Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Celebrity Estate Showdowns: Recent Celebrity Wealth Transfer Litigation Battles Unraveled
Transcript
- 0:02And welcome to Celebrity Estate Showdown's recent
- 0:05Celebrity Wealth Transfer litigation battles
- 0:06unraveled. We're thrilled to have you join us
- 0:08today. Before we begin, I'd like to take a moment
- 0:10to introduce Nancy Sanborn and Brian Joy of the
- 0:13Sanborn team. Nancy and Brian have been the official
- 0:15sponsor of this section since 2006. Nancy and
- 0:18Brian, please feel free to say hello. Thank you,
- 0:20Teal. Hi, everyone. Being based in Los Angeles,
- 0:23we've had the opportunity to represent many public
- 0:26figures and celebrities over the years. One thing
- 0:30that always stands out is that once we begin,
- 0:33the celebrity fades away and the responsibility
- 0:36remains the same. Whether our client is a living
- 0:41person or it's an estate, famous or not, our
- 0:44focus is always the same. Protect the asset,
- 0:48honor the process, and guide the transaction
- 0:50with clarity and care. That perspective is especially
- 0:55important when we look at these celebrity estate
- 0:57disputes because behind every headline is a situation
- 1:01that is very similar to what all families face
- 1:04every day. Thank you all and we look forward
- 1:08to the meeting and please know that your referrals
- 1:10are always appreciated and we look forward to
- 1:13working with you in 2026. Thanks Nancy and Brian.
- 1:18In addition to the San Morin team, the Trust
- 1:20and Estate section is also sponsored by Bond
- 1:22Services of California, Liberty Mutual Charity,
- 1:25California Title Company, and Pickford Escrow
- 1:26Company. Now I'd like to turn things over to
- 1:29Laura Zolanekov to provide this month's legal
- 1:32updates. Thank you, Tia. Good afternoon, everybody.
- 1:36My name is Laura Zolnikoff, and I'm a partner
- 1:38at Velasco Law Group, which will soon be known
- 1:40as VZ Law. And today I'll briefly highlight two
- 1:44California appellate decisions that are particularly
- 1:47relevant for probate and trust litigation practitioners.
- 1:51Both of these decisions that I will speak about
- 1:53were published in late 2025. First, the estate
- 1:57of Bodmin. This case confirms that a probate
- 2:00court may deny the appointment of a nominated
- 2:03executor based on misconduct that occurs before
- 2:07formal appointment. In this case, even though
- 2:10the nominee was expressly named in the will,
- 2:13the court found that his post -death, but pre
- 2:16-appointment conduct, specifically the mismanagement
- 2:20of estate assets and interference with business
- 2:22operations, demonstrated his unfitness to service
- 2:26a fiduciary. The key takeaway is that courts
- 2:29may consider pre -appointment behavior under
- 2:32probate code sections 8402 and 8502, and testamentary
- 2:38preference will not override demonstrated fiduciary
- 2:41unfitness. This case reinforces the probate court's
- 2:45broad discretion to protect estates where misconduct
- 2:48is shown. The second case that I would like to
- 2:51highlight is Gamow v. Merrill. Here, the Court
- 2:54of Appeal held that a prevailing defendant in
- 2:57a financial elder abuse case may recover cost
- 3:01-approved fees under Code of Civil Procedure
- 3:03Section 2033 .420. Importantly, the Court found
- 3:09that such fees are not barred by the Elder Abuse
- 3:12Act's unilateral attorney fee provision, which
- 3:15only benefits prevailing plaintiffs. The court
- 3:19distinguished attorney's fees from cost -approved
- 3:22sanctions, explaining that the latter serve a
- 3:25separate purpose, promoting efficient litigation
- 3:28and discouraging unreasonable denials of requests
- 3:31for admissions. As a result, defendants who prevail
- 3:35a trial may still recover those fees when appropriate.
- 3:39In sum, Bodmin expands the scrutiny placed on
- 3:42nominated fiduciaries before appointment, and
- 3:46GAMO provides an important litigation tool for
- 3:48defendants facing elder abuse claims. Now I'll
- 3:51turn it over to Jordan Parr to introduce our
- 3:54esteemed speaker. Thanks, Laura. Now onto the
- 3:57program. Today's speaker is Vashi Zetshin. Bachie
- 4:00is a partner at Jeffer Mangels Butler and Mitchell
- 4:03LLP, and a State Bar of California certified
- 4:06specialist in estate planning probate and trust
- 4:09law. His practice centers on sophisticated trusts
- 4:12and estates litigation, including breach of fiduciary
- 4:15duty claims, surcharge and trustee removal actions,
- 4:20will and trust contests, creditors claims, conservatorship
- 4:23and guardianship matters, and elder abuse disputes.
- 4:26He represents a broad spectrum of clients, fiduciaries,
- 4:29individuals, and charitable organizations navigating
- 4:32high stakes and often emotionally charged matters
- 4:35with precision and clarity. In addition to litigation,
- 4:39Vachi's practice includes trust and probate administration,
- 4:42where he advises trustees, handles the probating
- 4:45of estates, and resolves disputes among fiduciaries
- 4:48and beneficiaries. Please welcome Vachi Zetshin.
- 4:53And thank you, Jordan. And thank you to the Beverly
- 4:55Hills Bar Association for having me. I'm very
- 4:58happy to be here today to present to our esteemed
- 5:03bar and trust in Estates. I know and work with
- 5:06many of you. We've got a great practice. So it's
- 5:08a pleasure to be presenting to you. The presentation
- 5:11today is on Celebrity Estate Showdowns. I'm going
- 5:15to put up the slideshow now and there is a question
- 5:18and answer feature at the bottom of the screen.
- 5:20If we do have time towards the end of the presentation,
- 5:22I'm happy to answer some questions. If not, once
- 5:25we're done, please feel free to reach out to
- 5:26me if we don't have time and I can discuss, answer
- 5:29any questions you might have, but hope you enjoy
- 5:32the presentation. Let me switch over to the share
- 5:34screen. Okay. So we're going to talk about three
- 5:47celebrity cases. Hi, Vachi. Yes. It looks like
- 5:50the screen is not being currently shared through
- 5:55Zoom. Let's try that again. How about now? I
- 6:01don't see it. And yes, we are live. Thank you
- 6:06so much. Great. Okay. During this presentation,
- 6:12we're going to discuss some recent estate disputes
- 6:15involving celebrities, which many of you may
- 6:18have heard of on the news, talk about the impact
- 6:20of these cases, the lessons to learn for different
- 6:23practitioners, not just attorneys, but also the
- 6:26various professionals that we work with, fiduciaries,
- 6:29accountants, experts. Again, insight about these
- 6:33cases to navigate our complex cases more effectively
- 6:36and to look how we can apply these case examples
- 6:40to our own practices to protect our clients and
- 6:43provide them a better service. So the three case
- 6:46examples that we're going to talk about today
- 6:49are Tony Bennett, Jimmy Buffett, and Rupert Murdoch.
