Latest / Epic Fury: The US-Iran War Podcast / Iran War Day 67: Strait of Hormuz Clash, Ceasefire Under Fire, Conflicting US–Iran Claims
Transcript
- 0:16The ceasefire nearly broke on Monday.
- 0:19Iran fired 2 missiles at AUS Navy destroyer entering the
- 0:23Strait of Hormuz, or so Iran state media reported. the US
- 0:27denied it. The United States confirmed it
- 0:30destroyed at least six Iranian fast attack boats during the
- 0:33confrontation. Each side denied the other's
- 0:36account in its entirety. Only two US merchant vessels
- 0:40crossed the Strait on the first day of the guided transit
- 0:42operation. Not a return to commercial
- 0:45normalcy, but a test of intent and capability.
- 0:48The South Korean operated vessel caught fire after an explosion
- 0:52in the same waterway. The shipping insurance industry
- 0:55said it has no idea how the US transit plan is being
- 0:58coordinated with Iran, if at all.
- 1:01And hours after formally sending Congress letters declaring that
- 1:03hostilities with Iran have terminated under the War Powers
- 1:06Act, Trump stood before a Florida audience and said
- 1:09directly. You know we're in a war.
- 1:12It is Tuesday, May 5th, 2026, day 67 of Operation Epic Fury.
- 1:19Both sides traded fire in the Strait of Hormuz yesterday, or
- 1:23traded competing accounts of it. The ceasefire is intact, a name
- 1:27and under the severest operational stress of its four
- 1:29week existence and the gap between what is being publicly
- 1:33declared about this conflict, hostilities terminated, very
- 1:36positive discussions, confidence building measures and what is
- 1:39physically happening in the 34 mile wide waterway that carries
- 1:4320% of the world's oil has never been wider or more
- 1:46consequential. This is episode 67 of Epic Fury,
- 1:50the US Iran War podcast. Follow on Spotify and Apple
- 1:55Podcast to stay with this story as it develops.
- 1:58Let's get into it. Begin with Monday's
- 2:00confrontation in the Strait, because it was the most violent
- 2:03day between the two sides since the ceasefire was announced 4
- 2:06weeks ago, and because what happened in those hours changed
- 2:09the operational reality of this conflict in ways that cannot be
- 2:12reversed by morning briefings. CENTCOM established what it
- 2:16called an enhanced security area South of the normal commercial
- 2:19shipping lanes on Monday morning and announced it had begun
- 2:22guiding vessels through the Strait.
- 2:23Iran's armed forces responded immediately with a published
- 2:26warning. Any foreign armed forces, and
- 2:29particularly the aggressive U.S. Army, will be attacked if they
- 2:32attempt to approach or enter the Strait of Hormuz.
- 2:35That warning was issued in the morning hours.
- 2:38By midday, Iranian state media was reporting that AUS Navy
- 2:42destroyer had been struck by two Iranian missiles as it attempted
- 2:45to enter the Strait in what Iran characterized as a violation of
- 2:49traffic and shipping security. U.S. central Command denied
- 2:52categorically that any of its warships had been struck by
- 2:55Iranian fire. Iran denied the US account of
- 2:59events. the US confirmed it destroyed at least six small
- 3:03Iranian fast attack boats during the confrontation.
- 3:06Iran denied that account as well.
- 3:09Both governments filed publicly incompatible accounts of the
- 3:12same events in the same waterway over the same hours.
- 3:16Claims and denials that cannot both be factually accurate.
- 3:19The specific facts about who fired what, in what sequence,
- 3:23and with what result are contested and irreconcilable.
- 3:26As of this morning, CENTCOM denied any US warship was
- 3:30struck. Iran denied the US account of 6
- 3:33destroyed Iranian boats. the US confirmed 2US merchant ships
- 3:37crossed the Strait. Iran denied those crossings
- 3:40occurred. It is worth noting that
- 3:42competing accounts from 2 governments with strong and
- 3:45opposing strategic interests and how each event is characterized
- 3:48are not equivalently reliable on every specific claim.
- 3:52But the fact that both sides are disputing each other's accounts,
- 3:55rather than one side acknowledging events the other
- 3:57denied, means The public record on Day 67 consists of claims
- 4:01denials and the physical reality that a South Korean vessel
- 4:04caught fire after an explosion in the Strait and that the
- 4:07ceasefire has never before produced military action of this
- 4:10scale between the two parties. What is not contested?
