Latest / Jew York Times / Israel Election Listern Mailbag with Shanie Reichman from Israel Policy Forum
Transcript
- Eitan: Welcome to the Jew York Times 120 Angry Seats. My name is Etan Levine. As always, I am joined by Shinee Reichman from the Israel Policy Forum. Today we're going to be talking about Israel's election. Tomorrow is the big day. The first of 17 elections that plan to take on. Shanie: If we're lucky. Eitan: If we're lucky, it'll be over in 17. Tomorrow is. Officially election day in Israel. I in honor of this, we did a listener mailbag where I put up some question where I put up an open question submission forum on my Instagram and a bunch of you guys sent in your questions. So we're gonna be going through them. I also gonna be we're also gonna be going over the basics of what the polling is looking like all those stories and more on today's episode of the Jew York Times Chenille. Sing it with me. Shanie: Absolutely not. Eitan: Yeah da do One day Shanie: I just come on here to hear you serenade me. Eitan: It's beautiful. Listen, one day you're gonna join. I know that there's a whole Kalicia problem that you're trying to respect here, but Shanie: You don't know who listens to this podcast? Eitan: O Orthodox Jewish men who who cannot hear women sing. That's the demo for the entire thing. Shiny, Shanie: It's a target. Target audience. Eitan: you know, you're at the Israel Policy Forum. This is like your most busy time ever, I assume. Like Shanie: Mm. Eitan: you've got to be swamped. So what is like what what is your life kind of look like right now? Shanie: This week, I believe I'm recording seven different podcasts. Not all Eitan: Crazy. Shanie: elections focused, but many are. doing a couple of briefings for different organizations, probab speaking, probably speaking to a bunch of journalists. yeah, that's kind of try I've been like someone's been pushing me an opinions editor at a papers and pushing me to write an op ed that I'm trying to avoid doing. So like I'm kind of being a delinquent. And then I like have, you know, there's a lot of other things. parts of my job that I'm neglecting this week essentially. But this is like a very, very busy season would be a strong word, but this week is crazy. I told people, like, please don't talk to me this week. Eitan: When comes to the election specifically, what is like the top two things that people are wondering about or b or are curious about or or talking about? Shanie: Yeah, obviously everyone wants to know who's gonna win. That's like a given. That's number one. Number two, which is a very close second, is will it actually make a difference in terms of the US Israel relationship and how Americans and everyone else in the world talks and thinks about Israel? Because there is what I think is a right-wing propaganda tool, which is to convince people, to convince Israeli voters and everyone else that it actually is irrelevant who's in power in Israel. Everyone has always hated us, will always hate us. It's just anti-Semitism. And so it doesn't matter who's in charge. I don't believe that at all, but that's like What people are hearing, and so they're always asking me, will Gaudi Isencott actually be different? And even if he is different, will people who dislike Israel care about that? Will they be able to discern that difference? Eitan: we just had a conversation with Sammy Sage about this exact question about like what Israel American relations relations are gonna be like in a potential post-BB world. And you know, guys, what do you think? Like you y I don't know if I need to give my answer because people will have heard this episode already. But like, what do you think? will it change? Like, do you think that the average American voter, the person just in America who maybe has a neutral to slightly negative view of Israel, who maybe really doesn't like B B, are they gonna look at this and say, all right, slaves clean, new thing? Shanie: Yeah. I think the people who believe it won't make a difference are leaning into like you can see some really far left people, or I should say really anti-Israel people writing up ads like, don't be fooled, gaudy eyes and all will be the same, old, same. Like, don't don't misconstrue this and think that they're liberal now and that now you align with Israelis because we still don't, we still hate them. And but the fact that you see the extremists doing that makes me believe, like that's the reason I think, like they're saying that because they know that the average American is going to say, Wow, this is a new Israel. And think about ourselves, like. There are a lot of countries around the world who I think have corrupt, horrible leaders. And therefore I think the country is a bad, corrupt country in a very nuanced unnuanced way. When there is an election in those countries and there's a different person elected, I am inclined, as again, as like our average dumb American who knows nothing to think, maybe things are better there now. And if I see things that are different, I will be inclined to think differently. Now, I recognize there's an anti-Semitism that underlines a lot of how people feel about Israel, but there's also a lot of normal people. Who just see a leader who, personally, I don't like, and I can't blame them for not liking, doing things that again, I don't like and they shouldn't either. And so yeah, I think when that person changes, it makes a difference. And I think that it again, as much as I wanna wanna separate out like support for BB versus support for Israel, hatred of BB versus hatred of Israel. I thought about this the other day. If someone asked me, like, how do you feel about Russia and how do you feel about Putin? I would think of those as being the same question. And so when you ask me, Well, what do you think of Netanyahu? And what do you think of Israel? People read that as the same question and they feel it the same way. by the way, not Jews. American Jews are incredibly nuanced and able to separate Eitan: No I'm still. Shanie: those things, but nobody else is, and they shouldn't be. Like, I can't do that for any country and I don't do it. so yeah, I do think it will make a difference. And that is the one of the top questions I get. again, I really think it's like Netanyahu propaganda trying to say, like, don't be fooled, it has nothing to do with me. people just are always gonna hate us. And it has a little to do with you. You ran the country for 15, 16 years, like. Take a little responsibility for where we're at. Eitan: I I I think BB he represents the memefication of Israel. Where when people talk about Israel, they talk about the war, they talk about everything, even in West Bank, Palestinians, Gaza, it's not a real conversation. Everything has become so toxically heightened and through internet speak to a point where people don't view Bibi Netanyahu as a regular person. They view him as some sort of Jewish demigod that has his like fingers, has his Jewy fingers in all these places. And it does Look bad. It looks, when we talk about Jew people thinking that Jews control things or that Jews are dog walking America, or that we have, that we control the money system, or that our politics and support of Israel is what's propping up political support in America. If you take away BB from a lot of that, I do think that it definitely calms down the average person. I over 70% of Americans don't vote. There's no way that more than one percent, two percent care about Israel. So it's like if you get the best case scenario here is you get to a place where no one thinks anything positive or negative about Israel. They think about it the same way they think about Morocco, they think about Turkey, they think about Denmark. And what I love about Gaudi, honestly, is that he doesn't speak English. And I think that like not in okay, I'm not saying Shanie: He speaks English. Eitan: listen, not in a way where he's gonna be in the Oval Office every single time where Trump comes where where he comes into America, where he's Taking where he's giving there is an issue with Bibi Netanyahu seeming like an American in the way that he that he is, that I think that Gotti does kind of limit where if there's a wall pit between the prime minister and the president, it's not the worst thing to have. I think that he just he reads so differently than than BB does. He'll be called a war hawk. He'll be, you know it is? If anything, if BB is looked upon as some sort of like cunning, conniving. wheeler and dealer, then Gotti is gonna be looked upon as an artillery shell of a human being, I think, when people are looking to like to to put anything on him. They'll just be like, well, he just wants to, you know, push out the Palestinian. Whatever whatever fake whatever fake thing that they think they're gonna that he is that he is doing, they're gonna be able to put that onto him. And I think that it's gonna be him being more of like a force than wheeler and dealer. That's kind of my thought on him. Yeah. Shanie: Okay, so I have to comment on two things. First of all, it like a lot of the ways the cartoonish ways people per see people portray Benjamin Itanyao is fully anti-Semitic and really rooted in anti-Semitic memes and and perceptions. Eitan: Mm-hmm. Shanie: And it's really horrible and disgusting, and I hate it. that doesn't mean that the people who do that