Latest / How To Protect The Ocean / From Shoveling Coral Overboard to Negotiating at the UN
Transcript
- 0:00I bet you're sitting there, you know,
- 0:01you read the title of this podcast,
- 0:03and you're probably wondering how someone that starts off when they're younger
- 0:09or maybe they're working in a in a some kind of industry,
- 0:12and then eventually like 20, 30,
- 0:1440 years later, they become an advocate and and for the ocean and protect
- 0:19the ocean in some way. And and I'll be honest,
- 0:21for me, I always think of people who want to become who are scientists
- 0:25and they become more advocates because they've been working in the field
- 0:28a lot of the time.
- 0:29But today we're going be following the story of a man that
- 0:32I interviewed that's going to be Matthew Gianni,
- 0:35who is the co-founder and political advisor of the Deep
- 0:40Sea Conservation Coalition. I interviewed him on Friday.
- 0:43We're going to talk about his story today,
- 0:45because I want you to get to know who he is.
- 0:47And, you know, a lot of the times with guests that we have,
- 0:50I don't get to talk a lot about them other than what they talk about themselves.
- 0:56So I decide, you know what?
- 0:57Let's switch it up a little bit and let's really focus in on the story
- 1:01of Matthew Gianni, who is a was a t a fisherman in the United States
- 1:05for 10 years and how he ended up in Amsterdam,
- 1:08not only having experience working for Greenpeace for like 10,
- 1:1113 years, but also co-founding his own deep sea conservation coalition organization
- 1:17and is now advocating not only helping negotiate and putting together international
- 1:23agreements on deep sea fishing,
- 1:25but also
- 1:26Looking at mining and deep sea mining.
- 1:29We're gonna talk all about that on this episode of the How to Protect
- 1:32the Ocean podcast. This is the podcast where you find out everything
- 1:35you need to know on ocean news and ocean science and conservation Monday
- 1:39to Friday every week. I can't wait for you to s like follow,
- 1:45enjoy the journey, ~ and really dive into a resource where you can learn about
- 1:51the ocean and what's happening in the ocean,
- 1:52not just the education aspect.
- 1:54Of the ocean, like animals and so forth and habitats.
- 1:56We go through that as well. But we really talk about how things
- 2:00are progressing and how we are protecting the ocean.
- 2:02And today we're going to be talking about one of the people,
- 2:05one of the many, many people who has helped protect the ocean in a
- 2:09lot of different ways. And that is Matthew Gianni,
- 2:12who started his life as a fisher,
- 2:15or started his working life as a fisherman for 10 years on multiple coasts
- 2:21of fisheries.
- 2:22Now, this is this is an incredible story.
- 2:24Cause and then I want you to really start to think about what it takes
- 2:28for someone to go from fisher to advocate in the NGO speech space from
- 2:34an internationally. So going from local,
- 2:36right? So, you know, this is ~ like a fisherman who who's not just
- 2:40a fisherman in one fishery this entire time.
- 2:42He spanned like genuinely a wide range of fisheries,
- 2:46right? Not just
- 2:47On one boat or one coast. He did Florida.
- 2:50He ran around like gillnet fisheries for Spanish and ~ king mackerel.
- 2:55He worked on the Central California,
- 2:57New England, and Florida coasts on the bottom trawl fisheries for sole,
- 3:02redfish, hake, sable fish, shrimp,
- 3:05and other ground fish. Right? Like this is deep-sea trawling here.
- 3:08We're looking to we're talking about like off central California,
- 3:11down to a thousand meters, roughly 3,000 feet for my American friends.
- 3:16And in Oregon and California, he also participated in the hook
- 3:19and line fisheries for Salmon Alba Cortuna.
- 3:22So getting this wide variety of fish,
- 3:24and it doesn't stop there. In Northern California and Oregon as well,
- 3:27he looked at the pot fishery. He's worked at the pot fishery for Dugenous Crab.
- 3:30And then in Georgia's Bank, going on the East Coast,
- 3:33Mid-Atlantic, and in New England,
- 3:35dredge fishery for deep sea scallops.
- 3:38Now, I think a lot of times when we think about the people who are in these
- 3:43roles of like international policy roles and political roles,
- 3:47dealing with all the nuances that have to go into the regulations,
- 3:51whether it's national or international bodies,
- 3:53or even even more local. It's it's not as if like we don't know where they came
- 3:57from. Sometimes they come right out school and they work their way
- 4:00up through the policy career space.