- 4:13The Strait of Hormuz is now an active military confrontation
- 4:17zone between the US Navy and the Iranian Revolutionary Guard
- 4:20Navy, and this confrontation is occurring under a ceasefire that
- 4:24both sides continue to nominally claim is still in force.
- 4:27The Enhanced Security area, the guided transit operation, the
- 4:31Iranian warning, the missile claim and its denial, the boat
- 4:34destruction claim and its denial.
- 4:37All of it adds up to a waterway where the ceasefire's nominal
- 4:40existence is being tested in real time against the physical
- 4:43reality of two armed forces with fundamentally incompatible
- 4:46sovereign claims operating in the same 34 mile wide channel
- 4:50simultaneously. CN NS International Diplomatic
- 4:53Editor Nick Robertson reported that the future of the ceasefire
- 4:56could hinge on what happens in the Strait in the coming days.
- 4:59That assessment from one of the most experienced regional
- 5:02correspondents covering this conflict reflects A widely
- 5:06shared view among analysts watching Monday's events.
- 5:09The ceasefire has survived 4 weeks of significant stress, the
- 5:13IRGC seizure of the Tuska, the IRGC firing on tankers it had
- 5:17itself previously cleared, Iran's 2 written proposals being
- 5:20effectively rejected, and the April 22nd near expiry resolved
- 5:2490 minutes before the midnight deadline.
- 5:27It has never previously survived a day in which the US and Iran
- 5:30exchanged competing claims of directly firing on each other's
- 5:34military vessels in the same narrow channel.
- 5:39The guided transit operation produced exactly 2 US merchant
- 5:42ship crossings on its first day. Not a surge of commercial
- 5:46traffic, not a return to normal shipping through the world's
- 5:50most important oil waterway. 2 vessels.
- 5:53Iran denied even those two crossings occurred, claiming no
- 5:57American merchant ships had transited under its maritime
- 6:00regime. The shipping insurance
- 6:02industry's reaction to the operations first day captured
- 6:05the commercial reality with precision, Simon Kay, global
- 6:09director of reinsurance at North Standard, which provides
- 6:12liability insurance for a significant portion of the world
- 6:15shipping fleet, told CNN. There is no specificity about
- 6:18which countries have asked for this humanitarian mission, nor
- 6:21how this may be coordinated with Iran, if at all.
- 6:24That is the verdict of the organization that prices the
- 6:27risk of putting commercial vessels through the Strait.
- 6:30The North Standard assessment is not a political position.
- 6:34It is an underwriting decision when the organization that sets
- 6:38insurance rates for straight transit says it does not know
- 6:40how the US operation is coordinated with.
- 6:42Iran is saying that the risk level has not changed in a way
- 6:46that allows them to price a lower premium.
- 6:48No lower premium means no commercial search.
- 6:51Ships do not route through a war zone without affordable
- 6:55insurance. Iran is maintaining A sufficient
- 6:58perception of risk to keep merchant traffic to small
- 7:00numbers even under direct American naval protection, one
- 7:04maritime security analyst told CNN.
- 7:07The perception alone, regardless of whether the IRGC acts on any
- 7:11given day, is keeping commercial vessels from routing through the
- 7:14Strait. Commercial confidence is the
- 7:16center of gravity of the straits functioning as a commercial
- 7:20waterway. The two vessel crossing is a
- 7:22demonstration. That the US can technically move
- 7:24ships through is not evidence that commerce has returned to
- 7:28the Strait. The gap between demonstrating
- 7:30intent and restoring commercial confidence is the full measure
- 7:34of the guided transits first day and the challenge it will need
- 7:37to overcome in the days ahead to produce the commercial and
- 7:40political result it was designed to deliver.
- 7:42Iran is maintaining a perception of risk that keeps merchant
- 7:45traffic to small numbers, 1 maritime security analyst told
- 7:49CNN. Commercial confidence is the
- 7:52center of gravity of the straits functioning.
