Latest / Consumerpedia / 106 - Avoid a Vacation Rental Nightmare
Transcript
- 0:01You're planning your next vacation, and you've decided to
- 0:04stay in a vacation rental property rather than a hotel.
- 0:07Just beware, if something goes wrong with your rental, as can
- 0:11happen, you might be on your own.
- 0:14I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer Man, a contributing editor at
- 0:17checkbook.org. Welcome to Consumerpedia at
- 0:21checkbook.org. We're the nonprofit that helps
- 0:23consumers select services, avoid trouble, and save money.
- 0:27Because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 0:30any business, we recommend you can rely on checkbook.org to be
- 0:33completely independent and objective.
- 0:36Now here's the host of Consumerpedia, America's
- 0:39consumer expert, The Consumer Man Herb Wispom.
- 0:43In this episode, the results of a recent checkbook
- 0:46investigation, we found widespread problems with the
- 0:49websites that book vacation rentals, including fake listings
- 0:52and stolen deposits. Even worse, when something bad
- 0:56happens, many victims get little or no help from booking.com and
- 1:00VRBO. Kevin Brassler, Checkbooks
- 1:03Executive editor, is here with what he uncovered.
- 1:05Hello, Kevin. Hey, Herb.
- 1:06So today we're going to dive into something that millions of
- 1:09travellers now use every year, vacation rentals.
- 1:12And whether you've used Airbnb, VRBO or booking.com, you
- 1:16probably assume these platforms have your back if something goes
- 1:19wrong. I would, but Kevin did a deep
- 1:21dive into that assumption. And Kevin, the findings are
- 1:24pretty alarming. Yeah, and I'll say welcome
- 1:26listeners to what will be, you know, probably really a long
- 1:30rant for me about how these booking websites actually
- 1:33operate, specifically booking.com and Verbo.
- 1:37We found that generally when customers have problems, even
- 1:40serious problems like when they've been scammed on these
- 1:43websites, that they do very little to help these customers.
- 1:46They rarely issue refunds. They really, really, you know,
- 1:49offer to do anything. They say basically that
- 1:51customers are responsible for bearing all risks on these
- 1:54websites. And so, you know, anyways, I dug
- 1:56into this topic for several months, and the more I dug, the
- 1:59more concerned I got, the more frustrated I got.
- 2:01You know, not just as a consumer advocate, but as a traveler,
- 2:04that you think these websites are really there and that
- 2:06they'll protect you. These are huge, huge companies,
- 2:08multibillion dollar companies. But the reality is, if you run
- 2:12into trouble on Verbo or on booking.com, it's unlikely
- 2:15they're going to help you. So before we get into all the
- 2:17details, why don't you share with our listeners what made you
- 2:19want to investigate the vacation rental industry because that was
- 2:22something very personal to you. It all started more than a year
- 2:26ago. And when I learned, basically
- 2:27learned that two of my good friends had separately been
- 2:30scammed on one on Verbo and one on booking.com, the websites
- 2:35that I used to pay for my vacations in these two cases,
- 2:39you know, basically did nothing to help these people.
- 2:42More than a year ago, my family, we we were planning a trip to
- 2:44Venice for the day after Christmas and we were going to
- 2:47meet up with the Atkins. These are friends of ours who
- 2:50had at the time and still do they work for the State
- 2:52Department. They're stationed in India and
- 2:54our two oldest daughters are our best, best friends.
- 2:57And we just thought, well, you know, this would be a convenient
- 2:59place to meet up for the holidays.
- 3:00So kind of meet in the middle almost right.
- 3:03So a few weeks for the trip, Eric, the dad, he used
- 3:06booking.com and and he found like, you know, the perfect
- 3:09department in Venice and had positive reviews.
- 3:11The pictures look made it look great.
- 3:13The location was near the apartment that my family had
- 3:16already rented. So it seemed perfect.
- 3:18And he booked it. And because the trip was only a
- 3:20few weeks away, he had to pay in full up front.
- 3:23So it was about $1200 for a five night stay.
