
- 28:36of birds and things like that.
- 28:38And then you might see two or three dozen different species of fish.
- 28:42And every one of those species is just as different from each other as a parrot is to
- 28:47a chicken.
- 28:48They all have different needs.
- 28:50They have different kind of social structures that they'll build.
- 28:54They have different ways that they interact with each other.
- 28:58And pet stores will not make that clear to people.
- 29:03I never thought about it this way.
- 29:05But you're right.
- 29:07It's incredible.
- 29:08Okay, I have a weird follow up question.
- 29:12Why have we selected those species of fish, like goldfish or betta, instead of local fish
- 29:23that we can find in lakes and rivers of the US or North America or Europe?
- 29:32That's a very good question.
- 29:34I don't like I've never read anything about it.
- 29:36My guess would be because of the appearance and the breeding of some of these fish.
- 29:44So you know, like the betta fish that you see, every single betta you see in a store
- 29:49will have been bred in captivity because they look nothing like their wild ancestors.
- 29:55Bettas in particular were actually domesticated for fighting because they're a particularly
- 30:00aggressive species of fish.
- 30:03And so now they've been selectively bred for generations upon generations to have those
- 30:08fabulous brightly colored gorgeous fins that everybody loves, but that can hinder their
- 30:15quality of life.
- 30:18And so I think that's a big part of it is the appearance of them, you know, compared
- 30:22to if you go to like a, I don't know, a local pond or something that has native tiny minnows
- 30:28in it.
- 30:29The native minnows might be a little bit less pretty.
- 30:33But honestly, I think that part of it is just that those are the species that have always
- 30:36been kind of domesticated and bought and sold.
- 30:41And I don't fully know the history.
- 30:44It's something I should definitely read up on because now I'm really curious about it.
- 30:47I guess I've never thought about it a whole lot because that is a really good question.
- 30:51Like why, why do I have a room full of rescued tropical fish in Nevada?
- 30:57Like there is no reason for any of those fish to be here.
- 31:02You know, none of the fish who live in our house would survive for more than a minute
- 31:07or two in our ecosystems here.
- 31:10And all of the fish who live in our ponds and things would just wreak havoc on the ecosystem
- 31:16because they're also not native and they could survive and do well in the cold water, but
- 31:20they're not a native species and they would unintentionally destroy the ecosystem.
- 31:26So yeah, it's very bizarre.
- 31:30That's the thing.
- 31:31I hope someone wrote about it, but it might be the case that nobody wrote about this issue
- 31:37because it's not in interest of most people, most animal rights activists.
- 31:43So what about the general public?
- 31:49You mentioned how bitter was bread for fighting.
- 31:53What is fish fighting?
- 31:58I would say, you know, kind of like any other animal fighting for show, for entertainment.
- 32:07You know, my understanding is basically it would just be putting two generally male bettas
- 32:10into the same tank and watching them attack each other.
- 32:14I think it's the same thing that people are drawn to with things like cock fighting and
- 32:18dog fighting of just an awful display that I don't understand why people are drawn to
- 32:27it.
- 32:28You know, I think it's not, I wouldn't say it's particularly common, but I don't know
- 32:35a whole lot about kind of the state of fish fighting right now.
- 32:39My only experience with anything even slightly close to it, which is unfortunately very common,
- 32:45is people who are completely uneducated, they go to a pet store, they buy two bettas and
- 32:50they think they can live together.
- 32:52And then they just beat each other up really bad.
- 32:59You know, and it's not the fish doing anything wrong.
- 33:01It's them acting according to their nature.
- 33:05But yeah, it's really, really sad.
- 33:08We've had a few bettas who have been kept with others and they are always just, you
- 33:14know, their fins are shredded.
- 33:15They're so stressed.
- 33:17They might have wounds on their bodies and things.
- 33:19And it's just, it's awful.
- 33:22And I also want to talk about goldfish because it's the most popular species of fish that
- 33:30is kept in captivity.
- 33:35First of all, is it true that goldfish has no memory?
- 33:38No, not at all.
- 33:41Because that's the thing they are known for.
- 33:44It's such a common myth.
- 33:46Yeah.
- 33:47People will say the three second memory.
- 33:50Goldfish can remember things for years.
- 33:53They form incredibly strong family bonds and relationships.
