Latest / Kentucky Tonight / SB 150 and LGBTQ Issues
Transcript
- 0:02[♪♪]
- 0:11GOOD EVENING.
- 0:12WELCOME TO KENTUCKY TONIGHT.
- 0:13I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 0:14THANKS FOR JOINING US.
- 0:16OUR TOPIC TONIGHT: SENATE BILL
- 0:18150 AND LGBTQ-PLUS ISSUES.
- 0:21THE KENTUCKY GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 0:23PASSED SENATE BILL 150 EARLIER
- 0:24IN THE YEAR.
- 0:25IT INCLUDES A BAN ON
- 0:27GENDER-AFFIRMING MEDICAL CARE
- 0:28FOR TRANS YOUTH, AND IT LETS
- 0:31TEACHERS USE A PRONOUN ALIGNED
- 0:32WITH A STUDENT’S BIOLOGICAL SEX,
- 0:34EVEN IF THAT GOES AGAINST THE
- 0:35STUDENT’S WISHES. THE ACLU OF
- 0:37KENTUCKY IS ASKING A JUDGE TO
- 0:39BLOCK THE HEALTHCARE SECTION OF
- 0:40THE BILL, BEFORE IT GOES INTO
- 0:42EFFECT ON JUNE 29TH.
- 0:44THE LATEST DISPUTE IS OVER THE
- 0:47USE OF THE WORD “OR” IN ONE PART
- 0:48OF SB 150.
- 0:51THE LAW BANS ANY INSTRUCTION ON
- 0:54HUMAN SEXUALITY IN GRADES K
- 0:55THROUGH 5 -- OR -- INSTRUCTION
- 0:57ON GENDER IDENTITY OR SEXUAL
- 1:00ORIENTATION FOR ALL GRADES.
- 1:01THE DEPARTMENT SAYS THE USE OF
- 1:03THE CONJUNCTION 'OR'.... INSTEAD
- 1:06OF 'AND'..... MEANS SCHOOLS CAN
- 1:08STILL DO ONE OR THE OTHER.
- 1:10I TALKED TO EDUCATION
- 1:11COMMISSIONER JASON GLASS ABOUT
- 1:12THAT INTERPRETATION, WHEN I
- 1:13INTERVIEWED HIM LAST THURSDAY.
- 1:19>> COMMISSIONER GLASS THANK YOU
- 1:20FOR YOUR TIME.
- 1:21>> THANK YOU.
- 1:22IT'S GREAT TO BE HERE.
- 1:23>> LET'S TALK ABOUT THE COP
- 1:27JUNCTION MORE WHICH HAS GOTTEN
- 1:29MOREHEAD LINES.
- 1:31SENATE BILL 150'S LANGUAGE YOU
- 1:34HAVE USED THE WORD OR TO ALLOW
- 1:36FOR SCHOOL DISTRICTS TO DECIDE
- 1:37ABOUT TEACHING SENSUAL OTHER
- 1:41GENERATION AND SEXUAL IDENTITY.
- 1:43>> IT WAS THE LANGUAGE IN THE
- 1:44BILL IT WAS NOT OUR
- 1:46DETERMINATION TO USE THE WORD OR
- 1:48THAT IS IN THE STATUTE NOW.
- 1:50WE HAVE ISSUED TWO SETS OF
- 1:53GUIDANCE RELATED.
- 1:54THE FIRST SET DID NOT POINT OUT
- 1:56THAT DIFFERENCE AND WE STARTED
- 1:58HEARING FROM ATTORNEYS WHO
- 2:00REPRESENT SCHOOL DISTRICTS AND
- 2:01ASSOCIATIONS AND THEY POINTED
- 2:02OUT THAT ERROR IN THE LAW.
- 2:04WE KNOW IT IS AN ERROR BASED ON
- 2:06THE REACTION WE'RE SEEING FROM
- 2:09THE SENATE G.O.P. AND THE
- 2:10KENTUCKY COMPONENT.
- 2:12BUT IT'S BEEN BROUGHT UP TO US
- 2:14BY THE ATTORNEYS AND POINTING
- 2:16OUT THAT IS AN ERROR.
- 2:19>> Renee: SENATOR MAX WISE THE
- 2:20SPONSOR OF SENATE BILL 150 SAYS
- 2:23IT IS A WARPED INTERPRETATION TO
- 2:26WIGGLE OUT OF THE LAW AND CALLED
- 2:28IT AN ABSURD EFFORT TO SKIRT
- 2:31STATE LAW.
- 2:32COUNTER TO WHAT YOU WERE SAYING
- 2:34WHAT DO YOU MEAN BY THAT?
- 2:35>> I WOULD DISAGREE WITH SENATOR
- 2:38WISE.
- 2:38IT'S WHAT THE LAW SAYS.
- 2:39THEY ARE THE ONES THAT WROTE OR
- 2:42INTO THE STATUTE.
- 2:43IT WOULD BE A WARPED
- 2:47INTERPRETATION TO CALL OR AND
- 2:48AND INSTEAD.
- 2:50IT'S CLEAR THE LEGISLATORS MADE
- 2:52AN ERROR AND THE RIGHT THING TO
- 2:54DO, I ACCEPT RESPONSIBILITY AND
- 2:56I GO ABOUT STRAIGHTENING IT OUT.
- 2:58THEY HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO DO
- 3:00THAT NEXT SESSION AND I'M SURE
- 3:02THEY WILL CORRECT THE ERROR AND
- 3:04POINT TO ME AND SAY YOU CAUSED
- 3:06THIS IS FALSE.
- 3:07WE WERE NOT INVOLVED IN THE
- 3:09PROCESS OF THE BILL AND IT WAS
- 3:11RUSHED THROUGH AT THE
- 3:12LAST-MINUTE IT'S SURPRISING
- 3:13THERE ARE NOT MORE ERRORS WITH
- 3:16THE SPEED UNDER COVER OF
- 3:18DARKNESS THAT THIS MOVED
- 3:19THROUGH.
- 3:20>> .
- 3:21>> Renee: HAVE OTHER ERRORS BEEN
- 3:22FOUND?
- 3:23>> WE HAVE LOTS OF CONFLICTS
- 3:25WITH SCHOOL, BEST PRACTICES,
- 3:27WITH FEDERAL LAW, WITH POSSIBLE
- 3:29CONSTITUTIONAL QUESTIONS.
- 3:30ALL OF THOSE THINGS WILL COME
- 3:32OUT AS THIS GETS IMPLEMENTED
- 3:34PROBABLY TO BE SOLVED IN THE
- 3:36COURTS OR AS CHALLENGES RISE UP
- 3:37WE MAY SEE THE LEGISLATURE MAKE
- 3:40ADJUSTMENTS TO IT.
- 3:41THAT WILL HAVE TO BE DETERMINED.
- 3:42THERE IS A LOT WE DON'T KNOW IN
- 3:45OUR GUIDANCE WE TRIED TO POINT
- 3:46OUT THE COMPLEXITIES HERE ARE
- 3:49THINGS YOU NEED TO BE THINKING
- 3:51ABOUT TAKING CARE OF YOUR
- 3:52STUDENTS.
- 3:53HERE IS WHERE IT CONFLICTS WITH
- 3:55FEDERAL LAW AND WHERE IT MAY
- 3:56CAUSE A CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUE IT
- 3:59WILL BE UP TO THE SCHOOL
- 4:00DISTRICTS TO DETERMINE HOW THEY
- 4:01HANDLE THOSE ISSUES.
- 4:03>> Renee: YOU MENTION THAT
- 4:04REPUBLICANS ACKNOWLEDGED THIS
- 4:05WAS AN ERROR.
- 4:06WHO ACKNOWLEDGED IT WAS AN
- 4:08ERROR?
- 4:09>> IT DOESN'T SEEM LIKE THEY ARE
- 4:11OWNING UP TO IT.
- 4:12THEY ARE POINTING OUT THE INTENT
- 4:14WAS TO BE AND AND THAT IS NOT
- 4:16WHAT IT SAYS.
- 4:17SO WE ARE QUOTING THE EXACT
- 4:18LANGUAGE IN THE BILL THAT SAYS
- 4:20OR.
- 4:21AND SO I WOULD SAY BASED ON
- 4:23THEIR REACTION THE INTENT WAS
- 4:25FOR IT TO BE AND.
- 4:27THE RIGHT THING IS NEXT SESSION
- 4:29GO IN AND CORRECT THE ERROR.
- 4:31>> Renee: IN THE MEANTIME WHAT
- 4:33SHOULD HAPPEN IF IT IS AN ERROR
- 4:35OR POSSIBLE LITIGATION THAT MANY
- 4:37COULD FEAR SHOULD THEY COMPLY AT
- 4:39ALL?
- 4:40AND WOULD THERE BE PENALTIES FOR
- 4:42THAT?
- 4:43>> WE'VE PROVIDED NON-REGULATORY
- 4:46GUIDANCE.
- 4:47IT ADVISES THEM HERE IS THE
- 4:49LANDSCAPE IN WHICH THIS POLICY
- 4:51WILL BE IMPLEMENTED AND THINGS
- 4:53FOR SCHOOL DISTRICTS TO THINK
- 4:54ABOUT.
- 4:55IT WILL BE UP TO THEM TO CONSULT
- 4:57WITH THEIR ATTORNEYS AND WHAT
- 5:00ARE THEIR RISKS AND WHAT IS THE
- 5:02BEST INTEREST OF THE STUDENTS
- 5:03AND WHAT IS BEST FOR THEM.
- 5:05>> Renee: ARE YOU HEARING THEY
- 5:05ARE CONCERNED ABOUT LITIGATION
- 5:07EITHER WAY THEY INTERPRET THE
- 5:09LAW?
- 5:09>> YES.
- 5:10I THINK THEY SHOULD BE.
- 5:12BECAUSE AGAIN WE'VE GOT
- 5:14CONFLICTS WITH BEST PRACTICE AND
- 5:16CONFLICTS WITH FEDERAL LAW, AND
- 5:18CONFLICTS WITH POSSIBLE
- 5:19CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUES ALL WILL
- 5:21DEPEND HOW THIS IS IMPLEMENTED
- 5:22AND WHAT HAPPENS.
- 5:23I THINK WE WILL HAVE TO SEE HOW
- 5:25IT ROLLS OUT OVER THE NEXT
- 5:27COUPLE OF YEARS TO SEE CASES.
- 5:29THERE HAVE BEEN SOME FILED
- 5:31AGAINST ELEMENTS OF SENATE BILL
- 5:33150.
- 5:34BUT THERE ARE MULTIPLE POINTS
- 5:35THIS LAW COULD BE CHALLENGED.
- 5:37>> Renee: TO MAKE IT PLAIN WHAT
- 5:39DOES YOUR GUIDANCE GIVE SCHOOL
- 5:41DISTRICTS THE PERMISSION TO DO?
- 5:42>> WELL, IT MERELY SAYS THAT
- 5:43WHEN IT COMES TO ADOPTING A
- 5:48POLICY AROUND TOPICS RELATED TO
- 5:52GENDER IDENTITY, SEXUAL IDENTITY
- 5:55OR MATT TOURATION THERE IS A
- 5:58CHOICE THE DISTRICTS HAVE THEY
- 6:00CAN EXCLUDE IT FOR STUDENTS
- 6:02UNDER GRADE 5.
- 6:03OR THEY CAN EXCLUDE IT FOR
- 6:05EVERYONE.
- 6:06SO THAT OR IS THE OPERATIVE
- 6:10TERM.
- 6:10WE'VE SEEN SOME SCHOOL DISTRICTS
- 6:12LOOK AT THAT AND DECIDE THEY ARE
- 6:13GOING TO CHOOSE BETWEEN ONE OF
- 6:15THOSE BECAUSE THE LAW GIVES THEM
- 6:17THAT ABILITY.
- 6:18OTHERS ARE WRESTLING DO THEY DO
- 6:21BOTH?
- 6:21BECAUSE THEY ARE HEARING FROM
- 6:22THE LEGISLATURE THEY ARE GOING
- 6:24TO CORRECT THIS.
- 6:27IT'S --
- 6:28WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO SEE THE
- 6:30SCHOOL DISTRICTS AND HOW THE
- 6:32ATTORNEYS WILL HANDLE IT.
- 6:33>> THANK YOU COMMISSIONER GLASS,
- 6:35WE APPRECIATE YOUR TIME.
- 6:36>> THANK YOU.
- 6:37>> Renee: JOINING US TO DISCUSS
- 6:39THIS BY SKYPE, SENATE SENATOR
- 6:41MAX WISE A REPUBLICAN FROM
- 6:42CAMPBELLSVILLE AND THE SPONSOR
- 6:44OF 150.
- 6:49IN OUR LEXINGTON STUDIO:
- 6:50CHRIS HARTMAN, EXECUTIVE
- 6:51DIRECTOR OF THE FAIRNESS
- 6:51CAMPAIGN;
- 6:52RICHARD NELSON, FOUNDER AND
- 6:53EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
- 6:54COMMONWEALTH POLICY CENTER;
- 6:54AND REBECCA BLANKENSHIP,
- 6:55EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF BAN
- 6:56CONVERSION THERAPY KENTUCKY.