always realize, I think they often don't. and so I do think you're right that it can change when people remove Netanyahu, not because the anti-Semitism goes away, but because some of the people who use those tropes don't necessarily realize. because you do have to be like relatively knowledgeable to understand that when you have these gross memes of like the dog walker, this is actually like Nazi propaganda and it does take someone intelligent to realize. But I don't want to place all that blame on Netanyahu because like anti-semit Semitism Eitan: Hundred percent. Shanie: existed long before. I know you know that, but I have to say it because my job is to like insert the nuance in your rants, which I do love and align with your rants, but Eitan: I love it by the way. Shanie: important. and Gaudi Isencott, he speaks English. He does not come across as a polished, like straight out of Oxford guy. And I do think that lands well. I do think we need an Israeli leader who can come and speak with with Donald Trump or whoever the US president is. And I think Gaudi Eisenhock can do that. I don't think you need to be Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: absolutely fluent. I also think you can have a a foreign minister in Neftali Bennett, an excellent one, or Yari Eitan: Yes. Yep. Shanie: Lapide, both of whom speak perfect English. and that also can help. So and in terms of just speaking to the broader public. You don't need to have fluent English. You actually have amazing role leaders all over the world who don't speak fluent English. Gadi Eisencott's English from what I'm trying to remember last I heard him in English, but it's like quite solid and it has he has an Eitan: It's fine. Shanie: accent and like he's allowed to have an accent and actually if you message test it, not to be that person, but it lands better. Like people are much more like, much more likely to feel positively towards an Israeli leader with an accent. So it doesn't actually hurt perceptions of Israel. Eitan: I let just say I agree. That's the all everything you said is the points that I'm making where people think that BB, he's too he's too American, where he's able Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: to talk in the vernacular. Obviously, Gotti can speak English. Obviously, Gotti is gonna be able to hold his own with whatever American politician he's in the room with. There's no doubt in my mind that he's able to go in there and have those conversations. It is Shanie: Totally. Eitan: also, you know what's great about Shoei Otani? Is that we never hear him speak. And because of that, we can't attach things to him in a certain way. I only hear the translator. You know, Shanie: Mm. Eitan: Bennett, Lapide, whoever decides, whoever is put in charge of the relationship, whoever these is the minister, the foreign minister, or whatever title that they give him, I'm sure it's gonna do a totally okay job, assuming that, you know, this election ends in the way that you know, personally we're fingers crossed hoping for. But I do think though, I agree that getting rid of BB does kind of offer. Some reset, not a full reset, because we are still gonna be dealing with the voices out there. They're gonna be like that are gonna criticize Israel no matter what. And we'll continue to to say that, that whoever's in charge is just wants to carpet bomb the place and make a greater Israel project happen. that'll always be there. but you know, I do think the average person I dead serious, if you ask the average American who the prime minister of of Britain is, they're gonna say Tony Blair. Like No one's gonna know Gaudi's name like i i his n Shanie: Yeah. Well, that's because there are way too many prime ministers in a row in the UK. I don't know what's happening over there. Eitan: It's because Americans are stupid. It's because we don't it doesn't involve us. No one gives a shit. The only I don't think anyone, I think the average person will not know Gaudi Isencott's name within a year and a half after he's elected. After he's elected, and boy do I love that reality. That'd be amazing. Absolutely amazing. Ugh. Shanie: Perfection. One can one can only dream of a world in which the average person doesn't know the Israeli Prime Minister's name. Bezras Hashem. Eitan: Remember, for a lot of various until Donald Trump came along, I thought that the attorney general was just the like the the whoever the lawyer is for the army. I had no idea that there was and why? Because it never it never involved us. We didn't have to think Shanie: Ha ha Eitan: about this. There's no reason why I should know that Israel's voting system isn't based on geo geographics, it's it's a national system. Yes. Shanie: Totally. Keep this off keep this off everyone's radar. Eitan: No one should know this. No one we don't people don't need to know that there are thirty seven parties in this upcoming election, okay? People don't need to know that. They need to know that ultimately there's only a couple that are there. Which is, I will say, pat myself on the back, phenomenal segue. Absolutely phenomenal segue here. Sheny, we have a bunch of questions that came in about the elections. The first question that I want to ask you, though, didn't come in from the question submission thing that we put up. This actually came in from Sammy and was a question that I had also. One of the bigger stories about this election has been. all of the Israeli expats or Israelis who have moved out of the country in shocking numbers, tens of thousands have filtered back into Israel. For a while, there was a little bit of a concern that these people weren't gonna be getting be able to get back in because there was the whole, like, is BB gonna shut the airports? Are they gonna limit flights? Are they gonna whatever? I saw somewhere that it was in the 70,000 range of how many people had had come back into Israel. Two questions on this. The first question is: the people that are coming back. What do you, and there's no polling out there, I get this. What do you assume, or what do you think those voters, how are they gonna vote? Are all because they're coming back doesn't mean that they're gonna vote against BB, doesn't mean they're gonna vote for people. So I curious what you thought on that. And the second Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: one, and you can answer within the first one, is does it actually make a difference? The 70,000 voters who are coming back, does it actually make a difference? Those are my two questions. Shanie: Yeah, first of all, yes. it's between sixty and eighty thousand. I just read seventy thousand people flying back. Israel is a very small country. That's a couple mandate bam mandates. And don't forget, even 10,000 could be the sorry, not 10,000, even a thousand could be the difference between four seats and zero seats. Never forget that, okay? our our listeners know about the electoral threshold. The difference could be just a f just a thousand seats between getting four seats and getting no seats. But but any regardless, it's still a couple mandates, which really can shift things. I I do think they are overwhelmingly going to be voting for the opposition bloc, mainly because of the type of people who live abroad. A lot of these are people who basically moved over the past three few years because of the war left Israel. overwhelmingly, the people who did that were sort of upper middle class, upper class, educated. and from more liberal communities. We we just know the demographics of who moved. So academics and scientists and doctors and lawyers, tech folks. that's just technically this doesn't this does not mean they are lefties or liberals, but you don't have to be to vote for the opposition bloc in Israel. There are a lot of people in the center and the right wing who are voting for the opposition bloc because they don't want to see Netanyahu Gan, or they don't like Itzamar Benvir, or they want to see the ultra-orthodox drafted. There are a variety of reasons not to vote for Bibi, even if you're right wing, by the way. So it's not I think it's really expats are overwhelmingly overwhelmingly right wing, but I do think a lot of them left for the types of reasons that people vote against Netanyahu, right? the sharing the burden or feeling the economic impact, things like that. yeah. Eitan: Who who on the coalition side is that let's say there's that someone who is like pro BB all the way through, policy wise, but also doesn't want to deal with B B. That is someone that has just lost faith in B B. Who is that person gonna vote for? Shanie: You mean that they're right wing, but they don't support Netanyahu? Eitan: Right wing but don't want to vote in the in in the B B side or on any of the coalition that the B B is building. Shanie: Right. So you really have to decide if you c want Netanyahu to be the prime minister or not. that's something they would need to decide. because if they were right wing and they were okay with Gotti Eisencott, they could vote for Avigor Lieberman. Lieberman is very right wing, very hawkish, very anti-Haredi. he's very supportive of a military draft, but he's also very hawkish on security issues. So you could see him getting those people, but ultimately he's not gonna recommend Netanyahu to be the prime minister. So you have to be okay with an Eisencott Prime Minister