Latest / Bloomberg Law / Will Boeing Be Prosecuted & EPA Power Plant Rules
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 1: Boeing is under fire, facing investigations by the Federal Aviation Administration,
- 0:15Speaker 1: the Justice Department, and the National Transportation Safety Board. What's more,
- 0:20Speaker 1: Justice could tear up a controversial twenty twenty one deferred
- 0:24Speaker 1: prosecution agreement that allowed Boeing to escape criminal charges over
- 0:29Speaker 1: crashes in twenty eighteen and twenty nineteen that killed three
- 0:33Speaker 1: hundred and forty six people. And the testimony before Congress
- 0:36Speaker 1: two weeks ago of whistleblower Sam Salapor, a Boeing engineer,
- 0:41Speaker 1: could illustrate a reason for the Justice Department to tear
- 0:45Speaker 1: up that deferred prosecution agreement.
- 0:47Speaker 2: The NTSB chair reiterated Congress last week that Boeing has
- 0:50Speaker 2: said there are no records documenting the removal of the
- 0:54Speaker 2: last airline store. I'm not going to sugarcoat this. This
- 0:57Speaker 2: is a criminal cover up. Records do in fact exist.
- 1:00Speaker 2: I know this because I've personally passed them to the FBI.
- 1:04Speaker 1: Joining me, is Bloomberg Legal reporter Greg Farrell. Greg tell
- 1:07Speaker 1: us about the deferred prosecution agreement with Boeing.
- 1:10Speaker 3: This deferred prosecution agreement has turned out to be controversial
- 1:15Speaker 3: insofar as it was struck in the winning days of
- 1:18Speaker 3: the Trump administration, and in fact it was signed on
- 1:20Speaker 3: January sixth, twenty twenty one. You know, most news covers
- 1:24Speaker 3: that day focused on other events in Washington, DC rather
- 1:27Speaker 3: than on the Boeing TPA. It got almost no coverage
- 1:30Speaker 3: at the time, but essentially following two horrific crashes that
- 1:34Speaker 3: took the lives of three hundred and forty six people
- 1:37Speaker 3: and a two year Justice Department investigation, ended up with
- 1:41Speaker 3: a fine at the low end of two hundred and
- 1:43Speaker 3: forty three million dollars and acknowledgment that Boeing didn't cooperate
- 1:47Speaker 3: with the investigation for several months at the beginning. So
- 1:50Speaker 3: they got a good deal despite not cooperating very much.
- 1:53Speaker 3: They got a deferred prosecution agreement instead of an actual
- 1:55Speaker 3: criminal charge.
- 1:57Speaker 1: The families of the people that are killed, were they
- 2:01Speaker 1: not happy about that Boeing agreement.
- 2:05Speaker 3: Absolutely. First of all, they were blindsided by this settlement.
- 2:08Speaker 3: They suddenly just announced, you know, on January seventh. They
- 2:12Speaker 3: had asked the Justice Department on several occasions, you know,
- 2:15Speaker 3: throughout twenty nineteen and twenty twenty. You know, if they're
- 2:18Speaker 3: investigating Boeing and how's the criminal investigation going. And we're
- 2:20Speaker 3: told in twenty twenty that there was no criminal investigation,
- 2:23Speaker 3: so you know, they were not happy with that, but
- 2:26Speaker 3: they sort of had to deal with that and move on.
- 2:28Speaker 3: And then suddenly to find out that there was a
- 2:30Speaker 3: criminal investigation that they weren't informed of that it ended
- 2:32Speaker 3: up being very favorable to Boeing, and they weren't even consulted.
- 2:36Speaker 3: They were just shocked and blindsided by that. That really
- 2:39Speaker 3: like there was sault in the wound. And then the
- 2:42Speaker 3: charge that to which Boeing acknowledged its misconduct but didn't
- 2:46Speaker 3: have to plead guilty too as of then was defrauding
- 2:49Speaker 3: the US government by being dishonest with the FAA over
- 2:53Speaker 3: the need for extra training because of this this new
- 2:56Speaker 3: software program that would be an automated steering system under
- 3:00Speaker 3: certain circumstances, and eventually, you know, it was blamed for
- 3:05Speaker 3: you know, both of these failed crashes. The government focused
- 3:09Speaker 3: only on misleading the FAA, But what they did not
- 3:13Speaker 3: pay any attention to was the fact that boeinghead insisted
- 3:16Speaker 3: that the plane was safe even after the first crash.
- 3:19Speaker 3: The material has emerged in various congressional investigations that the
- 3:22Speaker 3: top executives were aware and trying to fix you a
- 3:25Speaker 3: possible problem with the steering during a period of time,
- 3:29Speaker 3: but the Justice Department did not bring any action against
- 3:31Speaker 3: senior executives at all. Instead, the only criminal charge for
- 3:35Speaker 3: an individual was this mid level technical pilot, a guy
- 3:38Speaker 3: named Mark Folkner, who was tried and acquitted in like
- 3:42Speaker 3: two hours. It was clearly viewed as a scapegoat by
- 3:45Speaker 3: the jury and even the FAA witnesses who were called
- 3:49Speaker 3: to testify, the ones who were deceived that felt the
- 3:52Speaker 3: same thing, even though this guy is just being set
- 3:54Speaker 3: up by the company. That's the sign of a weak
- 3:56Speaker 3: DPA is that you're blaming the death of three forty
- 4:00Speaker 3: six people, two horrific crashes on this controversial system that
- 4:04Speaker 3: was not disclosed through the FA, all on one guy,
- 4:06Speaker 3: as if no one above him knew about this.