- 33:58They remember individuals.
- 33:59They remember, you know, their favorite places.
- 34:03Just like other species of fish, they'll remember if they've experienced pain.
- 34:07Yeah, they're incredibly intelligent.
- 34:11They're, I think, as far as like myths and general perceptions go, if you're looking
- 34:17at pet species, goldfish have received by far the worst disservice from humans because
- 34:28there's all these myths about them that they have a three second memory, that they'll only
- 34:31live for a few months, that they're stupid, that they're boring, that they're any of these
- 34:35things that they grow to the size of the tank they're kept in.
- 34:37I mean, I could just ramble off all these myths.
- 34:42And it's all wrong.
- 34:44And it's heartbreaking because goldfish, they're personally my favorite species of fish.
- 34:52They're hilarious.
- 34:54And they are just incredible.
- 34:58Like I said, they form these really, really, really strong family and kind of friendship
- 35:04bonds to the point that our organization now, we basically have a policy that we will not
- 35:12keep a single pair of goldfish outside of very extenuating circumstances because when
- 35:19one inevitably passes before the other, the loss is just way too much for the remaining
- 35:25fish.
- 35:27We had a pair, Lucas and Wednesday.
- 35:29Lucas, we still have.
- 35:31Wednesday had neurological and other physical health issues from the treatment she'd received
- 35:38before us.
- 35:39And her original partner, Pugsley, passed away.
- 35:44And Lucas had just arrived.
- 35:47We finished out his quarantine and he moved in with Lucas, with Wednesday, to be a companion
- 35:51to her.
- 35:53And Wednesday passed away about a year ago.
- 35:56And I genuinely thought Lucas was going to die too.
- 36:00It was the most heartbreaking thing I've ever seen.
- 36:03He was laying at the bottom of the tank.
- 36:05He would not eat.
- 36:07He was just lethargic and completely uninterested in anything for well over a week.
- 36:14And I was freaking out because I'd never seen something like that so intense before.
- 36:19And I was like, oh my gosh, like Wednesday passed away of expected things.
- 36:25And I had some, I was suddenly worried, like, is Lucas so sick or something?
- 36:29Did something happen?
- 36:30And our vet came out and she said, no, he's doing fine.
- 36:33It was the loss of his companion.
- 36:38And so, you know, that I think is something that people don't recognize with fish and
- 36:43with goldfish, but all fish really is the bonds and the relationships that they can
- 36:48make.
- 36:49So Lucas now lives with all of our other fancy goldfish and they have, you know, their whole
- 36:55little family there together and they have a solid group and that's kind of always our
- 36:59goal is because they're just so social and they form those bonds.
- 37:03It's so important to keep them together.
- 37:06What you just described, I never heard before.
- 37:09I've heard about all the false ideas that we propagate on goldfish.
- 37:18And I'm just astonished by the disparity between that public image of goldfish and
- 37:25the reality of who they are.
- 37:30I always am too.
- 37:34It's like simultaneously, you know, very frustrating and heartbreaking because I see those public
- 37:40perceptions all the time.
- 37:43And then also a privilege to get to witness those relationships and the family bonds that
- 37:47they have.
- 37:50You know, watching Wednesday and Lucas's relationship and seeing the comfort that he provided to
- 37:58her at the end of her life is just like something that I will always cherish.
- 38:03Because, you know, even before she passed, she was slowing down, she wasn't doing well
- 38:10and in her last week she wasn't really eating and she was kind of hanging out at the bottom
- 38:13of the tank and Lucas wouldn't leave her side.
- 38:18And so seeing them in there together, knowing Wednesday's background and knowing that she
- 38:23was at the end of her life and watching the comfort that he gave to her was just incredible
- 38:27to see.
- 38:29And I think it's tragic that most people don't know that that exists or don't see it with
- 38:36fish and with all animals and the relationships that they form.
- 38:40I use the term anthropomorphized to describe a bit of how the characters in Finding Nemo
- 38:46are built.
- 38:47But I have kind of a complicated understanding of that word because we often use it to mean,
- 38:57oh, those feelings of grief and of complicated, complex emotions that we display as humans,
- 39:04they are our feelings and the rest of the animal kingdom don't share those feelings
- 39:09with us.
- 39:10They're not capable of that emotional depth.