- 3:26But unfortunately, the apartment Eric booked it did not exist.
- 3:30What happened was scammers had created a fake listing they'd
- 3:33posted on booking.com. They took Eric's money and then
- 3:37they just disappear. So booking after I guess getting
- 3:40a lot of complaints from other customers about this listing,
- 3:44they removed it and they cancelled Eric's reservation.
- 3:46So we didn't do anything. All of a sudden he got a notice
- 3:48saying base was kind of fraud alert and he called the 800
- 3:51number. You couldn't get it, you know,
- 3:52an explanation. And then the next day, like it
- 3:54was cancelled, you had to find a different place to stay.
- 3:57So here's the thing, even though the scam occurred entirely
- 4:00within booking.com and Eric paid via booking.com, and even though
- 4:05booking.com canceled his reservation, he did not get a
- 4:09refund. At some point over the next
- 4:12several months, while he's been complaining to booking.com about
- 4:15this whole problem and I haven't gotten a refund.
- 4:16What's going on? He was promised one, but he
- 4:20still never got it. I mean, now it's more than 15
- 4:22months later and even though he's asked, you know, dozens of
- 4:25times and engaged with booking.com via phone calls and
- 4:29messages and emails, he still hasn't gotten a refund.
- 4:32So now Fast forward, that was like whatever 15 months ago,
- 4:35right? That's.
- 4:36Terrible, by the way. Well, it gets worse.
- 4:38So Fast forward about 5 months from them.
- 4:40So this is like, I don't know, around a year ago or so, right?
- 4:43Different friends of mine, they'd come to me and they'd
- 4:46say, hey, we're, I'm from Kentucky, right?
- 4:48I grew up in Kentucky. And they came to me and they
- 4:49said, hey, we're thinking about booking this big estate in
- 4:52Kentucky for a family reunion. And the only reason they were
- 4:54thinking about going to Kentucky at all was it was kind of
- 4:56centrally located to where they all live.
- 4:58But also it was just cheap, a multi multi bedroom house with a
- 5:02pool and all this stuff. And it wasn't very expensive
- 5:05because it's in, you know, the middle of nowhere Kentucky.
- 5:07And so they're asking me for things to do.
- 5:08And I said, well, yeah, you hit the bourbon trail with your
- 5:10kids, right, Go to Churchill Downs.
- 5:13But that's why they came to me. It wasn't because I was some
- 5:15kind of consumer expert. They want to know what they
- 5:17could do in Kentucky. So I gave them some ideas.
- 5:19And then later on, I just, I saw them again at the soccer field.
- 5:22And Susan, my friend said, oh, you know what, that thing, it
- 5:25was a total scam. They booked this property on
- 5:29Verbo. They prepaid more than $7000 for
- 5:33this week long stay and basically the people who are
- 5:36hosting this property just took the money and ran.
- 5:39So Kevin, just to be clear, both your friends, Eric and Shannon
- 5:42found out ahead of time that the booking was a scam.
- 5:44They didn't wind up and find out there wasn't a room there when
- 5:46they arrived to the vacation destination as many people.
- 5:49Have so the good news is I guess you know that both my friends,
- 5:53they each got lucky. I'm using quoting fingers for
- 5:55Lucky and that they learned that they had been scammed ahead of
- 5:59time. So in Eric's case, he still had
- 6:01like, I don't remember like 5-6 days to find a different place,
- 6:05place and book it. And interestingly, he rebooked
- 6:07at a second place using booking.com because basically
- 6:10they had promised him that OK, yeah, this is a scam.
- 6:13That's why we cancelled. We'll go ahead and refund your
- 6:15money. Go ahead and find a different
- 6:16property. And for a minute, booking.com
- 6:19tried to help him find a different place to stay.
- 6:22And the case of my other friend, basically Verbo kicked this
- 6:25company that hosted. It wasn't a fake listing what
- 6:29they were doing. They were legitimate listings.