- 4:09Speaker 1: So, you know, we all know about that recent Boeing
- 4:12Speaker 1: mid air blowout of the door plug, so bad luck
- 4:15Speaker 1: for Boeing. That was just days before this deferred prosecution agreement,
- 4:20Speaker 1: and we.
- 4:21Speaker 3: Were the first to report that that it came just
- 4:23Speaker 3: two days before the three year term expired and shortly thereafter,
- 4:27Speaker 3: the Justice Department did start looking into that two parts
- 4:30Speaker 3: of criminal investigation into any whether any laws were broken
- 4:34Speaker 3: in terms of how this door plug came off, did
- 4:37Speaker 3: going again hide records or not disclosed things they should
- 4:40Speaker 3: have disclosed, And you know, concurrently with that, part of
- 4:43Speaker 3: the terms of the DPA is that you've got to
- 4:45Speaker 3: be good for three years, improve your disclosure system so
- 4:48Speaker 3: that you never deceive regulators again and don't commit any ponies.
- 4:52Speaker 3: And if it turns out that there was a felony
- 4:55Speaker 3: associated some evidence of criminal activity in either hiding or concealing,
- 5:00Speaker 3: are not doing the proper work or disclosing it about
- 5:02Speaker 3: the door plug? And that would be adequate grounds for
- 5:05Speaker 3: the government to tear up the DPA.
- 5:07Speaker 1: And there was congressional testimony that Boeing was not cooperating
- 5:11Speaker 1: and wouldn't give over the list of people who'd worked
- 5:13Speaker 1: on the door and said records had apparently disappeared, and
- 5:17Speaker 1: all this was hampering the government's investigation into the incident.
- 5:20Speaker 3: There should be like, you know, some kind of a
- 5:22Speaker 3: work review exactly over who did what and who would
- 5:24Speaker 3: the last people to look at the door plug, And
- 5:26Speaker 3: there was a there was a gap or at least
- 5:28Speaker 3: Boeing didn't have anything. And there was a whistleblower who
- 5:31Speaker 3: testified in Congress, you know, like two weeks ago, saying
- 5:34Speaker 3: that he was aware of paperwork and he had handed
- 5:36Speaker 3: it over to the FBI. So, yes, we have whistleblowers,
- 5:39Speaker 3: current and former who stay pluggedn't no pun intended to
- 5:43Speaker 3: what's going on at Boeing, you know, also calling attention
- 5:47Speaker 3: to this stuff.
- 5:47Speaker 1: So the victims' families have certain rights under the crime victims'
- 5:52Speaker 1: rights laws, and tell us about the attorney who's working
- 5:55Speaker 1: for them on this deferred prosecution agreement.
- 5:59Speaker 3: Hey, former federal judge a laury named Paul Cassel, based
- 6:02Speaker 3: in Utah took up the cause of trying to attack
- 6:06Speaker 3: the DPA intervene in the district in Texas where this
- 6:10Speaker 3: case was brought, and he was shot out Initially. The
- 6:14Speaker 3: judge eventually recognized that the families were victims and that
- 6:17Speaker 3: they were improperly shut out by the Just Department from
- 6:20Speaker 3: proper consultation before reaching this determination in the DPA. It
- 6:24Speaker 3: doesn't mean that the victims get a veal power over
- 6:27Speaker 3: what the prosecutors are going to decide, but it does
- 6:31Speaker 3: force the government to make sure they keep victims' families
- 6:33Speaker 3: surprised of what they're doing.
- 6:35Speaker 1: And the families of the victims had a meeting with
- 6:37Speaker 1: the Justice Department last week.
- 6:39Speaker 3: Just from this time wants to do right by the
- 6:41Speaker 3: victims in so far as to make sure they do
- 6:43Speaker 3: not repeat the mistakes of three years ago. So the
- 6:46Speaker 3: government they have six months to determine whether or not
- 6:49Speaker 3: the company complied with the elements of the DPA, and
- 6:52Speaker 3: six months from January seventh to July seventh. So as
- 6:55Speaker 3: that date is approaching, the family's gotten more concerned. The
- 6:58Speaker 3: government decided to bring them in to let them know
- 7:00Speaker 3: what was going on, also give them an opportunity if
- 7:03Speaker 3: they had any evidence to indicate that Boeing had violated
- 7:06Speaker 3: the terms of the DPA, they should bring it there.
