Latest / Change My Relationship / What Is Causing the Epidemic of Parental Estrangement?
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to an audio recording by Change My Relationship, featuring
- 0:04licensed marriage and family therapist and author Karla Downing.
- 0:08These audios are designed to provide you with practical solutions
- 0:11based on biblical truths for all your relationships.
- 0:18What are the causes of the epidemic
- 0:23of parental alienation?
- 0:27It is becoming more
- 0:28and more common to hear stories of parents
- 0:32who have been cut off by their children
- 0:36and aren't, and they're unable to see their grandchildren.
- 0:40The stories are heart wrenching.
- 0:44Those that have never met their grandchildren,
- 0:47those that have taken care of their grandchildren,
- 0:50even giving their time to help raise a grandchild.
- 0:56And then that child grandchild is just ripped away.
- 1:00Or parents that for no reason
- 1:02at all are cut out of their child's life.
- 1:06And it is.
- 1:07I just I could go on and on with stories and it is just
- 1:12really, really hard.
- 1:15If you're in that situation to understand what in the world has caused this
- 1:20and it is a cultural shift,
- 1:22it is more and more common in cultures
- 1:27where some of these following things are present.
- 1:32The first thing is a lot of our children in their 20s,
- 1:3630s, 40s have been raised in a therapy culture.
- 1:42They know a lot about relationships.
- 1:46They know a lot about boundaries.
- 1:48They've seen a therapist.
- 1:50They are encouraged to talk about the dysfunction that they were raised with.
- 1:56And I was raised in really bad dysfunction.
- 2:00I raised my children in really bad dysfunction.
- 2:04And I am a therapist, and I teach classes to help people
- 2:08navigate dysfunctional relationships.
- 2:11I also teach classes on healing the wounds of your past,
- 2:14which looks at how you've been wounded by dysfunctional relationships, toxic
- 2:19relationships, and looking at the truth about what you've also done.
- 2:23I teach classes on boundaries, so lots of things.
- 2:26I get it.
- 2:26I'm not saying that there's anything wrong with understanding relationships,
- 2:30but identifying what's And there isn't anything wrong with setting boundaries.
- 2:35I teach people how to set boundaries,
- 2:38but when you are raised in a therapy culture
- 2:42and you are told
- 2:45that you can set boundaries with people who are unhealthy for you
- 2:51or who are, add stress to your life or complications to your life
- 2:57when it is not given in a balance and it's all that you've been raised with.
- 3:03It can get tweaked in your life when it is mixed with some other factors.
- 3:11And so I can come back to that a little bit, or kind of
- 3:13weave that in with the other factors that I'm going to bring up.
- 3:19The second one is entitlement.
- 3:22A lot of the 20, 30s and 40 something kids
- 3:26have been raised in a culture where they are
- 3:31feel very, very entitled, entitled to their happiness,
- 3:35entitled to an easy life, entitled to provision,
- 3:40entitled to support,
- 3:43entitled to whatever it is that they want.
- 3:47And some of those will demand that from their parents.
- 3:51Some of those will cut off their parents when their parents
- 3:55don't give that to them.
- 3:57Some of them will expect their parents just to be at their beck and call
- 4:02and do anything that they demand.
- 4:05And if they don't, they'll cut them off.
- 4:08Some of
- 4:09those will even cut off their parents, because their parents have offered them
- 4:12some type of financial support.
- 4:15And for years and years.
- 4:18And then finally, the parents say
- 4:20that I can't do this anymore or I'm not willing to do this anymore.
- 4:24And then in retaliation or in anger, they'll cut their parents off.
- 4:28I have had unbelievable things told to me, things
- 4:31where kids have asked their parents for all of their retirement money.
- 4:37These parents are not rich.
- 4:38These parents don't have much.
- 4:40And yet the kids who've mismanaged finances
- 4:43expect their parents to give them their savings
- 4:46so that they can bail themselves out, or so that they can.
- 4:50Maybe a son can make things better for his wife and his children,
- 4:54and there's no regard for the parent's right
- 4:58to that money, or the parent's right to take care of themselves.
- 5:02I've had people who have, been told, or a mom or a dad or both
- 5:07that have been told that we expect you to give us your house,
- 5:11or it's time for you to sell your house and move out of your house.
- 5:14You don't need that anymore, and you need to give us your house.
- 5:17Meaning us, the child and the spouse.