- 39:16And we use, oh, you're anthropomorphizing animals in a way of saying this is the domain
- 39:26of humans.
- 39:27These emotions like the grief you mentioned is the domain that it's proper to humans
- 39:38and not to animals.
- 39:41Yeah, so when you tell stories like these, I think it destroys that view, that belief,
- 39:52which is so well rooted in our minds.
- 39:57Yeah, I think that's a really, really good way to describe it.
- 40:01And I haven't really thought of it from that perspective before, but you're completely
- 40:05right.
- 40:06We use this explanation of, oh, you're anthropomorphizing to just dismiss the experiences of animals
- 40:13and say that that is a uniquely human experience when it's not.
- 40:17And I think that's part of what lets us as a species treat other animals the way that
- 40:24we do and why these myths around fish in particular, but around all animals are still so pervasive.
- 40:33Because I think that if instead of saying that, oh, the grief that Nemo's father experienced
- 40:40is just anthropomorphization, and is that a word?
- 40:44Yes, I think so.
- 40:46Okay.
- 40:47If instead of dismissing it that way, we actually had to sit with the experiences like what
- 40:53I saw with Wednesday and Lucas and say, no, this is real grief and this is loss and this
- 40:58is an experience that is shared across species.
- 41:01I think it would make it much harder for humans to treat other animals the way that we do.
- 41:08And I would dare to go as far as to say that sometimes when we witness those behaviors
- 41:16and experiences, we can learn from them.
- 41:19What's so shocking about learning from animals, learning love, learning how to go through
- 41:26grief or being inspired by other animals.
- 41:31But for the general public, it's like blasphemy.
- 41:35Don't say it.
- 41:36Yeah, I mean, that's such a good point.
- 41:39It was so powerful for me to witness Lucas staying by Wednesday at the end of her life.
- 41:45And I've always believed that that's important.
- 41:51If your companion or a family member or someone is at the end of their life, I think it's
- 41:56so critical that we be there with them and go through that process and that experience
- 42:00with them.
- 42:01And I think that we often want to run from a lot of those feelings and those experiences.
- 42:07And I think that we really can learn a lot from animals and the relationships that they
- 42:12have with each other and the respect that they show to each other in those situations.
- 42:17I want to quickly go back to the pet store story.
- 42:22I truly want to make a good job at covering that industry.
- 42:28So they are captured or bred in foreign countries and then brought to the US or to Europe or
- 42:36wherever the demand is.
- 42:40How are they brought to another continent?
- 42:45What are the means of transportation and what is it like from their point of view?
- 42:52So of course I am in the US, so I have the most experience with that.
- 42:56I know that there are some countries that actually do have some protections in place
- 43:00for fish.
- 43:01The United States is not one of them.
- 43:04So again, it will vary by species how transport happens.
- 43:09So fish like goldfish and the other community species who can live in groups are often transported
- 43:17in just plastic bags, usually in some kind of styrofoam cooler.
- 43:23They'll just come in this big cooler and they're in a bag and there's, I don't know, the bag
- 43:27is maybe a third to half full with water and the rest is air.
- 43:32And then they are acclimated to the pet store tanks from those bags.
- 43:37Bettas are unique because they have to be separated and so they are, rather than a single
- 43:44large bag, they're transported in tons of tiny individual bags, which will mean that
- 43:48you'll have a fish in, like, it's such a small amount of water.
- 43:57I mean, maybe three to four tablespoons of water.
- 44:02I don't know how many milliliters that is, I'm sorry.
- 44:05Like a very small amount of water.
- 44:07Like if you've seen the cups that they're in on pet store shelves, they're transported
- 44:10in less water than that.
- 44:13And you know, it is incredibly stressful for any of these fish.
- 44:21Transport is really, really hard on fish and it's really hard on any animals, but I think
- 44:26for fish in particular because their entire environment is going to be sloshing around
- 44:30and splashing.
- 44:32For a fish kept in a bag with other fish, they're banging into each other.
- 44:36There might be stress-based aggression because, of course, the space is far too small.
- 44:42The water quality is getting steadily worse.
- 44:44They may be getting low on oxygen, depending on how long they've been in the bag.
- 44:49It's just very, very, very stressful.
- 44:53Fish in the bag will die and now they're there and their bodies, you know, it's just terrible.
