Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [13F] Michael Burry's Bifurcated Strategy: AI Short and Deep Value Longs
Transcript
- 0:00OK, let's unpack this. If you follow the markets, you
- 0:03know when Michael Bury files his quarterly holdings, well,
- 0:05everyone pays attention. Absolutely.
- 0:07He's got that track record from O 8.
- 0:08Exactly. But this Q3202513-F from Scion
- 0:13Asset Management, I mean, wow, it's not just an update.
- 0:16It feels more like a a financial statement, a really loud.
- 0:21One, it really does. We're talking a notional value
- 0:23here of what, $1.38 billion? And it's such a dramatic shift
- 0:28away from anything resembling diversification.
- 0:30Totally. It's straightened to these high
- 0:32conviction extremes. So today we're diving deep into
- 0:35this, what's really going on with this portfolio?
- 0:38You know, it's classic bury in a way, but also taken to another
- 0:42level, it's what you call a barbell strategy, really
- 0:44bifurcator. Bifurcator.
- 0:45OK, explain that. Is essentially split the
- 0:47portfolio in two. On one side you have this
- 0:50massive and I mean massive directional short bet against a
- 0:53very specific sector, high flying tech, and on the other
- 0:56side highly selective deep value leveraged bets mostly on let's
- 1:01call it the old economy things totally non correlated.
- 1:04Got it. So our mission here is to really
- 1:07breakdown this barbell. We need to get under the hood of
- 1:10that huge short position. And understand the logic behind
- 1:13those seemingly smaller but still explosive long positions
- 1:18on the other side. And crucially, let's clarify
- 1:20that term notional value right up front, because $1.38 billion
- 1:25sounds enormous. But it works differently with
- 1:27options, right? That's super important for you,
- 1:30the listener to grasp when we say $1.38 billion notional, most
- 1:35of that size is coming from put options.
- 1:37To sell. Exactly.
- 1:38So the notional value is the face value of all the stock he's
- 1:41betting against. The actual cash he spent on
- 1:43those options? Much, much smaller.
- 1:45But the leverage is immense. Immense.
- 1:47Which makes the directional bet incredibly powerful and risky,
- 1:51of course. OK.
- 1:52So the big take away before we even get into the details is
- 1:55this portfolio is billed for chaos.
- 1:58It's designed to profit from some kind of severe market
- 2:00dislocation. Yeah, it's structured to win
- 2:02big, whether we get a sort of deflationary tech crash or an
- 2:05inflationary old economy boom, whichever extreme wins out.
- 2:08All right, let's start with the elephant in the room, that
- 2:10massive short side. That's where the weight is.
- 2:12I mean, visually, if you map this portfolio, the
- 2:14concentration is just stark, roughly 80% of that entire $1.38
- 2:19billion notional value. 80%. Yeah, it's one gigantic
- 2:24directional bet against the art official intelligence sector.
- 2:26Wow just wow, $1.1 billion in notional risk against AI.
- 2:32Which specific names is he targeting with these puts?
- 2:35I assume it's the big ones. Oh yeah.
- 2:37The biggest target by far is PALANTIR, ticker TEEP LAUTR.
- 2:41That accounts for something like 66% of the whole portfolio's
- 2:44notional value. 66% that's over $900 million national on
- 2:49Palantir alone 9. $112 million roughly.
- 2:52And the second big one, NVIDIA. NVIDIA another what,
- 2:55$187,000,000 or so? Yeah, about 13.5% of the total.
- 2:59OK, Palantir and NVIDIA, those aren't fringe players.
- 3:02They're right at the heart of the AI excitement.
- 3:04Exactly. Which tells you this isn't just
- 3:06him saying oh the PE ratios look a bit stretched.
- 3:08No way this has to tie into those warnings he's been making
- 3:11publicly, right about bubbles and specifically that term,
- 3:14circular financing. That's got to be it.
- 3:17That's the forensic angle here. This huge short position is
- 3:21basically an argument questioning the quality of the
- 3:24revenue, the sustainability of the growth driving this whole AI
- 3:28boom. Circular financing.
- 3:31Explain that mechanism again. How does it work and why does it
- 3:34remind people of, say, the vendor financing issues
- 3:37beforethe.com crash? Right.