- 6:55So let's start to start off with the Tony Bennett
- 6:58Trust. Tony Bennett, of course, everyone was
- 7:00familiar with Mr. Bennett. He was a legendary
- 7:03singer. He died recently a couple of years ago
- 7:07at age 96, lived a long, successful life, 20
- 7:11Grammys, millions of records sold, so very successful
- 7:14career. After his death, there was a trust dispute
- 7:18between Mr. Bennett's son, Danny, who was his
- 7:23longtime manager and trustee. and other members
- 7:27of the family, essentially regarding control
- 7:29over his estate and benefit, including his music
- 7:35catalog, his royalty rights, his name and likeness.
- 7:38And so this all was before the New York courts
- 7:41where Tony resided. So the dispute was primarily
- 7:49about Tony's two daughters. Joanna and Antonia
- 7:54filing suit against their half -brother Danny.
- 7:58Danny was the appointed trustee and the son,
- 8:00claiming that Danny was mismanaging Tony's trust
- 8:04in the state. The daughter's filing claimed the
- 8:08state was worth about $12 million based on the
- 8:11state tax filings and the 706 and so forth, but
- 8:14it should have been worth in excess of $100 million.
- 8:17So that right there is obviously a big difference.
- 8:20right off the bat, there's a critical misunderstanding
- 8:23of what the state should have been worth, which
- 8:25probably prompted the daughters to bring this
- 8:27lawsuit. And there were claims of mishandling
- 8:30of the intellectual property, self -dealing,
- 8:34misappropriation, claims of a breach of fiduciary
- 8:36duty, unjust enrichment by the son, seeking accounting
- 8:40by the son, and trying to remove Danny as trustee.
- 8:44Danny objected, claiming that he was just acting
- 8:46at his father's direction and that he received
- 8:49reasonable compensation and he wasn't doing anything
- 8:51wrong. So let's talk a little bit about what
- 8:56the trust provided. So Tony first executed his
- 8:58trust in 1994 and he amended it on a couple iterations,
- 9:04last amending it in 2016. If you look at the
- 9:08trust, it's pretty ordinary in that we're used
- 9:10to seeing trust disputes when one beneficiary
- 9:12ends up receiving a lot more, son gets everything,
- 9:15daughter gets very little, or vice versa. But
- 9:19here, if you look at the trust on paper, it was
- 9:23equal. It was pretty ordinary. So that in and
- 9:26of itself doesn't mean you're not going to have
- 9:28a dispute, as we'll talk about. There were other
- 9:30issues beyond just the plain language of the
- 9:33trust. But the state plan divided the state essentially
- 9:37equally amongst the four children, divided the
- 9:39personal property equally, $900 ,000 upfront
- 9:42to each child at death, equalization for any
- 9:46gifts made previously to children, and the intellectual
- 9:50property administered equally for Tony's children,
- 9:55and the residue divided equally. So again, an
- 9:58effort to treat everybody equally. So what was
- 10:04the issue here? The issue primarily was in terms
- 10:07of the accounting, the management of the trust.
- 10:11So complex, large states like this, when they're
- 10:15managed by particular family members, especially
- 10:18when you have these blended families, half siblings
- 10:21and so forth like you do here between Danny and
- 10:23the sisters, it created suspicions over is Danny
- 10:27managing the trust properly? And those suspicions
- 10:31made way for a lawsuit. And so what happens there
- 10:35when you have, we're often dealt with that situation
- 10:38where a client comes to us and says, I think
- 10:41my father's estate is $100 million, but my brother
- 10:44who's managing it says it's only 12. He must
- 10:47have stolen money or he must have done something
- 10:49nefarious. There's no other explanation other
- 10:51than that. And so what do you do? What do you
- 10:53do in that situation like that? You can file
- 10:55a lawsuit and make the material allegations that
- 10:58end up being wrong. Or you can ask for an accounting
- 11:00first to understand what's going on. And so in
- 11:04this case, there was a request for an accounting.
- 11:07And the beneficiaries have a right to an accounting.
- 11:09And so I often encourage my clients, don't just
- 11:14shoot in the dark. You have a right to an accounting.
- 11:17Get to accounting. Make the trustee tell you
- 11:20what's going on. And then you'll have a more
- 11:24informed position to say what's right and what's
- 11:26wrong. Maybe some of your concerns are not. are
- 11:29not actual issues, maybe some are, make the trustee
- 11:32account to you if you have that right to an accounting.
- 11:35So in California, many states have similar provisions
- 11:39as to who's entitled to an accounting and what
- 11:41the accounting needs to contain. In California,
- 11:46that's set forth in the probate code in section
- 11:4816060 and onwards. The precise statute that talks
- 11:55about the right to an accounting is probate code
- 11:57section 16062. And it says that the account the
- 12:01trustee shall account at least annually of a
- 12:03termination of a trust change of trustee and
- 12:06the accounting is entitled to each beneficiary
- 12:08to whom income or principle is required or authorized
- 12:11in the trustees discretion. Now that last sentence
- 12:13is important because trusts often time contain
- 12:17remainder beneficiaries can contingent remainder
- 12:19beneficiaries. So not anybody who's named in
- 12:21the trust can ask for an accounting. It's whoever's
- 12:24currently potentially entitled to income or principle.
- 12:29And I want to distinguish between revocable trusts
- 12:32and irrevocable trusts. Beneficiaries are not
- 12:36entitled to accountings of revocable trusts.
- 12:38The probate code's clear on that too. So the
- 12:41typical husband and wife, they're alive, they
- 12:43have a trust. Beneficiaries, the children don't
- 12:45get to demand that their parents account for
- 12:47their assets. It's a revocable trust. The parents
- 12:50can change their mind. They can terminate the
- 12:52trust. They can change the trust an infinite
- 12:54number of times. It's revocable. you don't get
- 12:58a right to an accounting. Here in this case,
- 13:01Mr. Benedict passed away. And after Mr. Benedict
- 13:03passed away, all these provisions in the trust
- 13:07vested. And so it was an irrevocable trust at
- 13:10that point. And so there were rights for the
- 13:13daughters who were entitled to an equal cut of
- 13:16the trust. So they were entitled to income and
- 13:18principal to demand an accounting. So we're in
- 13:22the latter situation, an irrevocable trust. And
- 13:26there's another issue which we'll talk about.
- 13:28It's the right to compel a de facto trustee to
- 13:30account. So another question is, if you have
- 13:33a right to an accounting, what's the scope of
- 13:36that accounting? Does it start at death? Can
- 13:38you go to a period prior to death? And so here,
- 13:43the daughters claim that Tony Bennett was diagnosed
- 13:46with Alzheimer's disease and lacked capacity
- 13:48as of 2018. So that was about five years prior
- 13:52to... Mr. Bennett's death. And they claim that
- 13:56Danny was acting as a trustee, the de facto trustee
- 13:59during that time. So the question is, do the
- 14:02daughters get an accounting from 2018 onwards?
- 14:06Or do they get an accounting from date of death
- 14:082023 onwards? And so this really hinges on judicial
- 14:15discretion of whether or not the court agrees
- 14:19on the claim of a de facto trustee. So oftentimes
- 14:22you'll see that allegation being made in the
- 14:25pleading, such as it was here. And then it's
- 14:29up to a court to decide whether the scope of
- 14:32the accounting should go back to any time prior
- 14:35to the death. What I recommend is to have two
- 14:39prayers for relief. ask for an accounting from
- 14:42date of death, which is an absolute right if
- 14:46the probate code entitles you to it, and then
- 14:48ask secondarily, ask for the pre -death accounting
- 14:52so that because if the court needs to have a
- 14:56trial on capacity to determine the de facto issue,
- 14:59you don't want to hold up the whole accounting
- 15:01in the interim, you can at least get the benefit
- 15:03of the post -death accounting while you're trying
- 15:05the pre -death issues. And proving in capacity,
- 15:10as many of you know, it's a complicating issue.
