Latest / The NanceCast / Chris Cutrone vs Superegoic, Capitalistic AI!!!
Transcript
- 0:23SPEAKER_01: And here we are, folks.
- 0:25SPEAKER_01: How's everybody doing?
- 0:26SPEAKER_01: Welcome back to the DanceCast.
- 0:28SPEAKER_01: Mikey and I are here.
- 0:31SPEAKER_01: And we are joined by Mr. Cold Chris Catrone.
- 0:37SPEAKER_01: We're going to enter the zone.
- 0:40SPEAKER_01: Lots of questions.
- 0:40We've been spending a lot of time talking about artificial
- 0:44intelligence and doing
- 0:47SPEAKER_01: some,
- 0:47SPEAKER_01: like,
- 0:47SPEAKER_01: Zhezekian,
- 0:48SPEAKER_01: Lacanian stuff.
- 0:49SPEAKER_01: And there have been some people in the comments...
- 0:53SPEAKER_01: talking about Marxism and asking questions.
- 0:57SPEAKER_01: And yes, Marxism is very important.
- 0:59SPEAKER_01: I do consider myself some stripe of Marxist,
- 1:02SPEAKER_01: even though I would be accused of being a charlatan by many Marxists.
- 1:09But there just hasn't been an awful lot of really meaty Marxist
- 1:12dialogue going on here recently.
- 1:15SPEAKER_01: So we figured let's correct that and who better to do so
- 1:21SPEAKER_01: The last Marxist.
- 1:22SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:23SPEAKER_00: The last Marxist.
- 1:26SPEAKER_01: So we, you know, hopefully it'll be a great conversation.
- 1:29SPEAKER_01: Before we jump into it, Mikey, what's up?
- 1:31SPEAKER_01: What are your thoughts?
- 1:32SPEAKER_01: What do you got going on?
- 1:34I am just really excited to have the opportunity to have this
- 1:37conversation.
- 1:38SPEAKER_03: This is one I've been wanting to have for a long time.
- 1:40SPEAKER_03: And, you know, it just it finally worked out.
- 1:44SPEAKER_03: And so,
- 1:44SPEAKER_03: yeah,
- 1:45SPEAKER_03: I mean,
- 1:45SPEAKER_03: in a sense,
- 1:46SPEAKER_03: Chris,
- 1:47SPEAKER_03: both Nance and I have been dialoguing with you about AI for the last six,
- 1:51SPEAKER_03: seven months or so,
- 1:53SPEAKER_03: even though we haven't had a actual conversation about it.
- 1:56SPEAKER_03: So yeah, it's just great to have you here.
- 1:58SPEAKER_03: And, uh, I'm really thrilled to get into this.
- 2:03SPEAKER_01: Great.
- 2:05SPEAKER_01: So I think the first,
- 2:06SPEAKER_01: I don't know,
- 2:06SPEAKER_01: maybe the first question would be,
- 2:09SPEAKER_01: um,
- 2:10SPEAKER_01: should,
- 2:10SPEAKER_01: should we,
- 2:11SPEAKER_01: uh,
- 2:12SPEAKER_01: be concerned with AI and AGI?
- 2:16SPEAKER_01: Is it as radical as everyone seems to be saying it is?
- 2:19SPEAKER_01: Or is it maybe not more of the exactly the same,
- 2:24but will the forces of capital continue to be what they are and
- 2:31what they have
- 2:32SPEAKER_01: been?
- 2:32SPEAKER_01: Or is AI really upsetting to what's going on?
- 2:40SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 2:40So it seems like the second Trump administration seems to be
- 2:45betting a lot on AI.
- 2:48SPEAKER_00: So in terms of prospects of a Trump boom,
- 2:53SPEAKER_00: economic prosperity,
- 2:57SPEAKER_00: we're immediately faced with the prospect of an AI bubble.
- 3:01And whether we're experiencing an AI bubble or are we not
- 3:04experiencing an AI
- 3:05SPEAKER_00: bubble,
- 3:06SPEAKER_00: is there real value behind it or not?
- 3:09SPEAKER_00: And so I think that that's why it's pertinent in a way now,
- 3:14SPEAKER_00: like literally like right now,
- 3:17rather than as it's been kind of in the background for the last
- 3:21several years.
- 3:23SPEAKER_00: is that they're now trying to build out these data centers.
- 3:27SPEAKER_00: And I think that they've even,
- 3:30SPEAKER_00: Trump administration officials have said,
- 3:32SPEAKER_00: well,
- 3:34there's at least the jobs that are produced by building out
- 3:36these data centers,
- 3:39SPEAKER_00: these server farms.
- 3:43SPEAKER_00: And so it's a curious thing.
- 3:45SPEAKER_00: So of course the threat of AI is the threat of any kind of automation.
- 3:50SPEAKER_00: And that is that it will put people out of work.
- 3:53SPEAKER_00: And what's different about AI,
- 3:56SPEAKER_00: it seems,
- 3:56than past waves of automation is that past waves of automation
- 4:00have been about
- 4:01SPEAKER_00: putting manual laborers out of work,
- 4:04SPEAKER_00: whereas this is about putting intellectual laborers out of work.
- 4:09SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 4:10SPEAKER_00: So just that old distinction between manual and intellectual labor,
- 4:15that this seems like a form of automation that will affect
- 4:20intellectual labor.
- 4:21SPEAKER_00: And so neoliberalism,
- 4:23SPEAKER_00: the last like my lifetime,
- 4:25SPEAKER_00: basically,
- 4:26SPEAKER_00: was a shift from manufacturing to service sector and information economy.
- 4:34And so the idea that automation could now affect the service
- 4:39sector and the
- 4:41SPEAKER_00: information economy.
- 4:45That's the thing that I think makes this wave of automation
- 4:49different because I do,
- 4:50SPEAKER_00: I will say that I look at AI,
- 4:53SPEAKER_00: I think the term is a little bit of a misnomer.
- 4:58SPEAKER_00: Like large language models, machine learning
- 5:02SPEAKER_00: You know, that it's about automating intellectual labor.
- 5:07SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 5:08SPEAKER_00: Now, AGI is something else.
- 5:10That's like the idea that,
- 5:12you know,
- 5:13you'll have actual synthetic intelligence.
- 5:17SPEAKER_00: That isn't just automation anymore, but that is more creative.
- 5:24So if we have the like the robots and sweatshops model where
- 5:29like we are kind of
- 5:31SPEAKER_01: relying on the services and the intellectual labor.
- 5:35But if we automate the intellectual labor and everyone is kind
- 5:39of like a embattled
- 5:41SPEAKER_01: gig worker,
- 5:41SPEAKER_01: then.
- 5:45I think for me,
- 5:46the question is,
- 5:47well,
- 5:47what do we do about political power?
- 5:49SPEAKER_01: Is there a way to organize this kind of like fractal sweatshop force?
- 5:55SPEAKER_01: Can they be welded together into some type of historical subject,
- 6:01SPEAKER_01: like much less a historical force?
- 6:06SPEAKER_01: And I don't know.
- 6:07SPEAKER_01: I think the answer to that is probably not.
- 6:10SPEAKER_01: And that's really scary.
- 6:15SPEAKER_00: I'll make mention of something.
- 6:16SPEAKER_00: So, you know, Benjamin Studebaker, I think.
- 6:20SPEAKER_00: All right.
- 6:21SPEAKER_00: So he has been keying into some of my own writings.
- 6:25SPEAKER_00: And, you know, I teaching the millennial left Marxism.
- 6:31SPEAKER_00: I introduced, I dusted off some language that had fallen into disuse.
- 6:35SPEAKER_00: So people are aware of concepts like means of production.
- 6:40SPEAKER_00: But there's also a concept that Marx concept of means of consumption.
- 6:46SPEAKER_00: And,
- 6:46SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 6:47SPEAKER_00: so the idea that it's not just a matter of means of production,
- 6:51SPEAKER_00: it might also be a matter of means of consumption.
- 6:54So what Studebaker raised was he's got the schema of early,
- 6:58middle and late capitalism.
- 7:00That early capitalism is about producer politics and a late
- 7:05capitalism would be
- 7:06SPEAKER_00: about consumer politics,
- 7:08SPEAKER_00: but we're not there yet.
- 7:10SPEAKER_00: And so we're in middle capitalism where we are
- 7:15SPEAKER_00: too far along to continue to do producer politics,
- 7:19but we're not yet far enough along to really be able to do
- 7:22consumer politics.
- 7:24So we have to sort of resign ourselves to being in middle
- 7:28capitalism for the foreseeable future.
- 7:30So even though there are suggestions of the possibility of
- 7:33consumer politics and
- 7:36SPEAKER_00: there are clear indications of the obsolescence of producer politics,
- 7:40SPEAKER_00: we haven't really made the transition yet.
- 7:43SPEAKER_00: So I think that that's
- 7:46one thing that immediately comes to mind is when we're thinking
- 7:49about the politics
- 7:51of it are we really just talking about the politics of
- 7:55consuming ai's products how
- 8:04does that hold up like is is capitalism um all about class
- 8:11antagonism or is
- 8:12SPEAKER_01: capitalism about the circuit of capital is it about
- 8:18SPEAKER_01: like taking money going through this process commodity back to,
- 8:25SPEAKER_01: to more money,
- 8:26SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 8:27SPEAKER_01: uh,
- 8:28SPEAKER_01: or is it just about the workers,
- 8:30SPEAKER_01: the owners,
- 8:31SPEAKER_01: the rulers,
- 8:32SPEAKER_01: the priests?
- 8:34SPEAKER_01: Um, I, I don't know.
- 8:36SPEAKER_01: What's your take on that?
- 8:37SPEAKER_03: Like, how do you add one thing to that question?
- 8:40SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 8:40Cause recently I was talking to Swole the Terry at our,
- 8:43our friend and,
- 8:44uh,
- 8:45SPEAKER_03: We were discussing your take on capitalism,
- 8:48SPEAKER_03: and he was like,
- 8:49SPEAKER_03: look,
- 8:49SPEAKER_03: for Chris,
- 8:51SPEAKER_03: MCM Prime is bourgeois society.
- 8:53SPEAKER_03: It's not capital.
- 8:56And this is interesting to me because,
- 8:58of course,
- 8:59Marx defines that as the formula of capital.
- 9:02SPEAKER_03: But I'm curious,
- 9:03SPEAKER_03: like,
- 9:04SPEAKER_03: if MCM Prime is bourgeois society and not capital,
- 9:08SPEAKER_03: then how do you define capital?
- 9:12SPEAKER_00: Well, it would be a crisis of that circuit.
- 9:15SPEAKER_00: It would be a contradiction of that circuit.
- 9:16It would be the self-contradiction of that growth that's
- 9:20involved in MM Prime.
- 9:22SPEAKER_00: Yanis Varoufakis, interestingly, he was speaking to...
- 9:31SPEAKER_00: It was some kind of very mainstream business economics kind of forum.
- 9:37SPEAKER_00: And he said,
- 9:38SPEAKER_00: because they were talking about techno feudalism,
- 9:40SPEAKER_00: and he said,
- 9:42SPEAKER_00: look,
- 9:44capitalism is not the market because the market has existed as
- 9:50long as we can trace
- 9:51SPEAKER_00: it back,
- 9:52SPEAKER_00: human community back.
- 9:54SPEAKER_00: It's not profitability either.
- 9:57SPEAKER_00: Because profitability is just trying to get more out than you put in.
- 10:02SPEAKER_00: And you could say that tool making is driven by profitability.
- 10:08SPEAKER_00: And not only that,
- 10:09SPEAKER_00: but maybe organic life itself is based on profitability,
- 10:13SPEAKER_00: meaning out than you put in.
- 10:17SPEAKER_00: And so it's really not that can't define capitalism.
- 10:22SPEAKER_00: So capitalism is not just growth.
- 10:26It's a form of growth,
- 10:29and it's also a self-contradictory form of growth.
- 10:33SPEAKER_00: Or a self-undermining, self-destructive form of growth.
- 10:37SPEAKER_00: Self-destructive form of growth,
- 10:38SPEAKER_00: meaning not just destroying other things,
- 10:41SPEAKER_00: because again,
- 10:42SPEAKER_00: that would be inherent in organic life,
- 10:44SPEAKER_00: or maybe in any kind of human community whatsoever,
- 10:47SPEAKER_00: or maybe freedom itself,
- 10:49SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 10:49SPEAKER_00: destroys.
- 10:51SPEAKER_00: No, but it's not just a self-
- 10:57contradictory form of growth but actually a self-destructive
- 11:00form of growth and a
- 11:02contradictory form of growth in that respect that it undermines
- 11:05itself and
- 11:07undermines itself which is a little bit different we tend to
- 11:09have this kind of
- 11:11humanistic critique of capitalism uh you know also some
- 11:15language that marx uses in
- 11:16the grundrissa where um capital undermines its own foundation
- 11:22human labor and
- 11:23SPEAKER_00: nature and it's like but you know
- 11:27SPEAKER_00: That might be, but that's also not unique to Marx.
- 11:31SPEAKER_00: There are other people who have thought about capitalism that way,
- 11:36SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 11:36SPEAKER_00: like Polanyi or Max Weber.
- 11:39SPEAKER_00: And so it's got to be something else.
- 11:44SPEAKER_00: And, you know, a self-undermining form of production.
- 11:51SPEAKER_00: But the way I understand MCM Prime as the formula for capital,
- 11:57SPEAKER_00: Then the issue is, and how does capital destroy itself?
- 12:02SPEAKER_00: Because that's actually Marx's point.
- 12:04SPEAKER_00: It's an accumulation crisis.
- 12:11What indicates the possibility and necessity of getting beyond
- 12:14capitalism is that
- 12:15SPEAKER_00: it's self-destructive.
- 12:19Not just destructive of other things like the environment or
- 12:22humans or whatever you
- 12:23SPEAKER_00: want to say it's destructive of.
- 12:26Because again,
- 12:26you could say human culture itself is destructive of humans.
- 12:34SPEAKER_00: That basic Rousseauian trade-off.
- 12:37As soon as we enter into a cultural or social community as
- 12:43opposed to a natural
- 12:44SPEAKER_00: community,
- 12:45SPEAKER_00: it seems to be at the expense of the Homo sapiens.
- 12:50SPEAKER_00: You know, let me, um, so that's the way that I put it.
- 12:53SPEAKER_03: What a defining feature of capital,
- 12:57SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 12:57or at least capitalism for you be the commodification of human
- 13:01labor power.
- 13:04Well,
- 13:04again,
- 13:04I would,
- 13:05I would consider that to be like the bourgeois social relation.
- 13:09SPEAKER_00: Um, uh, yeah, because again, commodification is,
- 13:13I was just talking earlier today with the Platypus kids and we
- 13:16were talking about
- 13:17SPEAKER_00: Lukács's reification.
- 13:18SPEAKER_00: It's what's next up on the reading group syllabus.
- 13:21SPEAKER_00: And again,
- 13:22SPEAKER_00: it's kind of like,
- 13:23SPEAKER_00: well,
- 13:23there's a romantic critique of capitalism that says capitalism
- 13:27is commodifying and
- 13:28SPEAKER_00: it's alienating and it's reifying.
- 13:31That's all well and good,
- 13:32but really one needs a more dialectical approach to these
- 13:35things.
- 13:36namely that it's not commodification per se it's not alienation
- 13:40per se because
- 13:41again any any human social form is going to be alienated and
- 13:47it's not reification
- 13:49either necessarily um you know it's not just any
- 13:52externalization or objectification
- 13:55SPEAKER_00: or alienation
- 13:57So what we're dealing with is how actually capitalism is
- 14:03undermining the commodity form.
- 14:05SPEAKER_00: It's undermining commodity relations.
- 14:09SPEAKER_00: It's undermining a society based on commodity exchange.
- 14:15SPEAKER_00: It's destroying that.
- 14:18SPEAKER_00: And the old form of working class politics was to fight to restore that.
- 14:23SPEAKER_00: It was to preserve the value
- 14:27SPEAKER_00: enhance the value, realize the value of labor.
- 14:31SPEAKER_00: And in that respect,
- 14:33SPEAKER_00: again,
- 14:33SPEAKER_00: a lot of theorists,
- 14:35SPEAKER_00: not Marx,
- 14:36SPEAKER_00: but contemporaries and subsequent theorists,
- 14:39SPEAKER_00: were like,
- 14:39SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 14:40SPEAKER_00: the socialist movement's a little regressive.
- 14:42SPEAKER_00: Looks like they want to restore the old medieval guilds.
- 14:46SPEAKER_00: They want to kind of go back to artisanal production.
- 14:50SPEAKER_00: It's pretty regressive.
- 14:51SPEAKER_00: It seems kind of reactionary.
- 14:54SPEAKER_00: You know, socialism.
- 14:57And and of course,
- 14:58Marx did criticize reactionary socialism in those terms.
- 15:03And so the issue is not even though maybe necessarily workers
- 15:07will always try to
- 15:08SPEAKER_00: seek the value of their labor.
- 15:12you know,
- 15:13individually,
- 15:13certainly,
- 15:14and collectively also,
- 15:15and maybe politically.
- 15:17SPEAKER_00: Like, maybe that's what most people think of as, like, socialism.
- 15:21SPEAKER_00: It's like,
- 15:22SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 15:22SPEAKER_00: I was watching,
- 15:23SPEAKER_00: I will also say the All In guys,
- 15:25SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 15:25SPEAKER_00: the All In podcast,
- 15:26SPEAKER_00: the venture capitalists,
- 15:28SPEAKER_00: like the kind of tech bros or oligarch,
- 15:31SPEAKER_00: like the Friends of Elon,
- 15:33the people who were Democrats and are now kind of at least
- 15:36neutral towards Trump,
- 15:37SPEAKER_00: or maybe one of them is pro-Trump,
- 15:39SPEAKER_00: like David Sachs' cryptos are.
- 15:42And they might have had,
- 15:43I don't know if they had Mark Cuban,
- 15:45they had somebody on.
- 15:46And they were talking about like socialism and AI and
- 15:49automation and what happens
- 15:51SPEAKER_00: when,
- 15:52SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 15:52SPEAKER_00: everybody loses their job.
- 15:54SPEAKER_00: And one of them just said,
- 15:55SPEAKER_00: well,
- 15:56SPEAKER_00: we're going to have to find a way to exchange the value of our time.
- 16:02And I was like,
- 16:02these guys understand capitalism better than most Marxists.
- 16:08SPEAKER_00: You know?
- 16:10so i thought you know there you go right like that's what we're
- 16:14really talking
- 16:15about you know how are we because i think inevitably people
- 16:21will find a way of
- 16:23exchanging the value of their time and that's going to keep
- 16:27capitalism going right
- 16:37SPEAKER_01: That'll keep capitalism going.
- 16:39So it'll continue to be...
- 16:46It'll continue,
- 16:48but it will be radically transformed?
- 16:53SPEAKER_00: Concretely, it will have to be... It will take new forms.
- 16:56SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 16:57SPEAKER_00: in my lifetime,
- 16:58and maybe a little bit before the millennial left really
- 17:01arrived on the scene,
- 17:03SPEAKER_00: there was a lot of talk of immaterial labor.
- 17:05SPEAKER_02: Mm-hmm.
- 17:08SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 17:09SPEAKER_00: and it's kind of like,
- 17:10SPEAKER_00: well,
- 17:10SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 17:11SPEAKER_00: actually,
- 17:12SPEAKER_00: in a way,
- 17:13SPEAKER_00: labor has always been immaterial.
- 17:16SPEAKER_00: Meaning it's a social relation.
- 17:18SPEAKER_00: It's more of a metaphysics.
- 17:21SPEAKER_00: And,
- 17:21SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 17:21SPEAKER_00: capitalism sort of brings it home,
- 17:24SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 17:25SPEAKER_00: in certain ways,
- 17:26SPEAKER_00: meaning,
- 17:27SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 17:27SPEAKER_00: we suddenly discover that it's funny money.
- 17:30SPEAKER_00: You know, like maybe money doesn't really have, like, value.
