Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / California Tax Litigation Update
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to California tax litigation update.
- 0:06I'm Philip Baron, chair of the VHBA's Taxation
- 0:08Law Section, and I'm delighted to introduce our
- 0:11speaker and legend of the tax section, Marty
- 0:13Takesian. Marty is founder of Takesian Law, where
- 0:17he represents California taxpayers in complex
- 0:19tax matters. With over 25 years of experience,
- 0:23including roles at the State Board of Equalization
- 0:26and as an equity partner at Reed Smith LLP, he
- 0:29has led teams to significant administrative and
- 0:32judicial victories. A frequent speaker at California
- 0:35Tax Conferences, Marty is recognized for his
- 0:39deep expertise in state and local tax law. And
- 0:42now, Marty, take it from here. Philip, thank
- 0:46you. I appreciate the introduction. Before we
- 0:49get into the slides and the specific cases, I
- 0:53want to just give you an overview of what I plan
- 0:56to discuss. So we're going to discuss California
- 0:59state tax cases. Franchise Tax Board and Department
- 1:04of Tax and Fee Administration. We're going to
- 1:06talk about why these particular cases that I
- 1:10am presenting to you matter, not just kind of
- 1:13an update as to this is what happened to ABNC,
- 1:15but why they matter, why they're important. And
- 1:17then whenever possible along the way, I'll provide
- 1:21you with some tips to put yourself and your clients
- 1:24in the best possible position to succeed in what
- 1:26is a very, very difficult task, which is to go
- 1:29against the state of California in tax matters,
- 1:33in tax disputes. So with that, let's go to the
- 1:36next slide, please. Franchise Tax Board, which
- 1:42encompasses both corporate franchise and income
- 1:44tax, as well as personal income tax. We'll talk
- 1:47a little bit about, we'll select some cases from
- 1:50both sides of that. We can go to the next slide.
- 1:57Let's start with a very, very interesting case
- 2:00called American Catalog Mailers versus Franchise
- 2:03Tax Board. The underlying substance of this has
- 2:07to do with California's jurisdictional limits
- 2:10on income taxation. Under federal law, there
- 2:14is a statute called Public Law 86 -272. It says
- 2:19that if your only contact with a state, such
- 2:21as California, is to solicit sales of tangible
- 2:24goods, then you are not subject to the income
- 2:28taxing jurisdiction of that state. But anything
- 2:31in excess of those activities removes that protection.
- 2:36There is an entity called the Multistate Tax
- 2:38Commission, which is a non -governmental entity,
- 2:43but it is essentially a collection of tax administrators
- 2:47from the various states whose goal the organization
- 2:50is to establish multi -state tax uniformity and
- 2:54to issue model guidance for its various member
- 2:57states as to how to apply income tax laws, and
- 3:01in this case, how to interpret this jurisdictional
- 3:04limitation in public law 86272 in light of certain
- 3:08technological advances. We know that our economy
- 3:11has changed a lot. We've gone to this digital
- 3:13economy. And so for rules on jurisdiction and
- 3:17what the limits of that jurisdiction are, how
- 3:20are those rules interpreted in light of certain
- 3:22technological advances? So for instance, the
- 3:24Multistate Tax Commission has said that placing
- 3:28cookies on customer computers, providing post
- 3:31-sale assistance through email or chat functions,
- 3:34or accepting applications for employment online,
- 3:37among other things, these are considered to exceed
- 3:39that basic activity of soliciting sales of tangible
- 3:44goods in the state. And if you engage in these
- 3:46activities, you've blown your protection under
- 3:4886272, and you are now subject to tax in California.
- 3:53This is the Multistate Tax Commission's guidance.
- 3:55Now, of course, California is its own sovereign
- 3:57state and still needs to establish its own standards,
- 4:00which California did in this case. And the way
- 4:04that it did it is what the subject of the controversy
- 4:06is here. California adopted these federal standards
- 4:09in a technical advice memorandum and began enforcing
- 4:12these standards against taxpayers. The American
- 4:16Catalog Mailers Association, which represents
- 4:18a bunch of out of state retailers, online retailers,
- 4:22and catalog retailers, remote retailers, sued
- 4:24the Franchise Tax Board in San Francisco County
- 4:27Superior Court. saying that the technical advice
- 4:30memorandum, the TAM, was an unlawful underground
- 4:33regulation and thus unenforceable. Well, what
- 4:36does that mean? An underground regulation is...
- 4:40Let me just back up a second. In California,
- 4:42we have something called the Administrative Procedure
- 4:45Act. The Administrative Procedures Act in California
- 4:48says that if any administrative agency is going
- 4:51to adopt a rule or standard of general application,
- 4:54it must go through a specific... stakeholder
- 4:57process, a specific administrative process where
- 5:01it proposes these regulations, gives notice to
- 5:04interested parties and stakeholders, conducts
- 5:06hearings, and allows those parties to participate
- 5:09and have a say in what the regulation actually
- 5:12looks like. What state agencies cannot do is
- 5:17to simply enforce rules of general application
- 5:20without going through this process. This is kind
- 5:24of a recurring theme that we're seeing here in
- 5:26California tax litigation where state taxing
- 5:29agencies are, instead of seeking legislative
- 5:33changes and legislative guidance or going through
- 5:36a proper regulatory process or simply issuing
- 5:38pronouncements and imposing those pronouncements
- 5:41via administrative fiat on taxpayers. So ACMA
- 5:45said, no, you can't do that. So it's sued. the
- 5:48Franchise Tax Board and Superior Court saying
- 5:50that you need to go through a proper process.
- 5:52You didn't do that. And so you've basically promulgated
- 5:56an underground reg. This is a subversion of the
- 5:58democratic process. You don't get to make the
- 6:00law. The legislature does so on and so forth.