- 3:39So the concern is this kind of self reinforcing loop.
- 3:42Think about NVIDIA, the chip maker.
- 3:44They've also been a big investor in AI startups like Open AI, for
- 3:47instance. OK, so Open AI gets capital
- 3:50maybe partly from NVIDIA or related sources, and then uses
- 3:53that money to place enormous orders for Nvidia's expensive AI
- 3:58chips. Ah OK, I see where this is
- 4:00going. And then you've got the big
- 4:01cloud providers also buying billions and billions worth of
- 4:04the same chips from NVIDIA to build out their AI
- 4:07infrastructure. And who becomes a major customer
- 4:09of those cloud providers renting back the computing power?
- 4:12Companies like Open AI, using the very chips NVIDIA sold.
- 4:16So the money just goes round and round.
- 4:17NVIDIA invests. The recipient buys NVIDIA chips.
- 4:21Cloud providers buy NVIDIA chips.
- 4:23The recipient rents capacity from the cloud providers using
- 4:26those chips. Precisely, it creates this
- 4:28reflexive loop where the reported revenue growth might
- 4:32look fantastic, but it's potentially masking, you know,
- 4:36underlying weakness in truly organic third party demand.
- 4:40It's like they're funding their own customers to buy their
- 4:43products. That's the fear, and Bury's $1.1
- 4:46billion bet seems to be that the structure is inherently fragile.
- 4:50It looks good now, but it can't hold up under real pressure.
- 4:53And didn't the filing actually change language?
- 4:55I remember reading something about that.
- 4:56Yeah, that's significant. The previous quarters filing had
- 4:58some language suggesting the puts might just be hedges for
- 5:01long positions. That language is gone now.
- 5:03So no ambiguity. None.
- 5:06This looks like a clear unhedged directional bet that this AI
- 5:10structure is going to correct. Hard hashtag tag to the
- 5:13asymmetric barbell and cyclical defensive calls.
- 5:15OK, so one side of the barbell is this enormous aggressive
- 5:19short against the new economy AI barlings.
- 5:23But if he's that bearish on tech, why have a long side at
- 5:27all? Why not just sit in cash?
- 5:28Well, that's the elegance, or maybe the complexity of the
- 5:32barbell strategy, isn't it? He's not just betting on one
- 5:34thing happening. He wants to win either way.
- 5:37Or. At least win if either extreme
- 5:39plays out. The long side is designed to
- 5:42profit from a completely different scenario, one that
- 5:45might even contradict the tech collapse thesis.
- 5:47OK, so what's he using for that? More options.
- 5:49Yes, but call options this time leverage bets for price
- 5:52increases and they're designed to profit if we see, say, sticky
- 5:57inflation and rotation. Back to basics.
- 5:59Interesting. So what are the big calls making
- 6:01up this counterweight? 2 main ones stand out.
- 6:03First, a pretty hefty call position, about $61.5 million
- 6:06notional on Halliburton, ticker Hal.
- 6:09Halliburton Wow, that's about as far from NVIDIA as you can get.
- 6:12Energy Services. Exactly.
- 6:14It's the ultimate old economy, cyclical play.
- 6:16It's a leveraged bet on real assets, on energy, on the idea
- 6:21that maybe we're heading into a period of sustained inflation.
- 6:23Physical stuff matters more than software again, right?
- 6:26Where commodities and infrastructure come back into
- 6:28favor, it's a hedge against the deflationary outcome his short
- 6:31bets would profit from. OK, that makes sense.
- 6:33And the second big call. Pfizer ticker PFE even bigger,
- 6:37around $153 million notional value on those calls.
- 6:41Pfizer so big pharma defensive. Totally defensive.
- 6:44A classic fallen Angel, a healthcare giant with stable non
- 6:48cyclical cash flows that the markets kind of ignored during
- 6:52this AI frenzy. So if the economy slows or if
- 6:55that inflation does stick around.
- 6:57Money tends to flow into these kinds of safe, cash generating
- 7:00businesses, so PFE acts as this defensive ballast.
- 7:03So let me summarize the asymmetry here.
