Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #62 🎙️ |Public Inquiry Roads Week Beginning 19th May 2026| Day 2
Transcript
- 0:04I suppose what stood out today for me was the fact that early
- 0:08this morning I had a conversation with Doug Hill and
- 0:11later Bill Donnelly, individually and separately,
- 0:14each not knowing the other had spoken to me about the exact
- 0:17same issue, both of them contacting me, not me,
- 0:20contacting them, both men were expressing their disgust as to
- 0:25how they had been treated on Monday by the commission as they
- 0:28tried to give their evidence. Doug Hill is a senior roads
- 0:32engineer with over 40 years experience with roads and large
- 0:35infrastructure projects, and has much to offer about their
- 0:39proposals for the roads and road networks around the mine, Bill
- 0:44Donnelly, seasoned campaigner for many years against the only
- 0:47other gold mine in Northern Ireland, Kavanagh Kaw, was also
- 0:51angry and upset not to have been given due respect by the
- 0:55commission to speak about what he very clearly experienced of
- 0:59living beside the mine in Cavanaugh, and personally
- 1:02witnessing the deterioration of the roads due to heavy goods
- 1:05vehicles, the noise, dust, stress, and general upset it
- 1:09caused his community at that time. These two were so upset
- 1:15yesterday that I was concerned they would not return to the
- 1:18public inquiry today. However, these men are made of sterner
- 1:22stuff, and we are very grateful that we're both present today.
- 1:27It's hard to sit there day after day and witness the undisguised
- 1:30and perhaps unconscious bias the commissioners have for the other
- 1:33side. It's on the expressions of the faces, it's in the body
- 1:40language, it's in their attitudes, smiles, softening
- 1:46willingness to engage. I could say fawning, particularly with
- 1:50senior barristers, which are only on one side the room, not
- 1:55having the finances to pay these guys. You might guess it's not
- 1:58our side, or is even more interesting, while we have all
- 2:03noticed this behaviour in the room, it has been remarked to us
- 2:08by various random visitors and supporters in the audience who
- 2:12may have only been there once or twice, and without asking or
- 2:16prompting, bring up these very same observations, finding a
- 2:20shameful situation that people with only good intentions for
- 2:24their fellow human beings are being treated in this fashion.
- 2:28What was also remarkable today was hearing DFI Rhodes say for
- 2:32the first time in five weeks that their priority was the
- 2:35safety of human beings. Up until now, I cannot recall much
- 2:39mention from DFI of people, communities, or the lived
- 2:44reality of those who actually use these roads every day,
- 2:47whether that is a genuine shift in thinking or whether they have
- 2:51finally realised that this not so public public inquiry has in
- 2:55fact become spectacularly public. Who knows, probably just
- 3:00a change in strategy. More news from today straight in this
- 3:05morning, mr. Alvin took up where he left off the evening before
- 3:09and continued to build his case around why section 76 ought to
- 3:13be used to set the baseline before construction of the
- 3:16so-called new road, which, according to Doug Hill, senior
- 3:20roads engineer, is not a new road at all, but one that has
- 3:24been realigned and badly done at that was his throwaway comment.
- 3:29So, this again is a new material development, according to Pat
- 3:33Haughey, who requested that the roads topic be closed forth with
- 3:37until there is a proper structural survey. Doug Hill
- 3:42picked up the conversation with these observations. He did not
- 3:45hold back that a video survey proposed by the applicant and
- 3:49waved through by DFI is totally insufficient, that a structural
- 3:53survey must be carried out by independent specialists, such as
- 3:56pavement engineers, geotechnical engineers, lighting engineers,
- 3:59signing and environmental engineers, and that this is a
- 4:02major piece of work to be scoped by the client, and the final
- 4:06decision rests with the road service. He very clearly said
- 4:10that DFI need to take responsibility for the road that
- 4:13is going to be turned into a haul road. He further emphasised
- 4:17that lives are at risk here, that all of the work needs to be
- 4:20done first and foremost before the legal and financial
- 4:23agreements that we were talking about today are set in place. He
- 4:27said to quote, What I am witnessing here is a development
- 4:31scheme being cobbled together between DFI and Dalradian Gold
- 4:36representatives. And he finished with this question for the
- 4:39commissioner: Can I be of any more help to you? Negative was
- 4:45the answer. Mary Brawley went on to explain that, as third
- 4:50parties, we are, as is usual, very much in the dark. No
- 4:54baseline studies, no identification of parties for
- 4:57legal and financial agreements, no. Attention of community
- 5:00engagement, and that any agreements as these should be
- 5:04treated with extreme caution, remembering there is no bond,
- 5:09that Del Radian are only a shell company owned by Wheaton and
- 5:12registered in the Cayman Islands, and for DFI to rely on
- 5:17litigation and injunctions to recover costs would not be a
- 5:20sensible idea. She advised the DFI to review their position.
