Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Oh look it's the end of the world again
Transcript
- 0:00From the unexplained to the mundane, come join us on a journey to the fringe.
- 0:12Hello and welcome to Journey to the Fringe.
- 0:15Kind of like how you can pickle most anything.
- 0:18So too can you fringe up any topic.
- 0:21We are your podcast and or pickling hosts, Taylor and Chelsea, sometimes it's hard to
- 0:24remember which.
- 0:25Here today, take somewhat of a mundane topic.
- 0:29Chelsea, I think this is an interesting topic.
- 0:32We're going to see how it goes.
- 0:33Okay, I thought we were here to pickle.
- 0:36Maybe later and in any event, pickling a lot of the time is sitting and waiting so you
- 0:40could get your pickling done beforehand.
- 0:42Okay.
- 0:43But no, in fact, right now we're here to discuss people who have predicted the end of the world.
- 0:48But unlike those cowards who give up on it after one attempt, I have strictly decided
- 0:54to look at people who just kept on going and say, I'm sure second, third or onward times
- 1:01the charm in predicting the end of the world.
- 1:03I mean, are we talking end the world as we know it?
- 1:07Like the earth?
- 1:08Or are we talking like a mass extension event?
- 1:11For the most part, we're usually talking about the ones that I found, they're raptures.
- 1:16So the end of the Christian world, I guess would be a good way to put it.
- 1:19Okay.
- 1:20Well, I don't know that that's actually going to happen.
- 1:23Well, that's not what everybody thinks Chelsea.
- 1:26And in any event, I like to think that these guys get better with age and they just keep
- 1:30going at it, not like those cowards with the 2012.
- 1:33They kind of gave up on 2012.
- 1:36As soon as it happened, they should have kept going.
- 1:38I was thinking the earth exploding into like oblivion and the earth is no longer the world
- 1:43is ending.
- 1:44Oh, you know what?
- 1:45I'm acting like I've never heard this before.
- 1:48They don't predict that.
- 1:49Anyhow, let's look at this.
- 1:51We'll see if anybody got it right and we're just going to keep going from there.
- 1:55So Chelsea,
- 1:56There's got to be someone that gets it right.
- 1:57I've got three different people we're going to look at.
- 1:59The first one's kind of outside and there's not a lot of info on it.
- 2:03I just had to include this story because it includes Chinese tourists and cowboy hats.
- 2:07I love that.
- 2:09And I have to ask, is one of them a pope?
- 2:11You know what?
- 2:12I didn't convert everything from Chinese and there's not enough information.
- 2:15He may have ordained himself a pope.
- 2:17Yeah, I was like, do the Pope speak Chinese?
- 2:20Yeah, no, none of these pokes speak Chinese.
- 2:24Some of them, the very concept of another language is confusing them.
- 2:29None of them seem to know the guy.
- 2:32So the first man we're going to look at his name is Hanming Chen.
- 2:35He started a group called Chen Tao, which is the true way, also known as God's salvation
- 2:41church.
- 2:42He founded this in 1955 in Taiwan.
- 2:44At first it was associated with UFOs, but later claimed that the group had been misrepresented
- 2:49as a New Age UFO cult and it was later known as God's salvation church.
- 2:53Oh, this sounds familiar.
- 2:55Chen was a former professor who claimed to be an atheist until he joined a religious
- 3:00cultivation group that dated back for two generations to the original female founder,
- 3:05teacher, Yuxia Chen.
- 3:07But he broke with the group headed by the third generation teacher in 1993.
- 3:10Oh, sorry.
- 3:11I said earlier that it was founded in 1955.
- 3:14That's when he was born.
- 3:15Okay, same thing.
- 3:16So he broke with the group headed by the third generation teacher in 1993, created with another
- 3:21fellow cultivator, Tao Hongma, their own groups.
- 3:25It was later when he broke with Ma and decided to move to the United States that new elements
- 3:29such as pseudoscientific information and cosmology and flying saucers as well as Christian
- 3:33motifs of the prophecies of the end and the Great Tribulation were introduced to the group.
- 3:38In Taiwan, the group was originally officially registered as the Chinese Soul Light Research
- 3:44Association.
- 3:45And when the group moved to the United States from Asia, it was registered in the U.S. as
- 3:48God's Salvation Church.
- 3:50It first relocated to San Dimas, California, and then it moved to Garland, Texas.
- 3:56And I love it.
- 3:57The reason they chose Garland, Texas is because it sounds like Godland.
- 4:01That's as good as a reason as any.
- 4:06And I found a way back machine copy of their website with a few of their key points.
- 4:10And I actually love it.
- 4:12They had contact information, including phone numbers for the people you can speak to about
- 4:16this group.
- 4:17I never actually phoned them.
- 4:18My guess is the phone numbers don't work anymore, but I'm going to leave that out.
- 4:22Just I don't want to have some people being harassed out there.
- 4:26But anyhow, this is their website.
- 4:27And it starts out with the topic, the headline, Chelsea, the supernatural power of God's
- 4:31super high technology hyphenated, but not high technology, super dash high technology.
- 4:40For the purposes of the salvation of human beings and witnessing the great power of God's
- 4:44creation of the universe and planets, this is what their mission statement is.
- 4:47To help exercising demons and suppressing devils and join with God in Buddha, the messengers
- 4:52from the kingdom underground in the operating of devil sweeping.
- 4:55Trindu's people to contact and meet the human great ancestors who are more than 8,000
- 5:00years old, the Christ and Amitabha Buddha with physical body in the underground kingdom
- 5:06of eternal life and the UFO.
- 5:08To help construct super high tech equipment to eliminate various natural disasters and
- 5:12diseases and reconstruct people's imperfect inheritance and physical disposition such
- 5:17as the solar storms, typhoon, earthquakes, hurricanes, floods, droughts, cancer, AIDS
- 5:21and so on.