- 15:13It can often take years to get to trial on that
- 15:16issue. And so that's not going to be something
- 15:19that the court can quickly adjudicate, whereas
- 15:21post -death accounting is something the court
- 15:23can give you rather quickly. What is a de facto
- 15:28trustee? How is it proved? A de facto trustee
- 15:30is someone who's serving as trustee. prior to
- 15:34the time that they were authorized to serve as
- 15:35trustee because of the incapacity. So in this
- 15:41case, the sisters claim that Danny was doing
- 15:43all the work for Tony and Tony had no idea what
- 15:46was going on. So it's not that Tony was properly
- 15:48delegating duties and asking Danny to help, but
- 15:51Danny just took it upon himself to become the
- 15:54trustee because Tony lacked that ability. So
- 15:57that's the issue that needs to be proven to the
- 16:00court. What's the consequence of being a de facto
- 16:03trustee? Now, if the sisters can prove that Danny
- 16:07was in fact acting as trustee since 2018 because
- 16:10Tony lacked capacity, then the consequence of
- 16:15being a de facto trustee is that all the regular
- 16:19rules and regulations and duties of a trustee
- 16:22are imposed upon Danny. And so the court will
- 16:26treat him as if he was a trustee. So if he mismanaged
- 16:28the trust, he's responsible. If he misappropriated
- 16:31assets, he's responsible. And so Danny can't
- 16:34say at that point, well, I wasn't a trustee.
- 16:36You can't have it both ways. You were either
- 16:37acting or you weren't. And so once the court
- 16:40makes a determination that somebody's a de facto
- 16:43trustee, there's consequences. So for estate
- 16:48planning practitioners, litigators, how do you
- 16:50avoid this issue of the de facto trustee? I think
- 16:53the estate planning documents should be clear.
- 16:57about trustee succession and what the rules are
- 17:00as to who serves when, what's deemed to be incapacity,
- 17:04what's deemed to have a succession plan in there
- 17:07for the trustee, and to have perhaps a trust
- 17:11protector, to have somebody watching over the
- 17:14current trustee if you have. somebody like Tony
- 17:16Bennett, a famous celebrity, to have those right
- 17:18advisors in place so you don't end up with maybe
- 17:21this unknown situation where he might be at home
- 17:24lacking capacity and someone else is acting as
- 17:26trustee and no one knows about it. So you want
- 17:28to kind of plan, especially for older celebrities,
- 17:31older people with large trusts, you want to have
- 17:36that framework in place and the right advisors
- 17:39in place so that you're not having these convoluted
- 17:42arguments over whether someone was a de facto
- 17:43trustee or not. You want it to be clear who the
- 17:46trustee is and if that person can't act as trustee,
- 17:49you want it to be clear as to who's to receive
- 17:52notice and who's next in line. So this is an
- 17:58actual paragraph from the petition itself as
- 18:03filed with the court. A big issue in this case
- 18:06was the intellectual property, because Tony Bennett,
- 18:11being a singer, his music catalog, similar to
- 18:14other celebrity cases like Michael Jackson, I
- 18:16mean, their name and like this, their music catalog
- 18:19is the most valuable part of their estate and
- 18:22what's going to generate revenues moving forward
- 18:25post death, oftentimes becoming more valuable
- 18:27post death. So. The daughters were very unhappy
- 18:32about the handling of the intellectual property.
- 18:35And as you'll see here, they alleged that before
- 18:37Tony's death, so the de facto trustee issue,
- 18:40Danny orchestrated the sale of Tony's name and
- 18:43likeness and his royalty stream in his music
- 18:45catalog that was held in a limited partnership
- 18:48that the trust owned. And they claimed that Danny
- 18:52made millions of dollars in commissions from
- 18:54the sales and that it was a self -dealing transaction
- 18:57that he sold. these intellectual property rights
- 19:01for below face value and that he did it because
- 19:05Danny was in desperate need of money so they
- 19:07accused him of a fire sale orchestrating a below
- 19:10market fire sale because apparently Danny needed
- 19:13the money. So that was their allegation. The
- 19:19daughters claimed Danny improperly sold Ignite
- 19:21Music Fund and they claimed that Ignite had all
- 19:24the name and likeness rights and he shouldn't
- 19:25have done that. And this was reported in the
- 19:28news, Variety reported on March 19, 2024, that
- 19:31Tony's music catalogue had indeed been sold.
- 19:35And so there was some publicity on this issue
- 19:39at the time. And the daughters claimed that Danny
- 19:43needed the money, so he sold it for below fair
- 19:45market value. And the daughter said he could
- 19:47have made a better deal. was the claim and so
- 19:50that that brings us to so this is something that
- 19:53would be shown in the accounting by the way so
- 19:55if the daughter's claim well we think he sold
- 19:57the royalties and we think he did this and we
- 19:59think he did that you ask for an accounting,
- 20:01and the accounting would include the starting
- 20:04ledger of assets, ending ledger of assets, and
- 20:06sales in between. So if there's any change of
- 20:09any types of assets, if real property was sold,
- 20:11if intellectual rights were sold, and so an asset
- 20:15now is cash sitting in a bank account, that would
- 20:17all be contained in the accounting. And you can
- 20:19request all the substantiating materials as to
- 20:23like real property, the closing statements, any
- 20:27contracts to purchase, you can ask for all that
- 20:31documentation to understand the circumstances
- 20:33of the purchase, what was it sold for, what are
- 20:37the offers were there, and so forth. So that's
- 20:39all part of the accounting process where the
- 20:41beneficiaries can learn about the circumstances
- 20:44of this sale that they're questioning. So now
- 20:47that the beneficiaries have all the information,
- 20:50how do they prove their case? So here the daughters
- 20:54are claiming that these assets were sold Way
- 20:59less than what what it should have been sold
- 21:00for and so that's that's when the litigators
- 21:04get the experts involved And so there's there's
- 21:07valuation experts where? Where they this is what
- 21:12they do so they they They have their different
- 21:16valuation Methods to say what this property with
- 21:20intellectual property right right right was worth
- 21:23and so each side typically in litigation each
- 21:26side would get their own experts and so the sister's
- 21:30expert would say based on my analysis and explain
- 21:33that valuation method to the judge I think the
- 21:36music catalog was worth a hundred million dollars
- 21:38and that it was a and and and it shouldn't have
- 21:41been sold for 12 and then Danny's experts going
- 21:44to come in and talk about how well no it was
- 21:46only worth 12 and so you're going to end up with
- 21:48competing experts using different valuation methods
- 21:51and arguing why something's something was worth
- 21:54more or less. So a judge is gonna hear two experts.