- 6:56SEND US YOUR QUESTIONS AND
- 6:57COMMENTS BY TWITTER AT K-Y
- 6:58TONIGHT K-E-T. SEND AN EMAIL TO
- 6:58K-Y TONIGHT AT K-E-T DOT O-R-G.
- 7:00OR USE THE WEB FORM AT K-E-T DOT
- 7:04O-R-G SLASH K-Y TONIGHT. OR YOU
- 7:06CAN CALL 1-800-494-7605. WELCOME
- 7:07TO OUR GUESTS.
- 7:20NEAR AND A LITTLE FURTHER AWAY.
- 7:22SENATOR WISE I WANT TO COME TO
- 7:24YOU FIRST BECAUSE WE HEARD YOUR
- 7:26NAME MENTIONED A FEW TIMES WITH
- 7:28THE INTERVIEW WITH COMMISSIONER
- 7:30GLASS AND YOUR RESPONSE AND
- 7:32PARTICULARLY DO YOU ACKNOWLEDGE
- 7:34THE LANGUAGE IS AT BEST MURKY
- 7:36AND DO YOU ANTICIPATE THE
- 7:39KENTUCKY GENERAL ASSEMBLY TO
- 7:41CLARIFY THE INTENT OF WHAT WAS
- 7:43PASSED IN SENATE BILL 150?
- 7:45>> FIRST, RENEE THANK YOU FOR
- 7:48HAVING ME ON TONIGHT.
- 7:49BASED ON THE INTERVIEW WITH
- 7:51COMMISSIONER GLASS FIRST WE ARE
- 7:53LOOKING AT BUREAUCRATIC ACTIVISM
- 7:56AT ITS FINEST.
- 7:58GOVERNOR ANDY BESHEAR APPOINTED
- 7:59THE COMMISSIONER TO THE POSITION
- 8:02WHO HAS FAR LEFT LEANING VALUES
- 8:04THAT HE PUT FORTH AND ISSUING
- 8:06THAT IS WHAT IT SAYS THERE.
- 8:08AND WITH THAT, I THOUGHT IT WAS
- 8:10INTERESTING HIM TALKING ABOUT
- 8:11WHEN MISTAKES ARE MADE THAT HE
- 8:14HAS CORRECTED THOSE MISTAKES I
- 8:16WONDER WHERE HE WAS WAS THERE A
- 8:18CORRECTION OR ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF
- 8:19HIS COMMENTS FOR KENTUCKY
- 8:23TEACHERS WHEN HE TOLD THEM THEY
- 8:25NEED TO LOOK FOR JOBS NOT
- 8:29FOLLOWING THE ISSUE OF
- 8:32CURRICULUM HE WAS TRYING TO PUSH
- 8:33OUT.
- 8:33IN TERMS OF YOUR SECOND
- 8:36FOLLOW-UP, RENEE, IF WE GO BACK
- 8:38AND CHANGE THAT EXACTLY THERE'S
- 8:40TIMES THAT THE LEGISLATION
- 8:42INTENT IF WE LOOK AT STATUTES
- 8:44AND REVISIONS OR CORRECTIONS WE
- 8:46ALWAYS CAN DO THAT IN THE NEXT
- 8:47SESSION.
- 8:48I WILL SAY THIS HOW MANY TIMES
- 8:49WE TALK ABOUT BUREAUCRATIC
- 8:53ACTIVISM WE COULD GO THROUGH
- 8:55MULTIPLE LAWS IF WE'RE TRYING TO
- 8:58FIND WORDS THERE'S PROBABLY A
- 9:00LOT OF CASE LAW TO GO BACK TO
- 9:02AND INTERPRET THE WAY THE
- 9:04BUREAUCRAT INSTEAD OF FOLLOWING
- 9:06THE INTENT OF THE LEGISLATIVE
- 9:07BODY.
- 9:08>> Renee: WAS IT THE ACTUAL
- 9:09INTENT OR WAS IT THE LANGUAGE
- 9:11THAT WAS INSERTED TO GIVE SCHOOL
- 9:14DISTRICTS AN OPTION?
- 9:14WAS IT REALLY INTENTIONAL FOR IT
- 9:18TO BE AN OR?
- 9:19>> WHAT YOU HAD IS HOUSE
- 9:22COMMITTEE SUBONE WAS PUT IN THE
- 9:25SENATE 150, ANY BILL DOES AS IT
- 9:28RELATES THERE.
- 9:29ALL THOSE PORTIONS OF SENATE
- 9:30BILL 150 THAT YOU SAW AND THE
- 9:33TIME PRODUCT WERE PORTIONS OF
- 9:35SENATE BILLS MY ORIGINAL BILL
- 9:37150 AND YOU HAD HOUSE BILLS MAR-
- 9:42MERGED THERE.
- 9:43AND ATTORNEYS DRAFTERS AND SO
- 9:45FORTH ARE PUT INTO THAT MERGER
- 9:48OF THE HOUSE COMMITTEE SUBONE
- 9:51HAS IT WAS BROUGHT FORTHWITH THE
- 9:54HOUSE EDUCATION COMMITTEE.
- 9:55>> THIS IS FROM THERESA WHILE
- 9:57THE INTERVIEW WAS PLAYING AND
- 9:59IT'S DIRECTED TO YOU SENATOR
- 10:00WISE AND IT SAYS THE KENTUCKY
- 10:02DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION IS
- 10:03IGNORING THE LAW SB150.
- 10:07WHAT LEGISLATION ARE YOU WORKING
- 10:08ON THIS SUMMER THAT WILL ADD
- 10:11CONSEQUENCES TO SB150 FOR
- 10:14REFUSING TO OBEY THE LAW?
- 10:16FIVMENT YOU GO BACK TO THE
- 10:18ORIGINAL INTENT OF THE BILL I
- 10:19DRAFTED WITH OUR LRC BILL
- 10:23DRAFTERS THAT PORTION OF 150 A
- 10:25YEAR AGO WAS DONE IN JUNE AND
- 10:27JULY AFTER A MEETING BETWEEN
- 10:30LEGISLATORS AND COMMISSIONER
- 10:31GLASS IN THE ANNEX IN A CLOSED
- 10:33SESSION MEETING AND WE TALKED
- 10:35ABOUT THE CONCERNS WE ARE
- 10:36HEARING FROM SUPERINTENDENTS,
- 10:37ADMINISTRATORS AND PARENTS
- 10:38RELATED TO THE GINGERBREAD
- 10:42TOOLKIT PUT FORTH.
- 10:43WE TOLD HIM WE WANTED IT TAKEN
- 10:46OFF THE WEBSITE AND HAD THE
- 10:49QUESTION ABOUT PRONOUN USAGE AND
- 10:51KEEPING THINGS QUIET FOR
- 10:52PARENTS.
- 10:53THAT IS WHEN I STARTED WORKING
- 10:55ON THE PORTION OF SENATE BILL
- 10:57150.
- 10:58RIGHT NOW, I CAN'T SPEAK FOR
- 11:00OTHER LEGISLATORS.
- 11:01I HAVE NOT YET HAD A MEETING
- 11:02WITH ANY BILL DRAFTER YET.
- 11:04BUT THAT IS THE BEAUTY OF THE
- 11:06INTERIM THAT PART OF THE PROCESS
- 11:08WE CAN GO THROUGH AND SEE IF
- 11:10THERE'S HOUSE MEMBERS OR
- 11:11SENATORS THAT MAY WANT TO HAVE A
- 11:13CHANGE TO THIS OR MAYBE WE ADD
- 11:16THINGS TO THAT AS WELL.
- 11:18>> REBECCA BLANKENSHIP WELCOME
- 11:20TO "KENTUCKY TONIGHT".
- 11:21WE APPRECIATE YOU BEING HERE.
- 11:22GIVEN THE CONVERSATION YOU HAVE
- 11:23BEEN FOLLOWING THIS BILL AND
- 11:25WORKING AGAINST THIS BILL WHEN
- 11:27IT WAS UP BEFORE THE KENTUCKY
- 11:28GENERAL ASSEMBLY DO YOU FEEL --
- 11:30FIRST OF ALL DID YOU AGREE WITH
- 11:32THE LANGUAGE AS IT WAS WRITTEN
- 11:34AND DO YOU BELIEVE THIS CON
- 11:37JUNCTION OF OR WILL PROVIDE
- 11:40SCHOOL DISTRICTS WITH OPTIONS?
- 11:41>> I WILL SAY I DISAGREE WITH
- 11:44THE INTENTIONS OF SENATE BILL
- 11:46150.
- 11:47CONCERNING THIS PARTICULAR LAW
- 11:49MY ADVICE TO SENATOR WISE NOT TO
- 11:51RIGHT ONE THE NIGHT BEFORE HE
- 11:53PASSES IT LIKE A DRUNK COLLEGE
- 11:56STUDENT BANGING OUT A PAPER.
- 11:57OUR JUDICIAL SYSTEM MUST REPLY
- 12:00ON TEXTUAL INTERPRETATIONS OF
- 12:03LAW.
- 12:04IF WE DISREGARD WE ARE LICENSING
- 12:05THE COURTS TO USE THE JUDICIAL
- 12:08ACTIVISM THAT THE REPUBLICAN
- 12:09PARTY SPENT THE LAST THREE YEARS
- 12:12DECOUNTRYING AT EVERY
- 12:13OPPORTUNITY.
- 12:14WHEN WE HAVE TO GO BACK TO A
- 12:16PRECEDENT FROM 1952 TO JUSTIFY
- 12:19INTERPRETING AN OR AS AN AND
- 12:23WRITTEN BY A LIBERAL JUSTICE
- 12:25IT'S SHOCKING TO SEE THE
- 12:26MAJORITY PARTY DEPART FROM THE
- 12:29PRINCIPLES THEY ARTICULATED AS
- 12:30SOON AS THAT OPPORTUNITY IS
- 12:32AVAILABLE.
- 12:33KED I DON'T THINK THEY ARE
- 12:36COMMITTED TO LGBTQ RIGHTS.
- 12:38I HAD A CONVERSATION WITH Mr.
- 12:40GLASS WHERE I EXPRESSED MY
- 12:43DISMAY THE GUIDANCE HAD GONE
- 12:45BEYOND IN MY VIEW THE LANGUAGE
- 12:46OF THE LAW BY REQUIRING THAT
- 12:51SCHOOLS END GAY STRAIGHT
- 12:53ALLIANCES AND OTHER LGBTQ AFTER
- 12:55SCHOOL CLUBS.
- 12:56I THINK IT'S POSITIVE STEP THAT
- 13:00KED IS MOVING CLOSER TO A
- 13:03TEXTUAL INTERPRETATION AND THE
- 13:04GOVERNMENT AGENCIES SHOULD DO
- 13:06THAT.
- 13:06>> SENATOR?
- 13:08>> WELL, FIRST, I TAKE CRITICISM
- 13:10OF WHAT WAS BEING SAID ABOUT
- 13:13DRUNKEN COLLEGE STUDENT THE
- 13:14NIGHT BEFORE.
- 13:14I THINK THAT IS OUT OF LINE.
- 13:16FIRST OF ALL, TRY TO MAKE A
- 13:19COMPARISON OF ME OR MY
- 13:21COLLEAGUES THAT THAT IS HOW WE
- 13:22WORK THE NIGHT BEFORE.
- 13:23WE DO THIS ALL THE TIME.
- 13:24THE BILL WENT THROUGH THE
- 13:26LEGISLATIVE PROCESS.
- 13:27WENT THROUGH THE DEMOCRATIC
- 13:29PROCESS.
- 13:29EVERY PORTION OF THAT BILL HAD
- 13:32BEEN PREFILED OR FILED OR OUT IN
- 13:34THE GENERAL PUBLIC FOR THEM TO
- 13:35SEE.
- 13:36WHAT WAS PUT FORTH YES, IT MAY
- 13:38HAVE CAME AFTER WHAT HAPPENED
- 13:40WITH HOUSE BILL 490 ON THE
- 13:42CLERK'S DESK BUT YOU KNOW WE DO
- 13:44THIS ALL THE TIME IN TERMS OF
- 13:46MERGING AND PUT IN HOUSE
- 13:48COMMITTEE SUBS INTO SENATE BILLS
- 13:51AND VICE VERSA.
- 13:54>> Renee: SOMEONE I TALKED TO
- 13:55THE BILL ABOUT TODAY AND THE USE
- 13:57OF THE OR AND THE PLACEMENT,
- 14:00MADE AN ANALOGY LIKE SAYING I
- 14:03DON'T WANT YOU TO SIT ON THE
- 14:05COUCH OR THE CHAIR.
- 14:06I DON'T WANT YOU TO SIT ON
- 14:09EITHER ONE.
- 14:09IT IS THAT AN EITHER OR.
- 14:11IT'S NONE OF THEM.
- 14:12WHY DO YOU NOT INTERPRET THAT TO
- 14:14BE OR DO YOU INTERPRET THAT TO
- 14:16BE THE CASE IN SB150 IN THIS
- 14:20SECTION.