if you vote for him. on the other side, you have Amkre Israel, which is a right wing O'Fair Winters slate, which is probably not gonna make it into the government, which is a good thing, I think. but they're also that's the influencer slate that you liked as you like to call it. Eitan: They were in the news also a week ago because there was that whole thing about the can please, please, please, can Shanie: Don't make me talk about this, it makes me so angry. Eitan: we talk about a little bit? Just a little bit, just a tiny little bit. One little bit. Okay, guys, the Shanie: Fine, a tiny little bit. Eitan: funniest thing happened. last week there was a bunch of influencers who kind of got duped into going on a West Bank trip. They thought they were going to area C, which is Israel. They ended up in area B. Shanie: Area C is still over the green line, it is still occupied territory. Go on. Eitan: It's Israeli is what I would say. It is Israelis. Shanie: Is really controlled. Eitan: The Arab is A area area A is Arab controlled by Arab. Area B is Arab controlled by Israel. Area C is Israel controlled by Israel. They thought that they were going. We got listen, we're trying not Shanie: It's more nuanced than that, but continue. Eitan: to make this story too long, okay? My I the the this group of influencers, Holl Silverman was in there and and that girl from the Netflix dating show was there, and Floor Hassan, floor. Not Hassan, Flor, whatever her name is, who it is Hassan Florizan, who was in Shanie: That is her name, Hassan, yeah. I think so. Eitan: the Ophir Winter, she's political party. She was one of the people that would potentially be in Knesset if they end up meeting the threshold. They all went on some tour that was pushed to them. They thought they were going into one area, they ended up going into another area and started getting chased out. A brick was thrown through a window. There was a pregnant woman that was in the car and it became a whole thing. Then we found out later that it seemed to be that the influencers were duped into going into an area that they shouldn't have been going into. And that led to the whole story. The influences, some Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: of the influencers feel that they were taken advantage of and tricked. Some of them have been quiet about this and haven't really said anything past that they had a brick thrown out them, which makes me think that, you know, the conspiracy hat on me thought that they may be new or whatever. But Shanie: I don't think so. Eitan: You don't think that they can? Shanie: I I think I I think that I don't know like who would have been involved, but like it was it was orchestrated by Reg Avim, which is a far right pro settlement organization. That's goal is to show people the truth about the West Bank that there are Palestinians living in mansions, as if that like changes anything. the fact there's some like rich expats who live in in Palestine in mansions, like shouldn't how does that affect how you think about the conflict? I don't really understand it. Eitan: Mm-hmm. Shanie: It's like Very bizarre take, but that's their goal is to showcase this sort of thing. and I think that they clearly were paying attention to the fact that they were taking this group a week before the elections. Okay. I think that's really important to say. I also think I have no idea of Fleur's involvement, but I know that she is running with a Likud aligned slate, right? On the right. And Eitan: D but but when I say that they knew, I don't know listen, the the influencers I don't know I don't think the influencers knew, but I Shanie: No, I don't either. Eitan: do you think she knew Floor? I know. Yeah. Shanie: I think she benefits. I think that her party benefits. It does not mean she knew, but it's it's obvious that when Jews are attacked by Palestinians, parties on the right benefit. Okay. That's a fact. And Eitan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Shanie: so a week before an election, again, this doesn't there's a difference between orchestrating something and benefiting. I do think the settlement group that took them knew, and I don't know like Eitan: Hundred percent. Shanie: that for sure. And they took them specifically into a town where Heidi Levine, the journalist, had been attacked, I believe, in the exact same town. And they didn't tell them they're going into Area B. and I what I also read, what Golda had posted, who was also in the group, she wrote that that the car ahead of her had been stopped and a Palestinian guy came out and said, It's too dangerous, like you need to turn around, you shouldn't come in here. And none of that was conveyed to them and they drove them in anyway. And they didn't speak Eitan: Yeah. It's crazy. Shanie: Arabic, so they had no idea. So this tour guide, like whoever this whatever this tour is, knowingly took him into a place that was unsafe for them. So I definitely think that they were involved and absolutely like knew, and not to say that they like planted I don't believe in conspiracies. I don't think they like planted some guy. I think but I think they Eitan: No, they I'm sorry, the tour guys knew Yeah. Shanie: knowingly took them somewhere dangerous without their consent, knowing they have large platforms and can promote their their messianic vision intentionally or by act or accidentally, unknowingly, a week ahead of an election. so yeah, I'm super frustrated and it was horrible. and it's by the way, like doesn't excuse Palestinians for throwing stones in at them and and you know trying to kill them. and it's just suck. It's horrible terrible Eitan: Totally, but at some point we have an obligation to be the we have an obligation to be the adults in the room in so many it's so frequently. And this is one of those things where it's a the if you're going into antagonized, you know, groups then there's nothing to be benefited from that. I just want to can I just say yeah. Shanie: I don't think they intentionally I don't think the people in the car, the parti the f influencers, knew that they were like were had any intention Eitan: No, they just Shanie: of antagonizing anybody. But I think that their their presence during a really heated moment inherently did that and without them knowing and without their consent. And I think that's like it's horrible. Eitan: The Tor guy, I'm sorry, I'm sorry, the group that brought them the group that not the brought them Yeah. Shanie: The group we all agree we both agree. The group is the problem. Eitan: They knew what they were doing, they knew that this was an attack, just growing into an area. Obviously, don't throw stones Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: at people or whatever, but at the same time, if you know that this is an area where whatever, we agree on this. I will say you made Shanie: Yeah. Yeah. Eitan: a point that I before we get into the questions that we got, that I super agree with here. And I don't know why this became the thing, but frequently content out of Gaza and the West Bank Centers around being like, look how good things are. they got markets. things are phenomenal. Look at this. look at this beautiful house edge here. Look at this. Shanie: There's a beach! Look at them at the beach. Eitan: it's so great. And it is one of the it's first of all, optically, it looks bad. It looks so bad when you see Jews trying to push that things are actually good in these areas where it ain't great. It just, it's not. And it's a thing that keeps on getting pushed that does very, very much like frustrate me. It's also morally, it's like we're empathetic people at the end of the day. Most of us care. Most of us, it just, it ain't that. yeah. Shanie: I yeah, I feel like Palestinians have a good is the hottest of takes. the other piece Eitan: Well it's the best take. Shanie: I will sorry. The other piece I will say is Khen Mazig actually spoke about this recently because he's like, Yeah, you have people saying that we're committing a genocide, and then you have Israelis like rolling their eyes and laughing and like mocking those people. And it's like, this is a serious thing we're talking about, even if we don't believe it happened. The fact that you're mocking this conversation, you're mocking like very real concerns about. What's happening in Gaza is a is part of the problem, not just first of all, from a moral standpoint, there is a humanity problem here. And then there's the other layer of strategically, you're not actually convincing anyone when you roll your eyes and scoff and laugh at real serious accusations being lobbed at you. and I have seen it like the pictures of Gazan kids at the beach, as though, guys, it's like really great over there. They're like hanging out at the beach. Come on, give me a break. Eitan: Yeah. It's crazy. That's what we'll get to. Think eventually AI Yeah. Shanie: One day we'll get to the same strategic precision precision that killed the Ayatollah. Eitan: I listen, AI is eventually gonna handle this all. We won't even have to worry about being good or bad because it's just gonna decide and then handle people based on that decision algorithm that is made. Man. Shanie: Okay. This Eitan: Anyways, this is what I'm running for office on. All right, Sheny, Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: before we go into the questions, last question I have for you. And that is just can we get a quick polling update on where we are at in the election? Now, you actually said something interesting about polling blackouts. Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: there's no new polling that happens after October twenty third. The election is on October twenty seventh. So and you said that's just to not influence the public. Is that what it was? Shanie: Yeah, I I think it people in Israel vote in a strategic way because you have to decide, am I gonna vote for him? Is he gonna make it over the threshold? Things like that. As you've seen through these conversations, that it's not the same as in the states where you're deciding between just two parties. You're deciding in Israel based from multiple parties, also based on if you what you think the likelihood is of them getting in. So they don't want it to be too influenced, they don't want it to be down to the wire. Which is why, you know, a few days in advance, about a week before, they stopped running polls. So now I'm gonna tell you the like Average of three different channels for the last poll, which has the Eisenblock at 54, the Netanyahu block at 50, Eitan: T trademarked. Shanie: trademarked, and 16 not aligned. And not aligned includes the Arab parties, which is important to say because you have Ram here getting between five and six seats, which would actually, if you add him to Eisencott, would put him at 60, which is one short of a coalition. and Netanyahu. I mean he's at I see him at fifty and I don't see anybody who it will be hard for him to peel off, but you never know. yeah. Eitan: So on on that, you know, let's say that, let's say in this scenario, things hold and Gotti only ends up with fifth what'd you say, fifty-nine, sixty? Is that where he would be at? Let's assume sixty, right? Well, let's Shanie: sixty, exactly sixty. But it but again, things things change, but Eitan: just walk me through the the scenario here. Is that Gotti ends up having sixty seats, not enough to form a government. What happens next? What is the path to it? In fact, you know what? This is actually a pretty good once again segue into this. this was a question that we had from Cutler Klein. What are the most likely potential paths Isaacod has to form a government if he wins? And I want to kind of just like double that onto this about what happens if he doesn't hit 60 but still has more votes than BB has. Shanie: then we go back to elections, unfortunately. Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: But Netanyahu remains the prime minister. So he stays, it's called a caretaker government, and he just stays in power through the next election. And as many as there are until we find somebody, he will remain in powers. and we've had that happen, you know, a couple of years ago it happened three times in a row. Eitan: So with that, then if Gotti is at sixty, then where does he eventually if there is a path to victory here, where does that extra seat come from? Shanie: well, this is not this is not precise, right? Like if you I mean, I don't think this is I don't think this is exact. I would don't think you should expect it to be exact. The channel 12 Eitan: No no, obviously. I'm j Yeah. Shanie: poll, where you look if you look at the channel 12 poll, he has an he has 61, right? That was the comp that was the the compilation of two to three different channels, but one of the channels has him getting 56 without ROM and then an extra five at 61. So we Eitan: Yeah, but Shanie: we don't know. Like he would have to, he could he could end up with like he could end up getting 54. for the from the Zionist opposition. It's possible. yeah. Eitan: Okay. That was my question. It's like if he gets to sixty, then what is that then where does that extra seat that he would need Shanie: If he gets to 60, he can try to peel off people from the Leakhood Party, like individuals, which is something that that's a process that has already started. But those people are probably not going to want to sit with the Rom party, which means he'd have to peel off a lot of them, which Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: I'm very skeptical of. because Rom is five seats, five, six, maybe seven seats. Like sometimes they overperform. I actually I'm being indoctrinated by all of the left-wing Israeli propaganda right now, where I'm like, my God, there's gonna be amazing turnout. There's gonna be super high Arab voter turnout. it's gonna be a landslide. So like don't listen to me right now. I'm like very hyped from all of like get your goal on content online. but it is, it is possible. but in order for him, what's Eitan: Well there was wasn't there Yeah. Shanie: that? Eitan: I'd say there was there was a ruling this week also about how there would be no guns at certain places or there was a they're they they're making sure that the security forces are in areas to make sure that there's no people with guns that show up and potentially like intimidate Arab voters was was a story that that had been trending for like a minute this past week. Yeah. Shanie: Mm-hmm. Yeah, it's it's actually like really I don't know. It's it's it's a big problem because ahead of elections, there are always risks, there are always risks of having intimidation tactics, especially in Arab communities. And you do have people who don't vote as a result. and as a reminder, Arab Israelis have a tendency to vote at lower rates than Isr Jewish Israelis. And if they voted at the same rates, you would easily have some kind of some kind of coalition for the the Gaudi Eisenhock block if you especially voted for the Rom Party or yet your Gulan, which many of them do. so important to say that like the intimidation tactics are are present and like they are they are an issue. but the pol yeah the police chief said like I'm that that he's going to to work on making sure that that people are able to vote. Eitan: Yeah. Has Gotti spoken publicly about his plans to include or not include Ram in his coalition? Is he do you think he's ultimately gonna do it, but just isn't saying it because he doesn't want to potentially leech off any like people Shanie: I do. Eitan: that hate Arabs? Or like what is the tactic that he's going through here? Shanie: Been saying since day one that I feel pretty confident that he is going to sit with Ram. Maybe I'm wrong. I think he's been leaving himself a lot of room to do that. Although he has said that he needs a party that's willing to condemn Hamas. And right now the Ram party has avoided doing that. and I think part of it, not to defend it, but I will say there's so much rhetoric in Israel that says every Gaza Gaza is Hamas. All Gazans are Hamas. It is all the same. Every every Palestinian is Hamas. And so Because of that rhetoric, it leaves the impression with the Palestinian public that when you condemn Hamas, so are you condemning all Palestinians? If you say it's good to target Hamas, are you saying it's good to target all Palestinians? Because this conflation of all Palestinians are Hamas also brings Palestinians to the conclusion that if I say I hate Hamas, what am I saying about actually all Palestinians as a whole? Because Israeli society believes that they are one and the same. Do you know what I'm saying? It's like a bit circular, Eitan: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Shanie: but that's that's how he's described it. he he was on He was on the Unholy podcast and he described it that way. And I was like, you know what? That actually, I do get it. Once, you know what we've spoken about? That's this is a terrible comparison, whatever. You'll edit Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: it out if it if it comes out bad. but but when I think Eitan: Mm-hmm. Shanie: of like the way like le le liberal left-wing Jews will like bring up issues with Israel, and then the right wing will be like, You're anti-Zionist. And so they're like, Am I anti-Zionist? Like, maybe I am. Meaning like changing how you see because of all these conflations, like you start to misidentify things. so s I do think that's obviously you'd also Palestinians who support Hamas, in it sorry, Arab Israelis, Palestinian citizens who support Hamas. but that's I think less his issue. I think his issue is really like the sympathy that comes from f seeing an Israeli society that views at it all as the same. Eitan: When does he make that decision about having Rom potentially sit with him? Is that actually broad I know that like, you know, like the big leaders of the coal of the the opposition to to BB like met and they signed like a pact together where they're gonna be, you know, working towards same goals and not attacking each other and stuff like that. You know, when does that officially become solidified? Is it after the election happens or so The potential order of operations here is that tomorrow everyone votes and then we see how many seats each party has. And then the let's solidify the government part happens. So Gotti doesn't need to say that he's gonna sit with you know with Rom before the election, but he could say afterwards, like, like we need this seat, so that is when we are gonna include them. Did I get that correct? Okay. Shanie: Yeah, so so polls close, you have a pretty good sense pretty early on, but there are thousands of double