- 5:20Maybe the grandchildren.
- 5:21The audacity to not only ask and bring that up, but to demand it.
- 5:29I have had an attorney tell me that he more and more of the cases
- 5:34that they deal with in estate law is protecting the parents’ estate
- 5:40from the children while the parents are still alive.
- 5:44In other words, the children are trying to get their parents money
- 5:47while the parents are still alive, before the parents are willing
- 5:51to give it to them.
- 5:52That is a definite sign
- 5:55of a huge cultural shift that we're dealing with.
- 5:58I have to tell you that a lot of the stories
- 6:01that the heartbreaking stories that have been presented to me
- 6:05in these kids that cut parents off
- 6:08or a parent off have been single moms
- 6:11who have literally given their lives to raising these kids.
- 6:15Who said, I sacrificed everything to give my child
- 6:20everything, and now I'm literally discarded
- 6:25for something minor or I can't do it anymore.
- 6:29I'm not working, and now I need to take care of myself or whatever that is.
- 6:34And now this child is doing the OP is throwing the parent away.
- 6:38That's worked so hard for them without even
- 6:42acknowledging or respecting the fact that the parent has worked that hard,
- 6:46but they have instead become incredibly entitled because of that.
- 6:52The other is cultural relativism.
- 6:55What is that?
- 6:56That is basically sometimes you long ago, you used to hear it called humanism.
- 7:01It's just basically the idea that there's no God, there's no right or wrong.
- 7:05And it means that anything that you believe,
- 7:09anything that you feel is right for you and no one else can judge you.
- 7:14No one else can say that this is better than the other.
- 7:18So when you and in the public schools raise
- 7:23or teach moral relativism, they teach anti-God, right?
- 7:27And they teach that you can do no wrong and you get to decide and all of that.
- 7:34And it's been going on for, something like at least 40 years.
- 7:38But even more in the last 20 to 30 years
- 7:42to where kids are really brought up in a very
- 7:46anti-God, especially in the last, I should say,
- 7:49maybe 20 years and getting worse all the time.
- 7:53A very anti-God curriculum and a very anti-God stance.
- 7:58And when you're teaching that there's no right or wrong
- 8:02because, humans are animals and we're just,
- 8:06another animal and
- 8:10the whole idea that you can do
- 8:11anything you want and no one can judge you.
- 8:14So discarding your parent is not wrong.
- 8:19And keeping your parent in your life is not wrong or right.
- 8:25Either one.
- 8:26You get to decide what feels good for you,
- 8:28what is better for you, what makes your life easier?
- 8:33And again, this whole idea
- 8:35that you don't have to have stress and you don't have to,
- 8:38have to struggle with things and people that bother you and people
- 8:43that are annoying, whatever that is that you get to decide for you what's best.
- 8:48Cultural relativism means that
- 8:51God is not going to judge you for what you need to do.
- 8:56The other is, materialism
- 8:59we have raised in Western society these last generations.
- 9:04Think of what they have been raised with.
- 9:07When you're raised with
- 9:09videos at your fingertips, when you have
- 9:11cell phones, when you have
- 9:15all kinds of information, when you're given, even kids
- 9:18that don't have money come to school in shoes
- 9:22that are often name, brand and name brand clothing.
- 9:27And we have, very high
- 9:31I shouldn't even say that because I cannot speak.
- 9:34I have not lived in poverty, but we have over
- 9:39given over provided for our children.
- 9:44It is very common for parents in my circle
- 9:49for to be paying for adult children's cell phones.
- 9:52It's very common now for parents,
- 9:56especially boomers, to give their kids
- 10:00a lot of money to help their kids.
- 10:03And I'm not saying that that's wrong.
- 10:07I think that part of it
- 10:09comes from a very real phenomenon, and that is that it's very it's harder
- 10:15for our kids to make it in life
- 10:19where our, our my parents,
- 10:21one could work and buy a single family home
- 10:25and now two working cannot buy a single family home
- 10:29and parents in later in older generations
- 10:33have accumulated more money and wealth and can help their children.
- 10:37And so they often choose to provide and, help their children.
- 10:42But if it's not done in the right way and you do that with kids that do not have
- 10:48good habits and they are not respectful
- 10:50and they, are taking it wrong, it can turn into entitlement.