- 4:02And others they come from different backgrounds like Matthew,
- 4:05right? And and you know, we're looking at different types of fishery that
- 4:09he actually did looking at gill nets,
- 4:10trawls, hook and line, pots, dredges.
- 4:13Right, up and down the Atlantic and Pacific coast,
- 4:15the west and east coast, the east and west coast of the United States.
- 4:18And so it's it's not as if he had this narrow career,
- 4:22right? he has a general working knowledge of a ma of the American commercial fishing
- 4:26system, right? And and and he's taken a lot from that,
- 4:30you know. And I think it it it comes down to later.
- 4:33We'll we'll start to see this shape how he started choosing the different paths that
- 4:39he took.
- 4:40later on in his story, and and I want you to to really understand why
- 4:45the deep sea like what it meant to him and and what he really understood from going
- 4:51into like the the especially the the trawling,
- 4:54right? The central California coast,
- 4:56trawling down to a thousand meters.
- 4:58Now I want you to think about what happens there.
- 5:01A trawl go a traw net goes down.
- 5:02I've I've described how what a traw net looks like,
- 5:05You're looking at deep sea, so a thousand meters,
- 5:06three thousand feet. It goes down to the bottom.
- 5:09It's this net that has a wide opening and then different mesh sizes
- 5:12for depending on what you're what you're catching.
- 5:14It's got ~ sometimes it's got two doors on the side to keep the the
- 5:19the the opening open, right, of the net.
- 5:21And then it's got a chain at the bottom.
- 5:24And when it goes down on the bottom,
- 5:25these are bottom trawls. When it goes down at the bottom,
- 5:28the train and the the the with the doors.
- 5:30Weighing it down, as the boat goes at a certain distance or a certain speed,
- 5:35the dredge will actually dredge everything up on the bottom.
- 5:39In part destroying everything on the bottom.
- 5:41So if there's habitat out there,
- 5:43coral sponges, anything like that,
- 5:44that gets destroyed. That gets brought up into the net.
- 5:47And then, of course, the fish that are living there get brought up,
- 5:49whether hiding or not. If as that as that chain goes through the bottom
- 5:55or across the bottom, gets dragged across the bottom,
- 5:57all those fish kind of.
- 5:59Put in there. Now it could be anything.
- 6:00It could be crabs, it could be fish,
- 6:01it could be any kind of vertebrate or invertebrate that's down there,
- 6:05sometimes bigger than you expect,
- 6:06and sometimes smaller than you expect,
- 6:08right? Depending on the mesh size of the net.
- 6:10And so as that comes up, so it gets hauled up through that 3,000 feet,
- 6:15that 1,000 meters, it goes up into the boat and it come and it comes over
- 6:19the deck at like through this A-frame.
- 6:21It comes over the deck and then it gets plopped into like a sorting table.
- 6:25Now I've been a part of these things before,
- 6:27and we've seen.
- 6:29How like it through science. And we've seen how these fish react.
- 6:33A lot of the fish that come up,
- 6:34because they're coming up faster than their their air bladders would allow,
- 6:38you know, the fish's eyes are like popped out of its sockets.
- 6:41there's probably a lot of like I with the one that I was part of,
- 6:44the trial that I the number of trials that I was part of,
- 6:47they were like short, they were like shallower,
- 6:48but the deep sea halls that we brought in,
- 6:50like the an the animals, like the eyes are popped up and everything like that.
- 6:53Some are still alive, like invertebrates are still alive and so forth.
- 6:56But like you're looking through and you're sorting through what you want,
- 6:59what you want to keep. And a lot of them,
- 7:01what what Matthew was telling me in the interview,
- 7:03which I'll hear on Friday, they realized that a lot of them had no market value.
- 7:07So glass sponges, corals, starfish,
- 7:09crabs. The crew just like shoveling back,
- 7:12shoveling them back overboard and without knowing what they were actually
- 7:17destroying. They they generally did not understand what it looked like before
- 7:20because there's no cameras that go down there.
- 7:22They may have thought what was there,
- 7:24but they're probably thinking this is the deep sea.
- 7:25We're not really going over anything big.
- 7:27And maybe if it's one, it's just one little area.