- 7:55A Strait where Iran fires missiles at AUS destroyer,
- 7:58whether or not the destroyer was struck, whether or not Iran's
- 8:01account is accurate, is a Strait where commercial confidence is
- 8:04not returning, insurance rates are not coming down, ships are
- 8:08not routing through the two vessel crossing is not the
- 8:12opening of Hormus. It is a demonstration of intent
- 8:15that has not yet produced a commercial outcome.
- 8:18The Tuska crew release was the one genuine confidence building
- 8:22development of Monday, and its significance is amplified by
- 8:25what else happened on the same day.
- 8:27Pakistan flew 22 crew members from the Tuska, the Iranian
- 8:31cargo ship whose engine room the US Navy disabled by gunfire on
- 8:35April 20th in the Gulf of Oman, to Pakistan on Sunday night.
- 8:39Pakistan described the operation as a confidence building measure
- 8:43coordinated with the United States and Iran.
- 8:46The crew will be handed to Iranian authorities.
- 8:49The Tuska itself remains in US custody.
- 8:52Iran had demanded the immediate release of the Tuska and its
- 8:55crew from the moment of the seizure on April 20th.
- 8:59They called the seizure piracy, armed aggression and a ceasefire
- 9:02violation in letters to the UN Security Council.
- 9:06The crews released through Pakistani mediation does not
- 9:08resolve the Tuska question. The ship is still held, but it
- 9:12addresses the immediate human dimension of the seizure. 22
- 9:16people who have been in American custody since April 20th are
- 9:19going home through Pakistani mediation.
- 9:22That is a real outcome, small, specific and human, that both
- 9:27governments were willing to coordinate in the middle of a
- 9:29day when their respective naval forces were exchanging competing
- 9:32claims of fire in the same waterway.
- 9:35The coexistence of the two Scott crew release and the straight
- 9:38military confrontation on the same Monday morning is the most
- 9:41striking single illustration of the wars dual track reality that
- 9:44the conflict is yet produced on one track.
- 9:47Pakistan coordinating a crew handover described a confidence
- 9:51building measure. Both governments actively
- 9:53participating. Iran seafarers coming home on
- 9:56the other track. IRGC missiles.
- 9:59US destroyer denials. 6 Iranian boats claimed destroyed.
- 10:03Contested accounts across every wire service.
- 10:05The ceasefire under the most direct stress of its four week
- 10:08existence. Both tracks are happening
- 10:10simultaneously and on the same day.
- 10:14Neither cancels the other. The dual track reality of this
- 10:17war. Diplomatic engagement through
- 10:20Pakistan and military confrontation in the Strait and
- 10:23not breaking down. It is operating in both
- 10:26directions simultaneously at full intensity.
- 10:29Trump sent formal letters to Congress on Friday declaring the
- 10:32hostilities with Iran have terminated the legal position
- 10:35the administration has taken to justify crossing the 60 day war
- 10:39powers deadline without congressional authorization.
- 10:42Hours later, speaking in Florida, he said.
- 10:45You know we're in a war. Because I think you would agree
- 10:48we cannot let lunatics have a nuclear weapon.
- 10:52That juxtaposition, formally declaring to Congress that
- 10:55hostilities have terminated, then telling a Florida audience
- 10:58that, you know, we're in a war is the administration's dual
- 11:01register strategy applied to its own constitutional obligations
- 11:06to Congress. It is saying this is over the
- 11:08clock, stopped. We do not need authorization to
- 11:12its base, it is saying. We are in a war, and we.
- 11:15Are winning it. Both statements were made within
- 11:18hours of each other on Friday. Both were made by the same
- 11:22president. Whether the legal formulation or
- 11:24the political formulation is the accurate description of what is
- 11:27happening in the Strait of Hormuz on Monday is answered by
- 11:30the question of how you characterize Iran firing
- 11:33missiles at AUS warship while a ceasefire is nominally in force.