- 7:09Speaker 3: Although that's unrealistic. It's not up to the families to
- 7:11Speaker 3: do an investigation. It's actually the Justice Department's job. But
- 7:15Speaker 3: they did at least do what they did not do
- 7:17Speaker 3: four years ago and keep them apprized. They went a
- 7:20Speaker 3: little further and gave them some information about how this
- 7:23Speaker 3: is going to go down. They told the victims' families
- 7:26Speaker 3: and their lawyers if they hadn't made a decision yet
- 7:28Speaker 3: on what to do, whether not to tear up the
- 7:31Speaker 3: DPA or withdraw the true charge that was lodged three
- 7:35Speaker 3: years ago. Because they haven't made that decision, they expect
- 7:38Speaker 3: and hope to make it by the end of May
- 7:40Speaker 3: early June, in other words, and they said that if
- 7:44Speaker 3: they decide to withdraw the charge, the families will be
- 7:48Speaker 3: the first to know. They won't have to learn about
- 7:50Speaker 3: in the media the way they did three years ago. However,
- 7:53Speaker 3: if they do decide to tare up the DPA, they
- 7:55Speaker 3: want to give Boeing at least thirty days noticed so
- 7:58Speaker 3: they can appeal or argue against it, et cetera. So
- 8:01Speaker 3: that was the message from the Justice Department to the families.
- 8:05Speaker 1: Last week you mentioned Paul Cassell. He said, we have
- 8:08Speaker 1: no idea what the Justice Department will do, which leads
- 8:11Speaker 1: us to believe they're still in bed with Boeing, and
- 8:13Speaker 1: if they move to dismiss, we'll fight that motion vigorously.
- 8:17Speaker 1: Do you really think they'll dismiss when there's this criminal
- 8:19Speaker 1: investigation and other investigations into the Alaska air incident. I mean,
- 8:25Speaker 1: it would be controversial if they let Boeing off the hook.
- 8:27Speaker 3: Right, So politically, the optics of this for the Justice
- 8:31Speaker 3: Partment would not be good. If they determined that Boeing
- 8:33Speaker 3: as in fact not violated any term of it, they
- 8:35Speaker 3: would draw the charge. They might be able to justify
- 8:37Speaker 3: that legally, but it will look bad. It'll just be
- 8:40Speaker 3: another set of news cycles. At the same time, you
- 8:42Speaker 3: should not bring a charge because you don't want to
- 8:44Speaker 3: look bad. And clearly there's enough here because of this
- 8:47Speaker 3: Alaska Air incident. The Alaska Air incident really did trigger
- 8:51Speaker 3: this investigation. I think if it weren't for that incident,
- 8:54Speaker 3: that would be well on our way to a withdrawal.
- 8:56Speaker 3: But I think it's clear that the government is taking
- 8:59Speaker 3: this seriously. Paul. I think that's a default position because
- 9:02Speaker 3: of what happened a few years ago and that the
- 9:03Speaker 3: Justice Department has been unhelpful to the families. But at
- 9:07Speaker 3: the same time, it's not up to the Justice Department
- 9:09Speaker 3: to show their cards, you know, and if we take
- 9:11Speaker 3: them at their word that they haven't decided yet, right,
- 9:13Speaker 3: it would be improper for them to show their card.
- 9:15Speaker 3: So if the just Go Barnment does move to withdraw
- 9:18Speaker 3: this charge, then Paul Cassell does plan to litigate it
- 9:21Speaker 3: in the in Fort Worth. And this is far more
- 9:23Speaker 3: legal detail than you know, most people want to know,
- 9:27Speaker 3: but there's precedent. There have been several decisions going up
- 9:30Speaker 3: to the Supreme Court in recent years about judicial challenges
- 9:34Speaker 3: to defer prosecution agreements. When just a deferred prosecution agreement,
- 9:38Speaker 3: it's not legal until it comes in and then you know,
- 9:41Speaker 3: you get a judge to sign off on it. And
- 9:43Speaker 3: most of the time judges are fine with it. But
- 9:45Speaker 3: there have been a few cases, particularly in Washington, d C.
- 9:47Speaker 3: Federal judges where they've challenged the government on why you
- 9:51Speaker 3: give them, you know, these guys such a good deal.
- 9:53Speaker 3: In other cases and one of them, the judge you know,
- 9:56Speaker 3: didn't want to approve the DPA because he felt that
- 9:58Speaker 3: the prosecutors were too lenient on this foreign company that
- 10:01Speaker 3: had you know, facilitated weapons transferred to Iran. And then
- 10:04Speaker 3: it went to the Supreme Court and the Supreme Court
- 10:06Speaker 3: decided that in a different prosecution agreement, is beyond the
- 10:09Speaker 3: purview of the judicial branch of the government to question
- 10:13Speaker 3: prosecutorial decisions by the executive branch unless there's some evidence
- 10:17Speaker 3: of corruption or some wrongful conduct. But it's not up
- 10:21Speaker 3: to the juici branch to decide, you know, this is
- 10:23Speaker 3: a bad deal, you should go redo it. So the default,
- 10:26Speaker 3: particularly for this judge until now in Fort Worth, has
- 10:29Speaker 3: been like, you know, even if I want to, my
- 10:31Speaker 3: hands are tired. It can't do anything. However, the Fifth
- 10:34Speaker 3: Circuit last year, you know, ruled on the Crime Victims
- 10:37Speaker 3: Rights Act, et cetera, and allowed, in a message directly
- 10:41Speaker 3: to the judge it's involved in this case, said that
- 10:43Speaker 3: you only need to approve this if you think it's
- 10:45Speaker 3: in the public interest. In other words, if the government
- 10:47Speaker 3: decides to withdraw the charge, then the Fifth Circuit gave
- 10:51Speaker 3: the federal judge and Fort Worth the elbow room to
- 10:54Speaker 3: decide whether or not that would be in the public interest.
