Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #46: Efficient vs. Deliberative Government - Can it Be Both Swift and Thoughtful?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan political information
- 0:05and analysis.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:08Today, we're gonna talk about efficient versus deliberative government.
- 0:14Question for you.
- 0:16Do you prefer a government that is swift to respond, or do you prefer a government that
- 0:20thinks things over?
- 0:22In other words, do you want an efficient government or a deliberative government?
- 0:27Are the two inherently at odds?
- 0:29Can we have both efficiency and deliberation?
- 0:32How did the founding fathers see this debate?
- 0:34How does this debate apply to the executive legislative and judicial branches today?
- 0:39All this and more is on tap for today's episode.
- 0:42But first, this idea was spawned by a LinkedIn post I made the other day.
- 0:48It talked about unicameral versus bicameral legislatures, which is a legislature with one
- 0:53chamber or two chambers respectively.
- 0:56And I wrote how one of the philosophical debates behind having one or two chambers was
- 1:02based on whether you wanted a legislative structure that was theoretically at least more
- 1:06efficient or one that was theoretically more deliberative.
- 1:10And that got me to thinking, can we expand this framework of efficient versus deliberative
- 1:16government further?
- 1:18Because citizens and politicians alike often decry our government as inefficient.
- 1:22They take too long to address problems as they arise.
- 1:26They just have a lot of infighting about what to do.
- 1:30And then they also often deride it as too rash in responses, not taking the time to think
- 1:36things through or accounting for other viewpoints.
- 1:39And at first glance, it may seem like the two camps are at odds.
- 1:43It may seem like everybody wants to have it both ways.
- 1:47But could we have it both ways?
- 1:49Obviously, we'd ideally like a government that comes up with the best policy and the best time
- 1:54frame.
- 1:55So can we?
- 1:56Let's dive a little bit more into this.
- 1:59Let's first define efficient government and deliberative government.
- 2:04So in my context, efficient government is one that reacts swiftly to situations that is, for
- 2:13example, a major financial crisis like in 02/2008, a major policy issue, the system is
- 2:19designed to have an expedited response to challenges that arise.
- 2:24And the idea behind it is that there are many issues that are it's an imperative to come up
- 2:34with solutions as quickly possible.
- 2:37You need to address them right away.
- 2:38In the eyes of a supporter of a more efficient government sees a responsive government as when
- 2:44that problem arises, the government responds by acting quickly to limit the effects of the
- 2:49problem.
- 2:51On the other hand, you have a deliberative government, which is one that takes its time to
- 2:56think things through.
- 2:58The system is designed to consider more options before responding and more viewpoints.
- 3:04The idea is that you need to incorporate as many ideas as possible or at least hear them
- 3:10out.
- 3:11And so for a supporter of a more deliberative government, they might see responsive
- 3:16government as one that's when a problem arises, that government responds by taking as much
- 3:24information as possible and devising a solution from there.
- 3:29So you may have noticed the word I used was responsive.
- 3:32A core part of this debate, and again, people don't necessarily think of it in terms of
- 3:38efficient government versus deliberative government or even see an opposition between
- 3:43the two, but a core part of the debate is about the level of responsiveness from our government
- 3:49officials.
- 3:51Ideally, we want a responsive government, and it should be an ideal we strive for.
- 3:56But how do we define a responsive government?
- 4:00Is it just simply it just quickly resolves an issue?
- 4:03But what if the the response is not what we want it to be?
- 4:08Does that mean that the government was responsive, or did it just do what it wanted to
- 4:12do?
- 4:12Does it have to account for and incorporate as many opinions as possible?
- 4:17Even if it doesn't necessarily take all of those opinions, it might have heard, okay,
- 4:24citizen.
- 4:24We heard what you said, but we still think that we need to go this direction, theoretically.
- 4:30Usually, that's not gonna actually happen that way.
- 4:32But, theoretically, would that also be a responsive government?
- 4:38We'd obviously like both of the above.
- 4:39We want them to be quick to resolve a situation, but that we want the government to
- 4:44hear what we have to say.
- 4:46But is that viable?
- 4:48And if it is viable, what context is it viable?
- 4:53Does just hearing people out equal responsiveness?
- 4:58They might be responsive because the government is at least listening even if they don't
- 5:03ultimately incorporate those ideas, but it also might not be responsive because government
- 5:09never intended to incorporate any of those ideas in good faith.
- 5:13You think about town halls, for instance, or a committee meeting in a state legislature or
- 5:22congress when the balance of power is heavily lopsided towards one party, even if they're
- 5:28technically hearing out minority viewpoints, Are is that really being responsive and taking
- 5:35into account other viewpoints?
- 5:38Well, I mean, that's that's for you to decide.
- 5:41But does more action being taken automatically equal responsiveness?
- 5:47How do we define action being taken?
- 5:52Because what some people see as action being taken by the government, other people don't
- 5:57think that's a real action.
- 6:00And just because the government is acting on something in some way, it doesn't mean that
- 6:04they're actually listening to the people.
- 6:07Maybe they are.
- 6:08Maybe they're not.
- 6:09Regardless of the opinion on how to design a government, though, a responsive government is
- 6:14an ideal we should strive for.
- 6:15We should have a government that responds to what we think and feel.
- 6:19Otherwise, what's the point of us even electing them?
- 6:21So let's go back to the founding fathers here and how they saw this efficiency versus
- 6:28deliberative government debate.
- 6:30And they didn't necessarily use the exact words of efficient and deliberative.
- 6:36But when you look at the Articles of Confederation before we had the US
- 6:41constitution, when we had the constitutional convention to make the US constitution and in
- 6:47the federalist papers and even going to today, you do see some instances of that efficiency
- 6:54versus deliberative debate.
- 6:57How quickly should governments, particularly federal government, be able to respond to
- 7:02situations, and how much should they have to go through a deliberative process?
- 7:07And you can see some of the philosophical influences that the founding fathers had in
- 7:12that regard, like with Montesquieu, who was one of the primary people who espoused the idea of
- 7:20separation of powers where different branches of government have specific duties that they
- 7:28administer instead of it all being vested within a particular person or a small cabal of
- 7:35people or Jean Jacques Rousseau with the social contract, which basically the idea that you
- 7:40give up some rights in order to preserve the rest of your rights, where if you didn't have
- 7:45any sort of government structure, there's nothing to protect your personal rights.
- 7:52So you come up with a government that protects some, but you have to give up some level of
- 7:57freedom.
- 7:58So when you think about those, there is a little bit of that efficiency versus
- 8:03deliberation.
- 8:04The efficiency of this separation of powers were and how deliberative branches have to be
- 8:12with those separation of powers and the same thing with things like the social contract,
- 8:16John Locke with property rights, Voltaire with freedom of expression, and a bunch of other
- 8:21philosophers that's I haven't even mentioned.
- 8:24But if we go to the articles of confederation that we had when we became independent from the
- 8:32British, which instituted a very weak central government.