- 22:00So what's the judge to do? And so typically judges
- 22:05can hear both experts and can make its decision
- 22:09on which expert they think was right and which
- 22:12one was wrong, which one was more credible. What
- 22:14some judges could also do is use what's called
- 22:17the evidence code 730, where the court itself
- 22:20can appoint an expert. and say, well, I'm going
- 22:23to try to shortcut the battle of the experts.
- 22:26And I'm going to ask the parties to agree on
- 22:28a court -appointed expert or the court's going
- 22:30to appoint its own expert to come at this from
- 22:32a more neutral standpoint. And then each party,
- 22:34of course, has its right to have a rebuttal expert
- 22:36if they think the 730 expert's wrong. But some
- 22:40judges view a 730 expert as more credible. for
- 22:46purpose of trying to get to the chase. Again,
- 22:49you have somebody saying 100 million, somebody
- 22:5112, you've got two experts with very different
- 22:54viewpoints. So some judges might use 730 to get
- 22:57to the chase there, but it is gonna, I mean,
- 23:00the parties are gonna have to rely on experts
- 23:02to try to argue over what these things are worth.
- 23:06And then the court's also gonna have to consider
- 23:09what discretion did the trustee have to sell
- 23:12the digital rights? You have to look to the trust
- 23:16itself as to did Danny have the right to sell
- 23:19these assets or not. Typically, trusts have very
- 23:23broad standards as to the trustees management
- 23:27of its assets, whether to sell assets, re diversify,
- 23:32reinvest, whether to hold non income producing
- 23:35assets or not. And so a trustee can come in,
- 23:40look at the portfolio and make a business judgment
- 23:42rule. on what the trustee thinks it's best, whether
- 23:45to make keep a particular asset or not. And so
- 23:49it may be that the trustee has the discretion
- 23:53to sell an asset, but then the question is going
- 23:55to be whether that was a prudent decision or
- 23:57not. Again, if the trustee sold $100 million
- 24:01music catalog for 12 million, the court could
- 24:03say you had the right to do that sale, but you
- 24:06sold it for an imprudent price. And so of course,
- 24:09experts would be used to try to prove those damages.
- 24:11If a court agrees that it should have been sold
- 24:14for somewhere near 100 million, but the trustee
- 24:17did a fire sale for his own self -serving benefit,
- 24:20the court can sanction the trustee that difference.
- 24:24But that raises the question of what's the standard
- 24:26of the court considering the prudence of a trustee's
- 24:29business transaction? And so there is a business
- 24:32judgment rule. The court does... provide a trustee
- 24:36slack. So the court's not going to play Monday
- 24:39morning quarterback and assess a transaction
- 24:42today based on what the trustee was dealing with
- 24:45five years ago. The classic example is real estate,
- 24:49of course. It goes up and down. So if the real
- 24:51estate market is a lot higher today than it was
- 24:54five years ago, the court's not going to say,
- 24:58well, it's... you breach your duties by selling
- 25:00the property five years ago. So there is a business
- 25:03judgment rule. The court is going to provide
- 25:05some leeway for a trustee to do its job in administering
- 25:09the trust at exercising its discretion. And ultimately,
- 25:14the court's purpose is to determine whether the
- 25:18ultimate decision was prudent or not within the
- 25:21trustee's business judgment rule. And of course,
- 25:23with valuations, many of you deal with valuations
- 25:27in different contexts. And so if a 706 provides
- 25:33a low valuation, that doesn't necessarily mean
- 25:36the trustee is breaching their duties. A 706
- 25:38valuation, depending on what it's for, could
- 25:41be lower or higher. A 706 valuation on a second
- 25:45spouse's death where you're trying to minimize
- 25:47estate taxes, well, you're going to try to have
- 25:50as low of a reasonable valuation as possible.
- 25:52Or if you're trying to get a step up in basis
- 25:54for this first spouse, you're going to try to
- 25:55have a high 706. even with estate tax purposes,
- 26:01you can't read too deep into it without understanding
- 26:03what the purpose was of the estate tax. And when
- 26:06you have a particular transaction, you are still
- 26:09going to have to get an expert to look at the
- 26:11sale of this specific intellectual property,
- 26:14what fair market value as opposed to tax planning.
- 26:21So the sisters also complained about Danny's
- 26:26compensation because that's another typical hot
- 26:32button issue. Because when you have a large,
- 26:36tens of millions of dollars, and you have a trustee
- 26:38serving, from the beneficiary's viewpoint, that's
- 26:43the trustee's being compensated. And oftentimes,
- 26:46that's a lot of money in compensation. If you
- 26:48have a $100 million trust, that could be hundreds
- 26:50of thousands of dollars of compensation per year.
- 26:53Of course, from the trustee standpoint, the trustee
- 26:55is going to say it's the worst job in the world
- 26:57being a trustee. I'm being blamed for everything
- 26:59and it's a ton of work. I'm not just being paid
- 27:02to sit at home and not do anything. I'm dealing
- 27:04with a lot of issues. So there's two sides to
- 27:06that compensation story. But oftentimes there's
- 27:10a fight over whether compensation was reasonable
- 27:12or not. So in this case, Danny claimed that he
- 27:17was receiving reasonable compensation. The sister
- 27:19said, no, you're paying yourself. hundreds of
- 27:22thousands of dollars to harm the trust. So you
- 27:24shouldn't receive any compensation. So what's
- 27:27the standard under the California probate code?
- 27:31The first thing the court is going to look at
- 27:34is what the trust instrument provides. So if
- 27:36the trust instrument says, sometimes the trust
- 27:39instrument says no compensation. So sometimes
- 27:42the trust instruments lays out precisely what
- 27:44the compensation shall be. trust instruments,
- 27:50mirror the probate code, and just provide for
- 27:52reasonable compensation. And so the question
- 27:54is, what is reasonable? And there's a statutory
- 27:58authority and case law that guides the courts
- 28:00as to what is reasonable, but it's largely within
- 28:02the court's discretion. But the court can look
- 28:05at a bunch of factors, including the size of
- 28:07the trust, the complexity of the administration,
- 28:10the sophistication of the trustee. And so there's
- 28:13a list of things, the success of the administration.
- 28:16So if the trustee made the trust a ton of money,
- 28:19that's a factor. So there's a bunch of factors
- 28:22the court can look at in determining whether
- 28:24compensation in a particular administration was
- 28:29reasonable or not. It's not one size fits all.
- 28:35Not every $100 million trusts are the same. Every
- 28:38trust is different. So the court's going to look
- 28:39at each particular example. to determine whether
- 28:42that particular compensation was reasonable or
- 28:44not. So in terms of the estate planners, you
- 28:49can try to get ahead of this issue by clarifying
- 28:52what the compensation is. And the two competing
- 28:57formulas are hourly versus commission. Hourly,
- 29:04it's how we bill as attorneys. The trustee or
- 29:07the fiduciary will just have to log their time.
- 29:09specify an hourly rate and charge accordingly,
- 29:14or the commission -based structure, which is
- 29:16how a lot of the corporate fiduciaries charge.