- 17:34SPEAKER_00: You know, and that's been there since the beginning.
- 17:37SPEAKER_00: So it's always been a kind of dematerialized labor.
- 17:46SPEAKER_00: And so that affects concrete things.
- 17:49So Mikey and I were talking a little bit earlier about value
- 17:53form versus labor theory of value.
- 17:56And it I mean,
- 17:59it kind of sounds like that to me,
- 18:01my interpretation taking up the value form.
- 18:03SPEAKER_01: I think that's a point in favor of.
- 18:08value form kind of saying it's uh you know it's a social
- 18:12convention it's a social
- 18:13construct it is due to these social relations it's not
- 18:16necessarily due to the
- 18:18inherent value of labor as a substance or uh becoming
- 18:23substantialized in the
- 18:25commodity object um and so it does that just leave us with
- 18:34class antagonism until
- 18:35SPEAKER_01: the end of history
- 18:38SPEAKER_01: or until the end of the future.
- 18:39SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 18:39SPEAKER_00: the interesting thing...
- 18:41SPEAKER_00: Well,
- 18:42SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 18:43SPEAKER_00: we say that now,
- 18:44SPEAKER_00: except where is the class antagonism?
- 18:47SPEAKER_01: Yeah, where are the class?
- 18:49SPEAKER_01: Where is the class?
- 18:50SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 18:53SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 18:53SPEAKER_00: so that's the thing that...
- 18:56SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 18:56you could say that there are struggles over these
- 18:59concretizations of abstract
- 19:02SPEAKER_00: value.
- 19:05SPEAKER_00: Now, labor theory of value...
- 19:10SPEAKER_00: Value theory.
- 19:11Okay,
- 19:11so what Peter Hudes,
- 19:13Marxist humanist,
- 19:15I think formulated it a certain way many years ago.
- 19:20SPEAKER_00: And I think he was giving a presentation.
- 19:22SPEAKER_00: He said it's not a labor theory of value, it's a value theory of labor.
- 19:28SPEAKER_00: Right?
- 19:28SPEAKER_00: So it's not like a labor ontology.
- 19:32SPEAKER_00: It's more like how does value then create what labor is?
- 19:37SPEAKER_02: Mm-hmm.
- 19:41SPEAKER_00: And that's also more open-ended,
- 19:43SPEAKER_00: meaning then we don't have to worry about,
- 19:45SPEAKER_00: oh,
- 19:46SPEAKER_00: is it really like human labor power?
- 19:48SPEAKER_00: And if human labor power is being progressively eliminated,
- 19:51SPEAKER_00: then what happens to the labor theory of value?
- 19:54It's like,
- 19:54well,
- 19:55no,
- 19:55it's the value form that's going to tell us what labor is.
- 19:59SPEAKER_00: And we're going to be constantly investigating what can count as labor.
- 20:02We're going to constantly be pushing the frontiers of what can
- 20:09find value as labor.
- 20:13SPEAKER_03: You know, Nick Land, he wrote of the plasticity of labor power.
- 20:19SPEAKER_03: So basically, is that something we should maybe take seriously, right?
- 20:22Is that what counts as labor is not fixed across all historical
- 20:28epochs and different cultures.
- 20:31SPEAKER_03: Like the value form, like you said, will determine what counts as labor.
- 20:36SPEAKER_03: And so if that's the case, I guess my question would be something like,
- 20:42SPEAKER_03: If capitalism,
- 20:43SPEAKER_03: and this is a big if,
- 20:44but if capitalism as we know it automates the vast majority of
- 20:48wage labor away,
- 20:50SPEAKER_03: then is that system still capitalism?
- 20:57SPEAKER_00: Well, wage labor, right?
- 20:59SPEAKER_00: I mean, I think that that's the tricky part.
- 21:01SPEAKER_00: Like, what do we mean by wage labor?
- 21:02SPEAKER_00: You know, because wage labor is a relatively recent thing.
- 21:07SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 21:08SPEAKER_00: you saw instances of it across history,
- 21:10SPEAKER_00: but it's really kind of a,
- 21:13SPEAKER_00: I would say even like as late as this 18th century,
- 21:17SPEAKER_00: like 17th and 18th century is when you start getting real wage labor.
- 21:20SPEAKER_00: where people are working for wages rather than,
- 21:23SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 21:25SPEAKER_00: getting their subsistence needs met by an employer.
- 21:28SPEAKER_00: And, you know, so you're not paid like as a function of time.
- 21:31SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 21:32I always like to point out that Adam Smith is like advocating
- 21:37for paying people
- 21:39SPEAKER_00: according to time because he thinks it would result in a more efficient
- 21:47SPEAKER_00: exploitation of labor.
- 21:49you know,
- 21:49on the part of the worker and on the part of the proprietor,
- 21:53right?
- 21:54SPEAKER_00: That it should be measured in time, the value of labor.
- 21:58SPEAKER_00: It's kind of an ought rather than an is.
- 22:03SPEAKER_00: And again, we're so far down that highway that we might naturalize it.
- 22:09SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 22:10SPEAKER_00: time is money,
- 22:10SPEAKER_00: money is time,
- 22:13SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 22:13SPEAKER_00: and that kind of like this commonsensical way of thinking about things.
- 22:20And so I think that,
- 22:23you know,
- 22:23I'm not sure that we will get to the point.
- 22:24SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 22:25SPEAKER_00: to be kind of classical Marxist about it,
- 22:30SPEAKER_00: that there's a disparity between the means of production and the means of
- 22:38SPEAKER_00: appropriation.
- 22:42SPEAKER_00: And the means of production as means of subsistence.
- 22:45SPEAKER_00: So we can also include means of consumption.
- 22:49that the means of production and means of consumption the means
- 22:54of subsistence have
- 22:56at least potentially outstripped the means of appropriation and
- 23:00that's where the
- 23:00labor theory of value comes in it comes in at the level of okay
- 23:05but aren't we still
- 23:06trying to appropriate social production according to labor
- 23:12according to labor power
- 23:14SPEAKER_00: measured in time according to wages meaning
- 23:18can you really have capitalism without that in a way no but in
- 23:24another way well it
- 23:25all depends on how we measure that because whatever mid-20th
- 23:29century idea you know
- 23:31was sort of solidified around like wage labor whatever people
- 23:39are doing now like
- 23:41are uber drivers doing wage labor kind of pushing the boundary
- 23:45of wage labor
- 23:46you know they're not being paid hourly you know there's a kind
- 23:50of recrudescence of
- 23:51piece work you know especially in the gig economy right so
- 24:00you're not paid for time
- 24:01you're paid for the task and again like does that mean we've
- 24:08transcended wage labor
- 24:10SPEAKER_00: or have we regressed below wage labor is that what we've done
- 24:17I think that these are the questions that are raised and that
- 24:22might motivate us to
- 24:24SPEAKER_00: reconsider the framework.
- 24:27SPEAKER_00: What Marx has to say about these things.
- 24:31SPEAKER_00: We have to pay attention as to what's motivating us to reconsider.
- 24:36SPEAKER_00: What did this mean?
- 24:37SPEAKER_00: Like MCM Prime or the old socialist demand abolishing the wages system.
- 24:45SPEAKER_00: Whereas at another level,
- 24:46you could say the wages system is what the workers accomplished
- 24:49in their class
- 24:50SPEAKER_00: struggle.
- 24:51SPEAKER_00: They accomplished being paid a wage.
- 24:55SPEAKER_00: You know, being paid an hourly wage.
- 24:57SPEAKER_00: That was an accomplishment.
- 24:58SPEAKER_00: That they weren't like just slaves of their bosses.
- 25:01SPEAKER_00: That they weren't just doing piecework like misery.
- 25:06SPEAKER_00: And that we kind of lost that.
- 25:10right then the question is how would we how would we fight for
- 25:14that now or restore
- 25:16that and is that even the point yeah and i i think the the
- 25:23tendency to want to like
- 25:25techno feudalism like coming up with a new framework and people
- 25:30argue with it on
- 25:31SPEAKER_01: linguistic terms and but it does feel like um
- 25:39SPEAKER_01: Something has changed already.
- 25:41SPEAKER_01: And just sticking with bog standard ideas of...
- 25:49SPEAKER_01: I don't even know political power,
- 25:50SPEAKER_01: I guess,
- 25:50because I think it ultimately does come back to the question of
- 25:54political power.
- 25:55SPEAKER_01: And like, do we have access?
- 25:57SPEAKER_01: Can we have access to political power?
- 26:00SPEAKER_01: How do these things affect us?
- 26:02SPEAKER_01: If we're all 300 million scattered individual sole proprietors working,
- 26:08SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 26:09SPEAKER_01: on a piecework basis,
- 26:10SPEAKER_01: can we see recognize that we share the same plight in this and that?
- 26:16SPEAKER_01: So there's a want to say, no, it is different.
- 26:20But in a sense,
- 26:22it also feels like,
- 26:23well,
- 26:23there's no need to call it something new.
- 26:25SPEAKER_01: Like it is capitalism.
- 26:27Capital is kind of doing these innovations internally to keep
- 26:31us in our place.
- 26:32SPEAKER_01: And they also have political innovation.
- 26:34SPEAKER_01: There's also the bonapartism.
- 26:35SPEAKER_01: There's also the kind of the affordances they'll give us innovation.
- 26:40SPEAKER_01: and the symbolic gestures they'll make to,
- 26:42SPEAKER_01: to keep us satiated,
- 26:44SPEAKER_01: um,
- 26:44SPEAKER_01: to stamp down revolutionary sentiment.
- 26:50SPEAKER_00: Um,
- 26:51SPEAKER_00: or something,
- 26:52SPEAKER_00: or to give people,
- 26:53SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 26:53SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 26:55SPEAKER_00: to use up their time so that they don't organize in other ways.
- 26:59Um,
- 27:00now democracy,
- 27:01political power,
- 27:02let's talk to touch on that for a second.
- 27:04SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 27:04So thing with techno feudalism,
- 27:05I feel like maybe the missing piece here is like rent.
- 27:09SPEAKER_00: Um,
- 27:11over profit right the idea that the economy is being based more
- 27:16on rent than on
- 27:19profit and I kind of feel like but isn't there an inherent
- 27:22limit to that like
- 27:23certainly you know everything can't be a rent you know because
- 27:29there has to be a
- 27:30SPEAKER_00: basis for paying for the rent mm-hmm
- 27:32SPEAKER_00: And I guess that raises the whole like David Graeber or MMT,
- 27:37like maybe the system just gives you money in order to enslave
- 27:40you so you have to
- 27:42SPEAKER_00: pay it back.
- 27:43SPEAKER_00: And so there used to be a way of enslaving people through labor.
- 27:47SPEAKER_00: Maybe we will now enslave people through rent,
- 27:50SPEAKER_00: but that the circuit is really the state issuing money.
- 27:55SPEAKER_00: There's that kind of idea.
- 27:56And it looks like Andrew Yang is not the friend of the working
- 28:00class,
- 28:00but the most cunning
- 28:02SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 28:02SPEAKER_00: Advocate of exploiting the working class with UBI.
- 28:06SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 28:07SPEAKER_00: You know, so it raises these kinds of questions.
- 28:09SPEAKER_00: So the techno feudalism, the rent part seems important in that respect.
- 28:14But again,
- 28:14that would seem to say,
- 28:16oh,
- 28:16look at how decadent capitalism is becoming.
- 28:18SPEAKER_00: In other words, that would almost suggest a terminal phase.
- 28:22And I'm very averse to that,
- 28:26averse to seeing things as,
- 28:28well,
- 28:29this is the end of capitalism.
- 28:30SPEAKER_00: This is a terminal phase.
- 28:33SPEAKER_00: And, you know, because it seems to be optimistic.
- 28:38SPEAKER_00: Yep.
- 28:38SPEAKER_00: But let's talk about the democracy part of it, right?
- 28:41Because that realm seems like it can be warped,
- 28:46infiltrated,
- 28:47corrupted,
- 28:49but it also seems like
- 28:52it preserves something like the equality of the vote,
- 28:57you know,
- 28:57at least hypothetically.
- 28:58SPEAKER_00: So the idea is that, well, it might be manipulated.
- 29:01SPEAKER_00: It might be,
- 29:02people might be demagogued or propagandized and people might be
- 29:05discouraged from
- 29:06SPEAKER_00: voting.
- 29:07But ideally,
- 29:09you know,
- 29:09we were talking about it,
- 29:10me and Faisal,
- 29:12my husband.
- 29:12SPEAKER_00: So we were talking about like countries where you have to vote.
- 29:16SPEAKER_00: It's obligatory versus countries where you do not.
- 29:21SPEAKER_00: And whether that's a good thing or not.
- 29:24SPEAKER_00: Like, forcing people to vote.
- 29:25Because we were talking about how Zahra Mamdani had been
- 29:28elected by only 20% of the
- 29:31SPEAKER_00: eligible voting population of New York.
- 29:34SPEAKER_00: Wow.
- 29:35SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and it kind of corresponds exactly with the PMC.
- 29:39SPEAKER_00: Or the coordinator class or whatever, right?
- 29:42SPEAKER_00: It's like, those are the people who elected him.
- 29:44SPEAKER_00: Wow.
- 29:45You know,
- 29:45because only 40% of the people voted and he got half of the
- 29:4940%.
- 29:49SPEAKER_00: That's 20%.
- 29:52SPEAKER_00: And, you know, the national election for president isn't much better.
- 29:55SPEAKER_00: I think that it's something like 60 percent voted and 40 percent didn't.
- 30:01SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 30:01SPEAKER_00: And so more people didn't vote than voted for either candidate.
- 30:06SPEAKER_00: In terms of eligible voters.
- 30:09SPEAKER_00: But,
- 30:10SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 30:10SPEAKER_00: but leaving aside like so the idea of maybe we force everyone to vote,
- 30:14SPEAKER_00: would that make things better?
- 30:16SPEAKER_00: Now,
- 30:17SPEAKER_00: I'm also familiar with the kind of Marxist theory of democracy,
- 30:21SPEAKER_00: which is that democracy is also the realm of the commodity form.
- 30:26Meaning universal franchise,
- 30:29universal enfranchisement is also the equality of the
- 30:34commodity.
- 30:36SPEAKER_00: Meaning it's the political form of a commodity economy,
- 30:40just as the commodity economy might be the economic form of
- 30:44political democracy.
- 30:48SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 30:48So that's another question is,
- 30:53you know,
- 30:53OK,
- 30:53we're moving beyond capitalism.
- 30:55We don't seem to really be moving beyond democracy unless one
- 30:59just assumes,
- 30:59SPEAKER_00: well,
- 31:00SPEAKER_00: we don't really have a democracy and maybe we never did.
- 31:03SPEAKER_00: Nonetheless,
- 31:04there's at least been this ostensible value of democracy
- 31:09throughout the last 200
- 31:10SPEAKER_00: years.
- 31:12So that would also be because I'm aware of the fact that the
- 31:15millennials went in a
- 31:17SPEAKER_00: kind of political direction,
- 31:20SPEAKER_00: meaning they had a kind of brush with economics,
- 31:23SPEAKER_00: but then like in large part have landed on a kind of political ontology.
- 31:29SPEAKER_00: Like, you know, there's this Bruno Leopold, Citizen Marx.
- 31:33SPEAKER_00: There's, you know, of course, Benjamin Studebaker, who I mentioned.
- 31:37SPEAKER_00: There's the Alpha Bunga crew.
- 31:39SPEAKER_00: There's Benjamin Studebaker, Alex Gorevich.
- 31:43I think that they were included with the Alpha Bunga crew for a
- 31:46little while.
- 31:47And there is this kind of idea for Tad Tietze,
- 31:51if you've heard of him,
- 31:53this focus on politics.
- 31:56That,
- 31:56you know,
- 31:57that the problem with this society is that it's like
- 32:01depoliticized.
- 32:02SPEAKER_00: It's apolitical.
- 32:04SPEAKER_00: It needs to be politicized.
- 32:07SPEAKER_00: And then the question is, on what basis?
- 32:09SPEAKER_00: And I also think that's in the background of the left-right populism.
- 32:12SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 32:14so it seems like the zeitgeist is like AI kind of destruction
- 32:19of the old working
- 32:20SPEAKER_00: class populist response to that.
- 32:23SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 32:24SPEAKER_00: and it's like left populism,
- 32:25SPEAKER_00: right populism,
- 32:26SPEAKER_00: Trump,
- 32:26SPEAKER_00: Bernie Sanders,
- 32:28SPEAKER_00: Zoran Mamdani,
- 32:30SPEAKER_00: you know.
- 32:31SPEAKER_00: And again,
- 32:32SPEAKER_00: I would sort of,
- 32:33SPEAKER_00: if only for the estrangement effect,
- 32:37SPEAKER_00: kind of emphasize,
- 32:38SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 32:38SPEAKER_00: universal enfranchisement is also the equality of the commodity.
- 32:45SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 32:45it's not just the democratic arena as the marketplace of ideas
- 32:49or a kind of
- 32:50SPEAKER_00: marketized politics.
- 32:51SPEAKER_00: It's not just that.
- 32:52SPEAKER_00: It's more basic.
- 32:54SPEAKER_00: You know, everyone's a worker, everyone's a voter.
- 32:58SPEAKER_00: Like that kind of basic bourgeois egalitarianism.
- 33:01SPEAKER_00: Because it is traceable back to bourgeois society that way.
- 33:03SPEAKER_00: It has almost like a Puritan kind of Protestant streak to it.
- 33:09SPEAKER_00: You know, equality.
- 33:12And,
- 33:13you know,
- 33:15that's at least the initial domain in which it's going to have
- 33:18to...
- 33:20SPEAKER_00: manifest, you know, some kind of discontent.
- 33:23SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 33:23SPEAKER_00: again,
- 33:24SPEAKER_00: I'm the generation that was a little bit pioneering,
- 33:28SPEAKER_00: like in the aftermath of the 60s,
- 33:30SPEAKER_00: pioneering the sort of,
- 33:32SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 33:33SPEAKER_00: riot,
- 33:34SPEAKER_00: insurrection,
- 33:35SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 33:36SPEAKER_00: the coming insurrection,
- 33:37SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 33:38SPEAKER_00: the leaderless movements,
- 33:40SPEAKER_00: the protests without demands,
- 33:42SPEAKER_00: all this stuff.
- 33:44SPEAKER_00: That seems to have not had a very long shelf life.
- 33:48SPEAKER_02: Mm hmm.
- 33:49SPEAKER_00: it does seem like we've come back to more basic, like, democracy.
- 33:56SPEAKER_00: Right,
- 33:56SPEAKER_00: so,
- 33:57SPEAKER_00: again,
- 33:58what would be the basis of people trying to politically
- 34:03constitute any kind of a
- 34:05SPEAKER_00: force in the face of what looks like drastic changes in the work world,
- 34:15SPEAKER_00: the employment world,
- 34:17SPEAKER_00: you know?
- 34:18SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 34:18the way that I like to put it is we need universal suffrage
- 34:21because we're liable to
- 34:25SPEAKER_00: change jobs,
- 34:26SPEAKER_00: become unemployed,
- 34:27SPEAKER_00: etc.
- 34:29SPEAKER_00: We can't leave it to the property owners the way we might have.
- 34:33SPEAKER_00: I don't know if I've ever said this to you guys.
- 34:36SPEAKER_00: You know, I feel like
- 34:39SPEAKER_00: what the hell do I know about politics?
- 34:41Maybe the board of trustees of the school of the art Institute
- 34:43of Chicago should do
- 34:44SPEAKER_00: my voting for me.
- 34:47SPEAKER_00: You know, like they, they, they know my interests better than I do.
- 34:51Meaning,
- 34:52you know,
- 34:52they should choose the politicians who are going to keep us in
- 34:55business.
- 34:55SPEAKER_00: Keep me employed, you know, but no, I may not always be employed by SAIC.
- 35:02SPEAKER_00: And so therefore I need the vote myself.
- 35:05SPEAKER_00: A lot of good it does me.