- 45:01It's so stressful for fish to be transported in that way.
- 45:08And you know, whether a fish is moving two miles down the road or coming from Thailand
- 45:15to Nevada, transport is always stressful.
- 45:20There are ways to minimize the stress and my understanding, I could, you know, I'm not
- 45:26positive but my understanding is that some companies will put certain kind of chemicals
- 45:30into the water to try to help like keep the fish a bit calmer and things like that.
- 45:35But it's just generally horrendously stressful.
- 45:43And yeah, it's awful.
- 45:45Tons of fish will die in transport and it's really, really heartbreaking.
- 45:52Well, this whole industry and economic activity is awful the way you describe it and the details
- 46:02are just gut-wrenching.
- 46:07But it is not a tragic situation.
- 46:09We can do something about it.
- 46:11We can change things for the better.
- 46:14And you have made that choice by opening Friends of Philip.
- 46:19So let me start by asking you, who is Philip?
- 46:26So Philip was our first rescue.
- 46:30He did pass away just this year, but he had been with us for almost four years, which
- 46:38a typical Betta lifespan, it varies dramatically, but two to five-ish years, some have been
- 46:44known to live up to eight, a lot live for less than a year, you know, it really kind
- 46:48of varies.
- 46:49So he was quite elderly, geriatric is what our vet always called him.
- 46:55So Philip was our first rescue, he was a Betta, and it was basically the first of what has
- 47:04become a very often repeated story for us where I saw him on a pet store shelf.
- 47:13It was the classic situation of being in one of those little cups of water.
- 47:18He looked just terrible.
- 47:20You know, I was pretty new to fish at the time, but even having not seen very many sick
- 47:25fish, it was so apparent that he was in horrible shape.
- 47:29I look back at the photos of him now and I'm honestly surprised that he survived.
- 47:36But his fins were rotted away, he was incredibly thin, he was very, very pale, just, you know,
- 47:44to almost anyone looking at him, it should have been apparent that he was going to die
- 47:47if he stayed there.
- 47:50So I asked the manager at the pet store if I could adopt him, and they said yes, so they
- 47:58let me take him home for free.
- 48:01And so I had a fish, but I didn't have any of the equipment for the fish, which is not
- 48:08the thing I would recommend doing.
- 48:11What I did have was a very thorough understanding of the nitrogen cycle and a process called
- 48:16the fish-in cycle, and of all of the things that I needed to keep a betta healthy and
- 48:22safe.
- 48:24And so with that, I just needed the tank, so I ran to another store, I got the tank,
- 48:28I got all the equipment, and kind of got him home and situated, and then panicked about
- 48:33it for several weeks while I was doing the cycle process and going through all these
- 48:37things for the first time.
- 48:40But he recovered, and he did very, very well for a really long time.
- 48:47And seeing that process and facilitating that process is what kind of motivated me to keep
- 48:55doing it and to get more involved in fish rescue and advocacy.
- 49:02Let me say that I think it's beautiful how you had that instinct, that instant compassion
- 49:09for Philip and decided to adopt him in a spur of the moment situation, because we often
- 49:18have this instinct for doing good, for giving, for being compassionate, but then we stop
- 49:25ourselves and we don't express our inspiration to do good.
- 49:31So I'm so happy to hear that this was a true moment of instinct and inspiration that you
- 49:41had for him.
- 49:44So okay, you adopt Philip, he's in your home.
- 49:50How do you go from there to let's adopt more fish and let's create an animal sanctuary?
- 49:57That's a good question.
- 50:00I think I'd been vegan for a little bit.
- 50:06I'd been volunteering at a really amazing farmed animal sanctuary for a bit by that
- 50:12point too.
- 50:15And I think there was just always that part of me that was like, well, of course I'm going
- 50:22to eventually be rescuing animals.
- 50:25That's the only natural progression for my life.
- 50:29And so I think that was a decent part of it.
- 50:33And really it was that I was not in a position where I thought that I had the resources or
- 50:42really like the space to be able to rescue terrestrial farmed animals.
- 50:48And looking back on that, I'm kind of sad that that's the reason that fish became the
- 50:53focus because I wish that I had just known that fish needed so much more help.
- 51:01And I wish I had just known that, but I didn't.