- 29:20So you could have a basis point, half a percent,
- 29:230 .7%, 1%, come up with a percentage as a commission
- 29:26-based structure. What I would propose is thinking
- 29:32about that in advance, especially since there's
- 29:35the possibility of litigation. When the state
- 29:40planners come to me and say the trustees want
- 29:42to figure out their compensation, what I advise
- 29:44is get a couple bids. Go to a couple of the well
- 29:50-known corporate trustees. Go to some well -known
- 29:52professional fiduciaries. See what they would
- 29:55charge. Get a bid from them. Put that in our
- 29:59file. The later if there's a dispute, There was
- 30:03a basis as to why we decided to charge what the
- 30:06trustee did. It wasn't just some arbitrary number
- 30:09that we came up with. And ultimately, it's going
- 30:11to be within the judge's discretion, though.
- 30:15You can charge what a corporate fiduciary would
- 30:18have charged, but the judge is still going to
- 30:19look at whether what you provided was of value
- 30:21to the trust or not. So what are the practical
- 30:25lessons that we could take away from Mr. Bennett's
- 30:30estate? Transparency amongst beneficiaries can
- 30:34go a long way. And so the probate code requires
- 30:39sharing information. And there are instances
- 30:42in which a beneficiary oversteps and asks for
- 30:44too much information or is being overly intrusive
- 30:47or overly annoying. And it could be obstructive
- 30:50to administration. So there's that aspect of
- 30:52it. And then there's the other aspect for the
- 30:56trustee. of what's the harm of being transparent.
- 30:59Sometimes it's better to get ahead of the issues,
- 31:02put everything out there, and not start that
- 31:07slippery slope of mistrust, which often leads
- 31:10to litigation. Get ahead of the issues of diminished
- 31:13capacity to confirm control and oversight. So
- 31:17don't end up with this de facto trustee lack
- 31:20of capacity who's administering the trust dilemma.
- 31:23If you've got affluent elderly Settlers, famous
- 31:28settlers. Think about control. Think about oversight.
- 31:31Think about advisors. Put that proper framework
- 31:33in place. Think about reasonable compensation.
- 31:37Get those bids like I said. Talk about it. Come
- 31:40up with a formula. Draft a memo to file so that
- 31:4410 years later if somebody's arguing over how
- 31:47you came up with compensation, you could show
- 31:50the court that there was a reasoned process.
- 31:54which is going to increase the probability that
- 31:56the court is going to find the compensation to
- 31:58be reasonable. Clarify estate plannings for digital
- 32:03rights royalties and name them like this. Oftentimes
- 32:05estate plans neglect particular language about
- 32:12intellectual property and then you end up with
- 32:14a situation such as this where the lion's share
- 32:16of the trust is the intellectual property, but
- 32:18you have more of a generic trust that didn't
- 32:20really contemplate who's going to manage the
- 32:22intellectual property like an intellectual property
- 32:25trust, a separate trust with a separate trustee
- 32:28and separate qualified advisors, for example.
- 32:30So we've got some estate planners who are terrific
- 32:34in that area that deal with those issues beyond
- 32:38just standard estate planning. So if you have
- 32:40a famous client nowadays with any kind of digital
- 32:44rights, royalties, intellect, IP, think about
- 32:48that in advance. Think about control and management
- 32:50of those rights in advance. And avoid competing
- 32:53disputes among competing children by appointing
- 32:56professionals. And so sometimes the perfect trustee
- 33:00still gets sued just because they don't get along
- 33:02with their brother or sister. And there's egos,
- 33:04there's entitlements. So sometimes getting family
- 33:07members involved leads to a fight, even if nothing's
- 33:12wrong, asks for an accounting when nothing's
- 33:15wrong, right? Just because there's distrust there.
- 33:16So sometimes it helps to put in a corporate trustee
- 33:20or fiduciary, even if it's as a co -trustee,
- 33:23sometimes getting that neutral voice in there
- 33:26may make it harder for a discontent beneficiary
- 33:29to sue. So moving on to Jimmy Buffett, another
- 33:37very famous singer, songwriter, businessman,
- 33:40entrepreneur, also died recently, about three
- 33:44years ago, two and a half years ago, with an
- 33:46estimated estate of $1 billion, primarily consisting
- 33:50of his Margaritaville empire that he started
- 33:54later on in his career. And he had trademarks
- 33:56and a music catalog as well, sold more than 20
- 33:59million records, member of the Rock and Roll
- 34:01Hall of Fame. And so in his case, there was a
- 34:05dispute amongst heirs regarding distribution
- 34:07of his assets and ongoing control of his Margarita
- 34:10brand and questions about succession planning
- 34:12and blended families. So what happened here specifically
- 34:17is that his surviving spouse, Jane, with whom
- 34:20he was married since 1977, so long -term marriage,
- 34:24so this wasn't a new subsequent wife or anything
- 34:26like that, long established wife, filed suit.
- 34:31in Los Angeles, and then it was dismissed and
- 34:33refiled in Florida on those same grounds. And
- 34:36so we'll talk a little bit more about this later,
- 34:39but significance of court venue can play a big
- 34:41role. States have different laws. And something
- 34:45for estate planners to think about and beneficiaries
- 34:49and spouses and all that to think about is the
- 34:51situs of administration. A few live in California.
- 34:54have a state planning attorney in California,
- 34:57prepare a trust in California, the default is
- 34:59going to be that California trust applies. Now
- 35:01sometimes you don't want California trust to
- 35:03apply for whatever reason, and we'll talk a little
- 35:05bit more about that later with Rupert Murdoch,
- 35:08but some states have more advantageous laws.
- 35:13California is, I would say, very rule -intensive,
- 35:18and so cases cost a lot of money here, cases
- 35:22last a long time here, and so some states may
- 35:25be advantageous depending or bad depending on
- 35:29your point of view, and so something to consider.
- 35:33But what could happen, even if you establish
- 35:34a trust in California, if the settlers move out
- 35:39of California, which is what happened here, and
- 35:43you're living in Florida for a while and your
- 35:46life's in Florida and you pass away, 10 years
- 35:49later, at that point, you may be far enough detached
- 35:53from California where the situs of the trust
- 35:55became Florida. So people also have to understand
- 35:58when you move, that could impact the situs of
- 36:01your trust as well, unless you specify specifically
- 36:03where you want the situs to be. So these large
- 36:07mega trusts, you should be talking to your estate
- 36:09planning lawyer and your professionals, your
- 36:11accountants about situs type concerns. It could
- 36:14have a major impact on trusts. So, the surviving
- 36:20spouse Jane filed suit against the accountant
- 36:23who is the trustee, long -time accountant claiming
- 36:25mismanagement, hostility, and excessive trustees
- 36:28fees. So, in our prior example, we talked about
- 36:30appointing a professional neutral trustee. So,
- 36:34in this case, there was a professional appointed
- 36:36accountant, but as we'll talk about, there was
- 36:40bad blood between the spouse and the fiduciary.
- 36:45So, professional fiduciaries If you're considering
- 36:49one, there's advantages to picking the accountant
- 36:53that knows the family inside and out, but then
- 36:56there's probably going to be history there. So
- 36:58the accountant's not a truly detached neutral.