- 6:04And the San Francisco County Superior Court agreed
- 6:06with the. American Catalog Mailers Association
- 6:10and ruled against the Franchise Tax Board and
- 6:12said, walked through the elements of what an
- 6:14underground regulation is and decided that what
- 6:17the FTB had done was in fact a rule of general
- 6:19application and basically said that that action
- 6:23was invalid. The Franchise Tax Board did not
- 6:26appeal this, but... It took the TAM off of its
- 6:30website, and you can no longer find it now. And
- 6:33it is essentially promised not to enforce it
- 6:35as a rule of general application. So of course,
- 6:39why does this matter? I think I've given you
- 6:41some of the background, which it might be self
- 6:44-evident why this matters. But in case you are
- 6:47wondering, underground regulations exist all
- 6:50over the tax code in California, or I should
- 6:53say all over the administration of the tax law
- 6:55in California. And as I said before, it's very
- 7:00important to go through a proper process where
- 7:03stakeholders have a say and to avoid situations
- 7:07where the taxing agency just gets to decide what
- 7:09the law is and apply it as a general rule. That
- 7:13is not allowed. These are policy decisions that
- 7:15belong in the hands of the legislature and it's
- 7:17not the job of the agencies to simply decide
- 7:20this is what we think is best. No, you contact
- 7:23stakeholders, you shine light on the process,
- 7:26and after all that input and procedure has been
- 7:32followed, then and only then can you adopt these
- 7:36regulations. And then, of course, the regulations
- 7:38cannot exceed the scope of the underlying statute.
- 7:41So these are really important issues in California.
- 7:44The other thing to keep in mind here is that
- 7:47the American Catalog Mailers Association provided
- 7:51a declaratory relief action under the government
- 7:53code as an organization And so anytime you do
- 7:57something like that, standing becomes an issue
- 8:01because the Franchise Tax Board or the taxing
- 8:03agency will argue that you do not have a direct
- 8:05and beneficial interest in the litigation. And
- 8:08therefore you are unable to bring that only,
- 8:11for example, a member of the American Catalog
- 8:14Mailers Association is allowed to bring an action
- 8:18like that. And the FTB will argue that that person
- 8:20needs to go through an administrative process.
- 8:23apply for a refund, and so on and so forth. So
- 8:26whenever you see cases like this, and those standing
- 8:28arguments were, by the way, rejected by the trial
- 8:30court in American catalog mailers. But the key
- 8:34takeaway is the agencies will always try and
- 8:37erect procedural barriers to bringing these sorts
- 8:39of actions. They tried it here. It didn't work.
- 8:42And so this was a good outcome for taxpayers.
- 8:46Next slide, please. So appeal of Southern Minnesota
- 8:54beach sugar is an interesting case in terms of
- 8:57examining how our new, relatively new tax dispute
- 9:01resolution system in California is supposed to
- 9:03work. This is an office of tax appeals decision
- 9:06that essentially involves the apportionment factor.
- 9:12And the key question is, do you get to include
- 9:15deductible income in the apportionment factor?
- 9:18So if we could take a step back. if you're a
- 9:20business in California that's doing business
- 9:23in multiple states, you are subject to what is
- 9:26known under California law as apportionment of
- 9:29the income. So essentially what happens is you
- 9:32look at what the overall income pie is, what's
- 9:35the base of income that this company is generating
- 9:38in multiple states, and what is California's
- 9:41slice of that pie. And how do we measure California's
- 9:45slice of that pie? So if you think of the income
- 9:47as a base, apportionment is, if you think of
- 9:49the income as a base and you think of it as a
- 9:51pie, apportionment is designed to measure the
- 9:54slice of that pie that California gets relative
- 9:56to other states. And in California, the current
- 10:00apportionment regime says that you look to, but
- 10:03in measuring that slice, you look to the sales
- 10:06in California in the numerator of the fraction
- 10:08divided by sales everywhere. This simple ratio
- 10:12is what's used to determine California slice
- 10:15of that pie. But what goes into that apportionment
- 10:17factor? What goes into how do we count sales?
- 10:21And the definition of sales includes gross receipts.
- 10:24What are gross receipts? And what happens when
- 10:28you have gross receipts that don't actually generate
- 10:30income? Because the goal of the apportionment
- 10:32formula is to reflect the income -producing activity
- 10:36in California. So here the taxpayer had out -of
- 10:39-state income that was deductible as income from
- 10:41a cooperative under Reven Tax Code 24405, the
- 10:46cooperative deduction. And so all the income
- 10:52was subject to a corresponding deduction. The
- 10:55taxpayer argued correctly that under California
- 10:58law, that still goes in the denominator of the
- 11:01apportionment formula. and the bigger the denominator,
- 11:04the smaller the apportionment factor, and the
- 11:08better that is generally for taxpayers who are
- 11:10in an income position. If you're in a loss position,
- 11:13then the opposite is true. But if you're in an
- 11:16income position, then a larger denominator is
- 11:19better for you. And so The FTB, of course, took
- 11:23the opposite position and said, you know what,
- 11:25we understand that the statute says gross receipts,
- 11:28but, you know, really this isn't generating any
- 11:30income and this is problematic and we can't include
- 11:32it. And the officer tax appeals did what it should
- 11:35do, which is enforce the statute and essentially
- 11:37said, you know, look, FTB, we understand that
- 11:40you feel this way, but the statute requires that
- 11:42we put this in. There's no limitation on income
- 11:45that is subject to a corresponding deduction.
- 11:47And it's not necessarily This has sort of been
- 11:51sort of longstanding California law. This is
- 11:53what the statute says. If you want to make a
- 11:55change, go to the legislature. And so the Franchise
- 12:00Tax Board essentially said that, OTA, you don't
- 12:02really understand principles of cooperative income
- 12:04taxation. You don't really understand the appellate's
- 12:07business activity. You're making a mistake here.
- 12:09We're requesting a rehearing. OTA rejected the
- 12:12rehearing. And so why does this case matter?
- 12:16It matters because this issue, including receipts
- 12:19that don't generate a profit, applies in a lot
- 12:22of different situations, not just in the case
- 12:24of cooperative income. So case in point, after
- 12:28the OTA released this decision and made it presidential,
- 12:33another company, Microsoft Corporation, decided
- 12:36to test whether this same concept could be extended
- 12:39to deductible foreign dividends, whether dividends
- 12:43that are deductible at least to the extent of
- 12:4775 % should be included as gross receipts in
- 12:50the denominator of Microsoft's apportionment
- 12:52formula. The FTB of course, objected for the
- 12:55same reasons and the OTA to its credit was consistent
- 12:59and ruled in favor of the taxpayer once again,
- 13:01in line with this decision in the sugar beets
- 13:04case. Except this time, the universe of affected
- 13:10taxpayers was much greater. The universe of potential
- 13:13refund dollars was much greater. It was into
- 13:15the hundreds of millions of dollars at least.
- 13:19And so this was a very sort of interesting test
- 13:22to see how a massively impactful case would be
- 13:25decided by a new administrative tax dispute agency,
- 13:32the OTA, which has been viewed with some skepticism
- 13:36by taxpayers ever since its inception in 2017.
- 13:40So OTA issues this key decision in favor of taxpayers.
