Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Embedding Appellate Attorneys on Trial Teams with Kirk Jenkins
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Embedding Appellate Attorneys on Trial
- 0:06Teams. I'm Neal Wall, Secretary of the Beverly
- 0:09Hills Bar Association Barrister's Young Attorney
- 0:12Section, and I'm delighted to introduce today's
- 0:14speaker, Kirk Jenkins. Kirk Jenkins is a partner
- 0:17at the law offices of Kirk C. Jenkins and a seasoned
- 0:21appellate attorney with nearly 40 years of experience
- 0:24in high stakes litigation, particularly in federal
- 0:27preemption and constitutional law. He has handled
- 0:30complex cases and matters involving environmental
- 0:33contamination, product liability, and consumer
- 0:36class actions, consistently delivering successful
- 0:39outcomes through his deep legal knowledge and
- 0:42strategic approach. Known for his clarity and
- 0:45argument and leadership from trial through appeal,
- 0:48Kirk is a trusted advocate and respected authority
- 0:50in appellate practice. And now, let's get started.
- 0:55Thank you, Nia, for the very generous introduction.
- 0:58My name, as Nia said, is Kirk Jenkins, and I'm
- 1:01an appellate specialist in Atman Bay. I've been
- 1:05an appellate specialist for the last 31 of my
- 1:0939 years of practice. And as best I can figure,
- 1:12that is somewhere north of 300 appellate matters.
- 1:17And my task today is to convince you that you
- 1:20need to add a new senior lawyer. to your trial
- 1:24team. At the outset of my career, back in the
- 1:29medieval times, our cases came about in what
- 1:32one might think of as the traditional way. We
- 1:38got the call after either an adverse judgment
- 1:41had come down or the opponent had filed a notice
- 1:46of appeal. Because, fun fact, messing up a notice
- 1:51of appeal, My first job was always to scrutinize
- 1:54it to make sure the other side hadn't messed
- 1:56it up because if you mess it up, that's one of
- 1:58the few things in California appellate practice
- 2:00that you can't fix. Those days are increasingly
- 2:04past history today as clients recognize that
- 2:08an embedded appellate lawyer is a wise and important
- 2:12value added on the trial team. Now I know what
- 2:16you're thinking. How on earth am I going to persuade
- 2:20the client to allow me to add another senior
- 2:23lawyer to the trial team. Well, we all know that
- 2:26going to trial is terribly expensive, but not
- 2:30nearly as expensive as having to go to trial
- 2:32twice, and I'll have some statistics about that
- 2:35in just a moment. It also eliminates the expense
- 2:39of ramp -up time if the appellate lawyer was
- 2:42on the trial team. Appellate lawyers on the trial
- 2:46team started out in the insurance industry about
- 2:4910 years ago. but from there it spread to big
- 2:52pharma and most recently to more general corporate
- 2:56clients. Over the years I've played the role
- 2:59probably three dozen times. Appellate lawyers
- 3:03can be a matter of simple risk management in
- 3:06high dollar or bet the company cases. In complex
- 3:10statutory or regulatory cases, appellate specialists
- 3:15can offer expert guidance on preserving complex
- 3:18issues and we'll get back to preservation in
- 3:20a minute. I've been in a ton of sophisticated
- 3:24constitutional cases in my career and precision
- 3:28in briefing in these cases is absolutely critical.
- 3:33Finally, it's important to know when you're in
- 3:35a friendly circuit and mold your positions accordingly
- 3:39or in a hostile district. Defending a corporate
- 3:43client in Texas versus defending one in California
- 3:46or in the Fifth Circuit versus the Ninth Circuit,
- 3:50totally different deal. And trust me, there's
- 3:53a whole art form to representing insurance companies.
- 3:58A few examples for you. Tesla had appellate counsel
- 4:01on its trial team when it went to trial on the
- 4:04Enri Tesla Insurance Secure, Tesla Inc. Securities
- 4:08litigation. The Harvard Affirmative Action case
- 4:12from a couple years ago is another good example.
- 4:15In that case, both sides had embedded appellate
- 4:19counsel at the trial court level. The Federal
- 4:23Justice Department has embedded appellate counsel
- 4:25with trial teams routinely for years. Several
- 4:30U .S. Attorney's offices do, too. Now, you have
- 4:35to begin with doing your due diligence, and you
- 4:37begin that by checking out the judge. A friend
- 4:41of mine was an appellate specialist in private
- 4:44practice now as a trial judge in Los Angeles
- 4:47County. She's always delighted to see an appellate
- 4:50lawyer show up for trial. Take a look at the
- 4:55judge's rulings and the analytics on how sheer
- 4:58he has fared on appeal. That data is everywhere
- 5:01today. Does the judge get reversed a lot? Then
- 5:07the reaction to seeing appellate counsel shows
- 5:09up becomes a tad more difficult to predict. On
- 5:12the other hand, if the judge gets affirmed a
- 5:14lot, she might be just fine with seeing appellate
- 5:18counsel in the courtroom. Does your judge show
- 5:22an academic dent? Are there case citations all
- 5:26over the judge's trial court rulings, or is it
- 5:29what we call Ipsy Dixit law? Because I say so.
- 5:34The classic trial judge complaint about seeing
- 5:37an appellate lawyer show up was always, you're
- 5:41here to get me reversed. I heard the perfect
- 5:44response to that in a CLE about embedded appellate
- 5:48attorneys just a couple of months ago. No judge,
- 5:51I'm here to get you affirmed. Now we need to
- 5:56keep an eye on an obvious point that we might
- 5:58otherwise overlook. What's your opponent doing?
- 6:02If the opposing party has an appellate lawyer
- 6:05on the trial team and you don't, you might be
- 6:09at a serious disadvantage if you don't go get
- 6:12yourself one. So always keep an eye on the other
- 6:16counsel table. So what about the trial lawyer?