- 37:01So in this case, the wife didn't like that accountant,
- 37:04they didn't get along. So the wife stopped removing
- 37:08the accountant in place of a third party neutral
- 37:12professional. So here's the exact language from
- 37:16the wife's petition, one of her paragraphs, where
- 37:19the wife says that the accountant's trustee is
- 37:21failing to perform his duties as a co -trustee,
- 37:25including not providing her information, leaving
- 37:27her in the dark as to the trust's affairs, disrespecting
- 37:32her, belittling her, and she claims charging
- 37:36an enormous fee, $1 .7 million in 2024 to essentially
- 37:42run the trust in a way that she views was bad
- 37:45towards her. So let's talk a little bit about
- 37:50what the trust was here to understand what was
- 37:53going on. So Mr. Buffett had created the trust
- 37:55in 1990. He had amended it a few times, including
- 37:58last in 2023, shortly before he died. And the
- 38:02trust included his interest in his Margaritaville
- 38:05brand, his investments, and it was hundreds of
- 38:09millions of dollars, if not more. The trust was
- 38:13primarily a marital trust. So the trust was set
- 38:17up to be for the benefit of his wife. And then
- 38:21after the wife passed away, after Jane passed
- 38:23away, it went to the three kids. which is a common
- 38:28estate plan that married couples do to set up
- 38:31marital trusts to take care of the surviving
- 38:32spouse after they die. And then again, to the
- 38:34three kids afterwards. So there was nothing weird
- 38:37about what happened after the wife passed away.
- 38:39It just went to wife and then three kids after
- 38:41her death. Pretty ordinary. The marital trusts.
- 38:46So marital trusts. Oftentimes, estate planners
- 38:49will talk to their clients and say, who do you
- 38:51want to make the decisions of the marital trust?
- 38:53If you make your surviving spouse to trust their
- 38:56own marital trust, they can effectively do whatever
- 39:00they want, subject to being sued by the kids
- 39:03as a remainder beneficiary. So do you want that
- 39:05extra check and balance? That's what Mr. Buffett
- 39:08did here. He established a marital trust, and
- 39:12he made it clear that it's for his wife's primary
- 39:14benefit. But he required that there at all times
- 39:21be an independent trustee that makes those discretionary
- 39:25decisions as to what the wife's going to get.
- 39:27So he was clear that he did not want the wife
- 39:30to decide for herself as to what she's going
- 39:32to get. But he had advisory language in there
- 39:37about the trustee to do what's worthwhile and
- 39:41in the best interest of the spouse. and to take
- 39:44into account, quote, primary regard for the best
- 39:47interests of the settler's wife rather than for
- 39:49the remainder or other successor interests. And
- 39:53he had language to prefer income producing assets.
- 39:56So, quote, unproductive property shall not be
- 39:58retained as part of the principle of the marital
- 40:01trust without the consent of the settler's wife.
- 40:03So Jimmy basically said, make this trust as productive
- 40:05as you can for my wife. Focus on my wife while
- 40:08she's alive. my kids will get one, she's gone,
- 40:11focus on my wife for now. So that part was good
- 40:15that he clarified that sometimes marital trusts
- 40:17are ambiguous and that can create a fight as
- 40:19well. So it's good to have some guiding language
- 40:22as to what the primary purpose is of the marital
- 40:24trust. So you've got this marital trust, you've
- 40:28got the wife who's upset, you've got this trust
- 40:30that she doesn't get along with. So what are,
- 40:33and the trust gives that trust that she doesn't
- 40:35get along with, discretion. So what are the limits
- 40:38to the trustees discretion? It's it's it's it's
- 40:43It's it's damned if you do damned if you don't
- 40:45in a lot of these situations where You don't
- 40:48get along where the wife doesn't get along with
- 40:50the trustee because the wife can ask for a million
- 40:53dollars a month and The trustee can say I'm gonna
- 40:55give you 500 ,000 a month the wife's upset the
- 41:00trust so it's it's it's You're always gonna have
- 41:04that tension So the standard is that what the
- 41:09court's going to look at is arbitrary versus
- 41:11reasonable decision -making. In these discretionary
- 41:14cases, what I advise the trustees not to do is
- 41:18to not say yes or no arbitrarily. Because trustees
- 41:23are people too, right? They have their own history
- 41:25and impressions as, you know, because, well,
- 41:28that beneficiary is this or that, they're a deadbeat,
- 41:31they're unappreciative, whatever. Whatever the
- 41:34situation is, You do not want a trustee to make
- 41:37an arbitrary decision because that's going to
- 41:40create exposure. What you want the trustee to
- 41:42do is show reasonable decision making within
- 41:45the trustee's discretion. And so what does best
- 41:50interest mean? So this trust said, accountant,
- 41:54you have discretion to make distributions in
- 41:57Jane's best interest. So you want to show, so
- 42:00Jane says, I want a million dollars as trustee.
- 42:03You don't want them to respond and say, no, that's
- 42:06outrageous. What you want them to say is, can
- 42:08you please provide me a budget itemizing why
- 42:11you're requesting what you're requesting with
- 42:13supporting documentations and invoices? And so
- 42:16that way, the trustee can make a reasoned decision.
- 42:19Oftentimes, corporate trustees have panels and
- 42:22boards that make these discretionary decisions
- 42:25to insulate. Any argument of arbitrariness? So
- 42:29you want you you want to you want to put the
- 42:32beneficiary on the spot to provide you that information
- 42:34after beneficiary provides you that statement
- 42:36and says well I want a million dollars because
- 42:37I want a Ferrari and I want this and I want that
- 42:40and I want a 200 foot yacht and it's Completely
- 42:43contrary to what her usual standard in life has
- 42:45been the trustee could say nope You're entitled
- 42:48to a nice car. You're entitled to a yacht, but
- 42:51it's not gonna be the ones you're requesting
- 42:53because that's not how you've lived your life
- 42:56the past 20 years. That's not how you lived your
- 42:58life with Jimmy. And so this is what I'm gonna
- 43:00give you instead. I'm exercising my discretion
- 43:03to deem this is in your best interest. That's
- 43:06much harder to refute at that point if you go
- 43:09to court than if the trustee just said no. So
- 43:12you wanna make sure to avoid arbitrary decision
- 43:14making. There's also of course a tension between
- 43:18current and remainder beneficiaries. Anytime
- 43:20you have a marital trust, The spouse wants as
- 43:23much money as possible while she's alive. The
- 43:26kids, especially if they're not her kids, want
- 43:28as much money preserved for after her death.
- 43:30And so the trustee owes duties to both the current
- 43:33and remainder beneficiaries. Now, if you have
- 43:36a language like you do here, where the settler
- 43:39directs the trustee to prioritize the surviving
- 43:42spouse, that insulates the trustee a little bit
- 43:44from front loading more money to the surviving
- 43:47spouse now. But the trustee still owes duties
- 43:49to all beneficiaries. So the trustee has to show
- 43:52that he or she is reasonably exercising her discretion
- 43:56to not only take care of the marital trust spouse,
- 43:59but to also preserve money on the back end. So
- 44:02there's principal growth and you're not diminishing
- 44:09the remainder interest for the remainder beneficiaries.
- 44:12And so that of course raises issues of asset
- 44:14allocation. Are you buying assets that prioritize
- 44:17income or are you buying assets that prioritize
- 44:20principal growth? And again, the court's first
- 44:24gonna look to what the trust says. In this case,
- 44:26the trust said prioritize income growth. And
- 44:29so again, that gives the trustee direction on
- 44:32what types of assets to purchase. So the wife
- 44:39here claimed lack of transparency. So like our
- 44:43prior example, she said that the trustee is doing
- 44:46stuff. I have no idea what the trustee is doing.