- 6:31According to Verbo, what they were doing was taking deposits
- 6:34for properties or even full payment and then holding it for
- 6:37a little bit and then cancelling, but not returning
- 6:39the deposit. And so in the case of the Chuds,
- 6:42this Verbo place in Kentucky, they booked what might have been
- 6:45a legitimate property, but the people that were managing it and
- 6:49taking all the deposits for these properties, we're just
- 6:51cancelling on guests and not returning funds.
- 6:54They did this to a lot of people.
- 6:55They did it to bride to a plan weddings at some of these
- 6:58estates because it was more than just one place, more than just
- 7:01the one in Kentucky. They were all over the
- 7:02Southeast, but they had this long time reputation for
- 7:06basically taking in deposits and then stealing them essentially
- 7:10is what they were doing. So clearly this is not an
- 7:13isolated problem with a couple of people.
- 7:15This is a ongoing problem, an industry wide problem that's
- 7:18affecting a lot of people. At this point, like, you know, I
- 7:20learned about these two friends. Alarm bells are ringing in my
- 7:23head. So actually, I spent like a week
- 7:25just thinking about pretty much nothing else but vacation
- 7:28rentals. And you know how many people are
- 7:30victimized by this? Because this was a pretty easy
- 7:33way for people to steal money from my friends.
- 7:36You know how many fake listings are out there, how many people
- 7:38are complaining about these things?
- 7:39And in the end, you know, my friend's troubles kind of led me
- 7:42to find out that, you know, this problem is surprisingly
- 7:45widespread. And one reason I say it was
- 7:47surprising is that I use Verbo all the time to book vacations.
- 7:52I mean, I've probably had 30 or 40 stays using Verbo and, and
- 7:56fortunately I haven't had had problems.
- 7:59But after spending months digging, identifying and
- 8:03interviewing other victims, analyzing, we analyzed thousands
- 8:07of complaints. So the Better Business Bureau
- 8:08Against Problem Properties and Verbo and Booking and Airbnb,
- 8:12you know, we reviewed customer reviews on booking.com and
- 8:15Verbo. We found that there is this
- 8:17consistent pattern. Travelers book a stay that
- 8:20they're required to pay upfront. They do so sometimes in full,
- 8:24and then the host either cancels on them or disappears.
- 8:27The property turns out to be fake entirely.
- 8:29And here's the real concerning thing.
- 8:31And the surprising thing for me is that when victims turn to the
- 8:34platforms for help, when they've turned to booking.com and Verbo
- 8:38for help, we found that they're largely told, well, you're on
- 8:42your own. Sometimes travellers, they've
- 8:44done everything right. You know, they booked through a
- 8:46major platform. They paid through the platform.
- 8:49They're always warned, make sure you make all payments through
- 8:51our platform to keep you safe. But then they still got burned.
- 8:55And then when they asked for help, they had a wall.
- 8:57And that's the pattern that kept repeating.
- 8:59And then I decided, well, yeah, there's a story here.
- 9:01I can actually start writing this thing.
- 9:03And we'll get to that story next.
- 9:05What did Kevin find when he investigated the vacation rental
- 9:08business? I'm Herb Weisbaum, Consumer man,
- 9:10and this is Consumerpedia, powered by checkbook.org.
- 9:15At checkbook.org, we have the answers to your consumer
- 9:18questions 24/7. That's checkbook.org.
- 9:22We're a unique nonprofit that can help you with select local
- 9:24service providers, avoid trouble, and save money.
- 9:28Because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 9:31any business, we recommend you can rely on Checkbook to be
- 9:34completely independent and objective.
- 9:36Our advice is always free. Ratings of local services are
- 9:39available with a subscription. If you live in one of these 7
- 9:43metro areas and haven't joined checkbook yet, check us out.
- 9:46Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle, San Francisco,
- 9:50Minneapolis, Saint Paul and Washington DC Get your free 30
- 9:54day subscription by going to checkbook.org/consumer Pedia.
- 10:00So, Kevin, based on your friend's nightmare experiences,
- 10:02you decided to investigate the vacation rental industry.