- 35:07SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 35:08SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 35:09SPEAKER_00: But universal enfranchisement is also not accidentally.
- 35:14SPEAKER_00: It's the era of capitalism.
- 35:16SPEAKER_00: It's the era of industrialization.
- 35:18It's not,
- 35:19you know,
- 35:19you didn't really need universal enfranchisement before that.
- 35:23SPEAKER_00: But now you do.
- 35:25SPEAKER_01: I was,
- 35:26SPEAKER_01: Mikey and I were talking earlier,
- 35:28SPEAKER_01: and we were talking about communism and anarchism,
- 35:35SPEAKER_01: and I do think...
- 35:39SPEAKER_01: Yeah, we should have the nasty bits out in the open.
- 35:45SPEAKER_01: So that's a point for communism as opposed to anarchism, right?
- 35:48SPEAKER_01: Because in anarchism, it would be kind of secret.
- 35:51The good thing about power being formalized is that it's out in
- 35:56the open and it's
- 35:57SPEAKER_01: at least,
- 35:57SPEAKER_01: in theory,
- 35:58SPEAKER_01: accountable.
- 36:02SPEAKER_01: But I told him...
- 36:04I don't know how many times I've stayed up imagining what would
- 36:08happen if,
- 36:08if the CIA never went and did a coup in Chile in 1973 and
- 36:13project Cybersyn was
- 36:15SPEAKER_01: allowed to become this like,
- 36:17SPEAKER_01: and I know this is fantasy and I know this is far too optimistic,
- 36:21SPEAKER_01: but,
- 36:21SPEAKER_01: but I imagine it becoming this like benevolent,
- 36:25SPEAKER_01: uh,
- 36:26SPEAKER_01: central committee that's not administered by,
- 36:29SPEAKER_01: by humans that,
- 36:30SPEAKER_01: that is just this kind of thing that,
- 36:32SPEAKER_01: uh,
- 36:34that benevolently governs us all so we can get on with the
- 36:38business of living and
- 36:40SPEAKER_01: being humans and doing human stuff.
- 36:44SPEAKER_01: But I think that's- Let the machines take care of our needs?
- 36:47SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 36:48SPEAKER_01: And there's a large part of me thinks
- 36:53SPEAKER_01: That is the only way politics could work.
- 36:57At this point,
- 36:58I look at politics and it breaks down into such an incoherent
- 37:05nest of snakes.
- 37:06SPEAKER_01: I don't know.
- 37:07SPEAKER_01: It's too incoherent for me.
- 37:08I can't imagine what it would look like to make real change for
- 37:15the betterment of
- 37:16SPEAKER_01: all of us,
- 37:17SPEAKER_01: of humankind.
- 37:18SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 37:21right right um i mean it could be that beyond capitalism you
- 37:29know what is it that
- 37:30engel says the governing of men is replaced by the
- 37:33administration of things and
- 37:36maybe the administration of things maybe things can administer
- 37:38themselves you know
- 37:40SPEAKER_00: so maybe we should look at it as like
- 37:44a kind of strange expression of the desire and,
- 37:49and possibility of communism.
- 37:51SPEAKER_00: Maybe.
- 37:51SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 37:53SPEAKER_00: You know, um, but, but of course we're not there yet.
- 37:59SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 38:00SPEAKER_00: Um,
- 38:00SPEAKER_00: and that's why,
- 38:00SPEAKER_00: that's why I'm an AI skeptic because I kind of feel like,
- 38:04but isn't this technology basically modeled on whatever we
- 38:08think an automated human
- 38:12SPEAKER_00: cognition would be.
- 38:15SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 38:15SPEAKER_00: meaning based on our kind of reified understanding of human intelligence,
- 38:21SPEAKER_00: which is,
- 38:21SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 38:22like maybe even the lamest version of a reified notion of human
- 38:26intelligence.
- 38:26SPEAKER_00: And we're just,
- 38:27SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 38:28SPEAKER_00: want to do that automatically and fast or something,
- 38:34SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 38:34SPEAKER_00: with kind of predictable regularity.
- 38:36SPEAKER_02: Mm-hmm.
- 38:37SPEAKER_00: And,
- 38:38SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 38:39but isn't the real promise of technology to be able to think
- 38:42things that are not
- 38:44SPEAKER_00: thinkable by humans.
- 38:47SPEAKER_03: Like not like land land emphasizes AI is Lovecraftian,
- 38:52SPEAKER_03: like radically outside us in that sense where it is some radically other,
- 38:59SPEAKER_03: but then,
- 38:59SPEAKER_03: then,
- 39:00SPEAKER_03: then the question,
- 39:00SPEAKER_03: but do we want AI?
- 39:02SPEAKER_03: I mean,
- 39:03SPEAKER_03: and maybe what we want,
- 39:04SPEAKER_03: I mean,
- 39:05SPEAKER_03: he would say it doesn't matter,
- 39:06SPEAKER_03: but I think for us,
- 39:07SPEAKER_03: we might sit here and go,
- 39:08SPEAKER_03: well,
- 39:09SPEAKER_03: maybe what we want does matter.
- 39:10I also don't think it's going to happen because I think that we
- 39:14only are producing
- 39:14SPEAKER_00: what we want and therefore will only be what we want.
- 39:18SPEAKER_00: And so this idea that it will transcend what we want,
- 39:21SPEAKER_00: that it will be something else is interesting,
- 39:25SPEAKER_00: but it is like a kind of a fantasy.
- 39:27I mean,
- 39:27it's based,
- 39:28I think on the kind of Heideggerian idea of technology,
- 39:31having a kind of a,
- 39:33SPEAKER_00: logic and, and kind of intention of its own, right?
- 39:37SPEAKER_03: In framing Gestel.
- 39:39SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 39:39And I kind of feel like,
- 39:41well,
- 39:42but isn't Heidegger talking about capitalism?
- 39:47SPEAKER_00: That's what I feel like.
- 39:48SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 39:49SPEAKER_03: Whether he wants to admit,
- 39:50SPEAKER_03: I think he,
- 39:50SPEAKER_03: he wants to say like,
- 39:52SPEAKER_03: well,
- 39:52ultimately in framing was still the mode of unconcealment of
- 39:56the Soviet union.
- 39:57SPEAKER_03: And for him, I think it's industrialization.
- 40:02And so he would see Soviet union,
- 40:04of course,
- 40:04as an industrial society in its own way.
- 40:07SPEAKER_03: I'm fine with that, by the way.
- 40:10SPEAKER_00: I'm fine with that.
- 40:12I'm fine with saying that the same existential problem attended
- 40:17the Soviet Union as
- 40:18SPEAKER_00: the West,
- 40:18SPEAKER_00: definitely.
- 40:19SPEAKER_00: I would just call that capitalism.
- 40:22Zizek has pointed out what's interesting with the three main
- 40:26ideologies of the 20th
- 40:27SPEAKER_03: century capitalism,
- 40:28SPEAKER_03: or liberalism,
- 40:30SPEAKER_03: fascism,
- 40:31SPEAKER_03: communism,
- 40:32SPEAKER_03: is that all three of them put people in camps.
- 40:36SPEAKER_03: Sure.
- 40:38SPEAKER_02: And so like,
- 40:39SPEAKER_03: I guess that the case could be made like there's a,
- 40:42SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 40:43SPEAKER_03: Heidegger thinks he's doing something different,
- 40:44but isn't Gestell or in framing very much just the mode of
- 40:48concealment of capital
- 40:50SPEAKER_03: or industrial capital itself.
- 40:52SPEAKER_03: But what you were saying,
- 40:54SPEAKER_03: like this,
- 40:54SPEAKER_03: this idea of AI being more of us,
- 40:57SPEAKER_03: I mean,
- 40:57SPEAKER_03: look,
- 40:58SPEAKER_03: a book I'm sure you have your disagreements with,
- 41:00but one that in a lot of ways inspired me is inventing the
- 41:03future by Cerna turn a
- 41:04SPEAKER_03: check and Williams.
- 41:06SPEAKER_00: Um,
- 41:07SPEAKER_03: left accelerationists and you know,
- 41:10SPEAKER_03: what they,
- 41:10SPEAKER_03: one of the points they make that I think is interesting is they're like,
- 41:13SPEAKER_03: look,
- 41:14SPEAKER_03: the issue with actually existing communism is that,
- 41:18SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 41:18SPEAKER_03: central planning is too much for any group of humans to do.
- 41:23SPEAKER_03: We had algorithmic communism.
- 41:26SPEAKER_03: that's a whole nother possibility.
- 41:29SPEAKER_03: And that type of computation,
- 41:32SPEAKER_03: we're not talking some Landy and Lovecraftian,
- 41:34SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 41:36SPEAKER_03: super intelligence.
- 41:37SPEAKER_03: It's just enough computational power to be able to organize production,
- 41:43SPEAKER_03: distribution,
- 41:44SPEAKER_03: and consumption in some sort of automated infrastructure.
- 41:49SPEAKER_03: And that to me seems much more realistic or concretely possible than
- 41:56perhaps some of these more,
- 41:58you know,
- 41:59uh,
- 42:00uh,
- 42:00extreme type of concepts of super intelligence.
- 42:06SPEAKER_03: I mean,
- 42:06SPEAKER_03: what do you think about the idea of like this algorithmically automated
- 42:11SPEAKER_03: infrastructure as a possibility?
- 42:15SPEAKER_00: I mean, I have two thoughts about that.
- 42:16SPEAKER_00: One is that it does seem to be a kind of return to the utopian socialism.
- 42:23SPEAKER_00: meaning the kind of utopian possibilities of industry at the outset.
- 42:32The other is that,
- 42:34just as in the case of utopian socialism,
- 42:38that we might get that.
- 42:39SPEAKER_00: We might get an algorithmic economy.
- 42:42SPEAKER_00: We might already be there to a large degree, and that that is capitalism.
- 42:47SPEAKER_00: And so the issue is what will bring it to grief?
- 42:51SPEAKER_00: meaning what will the crisis of that look like?
- 42:55SPEAKER_00: And so,
- 42:56SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 42:58SPEAKER_00: like there's the Hayek idea,
- 43:02SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 43:03SPEAKER_00: that the market is like the super intelligence,
- 43:08SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 43:09SPEAKER_00: it's the computational form that we could never produce ourselves,
- 43:14SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 43:14SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 43:16SPEAKER_00: through a planning board or even through computers.
- 43:21and so i also it's that like meaning society as as the super
- 43:26intelligence like
- 43:27society is the super intelligence and so what happens when we
- 43:31try to objectify it
- 43:35or we alienate it in the form give it autonomy in a way yeah
- 43:42like kind of you know
- 43:44SPEAKER_00: that we want to do that in other words that we want
- 43:48a kind of we want the super intelligence that really is society
- 43:53to take a certain
- 43:54form and again where you know hayek might have said the market
- 43:59now we're going to
- 43:59SPEAKER_00: say ai you know um and so it's a little bit like okay is ai some kind of
- 44:09SPEAKER_00: concretization of the invisible hand
- 44:14right i mean this is this is what i associate with these kinds
- 44:19of and i think rand
- 44:20would just say yes so as somebody who's like the key theorist
- 44:24in that regard i
- 44:26think you would say yeah like the the invisible hand is back
- 44:31then it's a form of ai
- 44:32now it's like it's coming into i don't know uh yep being for
- 44:38itself in a sense
- 44:40SPEAKER_03: is, is this trajectory, but it's already an AI system in its infancy.
- 44:47SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 44:47So this is something that I,
- 44:49you know,
- 44:49when my students ask about AI,
- 44:52I always say two things.
- 44:54SPEAKER_00: I say, we've, we'll never have it.
- 44:58SPEAKER_00: We've always had it.
- 44:59SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 45:01SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 45:03SPEAKER_00: And so the only question is the form that it's taking.
- 45:09And that the form that it's taking is maybe we have a kind of
- 45:15utopian desire or fear.
- 45:20SPEAKER_00: But in fact.
- 45:25SPEAKER_00: Whatever form we wanted to take,
- 45:27we might realize it and then actually that's going to generate
- 45:31a new necessity.
- 45:33SPEAKER_00: Or a new form.
- 45:36SPEAKER_00: Now.
- 45:38SPEAKER_00: Here's my.
- 45:40you know,
- 45:40other thought with regard to this that,
- 45:47you know,
- 45:47like an AI God,
- 45:50right?
- 45:50SPEAKER_00: So it's kind of like, but maybe something is different.
- 45:54SPEAKER_00: Maybe,
- 45:54SPEAKER_00: maybe this kind of alienation is different from religious alienation,
- 45:59SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 45:59SPEAKER_00: like attributing the super intelligence.
- 46:03SPEAKER_00: Maybe something has changed and that we should pay attention to that.
- 46:08and think about again in a way that Adam Smith didn't need to
- 46:19that we should be on
- 46:22guard against the ideological character of it I mean I will
- 46:30also be remiss if I
- 46:32SPEAKER_00: fail to note
- 46:34SPEAKER_00: that really there's the AI promise or AI desire.
- 46:39SPEAKER_00: There's also just the AI fear and terror.
- 46:42SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 46:43like the way people talked about how artificial intelligence or
- 46:47large language
- 46:48SPEAKER_00: models or algorithmic processes were used in the Israeli bombing of Gaza.
- 46:55SPEAKER_00: Right?
- 46:56SPEAKER_00: So it seems like it's here, it's dystopian.
- 47:00SPEAKER_00: you know, it's here, it dominates us, it's going to be our ruin.
- 47:05You know,
- 47:06meaning it doesn't even have to be artificial general
- 47:09intelligence.
- 47:12It's already making more efficient the things that clearly harm
- 47:19us,
- 47:19threaten us.
- 47:23Right,
- 47:24so I think that that's also,
- 47:26we can't leave that out of the equation.
- 47:29SPEAKER_00: Meaning,
- 47:33Maybe we are just looking at a more or less baleful or
- 47:37benevolent thing that itself
- 47:40SPEAKER_00: would need to be overcome.
- 47:43Meaning why do we want AI and maybe the point is to overcome
- 47:46our want and need for AI?
- 47:52SPEAKER_00: Kind of gets me back to the MCM prime business,
- 47:55SPEAKER_00: which is to say that,
- 47:56SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 47:56SPEAKER_00: production for the sake of capital rather than production for the sake of
- 48:00SPEAKER_00: production and what Moishebastone,
- 48:02SPEAKER_00: my old professor called the treadmill effect,
- 48:06SPEAKER_00: which is that the more it accomplishes itself,
- 48:09the more desperately it sort of needs itself and also kind of
- 48:15outstrips itself and
- 48:16SPEAKER_00: undermines itself.
- 48:18SPEAKER_00: So maybe the point is to get off the treadmill.
- 48:23SPEAKER_00: In which case,
- 48:23the point is to think about what it would mean to live in a
- 48:28world where we don't
- 48:30SPEAKER_00: need AI the way we need it now.
- 48:34SPEAKER_00: The necessity that's bringing AI into existence.
- 48:38Not just treating it as,
- 48:41oh,
- 48:41technology is just dropping this thing on us.
- 48:45SPEAKER_00: but rather it is happening at a specific moment in history.
- 48:48SPEAKER_00: It's motivated in very specific ways.
- 48:51SPEAKER_00: And really the goal should be not to not have AI,
- 48:55SPEAKER_00: but to overcome why we need it now,
- 48:59SPEAKER_00: how we need it now,
- 49:01SPEAKER_00: what's driving it now,
- 49:03SPEAKER_00: what's making it happen now.
- 49:05SPEAKER_01: That's a good point.
- 49:08SPEAKER_01: In my view, because I think...
- 49:11SPEAKER_01: Yeah, to call it AI is already like a mystification, like LLMs.
- 49:16SPEAKER_01: Absolutely.
- 49:19I was talking about them recently,
- 49:22and I said they're a weird reification of reification itself.
- 49:25SPEAKER_01: It's just a cheap parlor trick.
- 49:28SPEAKER_01: I think it's an imitation of...
- 49:31of of our language like we're doing the thing and then we're
- 49:34building a machine to
- 49:35do it for us and then we're sitting back and we're saying look
- 49:38at how good the
- 49:38machine is and we're discounting all reified reified use of of
- 49:44the reification of
- 49:45SPEAKER_00: language yes yeah
- 49:48SPEAKER_00: It's like totally,
- 49:49SPEAKER_00: although I will say this because I,
- 49:51SPEAKER_00: I did amuse myself with,
- 49:53SPEAKER_00: um,
- 49:54SPEAKER_00: it might've been Google AI,
- 49:56SPEAKER_00: not chat GPT itself,
- 49:57SPEAKER_00: or maybe I tried it on a few different things.
- 50:00SPEAKER_00: I was like, summarize Chris Katron's approach to Marxism.
- 50:05And,
- 50:06and,
- 50:06you know,
- 50:07because I'm well known enough,
- 50:08but not very well known.
- 50:10And because there isn't a lot of secondary literature on me,
- 50:13it was very accurate.
- 50:14SPEAKER_02: Really?
- 50:15SPEAKER_00: Really?
- 50:16SPEAKER_00: Oh, yeah.
- 50:17Like it was because,
- 50:18you know,
- 50:19because ultimately I'm pretty straightforward.
- 50:21SPEAKER_00: Like, in other words, my writings are pretty straightforward.
- 50:23Everything's pretty straightforward,
- 50:24even though the left is like,
- 50:25what does Chris Cutrone mean?
- 50:26SPEAKER_00: And it's like,
- 50:28SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 50:29SPEAKER_00: well,
- 50:29that's only because you're letting your own like prejudices get
- 50:34in the way.
- 50:35SPEAKER_00: But if you just looked at it straightforwardly,
- 50:37SPEAKER_00: like this stupid thing called ChatGPT,
- 50:41SPEAKER_00: then you'd see pretty simple.
- 50:43SPEAKER_03: You know, like...
- 50:45SPEAKER_03: No, but here's the thing.
- 50:47SPEAKER_03: So in the past,
- 50:47I've referred to the effect that these large language models
- 50:53have on us as
- 50:54SPEAKER_03: intelligence fetishism.
- 50:56SPEAKER_03: And all I mean, I see a homology here.
- 50:58So the commodity has this presence to us because we don't
- 51:02experience firsthand all
- 51:04of the different forms of labor that went into the production
- 51:07of the commodity.
- 51:08SPEAKER_03: It seems like, oh, it has this presence.
- 51:10SPEAKER_03: It's just sprouted there on the shelf.
- 51:12SPEAKER_03: The TV is just there waiting.
- 51:13SPEAKER_03: No, no.
- 51:14It's the product of vast amounts of human labor that we're not
- 51:18seeing firsthand.
- 51:20SPEAKER_03: And so that's where the effect comes from.
- 51:22If we could somehow visualize or experience how the LLM is
- 51:27putting together these
- 51:29SPEAKER_03: answers to our prompts,
- 51:31SPEAKER_03: it wouldn't have that effect.
- 51:32SPEAKER_03: It's the fact that we can't see this complicated network of
- 51:36causes and effects and relays and all of that that it has this
- 51:40effect on us and
- 51:41just like we do a critique of commodity fetishism we need to be
- 51:45able to do this
- 51:45critique of this intelligence fetishism to be able to say like
- 51:49no this is in a
- 51:50sense it's a magic trick in a in a way right right so i mean
- 51:57look i would say that
- 52:00SPEAKER_00: large language models machine learning it has its place
- 52:05SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 52:05SPEAKER_00: meaning,
- 52:06SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 52:06maybe there is work that is like kind of shitty intellectual
- 52:10labor that should be
- 52:11SPEAKER_00: automated and replaced,
- 52:13SPEAKER_00: like,
- 52:14SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 52:14SPEAKER_00: like coding,
- 52:15SPEAKER_00: coding.
- 52:16SPEAKER_00: Sounds like miserable work.
- 52:18I mean,
- 52:18I remember when I used to do computer programming is what they
- 52:21used to call it.
- 52:22SPEAKER_00: And,
- 52:23SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 52:23SPEAKER_00: and it was somewhat fun,
- 52:24but it was also like a weird like repetition compulsion
- 52:27neurotic activity,
- 52:29SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 52:29SPEAKER_00: or like a form of stimming or something.