- 14:20>> I AGREE WITH Dr. GLASS'
- 14:23ASSESSMENT OF THAT CONJUNCTION.
- 14:26AND I FIND IT SO FUNNY.
- 14:28YOU KNOW, SENATOR WISE THE
- 14:30OTHERS THEY HAVE EGG ALL OVER
- 14:32THEIR FACE RIGHT NOW BECAUSE
- 14:34THIS COULD HAVE BEEN CAUGHT BUT
- 14:36FOR LIKE EVERYONE IS SAYING THIS
- 14:37WAS PASSED UNDER THE CLOAK OF
- 14:41DARKNESS IN THE MIDDLE OF THE
- 14:43NIGHT THEY WERE DRAFTING THIS
- 14:45THROWING EVERYTHING THEY COULD
- 14:46TO CREATE THIS FRANKENSTEIN
- 14:49MONITOR OF ANTI-FAIRNESS BILLS
- 14:52COMBINED INTO ONE AND OF COURSE
- 14:54THEY MADE MISTAKES BECAUSE THEY
- 14:56DIDN'T READ IT AND THEY DENT'S
- 15:00DEBATE IT AND THE SCHOOLS GET A
- 15:02CHOICE.
- 15:03DO YOU EITHER NOT TEACH ABOUT
- 15:05HUMAN SEXUALITY UNDER 6TH GRADE.
- 15:08OR DO YOU NOT TALK ABOUT LGBTQ
- 15:12ISSUES FROM KINDERGARTEN ALL THE
- 15:14WAY THROUGH SENIOR YEAR OF HIGH
- 15:16SCHOOL.
- 15:17WE DON'T LIKE EITHER OPTION.
- 15:19>> Renee: DO YOU CARE FOR EITHER
- 15:21OPTION?
- 15:21>> I HATE BOTH OPTIONS BUT IT'S
- 15:24GIVEN THE SCHOOLS A CHOICE
- 15:27BECAUSE OF THE ERROR. N>> DOES
- 15:28IT PLEASE YOU THAT SCHOOLS HAVE
- 15:32A CHOICE?
- 15:33>> I AM GLAD THAT AT LEAST ONE
- 15:34OF THOSE THINGS HAS THE
- 15:36OPPORTUNITY TO BE TAUGHT IN
- 15:38KENTUCKY SCHOOLS BECAUSE THEY
- 15:39ARE VITAL.
- 15:40KIDS SHOULD HAVE INSTRUCTION IN
- 15:42HUMAN SEXUALITY AND CONSENT AND
- 15:44PERSONAL SPACE AND OUR BODIES
- 15:47WELL BEFORE SIXTH GRADE AND YOU
- 15:49SHOULD BE ABLE TO TALK ABOUT
- 15:50LGBTQ ISSUES FROM KINDERGARTEN
- 15:52THROUGH 12TH GRADE.
- 15:53>> Mr. NELSON YOU HAVE BEEN ON
- 15:55THE PROGRAM BEFORE AND TALKED
- 15:56ABOUT THIS ISSUE, GIVEN WHERE
- 15:59WE'VE LEFT OFF WE HAVE THE KED
- 16:02REVISED GUIDANCE AND A A.C.L.U.
- 16:05LAWSUIT THAT WE WILL TALK ABOUT.
- 16:06DO YOU THINK THIS WAS WRITTEN
- 16:08SOLIDLY ENOUGH WHERE THE INTENT
- 16:10WAS MADE VERY CLEAR AND THERE
- 16:11SHOULD BE NO CONFUSION?
- 16:12>> I THINK IT WAS.
- 16:16THE INTENT WAS CLEAR AS FAR AS
- 16:18RESTRICTING WHAT CAN BE TAUGHT
- 16:20IN K-5 CLASSROOMS WHAT IS
- 16:22APPROPRIATE TO TEACH GRADES
- 16:256-12.
- 16:25BATHROOM POLICY THAT IS A BILL
- 16:27INTRODUCED GOING BACK TO 2015.
- 16:29IT'S COME UP SEVERAL TIMES SINCE
- 16:31THEN.
- 16:32ANOTHER PORTION OF THE BILL,
- 16:34RESTRICTS PUBERTY BLOCKER AND
- 16:37GENDER TRANSITION SURGERIES THAT
- 16:39IS INTRODUCED THE LAST THREE
- 16:40SESSIONS IN A ROW.
- 16:42THERE IS NO SECRET WITH THIS
- 16:44LEGISLATION.
- 16:45IT'S BEEN IN COMMITTEE.
- 16:47AND ONE REASON WHY THIS HAS BEEN
- 16:49INTRODUCED AND SENATOR WISE
- 16:50POINTED THIS OUT WAS BECAUSE OF
- 16:52THE GUIDANCE THAT THE KENTUCKY
- 16:55DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION ISSUED
- 16:56LAST SUMMER THAT SUGGESTED THAT
- 16:58PUBLIC SCHOOLTEACHERS USE THE
- 17:00PREFERRED GENDER PRONOUNCE OF
- 17:02STUDENTS AND KEEP IT SECRET FROM
- 17:04PARENTS IF THE CHILD WISHES
- 17:06THAT.
- 17:06NOW, THIS LED TO SOME OF THE
- 17:07SCHOOL DISTRICTS THAT HAVE
- 17:10INTERPRETED THAT AS DIRECTION
- 17:12INSTEAD OF GUIDANCE BUT WE KNOW
- 17:13OF SITUATIONS WHERE PUBLIC
- 17:15SCHOOLTEACHERS HAVE LEFT THE
- 17:16PROFESSION.
- 17:17I'M THINKING OF RANDY ADAMS THE
- 17:20PRINCIPAL AT ANDERSON COUNTY
- 17:22HIGH SCHOOL WHO HAD AN ISSUE
- 17:24WITH KEEPING SOMETHING SECRET
- 17:25FROM PARENTS.
- 17:26WHEN HE TALKED TO THE
- 17:27SUPERINTENDENT THERE, IN
- 17:29ANDERSON COUNTY, HE WAS PUT AND
- 17:32SHARED HIS CONCERNS HE WAS PUT
- 17:34ON ADMINISTRATIVE LEAVE.
- 17:36HE DETERMINED THAT HE COULD NOT
- 17:38CONTINUE TO TEACH IN ACCORDANCE
- 17:42WITH HIS CONSCIENCE.
- 17:43HERE IS THE TAKEAWAY, RENEE...
- 17:46OUR SCHOOLS SHOULD NOT BE PLACES
- 17:50WHERE GENDER IDENTITY ACTIVISM
- 17:52AND SEXUAL ORIENTATION IS
- 17:54INTRODUCED AT YOUNG GRADES AND
- 17:56BECAUSE OF THE GUIDANCE IT OPENS
- 17:58THE DOOR TO PRECISELY THAT IN
- 18:00GRADES K-5.
- 18:01THIS IS THE THING THAT PARENTS
- 18:03ARE UPSET ABOUT AND THIS IS WHAT
- 18:04THE LEGISLATURE RESPONDED TO.
- 18:07>> Renee: WE HEARD COMMISSIONER
- 18:08GLASS SAY THIS IS JUST GUIDANCE.
- 18:10IT DOESN'T TEAM TO BE
- 18:12REPERCUSSIONS FOR FOLLOWING IT
- 18:14OR NOT FOLLOWING IT.
- 18:15THIS COMMENT FROM MARIA.
- 18:17AND I WILL GET YOU TO SENATOR
- 18:21WISE.
- 18:21IF WE WOULD NOT ALLOW MINORS TO
- 18:24DECIDE ABOUT ALCOHOL AND TOBACCO
- 18:26WHY WE WITH WE ALLOW THEM TO
- 18:29DECIDE ABOUT GENDER ALTERING
- 18:31SERVICES AND TREATMENTS?
- 18:34>> OH, MY, THIS AGAIN.
- 18:37SO THE REALITY IS THAT FOR A
- 18:39CHILD TO RECEIVE GENDER
- 18:42AFFIRMING HEALTHCARE FIRST THE
- 18:44FIRST GENDER AFFIRMING
- 18:45HEALTHCARE THAT MOST CHILDREN
- 18:47RECEIVE IS TALK THERAPY.
- 18:49IS WORKING WITH A MENTAL HEALTH
- 18:52HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONAL TO TALK
- 18:53ABOUT WHAT THEIR GENDER
- 18:55IDENTITY.
- 18:56TO TALK ABOUT WHO THEY ARE
- 18:57IDENTIFYING AND WHO THEY KNOW
- 18:59WHO THEY ARE.
- 19:00WHEN PUBERTY IS GETTING READY TO
- 19:02HIT THAT IN CONSULTATION WITH A
- 19:06PEDIATRIC ENDOCRINOLOGIST AND OR
- 19:08THE CHILD'S PEDIATRICIAN, AND
- 19:11THE MENTAL HEALTHCARE
- 19:12PROFESSIONALS AND THE CHIDE'S
- 19:14PARENTS WE ARE TALKING ABOUT
- 19:17PARENTS' RIGHTS AS WELL.
- 19:19ONLY THEN ARE PUBERTY BLOCKING
- 19:21DRUGS AT TIMES ADMINISTERED,
- 19:23PRESCRIBED FOR TRANS KIDS AND
- 19:25THEN AT SOME POINT IN TIME YEARS
- 19:27LATER PERHAPS HORMONE
- 19:29REPLACEMENT THERAPY.
- 19:30THIS IS PROVEN SAFE AND
- 19:32EFFECTIVE AND MEDICALLY
- 19:33NECESSARY TREATMENT.
- 19:34AND SUPPORTED BY EVERY SINGLE
- 19:37MAJOR MEDICAL ASSOCIATION IN THE
- 19:38UNITED STATES OF AMERICA WHO
- 19:40HAVE FILED A FRIEND OF THE COURT
- 19:42BRIEF FOR THE A.C.L.U.'S
- 19:45LAWSUIT.
- 19:46WHY DOES SENATOR WISE AND
- 19:47RICHARD NELSON THINK THEY KNOW
- 19:49MORE THAN LITERALLY EVERY MAJOR
- 19:52MEDICAL ASSOCIATION IN THE
- 19:52UNITED STATES OF AMERICA?
- 19:55>> Renee: REBECCA BLANKENSHIP,
- 19:58ARE GENDER OR SEX CHANGE
- 20:00OPERATIONS HAPPENING TO MINORS
- 20:02IN KENTUCKY RIGHT NOW?
- 20:04>> NO, MA'AM, QUITE THE OPPOSITE
- 20:06AND EVERY LGBTQ ORGANIZATION IN
- 20:07THE COMMONWEALTH SAID WE WERE
- 20:08FINE WITH BANNING THOSE SORTS OF
- 20:11SURGERIES FOR MINORS.
- 20:12WE BAN UNICORN ATTACKS IT MAKES
- 20:14NO DIFFERENCE.
- 20:15THE REALITY IS THAT PROPONENTS
- 20:17OF THIS LEGISLATION HAVE TO LIE
- 20:19ABOUT IT HAVE TO LIE ABOUT WHAT
- 20:21TREATMENT KIDS ARE RECEIVING
- 20:22WHAT THIS ENTAILS.
- 20:23BECAUSE THEY DO NOT BELIEVE IN
- 20:25GENDER IDENTITY AT ALL.
- 20:27THEY DON'T THINK THAT SOMEBODY
- 20:28WHO IS SUFFERING FROM GENDER
- 20:31DYSMORPHIA SHOULD RECEIVE
- 20:33APPROPRIATE TREATMENT OR IF THEY
- 20:34DO THEY ARE ADVOCATES OF
- 20:37CONVERSION THERAPY.
- 20:37IT IS A SHAME WE'VE CUTOFF ALL
- 20:39OF THE MEDICAL OPTIONS FAMILIES
- 20:42HAVE TO KEEP THEIR KIDS SAFE AND
- 20:43HEALTHY.
- 20:44KENTUCKY'S FAMILIES DESERVE
- 20:45BETTER AND THIS IS NOT IT.
- 20:48>> Renee: SENATOR WISE, AND THEN
- 20:49YOU Mr. NELSON.
- 20:51>> THANKS.
- 20:52I WANT TO GO BACK.
- 20:53YOU MENTIONED ABOUT THE
- 20:54GUIDANCE.
- 20:54AND THAT IS WHAT THAT IS.
- 20:56IT'S FROM THE KENTUCKY
- 20:58DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION, THEY
- 20:59ARE NOT LEGISLATORS AND
- 21:01ESPECIALLY WITH COMMISSIONER
- 21:02GLASS AND ONCE AGAIN WE ARE
- 21:04GETTING INTO ALMOST MENTAL
- 21:06GYMNASTICS THAT THE COMMISSIONER
- 21:07AND THE GOVERNOR WANT TO PLAY OF
- 21:09SKIRTING THE LAW.
- 21:10I WILL SAY THIS...
- 21:11THEY GOT THE GUIDANCE RIGHT IN
- 21:13MID-APRIL.