- 7:29But that's what happened, right?
- 7:31That's the image that sits with me when I see this happen or when
- 7:35I hear this happen. Is like you have this swath of,
- 7:38say, however big the net is, say it could be like,
- 7:42I don't know, 20 feet wide. And and you're just scraping the bottom.
- 7:46It could be even bigger. You're just scraping the bottom.
- 7:48So you have these like swaths of.
- 7:51Destroyed habitat as you go through.
- 7:53And so imagine being this fisherman who's on board trying
- 7:59to maximize their catch with as much market value seafood that you
- 8:04can get and throwing all this other thing on board,
- 8:06it starts to you know hit you in the back of your head,
- 8:10like your subconscious. It starts to get to you in that subconscious,
- 8:13right? And so over that time.
- 8:17Matthew started to to think like certain certain things are not right,
- 8:20certain things are right, but we're gonna continue it through this.
- 8:22And then there were two specific moments and two specific projects that he was like,
- 8:27you know what? I can't stand for this.
- 8:30The first, there was a hundred and ten million dollar project to dispose
- 8:35of dredge spoils from the San Francisco Bay directly in prime fishing grounds along
- 8:40the southern coast of of ~ California.
- 8:44So you know, you're in this area,
- 8:45you're a fisherman, you want to maximize the area,
- 8:47you know what's around there. And then all of a sudden,
- 8:50this project, this major project,
- 8:52$110 million, comes through and says,
- 8:54hey, you know what, we're actually gonna take the dredge,
- 8:56like the San Francisco Bay needs to be dredged out,
- 8:58and we're just gonna dump them in this one area.
- 9:00And the fisherman, like, well,
- 9:01hold on a second, you can't do that.
- 9:03So, working together with some of his colleagues in the fishing industry,
- 9:06he helped halt that project for several years until the US Army Corps
- 9:10of Engineers and the EPA agreed.
- 9:12To move the disposal site off the continental shelf.
- 9:15Now, is that great? No, still not great,
- 9:18but not in his area. He won the fight with his colleagues together as
- 9:22a community of fishermen, they won that fight.
- 9:26And that takes a lot, like you're going up against the Army Army Corps of Engineers.
- 9:30It's a federal and EPA. Those are two federal bodies that were a
- 9:33lot stronger than they were today.
- 9:34Now, the second event that really kind of put him more towards.
- 9:40Advocacy are really learning toward what you can accomplish with the advocate,
- 9:43is he served as a fishing industry ~ representative in efforts to oppose
- 9:48to oppose offshore oil and gas leases along the central coast of California.
- 9:52Right? So oil and gas had like in California have a very interesting history.
- 9:57And so, as again, as part of the fishing industry and as a representative,
- 10:01he participated in efforts to ensure that there was no offshore oil
- 10:05and gas leases that were going to be.
- 10:07sold off of the central California coast.
- 10:09So, you know, two projects that were are worth being like,
- 10:13wow, like this is a fisherman who's who's standing up for his right and
- 10:19his like his people's rights, like his other fishermen's rights to fish
- 10:22in nice areas where they can get maximum fisheries,
- 10:25right? And but he's and and and he's still fighting these these things like
- 10:30you know looking at oil and gas
- 10:32Oil and gas leases, that how that can affect fishing,
- 10:34looking at dredging, being dumped in a prime fishing spot.
- 10:37So he's starting to think that,
- 10:39hey, I can get a lot done with this,
- 10:41right? And I think having the,
- 10:44and I can't say this for sure,
- 10:45but having the the the in the back of your mind,
- 10:48your subconscious, the knowing that the effects of what you're doing
- 10:51in this deep-sea trawling game,
- 10:52I think it started to really change the way he thought.
- 10:56And having these, this, these two experiences with advocacy.
- 11:00Could really help think that, hey,
- 11:02I maybe I can do a a lot more for the environment within fisheries.
- 11:06Still get, you know, I'm still standing up for fishers,
- 11:08but like we can actually do a little bit more,
- 11:11right? He went up against the Army Corps of Engineers and the EPA and they won,
- 11:15right? At least for a few years.
- 11:17That's like a that's pretty meaningful in that way,
- 11:20right? You know, it's it's it's the fact that the he didn't come from outside
- 11:24the industry to fight like, you know,
- 11:26for or against fisheries. He came in.