- 13:43And so what happened next is sort of a prime
- 13:45example of what's wrong right now with California's
- 13:49tax system and what the problems are that taxpayers
- 13:52are facing. So instead of just sort of moving
- 13:55on and just accepting the OTA's decision, the
- 13:58Franchise Tax Board decided to go to the legislature
- 14:00and not only change the law going forward, but
- 14:04to change the law retroactively. And so the legislature
- 14:07decided in a budget bill that it was going to
- 14:14overrule the Microsoft and Minnesota sugar beets
- 14:17decisions retroactively by declaring not only
- 14:21changing the law going forward, but declaring
- 14:24what the intent of the legislature was in 1966
- 14:27when this apportionment regime was adopted in
- 14:32California and what these definitions meant and
- 14:35what the legislature, some whatever, 50 plus
- 14:38years ago, Intended, and that's 60 years ago,
- 14:42I guess, now. Intended. And that is a problem.
- 14:45That is a problem. Retroactive taxation is a
- 14:50major problem. People who are in this area recognize
- 14:52that all the time. Businesses want to know what
- 14:55the rules are, and they can adjust accordingly.
- 15:00If the rules are x, then we can do y. But if
- 15:04the rules are x, and then the rules change 60
- 15:07years later, then that's a real problem. So we
- 15:10can go to the next slide, please. So what happens?
- 15:19So this new law passes to legislatively overrule
- 15:23these two taxpayer -friendly decisions at the
- 15:26OTA. So two taxpayer organizations decide that
- 15:29they're going to sue the state and decide that
- 15:31they're going to sue the Franchise Tax Board.
- 15:34on grounds that this is a violation of the constitutional
- 15:38rights of taxpayers, and that the retroactive
- 15:40application of this legislation is in violation
- 15:46of the due process clause of the United States
- 15:49and California constitutions. And so the taxpayer
- 15:55groups, we get back to this issue of standing
- 15:57that I mentioned, never got to the substantive
- 16:00issue in this case. because the Franchise Tax
- 16:02Board challenged whether or not they had standing
- 16:05to bring these actions versus a taxpayer in a
- 16:08normal refund context who's directly affected
- 16:12and can bring a refund action. That's sort of
- 16:15the normal course of action tax litigation. And
- 16:17the FTB in this case was successful. It wasn't
- 16:21successful in American catalog mailers in terms
- 16:23of challenging standing. But standing is often
- 16:26a factual question. And the court here found
- 16:29that the as far as the National Taxpayers Union
- 16:33was concerned, that it did not prove it was unable
- 16:35to satisfy its burden of proof that it had an
- 16:38affected member. And as far as CalTax was concerned,
- 16:42the court held that although CalTax was able
- 16:44to prove that it had an affected member, it was
- 16:47not able to approve that that affected member
- 16:49had exhausted its administrative remedies. So
- 16:52now the case is up to the, well, actually CalTax
- 16:55has decided it's not going to appeal. And the
- 16:59National Taxpayers Union has filed an appeal.
- 17:03But the appeal is not going to address the underlying
- 17:05merits. It's only going to address this issue
- 17:07of standing. And then if they're successful,
- 17:09it's going to go back down and address the underlying
- 17:12issue. So the takeaway for me here is that we
- 17:19have a policy argument here, right? Should you
- 17:22consider activity that does not generate a profit?
- 17:25You can make arguments on both sides. The arguments
- 17:27cuts both ways for taxpayers and sometimes and
- 17:30often for the franchise tax board. But ultimately,
- 17:34it's a policy decision. And like all policy decisions,
- 17:38it is reserved for the legislature, which is
- 17:41totally fine. The OTA made the right decision
- 17:44here. It decided this based on existing law and
- 17:48longstanding precedent. But you can't go back
- 17:51and if you're the legislature, and decide these
- 17:55issues retroactively. And there are lots of cases
- 17:59that say that. There are California Supreme Court
- 18:01pronouncements that say that. So let's see how
- 18:02this unfolds at the Court of Appeal in the NTU
- 18:06case. Next slide, please. Appeal of Janus Capital
- 18:12Groups. So this is another interesting dispute,
- 18:17again, over an FTB regulation. And what happened
- 18:21here is that The taxpayer and investment management
- 18:25company provided services to mutual funds, filed
- 18:28its returns using the single sales factor formula
- 18:30and the method applied by a special apportionment
- 18:33regulation 25137 -14, which says that gross receipts
- 18:39from sales of services to mutual funds should
- 18:41be assigned to the location of the mutual funds
- 18:44shareholders. not to the mutual funds themselves,
- 18:48but to their shareholders. And so the taxpayer
- 18:51here filed claims for refund, trying to assign
- 18:55its receipts to the locations of the funds themselves,
- 18:58not to their customers, not to their shareholders.
- 19:01And that's because the standard apportionment
- 19:04formula states that the receipts should be sourced
- 19:06to where the purchaser is located. And the purchaser
- 19:10in this case would be the mutual funds. And the
- 19:13premise behind this whole regulation the taxpayer
- 19:16argues, has expired. California went through
- 19:19a change in 2013 to move from an apportionment
- 19:23formula that measured California's slice of the
- 19:27pie not just by sales, which is the law today,
- 19:30but also including property and payroll. And
- 19:32the underlying rationale for this regulation
- 19:35was directly connected to that property, payroll,
- 19:39and sales regime. It was adopted before the statutory
- 19:42change. And so while an argument could be made
- 19:46that this was appropriate back then, it's not
- 19:49appropriate now, and is invalid and exceeds the
- 19:54scope of the FTB's authority. So this case is
- 19:59set for summary judgment that's going to be heard
- 20:02in April of 2026, but another case challenging
- 20:05the FTB's regulatory authority, very interesting.