- 5:22To use scientific and practical means that is the super high tech equipment to communicate
- 5:27with the world of Buddha and God and the extra celestial beings in every planet of the solar
- 5:32system to prepare for God's physical bodies dominance over the earth and recover the
- 5:36egalitarian force of justice that all living beings are created equal.
- 5:40People are urged to brave up the responsibility of self-salvation.
- 5:44Weirdly, kind of sounds like some of the stuff we learned about the Falun Gong and very broken
- 5:48English.
- 5:49This couldn't have been Google Translate because it came from the year 2000.
- 5:52Then it gives contact information for Professor Han Ming Chen, the one who prepares the way
- 5:56for God.
- 5:57I love that.
- 5:58You think that's more of a cultural thing that it has similarities in that?
- 6:02I do in fact because Christian cults in Asia are a specific thing that are fundamentally
- 6:09different from Christian cults in the rest of the world.
- 6:12At least from what I've learned about them.
- 6:14I find them absolutely interesting because they always seem to fuse Buddha into it too.
- 6:19But anyhow, this group that come to Garland, Texas in August of 97, Chen immediately predicts
- 6:24when they get there.
- 6:25March 31st, 1998, God would be seen on channel 18 all across North America.
- 6:32At the time, the group had roughly 140 to 160 members and members purchased more than
- 6:3620 homes in an upper middle class South Garland neighborhood.
- 6:39Like those neighborhoods, these followers were white-collar professionals, some of whom
- 6:43were reportedly wealthy and they dressed in white or cowboy hats and drove luxury cars
- 6:48according to a Dallas Morning News article from the time.
- 6:51Can you imagine living in that neighborhood?
- 6:54The weirdest Chinese Christian cult.
- 7:00The Garland Police Department understanding the potential gravity of the situation coordinated
- 7:04resources including religious studies professor Lonnie Cleaver and were on standby when the
- 7:09international media began arriving in what had previously been an upper middle class
- 7:13section of the Dallas suburb.
- 7:15One person stated, its presence unsettled many Garland residents.
- 7:18Can you believe this?
- 7:20Chinese people and cowboy hats just walking around.
- 7:23No, I couldn't ever.
- 7:24Fancy cars.
- 7:25And the predicted appearance did not occur, so March 31st, 1998 comes and goes, nothing
- 7:31happens.
- 7:32Surprisingly, the group gets very confused.
- 7:34The Chen Tao leader announced that he obviously had a misunderstanding with God's plan.
- 7:38A lot of the members quietly return home.
- 7:40Chen, however, offered to be stoned or crucified for the event.
- 7:45Ah, got it wrong.
- 7:47Nobody took him up on the offer though.
- 7:49I think mostly because you know that would likely have to be charged with murder.
- 7:52Oh yeah, in the United States for sure.
- 7:54And the funny thing is with this as well, Chen Tao seems to have effectively fallen apart
- 7:58after its leader's prophecies went unfulfilled.
- 8:01Immediately after the failed prediction, many of the members had to return to Taiwan owing
- 8:05to visa problems, which I think makes a lot of sense.
- 8:08If you think the world's gonna end, you're not gonna go for a long term visa.
- 8:12No, you're not.
- 8:14So screwed up and they had to leave.
- 8:16That's thinking about it logically.
- 8:18Why would you pay more?
- 8:20Exactly.
- 8:21That's actually gonna come up in the, oh no, sorry.
- 8:23That was on one of the ones I deleted.
- 8:25There's one guy who wouldn't return the money because he said, well, for people who are
- 8:28donating to advertise the end of the world, and he's like, well, it's gonna end later
- 8:31anyway, so I'm gonna spend the money on that.
- 8:33Exactly.
- 8:34It's a sound reasoning.
- 8:36So roughly two thirds of the people abandoned the group and later the remaining members moved
- 8:39to Lockport, New York and continued to wear cowboy hats but began stating that a war between
- 8:44China and Taiwan was going to lead to a nuclear holocaust that would result in much death.
- 8:50Also God would arrive in a God plane, which is in quotation marks, to save the members
- 8:55and then they originally state that this was going to occur in 1999.
- 9:00But again, they revise it to a later date.
- 9:02Unfortunately, I couldn't actually find anything about that though.
- 9:05What is the significance of the cowboy hat?
- 9:08I don't know, but I love it.
- 9:12More cults should wear cowboy hats.
- 9:15It's just stylish.
- 9:16There doesn't need to be a reason.
- 9:17I generally dislike cowboy hats because I feel they're a cultural appropriation of a group
- 9:22who has a hard time farmers by upper middle class people for fun.
- 9:26But no, this is perfectly fine in my mind.
- 9:29Cult, take it.
- 9:30It's fantastic.
- 9:31Totally acceptable.
- 9:32I just thought that's a fun story.
- 9:36Cowboy hats.
- 9:37Oh, that was a good one.
- 9:38Willing to crucify.
- 9:39That's where it goes.
- 9:40No, I like that one.
- 9:42Next one we're going to talk about is William Miller.
- 9:44So William Miller is born on February 15th, 1782 in Pittsfield, Massachusetts.
- 9:49Holy crap, that's a long time ago.
- 9:51In 1803, Miller married Lucy Smith.
- 9:53These nets, too, were actually kind of connected.
- 9:55It has some real world implications, these ones, actually.
- 9:57And they moved to a nearby hometown of Pultney, where he took up farming.
- 10:02While in Pultney, Miller was elected to a number of civil offices, starting with the
- 10:05office of constable.
- 10:06In 1809, he was elected the office of deputy sheriff and at unknown date was elected to
- 10:11be the justice of the peace.
- 10:13He was recently well off owning a house, land, and at least two horses.
- 10:17I really liked that that was included in the Wikipedia for this guy.
- 10:20Horses.
- 10:21It's notable.
- 10:22They couldn't get a square number, but they knew it was at least two.
- 10:28Shortly after his move to Pultney, Miller rejected his Baptist heritage and became a
- 10:32deist.
- 10:33In his biography, Miller records his conversion.