- 8:36Central government had almost no power unless all the states consented to that federal
- 8:42government doing something that affected the entire nation.
- 8:46Otherwise, states basically just handled their own affairs.
- 8:49That was definitely not about efficiency because in every issue of national scale, every
- 8:55state had to be unanimous in consent.
- 8:57And if you've ever tried to get a group of people, whether it's your friends to figure out
- 9:02what you wanna eat for dinner or if you've been ever been on a sports team, even as something
- 9:09as small as a basketball team or something bigger like a football team, trying to get all
- 9:14your teammates to move in the same direction, even if you all have the same goal, which is to
- 9:19win, but to actually do the play correctly or to not try to puff up your individual stats at
- 9:28the expense of the team.
- 9:29You know how difficult it is to get everybody marching in the same direction.
- 9:34So now imagine the difficulty of getting 13 states with 13 very different sets of interests
- 9:41because, really, the only thing that had united them really wasn't that united of a United
- 9:48States.
- 9:49The main thing that really united them was opposition to the British crowd.
- 9:53And even then, there were a lot of Americans that still wanted to stay loyal to the British,
- 9:58and there were a lot of Americans that just wanted to live their lives and not have to
- 10:03worry about the war for independence.
- 10:05They just wanted to be left alone, and whatever happened happened as long as it didn't involve
- 10:09them.
- 10:11So New York's a confederation, you have to think about the context of the time.
- 10:16Yeah.
- 10:16It was a very flawed document and which is why we ultimately moved away from it, although that
- 10:22that was not universally supported by any means.
- 10:26But when you take the context into account, there's a great distrust of a centralized
- 10:32government due to the Americans' dealings with the British crown and how they instituted
- 10:37taxation without representation, such as through the Stamp Act.
- 10:42In a way, that British crown and how that did things was sort of more of an efficiency
- 10:48perspective.
- 10:49It was whatever the crown said goes, goes, and there's nothing you do about it.
- 10:54Whereas the Articles of Confederation went the complete opposite way and saw things through a
- 10:58deliberative lens where central government had little say unless all the states consented to
- 11:05it.
- 11:06But that really bogged down things.
- 11:09So you had the flaws of the efficiency aspect where the British crown just ran rough shot and
- 11:15did what it pleased, but then you went the other way where you had a lot of gridlock,
- 11:19especially after the war the American Revolutionary War was over.
- 11:24So we fast forward to the constitutional convention, and this efficiency versus
- 11:29deliberation aspect became particularly problematic.
- 11:33Well, it was already problematic, but it sorta came to the fore in the constitutional
- 11:38convention.
- 11:38I mean, the constitutional convention multiple times threatened to dissolve.
- 11:43This idea that we oftentimes, the founding fathers are romanticized as completely putting
- 11:49aside all of their differences to come together for the common good, but the constitutional
- 11:54convention several times almost dissolved.
- 11:56Not even George Washington was gonna be able to keep it together.
- 12:00It was more Ben Franklin was really the guy who kept it altogether, but that's a little bit of
- 12:06a rabbit trail.
- 12:07But it threatened to dissolve multiple times, and there's partially this whole efficiency
- 12:12versus deliberation.
- 12:14How strong should this central government, this federal government be, and how do you still
- 12:20keep the consent of all of these interests, that is to say, these state governments, how do
- 12:26you still protect those?
- 12:29So this efficiency versus deliberation debate was one of the core debates to resolve, and you
- 12:36saw it in things like there's a lot of ideas that the framers and the founding fathers came
- 12:44up with the framers of the constitution had come up with that might sound very surprising,
- 12:49like, for example, whether the presidency should be one or three people.
- 12:53One person is definitely the more efficient aspect or the more efficient perspective.
- 12:59Three people would have been the more deliberative aspect where one person was just
- 13:05needed to run the show and make sure that everything is executed and enforce the laws.
- 13:11Obviously, there's people underneath that one person.
- 13:13But otherwise, then you have three chief executives that all need to agree on certain
- 13:20courses of action.
- 13:21Whether the legislature should be bicameral, which we will dive into as a case study later
- 13:28on in this episode, how to implement checks and balances between each branch.
- 13:32How does each branch make sure another branch doesn't become too powerful?
- 13:36How do you protect the efficiency and deliberation aspects there?
- 13:41What powers belong to the federal government and what powers belong to the states?
- 13:46And how many states needed to consent to changes to the US constitution?
- 13:51Ultimately, the US constitution did incorporate many many considerations for both efficiency
- 13:57and deliberation.
- 14:00And so you think about how some of those debates have come up even today.
- 14:06And back then, the Federalist papers really reflected a lot of these debates.
- 14:11For example, how I believe there's James Madison that wrote about this in particular,
- 14:16how states would handle localized matters given their proximity to the local population,
- 14:21especially back then when communication was a lot slower.
- 14:25You didn't have cars.
- 14:27You did not have social media, but federal government federal government would still
- 14:34handle wide ranging issues.
- 14:36And so you think about some of those debates in the context of today.
- 14:40One of the big aspects of US constitution, even though the word is not used specifically in the
- 14:47US constitution, is this concept of federalism, which refers to how the duties and spheres of
- 14:54responsibility for the federal and state governments, how they're divided, how they're
- 14:59split up.
- 14:59And you basically have two types.
- 15:01There's dual and there's cooperative, which we talked about in a couple of other previous
- 15:07episodes in this podcast.
- 15:09But, basically, dual is federal government has its own duties separate from the state, and the
- 15:16state has its own duties separate from the federal.
- 15:20And then there's the cooperative where the federal and state government responsibilities
- 15:25intermingle to some extent.
- 15:28So what is the most efficient divide in responsibilities between the federal and state
- 15:32governments?
- 15:33And then what criteria need to be met for the federal government to be involved in a state
- 15:39affair?
- 15:41Efficiency versus deliberation.
- 15:44Another aspect, again, not a word that's used in the US constitution, and I don't believe
- 15:48James Madison used this specific word either, but he does definitely talk about it in I wanna
- 15:54say it's federalist number 54.
- 15:56I can't remember off the top of my head, but pluralism basically describes or it's defined
- 16:01as the coexistence, competition, and distribution of power between varying political
- 16:07interests.
- 16:08And so James Madison argued in the Federalist Papers how competing interests would prevent
- 16:13any single one from taking too much power.
- 16:16So there's not not a really a numb a number you can put on the varying interests, but they all
- 16:24have this tug and pull where some of them will get their interests put forth and implemented,
- 16:30but they won't be able to usurp so much power that they can trample over other interests.
- 16:37Although that idea of pluralism today, that's not a an agreed upon thing.
- 16:45Some people still believe that that is working.
- 16:47Some people don't.
- 16:48And both the efficient and deliberative supporters could argue that the pluralistic
- 16:55view of government that James Madison and the framers of the constitution envisioned is
- 17:02working as intended, and there's people on both in both camps that could say that it's not
- 17:07working well.