- 10:05How widespread are the problems? Well, so it's hard to say after
- 10:08hearing about my friends getting scammed.
- 10:10You know, the first thing I did was just simply search
- 10:12booking.com, Verbo and Airbnb for specific terms like scam or
- 10:17fake listing. And because these websites, they
- 10:20index all their property reviews.
- 10:22So you stay at a place, you leave a review that gets indexed
- 10:24by Google. They want Google to index those
- 10:26reviews. And so I was able to spot, you
- 10:29know, just lots of problem properties right away.
- 10:31I mean, just within a few hours, I could identify like 25 to 50
- 10:36properties each on Verbo and booking.com just from people
- 10:39saying in the reviews, hey, this place doesn't exist or these
- 10:42people are total frauds. But what I found was really
- 10:45alarming is that some of these reviews complaining about fake
- 10:48listings, I mean, stolen deposits, fake listings, obvious
- 10:51problems, those reviews stretched back for months and
- 10:54sometimes even for more than a year.
- 10:56And so my first question was, well, why are these booking
- 10:58websites still hosting these properties if they're obviously
- 11:02set up to scam people? Good question.
- 11:04Yeah, And that was exactly the case with my friends, the Chuds.
- 11:08I mean, they had had their deposit stolen by these people
- 11:11running this estate in Kentucky, and the company these people had
- 11:14set up was offering dozens of similar estates and basically
- 11:18what they were just taking lots of deposits and then canceling
- 11:20later on. So did Verbo eventually kick
- 11:23them off? Yes, but not until lots and lots
- 11:26of consumers had been scammed. I mean, this is a company that
- 11:29was hosting properties on Verbo. They racked up 50 complaints
- 11:33with a Better Business Bureau on an F rating over the course of
- 11:36just a couple years. But according to those
- 11:39complaints and comported the reviews on Verbo, they had
- 11:41started stealing deposits in like April 2023 and Verbo didn't
- 11:47remove that company's listings until November 2024, which was
- 11:5118 months later. And even then they didn't refund
- 11:55their customers money. The money had been stolen is
- 11:58obviously this big problem, people complaining about it for
- 12:00a long time. What did VRBO do?
- 12:02They simply removed the listings and cancelled any future
- 12:05reservations, but didn't issue any refunds.
- 12:08So I'm curious, what do these booking platforms tell customers
- 12:11about their responsibility when something goes wrong?
- 12:13Don't they claim to protect them?
- 12:14Well, sort of. I mean, booking.com doesn't
- 12:17really make any kind of, you know, outward guarantees.
- 12:19They say if you run into a problem, we have 24 or 7
- 12:22customer help. It doesn't mean they'll actually
- 12:24help you. It's just that people are
- 12:25available to answer questions for 24 or 7.
- 12:28I guess taking complaints on the surface, Verbo seems to be
- 12:32helpful. They have Verbo has something
- 12:34called it's book with confidence guarantee.
- 12:36I mean, that sounds really reassuring, right?
- 12:38And it's in all their ads, it's on their homepage.
- 12:41But if you dig into their 10,000 plus word terms of service,
- 12:46which I did, I don't think many people are going to do that, but
- 12:49I did, their terms of service explicitly states that Verbo,
- 12:53it's just a venue. It's not a travel provider and
- 12:57it basically disclaims responsibility for any problems
- 13:00its customers encounter. And then if you dig into
- 13:03booking.com's terms and conditions, it's over 16,000
- 13:07words. But I dug in and it found that
- 13:09basically it says that quote, we're not a contractual party in
- 13:13quote to any booking. So essentially each of these
- 13:16companies is saying, look, you're dealing directly with the
- 13:19host. Yes, we have these properties
- 13:21listed on our websites. Yes, we urge you to pay through
- 13:25us to remain safe, but in the end, if anything goes wrong, Oh
- 13:29no, we're just a forum. We're just here to help you
- 13:32connect with people. Those are the people who have a
- 13:35contract with. So if there's some kind of
- 13:36problem, even if scams have occurred on our website,
- 13:40booking.com says essentially that's not our problem.