- 10:57Speaker 1: So Fifth Circuit once again out on a limb.
- 11:01Speaker 3: Yes exactly. That's component of this. If the government does
- 11:05Speaker 3: decide to basically withdraw the charge and bowen, can you
- 11:09Speaker 3: go in peace after the events of five years ago,
- 11:12Speaker 3: that needs to be approved by the judge and there'll
- 11:13Speaker 3: be vigorous argument about it.
- 11:15Speaker 1: So we may find out by the first week of June,
- 11:17Speaker 1: but certainly by July. Thanks so much, Greg. That's Bloomberg
- 11:22Speaker 1: Legal Reporter Greg Ferrell coming up next on the Bloomberg
- 11:25Speaker 1: Law Show. The EPA has some tough new power plant rules,
- 11:29Speaker 1: and there's sure to be litigation. This is Bloomberg. The
- 11:34Speaker 1: Environmental Protection Agency has proposed new regulations that would force
- 11:38Speaker 1: coal fired power plants to capture smoke stack emissions or
- 11:42Speaker 1: shut down, the Biden administration's most ambitious effort yet to
- 11:47Speaker 1: roll back planet warming pollution from the power sector, the
- 11:51Speaker 1: nation's second largest contributor to climate change, environmental legal experts
- 11:56Speaker 1: and advocates so the administration checked all the right boxes
- 12:00Speaker 1: to avoid the pitfalls that characterize the EPA's twenty twenty
- 12:04Speaker 1: two defeat in the Supreme Court. But West Virginia's attorney
- 12:08Speaker 1: general has already promised a lawsuit, and other Republican leaning
- 12:12Speaker 1: states and industry groups are likely to follow, joining Me's
- 12:16Speaker 1: environmental law expert Pat Parento, a professor at the Vermont
- 12:20Speaker 1: Law and Graduate School. What do these new EPA rules do?
- 12:24Speaker 4: So, there are four of them, and they're all aimed
- 12:27Speaker 4: at coal fired power plants, although one of them also
- 12:30Speaker 4: includes gas fire plants. But three of the rules deal
- 12:35Speaker 4: with conventional what I would call conventional regulation of coal plants.
- 12:40Speaker 4: One of them deals with mercury emissions. It's closing a
- 12:44Speaker 4: loophole for plants that burn lignite, which is the lowest
- 12:50Speaker 4: grade of coal and the dirtiest three times more mercury emissions,
- 12:56Speaker 4: which of course are neurotoxins dangerous to children and fish
- 12:59Speaker 4: and other things. And so the first rule just closes
- 13:04Speaker 4: this loophole that exempted these lignite plants from regulation under
- 13:10Speaker 4: the Clean Air Act. That's rule number one. Rule number
- 13:13Speaker 4: two deals with toxic discharges from coal plants, which also
- 13:20Speaker 4: include mercury, but in addition arsenic and some other toxic pollutants.
- 13:26Speaker 4: And that rule is under the Clean Water Act, and
- 13:30Speaker 4: it simply updates rules that should have been updated many
- 13:35Speaker 4: years ago. In fact, they were updated by Obama, but
- 13:38Speaker 4: of course then they were repealed by Trump, and so
- 13:41Speaker 4: now they're being reinstated by Biden. So the second rule
- 13:46Speaker 4: toxic discharges from coal fired power plants. The third rule
- 13:52Speaker 4: deals with the disposal of coal ash, which is also
- 13:58Speaker 4: hazardous and contains heavy metals again, mercury, cadmium, selenium, lots
- 14:05Speaker 4: of nasty stuff. So the third rule is frankly just
- 14:10Speaker 4: closing another loophole that didn't require cleanup of abandoned coal
- 14:17Speaker 4: ash pits and ponds, and these are the things that
- 14:20Speaker 4: sometimes fail and overflow. We had a huge disaster in
- 14:25Speaker 4: two thousand and eight at the Kingston coal plant run
- 14:30Speaker 4: by TVA in Tennessee. We had a more recent one
- 14:33Speaker 4: in two thousand and eighteen where there was a spill
- 14:37Speaker 4: of coal ash into the Dan River in North Carolina.