envelopes, which are prisoners and reservists and soldiers, and they're actually quite a lot of reservists and soldiers at the moment. and so that takes an extra day or two. so by the weekend, we would have a pretty good sense of the count, I would say. and then you have one week of President Herzog meeting with the heads of every party to ask them who they recommend for the prime minister. That's when he starts to get a sense. And I'm, I assume at some point during this conversation, he asks, What's your willingness to sit with these parties? but what you could envision again, it doesn't, I could be totally off. Like maybe I'm misreading the situation, or maybe Gotti starts to believe that actually he can peel off enough people from the Likud that he doesn't need the Arabs. I don't know. but if he is actually able, if he if he decides that he wants to be able to form a government with the Rom party. What he would do is I assume you'd have Ram put out a statement saying they condemn Hamas. That's my guess, is that he would come out and say, listen, or or some version of that, some version of of expressing something that would make him more palatable to the Israeli public and therefore make him aligned within Ghadi Eisenkot's like list of principles that he outlined. So that my guess is that he would push for that right before or right after. Like I actually think it's stra I think it's possibly strategic to not have him do it yet, because now he can say, like, Eitan: Totally. Shanie: nobody aligns with my principles. And then all of a sudden, look, he's now aligning with my principles. So that's my read on the situation. I really hope no Israeli Eitan: there's deniability. He Yeah. Shanie: voters watch this. But that is what I think is gonna happen. Eitan: You know what's you know what I could prom you know what I could actually promise you? I don't think a lot of Israeli voters are watching this at all. They're watching they no, you know what they are voting. I actually think that most Israeli voters are listening to this. Yeah, I'll go that path, actually. This is the deciding factor that's happening here. All right, Shani, couple questions for you. First question is coming from actually, wait, before I ask you the question, if you had to bet right now, right now on the poly markets to Cal Shis. If you were bet on who would win the election, who would you put money on? Shanie: On a moral level, I am ideologically opposed to betting on world events. I Eitan: Yes, yes. Shanie: the most likely, okay. I would put money on Gotti Eisencott because I have to. Eitan: Okay. Shanie: I like feel like I just need to. first Ministeraki Prime Minister also. but Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: the most if what you're really asking me is what's the most likely outcome of this election, the most likely outcome of this election is another election. Every poll I have seen leads me to that conclusion. The second most likely outcome. Sorry, you're gonna say something. Eitan: No, I was gonna I was gonna say assume let's assume this is the question is Prime Minister of Israel after the twenty twenty six election. That means that there's we've gone through and there is an ultimate winner who has who has figured it out no matter how many elections it takes. Shanie: Yeah. okay. Well that, yeah, fine. I'm still putting money on Gotti Eisenhock because it makes me sick to think about putting money on Bibi Netanyahu. however, I've been saying for six months only a fool bets against Bibi Netanyahu. And and which is which is why I the second most likely outcome is that Gotti Eisenhock becomes the prime minister and forms a coalition. That's what every poll consistently has shown me. And if this were any country, any other country in any other world. I would tell you that the odds of BB Netanyahu forming coalition are very slim and very unlikely. However, A, he has an uncanny ability to overperform, and he does tend to overperform compared to the polls. Two, he is not called the magician for nothing. He truly is an incredible politician. He is incredible at winning elections at campaigning. And so, again, if it were any other world, I would say that guy. He's out, but it's not that world. It's the world of Bibi Netariou. And so I I just cannot count him out ever, unfortunately. Eitan: I, if the election was one election, maybe even two elections, maybe three elections, sure. But the longer this thing goes, I it just it becomes, you know, it's like Trump. You deny, delay, you know, depose whatever the question is. It's like the longer that you stay in it, it's like all you gotta do is keep Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: on finagling and figuring out ways to kind of just remain, you know, to just to remain. If as long as you're it in order to be in the game, you gotta stay in the game. And I think that that is ultimately what is gonna happen is that we are gonna see different metrics. And you see slowly over time. Now the whole thing though is that Kingadi what? Shanie: Is that a sports thing? Is the like you gotta stay in the game a sports thing? Sound a sports thing. Eitan: no, I think it's actually a Hamilton lyric, if I'm not if I'm not mistaken. To be in the game, you gotta stay in the game. And by the way, that's Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: not a how this is a slam frank poster, play bull, by the way, over here. This is not a a Hamilton thing. But I'm just saying that if Gotti Shanie: So funny. Eitan: is able to cut this off in in only a couple of elections, if the longer it goes, the bigger percentage chance that B B will have, the quicker this goes, it seems like Gotti is the one that is more Shanie: Yes. Eitan: that has a a bigger percentage chance of going there. Yeah. Shanie: One hundred percent. One hundred percent. And also, as we've discussed in the past, as the incumbent in Israel, you have a lot more ability to shape what's happening in a way that Eitan: Yes. Shanie: you don't. I think the incumbent in the United States barely has an impact unless you're going to totally change the economy of a massive country. You can't really sway the vote even as even as the head of state. in Israel. I think you have so much potential to actually change what's happening on the ground by way of war and rhetoric and diplomacy and a hundred other things. So Unfortunately, you've had a unique advantage as the prime minister, which is why term limits should really exist in Israel. Thanks for coming to my TED Talk. Mm-hmm. Eitan: Yeah, but in and that is that's one of the things that the coalition has decided to do is to get rid of term limits. I will say also is that the one time, the only time it came close to potentially what whatevering that would be the insurrection. So unless that was the only way to stay to potentially sway to use your power as the president in order to keep the election from pushing forward, the closest thing we got to that was this idea of having Mike Pence not certify the vote or whatever, and that didn't work. Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: Clearly. Shanie: that's way more extreme than what I'm describing. Yes, that was horrible. That was horrible. Eitan: Yeah. okay, here we go. From the listener mailbag. Mighty burner put I mean you kind of already answered this, but what do you think the odds are that no party can form a durable coalition? So let's talk about that. You know, you had the the one, two, three here. Of the three here's the three scenarios. No coalition is made, so we go into another election. then Gotti wins, and then BB wins. Those are the three Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: possible you know paths here. What do you think is the percentage likelihood of of each path? Or something like that. Give me like a letter ranking, Shanie: my god. my god. Eitan: give me like a an A B C D E F or something. Shanie: Okay, I'm gonna say this pretending that I don't think Netanyahu is uniquely good. Like I'm gonna answer this as though I don't know that Bibi Netanyahu is Bi Netanyao, okay? In which case I think there is a 60% chance that there's another election. And then I let's say like 30% chance for Gotti, 25% chance for Gotti, 15% for BB, something like that. Eitan: I would let sorry, let me let me compartmentalize this. We kind of yes and no wait, let me rec let me recompartmentalize this. Percentage Shanie: Was that what you asked for? Okay. Eitan: chance that we go into another election, that'll stand on its own. So that it's that'll Shanie: okay. Eitan: be its own category here. And you know what we'll do this. a percentage chance it's one election and then percentage chance that it takes more than three elections, okay? Shanie: my God, this is too much math. What I hate this I hate this Eitan: And then divide that by seven and Shanie: plan. I think there is above a sixty percent chance that there's another round of elections. Eitan: And then do you how what percentage chance do you think is that we're gonna get multiple, over three elections? Okay. Okay, got it, got Shanie: Over three, no, but I th don't I don't know. I don't know. Stop with this. I have no idea. like I would be throwing out random numbers. Take let's take Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: it one election at a time. Eitan: Okay. So then, with B B as it