- 13:43That's a problem between you and the people who scammed you.
- 13:46We're just here to facilitate the transaction.
- 13:48So it sounds like when you looked into this, Airbnb handles
- 13:52things differently, better than Verbo.
- 13:54In terms of consumer protections against fraud, yes, I mean,
- 13:58Airbnb has its own kind of set of problems in that if you look
- 14:02at complaints filed against it with a Better Business Bureau,
- 14:05there's a lot of sketchy hosts on Airbnb.
- 14:07There's a lot of sketchy properties, a lot of people
- 14:09complaining about dirty properties or things.
- 14:11It wasn't what they expected, right?
- 14:13Or it's a shared house situation.
- 14:15I didn't think was going to be that.
- 14:17But at least with Airbnb, the difference is, is that Airbnb
- 14:21holds payments. They don't release any funds to
- 14:24hosts until about 24 hours after guests have checked in.
- 14:28And that's very different than Verbo and booking.com.
- 14:31With Verbo and booking.com, you as a host can opt to get paid
- 14:35right away. You can get deposits, which can
- 14:37be 50% of the cost of the stay, even if it's a year out or
- 14:40something right away. And so with Airbnb, because it
- 14:45doesn't release money until after people have checked in.
- 14:47Well, if you, there's no place to check in because it's a scam
- 14:49listing or it's not what was described right.
- 14:51Or if you're really unhappy and the problem goes against
- 14:54Airbnb's in terms and conditions for hosts, well, they can at
- 14:57least refund your money. The problem's not going to go
- 14:58away, but at least you get your money back.
- 15:00But in the case of booking.com and Verbo, no, these hosts,
- 15:04especially the criminals, the scammers can grab the money and
- 15:07just disappear with it. And that's what happened in the
- 15:09case of my friend Eric and Venice.
- 15:11You know, he lost his money to scammers because he paid via
- 15:14direct bank transfer. The money's gone and and that's
- 15:16likely why Bookie's reluctant to give him a refund, because they
- 15:19don't have the money. Which leads to the obvious
- 15:21question booking.com and verbal Why don't you just adopt the
- 15:24same model for protecting consumers that Airbnb has?
- 15:28That's the, in this case, the multibillion dollar question.
- 15:31They could eliminate a lot of this abuse simply by reforming
- 15:34how they handle payments. We also asked all three
- 15:37companies specific questions about how many fraudulent
- 15:40listings they remove each year. You know, how do you protect
- 15:43tech customers and under what conditions will you deny
- 15:46refunds? Because especially in the case
- 15:48of my friend Eric with the fake listing in Venice and several of
- 15:51the other victims we spoke to that booked fake properties, we
- 15:54just couldn't understand why they weren't issued a refund.
- 15:57They did everything they were supposed to do in terms of
- 15:59paying through the website, you know, paying through this
- 16:01booking platform and not paying, you know, around it or whatever.
- 16:04So Verbo and booking.com, they, they basically what got back
- 16:07were just vague PR statements that didn't address any of these
- 16:10questions. Booking.com said that customer
- 16:13services available 24/7. I've mentioned that already.
- 16:16Verbo just kind of pointed to its guarantee, but neither would
- 16:19tell us how often they actually issue refunds and bookie
- 16:22wouldn't tell us, well, how often, you know, does your
- 16:24guaranteed you kick it in? Do you actually give people
- 16:26money back when they've rented properties under your, you know,
- 16:30book with confidence guarantee? They wouldn't tell us.
- 16:32They couldn't tell us. So you said Eric paid via bank
- 16:34transfer. If he had paid via credit card
- 16:37then he could have complained to the credit card company.
- 16:39He got his money back, right? Yes.
- 16:41And so there's actually a key difference between what how Eric
- 16:44paid and how my friends, the chuds paid in that the chuds
- 16:48paid via credit card. So when their stay got cancelled
- 16:52essentially by Verbo, they heard from the host of this property.