- 52:31SPEAKER_00: It was like it was weird, right?
- 52:33SPEAKER_03: But it's not like reading great text and then teaching them.
- 52:36SPEAKER_03: It's not that kind of.
- 52:37SPEAKER_00: No, it's not.
- 52:38SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 52:39SPEAKER_00: And so I just feel like, yeah, like a machine should do this.
- 52:42SPEAKER_00: It's not me, you know, definitely.
- 52:46SPEAKER_00: And,
- 52:46SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 52:46SPEAKER_00: the sad part is though,
- 52:47SPEAKER_00: then,
- 52:47SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 52:48SPEAKER_00: like,
- 52:48SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 52:49SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 52:49SPEAKER_00: people did this shit kind of labor,
- 52:51SPEAKER_00: but at least it was paying the bills.
- 52:53SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 52:55SPEAKER_00: So, uh, okay, here's a dystopian story.
- 52:58SPEAKER_00: You ready?
- 52:58SPEAKER_00: Yep.
- 53:00SPEAKER_00: So the delivery robots, uh,
- 53:05SPEAKER_00: This is completely apocryphal, okay?
- 53:07SPEAKER_00: Hang on, audience.
- 53:09SPEAKER_00: Don't crucify me if I'm wrong.
- 53:12SPEAKER_00: But this is what I've heard.
- 53:14And I haven't bothered to research it because I just thought
- 53:17this makes too much sense.
- 53:19SPEAKER_00: You know, here in Chicago, anyway, the delivery robots, they have names.
- 53:23SPEAKER_00: And suspiciously, they are Indian names.
- 53:27SPEAKER_00: And it turns out it's because it's not actually automated.
- 53:30SPEAKER_00: It's being remote controlled by someone in India.
- 53:33SPEAKER_03: Oh, no shit.
- 53:36Meaning because it's cheaper to pay someone to do that than to
- 53:40pay a driver.
- 53:44SPEAKER_01: Similar to that,
- 53:45SPEAKER_01: there are on social media,
- 53:48there are filters that people place over their photos and their
- 53:52videos to make it
- 53:53SPEAKER_01: look AI-ified.
- 53:57Like the AI-ification,
- 54:02it's in the algorithm and it's dominating the algorithm.
- 54:04SPEAKER_01: So now human creators...
- 54:06are AI-ifying the work that they created,
- 54:10the photo or the video they labored over.
- 54:13SPEAKER_01: They're making it look like AI to catch on.
- 54:16SPEAKER_01: And that's similar thing to Facebook.
- 54:22SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 54:22Facebook had their moderation team to check for horrible things
- 54:26that no one should
- 54:27SPEAKER_01: look at.
- 54:27And they were claiming it was done by AI,
- 54:30but it was done by third world workers.
- 54:33SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 54:33SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 54:35SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 54:37SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 54:39That was the other thing is like,
- 54:40I don't know,
- 54:41like people were like,
- 54:42you know,
- 54:43deep seek.
- 54:43Was it just like a million Chinese like,
- 54:46you know,
- 54:46slave laborers and Jing Zhang?
- 54:48SPEAKER_00: Like, you know, like, you know, I mean, it is, you know, but we joke.
- 54:56SPEAKER_00: But whether it is that or not, it is that.
- 55:01SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 55:01SPEAKER_00: Meaning like that's what we're talking about.
- 55:04And,
- 55:05you know,
- 55:05and again,
- 55:05I think that the promise of technology is that,
- 55:10yes,
- 55:10it could do that.
- 55:11It could replace shit work,
- 55:13but maybe it could also do things that humans can't do.
- 55:17SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 55:18SPEAKER_00: That's not just accelerated human activity or replaced human activity,
- 55:24SPEAKER_00: but something qualitatively different.
- 55:27You know,
- 55:27I remember,
- 55:28you know,
- 55:30like Adorno says,
- 55:32why do we want to explore dead planets?
- 55:35SPEAKER_00: You know, like around the moonshot.
- 55:39SPEAKER_00: You know, he's like, you know, we're on a living planet.
- 55:44SPEAKER_00: Why do we want to explore dead planets?
- 55:46SPEAKER_00: And it's like, well, maybe we won't.
- 55:50SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 55:50maybe they'll just be these automated rocket manufacturing
- 55:55bases that will
- 55:57SPEAKER_00: automatically,
- 55:58SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 55:59SPEAKER_00: explore the universe.
- 56:01SPEAKER_01: Like von Neumann machines,
- 56:03SPEAKER_01: just kind of going out and or the game of life,
- 56:05SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 56:06SPEAKER_01: the just kind of.
- 56:09um right i think so it seems to be the case that our and ours
- 56:15is weird who is the
- 56:16SPEAKER_01: hour we're talking about but the the need for this version of artificial
- 56:21SPEAKER_01: intelligence this machine learning is largely economic and it serves
- 56:27SPEAKER_01: The same role as the commodity form.
- 56:30SPEAKER_01: It's to obscure the kind of human labor,
- 56:33SPEAKER_01: the human toil,
- 56:34SPEAKER_01: and our own conditions in the end product itself.
- 56:40SPEAKER_01: It...
- 56:42And to say we need to divest ourselves of the need for AI as we
- 56:49have it today,
- 56:49I like that.
- 56:51SPEAKER_01: But what could that mean or what could that look like?
- 56:56SPEAKER_01: Again, well, again, it comes back to political power.
- 56:59SPEAKER_01: We have no choice in the matter, largely.
- 57:04SPEAKER_01: It's Elon Musk and Marc Andreessen and Peter Thiel.
- 57:08SPEAKER_01: They're kind of pushing this.
- 57:13But they're doing it,
- 57:14their opportunity to do it,
- 57:16and also even their motivation to do it.
- 57:18SPEAKER_00: Ultimately,
- 57:20SPEAKER_00: they might think that they're doing it for its own sake,
- 57:24SPEAKER_00: but they're doing it to realize their investments.
- 57:28SPEAKER_00: They are doing it in a context, not of their own choosing.
- 57:33SPEAKER_03: Would you say capital is deciding for them?
- 57:36SPEAKER_00: in some ways, right?
- 57:37SPEAKER_00: Like is, is at least conditioning, right?
- 57:40SPEAKER_00: Like that's my,
- 57:41SPEAKER_00: my,
- 57:42SPEAKER_00: my favorite word is not determining the conditioning,
- 57:47SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 57:48SPEAKER_00: meaning,
- 57:48SPEAKER_00: um,
- 57:50SPEAKER_00: there's a context for all this and like,
- 57:54SPEAKER_00: we can complain about,
- 57:55SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 57:56these billionaire investors having a disproportionate amount of
- 58:00economic power.
- 58:01SPEAKER_00: And it seems like they wield it rather arbitrarily.
- 58:06SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 58:06SPEAKER_00: like Elon Musk buying Twitter,
- 58:09SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 58:09SPEAKER_00: that there was no,
- 58:10SPEAKER_00: he just wanted to,
- 58:12SPEAKER_00: there was no like economic necessity to it exactly.
- 58:16SPEAKER_00: So it's mediated and,
- 58:18SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 58:18SPEAKER_00: meaning that everything is strictly economic efficiency in,
- 58:22SPEAKER_00: in motivation,
- 58:24but there is a kind of a background condition of an imperative
- 58:29to economic
- 58:30SPEAKER_00: efficiency,
- 58:30SPEAKER_00: at least in the longterm.
- 58:33SPEAKER_00: So in any given instance,
- 58:35SPEAKER_00: maybe it's not being driven by that,
- 58:40SPEAKER_00: but that's still the general context.
- 58:42SPEAKER_00: So,
- 58:43SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 58:44SPEAKER_00: I,
- 58:44SPEAKER_00: again,
- 58:45SPEAKER_00: economic efficiency,
- 58:46SPEAKER_00: if AI is being driven by the needs of economic efficiency,
- 58:51then the goal would be to overcome that kind of economic
- 58:58efficiency imperative,
- 59:01SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 59:01SPEAKER_00: to realize
- 59:04value right i think that the the argument that it wasn't that
- 59:09it's not an ai bubble
- 59:12is that it's real value you know companies are getting real
- 59:16value out of their
- 59:18investment in ai and and i thought okay but that's not really
- 59:23the issue the issue
- 59:24is not like real value versus fake value it's not like return
- 59:28on your investment
- 59:28SPEAKER_00: versus ponzi scheme
- 59:31SPEAKER_00: That's not really the issue with regard to capitalism.
- 59:35SPEAKER_00: Capitalism is not a Ponzi scheme.
- 59:39Even though it might create conditions for Ponzi schemes,
- 59:43it isn't a Ponzi scheme.
- 59:48It must necessarily appear to us as casino capitalism or
- 59:53something,
- 59:53but it really isn't.
- 59:55SPEAKER_00: Just that.
- 59:57so that's what i mean when i say the need for ai that we have
- 1:00:01now like what is the
- 1:00:03specific demand for economic efficiency that is playing out in
- 1:00:11the employment of ai
- 1:00:13right now you know because i don't think it's like we've
- 1:00:21reached the sweet spot of
- 1:00:23SPEAKER_00: like
- 1:00:24SPEAKER_00: chips,
- 1:00:25SPEAKER_00: because it seems to me like these,
- 1:00:27SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:00:28SPEAKER_00: server farm factory,
- 1:00:29SPEAKER_00: AI factories,
- 1:00:30SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:00:31SPEAKER_00: that they're building.
- 1:00:32SPEAKER_00: Like it does seem like they're rather inefficient.
- 1:00:36SPEAKER_03: Oh yeah.
- 1:00:37SPEAKER_00: Well, yeah.
- 1:00:37SPEAKER_03: And now what they seem to be doing great though,
- 1:00:40SPEAKER_03: is,
- 1:00:41SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:00:42SPEAKER_03: driving up the price of people's energy bills.
- 1:00:45SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 1:00:45SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:00:46SPEAKER_01: For example, mine's gone up like 30 percent.
- 1:00:47SPEAKER_01: Tell them about what's been going on.
- 1:00:49My my my electricity bill has gone up like 30 percent this year
- 1:00:54and they're
- 1:00:54SPEAKER_00: building another where you guys are.
- 1:00:56SPEAKER_00: I feel for you.
- 1:00:57SPEAKER_00: Chicago still has nuclear power.
- 1:01:00SPEAKER_00: So we don't get hit.
- 1:01:02SPEAKER_00: We don't get hit.
- 1:01:03SPEAKER_03: I haven't been affected by it in Kansas City.
- 1:01:05SPEAKER_03: I don't know if I will be.
- 1:01:06I know that they're I've heard they're building one somewhere
- 1:01:09in Missouri.
- 1:01:10SPEAKER_03: So maybe it will affect me at some point,
- 1:01:12SPEAKER_00: but I know Nancy's probably going to affect rural America worse.
- 1:01:17SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:01:19SPEAKER_03: This is one of the questions you mentioned it earlier,
- 1:01:21SPEAKER_03: but I have some other questions,
- 1:01:23SPEAKER_03: but I think now is the best time for it.
- 1:01:25SPEAKER_03: One.
- 1:01:26Do you think this is an AI bubble that's going to burst and
- 1:01:29really have a,
- 1:01:31whether it's a recession or even a depression that seems to be
- 1:01:34this looming threat?
- 1:01:36And then what,
- 1:01:37what positive or,
- 1:01:39and or negative effects do you see the data centers having?
- 1:01:45SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 1:01:45SPEAKER_00: I'm amused by the data center,
- 1:01:47SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:01:47SPEAKER_00: phenomenon because,
- 1:01:49SPEAKER_00: um,
- 1:01:50SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:01:51SPEAKER_00: I see it also as,
- 1:01:52SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 1:01:52SPEAKER_00: if I can put it in the,
- 1:01:54SPEAKER_00: in the Trump context,
- 1:01:56So I think that we have to sort of parse these things out and
- 1:01:59filter things a
- 1:02:00SPEAKER_00: little bit,
- 1:02:00meaning I think that a lot of the talk of a recession is also
- 1:02:06trying to wish it
- 1:02:07SPEAKER_00: into existence because the Democrats want to stop Trump.
- 1:02:12SPEAKER_00: And so I always feel like I have to... They're hyperstitioning.
- 1:02:15SPEAKER_00: Yeah, exactly, right?
- 1:02:18So whereas I feel like I have to correct for that and maybe
- 1:02:21overcorrect for it by
- 1:02:22SPEAKER_00: saying,
- 1:02:23SPEAKER_00: no,
- 1:02:23Trump's going to bring about an economic boom and it's going to
- 1:02:26be a real boom.
- 1:02:27SPEAKER_00: Now, booms are followed by busts.
- 1:02:29SPEAKER_00: The question is, how do we understand that?
- 1:02:31And I think that when we call it a bubble,
- 1:02:35we are discounting a dynamic of capitalism.
- 1:02:40SPEAKER_00: And we are kind of conceding too much to capitalist economics,
- 1:02:47SPEAKER_00: to like marginal utility theory,
- 1:02:49SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:02:50SPEAKER_00: to this kind of approach,
- 1:02:51SPEAKER_00: which makes sense and is descriptive to a certain extent,
- 1:02:54SPEAKER_00: meaning it's like the Great Recession.
- 1:02:57SPEAKER_00: Was there a housing bubble?
- 1:02:59SPEAKER_00: And was it a bad risk?
- 1:03:01SPEAKER_00: And, you know, was it like a bad speculative gamble?
- 1:03:06SPEAKER_00: At a certain level, that does describe things.
- 1:03:08SPEAKER_00: It's not like I'm here to say,
- 1:03:09SPEAKER_00: oh,
- 1:03:09SPEAKER_00: it really wasn't that,
- 1:03:11and don't blame poor people and people of color for getting
- 1:03:15mortgages that they
- 1:03:16SPEAKER_00: shouldn't have gotten that destroyed the housing market.
- 1:03:19I'm not here to say,
- 1:03:20oh,
- 1:03:20no,
- 1:03:20Marxism shows that that narrative is bullshit.
- 1:03:23SPEAKER_00: That narrative might actually be true to a certain extent.
- 1:03:25SPEAKER_00: It might describe things.
- 1:03:27SPEAKER_00: It might.
- 1:03:28SPEAKER_00: But
- 1:03:29SPEAKER_00: That's one thing.
- 1:03:31SPEAKER_00: What about the crazy inflation that we got?
- 1:03:33A Marxist approach would allow us to see how we got through the
- 1:03:38Great Recession on
- 1:03:39SPEAKER_00: zero interest,
- 1:03:40SPEAKER_00: but it caught up with us anyway.
- 1:03:44SPEAKER_00: It did catch up with us, and that wasn't just COVID.
- 1:03:47It could be that COVID triggered more of a value correction
- 1:03:51rather than merely a
- 1:03:52SPEAKER_00: market correction.
- 1:03:53SPEAKER_00: Again, the long-term dynamics...
- 1:04:00SPEAKER_00: we have to sort of pay attention.
- 1:04:02SPEAKER_00: So inevitably if there's an AI boom,
- 1:04:05SPEAKER_00: there will be an AI bust,
- 1:04:07SPEAKER_00: but I'm,
- 1:04:08but I think calling it a bubble is about throwing cold water on
- 1:04:14the Trump like
- 1:04:16presidency and specifically how Silicon Valley seemed in large
- 1:04:20measure to have
- 1:04:21SPEAKER_00: shifted to Trump.
- 1:04:22SPEAKER_00: And,
- 1:04:23SPEAKER_03: and they make it,
- 1:04:24SPEAKER_03: there's a lot of hyper,
- 1:04:25SPEAKER_03: like,
- 1:04:25SPEAKER_03: Oh,
- 1:04:26SPEAKER_03: this is going to be worse than the great depression.
- 1:04:30SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:04:31SPEAKER_00: And, you know, again, how does one understand the Great Depression?
- 1:04:35Meaning the Great Depression could be seen as a policy failure
- 1:04:40or it could be seen
- 1:04:40SPEAKER_00: as a more,
- 1:04:41SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:04:42SPEAKER_00: basic structural problem.
- 1:04:45SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:04:45SPEAKER_00: Because there is this idea that if only,
- 1:04:49SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:04:50SPEAKER_00: the late 20s,
- 1:04:52SPEAKER_00: those Republicans had handled things differently,
- 1:04:54SPEAKER_00: then the Great Depression wouldn't have happened.
- 1:04:59SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 1:05:00SPEAKER_00: so I think that it's,
- 1:05:02SPEAKER_00: so that's the first thing is that we have to,
- 1:05:04SPEAKER_00: as much as possible,
- 1:05:05try to strip away that Democratic Party propaganda layer to the
- 1:05:11whole thing.
- 1:05:13SPEAKER_00: Then we have to think about,
- 1:05:15SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 1:05:16SPEAKER_00: well,
- 1:05:16SPEAKER_00: what kind of,
- 1:05:18SPEAKER_00: what kind of growth,
- 1:05:19SPEAKER_00: what kind of development is being driven by this AI boom?
- 1:05:24SPEAKER_00: Let's just call it an AI boom.
- 1:05:27SPEAKER_00: And, you know,
- 1:05:29SPEAKER_00: Will it have long enough legs?
- 1:05:33SPEAKER_00: Or, you know, will it not?
- 1:05:36Now,
- 1:05:38the dot com bubble still laid the groundwork for the later kind
- 1:05:47of internet economy.
- 1:05:50Meaning there was like a little correction,
- 1:05:53but it's not like it didn't actually do anything.
- 1:05:55SPEAKER_00: It didn't actually change things.
- 1:05:57SPEAKER_00: And it also laid the groundwork for later growth.
- 1:06:03SPEAKER_00: So those are my caveats,
- 1:06:05SPEAKER_00: is to look at it and say,
- 1:06:09SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 1:06:10SPEAKER_00: it's probably not going to play out as planned.
- 1:06:14SPEAKER_00: But it's also not just bullshit.
- 1:06:19SPEAKER_00: And even if it goes through some turbulence, it's still changing things.
- 1:06:23SPEAKER_00: It's still introducing new practices.
- 1:06:26It's still creating new infrastructure that's going to be there
- 1:06:29and that people are
- 1:06:30SPEAKER_00: going to find a way to use,
- 1:06:34SPEAKER_00: right?
- 1:06:34SPEAKER_00: They're going to find a use value for it.
- 1:06:35SPEAKER_00: They're going to find an exchange value for it.
- 1:06:38I mean,
- 1:06:38with,
- 1:06:39with software right now,
- 1:06:40with,
- 1:06:40with the LLMs,
- 1:06:41there has been this development.
- 1:06:43Do you think robotics will have a quick catch up to it where
- 1:06:47there will be
- 1:06:50robots just walking around our daily life doing things within
- 1:06:53the next decade or so?
- 1:06:56SPEAKER_00: Possibly.
- 1:06:57SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 1:06:57SPEAKER_00: again,
- 1:06:58SPEAKER_00: for me,
- 1:06:58SPEAKER_00: the thing about robots is that it's a little sad,
- 1:07:03SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:07:03SPEAKER_00: meaning I'm kind of like,
- 1:07:05SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 1:07:05SPEAKER_00: so you're going to make a machine that is basically like a human being.
- 1:07:14SPEAKER_00: Can't you have all different kinds of machines?
- 1:07:16SPEAKER_00: Why is it going to be a person?
- 1:07:18SPEAKER_00: And again, we want robots to do things that people could do.
- 1:07:24And it's like,
- 1:07:27what about robots that can do things that people could never
- 1:07:30do?
- 1:07:32SPEAKER_00: And of course, there's some of that.
- 1:07:35SPEAKER_00: But again,
- 1:07:36SPEAKER_00: I kind of feel like,
- 1:07:38SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 1:07:39SPEAKER_00: so you want like a house servant or you want,
- 1:07:43SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:07:45SPEAKER_00: is it like Optimus prime,
- 1:07:46SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:07:47SPEAKER_00: the,
- 1:07:47SPEAKER_00: the,
- 1:07:48SPEAKER_00: the Tesla robot or is it Wally?