- 10:36A deist is basically there is a God, but they don't really interact with us.
- 10:39So there's no point in having any religiousness.
- 10:42Quote, I became acquainted with the principal men in the village, Pultney, Vermont, who
- 10:46were professedly deists, but they were good citizens and of a moral and serious department.
- 10:51They put into my hands the works of Voltaire, Hume, Thomas Paine, Ethan Allen, and other
- 10:57deistical writers.
- 10:58So he kind of gets this idea that there's no real reason to have a strong connection
- 11:02with God.
- 11:03However, then the war of 1812 breaks out.
- 11:05He gets involved in this.
- 11:06He gets transferred to the 30th Infantry Regiment in the regular army of the United States
- 11:10in the rank Lieutenant.
- 11:11He saw his first action at the Battle of Plattsburgh, where vastly outnumbered American
- 11:16forces overcame the British.
- 11:17This is a quote from him.
- 11:18The fort I was in was exposed to every shot.
- 11:21Bombs, rockets, shrapnel, shells fell as thick as hailstones.
- 11:25One of these many shots exploded two feet from him, wounding three of his men and killing
- 11:29another, but Miller survived without a scratch.
- 11:32Miller came to view the outcome of his battle as miraculous and therefore, odds with his
- 11:36deistic view of a distant God far removed from human affairs.
- 11:40He later wrote, quote, it seemed to me that the Supreme Being must have watched over the
- 11:44interests of this country in a special manner and delivered us from the hands of our enemy.
- 11:50So surprising as a result, against such odds did seem to me like the work of a mightier
- 11:55power than man, end quote.
- 11:57So almost dies, doesn't get scratched at all, so becomes religious again.
- 12:01After the war, Miller returned to Pultney.
- 12:03Shortly after, moved with his family to Low Hampton, where he purchased a farm.
- 12:07About this time period, Miller was deeply concerned with the question of death and an
- 12:10afterlife.
- 12:11This reflection opened upon his own mortality, followed his experience as a soldier in the
- 12:15war, but also the recent deaths of his father and sister.
- 12:18Miller apparently felt that there were only two options possible following death, annihilation
- 12:22and accountability, neither of which he was comfortable with.
- 12:25As soon as he moved to Low Hampton, Miller took a tentative step toward regaining his
- 12:29Baptist faith.
- 12:30At first he attempted to combine both publicly espousing deism, while simultaneously attending
- 12:35his local Baptist church.
- 12:37His attendance turned to participation when he was asked to read the Day's Sermon during
- 12:41one of the local minister's frequent absences, and his participation changed to commitment
- 12:45one Sunday when he was reading a sermon on the duties of parents and became choked with
- 12:50emotion.
- 12:51Following his conversion, Miller's deist friends soon challenged him to justify his
- 12:55new faith.
- 12:56He did so by examining the Bible closely, declaring to one friend, quote, if he would
- 12:59give me time, I would harmonize all these apparent contradictions to my own satisfaction
- 13:04or I will be a deist still, end quote.
- 13:06Miller commenced with Genesis 1-1, studying each verse and not moving on until he felt
- 13:10the meaning was clear.
- 13:12In this way he became convinced that the time of Christ's second coming was revealed in
- 13:16Bible prophecy.
- 13:17Basing his calculations principally on Daniel 814, quote, unto 2300 days, then shall the
- 13:24sanctuary be cleansed, end quote.
- 13:27Miller assumed that the cleansing of the sanctuary represented the earth's purification by fire
- 13:30at Christ's second coming, then using the interpretive analysis of the day-year principle.
- 13:36Typically they think the day means year, so they can just substitute it.
- 13:39Miller and others interpret a day in a prophecy to read not as 24-hour period, but rather
- 13:44as a calendar year.
- 13:45Further, Miller became convinced that the 2300 day period started in 457 BC with the
- 13:51decree to rebuild Jerusalem by Arteserxes, one of Persia.
- 13:55There's too many X's in that for me to be comfortable pronouncing it.
- 14:00Simple calculations then revealed that this period would end in 1843.
- 14:05Miller records quote, I was thus brought to the solemn conclusion that in about 25 years
- 14:10from that time 1818 all the affairs of our present state would be wound up, end quote.
- 14:15It's always really nice too when they can get it wrapped up in their lifetime so that
- 14:19they can make another prediction if it fails.
- 14:22That end, most people think they are living through the end times.
- 14:24Like it is weird that every generation seems to have people like that.
- 14:29Having it predicted within your lifetime has its pros and cons.
- 14:32You got away with what you're going to go with obviously.
- 14:36If you predict it for everybody that's following you at the time and you predict it for after
- 14:40you're gone, you might be in the clear.
- 14:42Whereas if it's within a couple years, you might be around still probably.
- 14:47And then you're safe to make another prediction.
- 14:50And that's what I always liked.
- 14:51Isaac Newton did his own analysis of the Bible.
- 14:54He was born in the 1700s, or sorry 1600s he lived in the 1700s.
- 14:58But he predicted the end of the world from his reading of the Bible to be 2060.
- 15:02So he's one of those people that's bold enough to say, yeah, I'm going to predict it out
- 15:05here.
- 15:06It's not during my life.
- 15:07I'm with him on it.
- 15:08If I was going to predict it, I mean, I might just put it out there by the end of this
- 15:12episode.
- 15:13I'm going to think on it while you're talking.
- 15:14Oh, I'm sorry.
- 15:15Please let the world go longer than the end of this episode.
- 15:18Well, we'll see.
- 15:19But yeah, so what do I think?
- 15:21Am I going to go bold or am I going to go, oh, we'll see.
- 15:25We'll see.
- 15:26We'll see.
- 15:27Okay.
- 15:28So, as he was convinced of his calculations by 1818, he continued to study privately until
- 15:321823 to ensure his correctness of his interpretation.
- 15:35In September of 1822, Miller formally stated his conclusion in a 20-point document, including
- 15:40Article 15, quote, I believe that the second coming of Jesus Christ is near even at the
- 15:44door, even within 21 years, on or before 1843, end quote.