- 17:08So for the side that says pluralism is working or at least that it's working well enough where
- 17:13there's a healthy competition between all these interests and they're being heard out fairly,
- 17:22Somebody who supports a more efficient government might say the system is working and
- 17:26allowing these varying interests to compete for quick, effective solutions.
- 17:31As soon as one wins, you see it in political parties.
- 17:35Even though the founding fathers did not necessarily envision political parties, they
- 17:40took to them fairly quickly under the US constitution.
- 17:44And so these groups would one group would win a majority in government and implement their
- 17:54views, but then you'd have an election come up, and then the next maybe another group takes
- 17:59power or splits it up.
- 18:02So that's the efficient side.
- 18:04The deliberate side would say that there's a wide variety of interests that are being
- 18:09represented and heard out to come to deliberated solutions.
- 18:12They're saying, okay, you have to take into account a whole bunch of people's views in
- 18:18order to come up to a solution.
- 18:19You're deliberating on it.
- 18:21But both the efficient and deliberative camps might also say that pluralism is not working.
- 18:28And if you believe in a need for a government to be more efficient, you might say that
- 18:33hyperpluralism, which is basically that there's so many interests competing that it's bogging
- 18:39down political processes, but you're basically saying that that's running rampant and it's
- 18:45there's no real solutions that are coming because nobody's really able to come up with
- 18:52something.
- 18:52There's not really somebody that's able to win and make a an effective long running solution.
- 18:59If you're more of the deliberative side of things, you might say that there's actually
- 19:04relatively few concentrated interests that have taken over the SIPs system and stifled the
- 19:10interests and viewpoints of others.
- 19:12So they're not really taking a hyperpluralist route, but they're saying that the pluralism
- 19:17isn't really actually so plural.
- 19:20Their organized interests tend to beat unorganized interests whenever it comes to all
- 19:27else all else equal.
- 19:29The organized interests are probably going to win.
- 19:32So the deliberative side is going to say that there's a select few groups of interest that
- 19:39are running the show and are not hearing people out.
- 19:43So that brings us to this next point.
- 19:46What factors does the need for efficiency or deliberation in government depend on?
- 19:51When it's not necessarily that somebody believes we need efficient government in every
- 19:58single aspect, and then other people say we need deliberative government in every single
- 20:02aspect.
- 20:03What context might influence whether we want more of an efficient government and we want
- 20:11more of a deliberative government?
- 20:13Maybe somebody wants government in one context to be more deliberative, and then in another
- 20:18context wants it to be more efficient.
- 20:21So the important thing to remember is that neither inherently leads to better policy.
- 20:27So if we have efficient government, potential problems that you have there could be that what
- 20:35what's considered efficient is really just haphazard, ham fisted policy that hasn't taken
- 20:41the time to think think things over.
- 20:44It's just we just need to get this solution, and we've we've already got everything figured
- 20:49out.
- 20:49We don't need to listen to anything else.
- 20:51So the efficient side of things might be a complete disregard for other opinions that can
- 20:58potentially help make that policy better.
- 21:00You're thinking about things over and taking nuances into account and not just assuming
- 21:06you've already got the answer.
- 21:08For example, if we talk about because the budget right now is a big issue.
- 21:12If we pass a budget to simply avoid a government shutdown, is that inherently better
- 21:17for efficiency?
- 21:18Is that gonna cause issues for efficiency in government down the road?
- 21:22But then you've got the other side.
- 21:24There's those issues for efficient government or potential issues that arise from a efficient
- 21:30government.
- 21:30But what about issues from a deliberative government?
- 21:35Well, you might see the use of political grievances to bog down and even stop political
- 21:41processes.
- 21:42What looks like it may be, oh, we're just trying to think things over to come up with the
- 21:46best solution.
- 21:47Maybe somebody's actually using their power to try to slow down the political process to maybe
- 21:52they're trying to kill a bill that a lot of people think needs to get passed, and it it
- 21:59might lead to an untimely addressing of issues that maybe needed a quicker solution.
- 22:05Some solutions are more pressing and more pertinent than others.
- 22:09So, again, if we apply this to the budget, should our level of deliberation on a budget
- 22:14potentially lead to a government shutdown when somebody threatens to try to get the government
- 22:21to shut down because they think that the budget is not fiscally responsible, for example?
- 22:27Is that being truly being deliberative, or is that just being obstinate?
- 22:31So you have these issues that can potentially arise from efficient and deliberative
- 22:36government.
- 22:37You really need to think things over as to whether things are being efficient or are being
- 22:41deliberative.
- 22:42So several of the context to really think about when it comes to efficient versus deliberative
- 22:49government.
- 22:49Does it differ based on the level of government?
- 22:52So by level of government, we mean federal versus state versus local.
- 22:57Do governments closer to home, that is to say local and maybe to a lesser extent the state
- 23:03governments, do they need to be more efficient because they are more local to people?
- 23:07They are closer to the population.
- 23:11Therefore, do governments further away, that is to say federal and maybe in some cases state
- 23:16governments, do they need to be more deliberative because they have more interest to
- 23:21account for?
- 23:21There are more people and therefore there are more interests to think about.
- 23:26So you can't just take into account only a select few people.
- 23:32Or do governments closer to home need to be more deliberative because they have fewer
- 23:36people to consider and are more directly capable of addressing people's needs, and they
- 23:42need to have time to they they have the ability to take more time to think things over.
- 23:48And then therefore, do governments that are further away need to be more efficient because
- 23:53national and international issues are so wide ranging and oftentimes very pressing, and they
- 23:59have so many people that they affect.
- 24:00Next context for efficiency versus deliberation.
- 24:03Does it differ based on partisan or ideological bias?
- 24:07Because this debate, like, I mean, pretty much every other political debate, it becomes ripe
- 24:14for people to play political games with based on whether they support or oppose the party in
- 24:20power.
- 24:20So do we change whether we think we need more efficient or deliberative government based on
- 24:27which party's in power.
- 24:28For example, the people we don't like are in power, so the government is inefficient.
- 24:33So if your party is not in power, you're probably gonna wanna say that things are being
- 24:40run inefficiently because it's not your interest and you're gonna wanna you're trying
- 24:45to win and get your party back in power or you wanna see your party back in power.
- 24:48Or maybe you say, we are in power, but the people who we don't like are trying to bog down
- 24:53the the political process.
- 24:54So they say people who the minority party might be arguing they're being more deliberative and
- 25:01they want their voice heard, but the party in power is trying to say they're not being
- 25:05deliberative.
- 25:05They're just being obstinate.
- 25:08If the party or ideology we subscribe to is not in power, do we support a more deliberative
- 25:14government because our voice gets drowned out more?
- 25:17And we want therefore, we want a government more deliberative because we want to have our
- 25:22voice heard.
- 25:23We don't wanna be run over.
- 25:25If the party or ideology we subscribe to is in power, do we support a more efficient
- 25:30government because our interests are more likely to be implemented and we can just get
- 25:35them pushed through while we still have the power.
- 25:41How about in the context of the size of the population of the constituency?