- 11:29From the inside the industry, inside the fishing industry,
- 11:31say, hey, we need to stand up for our fishers.
- 11:33Oil and gas could be really bad for us.
- 11:34We saw that with the BP oil spill.
- 11:36Also, you're looking at you know,
- 11:39the EPA and the Army Corps of Engineers that put out dredge in the middle
- 11:43of a prime fishing spot. No, we're not gonna do that.
- 11:45So all that thinking allowed him to be like,
- 11:48Hey, you know what? I think I can do more.
- 11:51I think I can benefit more. And I wanna stay on the environmental side
- 11:54and really look at what we can do.
- 11:56So he went to work.
- 11:58For Greenpeace International, right?
- 12:00He helped start up their international fisheries campaign.
- 12:03That's pretty good. You know, he's working with NGOs
- 12:05and community-based organizations across Latin America,
- 12:08Southeast Asia, India, Europe,
- 12:11and the US on unsustainable aquaculture campaigns and other and other campaigns like
- 12:16that. That's pretty cool. Then he also led like Greenpeace's participation
- 12:20in the UN conference of straddling fish stocks and highly migratory fish stocks.
- 12:26And in the negoti and and in the negotiation of the UN FAO Code
- 12:29of Conduct for Responsible Fisheries.
- 12:31So now you're looking at international campaigns here.
- 12:34And he worked on and toward the end of his the campaign led,
- 12:38and the end of the campaign led the international effort to secure
- 12:41UN General Assembly moratorium on high-seas drift net fishing.
- 12:44And that was adopted in 1991 and 1992 at the UNS UN General Assembly
- 12:50and entered effect in 1992.
- 12:52That's pretty cool. Like that now you start like you're working with Greenpeace
- 12:55International, having this this advocacy experience from fisheries,
- 13:00now coming into the NGO game with a pretty,
- 13:03I would say, known and getting more and more reputable organization,
- 13:08like in the nineties and in in the ~ in the two thousands,
- 13:11right? And and cause they were a real like activist organization when
- 13:16it first started, right? One of the co-founders was Paul Watson.
- 13:20And so they were really into the ad activism part and they started to
- 13:23get into the advocacy part and you know looking at policy and so forth,
- 13:27right? They still do activism,
- 13:28but a lot of times looking at this,
- 13:30and so the reputation started to get bigger and better within
- 13:33the conservation ~ regime, right?
- 13:34They were within the conservation field.
- 13:36and then so any regularly represented Greenpeace at fisheries
- 13:39and ocean-related internet intergovernmental forums,
- 13:42including the UN FAO Committee on Fisheries meetings,
- 13:45technical and expert consultations.
- 13:47And the UN Commission on Sustainable Development,
- 13:50ICAT, and the 1992 UN Earth Summit.
- 13:54So I guess, you know, looking at from a policy perspective
- 13:58and looking at negotiations and look and his participation in that,
- 14:01Matthew's like getting in there.
- 14:03He's getting his feet wet, so to speak.
- 14:05Right. And then not only is he doing it in the back rooms,
- 14:09like in the meeting rooms, he's also organizing,
- 14:11you know, at this time, organized Greenpeace ships ~ expeditions.
- 14:15To document overfishing and unsustainable fishing practices,
- 14:17more on their activism side, on the Grand Banks,
- 14:19the Georgia's Bank, and the Barents Sea.
- 14:21And then he worked through a number of different campaigns where
- 14:25he became involved in international policy and treaty negotiations.
- 14:29And eventually he ran the entire ocean program for for ~ Greenpeace International.
- 14:34This is how he ended up ended up in Amsterdam,
- 14:37where he still lives today. Now,
- 14:39I I want to just go back into his fishing days.
- 14:44Fishing in a plethora of different industries.
- 14:47And then moving into like after two you know successful campaigns
- 14:53for fisheries industries moves into a larger platform
- 14:59and a larger scale of effect on these policies that he's putting into place
- 15:04or helping, you know, negotiate and form and shape and form.
- 15:07And now
- 15:09He's in charge of the entire Greenpeace International Ocean Program.
- 15:13From fisheries to ocean program.
- 15:16That's incredible. That's like that's pretty incredible.
- 15:20Right? I think, I think it's it's something where you you know
- 15:24you look you're talking about the UN General Assembly.