- 15:49Miller did not, however, begin his public lecturing until first Sunday in August of
- 15:531831 in the town of Dresden.
- 15:55In 1832, Miller submitted a series of 16 articles to the Vermont Telegraph, a Baptist newspaper.
- 16:01The Telegraph published the first of these on May 15th, and Miller writes of the public's
- 16:05response, quote, I began to be flooded with letters of inquiry, respecting my views and
- 16:10visitors flocked to converse with me on the subject, end quote.
- 16:13In 1834, unable to personally comply with many of the urgent requests for information
- 16:18and the invitations to travel and preach that he received, Miller published a synopsis of
- 16:22his teachings in a 64-page tract with the lengthy title Evidence from Scripture and
- 16:27History of the Second Coming of Christ, about the year 1844, exhibited in a course of lectures.
- 16:33And I also like, because he predicted 1843, but he also put in his title of the lecture
- 16:38on or about the year 1844.
- 16:41Like just plain and safe.
- 16:43You gotta, if it's within your lifetime.
- 16:45And it's getting closer, like he's been predicting this for 12 years now.
- 16:48You gotta give it a little wiggle.
- 16:49Like a, gotta, like a year at least in or about a year.
- 16:53So this gives rise to a religious movement called Millerism, which is just his last name.
- 16:58From 1840 onward, Millerism was transformed from an obscure regional movement into a national
- 17:03campaign.
- 17:04Despite the urging of his supporters, Miller never personally set an exact date for the
- 17:08expected second advent.
- 17:09However, in response to their urging, he did narrow down the time period to some time
- 17:14in the Jewish year beginning in the Gregorian year 1843, stating, quote, my principles in
- 17:20brief are that Jesus Christ will come again to this earth, cleanse, purify, and take possession
- 17:24of the same with all the saints sometime between March 21st, 1843 and March 21st, 1844.
- 17:31So Chelsea, I don't know if you know your history, but March 21st, 1844 passes and
- 17:37the world does not end.
- 17:38Hold on, it passed.
- 17:39In fact, nothing really important happens in that time period.
- 17:43It passed, you say?
- 17:45Yes.
- 17:46Okay.
- 17:47Wow.
- 17:48It wasn't prepared for that.
- 17:49And further discussion and study resulted in the brief adoption of a new date.
- 17:51And I love this.
- 17:53His outside date was March 21st, 1844.
- 17:56If you're going to amend your end of the world date, Chelsea, what are you going to go with?
- 17:59I'm still thinking on it.
- 18:02Feel like there needs to be a three in it.
- 18:04Feel that's the end of the world type number.
- 18:06I'm going to go like...
- 18:07Okay, I'm going to stop you here.
- 18:09He moved it three weeks, April 18th, 1844.
- 18:12Okay.
- 18:13He's done a different calendar and he's like, oh, just use the wrong calendar.
- 18:16No, I would probably push it out another at least 20 years, at least.
- 18:21He wanted to be around for it.
- 18:22At this point, I know you probably don't remember this from history class all that
- 18:26well, but April 18th, 1844 also two passes without much happening and most importantly,
- 18:31no return of Christ as we are aware.
- 18:33Yeah, this passes and Miller responds publicly by writing, quote, I confess my error and acknowledge
- 18:38my disappointment.
- 18:39Yes, I still believe that the day of the Lord is near even at the door and quote.
- 18:44And I love just looking back at this guy who lived roughly 200 years ago that yeah, he's
- 18:49he was not that close, but he was sure of it.
- 18:52I love that he had such a fear of death.
- 18:54Yeah, he like wanted it to be like, he wanted to take everyone with him.
- 19:00Yeah.
- 19:01Sorry guys, I didn't predict it right.
- 19:02You're all still alive.
- 19:03Hopefully it'll come in a few weeks.
- 19:07Yeah, in August of 1844 at a camp meeting in Exeter, New Hampshire, Samuel S. Snow presented
- 19:13a message that became known as the seventh month message or the true midnight cry.
- 19:18Don't know who this guy is, but it is important for the story.
- 19:21And a discussion based on the scriptural typology.
- 19:24Snow presented his conclusion still based on the calculations that came from Miller
- 19:30that the date is actually the 10th day of the seventh month of the present year.
- 19:36Or which he calls October 22nd, 1844.
- 19:40Dave refused to even leave the year.
- 19:42Like they're just keeping it tight.
- 19:44We can't see that far.
- 19:47After the failure of Miller's expectation of October 22nd, 1844.
- 19:51And I, sorry, I should say that like this is in addition to what Miller has been talking
- 19:55about.
- 19:56So they come to the agreement of understanding under Millerism that October 22nd is going
- 19:59to be.
- 20:00You know, Chelsea again, October 22nd came and went.
- 20:04This became known to the Millerites as the great disappointment.
- 20:09Herem Edson recorded that quote, our fondest hopes and expectations were blasted and such
- 20:14a spirit of weeping came over us and I never experienced before.
- 20:17We wept and wept till the day dawn.
- 20:20And quotes because they had to keep going on a living.
- 20:24Following the great disappointment, most Millerites simply gave up their beliefs.
- 20:28Some did not.
- 20:29And viewpoints and explanations proliferated.
- 20:32Miller initially seems to have thought that Christ's second coming was still going to
- 20:36take place that quote, the year of expectation was according to prophecy, but that there
- 20:40might be an error in Bible chronology, which was of human origin that could throw the dates
- 20:45off somewhat and account for the discrepancy.
- 20:48Miller never gave up his belief in the second coming of Christ.
- 20:51You just get pushing it back two weeks.
- 20:53Really?
- 20:54Yeah.
- 20:55He's like, maybe that's how far they were off.
- 20:56Like there was just a miscommunication when they're writing.
- 20:58They were pen pals and they didn't account for the time between.
- 21:01I enjoyed that one.
- 21:04That one was good.