- 25:47In other words, do we want a more efficient or more deliberative government based on how many
- 25:52people are being represented by that government?
- 25:54So if we talk about larger versus smaller states, California or Texas versus Delaware or
- 26:01Arkansas, larger or smaller cities, we talk about a place like New York City or Los Angeles
- 26:07versus Carmel, Indiana or Lancaster, Pennsylvania.
- 26:12Do we need a government to be more efficient or deliberative when there are more people being
- 26:17represented?
- 26:18If there are being more people being represented, the efficient side may say, Okay,
- 26:23there's a lot of people that are depending upon this and we need to get something done for all
- 26:28these people as quick as possible.
- 26:29Or do you say, Because there are so many people being involved, we need to think things over,
- 26:34we need to account for more people's views.
- 26:38So the efficient side may say it has a lot of resident needs to attend to, and many require a
- 26:43quick response.
- 26:44The deliberate side might say because there are so many resident interests to attend to, there
- 26:49are many voices that need to be accounted for and have their ideas incorporated into policy.
- 26:57So those are several general context for more of a theoretical view.
- 27:02Let's get more into there's still some theoretical aspects to this, but let's get a
- 27:06little bit more practical.
- 27:07Let's look at some case studies from the three branches of governments, mostly federal, but
- 27:12we'll have some state level stuff too.
- 27:14See let's see how efficiency versus deliberation works in theory and in practice.
- 27:20Efficiency versus deliberation in the context of the executive branch.
- 27:26So the federal government, presidents, cabinet, federal agencies, the state level governors,
- 27:33state executives, and state agencies that fall under their purview.
- 27:38So the executive branch executes and enforces the laws.
- 27:43That is the main general responsibility of the executive branch.
- 27:48The questions to ask about this branch when it comes to efficiency versus deliberation, and
- 27:53these are not the only questions, but a couple of really big ones.
- 27:58How responsive to an issue do we want a president or a governor to be?
- 28:05What parts of federal or state law are subject to a president or governor's interpretation,
- 28:11respectively?
- 28:12Sometimes when the legislature writes a law, there might be something that's vague enough or
- 28:19a president or governor argues is vague enough that they have some level of power to interpret
- 28:26in a certain way or execute the law in a certain way or that their agencies underneath
- 28:31them have the power to execute in a certain way.
- 28:35We talk about Chevron deference, which has been struck down by the supreme court, the US
- 28:40Supreme Court, but basically was the idea that the executive agencies have some sort of leeway
- 28:48to interpret Congress's laws within still within the framework, but they didn't
- 28:55necessarily need to rely on a very specific prescription of how the the legislature, in
- 29:02this case, congress prescribed them as to how they need to act in a certain situation.
- 29:08One recent case study we could talk about is Doge or the Department of Government Efficiency
- 29:13that Elon Musk was running.
- 29:16Definitely an example of the philosophy of a more efficient government.
- 29:20I mean, efficiency was in the name of the department.
- 29:22Now whether it actually has contributed to a more efficient government is a different
- 29:27question, and that's up to you to decide.
- 29:29I I don't get into that.
- 29:30That is definitely a can be a heated discussion, but it's an example of that
- 29:38efficiency versus deliberative aspect.
- 29:41It was certainly more along the lines of efficiency because efficiency wasn't the
- 29:45department's name.
- 29:46But let's look at a bit more of a general context or general case study.
- 29:52Let's look at the size of the executive branch.
- 29:54So over the years, the executive branch has grown considerably, far bigger than the
- 30:01founding fathers thought that it would more than likely.
- 30:05Now doesn't necessarily mean that it's done in an unconstitutional way.
- 30:09I'm not saying that, but it has definitely become far, far larger than the founding
- 30:15fathers had seen in their day.
- 30:21So as the government and the population has grown and more and more policy issues have
- 30:28arisen, the executive branch has expanded accordingly.
- 30:33And now we have many departments and agencies that handle various facets of government.
- 30:39For example, you have 15 cabinet departments for the federal government like interior and
- 30:47justice and energy and education.
- 30:51So if we look at the size of the federal branch in the terms of efficient versus deliberate,
- 30:58let's say we want a more efficient government.
- 31:01You could go about this a couple of different ways.
- 31:03You might actually think a larger executive is is good, or you might think a smaller executive
- 31:08branch is good.
- 31:09So if you're more of the efficient camp, you might think a larger executive is more
- 31:15efficient because you need more specialized departments and positions and jobs to handle an
- 31:21increasing workload for the government.
- 31:23It's you're there's too many issues that are going on, so you need a lot of people to be
- 31:29able to handle all of those things and get everything addressed and responded to in a
- 31:36timely manner.
- 31:37Or supporter of efficient government might think that a smaller executive is needed
- 31:42because they might say that too many departments and positions will bog down the
- 31:46efficiency of government.
- 31:47That was the idea behind Doge.
- 31:49Too many cooks in the kitchen and that it costs too much money in terms of taxpayer dollars.
- 31:56They have to get the money to fund the government in some way, and primarily that is
- 32:00done through taxpayer dollars.
- 32:02So supporting an efficient government could go either way.
- 32:07A deliberative supporter or a supporter of deliberative government might also support
- 32:14either a larger executive or a smaller executive branch.
- 32:19If they support a larger executive, they might say that more departments are needed to vote
- 32:23time to individual issues because if they're more specialized, they can think things over
- 32:29and account for a whole bunch of different views.
- 32:32And so you need enough people to be able to handle all of those differing views and all
- 32:38that differing information coming in.
- 32:41Or they might support a smaller executive.
- 32:43They might say that fewer departments will keep these people that are in the government more
- 32:50informed on a bunch of different issues and how they interweave together.
- 32:54So they need to think things over more about how all these issues interlock instead of
- 32:59having it spread out across a bunch of different people with differing views on how to
- 33:03apply the law.
- 33:05Or how about we look at efficiency versus deliberation in the context of executive
- 33:11orders, which is in this case, mostly in regards to the president, but similar arguments
- 33:16could extend to governors too because they have their own version of executive orders as well.
- 33:21And we discussed executive orders in at least a couple of previous podcast episodes, including
- 33:26number 18, which was about presidential power and the controversies that surrounding that
- 33:32surround its expansion.
- 33:35The American Bar Association defines executive order as a signed, written, and published
- 33:42directive from the president of The United States that manages operations of the federal
- 33:47government.
- 33:48And some of these are small scale, and some of these are much more wide ranging.
- 33:52And these wide ranging ones are controversial because they're often seen as a way for the
- 33:56president to circumvent Congress's power to write laws.
- 33:59Although the president will say that they're actually acting within the bounds of the law as
- 34:05it is written.
- 34:06They're just simply making sure it gets enforced.
- 34:12Dive a bit more into that specific controversy in that episode 18, so I don't want to go too
- 34:18much into it here.
- 34:19We're also focusing more on the efficiency versus deliberation aspect here.
