Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Decoding Drip Pricing: Legal Risks in Card Surcharges, Cash Discounts, and Hidden Fees
Transcript
- 0:03Well, good morning, everybody. Welcome to today's
- 0:06program, Decoding Drip Pricing, Legal Risks in
- 0:10Card Surcharges, Cash Discounts and Hidden Fees.
- 0:14I'm Alla Policastro, Director of Education and
- 0:16Professional Development here at Beverly Hills
- 0:18Bar Association. And today I am delighted to
- 0:21introduce Ellen Burge and Leonard Gordon. Ellen
- 0:25is a partner at Venable, where she co -chairs
- 0:27the firm's financial services, payment and payments
- 0:30and fintech practice groups, advising many of
- 0:33the world's most recognizable brands on advertising
- 0:36and marketing compliance, consumer protection.
- 0:39and payment regulations. Her cross -disciplinary
- 0:42practice spans federal and state regulatory frameworks,
- 0:48government investigations by agencies such as
- 0:50the FTC, CFPB, and the state attorney generals,
- 0:55and counseling fintechs, payments processors,
- 0:57and banks on merchant onboarding, money transmission,
- 1:00licensing, and banking as a service structure.
- 1:04A recognizable thought leader and frequent speaker
- 1:06on advertising law, subscription marketing, and
- 1:09payment processing, Ellen also co -chairs the
- 1:12Government Relations Strategic Interest Group
- 1:14of the Association of Payment Professionals and
- 1:17serves as a member of the Venable board. Leonard
- 1:21is a partner at Venable and chair of Venable's
- 1:24advertising and marketing group in New York.
- 1:26He brings deep regulatory expertise from his
- 1:29tenure at the Federal Trade Commission, where
- 1:31he served as regional director. He regularly
- 1:34represents companies and individuals in consumer
- 1:36protection and antitrust matters before the FTC,
- 1:40State Attorneys General, the DOJ, and the CFPB,
- 1:44as well as before the National Advertising Division
- 1:47and in class action litigation. Leonard also
- 1:50provides ongoing counsel to clients on antitrust,
- 1:53advertising, and marketing compliance issues.
- 1:55We're so excited to hear what they have to share
- 1:57with us today, so I'm gonna turn it over to them.
- 2:01OK. Well, thank you, everybody, for having us.
- 2:03I'm going to share our slides. Just one second.
- 2:09OK. And I take it these slides are now visible
- 2:12to you all. But anyway, I'm Ellen. Ellen, you
- 2:17can say hello. Good morning out on the West Coast.
- 2:21Good afternoon, if there's anybody from the East
- 2:23Coast. Thanks for having us. OK. So. We're gonna
- 2:28talk today about pricing, pricing disclosure
- 2:35laws, pay to pay type of issues that span a lot
- 2:41of different federal state and even payment network
- 2:44roles. So this has been a really hot area of
- 2:49regulatory interests, regulatory law enforcement,
- 2:54federal and state. Card network, like visa, MasterCard,
- 2:59interest, private class actions, all sorts of
- 3:04activity in this area, and we're going to try
- 3:07to break down the different component parts for
- 3:09you. We're going to talk first about, after we
- 3:13level set with some definitions that are sort
- 3:15of key throughout the presentation, we'll talk
- 3:18first about the card brand rules. We're going
- 3:20to explain surcharging and cash discounts and
- 3:23sort of what those are and what the differences
- 3:25are. We'll then bring it in a little bit with
- 3:28the federal and state laws on pricing, pricing
- 3:31disclosure. Some of these laws have been around
- 3:32for a long time. They're very much rooted in
- 3:35UDAP unfair and deceptive acts and practices.
- 3:40But we have a newer tranche of laws over the
- 3:44last two, three, four years on requiring price
- 3:48disclosures total all in pricing. We will bring
- 3:51this all together. There's been a lot of case
- 3:53activity too. So we're going to give you a flavor
- 3:54of current cases, recent cases, sort of where
- 3:57the case activity is currently trending and happy
- 4:02to try to take questions along the way too. So
- 4:05Len, anything else you want to say at the beginning?
- 4:07No, I think that's a real good setup for what
- 4:09we're going to cover today. Look forward to it.
- 4:11Okay, good. So let's get into the definitions
- 4:13and concepts. I'm going to take this first one
- 4:15and then Len will pick it up. These terms, cash
- 4:22just got in surcharge. Surcharge in particular
- 4:25is a little bit more rooted in card network rules.
- 4:30But when we talk about it here, we're really
- 4:32talking about an increase to the cost of a good
- 4:36or service imposed on a customer who is paying
- 4:40with a credit card. Instead of by cash or some
- 4:44other means, and that credit card term is important.
- 4:47It's, it's what it's how these a master card
- 4:49to find a surcharge. We'll go over this in a
- 4:53couple of slides, but you can't surcharge on
- 4:55a debit card. If there's an added fee on a debit
- 4:58card purchase, or if there's an added fee on.
- 5:02Credit cards debit cards, which is money coming
- 5:05straight on the checking account or a check or
- 5:08or or any other way that you're paying it's.