- 15:26You're talking about ship like planning ship expeditions into some of
- 15:30the most like contested fishing grounds on earth.
- 15:34Right? And he's got a seat in every major international fisheries.
- 15:39form that that it that pretty much existed.
- 15:41So that's like from an in for an individual to do that as part
- 15:46of an organization like this, that's pretty good.
- 15:48And a fisher no less, right? Like I think this is why we need
- 15:52to really understand that advocates and and and people like yourselves
- 15:58who are listening to this who really care about the ocean,
- 16:00you can you can get to a point wherever you want to by hard work
- 16:05And participating in things while doing like your job or anything to really build
- 16:10up your reputation, to really get to where you want to go and be able
- 16:14to ask the question: can I go bigger?
- 16:16Or maybe you want to stay at the same age,
- 16:19or can I do more for the ocean?
- 16:20This story is really starting to ask that question,
- 16:25right? For me, as I look towards a future in ocean conservation.
- 16:29I'm 47 years old. I still got a future,
- 16:31folks. I'm not that old.
- 16:33Right. And and I I think this story is inspiring in in looking at that.
- 16:38Right. And I think think about like this is a fisherman who once shoveled coral
- 16:43overboard and f and fought a like a dredge spoil project from the deck of a boat.
- 16:49Is is now negotiating global moratoriums at at the UN.
- 16:54Like I think that's pretty cool.
- 16:57Right.
- 16:59And then he said, you know what,
- 17:00in early 2000s, he said, I'm gonna I want to do more.
- 17:03Like I the Greenpeace has been great,
- 17:05but I want to really focus on the deep sea.
- 17:08And he co-founded the Deep Sea Conservation Coalition,
- 17:12which is an international coalition of over 80 organizations worldwide promoting
- 17:18protection of the deep sea's biodiversity from harmful activities.
- 17:22And he so he serves right now as the DSCC's political and policy advisor.
- 17:29And he it's aimed at ending deep water trawling primarily on seamount ecosystems
- 17:35on this high seas and is pursued through the UN General Assembly process.
- 17:39So he's again working on this international level,
- 17:42right? Now the organization has successfully advocated through the coalition,
- 17:47has successfully advocated for major changes to international law,
- 17:51policy, and regulations at the UN General Assembly and the UN FAO.
- 17:56And regional fisheries management organizations and other international forums,
- 18:00all focused on protecting deep sea ecosystems on the high seas.
- 18:03Now, I haven't mentioned deep sea mining yet,
- 18:05because this is before 2014. And they continue to do this for the deep sea.
- 18:09Because it's not just deep sea mining that is putting pressure on the deep sea.
- 18:14I want to get that clear. It is there,
- 18:16I mean, it's it's starting to put pressure on it,
- 18:18but that's not what we were worried about at this time.
- 18:21And for the deep sea conservation coalition,
- 18:25that
- 18:25was what they were worried about was deep sea trawling.
- 18:27That's where this is this is where this is where Matthew's experience really comes
- 18:32in. This is where his first concern of putting,
- 18:35you know, glass sponges, corals all over the over the overboard after
- 18:38a trawl started to come into play and started to say,
- 18:41hey, ~ we need to put this into effect.
- 18:43We need to protect the ocean. Now since 2014,
- 18:47the coalition started to take on the deep sea mining issue.
- 18:50Right. But I like
- 18:53I want I want you to think about this.
- 18:56He went from Fisher all over the place to international program
- 19:02or program internet like Greenpeace International program director for the oceans.
- 19:06Like the director of all of it.
- 19:09He left like a stable, high-level role in Greenpeace International,
- 19:13one of the biggest environmental organizations in the world,
- 19:15to go build something new. Aimed squarely at the exact kind of destruction
- 19:20he used to cause.
- 19:21With his own hands, like him and his crew.
- 19:23Like that's a pretty full circle moment right now.
- 19:26Right? So think about like how many years?
- 19:29This is over like like a couple of decades that he's like,
- 19:32We did so much wrong in the deep sea at the time when I started for where when
- 19:37I was fishing. Now I have the chance to really bring it into moment.
- 19:41I've I've put myself in a position where I can really make a difference.
- 19:45And now he's they're taking on the coalition's taking on deep sea mining.
- 19:50Right, started like the they that work started in 2014 for them.