- 21:13IT WAS APRIL 17TH IF I'M NOT
- 21:16CORRECT AND THEY WAIT TWO MONTHS
- 21:18LATER THE FIRST WEEK OF JUNE AND
- 21:20PUT OUT WITH MORE ATTORNEYS SAY
- 21:22WHAT ELSE CAN WE START TO FIND.
- 21:24ALL YOU'VE DONE IS CONFUSE
- 21:27SCHOOL DISTRICTS AND
- 21:28SUPERINTENDENTS GETTING READY TO
- 21:29RIGHT NOW WE'RE GETTING THE
- 21:31PORTION OF THE MIDDLE OF SUMMER
- 21:34SOON AND WE ARE HAVING TO GO
- 21:36BACK TO THIS.
- 21:36IF I AM A SCHOOL DISTRICT I'M
- 21:38FOLLOWING THE LAW NOT THE
- 21:39GUIDANCE THAT WAS PUT OUT THERE
- 21:41BY THE KENTUCKY DEPARTMENT OF
- 21:44EDUCATION UNDER COMMISSIONER
- 21:46GLASS.
- 21:46>> Renee: BEFORE WE COME TO YOU
- 21:47Mr. NELSON I DID TALK WITH
- 21:49DAVID WALLS THE DIRECTOR OF THE
- 21:54FOUNDATION FAMILY HERE ARE HIS
- 21:56THOUGHTS ABOUT THE GUIDANCE.
- 21:58>> DAVE WALLS WITH THE FAMILY
- 22:00FOUNDATION THANK YOU FOR YOUR
- 22:00TIME.
- 22:01APPRECIATE IT.
- 22:03>> GOOD TO BE WITH YOU, RENEE.
- 22:04>> Renee: WHAT ARE THE FAMILY
- 22:07FOUNDATION'S OBJECTIONS TO THE
- 22:10KDA GUIDANCE OR SB150.
- 22:12>> WE'RE CONCERNED ABOUT THE
- 22:14ABSURD GUIDANCE THAT THEY
- 22:15PROVIDED IN THIS UPDATED
- 22:18GUIDANCE WHERE THEY ARE
- 22:19ENCOURAGING SCHOOL DISTRICTS TO
- 22:21NOT FOLLOW THE LAW.
- 22:22THE IDEA THAT THE LEGISLATURE IN
- 22:26THESE IMPORTANT PROVISIONS AND
- 22:27PROTECTIONS FOR KIDS, GAVE
- 22:30SCHOOL DISTRICTS A CHOICE AS TO
- 22:33WHAT PORTION OF THE LAW WOULD BE
- 22:36FOLLOWED IS PRETTY RIDICULOUS.
- 22:38AND WE KNOW THIS IS THE CASE
- 22:40BECAUSE THE ORIGINAL GUIDANCE ON
- 22:42APRIL 17TH ON THIS SECTION JUST
- 22:46VERY GAVE A PLAIN READING OF THE
- 22:49PROVISIONS WELL UNDERSTOOD BY
- 22:50ADVOCATES ON BOTH SIDES BY
- 22:52LAWMAKERS, BY THE DEBATE THAT
- 22:53HAPPENED WHEN THIS WAS ON THE
- 22:55FLOOR.
- 22:55SO REALLY IT'S UNFORTUNATE TO
- 22:57SEE A CONTINUED POLITICIZATION
- 23:01OF THE KED PUTTING OUT GUIDANCE
- 23:02AND ENCOURAGING SCHOOL DISTRICTS
- 23:04TO ESSENTIALLY NOT FOLLOW
- 23:07IMPORTANT PROVISIONS OF SB150.
- 23:11>> Renee: WE WILL HAVE HEARD
- 23:13FROM COMMISSIONER GLASS IT WAS
- 23:15UPON A REVIEW BY ATTORNEYS THAT
- 23:18FOUND THAT LANGUAGE TO PRESENT
- 23:20PROBLEMS AND LAWSUITS FOR SCHOOL
- 23:21DISTRICTS.
- 23:23DOES THAT NOT HOLD ANY SPECIAL
- 23:25SWAYION IN YOUR VIEW?
- 23:26DO YOU BELIEVE THAT IS
- 23:30INTENTIONAL DODGING OF THE LAW
- 23:31BY ISSUING THIS GUIDANCE?
- 23:32>> WE ABSOLUTELY DO.
- 23:34AND UNFORTUNATELY, RENEE, AS YOU
- 23:36MAY BE AWARE, THERE'S BEEN A A
- 23:40SERIES POLITICIZED GLANCE PUT
- 23:42OUT BY THE KED UNDER
- 23:44COMMISSIONER GLASS PRIOR TO THE
- 23:46LAST SCHOOL YEAR WHERE THEY PUT
- 23:48OUT THE GUIDANCE ON PRONOUN
- 23:51USAGE THAT TRAMPLED ON PARENTAL
- 23:53RIGHTS.
- 23:53SOME OF THE PROVISIONS IN SB150
- 23:57SPECIFICALLY HAD TO BE WERE
- 23:59INCLUDED BECAUSE OF SOME OF THE
- 24:01PROBLEMS IN THE PREVIOUS
- 24:02GUIDANCE AS IT RELATED TO
- 24:04PARENTAL RIGHTS.
- 24:05SO NOW UNFORTUNATELY, THE KED IS
- 24:08ONCE AGAIN GIVEN INTO THE
- 24:10DEMANDS OF LGBTQ ADVOCATES WHO
- 24:12HAVE BEEN DEMANDING THAT SB150
- 24:16NOT BE FOLLOWED FROM THE MOMENT
- 24:18IT WAS FIRST PASSED.
- 24:20SO I HAVE EVERY REASON TO
- 24:23BELIEVE WHEN YOU PUT OUT
- 24:25GUIDANCE THAT IS A PLAIN READING
- 24:26WHAT THE LAW REQUIRES AND YOU
- 24:27HEAR FROM ADVOCATES, TELLING YOU
- 24:30TO NOT FOLLOW THE LAW AND TO
- 24:32LOOK FOR WAYS AROUND THE LAW AND
- 24:33THEN YOU PUT OUT AN UPDATED
- 24:35GUIDANCE SAYING THAT IT'S PRETTY
- 24:37CLEAR WHAT IS GOING ON HERE.
- 24:39>> Renee: WHAT HAS BEEN THE
- 24:40FAMILY FOUNDATION'S SUPPORT AND
- 24:41THE ARGUMENTS YOU'VE MADE IN
- 24:43SUPPORTIVE OF SB150 ALL ALONG
- 24:46THE FAMILY FOUNDATION HAS BEEN
- 24:48FOR VAL IN SUPPORT OF THIS
- 24:50LEGISLATION.
- 24:51WHY?
- 24:51>> YOU KNOW THERE'S SEVERAL
- 24:53IMPORTANT PARTSES OF BILL AS IT
- 24:55RELATES TO THE GUIDANCE AND THE
- 24:56ISSUE WE HAVE BEEN TALKING ABOUT
- 24:57HERE.
- 24:58THESE ARE JUST VERY
- 25:00STRAIGHTFORWARD PROVISIONS.
- 25:01BROADLY SUPPORTED THAT SIMPLY
- 25:03SAY THAT WE SHOULDN'T TEACH
- 25:05CHILDREN IN K-5 HUMAN SEXUALITY
- 25:09OR A SEX EDUCATION TOPICS NOT
- 25:11APPROPRIATE AT ALL.
- 25:12AND IF THEY ARE TAUGHT IN GRADE
- 25:14SIX AND ABOVE PARENTS NEED THE
- 25:16ABILITY TO REVIEW AND OPT-IN.
- 25:18AND THEN ALSO AN IMPORTANT
- 25:20PROTECTION THAT SAYS WE ARE THAT
- 25:22IN FAVOR OF INDOCTRINATING OUR
- 25:25CHILDREN ON RADICAL IDEOLOGY AT
- 25:27ANY GRADE LEVEL.
- 25:29THESE ARE IMPORTANT PROTECTIONS.
- 25:30WE KNOW UNFORTUNATELY SOME OF
- 25:32THE TOPICS HAVE BEEN TAUGHT IN
- 25:35AGE INAPPROPRIATE WAYS IN
- 25:36SCHOOLS.
- 25:37THESE PROVISIONS ARE AGE
- 25:40APPROPRIATE PROTECTIONS FOR KIDS
- 25:43THAT EMPOWER PARENTS.
- 25:45SO IT'S VERY IMPORTANT FROM OUR
- 25:47PERSPECTIVE TO INSURE THIS LAW
- 25:48IS FOLLOWED AND THAT SCHOOLS ARE
- 25:50ENCOURAGED TO FOLLOW THE LAW AND
- 25:52WHY WE HAVE BEEN ENCOURAGING OUR
- 25:56ADVOCATES TO CONTACT
- 25:57COMMISSIONER GLASS AND CONTACT
- 25:58THE GOVERNOR, CONTACT THE KED TO
- 26:01ENCOURAGE THEM TO DROP THIS
- 26:03GUIDANCE AND WE'VE HAD 20,000
- 26:05MESSAGES SENT.
- 26:05THIS ISSUE IS RESONATING WITH
- 26:07PEOPLE ACROSS KENTUCKY TO SEE
- 26:09THE LAW FOLLOWED.
- 26:11>> Renee: THERE ARE SOME
- 26:12CONCERNS ABOUT THE LANGUAGE WHEN
- 26:13IT COMES TO DISCUSSION OF
- 26:16SEXUALLY TRANSMITTED DISEASES
- 26:17AND EVEN AS FAR AS HELPING YOUNG
- 26:19GIRLS UNDERSTAND THE BIOLOGICAL
- 26:21CHANGES THAT ARE HAPPENING TO
- 26:22THEIR BODY WHEN IT COMES TO
- 26:26MENSTRUATION.
- 26:26DO YOU BELIEVE THAT IS TOO FAR?
- 26:28IS THAT IN LINE WITH WHAT THE
- 26:30FAMILY FOUNDATION WOULD SUPPORT?
- 26:32>> SO IF YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT
- 26:35HUMAN SEXUALITY, SOMETIMES SEX
- 26:38EDUCATION TOPICS AGAIN, SB150,
- 26:41JUST SAYS THAT THOSE TOPICS ARE
- 26:44NOT APPROPRIATE IN ELEMENTARY
- 26:47SCHOOL.
- 26:49LEAVE THOSE DECISIONS UP TO
- 26:50SCHOOL DISTRICTS IN GRADES 6-12
- 26:51BUT REQUIRES THAT SCHOOL
- 26:54DISTRICTS GET AN AFFIRMATIVE
- 26:55OPT-IN FROM PARENTS.
- 26:56SO I THINK THAT IS A
- 27:00WELL-BALANCED FRAMEWORK FOR
- 27:02SCHOOL DISTRICTS IN KENTUCKY.
- 27:04AND SO I THINK IT WOULD ALLOW
- 27:06LOCAL SCHOOL DISTRICTS TO MAKE
- 27:08DECISIONS ABOUT WHAT THEY THINK
- 27:10SHOULD BE TAUGHT.
- 27:11BUT INSURE THAT PARENTS ARE
- 27:13INFORMED AND HAVE THE
- 27:14OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE A SAY.
- 27:16>> Renee: DAVID WALLS THANK YOU
- 27:17FROM THE FAMILY FOUNDATION.
- 27:19WE APPRECIATE A FEW MOMENTS OF
- 27:20YOUR TIME.
- 27:21>> RENEE APPRECIATE THE
- 27:22OPPORTUNITY AS ALWAYS TO TALK
- 27:23WITH YOU.
- 27:24>> Renee: Mr. HARTMAN, I WANT
- 27:26TO ASK YOU BECAUSE IT SEEMED
- 27:27THAT PERHAPS Mr. WALLS
- 27:30INTIMATED THERE WERE ATTORNEYS
- 27:31PART OF THE FAIRNESS CAMPAIGN OR
- 27:34BAN CONVERSION THERAPY WHO WERE
- 27:35COLLUDING WITH THE KENTUCKY
- 27:37DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION
- 27:38ATTORNEYS TO FIND OBJECTIONABLE
- 27:40LANGUAGE TO ISSUE THIS GUIDANCE.
- 27:42CAN YOU SET THE RECORD STRAIGHT
- 27:44THERE?
- 27:44>> I'VE NEVER SPOKEN WITH
- 27:47COMMISSIONER GLASS NO ONE ON OUR
- 27:48BOARD HAS TO MY KNOWLEDGE I
- 27:50DON'T KNOW THAT I'VE BEEN IN THE
- 27:52SAME ROOM.
- 27:53YOU DON'T NEED AN ATTORNEY TO
- 27:54LOOK AT THE VERBIAGE OF THE LAW
- 27:57AND SEE THAT IS STATES EITHER
- 27:59OR.
- 28:00>> Renee: Mr. NELSON?
- 28:01>> THERE ARE SEVERAL COURT
- 28:03RULINGS THAT ADDRESS THIS TOPIC.
- 28:05THERE'S AT LEAST FIVE IN
- 28:07KENTUCKY.
- 28:08I'M LOOKING AT COMMONWEALTH V
- 28:11BAR THOL MIEUX.