- 5:12It's not technically a surcharge under the carbon
- 5:14rules. It's often called a surcharge legally.
- 5:16I don't think federal and state regulators care
- 5:19what you call it. But if it's this other fee
- 5:25that's charged on, regardless of the payment
- 5:27method, it's really just another kind of fee.
- 5:30It could be a convenience fee, processing fee.
- 5:32There's all sorts of labels for it that we see
- 5:34technology fee, service fees. We've listed some
- 5:38of them here. Fee names get very creative. We'll
- 5:41talk about those too, just in terms of whether
- 5:43they could potentially be deceptive and misleading
- 5:45in their naming. But surcharges for credit cards,
- 5:50other fees, these pay -to -pay kind of fees,
- 5:53we'll talk about. A cash discount is something
- 5:57a little bit different. A cash discount is whenever
- 5:59you have a stated price and you actually, whenever
- 6:02the customer shows up and says, hey, I'm going
- 6:05to pay with cash, you can. say okay well instead
- 6:08of paying a hundred dollars you'll get a three
- 6:11percent cash discount and we'll charge you ninety
- 6:14seven dollars for this give me ninety seven dollars
- 6:17but what you can't do is artificially you can't
- 6:24say well look it's ninety seven dollars if you're
- 6:26paying by cash and you advertise ninety seven
- 6:29dollars and then somebody shows up and they pull
- 6:31out their credit card And you say, actually,
- 6:34it's $100. So that's the opposite of what you
- 6:37can do with cash discounts. So we'll go over
- 6:40that a little bit more. Outside of the credit
- 6:43cards and surcharging line, you want to talk
- 6:44about these other terms? Sure. As we talk about
- 6:50fees today, you'll find that they fall into pretty
- 6:54much three different buckets. And those buckets
- 6:57are treated differently legally. Mandatory fees
- 7:01are those fees that consumer has to pay when
- 7:04they buy a good or service. They can't get around
- 7:07it. It's imposed. And think about things like
- 7:12resort fees at hotels, processing fees for credit
- 7:14cards, convenience fees if it's unavoidable,
- 7:17or other types of administrative fees. If you
- 7:20have to pay that fee, it's mandatory and there
- 7:23are disclosure obligations and it's treated differently.
- 7:26The next bucket of fees are sort of the converse
- 7:30of that. And that's avoidable fees, a late fee,
- 7:33optional insurance, gift wrapping, some additional
- 7:37add -on, early boarding, or something like that.
- 7:44The consumer has the choice whether they want
- 7:46to pay more for that extra. And the disclosure
- 7:51obligations, especially on the initial price
- 7:53disclosure, is different because the avoidable
- 7:57nature of it makes it different. And then government
- 8:02imposed fees. Taxes, probably the most common
- 8:08example there. You typically don't have to disclose
- 8:12the taxes upfront. You know, you probably need
- 8:15to disclose them at the end. It gets a little
- 8:19more complicated when you start talking about
- 8:21businesses that have to pay. for the right to
- 8:27do business, you know, a franchise at an airport
- 8:30or something like that. If there's a per transaction
- 8:34fee that the airport authority charges, that's
- 8:37one thing, but the business can't sort of take
- 8:42parts of it overhead and charge them as extra
- 8:45fees. They're gonna have to get wrapped into
- 8:48price and disclosed upfront. So we go to the
- 8:51next slide. There we go. And here the phrases
- 8:56are a bit more pejorative. They probably all
- 9:00fall under the definition or the umbrella of
- 9:06dark patterns. Dark patterns is a big issue in
- 9:11behavioral economics and it's the way businesses
- 9:15supposedly manipulate consumers and essentially
- 9:19deprive consumers of their choice unwittingly.
- 9:22Some people refer to that as marketing. Some
- 9:24people call it dark patterns. But there's a couple
- 9:27that we're talking about today, junk fee. And
- 9:30during the Biden administration, there was a
- 9:32White House council and Rose Garden initiatives
- 9:35on junk fees. Obviously, it's judgmental and
- 9:42nomenclature about the value of what that fee
- 9:45provides. But it's generally thought of something
- 9:48that's unnecessary. excessive or deceptive because
- 9:51it's not something the consumer expects. It's
- 9:53sort of that surprise at checkout. And it's generally
- 9:58thought to be a fee that is not well justified
- 10:04or is inflated and gets stuck on at the end,
- 10:09hoping the consumer is so far down the pipe that
- 10:12they're not going to turn away from the transaction.
- 10:18Drip pricing. is a term used to sort of say where
- 10:24the price comes out drip by drip you know you
- 10:26get you see the advertised price and then you
- 10:28go like another step or two through the enrollment
- 10:30or the funnel process and all of a sudden another
- 10:33fee is tacked on or added to your cart and then
- 10:37perhaps you know a checkout there's another price
- 10:41or you know at the end of your your transaction
- 10:44And it's that drip by drip pricing that again,
- 10:47it's considered a dark pattern Deceptive because
- 10:50you know consumers are trapped that you know,
- 10:52it's got sort of inertia. They've wasted some
- 10:54time and They're they're getting through the
- 10:57death by a thousand cuts on the fees hidden fees
- 11:01You know the Fee is not well disclosed upfront
- 11:07or even sometimes at checkout. It just sort of
- 11:09jammed in there at the end And it just says,
- 11:12admin fee or something, no real explanation as
- 11:15to what it is. And it's in small print. And it
- 11:17comes very late in the process. And the concern
- 11:21there is that the consumer is paying for things
- 11:24that they didn't really understand or agree to
- 11:27pay for when they started their transaction.