- 51:04But it was really bringing Philip home and connecting with him and starting to learn
- 51:09more and more about our treatment of fish and our interactions with fish that kind of
- 51:16drove me towards aquatic animals and fish specifically.
- 51:21Because I think to that point, I had been a, I would say, a pretty typical vegan that
- 51:29I cared so strongly about terrestrial animals.
- 51:31And I of course didn't eat fish and I thought fishing was terrible.
- 51:34And I knew on the very broad level how bad some of these things were.
- 51:41But I think just like many of us, I'd never had that moment of understanding and connection
- 51:46with a fish and recognizing just how incredible they are.
- 51:53And so getting that connection with Philip really facilitated that.
- 51:57And it sort of became, it was just this moment of like, wow, this is something that I could
- 52:01actually do is that I have the space, I have the resources, I have the time.
- 52:07I was very successful with our first rescue and I thought I could do it again.
- 52:15So a couple months, I want to say, I brought Philip home in July and I think in October
- 52:23or November, our next two rescues came home and that was Frankie and Ozai who were two
- 52:28bettas that had been kept together in a really just awful situation.
- 52:33And I got to see them recover and them flourish and do very, very well.
- 52:40And it just kind of continued to build steadily from there.
- 52:45I never wanted to let things get crazy of suddenly going from zero tanks to 50 overnight
- 52:52and getting it over my head or something.
- 52:53But a bit over a year after Philip came home, I decided to actually make it into an organization.
- 53:04And I was bouncing around of should it be like a pet fish rescue?
- 53:09Should it be a small animal rescue?
- 53:10What kind of organization should this really be?
- 53:13And ultimately settled on a fish sanctuary because I think that farmed animal sanctuaries
- 53:21are so valuable and I can see what they do to let people connect to farmed animals.
- 53:27And I know that fish need that too.
- 53:31How many residents are right now in your care?
- 53:38Right around 100.
- 53:39Wow.
- 53:40Yeah, of just over 25 species.
- 53:44And where did they come from?
- 53:50So it varies a bit.
- 53:51Most of our bettas came from pet stores in the same way that Philip did.
- 53:55We of course would never buy a fish, but we do take in pet store surrenders.
- 54:00So most of our bettas came from that situation.
- 54:06All of our community species, so like the tetras, the danios, the Corydoras, the cute
- 54:16little tropical dudes, those were all caregiver surrenders.
- 54:22And then our goldfish were also caregiver surrenders.
- 54:27Oh, there's a train driving past my house.
- 54:30I hope you can't hear it.
- 54:31Oh, it's okay.
- 54:32I mean, it adds to the ambiance.
- 54:35Okay.
- 54:36Yeah, I can go on mute.
- 54:38There's an intersection right over there.
- 54:42Sorry.
- 54:44But yeah, so the goldfish and the cold water species were also caregiver surrenders.
- 54:52And then we have two geckos who were caregiver surrenders and we have three hens who were
- 54:57as well.
- 54:58But of course, mostly fish.
- 55:00And what does it take to care for all of them?
- 55:07First of all, how many tanks do you have for all of those fishes?
- 55:14It's a little embarrassing because I never know off the top of my head and I always have
- 55:17to count even though it's always the same number.
- 55:21But well, actually it has changed recently.
- 55:24We've said goodbye to some of our older betta residents recently.
- 55:29So I've kind of decreased the number of small tanks that we have.
- 55:34But we currently have, oh dear, sorry, 20 tanks.
- 55:43And that includes two, I call them like stock tank ponds.
- 55:45So you know, like the big plastic kind of look in stock tanks that are often used for
- 55:50farmed animals to just drink water out of.
- 55:53We have two of those in our garage for goldfish and cold water species.
- 55:58And the other tanks are your kind of classic glass aquarium that have our tropical species
- 56:04in them.
- 56:05We have one additional stock tank outside and then we just finished our larger in-ground
- 56:11pond.
- 56:13So I don't think that quite counts as a tank though.
- 56:16Well, that's amazing.
- 56:18A pond.
- 56:19There's a lot.
- 56:20How big is it?
- 56:21How big is it, Paul?
- 56:23It is 3,300 gallons.
- 56:26So it's about six feet, it's just over six feet deep at its deepest point.
- 56:32And yeah, it's pretty sizable.
- 56:35It was a very big hole.