- 21:05And estimates of Miller's followers, they vary anywhere from 50,000 to 500,000 during
- 21:10kind of his like peak.
- 21:12Wow.
- 21:13Miller's legacy includes the Advent Christian church with 61,000 members today and the seventh
- 21:18day Adventist church, which has over 19 million members.
- 21:21So those are both offshoots of Millerites.
- 21:23What?
- 21:24What?
- 21:25I guess he was he like took he was a was a like, what do you call him?
- 21:30Giving sermons.
- 21:31Both these denominations have a direct connection with Millerite and the great disappointment
- 21:35of 1844 and a number of other individuals who ties the Millerites founded various short
- 21:40lived groups, which we don't really need to talk about.
- 21:43But yeah, Miller died on December 20th, 1849, still to the end, so the second coming was
- 21:49imminent.
- 21:50Just kept going with it.
- 21:52Love that.
- 21:53You know what it was missing?
- 21:54The end of the world.
- 21:55Cowboy hat.
- 21:56No, you know what the cowboy hat as we envision it wouldn't have been invented by that point.
- 22:01We'd have to do some collective historical work for that.
- 22:04But okay, I can live with it then.
- 22:07We're going to move on from Miller to a man by the name of Charles Taze Russell.
- 22:12He was born February 16th, 1852, as foretold by Miller.
- 22:17Maybe maybe he did.
- 22:18We didn't write it down.
- 22:20Who knows in Allegheny, Pennsylvania.
- 22:22Now Russell lived for a time in Philadelphia before moving to Pittsburgh where they became
- 22:27members of the Presbyterian Church.
- 22:28When Charles was in his early teens, his father made him partner of his Pittsburgh based Haberdashery
- 22:33store, which I looked up is really just like a sewing store.
- 22:37A Haberdashery that needs to make a comeback for sure.
- 22:40Never heard that word before.
- 22:42Like where would you use that word though?
- 22:44Oh, you need to make up some stuff from the Haberdashery because you've got a hole in
- 22:47your shirt or something.
- 22:50You would become an empty empty.
- 22:52I'm pretty sure.
- 22:53So yeah, he has brought in by age 12, Russell was writing business contracts for customers
- 22:57and given charge of some of his father's other clothing stores.
- 23:00In age 13, Russell left the Presbyterian Church to join the Congregational Church and in his
- 23:05youth.
- 23:06Then by the way, we talked about a lot of offshoots of Christianity.
- 23:08We're not really going to talk about any of them.
- 23:11There's just not enough time.
- 23:12And like it's such minute details that separate a ton of these that it's not worth discussing
- 23:16unless you have like a PhD in religious studies.
- 23:19I also really like that the dad trusts a 12 year old to write up those contracts.
- 23:23I mean, why not?
- 23:24It takes the work off you.
- 23:26Yeah, you're busy just trying to specify.
- 23:30He's owning a Haberdashery.
- 23:32He's owning 12 Haberdashery.
- 23:35It's like the only Haberdashery ever, right?
- 23:38Yeah, you know what?
- 23:39I don't see the word after this finishes.
- 23:42So I think it dies out with them.
- 23:45I think it does.
- 23:47Russell in his youth was known to chalk Bible verses on fenceboards and city sidewalks in
- 23:51an attempt to convert unbelievers.
- 23:53We particularly noted the punishment of hell awaiting the unfaithful.
- 23:56I have a hard time calling him a rebel, but he is vandalizing things.
- 24:00It's okay.
- 24:01I love that.
- 24:03At age 16, a discussion with a childhood friend on faults perceived in Christianity, such
- 24:07as contradictions and creeds along with the medieval traditions led Russell to question
- 24:11his faith.
- 24:12He investigated various other religions, but concluded that they did not provide the answers
- 24:15he was seeking.
- 24:16At 1870 of age 18, he attends a presentation by Adventist minister, Jonas Wendell.
- 24:22And you'll remember that the Adventist church is a direct offshoot of Millerites.
- 24:27So Russell later said that although he had not entirely agreed with Wendell's arguments,
- 24:31the presentation had inspired him with a renewed zeal and belief that the Bible is the word
- 24:35of God.
- 24:36So Russell, a charismatic figure, however, did not claim any special revelations or visions
- 24:41for his teachings and no special authority on his own behalf.
- 24:44He said that he did not seek to found a new denomination, but intended to gather together
- 24:48those who were seeking the truth of God's words during this harvest time.
- 24:53He wrote that clear unfolding of truth within his teachings were due to the simple fact
- 24:57that God's due time has come and if I did not speak and no other agents could be found,
- 25:02the very stones will cry out.
- 25:05So in about 1870, Russell and his father established a group with a number of acquaintances to
- 25:10undertake an analytical study of the Bible and the origins of Christian doctrine, creed,
- 25:15and tradition.
- 25:16The group strongly influenced by the writings of Millerite Adventist minister George Storrs
- 25:21and George Stetson.
- 25:23So yeah, there's two Russells here.
- 25:27These people are also frequent attendees and concluded that many of the primary doctrines
- 25:32of the established churches, including the Trinity, Hellfire, and the inherent immortality
- 25:36of the soul, were not substantiated by the scriptures.
- 25:39Around January of 1876, Russell received a copy of Nelson Barber's Carrold of the Morning
- 25:44in the Mail.
- 25:45Barber was an influential Adventist, writer, and publisher, and Russell telegraphed Barber
- 25:49to set up a meeting.
- 25:51Barber and John Henry Patton visited in Allahenny in March 1876 at Russell's expense so that
- 25:57he could hear their arguments and compare the conclusions that each side had made in
- 26:01their studies.
- 26:02Russell sponsored a speech by Barber in St. George's Hall, Philadelphia in August of
- 26:061876 and attended other lectures by Barber.
- 26:09Among the teachings Barber introduced was the view that Christians who had died would
- 26:13be raised in April 1878, meaning the end of the world.
