Latest / ThisWeekInGeek / Future Imperfect - Star Trek Picard Season 3 Discussion (Part 1 Of 2)
Transcript
- 0:08Captain de bridge, spark here and these signs of life negative? Have you
- 0:12tried all healing frequencies? Affirmative? No answer from the cube? Have the
- 0:16department has meet me on the bridge already standing by life sciences? Same report?
- 0:27So are we gonna just let it hold us? Here? We've got
- 0:29phase of weapons? I vote we blasted. I'll keep that in mind,
- 0:32mister Bailey. Unless becomes a democracy, you realize that the aim will,
- 0:38of course be very crude. I don't care if you hit the broadside of
- 0:43a barn. Just hurry, please, Captain, Why should I aim at
- 0:48such a structure? Mind spark, Just get all the job. Guys,
- 0:57what's going on? You are listening to Future Imperfect only on this week in
- 1:00geek dot Net. I am lieutenant commander like the Burman, but I'm not
- 1:04alone. As we go across the Alpha quadrant in Well, you don't know
- 1:10who to trust these days, do you. I'm joined by the person I'm
- 1:14pretty sure is who he says he is, Alex. I got now that.
- 1:21What was it? Or didn't we see Orion's or something in the on
- 1:26the ship too? Like racism? Yeah, so I guess anybody can be
- 1:30in Starfleet now right, Yeah, pretty much like, hey, guys,
- 1:33come on out, and that other voice you heard is our good friend,
- 1:36our science officer, the person who can basically build it virtually anything when it
- 1:40comes to Star Trek. He does stuff for all sorts of stuff in Star
- 1:44Trek. Specifically, he does stuff for modifious and pretty much makes all the
- 1:49cool things. Then your role playing games happen, that is and Marion Pollier
- 1:53all right, guys, so we have a lot to talk about, and
- 1:56we're actually excited to talk about a Star Trek property that isn't lower decks,
- 2:01that isn't strange new worlds. What are you talking about, Mike, Well,
- 2:06I'm certainly glad you asked so. Last time on Dragon Ball z UM,
- 2:13we've talked about the Cards season one, season two and expressing highs,
- 2:16lows and what the fucks as we've gone through that mostly mostly bewilderment. Actually,
- 2:23I think you know certain episodes we talked about in season one where we
- 2:28were like, huh, season one was mostly head scratcher. Yeah, why
- 2:34why is this? Why is this Mass Effect meets Babylon five? There's some
- 2:37good stuff in it, There's there there is I have to be care.
- 2:40There is some good stuff, but most of it is just baffling. Yeah,
- 2:45I think out of the ten episodes of season one, you could have
- 2:49made a really good, not great, but a good one hour, one
- 2:53and a half hour TV movie if you cut out the extraneous stuff that was
- 2:58head scratching. And then season two same thing. Maybe. Yeah, there
- 3:04were some interesting ideas. I just don't know if it was fully baked through,
- 3:09you know what I mean, Like characterization made no sense in season two
- 3:13at all. Yeah, Like there's definitely something where maybe another writer's room should
- 3:16have taken a pass over this, just to tighten things up a little bit.
- 3:21And before we get like into the full bore of the first half of
- 3:24season three that has aired as of this recording, one thing you and I
- 3:29binged. I rewatched, but you binged for the first time the latest three
- 3:32episodes of the show. And one thing that was very apparently we both mentioned
- 3:37to each other was how comfortable Patrick Stewart seems to be back in the role
- 3:46in season three comparatively to seasons one and two. Yeah, it's almost like
- 3:51almost like having having the older actors around him, but also having because there
- 3:59are different direct for each other, like every two episodes has a different director,
- 4:01so they're doing them in pairs, and there are different writers, but
- 4:04there is a clear writer's room. There is a clear, if not series,
- 4:09a season bible for this. Yeah, he seems to feel whether or
- 4:15not through direction to him or he's just eased back into it more. He
- 4:20seems to feel more like the character we knew where he didn't appear or act
- 4:26at all in season one and two like he should have based on the character
- 4:30that was established. It was almost like he was just playing him. It
- 4:34was like, this wasn't John Luke Piccard, it was just Patrick Stewart being
- 4:38Patrick Stewart. Yeah, I'm tending to be John Luke. I will agree
- 4:42that it felt more like Patrick Stewart and screen rather than John Luke Paccard in
- 4:46season one and two. But I don't know if I would want to say
- 4:49that it's in being out of character, because I mean, yeah, people
- 4:54change all the time and all that. But yeah, it felt a jarring
- 4:58change. Yeah, it was a ring change. Will I will agree with
- 5:00that, And it's more jarring now that watching season three, seeing how he's
- 5:05essentially he is has the elements of seasons one and two like they were trying
- 5:12to portray, but it seems to be more of an organic progression in this.
- 5:18Had he been like this in season one, it would have felt at
- 5:23home, I guess, all at ease. But it was like just the
- 5:27mannerisms, the amount of energy he puts into his lines, even when he
- 5:30is wistful or contemplative. In this, it has the same on screen presence
- 5:36as he did in the original series. Now, BEFU, Now, before
- 5:42we get any further to kind of give you guys exact context what we're kind
- 5:45of talking about here, so we as briefly mentioned there, we're going to
- 5:48talk about the first as of this recording, six episodes that have aired,
- 5:53five aired. Five have aired as of this recording. The six will be
- 5:57out seven will be out fairly shortly after that. And this is kind of
- 6:02our mid term report on Picard, and I guess we can kind of maybe
- 6:09towards the end of the podcast here we'll kind of maybe share some overall thoughts
- 6:15because what I said to Alex about this, this feels like an entirely different
- 6:21show. Like I remember looking at Alice. I think this was either in
- 6:27the episode seventeen seconds or the one after at Alex like I think I looked
- 6:31you dead in the face, Like, where the hell was this since season
- 6:35one? Yeah? Like this and this is Star Trek. This is Star
- 6:41Trek. And even though there are different directors and there's different writers, you
- 6:46know, every two episodes or whatever, this and it's always a collaborative.
- 6:53Ever this you can point, you can pinpoint it. It's Terry Matalis being
- 6:57the showrunner and basically being in charge of everything. He's the narrative guy.
- 7:00He's the guy that's out there at all the interviews with all the actors.
- 7:03And it's quite clear he was listed as co showrunner for season two, but
- 7:09he only really showed up near the end and he directed one episode. Like
- 7:13he was not in control until this season. And it's pretty clear. Like
- 7:17I'm not trying to be like, oh, he's the savior of the show,
- 7:20but it's it's quite clear there is a stark contrast, you know,
- 7:25whether or not visually, it's it's not been lightened up as much as people
- 7:28would like that. That's when the when the biggest complaint now is that the
- 7:31bridge and everything is too dark. Yeah, it's a miserable workplace environment is
- 7:35Yes, that's that's the biggest complaint this season comparatively to what the discourse has
- 7:42been like online for the first two seasons. Yeah, it's you know,
- 7:46it's pretty clear that there there was a substantial change in overall, Like here's
- 7:53the tone, here is the script. It's it's like everybody was on board.
- 7:58You could tell things were planned a lot more of the season. Yeah,
- 8:01beforehand, absolutely other than here, here is the red herring, here's
- 8:05the mcguffin, here's here's the standard plotline that that production crew on every show,
- 8:11even outside of track, always seems to do this. This might have
- 8:16that a little bit for their b plot, but this is broken up different.
- 8:20This is like multiple episode art. It's almost like we're getting four episode
- 8:24like TV movies with you know, each each act and that. Now,
- 8:28so it's like there's first four episodes of an arc, the next four episodes
- 8:31is going to be an arc, and then we're gonna get a double part
- 8:33finale. But there's there's clear thought put into, you know, how every
- 8:41aspect of the plot is going to fit together. There's good characterization. You
- 8:43can argue some of the dialogue, you know, an episode episode might you
- 8:48know be a little inconsistent, but it's a very different feel. There's a
- 8:52story being told here. There's a story told with actual characters. There's another
- 8:58thing too, and one of the things that comes across with this to me,
- 9:03at least in my opinion, there seems to be a different air and
- 9:07atmosphere with just the way lines are delivered things are performed. This feels like
- 9:13trek not just because they're throwing a words like transporters. There's this thing that's
- 9:18leaking like problems are trekkish. They make sense. Lines are delivered in a
- 9:26way that doesn't feel hokey, like I know, me and Alex brought this
- 9:30up, like when we were hanging out the other day in season two,
- 9:35the one lady from Starfleet says to Picard and your quote unquote fucking Hubris or
- 9:41sorry season one or whatever, and then the one person and then Piccard says
- 9:46to Captain Shaw, look, I know you're just a dipshit from Chicago.
- 9:52Sure, Picards swore it was funny, and it actually felt like something Piccard
- 9:58actually didn't say, and that wasn't it that. Yeah, we'll get to
- 10:01that episode, you know, directly when we do. But there's a reason
- 10:05for it. And it was set up earlier, and it's saying something,
- 10:09say something that only you would know or that that would make sense, but
- 10:13out of character. That basically it was to show that he's not a danger
- 10:20well, and we'll get to the reason for that obviously when we do spoiler
- 10:24discussion, and it's and it was it was done for a witty reason,
- 10:28just to lighten theo, to lighten the mood and because that that is out
- 10:33of character for him to speak like that, and enough enough out of character
- 10:39that it makes Shago, Oh, I see what you're doing. So again
- 10:45there's a little thought put into it that way, or a little more thought
- 10:46put into it. Also, even though this has the modern filming techniques,
- 10:52you know, a lot of over the shoulder stuff and more close ups and
- 10:54this and that. And one thing that I think changes the entire tone of
- 11:00this season compared to the last two is these shots have time to breathe.
- 11:05Yeah, they let them go. Yeah. It's not not obviously, not
- 11:09like not over too long. It's not uncomfortable. It's only uncomfortable if it's
- 11:13meant to be uncomfortable. But it's not the same you know, I,
- 11:18you and I and everybody we'd be happy if it went back to the st
- 11:20like the long stuff of the of the nineties. Yeah, but this what
- 11:26this has brought it down. This is more like how First Contact was shot
- 11:31this and it's this is more like I've come to be much more happy with
- 11:37this season when I thought of it in the context of, oh, we're
- 11:43just getting a couple TNG movies we didn't get before. And if I'm thinking
- 11:50of it and okay, they're playing for a movie audience, they're not playing
- 11:52for a TV audience. This is okay, then I'm okay with what I
- 11:56would have compared it to filming one would have been the expanse. There's there's
- 12:03enough like motion still in the show to keep it feeling really action or are
- 12:11more fast paced than what you would have seen back in the nineties, but
- 12:15it's still there to tell a story. So you're letting your camera linger on
- 12:18characters, which bat Battlestar Galactic comes to mind too, but just not without
- 12:24the shaky cam, without the shaky cam exactly exactly. So I mean where
- 12:28I where I think this this season generally does show its TNNG roots is as
- 12:35as I said, actually telling a story on inters when they're when they're sitting
- 12:43there and talking about their emotions and not in like if you look at the
- 12:48seasons one and two, the dialogue doesn't sound when they're trying to be very
- 12:52emotional, when he's being self reflective, it doesn't sound like dialogue a human
- 12:58would make. Yeah, well, yeah, we're being told how they feel
- 13:01rather than being shown, and we're actually like learning how they feel through them
- 13:07trying to trying to explain themselves. Card says more when you see the reaction
- 13:18on his face when Shaw is berating him in the holidack, Oh, absolutely,
- 13:24When when you see the real when he realizes what Shaw is going to
- 13:28say, he completely shuts down. I see, I didn't see No he
- 13:35like he shuts down is and he's he he might was. He looked like
- 13:41he was ready to have a rebuttal to whatever he was going to say.
- 13:43And then when he realizes what he's going to say and why he's going to
- 13:48say it, he lets him say it. He lets him say it because
- 13:50he has no defense for it. That's why he in the end says,
- 13:54yeah, that's okay, it's okay, exactly whereas I feel in season one
- 14:00and two it would have been a long diatribe about how sorry he is when
- 14:05it could have all been portrayed in his face, which is what happened in
- 14:07season exactly. And that's why Patrick Stewart is a good actor. He's always
- 14:11been a good actor. Just need to give him the material to do it.