- 28:12IT SAID WHEN NECESSARY TO
- 28:15EFFECTIVE OBVIOUS INTENTIONS OF
- 28:16THE LEGISLATURE CONSTRUCTION
- 28:20WORDS CAN BE CON TRUED AS CON
- 28:24VERSIVE.
- 28:25AND AND IN THE STATUTE SHOULD BE
- 28:31WHEN NECESSARY TO EFFECTIVE
- 28:35OBVIOUS LEGISLATIVE INTENT.
- 28:36I THINK THAT IF THE KED
- 28:39ATTORNEYS DID THAT THEY WOULD
- 28:40HAVE NOT REVISED THEIR GUIDANCE
- 28:43THEY WOULD HAVE LEFT THE
- 28:44ORIGINAL GUIDANCE THEY LEFT GAVE
- 28:49OUT ON APRIL 17TH IN PLACE.
- 28:52IF WOULD HAVE BEEN HELPFUL IF
- 28:54THEY STAYED WITH THE ORIGINAL
- 28:56GUIDANCE AND LET THE LOCAL
- 28:58SCHOOL BOARD ATTORNEYS TO FIGURE
- 29:00IT OUT.
- 29:01IT'S NOT HELPING ANYBODY.
- 29:02IT WAS VERY CLEAR THAT THE
- 29:04LEGISLATURE IN A BIPARTISAN
- 29:05FASHION IN THE HOUSE AND SENATE,
- 29:07PASSED THIS BILL INTO LAW.
- 29:09>> BUT THAT IS NOT WITH SUPER
- 29:12MAJORITIES.
- 29:12>> IT WAS EVENTUALLY, WHEN
- 29:14GOVERNOR BESHEAR VETOED IT WAS
- 29:18OVERRYDEN.
- 29:20PARENTS WERE DEEPLY CONCERNED
- 29:22WHAT WAS HAPPENING IN PUBLIC
- 29:24SCHOOLS.
- 29:25>> AGE INAPPROPRIATE CURRICULUM,
- 29:27BATHROOM POLICIES CONFUSING THAT
- 29:29SHOULD HAVE NO PART OF THE
- 29:31KENTUCKY DEPARTMENT OF
- 29:32EDUCATION'S MISSION.
- 29:35WE ARE LAGGING BEHIND IN
- 29:38EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT, THE
- 29:40FOUNDATION ISSUED ITS REPORT
- 29:43RECENTLY, WHAT 69% OF FOURTH
- 29:45GRADERS ARE NOT READING TO GRADE
- 29:46LEVEL.
- 29:47I BELIEVE IT'S 79% OF 8 GRADERS
- 29:50ARE NOT AT GRADE LEVEL IN MATH.
- 29:53WE NEED TO FOCUS ON PACICSISM
- 29:56THEY ARE SEEKING JUSTIFICATION
- 29:58BECAUSE THEY HAVE BEEN CALLED
- 30:00OUT ON A GRAMMATICAL ERROR.
- 30:03>> HOW IS THIS HATE?
- 30:05>> SENATOR WISE I WANT TO COME
- 30:07TO YOU THERE ARE MANY WHO SAY
- 30:09THAT THESE TYPES OF BILLS THAT
- 30:11HAVE CIRCULATED THROUGH MANY
- 30:13GENERAL ASSEMBLIES HAVE COME
- 30:15FROM GROUPS CONSERVATIVE GROUPS
- 30:17LIKE ALEC THEY ARE FILL IN THE
- 30:20BLANK PIECES OF LEGISLATION THAT
- 30:21ARE NOT DRIVEN PERHAPS BY
- 30:25CONSTITUENT CONCERN.
- 30:26ANSWER THAT FOR US, IF YOU WILL.
- 30:29>> WHEN I FIRST DRAFTED THE
- 30:36SENATE BILL I HAD THE WORK OF
- 30:38MYSELF AND OUR SENATE EDUCATION
- 30:40POLICY ADVISER AND THE BILL
- 30:42DRAFTER.
- 30:42WE PASSED SENATE BILL 150 AND IT
- 30:45BECAME A COPY THAT OTHER STATES
- 30:47ARE LOOKING AT WHAT WE DID.
- 30:49WE MADE AN OMNIBUS BILL.
- 30:52IT'S FRAMED AS THE MOST HATEFUL
- 30:54BILL, BUT IT ALSO WAS THE
- 30:56STRONGEST BILL FOR
- 30:58COMMUNICATION, IT WAS THE BILL
- 30:59TO PROTECT OUR CHILDREN AND IT
- 31:00WAS A BILL TO ULTIMATELY SHOW
- 31:03WHERE WE STAND IN TERMS OF
- 31:04PARENTAL RIGHTS IN THE
- 31:05COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY.
- 31:06SO I DID NOT PERSONALLY WORK
- 31:08WITH ANY OF THE ORGANIZATIONS
- 31:09THAT YOU MENTIONED JUST THEN.
- 31:12HOUSE COMMITTEE SUBONE WAS PUT
- 31:14FORTH THOSE WERE LEGISLATORS
- 31:16THAT HAD THEIR OWN BILL.
- 31:17I WILL NOT COMMENT ON BEHALF OF
- 31:19THEM BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT ON THE
- 31:20SHOW.
- 31:21AND WHEN THAT WAS PUT FORTH I
- 31:23DON'T KNOW WHO THEY MAY HAVE
- 31:24WORKED WITH.
- 31:25A LOT OF THOSE BILLS AND WE'VE
- 31:27SAID TONIGHT, BATHROOM BILL,
- 31:30EMBREE WHO WORKED ON THAT YEARS
- 31:32AGO IN THE LEGISLATIVE CHAMBERS.
- 31:34WESLEY PUT HIS BILL IN NOVEMBER
- 31:36THAT DEALT WITH BATHROOM PRIVACY
- 31:39AND REPRESENTATIVE DENGERS AND
- 31:42REPRESENTATIVE BAKER'S WAS
- 31:44INTRODUCED IN JANUARY.
- 31:45THESE BILLS WERE OUT FOR PEOPLE
- 31:47TO SEE AND FOLLOW.
- 31:48I DID NOT HAVE LOBBYISTS
- 31:50REPRESENTING THE LGBTQ COME AND
- 31:52TALK TO ME ABOUT SENATE BILL 150
- 31:56IN ITS INITIAL STAGE.
- 31:57I HAVE AN OPEN DOOR POLICY.
- 32:00I'VE HAD CONSTITUENTS AND OTHER
- 32:02ACTIVISTS THEY CAME TO MY
- 32:03OFFICE.
- 32:03BUT THERE WAS NOT A SINGLE
- 32:05LOBBYIST IN TERMS OF THOSE
- 32:07ISSUES IN SENATE BILL 150 THAT
- 32:10EVER CAME TO ME TO TALK ABOUT
- 32:12THE LEGISLATIVE PROCESS.
- 32:14>> Renee: DID YOU OR ANYONE
- 32:15ALIGN WITH YOUR GROUP TRY TO
- 32:19TALK TO SENATOR WISE.
- 32:21>> OUR COMMUNICATIONS DIRECTOR
- 32:24WAS IN COMMUNICATION WITH HIM.
- 32:26HE IS LYING WHEN HE SAYS WE DID
- 32:29NOT COME TO HIM TO TALK ABOUT
- 32:30THAT BILL.
- 32:31I WOULD LIKE TO ADDRESS
- 32:32SOMETHING Mr. NELSON SAID WHEN
- 32:35ASKED IN WHAT WAY IS THIS BILL
- 32:37HATEFUL?
- 32:37THE REALITY IS THIS GROUPS ARE
- 32:40MAKING EFFORTS TO CONFLATE LGBTQ
- 32:42IDENTITY WITH SEXUALLY EXPLICIT
- 32:44CONTENT.
- 32:45THAT IS UNTRUE.
- 32:46I THINK THAT EVERYBODY ON THIS
- 32:48PANEL AGREES THAT SEXUALLY
- 32:51EXPLICIT CONSENT SHOULD NOT BE
- 32:52IN OUR SCHOOLS WHETHER IT'S GAY,
- 32:55STRAIGHT, LESBIAN.
- 33:00THE REALITY IS I SUBMITTED
- 33:01WRITTEN TESTIMONY ON BEHALF OF
- 33:05BAN CONVERSION THERAPY KENTUCKY,
- 33:07BECAUSE I THOUGHT IT WAS FAIR AS
- 33:09A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER AND PARENT
- 33:10THAT WE DO SOMETHING IDENTITY
- 33:13AND VIEWPOINT NEUTRAL TO REMOVE
- 33:20SEXUALLY EXPLICIT TERRIBLES IN
- 33:22OUR SCHOOL.
- 33:23THERE IS NO TO SUGGEST THAT OUR
- 33:25LIVES AND EXISTENCE DISCUSSION
- 33:26OF WHICH IS INAPPROPRIATE.
- 33:29JUST TO TRY TO KNOCKOUT SEXUAL
- 33:32CONTENTED.
- 33:33AND BY THE WAY I POINT OUT ANY
- 33:36BILL PROVISION IS LIKELY
- 33:38UNCONSTITUTIONAL THANKS TO
- 33:40EXISTING SUPREME COURT CASE LAW.
- 33:42BROCK KET VERSUS SPOKE AN OF
- 33:461985.
- 33:47WHEN GROUPS LIKE THE
- 33:49COMMONWEALTH POLICY CENTER AND
- 33:50THE FAMILY FOUNDATION TELL
- 33:52LEGISLATORS THEY CAN WRITE BILLS
- 33:54THIS WAY THEY ARE IGNORING
- 33:56FEDERAL EXISTING LAW.
- 33:57THEY HAVE BEEN CAUGHT LYING
- 33:59BEFORE AND THIS TIME IT HAS THE
- 34:02EFFECT OF DISCREDITED OUR
- 34:03ASSEMBLY BY FORCING THEM INTO A
- 34:05CONSTITUTIONAL FIGHT THAT THEY
- 34:06WILL NOT WIN.
- 34:07>> Renee: THIS COMMENT FROM
- 34:08LOUISVILLE, MY SON COMMITTED
- 34:10SUICIDE DIED MY SUICIDE SICK
- 34:12MONTHS AGO.
- 34:13BEFORE WE GOT HOME FROM THE
- 34:16FUNERAL WE WERE RECEIVING HATE
- 34:19MAIL OVER HIS STATUS OF TRANS.
- 34:24IT'S TO DEMONIZE THE GROUP.
- 34:27TALKING ABOUT RIGHTS AND
- 34:29POLITICIZATION OF AN ISSUE IS
- 34:31IRONIC.
- 34:32SENATOR MAX WISE A RESPONSE TO
- 34:33THAT COMMENT FROM A LOUISVILLE
- 34:34VIEWER AND ANY OTHER COMMENTS
- 34:36YOU CARE TO MAKE?
- 34:38>> WELL, RENEE, I WILL SAY
- 34:41ANYTIME ANY YOUTH COMMITS
- 34:43SUICIDE WE'RE SEEING THE RISE IN
- 34:45SUICIDE AND THAT HAS BEEN OVER
- 34:46THE PAST FEW YEARS.
- 34:47WE WORKED ON SCHOOL SAFETY BILL
- 34:50AND LOOKED AT THE RISE OF
- 34:52SUICIDE OVER THE LAST FIVE, 10,
- 34:53PLUS YEARS IT IS A CONCERN AND
- 34:55I'M LOOKING FORWARD TO FOLKS ON
- 34:57SCHOOL SAFETY FUNDING THAT CAN
- 34:58LOOK AT ISSUES SUCH AS THIS.
- 35:01AND WE HAVE A RISE OF SOCIAL
- 35:02MEDIA BULLYING AND SOCIETAL
- 35:04PROBLEMS THAT RELATE TO PHYSICAL
- 35:06AND SITUATIONS INVOLVING THE
- 35:07HOME.
- 35:08I THINK WE CAN'T PUT ONE ISSUE
- 35:11AND SAY THIS IS THE REASON.
- 35:12THERE ARE SO MANY THINGS THAT
- 35:13ARE OUT THERE.
- 35:14MY HEARTBREAKS FROM ANY FAMILY
- 35:17LOSES A CHILD FROM SUICIDE OR
- 35:19DEATH.
- 35:20>> THE REALITY IS THEY JUST
- 35:22DON'T CARE AND SENATOR WISE
- 35:26STOPPED CARING WHEN HE RAN FOR
- 35:29LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR.
- 35:30THEY GOT A MISERABLE THIRD PLACE
- 35:32IN THE RACE AND NOW THE WORST
- 35:35ANTI-TRANS LAW IN THE ENTIRE
- 35:36COUNTRY THAT IS INEVITABLY GOING
- 35:38TO LEAD TO HIGHER DEPRESSION AND
- 35:40SUICIDE RATES AMONGST OUR
- 35:41TRANSGENDER KIDS IN KENTUCKY AND
- 35:43ONCE AGAIN THEY COULD NOT
- 35:46CARELESS.
- 35:47>> Renee: Mr. NELSON?
- 35:49>> THANK YOU.