- 11:31So back to you, Ellen. OK. So we're going to
- 11:35cover surcharging. We're going to cover a little
- 11:37bit quickly. And we're going to start with where
- 11:39Where Visa and MasterCard are on it, it helps
- 11:42to understand, as I mentioned, under the card
- 11:44network rules, you may only apply a surcharge
- 11:47to credit card purchases, not debit cards. I'm
- 11:51not sure federal and state regulators care as
- 11:53much, but the card networks do. Merchants that
- 11:58are surcharging need to let their payment processors
- 12:01and banks know that they're doing it. A lot of
- 12:03times they miss that step. There's actually a
- 12:07lot of secret shopping efforts by Visa and MasterCard
- 12:10to go out and find merchants and find them, impose
- 12:16a monetary penalty for surcharging unlawfully
- 12:19or without notice unlawfully under their rules.
- 12:24Let's see what else. Visa and MasterCard have
- 12:28Notice and disclosure requirements for surcharging.
- 12:32They do, in their rules, specify that surcharging
- 12:34has to be disclosed at the points of entry, points
- 12:37of sale, clear and conspicuous disclosures. Visa
- 12:42and MasterCard each have different, but they
- 12:44do both impose a maximum surcharge. A lot of
- 12:47this is tied to sort of the cost of processing
- 12:51the card. Credit card processing fees, by the
- 12:53way, are pretty expensive. I mean, they can be
- 12:56two, three. Percent, which, which adds up, especially
- 13:00on larger transactions. So visa masquerade sort
- 13:02of cap there are things around there and there
- 13:06are some other things, but and again, they're
- 13:07often missed by merchants, but it's something
- 13:10to keep in mind. Moving to the, the, the legal
- 13:15realm now, the federal law does not prohibit
- 13:17surcharging. So that's that's helpful in a way.
- 13:20But surcharging is now just another 1 of those
- 13:24many, many issues that we are getting death by
- 13:271000 cuts among the state. So all the pricing
- 13:32loss we're going to talk about today. Well, many
- 13:34of them are state issues. Surcharging has become
- 13:37very much a state issue, automatic renewals,
- 13:39whatever it is, privacy, of course. So this is
- 13:43another 1. So in most states, surcharging is
- 13:48not Flat out prohibited there are a few lingering
- 13:52states where a merchant cannot add a surcharge
- 13:55onto its bills. Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts,
- 14:00and Puerto Rico as well. But a lot of other states
- 14:04to regulate it in some way, even if they allow
- 14:07it, they might put some impose some caps on it
- 14:12here. Let me go to the next slide. Here's some
- 14:15examples. There's a lot of states. That require
- 14:19disclosure. So this idea of like a sticker pricing
- 14:22issue. So if you're going to. Boost up the price
- 14:25with the surcharge that has to be disclosed on
- 14:29the sticker of the item. Essentially, there's
- 14:32an example here in Colorado of putting a cap
- 14:37on the surcharge. So you can't if you're a merchant,
- 14:39you can't charge more than 2 % or the actual
- 14:44amount that you pay. It's it's your choice. So,
- 14:46um, but. There's that in Colorado. Louisiana
- 14:51has a new law that will become effective soon
- 14:54that will prohibit surcharging on debit card
- 14:56transactions, which is very interesting and debit
- 14:59card. By the way, it's a little bit like cash.
- 15:02I mean, the money is coming straight out of your
- 15:04account. So, um, maybe this makes sense to, to,
- 15:08to folks here why you wouldn't be able to do
- 15:10that. But this is something noteworthy and new
- 15:12in Louisiana. Um, some other things here, you
- 15:15can see the different caps, Massachusetts, as
- 15:18I mentioned, merchants cannot surcharge, but
- 15:203rd party payment processors can. Um, and I'm
- 15:24just going to put a pin there because there are
- 15:26a lot of, um, examples we're going to talk about
- 15:28here about. 3rd party charges may not be a payment
- 15:34processor, but platforms, payment, facilitating
- 15:39facilitators, those types of things. There's
- 15:43a lot of examples sort of that we're going to
- 15:45give here on some of these sort of 3rd party
- 15:48costs. Food delivery is another one. So, okay,
- 15:52where are we? Len, I think you were going to
- 15:55mention the New New York sort of surcharge law.
