Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 247. “Matt”er of Fact: Coaching on Feedback and Q&A
Transcript
- 0:04Matt Abrahams: At some point in our lives, most of us have benefited from
- 0:07the advice and guidance from a coach.
- 0:09Today we're going to hear from two coaches I know quite well.
- 0:13My name is Matt Abrahams, and I teach strategic communication at
- 0:16Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:18Welcome to this special Quick Thinks episode of Think
- 0:21Fast Talk Smart the podcast.
- 0:24This episode is very different than any we have ever done.
- 0:28You'll have an opportunity to learn from three versions of me, and
- 0:32afterward you'll be able to do the same.
- 0:35But before we get to that, on December 1st, we're opening up our Think Fast
- 0:39Talk Smart online learning community designed to help people around the
- 0:44world sharpen communication skills in a personalized, collaborative way.
- 0:48Our subscription-based learning community is open to anyone and includes
- 0:52incredibly useful tools and features like asynchronous learning lessons, interactive
- 0:57learning plans, and quests, book clubs, and not one, but two AI coaching tools.
- 1:04Like many of you, we at Think Fast Talk Smart have been experimenting with AI
- 1:07and I'm thrilled to share the results.
- 1:09With the help of some very talented developers we've co-created two AI tools.
- 1:14One is a digital twin created by sounding board that has been trained
- 1:18on my writings and coaching practice.
- 1:20We'll call him Coach Matt.
- 1:22You can have a vocal conversation with him and he sounds just like me.
- 1:26It's like having a phone call with me to get the advice you want.
- 1:29The other AI tool is a text-based chat bot that has been trained on all of
- 1:33our Think Fast Talk Smart episodes.
- 1:35We call it Chat Mattt.
- 1:37You just type in your queries and Chat Matt types back answers for you.
- 1:42I'm super excited about these tools and I thought it would be fun to share them
- 1:46with you so you can learn from them and see how useful they can be to you.
- 1:50So in this episode, I'm going to have a conversation with Coach
- 1:53Matt to get coaching on how best to interact with Chat Matt.
- 1:57I'll then follow Coach Matt's advice when I interact with Chat Matt.
- 2:01Okay.
- 2:03That is the longest setup I have done for any interview.
- 2:07Let's get started with my conversation with Coach Matt.
- 2:10Welcome, Coach Matt.
- 2:11I look forward to our conversation and learning from you.
- 2:14Coach Matt: Hi Matt.
- 2:14Welcome back.
- 2:15I'm excited to work with you again.
- 2:16What's one speaking moment you are preparing for today?
- 2:20Matt Abrahams: So Coach Matt, I need your advice and guidance.
- 2:22I'm interviewing a text-based chat bot I help create that has been
- 2:26trained on all of our Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast, episodes.
- 2:30I'm a bit nervous for my conversation because I'm not sure how it will go.
- 2:35How can I feel more confident?
- 2:37Coach Matt: Alright, let's think about this for a sec. That's fascinating.
- 2:40You're essentially interviewing your own creation.
- 2:42I can hear both excitement and some uncertainty in your voice.
- 2:45You've built something impressive, but now you're stepping into uncharted
- 2:48territory to see how it performs.
- 2:50Let me ask you this.
- 2:52When you think about sitting down with this chat bot, what
- 2:55specifically has you feeling nervous?
- 2:57Is it more about whether the technology will work as expected, or are you worried
- 3:01about how you'll come across during the conversation, or something else entirely?
- 3:05I'm curious because understanding the root of that nervousness will
- 3:08help us figure out the best way to get you feeling confident and ready.
- 3:12Matt Abrahams: So I think I'm nervous both about the technology working or
- 3:16not, and I'm, I'm a little nervous to, to see what the results are.
- 3:20Are they gonna be accurate?
- 3:21Are they gonna be what I think they should be?
- 3:23Coach Matt: Got it.
- 3:23I hear you.
- 3:24So you've got this dual anxiety, the tech performance piece, and then the
- 3:28bigger question of whether your creation actually reflects what you hoped it would.
- 3:32Here's what I'm thinking.
- 3:33You're dealing with what I call future-focused anxiety.
- 3:36You're worried about outcomes you can't control right now.
- 3:39The technology might hiccup, the responses might surprise you,
- 3:42and that's actually pretty normal when you're testing something new.
- 3:45Let me offer you a reframe that might help.
- 3:48Instead of thinking of this as a high stakes test where everything
- 3:51needs to be perfect, what if you approached it more like a curious
- 3:54conversation with a colleague?
- 3:56You're not evaluating whether you're a good creator.
- 3:58You're simply exploring what this tool can do.
- 4:01Before we dive into some specific techniques, tell me, when you
- 4:04imagine the conversation going well, what does that look like to you?
- 4:08What would make you feel like, yes, this worked?
- 4:10Matt Abrahams: I love the idea of the reframe.
- 4:12I, I think success for me is that I get results that are actionable.
- 4:16That make sense, and I think would benefit everybody.
- 4:18Coach Matt: Hmm.
- 4:19Okay.
- 4:19I love that.