yeah. Shanie: But but you were right. Your initial assessment that the longer this goes on, the more advantage B B has. I do historically that's been true. And I do think in gen I think that's true overall. Eitan: And do you think percentage wise, what do you think the I the percentages of Isencott, of Gotti Eisencott getting an election, getting a coalition together compared to B B outlasting and and figuring out his coalition? Shanie: I think Gaudi Isencott is much is is the more likely character to form a coalition by by quite a bit, by two to one. but Netanyahu again has historically managed to do this in very unusual times and unusual ways. He he's really masterful at it. Eitan: next question is from General Louie. Who is not getting into Knesset? Now there's a bunch of parties that are on the fringes that are flirting with that 3.25 percentage threshold that are gonna that they're gonna hit. Who is around Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: that number that we've talked about that is not going to get in, do you think? Shanie: Amcha Israel is around that. That is Ofer Winter's party with Fleur Hassan and Yosef Haddad that we mentioned earlier. That's a Likud-aligned party. that it's a right-wing liquid-aligned party. and they are hovering around the threshold. So if they make it in, by the way, that would change totally change things for Netanyahu. That would really help him. I still don't see a clear path for him. but you never know. And by the way, maybe he peels people off from the other parties. maybe he peels off some. Folks from a Vigor Lieberman's list or something. I don't know. There's there's some could be something there. so them, I don't think they're gonna get in, but you never know. And then we have the reservist party, which is hypothetically non-aligned. and they're still going to they're they are looking for some kind of unity government, the Miloim Nikim, and that's Yuaz Hendel, A. Not Wilf ended up on that slate as well by Eitan: wow. Shanie: by by way of merger and Zelija, an economist. So it's sort of an interesting slate. they're also hovering around. I see one poll has them at three percent, but you know, others have they they hover around. They sometimes make it in and sometimes don't, depending on the poll. They're somewhere between two and three percent, which means they could go either way. And if those two make it in, they could maybe throw some kind of lifelines in Nessen Yao, but I'm still not really seeing the numbers add up for him. Eitan: Hmm. and then, you know, there was a someone had asked, actually, do I have them? Okay, no, I don't have this question, but someone did ask about the Haredi voters, about some of the Haredi blocks, specifically newer ones. There was one that had an idea that was pushing like, okay, like we're not all gonna serve, but it's not the worst thing if some of us serve. There was one like we had talked about on this podcast where we had a a woman on one of the s the Haredi slates. Are any of those like surprise? willing to play ball Haredi groups are they potentially gonna get in or is it kind of like you know like thanks for playing, ne see ya next time. You know, we loved what you had, but we want to see your next stuff. Shanie: It's it's a thanks for playing. They don't even really make it on to the polls, if I'm being honest. I haven't even seen Eitan: Mm. Yeah. Shanie: them listed in polling for the most part. I I don't see them listed anywhere. so no, they're like really nowhere near making it in. like they're below one percent of the public. and you need 3.25% of the votes. but it's good that they exist. I like that they exist. you need to grow a brand, you know, maybe they can like build up this momentum and reputation, and maybe they'll be a force in a future election. I don't know. I'm I'm very happy to see it that it exists, even though ultimately I don't necessarily align with them on most things. I like that there is a growing alternative to the dominant ra rabbinic rabbinic dominated Hurri parties. Eitan: Let's say there's a future, you know, like let's the hypothetical on here is that like you know opposition wins and then it's a gaudy Isencott. anti not anti-haredi, but like not willing to let the Haredium continue not to serve or not to participate in the Israeli society like the way that they have been going. Let's say that there's a reality here where over the next couple of years the haredium start to serve and they start to like, you know, get pushed into into society. Do you see a future where the their voting blocks become more like that that boat I don't remember the name of that voting block, but like that voting block becomes more like that group that was more willing to play ball? Or do you see them kind of doubling down and fighting against the against the idea that they have to serve and participate a little bit more Shanie: I I think generally speaking, the people who are building this alternative recognize the problems in within Khariti society and they are trying to find amenable solutions, compromising solutions. And so I think one of the things most of those people probably agree with is that boy that those that kids should get a proper education. which to me is the foundation of making this change. So they don't think that everybody should stud that like nobody should study and everybody should go to the military, but they probably recognize that. They recognize that a percentage should go to the military, and they recognize that the education system is really broken on the huge problem. And they also most likely believe that more a higher percentage of their their population should should get jobs. So overall, they agree, like they've diagnosed the problem correctly. I think they're gonna come up with different solutions that are much more compromising, but they still at least can identify that there's a problem here. And to me, that's the main barrier. the issue with the bigger Koreadi parties is they're like, they're no problem. You, the Israeli society's the problem for being so secular. We are not the problem. Whereas these are people who can say, actually, like our community is also part of the problem, and we need to be part of the solution. Even if we don't think that all 80,000 eligible Kharedi men should serve, maybe we believe that a quarter of them should serve. And if a quarter of them serve, you've actually solved the draft crisis, basically. Like you only really need a quarter of them to serve. To meet the needs the IDF is saying that they have. So if you can do that, that's a huge step. That is some version of a compromise. Again, in theory, there shouldn't be exception. the fact that a Tel Aviv leftist goes to prison for something that every ashiva on Israel is doing is a problem. And there are like there's gonna be a need to compromise just because of the political nature of this issue. and I think that they recognize that, even though sometimes I hear their talking points and I'm like, my God. but but again, like the bar is low. And this is progress. And I don't believe, I don't believe it's like black and white. I think that any progress is good. I believe in incrementalism. So the fact that anything exists that's an alternative to these people, to these crazy rabbis, I'm thrilled. Eitan: You see that d what is the name of that party? What is like do you see Shanie: one is called the Haridi public. It's it's Multi Lightner's party. Is that it? Multi lightning. Eitan: Okay, so let's just do you see a future where the Haredi society in general leans more towards that or do you see opposite way where they fight it more? Shanie: it's hard to pinpoint a community that's growing so rapidly. but I Eitan: Yeah. That's true. Shanie: I mean, I would say you still have, you know, almost half of the population falls into these categories of like identifying as Israeli Haredi or modern Haredi of like 40, 45% of the population that falls into those categories. I would say those are people who can s who understand the issue. Does it mean they all want to draft? No. and by the way. Even if they believe in theory you should draft, doesn't mean that am I gonna send my kids to draft? Am I gonna be the one who goes willingly to serve? Like, no. Why would I do that? I don't have to. No one's making me. Like, what what for what purpose would I now do this? so I do think you have like a significant number, again, not more than half, but you have a significant, substantial number of the percentage of population that understands the problem and wants to be part of some kind of compromising solution in theory. I think the Haredi community is gonna segment itself more and more over the years. The pop the population is growing. Eitan: Interesting. Shanie: I think they are going to continue to segment and you're gonna see a divide where you have some who are, not necessarily going to the army over time, maybe, but in the short term, saying we're not, we're not part of this because we recognize this country is gonna break down as a result, and the like more extremists who are gonna dig their heels into the ground. the more that we as people who see the problem can separate out the different segments of the Haredi population, the better off we all are, I think. And so trying to, you know, hype up this Haredi public party, which ultimately is like