- 14:16Yeah, And I mean, and a lot of things came out about
- 14:20how he had a lot of creative control over how the season and how he
- 14:24was written and the dialogue in season two. Not all great actors can be
- 14:28great writers, and you can have a great input for certain things. I
- 14:33think he was given a little too much leeway to be a little too self
- 14:35indulgent in season two, And I mean he's earned the right to do that
- 14:39in certain projects. I just think it didn't work. Yeah, and this
- 14:43is a much better you know overall. So I guess we should probably summarize
- 14:46episode one just because I think we talked about it previously, but if we
- 14:50didn't and Mikey weren't there for that. Basically, episode one is the like
- 14:58introduction to Hey, we're changing everything up this this season is gonna be different.
- 15:05Hey, we're gonna it's gonna have a lot of the the like I
- 15:09guess, hey, remember this moments in it. But at the same time,
- 15:13uh, they're setting a tone that's that's entirely different than you know,
- 15:16because that's didn't I believe we open up on um is it? We open
- 15:22up with Beverly, We open up with the SSPs twelve. I don't want
- 15:28to set the world on fire. Oh that's right, yeah, yeah,
- 15:31yes, so we we Yeah, we get the Uh the member barries moments
- 15:37where they're showing off all little little things from um, you know, deep
- 15:41cuts from TNNG. Actually, I think, doesn't it prove It opens with
- 15:45Piccartata his home getting rid of everything, Um, does it? Yeah,
- 15:50I've seen the recalls. He's something about getting rid of starting to get rid
- 15:54of like a painting, and then they're like that to get Yeah, yeah,
- 16:00oh it's it's one of those. I think it doesn't it flow,
- 16:04but I think it flows between them. He talks a little bit about the
- 16:07enterprise d with Loris, and then it cuts to Beverly and it shows uh
- 16:14some of the some stuff of hers, some stuff of his, some stuff
- 16:18of jack Crushers, and um. Basically she's under attack from some unknown alien
- 16:25force. UM. And by the way, that's the weakest part of this
- 16:29episode in my opinion. Yeah, because like seeing it was good action.
- 16:34Just doesn't she have what pops up into my head because I'm doing from memory
- 16:37from several weeks ago now on this. Uh, I just remember pump action
- 16:44face her rightful. Yeah, that got my ump action phaser. That announces
- 16:48very loudly when it's out of AMMO, so everyone, all your your opponents
- 16:52can hear you do it. So that was one ding on the dumb,
- 16:56the dumb, dumb. The guys are firing, sound effects are very clearly
- 17:04AK forty seven's firing. Nice. Maybe they just are fans, I don't
- 17:11know. And one of those things like I heard it and I was like,
- 17:14you can't unhear it when you hear it, Like oh yeah. When
- 17:18we were watching it, it was like I we all watched it separately,
- 17:22but I was making like little mental notes. I'm like, you know what,
- 17:26this is still better? Yeah, no, it is, it is.
- 17:30It was already still better. Uh, except where I was like,
- 17:33I didn't know Beverly like to murder people. I mean, I know she'll
- 17:40do it if she has to, but like would I don't remember a time
- 17:42where Beverly didn't give a warning or you know, think of I could just
- 17:51stun them and then put them into like cryostasis or something. Nope, just
- 17:55straight up murder. She's murdering him because she wants to make him into ghosts
- 17:59that she can. Yes, oh there's that. Yeah, there are memes
- 18:06have been popping up about that. And what was it? Uh there there's
- 18:10a beam that popped up online of just you know, pictures still shots from
- 18:14it. Uh. And and it's her talking to the car when they're having
- 18:18their big sit down, and she's like, and you know, we were
- 18:22together all these five different times, and then you ghosted me and his responses
- 18:25I thought you liked that. Yeah, And I'm like, oh boy,
- 18:30here we go. Okay, I thought you were in you know, it's
- 18:34it's and you have to read it in his voice, and it's I thought
- 18:37you were into that sort of thing. But yes, and and then we
- 18:41you know, we get introduced to uh, her son or her her new
- 18:45son, who is like thirty but he's pretending to be twenty. And I'm
- 18:51like, yeah, we're back in the nineties when we used to castle like
- 18:52that. And good actor though, hey, good actor. And when I
- 18:55saw him immediately, I'm like, my first line is, oh, he's
- 18:57gonna be a bad guy, because the last time I saw him was on
- 19:02Outlander of Ronald D. Moore show, where he plays a very bad man
- 19:07okay, in In in the seventeen hundred. Basically, he's a pirate who
- 19:12loots pillages, does various very abusive sexual things to people in it, and
- 19:22he when he finally gets found out, they punish him, and the punishment
- 19:26is tying him to a stake while the tide is out letting the tide come
- 19:30in. Okay, And and I was like, oh, man, Like,
- 19:34I wonder if he got the job because ron Moore, you know,
- 19:37being star trek right, Um, it wouldn't surprise me if they're like,
- 19:41pick him. But I'm like, I've never seen him play a good guy.
- 19:44He's going to be a bad guy, isn't he. Uh. And
- 19:47it's still yet to be known whether he ends up being a bad guy.
- 19:49Probably won't, but you never know. Um. And I don't know if
- 19:55it's it's not revealed in the first episode, but it's hinted at that he
- 19:59might be Picard's son. And uh, basically they the first episode is about
- 20:07getting Riker back together with Picard and they end up borrowing in quotes a shuttle
- 20:14and then borrowing a ship and they get in trouble. Boom. End of
- 20:19story. But we I think we all sort of liked it. It was
- 20:22a good opening. Um, it was intriguing, But we still were,
- 20:25like we talked for a couple of weeks. The first two weeks, we
- 20:27were very on the fence of whether or not we were gonna like the season
- 20:30or not. Yeah, because the second season started off fairly strong. Um,
- 20:36which I think the first episode was actually written and directed by Terry Matalis
- 20:40of that season. Maybe I gave this one like the first episode of five
- 20:45point six out of ten, which which which comparatively didn't you give the last
- 20:49episode of season two a one? The last episode of season two? I
- 20:53think I gave it yea, It was like a one point one. Yeah.
- 21:00Yeah, and that was only for the scenes that had John Valancian.
- 21:04I think, um, no, it was. It was actually like the
- 21:08Starship porn for the most part, because it was actually fairly well done the
- 21:15right It was just complete nonsense, it was, that's right. I remember.
- 21:18The comment was they fixed the issue from season one of not just cookie
- 21:22cuttering all the ships and all the sky, which was that was the only
- 21:25real positive thing I felt. So it's a that's a big that's a big
- 21:30improvement over the finale of season two. Then yes, absolutely, Also it
- 21:36gained points in my mind because there was no elmore the the space elf.
- 21:41Uh. There's some fantastic stuff in this episode, though, like just background
- 21:45pieces. Remember I'm like mister science and tech guy and in Starship and plot
- 21:51wise, this this whole season is always going to be hampered down by having
- 21:53Raffi in it. Every single scene that has Raffi is of lower quality because
- 21:59she's in it. Man, See, I like the actress. I actually
- 22:02like the this is thing too. I actually like as an actress. I
- 22:04liked her in a lot of other stuff. She has given the worst dialect.
- 22:08She's not the right person for this role, and this role is also
- 22:12not written well. I think I think she's it feels like it's from a
- 22:17different show. It does. But I think she's so much better in this
- 22:22season, and so much better she is, but the overacting is still way
- 22:27over the top compared to everybody else. It's like, as she's just not
- 22:32getting the character, and I don't understand. I don't know if it's a
- 22:40if it's a like a politics thing within the company. What is with the
- 22:45push to try to make her be cool when she's not cool? The character
- 22:49isn't cool. The character is a strung out drug addict who's always on edge,
- 22:56and nobody likes I don't know. I can see why people might like
- 23:00her. She's not a perfect character, but but nobody does. This is
- 23:04like if you look online, there's been discourse back and forth between you know,
- 23:08old Trek fans new Trek fans about it. You've seen this for the
- 23:11last five years or so, right with all the all the different shows universally,
- 23:15that character isn't liked. She's the new Wesley. I guess I'm you
- 23:22know, I don't think she's a very interesting character. That's fair, But
- 23:26I don't hate her like you could. You could take her out of this
- 23:32season and nothing would change. Oh, she's inconsequential. I warf could have
- 23:40done everything without us. Then again, we haven't seen the whole season yet,
- 23:45so I'm really I don't give her the benefit of the doubt. Okay,
- 23:48as of halfway through the season, she hasn't even been the like analog
- 23:53for the viewer. There's nothing she's been in that she had to be in
- 23:57because Warf was there doing the same thing. The only thing she was there
- 24:02to do. And I'm going to agree with Alex on this point, is
- 24:06there's a point she's in a fight with Warf to fool somebody, and she's
- 24:10there to best Wharf. She's there to set up jokes for Wharf. Think
- 24:17about that, Alex. Every time Warff said something funny, she's trying to
- 24:21be all serious and John Wick badass and he's like, I'm bleeding quite profusely.
- 24:26I must consult a medical doctor. And she's like, oh, yeah,
- 24:29I didn't mean to her joke, Like she the only good thing she
- 24:33did was set him up for the t joke. Yeah. And it's like
- 24:37like, couldn't this have been a different character? Like why? Why?
- 24:41Why did it have to be her? Other than that she was under a
- 24:45contract maybe and they had to use her, Like why couldn't this have Why
- 24:48couldn't the surprise have been And I mentioned this, I think the mike.
- 24:52I don't know if I mentioned this on recording her on air? Why couldn't
- 24:56instead of RAFFI why couldn't we have just seen some other Starfleet officer and then
- 25:02have it turn out like, you know, surprise, surprise, it's revealed.
- 25:06It's like O'Brien's daughter. Um, Like, why why could we have
- 25:11had a younger actor? Like why couldn't it have been one of the children
- 25:14from Enterprise or from DS nine or even somebody from Voyager that just has grown
- 25:18up? Sure, and I see what you're saying, like what like like
- 25:22if you had to have this character, you know, who would have been
- 25:26cool here to help warf In my opinion, and this is probably not going
- 25:30to be a popular one. I would have liked to have seen Tuvok here
- 25:37because he's done deep, he's done d He hasn't he gone crazy at this
- 25:41point. No, because he got back to the Alpha Quadrant, so he's
- 25:45had that, he's had that kind of treatment. Plus he's done deep undercover
- 25:48work before with Starfleet Intelligence. But I mean, if they wanted to like
- 25:52keep you guessing as to what this character is and what they're doing or who
- 25:56they are, you could have used somebody like I just I don't know why
- 25:59they have or Garrett Wong could have done it. I don't know why they
- 26:02kept this new character. They dropped the other characters, except well seven wasn't
- 26:07a new character. But you know, they dropped all the other characters from
- 26:08the other seasons. Why did they keep her. She's the character nobody liked.
- 26:14Um she was the one that was willing to stay. They probably she
- 26:18was or she was the one that was under a three year contract. Who
- 26:22knows, but like and again, I feel bad because I have liked her
- 26:25in a lot of other shows and programs she's done. I just I feel
- 26:29like if you removed almost every scene that she's a part of. The the
- 26:34b plot with Warf is kind of sucky right now because every time they transition
- 26:38from the ship to the ground, it looks like a really, really,
- 26:42really low budget sci fi. It's a very different show when it goes to
- 26:45Warf and Ravvy that that's fair. I will I will agree with um and
- 26:51And I mean, and I'm not trying to I'm really not trying to harp
- 26:53on it too much. It's just it's kind of jarring. Like the best
- 26:56episode of the season so far had no raffy scenes. You know, that's
- 27:00that is true. I don't know if it is because of that, because
- 27:03I would say in my notes that I do give positives to some of the
- 27:07scenes with Warf and Raffi um, but if they're together, they're fine.
- 27:12It's just a lot of it is pacing seems odd, things deep like it's
- 27:18almost like every everything in the show has slowed down, you know a little
- 27:23more, you know, in line with TNG and she's still moving at the
- 27:26pace of seasons one and two. In her dialogue and how she's moving,
- 27:30it's like, okay, take it down from a ten, take it down
- 27:33to a seven, or we should you know, calm down a bit.