- 6:22The relationship between trial and appellate
- 6:24lawyers has always been just a bit fraught. Now
- 6:29I'm a big believer in staying in my lane. I have
- 6:33nothing but respect for trial lawyers. I did
- 6:36it for the first eight years of my career, and
- 6:40you'll notice I don't do it anymore. The most
- 6:44important note and put this in all caps in your
- 6:47notes is if you're the appellate lawyer, you
- 6:50are not in charge. Trust me, if a corporate in
- 6:56-house lawyer gets the sense that the embedded
- 6:58appellate lawyer thinks they're in charge, They're
- 7:02gonna be fired on the spot. I've heard in -house
- 7:06counsel who use embedded appellate counsel all
- 7:09the time publicly promise that in a panel discussion
- 7:12just a couple of months ago. The first chair
- 7:17trial lawyer is your client every bit as much
- 7:20as the client is. Listen to her, work with her.
- 7:25Give her your best advice step by step, but if
- 7:28at the end of the day she decides to go another
- 7:31way, that's the trial lawyer's prerogative. The
- 7:36classic complaint about adding an appellate lawyer
- 7:39is, well, if he has trial lawyer partners, they'll
- 7:43post the work if this matter gets reversed and
- 7:46sent back for retrial. Now, I hope I don't have
- 7:49to say this, but never, ever. poach trial work
- 7:54from clients that you met in the course of your
- 7:57trial consulting practice. If you get a call
- 8:00from a client that you met that way, gently tell
- 8:03her no and your next call is to your trial lawyer.
- 8:08Nobody can afford to shoot their practice in
- 8:11the foot like that. So where are you going to
- 8:15sit in court? I've had trial lawyers say they
- 8:18don't want the jury to think they're over lawyering
- 8:20the case. So they think the appellate lawyer
- 8:24should sit in the back. Some of them even advise
- 8:28the appellate lawyer to dress in what today we
- 8:31call business casual rather than what you would
- 8:33ordinarily wear to dry a case. I think with all
- 8:38due respect to our trial lawyer clients that
- 8:41this is a mistake. Very few cases are, how shall
- 8:46we put this, major draws for getting together
- 8:49a crowd. So it's not like The judge isn't going
- 8:53to notice that person in the back row madly scribbling
- 8:56in a legal pad all the time. I heard a war story
- 9:01not long ago of a lawyer who was told by the
- 9:03judge, counsel, if you're a lawyer in this case,
- 9:07you need to come forward and enter your appearance.
- 9:10And bang, you just shot yourself in the foot.
- 9:14Now I talk about sitting in court. There is another
- 9:18alternative. If your client is reluctant, or
- 9:22the budget is short. Now, there's a lot of variation
- 9:26to this. I haven't run numbers on it. So some
- 9:28cases, it may be a good bit cheaper. Some cases,
- 9:32it may not be. But it is possible to make your
- 9:36embedded appellate attorney into a kind of office
- 9:39staff. That way, she or he can concentrate on
- 9:43writing briefs and motions during the day and
- 9:46review the daily transcripts every night. I don't
- 9:51particularly recommend this because you lose
- 9:54the advantage of your appellate lawyer warning
- 9:56you immediately to preserve something or get
- 9:59another bit of testimony in. But I have done
- 10:02it multiple times in my career and it can work.
- 10:07The first slide differing perspectives of trial
- 10:13and appellate attorneys. Consider the differing
- 10:17perspectives of trial and appellate lawyers.
- 10:20Trial lawyers are working in front of juries
- 10:22of laypeople. Appellate attorneys are working
- 10:26in front of panels of three or sometimes even
- 10:29seven judges. The question is different, and
- 10:34you can see that when a trial lawyer makes the
- 10:36mistake of coming to an appellate court and offering
- 10:39his jury argument. We appellate lawyers always
- 10:42say we can spot a trial lawyer at the Court of
- 10:44Appeal from a mile away. At trial, The issue
- 10:49is what is right and just. That's the trial lawyer's
- 10:52focus, and that's what the trial lawyer's focus
- 10:54should be. For the appellate lawyer, the question
- 10:59is whether there was error, not just mere error,
- 11:03but reversible error, error that potentially
- 11:05led to a different result on the merits. Appellate
- 11:09lawyers are always focused on the elements of
- 11:12the claim or the defense. By next slide. talks
- 11:18about the attributes of appellate vision, the
- 11:22things that appellate lawyers spend their days
- 11:24thinking about. Appellate lawyers are always
- 11:28laser focused on the record. They focus on preservation.
- 11:33The saying among appellate lawyers is if it's
- 11:35not down in the reporter's transcript, it never
- 11:38happened. Now, I promised you a minute ago an
- 11:41example of that, and here it is. an amazing example
- 11:45from an article I found in JD Supra. Of course,
- 11:50preservation doctrine isn't new. What is new
- 11:53is how often it's becoming the central reason
- 11:56an appeal fails, and therefore a powerful reason
- 12:00to have an appellate lawyer on the trial team.
- 12:04Now, for the data nerds among us, the earliest
- 12:07example of this would be Trenier versus Stewart
- 12:10101 US 797, But a quick test on Westlaw confirms
- 12:18the point. We search for fail within three of
- 12:22preserve in the same sentence as appellate within
- 12:26the same sentence as review, targeting opinions
- 12:29that address a failure to preserve an issue for
- 12:32appellate review. The result is 2 ,554 hits just
- 12:40from the federal courts of appeal. And if we
- 12:43apply a date filter, we discover that 251 of
- 12:48these decisions were issued just within the past
- 12:51three years. In other words, 10 % of all federal
- 12:57appellate decisions addressing failures to preserve
- 13:00error since 1879 have come down in the last 36
- 13:05months. That's not just noise. That's a signal
- 13:10of an increasingly cranky appellate bench squarely
- 13:14focused on the state of the record. Appellate
- 13:20lawyers worry about standards. How is this issue
- 13:24going to be reviewed on appeal? They focus on
- 13:28the elements of the claim or defense and whether
- 13:31there is harm. There is also a big picture aspect.