- 15:59So and it's a new law because the other one there
- 16:01was some first amendment issues the prior law
- 16:03about disclosure and compelled speech statute
- 16:09and it actually was found to violate the first
- 16:11amendment so the legislature went back to work
- 16:13and the governor signed it and there's a new
- 16:17new york law gbl section 518 it's pretty straightforward
- 16:21especially for new york which sometimes has some
- 16:24arcane laws No surcharge for consumer unless
- 16:30there's three prongs clearly and conspicuously
- 16:33disclosed total price for using the credit card
- 16:36including the surcharge can't inflate the surcharge
- 16:41to be beyond what you pay for credit card processing
- 16:44and The final sales price can't include an amount
- 16:49greater than the posted price. So you you've
- 16:51got a You know have the all -in pricing and all
- 16:54-in pricing is sort of a term we'll hear a lot
- 16:57as we talk about these various pricing regimes
- 17:00and regulations. The law does not prohibit two
- 17:05-tier pricing, you know, when I think of that
- 17:06I think of a gas station, you know, cash and
- 17:08credit price and this statute really in many
- 17:12ways reflects that model and I've probably aimed
- 17:16at that model a little bit given the sensitivity
- 17:20and gas prices. And there are There are penalties
- 17:24500 per violation state AG and local municipal
- 17:27governments can Enforce it and again that I think
- 17:32reflects the fact that it's really focused on
- 17:33sort of local conduct The guidance the governor's
- 17:38office issued guidance What you can and can't
- 17:42do and the bottom line here is no math You can't
- 17:46require the customer to do math. And if you're
- 17:49like me or my wife, that's a really good thing
- 17:52because we're not very good at math. That's why
- 17:53we're lawyers instead of bankers. So you can't
- 17:58say, you look at the example on the right, 4
- 18:01% credit card processing fee. That's no go. You
- 18:05can have sort of like the guess. price example,
- 18:08thankfully gas is not quite that expensive in
- 18:10New York or Beverly Hills yet, but it's getting
- 18:12there. The credit and cash price, that's fine.
- 18:15The customer doesn't have to do any math. You
- 18:21can't just say that there's a fee going to be
- 18:24charged if you use a credit card. That's not
- 18:28going to work either. The all -in price has to
- 18:30be disclosed if you're going to be charging an
- 18:32additional price for the use of credit What does
- 18:39comply again the gas station example credit card
- 18:42price cash price The business just lists the
- 18:46higher price and you know, you find out the discount
- 18:49pleasantly When you pay with cash Or obviously
- 18:56you can pay this charge the same price that no
- 19:00surprises and no math are really are no unpleasant
- 19:03surprises and no math is sort of the The rule
- 19:06here. Okay, let's see. We also have did I skip
- 19:15something? No. Okay, we're good. So. Okay, and
- 19:22then, so this is also every year we're seeing
- 19:25new proposed bills come up the legislative cycle
- 19:28for. Whatever cycle everybody was just in is
- 19:33pretty much wrapped up. So, bills that were proposed
- 19:36that did not go through maybe will be reintroduced,
- 19:40but you can see here just an example of legislation
- 19:44that was considered most recently in the twenty
- 19:47five, twenty six terminal on of these places.
- 19:49So, um, the, the highlights are along the lines
- 19:51of what we've already talked about. So, um, Illinois,
- 19:55Minnesota, both set for something that would.
- 19:58Prohibit a surcharge unless the seller also accepts
- 20:02cash. So they were looking for some way to avoid
- 20:05that surcharge, but they would prohibit a cash
- 20:09discount. So again, if your advertised price
- 20:11is $100 and somebody shows up to pay with cash
- 20:15and you're only going to charge them 97, that
- 20:17would be okay. The other ones are more along
- 20:19the same lines here. Georgia, you can't exceed
- 20:25the actual processing costs. New Jersey, somebody
- 20:31in New Jersey tried to prohibit surcharges altogether,
- 20:34but would allow cash discounting to go forward.
- 20:38And then Oklahoma had some really disclosure
- 20:43law, surcharging will be allowed, but it has
- 20:45to be separately listed as a line item. So again,
- 20:47these get really. Potentially problematic if
- 20:51you're a nationwide seller of things, we think
- 20:55about these things a lot in brick and mortar
- 20:59retail, like signs and notices posted, but very
- 21:03much all of these laws would apply to online
- 21:04transactions too, so keep that in mind. Let me
- 21:09see, where are we going here? More here. In Massachusetts,
- 21:16Massachusetts, there's a lot of people really
- 21:18concerned about this issue in Massachusetts because
- 21:20they. They had a lot of sometimes conflicting
- 21:22bills that were being proposed. So, lots of different
- 21:24ideas on what to do with surcharging like the
- 21:271st, 1 listed would have prohibited surcharging.
- 21:30The 2nd, 1 listed would have allowed surcharging
- 21:33as long as there was a clear notice of it. I
- 21:37think this. Sort of maybe all these conflicting
- 21:39things did themselves and I'm not sure that any
- 21:42of these passed. Look at the last one, you could
- 21:44surcharge, but it has to only be up to one half
- 21:47of the processing costs. Processing costs, by
- 21:50the way, are really hard to sort of figure out
- 21:52sometimes. So, just to be aware that these things
- 21:58are coming forward and there are lots to watch
- 22:02as legislatures come back in a session. Len,
- 22:05it's worth a moment to talk about our Interchange
- 22:08Fee Prevention Acts, which you've had a lot of
- 22:10experience with. Sure. And this one's complicated.