- 27:37You're like, just the way the way she's been written. It's not the
- 27:45actress's fault if that's what they're wanting out of her, but it just seems
- 27:49it's very odd that she seems very out of place now, okay, And
- 27:57maybe maybe it'll get better as it go was on. I think it could
- 28:00if they are clearly trying to make this the nostalgia trip season where we're going
- 28:03to get as many people back as we can. I would have thought if
- 28:07they're really trying to pluck on your nostalgia, you know, feelings, you
- 28:11might want to go with the character instead of her or completely or completely.
- 28:18I understand. Maybe you're somebody completely I understand what you're saying. And I
- 28:22think that if we didn't have Raffy from season one and two in our heads
- 28:27watching those scenes season three, RAFFI would be would be acceptable. I'm not
- 28:33saying great, I'm just saying acceptable. Yeah, And I think, you
- 28:37know what, it also bugs me. She's the only character in the entire
- 28:40show with goofy raccoon makeup on, like where they like, yeah, like
- 28:44like she looks like she's ready, she's got war paint on, ready to
- 28:45go to war. It's like nobody else in the show has like that.
- 28:51Is it trying to like emphasize maybe that she's still on drugs? Like,
- 28:53I don't get it, Like it doesn't. It looks odd because it's not
- 28:57like she's an alien. But it's not like anybody on earth has that quarter
- 29:03inch like like commando makeup on. Talking about positive thing, it's just yeah,
- 29:11yeah, we'll talk about it. Yeah, I'm trying to get all
- 29:12the negative the negative. It's just something feels odd. I don't I can't
- 29:15pinpoint at something. It looks like it like Mike, really it looks like
- 29:21a different show. Yeah, Like it looks like I'm watching something like Lex
- 29:26when she's in it, or uh, actually hold on because Aaron will know
- 29:32exactly what I'm talking about. But it was Alex that you mentioned this.
- 29:34We're watching this where it's Raffian Wharf on the planet and Alex goes to me,
- 29:40Mike, does this look like Shadow Run to you? Yeah? Because
- 29:44it's it's kind of it looks like a cyberpunk ish setting on the planet.
- 29:48Yeah. Yeah, And I was like, huh, interesting way to back
- 29:52to our pilot something. But it's very drying, like it's almost like and
- 29:56are they setting it up for Wharf and her to have their own show that
- 30:00looks different? I'm kind of I don't. I don't know if Michael Doran
- 30:03would do that, or are they setting it up for a raffie to have
- 30:10our own show. I think they're going to be testing the waters. I
- 30:14mean, I know if I was a network executive, I would be paying
- 30:18very close attention to what that set looks a lot cheaper to film. Think
- 30:22that they're more likely trying to figure out what will work for the section thirty
- 30:26one show, how much violence they can get away with, how much you
- 30:30know? Yeah, I don't. I don't want to watch a show,
- 30:33So yeah, it was it was either episode one or two? Is that
- 30:37is? Do we see warfare? Now? We don't see him in till
- 30:38episode two. Um, I don't remember what happens in episode two. I
- 30:42remember everything, But let me talk about this episode episode starship degree from episode
- 30:48one that's okay, yes, yes, of course we get we get to
- 30:51see Eagle Moss models and episode one in the bar if you did not notice
- 30:56all the little models like thoughts, but you know what. One of the
- 30:59models that we see in there is the Federation class Dreadnought, which has never
- 31:04been seen on screen before, but now it's theoretically cannon and shouldn't have been
- 31:11there because it was designed by France Joseph and Franz Joseph not give the rights.
- 31:18It was meant to set dressing, and somebody snuck the Federation class Dreadnought
- 31:21in there. It's the three nacell Coos era starship. I don't know if
- 31:26you've ever seen the star Starfleet Technical Manual like the seventies. I'm speaking Greek,
- 31:34aren't I? I understand most of it, mostly because I've read the
- 31:42tech manual. Okay, but I get you there, and it was supposed
- 31:45to be set dressing and supposedly that was a mistake. I love that because
- 31:52I've just never got to see it on screen before. I think that's great.
- 31:53I'm not like one of those like recent Dreadnought stands that you know must
- 31:59have it on there. But um, I saw them and I was like,
- 32:04I don't some of them I didn't recognize. But I'm not as steeped
- 32:06in the lore as you guys are. Only I was only two. There
- 32:09was only two and it was the Enterprise D. I think I only saw
- 32:13in the first episode. It was Enterprise D and one Federation Dreadnought. Um.
- 32:19The we get to see Titan the Titan A in this episode, and
- 32:23it's talked about as a neo Constitution or Constitution three class. It's also supposed
- 32:30to have five hundred crew, we learn I hope you guys heard that on
- 32:37there, And I'm not like, it is supposed to be huge, okay,
- 32:43because it has five supposed to be something like five hundred and something meters
- 32:46long. How many crew was on the Enterprise D. Phrase D was a
- 32:51thousand, little less I was gonna say, But here's the thing, Okay,
- 32:55Neo constitution or the cost or Constitution three class like the Titan a here
- 33:01um. You can tell exactly how large it is because you know how big
- 33:06those windows are, and it very clearly in the first episode Joe's docking ports
- 33:10on it, so you can tell exactly how big that is. And it
- 33:15is actually smaller than a standard Constitution class. Maybe people got shorter in the
- 33:24future. Yeah, I mean, if if it was as big as the
- 33:28designers say it should be. The the orbital shuttle pod, you know,
- 33:34like the thing that Kirk and Scottie take over to Enterprise in the motion picture.
- 33:42In order for it to be the size I need to be the size
- 33:45that they say it's it is. Shuttle pods need to be three decks high
- 33:50now in order for it to be to match up with what we actually see
- 33:57the the CGI model of tight it is amazingly detailed. Amazingly Yeah. Scale
- 34:05seems to be always the thing that they have the most trouble with, And
- 34:07I mean it makes sense. When you're not building a physical model to base
- 34:10things on, it can be hard, like especially like when they're flying you
- 34:15know, the fly a shuttle and you're like that that shuttle Now looks too
- 34:19big compared to the ship. You know what I mean, that sort of
- 34:21stuff. So, I mean, I guess the solution would be to build
- 34:24a physical model that to then have the CG people want something, but that's
- 34:30that's too dress design helped design this ship, right, and he's an incredibly
- 34:35detail oriented person, right, And the Accudas are on staff. I saw
- 34:40it in the credits, and you can sit there and count the decks of
- 34:45Titan A and count the decks. It is a smaller ship like Standard Constitution,
- 34:52which means when you see it leave dry dock here, well, Space
- 34:54Doc, I should say in episode one Space Doc, even though this new
- 35:00Space Doc is supposed to be huge compared to the old Space Doc, it's
- 35:04actually smaller than the old Space Doc because you know exactly how big Nay should
- 35:08be because of those docking ports. It gets it gets crazy. What I'm
- 35:13trying to say is like it is not a big ship, but the ship
- 35:16model is so highly detailed that people really put time and effort into designing that
- 35:23ship. And I want to give credit work credits due it's beautiful. It
- 35:29looks movie quality, absolutely beautiful. So and and and that's you know that
- 35:35was a good introduction. I guess to sorry for babbling on about science and
- 35:37text. Oh no, no, I mean this is good because these are
- 35:42the things that sometimes, if you're watching, you might have in the back
- 35:45of your head you're like, something seems different, what's going on here?
- 35:47And it's because you're so used to seeing so many episodes where the scales are
- 35:51different, and you're like, okay, so it doesn't have a crew of
- 35:54five hundred, even though they say it has a crew of five hundred,
- 35:57it since it's actually smaller than it would have to be, like it would
- 36:02actually be more like one hundred ninety to one hundred people. I was but
- 36:07yeah, because the Wager has a max crew compliment of about one hundred and
- 36:10fifty if I'm not mistaken, And if you look in some of the when
- 36:14the episodes are gone, like obviously there's there's crew constraints, but like it
- 36:16would make sense based on the most recent episode where they were transporting people off
- 36:22the ship, like they had ninety percent of the crew transported off within like
- 36:28ten minutes, it would take a lot longer than that. Yeah, if
- 36:32you had five hundred people to transport at like six and I would wonder where
- 36:36they put five hundred people on that ship cargo base? Maybe? Yeah,
- 36:43I mean, I mean it also depends on how many how many aliens do
- 36:45we have on the crew that are like three feet tall? Yeah? Um?
- 36:51Also also aaron because you're a ship dork like me. Um, did
- 36:57you like? I found it very interesting how they called the ship the Intrepid,
- 37:00but I guess the original Intrepid's no longer in service and Trepid Yeah yeah,
- 37:07it would be. It's it's a new Intrepid. Yeah, yeah,
- 37:10that's what I figured. But would that not constitute it calling the USS Intrepid
- 37:15A or just because it's a class? See the A things but way overusing
- 37:22the A thing and on Enterprise while the letter thing on Enterprise was like an
- 37:27honorary thing because it was Enterprise was the flagship of the Federation and seventeen oh
- 37:34one was such a legendary starship even its number was notable, so retiring that
- 37:45number was like, no, we can't do that. So giving a starship
- 37:49an A was like, this was Enterprises thing and it really shouldn't go for
- 37:55other starships. So having like a Titan A with a legacy um registry number
- 38:01that's I don't I don't buy it, not with the arguments that I've seen
- 38:07online, but um oh so, so it would have to be another ship
- 38:10that had a certain amount of YEA. And according to like background tweets,
- 38:15we we learned that there was a Titan U in uh the movie era,
- 38:22captain by Savic that supposedly was the flagship of the Federation as well in like
- 38:30the four months that there was no Enterprise one blew up and Kirk was traveling
- 38:39back in time to save the whales. Okay, which sets, as one
- 38:46does, so silly outside of our excuse me, no, no, no,
- 38:52it would have actually been between the point of time in Star Trek after
- 38:55Star Trek six, where Enterprise A was ret is and Enterprise B was was
- 39:01not launched. And I think there's like um ten month time period between those
- 39:07those two launches. So are we are we talking when when Kirk was in
- 39:13the Nexus before then? Right before then? But titan that Titan had like
- 39:21a seventeen hundred registry number and supposedly it was flagship of the Federation because guests
- 39:30Spock recommended Savic or Sulu recommended Savik. And it's a tiny ship. It
- 39:38was a tiny ship, and there were other constitutions, and you would think
- 39:42that Starfleet would go, No, our flagship for the time being should be
- 39:45Excelsior, because that's kind of like top of the line, amazing starship.
- 39:54So if that was the flagship, you would think that the legacy registry would
- 39:59be the NCC seventeen whatever it was dash A for Titan instead of Riker's Titan,
- 40:07because they also gave the background on what Riker did and write what Riker
- 40:12did seemingly wasn't anywhere as impressive as what Savac did with Titan from the late
- 40:17twenty third century. I know I'm babbling here, but like, no,
- 40:22but I don't like legacy registry numbers. For Enterprise it made sense, but
- 40:28for anything else, it's kind of like, all right, well, fine,
- 40:31you can have the ship names that are the same, a new Intrepid,
- 40:36absolutely, a new Titan, just that legacy registry numbers should be one
- 40:39of those things that so incredibly rare that you only see it really once or
- 40:45twice. Because the US Navy a legacy registry number based on Enterprise from World
- 40:52War Two, even though that's still the highest awarded most decorated vessel on the
- 41:00planet out of any navy. It has awards from other nations, and there's
- 41:06no legacy register. Yeah, it would be like like in Japan, the
- 41:12Amato sort of thing, like it's become almost focal sort of. But having
- 41:16another ship named Amato is completely okay. It's using the same number on its
- 41:22hull. That is, it's even stranger. So like so like in so
- 41:30in Star Trek, like maybe you give the Defiant no, the same one,
- 41:35wouldn't I would not even Voyager, even though Voyager arguably did something incredible
- 41:39by surviving its journey back home. Maybe you don't want to curse the ship
- 41:45with the same the same name. In that case, again, the names
- 41:49are fine, it's the number that is the actual legacy thing, the dash
- 41:52A. So yeah, I guess that makes well because if the argument is
- 41:59with the Enterprise, it's the ship that basically launched the federation, Yes,
- 42:06and every ship right like like with Archer, right like, so the ideas
- 42:10you would want to keep that because it's literally the foundation of it. But
- 42:15it's it's more like Kirk's Enterprise was so amazing that that's the number that stuck
- 42:22around. Yeah, okay, yea, because it was. It was just
- 42:25an extra one, right. Even though Archer's Enterprise was fantastic and it was
- 42:30damn near legendary, still didn't deserve like a legacy registry number, because you
- 42:37remember, you don't call the seventeen oh one D Enterprise D Universe. You
- 42:42wouldn't say that it's Enterprise SEC seventeen oh one dash D because it's the legacy
- 42:49registry number. So new you know, new starships the same name as an
- 42:52old starship. Totally cool, absolutely cool. Registry numbers to me are just
- 42:58kind of weird. You can make every excuse you want to to have it
- 43:01in your in your in your show. That's fine, I'm okay with it.