- 44:48I'm asking questions. I'm not getting good answers
- 44:50to my questions. I don't think the trustee is
- 44:53properly investing. The trustee is not really
- 44:55explaining the investments to me. I think the
- 45:00trust is worth $275 million, but it's only producing
- 45:03$2 million in net income. That's a bad return
- 45:06for a trust that's worth that much. And the trustee
- 45:10responded, you're wrong. Your assessments are
- 45:14incorrect. You have to create adjustments to
- 45:16your life and to your expenses because you're
- 45:21wrong as to what you think the trust should generate.
- 45:26The wife's a beneficiary, she can request accountings,
- 45:29and she can look at what the trustee is investing
- 45:31in, and she can challenge the trustee's decisions.
- 45:35And the court within the business judgment rule
- 45:37is going to give the trustee some discretion
- 45:39if what the trustee is doing makes sense. Now,
- 45:42if they're entirely unreasonable investments,
- 45:47like $100 million sitting in a non -interest
- 45:49-bearing account, then the court's going to critique
- 45:52that. So there's going to be some tension over
- 45:55what the trustee is doing. And of course, the
- 45:59wife was challenging the trustees fee saying,
- 46:01I don't think you're doing a good job, but yet
- 46:03you're paying yourself all this money. The trustee
- 46:07claimed that this is what Jimmy wanted. He wanted
- 46:11me to manage your assets. He wanted me to make
- 46:14these decisions for you. And you're just angry
- 46:15I'm in charge and you don't like the way Jimmy
- 46:17structured the trust. But that's not my problem.
- 46:20I'm just doing what the trust says. So the issue
- 46:22was really about control. The wife wasn't very
- 46:24thrilled that you have this accountant she doesn't
- 46:26like in the way that's deciding what she gets.
- 46:31The wife requested removal of the trustee, with
- 46:35the goal there being, I think, so she made a
- 46:38calculated decision that if I get rid of Maz
- 46:40interred accountant, I think I'm going to get
- 46:42along with the new trustee better. And there's
- 46:45a higher chance that the new trustee is going
- 46:47to not give me a hard time or go along with my
- 46:52discretionary requests. And so under Florida
- 46:55law, removal is possible where it serves the
- 46:59best interest of the trust or where there's unfitness,
- 47:02unwillingness, hostility amongst the trustee,
- 47:04lack of cooperation amongst the co -trustees.
- 47:08California law, similar statute. Section 15 -642
- 47:12lays the grounds for removal. So ground for removal
- 47:15for breach of trust, or for trustees unfit to
- 47:18serve, hostility or lack of cooperation, or excessive
- 47:23compensation. And under California law, a trustee
- 47:26could be suspended at any time pending removal.
- 47:28So court has wide discretion to suspend pending
- 47:31removal. Similar, here's another statute, Nevada,
- 47:35similar standard. So a lot of states have the
- 47:37same removal provisions. So the wife was seeking
- 47:42removing Mosenter. So Mosenter in turn sought
- 47:45to decant the trust. So he filed, he said, you
- 47:48know what, Jane, you're at this point, you've
- 47:51got an ax to grind with me. And then Jane also
- 47:56had a power of appointment so she could have
- 47:59reportioned amongst her children who received
- 48:02what after her death. So Mosenter was afraid
- 48:05that Jane's gonna try to weaponize the trust
- 48:06to get her children to be on her side. to get
- 48:09rid of him. And so he sought the decant to take
- 48:12the wife out as trustee and to strip her of her
- 48:14power of appointment. And so that was kind of
- 48:16his responsive play in response to her trying
- 48:22to get rid of him and suing him for breach of
- 48:25duty. that case is still pending. So what is
- 48:30decanting? Decanting we'll talk about in a little
- 48:33bit in relation to the Rupert Murdoch case, but
- 48:37it's available in different jurisdictions to
- 48:39allow you to essentially, just like it sounds
- 48:42decanting wine, it allows you to pour one trust
- 48:44into another trust, effectively changing some
- 48:47of the provisions of the trust, such as who the
- 48:49trustee is and the terms upon which a beneficiary
- 48:52can receive. And every state, every jurisdiction
- 48:54is different. Some states are much more limited
- 49:01in terms of what you can do with decanting, and
- 49:03some states are very flexible with decanting,
- 49:05and so we'll talk about that in a little bit.
- 49:08So what happened here, you've got all these claims,
- 49:11the court ordered mediation. We'll talk about
- 49:13mediations a little bit, but oftentimes what
- 49:15happens in these sticky cases, the court asks
- 49:17you to go mediate. So Jimmy Buffett practical
- 49:20lessons. Consider tensions with surviving spouses
- 49:24and use of discretionary trust. Spouses are not
- 49:28going to be happy or putting a middleman in the
- 49:30way to decide what they get. So think about that
- 49:32dynamic and plan accordingly. Pick the right
- 49:35trustee. If it's someone that the beneficiaries
- 49:40get along with, of course, do you want them to
- 49:42be qualified and you want them to be firm and
- 49:44do their job properly? But if it's a trustee
- 49:47where there's some tension there or bad blood,
- 49:49there's going to be potential problems. Have
- 49:51a contingency plan. Talk about who you want to
- 49:53be the second or third trustee just in case.
- 49:56Get ahead of the issue of trustee transparency
- 49:59like we talked about as trustee. Maybe share
- 50:02information to avoid claims that you're hiding
- 50:04something or doing something wrong. Document
- 50:07due diligence and discretionary decisions. So
- 50:11get ahead of that argument that you're being
- 50:13arbitrary. Show that you're exercising discretion
- 50:18reasonably. that you're not being arbitrary.
- 50:21And then use proper advisors to determine allocation
- 50:23of assets among income producing and prudent
- 50:26investing so that you're not... dealing with
- 50:30arguments over the tension between remainder
- 50:34beneficiaries and current income beneficiaries.
- 50:37So if you have advisors, the proper advisors,
- 50:39wealth managers, and so forth, telling you how
- 50:42to prudently invest as a trustee, you're insulating
- 50:44yourself from, again, arbitrary arguments and
- 50:47breach of duty type arguments. So our third case
- 50:53example, Rupert Murdoch. This was the inspiration
- 50:57for the HBO show Succession. And so Rupert Murdoch,
- 51:0294 years old, still alive. He's known for owning
- 51:08Fox or a large share of Fox. It is his involvement
- 51:12in Fox News. And so this case was about trustee
- 51:15succession. and Mr. Murdoch's ability to try
- 51:20to direct who's going to control his empire of
- 51:23his irrevocable trust amongst his children and
- 51:27how that all played out. So this case was pending
- 51:33in Nevada. The reason why it was in Nevada was
- 51:37because Nevada has, amongst the many reasons,
- 51:41Nevada is, I think, more of a trusty, friendly
- 51:44state. more of a settler friendly state than
- 51:47California is or some other states are. And so
- 51:50Rupert Murdoch kind of wanted Nevada to be the
- 51:52playing field. He felt that gave him the best
- 51:53chance. But Nevada allows sealed trust records.
- 51:58So in California, it's a very, it's a very, um,
- 52:03onerous process to try to seal court documents.