- 19:53And in his own like it in in in Matthew's own words,
- 19:56he's he said he started on the basis of that work,
- 20:00the seamount trawling ~ campaign,
- 20:02that that he eventually got into the issue of deep sea like deep sea bed mining,
- 20:08like himself. Right. That's what he's looking at,
- 20:10right? He's looking at, you know,
- 20:12going through deep sea trawling.
- 20:13Now you got deep sea mining, you know,
- 20:16you're looking on the seabed, you need to
- 20:18clean that up. You make you gotta make sure that's not gonna cause a problem.
- 20:21So he saw like the core of the problem was the same that drove him to find like
- 20:26to to start the like the deep sea conservation coalition in the first place.
- 20:30Like there's almost no baseline data that exists for either seamounts
- 20:34or deep sea beds. Right. So there's no way to know what has been lost until after
- 20:39it's already gone. This is what scientists have been proposing for a long,
- 20:42long time, over a decade.
- 20:45Right. also points like specific gaps.
- 20:47So like looking at connectivity between species.
- 20:49So looking at how these species go from one place to another.
- 20:53So a lot of times I mentioned in past episodes that a lot of the species will,
- 20:58you know, be born or hatch as larvae in one area and the currents will bring
- 21:02it to another area. And that distance can can vary depending on the species from
- 21:06a couple of kilometers or even like a couple of feet all the way to 10,
- 21:1120 kilometers, maybe even more.
- 21:13Right. And looking at how deep sea ecosystems are structured,
- 21:16looking at how long species will live down there,
- 21:18how they reproduce, you know, what they even like what can they even look like
- 21:23as larvae. And and none of that is really well understood in the deep sea.
- 21:28So it's not as if like he just did this,
- 21:30like started the deep sea coalition conservation conservation or coalition
- 21:35on the on like as a way of just like let's just do this for the sake of it,
- 21:38right? He did it because it's the same fight that's followed him since
- 21:42his his trawling days. You know,
- 21:44he spent years proving that trawling was destroying seamount species.
- 21:48we haven't even discovered yet.
- 21:49Deep sea mining raised like the exact same fear.
- 21:53An industry like about to.
- 21:55tear into the seabed or suck up stuff on top of the seabed before scientists
- 22:00can even be like map what lives there.
- 22:03Right. And and we're going to be talking tomorrow.
- 22:05We're going to be talking about what the what what the effect of like trawling
- 22:10on seamounts can do in deep sea and why that's important.
- 22:12And something that really took Matthew to the next level after seeing this study.
- 22:16We're going to focus on that study.
- 22:17And then on Thursday and Friday's episodes,
- 22:21we're really going to dive into deep sea mining.
- 22:22And then the the Thursday one is going to be interesting,
- 22:25or the fr Wednesday one's going to be interesting because I'm really going
- 22:27to dive into what makes
- 22:29A CEO from one of these mining companies look at deep sea mining and say,
- 22:33Hey, you know what? This is a good idea.
- 22:34And then we're gonna go into like what some of the claims are
- 22:38on Thursday's episode and say of deep sea mining and why they're
- 22:42not really bothering anybody, because apparently the deep sea is just
- 22:46a desert and there's really not that much going on there,
- 22:48which we know is not true. So we're gonna go through all that.
- 22:50And of course, we're gonna end the week with an interview with Matthew Gianni.
- 22:54talking about a lot of the stuff that we talked about today,
- 22:56but you're going to hear it straight from his mouth.
- 22:58And it's going to be an incredible,
- 23:00incredible week of looking at the deep sea.
- 23:02So I want you to follow this podcast if you haven't followed before
- 23:06on your favorite podcast app. And of course you can also check
- 23:08out Ocean Decoded Live on YouTube.
- 23:10I've started Monday to Thursday doing a live show talking about
- 23:14all these different things that are happening around the ocean because
- 23:16I can't keep it all and do it all on here on this podcast,
- 23:20but I can do it.
- 23:21as well. I can do it on on YouTube as well.
- 23:23So ~ be sure to check that out.
- 23:26~ I wanna thank you for joining me on today's episode of the How
- 23:29to Protect the Ocean podcast. I'm your host,
- 23:31Andrew Lewin. Have a great day.
- 23:32We'll talk to you next time and happy conservation.