- 20:08Next one, please. Smithfield versus FTB. Again,
- 20:18sort of a common theme, we're having another
- 20:20dispute over apportionment, over measuring the
- 20:23slice of the pie. Here, the taxpayer was arguing
- 20:28that essentially qualified for the agricultural
- 20:33business activities apportionment formula, which
- 20:38is a special one that uses the old property payroll
- 20:41and sales apportionment formula. versus the new
- 20:44one that only uses sales. And so the taxpayer,
- 20:48which is the world's largest hog producer, argued
- 20:51that it satisfied the statutory definition of
- 20:55agricultural business activity, which means activities
- 20:59relating to any stock, dairy, poultry, fruit,
- 21:02et cetera, et cetera. It also includes activities
- 21:05relating to cultivating soil or harvesting any
- 21:09agricultural commodity and felt that it was within
- 21:13the scope of the statute. The Franchise Tax Board
- 21:16adopted a regulation that in the taxpayer's estimation
- 21:20exceeded the scope of the statute because it
- 21:24linked to, well, not only linked to the business
- 21:27of farming as defined in the Treasury Regulation,
- 21:30but the FTP took a very specific interpretation
- 21:32of what the business of farming means that in
- 21:35the taxpayer's estimation exceeded the scope
- 21:38of the statutory definition. So again, we have
- 21:41a case where taxpayers are testing the limits
- 21:45of the Franchise Tax Board's ability to interpret
- 21:48statutes, whether in an administrative pronouncement
- 21:52or through a duly adopted regulation. This is
- 21:55sort of a hot button issue in California today.
- 21:58The trial in this case took place in December
- 22:01and the parties are still awaiting decision.
- 22:05So. One other thing that I was gonna mention
- 22:09about this case, which is very interesting is
- 22:13in, you know, speaking to counsel on both sides
- 22:17of this dispute, the FTB has argued that the
- 22:21taxpayers was, you know, one of their arguments
- 22:23was a procedural one. which the FTB likes to
- 22:25do a lot to avoid getting to the substantive
- 22:28issues, likes to test the limits of the procedural
- 22:32requirements that taxpayers must follow, the
- 22:35FTB essentially said that the taxpayer failed
- 22:39to exhaust its administrative remedies because
- 22:41it failed to produce evidence at audit that is
- 22:45now producing a trial. And that's simply not
- 22:48true. The taxpayers in California tax litigation
- 22:51are entitled to a trial de novo in superior court.
- 22:54This means a brand new trial and brand new evidence
- 22:57is taken by a superior court judge. It's not
- 23:01restricted to the administrative record in any
- 23:03way, shape or form with limited exceptions. Not
- 23:06relevant here. There are some cases where that
- 23:08might be a true, but in a general refund action,
- 23:12it is 100 % de novo. It's written in the statute.
- 23:14And so, you know, This is a brand new record.
- 23:20So you can, especially in California, file a
- 23:23refund claim, not provide any supporting evidence,
- 23:26have it be denied or deemed denied, and then
- 23:28go immediately to Superior Court for a trial
- 23:30de novo. That is allowed under California procedure.
- 23:32So this position that I'm told that the FTB took
- 23:35in this case is totally invalid. With that being
- 23:38said, you do want to make sure to raise all arguments
- 23:41in the... presentation of your refund claim or
- 23:45the administrative prosecution of that claim
- 23:47to avoid any headaches later. Next slide, please.
- 23:53So now we're gonna talk about a personal income
- 23:55tax case that was somewhat impactful. And the
- 24:00issue here is how income of non -residents from
- 24:04the sale of Goodwill and other intangibles is
- 24:07treated for California. As we all know, California
- 24:11taxes the worldwide income of residents regardless
- 24:15of source. But for non -residents, it can only
- 24:19tax income that has a source in California. So
- 24:24what happens when you have income from intangibles,
- 24:27say from the sale of stock? Well, under Revenue
- 24:30and Taxation Code Section 17952, if you're a
- 24:35non -resident, California law follows what's
- 24:38known as the Mobiliar Rule. which is rooted in
- 24:41the constitution, really. And the rule is that
- 24:44income from the sale of intangibles, such as
- 24:46stock, is sourced to the taxpayer's domicile,
- 24:50to the non -resident's domicile, subject to two
- 24:53exceptions that are not relevant here. One of
- 24:56which is if you establish that, if that intangible
- 25:00establishes situs in California, or if you are
- 25:05engaged in the regular trading of intangibles,
- 25:07then California gets to apportion some of that.
- 25:10But here, in the JP Morgan Trust case, the taxpayers
- 25:15were non -resident trusts and were shareholders
- 25:18of an S corporation. And the underlying business
- 25:21was sold and the major portion of that sale was
- 25:24attributed to Goodwill, which undisputedly is
- 25:27an intangible. So the Franchise Tax Board, and
- 25:30I'm editorializing here a little bit, but I think
- 25:32my comments are fair, adopted a regulation to
- 25:35specifically, I think, circumvent Section 17952
- 25:39to state that where the income from intangibles
- 25:42is through the sale of an S corporation, then
- 25:45notwithstanding 17952, that's apportioned to
- 25:48California based on the factors of the underlying
- 25:51corporation, which to me is grossly in excess
- 25:55of the FTB's authority. In the Metropolis decision,
- 26:00the issue was not whether the regulation was
- 26:03invalid. The issue was whether the FTB's apportionment
- 26:11regulation ought to apply versus 7952 and almost
- 26:17treating 7951 -4, which is the regulation at
- 26:22issue, as an established co -equal rule along
- 26:28with the statute, which is actually what the
- 26:30court said, which is one of many mistakes the
- 26:31court made in this case. And the court decided
- 26:34that because the regulation was more specific
- 26:38than the statute that the regulation would apply,
- 26:41which was an incorrect result. And so the taxpayers
- 26:44ended up having to apportion their income and
- 26:47were not able to source the entirety of their
- 26:49income to the non -resident state, which I recall,
- 26:52if I recall correctly, was Delaware. So a couple
- 26:56of takeaways here. in my opinion. First of all,
- 27:00what we're seeing is over the years, the FTB
- 27:04and to some extent the courts have enabled the
- 27:07FTB to chip away at the favorable sourcing of
- 27:11income rules for non -residents. And so we are
- 27:15seeing this erosion in the mobilia rule. We're
- 27:18seeing this erosion of a rule that income from
- 27:21intangibles is sourced to domicile. And the FTB
- 27:24is via regulation carving out all these little
- 27:27exceptions to it, which in our view is not allowed.
- 27:32And so the issue of the regulations, another
- 27:36sort of important takeaway is that the issue
- 27:38of the regulations and whether the regulation
- 27:40was invalid was not raised in this case. And
- 27:43it wasn't raised because this was in a claim
- 27:46for refund posture. And at the OTA, the the taxpayer
- 27:52did not raise the issue of the reg being invalid.
- 27:55And the likely reason for that is because prior
- 27:58to very recently, the Office of Tax Appeals position
- 28:00was that it could not hear regulatory challenges.