- 56:37And how many hours of work does it represent to care for all of them?
- 56:44It really varies.
- 56:46So each day I spend, it's really very quick.
- 56:50That's the fun thing with fish and aquariums is that there's not the kind of, you know,
- 56:55daily poop scooping that you do, like we do for like the chickens.
- 56:59So each day it's probably 10 minutes in the morning, 10 minutes at night to feed everybody
- 57:04and check on everyone and make sure they're doing okay.
- 57:07And then when they need water changes, it'll be several days.
- 57:13You know, maybe I'll spend an evening doing six or eight water changes and I'll do that
- 57:19a few nights a week.
- 57:22But it does depend a bit on when the tanks need changes and how everyone's doing and
- 57:27all of that kind of stuff.
- 57:30And the logistics of it, I mean, you had to have taken the time to think about it.
- 57:39And I don't think there is a manual out there that you can read from to tell you how to
- 57:47care about all of them.
- 57:50Unfortunately, there's almost too many manuals and most of them are not very good.
- 57:58So that's one of the challenges is that there isn't in for most cases a single place that
- 58:04you can go and really learn about how to care properly for fish.
- 58:11That is changing.
- 58:12Our Aquatic Vet has an amazing website with all kinds of resources on it.
- 58:17More and more sites like, have you heard of the Open Sanctuary Project?
- 58:22Yes.
- 58:23And the Micro Sanctuary Resource Center.
- 58:26They're both doing more and more resources on fish, which is amazing and things like
- 58:31that.
- 58:32So resources are becoming available, but a lot of what I know has just been gathered
- 58:38through hours upon hours of searching through things on the internet and trying to think
- 58:44really critically.
- 58:45Because some sites will tell you that a goldfish does great in a 20 gallon tank and that is
- 58:50not true.
- 58:52So there is just a lot of kind of critical thinking and trying to figure out, okay, how
- 58:56much do I trust this source?
- 58:58And does this just make sense to me based on my experience with fish either similar
- 59:04to this species or the species in particular and that kind of thing?
- 59:07I'm so happy that you're doing this pioneering work, but at the same time, I'm thinking we
- 59:13have been keeping goldfish in captivity for decades and it's only now in 2023 that we're
- 59:22gathering that kind of data on the topic.
- 59:26I thought that we were more informed on how to care for them.
- 59:32I think we're informed in a lot of ways, but I think a lot of the information around fish
- 59:39keeping is honestly really similar to what you find with terrestrial animals where it's
- 59:47information on how to keep them alive and healthy enough, but it's not really information
- 59:54on how to provide them with an environment where they can truly thrive.
- 1:00:00I encounter this a lot with like our hens where we have a heater, of course, in our
- 1:00:04coop for our chickens because it gets incredibly cold here in the winter.
- 1:00:08But if you go onto any kind of quote unquote backyard chicken resource, they'll say, oh,
- 1:00:13chickens can handle the cold or this is a cold hardy breed.
- 1:00:17I think a lot of the information around fish is very similar where it's, yeah, a goldfish
- 1:00:22can survive in a 20 gallon tank alone and they will never be happy that way.
- 1:00:31But when our goal is to have something pretty to look at and have that thing as we see it
- 1:00:38survive, it's not too much of a concern to the people putting together that information
- 1:00:44whether the fish is actually happy.
- 1:00:47I guess that's where the vegan factor plays a role, an important role.
- 1:00:51That's why it's important for animal rights organizations to be led by vegans and not
- 1:00:57just your random person who is not truly committed to the animal rights cause.
- 1:01:05Yeah, I agree and I think you encounter that in the fish keeping world.
- 1:01:12People call it the hobby, which I hate, but you encounter that a lot in that community
- 1:01:18where there are plenty of people who care very strongly about their fish being healthy
- 1:01:23and happy.
- 1:01:26But those are some of the same people who will turn around and be getting rid of their
- 1:01:31fish because they want to go in a different direction with their tank or something like
- 1:01:34that.
- 1:01:39If we truly care about these animals and want them to thrive and survive and be happy, their
- 1:01:47well-being has to be the priority.
- 1:01:49It can't be what we want and what we think is a good look or what we think makes sense
- 1:01:54for them.
- 1:01:55It has to truly be from the perspective of, okay, is this best for the individuals?