- 43:07Just that it should be a rare thing and it should be fair enough.
- 43:10I got that makes perfect sense, it does. No, it's a's
- 43:16all good. So like, yeah, episodes one and two two, we
- 43:20get established that or it's hinted and revealed that, uh that it is.
- 43:29It's actually Picard's son. They're on the run from the this mysterious you know,
- 43:37Lady bounty Hunter and ship called the Shrike, which I looked up interesting
- 43:44uh reference, So it's it is another bird of prey technically, UM,
- 43:49a bird, A shrike is a bird that grabs worms and bugs and even
- 43:53mice and other like even like baby squirrels and stuff. And it will impale
- 43:59them on bikes and then eat them while they're alive. It's it's awful.
- 44:02So but but the parallels to the show where she's like, I'm going to
- 44:08pick you off one by one, that's literally a reference to the shrike.
- 44:15It's a reference to the actual birth that I like. That ship design,
- 44:16it's very cool. It's to me, it looks like almost an evolution of
- 44:22of shins on ship or Nemesis, And I think that's what they're kind of
- 44:27trying to make you think of too, in a weird way. Because the
- 44:31as much as some people were divided on that movie, I always liked the
- 44:35movie. I it's the only Trek movie, well of classic Trek that I
- 44:39was able to see in theaters. Personally, UM, I didn't well,
- 44:43I was I was like my parents didn't take me to see a lot of
- 44:45movies. And remember I was like nine when First Contact came out, UM,
- 44:51and I didn't know Insurrection was in theaters. I rented them both on
- 44:57video when my local video store had them, and I was like, wow,
- 45:00there's Star Trek. There, there's new Star Trek movies. I thought
- 45:02that all the movies were just you know, the old crew. I didn't
- 45:05even know generations existed, because you know, pre Internet. For me,
- 45:08I'm the old and what's that's the thing. It's like, Oh, I
- 45:15was always excited when I see these stuff. So I saw Nemesis and theaters
- 45:17and you know, people were dressed up, you know, like there was
- 45:21like at least ten people waiting to see it when I thought that were in
- 45:24full gear and we and most of us had a good time there. There
- 45:29were some fans that were there. I remember griping about things here and there,
- 45:32and the biggest consensus among people were, well, this wasn't the greatest
- 45:37one. Uh you know what, maybe the next one's going to be better.
- 45:40And then the next one didn't happen until I guess now. Um.
- 45:45But the one consensus that everybody had watching it was the best parts of the
- 45:49movie were the standoffs, uh you know with the scimitar. That's what it
- 45:54was sold, right, and the standoffs, and then of course the you
- 46:00know, the ramming speed that that whole scene, that's what everybody remembers from
- 46:06it is the cat and Mouse game, then when the Romulance came and they
- 46:09had to team up, like that's all the ghost and we get that here,
- 46:15we don't get the team up, but we get the cat and mouse,
- 46:16the very grata Connie sort of stuff. And then of course, you
- 46:23know, we're setting things up, and then we hit the two episodes that
- 46:28we are probably gonna have the most to talk about here, episodes three and
- 46:30four. I forget the names of them off top of my head. But
- 46:36what's interesting is I'll just very briefly mention this show doesn't have the full theme
- 46:43song that the first two seasons would have, where they would have a theme
- 46:45song that had like an intro, long intro representing sort of what was happening
- 46:50in the season. Here we're getting sort of a very short intro, and
- 46:52it's they're calling each part. It's not like season three. They're calling it
- 46:58start to up a card part this, and it's like we're watching a mini
- 47:01movie mini series. And then it's reusing musical themes from TN and then some
- 47:07of the other films. So it's interesting what they've done here. They've changed
- 47:10the way the tone of the show is just even having its intro changed like
- 47:14that. And in this third and fourth episodes we get the most character driven
- 47:22moments. That there's more character development in these two episodes than twenty episode.
- 47:28Absolutely absolutely, and it is well acted, well acted, well taste.
- 47:37Like in episode three, we have the conversation between Beverly and and Picard,
- 47:44and maybe it's because we had years to get to know these characters. Maybe
- 47:51maybe it's because of that, I don't know, but them having this like
- 47:55much needed conversation about their relations and ship, what they've done together, why
- 48:01it didn't work, why Beverly didn't tell Picard about Um, about Jack,
- 48:10Why Picard feels like this this was something that he needed to know about,
- 48:16that he needed to have the information to even be able to make an educated
- 48:21choice rather than not being allowed to make a choice. You can see where
- 48:25both of the characters are coming from. They're both right, they're both wrong
- 48:30in their own ways, and it's wonderful they're flawed, but in a very
- 48:37believable way. And also the other thing to take into account is they weren't
- 48:43when she got pregnant. They weren't, you know, young dumb kids they
- 48:50like she like and I've seen some people like make comments online that maybe don't
- 48:54aren't like super deeper, are thinking super deep into the truck. They're like,
- 49:00you know, how is she she's got a twenty year old how's she
- 49:02having a kid if she's supposed to be like eighty or something. In this
- 49:06it's like because it's like you realize that, like fifty years ago, you
- 49:10were really old. If you had to get this, this is a deal.
- 49:15This is It's like, it's like we're we're we're in a we're in
- 49:17a future where people regularly live a significant amount of time, longer and healthier
- 49:23due to modern medicine even now. So so if the average life expectancy from
- 49:29one hundred years ago went from being like fifty five to eighty and we're and
- 49:35this is without alien technology, We're talking several hundred years in the future,
- 49:38what's the average life span like one hundred and fiftything like that? How humans
- 49:43are like about one hundred and twenty. Okay, so like one hundred and
- 49:47twenty, it's still that would mean that it's potential that the viability to have
- 49:52a child. You could have a child or sixties couldn't at that point because
- 49:57because Again, fifty years ago, it was very rare for women in their
- 50:00mid forties to have kids, so like it was just you were you were
- 50:05expected to have kids between the ages of like sixteen and thirty, and that
- 50:09was it. And now people aren't even starting families a lot of the times
- 50:13until they're in their forties. So it's you you've got to sort of think
- 50:16in the mindset of a future where a woman might be fertile, like twenty
- 50:22years long. Hard is ninety six in this season? Yeah, a robot,
- 50:28it's supposed to be ninety six. F yi. Um, I'll have
- 50:35to figure out. I hope I look that good when I'm nineties. Well,
- 50:37and and if Beverly, like I'm saying, like I don't know her
- 50:39exact age, she's supposed to be in this, but like if they knew
- 50:43each other in the academy, you know, it's it's it's easy to believe
- 50:45that she's supposed to be somewhere in these in this season. Okay, so
- 50:52so she was fifty seven, that's not it's rare, very rare now,
- 50:57but it wouldn't be unheard of in the future when you know you might not
- 51:01might not hit menopause. Makes complete sense to seventy when yeah, when you
- 51:06live to be one hundred and twenty and middle age is sixty to sixty five
- 51:09or seventy, you know that makes sense then. So I think that's that
- 51:14debunks anybody that's complaining about that. Um So, I mean they had a
- 51:20good moment together. Everything made sense. They were believable together in this.
- 51:23The way they talked, uh A Riker Riker in this I've come to the
- 51:28realization Riker is movie riker right in in in the way, in the the
- 51:36amount of comedy here, sure in the quip and not not not movie raker
- 51:40as in that's I didn't mean that as a bad thing. If anybody's thinking
- 51:44it's a bad thing movie raker in the um in the quips that he gets
- 51:49to half back and forth, like I'm fully expecting when they meet up with
- 51:52uh with Wharf, there's gonna be a bunch of funny little uh like jabs
- 51:57and pokes between them sort of thing like this is you know where he gets
- 52:02to be a little more. He's more playful in here, like you even
- 52:07the look in his eyes when he's talking to to certain characters. Except you
- 52:12know, serious moments are serious obviously, but like the moments when they're on
- 52:15their own or they're getting to have their little speeches together, he feels more
- 52:19like he's in the movies versus you know, the show. And that might
- 52:23have to do with the fact that he's now the you know, an authority
- 52:27figure, if not the authority figure, versus having to you know, be
- 52:32you know, be under somebody's command. Um and uh, I mean I
- 52:38did like the third episode had probably I don't know if I like the third
- 52:45or fourth episode better. I think the I have the fourth down as a
- 52:52seven point eight out of ten, which you understand how I read things.
- 52:55That's very high and and that's and that's for Trek, which is which is
- 53:00already a harder curve than your regular science yea. And in episode three I
- 53:05gave a six point two, which it's still very good. Yeah, it's
- 53:10it's setting things up. And I remember when the third episode finished we had
- 53:15a discussion. Mike hadn't seen it yet because we ended up watching it after
- 53:17a like, but you and I mentioned to each other, like both right
- 53:21are at the same time? Is this the best episode of Trek of new
- 53:24Trek, like of the newer stuff, like like it was it. The
- 53:28first couple episodes were about on par with what we liked from Strange New Worlds.
- 53:32Some I would say some parts of Strange New Worlds were better, but
- 53:35that might have just been because the budget seems bigger. For that shows are
- 53:39very charismatic and in Strange New Worlds. Yes, and and and that show
- 53:45is going for a sort of pseudo sixties throwbacks sh which you feel obviously going
- 53:51to tweak our nostalgia buttons. Yeah, where like that that even though that
- 53:57show looks like a show film now, it has much more of the ts
- 54:01Field like like just I like the even the Goofy episodes that they did to
- 54:09that felt more like sixties goofy than modern goofy, if that makes any sense.
- 54:14So it is a little different. But like we had that discuss,
- 54:16we're like, wow, this is this is if this is what it's going
- 54:20to be like for the rest of the season. That's where I was like,
- 54:22all right, let's watch another episode, because the plot of of episode
- 54:27three is just it's it's the tension building yes for the for the arc of
- 54:31this and this is where we sort of came to the realization that this isn't
- 54:37going to be a giant long season arc. There's going to be a B
- 54:39plot in a C plot that carry the season forward. But like, it's
- 54:43not like the last two seasons where it's one long story. It's looking like
- 54:47we're getting two or three multi episode arcs, and or I was like,
- 54:52Okay, so this is what's happening here, Like they were building to the
- 54:54big tension moment and the big conflict in here that I was interested to see
- 55:00because you didn't really see that on the original show really much, if at
- 55:04all. Is the big clash that we got between Riker and Piccart over how
- 55:13to handle The one criticism about episode three would have been that conflict between Riker
- 55:22and Picard right at the end, because the conflict through the whole of episode
- 55:28three in general was really well done. Yeah, you can have a disagreement
- 55:32and get professionals the yeah, the professional dilemma and the personal dilemma. Like
- 55:39I get what they were going for with right at the end of that episode
- 55:44though, where he goes you've killed us all, get off my bridge,
- 55:46and I'm like, wow, that is one of the most unprofessional conduct,
- 55:51unbecoming of an officer action that I have. I've seen out of Riker.
- 55:55That seems so wildly out of character. It's dude, you're the captain.
- 56:00You agreed with his line of action, you gave the orders. Do not
- 56:06accuse the old man who you agreed with, of causing all of these problems.