- 35:49I DON'T THINK IT'S HELPFUL TO
- 35:53IMPUTE MOTIVES.
- 35:54THERE ARE OTHER --
- 35:56THERE ARE A LOT OF OTHERS I WILL
- 35:58FINISH IF YOU LET ME.
- 35:59WE ARE NOT CONSIDERING PARENTAL
- 36:01RIGHTS.
- 36:03PARENTS.
- 36:03>> I KNOW YOU'RE NOT.
- 36:04>> PARENTS ARE THE RIGHT TO KNOW
- 36:06WHAT IS BEING TAUGHT IN THEIR
- 36:07SCHOOLS THIS IS PART OF SENATE
- 36:09BILL 150 DOES IT REQUIRES THEY
- 36:11ARE FULLY INFORMED AND THAT THE
- 36:14CHILD CAN OPT-OUT.
- 36:16IF THEY OBJECT TO THAT.
- 36:17WE ARE ALSO MISSING THE BIG
- 36:19POINT OF AGE APPROPRIATENESS.
- 36:21WHAT IS APPROPRIATE TO TEACH THE
- 36:24DIFFERENT AGES?
- 36:25I THINK RENEE, ON THE LAST
- 36:27PROGRAM WE DID WE TALKED ABOUT A
- 36:29CONTROVERSIAL BOOK THAT WAS IN
- 36:30ONE OF THE LOUISVILLE SCHOOLS.
- 36:32AND YOU ASKED ME TO READ A
- 36:35DESCRIPTION AND I WAS
- 36:36EMBARRASSED TO READ IT.
- 36:37IT WAS PORNOGRAPHIC.
- 36:39IT WAS OBSCENE.
- 36:40PARENTS OBJECTED TO IT BUT THE
- 36:42SCHOOL BOARD ALLOWED IT TO
- 36:44CONTINUE.
- 36:44I DO HAVE AN EXAMPLE OF
- 36:46SOMETHING THAT IS AGE
- 36:47APPROPRIATE THAT I CAN SHARE ON
- 36:48THE PROGRAM AND THIS WAS FROM A
- 36:50LINK ON THE KED'S GUIDANCE LAST
- 36:53SUMMER AND THIS IS THE GENDER
- 36:55BREAD PERSON.
- 36:56AND I'M HAPPY TO SHOW IT.
- 36:58AND YOU CAN SEE WHAT IS SUPPOSED
- 37:00TO BE THE GINGERBREAD MAN.
- 37:03WHERE THE BRAIN'S IDENTITY IT
- 37:06TEACHES ATTRACTION OF THE HEART
- 37:07AND THEN SEX.
- 37:08THIS IS SOMETHING THAT IS NOT
- 37:09GEARED TOWARDS HIGH SCHOOLERS OR
- 37:12MIDDLE SCHOOLERS THIS IS
- 37:14KINDERGARTEN AND ELEMENTARY
- 37:15SCHOOL STUDENTS AND THIS IS THE
- 37:16KIND OF THING THAT PARENTS
- 37:18OBJECT TO.
- 37:18THEY ARE SAYING LOOK MY
- 37:20FIVE-YEAR-OLD AND SIX-YEAR-OLD
- 37:21AND SEVEN-YEAR-OLD THEY DON'T
- 37:23NEED THAT TAUGHT.
- 37:24PLEASE TEACH THEM FONNICS AND
- 37:27HOW TO WRITE.
- 37:28HOW TO READ THAT KIND OF THING
- 37:30THEY DO NOT WANT THIS TAUGHT.
- 37:32NOR DO THEY WANT GENDER IDEOLOGY
- 37:34OR SEXUAL OTH ORIENTATION PROMON
- 37:37IN THE SCHOOLS AND THAT IS WHAT
- 37:39SENATE BILL ADDRESSES.
- 37:40>> Renee: SENATOR WISE?
- 37:41>> I AM GOING BACK TO THE
- 37:44COMMENT THAT Mr. HARTMAN MADE
- 37:45ABOUT ME WAS RUNNING WITH KELLY
- 37:47CRAFT THAT IS ABSURD.
- 37:49ONCE AGAIN, I WORKED WITH THE
- 37:51BILL DRAFTERS WAY BEFORE THE
- 37:53ANNOUNCEMENT OF ME COMING OUT AS
- 37:55LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR.
- 37:55I WILL SAY THIS...
- 37:57ALL THE CANDIDATES OUT THERE ARE
- 37:58TALKING ABOUT THESE ISSUES ON
- 38:01THE REPUBLICAN TICKET.
- 38:03BECAUSE THAT IS WHAT THE
- 38:06CONSTITUENTS ARE TALKING ABOUT,
- 38:08CHRIS.
- 38:08THAT ARE THE ISSUES.
- 38:14ALLOWING CURRICULUM TRANSPARENCY
- 38:16AND TO NOT HAVE KINDERGARTEN-5
- 38:19GRADERS TALKING ABOUT STD,
- 38:22SEXUAL OTHER JENTATION.
- 38:24THESE THINGS ARE RIGHT NOW ON
- 38:25THE WAVE OF OUR COUNTRY.
- 38:27AND PEOPLE ARE TALKING ABOUT IT.
- 38:28AND I THINK IT IS AN ISSUE I
- 38:31SUPPORT DANIEL CAMERON RUNNING
- 38:31IN NOVEMBER WHO I HOPE IS GOING
- 38:33TO CONTINUE TO TAKE ON THE
- 38:34CHARGE OF THESE ISSUES THAT WE
- 38:36BROUGHT OUT AS WELL AS THE OTHER
- 38:37CANDIDATES ON THE CAMPAIGN
- 38:38TRAIL.
- 38:39>> .
- 38:39>> MAX WHAT DID YOUR RUNNING
- 38:42MATE MEAN UNDER A CRAFT
- 38:43ADMINISTRATION THERE WILL BE NO
- 38:47TRENDS IN KENTUCKY SCHOOLS.
- 38:48>> THAT WAS HER COMMENT NOT
- 38:50MINE.
- 38:51IT WAS AN OVERSTATEMENT.
- 38:54>> WHACHES THE CRAFT WISE PLAN
- 38:56TO ACHIEVE THAT AIM?
- 38:57>> SENATE BILL 150 WAS LOOKING
- 39:02AT TRAN GENDER CURRICULUM AND AS
- 39:05IT RELATES TO PUBLIC SCHOOLS AND
- 39:07THESE ARE THE CONVERSATIONS IN
- 39:09TERMS OF PARENTAL RIGHTS AND
- 39:11GETTING BACK TO TEACHING.
- 39:13READING, WRITING AND ARITHMETIC
- 39:16NOT POLICIES BEING PUSHED DOWN
- 39:18CERTAIN PEOPLE THEY ARE NOT FOR
- 39:20IT.
- 39:20LOOK AT OUR COUNTRY.
- 39:21PEOPLE WHO ARE JUST TRYING TO GO
- 39:23ABOUT THEIR BUSINESS GOING TO A
- 39:25MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL GAME THEY
- 39:28HAVE TO --
- 39:29LA DODGERS THERE ARE THINGS
- 39:31HAPPENING WITH OUR GENERAL
- 39:33SOCIETY THAT THE PUBLIC SAYS
- 39:34THAT IS NOT US.
- 39:35AND THAT IS GOING TO BE A
- 39:36TALKING POINT THAT WILL CONTINUE
- 39:37TO BE THERE.
- 39:38>> MAX COSIGNED THE STATEMENTS
- 39:40AS A PARTY TO THAT TICKET.
- 39:42HE REFUSED TO REFUTE THAT TYPE
- 39:46OF ERADICATION TALK THERE WILL
- 39:48BE NO TRANSGENDER KIDS IN A
- 39:51CRAFT-WISE ADMINISTRATION.
- 39:51HOW ARE THEY GOING TO DO THIS?
- 39:53THAT IS THE TYPE OF THINGS THAT
- 39:55TRANS KIDS ARE HEARING AND THE
- 39:57DEPRESSION IS INCREASING AND
- 39:58SELF HARM AND SUICIDAL IDEATION
- 40:02INCREASES WHEN THE POWERFUL
- 40:03PEOPLE IN THE STATE SAY THINGS
- 40:05YOU HAVE NO PLACE IN KENTUCKY
- 40:07SCHOOLS AND WE WILL MAKE CERTAIN
- 40:08IS YOU ARE NOT THERE.
- 40:11>> Renee: SENATOR MAX WISE NOT
- 40:12ALL OF THOSE WHO IDENTIFY AS
- 40:14REPUBLICAN FEEL AS PERHAPS YOU
- 40:16AND YOUR FORMER RUNNING MATE
- 40:18FELT.
- 40:18WE DO KNOW THAT FORMER STATE
- 40:22REPRESENTATIVE BOB WHO WAS AS
- 40:24LOBBYIST FOR THE FAIRNESS
- 40:26CAMPAIGN GAVE A IMPASSIONED PLEA
- 40:29NOT TO PASS SENATE BILL 150 AND
- 40:32A FORMER REPRESENTATIVE JERRY
- 40:33MILLER A CHAIRMAN OF THE HOUSE
- 40:35STATE GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE ALSO
- 40:36TALKED ABOUT HIS GRANDCHILD
- 40:39IDENTIFYING AS TRANSGENDER.
- 40:41AND COMPELLING THE GENERAL
- 40:42ASSEMBLY TO NOT PROCEED WITH
- 40:45SENATE BILL 150.
- 40:46NOT ALL REPUBLICANS PERHAPS FEEL
- 40:49THE WAY SOME WHO WERE RUNNING
- 40:51FOR THE GOVERNOR'S MANSION FEEL.
- 40:53IS THAT A FAIR ASSESSMENT?
- 40:54>> IF TERMS OF THE ONES THAT
- 40:57BROUGHT TO THE TABLE TO TESTIFY
- 40:58THEY HAD THEIR VIEWS.
- 41:00AND 76 REPRESENTATIVES VOTED FOR
- 41:03THAT THERE WAS BIPARTISANSHIP
- 41:05AND A DEMOCRAT CROSSED THE
- 41:06AISLE.
- 41:06YOU HAD 29 STATE SENATORS 105,
- 41:11VOTED FOR IT AND ALSO OVERRODE
- 41:14THE GOVERNOR'S VETO.
- 41:15IT SHOWS IN TERMS OF A SUPER
- 41:18MAJORITY THAT LISTENS TO
- 41:19CONSTITUENTS AND WORK FOR THEIR
- 41:20DISTRICTS THEY LISTENED AND
- 41:22VOTED THAT WAY.
- 41:26>> Renee: REBECCA BLANKENSHIP
- 41:27WHEN YOU HEAR HIGH NUMBER
- 41:29BIPARTISAN AGREEMENT FOR THE
- 41:30MEASURES THAT IS WHERE KENTUCKY
- 41:32IS TRENDING.
- 41:33THE POSITIONS THAT YOU ARE
- 41:37ESPOUSING OUT OF STEP WITH THE
- 41:38MAJORITY OF KENTUCKIANS.
- 41:40>> THE OPPOSITE.
- 41:40THE POLLS WE'VE SEEN ON THE
- 41:42ISSUES THAT SURVEY REGULAR
- 41:44KENTUCKY VOTERS MOST DO NOT BUY
- 41:46INTO THE HATEFUL RHETORIC AND
- 41:48ATTITUDES.
- 41:50THE FACT THAT THE SUPER
- 41:52MAJORITIES CAN STRONG ARM
- 41:53CAUCUSES BY HOLDING BILLS
- 41:55HOSTAGE AND THREATENING NOT TO
- 41:56FUND PROJECTS, THE FACT THAT
- 41:59PRODUCES THE OVERWHELMING VOTES
- 42:00I DON'T THINK THAT IS
- 42:01SURPRISING.
- 42:02WHAT I THINK IS SURPRISING WE
- 42:04END UP WITH BILLS AS POORLY
- 42:07WRITTEN LIKE ONES LIKE THIS.
- 42:08THAT HAVE THE EFFECT OF
- 42:11TARGETING EVERYBODY IN KENTUCKY
- 42:13NOT JUST LGBTQ PEOPLE THAT THE
- 42:15LEGISLATURE IS AFTER.
- 42:16GUESS WHAT?
- 42:17IF WE PROHIBIT ALL DISCUSSION OF
- 42:20SEXUAL ORIENTATION IT IS NOT
- 42:21JUST GAY PEOPLE THAT GET HIT BY
- 42:24THAT.
- 42:25WE ARE SEE BANS ON CHURCH GROUPS
- 42:27COMING IN TO TALK ABOUT SEX AND
- 42:29MARRIAGE WITH STUDENT GROUPS.
- 42:31WE'RE GOING TO SEE BANS OF THE
- 42:32BIBLE.
- 42:33EVERY REPUBLICAN IN KENTUCKY
- 42:35BETTER PRAY THIS BILL IS NOT
- 42:37IMPLEMENTED THEY FOLLOW THE
- 42:38KED'S GUIDANCE IN EVERY SCHOOL
- 42:39DISTRICT IN THIS STATE BECAUSE
- 42:41REALITY IS THESE FOLKS HAVE
- 42:43BANNED TALKING ABOUT NORMAL
- 42:45THINGS IN THE QUEST TO SUPPRESS
- 42:47LGBTQ RIGHTS.