- 11:37The Washington Post, ABC News and Ipsos publish a poll on
- 11:40Friday showing that only 36% of Americans believe the United
- 11:44States did the right thing in using military force against
- 11:47Iran. 67 days and past the ceasefire, past the written
- 11:51proposal exchange, past the guided transits contested
- 11:55launch. Only one in three Americans is
- 11:57willing to say the use of military force against Iran was
- 12:00the right decision. That is not a minority fringe
- 12:03position. It is a majority of the American
- 12:06public that has absorbed 67 days of war, a 50% petrol price
- 12:10increase, a closed straight, 13 American service members dead, a
- 12:14congressional quagmire accusation, a war powers
- 12:17deadline crossed and reached the conclusion that the force was
- 12:20not the right decision. Trump responded to the polling
- 12:23by questioning its methodology. He said the question was biased
- 12:27against him, that polls on Iran are totally fake, and that even
- 12:31a question about whether Iran should have a nuclear weapon
- 12:33would not substantially change his numbers.
- 12:36His skepticism about poll methodology is not without any
- 12:39basis. The precise wording of questions
- 12:41about complex military decisions does affect responses in ways
- 12:45that are difficult to control. But 36% is not a figure produced
- 12:49by one outlets idiosyncratic methodology if replicated across
- 12:54different polling organizations, and no contradictory poll has
- 12:57been cited by the administration.
- 12:59It describes a country in which the president is prosecuting a
- 13:02war that the majority of his own citizens, looking back, do not
- 13:06endorse. The Trump administration sent
- 13:08letters to Congress on Friday formally declaring the
- 13:11hostilities with Iran have terminated the legal claim
- 13:14needed to cross the 60 day war powers threshold without
- 13:17authorization within hours. Speaking in Florida, Trump said.
- 13:21You know we're in a war. That juxtaposition, termination
- 13:25of hostilities to Congress, acknowledgement of war to a
- 13:28Florida audience, Is the administration managing its
- 13:31constitutional exposure and its political base through different
- 13:34registers simultaneously? To Congress, the clock stopped,
- 13:39no authorization needed. To the base, the war is ongoing,
- 13:43worth fighting, and you know it. Both statements are politically
- 13:47necessary. Neither is fully compatible with
- 13:50the other. And on Monday, AUS destroyer in
- 13:54the Strait either was or was not fired upon by Iranian missiles.
- 13:58And either outcome has implications for at least one of
- 14:00those two positions. The 31 Iranian tankers carrying
- 14:0453,000,000 barrels of oil trapped in the Persian Gulf are
- 14:07the most specific available quantification of what the
- 14:10blockade has actually achieved as an economic instrument, Axios
- 14:14reported the figure, citing Pentagon officials.
- 14:17At current oil prices, 53,000,000 barrels represents
- 14:21approximately $5 billion in crude oil value sitting in the
- 14:24hulls of ships that cannot unload their cargo, cannot
- 14:27return to Iranian ports for reloading, and cannot sail to
- 14:31buyers because the US blockade intercept them on route.
- 14:34The tankers are warehouses that cannot be opened.
- 14:37The oil is revenue that cannot be collected.
- 14:41The blockades economic impact operates through three
- 14:44simultaneous channels. The first, Iran cannot export
- 14:48the oil it has. 31 tankers worth of accumulated production is
- 14:52sitting in the Gulf rather than being delivered to buyers.
- 14:56The second, Iran cannot produce new oil at normal rates because
- 14:59it cannot clear existing production from storage
- 15:02facilities and tanker capacity. The pipeline backs up behind the
- 15:05block distribution system. The card island storage filling
- 15:09up is the land based equivalent of the trapped tankers
- 15:11production backing up behind a block distribution system.
- 15:15The third, the US Global Blockade intercept, shadow fleet
- 15:18tankers attempting to move Iranian oil beyond the Strait,
- 15:22removing Iran's primary mechanism for routing around the
- 15:25hormones closure that has served it throughout the sanctions era.
- 15:28All three channels of the blockades economic impact are
- 15:31operating simultaneously and compounding each other.
- 15:35The 53,000,000 barrel figure is also a measure of how long the
- 15:38blockade has been effective. 48 days of blockade since April
- 15:4213th at Iran's pre war production of approximately 3
- 15:46and a half million barrels per day with a large percentage
- 15:49blocked from export produces A trapped cargo of this scale.
- 15:53The figure is not static. Every day the blockade
- 15:57continues, more barrels are added to the accumulation.
- 16:00Every day those tankers sit in the Gulf without unloading,
- 16:03Iran's fiscal position deteriorates further.
- 16:06The economic cost of not making the nuclear concession is
- 16:09compounding daily toward the threshold where it exceeds the
- 16:13political cost of making it if it is not already crossed it.