- 56:12You were as much to blame, and that just made a big problem
- 56:15in front of junior officers on the bridge. That's the line I would have
- 56:21expected from the Riker that was going crazy in the Parallels episode where the board,
- 56:29Like, like if he if he was all disheveled and he was screaming,
- 56:32no, I won't go back, then I'd be like, that's the
- 56:37like, that's the kind of line that would have come from him, not
- 56:39from this was a good episode, a very good episode, and you know
- 56:45we we end on the cliffhanger there and then episode four airs and Mike,
- 56:50did you have anything to add to episode three? Sorry you guys haven't let
- 56:57me get a word in edgement. Sorry, buddy. I like what I've
- 57:01seen, Like it's a dramatically different show from the writing from just the way
- 57:07like and I come from newly educated creative writing. There's emotion in each scene,
- 57:17chemistry is actually there, which is not something you can say was really
- 57:22present. Now you can say an actor has charisma, like I know Alex
- 57:28doesn't like Alison pill as Gerardi, but you can't deny she had charisma,
- 57:32but she had no chemistry with anybody on scene, or if it did happen,
- 57:37it was exceptionally rare. Almost everybody here has charisma and chemistry, the
- 57:42exception being Raffi. Outside of a few minor moments, everything that is working
- 57:50with this season three, Episode three that you guys are kind of talking about,
- 57:55the thing that I really liked is you're seeing a Card evolve into a
- 58:01different type of character, and it's something that I think that's been a long
- 58:05time in commings. I know in some of the preseason interviews, this is
- 58:08going to deal a lot with kind of legacy and Aaron, you were talking
- 58:13about this a couple of moments ago about how Ricard's never given a choice to
- 58:19know that he was a father, and when Beverly says, if if Jack
- 58:23was known to be the son of Jean Piccard, he would have had a
- 58:27target on his back from the moment he could walk. And that's something that
- 58:32I think this season deals with in a very interesting way. Is the idea
- 58:37of hero worship because you think about that Beverly's and could I could I've made
- 58:45the same decision, you know what, it's that Sophie's choice. Maybe I'm
- 58:49not wrong for thinking this because everybody says, oh, that's Captain McCard,
- 58:52he'll save the day. Captain mccart's an old man. And all it takes
- 58:54is somebody with a phaser or a bomb or something to take out your family.
- 59:00If Beverly ran the protect her son because nobody cares about the rest of
- 59:04the crew. Maybe data, maybe Riker maybe, but she's just Beverly Crusher.
- 59:08No one cares. She can go live her life and do whatever she
- 59:10wants without constantly being under threat wherever Captain Picard goes. He tries to go
- 59:16out for frigging lunch one day, and he can't even take a bite of
- 59:21his sandwich because nobody will leave him alone. Everywhere you go, you will
- 59:24be followed. And I don't blame her. I don't And I know that
- 59:30says good point on that with with the with the lunch thing too, you're
- 59:32right, because that was, yeah, it was you know what it was
- 59:37getting ready for what was a l Yeah, people people come up and it's
- 59:45it's it's clear. He like he sort of pretends he doesn't like it,
- 59:47but he does like the attention. Yeah, and like it's just something about
- 59:52that too. And then not too long before that scene happens. Um,
- 59:58I don't know if it's episode three or four. I've lost count. At
- 1:00:00this point, there's a scene where Shaw's talking about the day he met Piccard.
- 1:00:06He's like, oh, yeah, you know, the first day I
- 1:00:07met him starred blah blah blah blah blah. Yeah in the season. Yeah,
- 1:00:15that's one of the highlights and Trek, in my opinion, in since
- 1:00:21Enterprise, because that's PTSD and this is a character who was mostly written for
- 1:00:29laughs. But when you get that guy in a moment, that manic depressive
- 1:00:35energy, somebody who looked in in the abyss saw his friends die. Was
- 1:00:40when he says the point when this lieutenant came down and said you you you,
- 1:00:45and you get it in the escape pod. That's an order survivor's guilty
- 1:00:51fucking thing, and it's something and it's something Trek has never particularly dealt with
- 1:00:55well. In my opinion, Voyager had a few moments they kind of deal
- 1:01:00with it, but it was always hey, we're better by next episode,
- 1:01:04Cisco, Like that was a key stick issue, you know, with even
- 1:01:08the pilot for DS nine, Right, you know why he does not like
- 1:01:15Yeah, and there's a reason. There's a reason for that, and and
- 1:01:17that reason is his wife on the ship, which yeah, But you have
- 1:01:22to wonder how many other Starfleet officers feel like this way about Picari, Like
- 1:01:24everybody has them has him as this iconic hero. Oh, he's the man
- 1:01:29who saved humanity and all that. Yeah, but you killed my dad,
- 1:01:32especially especially if you look. It's all except for the pure fucking Hubris lady.
- 1:01:40It's everybody that knew him before Lacutus respects and loves him. All of
- 1:01:50the Trek people, all the kids that weren't born when this happened look up
- 1:01:54to him as some war hero, some hero of the Federation. People that
- 1:01:58were at Wolf people. It's the people that were at World three five nine.
- 1:02:02It's the people that we're serving that weren't captains that knew him beforehand,
- 1:02:07that rank and file that we're serving after that are now captains. It's this
- 1:02:15there's there's the generation, his generation and the generation not the one right after
- 1:02:20him, but the one after that, like him, but his immediate success
- 1:02:24successful generation that came after that, there's a whole group that will probably not
- 1:02:30like him or not trust him. And because a lot of the people that
- 1:02:32he served with are now retired and aren't even in star Fleet, so it's
- 1:02:37not the same star Fleet that he would have known. Yeah, Like,
- 1:02:42that's something I really like about this season, really dealing with the aspect of
- 1:02:45legacy, Like it's not just what we leave behind in our lives, because
- 1:02:51we're still alive. Like history is very much still being written, and Picard
- 1:02:55has kind of let history make its own narrative out him in my opinion,
- 1:03:00because he's like, oh, yeah, I'm this, and he likes the
- 1:03:04attention, as you pointed out, and he likes to tell stories at lunch,
- 1:03:07but also let yeah like him that wasn't true. Think Yeah, Like,
- 1:03:17there's very good writing in this year, and I like the idea of
- 1:03:22subtlety and subtexts and saying something without having it plastered and flashing neon lights or
- 1:03:29whatever. The thing that I like most about season three so far is you're
- 1:03:35right, Aaron, you said this about a half hour ago, Like there's
- 1:03:38this is Trek being told in with characters, with feeling, with emotion,
- 1:03:45with real stakes, and when you see Patrick Stewart act this like, there's
- 1:03:52a moment I'll when you guys get to the row kind of layer and stuff,
- 1:03:55which, by the way, this podcast could almost be a two parter
- 1:03:58at this point. Boys, m oh well, no, don't worry.
- 1:04:00It's it's not that much to get to. But yeah, I know what
- 1:04:02you mean. Yeah, Like it's there are some moments genuinely in here.
- 1:04:09We're closing the loop on some plot threads that have been hanging for twenty five
- 1:04:15plus years, and this is something that Star Trek is finally getting a chance
- 1:04:21to close certain loops, and I'm loving how well it's finally paying off.
- 1:04:28I'm just really I'm more upset at season three for this reason. This is
- 1:04:32what season one should have been. This should have been resolving old things to
- 1:04:38reward old people who've watched the show for twenty thirty whatever years, and to
- 1:04:44get new people interested to seeing Okay, where did this start? Season three,
- 1:04:48as we've mentioned, has been a wonderful nostalgia trip, but some of
- 1:04:53it has been largely inconsequential. I'm looking at you, Ravy, but you
- 1:04:58look at the story that's being painted and even the idea of Piccard's son.
- 1:05:02You could call that hokey, but I like, we don't know where it's
- 1:05:08going yet either, Yeah, exactly. And I like the fact that you
- 1:05:12see panic in this guy's face and and how he reacts and yeah, he's
- 1:05:15got that I'm Jason Bourne moment in one part, which is ridiculous. But
- 1:05:21the red door, the blood connects, the blood culs and I keep thinking,
- 1:05:27are we going to see the black pyramid back there? Is he seeing
- 1:05:30what happens when when crew when bridge crew members die and get yeah, like
- 1:05:38like we are we seeing that? Like I mean, this is that that's
- 1:05:42an element that's a little bit of a holdover from the hokey stuff that uh,
- 1:05:46the Abrams verse kind of stuff that they would do, yeah, in
- 1:05:49their TV shows even outside of track. It's like, Okay, it is
- 1:05:54what it is. But I did like when like you're saying there like his
- 1:05:59reactions to it when they're like, how did you you know you took out
- 1:06:02four? You knowing that year in a moment, but like you know what
- 1:06:06the pot And he's like, I didn't know there were changelings And it's like
- 1:06:11he's scared, he's scared where he looks terrified of himself. Yes, fantastic.
- 1:06:19Yes, I was just about just about to bring that up because he
- 1:06:23says, I think there's something wrong with me, and I would like to
- 1:06:28know how many takes that took. I really have a feeling, just from
- 1:06:31my limited experience with acting, I think that was one of the shots that
- 1:06:36like, you know what, you got it, Let's move on, because
- 1:06:41that's just a moment you can capture in time where only the in my opinion,
- 1:06:46that super professional actors who've been doing it for like thirty forty years,
- 1:06:49they get a few moments like that in their career. I think this is
- 1:06:54one of that actor's big moments where like he nailed that moment, stakes are
- 1:06:59high, and then guess what, guys gotta tune in next week. I
- 1:07:02love that, and I really really appreciate that about this season because everything has
- 1:07:06just been elevated so much, and I know I'm putting this up on a
- 1:07:10pedestal despite we've had some goof some goofy moments, but everything so far as
- 1:07:15worked me. Like, and I said this to Alex while we were kind
- 1:07:16of watching, I haven't been excited to watch a Trek like this since Lower
- 1:07:23Decks. I love Lower Decks, I love Prodigy. I haven't gotten in
- 1:07:26the Strange New Worlds. I know, shoot me, um, but this
- 1:07:29is exciting. I'm actually legitimately excited to look forward to an episode of Picard.
- 1:07:33Why do you have to be over in four hours? Well when when,
- 1:07:36well, when this is over, Mike, with the advantages, you
- 1:07:39can then go and watch Strange New Worlds in preparation for season two. Yeah,
- 1:07:44you haven't watched straight so I mean it is. It is good.
- 1:07:47So there's like, I think one episode where I would say that you could
- 1:07:51skip it. Some other people would disagree with me. Although, yeah,
- 1:07:56it's it's probably the one, is it the Renaissance one, which is one
- 1:08:00of my I'm like, it's I didn't even rate it because I'm like,
- 1:08:03this isn't start it's I took it in my head. I started in my
- 1:08:09head. Not in a bad way. I'm not saying that in a bad
- 1:08:12way. I'm just saying like, this is so not a standard Star Trek
- 1:08:15episode that I can't really rate it as that. Mike. They wake up
- 1:08:23one day and the entire ship has been turned into a little Girl's imagination of
- 1:08:29a fairy tale. So like an episode of Voyager where they found the imaginary
- 1:08:33friend of Neelix's uh orpier. Captain Pike is now a wimpy jester. Everybody
- 1:08:44is like rent fair stuff, and they're they're basically having to act out a
- 1:08:50Dungeons of Drags. They don't know they're doing it. Yeah, they don't
- 1:08:55know they're doing The only person that knows that it's happening is, yeah,
- 1:09:02Benga and ham and hammered because he's blind. It's he's uh, his optical
- 1:09:11sensors whatever. He wasn't affected by whatever happened. So the entire episode he's
- 1:09:15just like, what the fuck is happening with you people? And they're all
- 1:09:18like dressed like pretty princesses and talking in ye old English okay, and he's
- 1:09:24like what is going on? He's like he's like, cease this, please
- 1:09:28stop. And then there and then like Benga's like, well look at yeah,
- 1:09:31and he's like play along. He's like anything to make the stop.
- 1:09:36And then like the whole time, like Pike is hamming it up worse than
- 1:09:41like than than like shattered, and it's over way over the top. But
- 1:09:45yeah, the episode is brilliant. It's terrible trek, but it's brilliant.
- 1:09:51Like, it's the most fun the actors had. You could there. You
- 1:09:55could almost see them almost breaking in every scene like they were. They was
- 1:09:59very hard for them to get all the shots. It's worth watching, Mike.