- 34:23So somebody who believes in a more efficient government, they're probably more amenable to a
- 34:31president's use of executive orders because there's less reliance on government or congress
- 34:37to enact policy.
- 34:39They may see executive orders as necessary to get a round in, in their eyes, inept or
- 34:45ineffective congress.
- 34:47And they will say that executive orders are allowed by the constitution to execute the
- 34:52nation's laws.
- 34:54Somebody who supports a more deliberative government, probably gonna support little usage
- 34:59of executive orders, if at all, because they see it as they need to rely more on congress to
- 35:05pass legislation, and they see executive orders as unconstitutional and an imbalance of the
- 35:12separation of powers and checks and balances.
- 35:15Or how about we go to the war powers?
- 35:18Basically, what powers does the president have to be able to dictate war, to wage war, to
- 35:24declare war?
- 35:26And that was also discussed in podcast episode number 18, and and I believe I had another one
- 35:31that talked about it as well.
- 35:33But the controversies or the debates surrounding it are what exact powers does the
- 35:40president have regarding the declaration of war?
- 35:43Is it that they're just commander in chief?
- 35:46Do they get to clear to declare war unilaterally?
- 35:49Do they have to get permission from congress first, or can they declare war and then later
- 35:54on get permission from congress?
- 35:58It's definitely become, over the past fifty years, a more heated discussion, I suppose, a
- 36:06more pertinent discussion.
- 36:08So if we look at it in the context of efficient government versus deliberative government,
- 36:13somebody who supports a more efficient government is probably going to be more
- 36:17supportive of the president having more wide ranging war powers because they're gonna say
- 36:21that the president should have more power to declare and or make war and that he needs to be
- 36:27or she needs to be able to be swift in responding to international issues concerning
- 36:32warfare because when it comes to war, it tends to be a very pressing issue.
- 36:37People are dying.
- 36:39People are losing their homes.
- 36:40People are being starved and tortured.
- 36:45And so these people for efficient government will say that the constitution actually leaves
- 36:52war powers responsibility ambiguous, and that it allows the president to repel invasions of
- 36:58their own authority and thus leaves power to make war quote unquote, a concurrent
- 37:04responsibility of both branches.
- 37:07They're saying it as that The US is just executing and enforcing laws.
- 37:12And they'll also say that congress has willingly ceded war powers without pushing back
- 37:17anyways.
- 37:18On the flip side, somebody who supports a more deliberative government will say that the
- 37:22president should have less power to declare and or make war and that they need to refer to
- 37:27other branches, particularly congress, on what to do.
- 37:30Because it is such a wide ranging issue and so many people are being negatively impacted, you
- 37:38need to be able to take the time to think things over about how best to proceed with
- 37:44these issues in warfare.
- 37:46And they'll say that somebody who supports a deliberative government in in the context of
- 37:50war powers will say that there's a clear demarcation of power to declare war belonging
- 37:55to congress while the president is just the commander in chief and that the power to
- 38:01unilaterally declare war is an abuse of power that doesn't belong to one person and that the
- 38:08courts have not stopped the president like they should.
- 38:10So they're saying that the not just that congress should be involved for in a more
- 38:15deliberative way, but that the courts need to also have their opinion voiced and try to stop
- 38:23the president from being so involved in war powers, and that he needs to refer to the other
- 38:29branches more often.
- 38:31Now let's move to the legislative branch.
- 38:33So the congress and the state legislatures.
- 38:37Main responsibility, generally speaking, the legislative branches that they write the laws.
- 38:43So some of the questions, not all the questions, but some of the questions to ask
- 38:46about this branch when it comes to efficiency versus deliberation, Is an efficient or
- 38:53deliberative process more conducive to productivity of a state legislature?
- 38:58Podcast episode number 40 here was talking about the productivity of state legislatures in
- 39:04Congress and what exactly constitutes productivity.
- 39:08It doesn't I didn't come up with my own definition.
- 39:11I just brought up some questions to think about when it comes to defining productivity.
- 39:16Like, is it just about how many bills are introduced?
- 39:19Is it about how many are passed?
- 39:21Is it about the percentage of bills that are passed compared to how many were introduced?
- 39:27Not necessarily clear answers.
- 39:29Another question to think about, should legislatures be more efficient or deliberative
- 39:34than the other branches?
- 39:36They are the ones that are devising the laws after all.
- 39:39I believe it was Alexander Hamilton and I can't remember what federalist paper it was, but base
- 39:44I believe one of them was talking about why they had a bicameral legislature and basically
- 39:51were saying that the legislative branch is inherently the most powerful branch.
- 39:55So it needed to have its power split up between two chambers so that it could deliberate more
- 40:01about how to write laws for the nation.
- 40:06And if you only count, quote, unquote, main officials of each branch of government,
- 40:13legislator branch has the most members because you have a congress or you have state
- 40:17legislatures.
- 40:18The courts, if you talk about specifically just the justices and not the clerks and all the
- 40:25people underneath the the justices, and then if you talk about the in the executive branch, the
- 40:31president and the cabinet or a governor and other state executives in a given state,
- 40:36legislative branch is gonna have the most, quote, unquote, main officials.
- 40:40So do we need to have that branch be more efficient because there are so many people or
- 40:47be more deliberative because there are so many people to account for.
- 40:51So let's go to the case study of the unicameral or bicameral legislature, which was really the
- 40:59thing that spawned this idea for this podcast episode in the first place, that LinkedIn post
- 41:04I talked about where I was discussing whether somebody who wants a more efficient government,
- 41:10what they would support, and whether somebody who wants a more deliberative government, what
- 41:15they would support.
- 41:16And just to reiterate, bicameral means there's two chambers.
- 41:20So there's a house or in a few states, they call it an assembly such as in New York and a
- 41:25senate.
- 41:26And in other countries, it might be called something different.
- 41:30Like in Britain, they have the house of commons and the house of lords, but they're base it's
- 41:35basically the same thing.
- 41:36And also British, it's called or in Britain, it's called parliament, not congress.
- 41:41Unicameral is one chamber, and countries that use this system include Denmark, Greece, New
- 41:47Zealand.
- 41:48But in The US, in congress, and all the state legislatures, there are two chambers.
- 41:56They are all bicameral except Nebraska.
- 42:00Because in 1934, voters in Nebraska passed a state constitutional amendment that shifted
- 42:06from a bicameral legislature to a unicameral legislature.
- 42:09And, also, so it left just a senate.
- 42:11And that same change also made it the only nominally nonpartisan legislature.
- 42:16Now the legislators in Nebraska still tend to ally with either the republican or democratic
- 42:21parties, but officially, are all considered nonpartisan for the state legislature.
- 42:28So if you are a supporter of a more efficient government, you're probably gonna be more
- 42:34likely to support a unicameral legislature because it's gonna be much quicker to pass
- 42:39bills because you don't have to worry about two chambers.
- 42:42Because if you have two chambers, they both need to not just agree on the basic idea behind
- 42:47a bill, but they need to agree on the exact same wording down to a t.