- 16:56So sorry, this has been, you know, that we've been de
- 16:59platformed or what It was something like that that was the
- 17:01word and they used. But yeah, their stay had been
- 17:03cancelled. They were actually able to get
- 17:05their money back because they had paid by credit card and
- 17:08Verbo directed them to go ask for a chargeback from their
- 17:12credit card company and they were able to get it.
- 17:14Weird thing with that situation was these hosts who had stolen
- 17:18deposit and still haven't gotten it back to anybody told them
- 17:20initially, oh, if you fill out this refund form, we'll send you
- 17:24a refund via bank transfer. Give us your bank account number
- 17:28and the routing number. Well, what do you think would
- 17:29have happened if they had done that, right?
- 17:32But the problem is a lot of other people who had hired this
- 17:35company, who'd booked through this, this company that was
- 17:37stealing a bunch of deposits, they never got their money back
- 17:39because they didn't pay by credit card.
- 17:40They paid by debit card or bank transfer or cheque or some other
- 17:44way. And in Eric's case, the crooks
- 17:46who scammed him, they insisted the only way he could pay was
- 17:49bank transfer. They wouldn't even take a credit
- 17:51card. And so Eric was like, well, that
- 17:53seems weird. So he did a quick Internet
- 17:55search about it and found that, no, it's actually quite common
- 17:57on Verbo and these other websites that people request
- 18:00payment via transfer because then they don't have to pay the
- 18:03credit card company these big fees.
- 18:05So he went ahead and did it. He thought, oh, I'm dealing with
- 18:07booking.com. It's a multi billion dollar
- 18:09company. It's the largest travel booking
- 18:10website in the world. What could go wrong?
- 18:13Well, this is what went wrong. He still hasn't gotten his money
- 18:15back. One more thing you touched on in
- 18:17your article is fake reviews. How big a problem is that?
- 18:21Yeah, it's a real problem. Your host can easily generate
- 18:24fake positive reviews by essentially booking their own
- 18:27property from themselves. You know, use a dummy e-mail.
- 18:30Or have it, you know, have a friend do it for them.
- 18:33So then the their cost of doing that is, you know, they have to
- 18:35pay the platform a Commission, which is a small price to pay if
- 18:39you're intending on setting up fake listings and then later on
- 18:42keeping people's full deposits, right?
- 18:44It's a little bit of an investment you make to get your
- 18:47thing up there with a couple positive reviews and then you
- 18:49get to take other people's money.
- 18:51And that's probably what happened with Eric.
- 18:53You know, the other thing we found is that even when people
- 18:55leave legitimate negative reviews, sometimes they kind of
- 18:59get buried under how these platforms, how their rating
- 19:02systems work. We found a property in Glasgow
- 19:04when we're doing all this research, It was ranked dead
- 19:07last on booking.com. It was ranked 413 out of 413
- 19:12properties in Glasgow. And yet booking.com at the time
- 19:16still displayed this guest choice badge along with that
- 19:20property really well. How did it get guest choice?
- 19:23It's dead last, right? Well, it's based on the fact
- 19:26that had a pile of reviews. All the reviews were negative,
- 19:29but at least had a pile of reviews.
- 19:30And that was enough for bookie.com, I guess, to decide
- 19:32was going to get this badge. So that was one of the things we
- 19:35asked booking.com to explain. We're like, how's this
- 19:37happening? booking.com never responded to
- 19:39that question. We sent it multiple times.
- 19:42And then a few weeks after we initially asked about this, this
- 19:45guest choice badge, it removed it entirely from all the
- 19:48listings on this website. It just stopped using it, which
- 19:51was, yeah, a little lot, a little a little curious.
- 19:54Way to go, Kevin. Well, clearly there is a problem
- 19:57here. So how do you protect yourself
- 19:58when you book a vacation rental? Kevin has some important tips to
- 20:01share with you. Next.
- 20:02I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer man, and you're listening.
- 20:04To Consumer Pedia, powered by checkbook.org.
- 20:08Consumer Pedia. Fast Facts.