- 5:26Alvin, DFI counsel, kept pushing for his section 76 which was
- 5:31explained in my last podcast, number 16 at one, claiming it
- 5:36was in the public interest, much more workable and easier to
- 5:39enforce. For some reason, now Elvin has begin to realise that
- 5:43humans are involved, or maybe the awareness of the amount of
- 5:46bad press that DFIs begin to attract. I, for one, don't
- 5:50believe it's a change of heart, probably just a change of
- 5:53strategy. At some point, his conversation then shifted more
- 5:58into road use and the change of use from an ordinary country
- 6:01road to a hall route. Niall McAleer also agreed that using
- 6:05videos to survey was totally insufficient, and he's an
- 6:08architect and is well versed in what will be needed for baseline
- 6:11studies such as this. He went on to say that with 218,000 loaded
- 6:18heavy goods vehicles travelling these roads over the lifetime of
- 6:22a mine, plus about 2 million car journeys by staff, that the road
- 6:27would have to be substantially upgraded to become a haul road,
- 6:30and only ground penetrating radar would be suitable for the
- 6:33initial baseline surveys. Sean Clark pointed out there had
- 6:38never been any contact with major community activity, the GA
- 6:42Club about the proposals for the road and road network in all the
- 6:45time he has been club secretary, and he's been there for years.
- 6:50Beachy disagreed, claiming that there was evidence of community
- 6:53consultation within the materials submitted to the PAC.
- 6:58I suspect he may have confused genuine consultation with the
- 7:01old Dalradian Roadshow, the carefully stage-managed
- 7:05marketing exercise held in Greencastle, Ruskin, Gorchin,
- 7:08back in the day, an understandable mistake, perhaps,
- 7:12if you believe public relations and community content are the
- 7:15same thing. Thomas O'Kane, retired rural primary school
- 7:20principal was absolutely shocked to hear that schools were not
- 7:23consulted, and said this was not good practice, dangerous to say
- 7:28the very least. Dr. Louise Taylor said the precautionary
- 7:32principle should at least apply that the project is a threat to
- 7:35life, is incoherent, inconsistent, and utter
- 7:38nonsense, and that she was deeply concerned. Dorman from
- 7:42the company Hoydorman, who supposedly carried out the base
- 7:45survey, tried to shift the burden of responsibility of
- 7:48safety of the road onto the young children using the road by
- 7:51saying everyone should look after themselves. We then moved
- 7:58on to the grandiose travel plans concocted by Dalradian, which,
- 8:01after a long conversation, were not worth talking about any
- 8:04more, because everyone in the room knew that there could be no
- 8:07monitoring, no robustness, built-in hypotheticals not
- 8:11sufficiently detailed, lacked enforcement to comply, and that
- 8:15the PAC should conclude the travel plans were rubbish,
- 8:19mitigation measures, and a total waste of time. Why they were
- 8:23accepted by DFI in the first place is a mystery. Manonoma
- 8:29District Council simply said they were long on promises and
- 8:32short on outcomes or guarantees. Elvin, at this point, appeared
- 8:38to agree and went on to suggest that section 76 should cover it.
- 8:42Who is he? Kitten, we all wonder. Niall reminded that PAC
- 8:48that this is a turning into a facilitation exercise for new
- 8:51strategy rather than interrogation. And asked, why
- 8:55have the DFI left it so late to say that this travel plan is no
- 8:59good? Could it be part of the strategy of to keep moving the
- 9:04goal posts? This question was passed over to Alvin, who
- 9:11answered, but it was so lost in legal ease and jargon that God
- 9:15alone knows what twisted rubbish was coming out of his mouth.
- 9:18Something about final versions and frameworks. I missed most of
- 9:22the session after 2pm as I had an urgent appointment with the
- 9:26dentist. Coming back later, I wasn't in much shape for taking
- 9:29any more notes, feeling like I'd done a couple of rounds in the
- 9:31boxing ring, and it was the day concluded, which you've probably
- 9:37guessed more exciting timetable updates this time with topics
- 9:42included. Now we have the topics, but somehow or other
- 9:45we've lost a day in August that we were told was going to happen
- 9:48last week. I won't bore you with the details, because I am sure
- 9:52it will change tomorrow again. One final note, I do sometimes
- 9:57wonder when people stop being people. Became receptors
- 10:03somewhere along the line. Families, neighbours, and entire
- 10:08rural communities seem to have been reduced to technical
- 10:11obstacles on a consultant spreadsheet, passive objects
- 10:17there to absorb noise, dust, vibration, and disruption, a
- 10:23remarkable bit of language, really. Strip away the word
- 10:27human, and it becomes much easier to strip away the
- 10:30humanity. And on that note, I'll see you all tomorrow. A small
- 10:40request, if you are listening regularly on Spotify, don't
- 10:45forget to follow the podcast on Spotify, and if you're listening
- 10:49on Apple, do leave a review or give us a few stars. It really
- 10:54does help more people find the show and keeps these
- 10:57conversations moving further and further out into the world. See
- 11:02you all soon, you.