- 1:10:01But it doesn'tn't fit. I'm okay, you like, That's why I
- 1:10:05said it. Since it doesn't fit, you can skip it and not miss
- 1:10:08anything. But it is fun in its own way. Yeah, but yeah,
- 1:10:15getting back to you'll like it, Mike, believe me. Getting back
- 1:10:16to this. This this episode was how how does everybody deal with the idea
- 1:10:23that like they're on borow time and like you said, going to the the
- 1:10:28holow deck. Uh, I don't know. Had it ever been explained before
- 1:10:31that the hold doesn't give me no? Yeah, okay, so we'll save
- 1:10:39that. We'll just say that that that's that's not um or, or we'll
- 1:10:44say that it's solar powers. Why would you have it on a different emergency
- 1:10:47power reactor for a holiduck when you brought most likely rather have that hooked up
- 1:10:51to your life support so you could all have readable air. Um Can we
- 1:10:57just wave our hands and say it's because of the holod war for and here's
- 1:11:00the biggest argument against that. You say, oh, it's here as like
- 1:11:03a way to escape, you know, when when things are bad and the
- 1:11:08ship is burning up, that you can go to the holidack and spend your
- 1:11:11last moments happy. And when the answer the answer would be no, you'd
- 1:11:15be spending your last moments doing any Exactly what sucks is you have an engineering
- 1:11:19team desperately patching the hull and then half of them put down their freaking tools
- 1:11:25to go screw in the holidack. No, no, no, sir,
- 1:11:30let's let's let's ignore. So we're gonna We're gonna ignore it. I had
- 1:11:33to mention it. I'm sorry I had to bring it up, but we
- 1:11:36had to mention it. But we were talking about closing loops, Michael.
- 1:11:41The one of our fears was is Shaw going to be an asshole for no
- 1:11:45reason for this whole season, just because they want to make a snarky asshole.
- 1:11:48And it's like, yeah, no, they fixed. The biggest issue
- 1:11:51that I had from episode one was, you know, outside of my my
- 1:11:56not irrational hate but my dislike of RAFFI was, oh, is this going
- 1:12:01to be a whole season of this guy being being over the top asshole for
- 1:12:05no reason. No, we get one of the best performances of the show
- 1:12:11and literally like, oh, like he's basically turned. He's ignored his mental
- 1:12:18health for so long that his his post traumatic stress has internalized and made him
- 1:12:26extremely bitter and epathetic to his own job. And and he admits it in
- 1:12:31front of the crew there and we see us we see a little in that
- 1:12:36episode and the episode after we see he's still an asshole, but we see
- 1:12:41an uptick in its personality. It's almost like letting it out. Fine,
- 1:12:44like this had been boiling in him for obviously twenty five thirty years as it
- 1:12:48is, but and and exasperated much worse when he saw who showed up on
- 1:12:53his ship. That's why he was even more of a dick. And this
- 1:12:56finally that you know, he was just po dunk dude in engineering and the
- 1:13:03ship was burning around him, and he made it to the lifeboats and there
- 1:13:06was one lifeboat left. No one wanted to get on the lifeboat because there
- 1:13:12wasn't enough room, and then like a lieutenant showed up and ordered like random
- 1:13:16people onto the lifeboat, including him. And I showed Darlene the scene,
- 1:13:23and she hasn't been into card because she was really burned on the first two
- 1:13:27seasons. But she was like, oh my god, because you know that
- 1:13:31that lieutenant died and that he couldn't say thank you to the one lieutenant,
- 1:13:36the one person who basically just randomly saved his life, and now he has
- 1:13:42no idea why he lived, just random happenstance, right, and even said
- 1:13:48like he wasn't skilled. It wasn't like he was better. There were other
- 1:13:50people that were maybe better and more qualified. They just pointed random fingers and
- 1:13:55one was pointed. He's like once pointed at me. And then he goes
- 1:14:00eleven people of his ship, you know, potentially survived or whoever or however
- 1:14:03many who knows, we're blown up out there. But he mentions, wasn't
- 1:14:06it like six or eight thousand people or whatever? Maybe it was from whatever,
- 1:14:12like thousands of people just dead right there, and you know he's floating
- 1:14:15away and he's just like all it would have taken that lieutenant pointed that lieutenant
- 1:14:20could have taken half a second longer and pointed at somebody right next to hip.
- 1:14:25So there's that, you know, you have that lingering in you the
- 1:14:28whole time, and then you see face to face the face of your torment
- 1:14:33dead, and and and and being a very intelligent man himself anyway, knowing
- 1:14:42at his court, the logical part of his court, that this wasn't Piccard's
- 1:14:45fault, it wasn't his fault that this happened. But he's still, yeah,
- 1:14:50yeah, exactly, You're still the cause, Like he in his head,
- 1:14:54he's like, even though I know it's not your fault, you're the
- 1:14:57cause, and you're still praised. Yeah, why why why does everybody here
- 1:15:02forgive? People that I served with and I saw Burne in front of my
- 1:15:05eyes aren't And so you deal with it like and you see that, and
- 1:15:12he's never gonna be lovey devy with him, but you see like he was
- 1:15:16able to get it out. And we see over the next two this episode
- 1:15:20and the episode after that that he does fix his relationship with seven. Yeah
- 1:15:28uh for the most part, like to the point where there is an actual
- 1:15:31amount of he did. He admits he did not have enough respect for her
- 1:15:35for what she had gone through because he wasn't mad. He's he was mad
- 1:15:41at her because he sees Picard through her. Any Borg that comes back is
- 1:15:46still a potentially still cute. See, folks, if you can't tell the
- 1:15:51fact that we're just kind of talking about aspects of episodes that are going across
- 1:15:57different episodes, should say that there's meat in this season. Yeah, and
- 1:16:03we're not going as deeper as you know, assinineing to it as possible.
- 1:16:08These are just things there's so we can just see here and talk about them
- 1:16:12for however long we've been recording, like yeah, we could still go on
- 1:16:15and yeah, yeah, we're gonna go just a few minutes more. It's
- 1:16:19just basically rapid fire here. With this fourth episode, we have all this
- 1:16:24going on. We have Riker is trying to record essentially his his wartime letter,
- 1:16:31you know, in the event of my death, please send this to
- 1:16:33my loved ones, to Deanna, and he doesn't. He starts trying to
- 1:16:38record it, he can't finish it. He doesn't know what to do.
- 1:16:40He's still tormented by his own guilt over just having to bury his own child,
- 1:16:46you know, years prior. And that is that is rightfully brought up
- 1:16:49by Piccard, not in the most tactful way possible as as clouding his judgment
- 1:16:57for his own crew, like he's he's unwilling to put anybody at risk,
- 1:17:01and the unwillingness to put anybody at risk is actually making things worse. Uh,
- 1:17:06it's just not said in the nicest way possible. And then that's part
- 1:17:11of their main conflict and all the while, sort of the B plot,
- 1:17:15there's the C plot, I guess with Raffi and Wharf where they're trying to
- 1:17:18uncover where the portal gun is. By the way, we didn't mention that,
- 1:17:21but the portal gun's kind of cool. Um. Basically, it's literally,
- 1:17:26if you've played the video game Portal, it's the portal gun. You
- 1:17:29fire one point of entry. Uh, something goes into the portal you and
- 1:17:33it reappears somewhere else that you've calculated, and they use it to make it
- 1:17:36so that the ship can't escape. And then they even use it when uh
- 1:17:41Picard decides to order them to fire all their their phaser or fire their photon
- 1:17:46torpedoes. Good thing they didn't fire any quantum um and and I saw a
- 1:17:51comment online that we saying, why did they fire any quantum torpedoes? And
- 1:17:54it's and it was actually the Terry matallus the show who say they'd be dead
- 1:17:59equipped with Clum is no, but he's but but he literally is like if
- 1:18:03they had them and they fired them, they'd be dead because because it's like,
- 1:18:08okay, so just fire standard ones then um but still uh. And
- 1:18:13the actual B plot is that there's a saboteur on the ship and it's revealed
- 1:18:17that the the Changelings, like the Odo's race, right, the Founders are
- 1:18:24back, or a faction of them are back, and they're sabotaging the ship
- 1:18:28and they somehow want Card's son for some reason. And he's having all these
- 1:18:31weird blood flashes. I'm seriously hoping it's not that he's some hybrid uh DNA
- 1:18:38creature from them. We could will briefly talk about that at DAN because I
- 1:18:44have a couple theories too. But the idea is the plot is he's uncovering
- 1:18:47that there's a threat there. And this is sort of the b plot where
- 1:18:53Seven comes back to terms with with Shaw. He shows that he's not just
- 1:18:59some dumb um you know, uh captain that's mean to everybody. He's actually
- 1:19:03quite smart. He he is quite well read on everything, obviously having been
- 1:19:09in the Dominion war. Um, you know, he he knows everything about
- 1:19:13He knows enough about how changelings work and their physiology and what to look for.
- 1:19:18I did laugh at when he's like they leave like a good trail,
- 1:19:23Like I mean, it's it's it's done. But like the idea is he's
- 1:19:26hurt. Everything's going on. He's not going to be all formal and and
- 1:19:28remember everything. He's just like he's talking the way you would talk in a
- 1:19:31panic, if you're like, here's what you need to look for, um
- 1:19:35and uh, then we get a you know a little bit of uh standards,
- 1:19:41you know, changelings style tropes. You know, what do you look
- 1:19:45for when you um, you know, find the cracks in their logic,
- 1:19:49find the cracks in their knowledge. Uh, we find out the h that
- 1:19:56you know. They're going to try to harness the energy of this space.
- 1:20:01I guess labor that's happening, and they're going to suck in the energy from
- 1:20:06these contractions of this of this energy species. They don't know what it is
- 1:20:11and to do so, they're going to have to open the new cells and
- 1:20:14suck the energy directly in and low and behold. As mentioned earlier, he
- 1:20:20Shaw was an engineer, like a whiz kid engineer thirty years ago at the
- 1:20:26Battle of well Through five nine, so he knows how to actually, you
- 1:20:30know, override some stuff that the young cadets would young people wouldn't know.
- 1:20:35So he has to go do it with Seven. Laforge's daughter shows up.
- 1:20:40But to us the audience, we've you know, if you're anybody who's seen
- 1:20:43any amount of science fiction, you know what's coming that this is actually a
- 1:20:46change link. We find out it's because Seven has a personal relationship with the
- 1:20:51Forage and the Forge talk differently than she would have, and that's where we
- 1:20:56sort of see the mutual respect get back between the two between Shaw and Seven,
- 1:21:01and I like that. I like that character development there. And then
- 1:21:08we see that the Shrike has I know, I'm going rapid fire, but
- 1:21:10we'll get through it quickly. We see that the Shrike has the Captain I
- 1:21:14wrought a blank on her name, but it's uh vat Vatic it's right,
- 1:21:18played by Christopher Plumber's daughter, Manda Plumber. Christopher Plumber obviously being uh from
- 1:21:25the general Changer. I think it was the name Um. No relation obviously
- 1:21:30between the characters, just you know, fun little Um. I guess fun
- 1:21:34little familial note here um, and we find out that her hand is a
- 1:21:41change link. She's not a change link, but a changeling is masquerading as
- 1:21:45her hand. And also and also clearly controlling her, has something over her,
- 1:21:53has some sort of threat. So it's she's not as crazy evil as
- 1:21:58you might think. It looks like she's been driven to be that way because
- 1:22:01out of fear. Uh. And we see at the end of the of
- 1:22:06episode four, Richer does a pretty freaking funny and cool maneuver, which is,
- 1:22:12let's use a tractor beam and sling shot a meteor or or an aster
- 1:22:17asteroid sorry, meteors when it's as an a meteor when it's falling an asteroid
- 1:22:20when it's in space, right right into the meteors in the sky, burning
- 1:22:26up. Oh that's right, okay, sorry, yes, sorry, sorry,
- 1:22:30I got my science wrong. Uh. And he sling shots, it
- 1:22:34smashes into into the strike. The strike just basically has to limp away.
- 1:22:39And did you just throw you throw an asteroid? Goddamn right I did.
- 1:22:47And that's where I'm like, that's like the movie Riker, right, Like
- 1:22:49that's that's something I laughed at it. I'm like, you know, that's
- 1:22:53kind of fun. Okay, I'll take it. It's dumb, but it's
- 1:22:56fun, and it's sort of playing with the whole uh. You know,
- 1:23:00we had the portal thing, you know, here's here's a little here's a
- 1:23:03low fi, a low tech solution, even though it's using a tractor beam.
- 1:23:09Still um. And then we we that's you know, our arc ends
- 1:23:14with them, you know, going off into space, and I'm like,
- 1:23:15that's a cool little mini arc for like a miniseries arc. And then we
- 1:23:19have episode five and we bring h Row back. Now, I didn't watch
- 1:23:24as much seasons five through seven. I didn't know that inc Row was only
- 1:23:29in like nine episodes. I didn't see Um. I thought that she had.
- 1:23:32I thought she had see I thought she had joined as like a main
- 1:23:36character. I didn't. I honestly didn't know you were supposed to be.