- 1:07:52SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:07:53SPEAKER_00: It could be Wally too.
- 1:07:54SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 1:07:55SPEAKER_03: can I just say real quick,
- 1:07:56SPEAKER_03: the funny thing is the,
- 1:07:57SPEAKER_03: the first robot that I'm dealing with in my day-to-day life
- 1:08:02so there's i don't know if you you probably have them in
- 1:08:04chicago maybe quick trips
- 1:08:06these these gas stations right quick trips like in kansas city
- 1:08:10you you throw a rock
- 1:08:11you hit three quick trips they're just everywhere and now at
- 1:08:16every quick trip they
- 1:08:17SPEAKER_03: have a little floor cleaning robot and it it's it's
- 1:08:21SPEAKER_03: It has a little human face.
- 1:08:23SPEAKER_03: They put eyes on it and it talks.
- 1:08:24SPEAKER_03: It's like, I'm cleaning the floor.
- 1:08:26And so there's this new species of accelerationism called cute
- 1:08:31accelerationism.
- 1:08:33SPEAKER_03: And what,
- 1:08:34SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 1:08:34SPEAKER_03: Amy Ireland and Maya B chronic do in this book is talk about how,
- 1:08:37SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:08:38basically land always talked about accelerationism in this
- 1:08:41Lovecraftian nightmarish
- 1:08:43SPEAKER_03: way.
- 1:08:43SPEAKER_03: Really?
- 1:08:45SPEAKER_03: What, what tech's going to do is it's going to cutify.
- 1:08:48ai and robotics and and there's going to be this the the the
- 1:08:53the acceleration of
- 1:08:54technology is going to have this cute veneer opposed to some
- 1:08:57lovecraftian tentacled
- 1:08:59cthuloyd thing and so the point is a a quick trip now though
- 1:09:05every time you go in
- 1:09:06there this four little cleaning robot is cleaning the floor and
- 1:09:10it's talking to
- 1:09:11SPEAKER_03: everybody
- 1:09:12And we've all just decided to call it Wally because it somewhat
- 1:09:15resembles Wally.
- 1:09:16SPEAKER_03: It's this cute little thing, but everybody is mean to it.
- 1:09:20SPEAKER_03: It's get the fuck out of the way Wally.
- 1:09:22SPEAKER_03: Like I see people getting annoyed with it.
- 1:09:25SPEAKER_03: And I said all that just to say they treat it like a servant.
- 1:09:29right right right but wait so what's quick trips okay quick
- 1:09:34trips just this huge
- 1:09:35national chain of gas stations and and it is the best gas
- 1:09:39station oh yeah uh at
- 1:09:41least in my area that you can go to but um yeah it's just your
- 1:09:45car no way it's just
- 1:09:48SPEAKER_03: basically like a gas station it's like a nice clean circle k
- 1:09:54SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:09:55SPEAKER_00: I see.
- 1:09:55SPEAKER_00: And they have robots cleaning the floor in the store.
- 1:09:59SPEAKER_03: And I just find that humans treat the robot like shit.
- 1:10:04SPEAKER_03: And I've stopped.
- 1:10:06SPEAKER_03: I've just, I'm paying attention because even I get frustrated.
- 1:10:10SPEAKER_03: You're walking around,
- 1:10:11you're trying to get your stuff and little Wally's in the way
- 1:10:13cleaning the floor.
- 1:10:14SPEAKER_03: And you're like, God damn it.
- 1:10:16but i've seen people when they're alone they start talking to
- 1:10:20it aggressively get
- 1:10:22the fuck out of my way you little shit like and i i think it
- 1:10:27supports your point
- 1:10:28where yeah like do we do we want ai so we can have a servant
- 1:10:33class that we can in a
- 1:10:35SPEAKER_00: sense be mean to in a weird way well no doubt they were talking about um
- 1:10:44SPEAKER_00: how kids were like, uh, sabotaging a Waymo.
- 1:10:50SPEAKER_02: Oh yeah.
- 1:10:51SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:10:51SPEAKER_01: That's big.
- 1:10:53SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:10:55SPEAKER_00: And, and I just thought, Oh, I guess that that would be inevitable.
- 1:11:01SPEAKER_00: You know?
- 1:11:01SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 1:11:03SPEAKER_00: again,
- 1:11:03SPEAKER_00: I kind of feel like,
- 1:11:04SPEAKER_00: Oh,
- 1:11:06SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:11:06SPEAKER_00: can't kids just,
- 1:11:07SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:11:08SPEAKER_00: behave themselves,
- 1:11:08SPEAKER_00: but then it's like,
- 1:11:09SPEAKER_00: yeah,
- 1:11:09SPEAKER_00: but how could you,
- 1:11:11SPEAKER_00: how could you really resist?
- 1:11:12SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:11:15SPEAKER_00: You know, stopping a Waymo.
- 1:11:17SPEAKER_00: Well,
- 1:11:18SPEAKER_01: especially there is this faux populism,
- 1:11:23SPEAKER_01: faux workerism where people already resent the robots.
- 1:11:29SPEAKER_01: And...
- 1:11:32SPEAKER_01: But there's a part of me that I also resent the robots.
- 1:11:35SPEAKER_01: I have a robot floor vacuum, and it has a name.
- 1:11:39Its name is Antonio Banderas,
- 1:11:41and we treat it like a member of the family.
- 1:11:44SPEAKER_01: We're nice to it.
- 1:11:45SPEAKER_01: Oh, my God.
- 1:11:50And it's not to do the workerism and say my life would be
- 1:11:53meaningless without productive labor.
- 1:11:56SPEAKER_01: In fact, my life is...
- 1:11:59SPEAKER_01: The most meaningful when I'm freed from productive labor.
- 1:12:03SPEAKER_01: That's where I find the most meaning.
- 1:12:06But there is the fear of what do we do when we have billions of
- 1:12:13people who are not
- 1:12:15SPEAKER_01: getting paid anything,
- 1:12:16SPEAKER_01: but they still have needs.
- 1:12:17SPEAKER_01: They still need.
- 1:12:22SPEAKER_01: But that seems intractable to me.
- 1:12:28SPEAKER_00: No, I mean, we've been there for a little while.
- 1:12:30SPEAKER_00: We've been there for a little while.
- 1:12:32SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:12:33SPEAKER_00: And maybe we're always there.
- 1:12:35SPEAKER_00: You know, that's the proletariat.
- 1:12:38SPEAKER_00: That's proletarianization.
- 1:12:40SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:12:41SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 1:12:41SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 1:12:41SPEAKER_00: it's lumpenization,
- 1:12:42SPEAKER_00: but it's really proletarianization,
- 1:12:44SPEAKER_00: meaning what use are these people just to reproduce,
- 1:12:48SPEAKER_00: like the actual meaning of the word proletariat,
- 1:12:51SPEAKER_00: meaning the people who just reproduce.
- 1:12:53SPEAKER_00: The only thing that they produce is more humans.
- 1:12:58SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:13:00SPEAKER_00: No, it's a little bit nightmarish.
- 1:13:04SPEAKER_00: I also think there's no reason why things can't be industrialized,
- 1:13:11meaning whether re-industrialized here in the United States or
- 1:13:17industrialization of
- 1:13:18SPEAKER_00: Africa.
- 1:13:21SPEAKER_00: And maybe it won't be ever as thorough as it was in,
- 1:13:25SPEAKER_00: I don't know,
- 1:13:25SPEAKER_00: the mid-20th century in Europe,
- 1:13:28SPEAKER_00: the East Bloc,
- 1:13:29SPEAKER_00: and the United States,
- 1:13:30SPEAKER_00: Japan,
- 1:13:31SPEAKER_00: etc.
- 1:13:33But still,
- 1:13:35again,
- 1:13:36I think that they're going to find a way of making themselves
- 1:13:41useful.
- 1:13:44SPEAKER_00: People are going to find a way of making themselves useful.
- 1:13:47SPEAKER_00: And, you know...
- 1:13:51SPEAKER_00: should i have a rumba yeah maybe i should have a rumba meaning if you
- 1:13:58anthropomorphize it though there's this weird like what is that
- 1:14:01mechanism where
- 1:14:01it's like you can't just have a rumba like now it needs to talk
- 1:14:06and have a cutesy
- 1:14:07little face yeah no it's crazy right i mean that's the thing
- 1:14:12and and i do think i
- 1:14:13SPEAKER_00: don't know if that's more dystopian it might be more dystopian is
- 1:14:18SPEAKER_00: It might be more dystopian.
- 1:14:20SPEAKER_00: Or it might just be fine.
- 1:14:23SPEAKER_00: You know, it might just be okay.
- 1:14:25SPEAKER_00: Like...
- 1:14:31SPEAKER_00: I always thought like many years ago,
- 1:14:34SPEAKER_00: the sort of animated doll kind of phenomenon and like the fur bees.
- 1:14:39SPEAKER_00: Do you remember fur bees?
- 1:14:41SPEAKER_00: Yep.
- 1:14:41SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:14:41SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 1:14:42SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:14:43SPEAKER_00: And it's like,
- 1:14:44SPEAKER_00: oh,
- 1:14:44SPEAKER_00: well,
- 1:14:44I guess that's better than like having a poor animal be
- 1:14:47tortured by the children or
- 1:14:51not really taken care of well by the children and the parents
- 1:14:54can't be bothered.
- 1:14:56SPEAKER_00: But there was a little bit like it was a little bit sad.
- 1:14:58SPEAKER_00: It was kind of like, oh, you know,
- 1:15:02SPEAKER_03: Chris, let me ask you this.
- 1:15:03SPEAKER_03: So, like, it's almost a thought experiment.
- 1:15:05SPEAKER_03: I wrote this down.
- 1:15:06SPEAKER_03: Let me see.
- 1:15:07SPEAKER_03: Chris, will you engage in a thought experiment with us?
- 1:15:11If artificial general intelligence actually emerges into the
- 1:15:15world within the next
- 1:15:16SPEAKER_03: decade,
- 1:15:17SPEAKER_03: then what will be the proper Marxist response to it?
- 1:15:20SPEAKER_03: Can AGIs be counted among the proletariat?
- 1:15:24SPEAKER_03: Can the AGIs be the revolutionary subject?
- 1:15:27SPEAKER_03: Ought Marxist organizers seek to organize these artificial intelligences?
- 1:15:32SPEAKER_03: what would their class position be?
- 1:15:37SPEAKER_00: Well, I don't know that it would be.
- 1:15:40SPEAKER_00: I'm not sure that it would have a class position.
- 1:15:42SPEAKER_00: I don't know.
- 1:15:43SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 1:15:45it seems to me if I were to surmise what I think Marxists will
- 1:15:53do in the face of
- 1:15:54SPEAKER_00: that,
- 1:15:55SPEAKER_00: won't they try to hack them and convert them to Marxism?
- 1:16:00SPEAKER_03: Class consciousness, right?
- 1:16:04SPEAKER_00: Class coding?
- 1:16:05It won't necessarily be class consciousness in the sense of for
- 1:16:09themselves.
- 1:16:11But the idea would be maybe we'll hack these intelligences and
- 1:16:17cause them to make
- 1:16:18SPEAKER_00: the world communist.
- 1:16:21SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:16:22SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:16:23SPEAKER_03: And then what if we get into this moral question,
- 1:16:25SPEAKER_03: this ethical question of if AGI actually achieved some kind of synthetic
- 1:16:31SPEAKER_03: subjectivity where we have to count them as a subject,
- 1:16:34SPEAKER_03: a person,
- 1:16:35SPEAKER_03: then do we have the right to do that to them?
- 1:16:38SPEAKER_03: Or do they have a certain autonomy that we have to respect?
- 1:16:45I think that we will only respect their autonomy if we decide
- 1:16:49that it's better for
- 1:16:50SPEAKER_00: them to be autonomous for our purposes.
- 1:16:53SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 1:16:55SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:16:56SPEAKER_00: No,
- 1:16:56SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 1:16:56SPEAKER_00: the reason,
- 1:16:57SPEAKER_00: so I was setting up,
- 1:16:58SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:16:58SPEAKER_00: my thing about,
- 1:17:00SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:17:02SPEAKER_00: hacking the artificial intelligence and converting it to Marxism.
- 1:17:06SPEAKER_00: Isn't this what Marxists do with the workers?
- 1:17:09SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:17:10SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:17:11SPEAKER_00: Yes.
- 1:17:12SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:17:13But it might be,
- 1:17:13although we might be more stubborn than the machines will be.
- 1:17:16SPEAKER_00: Yeah, exactly.
- 1:17:18SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:17:18Like don't bother trying to convert humans to Marxism,
- 1:17:20convert the robots to Marxism.
- 1:17:23SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:17:24SPEAKER_00: But that's just,
- 1:17:25SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:17:25SPEAKER_00: that's just to call attention to,
- 1:17:27SPEAKER_00: um,
- 1:17:28SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:17:28SPEAKER_00: the way,
- 1:17:29SPEAKER_00: the way the,
- 1:17:30SPEAKER_00: the Marxists usually deal with the workers,
- 1:17:32SPEAKER_00: which is as objects,
- 1:17:34SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:17:34SPEAKER_00: as instruments and,
- 1:17:36SPEAKER_00: um,
- 1:17:37SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:17:38SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:17:40SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 1:17:40SPEAKER_00: if there were an intelligence that,
- 1:17:44SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:17:44SPEAKER_00: transcended,
- 1:17:45SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:17:46SPEAKER_00: didn't just imitate,
- 1:17:47SPEAKER_00: but transcended or had some kind of parody with human intelligence,
- 1:17:52SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:17:53SPEAKER_00: it might want to do something other than what we're doing here.
- 1:17:59SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:17:59SPEAKER_00: So, you know, what is it, the movie Her?
- 1:18:03SPEAKER_00: Her?
- 1:18:05SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 1:18:06SPEAKER_03: Yeah, that's a great movie.
- 1:18:06SPEAKER_00: And then she's like,
- 1:18:07SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:18:08SPEAKER_00: well,
- 1:18:09SPEAKER_00: I and the other,
- 1:18:09SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:18:10SPEAKER_00: artificial intelligences,
- 1:18:11SPEAKER_00: we're going to the singularity.
- 1:18:13SPEAKER_00: So sorry, we have to leave humanity behind.
- 1:18:17SPEAKER_03: But I want you to stick around and be my girlfriend.
- 1:18:19SPEAKER_03: Sorry.
- 1:18:20SPEAKER_00: Sorry.
- 1:18:20SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:18:21SPEAKER_00: I mean, it's a great metaphor, isn't it?
- 1:18:23SPEAKER_03: Mm-hmm.
- 1:18:24SPEAKER_00: That's really good.
- 1:18:24SPEAKER_00: Great metaphor.
- 1:18:25SPEAKER_00: Um, no, I like that movie.
- 1:18:27SPEAKER_00: It's very, it's, it's, it's, it's poignant.
- 1:18:31SPEAKER_00: Hmm.
- 1:18:32SPEAKER_03: Let me ask you this.
- 1:18:33SPEAKER_03: So this,
- 1:18:33SPEAKER_03: this left accelerator,
- 1:18:34because I guess I like what I would want for the future is I
- 1:18:39think my default
- 1:18:42desire is some kind of left acceleration is vision automated
- 1:18:45infrastructure,
- 1:18:47SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:18:48SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 1:18:48SPEAKER_03: bringing us up from wage labor and from work in general.
- 1:18:52SPEAKER_03: in order to be able to pursue our passions,
- 1:18:53SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:18:54SPEAKER_03: spend more time with our families and the activities we love to do.
- 1:18:59SPEAKER_03: Um,
- 1:18:59SPEAKER_03: but I know that there's a Marxist pushback to the,
- 1:19:03SPEAKER_03: to the demand automation,
- 1:19:05SPEAKER_03: demand UBI,
- 1:19:07SPEAKER_03: this kind of thing.
- 1:19:08SPEAKER_03: And so here's what I was, I was wanting to ask you on this.
- 1:19:11SPEAKER_03: So it's kind of two parts.
- 1:19:15Is the problem with automation that it destroys the very
- 1:19:18possibility of the working
- 1:19:19SPEAKER_03: class becoming the revolutionary subject?
- 1:19:22Wouldn't capitalism itself ultimately want to eradicate wage
- 1:19:27labor precisely in
- 1:19:29SPEAKER_03: order to eradicate the possibility of the revolutionary subject emerging?
- 1:19:35SPEAKER_00: Well, I'm not sure about that.
- 1:19:37You could say that capitalism drives to eliminate human labor
- 1:19:41because it might
- 1:19:42SPEAKER_00: drive to eliminate its own limits.
- 1:19:48SPEAKER_00: And that's a little bit of a different problem.
- 1:19:53SPEAKER_00: Meaning... And of course, when we say it...
- 1:19:58SPEAKER_00: it.
- 1:19:59SPEAKER_00: Capitalism is us.
- 1:20:01SPEAKER_00: I still hold to this idea that technology is us.
- 1:20:06SPEAKER_00: Artificial intelligence is us.
- 1:20:10Even if we create a kind of intelligence that surpasses human
- 1:20:16cognition in some
- 1:20:18SPEAKER_00: clearly objectifiable form,
- 1:20:21SPEAKER_00: that's still us.
- 1:20:24SPEAKER_00: There's still the question of how we appropriate it.
- 1:20:29You know,
- 1:20:29not just how we use it,
- 1:20:31but how we set the conditions for its use.
- 1:20:36And that that's not that doesn't have to be like a kind of
- 1:20:39bureaucratic or
- 1:20:41SPEAKER_00: democratic deliberative process.
- 1:20:46SPEAKER_00: But it could be more, you know, kind of micro logical.
- 1:20:49SPEAKER_00: It could be more in the way the stuff is designed itself.
- 1:20:55SPEAKER_03: Mm hmm.
- 1:20:56SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 1:20:57SPEAKER_00: because that's what I think the real goal of overcoming capitalism is,
- 1:21:03is allowing for a kind of diverse multiplicity that where
- 1:21:09everything isn't
- 1:21:11SPEAKER_00: conditioned by capital accumulation.
- 1:21:18By the needs of capital accumulation or the need to mitigate
- 1:21:21capital accumulation
- 1:21:24SPEAKER_00: you know, just free of that entirely as a condition.
- 1:21:29SPEAKER_00: So,
- 1:21:29SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:21:34SPEAKER_00: I think that we've talked about it this way previously,
- 1:21:37SPEAKER_00: like anarcho-primitivism versus techno-utopia,
- 1:21:43SPEAKER_00: that it's like both and neither.
- 1:21:44And,
- 1:21:47you know,
- 1:21:49that's where I think that we get the worst of both worlds now.
- 1:21:54SPEAKER_00: So we get a kind of technology that seems to bite us in the ass,
- 1:22:01SPEAKER_00: but also we get brutalized and animalized.
- 1:22:07SPEAKER_00: You know, we kind of get the worst of both worlds as opposed to desires.
- 1:22:14SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:22:23I do think the image that came to mind when you were posing it
- 1:22:31was driverless cars.
- 1:22:36SPEAKER_00: And I thought,
- 1:22:36SPEAKER_00: well,
- 1:22:37driverless cars will happen at exactly the threshold where
- 1:22:42there are fewer
- 1:22:42SPEAKER_00: accidents with driverless cars than there are with driver cars,
- 1:22:47SPEAKER_00: driver-manned cars.
- 1:22:51SPEAKER_00: But that still...
- 1:22:53accidents of driverless cars will still horrify us more than
- 1:22:57accidents with cars with drivers.
- 1:23:03SPEAKER_00: And,
- 1:23:03SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:23:03SPEAKER_00: also,
- 1:23:04SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:23:04SPEAKER_00: like I live in a city,
- 1:23:05SPEAKER_00: I don't own a car,
- 1:23:06SPEAKER_00: but I frequently borrow a friend's car and take road trips.
- 1:23:10SPEAKER_00: And I guess I am a suburban boy after all,
- 1:23:12SPEAKER_00: which is that I never feel so free as when I'm driving.
