Latest / Kublai Khan and the Mongol Rule of China — Fexingo History / Kublai Khan's Coinage Crisis: Bronze vs Paper Money
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot about Kublai's military campaigns — the invasions of Japan, Vietnam, Java — but today I want to look at something that affected every single person in his empire: money. Specifically, Kublai's attempt to control the economy through a unified currency system. Luna: Right, because he was ruling over a patchwork of economies — Song China with its bronze coins, the Silk Road using silver and silk, and the Mongol steppe with its own traditions. Lucas: Exactly. And he had a bold idea — paper money. The Yuan Dynasty's 'chao' was supposed to be the only legal tender. But it wasn't that simple. In fact, Kublai also minted bronze coins, creating a confusing dual system that lasted through his reign. Lucas: To understand the problem, we have to go back to the Song Dynasty. The Song had pioneered paper money, the 'jiaozi', because their bronze coin economy was incredibly heavy — imagine carrying a hundred coins just to buy a meal. But by the time Kublai conquered the south, the Song currency system was collapsing under hyperinflation and counterfeiting. Luna: So he inherited a mess. Lucas: A complete mess. And Kublai's initial solution was pragmatic: he allowed local currencies to keep circulating while he introduced the chao gradually. But his advisors, especially the Confucian scholar Liu Bingzhong, pushed for a unified standard. So in 1260, the same year Kublai became Great Khan, he issued the first Yuan paper money — the 'zhongtong chao'. Luna: Wait — did he also mint coins at the same time? I thought paper was the main thing. Lucas: He did. The first Yuan coins, called 'zhitong yuanbao', were cast in brass and bronze starting in 1260 as well. They were meant to supplement the paper, especially for small transactions. But the problem was that the coinage wasn't consistent — different mints produced coins of varying weight and purity. Lucas: And the paper money itself had issues. The chao was supposed to be convertible into silver at a fixed rate, but the government kept printing more to cover its expenses — those huge military campaigns cost a fortune. By the 1280s, the chao had lost about eighty percent of its value. Luna: So it was inflation, basically. The same thing that happens when governments print too much money today. Lucas: Exactly. Marco Polo, who visited China in the 1270s, was amazed by paper money — he wrote that 'all the people of the Great Khan's dominions are obliged to receive it' — but he also noted that the government could simply declare old notes invalid and force people to exchange them at a loss. That was a hidden tax. Lucas: Meanwhile, in the regions — especially Yunnan and the old Song territories — people hoarded bronze coins and silver. The chao was accepted in the capital, Dadu, but in the provinces, merchants demanded hard currency. Luna: Marco Polo also mentioned that Kublai used paper to pay his officials and soldiers, right? Lucas: He did, and that forced the paper into circulation. Soldiers would get paid in chao, then spend it at local markets. But the problem was that the paper had no intrinsic value — it relied entirely on trust in the government. And when that trust weakened, the whole system wobbled. Luna: It sounds like a really early experiment in fiat currency. Lucas: It was, and in some ways it was remarkably successful. For decades, the chao circulated alongside coins, and foreign travelers like William of Rubruck and Ibn Battuta noted that it worked surprisingly well for long-distance trade. But the dual system created constant confusion — what was the exchange rate between a zhitong yuanbao coin and a chao note? The government set official rates, but black markets thrived. Lucas: Kublai also tried to impose the chao in tributary states — Goryeo in Korea, and even in Đại Việt after the invasion attempts. But those regions resisted, preferring their own coinage or barter. In the end, Kublai's monetary policy was a mixed legacy: he standardized currency across much of China, but the inflation and distrust sowed seeds for the Yuan's later economic collapse. Luna: It's fascinating how something as mundane as currency can tell us so much about how an empire actually functioned — and failed. Lucas: Absolutely. And speaking of keeping things functioning — we don't run ads on this show. That's a deliberate choice. But it means we rely on listeners who find value in these conversations. If today's episode was useful to you and you want to keep it ad-free, buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo helps. Luna: Yeah, it's a small way to make a big difference. Lucas: So, back to the money — one of the most interesting details is how Kublai's government tried to control counterfeiting. They used a special paper made from mulberry bark, and each note had a serial number, a seal, and even a warning: 'counterfeiters will be executed.' Luna: Execution for counterfeiting — that's harsh. Lucas: It was, but counterfeiting was rampant. The Song had already struggled with it, and the Yuan's notes were easier to forge because they used woodblock printing. There are records of entire rings producing fake chao in remote areas. The government responded with periodic recalls — issuing new notes and invalidating old ones, forcing people to exchange them at a discount. Lucas: Meanwhile, in the markets of Dadu, you'd see a mix: a farmer paying taxes in grain, a merchant trading silk for silver ingots, and a shopkeeper accepting chao notes for a bowl of noodles. It was a chaotic but remarkably resilient system. Luna: Did the bronze coins ever become the dominant currency again? Lucas: Not under Kublai. His successors tried to revive coinage, but by the mid-14th century, the paper money had collapsed completely, and the Yuan fell apart. After the Ming took over, they initially tried paper again, but eventually reverted to silver as the main currency — a system that lasted into the Qing. Lucas: So in a way, Kublai's experiment with paper money was ahead of its time — but it also taught later dynasties a hard lesson about inflation and trust. Luna: I never realized how much the Mongol economy was shaped by these practical decisions — not just conquest. Lucas: That's the thing about Kublai — he wasn't just a warrior. He was an administrator trying to hold together the largest land empire in history. And currency was one of the tools he used to do it.