- 42:48>> Renee: I WANT TO GET THAT
- 42:50PERSPECTIVE FROM SENATOR WISE.
- 42:52SHE MENTIONED WHERE THIS
- 42:54INTERPRETATION COULD GO WHEN IT
- 42:55COMES TO PRO LIVE GROUPS AND
- 42:58GROUPS CURRY FAVOR WITH THE
- 42:59REPUBLICAN PARTY THAT IS NOT THE
- 43:01INTENT OF SENATE BILL 150, IS
- 43:02IT?
- 43:03>> NO, NOT AT ALL.
- 43:04WE LAID OUT WHAT WAS STATED IN
- 43:08SENATE BILL 150.
- 43:09I GO BACK AGAIN PEOPLE WANT TO
- 43:11GET BACK TO EDUCATION.
- 43:12THEY WANT TO KEEP ISSUES LIKE
- 43:14THIS OUT OF ESPECIALLY K-5 AND
- 43:176-12 TALKING ABOUT THIS AND GIVE
- 43:19THE PARENTS THE RIGHT TO SEND
- 43:21THEIR CHILDREN TO SCHOOL AND GET
- 43:23BACK TO EDUCATION.
- 43:24RICHARD CITED NUMBERS IN TERMS
- 43:26WHERE WE ARE WITH TESTING.
- 43:28GET BACK TO THE BASICS.
- 43:30AND I WILL SAY THIS IN TERMS OF
- 43:32WHERE WE ARE AND WHERE WE'RE
- 43:34GOING I CAN'T SAY WHAT THE NEXT
- 43:36SESSION IS GOING TO BRING.
- 43:39IN IT WAS JUST CHANGING THIS
- 43:41THAT IS AN EASY FIX WE DO THAT
- 43:43ALL THE TIME.
- 43:43IN MATERIALS OF OTHER THINGS
- 43:45THAT MAY BE CREEPING IN AND
- 43:46LOOKING AT WE'LL SEE WHAT THE
- 43:48SUPER MAJORITY HAS TO DEAL WITH
- 43:50COME JANUARY.
- 43:51>> Renee: THAT IS A GOOD POINT.
- 43:53SOME SOME WONDERED WHAT IS NEXT
- 43:54AND HOW MUCH FURTHER WILL THE
- 43:56KENTUCKY GENERAL ASSEMBLY GO
- 43:57WHEN IT COMES TO THESE ISSUES.
- 43:59ARE THERE MEASURES THAT WERE
- 44:01PART OF 470, HOUSE BILL 470 THAT
- 44:04WERE NOT INCLUDED IN 150 THAT
- 44:07YOU SEE HAVING LEVERAGE AND SOME
- 44:10GRAVITY FOR NEXT YEAR'S SESSION?
- 44:12ARE THOSE DISCUSSIONS ALREADY
- 44:14UNDERWAY TO TAKE THIS FURTHER
- 44:15THAN IT IS NOW?
- 44:16>> I THINK RIGHT NOW WHAT YOU'RE
- 44:18SEEING IS WE HAVE DONE A GOOD
- 44:20JOB WITH OUR HOUSE AND SENATE
- 44:22MAJORITY LEADERS TO LOOK AT THE
- 44:24INTERIM AND FOCUS ON POLICY
- 44:26ISSUES.
- 44:26THERE ARE A LOT OF THINGS WE'RE
- 44:28FACING AS KENTUCKIANS.
- 44:30ISSUES THAT DEAL WITH THE
- 44:31FLOODING AND TORNADOES IN TERMS
- 44:33OF REIMBURSEMENT AND GETTING US
- 44:36BACK WITH BROADBAND TO MAKE SURE
- 44:38THAT EVERY AREA OF KENTUCKY HAS
- 44:39THAT.
- 44:40I TALKED ABOUT SCHOOL SAFETY.
- 44:41I CAN'T SAY SPECIFICALLY IF 470
- 44:43OR THE OTHER BILLS WHAT IS GOING
- 44:45TO COME ABOUT.
- 44:47EVERY LEGISLATOR HAD THE
- 44:49PRIORITY TO FILE WHATEVER
- 44:51LEGISLATION THEY THINK IS A
- 44:52PRIORITY FOR THEM AND THEIR
- 44:53DISTRICTS.
- 44:54I CANNOT SPEAK ON BEHALF OF
- 44:55OTHER REPRESENTATIVES OR
- 44:56SENATORS BUT WE HAVE A HOST OF
- 44:58ISSUES WE ARE GOING TO CONTINUE
- 44:59TO FOCUS ON.
- 45:01IT GETS BACK TO WHAT IS THE
- 45:03PUBLIC DEMAND AND WHAT ARE THE
- 45:04THINGS WE'RE HEARING.
- 45:05TRAVELING ACROSS THE STATE THERE
- 45:06IS A LOT OF PEOPLE IN TERMS OF
- 45:09SENATE BILL 150 ARE PLEASED
- 45:12SEEING THAT WE'RE PROTECTING OUR
- 45:13KENTUCKY CHILDREN.
- 45:15>> Renee: REBECCA BLANKENSHIP
- 45:16WHAT DOES THIS DO TO YOUR CAUSE
- 45:18TO BAN CONVERSION THERAPY WHICH
- 45:21HAD MORE DISCUSSION A FEW YEARS
- 45:23AGO, HAD A SPONSOR WHO IS NO
- 45:26LONGER IN THE SENATE.
- 45:27ARE YOU PESSIMISTIC OF THAT
- 45:29GETTING TRACTION IN THE GENERAL
- 45:32ASSEMBLIES TO COME?
- 45:33>> QUITE THE OPPOSITE WE SAW
- 45:35MORE DISCUSSION OF THE ISSUE
- 45:37THIS YEAR THAN LAST YEAR.
- 45:39BECAUSE FAMILIES HAVING HORMONE
- 45:42REPLACEMENT THERAPY BANNED ARE
- 45:43FACING DIFFICULT CHOICES.
- 45:45EARLIER DRAFT OF HOUSE BILL 470
- 45:48WOULD HAVE REQUIRED CONVERSION
- 45:52THERAPY FOR KIDS THAT IDENTIFY
- 45:53AS TRANS.
- 45:54TO SEE THAT CONFRONTED MORE
- 45:57DIRECTLY WAS IMPORTANT.
- 45:58WE ALSO SAW PEOPLE LIKE Dr.
- 46:01VAN MALL A NOTED CONVERSION
- 46:03THERAPIST COMING TO KENTUCKY TO
- 46:05TESTIFY IN FAVOR OF THIS
- 46:07LEGISLATION.
- 46:07WHETHER WE WANT IT OR NOT THE
- 46:09ISSUE IS BECOMING FRONT AND
- 46:10CENTER AND I CONTINUE TO LEAVE
- 46:11THAT MORE REPUBLICANS THAN NOT
- 46:14VIEW THAT TYPE OF PRACTICE AS
- 46:16HAIN NOWS AND UNFAIR.
- 46:18THE UTAH PROVIDES A CLEAR
- 46:21EXAMPLE OF THE PATH FORWARD.
- 46:24THEY PASSED A BAN ON GENDER
- 46:27AFFIRMING HEALTHCARE.
- 46:28SO I DON'T THINK THOSE THINGS
- 46:30ARE MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE.
- 46:32AND I HOPE THE KENTUCKY
- 46:34LEGISLATURE WILL VIEW THIS IS AN
- 46:36OPPORTUNITY TO DO RIGHT BY THE
- 46:37KIDS THAT THEY HURT SO MUCH THIS
- 46:39YEAR.
- 46:40>> Renee: I WANT TO GET YOUR
- 46:42PERSPECTIVE Mr. NELSON DO YOU
- 46:44SEE THOSE AS MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE
- 46:46ISSUES?
- 46:47>> WELL, I THINK SEXUAL
- 46:49ORIENTATION, CHANGE EFFORTS THAT
- 46:50THE IS ANOTHER ISSUE.
- 46:51I WANT TO GET BACK TO SOMETHING
- 46:53MORE FOUNDATIONAL.
- 46:54I THINK THERE IS A CONFLATION OF
- 46:57POLICY THAT IS AGE APPROPRIATE
- 46:59THAT AFFIRMS PARENTAL RIGHTS
- 47:01BEING INTERPRETED AS BEING
- 47:03AGAINST LGBTQ YOUTH.
- 47:03I THINK THAT YOU HAVE PEOPLE OF
- 47:06GOODWILL WHO DISAGREE AS TO WHAT
- 47:08SHOULD BE TAUGHT IN THE PUBLIC
- 47:10SCHOOLS.
- 47:11WHEN IT COMES TO GENDER
- 47:12IDENTITY, WHEN IT COMES TO
- 47:15SEXUAL ORIENTATION CURRICULUM.
- 47:17AND WHEN YOU CONFLATE THE TWO,
- 47:21YOU'RE VILLAINIZING THOSE AND
- 47:23IT'S BEEN HERE, VILLAINIZE THOSE
- 47:25WHO HAVE A DIFFERENT OPINION ON
- 47:27THIS.
- 47:27THIS IS NOT HELPFUL TO THE
- 47:28CONVERSATION.
- 47:29I THINK I CAN AFFIRM SOMEBODY
- 47:32WHO IS A YOUTH LGBTQ IDENTIFIED
- 47:34I CAN AFFIRM THEM BEFORE THEM
- 47:36AND I WILL SAY I THINK IN THE
- 47:39ORIGINAL GUIDANCE AT THE
- 47:40KENTUCKY DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION
- 47:41HAD LAST YEAR, PART OF THEIR
- 47:44IMPETUS WAS TO AFFIRM LGBTQ
- 47:47YOUTH AND TO PROVIDE A SAFE
- 47:48PLACE FOR THEM.
- 47:49I CAN BE FOR THAT.
- 47:50BUT I DON'T HAVE TO AGREE WITH
- 47:53HOW WE GET THERE.
- 47:55AND IN FACT WHEN IT COMES TO
- 47:58GENDER DISFORIC YOUTH, THE MOST
- 48:01LOVING THING YOU CAN DO IS HELP
- 48:03THEM ALIGN WITH THE BORN
- 48:05BIOLOGICAL SEX.
- 48:06IT IS NOT TO GIVE THEM HORMONE
- 48:07THERAPY.
- 48:08IT IS NOT TO GIVE THEM TO STEER
- 48:11THEM TOWARDS TRANSITION SURGERY.
- 48:13AND HERE IS SOMETHING ELSE I
- 48:15WANTED TO MENTION THERE WAS NEWS
- 48:17DURING THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 48:18SESSION THERE IS A GENDER CLINIC
- 48:20FOR YOUTH IN BOLLING GREEN
- 48:22OPENING UP.
- 48:24VANDERBILT NOT FAR FROM BOLLING
- 48:26GREEN HAS A YENDER CLINIC FOR
- 48:30YOUTH THEY HAVE CLOSED BECAUSE
- 48:31OF THE BLOWBACK AS TO WHAT THEY
- 48:33WERE DOING THERE.
- 48:34THAT AMOUNTS TO EXPERIMENTATION
- 48:37UNTESTED EXPERIMENTATION ON
- 48:38YOUTH THAT IS WHY EUROPE IS
- 48:39ROLLING BACK.
- 48:41I BELIEVE IT'S FINLAND, SWEDEN,
- 48:44ENGLAND, THEY ARE PUTTING A HALT
- 48:45TO GENDER TRANSITION SURGERY AND
- 48:48PUBERTY BLOCKERS FOR MINORS
- 48:50BECAUSE OF THE PROBLEMS.
- 48:51>> THAT IS NOT TRUE.
- 48:52>> WE HAD TESTIMONY IN THE STATE
- 48:55LEGISLATURE TO THAT EFFECT.
- 48:57>> THE IDEA THE TREATMENTS ARE
- 49:01EXPERIMENT TALL IS OUT RIGHT
- 49:03LIE.
- 49:04THE FIRST SURGERY WAS HELD IN
- 49:081922.
- 49:10HORMONE REPLACEMENT THERAPY
- 49:11BEGAN IN THE 1930s.
- 49:12IT WAS IN THE 1980s THAT TRANS
- 49:15YOUTH BEGAN TO RECEIVE PUBERTY
- 49:17BLOCKERS AND 90s THEY BECAME
- 49:19ELIGIBLE FOR HORMONE REPLACEMENT
- 49:22THIRP THERAPY.
- 49:24HE ARE IGNORING A CENTURY OF
- 49:26DATA THAT PROVES THEY ARE HIGHLY
- 49:28EFFECTIVE AND SAFE.
- 49:29AND YOU ARE INVALIDATING THE
- 49:31LIFE EXPERIENCES OF THOUSANDS OF
- 49:33PEOPLE INCLUDING KENTUCKIANS WHO
- 49:35HAVE EXPERIENCED THESE
- 49:36TREATMENTS AND SEEN THEIR LIVES
- 49:38IMPROVED AS A RESULT.