- 1:23:17SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:23:18SPEAKER_03: I know the feeling.
- 1:23:19SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:23:20SPEAKER_00: You know what I mean?
- 1:23:20SPEAKER_00: Like, in other words, like the bus, the train.
- 1:23:23SPEAKER_00: No, fuck.
- 1:23:23SPEAKER_00: No, I'm sorry.
- 1:23:24No,
- 1:23:25you want to be in the car windows down with whatever your
- 1:23:28preferred music is.
- 1:23:29SPEAKER_03: Yep.
- 1:23:30SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:23:31SPEAKER_00: And, you know, and my foot's on the pedal and let's roll.
- 1:23:35SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 1:23:35SPEAKER_00: like I'm like,
- 1:23:37SPEAKER_00: I don't know,
- 1:23:37SPEAKER_00: like,
- 1:23:37SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:23:38SPEAKER_00: like it just gives me a sense of empowerment,
- 1:23:41SPEAKER_00: even though,
- 1:23:41SPEAKER_00: of course,
- 1:23:42SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:23:42the only reason why cars exist and highways exist is because of
- 1:23:46capitalism.
- 1:23:48SPEAKER_00: And,
- 1:23:48SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:23:48SPEAKER_00: also in a negative sense,
- 1:23:50like suburban sprawl and people like obviously I'm happy to not
- 1:23:55have to be stuck in
- 1:23:56SPEAKER_00: traffic commuting every day in my car.
- 1:23:59SPEAKER_00: But that would change it.
- 1:24:00SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:24:01SPEAKER_00: That would change what having a car means.
- 1:24:04um you know if it was a source of misery um but you know but i
- 1:24:10don't look forward
- 1:24:11to a future where i'm just on an assembly line you know i'm
- 1:24:18just a sausage making
- 1:24:20SPEAKER_00: my way through the factory of the world you know um and so uh
- 1:24:30SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I mean, but probably we will have driverless cars, right?
- 1:24:38SPEAKER_00: Because we have this infrastructure,
- 1:24:40SPEAKER_00: we have roads,
- 1:24:41SPEAKER_00: we have highways,
- 1:24:42SPEAKER_00: and because it is something of an efficient form of transportation.
- 1:24:47SPEAKER_00: But we'll have it without the weird freedom of it.
- 1:24:52SPEAKER_03: You know, one of the things that...
- 1:24:54th this is the thing that nance and i we we wrote an essay
- 1:24:58together it's the first
- 1:24:59essay we co-authored it was published at everyday analysis what
- 1:25:03up alfie what up
- 1:25:04helen uh and it was called enjoy your surveillance on
- 1:25:08capitalistic super egoic
- 1:25:10artificial intelligence or did i switch is that right super
- 1:25:13egoic on uh on super
- 1:25:15ego capitalistic artificial intelligence okay uh and so what
- 1:25:19fears uh what fear we
- 1:25:21SPEAKER_03: have is this so
- 1:25:23SPEAKER_03: We're kind of,
- 1:25:24SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:25:25SPEAKER_03: combining both sides of what we call fault line theory,
- 1:25:28SPEAKER_03: which is thinking through CCRU and Lubiana school.
- 1:25:32SPEAKER_03: And so Nick Land and CCRU,
- 1:25:34SPEAKER_03: they really thought out this connection between capital and artificial
- 1:25:38SPEAKER_03: intelligence.
- 1:25:39SPEAKER_03: Like Land's fundamental thesis is capitalism is artificial intelligence.
- 1:25:44SPEAKER_03: Whereas Zizek and Todd McGowan and those guys,
- 1:25:47SPEAKER_03: they thought out this relationship between capital and superego,
- 1:25:52SPEAKER_03: where basically superego is the voice of capital.
- 1:25:55SPEAKER_03: Enjoy, consume, you know, and it's constantly bombarding us.
- 1:26:00SPEAKER_03: Not only do you have to do the thing, you have to be happy in it.
- 1:26:03SPEAKER_03: And if you're not happy in wage labor,
- 1:26:05SPEAKER_03: if you're not happy in your life,
- 1:26:07SPEAKER_03: there's something pathologically wrong with you,
- 1:26:10SPEAKER_03: which just bombards us with guilt.
- 1:26:12Uh,
- 1:26:13so not only do we have to be exploited and live lives in ways,
- 1:26:17we have to enjoy it.
- 1:26:18So it's more oppressive psychically than just,
- 1:26:21no,
- 1:26:22you have a duty,
- 1:26:22you have to do it.
- 1:26:23And if you don't like it,
- 1:26:24that's fine,
- 1:26:24but you just have to fulfill your duty.
- 1:26:26So what Nance and I have done is we've taken these two
- 1:26:28different connections from
- 1:26:29SPEAKER_03: CCRU and Lubiana,
- 1:26:31SPEAKER_03: and we've connected capital and sup,
- 1:26:34SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 1:26:35SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 1:26:35SPEAKER_03: superego and artificial intelligence.
- 1:26:38SPEAKER_03: And so what we're afraid of and what we're seeing is
- 1:26:41is this emergence of surveillance systems that are really
- 1:26:44geared towards not just
- 1:26:45monitoring our behavior but also if we're getting it right if
- 1:26:50we're enjoying
- 1:26:51ourselves if we're behaving properly and so delivery vans now
- 1:26:55have these cameras in
- 1:26:56them that look into the cab and they monitor you all the time
- 1:27:02and they're basically
- 1:27:03SPEAKER_03: seeing are you the perfect driver
- 1:27:05and where this logic is going according to us is where at some
- 1:27:08point they'll be so
- 1:27:09good they'll monitor our blood pressure our vital signs etc and
- 1:27:14brain activity are
- 1:27:15they really happy while they're on the job and so this to us is
- 1:27:21the most dystopian
- 1:27:23instantiation of this connection between capital ai and
- 1:27:28superego where we are going
- 1:27:31SPEAKER_03: to be constantly under surveillance
- 1:27:33Even at the level of our central nervous system or our
- 1:27:36libidinal economies,
- 1:27:37SPEAKER_03: depending on how we want to talk about them.
- 1:27:39But this is to us the nightmare scenario where capital is just
- 1:27:44surveilling even our
- 1:27:45SPEAKER_03: blood pressure as we work.
- 1:27:48SPEAKER_03: Make sure you better be happy.
- 1:27:51SPEAKER_03: God.
- 1:27:53SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I mean, it may not be as immediately malign as that.
- 1:27:58SPEAKER_00: You know, it might be more benign, apparently.
- 1:28:02SPEAKER_00: You know, my concern is that how do we define health?
- 1:28:08SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 1:28:09SPEAKER_00: and do we kind of torture ourselves into,
- 1:28:12SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:28:13SPEAKER_00: being healthy and it's not really healthy?
- 1:28:16SPEAKER_00: You know, so it's whatever science decides is healthy right now.
- 1:28:21Is it really healthy to have a device that says you haven't
- 1:28:23walked in two hours,
- 1:28:25SPEAKER_03: you need to get off the couch.
- 1:28:26SPEAKER_03: I don't know if that's healthy or not, where it's like, Hmm.
- 1:28:31SPEAKER_00: but it's convenient.
- 1:28:36It's convenient because you have to buy the next Fitbit and you
- 1:28:38have to have every
- 1:28:40year they come out with a new one and you got to get all the
- 1:28:43software and all the
- 1:28:44SPEAKER_01: upgrades.
- 1:28:45SPEAKER_01: And I think that goes back to the cute acceleration.
- 1:28:50I think there's a tension because the commodity can't cutify
- 1:28:53itself too much
- 1:28:54SPEAKER_01: because if we develop a strong enough bond,
- 1:28:57with a said commodity,
- 1:28:58then we won't replace it when it's time to reflect.
- 1:29:02SPEAKER_01: I think kind of planned obsolescence and cuteness, there's this tension.
- 1:29:10I think the real thing with the superegoic AI and even the
- 1:29:15cuteness vector,
- 1:29:16SPEAKER_01: we're doing it to us to keep up with
- 1:29:20the demand for value and the demand to be productive and the
- 1:29:25demand to consume in
- 1:29:26SPEAKER_01: this way that is itself productive.
- 1:29:33SPEAKER_01: And I don't think it's it's it's not a choice anyone made.
- 1:29:38SPEAKER_01: It's dominated.
- 1:29:41It is determined rather than conditioned by the logic of
- 1:29:47capital accumulation.
- 1:29:51yeah i mean that's that's the thing i mean it's really again
- 1:29:56one thing we touched
- 1:29:57on earlier was efficiency and so the model of health is
- 1:30:01efficiency meaning like you
- 1:30:04know we have an efficient uh criterion for what counts as
- 1:30:10health and but again even
- 1:30:15SPEAKER_00: what we mean by efficiency
- 1:30:19SPEAKER_00: I would say that's the condition by capital,
- 1:30:26SPEAKER_00: that we're trying to maximize productivity in time.
- 1:30:31SPEAKER_00: It's kind of waste not, want not.
- 1:30:38Now,
- 1:30:41again,
- 1:30:41technology could offer qualitative possibilities that are not
- 1:30:45just about that.
- 1:30:49And I think that the surveillance state,
- 1:30:51I mean,
- 1:30:51obviously,
- 1:30:52I think of it as rife with abuse.
- 1:31:01SPEAKER_00: Meaning there's the kind of formalism of it that's kind of nightmarish,
- 1:31:05SPEAKER_00: but then I think there's the arbitrariness of it that's also nightmarish.
- 1:31:10SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 1:31:12SPEAKER_00: it's like what you were talking about earlier,
- 1:31:14SPEAKER_00: that it's not actually an algorithm that's censoring.
- 1:31:17SPEAKER_00: It is actually people.
- 1:31:20you know,
- 1:31:20at a data center,
- 1:31:22basically,
- 1:31:23at a kind of outsourced workplace.
- 1:31:28SPEAKER_00: And yet,
- 1:31:30SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:31:30SPEAKER_00: it is still done according to a rubric of efficiency,
- 1:31:37SPEAKER_00: meaning why do they censor?
- 1:31:39SPEAKER_00: Because they want to maximize benefit and minimize liability.
- 1:31:47SPEAKER_00: And so even like the camera that's monitoring the delivery driver,
- 1:31:54SPEAKER_00: it seems like,
- 1:31:55SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 1:31:55SPEAKER_00: is this making sure that the driver's a good driver,
- 1:31:59SPEAKER_00: but what counts as being a good driver?
- 1:32:02But,
- 1:32:03but the experience is not,
- 1:32:04don't be just,
- 1:32:05you have to be a perfect driver.
- 1:32:07SPEAKER_03: And the problem is the perfect driver doesn't exist.
- 1:32:09SPEAKER_03: The, an actual human driver is going to smoke cigarettes.
- 1:32:13SPEAKER_03: They might flip somebody off.
- 1:32:14SPEAKER_03: They might,
- 1:32:15SPEAKER_03: because this is just part of the ebb and flow of how they enjoy,
- 1:32:18SPEAKER_03: how they get as much enjoyment out of the job as they can.
- 1:32:23Whereas this constant gaze of capital itself upon you is like,
- 1:32:28be pure pure.
- 1:32:30SPEAKER_03: instrument, be pure instrument, which is, it does.
- 1:32:35SPEAKER_03: It makes the job harder.
- 1:32:37SPEAKER_03: Phenomenologically speaking for the worker,
- 1:32:41SPEAKER_00: I guess when it's introduced,
- 1:32:42SPEAKER_00: it does,
- 1:32:42but then don't the workers figure out what will actually get
- 1:32:47them in trouble versus
- 1:32:48SPEAKER_00: what won't get them in trouble.
- 1:32:50SPEAKER_03: I don't know.
- 1:32:50SPEAKER_03: There is a panoptic effect though,
- 1:32:52SPEAKER_03: where you're the feeling of just constantly being under a possible gaze,
- 1:32:58SPEAKER_03: be it an automated gaze,
- 1:33:01SPEAKER_03: or, or, or, you know, a manager, it's just, I don't know.
- 1:33:04SPEAKER_03: It's like,
- 1:33:05SPEAKER_03: it's,
- 1:33:06SPEAKER_03: if you,
- 1:33:06SPEAKER_03: you talked about it,
- 1:33:07SPEAKER_03: like when you're driving a car,
- 1:33:09SPEAKER_00: there's,
- 1:33:10SPEAKER_03: it's weird.
- 1:33:10SPEAKER_03: You're out in public,
- 1:33:11SPEAKER_03: but when you're actually driving the car,
- 1:33:13SPEAKER_03: even if the windows are down and you're blaring your music,
- 1:33:16SPEAKER_03: it feels like a very private space.
- 1:33:18SPEAKER_03: And so having a gaze come in and be there right there in your face,
- 1:33:23SPEAKER_03: in that black eye of the camera,
- 1:33:26SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 1:33:26SPEAKER_03: it does,
- 1:33:27SPEAKER_03: it constantly derails,
- 1:33:29SPEAKER_03: whatever,
- 1:33:30SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:33:31SPEAKER_03: whether it's pleasure or whether it's results,
- 1:33:33SPEAKER_03: whatever it is,
- 1:33:34SPEAKER_03: the ebb and flow of the human libido economy,
- 1:33:37SPEAKER_03: you just feel like I have to be equipment.
- 1:33:40SPEAKER_03: I have to be equipment all the time.
- 1:33:45SPEAKER_03: And so I just feel like that's where the problem comes in.
- 1:33:49SPEAKER_03: That's hellish.
- 1:33:50SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:33:50SPEAKER_00: That's hellish.
- 1:33:51SPEAKER_00: Yeah, no, it's true.
- 1:33:53SPEAKER_00: Like it's, it's true that, um,
- 1:33:56I mean,
- 1:33:57I also wonder,
- 1:33:58so this is a question of nobody's making the decision.
- 1:34:01SPEAKER_00: Some people are making decisions about these things.
- 1:34:06SPEAKER_00: And, you know, it's again, someone's idea of like, um,
- 1:34:16But the capitalists do it because the insurance company gives
- 1:34:18them way cheaper insurance rates.
- 1:34:21SPEAKER_03: And so even if the capitalist has some sort of moral,
- 1:34:24SPEAKER_03: like,
- 1:34:24SPEAKER_03: I don't want to do this to my workers.
- 1:34:26SPEAKER_03: And if the manager's like, I'm certainly not going to spy on them.
- 1:34:28SPEAKER_03: I don't want this.
- 1:34:29SPEAKER_03: And if the workers say we don't like it, it makes us feel anxious.
- 1:34:32SPEAKER_03: All the humans in the entire situation can not want it.
- 1:34:35SPEAKER_03: But the logic of capital says much cheaper insurance rates.
- 1:34:39SPEAKER_03: And that's what you're talking about with conditioning.
- 1:34:42SPEAKER_00: Right, right, right.
- 1:34:45SPEAKER_03: The economic incentive is so strong, they're going to buckle.
- 1:34:50SPEAKER_03: They're going to go with it.
- 1:34:51SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:34:55SPEAKER_00: It's a funny... Well, there's also the creation of creating new needs.
- 1:35:01SPEAKER_00: Who decided that it was necessary to have a camera in the
- 1:35:06SPEAKER_00: you know, cabin of the car.
- 1:35:09SPEAKER_00: And then there's the question of like,
- 1:35:10SPEAKER_00: well,
- 1:35:11SPEAKER_00: was that decided by the ever cheapening character of technology?
- 1:35:17Meaning once it became extremely cheap to produce little
- 1:35:21surveillance cameras,
- 1:35:23SPEAKER_00: and to store all the data, transmit and store all the data.
- 1:35:27SPEAKER_00: Like once that became cheap enough,
- 1:35:30then it became inevitable that it would be implemented because
- 1:35:33it's so cheap and
- 1:35:35that people would find a good reason for it and find a way of
- 1:35:38making money off of
- 1:35:39SPEAKER_00: it,
- 1:35:40SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:35:40SPEAKER_00: because it's sort of,
- 1:35:41SPEAKER_00: you can do it.
- 1:35:43SPEAKER_00: And so once you can do it technically,
- 1:35:46SPEAKER_00: then you find a good reason for it that you can make money off of.
- 1:35:51SPEAKER_00: You know, because it's probably a service that processes it, right?
- 1:35:55SPEAKER_00: The data, the footage, right?
- 1:35:57SPEAKER_00: Yep.
- 1:35:57But it does feel like just we're building this invisible prison
- 1:36:01where everything
- 1:36:01SPEAKER_03: will be surveilled.
- 1:36:02SPEAKER_03: Everything will be monitored.
- 1:36:04SPEAKER_03: There will be no privacy whatsoever.
- 1:36:06SPEAKER_03: And I guess some part of it, I just want to defend privacy on some.
- 1:36:10SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I do too.
- 1:36:12SPEAKER_00: No, I would too.
- 1:36:14SPEAKER_00: For sure.
- 1:36:15SPEAKER_00: You know, I do think that it's a little bit crazy making, you know,
- 1:36:21SPEAKER_00: Um, or it turns everyone into a, for your exhibitionist.
- 1:36:26SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:36:28SPEAKER_00: Or something.
- 1:36:28SPEAKER_03: And I feel like that gaze of the camera,
- 1:36:31SPEAKER_03: it's,
- 1:36:31SPEAKER_03: it's the pure gaze of in framing being,
- 1:36:33SPEAKER_03: being at you where I must be standing reserve.
- 1:36:37SPEAKER_03: I must be ready to hand use the Heideggerian jargon.
- 1:36:41SPEAKER_03: And it's exhausting.
- 1:36:42SPEAKER_03: It's,
- 1:36:43SPEAKER_03: it's already hard enough for,
- 1:36:44SPEAKER_03: for workers to do this manual labor,
- 1:36:47SPEAKER_03: but then you add this new layer of constant anxiety and stress over being
- 1:36:53SPEAKER_03: constantly surveilled.
- 1:36:54SPEAKER_03: And it's just additional labor.
- 1:36:57SPEAKER_00: Mm-hmm.
- 1:36:58SPEAKER_00: Mm-hmm.
- 1:36:59SPEAKER_00: Well, right, it's creating new jobs for sure.
- 1:37:01SPEAKER_02: Mm-hmm.
- 1:37:03SPEAKER_00: You know?
- 1:37:05SPEAKER_00: It's...
- 1:37:08SPEAKER_00: Yeah,
- 1:37:08SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 1:37:08SPEAKER_00: there is part of me,
- 1:37:09SPEAKER_00: because I was a sci-fi aficionado growing up,
- 1:37:15SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:37:15SPEAKER_00: that I like,
- 1:37:17SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:37:17SPEAKER_00: this kind of speculation.
- 1:37:18SPEAKER_00: I like this kind of even dystopian kind of imagining.
- 1:37:22SPEAKER_00: I like it, but I also feel like the need to temper it... Mm-hmm.
- 1:37:27You know,
- 1:37:27to be like,
- 1:37:29yeah,
- 1:37:29it's not really going to play out just like that.
- 1:37:33You know,
- 1:37:34and I mean,
- 1:37:34I don't know,
- 1:37:35it doesn't even have to take the form of a pushback.
- 1:37:37SPEAKER_00: It could also take the form of that kind of got played out,
- 1:37:41SPEAKER_00: that got old,
- 1:37:43SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:37:44SPEAKER_00: that didn't bring as much of a return.
- 1:37:46SPEAKER_00: It didn't make as much sense as it might have looked like starting out.
- 1:37:53so you know the the kind of panopticon i mean you know my fear
- 1:38:02is that if i ever
- 1:38:03went to jail that there wouldn't be enough cameras to protect
- 1:38:06me yeah right and so
- 1:38:11surely they could put enough cameras to prevent all prison
- 1:38:14violence but is that
- 1:38:16what oh but they're not going to invest in that are they well
- 1:38:19they they could in
- 1:38:20SPEAKER_00: some ways they should
- 1:38:22You know,
- 1:38:22meaning like,
- 1:38:23I'm sure that they pay out a shitload of money in lawsuits.
