Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Emergency Pod: Did NCUA Just Vote On It's Trump Mandated Restructuring Plan?
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another
- 0:02episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:04I guess this is an emergency podcast, using that term loosely.
- 0:10I follow some sports podcasts and with it being free agent time, they're
- 0:15doing a lot of emergency podcasts when the Minnesota Vikings signed certain
- 0:19free agents, which has been cool.
- 0:21So I'm in that emergency podcast mode.
- 0:24So I'm sitting here minding my own business And I get an email from the
- 0:31Federal Register which I subscribe to.
- 0:33I subscribe to notifications that are put in the public register for
- 0:37NCUA and other federal agencies.
- 0:40And I saw That this related to N.
- 0:44C.
- 0:44U.
- 0:44A.
- 0:44So I downloaded the P.
- 0:46D.
- 0:46F.
- 0:47And it indicated that there was a meeting that occurred.
- 0:51And I thought, is this for the upcoming March board meeting?
- 0:54And no, it was a meeting that they held today at 10 a.
- 0:59m.
- 0:59on N.
- 1:00C.
- 1:00U.
- 1:00A.
- 1:00personnel actions and the notice to the federal register, which
- 1:04says it will be published in the federal register tomorrow.
- 1:07But this is what they filed stated that at 10 a.
- 1:10m.
- 1:11today, March 12th, the NCOA board met, and they met in a closed
- 1:18status because there were things that they couldn't say publicly.
- 1:21And it says the NCOA board unanimously determined that agency business required
- 1:25holding a closed meeting with less than seven days notice to the public.
- 1:31And that no earlier notice of the meeting was possible.
- 1:34Generally speaking they always have to say that because that's
- 1:36how they comply with the law.
- 1:38They have to say, we couldn't have told you earlier and this was an emergency.
- 1:42Matters to be considered, personnel closed pursuant to Exemption 2,
- 1:46and it explains who the contact person is, et cetera, et cetera.
- 1:49Over its history, NCUA has gone from having open board meetings, followed
- 1:54by closed board meetings, and different boards at NCUA view the legal rights
- 2:02for what you can do at a closed meeting, what you can do by notation vote, etc.
- 2:08differently.
- 2:09Some boards had a very robust, closed.
- 2:13For example this personnel closed pursuant to exemption to item that is
- 2:18here Yolanda wheat back when she was on the NCAA board had this on every
- 2:22board meeting, just in case she wanted to propose that somebody be moved.
- 2:27She was pretty aggressive in that regard.
- 2:29So every board meeting that came out when Yolanda wheat was on the
- 2:32board would have the open agenda and then would have the closed agenda
- 2:36since Todd Harper has been back.
- 2:39There have been very few closed board meetings, which means those things
- 2:43are being done by notation vote.
- 2:45And so you have the things that are done in the sunshine in the open meeting.
- 2:50You have things that are done in the closed meeting with less
- 2:53sunshine, because they have legal reasons to not be disclosed.
- 2:58So you could be talking about a credit units being conserved, and
- 3:00you could be talking about the camel ratings, or you could be talking
- 3:03about promoting someone, or you could be talking about firing someone.
- 3:07That's where these personnel items come in.
- 3:09Or, with the recent deadlines that I saw that OPM has created for agencies
- 3:15to put their restructure plans together, my guess, and this is a guess, I've not
- 3:21heard from anybody particularly at NCUA.
- 3:24And I don't want to hear from anybody at NCUA because I don't want
- 3:27anybody who is in the know To be accused of having told me anything.
- 3:31I'm doing this based solely on what I'm reading on federal agencies and
- 3:35solely what I know about how NCUA runs.
- 3:38So there was a personnel item done at the, at a closed board meeting.
- 3:43They didn't tell the world about it until after it happened.
- 3:46And it could have been somebody was promoted, although I
- 3:50doubt that's what it is.
- 3:51I truly believe this links to a restructure plan, whether that's
- 3:55buyouts whether that's riffs.
- 3:59Reductions in force.
- 4:00My guess is it would be buyouts that they're offering certain
- 4:03things to try and hit a target.
- 4:05Cause as I believe I mentioned in a previous podcast Kyle Helpman
- 4:10at GAC indicated that the.
- 4:15That the excuse me, Kyle help and indicated that staff he could
- 4:20expect a staff cut of about 100.
- 4:23Now did all of those come from the Trump buyout of 8 months?
- 4:27Probably not.
- 4:28My guess is that something was proposed today.
- 4:31And I also am guessing that since they've.
- 4:35Had zero closed board meetings in at least, I want to say it's at least a
- 4:40year, but I think it's at least two years that Kyle Haltman probably took it down
- 4:44the path of doing this by notation vote.
- 4:46But if you read the trade press, there was an excellent article in
- 4:50CU times where there's a release.
- 4:53Referencing a release that Todd Harper put out about him vehemently disagreeing
- 4:59with Kyle Hauptman changing the call reports for billion dollar credit unions.
- 5:03It's very clear to me, the honeymoon at the end to a board level is over.
- 5:07And so it's possible that Kyle Hauptman tried to do this by notation vote.
- 5:12And the way notation votes work is you can do it by notation vote.
- 5:19And you could end up with a two, one vote and everybody
- 5:21agrees to do bone notation vote.
- 5:23You could have a unanimous vote and everybody agrees to do notation vote.
- 5:27But if one board member decides they want to pull it to the table, they can say, I
- 5:33don't agree to put this by notation vote.
- 5:35And so it's possible that the two D's said we want to do this at the table.
- 5:40And this is basked in the statement that this was done unanimously.
- 5:45And so Houtman said, okay, I agree.
- 5:47We'll do this.
- 5:48We'll take this to the board and we'll vote to have this meeting.
- 5:51That's that may have happened, or they could have just decided to do it at
- 5:55a closed meeting because it needed discussion, which would make sense.
- 5:58If you're talking buyouts and the ramifications of those, you think there
- 6:01should be a robust dialogue on the closed record about what the board is thinking.
- 6:06So my guess is NCOAs have the it's most challenging or exciting board
- 6:11meeting for staff and for the board.
- 6:14Will they be making announcements relative to this?
- 6:17Will they be sending this over to OPM?
- 6:20Will they be sending offers out to staff, et cetera, et cetera?
- 6:24All of these are unknown, but some of those, my guess is about to happen.
- 6:29So anyway, I will do a post on LinkedIn about this as well, but I
- 6:35believe something big as it relates to the restructuring of NCOA may have
- 6:41happened at the board table just.
- 6:44An hour and a half ago, or who knows, maybe it's still going on as we speak, if
- 6:49they can't reach consensus and remember there's two Democrats and one Republican
- 6:55Kyle Hauptman is trying to comply with the wishes of the Trump administration.
- 7:03But he doesn't have a second vote, but will the Democrats agree to do some things
- 7:09that might make sense for NCOA or not?
- 7:12We may never know all the details, but we'll start to see some things
- 7:15trickle out when we see who's.
- 7:18who's leaving, how quickly they're leaving, or if this was just a
- 7:22promotion or reassignment of people, which, by the way, makes absolutely
- 7:25no sense in all this chaos, maybe this is much ado about nothing.
- 7:30But the fact that they dropped this out there, boom, we have
- 7:33to have this meeting signals something strange going on at NCUA.
- 7:38All right, that's it.
- 7:39This is Mark Treichel and if I have more on this later, I will let you know.