- 10:55And when parents say no, then all of a sudden when you expect
- 11:02and you don't get it
- 11:04with a lack of of moral values
- 11:08and with a feeling of entitlement and the therapy generation where you are
- 11:14told that you can cut someone off who does something to you that's hurtful,
- 11:19or, where, you can have boundaries to protect yourself.
- 11:23It all comes together and it ends up being
- 11:26and a huge amount of cut off
- 11:30that is incredibly painful.
- 11:34I mentioned respect.
- 11:36I think one of the main causes of
- 11:39this is a loss of respect overall
- 11:43in Western culture, Western civilization,
- 11:47there is a lack of respect for authority, whether that be
- 11:52the police or
- 11:55whether it be the church, or whether it be institutions
- 12:00or the family,
- 12:03any of those there is a lack of a respect.
- 12:07Respect means to honor.
- 12:10Respect means to
- 12:12treat somebody in that position
- 12:15according to how they should be treated.
- 12:19Now, kids for quite a while
- 12:22have looked at themselves as equal to their parents.
- 12:27So it's that your parent isn't the one that can tell you what to do.
- 12:32Your parent isn't the one who has authority over you.
- 12:35It's like you are equal to your parents.
- 12:39That's the perception.
- 12:41And very clearly, scripturally,
- 12:46God has said that there is to be respect in all relationships.
- 12:50You are to respect your elders.
- 12:52You are to respect your
- 12:56parents. You are to respect.
- 12:58I should say you're ever to to respect church authority.
- 13:02You are to respect which scripturally that talks
- 13:04about the elders, the deacons and the, shepherds or the pastors.
- 13:09You are to respect your husband.
- 13:12You are to respect the husbands, are to respect wives.
- 13:15Parents are to respect children and treat them accordingly, and treat them
- 13:20not in a way that provokes them to wrath, but children are to respect parents.
- 13:26And we are to respect each other.
- 13:28Bible even talks about
- 13:31that in that culture, not condoning slavery.
- 13:34But back in that culture, there were slaves and they were slave
- 13:38holders.
- 13:38And that says they are to both respect each other.
- 13:42A God wants respect in everywhere, in every relationship.
- 13:45I think that can apply also to employers,
- 13:48to employees mutual respect.
- 13:51Respect means that
- 13:53we would not treat someone in a way that
- 13:59is not reflective of who they are.
- 14:01My father in law was a narcissist
- 14:06and was actually harmful to me and my husband's marriage.
- 14:10But back in the in that context, of course,
- 14:12I didn't know that much about boundaries or dysfunctional relationship.
- 14:16Some that never at all did we think that we could
- 14:22choose to withhold our grandchildren, his grandchildren, from him.
- 14:26We still felt that even though he had done things to hurt us
- 14:29and that we, ended up having a break in the relationship with him,
- 14:33that if he wanted to see our kids, we should let them see the kids. And,
- 14:39actually, the break was
- 14:40was more initiated by him rather than us.
- 14:45So it wasn't even something
- 14:47that we had decided to do and would not have done.
- 14:51So when I think about that amount of respect,
- 14:54when I think about my parents, like my parents were not abusive,
- 14:59I was when I was an adult, my dad quit drinking when I was 17
- 15:03so that alcoholism wasn't involved in the family,
- 15:07but I was respectful
- 15:09in how I talk to my dad about the past and also
- 15:14how I talked to him about problems that he still had.
- 15:19I mean, he would sometimes loses temper some.
- 15:21He was still, be not always calm, especially with my mom.
- 15:27But when I talk to him, I always it always reflected the fact that he was my dad.
- 15:33And there were so many good things about him.
- 15:37So I interacted with him in a certain way.
- 15:41And the same thing with my mom and all of our parents have annoying
- 15:46characteristics.
- 15:47There are things about them that are annoying
- 15:50that are as they get older, they're things that are difficult.
- 15:53The things that we don't like and yet
- 15:57we process through the past.
- 15:59I went through to therapy.
- 16:01Did I think about blaming my parents?
- 16:03No. I understood that they had problems and that they did
- 16:06the best they could to deal with them.
- 16:09But at the same time, I knew that it was my responsibility
- 16:12to deal with my baggage that I had, even from my childhood.
- 16:15Now, do I think that there's a time to cut off your parents?
- 16:19Because it's. Absolutely.
- 16:21But it is a last resort.