- 26:18Russell was moved to vote his life to what he was convinced were now the last two years
- 26:23before the invisible spiritual return of Christ, and he sold his five clothing stores for $300,000
- 26:36at that time, which is roughly worth $8.5 million today.
- 26:41With Russell's encouragement and financial backing, Barber wrote an outline of their
- 26:45views in Three Worlds and the Harvest of This World, published in 1877.
- 26:50A text Russell had previously written titled The Object Manor of Our Lord's Return was
- 26:54published concurrently through the Office of the Herald of the Morning.
- 26:57Russell was eager to lead a Christian revival and called to two separate meetings with the
- 27:00Christian leaders in Pittsburgh.
- 27:01Russell's ideas, particularly stressing the imminence of the rapture and the second advent
- 27:06of Christ, were rejected both times.
- 27:08When 1878 arrived, failure of the expected rapture brought great disappointment for Barber
- 27:13and Russell, and their associates and readers, but one of Russell's associates claimed that
- 27:17Russell was not upset.
- 27:19This is a direct quote from Alexander Humick Millen.
- 27:21While talking with Russell about the events of 1878, I told him that Pittsburgh Papers
- 27:25had reported he was on the 6th Street Bridge dressed in a white robe on the night of the
- 27:29Memorial of Christ's death, expecting to be taken to heaven together with many others.
- 27:33I asked him, is that correct?
- 27:35Russell laughed heartedly and said, I was in bed that night between 10.30 and 11.00
- 27:39pm.
- 27:40However, some of the more radical ones might have been there, but I was not.
- 27:43Neither did I expect to be taken to heaven at that time, for I felt there was much work
- 27:47to be done preaching the kingdom message to the peoples of the earth before the church
- 27:51would be taken away.
- 27:52Confused by what was perceived to be an error in calculation?
- 27:56Russell then reexamined the doctrine to see if he could determine whether it was a biblical
- 28:00origin or simply Christian tradition.
- 28:02He concluded that the doctrine was Christian tradition.
- 28:05Through the pages of the herald, he wrote about what he had concluded on the subject.
- 28:09Barber, embarrassed by the failure of these expectations, rejects Russell's explanation
- 28:13and they conducted a debate in successive issues of the journal from early 1878 to 1879.
- 28:19Funny enough, the guy who actually came up with the original one, he's like, yeah, let's
- 28:22just give this up.
- 28:23But nope, Russell's in it to win it.
- 28:26He's gonna get this right.
- 28:27In a matter of months, Barber changed some of the views which he and Russell had previously
- 28:31shared and no longer relied on the prophetic chronology.
- 28:33They began a debate over the issues of Christ's ransom and who eventually separated because
- 28:38of their disagreement.
- 28:39Russell withdrew his financial support and started his own journal, Zion's Watchtower
- 28:43and Herald of Christ's Presence.
- 28:46Publishing his first issue in July of 1879, Barber formed the Church of the Strangers
- 28:50that same year, continuing to publish Herald of the Morning.
- 28:53At an 1881, Russell founded Zion's Watchtower Tract Society with William Henry Conley as
- 28:59President and Russell as Secretary Treasurer.
- 29:01They intended to disseminate tracts, papers, doctrinal treatises, and bibles.
- 29:07Society was incorporated in 1884 with Russell as President and in 1886, its name was changed
- 29:12to the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society.
- 29:14Chelsea, have you ever heard any of those words?
- 29:17I don't think so.
- 29:18Okay, they were in for a good surprise at the end here then.
- 29:20Okay, I love the prize.
- 29:21So, by 1881, Russell had found a biblical basis for extending the harvest to a new date.
- 29:28Later that year, he explained, coming to the spring of 1878, we naturally and not unreasonably
- 29:33expected some change for our condition and all were more or less disappointed when nothing
- 29:37supernatural occurred.
- 29:39But our disappointment was brief, for we noticed that the Jewish Church was the pattern of
- 29:43ours and therefore we should not expel parallels to Pentecost or to anything which happened
- 29:47in the beginning of this Church.
- 29:49Russell wrote that the light upon our pathway still shines and is more and more glorious
- 29:54and that since 1878, the light had glowed stronger.
- 29:57Quote, we know not the day or hour but expect it during 1881, possibly near the autumn where
- 30:03the parallels show the favor to Zion, complete and due to end, the door to the marriage to
- 30:07shut and the high calling to be the bride of Christ to cease.
- 30:11End quote.
- 30:12So sometime near the end of 81, and I keep hitting spacebar, I hate this.
- 30:16The second failure in 1881 precipitated a more serious crisis in the Bible student ranks
- 30:21and for several years, Russell's followers waited for the belated translation to occur.
- 30:26Russell's chronological timetable had already identified 1914 as the ultimate end of the
- 30:31time of trouble.
- 30:32And it's important because invisible Jesus shows up in 1881, but the world doesn't end
- 30:37until 1914, that was kind of the whole prediction.
- 30:40But Jesus didn't show up in 81.
- 30:41So he basically just says, oh yeah, well then 1914's the new date.
- 30:45Obviously, he got it a little bit backwards.
- 30:48Yeah, but many members of his group found it inconceivable that their earthly departure
- 30:53might be delayed that long, 33 years.
- 30:58Maybe you got to make it a lot short.
- 31:00Maybe that's why.
- 31:01And I almost feel like that they took into account the age of Jesus when he was crucified
- 31:06because he was in his 30s.
- 31:07So maybe that's why he said 33 years or something like that.
- 31:10Like he's got to get up to crucify an agent to take everybody up or something like that.
- 31:14It's just an invisible baby Jesus for now.
- 31:16So Russell consoled members with the news that 1881 had still marked the time when death
- 31:21became a blessing in the sense that any saint who died would henceforth be instantaneously
- 31:26changed into a spirit being.
- 31:27The revised view provided comfort for the early believers who had held the view that
- 31:32living faithful would never experience a physical death and yet had seen other members in fact
- 31:36dying while they awaited their upward call.