- 7:05He wins massively if the AI bubble pops, leading to a tech
- 7:09collapse, maybe deflationary pressures.
- 7:11That's the puts. Correct.
- 7:12The PLTR and MBDA puts cash in big time.
- 7:15But he's also positioned to win if inflation stays high.
- 7:19Maybe the economy avoids a deep recession, but capital flees
- 7:22growth for value. Then the Halliburton and Pfizer
- 7:25calls potentially pay off handsomely.
- 7:28It's about capturing dislocation whichever way the market breaks.
- 7:32OK. Beyond those big macro bets via
- 7:34options, the rest of the portfolio is actually pretty
- 7:37small in comparison, but very selective.
- 7:40Yeah, individual stocks and one preferred stock.
- 7:43This is where we can alley that deep value great company
- 7:46scorecard framework we use. Right, because Bury loves things
- 7:49that look cheap. But we always need to ask, is it
- 7:52cheap for a reason? Is it actually a good business?
- 7:55Exactly. But first we need to pull one
- 7:57name out because it doesn't quite fit the standard analysis.
- 7:59That's Bruker. Bruker, he didn't buy the common
- 8:02stock, right? He sold that.
- 8:03Right sold the common BRKR and instead bought about $13 million
- 8:07worth of the preferred stock BRKRP.
- 8:10OK. That's a classic special
- 8:12situation capital structure arbitrage, basically.
- 8:15That's the perfect term for it, yeah.
- 8:16He's playing the difference between securities from the same
- 8:18company. He's swapping the volatility
- 8:20risk of the common equity. For what?
- 8:23A fixed payment. For a secure fixed income like
- 8:26yield, that preferred stock pays a 6.375% dividend.
- 8:32So it's locking in income, reducing risk, stepping away
- 8:35from the equity markets gyrations with that specific
- 8:38holding. Got it.
- 8:39De risking. OK, now let's get to the actual
- 8:41common stocks we can run through our scorecard.
- 8:44Let's start with SLM Corporation Sallie Mae.
- 8:46Sallie Mae Oh yeah, this screens Bury.
- 8:49It's a classic contrarian cigar butt kind of play.
- 8:52Looks cheap on the surface. Definitely passes basic
- 8:55valuation metrics. Low PE, low PEG ratio looks
- 8:58undervalued on ADCF non profitability metrics like
- 9:01return on equity through the roof.
- 9:03Average Roe over five years is like 34.5%.
- 9:07Wow, so statistically it looks like a steal.
- 9:09It does, but that's why the scorecard is crucial.
- 9:12What's underneath those numbers and whatever we find, well, it's
- 9:14a bank, right? Or a student loan company
- 9:16basically functions like 1 and the structure is just loaded
- 9:20with leverage. Not much leverage.
- 9:21Debt to equity ratio around 2.9. I mean, banks always use
- 9:24leverage, but that's high. I mean, those great returns are
- 9:27really dependent on borrowed money and the whole thing is
- 9:29super sensitive to economic downturns or credit issues.
- 9:32So the verdict. On our great company checklist.
- 9:36It's a catastrophic fail. It's cheap, yes, but it's high
- 9:40risk, heavily leveraged, not a quality compounder, more of a
- 9:43gamble. OK.
- 9:44Cheap but not great. Let's flip to another one,
- 9:47Molina Healthcare, one MOH. This one felt different, more
- 9:50like GARP growth at a reasonable price.
- 9:52Yeah, Molina fits that garpold much better.
- 9:55Looks like Scion bought it when the whole healthcare sector was
- 9:58pessimistic, pushing the PE down into the, you know, 9 to 10
- 10:01range. Really cheap for its quality.
- 10:04And the quality metrics, how did they stack up pretty?
- 10:06Impressive, actually. Solid compounding numbers, five
- 10:09year average Roe near 30%, return on invested capital over
- 10:1315% and it generates a lot of actual cash for shareholders.
- 10:17Owners earnings yield was around 16.5%.
- 10:19And crucially, how's the balance sheet compared to Sallie Mae?
- 10:22Much much safer. Still operates in a regulated
- 10:25industry, but it's interest coverage is strong, like 7.6 X
- 10:29plenty of cushion to pay its debt.