- 1:02:02How do you provide healthcare to your sanctuary's residents?
- 1:02:08That's a great question.
- 1:02:10Unfortunately, in the fish world, most people think that vet care is just not a thing, which
- 1:02:18is not at all the case.
- 1:02:20If you go to most fish stores in the United States, they'll be selling all kinds of different
- 1:02:26medications and antibiotics and things.
- 1:02:28I don't know what it's like in other countries, but I know in the United States, these are
- 1:02:32not regulated medications and they're sold.
- 1:02:36You can get random antibiotics that aren't regulated or tracked or things like that that
- 1:02:42you then go home and are exposing yourself to and putting in your tank to treat something
- 1:02:46that may or may not actually need that medication.
- 1:02:52There's all kinds of misinformation online about fish healthcare and treatment.
- 1:02:58Most people think that that's the only option, but we use an incredible aquatic veterinarian,
- 1:03:04Dr. Jessie Sanders at Aquatic Veterinary Services.
- 1:03:07She has a mobile practice that covers California and Nevada, which is incredible, but there
- 1:03:12are aquatic vets all over the place.
- 1:03:15They're not as common, of course, as your typical dog and cat vet, but they do exist
- 1:03:21and you can find them.
- 1:03:24For our residents, I have a small number of things that I will do personally.
- 1:03:29If a new fish is coming home and needs some additional support, I might use some aquarium
- 1:03:33salt or things like that.
- 1:03:36For any kind of true treatment, it's all done by our veterinarian.
- 1:03:41We only use medications that have been prescribed.
- 1:03:43We only treat based on her prescriptions and recommendations.
- 1:03:47We've had a number of fish deal with things like bacterial infections that she can diagnose
- 1:03:54and then provide good regulated prescribed medications for.
- 1:04:03That's just huge.
- 1:04:04Fish vet care looks just like terrestrial animal care.
- 1:04:08Our residents have received x-rays, they've gotten ultrasounds, they've gotten injections
- 1:04:13of antibiotics, they've had antibiotics added to the water.
- 1:04:19We've had all kinds of treatment just like a terrestrial animal can receive.
- 1:04:25I think that that's really, really valuable.
- 1:04:28Something that maybe people don't know about is that there are aquatic vets and they're
- 1:04:33amazing and they are so critical to providing responsible, compassionate care to fish.
- 1:04:41I want to highlight how if you visit your Instagram account, there are some residents
- 1:04:49that you post about who have been gravely mutilated or went through hell and you're
- 1:04:58keeping them alive, which is quite touching.
- 1:05:02I guess your vet is playing a key role in that process.
- 1:05:08Absolutely.
- 1:05:09Yeah.
- 1:05:10We have a number of disabled residents, like you said.
- 1:05:13We have fish who've come in with injuries and things.
- 1:05:19We consult with our veterinarian on things like that in the same way that we would for
- 1:05:23any other species.
- 1:05:26It's incredibly, incredibly important to me to prioritize quality of life and an animal's
- 1:05:32ability to live a happy, healthy life over anything else.
- 1:05:38Our disabled residents will put some accommodations into their tanks, things that our vet has
- 1:05:44recommended, things that I've learned online, things that we've just learned help them through
- 1:05:48observation.
- 1:05:53Our relationship with our vet is so integral to all of that, being able to provide the
- 1:05:59care for our disabled residents and for our fully abled residents.
- 1:06:05Because without her, we would be kind of in the dark on a lot of this stuff and knowing
- 1:06:11if we're doing the right thing.
- 1:06:13It's so, so important to have that relationship.
- 1:06:16For the listeners who are inspired by what you're doing and who understand now how important
- 1:06:27your work is and how you're working hard to care for them, how can they support your mission
- 1:06:35and your sanctuary?
- 1:06:39There are a few ways.
- 1:06:40We're on Instagram and on Facebook.
- 1:06:43Both are friends of Philip Fish Sanctuary.
- 1:06:45It's a little long.
- 1:06:48So we're on there.
- 1:06:49You can follow us and follow along with the residents and things.
- 1:06:54We do have through the social media links to different ways to support us through donations
- 1:07:00and whatnot.
- 1:07:01Honestly, the best way to support what we're trying to do is to just talk about fish more
- 1:07:10and to advocate for them when you can.