- 52:05And it requires filing a motion every single
- 52:07time you want to try to seal something. Nevada
- 52:09has a more robust sealing procedure where, look,
- 52:12I mean, like, like even the case title was it.
- 52:14the matter of the Doe One Trust, right? So in
- 52:17California, you'd have the name of the trust.
- 52:21But still information leaked through the media,
- 52:23as it often does. And so what happened here is
- 52:26you had an irrevocable trust that provided Rupert's
- 52:29four children are to court trustees. But fast
- 52:32forward to now, Rupert was concerned that his
- 52:36children's political ideologies differed. And
- 52:39so if they became the court trustees with the
- 52:42voting shares to Fox, they could essentially
- 52:45change Fox from what his vision was of what Fox
- 52:48should be. And so he didn't want that to happen.
- 52:52So he decided he wanted one of his children,
- 52:54Lachlan, who was most aligned with his ideology
- 52:56to be the trustee. So he had an irrevocable trust.
- 52:59He wanted to change his mind. So Mr. Murdoch
- 53:04filed in Nevada seeking to decant, modify the
- 53:07trust under Nevada jurisdiction. Why Nevada?
- 53:09Because he met with his lawyers and advisors
- 53:11and Nevada had more flexibility than say California
- 53:14would have to do this type of a modification.
- 53:17And so Nevada has a procedure for the court to
- 53:20take jurisdiction over a trust even if it's not
- 53:24a Nevada trust to begin with and then there's
- 53:27more flexibility to try to modify the trust.
- 53:30So California is pretty limited on how you can
- 53:32modify any irrevocable trust. Nevada has more
- 53:35opportunities for that. But it still didn't work
- 53:39initially in a 96 page sealed ruling parts of
- 53:43which leaked. Again, it was supposed to be sealed.
- 53:45The whole point was that he wanted to try to
- 53:47do this under seal so that if it didn't work,
- 53:49nobody knew. Parts of it still came out. The
- 53:53court said that Mr. Murdoch's request was in
- 53:55bad faith, called it a carefully crafted charade
- 53:59to permanently cement Loughlin's executive roles.
- 54:02And so the court essentially said you had an
- 54:04irrevocable trust to the four trustees, to your
- 54:08kids. You did what you did. You can't like completely
- 54:12changed it now to only make one of your kids
- 54:14a trustee, so the court didn't allow it. So Rupert
- 54:17Murdoch then threatened to appeal and sell the
- 54:19company, which he could have done as trustee
- 54:22of his trust. He could sell the assets of the
- 54:23trust. And so he said, I'm going to sell the
- 54:25company then. And so that forced the parties
- 54:28into mediation, and they globally settled at
- 54:31the mediation as part of a $3 .3 billion settlement.
- 54:35So they agreed in settlement that Loughlin will
- 54:38maintain control over the voting shares of Fox
- 54:41until at least 2050 and those other three siblings
- 54:44each received 1 .1 billion dollars each and the
- 54:48half siblings remain non -voting beneficiaries
- 54:52in the trust and entitled to assets when they
- 54:54turn 30 so they essentially agreed on distributions
- 54:57in exchange for maintaining the voting rights.
- 55:02Probate court approval of settlements agreements.
- 55:05When's it necessary? In Nevada, again, there's
- 55:07loosened rules as to when you need probate court
- 55:09approval of settlements agreements. California,
- 55:13you don't need court approval in California,
- 55:15but oftentimes you want it because you want that
- 55:18settlement to be binding against. all beneficiaries,
- 55:21including sometimes unborn people or persons
- 55:23who didn't participate in the case. You don't
- 55:25want someone to come out of the woodworks later
- 55:27and claim, I didn't agree to this or that. So
- 55:30the probing court approval of the settlement
- 55:31makes it rubber stamps to settlement and makes
- 55:35it binding against all people involved in the
- 55:39trust so that there's a major benefit to that.
- 55:43And in fact, in California, there's a somewhat
- 55:45recent case called Breslin v Breslin, which many
- 55:47of you are familiar with, which says that the
- 55:50courts in California can compel parties in a
- 55:54trust to mediate as part of the court's role
- 55:58as a super fiduciary, where usually mediation's
- 56:00optional. You can't compel mediation, but you
- 56:04can in trust matters. So what are the practical
- 56:08lessons of the Rupert Murdoch? case, risks of
- 56:12irrevocable trusts. Irrevocable trusts are great
- 56:14and they have significant benefits, including
- 56:16tax planning. They could be invaluable when it
- 56:19comes to tax planning. But think ahead in terms
- 56:22of what kind of flexibility you need. You can
- 56:25maintain some flexibility in an irrevocable trust
- 56:27and still get the tax benefits. And so I don't
- 56:31think Rupert thought, he didn't think about the
- 56:33situation where Who's going to run Fox News 20
- 56:37years from now? He didn't think about that situation.
- 56:39What if my kids disagree with me? I guess he
- 56:41presumed his kids are just going to go along
- 56:43and do what he wanted, and everyone's going to
- 56:45think like he is. So he didn't think about that
- 56:47issue. So think ahead. Think about succession
- 56:50planning. Think about who's going to control
- 56:53your empire, especially these big celebrity cases.
- 56:55Think about contingency plans, using trust protectors,
- 56:58maintaining the ability to swap trustees. So
- 57:00there's different things you can do if you plan
- 57:02ahead. But complex succession planning must anticipate
- 57:06conflict. And there's always a planning for control
- 57:10versus benefit, right? Regardless of who benefits
- 57:13with these big empires, you're running companies,
- 57:15control matters sometimes more than who benefits.
- 57:19So think about those issues in advance. Think
- 57:22about public exposure and opinion. These cases
- 57:25are highly sensitive. the public wants to know
- 57:29what's going on and sometimes these trustees
- 57:34want to keep things under wraps and so there's
- 57:36certain states where you could do things under
- 57:38wraps there's things you could do so a state
- 57:40planner should think about that from now and
- 57:42talk about dispute resolution protocols and so
- 57:44forth to try to avoid some of this stuff spilling
- 57:48into the public forums and also of course There's
- 57:56tax consequences to all this that you should
- 57:58think about. Always advise the tax professionals
- 58:00properly. You can apply for private letter rulings
- 58:02on a lot of these issues about changing irrevocable
- 58:05trust. Is it going to reopen my estate up to
- 58:09a state taxation for assets that I removed from
- 58:11my estate? So get the right professionals involved
- 58:15and make sure you think about the big picture
- 58:18and not just the specific problem you're dealing
- 58:21with and plan accordingly. And that's that. And
- 58:29so I think there's a minute or two, but we're
- 58:32probably out of time. But again, if any of you
- 58:34have any questions, feel free to reach out to
- 58:37me. And again, I wanna thank the Beverly Hills
- 58:39Bar Association for having me here today and
- 58:41allowing me this opportunity. Thank you, Vachi.
- 58:49This concludes today's program. We'd like to
- 58:52again extend our thank you to Vachi for an excellent
- 58:55presentation. Our next program will be on February
- 58:5817th, and speaker will be Kristin Mationi of
- 59:03Whittier Trust, and we hope to see you then.
- 59:06Thank you all for joining us this afternoon.