- 4:20You're focused on value and impact.
- 4:22That's exactly where your energy should be.
- 4:24That tells me you're approaching this from the right place.
- 4:27Here's a quick confidence tool I want you to try.
- 4:29Since you're worried about both the tech and the results, let's use
- 4:32what I call productive preparation.
- 4:35Instead of trying to predict what might go wrong, spend a few
- 4:37minutes thinking through what you'll do if things go really well.
- 4:40Picture yourself getting those actionable, sensible results that could help everyone.
- 4:44This does two things.
- 4:46It gets your brain focused on success rather than failure, and it actually
- 4:50prepares you to make the most of good moments when they happen.
- 4:53Also, remember, you know this content better than almost anyone.
- 4:57You've been living and breathing Think Fast Talk Smart.
- 5:00Trust that knowledge.
- 5:01The chat bot learned from you.
- 5:02So in many ways, you're the expert in the room.
- 5:04What do you think?
- 5:05Does that reframe feel helpful or is there another angle of this
- 5:08nervousness we should tackle?
- 5:10Matt Abrahams: That reframe is really helpful.
- 5:12Focus on what can happen that's positive and really put my energy there.
- 5:16Let's say Chat Matt does not perform as well as I wanted it to.
- 5:20I'll have to give constructive feedback to the people who developed it.
- 5:23I want to give direct feedback, but I don't wanna offend
- 5:25them or hurt their feelings.
- 5:27How should I approach that situation if it comes up?
- 5:29Coach Matt: You, you're being really thoughtful about this and that
- 5:32care for the developer's feelings actually shows great leadership.
- 5:35Let me give you a structure that can help you be both direct and respectful.
- 5:39It's called what, so what, now what?
- 5:41And it's perfect for giving constructive feedback without creating defensiveness.
- 5:45Here's how it works.
- 5:46Start with the what.
- 5:48Describe what you observed without judgment.
- 5:50Then the so what, explain why it matters to the bigger picture.
- 5:54Finally, now what, suggest a path forward that feels collaborative.
- 5:58For example, what?
- 6:00I noticed the chatbot struggled with some nuanced questions about handling anxiety.
- 6:04So what?
- 6:06Since that's such a core part of our content, we wanna make sure
- 6:09people get reliable guidance there.
- 6:11Now what?
- 6:12I'd love to work with you to identify specific episodes or concepts we
- 6:16could emphasize in the training.
- 6:18See how that lands as helpful rather than critical.
- 6:21You're focusing on the work, not the people, and you're positioning yourself
- 6:25as a partner in making it better.
- 6:27Wanna try crafting one example using this structure?
- 6:29Matt Abrahams: You know, Coach Matt, that's a great structure one I really
- 6:32like and I love your advice and I'm gonna take care of the practice in a little bit.
- 6:36But I'd really like your advice on one more thing.
- 6:39When I sit down with the chat bot to type in some questions, can you gimme
- 6:43a suggestion for a good question that I could ask to test to see if it really
- 6:48does know its communication advice?
- 6:50Coach Matt: Here's what I'd suggest.
- 6:51Ask it something that requires it to synthesize multiple concepts
- 6:55and apply them to a real scenario.
- 6:57Something like, I'm about to give a presentation to senior executives
- 7:01who seem skeptical about my proposal.
- 7:03I'm feeling anxious and I only have two minutes to make my case.
- 7:07What's your advice?
- 7:09This question is perfect because it tests whether the chat bot can
- 7:12recognize the anxiety component and offer practical tools.
- 7:16A good response should touch on managing nerves using a clear structure
- 7:19like problem, solution, benefit, and maybe even audience focused language.
- 7:24If it just gives generic advice or misses those layers,
- 7:26you'll know there's work to do.
- 7:28What do you think?
- 7:29Does that feel like it would give you a good read on whether
- 7:31Chat Matt really gets it?
- 7:33Matt Abrahams: I think that would be great.
- 7:35I think it would give me a very good read, and I'm very
- 7:37impressed by your detailed answer.
- 7:39Thanks so much for that, and do me a favor.
- 7:42Give me a goodbye that I can share with other people.
- 7:45How would you close out our conversation?
- 7:47Coach Matt: I'm gonna create a card for you with that goodbye,
- 7:49so you can easily share it.
- 7:51There you go.
- 7:52And thank you for catching that I used what, so what, now what, in my
- 7:55feedback, that's exactly the kind of awareness that's going to serve you well.
- 7:59You're more ready than you think you are.
- 8:00Good luck with Chat Matt.
- 8:03Matt Abrahams: Thank you very much, and that goodbye message is fantastic.
- 8:08We've now heard helpful advice from Coach Matt.
- 8:11Let's switch to the keyboard and have a typed conversation with Chat Matt.
- 8:16Since many of you are listening on the go and not watching, we've used
- 8:19a text to voice tool so you can hear what Chat Matt typed back to us.
- 8:26Chat Matt, I'm about to give a presentation to senior executives
- 8:29who seem skeptical about my proposal.
- 8:32I'm feeling anxious and I only have two minutes to make my case.
- 8:35What's your advice?