- 1:23:40And then I think there was some writing problems. She was supposed to be
- 1:23:44a transition character for because oh, okay, that makes sense. But like
- 1:23:55I guess it's just because a lot of her episodes when they would do reruns
- 1:23:58were always shown on TV. UM. So I just assumed, like it's
- 1:24:02it's funny because I haven't done a full watch of Like I've seen a lot
- 1:24:06of seasons one through four, and then I've seen like the highlight episodes from
- 1:24:11seasons five through seven, so I didn't know that, but it's interesting to
- 1:24:14me. Um they so, you know, surprise, surprise, they they've
- 1:24:19already contacted Starfleet and they are now you know, Shaw was like, you're
- 1:24:24in troubo, but I'm gonna give you a few minutes to bullshit story stray
- 1:24:27story straight people. Yeah, that was funny. Yeah, so that was
- 1:24:32I was like, Okay, that's nice. I like that. And you
- 1:24:35know, surprise, surprise, who shows up? It's Row but now Commander
- 1:24:40somehow uh. And most of the episode, or at least half of it,
- 1:24:44is set up to be a very the thing situation where it's who is
- 1:24:49you know? Are you? Are you who you say you are? Uh?
- 1:24:53You know, is she being set up to be a changeling? Is
- 1:24:57she not being set up? And you know, you sort of sort of
- 1:25:00figure it out as it goes on, as they start to discuss things more
- 1:25:02in the holiday and you realize, you know, we get we get twenty
- 1:25:08five years of character development in the span of about and that is again some
- 1:25:14of the best stuff is new Trek has like Michelle Forge is that her name?
- 1:25:20Michelle Forge or Michelle Forge there, she's fantastic. Yeah, like this
- 1:25:26is career highlight performance from what I know of her. Um, Honestly,
- 1:25:31it's intense, it's emotional. And when her and Picard lay out all their
- 1:25:36cards out on the table and they basically say like it it's like a father
- 1:25:45daughter thing. It's like I wanted to mold you in my image, like,
- 1:25:47but I didn't want that. And again I want I wanted your basically,
- 1:25:53I wanted your respect and love, but not on your terms. Yeah,
- 1:25:57it's like, love me for who I am and what I can stand
- 1:26:00for on my own. I don't need your ideals. And I know she
- 1:26:03has a great line about just like you confuse duty and morality or something along
- 1:26:11those lines, and I'm thinking that's some fucking great writing, not you know,
- 1:26:17dual wielding Akimbo phasers and blowing people up. Like yeah, like there
- 1:26:25are some remember that's only on Tuesdays. Yeah, Like there are some moments
- 1:26:32with character development where you can accomplish something that, like I said, people
- 1:26:40have wanted to see what happened to Roe Larren since she disappeared way back when.
- 1:26:44And that's astounding writing. And it's not talking at the camera. It's
- 1:26:49not delivering a monologue or soliloquy or whatever. It's literally two people having a
- 1:26:56conversation. And even pick Card says this or she's like, He's like,
- 1:27:00I've been rehearsing this conversation for he has so much bitterness in his heart and
- 1:27:04what he feels she did, but doesn't understand her point of view on it.
- 1:27:10Yeah, yeah, because he if you look, why has he always
- 1:27:15been so close? Because anytime he opens his heart to somebody, they either
- 1:27:19die or betray him in his mind, Yeah, and so that's what he
- 1:27:24feels. So again, it almost lends into the discussion that we had,
- 1:27:28or and that he had with Beverly. Why should you know, why should
- 1:27:32she have told him about his son? If this is how he behaves when
- 1:27:36things don't go his way. So there's lots of things. It's very well
- 1:27:42done. You know, this is more conspiracy stuff. What she's setting up
- 1:27:47is she's setting up a conspiracy on the level of what we saw in season
- 1:27:53one's conspiracy, only with time to breathe. She's basically saying, hey,
- 1:27:59I've been monitored during she's the contact that WARF has and the start fleeting intelligence
- 1:28:03and she's been monitoring I think she said there were twelve incidents of changelains on
- 1:28:09ships that where people were killed and that that are being hushed up, and
- 1:28:14she's like, that's a lot even for us to have covered up, Like
- 1:28:18like it's one thing to maybe cover up one or two things to keep you
- 1:28:21know, keep the peace, but this is a pattern that is being covered
- 1:28:26up to the point where it should have been a it should have been something
- 1:28:29that was mentioned to senior level captains of ships, and it was being locked
- 1:28:32out from anybody outside of intelligence. That didn't make sense, and that similarly
- 1:28:39to the conspiracy episode ship move, ships are being moved around in weird ways
- 1:28:44that don't make sense. And when they're I think it's foundation day it's coming
- 1:28:50up, and she's like, every ship is going to be there, and
- 1:28:54that's not normal to have every ship in the fleet on display, and it
- 1:29:00doesn't make sense that this that this security memo has not gone out to anybody,
- 1:29:03and that and she felt that things are odd even on the ships that
- 1:29:08she's been serving on when she's gone out into space outside of intelligence so basically
- 1:29:14it's it's the you know, trust no one. Uh, it's done better
- 1:29:16than I think a conspiracy. It was still cool when you know that he
- 1:29:19met with the other captains on the planet and they they had to do the
- 1:29:23whole Are you who you say you are? It's very similar, except now
- 1:29:26we're not getting space bugs and we're getting changelings. But uh, you know,
- 1:29:31obviously they kill off the Row is dead by the end of this.
- 1:29:34You know, spoiler people, but this is how you can sell off a
- 1:29:39character. We know, this isn't each being ripped apart. He's not being
- 1:29:42ripped apart in the first ten seconds of an episode in some horrible torturous way.
- 1:29:46This is Row hands him her her Brajoran earpiece, her earring, walks
- 1:29:53away, and then you know her crew was actually changelings and they put a
- 1:30:00bomb ownership and what does she do. She come and cost ship and she
- 1:30:04it's gives them time because like she's flying close enough to the TOPI the was
- 1:30:11that the Intrepid? Uh, and she just guns it. She's like,
- 1:30:15all right, I know now that that the Intrepid has been compromised, even
- 1:30:19though a lot of the crew had been flown had been transported over there.
- 1:30:23So they have a skeleton crew basically running the Titan right now, and she
- 1:30:28just come and like the look on everybody's face and and like Captain Shaw is
- 1:30:32there and he's the look on his face is what the fuck just happened?
- 1:30:36Like like what? And like and then all the junior officers are like what,
- 1:30:43like just a commander from Starfleet just flew the ship? What? And
- 1:30:49uh, you know. Finally Shaw agrees, He's like, okay, like
- 1:30:54they're they're like, you've seen with your own eyes. If you don't,
- 1:30:56you don't have to trust us. Trust your own eyes. And he's like,
- 1:31:00all right, let's drive away, and they barely make it away,
- 1:31:03and this you know it. It's it ends with them with a Riker realizing
- 1:31:10that that the the earring was actually basically like a storage device. I think
- 1:31:17he called what you call it a data cube or something or or a data
- 1:31:19old school spycraft and I love that line. Yeah, and it pulls up
- 1:31:24and it's all and it's every report that she's been pulling up of all the
- 1:31:27movements of everything. And then we finally get to sort of meet face to
- 1:31:30face or at least video to face with Wharf and we're setting up you know
- 1:31:34what's potentially going to happen with this next arc being about the the some sort
- 1:31:41of insurgency within Starfleet by a violent Founder dominion war takeover, which as we
- 1:31:53begin to close out this episode, I'm gonna say this, in the next
- 1:31:57two episodes, major character dies, not just Row somebody. It's gonna be
- 1:32:01somebody from the TNG cast. And I can the reason I'm predicting that.
- 1:32:06Look at the trailers we saw in the preseason. Yes, and I guess
- 1:32:11sorry it closes with um this is the episode that closes, I think with
- 1:32:16the visions of Jack Crusher right yeah, where he's like he's like something seriously
- 1:32:23wrong with me and he's seeing like all these weird things happen. I will
- 1:32:26say very quickly what my predictions are or what or my things that I see
- 1:32:30where things are going here with Crusher. I think where they're leading us to
- 1:32:34believe with all these blood things that he's seeing is that he's some hybrid uh,
- 1:32:40that he's got human DNA and he's got Founder DNA and um u um
- 1:32:45with the reason, the one way it could go is that the they might
- 1:32:49be leading us to believe is that the Founders want him because he has This
- 1:32:56is gonna be stupid, but and I hope it's not going this way,
- 1:32:59because this is the stupid Piccard way of Seasons one and two, that they
- 1:33:02want him to go to their planet where he joins in what do they call
- 1:33:06it the Great Link? The Great Link because he has the DNA of Piccard,
- 1:33:13which will allow them to try to control the board through communication with the
- 1:33:18board. I have three the other way, the other way it goes in
- 1:33:25my head. He's not human at all, and he is a change link.
- 1:33:33He's a change link that has been tricked into He's a clone of Jack.
- 1:33:39Like the idea is Jack's talked about all these crazy things and trips that
- 1:33:43they've been on where they've been, they've had people hijacked their ships of this.
- 1:33:45At some point he was kidnapped and cloned and he's actually dead, Like
- 1:33:51the actual Jack is dead and this is a clone. He's he's a sleeper
- 1:33:56agent that doesn't realize he's a sleeper agent and some born identity bullshit. No,
- 1:34:01but what's gonna what I would if that's happen, If that happens and
- 1:34:04the real Jack is dead, and and he's been replaced or whatever, or
- 1:34:09he's been altered and he's a sleeper agent. What's going to happen is he's
- 1:34:13going to eventually he'll rebel against his sleeper agent programming or his founder program and
- 1:34:18he's end up going to end up basically still being the son um or or
- 1:34:25the message or in his head, like the message you kept hearing was come
- 1:34:30back to us, And I couldn't tell if that in my head. I
- 1:34:32couldn't tell if that sounded like V talking like or is it literally the board
- 1:34:41talking to him and he doesn't know what it is? Like? Does he
- 1:34:44have some genetic marker in him? Because his father before him, like his
- 1:34:49father was, was assimilated and then freed. But still I was able to
- 1:34:55have those hints of connections as we saw throughout first contact, and that he
- 1:35:00would get like the echoes where he could hear them. Is that some genetic
- 1:35:03marker that has changed within his body that when he sells a kid, that
- 1:35:06kid can also hear The Board had a touched on a couple of my theories,
- 1:35:10like one is that he's a change changeling sleeper agent, but the borg
- 1:35:15thing, I think he's human but because card was borg as Nanite's still in
- 1:35:23them and he had sex with Beverly And yeah, okay, are there so
- 1:35:31like like like Nanite's passing through through like vessels or whatever sort of thing slowly
- 1:35:38creeping through Jack's brain. Link with us, join with us, you know?
- 1:35:45Okay, that's fair. The whole link with us thing is like the
- 1:35:47great length, which like He's like, yeah, exactly is it a red
- 1:35:53herring? Like are they are they throwing that at us? Is it is
- 1:35:56the link with us? Return to us? Do they not know? Like
- 1:36:00are they saying it as if they're talking to a car, Like they don't
- 1:36:05they like? What's red in this show? Weird and creepy and deals with
- 1:36:12nuclear blasts, um, the the death bots from season one, the fucking
- 1:36:24Reapers. Hope it's not, but I can't. It's the Reapers. They
- 1:36:27bring them back? What what? What is what is the obsession with the
- 1:36:32writers of New Track and red things? The Red Angel, the the the
- 1:36:38Hut and you have a red door that he's seeing all the time, and
- 1:36:47and and what was it? The the burn was like a giant red explosion?