- 13:36of appellate vision that can be valuable all
- 13:39around. The appellate lawyer typically hasn't
- 13:43been involved in discovery, although we are occasionally
- 13:47brought in for discovery motions. So she or he
- 13:50can focus on the truly salient points, cutting
- 13:54to the chase for the trial judge in a way that
- 13:58the appellate court will understand and appreciate.
- 14:02Let's talk about the areas where the appellate
- 14:06lawyer adds value during the trial. And that's
- 14:09my next slide. First, witness examinations. You
- 14:18need to spend the night before each key witness
- 14:21exam reviewing the examination outline with your
- 14:25trial lawyer client. The last thing you need
- 14:29is for the appellate lawyer to obviously be stroking
- 14:32out over a counsel table. when the trial lawyer
- 14:35asks a question that plants error in the record.
- 14:39You need to discuss these points the night before
- 14:41and have those conversations. Second, critical
- 14:46motions. Motions in limine can frequently be
- 14:50the whole ball game. What gets in in trial and
- 14:53what doesn't. Now, they're an interesting problem
- 14:57once you go up on appeal. since most of the evidentiary
- 15:01decisions are going to be abusive discretion
- 15:04review. And listen very carefully to the ruling
- 15:08on emotion and alimony. Very often, a trial judge
- 15:13will say something like, we'll wait and see how
- 15:15it comes in. The appellate lawyer's eyes are
- 15:19gonna light up when he or she hears that, because
- 15:22at that point, you definitely have to renew your
- 15:25motion in order to preserve the point. And in
- 15:29some jurisdictions, it's even worse than that.
- 15:31You have to renew all the evidentiary motions
- 15:34to preserve your objections. The motion in Lemony
- 15:37alone isn't enough. Discovery motions are much
- 15:41the same way. What that means is you probably
- 15:46need to win at the trial court. There are about
- 15:52a million citations for the proposition that
- 15:56we disagree with the trial court is not a valid
- 16:00reason to find an abuse of discretion. And it's
- 16:04certainly true that reversals for abuse of discretion
- 16:07are rare. One of my proudest moments was when
- 16:11I took the presiding judge of the district court
- 16:14up on four abuse of discretion issues and got
- 16:18him reversed on all four. So it is possible,
- 16:22but that doesn't mean it's something you can
- 16:24rely on. And there's some good news here too.
- 16:29A lot of people don't spend much time pondering
- 16:32the standard of review, but it's something that
- 16:35appellate lawyers live and die by. It's not much
- 16:38more than cut and pasted from the last brief,
- 16:41but it's possible to make up some ground here.
- 16:45I remember arguing a case in San Francisco about
- 16:47five years ago. I began my argument and the presiding
- 16:53justice wearing what looked suspiciously like
- 16:56a, you're new at this, aren't you, look, said,
- 17:00and what's the standard of review for that? I
- 17:04explained that the court needed to address the
- 17:06standard of reviewing two steps. At the core
- 17:10of the question was a legal issue, and that's
- 17:14de novo review. Only after the court had resolved
- 17:18the legal issue, one way or the other, Can you
- 17:22then take on the overall issue, which is reviewed
- 17:26for abuse of discretion? I was pleased to see
- 17:29that in the final opinion, the court agreed with
- 17:32me and it made an easier road for us on appeal.
- 17:37Interim appellate interventions. This is another
- 17:40area where you need an experienced appellate
- 17:44lawyer because different states have very different
- 17:47attitudes towards interlocutory appellate relief.
- 17:51In the federal courts, it's virtually impossible
- 17:54to get. Trial lawyers think it's easy in the
- 17:58California state courts. When you're ramping
- 18:03up to trial or in the middle of trial, everything
- 18:05that you lose, it's even money somebody's going
- 18:08to say, can we take a writ on it? The fact is,
- 18:12it's a good bit more difficult than you might
- 18:14think. To understand whether a court is likely
- 18:17to intervene, The primary question is whether
- 18:20the court is likely to think this will all come
- 18:23out in the wash or we'll be able to address the
- 18:27question more thoroughly after the record has
- 18:29been developed more. These are the kinds of issues
- 18:33that block most writ petitions and lead to those
- 18:37postcard denials that we've all heard about.
- 18:41Now we talked a minute ago about the need to
- 18:44determine whether interim appellate relief even
- 18:48possible. But there are all kinds of traps for
- 18:51the unwary scattered across the landscape here.
- 18:55First is the problem of statutory writ petitions.
- 18:59They're mostly a creature of California state
- 19:02law, but you need to have somebody on the team
- 19:05that knows those deadlines because the deadline
- 19:07to file, and mind you these deadlines are almost
- 19:11always jurisdictional, tend to be really short.
- 19:16So what about injunctions? That's another one.
- 19:19You have a client gets an injunction pointed
- 19:21their way. They're gonna want to take it up to
- 19:24the appellate court. So it's easy when you lose
- 19:29a money judgment. You just put up an appellate
- 19:32bond. How do you get out from under an injunction
- 19:35while you go up to the appellate court in the
- 19:39middle of a trial? The answer depends on whether
- 19:43the injunction is classified as mandatory or
- 19:46prohibitory, which means does the injunction
- 19:49maintain the status quo or does it require affirmative
- 19:53action? Now, you may hear that and think that's
- 19:57a fairly simple issue to figure out. Well, let
- 20:00me tell you, I've been involved in appeals that
- 20:03lasted two years that entirely revolved around
- 20:07the question. of whether the injunction at issue
- 20:10was mandatory or prohibitory. So no, it's far
- 20:14from simple to figure out. Other issues, collateral
- 20:19orders. Most trial lawyers haven't had to think
- 20:23about collateral orders since bar review, but
- 20:26you need to recognize them when you see them
- 20:30so you can alert your trial team that, hey, we
- 20:33can take this up right away. And the thing is,
- 20:37If it's a collateral order and therefore appealable
- 20:42immediately and you don't appeal it, you just
- 20:46waived it. And there's also such a thing as statutory
- 20:50interlocutory appeals to make it even more complicated.