- 16:16The South Korean operated vessel caught fire after an explosion
- 16:20in the Strait of Hormuz on Monday.
- 16:22South Korea's Foreign Ministry confirmed the ship was carrying
- 16:2524 crew members, including six South Korean nationals.
- 16:29All crew were reported safe. The vessel will be towed to a
- 16:32nearby port for inspection and repairs.
- 16:36The cause of the fire with a missile strike, drone minded
- 16:39nation or accident had not been officially confirmed as of this
- 16:42episode's recording. South Korea is one of Iran's
- 16:46most significant pre war oil customers and is not a party to
- 16:49the US Iran conflict in any military sense.
- 16:53A South Korean vessel Catching Fire in the straight in the
- 16:55middle of a confrontation between the US Navy and the IRGC
- 16:59is the kind of event that draws additional navies, additional
- 17:02diplomatic protests and additional international
- 17:05attention to the straight at a moment when the operations
- 17:08commercial credibility is already being questioned.
- 17:11Seoul's Foreign Ministry was monitoring the situation closely
- 17:14and said it would carry out investigations once the vessel
- 17:17was towed to port. Monday's confrontation in the
- 17:22Strait did not produce a formal breakdown of the ceasefire.
- 17:25No new American bombs fell on Iranian territory, no Iranian
- 17:30missiles. Whatever fired whatever target
- 17:32on Monday landed on American military bases across the
- 17:35region. The ceasefire in its most
- 17:38minimal and technical definition held through the day, but the
- 17:42architecture that has sustained it, the implicit understanding
- 17:45that both sides are exercising meaningful restraint in exchange
- 17:48for a diplomatic process through Pakistan, is under the most
- 17:51severe operational stress it has faced since the agreement was
- 17:55announced on April 8th. The ceasefire is being held
- 17:58together by three things simultaneously.
- 18:01The proposal exchange through Pakistan which is now bi
- 18:04directional with both sides sending written documents and
- 18:07Iran reviewing AUS response. The two Scott crew release a
- 18:12small but real coordinated confidence building action that
- 18:15both governments participated in on Monday and the private track
- 18:18that trump confirmed on Thursday.
- 18:20The one only he and a handful of others understand which he
- 18:24described on Sunday as producing very positive discussions.
- 18:28Those three things are the architecture of a ceasefire that
- 18:30is still by the narrowest of margins.
- 18:33Holding set against them are IRGC missile claims denied by
- 18:37CENTCOM, US fast boat destruction denied by Iran, a
- 18:41South Korean vessel on fire in a straight 36% public support for
- 18:45the war, and a shipping insurance industry that says it
- 18:48has no idea how the guided transit operation is being
- 18:51coordinated with Iran, if at all.
- 18:53The 2 Scott crew is free and on their way to Pakistani
- 18:56authorities. The proposals are flowing in
- 18:59both directions through Pakistan, The Strait is
- 19:02producing military confrontations and the ceasefire
- 19:06by the narrowest of margins and in the most technical of census,
- 19:09is still intact. If this podcast is helping you
- 19:12make sense of what's happening, take 2 seconds to leave a five
- 19:15star rating on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
- 19:18It makes a huge difference to how many people find the show.
- 19:22And if you want the deeper breakdown of what's really going
- 19:24on and where this is heading, you can unlock the premium
- 19:27episodes directly in Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
- 19:31This has been episode 67 of Epic Fury the US Iran war podcast
- 19:37episode 67. Iran fired at AUS destroyer. the
- 19:42US destroyed Iranian fast boats. Both sides deny the others
- 19:46account. 2 merchant ships cross the Strait.
- 19:50The insurance industry has no idea how it's being coordinated
- 19:54with Iran. The 2 Scott crew is free.
- 19:57Trump told Congress hostilities terminated, then told Florida
- 20:01we're in a war. Only 36% of Americans think the
- 20:04war was the right call. 53,000,000 barrels of Iranian
- 20:08oil are sitting in the Gulf in tankers that cannot reach their
- 20:11buyers and cannot unload. The ceasefire holds a name under
- 20:16gunfire, under competing claims and under the narrowest of
- 20:20possible margins. We will be back very soon.