- 42:53Everything has to be the exact same for that chamber or excuse me, for that legislature to
- 42:59pass a bill and then send it to the chief executive, whether it's the president for
- 43:05congress or the governor for a state legislature.
- 43:10Now that doesn't mean that just because of that unit camera legislature doesn't mean that that
- 43:15is gonna be a good bill.
- 43:16A single chamber can just railroad a bill toward passage without ironing out all the
- 43:21issues.
- 43:22They didn't have two chambers to really deliberate on something.
- 43:27On the flip side, the deliberative arguments would be more likely to support a bicameral
- 43:32legislature because the chambers have to come together to think through how they are going to
- 43:37agree on the same bill.
- 43:38There are competing interests that have to be accounted for and taken into a into the bill so
- 43:46that both chambers can agree to it.
- 43:49However, this can lead to more political fighting even if both chambers are controlled
- 43:54by the same party.
- 43:55I can tell you here in my state, with the Florida legislature, the senate and the house
- 44:00and the governor too, but especially the house and the senate, were very much at odds about
- 44:05what the budget should ultimately be for this coming fiscal year.
- 44:11So they are actually in the midst as I'm recording this, they're in the midst of a
- 44:16special session right now to iron out all the issues for the budget because they didn't get
- 44:21it done during the regular session.
- 44:23And other states have had that kind of issue before too, so they might a deliberative
- 44:28government in that context might be bogged down by gridlock.
- 44:32So a pro and a con, at least in theory, for both the efficient side for a unicameral
- 44:39legislature and then the deliberative side for a bicameral legislature.
- 44:44And if you wanna extend the efficiency versus deliberative arguments to the statistics on
- 44:54bills passed by congress and state legislatures, Just real quick, go through all
- 45:00of those.
- 45:01Again, episode 40 talks more in-depth about this, but a few of the facets that were
- 45:07introduced or or talked about in that episode were the number of bills introduced, the number
- 45:11of bills passed, and the percentage of bills passed.
- 45:15And so for 2021 statistics, and I got this data from the website fiscal note, which is they do
- 45:23a lot of government affairs stuff and data and have a database tracking state legislative
- 45:28bills.
- 45:30The number of bills introduced in 2021 ranged from 436 in Alaska to 16,818 in New York.
- 45:38The number of bills passed, 48 in Alaska to 3,849 in Texas.
- 45:48And then percentage of bills in Massachusetts, there is 0.41% that were passed in 2021 to
- 45:5881.27% in Colorado.
- 46:01And then if you look at GovTrack, which tracks congress bill statistics, and this was actually
- 46:08for the whole term of 2021 and 2022 because it didn't break it down into each year.
- 46:13It did it just by each term of congress.
- 46:16The number of bills passed there, 17,817.
- 46:20Again, that's over two years.
- 46:22The number of bills passed was 1,234, and then the percentage of bills passed was 6.93%.
- 46:32So when you're talking about those statistics in the context of efficiency versus
- 46:40deliberation.
- 46:41Does introducing and passing more bills mean we are being more efficient, or does it mean that
- 46:46a majority party is abusing its power and just ramming in ham fisted legislation to assert
- 46:52dominance?
- 46:54Does passing only a small percentage of bills mean we are being more deliberate, or is it
- 46:59political gainsmanship bogging down the political process?
- 47:03Because there's been a wide range of numbers in how many bills have been passed in the
- 47:08legislature and or introduced in the legislature and how many were passed, and then
- 47:15therefore the percentage of bills that were passed.
- 47:18Starkly different numbers across states.
- 47:21But does that mean that x state was being more efficient and another state was being more
- 47:28deliberative?
- 47:30Maybe state was being both.
- 47:32Maybe a state was being neither.
- 47:33Maybe it was inefficient and not deliberative.
- 47:35Maybe it was both efficient and deliberative.
- 47:39It's not really a straightforward question.
- 47:41It's something to really think about a lot more.
- 47:45And then for the second case study for the legislative branch before we move to the
- 47:49judicial branch, talk about congress's involvement in confirming presidential
- 47:54nominations for federal courts.
- 47:56And this goes back to episode number 18 of the podcast again, which was the debate about
- 48:00whether the president has too much power in the selection of judges.
- 48:05So thinking about that debate, the efficient side is going to say that congress does not
- 48:12need to be more involved in judicial selection because they're gonna say, well, the power the
- 48:16president only has the power to nominate, and that bringing congress into more of a role in
- 48:23the nomination process invites more political factionalism into the process.
- 48:27They're saying it's not being deliberative.
- 48:29It's just being bogged down by gaysmanship.
- 48:32And they'll say it is the US senate that actually exercises too much power by
- 48:37obstructing the confirmation process on partisan and ideological grounds.
- 48:43Meanwhile, the deliberative side is going to say Congress needs to be more involved in
- 48:47judicial selection because the US Senate advice function because in in the constitution, it's
- 48:53supposed to be advice and consent, not just consent.
- 48:57They say the US senate advice function has been largely reduced when they are supposed to
- 49:02provide both advice and consent.
- 49:05So it's not being efficient, it's just being the president railroading their nominees, at
- 49:13least in the eyes of some people who support a more deliberative government.
- 49:18And they'll also say that the threshold of for confirmation of judges needs to be raised from
- 49:22a simple simple majority saying that a simple majority is really that's not being efficient.
- 49:27There's just one interest just having their way and not really having to think things over.
- 49:35You're not trying to account for multiple interests and therefore trying to come up with
- 49:39a judge that is more amenable to more people.
- 49:43And they'll say that presidents are far too political in making appointments to what is
- 49:48supposed to be an apolitical branch.
- 49:50Ideally, you want your judges to be completely impartial.
- 49:54If anybody in the government is is to be impartial, you want it to be the courts.
- 49:59So do we want our legislature to be more efficient or deliberative, or do we want them
- 50:05efficient in certain contexts and then deliberative in other contexts?
- 50:09Something to think about.
- 50:10And now finally, let's go to the judicial branch and the several case studies there.
- 50:16So we're talking about the Supreme Court of the United States or SCOTUS and the state courts.
- 50:22The main general function of the courts is to interpret the laws, and the legal system is
- 50:30bogged down in ways that make it very inefficient because trials can drag on forever.
- 50:34You have superfluous lawsuits that may or may not make it to court.
- 50:38But the importance of many lawsuits also requires some level of deliberation.
- 50:43So how do we balance the two?
- 50:46To some extent, the nature of efficiency versus deliberation, that that debate, it's inherently
- 50:51different for judicial branch versus the executive and legislature.
- 50:56Given that it interprets laws, the judicial branch does, it's naturally a more deliberative
- 51:01branch, but it has issues with efficiency.
- 51:05That being said, though, we can still have some discussion about the structure and function of
- 51:10the judiciary in terms of whether to favor efficiency or deliberation, or maybe you could
- 51:16have both.