- 28:05And that changed very recently, relatively recently,
- 28:11less than a year ago, when the attorney general
- 28:13opined that the Office of Tax Appeals does in
- 28:16fact have the ability to consider regulatory
- 28:18challenges in addition to deciding what I would
- 28:22call regular or substantive tax issues. And so
- 28:25that's likely the reason why it wasn't raised
- 28:27here. So the issue of the validity of the regs
- 28:30is still, in my opinion, an open question and
- 28:35could be challenged in the future. And if it's
- 28:37challenged, I think a court will see that this
- 28:41was a narrowing of Section 17952, a pretty unabashed
- 28:47narrowing of Section 17952, and the reg should
- 28:50probably be disallowed. So there you have it.
- 28:57I think we can move on to the next slide. Oh,
- 29:03I'm sorry. We have continuing slides here on
- 29:06the JP Morgan Trust case, which you can review
- 29:09later. We can go to the next slide. And we've
- 29:11got one more. Oh, okay. Well, I mean, I guess
- 29:14just as a procedural point, the Court of Appeal
- 29:17in the JPMorgan Trust case said a couple of additional
- 29:20very interesting things. One, as I think I mentioned
- 29:23earlier, it said that regulations, and I think
- 29:27it was wrong in saying this, regulations, quasi
- 29:30-legislative regulations have the dignity of
- 29:33statutes, which in some sense is true. where
- 29:37the court went overboard and said that the regulation
- 29:39was co -equal to the statute and decided to apply
- 29:43the reg as the more specific statute. I mentioned
- 29:45that. The other thing that the court got wrong
- 29:48was that it decided that for the first time in
- 29:5280 plus years, I've never even heard of this
- 29:55rule before, that the concept of business situs
- 29:58was not an all or nothing concept, that business
- 30:02situs was subject to partial situs and apportioned
- 30:07situs, which was a huge departure from existing
- 30:10law, not only in California, but throughout the
- 30:12country. And so despite all this, the California
- 30:16Supreme Court did not take the case. Review was
- 30:19denied. And we can now move on to the next slide.
- 30:25So California Department of Tax and Fee Administration,
- 30:28which covers sales and business tax cases. Next
- 30:31slide, please. Okay, so Olympus America Inc versus
- 30:38CDTFA. Interesting case here where the taxpayer
- 30:44incorporated repair parts into property used
- 30:47out of state under an optional maintenance contract.
- 30:52So parts are going to be, the property is going
- 30:54to be repaired. They sent it into California.
- 30:56Taxpayer incorporates repair parts into that
- 30:59property. The taxpayer... claimed an exclusion
- 31:01under Reven tax code section 6009 .1, arguing
- 31:06that because that property was going to be transported
- 31:08out of state and ultimately used out of state
- 31:10that it came within the letter of the statute.
- 31:13The CDTFA instead argued that the statute was
- 31:16designed for property whose presence in the state
- 31:18is transitory and incidental to out of state
- 31:22use. It was not for equipment brought into the
- 31:25state to be repaired under contract. The taxpayer
- 31:29argued In addition to the CDTFA's interpretation
- 31:35being incorrect, that the CDTFA's interpretation
- 31:38violated the Commerce Clause, the trial court
- 31:41did agree with the CDTFA's interpretation, and
- 31:44here argued that the constitutional arguments
- 31:46were waived because the taxpayer failed to address
- 31:49them. The taxpayer recently filed an appeal,
- 31:53so we'll see how that turns out. But a couple
- 31:57of takeaways here. When you're litigating a tax
- 31:59case against the taxing agencies, you've got
- 32:01to go into it knowing that the trial courts are
- 32:04going to defer significantly to the interpretation
- 32:08of the taxing agencies. The taxing agencies will
- 32:11hammer on that. And trial courts, which are not
- 32:14specialized tax courts in California, they're
- 32:17general jurisdiction courts. They hear all kinds
- 32:19of different cases. those are the same judges
- 32:22that are gonna hear the tax case. So if they
- 32:25don't understand it, they will defer to the state.
- 32:28And that is sort of the default that you've got
- 32:31to come to grips with when you decide whether
- 32:34to move a case into litigation. So even in a
- 32:39case like this where the CDTFA's interpretation
- 32:41might seem excessive, they seem to add words
- 32:43to the statute that don't exist. you know, the
- 32:47trial court's gonna give the agency a lot of
- 32:50leeway. And so you just have to know that. And,
- 32:53you know, what's really important is being able
- 32:56to show mastery of the subject matter, make things
- 32:59easy for the trial court, make a tax case, not
- 33:03a tax case. I'm not saying, you know, dumb it
- 33:06down, you know, that, you know. What I am saying
- 33:09though is don't make it unnecessarily complicated
- 33:12and be able to tell the court the story of what's
- 33:14actually happening here and be able to tap in
- 33:19to a judge's instinct to do the right thing and
- 33:25to address evidentiary issues, to understand
- 33:29the facts of the case, and you know sometimes
- 33:32to make the case a narrow case if you can so
- 33:34that the court doesn't feel like it's going to
- 33:36do something And if it decides to do something,
- 33:38it's going to be massively consequential. And
- 33:41so that could be another reason to sort of defer
- 33:43to the agencies and say, this is just too big
- 33:48of an issue. I'm going to let the Court of Appeal
- 33:50decide it. So this gives you an idea of just
- 33:53sort of a deference that taxing agencies enjoy
- 33:57in front of the trial court. A couple of questions
- 33:59I would ask is if the CDTFA is saying that the
- 34:07Statute was designed for property whose presence
- 34:09in the state is transitory and incidental. It
- 34:11was not for equipment brought into the state
- 34:13to be repaired under contract. That seems like
- 34:16a general rule to me. Is this another underground
- 34:18regulation? It may have been worth it for the
- 34:20taxpayer to raise that issue and to, if nothing
- 34:24else, lower the degree of deference that the
- 34:27trial court would give to the CDTFA interpretation
- 34:30and say, you know what, you're saying that CDTFA
- 34:34But this is a general rule. It's not undergone
- 34:37the rigors of the administrative process. And
- 34:40so it's just your litigating position. And so
- 34:43to kind of decrease the respect and the deference
- 34:48that that opinion might enjoy. And the other
- 34:51thing that just sort of occurred to me is that
- 34:54Section 6009 .1 of the Reven Tax Code is not
- 34:59under, it's not an exemption. It's really an
- 35:01exclusion. And why would that matter? Why is
- 35:04that important? Well, exemptions are in their
- 35:06own separate section of the sales and use tax
- 35:08law. And this is in essentially the definitional
- 35:12provisions of the sales and use tax law. And
- 35:15the difference between an exclusion and exemption
- 35:17is exemptions are considered matters of legislative
- 35:21grace and are construed narrowly against the
- 35:25taxpayer. and all doubts are resolved in favor
- 35:29of the government. And exclusion, on the other
- 35:32hand, is part of the taxing scheme itself, like
- 35:36the imposition of the tax itself. In statutes
- 35:39imposing taxes, the opposite is true, that they're
- 35:43what the courts call ad in vitam, and they are
- 35:47resolved, the doubts are resolved in favor of
- 35:49the taxpayer. So I'm wondering whether or not
- 35:51that's an argument that should be raised by the
- 35:54taxpayer at the Court of Appeal, or whether or
- 35:57not that was discussed. I didn't see it discussed
- 35:59from the documents that I had. Next slide, please.