not going to get them many votes. but like the stronger, the the stronger a political tool that can be, the better. I mean, you do have some people trying to make a change, but again, it's like the they see themselves as a monolith, we see them them as them as a monolith. Like this feeds into the problem. Eitan: Yeah. I listen, the biggest issue that they're facing is people finding about the New York Times podcast and putting everyone in Charim. Shanie: Ha ha ha. Eitan: You know, if you put everyone in Charim, then Chayrim becomes its own little city. That's actually not a bad that is not a bad, nice little Jewish saying that everyone can take for you use it on your own. If you put everyone into Chayram, then Charim becomes its own little city. All right. Shanie: Clarum is exile. Eitan: Hanna Lux, explain election implications like I'm five. Ooh. Okay. Shanie: my God. I okay. Bibi Netanyahu, if he forms a government, it will look very much like the current government that we have. And so you won't see a really big change. You'll continue to have the appeasement of the ultra-orthodox. You might see an advancement of judicial reform and overhaul. You'll see much of what we have seen in the past. Eitan: This is how you talk to children in Aaron Sorkin movies. Okay? This is not I need to dumb down. Shanie: I I don't know how to do that. I'm not I'm not good with kids. I don't know how to talk to them. I'm like, do you want to hear about the occupation? Eitan: He Shanie: no, I'm not, I'm not, I'm not sure what what educators do. But you know what? Like real educators will be able to translate my analysis. option one is more of the same, if that helps. I think that was short enough. Short and Eitan: Okay. Yeah. Shanie: sweet. and then op and then option two, if you have a coalition. I think that on the peace and security front, you'll see you will not see as much legalization of settlement outposts. I think you will see very limited settl settlement growth. I think you will see a crackdown on settler violence, but you will not see some kind of disengagement from the West Bank or Gaza. In Gaza, you'll see playing ball as much as possible with the Board of Peace and trying to work with to with them with their plan. Eitan: I would pay I would pay money to watch you say this to a five-year-old. I actually, this is the hilarious segment idea. Is Shanille trying to relate to children? Shanie can't even relate to mid-20-year-olds because of their music choices. This is so funny. I'm like, how are you talking to a to a five-year-old? You're like, okay, to a five-year-old. Okay. Well, the West Bank settled the violence was gonna is gonna go down for sure. In my mind, I'm thinking like Well, Israel's one big bowl of Cheerios, right? And sometimes someone wants honey nut, and sometimes, you know, everyone we've been everyone's been eating regular flavored Cheerios for 20 years. And some people are starting to get annoyed at that. And some people look at the fact that we've poured the Cheerios into the rice Krispie box. And no People maybe they don't want the Cheerios in the Rice Krispie box. Maybe they want honeynut Cheerios. Maybe they just want Rice Krispies alone and to be in their own little boxes, right? So this whole election is a conversation about cereal preferences and what to do when you want to mash the cereal together into one beautiful bowl. Shanie: Did you practice that? That wasn't bad. No, I understand less about Israel now that I heard that. That came. Eitan: You're like Shanie: I am sorry that I don't know how to answer this question of I'm gonna, I'm, I'm gonna plead the fifth. Eitan: To the five year olds. All right. Next up, Steven Fram. How long will it take to get election results? Shanie: election pure results will just be a few days, but don't forget we need to then give them like four to six weeks is how long they have to build a coalition. So it might be some kind of landsliver where it's super obvious that one group has won, but more likely it's not that obvious. so it'll really be six weeks for us to know what's happening. Eitan: When it comes to walk me through this process a little bit. election happens, everyone, we see how many seats everyone has. What is the process then about solidifying and congealing the your government? Let's say you're the person that's in charge, your your your party and your coalition that you think it's gonna be has, you you've won the the the majority. How do you physically go about signing everyone up you are officially part of this thing. And do people drop and do parties drop out during this time? is there gonna be a worry about maybe Isencott gets enough, breaks the threshold, and then one party's like, actually, now that we know that you really need us, we're not gonna you know go with your plan unless XYZ thing happens. Shanie: that's exactly what happens. so after Herzog, the president, meets with every head of party, he decides after that week who he's going to hand the mandate to, that's what they call it, where he might say to Gotti Eisencott or Netanyahu, here you go, go and try to form a government. And it's not necessarily the guy who won the most seats, right? It could it usually is, but it it could be the person who's just most likely to build a coalition, which makes sense. and so then he has to go and Essentially bribe all of these other party leaders to work with him. I say bribe because I actually think coalition negotiations are really icky. it's how we end up with all of these dumb ministries where Eitan: Yes. Shanie: you're like, all right, you can be a minister and you can be a minister and you could be a minister, because otherwise they're like, screw you, I'm not gonna recommend you and I'm not gonna sit with you and build a coalition unless you give me what I want, which could be legislation, it could be minister being a minister, it could be money for yeshivas. It could be money for my other random thing that I care about. it could be anything. and Eitan: I wanna be the secretary of Umpum. Who is the secretary of Umpum? Shanie: I you always ask me this. no, but truly there's like all these, there's a lot of dumb things that have been created because of this process. and so that's what happens. They have to like sit there and negotiate. and this is where Netanyahu really becomes like really good. Like, this is the best part for him, because he's really convincing and he's really willing to kind of like throw any sort of value or campaign promise out the window in order to build a coalition, which is a huge asset when you're doing something like this. And I don't Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: know Gotti Isencott is as willing to go back on his campaign pro promises because he's not a politician in that way. So we'll see. Eitan: Interesting. next then sorry, then let's say the election happens and we don't get a clear winner and everything, we go back into you know another election happens. How long what is that process like? Like how long after the first election would the second election possibly be? Shanie: about three months after after you call for them. I think it's three months. Eitan: next question here are it is Rory, acceptable level for non-Israelis to engage in discourse about the election? Now I asked the same question over to Sammy. as Americans, you can't you can't vote. you can't vote, right? You're not you can Shanie: I can vote, but Americans can't vote. I'm an Israeli citizen. Eitan: You're an Israeli citizen. I am not an Israeli citizen, I cannot vote. This brings up the big question of here what is the level of engagement and how much should we be involved or non voting Shanie: Maxima, Maxima. I know Sammy. Eitan: Maximum engagement. Shanie: I know Sammy was probably way like more polite about this, but I just feel like I don't care. we're first of all, it depends who the question is for, but Jews are the diaspora. Like that we are this is the nation state of the Jewish people, this is the homeland of the Jewish people. We have so much skin in the game. Like, let's use our voice, like, talk about it. By the way, when elections are in America, Israelis Don't shut the hell up. All they do is call me and tell me all their freaking opinions and what they think about who I voted for and who I should vote there. I'm sure you have the same thing. Okay. All day they're yelling about it. They're getting involved. You well, yeah. Didn't do not shut the hell up to. Eitan: They didn't shut up about Mam Dani. Like they didn't shut up about it. They don't shut up about Trump. They don't shut up about Mam Dani. They shut they don't shut up about our stuff. So you don't get the sh Yeah. Yeah. Shanie: Yeah. Yeah, which is fine. it's a free country that we both s technically still live in. So I'm fine with that. But yes, I have no problem with Jews speaking out and speaking up, especially if you're people who like are generally really vocal about things happening in Israel, and you're deeply impacted by what happens in Israel. Yeah, like freaking talk about it. I I mean, you know, I'm doing it all the time, but I'm pushing people to do it all the time because I think it's important. I think that like we have values and there are clear Parties and leaders who align with those values and ones that spit on those values. And why shouldn't we speak about that? and