- 16:24It is only when you have done everything you can,
- 16:28and the problems in the relationship
- 16:31are truly hurting you and your family, not
- 16:36bothering you, not
- 16:39something that you idiosyncrasies or annoying little habits.
- 16:43It literally has to be harm.
- 16:46Toxic means to cause harm.
- 16:47There has to be damage, not just your inconvenience.
- 16:52Not that they don't give you your way.
- 16:54Not that there's something that they said that that upset you.
- 16:59We are to go.
- 17:00According to Matthew 18 to, the person that we think is doing something wrong,
- 17:05we are to go to them and we are to talk to them.
- 17:10We are to be willing to go.
- 17:15Galatians 6:1.
- 17:16In a spirit of humility, knowing that we ourselves are not perfect,
- 17:22so we have a obligation to make an effort
- 17:27to try to resolve differences in all of our relationships.
- 17:31That's, Romans 12.
- 17:32I believe it's 18, says in far is as far as it is
- 17:38possible for you
- 17:41to make peace in all your relationships,
- 17:45to work things out, to attempt to work things out.
- 17:48Where, to be honest, were to be truthful, were to speak the truth in love.
- 17:52We need to have a good deal of willingness
- 17:59to attempt to reconcile and attempt to work things out,
- 18:05if not just for our parents,
- 18:08but for ourselves, because cut off leaves you.
- 18:11It's not like you just cut off and you're done.
- 18:14When you cut off, there is an emotional ties that still hold
- 18:20you and those emotional ties and that cut off affects your heart,
- 18:26and it affects your life and it affects you.
- 18:29So thinking that you're just cutting your parents off
- 18:33and not caring, even if you harden your heart,
- 18:36even if you say, I'm not going to think about this,
- 18:40there is something that goes on inside of you.
- 18:42There are still ties that bind you with your parents,
- 18:46and it has to be a very carefully
- 18:49thought out, very carefully
- 18:54made decision when you really have to.
- 19:00And then I would say, there are so many times
- 19:02that, again, this is done without letting your parents know
- 19:07if what is going on you have there needs to be an attempt.
- 19:11And again, with the respect back to respect,
- 19:15if there is respect and there is the feeling
- 19:18of recognizing obligation, then you will attempt to do that.
- 19:22Now if you've if there truly is harm and done, everything you possibly can do
- 19:29and there still is no resolve, and you let them know what needs to change
- 19:34in order for their relationship to continue.
- 19:38Then at that point, if it truly is harmful and there is no change
- 19:44and you have to protect yourself or your family, I mean, truly protect
- 19:49not just because a parent doesn't do what you want,
- 19:52then that is something that you can do.
- 19:56But it has to be because
- 19:58there is something substantial and not something
- 20:03that is minor.
- 20:06So what causes the epidemic of parental alienation?
- 20:10For those of you that are affected by this, and your hearts are breaking
- 20:17the therapy culture, which
- 20:18has our kids have been raised with, that are just
- 20:23telling them so much about
- 20:25and and I'm not again, at the, boy, I sound not like a good counselor.
- 20:29This is all very, very good, but it must be done in a balance.
- 20:35Entitlement.
- 20:37I'm owed happiness and everything I want to.
- 20:39If I don't get it, I can just cut people off
- 20:43a cultural relativism.
- 20:46There's no right or wrong materialism
- 20:50been just over given
- 20:52so many material goods
- 20:56that they think they deserve it and they demand it.
- 21:00And then the loss of respect for all institutions, including the family
- 21:05and including parents, and including God and the church.
- 21:10So hopefully this will give you a better understanding of what's going on.
- 21:14Doesn't give you any way to fix it necessarily.
- 21:17That's for another video and for others that are talking about that.
- 21:22But I just hope that this gives you some
- 21:26peace by at least understanding.
- 21:29So God bless you.
- 21:30Please check out my website and all of my resources.
- 21:35God bless.
- 21:36Thank you for listening to Change My Relationship.
- 21:39We hope you will subscribe to these podcasts and share them with your friends.
- 21:43Karla would love to hear from you.
- 21:45She welcomes ideas for a future podcast, as well as your feedback
- 21:49on how the podcasts have helped your life and relationships.
- 21:53You can email her at.
- 21:54karla@changemyrelationship.com
- 21:58For more information on Change My Relationship and Karla
- 22:01Downing's ministry, including her books, studies, devotionals, podcasts
- 22:06and YouTube videos visit changemyrelationship.com.