- 20:55Now, 1292B appeals, 28 U .S. Code 1292B. I practiced
- 21:01appellate law for 12 years in Chicago. And let
- 21:05me tell you, 1292B appeals were the bane of our
- 21:08existence. You read the statute, and it's attached
- 21:12to the materials for this webinar. And it sounds
- 21:16like the only function of the petition is a plain
- 21:20vanilla, please let me get into the queue and
- 21:22appeal this. Outside of the Seventh Circuit,
- 21:28that's what even federal appellate specialists
- 21:30think it is. But here's the thing. There are
- 21:34several judges in the Seventh Circuit who have
- 21:37the nasty habit of summarily deciding appeals
- 21:40based just on the petition. Several years ago,
- 21:44I had an antitrust case in the Seventh Circuit.
- 21:48The opponent, I won't name him, but he was a
- 21:52well -known appellate specialist, but not a Seventh
- 21:55Circuit appellate specialist. He filed one of
- 21:58those plain vanilla petitions, just let me in
- 22:01line. And I remember thinking, you may live to
- 22:05regret that. And sure enough, the circuit puts
- 22:09out a decision ripping the guts out of a nine
- 22:12-figure antitrust claim based solely on that
- 22:15petition. Now, of course, opposing counsel went
- 22:19bananas. Finally, the Seventh Circuit said, yeah,
- 22:23okay, whatever, and took the decision down and
- 22:26scheduled oral argument. Well, was present at
- 22:30the oral argument and I counted and the same
- 22:33judge the author of the decision that had been
- 22:36posted and then taken down asked 57 questions
- 22:41in 30 minutes of this poor guy and Of course
- 22:45a few days later the court entered an opinion
- 22:47It looked an awful lot like what they put out
- 22:50a few a couple of months earlier The moral of
- 22:54our story, of course the house always wins There
- 22:59are other more obscure appellate options that
- 23:01you need to have on your menu as you approach
- 23:03trial. If you're facing a putative class action,
- 23:08you need to distinguish between mandatory appeals
- 23:11under the Class Action Fairness Act or whether
- 23:14we're going to have to resort to a discretionary
- 23:17appeal under 28 U .S. Code 1453. Now, the Class
- 23:28Action Fairness Act, I've done several appeals
- 23:31under that, and we could easily fill the entire
- 23:35hour on that subject. Basically, under 1447D,
- 23:42many remand decisions are simply not reviewable
- 23:45at the Court of Appeal level, but not all. The
- 23:50rule has exceptions to it. One exception is the
- 23:52Class Action Fairness Act. Basically, CAFA, as
- 23:57it's universally known, establishes a system
- 24:01of minimal diversity, a $5 million amount of
- 24:06controversy, and at least 100 plaintiffs. And
- 24:09you can go straight to federal court. U .S. Code
- 24:131453C provides that notwithstanding, 1447D, Agreed
- 24:20litigants can petition the Court of Appeals for
- 24:23permission to appeal an order remanding a case
- 24:26that was removed under CAFA. Moreover, 1447D
- 24:31does not apply to all remands. The Supreme Court
- 24:35has held that it must be read in the context
- 24:37of the rest of the statute. And the Supreme Court
- 24:43held in ThermTron Products versus Hermansdorfer
- 24:46that 1447D applies only to remands authorized
- 24:51by the neighboring 1447C. 1447C authorizes remands
- 24:58due to a lack of subject matter jurisdiction
- 25:00or a procedural defect in the removal. So if
- 25:04a district court remands an action for any other
- 25:07reason, you're good to go. You can take it directly
- 25:10up. And so long as the remand mark the end of
- 25:13the action, the remand can automatically be reviewed
- 25:17under 1291. There's a whole host of pre -trial
- 25:23motions that, and you can go to the next slide
- 25:27there. There's a whole host of pre -trial motions
- 25:29that you have to give consideration to before
- 25:32you approach your trial date. Demurrers are governed
- 25:37at California State Court by rule 3 .1320. The
- 25:41party must file and serve a notice of hearing
- 25:43on the demurrer. Then there are motions to strike.
- 25:48These are governed by rule 3 .1322 and the notice
- 25:52of motion must be given within the time allowed
- 25:55to plead. Amended pleadings are another thing
- 25:58you have to think about. Increasingly, you have
- 26:01to think about motions challenging personal jurisdiction
- 26:05because purposeful availment that we all remember
- 26:09from bar review has gotten tighter than it's
- 26:13ever been before. And personal jurisdiction over
- 26:16corporate clients in particular is tighter in
- 26:19the federal courts than it has ever been. So
- 26:21you need to take a very hard look at what the
- 26:25connections between your client and the state
- 26:28of California, if that's where you are, are and
- 26:32whether they're direct enough to constitute purposeful
- 26:35availment because there's a gigantic body of
- 26:38law on what does and does not constitute purposeful
- 26:42availment. Motions for change of venue are another
- 26:46big area. Are you better off in a different district
- 26:50or circuit? Do you have grounds to move? After
- 26:54denial of the motion to transfer, you get an
- 26:56automatic 30 calendar days under rule 3 .1326
- 27:01to file your motion for change of venue. The
- 27:06final motion that we want to review here is motions
- 27:10concerning arbitration. And today, they are everywhere.
- 27:15They're becoming increasingly important as we
- 27:17move forward. Caseloads in the appellate courts
- 27:20have consistently been falling in recent years.