- 49:39AND IF YOU COULD ACTUALLY
- 49:41PRODUCE EVIDENCE THAT THIS WAS A
- 49:43NEGATIVE PRACTICE, I THINK YOU
- 49:45WOULD HAVE BEEN ABLE TO FIND A
- 49:47KENTUCKIANS TO TESTIFY TO THAT
- 49:49EFFECT.
- 49:50BUT INSTEAD YOU HAD TO FLY
- 49:52PEOPLE FROM NEBRASKA AND BRING
- 49:53PEOPLE UNDER THE ZOOMS FROM
- 49:55CALIFORNIA WHO WERE PSEUDO
- 49:59DOCTORS.
- 49:59IT'S OFFENSIVE TO HEAR YOU LIE
- 50:00ABOUT THESE THINGS.
- 50:01AND THE REALITY IS THIS...
- 50:03WHEN YOU HAVE TO BRING IN A
- 50:05CONVERSION THERAPIST, SOMEBODY
- 50:07WHO ADVOCATES TOTALLY
- 50:10DISCREDITED PRACTICE SOMETHING
- 50:10THAT PEOPLE LIKE ELLIS AND
- 50:14SIGMUND FREUD WERE FINDING TO BE
- 50:17A FAILURE IT SHOWS THE LENGTHS
- 50:19YOU ARE WILLING TO GO TO TO
- 50:21IGNORE SCIENCE IN PURSUIT OF
- 50:24IDEOLOGICAL DEVASTATION OF
- 50:25PEOPLE YOU DON'T LIKE.
- 50:27JOHNS HOPKINS WAS A PIONEER IN
- 50:29GENDER TRANSITION FOR MINORS AND
- 50:31FOR ADULTS.
- 50:32AND THEY PUT A HALT TO IT AFTER
- 50:34THEY DISCOVERED THE HARM IT WAS
- 50:37CAUSING.
- 50:38PAUL McCUE, THE PSYCHIATRIST
- 50:39IN CHIEF THERE IN AN OP-ED NOT
- 50:43TOO LONG AGO, IT IS A COUPLE
- 50:44YEARS AGO.
- 50:45BUT ESSENTIALLY CALLED IT CLOSE
- 50:47TO ABUSE WHEN CHILDREN UNDER THE
- 50:49AIMING OF 18 ARE PUSHED TOWARDS
- 50:53TRANSITION.
- 50:54>> JOHNS HOPKINS CONTINUE TO
- 50:56PROVIDE GENDER AFFIRMING CARE.
- 50:58>> THE TESTIMONY FROM OTHER
- 50:59STATES PEOPLE WERE AFRAID TO
- 51:00TESTIFY IN KENTUCKY THEY DID NOT
- 51:02WANT TO BE SINGLED OUT.
- 51:03SOME WERE AFRAID TO LOSE THEIR
- 51:05JOBS THEY DIDN'T WANT TO BE
- 51:07BULLIED.
- 51:08THE HEARINGS WERE FILLED WITH
- 51:11PEOPLE AGAINST 150.
- 51:12VERY FEW PEOPLE FROM KENTUCKY
- 51:15WERE LOOKING TO SPEAK AGAINST
- 51:17IT.
- 51:19SHE TRANSITIONED FROM 16, HAD A
- 51:23DOUBLE MASTECTOMY AND GIVEN HIGH
- 51:25DOSES OF TESS TOES RON
- 51:29TESTOSTERONE.
- 51:30SHE IS SUFFERING TERRIBLELY FROM
- 51:32THAT TREATMENT.
- 51:33>> Renee: Mr. HARTMAN?
- 51:35>> SO MUCH THERE.
- 51:36LET ME SAY THIS THE CONSENSUS
- 51:40AMONG KENTUCKIANS IS CLEAR FROM
- 51:42THE ONLY POLL DONE WHICH WAS A
- 51:44MASON DIXON POLL SHOWED 71% OF
- 51:47KENTUCKY VOTERS OPPOSED THE
- 51:50GENERAL ASSEMBLY LIMITING
- 51:51PARENTS AND CHILDREN'S ACCESS TO
- 51:54THIS MEDICALLY NECESSARY AND
- 51:56SUPPORTED BY EVERY MAJOR MEDICAL
- 51:58ASSOCIATION CARE.
- 52:00AND THE FACT THAT THEY HAVE BEEN
- 52:02SO FIXATED ON THIS.
- 52:03SUCH A SMALL POPULATION IN THE
- 52:08AMcDISCUSS BRIEF FILED BY THE
- 52:11AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS
- 52:12THEY ESTIMATE ONLY 140,000 LGBTQ
- 52:17OR TRANSGENDER KIDS UNDER THE
- 52:18AGE OF 18 ARE ELIGIBLE FOR
- 52:22PUBERTY BLOCKING THERAPY.
- 52:23YOU CAN FIT THE ENTIRE
- 52:25POPULATION IN CHURCHILL DOWNS ON
- 52:27KENTUCKY DERBY DAY.
- 52:29YET THEY HAVE ACTED LIKE THIS IS
- 52:30THE MOST PRESSING ISSUE IN
- 52:33CONSERVATIVE POLITICS.
- 52:34WHY THE FOCUS, THE SCRUTINY ON
- 52:36SUCH A SMALL POPULATION SIMPLY
- 52:39TO GAIN CHEAP POLITICAL POINTS.
- 52:41>> Renee: I WANT TO ASK MAX WISE
- 52:43THAT BECAUSE THERE WAS A
- 52:44RESPONSE THAT CAME IN FROM A
- 52:46LEXINGTON RUE VOOER THAT ASKED
- 52:48WHY ARE WE SPENDING SO MUCH TIME
- 52:50AND MONEY ON THIS WHEN KENTUCKY
- 52:52FACES MORE SERIOUS PROBLEMS.
- 52:54ANSWER THAT QUESTION ALONG WITH
- 52:55THE RESPONSE COMMENTS FROM Mr.
- 52:57HARTMAN?
- 52:58>> ONCE AGAIN, THESE ARE ISSUES
- 53:00THAT HAVE BEEN IN THE
- 53:01LEGISLATURE BEFORE.
- 53:02IF YOU LOOK AT EVERYTHING?
- 53:04SENATE BILL 150 A MAJORITY OF
- 53:06THAT BILLS PREVIOUSLY FILED IN
- 53:08PREVIOUS SESSIONS AND THIS WAS
- 53:09JUST PART OF A SESSION OF WHERE
- 53:11IT BECAME A FOREFRONT ISSUE.
- 53:15IT WAS THAT ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
- 53:16WE LISTEN TO OUR DISTRICTS TO
- 53:19OUR CONSTITUENTS AND OUR BASE.
- 53:20AND THAT IS ONE OF THE THINGS
- 53:22I'M A FATHER OF FOUR CHILDREN
- 53:24TWO BOYS TWO GIRLS.
- 53:25AND WHERE I LIVE FROM THE
- 53:27PSYCHIATRIST TRICK I REPRESENT
- 53:30STANDING UP FOR BATHROOM POLICY,
- 53:32AND PARENTAL RIGHTS AND
- 53:35CURRICULUM TRANSPARENCY, I HEAR
- 53:37THAT SO MUCH FROM SO MANY AND
- 53:38THAT IS WHY YOU SAW BIPARTISAN
- 53:40ON THE BILL AND THE NUMBERS THE
- 53:41WAY IT IS.
- 53:42AND I WOULD REFER BACK TO THE
- 53:43POLL THAT CHRIS MENTIONED HE IS
- 53:45CORRECT THAT WAS A MASON DIXON
- 53:47POLL BUT I DON'T THINK THAT
- 53:49CORRECTLY SAID THOSE WERE LIKELY
- 53:51VOTERS IN THAT POLL.
- 53:52THOSE WERE REGISTERED.
- 53:54DID IT SAY LIKELY VOTERS WHO
- 53:56WERE GOING TO VOTE OR NOT?
- 53:57BECAUSE IT IS AN ISSUE.
- 53:59THAT IS STILL GOING TO BE A BIG
- 54:01ISSUE TO EVERYONE ON THE PANEL
- 54:02TONIGHT AS WE GO FORWARD WITH
- 54:05THIS GOVERNOR'S ELECTION IN
- 54:06NOVEMBER.
- 54:07THIS IS NOT GOING AWAY.
- 54:08I THINK FAMILIES ACROSS
- 54:09KENTUCKY, I THINK FAMILIES
- 54:11ACROSS THE UNITED STATES, ARE
- 54:12LOOKING AT A LOT OF THESE ISSUES
- 54:15AND WE'LL SEE WHO IS THERE WITH
- 54:17THE BASE IT WILL COME OUT.
- 54:19>> Renee: SENATOR WISE, THIS
- 54:21TWEET FROM HARRIET IN LOUISVILLE
- 54:23ASKS AS THE TEACHING SEXUAL
- 54:26HEALTH IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOL DO
- 54:28THOSE WHO FAVOR SENATE BILL 150,
- 54:32GIRLS MAY MENSTRUATE BEFORE 10.
- 54:35WHAT ABOUT LESSONS ABOUT BAD
- 54:36TOUCH?
- 54:37>> IN THE TERMS WITH CHILD ABUSE
- 54:39AND LAWS AND THINGS FORTH WITH
- 54:43GUIDANCE ARE THERE AND OUR
- 54:44PROGRAMS WITHIN OUR SCHOOLS THAT
- 54:45IS SOMETHING THAT HOPEFULLY IS
- 54:47ALREADY THERE.
- 54:47THESE ARE THINGS WE CAN CONTINUE
- 54:49TO LOOK AT AS A LEGISLATIVE BODY
- 54:51AS WE GO FORTH.
- 54:53>> Renee: THANK YOU, SENATOR
- 54:55WISE.
- 54:55I WILL ALLOW A QUICK RESPONSE
- 54:59REBECCA BLANKENSHIP A FINAL
- 55:00COUPLE OF WORDS BEFORE WE END
- 55:01TONIGHT'S CONVERSATION.
- 55:02>> IS THE REALITY IS THIS WILL
- 55:04BE LITIGATED IN THE COURTS.
- 55:05AND YOU KNOW IN THE SIXTH
- 55:07CIRCUIT WE HAVE PRECEDENT
- 55:08PROTECTING THE RIGHTS OF LGBTQ
- 55:10PEOPLE INCLUDING CASES LIKE
- 55:12DODDS VER SUGGESTION THE U.S.
- 55:15DEPARTMENT OF 2015 AND THE
- 55:17DECISION THAT QUOTED THAT
- 55:18OPINION AND SAYING TRANSGENDER
- 55:20RIGHTS ARE WELL ESTABLISHED.
- 55:21MY HOPE IS THAT THE COURTS WILL
- 55:23SHOW THE SAME DEFERENCE TO HUMAN
- 55:26RIGHTS THAT THE KENTUCKY GENERAL
- 55:28ASSEMBLY OUGHT TO HAVE.
- 55:29>> Mr. NELSON?
- 55:31>> YES.
- 55:31IT'S INTERESTING CHRIS MENTIONED
- 55:33THAT WHY WE ARE FOCUSING ON THE
- 55:36KIDS IT'S BECAUSE THESE ARE
- 55:37PERMANENT CHOICES THAT WILL
- 55:39AFFECT THEM THE REST OF THEIR
- 55:40LIVES AND IT'S WORTH ADVOCATING
- 55:42ON THEIR HALF.
- 55:43CHILDREN CANNOT APPRECIATE DOING
- 55:44A GENDER TRANSITION OR HAVING
- 55:47SURGE RALE INTERVENTION.
- 55:48THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS SHOULD FOCUS
- 55:50ON ACADEMIC EXCELLENCE AND ROOT
- 55:52OUT DIVISIVENESS LIKE GENDER
- 55:54IDENTIFY PROGRAMS AND INVITE
- 55:56PARENTS INTO THE EDUCATIONAL
- 55:57FORMATION PROCESS AND RESPECT
- 55:59THEIR RIGHTS.
- 56:00>> Renee: I HAVE TO LEAVE IT
- 56:02THERE.
- 56:03THANK YOU ALL FOR THIS
- 56:06DISCUSSION.
- 56:06SENATOR THANK YOU FOR JOINING
- 56:07US.
- 56:07THANK YOU FOR BEING IN THE
- 56:10STUDIO.
- 56:13NEXT MONDAY ON KENTUCKY TONIGHT•
- 56:14A DISCUSSION ABOUT THE STATE OF
- 56:15THE ECONOMY.
- 56:16BE SURE TO JOIN US EACH
- 56:18WEEKNIGHT AT 6:30 EASTERN, 5:30
- 56:20CENTRAL FOR ‘KENTUCKY EDITION.’
- 56:22AND JOIN BILL BRYANT AND A TEAM
- 56:24OF WORKING JOURNALISTS TO
- 56:25DISCUSS THE NEWS OF THE WEEK ON
- 56:26‘COMMENT ON KENTUCKY,’ FRIDAY AT
- 56:27EIGHT EASTERN, SEVEN CENTRAL.
- 56:28HAVE A GOOD WEEK.