- 22:14The Interchange Fee Prevention Acts, it started
- 22:16in Illinois. The governor wanted to raise sales
- 22:19taxes. The retail community balked. And one of
- 22:24the things they balked about is, well, we have
- 22:25to pay. credit card interchange on sales taxes,
- 22:29in fact, on gratuities. And we don't get any
- 22:31of that money, but we still have to pay the interchange,
- 22:33and that's not fair. So the governor through
- 22:37the retail community of Bone and worked with
- 22:39the legislation to get this bill passed that
- 22:40said the credit card networks and the banks can't
- 22:43charge merchants for interchange on the tax and
- 22:47gratuity portions of card transactions. There's
- 22:49also some restrictions on the use of card data.
- 22:53And the banking industry challenged it as saying
- 22:56that the state statute was preempted by the National
- 22:59Bank Act and similar statutes for credit unions
- 23:03and savings and loans because it was regulating
- 23:05the business of banking in an area where the
- 23:07control of the currency and the National Bank
- 23:11Act occupied the field. A bunch of other states
- 23:14piled on. The litigation has been twisted. The
- 23:20judge issued an injunction. prohibiting the imposition
- 23:23of fees then reversed herself at summary judgment
- 23:26and said no most of the fees can be allowed there
- 23:30was a couple exceptions and then also the restrictions
- 23:34on card data were stricken went up on appeal
- 23:36while was on appeal the office of the comptroller
- 23:38of the currency issued a rule that found it preempted
- 23:42so it went back to the district court it's still
- 23:44there it's going to go back and forth Seventh
- 23:49Circuit maybe even to the Supreme Court before
- 23:52it's over. But it shows sort of the struggle
- 23:54between merchants, consumers, and the credit
- 23:56card networks as to who pays for what when it
- 24:00comes to the cost of credit card processing,
- 24:04which there's an enormous network that allows
- 24:07us to have this fast instantaneous transactions.
- 24:11And there's a lot of fight about who has to pay
- 24:13for that. All right, so let's move away from
- 24:19maybe a credit card processing room for a little
- 24:21bit and go into some of our consumer protection
- 24:25laws. This is fundamentally rooted in false deceptive
- 24:32pricing issues, but Len, anything background?
- 24:36Yeah, sure. So, I mean, a while ago, the FTC
- 24:39published guides against deceptive pricing. And
- 24:44most of this is really what we would call reference
- 24:47pricing. 20 % off, 50 % off, lowest price ever,
- 24:52where you're comparing the price that's being
- 24:54touted to the consumer to a former price. And
- 24:58the FTC guides... discussed that comparing that
- 25:01to a price that is illusory is deceptive, makes
- 25:05sense. If it's 50 % off, but you know, you never
- 25:08sold anything at the 100 % price, that's a problem.
- 25:11If it's buy one, get one, but you have to buy
- 25:13two or no one ever buys one, they don't even
- 25:15offer it as a single, that can be a problem.
- 25:19And anything that sort of gives a deceptive or
- 25:22manufactured sense of savings when that's not
- 25:24real. runs afoul of the guides. Now, the guides
- 25:27aren't regulations that you can get fined for
- 25:29violating, but they do inform how the FTC would
- 25:33interpret section five of the FTC Act. Courts
- 25:38look to them. Planespar looks to those guides
- 25:40as well, and sort of bringing state consumer
- 25:42protection cases. California has a particular
- 25:47statute on this. The former price has to be,
- 25:51the reference price has to be, prevailing market
- 25:54price. within three months, not just offered
- 25:56once, but you know actually a price you're really
- 25:58charging for that. Why is this relevant to drip
- 26:03pricing? Well one of the things that certain
- 26:07merchants have done over time is to talk about
- 26:10how something is on sale and there's a discount
- 26:14and then try and essentially recapture that discount
- 26:18by jamming some fees on at the end of the transaction
- 26:24so that it's both a drip fee issue and a reference
- 26:30pricing issue. The next one. And there's the
- 26:37plainest bar. They're energetic, they're creative,
- 26:41and they're active. And they're looking for cases
- 26:48on this false discount. Ann Taylor Loft got one
- 26:53where the systematic advertising discounts reflected
- 26:58the reference prices that were never charged.
- 27:00That was brought under the Oregon statute and
- 27:04analogized to the FTC Act. There's no private
- 27:06right of action of the FTC Act. But again, they
- 27:08used the guides there to inform that. The Brooms
- 27:13case in California, again, brandy clothing, inflated
- 27:17reference prices. One of the things we see in
- 27:21these cases frequently, you know, the 100 slash
- 27:25500. No, it's normally 100 now. I'm sorry. 150.