- 36:06Medtronic versus CDTFA. Another interesting case,
- 36:10this one has to do with an exemption, the medical
- 36:14devices exemption. We just talked about exclusion
- 36:16versus exemption. This exemption is actually
- 36:18found in the exemption section. it is clearly
- 36:21an exemption and a construed narrowly against
- 36:24the taxpayer. And again, that is something that
- 36:29whenever you're dealing with an exemption statute
- 36:31that can cloud the discussion and really tip
- 36:36the scales even more in favor of the taxing agency.
- 36:39They already are. enjoying some level of deference
- 36:41going into it. And then when you have a rule
- 36:43that says that exemptions are construed against
- 36:47the taxpayer and all doubts are resolved in favor
- 36:49of the government, it makes it really hard. So
- 36:50you have to show that you clearly come within
- 36:53the scope of the exemption. And here Medtronic
- 36:56was trying to get a refund for its insertable
- 37:01cardiac monitors, saying that they were... they
- 37:07fit within the definition of medicines under
- 37:116369 of the Reven Tax Code, or they were an implantable
- 37:15device and they were exempt under that rule.
- 37:18And the CDTFA argued that the definition of medicines
- 37:22does not include devices at all. And so the statute
- 37:28itself just specifically excludes devices. And
- 37:32if you're trying to taxpayer get an exemption
- 37:35for an implantable device, well, the exemption
- 37:38doesn't include cardiac monitors because this
- 37:41only includes implantable devices that assist
- 37:43in the functioning of an organ. And these don't
- 37:46assist in the functioning of the organ. They
- 37:48only monitor the organ. And so they don't come
- 37:51clearly within the statutory exemption. In addition
- 37:56to its statutory arguments, the taxpayer, I think
- 37:58what they really were focusing on was the regulation.
- 38:01And there was a specific regulation that actually
- 38:04was quite favorable to the taxpayer in this situation
- 38:07that says that the exemption includes articles
- 38:11permanently implanted in the human body to mark
- 38:13the location of a medical condition. And based
- 38:18on that description, permanently implanted in
- 38:21the human body to mark the location of the medical
- 38:23condition, I think you can argue persuasively
- 38:25that that includes cardiac monitors. But here's
- 38:28what happened, very interesting decision. The
- 38:31court said, we are bound by what the statute
- 38:33says, which is correct. But the regulation, even
- 38:38though it may have seemed to be in favor of the
- 38:40taxpayer, the court refused to consider it because
- 38:43it said that even if we were to consider the
- 38:45reg, essentially we're not saying this, but...
- 38:50the reg could exceed the scope of the statute.
- 38:51So we're not going to look at the reg. We're
- 38:53going to look at the four corners of the statute,
- 38:56which is interesting because the regulation represents
- 38:59the CDTFA's interpretation of the statute and
- 39:03the court was undeterred by that and said, we've
- 39:06got to stay within the statute. You're not allowed
- 39:08the exemption. The regulation may exceed it.
- 39:11So it's interesting. And the reason that this
- 39:15regulation was even there to begin with, and
- 39:17again, probably some commentary here, is the
- 39:19regulation was adopted by the State Board of
- 39:21Equalization. And we had a change in tax agencies
- 39:25in 2017. In July 1, 2017, the Board of Equalization's
- 39:31duties to administer the sales and use tax law
- 39:33were transferred to the California Department
- 39:36of Tax and Fee Administration. And the Board
- 39:38of Equalization had five elected members that
- 39:40ran it, the CDTFA, has a single director who's
- 39:44answerable to the governor. And so what we have
- 39:48seen as a taxpayer community is that the CDTFA
- 39:51has revisited several, what I would consider
- 39:53pro -taxpayer board of equalization policies
- 39:56and reversed them. And so the fact that this
- 40:01case got to litigation instead of the CDTFA saying,
- 40:05yeah, that's our regulation, we're gonna follow
- 40:07it here. signals to me a shift in how sales and
- 40:11use tax laws be administered in California. So
- 40:15interesting, interesting. Next slide, please.
- 40:22We have more there on Medtronic that you can
- 40:24read later. Next slide. City of San Bruno versus
- 40:30California Department of Tax and Fee Administration.
- 40:33Well, this is interesting. So under California
- 40:36law, we have the state component of the sales
- 40:39and use tax. And then we also have the local
- 40:42component of the sales and use tax. And what
- 40:47has been the subject of considerable dispute
- 40:51and litigation is which jurisdictions get what
- 40:55amount of the local sales and use tax revenue.
- 40:59And in California, the law allows for local jurisdictions
- 41:06to enter into agreements with retailers to route
- 41:11local tax revenues to that particular jurisdiction
- 41:16versus having the revenue sprinkled throughout
- 41:20the state. So for example, in this case, San
- 41:23Bruno and Walmart entered into an agreement for
- 41:26Walmart to establish facilities within the boundaries
- 41:29of the city of San Bruno. And then that would
- 41:32allow Walmart sales, the sales tax on Walmart
- 41:37sales, to be routed to the city of San Bruno.
- 41:40Absent that, presumably, the revenues would have
- 41:45been sprinkled throughout the various states
- 41:46based on customer location. But by establishing
- 41:50these facilities within the city of San Bruno,
- 41:55that portion of the revenue of the sales tax
- 41:57revenue attributable to Walmart sales was routed
- 42:00to San Bruno. And why would Walmart do that?
- 42:02Well, because these agreements call for the city
- 42:08and the retailer to share in the tax savings.