- 14:41Speaker 4: So the third rule is just another closing of a
- 14:45Speaker 4: loophole requiring cleanup of these abandoned ash pits. The fourth
- 14:51Speaker 4: rule is the big one and the one that's most controversial,
- 14:54Speaker 4: and that's the rule that replaces the Clean Power Plan
- 14:59Speaker 4: that Obama had adopted and the Supreme Court of course killed. First,
- 15:04Speaker 4: the Supreme Court put a stay on the Clean Power
- 15:07Speaker 4: Plan so it never took effect. And secondly, it issued
- 15:11Speaker 4: this infamous decision West Virginia versus EPA, which not only
- 15:17Speaker 4: invalidated the Clean Power Plan, which, by the way, EPA
- 15:22Speaker 4: had said it had no intention of reinstituting, it was
- 15:25Speaker 4: moving on to a different approach. But nevertheless, the Supreme
- 15:28Speaker 4: Court struck it down and adopted what we now know
- 15:32Speaker 4: as the Major Question Doctrine. The fourth rule is called
- 15:38Speaker 4: greenhouse Gas regulation of existing coal fired power plants and
- 15:48Speaker 4: new gas fired power plants. EPA's original proposal was to
- 15:54Speaker 4: regulate both new and existing gas plants, but in the
- 15:59Speaker 4: final rule, EPA opted not to regulate existing power plants.
- 16:06Speaker 4: That's through an awful lot of criticism from the environmental
- 16:11Speaker 4: community and from people concerned about climate change. But EPA
- 16:17Speaker 4: is counting on dealing with existing gas plants. Should President
- 16:24Speaker 4: Biden get a second term A big question mark, of course,
- 16:28Speaker 4: but that's what EPA decided. They're going to postpone dealing
- 16:31Speaker 4: with existing gas plants to the future.
- 16:35Speaker 1: And pat Most people who listen to the show have
- 16:38Speaker 1: heard about the Major Questions doctrine, but explain it for us.
- 16:43Speaker 4: It's a new way of interpreting agencies authority under statutes
- 16:48Speaker 4: that aren't crystal clear, and that doctrine says, if a
- 16:52Speaker 4: rule would have quote vast political and economic consequences, then
- 17:00Speaker 4: Congress must have explicitly in the text of the law
- 17:05Speaker 4: authorize EPA or any other agency to undertake that kind
- 17:11Speaker 4: of regulation. It means no deference to the agency's interpretation,
- 17:17Speaker 4: regardless of policy considerations, regardless of the agency's expertise, regardless
- 17:24Speaker 4: of the fact that Congress oftentimes delegates broad authority the
- 17:29Speaker 4: agencies to implement incredibly complex laws like the Clean Air Act,
- 17:36Speaker 4: dealing with incredibly difficult problems like the climate crisis climate disruption.
- 17:43Speaker 4: Regardless of all of that that the Supreme Court in
- 17:46Speaker 4: the West Virginia case, the Court will decide, which means
- 17:51Speaker 4: five members of the Court will decide what the law
- 17:55Speaker 4: means and what the agency's authority is.
- 18:00Speaker 1: I've read that this new rule could require the power
- 18:03Speaker 1: industry to install billions of dollars worth of emissions control technologies.
- 18:09Speaker 4: It's a complicated rule. It's staggered. Okay, So what the
- 18:15Speaker 4: rule says. If you plan to close your coal plant
- 18:23Speaker 4: by twenty thirty two, you don't have to do anything.
- 18:27Speaker 4: If you plan to operate your coal plant beyond twenty
- 18:35Speaker 4: thirty nine, you have to install carbon capture and sequestration
- 18:44Speaker 4: technology CCS that will achieve ninety percent removal of the
- 18:51Speaker 4: carbon by twenty thirty two. So you can see how
- 18:56Speaker 4: complicated this is. It's designed, you could say, to encourage
- 19:02Speaker 4: owners of coal plants to retire them early, or if
- 19:08Speaker 4: you want to take the pejorative, you can say it's
- 19:11Speaker 4: forcing premature closure of coal plants. You see what I mean.
- 19:17Speaker 1: So it's not just future coal plants, then it's affecting
- 19:20Speaker 1: coal plants today.
- 19:22Speaker 4: Oh yeah, it's existing. There will be no new coal plants.
- 19:25Speaker 4: There haven't been for ten years. There won't ever be
- 19:27Speaker 4: another new coal plant. That's not my prediction. That's the
- 19:30Speaker 4: Energy and Information Agency of does as that there isn't
- 19:34Speaker 4: going to be any more new coal plants. So this
- 19:37Speaker 4: is all about and there are two hundred coal plants
- 19:40Speaker 4: in the country, so this is all about existing coal plants.
- 19:43Speaker 1: So what's West Virginia and other Republican leaning states going
- 19:48Speaker 1: to argue to get this rule shut down.
- 19:50Speaker 4: They're worried about closing the coal plants that exist now,
- 19:54Speaker 4: and they have three arguments. One, they think that this
- 19:57Speaker 4: is just a repeat of what happened in the West
- 20:02Speaker 4: Virginia versus EPA case. And they're arguing that the major
- 20:06Speaker 4: question doctrine means EPA doesn't have the authority to impose
- 20:11Speaker 4: these kinds of high costs with the clear intent to
- 20:20Speaker 4: put coal out of business. That's number one. So they're
- 20:24Speaker 4: going to try to get this case back before the
- 20:26Speaker 4: Supreme Court and get the Supreme Court to rules that, oh,
- 20:29Speaker 4: this is just like what we struck down before in
- 20:33Speaker 4: West Virginia versus EPA. That's not true, and I can
- 20:36Speaker 4: come back to that, but that's going to be their argument.