- 27:29Normally 100 bucks now on sale for 50. It's limited
- 27:32time only where, frankly, it's always offered
- 27:34at that price. 50 % off where it's a reference
- 27:38price is inflated or illusory. And again, you're
- 27:44deceiving the consumer into thinking they're
- 27:46getting a good deal, a special deal. But in fact,
- 27:49they are not. So next, we're going to go into
- 27:53price transparency laws. But just a question
- 27:55for you, Len. First, we have general laws that
- 28:01prohibit unfair and deceptive practices. We already
- 28:04had an FTC guidance against deceptive pricing,
- 28:10which is effectively a trade regulation rule,
- 28:13I believe. So why do we now have very specific
- 28:16pricing laws that have cropped up? So in 2021,
- 28:26the Supreme Court ruled that the FTC couldn't
- 28:29get money for violations of the FTC Act. So the
- 28:32FTC started issuing rules, especially under when
- 28:37Lena Kahn was the chair, to restore some of their
- 28:42lost powers to get money back. there's a different
- 28:48part of the FTC Act that allows the FTC to get
- 28:51money, either civil penalties or restitution
- 28:54for violations of FTC rules where they can't
- 28:56get it for violations of just the FTC Act. So
- 28:59that started a flood of rule -making. We called
- 29:04it rule of Palooza at the FTC. And that's what
- 29:08you're still seeing now. The FTC rule on unfair
- 29:11deceptive fees is one of those rules. It was
- 29:13initially much broader and would have covered
- 29:15really the entire economy. There was some effective
- 29:19lobbying and some division among the commissioners,
- 29:24and they ultimately had it just apply to live
- 29:27event tickets and short -term lodging. But the
- 29:30approach that the FTC takes here is one that
- 29:33will inform how to comply with the FTC act. Generally,
- 29:38total price has to be the most prominent price.
- 29:43It has to include everything except government
- 29:46charges. And again, it has to be the actual government
- 29:48charge. No padding that. Shipping charges, again,
- 29:52no padding that. It's got to be what you paid
- 29:54UPS or FedEx to deliver the thing. Well, it doesn't
- 29:57have to include optional fees. If the customer
- 30:00decides they want some bells and whistles at
- 30:01the end, you don't have to tell them what that's
- 30:03going to cost at the beginning. You do have to
- 30:04tell them what it's going to cost before it goes
- 30:06into the cart. Same kind of thing for late fees.
- 30:12If it's dynamic pricing, in other words, the
- 30:14price changes all the time, the adjusted price
- 30:16still has to include all the mandatory fees.
- 30:18You can't say, well, it's too hard for us to
- 30:21do that. If you're going to charge for your goods
- 30:23or services with a dynamic pricing model, you've
- 30:26got to figure out a way to bake into that total
- 30:28price. The fees that are going to have to be
- 30:31closed, charged, I'm sorry. Again, the mandatory
- 30:34fees. Remember, we talked about that at the beginning.
- 30:38Surcharges. You don't have to disclose it up
- 30:41front if there's a way for the customer to pay
- 30:46with cash or ACH or debit card Then the credit
- 30:51card processing fee doesn't have to be charged
- 30:52in total price if there isn't if you only take
- 30:55credit cards Then that's that's a mandatory fee
- 30:58and it's got to be in the total price And again,
- 31:02the rule is limited to these two business verticals,
- 31:05but it's really the way that the FTC looks at
- 31:08these things, and I think you're going to see
- 31:10courts and plaintiff's lawyers pointing to the
- 31:12rule as guidance as to how state laws ought to
- 31:15be interpreted on these issues. Another part
- 31:20of the rule, and this is another area where it
- 31:25applies more, I think it applies more broadly,
- 31:27or certainly guides enforcement more broadly,
- 31:31total price has to be the most prominent price.
- 31:38Again, you can exclude government charges and
- 31:40shipping charges that are reasonably incurred.
- 31:45Again, you can't pad any of these additional
- 31:48fees. And then the nature and purpose of fees.
- 31:55You can't say that something's a shipping fee
- 31:57when you're just using it to defer your overhead.
- 32:00You can't say it's an environmental fee when
- 32:02you're just using it to defer, you know, your
- 32:04shipping costs or employee costs. You can't say
- 32:08something's a service fee when you're just using
- 32:10it to pay your rent. If you're going to charge
- 32:13an employee benefits fee for something, that
- 32:16money has to go directly to pay for health care
- 32:19benefits. And you got to be able to show the
- 32:21math on that. And the FTC has brought a bunch
- 32:27of cases against certain companies in the gig
- 32:31economy where fees were charged that were seemingly
- 32:35going to employees or independent contractors.
- 32:38And in fact, they're being kept by the company.
- 32:40So that's sort of doubly deceptive. It's deceptive
- 32:42as to the customer, but it's also abusive or
- 32:46deceptive to the independent contractor or employee.