- 20:11According to a Statistic Consumer Insight survey, 54% of
- 20:15those who traveled for pleasure in the past year stayed in a
- 20:18hotel. 20% stayed in a vacation rental house or apartment
- 20:21through booking platforms like Airbnb or VRBO. 17% stayed at a
- 20:26campsite for international travel.
- 20:28Hotels were also the most popular.
- 20:30Pick 55% of travelers on a pleasure trip to the United
- 20:34Kingdom and 48% to Germany. Choose a hotel.
- 20:37Statista also asked travelers which type of pleasure trips
- 20:40they took in the past. 12 months 60.
- 20:42Percent said. They went to see.
- 20:43Family and friends, other popular getaways, beach vacation
- 20:47and city trips followed by a nature or outdoors vacation.
- 20:53OK, so you've heard all the potential risks involved with
- 20:56using a vacation rental booking site.
- 20:57What should you do if you go this route rather than staying
- 21:00in a hotel? And as we touched on Kevin, the
- 21:02only way to pay to be safe is with a credit card.
- 21:05Yeah, and that's the most important thing to do.
- 21:07I mean, don't pay by bank transfer.
- 21:09Don't even use a debit card. Use a credit card, because if
- 21:11you run into trouble, at least you can get your money back.
- 21:14The problem's not going to go away, but at least you can get
- 21:16your money back. The other thing is, I think
- 21:18Airbnb, it does offer stronger consumer protections.
- 21:21We've touched on that too. Having said that, no matter
- 21:25where you book, if you're booking a vacation rental, just
- 21:27know, look, this is going to be treated as a transaction between
- 21:31you and whoever the hosts are. The hosts are criminals.
- 21:33You're dealing with criminals that no one's going to step in,
- 21:36even these trusted brands and make things right.
- 21:39If you go wrong, you have to just assume this is that you're
- 21:41on your own and be very careful. Any other red flags we should
- 21:44look out for? You know, I'd be wary of of new
- 21:47listings with no reviews and I would be very wary of listings
- 21:50where, oh, they have some reviews, but they're all very
- 21:53recent and all very positive. At this point, I would only book
- 21:56a property that has reviews stretching back six months or
- 22:00longer, maybe even a year. And I would really make sure
- 22:04that there are no negative reviews that say this is a scam
- 22:06listing. I mean, I would read every
- 22:08single review. Make sure you look at all of
- 22:10them as the sites say, as the platform say, you shouldn't pay
- 22:14anybody outside the platform. I think that's a good rule.
- 22:17But just know that that even when you're paying within the
- 22:19platform, if you get scammed, you might not get your money
- 22:21back. Another thing is check the
- 22:23photos. In the case of Eric, there were
- 22:24great photos of this fake apartment, but, you know, check
- 22:27that the photos show the exterior of the building, you
- 22:29know, the street, multiple rooms.
- 22:32And I would also try to avoid properties that require really
- 22:35big upfront deposits, although in some cases that's hard to do,
- 22:38like if you're going to Maui for a week, you might have to pay
- 22:4050% upfront. That's just kind of the way it
- 22:42works. What about the travel protection
- 22:44insurance sold by these platforms?
- 22:46And that was the other thing we thought, well, maybe if they had
- 22:47bought travel insurance, you know, that would kick in.
- 22:50Nope. I mean, we looked into the fine
- 22:52print for the insurance policy sold by Verbo, and it explicitly
- 22:55excludes fraud in most cases. So if you've been scammed, the
- 23:00insurance policies you buy these trip interruption plans largely
- 23:03won't protect you. You won't get your money back
- 23:05that way either. Well, they sell your protection.
- 23:07That won't protect you. That's right.
- 23:09And they have a guarantee that doesn't necessarily kick in.
- 23:11It's their book with confidence guarantee, but it only applies
- 23:14that they feel like applying it to your case.
- 23:16So it sounds like there's some changes needed in this industry.
- 23:19It's unfair for these huge companies, multibillion dollar
- 23:22companies to profit enormously from these transactions.
- 23:26Oh, but when there is a problem, we claim no responsibility.