- 27:24And most judges I talk to attribute the change
- 27:28to arbitration and the Federal Arbitration Act,
- 27:32while the rule governing arbitrations and motions
- 27:35is 3 .1330. Daubert motions. as we review the
- 27:44the motion list. Daubert motions are another
- 27:48turning point in your case. I was the embedded
- 27:52appellate attorney or actually I should say I
- 27:55was the embedded civil appellate attorney since
- 27:57I had a colleague who was a criminal appellate
- 28:00specialist in an antitrust case that went on
- 28:02for years because in my previous life as an economist
- 28:07I was handling all the economic experts. We fought
- 28:12out multiple Daubert motions over the course
- 28:15of a number of weeks. I successfully saw a game
- 28:19theorist through the Daubert process. I thought
- 28:22the opposing economist was ignoring the principle
- 28:25that correlation does not equal causation. So
- 28:29I found this article arguing that just because
- 28:31shark sightings and ice cream prices both rise
- 28:34into summertime doesn't mean one causes the other.
- 28:37I told the judge that the opposing economist's
- 28:41analysis was nothing but sharks and ice cream.
- 28:45My co -counsel thought it was hilarious. Offers
- 28:48of proof. Say the trial court excludes some of
- 28:56your evidence. You need the appellate lawyer
- 28:59to prepare an offer of proof showing what the
- 29:02evidence would have proven. and more importantly,
- 29:05how it's crucial to your case. Next slide, please.
- 29:14The thematic double check, what I'm talking about
- 29:17there is what I mentioned a few moments ago,
- 29:20the idea that you have to be very much aware
- 29:23of what jurisdiction you're in and be prepared
- 29:26to pitch your case in a different way. depending
- 29:30on exactly what the inclinations of the district
- 29:33or the state and the law in the state is. Next
- 29:39slide. We have been through all of those. The
- 29:51next slide. Dawbert motions and limiting preparing
- 29:59trial briefs preparing trial briefs is another
- 30:02crucial job of the Where the appellate lawyer
- 30:06can be helpful? Because you can demonstrate to
- 30:10the both the trial judge and just as importantly
- 30:13to the opposing party That you have preserved
- 30:17all your issues And are ready to go up on appeal
- 30:21if you need to be phrasing of offers and objections
- 30:25As I'll say, repeat in a moment, you have to
- 30:28be very sure that all of the offers of proof
- 30:31have been followed up on and all of the objections
- 30:34have been ruled on. Next slide, please. Let's
- 30:41talk about the hard part, daily trial reports.
- 30:46For the lead trial lawyer, this is going to be
- 30:50one of the primary barriers to your being the
- 30:53embedded appellate attorney on the team. They're
- 30:56going to think, oh, well, you're just going to
- 30:58rat me out to the client. But remember this.
- 31:03In my experience, most criticisms are actually
- 31:06confessions. And it's certainly true when you're
- 31:09talking about the embedded appellate attorney
- 31:12and the trial lawyer. I don't think we preserve
- 31:16this issue. Well, that's on you. We didn't provide
- 31:21all the necessary parts of the defense. Well,
- 31:24that's also on you. I'm not aware of many issues
- 31:28that you could conceivably complain about that
- 31:31aren't your failure as the appellate lawyer.
- 31:35But one of the main jobs for the embedded appellate
- 31:37attorney, tracking the evolution of potential
- 31:41issues for appeal. Do you have substantial evidence
- 31:46in the record for all of the elements of the
- 31:48claim or defense? If it's a point that you've
- 31:52already lost, take a clear -eyed look at whether
- 31:55you've got enough to argue at the Court of Appeal
- 31:58that the error was prejudicial, that harmed your
- 32:02case. And just as importantly, where are you
- 32:05about possible settlement of the case? The appellate
- 32:08attorney aids in determining where your case
- 32:11stands on that issue. The focus of the appellate
- 32:16lawyer is always on the status of error. You
- 32:20have to be consulting with your trial lawyer
- 32:22every night. What do you plan to ask the witnesses
- 32:26tomorrow? We've all had our moments where we
- 32:30had to tell the trial lawyer, no, you can't ask
- 32:33them that. Why? Because it'll get us reversed.
- 32:36That's why. Next slide. The name of the game
- 32:46is making sure all your objections are made and
- 32:50all the necessary motions have been renewed.
- 32:54You need to be sure that the judge has actually
- 32:57ruled on all the objections, because it's just
- 33:00routine for some points never to be ruled on.
- 33:05You also have to track all, and I mean every
- 33:08single one of the exhibits. Make sure each has
- 33:12been either definitively admitted or excluded.
- 33:16The same thing goes for your evidentiary rulings.
- 33:20You need to be very certain that every single
- 33:22one of them has been ruled on. Jury instructions
- 33:27and verdict forms are incredibly important for
- 33:31the appellate lawyer. Jury instructions are about
- 33:35parsing out the elements of the claims. the elements
- 33:39of the defenses and making sure in the verdict
- 33:43form that every one of them has been decided
- 33:46one way or the other. Many trial lawyers will
- 33:50be tempted to capture the entire story of the
- 33:53case in a single instruction that goes on for
- 33:56pages and pages. This is a critical mistake.
- 34:01In nearly every jurisdiction, a trial judge is
- 34:05permitted to reject an instruction that's erroneous
- 34:09in any detail, and appellate lawyers are immersed
- 34:14in the details from State Farm v. Campbell and
- 34:18BMW v. Gore on how punitive damages need to be
- 34:23instructed on. The appellate lawyer needs to
- 34:28understand and keep in mind whether something
- 34:31has gone wrong during the case. Does there need
- 34:35to be curative instructions? or limiting instructions.