- 20:39Speaker 4: The second argument they're going to make is that this
- 20:42Speaker 4: technology you're talking about, this CCS carbon capture and sequestrations.
- 20:48Speaker 4: While it's true it has been demonstrated at a pilot
- 20:53Speaker 4: level or a small scale level, it's not adequately demonstrated
- 21:01Speaker 4: to scale up to a ninety percent removal rate in
- 21:06Speaker 4: the timeframe. You're talking about complicated system. It requires capturing
- 21:11Speaker 4: the emissions at the plant, liquefying them, putting them into
- 21:17Speaker 4: a pipeline, and taking them to an area where you
- 21:21Speaker 4: can inject the carbon into a formation that will hold
- 21:26Speaker 4: it basically forever. So it's this big, complex, very expensive system,
- 21:35Speaker 4: and it's not been demonstrated to the point where coal
- 21:40Speaker 4: plant operators can achieve it in the timeframe you've provided,
- 21:46Speaker 4: even though the timeframe is lengthy. I mean, they have
- 21:49Speaker 4: at least eight years to install these systems. But they're
- 21:53Speaker 4: making an argument, we can't do it, we won't be
- 21:56Speaker 4: able to do it, and your rule is simply going
- 21:58Speaker 4: to shut us down. You can't do that, and then
- 22:02Speaker 4: the third thing they're arguing is that as you begin
- 22:06Speaker 4: to force the closure of these coal plants, which are
- 22:12Speaker 4: baseload plants that can operate even when the sun isn't
- 22:18Speaker 4: shining and the wind isn't blowing to make up for
- 22:22Speaker 4: the intermittency of renewable energy systems which are coming online
- 22:28Speaker 4: more and more. If you take these base load plants
- 22:32Speaker 4: out of the system, you're going to have reliability problems
- 22:36Speaker 4: big time. So the third big argument is you're going
- 22:40Speaker 4: to destabilize our grid and you're going to cause people
- 22:45Speaker 4: to have blackouts and interruptions in power service in many
- 22:50Speaker 4: areas of the country. So those are their three big arguments.
- 22:53Speaker 1: So tell me why this Supreme Court and that West
- 22:56Speaker 1: Virginia decision was six to three down ideological lines. Why
- 23:01Speaker 1: wouldn't this Supreme Court agree with them? I mean, this
- 23:04Speaker 1: is not the most environmentally friendly Supreme Court.
- 23:08Speaker 4: Oh that's true. And we won't know, of course, and
- 23:12Speaker 4: listen until we see what the Supreme Court does with this.
- 23:15Speaker 4: But here's how the rule differs. The thing that troubled
- 23:19Speaker 4: the Supreme Court and Chief Justice Roberts, who wrote the
- 23:22Speaker 4: opinion in West Virginia, was that EPA was taking a
- 23:27Speaker 4: system wide approach to regulating the power plant sector, and
- 23:34Speaker 4: that it was forcing what it called generation shifting from
- 23:39Speaker 4: fossil fuel based plants gas and coal to renewable sources
- 23:45Speaker 4: wind and solar, and Justice Roberts felt that went too far.
- 23:49Speaker 4: That was an overreach Congress could not possibly have intended
- 23:54Speaker 4: in the nineteen seventy Clean Air Act, which is what
- 23:57Speaker 4: was being interpreted to give EPA that kind of broad
- 24:02Speaker 4: energy policy authority. That's what bothered Justice Roberts. He thought
- 24:08Speaker 4: the rule was unlike any rule EPA had ever adopted.
- 24:11Speaker 4: That's arguable, but that's what he thought. Thought it was novel.
- 24:15Speaker 4: He thought it was based on an obscure provision of
- 24:18Speaker 4: the Clean Air Act Section one eleven, which isn't obscure
- 24:22Speaker 4: at all. It's been there from the beginning, and it
- 24:24Speaker 4: was there for a very specific purpose. But nevertheless, he
- 24:27Speaker 4: thought it was an obscure provision, and so he characterized
- 24:31Speaker 4: this as Congress wouldn't hide an elephant in a mousehole.
- 24:36Speaker 4: So that's the metaphor.
- 24:37Speaker 1: I remembered that hard you forget, right.
- 24:41Speaker 4: How could you forget? So that's the idea of this great,
- 24:44Speaker 4: big authority with vast economic consequences hidden in this little
- 24:50Speaker 4: mousehole of a provision. That's the way he viewed it.
- 24:53Speaker 4: This time around, EPA has gone to great legs. I mean,
- 24:58Speaker 4: there's one hundred pages, by the way in EPA's justification
- 25:03Speaker 4: and explanation for this new rule talking about West Virginia,
- 25:08Speaker 4: talking about how this rule differs from the Clean power Plant,
- 25:11Speaker 4: et cetera. And it really is different. This rule is
- 25:15Speaker 4: a very traditional use of EPA authority to require technology
- 25:22Speaker 4: based requirements to reduce emissions pausing public health and environmental damage.