- 8:37Chat Matt: First, I want to thank you for sharing a really important and common
- 8:40concern, feeling anxious before addressing a skeptical high stakes audience.
- 8:46Let's jump right in.
- 8:47If you only have two minutes, my advice is to set very clear boundaries for
- 8:51yourself and your message from the start.
- 8:53Think about what your bottom line is.
- 8:56What's the one thing you want those senior executives to remember or walk away with?
- 9:00You don't have time to tell them everything.
- 9:02Instead, focus on delivering your high level overview as
- 9:05succinctly and clearly as possible.
- 9:07Now, let's talk anxiety.
- 9:09What I'm really hearing you say is that the stakes feel high,
- 9:12and that's totally normal.
- 9:14In fact, upwards of 85% of people feel nervous in these sorts of situations.
- 9:19Here's what I recommend.
- 9:21Before you present, do something to help you be more present oriented.
- 9:26For example, take a short walk, listen to a favorite song, or even
- 9:32more practically, if you're pressed for time, take a few deep breaths.
- 9:37These techniques help manage your symptoms of anxiety, allowing you to focus on
- 9:42your message rather than your nerves.
- 9:44When you get up there, start by setting expectations.
- 9:49For example, you might say, I'm really excited to share my proposal.
- 9:55I'd like to take just two minutes to outline the key points, and
- 9:58then I welcome your questions.
- 10:00This approach signals confidence, controls the flow, and sets respectful
- 10:05boundaries with a skeptical audience.
- 10:07And finally, remember, you don't need to answer every question in advance, but
- 10:12you should anticipate the toughest ones.
- 10:15Take some time to reflect on the questions you're likely to
- 10:17get and practice your answers.
- 10:20This preparation not only builds confidence, but also ensures you're
- 10:24ready if the conversation shifts quickly.
- 10:27So here's my summary.
- 10:29Clarify your main point.
- 10:31Set clear boundaries.
- 10:33Use presence techniques to tame anxiety and anticipate questions.
- 10:38You've got this and I'm excited for you to make your case.
- 10:42Matt Abrahams: Thanks, Chat Matt.
- 10:44Your advice about my approach is very good, but I don't feel like you
- 10:48gave me insight into how to craft my proposal in a short amount of time.
- 10:52Without a strong proposal, I'll be in trouble.
- 10:55Can you please provide a bit more advice on how I can be more clear and compelling
- 10:59in my two minutes I have for my proposal?
- 11:03Chat Matt: Thank you for that question, and I really appreciate
- 11:06your honesty and drive to get this right under time pressure.
- 11:10So let's jump right in.
- 11:12When you've only got a couple of minutes to craft and deliver
- 11:14your proposal, clarity and focus are absolutely essential.
- 11:19Here's what I'd recommend based on my experience and
- 11:22the insights from our guests.
- 11:24First, start by clearly understanding the mission or priorities of the person
- 11:28or group you're making the request to.
- 11:30That's your North star.
- 11:32If you're not speaking directly to what matters to them, it's
- 11:35game over before you begin.
- 11:37Second, in your two minutes, you'll want to map out these core ingredients.
- 11:43State the big problem.
- 11:45Briefly outline the larger problem or opportunity you
- 11:48want to be part of solving.
- 11:50This helps your audience see the significance right away.
- 11:54Narrow your focus.
- 11:55Zero in on the specific piece of that problem you, and only you,
- 12:00are uniquely positioned to address.
- 12:03Show the opportunity.
- 12:04Clearly convey that this sub problem hasn't been solved yet, but you have
- 12:08the insight or approach to tackle it.
- 12:11Present concrete actions.
- 12:13Boil your approach down to three to five crisp action steps.
- 12:18You don't need all the details, just the highlights that demonstrate
- 12:21you've thought this through.
- 12:23Paint the future state.
- 12:25End with a quick summary of what things will look like once you succeed.
- 12:29What's the positive future you're proposing?
- 12:32And remember, because attention is our most precious commodity, parachuting in
- 12:37with an engaging start, a provocative question, a vivid statistic, or
- 12:42a quick story can make all the difference in those opening seconds.
- 12:47So if I were to summarize for you, focus on concision, relevance, and precision.
- 12:53Think, what's their mission?
- 12:56What's the big problem?
- 12:58How do I and my approach uniquely fit?
- 13:01What will I do?
- 13:03What does success look like?
- 13:05Hit those beats and you'll make your two minutes count.
- 13:08Thanks for giving me the opportunity to clarify, and I wish you the
- 13:12best of luck with your proposal.
- 13:14Let's get you set up for that future state of success.
- 13:18Matt Abrahams: A big thank you to both Coach Matt and Chat Matt.
- 13:21Every time I work with either of them, I'm amazed at what is
- 13:25possible with AI technology.
- 13:27I hope you learn something from our coaching session about giving feedback
- 13:30and asking insightful questions.
- 13:32Now it's your turn.
- 13:34I invite you to try out Coach Matt and Chat Matt on our Think Fast
- 13:37Talk Smart Learning Community.
- 13:39You can sign up at fastersmarter.io/learning.