and yeah, though I like have and and by the way, on the right, nobody cares. nobody is doing this dance on the far right. Sheldon Adelson bought a newspaper in Israel, which is the most disseminated, widely read newspaper in Israel, and it's free because he bought it to shape the discourse in Israel. Okay. And Eitan: What Shanie: In a Eitan: yeah. Shanie: someone on the left would never do that. a liberal Zionist in America would be like, my God, God forbid I intervene in Israeli politics. Not to say that that's what I wouldn't do that, but like my point is on the right, this has been happening like so actively and effectively and intensely. Whereas like the vast I the re not to assume that everyone listening is is on the left in Israel, but like just by demographics, American Jews if you took a vote of American Jews, Netanyahu would get three mandates and wouldn't pass the threshold, right? maybe like five maybe like six seats, okay, in the Knesset. Eitan: Yeah. Yeah. Shanie: So like this is where we know we know who our audience is. yeah, like we should we should make our values clear. And I also think, again, it's not like Israel should like say, What do American Jews think and then vote based on that? Of course not. but if the US Israel relationship matters, if the Israel diaspora relationship matters, by the way, they both should, and I believe they're both national security issues for Israel. then you should it should be part of your your calculation when you're when you're making a vote. It should be one of the things that people think about. It doesn't have to be the top voting issue. Just like a lot of things are on my list of issues and they're not my number one. Eitan: Yeah. I I super agree with all that. You I I brought this up with Sammy and I think that the role of Americans for maybe a couple of years after October seventh, I I firmly I still believe in a lot of ways that the American Jewish voice was way too much, was way too taking over the conversation. A at time just overwhelming. And in ways that I thought that it was it it shouldn't have been that we shouldn't maybe before the past couple of months or before the the midterm primaries that happened here. I do think that American Jews had a little bit less of a leg to stand on when it came to talking all overly about this stuff. That being said, when the Israeli election started to influence American elections, it started to become a problem for us here, I think it does open up the path to at least start to talk about this stuff in a way without feeling like we don't have an ability to weigh in on this. Obviously my thought here, my thoughts on this doesn't matter as much as someone that's voting in Israel, but it doesn't mean that, you know, If you are an American Jew who has some level of engagement or some connection to the country, that you don't get to speak up on this because you a thousand percent get to. Just like they are speak on our elections, we get speak up on their elections. is there anything else Shanie: Yeah, more or less. Eitan: that we are kind of like missing from this as we go into the election tomorrow? Shanie: I think I got all of your questions, but I will say I did something for you that I would never do for anyone else, which is place a bet against Bibi Netanyahu, which is something I swore Eitan: Ooh, Shanie: I would never do. Eitan: you know what? I will place a bet also, not against BB, but for Gotti. Because that's what we're gonna be positive here. Right now on Cal She, Gotti Shanie: I love that. Eitan: is at 55% chance of of winning the election. So even that and then I what's it BB is in the twenties there. I'm curious, I'm honestly curious how the prediction markets go after the first election. If people start to I I'll end on this. The American community society is about to really get a front row seat to how fucked up this process is in the funniest way possible. It's gonna be one of those embarrassing, you know, when you go to a wedding and your family, who's maybe totally fine 364 days of the year, everyone decides to bring their baggage to the wedding. Everyone decides that. Now is the time to voice their gripe. And it's the one time that all of your friends Shanie: Totally. Eitan: are there and all your coworkers are there. And you're like, please don't see my family. Please, I know my family is deep downside. Please don't show, don't show, don't show. And then you get there and then everything's going good. And then all of a sudden your aunt goes, like, and by the way, I don't think Ethiopians should vote. And you're like, God damn it. that is essentially what America is about to see. And Jews, Israelis, you're about to spend a couple of weeks just going like this. A couple just yeah. it's gonna be beautiful. Wait till Hassan Piker Shanie: I am not ready for this. I'm not ready for this. my god. Eitan: has to figure out how the intricacies of Shoss versus UTJ went. Like, imagine what is gonna happen when I was gonna say the H3 podcast, but not them anymore. Imagine what is gonna happen when all of a sudden you have Hannah Einbeiner going out there trying to figure out the differences, you know, in in mandates. Shanie: my God, I don't need that in my life. Eitan: With that Shaenee, thank you so much for coming on. the next one, I mean I'll see you after the election for a brand Shanie: Yeah, see you then. Eitan: new 120 angry seats. Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: which is like we said, is is gonna be we'll be with you through all 15 elections that are gonna be happening. We will be there for all of them. Shanie: Mm-hmm. We're gonna grow old with this with this series. Eitan: She do you have a podcast, a brand new podcast that you maybe want to pitch and talk about? Shanie: I do it's called disputed territory. one of the reasons I launched the podcast, I feel like we're all in the family here, so I can say it, is because I feel like most of the like pro-Israel, Israel connected podcasts, not this one, but in general, that are like centered on Israel are on the right and they're like pretty right Eitan: Mm-hmm. Shanie: wing voices. And that's okay. Like I love that for them. That should exist and that should flourish. But I didn't feel like there were enough building out like the center liberal and progressive. spaces in the pro-Israel committed to Israel camp. And so I wanted to do that. And so I bring on Israelis and Palestinians and Americans and Jews and non-Jews and everybody else to like talk about Israel and really dig into like it's not breaking news. It's not meant to address mostly current events, although we are going to have a couple that do around elections. But in general it's really meant to think about like bigger conversations, the conflict about the conflict, as we like to say. So yeah, disputed territory. Get it everywhere you get your podcast. Is that what I'm supposed to say? Yeah. Something like that. Eitan: I and and not only is that what you're supposed to say, you said it so well, so confident. Yeah, Ted Mazik was on an Shanie: Thank you. I'm practicing. Eitan: episode, Alana Zajczyk was on an episode. I saw wait, there was another one that you released soon that I agree. Yes. Yes. Shanie: Mm-hmm. Ihab Hassan, Michael Koplau. and I have some more coming out soon. There it's coming Eitan: Sure. Shanie: out every single week, so just check it out. Eitan: Check that out. And then also, I will say a little bit of another plug is that the Israel Policy Forum has the Israel tracker that I've been finding myself that's Shanie: One twenty project elections tracker, yeah. Eitan: what it is 120 Project Elections Tracker. Make sure to go check that out if you're looking for up-to-date info on the elections. And with that, I will be in Philadelphia November 5th for Jewish or anti-Semitic. Philadelphia again for just regular stand-up, December 23rd. And on December 10th. I will be headlining DC improv. Make sure to go out there and see me live. Come say hi. I'll sign something for you or whatever. And also, as we end the podcast, I gotta talk about we have a Patreon. help us fight for the Jew York Times, baby. Help support independent Jewish journalism and Jewish thought. Like Shanice said, there is a lot of content on the hard right. Not the hard right, the lot of content on the right. There's a lot of content. On the hard left, there's not a lot of content that is moderate, main moderate views, nuanced views on Israel that whether we are willing to admit it or not, reflect how most people feel. And the only way to fight against Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: the loudmouths on both sides is to you know give to my Patreon. And also everyone else's Patreons. If you have creators out there who who you like are looking for who who are we're all looking for money, and if you have Group or people that you politically align with, go send them a couple bucks. And if you like this podcast, Shanie: Mm. Not me. I have a real job. Eitan: don't give it to Chenille. Take your money and throw it into the ocean. Nowhere near Shanie: Ha ha ha Eitan: here. You rip it up and you throw it in the ocean and you throw it in the seas. Shanie: Mm. Eitan: but you know, if you want to give to this podcast, the Patreon is up there to donate to. And with that, we'll see you guys next week in honor of Rich Barstool.