- 42:11So if revenue is coming to the city of San Bruno,
- 42:14Walmart will get a piece of that back. That's
- 42:17not exactly how these agreements are structured,
- 42:18but in substance, that's what's happening. Now,
- 42:21the fact is that these agreements have been allowed
- 42:23for decades. And in fact, the last two governors,
- 42:26Governor Newsom and beforehand Governor Jerry
- 42:28Brown, both have supported these agreements and
- 42:32referred to them as valuable economic development
- 42:34tools. You can imagine that this is a divisive
- 42:37issue. A lot of the cities that are on the receiving
- 42:42end of this new revenue support it. Those that
- 42:45are losing the revenue are against it. And so
- 42:47there has been considerable discussion in the
- 42:48halls of the legislature as to whether to restrict,
- 42:52to limit, to modify, or to eliminate these agreements
- 42:55altogether. And those efforts have failed. So
- 42:58why do we have a controversy here? In my opinion,
- 43:02the California Department of Tax and Peer Administration
- 43:04does not like these agreements. and has been
- 43:06trying to administratively eliminate them instead
- 43:09of continuing to pursue legislative reform or
- 43:13have a say in the legislative process, they have
- 43:15tried to shut these agreements down. And so this
- 43:20particular litigation was spawned by a CDTFA
- 43:26disallowance, essentially, of this agreement
- 43:29between San Bruno and Walmart. What's interesting
- 43:34here is that rather than go through the entire
- 43:36administrative process, Walmart and the City
- 43:39of San Bruno got their adverse audit level decision
- 43:44from the CDTFA, had discussions with CDTFA about
- 43:48why this was incorrect, and after those discussions
- 43:51were not fruitful, decided to go straight to
- 43:53court to challenge the decision. They bypassed
- 43:56the CDTFA petitions process and they bypassed
- 43:59the Office of Tax Appeals on grounds of futility.
- 44:04based on that it would be pointless to go through
- 44:07the process with the CDTFA and the OTA, that
- 44:09this was somehow a fait accompli, that there
- 44:11was no point in doing that, that we all know
- 44:14how the agencies are going to rule, so let's
- 44:15just skip that and go directly to the trial court.
- 44:20Which is interesting. The futility exception
- 44:24to exhaustive administrative remedies is a real
- 44:27thing, but it's difficult to It's difficult to
- 44:33prevail on the futility exception. And in this
- 44:37case was no exception, the trial court essentially
- 44:39ruled that the case is not ripe and that San
- 44:42Bruno and Walmart have not exhausted their administrative
- 44:44remedies. And even if they were to, if the court
- 44:47were to agree that the CDTFA process is futile,
- 44:50the same cannot be said of the Office of Tax
- 44:53Appeals. And so the case is stuck. Again, we
- 44:58have a procedural issue. that is preventing the
- 45:01substantive issue from being considered and so
- 45:05this is ongoing and the CDTFA has filed a motion
- 45:09to dismiss which will be heard on June 16th of
- 45:13this year and so you know I guess you know my
- 45:18practitioner tip here is that if you try something
- 45:21like this and you don't exhaust your administrative
- 45:23remedies you're likely to be stuck in court for
- 45:27years arguing over that issue. and will often
- 45:32delay, as it has in this case, getting to the
- 45:35underlying merits. And in most cases, it'll be
- 45:39longer than if you had simply moved as quickly
- 45:41as possible through the administrative process.
- 45:44If this now goes to the Court of Appeal, this
- 45:47will be another two, three years before the case
- 45:49is resolved on this procedural issue. And even
- 45:54if they're successful, they will have lost those
- 45:55years and now they will finally get their opportunity
- 45:59to discuss. the merits of the case. So if at
- 46:03all possible, and there are ways to shortcut
- 46:06the process, but do your best to always exhaust
- 46:11your administrative remedies. It's the number
- 46:12one defense that is raised by the state in any
- 46:16litigation. All right, next slide, please. Next
- 46:22slide, please. Okay. Andal versus Maduros. What
- 46:31happened here? The Andal, in this case, who is
- 46:34the plaintiff, is retired State Board of Equalization
- 46:38member Dean Andal. And he sued the California
- 46:42Department of Tax and Fee Administration, which
- 46:44is why Nicholas Maduros is mentioned in the lawsuit.
- 46:48He was the director of the CDTFA at the time.
- 46:53And board member Andal sued the CDTFA under a
- 46:58provision under the taxpayer waste doctrine.
- 47:03And the case is about what Andall believes is
- 47:09the CDTFA enforcing an invalid underground regulation
- 47:14pertaining to local tax reallocation, which we
- 47:16just discussed in the city of San Bruno case.
- 47:21So let's take a step back. What is a taxpayer
- 47:23waste action? What is the taxpayer waste doctrine?
- 47:27So under common law for about the last 100 years,
- 47:35you as a taxpayer in California can bring an
- 47:38action challenging the waste of government funds,
- 47:43challenging unlawful government expenditures.
- 47:46Case law has held that the enforcement of an
- 47:49invalid ordinance or an invalid law is in itself
- 47:53taxpayer waste and allows ordinary citizens to
- 47:58challenge illegal and wasteful government action.
- 48:02The standing requirements are very broad. All
- 48:04you need to show is that as a plaintiff, you've
- 48:07either paid an income tax, property tax, or use
- 48:09tax within 12 months before the filing of the
- 48:13complaint. You don't have to have a direct interest
- 48:15in the outcome of the case. It would help if
- 48:19you did to avoid any sort of standing challenges,
- 48:21but you're not required to. The taxpayer... A
- 48:24waste doctrine is very broad and is designed
- 48:27to serve as a check to allow people to try to
- 48:33overturn unlawful government action on the wasteful
- 48:36government spending. So Andal decides to bring
- 48:42this lawsuit under the taxpayer waste doctrine.
- 48:45He also decides to challenge the invalidity of
- 48:50the regulation under government code section
- 48:5211350. He also brings it rid of mandate action.
- 48:55And as expected, the Department of Tax and Fee
- 48:58Administration has challenged Andal's ability
- 49:01to bring the action. Their argument is that taxpayer
- 49:07waste actions are not designed for cases like
- 49:09this, that Andal does not have a direct and beneficial
- 49:12interest in the outcome, and that interested
- 49:15parties are the only ones who can bring these
- 49:17actions, and they need to do it by bringing a
- 49:19refund action. And that's just not the case,
- 49:22but that's what the CDTFA is arguing. The case
- 49:25is pending in Sacramento County Superior Court.