- 34:40Pay attention to whether something came in for
- 34:43a limited purpose only and make sure you've locked
- 34:46that down in the instructions. And here we can
- 34:54move on to the next slide. Sorry, mistrial motions
- 35:04are also a very important one that I should have
- 35:07noted as I went by. Here's one of the most important
- 35:15contributions of the appellate lawyer. You're
- 35:18going to get hit by something you weren't expecting.
- 35:22If you're up against a good tactician, She's
- 35:26going to notice when you got ten other things
- 35:28to worry about and she's going to trot out emotion
- 35:31from left field for you to grapple with. That's
- 35:35what your appellate lawyer is for. Among appellate
- 35:40lawyers, we've all heard the objection, you can't
- 35:43do this or that because you're going to turn
- 35:45the trial judge against us. Well, that's an important
- 35:50function of the embedded appellate attorney.
- 35:53The trial judge needs to be very clear on what
- 35:56your function is and that you are not part of
- 35:59the trial team, strictly speaking, because then
- 36:03your job can be to be the buffer between the
- 36:06trial counsel and the judge. Don't hate my trial
- 36:09counsel, focus on me. The state of the record
- 36:15is absolutely crucial from the viewpoint of the
- 36:20appellate lawyer. And we can go to the next slide.
- 36:28The most frequent single question, where is the
- 36:32court reporter? Remember, if it's not in the
- 36:35reporter's transcript, it never happened. Trial
- 36:40lawyers will frequently think, well, I don't
- 36:42want to annoy the trial judge. Well, that's what
- 36:46you have your appellate lawyer for. Everything.
- 36:50must be transcribed. Sidebars, in -chambers discussions,
- 36:55visuals by experts, videotaped deposition testimony,
- 37:00juror questions, all of it. Every appellate lawyer
- 37:05I know has had the experience of getting a transcript
- 37:09for a case they weren't on at the trial level
- 37:12or they weren't the embedded appellate attorney.
- 37:15Finding error and then realizing they don't have
- 37:19enough in the record to make the case. One of
- 37:22the primary jobs of the embedded appellate attorney,
- 37:26you must carefully review all daily transcripts
- 37:31as the trial continues. It's your job to ensure
- 37:35that sufficient evidence is admitted on every
- 37:38key point. I believe we can move on to the next
- 37:43slide. And also, as this slide points out, you
- 37:55need to identify points as you go on which you
- 37:57need additional testimony. When the jury comes
- 38:02back, you're going to need to pull them. The
- 38:07juror verdict form. This is an incredibly important
- 38:10contact point. As an appellate lawyer, you have
- 38:14to review it in a very big hurry. Is it internally
- 38:19inconsistent? Have they made two findings that
- 38:23cannot be reconciled with each other? Because
- 38:27if it's not, if it's not internally consistent,
- 38:31you have to object right now before the jury
- 38:34is allowed to go on their way. Otherwise, you've
- 38:39waved the point. Juror interviews. My last note
- 38:46on this slide. Candidly, everyone wants them
- 38:50and they are nearly always a waste of time. There
- 38:53is a very narrow range of issues that can be
- 38:57heard on post trial motions on juror interviews.
- 39:03Next is a crucial point that I think it's fair
- 39:06to say only appellate lawyers think of. And that
- 39:16is if your client is the defendant or the cross
- 39:20-defendant, when you get to the point of submitting
- 39:23the case to the jury, you have to start thinking
- 39:26about the appeal bond. You have to ask the hard
- 39:30questions about your client's financial situation.
- 39:35The time you can halt execution without the bond
- 39:41is very, very short. typically as little as 10
- 39:45days. And you're going to have about a day to
- 39:49get that motion on file. And appellate lawyers
- 39:54will have a Rolodex or whatever has replaced
- 39:57Rolodexes these days, full of numbers to call
- 40:02to find people who can provide the appellate
- 40:05bond for the client in about 24 hours. And your
- 40:11client is going to want to know two things. First,
- 40:16how long is my money going to be tied up? And
- 40:20second, how quickly are the interest charges
- 40:22going to build up? So your appellate lawyer is
- 40:26the person that's going to need to know all of
- 40:28those at the tip of the tongue. It can matter
- 40:31a lot how long the appeal is likely to take for
- 40:36this exact reason. Now let's talk post -trial
- 40:44motions, which I believe is... Go back one if
- 40:53you can. I think we skipped one there. Now let's
- 40:59talk post -trial motions. In California, rule
- 41:023 .1600 says that council must file a memorandum
- 41:07in support of a motion for new trial. within
- 41:1010 days of following the notice of intention
- 41:13to move for a new trial. Particularly on the
- 41:17federal level, some motions need to be renewed
- 41:20in order to preserve them for review on appeal.
- 41:25As soon as all your evidence on a particular
- 41:26point has been put in, you make your motion for
- 41:31judgment as a matter of law pursuant to Rule
- 41:3350A. Now you're not going to win that motion.
- 41:38But the reason you make it is so you can renew
- 41:42the motion after the jury comes back. If you
- 41:45didn't make it to start with, you can't renew
- 41:48it. And you're limited to the issues that you
- 41:52put in that motion when you made it at the close
- 41:54of all of your case. If you didn't move for judgment
- 41:59as a matter of law under Rule 50A, you can't
- 42:03renew the motion under 50B. However, the good
- 42:07news is... You can also make a motion for a new
- 42:10trial under federal rule 59 and those aren't
- 42:15limited by the scope of your earlier motion for
- 42:18judgment as a matter of law. If you get a shocking
- 42:23damages award, you'll need your appellate lawyer
- 42:27to prepare a motion for remittitor. Those these
- 42:31days are typically on punitive damages awards,
- 42:35which almost always will bring a motion for remitted.