- 1:36:50What is this? What is the thing? Not the obsession with red
- 1:36:54things. Why can't but I can't. Problem Um, it's going to definitely
- 1:37:02whatever, we might be completely wrong, but I do think the key to
- 1:37:08this, whether or not he's a sleeper, is going to be that the
- 1:37:13Founders want him because of some connection to the Borg, whether it be that
- 1:37:18they want to be able to control the Borg or do they want do they
- 1:37:23want him because the Borg have found a way to to assimilate them, like
- 1:37:30have they been assimilated by the Boorg somehow or it's it's clear like it was
- 1:37:35mentioned. Actually, one thing I'll say, remember how we've said there was
- 1:37:40basically a clean bake from season one and two except for Raffi. There was
- 1:37:43a little mentioned at one point of Picard being a robot. Now they made
- 1:37:48like an offhanded remark and Captain Shaw. Captain Shaw when he's like, he's
- 1:37:54like, I don't care about the whatever Borg it was, and it's the
- 1:37:57board that are now apparently part of stuff about the real Borger part of the
- 1:38:00Federation. Yeah, he says, he's he's yeah, the real Borg are
- 1:38:04out there. It's like, oh, you just destroyed everything the writers trying
- 1:38:08to do the salison Pillborg aren't from our universe. There from that pocket universe
- 1:38:18exactly. And he's like, no, no, like the real Borg,
- 1:38:20the scary Borg are still there, is his response. Right, So there's
- 1:38:26that, uh, but I do think it's gonna be Borg. But also
- 1:38:30they did mention, uh the what was the what's the the Uh? That's
- 1:38:44that's what It's clear like what they showed, like what was stolen from there,
- 1:38:46what was probably stolen from there or how they got there would have been
- 1:38:49Moriarty. It's either that or date or Lore is there. It's one of
- 1:38:56two things, either Moriarty. Either Moriarty was used to get Lore or get
- 1:39:01get get something from there pertaining to Lore, or Lore was used to get
- 1:39:08in there, and we're gonna have to use moriarity to stop that. I
- 1:39:12think it would be fun that you you do have a link between the Borg
- 1:39:15and crewded Borg. So yeah, exactly. So it's all gonna come down
- 1:39:24like the right now where this arc is going to be about the founders and
- 1:39:30and the the change links for the next three or four episodes, and I
- 1:39:34think the final two episodes the double part. They already said that the last
- 1:39:38two are two part episodes, so expect like two hours or whatever program might
- 1:39:42even be longer episodes. That final two of my prediction is it's a board
- 1:39:46fight um or or a board or like whether it be something or other around
- 1:39:51that than that sense or I'm thinking the only other thing that they could throw
- 1:39:57at us is I'm thinking if it's something to do with the boy and the
- 1:40:00change links, because it would make sense, like the board can't assimilate the
- 1:40:03change links because they don't have a solid force, Like if you're trying to
- 1:40:08put nanites in or whatever and affect their cerebral cortex, how do you do
- 1:40:13it when they can shift their cerebral cortex to anywhere in their body, right,
- 1:40:16Like are they're more similar to like energy based being in that sense?
- 1:40:20I don't think I would see a problem with the borg assimilating change links in
- 1:40:26the end because they do have like a structure of some sort. They just
- 1:40:30kind of go um. They still have to have some sort of neuron.
- 1:40:33Yeah, maybe maybe maybe it's harder, it would be. It would be
- 1:40:38interesting to me. I would like to see it. If you know,
- 1:40:42is this a situation where the change links they're infiltrating us, they're screwing with
- 1:40:46us, But maybe they're doing it because they're afraid of the board, Um,
- 1:40:51like have the Borg decided that they've sent their sights on them or or
- 1:40:57like it is the reveal is there going to be like I know, we're
- 1:41:00getting a closing to this, this whole series. It's supposed to close everything
- 1:41:02for Picard and then maybe leave the doors open for spinoff series later on,
- 1:41:08Like if we are going to get a cliffhanger ending, not cliffhanger, but
- 1:41:12like like a post credit, you know, little tease. It would be
- 1:41:15interesting if what Starfleet Intelligence finds out or what this whole reveal is that there's
- 1:41:20been reports of Cube sightings and the Gamma quadrant like have like like what if
- 1:41:28the board went you know what, it's not worth it right now, we're
- 1:41:30giving up on going after the Alpha and Beta and it's Gamma. And that's
- 1:41:33why the Founders are on the move, like there's they're they're so freaked out
- 1:41:38that they think they have to control us because they can't ask free help.
- 1:41:42I think it's I think it's worth pointing out again that since we're just sitting
- 1:41:45here theorizing, it's enough information in this season so far that it's got our
- 1:41:49brains going and oh yeah, yeah, I can't. I can't wait for
- 1:41:55the final half. So that that's my closing thoughts. Sorry talking minds.
- 1:42:00There's so many good things about the first half of the season. Um,
- 1:42:04I have clapped watching this first half of this season. I have like literally
- 1:42:09stood up out of my chair and you know, good job show, Like
- 1:42:13seriously, you a surprised me. You did something that like really felt trek
- 1:42:18in a way that I hadn't seen before something like that. Um, I
- 1:42:24have I have been very positive with like Lower Decks and and Prodigy. This
- 1:42:29has made me feel very positive as well. And this is the treck we
- 1:42:34should have gotten when they launched Piccard. This is great. Oh yeah yeah,
- 1:42:42Like I'm with with like Aaron this like when I sat here with Alice,
- 1:42:45I said, this is a completely different show. This actually makes me
- 1:42:48excited. This this brings me back and makes me excited for what could come
- 1:42:54next. And I'm afraid yeah yeah, like a major legacy character is going
- 1:43:02to die in the next two episodes. What I'm afraid of is if it
- 1:43:05ends up being a board fight in the last two episodes, that that seven
- 1:43:10dead. If it's if it literally is a full scale board thing. I'm
- 1:43:14afraid of that, or or or them do like as long as they don't
- 1:43:17do the dumb thing and make her the queen. I am. I will
- 1:43:21tell you who is plot proof right now, depending on how risky they want
- 1:43:26to get, and then I seriously would like to eat some dinner. Okay,
- 1:43:30So um, I think I don't think Deanna is off the table.
- 1:43:35And here's why. It certainly adds a new layer of tragedy. But do
- 1:43:41you do it for tragedy's sakes? I don't think so. They still have
- 1:43:43a young girl, Yeah, but that might make I don't know. Riker
- 1:43:48may not be off the table either. I'm I have to if I had
- 1:43:53to predict Michael. Uh. We haven't seen Jordy. I think I think
- 1:44:00the big reveal is going to be that Geordie is captaining the Enterprise. And
- 1:44:03I don't think. I don't think he's captaining the Enterprise. I think he
- 1:44:09commandeers the Enterprise because I have I'm having this prediction that he's very smart.
- 1:44:14He's also in charge of isn't he in charge of the ship docks or whatever
- 1:44:17or the prongineering whatever, Yeah, whatever's going on there. What I think
- 1:44:26is going to happen is he's gonna find out what's been going on, Like
- 1:44:30he's going to get a message that hey, one of your daughter's ships is
- 1:44:34now rogue and wanted for attacking the Fat and he's gonna be like, that's
- 1:44:40that's not possible, and he's going to see a thing saying it's gonna say
- 1:44:44that, uh uh, the ship was hijacked by Riker and Piccardi's gonna be
- 1:44:47like, I don't believe it, but not with my daughter in there.
- 1:44:50And then he's going to get his other other daughter who's probably serving on the
- 1:44:55Enterprise, and he's going to take the ship over with him. I personally
- 1:44:59would love to see if it was like that he was he independently of Row
- 1:45:02was putting together that it doesn't make sense for these ships to be moved around
- 1:45:06or things like from from Starfleet, like from engineering didn't make sense, and
- 1:45:11he's going to figure something's wrong and show up. I would personally love to
- 1:45:15see like some major engineering conundrum that has to be solved with him one of
- 1:45:23his daughters and maybe O'Brien I don't know, But again, that's just if
- 1:45:29we're trying to do like fan service and stuff. I think he's going to
- 1:45:30show up on the Enterprise with his daughter, and that's how they're going to
- 1:45:34get saved at some point here, and they're gonna have to, you know,
- 1:45:38abandon the Titan over onto the Enterprise, and we're gonna regardless if it's
- 1:45:42in the next two episodes or in the last the final two, what might
- 1:45:45end up happening is the show might just end with the Bridge crew on the
- 1:45:50Enterprise flow. I don't want to make any predictions about who's gonna live and
- 1:45:54who's gonna die. I don't, yeah, but I but I think what
- 1:46:00I mean, what I was getting to is, I think it's possible that
- 1:46:02Jordy goes just because of how he's been talking in interviews, Like he's talking
- 1:46:10about how much he's been talking on like the the press junket circuit, but
- 1:46:15how much, how happy he was, and how he only came back on
- 1:46:19the condition that he was able to work with his daughter when they offered it
- 1:46:23to him. That was the that was the tipping point, and how it's
- 1:46:26important, how the show is important to him, and he's been the most
- 1:46:30teary eyed talking. So I'm just I'm just getting this odd feeling that it's
- 1:46:36that Jordy's going to have to do something, that something he's gonna have to
- 1:46:41do. He's he's gonna have his wrath of con going into the core moment.
- 1:46:45I'll be okay with that. I really would. Oh yeah, oh
- 1:46:50I'll be a mess. But but I just as you were sayingbut I just
- 1:46:54think if there's a main crew member, I think it's him. Yeah,
- 1:46:58you're probably right. All right, guy, So we are going to wrap
- 1:47:00this up, So thank you for enjoying this supersized episode. A Future Imperfect
- 1:47:04definitely. We are definitely a Dreadnought class now. So anyway, guys,
- 1:47:09we will be coming back with more Future Imperfect. We got we're going to
- 1:47:12do something on time travel movies. I know, me and Aaron we're going
- 1:47:15to talk about like me and Aaron had the show planned at since last year.
- 1:47:17We're gonna do something about cryptids at some point. We're going to talk
- 1:47:21about about other sci fi franchises you maybe have forgot about. We've just got
- 1:47:29a lot of interesting stuff cooking, and I think you're gonna be very very
- 1:47:31very pleased. Yea. As far as as far as doing a second half
- 1:47:35where we do episodes, you know, like like six to ten, we'll
- 1:47:41probably do that like this, and unless if a lot of really major stuff
- 1:47:45happened in the next two to three episodes, maybe we'll have to just we'll
- 1:47:47have to do it, split it into two episodes. Yeah, so you
- 1:47:51will definitely get more of this, and then we'll do kind of a Picard
- 1:47:55report card after everything is all said and done. So you'll hear us talk
- 1:47:59about season one, season two, and season three in their entirety. How
- 1:48:02does the Piccard series hold up and the legacy of the Jean Picard character as
- 1:48:06portrayed by Patrick Stewart. So, anyway, guys, for future imperfect joining
- 1:48:12us from the land of Kitchener, we have been alex I don't know what
- 1:48:15my rank is anymore. Sub commander, subcommand, subcomm Yeah, fuck you?
- 1:48:24What what was uh? Gall gall? Whatever? Call Alexander Gall Alexander.
- 1:48:32We'll go with that. It'd be like, what you're part of the
- 1:48:34dominion? Shut ups? And of course, or or I guess what's another
- 1:48:41good position, chief pray tour tour. I'd pray tour alex to be like,
- 1:48:48but there isn't any right, just let him have the title, okay,
- 1:48:55And and of course, it wouldn't be a future Parati without our trek
- 1:48:58expert. All right, guys, I have been Lieutenant Commander Mike the Birdman
- 1:49:02saying, and until next time, folks, live long and prosper computer.
- 1:49:08This is Captain James Kirk of the USS Enterprise Destruct sequence one COLDE one one
- 1:49:19A computer. Initiate the self destruct sequence authorization Jane Way Pie one one zero
- 1:49:26computer. This is Captain Benjamin Cisco. Initiate autodestruct sequence authorization Cisco Alpha one
- 1:49:33Alpha yin auto destruct sequence authorization Picard four seven Alpha Taco self destruct in fifteen
- 1:49:41minutes. There will be no further audio warning my lord, the ship appears
- 1:49:47to be deserted. How can that be? They're hiding, Yes, sir
- 1:49:53as the bridge scene will be run by computer. It is the only thing
- 1:49:56speaking speaking, let me hear nine eight seven. Fine. At no point
- 1:50:15in your rambling incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered
- 1:50:23a rational thought. Thanks for listening to this episode of This Weekend Geek Hungry.
- 1:50:29For more, check out our website. If this Weekend Geek dot net,
- 1:50:31you can subscribe to the podcast, browse our Twitter and Instagram, and
- 1:50:35leave your thoughts on today's topics. If you'd like to give us some feedback,
- 1:50:39send us an email at Feedback at this weekend geek dot net. Tune
- 1:50:43in next time and remember your shields and surrender your listenership. We would be
- 1:50:47honored if you would join us. Thank you for your cooperation. Good night,