- 51:17So some of the questions to ask about this branch when it comes to efficiency versus
- 51:22deliberation, How many courts do you need to handle caseloads, particularly in the state
- 51:27court system?
- 51:28Because some states have multiple circuits for their intermediate appellate courts.
- 51:32They might call them circuits.
- 51:33They might call them there's a couple of other terms that they use, and then I'm blanking on
- 51:38what they are right now, but they have several different circuits.
- 51:41And then some of the lower courts may also have circuits as well.
- 51:46Should some of these larger cert courts be broken up into panels?
- 51:51Like in California, they have some much bigger courts, and they sometimes have panels within
- 51:56these circuits.
- 51:59How many judges need to be on the bench for a court?
- 52:03This is more relevant for state supreme courts and intermediate appellate courts.
- 52:07Some of the lower courts will just have one judge.
- 52:10And then what kinds of cases should go before which courts?
- 52:14So supreme court of the United States, everyone agrees it only needs to hear the cases of the
- 52:19utmost national importance, but maybe there are some cases we think should be heard by the US
- 52:24Supreme Court that don't get heard, or we think that for the state supreme courts.
- 52:29And then in a couple of states, Oklahoma and Texas, they have two supreme courts.
- 52:34They're not both only one of them in each case is called a supreme court, but there are two
- 52:41courts of last resort, one for civil cases and one for criminal cases.
- 52:47And one other question to think about, is there a need for tort reform?
- 52:52So torts are personal injury lawsuits, and tort reform is the whole idea of changing laws
- 53:00related to personal injury lawsuits and which ones can be brought before a court.
- 53:06Do we need a change in that to better supplement efficiency of courts or deliberation
- 53:13for courts?
- 53:14So first case study to think about here is how many judges should be involved in a certain
- 53:20court case.
- 53:21Because depending on the case and the court with jurisdiction, there might be one judge or
- 53:26multiple judges that take a case.
- 53:31So for example, a lot of trial courts are just a singular judge, but the US Supreme Court and
- 53:35state supreme courts are multiple judges.
- 53:37In the US Supreme Court, it's nine judges.
- 53:40Some state supreme courts are also nine, some are all are seven, and then some are five.
- 53:45And then there's a bit more variety in bench size when it comes to intermediate appellate
- 53:51courts.
- 53:54You might hear about in the news, you might hear about a single judge temporarily halting a
- 53:59federal or state law, while in other cases, might be a panel of judges that grants an
- 54:04injunction against a law, especially with some of these immigration laws that we've seen
- 54:10recently.
- 54:11Sometimes it's been a federal judge that has or a singular judge that is granted a stay,
- 54:18whereas in some other cases, not necessarily the immigration laws, but other injunctions
- 54:24might have multiple judges, a panel of judges granting a temporary injunction on a law.
- 54:31If you're a supporter of more efficient government, you might say that we should have
- 54:35fewer judges on a case because fewer judges for plaintiffs and defendants to argue in front of.
- 54:42So there's fewer judges to have to question defendants, and thus, you don't the idea was
- 54:48necessarily that you don't have a whole bunch more questions from judges to slow down a
- 54:55process, and they'll say that fewer judges can come to a quicker ruling on a case and then
- 55:02write their majority or and concurring and dissenting opinions.
- 55:06A majority opinion is one that is considered the official opinion of a court on a case.
- 55:15Concurring opinions are ones that support the majority rule, but they have different reasons
- 55:20for doing so.
- 55:21And then dissenting opinions are the judges who don't agree with the rest of their cohorts,
- 55:28their fellow justices on that bench.
- 55:31They do not support that judicial ruling.
- 55:36Whereas a more deliberative government supporter might say that we need more judges on
- 55:41the case because more judges with differing views can discuss a case and thoroughly
- 55:46question plaintiffs and defendants, and they'll say that more judges can provide more
- 55:51information on their decisions in their majority concurring and dissenting opinions.
- 55:57And then in the second case study to think about here, should there be state supreme
- 56:01courts for both civil and criminal cases?
- 56:04So like we said earlier, right now, only Oklahoma and Texas have two courts of last
- 56:11resort.
- 56:12They're both technically supreme courts, but only one in each state is actually called that
- 56:18state's Supreme Court.
- 56:21Now, this is a case where for both the efficient supporter or the supporter of an
- 56:27efficient government and a supporter of a deliberative government could both argue for
- 56:31having two state supreme courts or two courts of last resort, and they could argue for one
- 56:39court of last resort.
- 56:40So the efficient side for arguing for or against two courts of last resort, they might
- 56:49say that you do need two courts of last resort because that could lighten the caseload that
- 56:54one state supreme court would have, and this would lead to a smaller case backlog bogging
- 57:00down these highest courts.
- 57:03They don't have to slog through all of them.
- 57:06You could have two different courts to be able to split up the caseload, one for civil, one
- 57:12for criminal.
- 57:13But if supporter of an efficient government might say that there's one or that we only need
- 57:21one state supreme court because it would lessen the cost of government function, so you're
- 57:26having to pay fewer judges, which means less taxpayer dollars that are needed to pay for
- 57:31them and for their legal clerks and all the other people underneath them, and that you
- 57:36don't need to have to devise a new structure below a second court of last resort, and that
- 57:43higher quality judges can handle both criminal and civil cases just fine.
- 57:49On the deliberative side, somebody who supports a more deliberative government, again, they
- 57:53could argue for or against having two courts of last resort.
- 57:57In the case of two courts of last resort, they might say that that is needed because it allows
- 58:03specialized judges to devote time to thinking over respective civil and criminal cases.
- 58:09Somebody who handles a lot more civil law and then somebody who handles a lot more criminal A
- 58:13lot of lawyers and judges handle both civil and criminal matters, but in a lot of cases, some
- 58:19of them will have a lot more expertise in criminal matters and then some will have more
- 58:23expertise in civil matters.
- 58:26But a supporter of deliberative government might say instead that we need one state
- 58:34supreme court because that would lead to a consistent uniform application of law and
- 58:39justice for individuals or groups.
- 58:43They're saying that only one person needs to think these things over, and it's not if you
- 58:50have a consistent approach, it doesn't lead to issues down the road, which might sound like a
- 58:59little bit more of an efficient argument, but they're saying that these people that a one
- 59:07supreme court can be more consistent and take the time to think these things over in the
- 59:14context of what the law says.
- 59:20And that's going to do it for all these case studies.
- 59:22So I want to leave some final thoughts here about whether efficiency and deliberation are
- 59:28inherently at odds.
- 59:31Efficiency efficiency generally looks for quick solutions to problems, while deliberation looks
- 59:37for solutions to be thought over first.
- 59:40So it may seem like they're automatically opposed to each other, but maybe that depends
- 59:44on how we frame things.
- 59:47Some people get a either positive connotation from efficient or a negative connotation from
- 59:53efficient.
- 59:54They might say efficient is, hey.
- 59:56Things are working well.
- 59:57They're working at their highest ability that they should, whereas they might say efficiency
- 1:00:02is actually just a euphemism for hamfisting railroading policies and rulings.