- 42:39It's a long shot, but you'll also be considering
- 42:43a motion for relief from the judgment under Rule
- 42:4660. And here's an important point that I make
- 42:51on either this slide or the next one. Some verdicts
- 42:54can be successfully attacked in post -job motions,
- 42:58making an appeal unnecessary. That's particularly
- 43:02true of punitive damages award. You read all
- 43:05the time about punitive damages awards that are
- 43:09massively sliced in post -trial motions. And
- 43:13in the majority of those cases, ultimately there
- 43:16isn't an appeal. Once again, the issue is where
- 43:21is the law going to be in one to two years, not
- 43:26where it is now. You must monitor cases which
- 43:31are currently in progress. So you know how the
- 43:35law in your jurisdiction is likely to change.
- 43:39Excuse me, you can go to the next slide. Okay,
- 43:52this is some of the big picture items that we
- 43:57discussed earlier in the presentation. It is
- 44:00possible to lose the game in the first inning
- 44:03The appellate lawyers are kind of thought of
- 44:07as the academic on the team worrying about the
- 44:10rules worrying about the elements of the claim
- 44:13or defense and worrying about Deflect deflecting
- 44:18blame you can move on to the next slide Okay,
- 44:26this is the issue that I was talking about. The
- 44:31appellate strategist has to know where the appellate
- 44:37lag time is increasing in your area, because
- 44:42that determines when the opinion is likely to
- 44:44come down. In California, if you file a notice
- 44:49of appeal today, you're not going to have an
- 44:51opinion for two to three years, depending on
- 44:53the district you're in. So it's crucial that
- 44:58you monitor cases in progress in the geographical
- 45:02area where you are. So you're in a position to
- 45:06warn the trial team so they can take advantage
- 45:09of brand new precedent. You're going to be reading
- 45:11a lot of the daily notices of the new decisions
- 45:17coming down. One of the most important tools
- 45:20when the law is underdeveloped. The strategic
- 45:24amicus brief. And I think that's the next slide.
- 45:30Yes. I talked about CAFA and personal jurisdiction
- 45:33earlier, but the rest of these issues. The strategic
- 45:38amicus brief. First, what is your jurisdiction's
- 45:42attitude towards amicus briefs? Because believe
- 45:45it or not, they can be very, very different.
- 45:49Illinois. for example, where I practiced for
- 45:51many years, is very restrictive towards amicus
- 45:55briefs. Illinois, both in state court and in
- 45:58the Seventh Circuit, Judge Posner issued a couple
- 46:06of chamber's opinions about 20 years ago, in
- 46:10which he flatly said, this is not a show of hands,
- 46:14and set out a seven point test. that you need
- 46:18to be able to meet. And if you can't demonstrate
- 46:23that you meet those seven points, he said, we
- 46:26don't want it. You're only burdening the court.
- 46:29And the Illinois State appellate courts have
- 46:33adopted basically the same test. So it is virtually
- 46:36impossible to get him make us briefs in Illinois
- 46:41courts. I had a big workers' compensation case
- 46:46there many years ago that I somehow managed to
- 46:53keep, I think it was eight Fortune 500 corporations
- 46:58on a single amicus brief. And you talk about
- 47:02herding cats. One of the most important tools
- 47:06when the law is underdeveloped, the strategic
- 47:08amicus briefs. California accepts almost all
- 47:12of them. The only way that you can get an amicus
- 47:16brief turned down, particularly in the California
- 47:19Supreme Court, is if you're, shall we say, new
- 47:24around here and wait to submit it until a week
- 47:27before the oral argument when the case has actually
- 47:30already been decided. As long as you submit it
- 47:33during the briefing process, they're going to
- 47:36take it. And that's been true for at least 40
- 47:40or 50 years. In California, moderately often,
- 47:47the state Supreme Court will actually allow an
- 47:51amicus to participate in oral argument. Let me
- 47:54tell you, that would never ever happen in Illinois.
- 47:58But I see it fairly often in California. You
- 48:02admittedly have to have a fairly close relationship
- 48:05with one of the parties. because you're going
- 48:08to have to divide your time. And a well -developed
- 48:12argument for wire relief that will benefit that
- 48:16party will get you what you need, but it does
- 48:19happen fairly frequently. One of the crucial
- 48:23contributions that you can make as an amicus
- 48:25author is educating the appellate court on the
- 48:29realities of the industry that you're working
- 48:31in. Also, you can discuss the policy implications
- 48:36of the decision and set out the legislative history
- 48:39of the matter. I talk at the end of this slide
- 48:46about staving off the Thelma and Louise case.
- 48:50What that means is the case where the opposing
- 48:55party is bent on betting it all. on the result
- 49:02of the case, the now shove everything to the
- 49:06center of the table kind of situation. And you
- 49:09want to, through your amicus brief, make the
- 49:14argument that this was actually a very fact driven
- 49:16situation, meaning that it's not going to be
- 49:19a good vehicle for anybody to make a broad sweeping
- 49:24pronouncement of what the law is in any area.
- 49:30Now, I believe this is the next slide. At times,
- 49:35your appeal will wind up in appellate mediation.