- 31:39After 1881, physical death was defined as one of the ways in which some of the saints
- 31:44might undergo their translation.
- 31:46Russell's studies in the scripture series had explicitly identified October of 1914
- 31:50as the full end of the times for the Gentiles and consequently the farthest limit of human
- 31:55rulership.
- 31:56It would bring a beginning of Christ's millennial reign and all the followers expected the immediate
- 32:01translation of the saints to rule with the revealed Christ that year.
- 32:05Following the earth's tribulations and unrest the Jews would return to God's favor.
- 32:08The nominal church would have fallen.
- 32:10The final battle between Christ and Satan would have ended.
- 32:13The kingdoms of the world would be overthrown.
- 32:15Christ would have gathered his saints into heaven and they would reign and when the millennium
- 32:19would begin.
- 32:20That's incredible.
- 32:21The belief was unequivocal based on his studies of the Bible and the Great Pyramid and satisfied
- 32:26only upon the establishment of an earthly paradise.
- 32:29Russell remarked that altering the prophecy by even one year would destroy the perfect
- 32:33symmetry of its biblical chronology.
- 32:36Which is a real big thing for a guy who's already been wrong twice to say you can't
- 32:40change the state.
- 32:42This one is perfect.
- 32:43Those other two I didn't put my all into it.
- 32:46If it's off or all fucked if it doesn't happen.
- 32:49In the second book of his studies in the scripture series he described it as quote an established
- 32:53truth that the final end of the kingdoms of this world and the full establishment of the
- 32:56kingdom of God will be accomplished at the end of AD 1914 end quote.
- 33:01The result he wrote was that quote all present governments will be overthrown and dissolved
- 33:04end quote along with the destruction of quote what God calls Babylon and what men call
- 33:09Christendom end quote.
- 33:10And in 1894 watchtower which is his newspaper responding to readers who questioned whether
- 33:16because of recent political upheavals the world could last until 1914.
- 33:20He wrote quote we see no reason for changing the figures nor could we change them if we
- 33:25would.
- 33:26They are we believe God's dates not ours but bear in mind that the end of 1914 is not
- 33:30the date for the beginning but for the end of the time of the trouble end quote.
- 33:34As 1914 approached excitement mounted over the expected change of anointed Christians
- 33:39early that year some Bible students convinced that the end of the world had arrived began
- 33:43distributing their material belongings abandoning their jobs and eagerly anticipating the future.
- 33:47In May of 1914 five months from the expected end Russell warned followers against coming
- 33:52to doubt quote there is absolutely no ground for Bible students to question the consummation
- 33:57of this gospel age is now even at the door and that it will end as a scripture foretells
- 34:02in a great time to trouble such as never was since there was a nation.
- 34:06We see the participants in this great crisis banding together themselves the great crisis
- 34:11the great clash that will consume the ecclesiastical heavens and the social earth is very near
- 34:16end quote.
- 34:17However by September Russell was pairing readers for the possibility that quote Armageddon
- 34:21may begin next spring yet it is purely speculation to attempt to say just when end quote.
- 34:27Yet the evidence he wrote still pointed to quote the year just before us particularly
- 34:31the early months end quote when again nothing takes place predictions regressed to their
- 34:36earlier short term orientation.
- 34:37The watchtower wrote quote it may be that many of the Lord's people were expecting
- 34:41more than they should have looked for to occur with the opening of the Jewish year 1915 which
- 34:46began with September 21.
- 34:48The human mind seems to have a natural tendency and one with which we should have sympathy
- 34:53to expect matters to culminate more rapidly fulfillments to come more suddenly than they
- 34:58ever do come.
- 34:59Studying God's word we have measured the 2520 years the seven symbolic times from that
- 35:05year 606 BC and have found that it reached down to October 1914 as nearly as we were
- 35:11able to reckon we did not say positively that this would be the year we merely left
- 35:16everyone to look at the facts of history and reckon for himself end quote I love that just
- 35:21completely backs out of it.
- 35:23Yeah he took the opportunity to remind readers of some cautionary pronouncements he had made
- 35:27several years earlier in 1912 he had left open the possibility that nothing happened
- 35:31in October of 1914 it could still happen in October of 1950.
- 35:35He also pointed out that the period of transition could quote run a good many years.
- 35:39In a lengthy article of consolation Russell wrote that it was a testing time for Christ
- 35:43disciples and that some Bible students had unreal expectations and he said it was also
- 35:48possible that God's kingdom on earth would be established gradually.
- 35:51We find that some have one idea others another some think that just the next hour after midnight
- 35:57would see a great great change everywhere evil blotted out in 60 minutes or in 60 seconds
- 36:03but would it be a reasonable expectation that the Gentile Kingdom would be snuffed out inside
- 36:07of an hour inside a day if God had said so it would be different.
- 36:11We know that God has all power to do his will everywhere but are we in any sense of the word
- 36:15to expect such a sudden transition that going to bed on the night of September 20th we
- 36:20would find on the morning of the 21st all the kingdoms of the world destroyed in the
- 36:24kingdom of Christ set up.
- 36:26The saints in glory etc.
- 36:28Such would be a lightning change we do not think that and he would have been justified
- 36:32in so thinking if any such expectations it was unwarranted despite the fact he said that
- 36:38like three years before.
- 36:39I love how he gaslights everybody.
- 36:41Yet on October 2nd 1914 he entered the staff dining room at the Watchtower Society headquarters
- 36:46and declared that the Gentile times had ended and that their kings have had their day.
- 36:50It signaled that God had withdrawn his benevolent disposition towards the Christian nations.
- 36:55The statement implied that the legitimacy of earthly governments had been downgraded
- 36:58in the eyes of God which sociologist Joseph Zygman suggested may have contributed to the
- 37:03subsequent adoption of bolder tactics and condemning global political systems.
- 37:08Russell viewed the outbreak of World War I as the beginning of Armageddon which would
- 37:11soon descend into a world wide revolution and in 1916 shortly after his death he reaffirmed
- 37:16his conviction that the end was close and the harvest of saints was going on.