- 32:53Okay. And I will just... Emphasize and I made
- 32:58this point that even though. These things are
- 33:01rooted in the pricing role for short term launching
- 33:03and ticket sellers. Guidance typically becomes
- 33:07sort of the guidance for everybody. So, and I
- 33:10think these misleading fees is a. Is the next
- 33:14direction of these types of issues, sort of this
- 33:18nature and purpose types of things. There's a
- 33:20lot of confusion. When you have to play a service
- 33:23fee at a restaurant, for example, if that's actually
- 33:25a gratuity going to the staff or what so. Not
- 33:31falling too far behind, we're seeing a new crop,
- 33:34a newer crop of state. Price transparency laws,
- 33:38they're emerging all the time. California led
- 33:43the way in 2024. Minnesota was close behind Colorado,
- 33:49Virginia. Other states have come up. This slide
- 33:52might be a little bit old now and need a little
- 33:54bit of updating, but these are very much, again,
- 33:58total price disclosure type requirements, like
- 34:02a single number with everything mandatory included
- 34:06in it, excluding the usual. taxes or government
- 34:11surcharges. And then also the more prominent,
- 34:16more prominently disclosed than anything else.
- 34:19So here's the California law. It's a good starting
- 34:22place for this because this provides sort of
- 34:23the baseline for understanding how the other
- 34:25laws are built or what differences there are
- 34:27among the other laws. So sometimes it's called
- 34:31the honest pricing law or the hidden fee statute
- 34:34or just the total price disclosure law. As you
- 34:38would expect, it makes it illegal for businesses
- 34:40to most businesses to offer a price for a good
- 34:44or service that does not include all mandatory
- 34:46fees or charges. There are the usual exclusions
- 34:49for taxes, government fees and an exception for
- 34:55postage or carriage charges that will be reasonably
- 34:59and actually incurred to ship. And this is one
- 35:04line where we. We see a lot of folks get tripped
- 35:08up over it because. And this is tough for some
- 35:11industry, some industries actually figure out
- 35:14a shipping cost. They might come up with a flat
- 35:16rate shipping that they can apply across the
- 35:18country. Because it's different depending on
- 35:21where you're going, but it's too confusing to
- 35:23figure it out. But it's not, it may not be what's
- 35:25actually incurred at the end of the day. And
- 35:27it may not be that out of line, but it's it's
- 35:301 that I think is. potentially an issue. So that
- 35:35actually incurred as a lot of meaning. Yeah.
- 35:37And I think the key there is, if you average
- 35:41it out and you're flat, I think that's fine.
- 35:44Some maybe cost a little more, others it costs
- 35:46a little less. But if it's a profit center, that's
- 35:50going to be a real problem. It's a real problem
- 35:53because you're essentially lying to consumers
- 35:55about what you're charging them for. Of course,
- 36:01there are class actions allowed under this law.
- 36:03We're going to talk about a bunch of cases in
- 36:05a second, and there are tons and tons of them.
- 36:08And there are some exemptions. We put them in
- 36:11here. One that's interesting is the food delivery
- 36:14platforms. They're exempt to a certain extent.
- 36:16It's really that restaurants don't need to bake
- 36:20in the cost of a third party food delivery platform
- 36:23into the cost of the menu items. To the extent
- 36:27there's a third party delivery fee, that has
- 36:30to be an all in fee. You can't sort of tee up,
- 36:33well, it's going to be a $4 delivery service
- 36:35fee. And then once you're on the delivery platforms
- 36:39website, you're finding out there's another $2
- 36:42here, another $6 here, whatever it is. So there's
- 36:45a whole nother role in California, as some of
- 36:47you may know, for food delivery platforms and
- 36:51how to sort these things out between menu prices
- 36:54and food delivery. The California attorney general
- 37:00has issued some helpful guidance. Actually, you
- 37:03can find this online. On how to, you know, what
- 37:07this law really means. They put this out right
- 37:09when the rule came into effect and it's it's
- 37:12something we refer to. It's actually pretty good
- 37:14guidance, but, you know, they go through the
- 37:16basics. You can't. You can't wait until later
- 37:19in the transaction to disclose. Some of the pricing
- 37:23issues they mentioned the. Reasonably and actually
- 37:29encourage shipping, but there's like, look, handling
- 37:33charges. Nobody really never knows what handling
- 37:36charges are. I mean, so, and we had. We had a
- 37:40slew of class action lawsuits many, many years
- 37:42ago. I remember these one in New Jersey where
- 37:45somebody was saying like, what's the handling
- 37:47charge? How much are you really paying somebody
- 37:48to go and literally pick the item off the shelf
- 37:51and put it in the box? So that was the profit
- 37:53center. So let me mention. The other thing that
- 37:57the AG's made clear, you know, I've had to fight
- 38:00with some of our clients on this frequently is
- 38:03you can't just say additional fees will apply.
- 38:07You've got to say what the whole price is. You
- 38:09can't leave that detail for later. And if your
- 38:14pricing is such that you don't know what the
- 38:16price is because it's too indeterminate yet,
- 38:18then you can't advertise a price. I mean, you
- 38:20can advertise perhaps a range. But if you state
- 38:27a price, it's got to be the all -in price. And
- 38:31you can't sort of have the asterisk saying additional
- 38:33fees may apply or will apply. Other things they've
- 38:38said, you can offer a discount or coupon. This
- 38:41looks a little bit like a discount or is okay.
- 38:47Fees contingent on certain later conduct by consumers.
- 38:50So if are not mandatory, this would include late
- 38:54fees. It would also include if you want to pay
- 38:57for expedited shipping and that's something that
- 38:59you can add in later. But I am going to come
- 39:02back and talk about shipping again in a moment.