- 49:29And so we'll wait and see what happens. But if
- 49:33these procedural challenges are overturned, then
- 49:37the court will turn its attention to whether
- 49:40or not the test that the CDTFA adopted the genuine
- 49:45physical human interaction test, whether that
- 49:48is in fact an invalid underground regulation.
- 49:53So before we get to that, though, we have to
- 49:55first decide whether or not the plaintiff is
- 49:57the correct plaintiff. So the hearing on that,
- 50:00as you can see on the slide, is scheduled for
- 50:02February 20, 2026. Next slide, please. And that
- 50:11brings us to Southwest Airlines versus California
- 50:14Department of Tax and Fee Administration as the
- 50:18last case in our selection today. And what happened
- 50:22in this case was we had state level law that
- 50:27said that the sales tax on jet fuel was limited
- 50:31to being taxed on only 25 % of the gross receipts
- 50:34at the local level. a later change in state statute
- 50:38lifted the limitation so that localities could
- 50:41tax 100 % of the gross receipts on the sale of
- 50:46jet fuel. Based on this change in statute, certain
- 50:51localities automatically increased the tax on
- 50:53sales of jet fuel from 25 % to 100%, and they
- 50:58did so without voter approval. The taxpayer in
- 51:01this case, Southwest Jet Fuel, sued the CDTFA
- 51:05for a refund of a local portion of the sales
- 51:07tax on jet fuel. And the reason Southwest sued
- 51:10the CDTFA is because the CDTFA under the Bradley
- 51:16Burns Uniform Local Sales and Use Tax Act has
- 51:21contracted with localities to administer and
- 51:24collect the tax on their behalf. So as part of
- 51:27that uniform act, the appropriate defendant here
- 51:30would be the CDTFA versus going to each of the
- 51:32localities and suing them for the refund. But
- 51:35of course, the localities are real parties in
- 51:37interest, so they intervened and were allowed
- 51:39to intervene in the lawsuit. And so taxpayers
- 51:43sues the CDTFA for a refund on the local portion
- 51:46of the sales tax. And the taxpayer's theory was
- 51:49that while the state statute authorized the tax,
- 51:53the increase of the tax from 25 % to 100%, it
- 51:56did not actually impose the tax. and that under
- 51:59California statutory law, local governments who
- 52:04wish to implement the higher tax are required
- 52:07to seek voter approval under Proposition 62,
- 52:10which is a ballot measure. They're required to
- 52:12seek local voter approval in order to impose
- 52:16that tax. And it's not disputed here that the
- 52:19seven counties at issue, which were all located
- 52:21in jurisdictions where there was significant
- 52:24airports and significant sales of jet fuel, It
- 52:27was undisputed that none of these counties had
- 52:31even adopted it. Well, except I think that there
- 52:34was one county that adopted an ordinance, but
- 52:36it wasn't subject to voter approval. The remaining
- 52:38counties didn't even adopt an ordinance. They
- 52:40just started collecting the tax on 100%. So the
- 52:44trial court agreed with Southwest and said that
- 52:48this was an overreach by the localities. They
- 52:52should have subjected it to voter approval. But
- 52:55the Court of Appeal reversed. And the Court of
- 52:57Appeal reversed and essentially said that this
- 53:01wasn't really a tax increase because it didn't
- 53:05really increase the base of tax because the same
- 53:09group of people were still being taxed and that
- 53:12the disallowance of an exemption really wasn't
- 53:17an increase in tax, which is... Not the law,
- 53:21it's contrary to case law, but the Court of Appeal,
- 53:25of course I'm editorializing here, the Court
- 53:28of Appeal did in fact reverse and the California
- 53:31Supreme Court denied review in this case. And
- 53:34so that's kind of where this case ended up. And
- 53:38so we'll see if there's any more to come on the
- 53:40Southwest case. But again, what's interesting,
- 53:42voter approval. I thought that this case, especially
- 53:46with the trial court win and with the issue of
- 53:48voter approval at stake, I didn't think the court
- 53:51of appeal would disturb it, but they went ahead
- 53:52and they reversed, which was interesting. So
- 53:57in the last few minutes that we have here, I
- 54:02will say that winning tax cases and presenting
- 54:06tax cases successfully against California taxing
- 54:10agencies requires Really three different things.
- 54:14You have to know, of course, the underlying law
- 54:16and the facts of your case. You have to understand
- 54:19the intricacies of tax procedure so that you
- 54:23can choose the proper causes of action, maneuver
- 54:26as appropriate through the administrative and
- 54:28judicial process, and be able to get the outcome
- 54:32that your clients want. Sometimes your clients
- 54:36want to resolve an issue as quickly as possible,
- 54:40get the best result as quickly as possible. And
- 54:43then other times, if the state is being unreasonable
- 54:46in terms of offering settlements and so forth,
- 54:49or taking really aggressive positions, sometimes
- 54:52your clients want to be able to go the distance
- 54:54and they want to be able to go and do that as
- 54:57efficiently as possible. And so understanding
- 55:01the procedures is really key. The third thing
- 55:04I would say is you need to be really undeterred
- 55:07by the length and the difficulty of the process.
- 55:11You can see these cases take time. I mean, some
- 55:13of these cases, the tax periods go back a decade
- 55:15or more and you have a very robust administrative
- 55:19process that is a precursor to the litigation.
- 55:24So you could be at the Franchise Tax Board at
- 55:26the CDTFA and the Office of Tax Appeals. for
- 55:30four, five, six, seven, eight years. Some cases,
- 55:33depending on what remedies are pursued, can be
- 55:37at the administrative level 10 years or longer.
- 55:40You have to understand how to maneuver with that.
- 55:42How do you shortcut that process? And the concluding
- 55:47thought I will sort of leave you with, and we
- 55:50can take questions if there are any, is, Always
- 55:55be mindful of three things when you are litigating
- 55:58tax cases. Because of the length of the process,
- 56:02be mindful of managing costs. Be mindful of managing
- 56:06costs. Be mindful of managing risk and maintain
- 56:11optionality. Maintain as many procedural remedies
- 56:14and options as you can. A lot of times this is
- 56:17about being determined and knocking on as many
- 56:22doors as possible until you get the answer that
- 56:24you want. So with that, I will conclude. I will
- 56:28thank you for your time and attention. And if
- 56:30we have any questions, I'm happy to take those.
- 56:33It looks like we currently don't have any questions.
- 56:35So this concludes today's presentation. Thank
- 56:37you so much, Marty, for an excellent examination
- 56:41of recent cases. And thank you so much to our
- 56:43audience for joining us today. Have a great day,
- 56:45everybody. Thank you.