- 23:31Even if we've basically enabled a scam on our website, we're not
- 23:35going to refund you money or we're going to just make it so
- 23:37much trouble that you're not going to get the refund.
- 23:39I mean, Airbnb is showing here that, you know, you can run a
- 23:42profitable marketplace while still holding customer funds
- 23:46until check in, while still, you know, maintaining charge of this
- 23:50transaction. And so booking in Verbo, they
- 23:52could do the same thing. And until then, basically what
- 23:55they're saying is that the burden falls on on their
- 23:58customers and that any risk that's out there that you're
- 24:02taking the risk, not these huge multibillion dollar companies
- 24:05that encourage you to book through their websites.
- 24:07Kevin, this has been an eye opening conversation.
- 24:09Kevin Brassler is executive Editor at checkbook.org and also
- 24:13a frequent traveler. And now you know why.
- 24:15When the Consumer Man and Mrs. Consumer Man travel, we go to
- 24:18Sheraton or Hyatt or Marriott or something like that.
- 24:21May be dirty inside, but there's always a building there.
- 24:24Well, it's not. It's not a terrible point to
- 24:25make. I mean, this is my colleagues
- 24:26and I were talking about this. We're doing the research.
- 24:28And one of them said, I think the lesson here is just always
- 24:30stay in a hotel. And it's not such terrible
- 24:32advice because there's another problem with these vacation
- 24:35rental properties in that in some of these cities, especially
- 24:39including places like Venice and Paris and Barcelona, they're
- 24:42actually a big problem in terms of the local economy.
- 24:45They drive up real estate costs for everyone living there.
- 24:47You have some communities like Barcelona, which have moved to
- 24:50basically ban these rentals and the long term or they've set
- 24:54such strict, you know, limitations in place, it's
- 24:56really hard to operate one of these places.
- 24:58And I don't think that's such a bad thing either.
- 25:00I mean, I think they're trying to, you know, help their year
- 25:02round citizens have affordable places to live.
- 25:05And that is another problem. It's kind of a different
- 25:07problem, but yet another problem with vacation and rental
- 25:10properties. So I would say that, you know,
- 25:11it's just something to consider when you book, but more than
- 25:14anything, the thing to consider is please pay by credit card if
- 25:18you can. All right, well, we know you got
- 25:19a pack for the next trip, so safe travels, Kevin.
- 25:22Thanks Herb, Good to talk to you before.
- 25:23We go a few related Consumerpedia episodes you might
- 25:26want to check out number 89 How to avoid a hotel horror show,
- 25:31number 86 travel tips, how to find deals and avoid scams, and
- 25:35#60 how to avoid a big cell phone bill when traveling
- 25:39Abroad. And with that, we're out of
- 25:41time. We hope you we'll rate this
- 25:43episode. It's really helpful.
- 25:44And follow us on Apple Podcast, Spotify or wherever you listen
- 25:48to your podcasts. Remember, we release new
- 25:50episodes every other Thursday. Another way you can support this
- 25:54show is to follow us at Consumerpedia on Facebook and
- 25:57Instagram, at consumerpedia.org on Blue Sky and at my
- 26:01Consumerpedia on X. You can find me at
- 26:04consumerman.com. I'm her Weissbaum always looking
- 26:08out for you. Until next time, be smart and
- 26:11shop wisely. Consumerpedia is a public
- 26:14service of checkbook.org. We're a unique nonprofit that
- 26:17helps you save money and make smarter choices.
- 26:19You can count on Checkbook to help you find the best services
- 26:22and avoid the worst with local ratings that are accurate and
- 26:26unbiased. If you live in or around these
- 26:28seven cities and haven't joined Checkbook yet, check us out
- 26:32Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Minneapolis, Saint Paul,
- 26:35Seattle, San Francisco, and Washington DC.
- 26:39To get your free 30 day subscription, go to
- 26:41checkbook.org slash Consumer Pedia Consumer Pedia.
- 26:45Empowering consumers to save money and make smarter choices.