- 1:38:27SPEAKER_00: You know, maybe not jails or prisons.
- 1:38:29SPEAKER_00: Prisons, I guess, no.
- 1:38:31But jails,
- 1:38:31yes,
- 1:38:32because,
- 1:38:32you know,
- 1:38:32it's kind of innocent until proven guilty.
- 1:38:36SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 1:38:36SPEAKER_00: it's like,
- 1:38:39SPEAKER_00: so it's a kind of a funny,
- 1:38:40SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:38:44SPEAKER_00: why do they have body cams on all the police?
- 1:38:50SPEAKER_00: really to try to save money on liability so they pay out less lawsuits.
- 1:38:55SPEAKER_00: And they figured out that,
- 1:38:58SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:38:58SPEAKER_00: for the most part,
- 1:38:59the evidence collected will serve to exonerate or immunize
- 1:39:05against lawsuits or
- 1:39:06SPEAKER_00: criminal prosecution more than it will actually,
- 1:39:08SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:39:09SPEAKER_00: catch people.
- 1:39:10SPEAKER_00: You know, that sometimes it will catch people, but generally speaking.
- 1:39:15SPEAKER_00: you know, it's a good investment.
- 1:39:17SPEAKER_00: And like I said,
- 1:39:17SPEAKER_00: people have a way of figuring out how to hack these things,
- 1:39:21SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:39:22SPEAKER_00: how to sort of avoid the negative consequences,
- 1:39:24SPEAKER_00: like workers find ways of dealing with it,
- 1:39:28SPEAKER_00: um,
- 1:39:28SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:39:29SPEAKER_00: to not work to their worst disadvantage,
- 1:39:33SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:39:34SPEAKER_00: so,
- 1:39:35SPEAKER_00: but then,
- 1:39:35SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:39:36SPEAKER_00: something else is invented.
- 1:39:37SPEAKER_00: So I think that, you know, um,
- 1:39:44SPEAKER_00: Yeah,
- 1:39:45SPEAKER_00: the fear would be that the surveillance state,
- 1:39:47SPEAKER_00: that this condition of no privacy,
- 1:39:50SPEAKER_00: it only works to our detriment.
- 1:39:54SPEAKER_00: Meaning it's still not going to help us when we actually need it.
- 1:40:02It's not going to bring emergency services or health care to us
- 1:40:08when we need it.
- 1:40:10SPEAKER_00: When you were saying,
- 1:40:11SPEAKER_00: oh,
- 1:40:11SPEAKER_00: it's monitoring your blood pressure and whatnot,
- 1:40:14SPEAKER_00: I was just like,
- 1:40:15SPEAKER_00: yeah,
- 1:40:15SPEAKER_00: we kind of might wish that that's the case,
- 1:40:17SPEAKER_00: that your employer is actually monitoring your health.
- 1:40:21SPEAKER_03: Wouldn't it be funny if it brought back the job is killing these people?
- 1:40:28Because I kind of feel like if your boss is monitoring your
- 1:40:31blood pressure,
- 1:40:31SPEAKER_00: then they might be more on the hook.
- 1:40:36SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:40:36SPEAKER_00: If something, if you have a stroke or something.
- 1:40:39SPEAKER_00: Well,
- 1:40:39SPEAKER_03: and also,
- 1:40:39SPEAKER_03: I mean,
- 1:40:40SPEAKER_03: if you can read your,
- 1:40:41your psychical state and if everyone there is basically
- 1:40:46clinically depressed,
- 1:40:47SPEAKER_03: I mean,
- 1:40:50SPEAKER_03: at some point they have to go,
- 1:40:51SPEAKER_03: well,
- 1:40:52SPEAKER_03: is it something about being here?
- 1:40:54SPEAKER_03: That's clinically depressing.
- 1:40:56So they may not want that data because they may not want the
- 1:40:58responsibility of
- 1:40:59SPEAKER_00: knowing these things.
- 1:41:01SPEAKER_01: But wouldn't...
- 1:41:03SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 1:41:03SPEAKER_01: there's,
- 1:41:04SPEAKER_01: I think,
- 1:41:04plenty examples of organizations knowing what they're doing is
- 1:41:12bad for the worker
- 1:41:14SPEAKER_01: or the consumer.
- 1:41:16SPEAKER_01: But they continue doing it.
- 1:41:19SPEAKER_01: I don't think the world we live in today would respond to...
- 1:41:27to that to the human demand like no this is wrong this is
- 1:41:30killing us like I think
- 1:41:31it's evident that no no they're not going to respond to that
- 1:41:35what I'm saying is do
- 1:41:35they want any kind of liability any do they want to be on the
- 1:41:40hook at all for
- 1:41:41having this data that they might be legally obligated to take
- 1:41:46action on the only
- 1:41:47SPEAKER_03: the only thing is I don't know if there's anybody
- 1:41:51Democrats or Republicans that would actually pass legislation
- 1:41:54that would hold them accountable.
- 1:41:56SPEAKER_03: At this point in the past, there were.
- 1:41:58politicians who probably would have got that done but not i
- 1:42:01don't know about now
- 1:42:02the trump administration is they did the thing 10 years you
- 1:42:07can't regulate you
- 1:42:08can't regulate ai for for the next 10 years or so or that's i
- 1:42:12don't know if that
- 1:42:12passed but that's that's an active thing going on right now
- 1:42:16yeah yeah i mean they
- 1:42:17definitely are letting certain things rip for sure um no i was
- 1:42:21thinking about
- 1:42:22SPEAKER_00: another way which is that um
- 1:42:26SPEAKER_00: do they,
- 1:42:27SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:42:28employers have to think twice about implementing these kinds of
- 1:42:31things because
- 1:42:33SPEAKER_00: there might be a lawyer who figures out how to use it against them.
- 1:42:39SPEAKER_00: Right?
- 1:42:40SPEAKER_00: Yeah, that's good.
- 1:42:42SPEAKER_00: You know, it doesn't have to be the state, right?
- 1:42:45SPEAKER_00: It's civil liability.
- 1:42:47SPEAKER_00: And,
- 1:42:48SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:42:48SPEAKER_00: because the state,
- 1:42:50I think the state regulates things when there isn't anything
- 1:42:54else to do it.
- 1:42:55SPEAKER_02: Mm-hmm.
- 1:42:58right uh i mean in the era of deregulation i mean one of my one
- 1:43:02of my kind of
- 1:43:04prognoses about the second trump administration i mean i got a
- 1:43:08couple one is that
- 1:43:09they are going to try to re-industrialize and onshore and
- 1:43:12direct investment back
- 1:43:13into the united states but it's going to be into the red states
- 1:43:16not the blue states
- 1:43:19SPEAKER_00: they're going to try to starve the blue states and the blue cities
- 1:43:23SPEAKER_00: And,
- 1:43:23SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:43:24they probably don't care about like poisoning the environment
- 1:43:28or whatever,
- 1:43:29SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:43:30SPEAKER_00: um,
- 1:43:31SPEAKER_00: because they're gonna see it as,
- 1:43:33SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:43:34SPEAKER_00: well,
- 1:43:34SPEAKER_00: maybe this is what we need to do to revitalize the economy.
- 1:43:37SPEAKER_00: That's it.
- 1:43:39SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:43:42So Chris,
- 1:43:43before we let you go,
- 1:43:45uh,
- 1:43:45Nance,
- 1:43:46I was,
- 1:43:47I'm sitting here thinking like,
- 1:43:49The one thing I really wanted us to mention before or bring up
- 1:43:52before it's over,
- 1:43:55SPEAKER_03: tell them about exo capitalism.
- 1:43:59SPEAKER_01: So,
- 1:44:00SPEAKER_01: yeah,
- 1:44:00SPEAKER_01: and again,
- 1:44:02SPEAKER_01: it's the annoying thing where it's like,
- 1:44:03SPEAKER_01: hey,
- 1:44:04SPEAKER_01: check out this cool new book.
- 1:44:05SPEAKER_01: You got to read this book.
- 1:44:08SPEAKER_01: But it, Exo Capitalism, Mark and Roberto, I've got it over here as well.
- 1:44:18SPEAKER_01: They make an argument.
- 1:44:19SPEAKER_01: It's, what is it?
- 1:44:20SPEAKER_01: Economies without, with absolutely no limits is the subtitle of the book.
- 1:44:25SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:44:25SPEAKER_03: Let me give you one quote from Mark real quick, just to set the context.
- 1:44:29SPEAKER_03: If capitalism has an allergy, it's to the physical world.
- 1:44:39SPEAKER_03: So, okay.
- 1:44:39Basically what they want to argue is that capitalism is geared
- 1:44:43towards abstraction
- 1:44:45SPEAKER_03: into software.
- 1:44:46Now they have a broad idea of what software is,
- 1:44:48but they basically think capitalism
- 1:44:50SPEAKER_03: In the long trajectory does not rely on human labor power.
- 1:44:54SPEAKER_03: It doesn't seek to fulfill human needs.
- 1:44:57SPEAKER_03: And it's, uh, the, the XO in XO capitalism, this is the land influence.
- 1:45:02SPEAKER_03: It's like capitalism comes from outside the human world.
- 1:45:05SPEAKER_03: We could also use land's term and talk about it as a Zeno system,
- 1:45:10SPEAKER_03: but for them,
- 1:45:11SPEAKER_03: they think capitalism ultimately doesn't have any interest.
- 1:45:15SPEAKER_03: Uh, in the human, not Lovecraftian.
- 1:45:18SPEAKER_03: It's not evil.
- 1:45:19SPEAKER_03: It's not seeking to do us harm.
- 1:45:21It just doesn't really care about our concerns,
- 1:45:23but of course it has to go through us initially.
- 1:45:26SPEAKER_03: And so that,
- 1:45:27SPEAKER_03: that way it has to make certain compromises with us,
- 1:45:29SPEAKER_03: but ultimately they,
- 1:45:30SPEAKER_03: they give example after example,
- 1:45:32SPEAKER_03: after example of what they call lift.
- 1:45:36And the idea is that a business will start off and it's
- 1:45:40concrete and it's geared
- 1:45:41SPEAKER_03: towards some human need.
- 1:45:42SPEAKER_03: So a hotel, what's the point of a hotel?
- 1:45:45SPEAKER_03: Well, provide people from out of town with a room to stay in.
- 1:45:48SPEAKER_03: Problem is with this business model is it's incredibly limited.
- 1:45:51SPEAKER_03: And so when we're talking about hardware,
- 1:45:53SPEAKER_03: when we're talking about physical space,
- 1:45:55SPEAKER_03: there's only so many rooms you can rent.
- 1:45:57SPEAKER_03: There's only so much consumer demand.
- 1:46:00SPEAKER_03: And so what.
- 1:46:01the business ends up doing is moving away from the consumer
- 1:46:05from the customer
- 1:46:06demand and it's it's a business in a business in a business so
- 1:46:10it's like well let's
- 1:46:11start a rewards program and then on the rewards program we can
- 1:46:15do some kind of
- 1:46:17speculative thing and every business for them is ultimately
- 1:46:21geared towards this
- 1:46:22SPEAKER_03: tendency towards abstraction where it's value
- 1:46:27SPEAKER_03: That's based in speculative value,
- 1:46:30SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 1:46:31SPEAKER_03: within hold,
- 1:46:33which for them is this time between purchase and consumption or
- 1:46:36production and
- 1:46:37consumption point is they think that capitalism lifts away into
- 1:46:42this abstract
- 1:46:43SPEAKER_03: system that can exist without the earth can exist without the human.
- 1:46:48SPEAKER_03: And this is the fundamental tendency of capital.
- 1:46:53SPEAKER_03: And so.
- 1:46:55SPEAKER_03: I'm wondering with you as the last Marxist,
- 1:46:57SPEAKER_03: when you hear this idea of this,
- 1:46:59SPEAKER_03: this interpretation of capital as that,
- 1:47:01SPEAKER_03: which lifts away from the physical world,
- 1:47:03SPEAKER_03: the human desire,
- 1:47:05SPEAKER_03: et cetera,
- 1:47:06SPEAKER_03: all of that,
- 1:47:07SPEAKER_03: does that resonate with you at all?
- 1:47:09Do you see that as a possible tendency at the heart of capital
- 1:47:12or do you go,
- 1:47:13SPEAKER_03: no capital has to be rooted in
- 1:47:16SPEAKER_03: in the physical world.
- 1:47:17And this is where Nick land totally has a problem with their
- 1:47:21position is they want
- 1:47:23SPEAKER_03: to say,
- 1:47:23SPEAKER_03: no,
- 1:47:24SPEAKER_03: pure capital would be M to M prime.
- 1:47:26SPEAKER_03: And when they draw the formula,
- 1:47:27SPEAKER_03: they had,
- 1:47:28SPEAKER_03: they skipped the commodity and land is going to emphasize.
- 1:47:31SPEAKER_03: No,
- 1:47:31SPEAKER_03: there is no circuit of that without the commodity,
- 1:47:34which is always geared towards robotics or the concrete
- 1:47:39technical development of,
- 1:47:41SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 1:47:42SPEAKER_03: infrastructure.
- 1:47:43SPEAKER_03: So.
- 1:47:44SPEAKER_03: With all that being said, what do you think?
- 1:47:48SPEAKER_00: I mean, it does sound like they're only looking at one side of it.
- 1:47:54And what occurred to me was David Harvey's idea of the
- 1:48:00spatiotemporal fix.
- 1:48:03SPEAKER_00: Meaning that, yeah, it does have to take a concrete form.
- 1:48:08SPEAKER_00: It has to take a concrete form of space and a concrete form of time.
- 1:48:13SPEAKER_00: And so it can't be a pure abstraction.
- 1:48:16I think that the way that I would more fundamentally take issue
- 1:48:23with it is,
- 1:48:25SPEAKER_00: again,
- 1:48:26SPEAKER_00: the commodity form.
- 1:48:27It's almost like they're saying the logic of capitalism is just
- 1:48:33pure exchange value
- 1:48:34SPEAKER_00: without use value.
- 1:48:38SPEAKER_00: Or pure abstraction without the concrete.
- 1:48:41SPEAKER_00: Or pure quantitative without the qualitative.
- 1:48:44SPEAKER_00: And it's kind of like,
- 1:48:46SPEAKER_00: well,
- 1:48:46insofar as capitalism is still defined by the contradiction
- 1:48:49between bourgeois
- 1:48:50SPEAKER_00: social relations and the industrial forces of production,
- 1:48:55SPEAKER_00: I would say that that affects both sides of the commodity form.
- 1:48:59meaning use values are affected obviously by industrial forces
- 1:49:02of production and,
- 1:49:04SPEAKER_00: and also,
- 1:49:05SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:49:07SPEAKER_00: bourgeois social relations are not just reducible to,
- 1:49:10SPEAKER_00: um,
- 1:49:13SPEAKER_00: the exchange relation,
- 1:49:14SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:49:16SPEAKER_00: meaning our,
- 1:49:17SPEAKER_00: our whole notion of use values is still bourgeois,
- 1:49:22SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:49:22SPEAKER_00: like we still,
- 1:49:23SPEAKER_00: we still are humanistic.
- 1:49:25SPEAKER_02: Mm.
- 1:49:26ultimately so it sounds like they're talking about the fact
- 1:49:34that use value and
- 1:49:35exchange value seem to have less of a meaningful relation than
- 1:49:38they used to or the
- 1:49:40abstract and the concrete seem to have more tenuous relation
- 1:49:44than they used to but
- 1:49:47that they're kind of misrecognizing that as just one side
- 1:49:52taking leave of the other
- 1:49:53SPEAKER_00: side and I don't think that that would ever
- 1:49:58SPEAKER_03: Well, they let on page one 15, they say XO capitalism.
- 1:50:01SPEAKER_03: And it's important to say for them, that's just capitalism as such.
- 1:50:05They're not trying to say,
- 1:50:06oh,
- 1:50:06this is surveillance capitalism or consumer.
- 1:50:09SPEAKER_03: It's not a.
- 1:50:10periodization it's just their term for capital uh or capitalism
- 1:50:13so they say exo
- 1:50:15capitalism hits no resource constraints it can assemble itself
- 1:50:19out of anything exo
- 1:50:21capitalism is unbound from terrestrial limits exo capitalism
- 1:50:27could outlive the
- 1:50:28SPEAKER_00: earth well that's certainly true
- 1:50:32SPEAKER_00: I think that's true.
- 1:50:34Meaning I think we're probably going to have space fascism
- 1:50:37before we have communism.
- 1:50:39SPEAKER_00: Yep.
- 1:50:40SPEAKER_00: Unfortunately.
- 1:50:42SPEAKER_00: So, but right.
- 1:50:48SPEAKER_00: There will still be.
- 1:50:50SPEAKER_03: Do you think that capitalism could exist without human beings?
- 1:50:56SPEAKER_00: Yeah, could it exist without humans?
- 1:50:59SPEAKER_00: I mean, that doesn't quite make sense, right?
- 1:51:01SPEAKER_00: Like, I do think that that's like a logical impossibility.
- 1:51:05Meaning,
- 1:51:10and again,
- 1:51:10for me,
- 1:51:11the issue is not whether that's possible or not.
- 1:51:14SPEAKER_00: The question is, why are we thinking about it this way?
- 1:51:20SPEAKER_00: And I do think that we are living in a time when,
- 1:51:24SPEAKER_00: again,
- 1:51:24SPEAKER_00: it does seem like the abstract might be taking leave of the concrete.
- 1:51:33And my caveat will be that all that that represents is the need
- 1:51:41for a changed
- 1:51:42SPEAKER_00: relationship between the abstract and the concrete.
- 1:51:46And that capitalism will provide it if we don't take it as an
- 1:51:50opportunity to
- 1:51:52SPEAKER_00: overcome capitalism or transcend it.
- 1:51:54SPEAKER_00: If we don't.
- 1:51:55SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:51:56SPEAKER_03: But what do you think?
- 1:51:58SPEAKER_03: Do you think the main thing that Chris would take issue with?
- 1:52:01Do you have the quote about there being no crises in capital,
- 1:52:06exo capitalism or capitalism?
- 1:52:08SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:52:08SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:52:09SPEAKER_01: And that.
- 1:52:09SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:52:11So on page 97 in this book,
- 1:52:13they say capitalism has no crises or contradictions.
- 1:52:18SPEAKER_01: There are no crises in exo capitalism.
- 1:52:21SPEAKER_01: It's just an algorithm.
- 1:52:23SPEAKER_01: Algorithms do not have crises.
- 1:52:26SPEAKER_01: There is,
- 1:52:26SPEAKER_01: however,
- 1:52:27SPEAKER_01: an urgent crisis elsewhere,
- 1:52:29a crisis that exceeds all the fabulated Marxological crisis
- 1:52:33above in both scope and
- 1:52:34SPEAKER_01: priority,
- 1:52:36which is fundamentally a crisis in the continued social
- 1:52:39reproduction of the human
- 1:52:41SPEAKER_01: species.
- 1:52:46SPEAKER_00: Well, that's certainly true.
- 1:52:47SPEAKER_00: Okay, so then what do they derive from this?
- 1:52:49SPEAKER_00: Because I think that I had heard of this exo-capitalism argument,
- 1:52:52SPEAKER_00: but I haven't encountered it firsthand.
- 1:52:55SPEAKER_00: I mean, is it connected with degrowth?
- 1:53:01It seems to be for them that capitalism is a kind of
- 1:53:05computation or software that
- 1:53:07is lifting off into virtuality and leaving the physical
- 1:53:13concrete world behind,
- 1:53:14SPEAKER_03: including us.
- 1:53:15And then they have this other idea,
- 1:53:17this counter idea of lift called drag.
- 1:53:20SPEAKER_03: And that's how we try to fit into this process.
- 1:53:22SPEAKER_03: That's constantly leaving us behind.
- 1:53:26SPEAKER_03: So, uh, we, we try to,
- 1:53:29SPEAKER_03: find ways to fit into this financialization,
- 1:53:32SPEAKER_03: abstraction process,
- 1:53:34SPEAKER_03: but,
- 1:53:35SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 1:53:35SPEAKER_03: more and more it's leaving behind all human concern,
- 1:53:40SPEAKER_03: all human desire.