- 37:21Quote, some of us were quite strongly convinced that the harvest would be ended by now but
- 37:25our expectations must not be allowed to weigh anything as against the facts.
- 37:30We see no reason for doubting therefore that the times of the Gentiles ended in October
- 37:34of 1914 and that in a few more years we'll witness this utter collapse of the full establishment
- 37:39of God's kingdom in the hands of Messiah.
- 37:41In post-humus editions of the studies of the scriptures entire sections were rewritten
- 37:45to accommodate the failures of the anticipated events in 1914 now identified as the beginning
- 37:49of the end of the Gentile times.
- 37:51The outbreak of World War I was taken to be its confirmation, sociologist James Bechford
- 37:55claimed that Russell's sometimes ingenious ex-post facto rationalization events in 1914
- 38:01contributed to the survival of the Bible student movement.
- 38:04None are doctrinal changes introduced by his successor Joseph Franklin Rutherford.
- 38:08It was later decided that the millennium would come within the generation of those who saw
- 38:13the events of 1914.
- 38:15The years of 1799 and 1874 until then significant dates in Russell's millennial chronology
- 38:20were also abandoned.
- 38:21So yeah, he dies, they come up with a new date of 1918, this is running long so I'm just
- 38:26gonna...
- 38:27Chelsea, this is still around, you want to take a guess at who this is?
- 38:30One of the popes.
- 38:31Not quite, it's the Jehovah's Witnesses.
- 38:34What?
- 38:35Yes.
- 38:36And are they still just like running it on like a couple of...
- 38:39Not only that, they're still guessing the end of days.
- 38:42Is that the whole thing of the...
- 38:43The guest?
- 38:44They move it to 1918.
- 38:45The Jehovah's Witness.
- 38:46They move it to 1920.
- 38:47They move it to 1921, 25, 32, 35, 40s, 51, 75, 80, 86 and 2000.
- 38:57And now they're at 2033.
- 38:58So...
- 38:59233, hey?
- 39:00That's a good guess, that's not a bad guess, 2033.
- 39:03That's a good even number.
- 39:04Oh, an even number.
- 39:06That was the twist I didn't think you'd see coming.
- 39:08But their writings are called the Watchtower and it comes from Russell.
- 39:13He started it all.
- 39:14Really?
- 39:15Interesting.
- 39:16I love that for them.
- 39:17They're still going strong and they're still...
- 39:19I guess technically his predictions are still going strong and wrong.
- 39:22I love that.
- 39:23Steeped in tradition.
- 39:24He can't just stop predicting.
- 39:26No, he can't.
- 39:27Not like that towered at the beginning of the Russell story.
- 39:30He was like, no, I'm done.
- 39:31I was wrong.
- 39:32Or David Wilcock.
- 39:33I can throw him under the bus too, because he was one of the 2012 people.
- 39:37Sure was.
- 39:39He just...
- 39:40He went another way with it though, I don't think he ever acknowledged it.
- 39:42No, he kind of says that while I was never predicting like the end of the world, it was
- 39:46a spiritual change that did definitely happen.
- 39:49Oh yeah, I was thinking that while I was going on, I was like, hold on.
- 39:53I remember a lot of people from 2012 saying that it was just like a gradual change that
- 39:58has happened.
- 40:00Does that not follow Russell exactly?
- 40:02Where he just doesn't throw away 1914?
- 40:05And like, no, all these things, the world did end.
- 40:07You can tell from all the things that happened.
- 40:09Exactly.
- 40:10But yeah, that's I think where I'm going to end off.
- 40:11I did not expect in my research to end up with, and the Jehovah's Witnesses are still
- 40:16continuing this tradition today.
- 40:17They're still predicting it, and they keep moving it up.
- 40:23They'll never stop, because I assume they'll never stop, because it's steeped in tradition.
- 40:28And everybody should look at this, because I find it really interesting.
- 40:30There's the Wikipedia article called the Unfulfilled Watchtower Society Predictions, and there's
- 40:35a specific section in it called Adherence Responses to the Failed Predictions, which
- 40:39kind of gives you an idea of the psyche of the people who continue to follow it, despite
- 40:43the fact that they've been wrong so many times.
- 40:46I'd like to take a look at the article as well, but here I'm going to have my say on
- 40:50things that I haven't looked at.
- 40:52If somebody believes it, and it's a core belief of theirs, they're just going to accept anything
- 40:58for continuing to believe that the end of days are coming.
- 41:00Yeah, and that's one of those things where too, it kind of just isolates you.
- 41:04If you continue to follow something like this, the normal people in your life are going to
- 41:09believe, and you're just going to end up with this group, and you're just going to continue
- 41:12to believe what they're saying even more so because they're more people you have than
- 41:16you need it.
- 41:17Because you all hold the same beliefs.
- 41:18Yeah, but bleak.
- 41:19At least add cowboy hats.
- 41:21And yeah, if Joe Hope is with us, if you learned nothing else from this episode, please just
- 41:25add cowboy hats to the story.
- 41:30Thanks for listening, Joe Hope, with Witnesses.
- 41:32Yeah, and I think with that, I have been Taylor.
- 41:35Here with Chelsea.
- 41:36We are Journey to the Fringe.
- 41:37We'll see you all for listening and we'll see you next week.
- 41:39Goodbye.
- 41:40Thank you for listening to Journey to the Fringe.
- 41:44If you have liked what you have listened to, please like, share, subscribe, or follow,
- 41:50depending on what venue you are listening to us through.
- 41:53Also, please, if possible, leave a five-star review, as that really helps us in the algorithms.
- 41:59Should you wish to interact with us, please check us out on your social media of choice.
- 42:04I bet you we are there, and if you really want to communicate with us and give us ideas
- 42:09for new episodes or tell us that we're wrong and terrible, either way, please send us an
- 42:13email at journeytothefringe at gmail.com.
- 42:17For now, I'll see you in the next episode.