- 25:32Speaker 4: That's what CCS is. It's a technology, it's a system
- 25:39Speaker 4: of technologies because it's capturing the emissions and it's putting
- 25:44Speaker 4: them in this pipeline and taking them for disposal in
- 25:47Speaker 4: a safe underground location. So it is a system in
- 25:50Speaker 4: that sense, but it's source specific. It isn't looking at
- 25:55Speaker 4: the entire energy system as a whole, looking at the grid,
- 26:00Speaker 4: the integrated grid as a whole, which EPA did do
- 26:04Speaker 4: in the Clean Power Plant. So it's very much tailored
- 26:08Speaker 4: to individual sources and it's telling them, if you install
- 26:12Speaker 4: this technology, which we believe is commercially available. EPA is
- 26:17Speaker 4: pointing the two plants that are currently operating and capturing
- 26:22Speaker 4: emissions at ninety percent rate. One of them, the Petra
- 26:26Speaker 4: Nova plant in Texas, was out of operation for a
- 26:31Speaker 4: few years, but it's back in operation and it is
- 26:34Speaker 4: shown that it can capture ninety two percent actually of emissions.
- 26:39Speaker 4: There's another one being built in North Dakota and so on.
- 26:42Speaker 4: So EPA is saying, all we're doing here is what
- 26:46Speaker 4: we've always done in implementing the Clean Air Act, requiring
- 26:52Speaker 4: proven technology that will make your plants run cleaner and
- 26:56Speaker 4: protect public health and the environment. They've also built in
- 27:02Speaker 4: safeguards for reliability. They've given these coal plant operators eight
- 27:07Speaker 4: years to install ccs. That I mean eight years is
- 27:12Speaker 4: a long time, right, So they've given them adequate time.
- 27:16Speaker 4: EPA believes to install technology as I say, is being
- 27:21Speaker 4: installed and operated even now. Secondly, they've said, if there
- 27:26Speaker 4: really is a problem with retiring a particular coal plant
- 27:33Speaker 4: in a particular area of the country that threatens reliability,
- 27:39Speaker 4: they're going to give that coal plant an extra year
- 27:44Speaker 4: to meet its requirement. Plus, the Biden administration is investing
- 27:50Speaker 4: billions of dollars in upgrading the grid and these two
- 27:55Speaker 4: there are two integrated grids in the United States. Texas
- 27:59Speaker 4: has its own, but there are two grids that connect
- 28:02Speaker 4: the United States together, and it is improving the operation
- 28:10Speaker 4: of the grid system that we have, and it's adopting
- 28:14Speaker 4: streamline procedures to expand the grid faster than it's been
- 28:19Speaker 4: able to do. So my point is EPA is addressing
- 28:25Speaker 4: each and every one of the contentions against the rule,
- 28:29Speaker 4: and it's specifically addressing why this rule is not the
- 28:33Speaker 4: same as the rule that the Supreme Court struck down
- 28:37Speaker 4: in West Virginia. Of course, we're going to have to
- 28:40Speaker 4: wait to see how this all plays out in the
- 28:43Speaker 4: litigation that will start very soon as soon as these
- 28:47Speaker 4: rules are published in the Federal Register, which could occur
- 28:52Speaker 4: later in May or perhaps June. Then the fund begins,
- 28:56Speaker 4: Then the lawsuits get filed, and we'll see what happens
- 28:59Speaker 4: after that.
- 29:00Speaker 1: Stay with me, Pat, coming up, We're going to continue
- 29:03Speaker 1: this conversation, and this is Bloomberg. I've been talking to
- 29:06Speaker 1: Professor Pat Parento of the Vermont Lawn Graduate School about
- 29:10Speaker 1: the Environmental Protection Agencies proposed new rules for coal fired
- 29:14Speaker 1: power plants. The major questions doctrine. They just sort of
- 29:20Speaker 1: made that up out of whole cloth. And now it
- 29:22Speaker 1: hangs over everything we talk about.
- 29:25Speaker 4: Yeah, it's based on some earlier cases that did acknowledge
- 29:32Speaker 4: that where you have a rule, the source of this idea,
- 29:37Speaker 4: people call it a doctrine. I would just call it
- 29:40Speaker 4: an idea. But the source of this major question idea
- 29:45Speaker 4: was an opinion by Justice O'Connor in Brown and Williamson
- 29:49Speaker 4: Tobacco versus FDA. This is when FDA, for the first
- 29:53Speaker 4: time in its history, decided to regulate cigarettes and even
- 29:59Speaker 4: to suggest a band on cigarettes. And the Supreme Court
- 30:03Speaker 4: in that case said, wait a minute. You know cigarettes
- 30:06Speaker 4: aren't identified in the Drug and Cosmetic Act, and FDA
- 30:11Speaker 4: has never regulated cigarettes, and all of a sudden, now,
- 30:14Speaker 4: out of the blue, you've decided to do that. Well,
- 30:17Speaker 4: this is going to have tremendous implications, probably both good
- 30:20Speaker 4: and bad, as we know, but certainly tremendous implications. So
- 30:24Speaker 4: we don't think Congress have that in mind. All right,
- 30:27Speaker 4: So I wouldn't go so far as to say the
- 30:31Speaker 4: major Question doctrine is made out of whole cloth, But
- 30:34Speaker 4: certainly the way it was fashioned in the West Virginia
- 30:39Speaker 4: case is unlike anything that had been done by the
- 30:44Speaker 4: Supreme Court before this whole idea that you can completely
- 30:50Speaker 4: disregard Congress's ability to delegate broad authority to an expert
- 30:57Speaker 4: agency like EPA to deal with problems that Congress could
- 31:01Speaker 4: not have foreseen, and that Congress could not have had
- 31:05Speaker 4: the expertise even to legislate about. That's new, And you're right.