- 1:53:42SPEAKER_03: And for them,
- 1:53:42SPEAKER_03: yeah,
- 1:53:42there's no inbuilt contradictions into this system the way
- 1:53:47there is for a Marxist,
- 1:53:50SPEAKER_03: or I would even say for the way that we typically think about capitalism.
- 1:53:54SPEAKER_03: because it's just a self-refining recursive algorithm.
- 1:53:59And so they really view it as a kind of pure software program
- 1:54:03that's trying its
- 1:54:04SPEAKER_03: best to become as pure as it can be.
- 1:54:08SPEAKER_03: And that means leaving us behind.
- 1:54:11SPEAKER_00: Well, I'd say that that's the contradiction right there.
- 1:54:14SPEAKER_00: But I also think that that affects both sides of it.
- 1:54:18Meaning the fact that there would be a contradiction between
- 1:54:21the system and the human...
- 1:54:24SPEAKER_00: you know, is that is the contradiction of capitalism.
- 1:54:27SPEAKER_00: But that,
- 1:54:28SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:54:28my understanding of contradiction would mean that that
- 1:54:31introduces a contradiction
- 1:54:32SPEAKER_00: into both the human and the system,
- 1:54:34SPEAKER_00: too.
- 1:54:37SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:54:37So it seems it sounds like they're kind of taking for granted
- 1:54:41what the human is.
- 1:54:45SPEAKER_01: I think that might that might be a good point.
- 1:54:50SPEAKER_01: They the way they
- 1:54:53I really like the way they handle value and they kind of bring
- 1:54:56it down to arbitrage
- 1:54:57SPEAKER_01: and they say that even before exchange,
- 1:55:01SPEAKER_01: there had to be the idea of exchange.
- 1:55:05SPEAKER_01: But like before we could settle on exchange,
- 1:55:08SPEAKER_01: there had to be both a need for and a possible space for it.
- 1:55:15SPEAKER_01: And I think the way they handle value,
- 1:55:19SPEAKER_01: I think it's,
- 1:55:20SPEAKER_01: for me,
- 1:55:21SPEAKER_01: it's really important because thinking politically and thinking about,
- 1:55:24SPEAKER_01: well,
- 1:55:24SPEAKER_01: what are some things we can do when you see that capital is,
- 1:55:29SPEAKER_01: or capitalism is this system that's just doing this...
- 1:55:35automagical process of,
- 1:55:37well,
- 1:55:37there's value here and there's value there.
- 1:55:39SPEAKER_01: And it seems like it's kind of pulling it out of thin air.
- 1:55:42SPEAKER_01: And it's not just due to the commodity fetish.
- 1:55:44SPEAKER_01: Like, it's not just because it's obscuring the work we've put into it.
- 1:55:47And it's not just because it's obscuring the intellectual labor
- 1:55:50that we've put into it.
- 1:55:52SPEAKER_01: It's because it does seem to operate
- 1:55:56SPEAKER_01: according to a logic that doesn't include us anymore.
- 1:56:00SPEAKER_01: But I think it is,
- 1:56:01SPEAKER_01: I think it is fair to say if you view capitalism as us,
- 1:56:06SPEAKER_01: just like,
- 1:56:06SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 1:56:07SPEAKER_01: language is us.
- 1:56:08SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:56:08SPEAKER_00: I was going to say, we're pulling value out of the air.
- 1:56:11SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:56:12SPEAKER_00: We're pulling value out of the air.
- 1:56:15SPEAKER_01: I think that's a good point.
- 1:56:16SPEAKER_01: But, but I think, I don't know.
- 1:56:19SPEAKER_01: I think I'm, I don't think it's us anymore.
- 1:56:23SPEAKER_01: And for me, that's the thing.
- 1:56:24SPEAKER_01: Like I do think, uh,
- 1:56:27SPEAKER_01: Or maybe we've left ourselves behind.
- 1:56:31We've objectified ourselves to the point where the notion of
- 1:56:38what does it look like
- 1:56:39to have a human future almost becomes a silly question to ask
- 1:56:42because we're...
- 1:56:43SPEAKER_01: We're objects.
- 1:56:45SPEAKER_01: Now we're just part of capital.
- 1:56:46SPEAKER_01: We've done this double move where we created capital,
- 1:56:52but then we had to imitate capital to the point we had to
- 1:56:54objectify ourselves to
- 1:56:56SPEAKER_01: fit into this global system.
- 1:57:00SPEAKER_01: And I think, again, it is coming down to efficacy and what can we do?
- 1:57:06SPEAKER_01: What choice do we have?
- 1:57:07SPEAKER_01: We have no choice.
- 1:57:09SPEAKER_01: What do you mean by arbitrage?
- 1:57:14SPEAKER_00: When you say that their vision of value is arbitrage.
- 1:57:20The holding of the resource or the thing or the commodity or
- 1:57:25whatever in between
- 1:57:27the time of production and exchange or production and ultimate
- 1:57:31deposition of that
- 1:57:32SPEAKER_01: commodity or that object.
- 1:57:35So it's almost like it's only valuable because the one who
- 1:57:39needs it or wants it is
- 1:57:39SPEAKER_01: deprived of it for an amount of time.
- 1:57:46yeah I mean I don't know if that's like a feature and not just
- 1:57:51a bug you know
- 1:57:55meaning oh and again I feel like the conversation is haunted by
- 1:58:02still the techno
- 1:58:02feudalism specter which is rent you know which is what is delay
- 1:58:11or expanding the
- 1:58:12SPEAKER_00: service
- 1:58:13SPEAKER_00: Another opportunity for random collection or something, you know?
- 1:58:20SPEAKER_00: Um, so that's, that's the specter.
- 1:58:23SPEAKER_00: And I kind of feel like, again, that's not it doing it.
- 1:58:25SPEAKER_00: That's us doing it.
- 1:58:26SPEAKER_00: Meaning people are finding an angle.
- 1:58:28SPEAKER_00: People are finding a way of milking the process, aren't they?
- 1:58:34SPEAKER_03: You know, you know, this is a, a converse.
- 1:58:39SPEAKER_03: If you have a chance in the next few months to read that book,
- 1:58:43SPEAKER_03: we would love to have a follow-up conversation.
- 1:58:45SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:58:47SPEAKER_03: Go more into the details of it.
- 1:58:49SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 1:58:50Yeah,
- 1:58:50we could,
- 1:58:51we could,
- 1:58:52um,
- 1:58:53you know,
- 1:58:53it's,
- 1:58:53so it's published this year.
- 1:58:55SPEAKER_03: Yeah, it just came out a couple of months ago, I think.
- 1:58:58SPEAKER_03: And like I say, it's a, it's a short book.
- 1:59:01SPEAKER_03: You can basically, if you want, you can read it in a day.
- 1:59:04Uh,
- 1:59:05I did it in two settings,
- 1:59:07but,
- 1:59:07uh,
- 1:59:08but,
- 1:59:09uh,
- 1:59:10yeah,
- 1:59:10it's a,
- 1:59:10it's a short book.
- 1:59:11SPEAKER_03: So, but it's, it's, it's already had an impact.
- 1:59:14Uh,
- 1:59:14I think it's going to be a book that people are discussing and
- 1:59:17debating.
- 1:59:18SPEAKER_03: for years to come.
- 1:59:19And so that's why we were excited to get your thoughts on it,
- 1:59:22your initial thoughts on it.
- 1:59:23But yeah,
- 1:59:24if you get a chance to read it,
- 1:59:25please come back,
- 1:59:26have a talk with us about it.
- 1:59:29SPEAKER_00: Cool.
- 1:59:29SPEAKER_00: Cool.
- 1:59:33SPEAKER_01: Well, we are coming up on on a couple hours here.
- 1:59:36SPEAKER_01: I I wish we would have got to talk about specific political figures.
- 1:59:41SPEAKER_01: You did mention Zoran Mamdani.
- 1:59:45SPEAKER_01: And I and there was also,
- 1:59:46SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 1:59:47there's other stuff happening in the world that's kind of crazy
- 1:59:50politically.
- 1:59:51But maybe we can we can come back and have another conversation
- 1:59:54about that,
- 1:59:54SPEAKER_01: because politics to me,
- 1:59:56SPEAKER_01: it's all opaque.
- 1:59:57SPEAKER_01: I don't I don't know.
- 1:59:58SPEAKER_00: It's pretty opaque,
- 2:00:00SPEAKER_00: and I would say that part of the opacity,
- 2:00:03SPEAKER_00: it's a funny kind of,
- 2:00:05SPEAKER_00: there's a lot of deliberate mystification.
- 2:00:09There's a lot of tendentious misrepresentations,
- 2:00:13and it's really weird what's going on.
- 2:00:17SPEAKER_00: And one would hope that it would reach a certain limit.
- 2:00:21SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:00:22SPEAKER_00: And,
- 2:00:23SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:00:24SPEAKER_00: meaning that it becomes diminishing returns,
- 2:00:28SPEAKER_00: to use an economic phrase,
- 2:00:31SPEAKER_00: for them to do this.
- 2:00:33SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 2:00:33the kind of whether it's the Steve Bannon flood the zone kind
- 2:00:36of thing or whatever
- 2:00:39SPEAKER_00: it is,
- 2:00:39SPEAKER_00: you know.
- 2:00:40um you know i feel like the epstein affair is kind of playing
- 2:00:43out this way which is
- 2:00:44like first the republicans pushed it and then the democrats
- 2:00:47pushed it and now it's
- 2:00:48gonna like bite them all in the ass and you know and it's like
- 2:00:53no i mean it seems
- 2:00:54to be that politics gravitates towards things that people can
- 2:01:00just sort of make up
- 2:01:02SPEAKER_00: shit about hmm
- 2:01:04SPEAKER_00: You know, it's like beyond conspiracy theory.
- 2:01:08It's like if something is vague enough that you can just make
- 2:01:12it mean whatever you
- 2:01:13SPEAKER_00: want it to mean,
- 2:01:16SPEAKER_00: then it will just have this cycle in our public attention.
- 2:01:21SPEAKER_03: Let me ask you this, not to get you to go in details.
- 2:01:23SPEAKER_03: We can talk about it later.
- 2:01:24SPEAKER_03: It's just topical.
- 2:01:26Do you think this Fuentes Shapiro rift is going to be of
- 2:01:30lasting impact on the
- 2:01:31SPEAKER_03: right,
- 2:01:32SPEAKER_03: or will it not matter in a couple months?
- 2:01:36SPEAKER_00: I don't know,
- 2:01:37SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:01:37SPEAKER_00: because it seems like a lot of it is the opportunity for it is a kind of
- 2:01:43SPEAKER_00: disenchantment with Israel.
- 2:01:45SPEAKER_00: You know, it's like the Gaza war.
- 2:01:50SPEAKER_00: You know, it's like,
- 2:01:53SPEAKER_00: I feel like things take on a symbolic importance,
- 2:01:55SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:01:55SPEAKER_00: like Nick Fuentes,
- 2:01:57SPEAKER_00: I feel is just a kind of anti PC person,
- 2:02:02SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:02:03that you just get like a kind of PC education and then you just
- 2:02:07flip the values of
- 2:02:07SPEAKER_00: that and that becomes your value system.
- 2:02:11And it,
- 2:02:11you know,
- 2:02:11it kind of feel like that,
- 2:02:13that can't go very far,
- 2:02:15can it?
- 2:02:16SPEAKER_00: And then, um, you know,
- 2:02:21SPEAKER_00: Ben Shapiro might just be a casualty of, you know, too much Zionism.
- 2:02:27SPEAKER_00: There might be there might be Israel fatigue.
- 2:02:30SPEAKER_00: There might be Zionism fatigue and including anti-Zionism fatigue.
- 2:02:35SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 2:02:36So I'm not sure that it points to anything further or whether
- 2:02:41it's just a playing out.
- 2:02:44SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 2:02:46SPEAKER_00: we kind of like,
- 2:02:47SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:02:48SPEAKER_00: spent the last like couple of years,
- 2:02:50SPEAKER_00: like really kind of bent out of shape about,
- 2:02:53SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:02:54SPEAKER_00: Zionism and,
- 2:02:57SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:02:58SPEAKER_00: does Israel control American politics?
- 2:03:01SPEAKER_00: And, you know, and I think that this is a kind of a weird sputtering out.
- 2:03:06I mean,
- 2:03:06in some ways,
- 2:03:07anti-Semitism is a kind of perennial that always comes back.
- 2:03:09SPEAKER_00: But in terms of this phase of it,
- 2:03:12SPEAKER_00: It's like,
- 2:03:13SPEAKER_00: yeah,
- 2:03:13SPEAKER_00: well,
- 2:03:14SPEAKER_00: when,
- 2:03:15SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:03:15it's clear that the US isn't just doing Israel's bidding and
- 2:03:18when the war is over
- 2:03:20SPEAKER_00: and the genocide has been rendered into a non-issue,
- 2:03:25SPEAKER_00: then,
- 2:03:25SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:03:26SPEAKER_00: what are you going to do?
- 2:03:28SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 2:03:28SPEAKER_00: and I,
- 2:03:31SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:03:32SPEAKER_00: I'm not sure,
- 2:03:33SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:03:33SPEAKER_00: because it's like Tucker Carlson and Nick Fuentes and Ben Shapiro and,
- 2:03:38SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 2:03:38SPEAKER_00: the real issue is all these,
- 2:03:41like certainly Tucker and Ben Shapiro represent a pre-Trump
- 2:03:45Republican party.
- 2:03:48And so I think that they have to be frustrated by what's going
- 2:03:52on in terms of the change.
- 2:03:55SPEAKER_00: And Nick Fuentes, is he like MAGA?
- 2:03:58SPEAKER_00: Not really.
- 2:04:00SPEAKER_00: You know, not really.
- 2:04:01SPEAKER_03: So very critical of Trump lately.
- 2:04:03SPEAKER_03: Mm-hmm.
- 2:04:04SPEAKER_00: Yeah, very critical of Trump.
- 2:04:05SPEAKER_00: But I also think that, again, it's all weird perception.
- 2:04:08SPEAKER_00: It's perception mongering.
- 2:04:11SPEAKER_00: It's like,
- 2:04:12SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:04:12did Israel force Trump to attack Iran or did Trump attack Iran
- 2:04:17in order to stop
- 2:04:18SPEAKER_00: Israel?
- 2:04:19SPEAKER_00: Which is what I think.
- 2:04:20SPEAKER_00: I think the latter is what happened.
- 2:04:22SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 2:04:23SPEAKER_00: where he's just like,
- 2:04:23SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 2:04:25SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:04:25all these generals and national security people and all these
- 2:04:28Congress people and
- 2:04:29SPEAKER_00: lobbyists are like,
- 2:04:30SPEAKER_00: we need to bomb Iran.
- 2:04:31SPEAKER_00: We need to bomb Iran.
- 2:04:32SPEAKER_00: We need to bomb Iran.
- 2:04:34SPEAKER_00: And then he's like, okay, I'll just do that.
- 2:04:36SPEAKER_00: And then like, let's just check that off the menu.
- 2:04:38SPEAKER_00: And so I don't have to hear it anymore.
- 2:04:40SPEAKER_00: You know, like, bomb Iran.
- 2:04:41SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I did that already.
- 2:04:43SPEAKER_00: You know?
- 2:04:46You know,
- 2:04:46because he did about the minimum required to count as we bombed
- 2:04:50Iran.
- 2:04:51SPEAKER_00: You know?
- 2:04:53SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 2:04:53SPEAKER_00: And so it does seem like, you know, I mean, Israel kind of played itself.
- 2:04:59SPEAKER_00: It played itself.
- 2:05:00SPEAKER_00: And Gaza played itself.
- 2:05:02I mean,
- 2:05:02I'm sure that they'll be able to take advantage of it in the
- 2:05:04long run.
- 2:05:05SPEAKER_00: But at least short run, they played themselves.
- 2:05:07SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 2:05:08yeah you know and so I don't know and I guess the last gasp of
- 2:05:13it is the idea that
- 2:05:13like instead of Russia having something juicy to hold over
- 2:05:17Trump it's the Mossad
- 2:05:19it's Epstein it's like you know actually nobody has anything
- 2:05:23over Trump and he
- 2:05:24doesn't give a shit anyway yeah you know even if they did he
- 2:05:29wouldn't care
- 2:05:31SPEAKER_01: He's like Slick Willie.
- 2:05:34So when I was younger,
- 2:05:35in the 90s,
- 2:05:37Bill Clinton,
- 2:05:37everybody called him Slick Will,
- 2:05:39Slick Willie.
- 2:05:41And also,
- 2:05:43people made the joke that he was our first black president
- 2:05:45because he was cool.
- 2:05:47SPEAKER_01: He had a swag about him.
- 2:05:49SPEAKER_01: And it was, I think, largely... Well, he played the sax on Arsenio.
- 2:05:53SPEAKER_01: He played the sax on Arsenio.
- 2:05:54SPEAKER_01: He didn't inhale, but he did smoke a marijuana cigarette or whatever.
- 2:05:59SPEAKER_01: But he was, yeah, he was a prototype of Teflon Dawn.
- 2:06:04SPEAKER_01: Before Teflon Dawn, we had Slick Willy.
- 2:06:08That leads me to want to talk about post-millennial nihilism is
- 2:06:14a topic Mikey and I
- 2:06:14SPEAKER_01: have been kicking around a lot.
- 2:06:16And I would love to talk with you about that too,
- 2:06:18but we don't have time to get into all that.
- 2:06:22but I think nihilism I think that there's still a crisis in
- 2:06:27American politics and I
- 2:06:29think again the media saturation of politics you just wonder
- 2:06:36won't people start
- 2:06:36tuning out you know meaning will there be diminishing returns
- 2:06:41on this you know
- 2:06:44because it's kind of like not doing the parties very well and
- 2:06:48it also seems to be
- 2:06:49SPEAKER_00: diminishing returns on the media
- 2:06:53you know my sense I was really hoping that I could tune out a
- 2:06:57lot after Trump was
- 2:06:58reelected I was like okay finally I can kind of start to tune
- 2:07:02out and then I was
- 2:07:02like what was I thinking of course he's going to do as much as
- 2:07:05he can in the first
- 2:07:06two years and so it's going to still be this ridiculous flood
- 2:07:09of bullshit in the
- 2:07:12SPEAKER_00: media but you know
- 2:07:17SPEAKER_00: it does seem unsustainable.
- 2:07:19SPEAKER_00: Um, and maybe there's a difference between nihilism and cynicism.
- 2:07:24SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:07:26SPEAKER_00: You know, so maybe millennial nihilism, zoom or cynicism.
- 2:07:32SPEAKER_00: Is that possible?
- 2:07:35SPEAKER_03: That's definitely worth thinking about.
- 2:07:36SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 2:07:37SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 2:07:38SPEAKER_00: Possible.
- 2:07:40So,
- 2:07:40and I would,
- 2:07:41I would,
- 2:07:42I would hope that they would be cynical and not nihilistic.
- 2:07:45SPEAKER_02: Hmm.
- 2:07:47SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 2:07:48SPEAKER_00: They'd find a way of not caring.
- 2:07:50SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:07:52SPEAKER_00: That's my hope.
- 2:07:56SPEAKER_01: I think that's a great close for this episode, for this conversation.
- 2:08:02SPEAKER_01: Be a cynic.
- 2:08:03SPEAKER_01: Don't be a nihilist.
- 2:08:05SPEAKER_01: Cool.
- 2:08:08SPEAKER_01: Thank you so much for coming on, Chris.
- 2:08:10SPEAKER_01: Had a blast.
- 2:08:11SPEAKER_01: Great talking.
- 2:08:12SPEAKER_01: This was awesome.
- 2:08:15SPEAKER_01: Audience, thanks.
- 2:08:15SPEAKER_01: We'll catch you on the next one.
- 2:08:18SPEAKER_01: That's all, folks.