- 1:00:10On the deliberative side, deliberation may think may sound like in a positive connotation,
- 1:00:15oh, they're really taking the time to think things over and incorporating things.
- 1:00:19Others may say that deliberation is just dawdling and and just taking their sweet
- 1:00:25precious time when something needs to be addressed right away.
- 1:00:29So be careful not to get weighed down by wanting efficiency or deliberation for
- 1:00:35government simply for the sake of having efficiency or deliberation.
- 1:00:40Maybe there are some contexts where efficiency would be better, and then there's other
- 1:00:44contexts where deliberation would be better.
- 1:00:47You don't necessarily need to think in those specific words in the in having those specific
- 1:00:53words on the top of your head, but the general ideas between how you're trying to get
- 1:00:58government to function are going to incorporate those ideas, whether you're trying to get
- 1:01:02government to swiftly respond to things or whether you're trying to get it to incorporate
- 1:01:07as much information as possible.
- 1:01:09Some cases, an efficient approach may be needed.
- 1:01:12Other cases, a deliberative approach may be needed.
- 1:01:15There's no easy answers for that.
- 1:01:19But as demonstrated in several of these case studies we discussed, efficiency and
- 1:01:24deliberation are not always inherently opposed.
- 1:01:28They may be in agreement, but for different reasons.
- 1:01:32Go back to a couple of those case studies.
- 1:01:34Somebody who supports a more efficient government may favor a larger executive since
- 1:01:39there are so many different policies and large population and specialized needs that they need
- 1:01:46to be able to have a larger executive to be able to run the government smoothly and address
- 1:01:51all these issues.
- 1:01:53Deliberative side, the deliberative a supporter of deliberative government might also favor a
- 1:01:59larger executive branch, but for a different reason, they may say that a larger executive
- 1:02:04allows more people to devote time to executing different parts of the law.
- 1:02:10They're able to account for varying interests, But efficient and deliberative supporters might
- 1:02:19also oppose a larger executive branch.
- 1:02:22For somebody who wants a more efficient government, they may say a larger executive is
- 1:02:25a case of too many exec cooks in the kitchen, and then it's not really leading to an
- 1:02:31efficient response.
- 1:02:32It's just bogging things down because it's it's too bloated, and they'll say it just costs more
- 1:02:37taxpayer dollars.
- 1:02:39Deliberative supporters may also oppose a larger executive branch because it prevents
- 1:02:44members of the branch from being informed about a wide variety of policies and how they
- 1:02:50interweave.
- 1:02:50It's getting spread out by too many people, and they don't necessarily need to communicate with
- 1:02:55each other.
- 1:02:57Or we take it in the context of these two state supreme courts or two courts of last resort in
- 1:03:02the judicial branch, and this is more for the state level.
- 1:03:06This is not something that's gonna change for the federal level.
- 1:03:10And this US Supreme Court operates a little bit differently than state supreme courts do
- 1:03:16anyways in terms of what kinds of cases they take and why they take some of those.
- 1:03:23So if you talk about two courts of last resort, somebody who wants a more efficient government
- 1:03:29may favor it to lighten the caseload that would be on one state supreme court.
- 1:03:35It would lead to a smaller backlog of cases that are bogging down the highest courts.
- 1:03:40But somebody who supports a more deliberative government may also favor two state supreme
- 1:03:44courts because it allows judges to specialize in civil and criminal cases.
- 1:03:48They can think things over and account for a bunch more information.
- 1:03:53They don't have to put it all on one state supreme court.
- 1:03:59But both efficient and deliberative supporters may also oppose two state supreme courts
- 1:04:06because it would for an efficient supporter, it would increase taxpayer costs because you're
- 1:04:12having to have two supreme courts and or two courts of last resort, and the people that are
- 1:04:18beneath them, they all gotta get paid, and that increases taxpayer dollars because it's a
- 1:04:22government entity.
- 1:04:24And so government function costs more, and you would also need to revamp the legal structure.
- 1:04:30And then for somebody who supports a deliberative government, they may also oppose
- 1:04:34it, but because it may lead to an inconsistent application of law and protection of personal
- 1:04:40rights based on which court hears the case, that there really needs to be a more uniform
- 1:04:47application of the law and it's just one person that has the experience is able to think things
- 1:04:54over.
- 1:04:55So in those contexts, you could potentially have an efficient and a deliberative government
- 1:05:03depending on how you implement the ideas.
- 1:05:08But as the case studies show, there is a difference between the theoretical and
- 1:05:13practical sides.
- 1:05:15Things that seem efficient at face value may not be efficient at all.
- 1:05:21Seemingly deliberate things may not be deliberate at all.
- 1:05:24The things that are efficient might just be somebody just railroading in what they want to
- 1:05:29happen.
- 1:05:29Somebody who's being deliberate may just be trying to slow down the process because they're
- 1:05:33not getting their way.
- 1:05:36But maybe the most efficient way to do something is also the more deliberative.
- 1:05:41So, basically, the idea here just hopefully think things over more because at face value,
- 1:05:48you you want the government to be more efficient, but you also want it to incorporate
- 1:05:55more opinions.
- 1:05:57Unless, well, it might depend on whether you support the people that are in charge, whether
- 1:06:03it's federal government or state government.
- 1:06:05So just be careful that your biases are also not influencing whether you support efficient
- 1:06:13or deliberative government.
- 1:06:15It's definitely something that really needs to be talked about more, maybe not necessarily in
- 1:06:20these specific words with this specific terminology, but it really does have a lot of
- 1:06:28implications for the best forms of governance and in terms of how the government functions
- 1:06:35and how it's structured.
- 1:06:38Hopefully, we can have some of these issues resolved in some way now, whether in terms of
- 1:06:46whether some aspects of government need to be more efficient, whether some aspects need to be
- 1:06:50more deliberative.
- 1:06:52That's up to you to decide.
- 1:06:54But, hopefully, this has just gotten the mental gears churning and and and twisting and turning
- 1:07:00in that regard.
- 1:07:01But that is going to do it for today's episode of the podcast.
- 1:07:05As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 1:07:07Please like, comment, and subscribe, and share this podcast.
- 1:07:12It's on YouTube, it's on Spotify, and it's on Apple Podcasts.
- 1:07:15Hopefully, we'll expand it more in the near future.
- 1:07:18Links in my show notes, my Facebook, my LinkedIn, matchmaker FM profile if you wanna
- 1:07:26potentially be a guest on this podcast or you want me as a guest on your podcast, my
- 1:07:31educational email course about the mistakes we make when trying to depolarize politics and how
- 1:07:36we can correct those mistakes and also why we make those mistakes, but then also ultimately
- 1:07:41correct those mistakes.
- 1:07:42My book, why independents rarely win elections and how they become more competitive, and
- 1:07:48believe that is it.
- 1:07:50So as always, thank you so much for listening, and hope you enjoyed this.
- 1:07:56And until next time, Take care.