- 10:31Current ratio is healthy, so despite maybe failing a couple
- 10:35of generic tests due to its industry, the overall picture is
- 10:38strong. So the verdict on Molina?
- 10:40That's a clear pass. It looks like a high quality
- 10:43business, a good compounder that he managed to snag at a deep
- 10:46value price during a down cycle. All right, one more, and this
- 10:49one's maybe the highest conviction equity bet because
- 10:52Scion actually doubled its position.
- 10:54Lululemon. Lululemon.
- 10:57Yeah. This is fascinating because
- 10:58Larial U is usually the opposite of a brewery stock.
- 11:01It's almost always expensive. A known great company.
- 11:03So why buy it now, and why double down?
- 11:05Valuation. The recent pullback in the stock
- 11:08price actually brought its metrics PE around 11 peg below 1
- 11:12into what you could argue is genuine value territory.
- 11:14That just doesn't happen often with Lululemon.
- 11:16And structurally, is it still a great company?
- 11:18Oh, absolutely. Textbook example.
- 11:20Pass like 14 out of 19 of our scorecard tests.
- 11:22Profitability is elite. Gross margins near 60%, Roe over
- 11:2740%. Five year average ROI is an
- 11:29incredible 48%. Wow.
- 11:32And the balance sheet, that was the killer for SLM.
- 11:34Fortress tiny debt to equity ratio like .4.
- 11:38And here's the key zero interest expense.
- 11:40Why? Because they effectively carry
- 11:42no debt. Current ratio is super safe too.
- 11:44So easy call on the verdict. Yeah, highest conviction pass.
- 11:47Yeah, this looks like a case where Bury saw an absolutely
- 11:50elite wide Moat business temporarily on sale and he
- 11:53jumped on it with both feet. Hashtag tag outro.
- 11:55So when you step back and look at this whole Q3 filing, yeah,
- 11:58it's pretty clear sign asset Management isn't acting like
- 12:01your typical diversified value fund right now.
- 12:03Not at all. It feels much more like a macro
- 12:05timing operation. It's driven by these really
- 12:08extreme, almost opposing theses playing out simultaneously.
- 12:11You've got that systemic pessimism, that huge forensic
- 12:14bet against AI's foundations. Right.
- 12:15The circular financing short on NVDA and PLTR, that's the big
- 12:19bearish macro call. But then paired with this very
- 12:21specific bottom up optimism in the long book, and even there
- 12:25it's sharply divided. Exactly.
- 12:28You see the clear distinction between the highly leveraged,
- 12:31just statistically cheap cigar butt like Sallie Mae.
- 12:35Which failed our quality checks. Right, versus the truly elite
- 12:40wide Moat compounders like Lululemon and Molina, which pass
- 12:44with flying colors, bought when they were unusually cheap.
- 12:47They're just totally different kinds of bats.
- 12:49This whole approach gives you, the listener, a really powerful
- 12:53lens, I think, for looking at your own investments or just
- 12:55understanding the market. It really does the same Barbell
- 12:58kind of forces you to ask 2 separate questions about any
- 13:00anything you're considering first.
- 13:02Is this thing statistically cheap right now?
- 13:04Just based on the numbers. But then the second maybe more
- 13:08important question, is this structurally a great company?
- 13:11Does it have strong balance sheet?
- 13:12A real mode? Good returns on capital?
- 13:14Because the answers can be very different.
- 13:16Absolutely. If it's cheap but structurally
- 13:19weak, maybe it's a short term trade a cigar butt like Cecil M
- 13:23High risk. But if it's both cheap and
- 13:25great, that's rare. That's where you get conviction.
- 13:29Like the Lulu position? So here's a final thought for
- 13:32you to chew on. When the next market storm hits
- 13:35and things start looking cheap across the board, will you be
- 13:39able to tell the difference? Can you separate the genuinely
- 13:42high quality businesses that are just temporarily on sale the
- 13:45Lululemons from the structurally flawed companies that were maybe
- 13:48cheap for a good reason all along the Sallie Mae's?
- 13:51Because making that distinction, well, that's often the
- 13:53difference between finding a true multi bagger investment and
- 13:55just, you know, catching a falling knife.