- 31:14Speaker 4: The doctrine, I mean, Justice Robertson in the West Virginia
- 31:18Speaker 4: case said, this is an extraordinary doctrine or idea, meaning
- 31:24Speaker 4: this shouldn't be a routine reason to reject an agency's interpretation.
- 31:31Speaker 4: But what has happened, of course, in the lower courts
- 31:36Speaker 4: is there's been an explosion of cases being brought based
- 31:40Speaker 4: on the major question doctrine, many of which are succeeding.
- 31:45Speaker 4: And guess where the most successful cases are. They're in
- 31:49Speaker 4: the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, which is the most
- 31:53Speaker 4: conservative court in the land.
- 31:56Speaker 1: What a surprise, What a surprise.
- 31:59Speaker 4: And it's the court the industry and the Republican Attorneys
- 32:04Speaker 4: General run to all the time to try to get
- 32:10Speaker 4: decisions in their favor, and they've been successful in many cases.
- 32:14Speaker 4: The trick with the rule regulating power plant emissions is
- 32:22Speaker 4: they have to go to the DC Circuit the law
- 32:25Speaker 4: is clear that the DC Circuit has exclusive jurisdiction over
- 32:29Speaker 4: all of the major rules under the Clean Air Act,
- 32:32Speaker 4: and the DC Circuit I won't say they rubber stamp
- 32:37Speaker 4: EPA because they don't, but the DC Circuit is very
- 32:40Speaker 4: expert at evaluating these really high complex rules, and they
- 32:46Speaker 4: have been more favorable to EPA's interpretation over the years
- 32:52Speaker 4: than any other circuit. That doesn't mean that the Supreme
- 32:57Speaker 4: Court is going to adopt the DC circuits decision, No,
- 33:02Speaker 4: far from it. But it does mean that at least
- 33:04Speaker 4: at this first level of litigation, EPA is in the
- 33:10Speaker 4: right court. If it's going to win this argument, it's
- 33:13Speaker 4: in the right court to do so.
- 33:15Speaker 1: The EPA's enforcement activity has been accelerating. In December, the
- 33:20Speaker 1: agency said it opened one hundred and ninety nine criminal
- 33:23Speaker 1: investigations in twenty twenty three, a seventy percent increase over
- 33:27Speaker 1: the previous year, and it concluded settlements in one thy
- 33:32Speaker 1: seven hundred and eighty nine, which is one hundred and
- 33:34Speaker 1: fifty over fiscal twenty twenty two. I mean, is there
- 33:37Speaker 1: a reason why these are stepping up?
- 33:39Speaker 4: Well, several reasons. They're getting an awful lot of pressure
- 33:43Speaker 4: to step them up. Number two, the Biden administration has
- 33:49Speaker 4: put a lot more resources into EPA's environmental justice program
- 33:56Speaker 4: to increase the level of attention on in four horsemen
- 34:00Speaker 4: in communities that are disproportionately affected. And I guess number
- 34:06Speaker 4: three would be the election and the need for the
- 34:13Speaker 4: Biden administration to show that it's really responding to what
- 34:21Speaker 4: communities are demanding, not only in terms of environmental justice issues,
- 34:26Speaker 4: but climate issues, environmental quality issues writ large. And obviously
- 34:32Speaker 4: the president is involved in an incredible battle for re election.
- 34:39Speaker 4: This is a game of inches where thousands of votes
- 34:43Speaker 4: are going to make the difference in these battleground states
- 34:46Speaker 4: literally in terms of the electoral College, and Biden needs
- 34:50Speaker 4: to turn out every single Democrat and certainly every single
- 34:56Speaker 4: environmentalist in the country the win. So he's one of
- 35:02Speaker 4: the reasons I think we're seeing all these rules coming
- 35:05Speaker 4: out and all this activity around enforcement and cleanup is
- 35:11Speaker 4: partly because the administration has been committed to that from
- 35:14Speaker 4: the beginning, but also because they realize they're in the
- 35:17Speaker 4: fight of their life for re election. That's my best
- 35:21Speaker 4: guess at.
- 35:22Speaker 1: It sounds like a good guest to me. Thanks so much, Pat.
- 35:25Speaker 1: That's Professor Pat Parento of the Vermont Law and Graduate School.
- 35:29Speaker 1: And that's it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast.
- 35:32Speaker 1: Remember you can always get the latest legal news by
- 35:34Speaker 1: subscribing and listening to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 35:39Speaker 1: and at Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast, slash Law. I'm
- 35:42Speaker 1: June Grosso and this is Bloomberg