- 1:07:13I think a lot of us encounter fish as these living decorations in people's homes and it
- 1:07:19can be an uncomfortable conversation to say, hey, I see you have a fish in a bowl.
- 1:07:23Have you considered getting them a tank and things like that?
- 1:07:28Then of course, to just not buy them and to not support the industries that are harming
- 1:07:34them, that is always going to be the best and easiest way to support and advocate for
- 1:07:39fish.
- 1:07:40Well, that was my next question.
- 1:07:41For the vegans who are listening to this podcast, what is your message to motivate them to take
- 1:07:50action for sea life, for the fish population, against what is happening in pet stores and
- 1:07:58through the fishing industry?
- 1:08:01That's a very good question.
- 1:08:05I think the main thing I would want to say is to not underestimate your own power and
- 1:08:11influence in these situations.
- 1:08:16If you're in the position and prepared to want to individually rescue a fish, that's
- 1:08:20amazing, but a lot of people can't do that or simply don't want to take that on and that's
- 1:08:26fine.
- 1:08:28I think that the worst thing we can do is nothing because if we're silent, then nothing
- 1:08:37is ever going to change.
- 1:08:40Having ways to advocate that align with you personally and the things that you are passionate
- 1:08:48about and motivated to do, whether that's going to protests, whether it's sharing on
- 1:08:53social media, whether it's individual rescue, whether it's volunteering at a sanctuary or
- 1:08:59things like that, I think that that can be really huge.
- 1:09:04I would say that if you're a vegan who's already involved in animal rights and animal advocacy,
- 1:09:10I would just say please evaluate your messaging and make sure that you're including fish.
- 1:09:18It's so, so, so easy and so, so, so common for individual vegans and vegan organizations
- 1:09:26to just not include fish at all.
- 1:09:29I don't think it's ever done out of any malice.
- 1:09:31It's just out of that same perspective that we all kind of struggle sometimes to connect
- 1:09:36to aquatic life because we don't see them as much.
- 1:09:39And so, if you're in the position to, I don't know, work with an organization and change
- 1:09:43their messaging to better include fish and aquatic life, that's huge.
- 1:09:48And that's exactly what these animals need.
- 1:09:51And of course, people will find links to your Instagram and other resources in the description
- 1:10:01below.
- 1:10:03So Gwendolyn, this was a pleasure.
- 1:10:08I think we covered most of what I wanted to cover.
- 1:10:14Did you have anything more to add before we end this conversation?
- 1:10:19Yeah, I think there's kind of one thing I always try to emphasize when I'm talking about
- 1:10:26fish and fish rescue in general, because I think a lot of very well-intentioned people
- 1:10:31will hear me talk about fish rescue and get motivated to do it themselves.
- 1:10:36And that's amazing.
- 1:10:39And my historian, Philip, is very cute, and I rescued him in some ways on impulse.
- 1:10:46But I had an incredibly thorough understanding of what I needed to do to keep him safe and
- 1:10:53keep his aquarium healthy.
- 1:10:56And just Googling the nitrogen cycle and researching that and making sure you understand it is
- 1:11:04going to be one of the most important things you could ever do if you're interested in
- 1:11:08fish rescue.
- 1:11:09And going into fish rescue or bringing a fish home without a thorough understanding of the
- 1:11:14nitrogen cycle and how to keep them safe and how to take care of their aquarium is doing
- 1:11:19them a huge disservice, regardless of intention.
- 1:11:24And so I don't want to discourage anyone from rescuing fish or any animals if they're excited
- 1:11:29to, but it's so, so, so important to make sure that we're doing it responsibly.
- 1:11:35That's the key word here.
- 1:11:36We want responsible rescuers.
- 1:11:40If not, you're just part of the problem, I guess.
- 1:11:45Exactly.
- 1:11:46Amazing.
- 1:11:47So again, this was such a pleasure talking with you and such an inspiring and educative
- 1:11:55conversation.
- 1:11:56Thank you so much, Gwendolyn, for having accepted my invitation.
- 1:12:00Oh, of course.
- 1:12:02Thank you so much for having me.
- 1:12:03It's been a pleasure.
- 1:12:04Thank you everyone for listening.
- 1:12:06I kindly invite you to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 1:12:10Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 1:12:13Again, thank you so much for caring and I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.