- 49:39There are still many things you can accomplish
- 49:41here. Don't hesitate to hand your brief to the
- 49:46other side. I've done it a number of times. Basically,
- 49:50this is what I'm going to do to you if we go
- 49:53to briefing. It's persuading the opponent that
- 49:58the appeal is a gamble. The Ninth Circuits are
- 50:03a gamble or a waste of money. Review carefully
- 50:07the districts or circuits you can target and
- 50:10figure out where you want to go. The Ninth Circuits
- 50:15program, the Ninth Circuit mediators are very,
- 50:19very good, and you can frequently get cases resolved
- 50:23in the Ninth Circuit. The California Court of
- 50:27Appeal, it varies somewhat from one district
- 50:30to the next, but I've had a lot of good results
- 50:33over the years in appellate mediation. I talked
- 50:39a moment ago about balancing conflicting decisions
- 50:42from different districts. Review carefully the
- 50:46districts or circuits you can target and figure
- 50:48out where you want to go. If you get an adverse
- 50:51result from one circuit, Balance it with a positive
- 50:55result from another circuit and then you're in
- 50:57business because you can ask the Supreme Court
- 50:59to resolve the conflict Excuse me again Now we've
- 51:09got a little bit of time for for questions Before
- 51:16we wrap up So I will. Alrighty, so it does look
- 51:30like we have a bit more time for questions. Do
- 51:32you have any any closing statements or pointers
- 51:36that you would like to provide for our audience
- 51:40while we wait for questions to come in? Well,
- 51:43it's a it's a been a pleasure being with you
- 51:46and as you can see my email and phone number
- 51:48at the end of the handouts, so you should certainly
- 51:51feel free to call email or text. Anytime you
- 51:55have something I can help you with. But the bottom
- 52:00line of this entire discussion to me is preservation
- 52:05is all important. Remember those statistics that
- 52:10I talked about with the number of cases, the
- 52:14number of cases that fail because of failure
- 52:18to preserve the issue. Trial lawyers, can't be
- 52:24expected to think of everything. They have enough
- 52:26on their plate. And you need to have the academic
- 52:31on the team who is laser focused on the state
- 52:35of the record at all times and making sure, xing
- 52:40off everything that goes through as it gets preserved
- 52:46because there's nothing worse than reaching the
- 52:49Court of Appeal and finding that you have issues
- 52:53that you could have made out, but they're not
- 52:57properly preserved in the record. All right.
- 53:04We do have a few questions now rolling in. Giacomo
- 53:08Russo asks, do you find Big Law folks are more
- 53:11formidable than boutique firms? Actually, in
- 53:17my experience, the opposite. I have been opposed
- 53:24both types of firms over the years. I've been
- 53:28in big law firms for the last several years,
- 53:32but some of the finest appellate lawyers in the
- 53:37state of California are in very, very small firms.
- 53:42The Horvitz firm, they're all very fine appellate
- 53:44lawyers. The Greenis Martin firm, California
- 53:49appellate litigation group, the people that I
- 53:57see on the opposing council list and think, okay,
- 54:00got to get the A game on this time, are the people
- 54:04from the small boutique firms. All right, perfect.
- 54:10And we have a question from Sheila Pendergast
- 54:13asking, how do you delicately handle strategic
- 54:16conflicts with your trial counsel? You have to
- 54:21make sure she understands exactly. Basically,
- 54:26the answer is you have to treat them like a client.
- 54:28You have to understand exactly what the decision
- 54:36involves. what the risks are, what the best case
- 54:40scenario is, what the worst case scenario is.
- 54:43And then at the end of the day, as I said in
- 54:46the presentation, you're not in charge. So if
- 54:51the appellate lawyer recommends something and
- 54:55fully explains this is what we're risking, this
- 54:58is the worst case scenario, this is the best
- 55:00case scenario, at that point it's up to the trial
- 55:04lawyer. And I have had, I have absolutely had
- 55:09that experience of ways that I recommended that
- 55:14certain things be handled, that the trial lawyer
- 55:17has gone another way. And it's absolutely no
- 55:22different than when it happens with a client,
- 55:26because they're your client too. Great. And we
- 55:31have another question. How do you balance the
- 55:34appellate attorney's focus on preservation and
- 55:37the trial team's focus on persuasion? The answer
- 55:43is you do have to balance them. I hesitate to
- 55:49use the phrase walk and chew gum because it sounds
- 55:52condescending. There are times, for example,
- 55:58when you're in a chambers conference, the trial
- 56:09judge has to understand when you come back out,
- 56:12you have to enter a description of it into the
- 56:16record so that it'll be there in the reporter's
- 56:20transcript. Preservation. you have to preserve
- 56:26every possible error because there is nothing
- 56:29worse than getting to the Court of Appeal and
- 56:33recognizing that something wasn't properly preserved.
- 56:37But at the end of the day, once again, it's the
- 56:39same thing. The trial lawyer is in charge, the
- 56:42appellate lawyer isn't. I have also had that
- 56:47experience of telling the trial lawyer, I think
- 56:52it's dubious whether we preserve this or not.
- 56:55And at the end of the day, it's his or her decision.
- 57:01All right, great. And it looks like we have two
- 57:03more questions right now. Christian Dale asks,
- 57:07if a motion for reconsideration is filed first,
- 57:10can any new evidence presented to the judge at
- 57:13that stage be utilized on appeal? I would think
- 57:20the answer would be it would be very difficult
- 57:22to get it out, get it in, that I think the record
- 57:27is probably frozen at that point, so my answer
- 57:31would be probably not. Okay, and Marie Wrighton
- 57:39asks, presume you timely object that there is
- 57:43an inconsistent verdict before the jury is discharged.
- 57:47What happens next at the trial court level? Jury
- 57:50gets sent back. To consider further, the judge
- 57:55explains your answer to question 1B and 1C can't
- 58:02both be right, so I need you to go back and figure
- 58:05out which one you want to stand by. All right,
- 58:11and what would you say are the most overlooked
- 58:14post -trial motions or steps that can affect
- 58:17appealability or preservation of issues? Things
- 58:24like motion for new trial are the easy ones,
- 58:26but in the federal court, renewing motion for
- 58:30judgment as a matter of law is one of the crucial
- 58:35ones. As I said during the presentation, challenges
- 58:40to personal jurisdiction. are becoming very,
- 58:43very, very important. And there are specialists
- 58:48out there in that area of law because there is
- 58:51so much of it. What constitutes purposeful abalement
- 58:55and what doesn't? So there are a lot of them
- 59:01is the answer. All righty. Well, it looks like
- 59:07we don't have any more questions. So Thank you
- 59:11so much, Kirk, for your time today and thank
- 59:13you so much for our audience. I wish you a lovely
- 59:17afternoon. Pleasure being with you.