- 39:06Um, as I mentioned, you can't put a price in
- 39:09there and just say, you know. You know, there's
- 39:12going to be something at it later, but you can
- 39:15tell people that the total price includes certain
- 39:19fees and charges and we've seen a lot of retailers
- 39:22try to do this so that because effectively they're
- 39:25advertised prices. look like they all increased
- 39:27after this locking menu effect. So they've tried
- 39:30to tell you that this $50 price that used to
- 39:33be $40 includes our service fee, includes our
- 39:36delivery fee, whatever it is. And then there's
- 39:40one down here. I just flagged the very last one.
- 39:42You can't advertise one price and then add a
- 39:46variable service fee later in the transaction.
- 39:50And the guidance there is if you don't know how
- 39:52much you're going to need to charge a consumer
- 39:54at the beginning of a transaction, you should
- 39:57wait to display a price until you know how much
- 40:00you're going to charge. And I just, that's the
- 40:02one where I'm just not sure that's very practical
- 40:04for most businesses to wait and advertise pricing
- 40:07later. But that was in the guidance. Just a quick
- 40:12note on the surcharging to bring it back to this.
- 40:14But California followed. What Len had said earlier
- 40:19is that, look, if a credit card processing surcharge
- 40:23is reasonably avoidable, then it's not a mandatory
- 40:27fee. And so it's not going to be lumped into
- 40:33the total price. But if the business only accepts
- 40:37credit cards as a form of payment, or there's
- 40:40really no reasonable way for the consumer to
- 40:42avoid it, Then it's got to be included in the
- 40:45advertised price and there are sometimes. Cases
- 40:49and threatened cases we've seen over this issue.
- 40:52How reasonable is it for everybody to have both
- 40:55a credit card and a debit card in their wallet
- 40:58or to have easy access to the debit cards? There's
- 41:00all sorts of. Factual issues there, but again,
- 41:03if you can avoid that credit card fee reasonably,
- 41:07then it's not going to be in the total price.
- 41:10There are lots and lots of cases, as I mentioned.
- 41:13I mean, from, I think within, I would say it
- 41:16took about eight weeks after the law became effective
- 41:19in 2024 for like cases to just start flying in
- 41:22the door. We have a tracker on them. We literally
- 41:26see them every day. I'm not lying. Every day
- 41:29we see cases, sometimes two or three a day. The
- 41:34earliest cases we saw. We're hitting these issues
- 41:39surcharges the restaurants were taking a lot
- 41:41of hits here surcharges added to restaurant bills.
- 41:45Tickets without a service free and the price
- 41:48hidden fees and hotel rooms. All the complaints
- 41:53would have all sorts of like. Pictures of receipts
- 41:56and things like that that people were putting
- 41:57in the complaints like, okay, I bought. A slice
- 42:01of pizza for $4, but by the time I checked out,
- 42:03it was $12 because I was charged. To go fee and
- 42:07an employee service fee and a credit card surcharge
- 42:11on top of that. Convenience fees and transaction
- 42:15processing fees. We mentioned we're hit very
- 42:17early and then there are things that sort of
- 42:20seem like. They might even seem like government
- 42:24imposed charges like the living wage surcharge,
- 42:28which a lot of. Restaurants and others were adding
- 42:34the bills. And we've seen challenges to those
- 42:38saying, hey, business, that is your cost of doing
- 42:41business. If you are required to remit 3 % for
- 42:47this living wage surcharge under California Proposition
- 42:5022, that's your cost of doing business. Why are
- 42:53you passing that on to us? So those cases have
- 42:57come up quite frequently too. It's not just the
- 43:02plaintiff's bar that's interested here. We're
- 43:05defending a case now brought by the DA task force
- 43:10and the attorney general. And every time we talk
- 43:13to them, the lawyers from the attorney general's
- 43:16office make it clear that this is a real priority
- 43:18for their office and a real priority for the
- 43:20attorney general to help draft the statute. So
- 43:24the plaintiff's bar is all over this. But so
- 43:28so there's the California District Attorneys
- 43:30and the Attorney General's office. They've got
- 43:32a task force They're working together on these
- 43:34issues. So there are really consequences here
- 43:39and Part of the reason you really need to pay
- 43:43attention. This is you know, we're talking about
- 43:46You know a couple bucks Usually in these fees,
- 43:50but the penalties and such can can outstrip that
- 43:54pretty quickly. So It's not, it may seem like
- 43:58a small deal, but it's not. Here's a list of
- 44:02a bunch of other cases. You all will get these
- 44:04slides so you can read them, get a flavor of
- 44:07them. I also wrote down just ones that literally
- 44:10came in within the last week, but a 12 dollar
- 44:12rental damage waiver fee that was charged. Same
- 44:16day floral delivery arrangements that were alleged
- 44:19to have a drip pricing component because by the
- 44:21time you checked out, you weren't paying what
- 44:23you saw. video game retailer who was adding service
- 44:28fees, a customer protection fee, and a monthly
- 44:30subscription to it, hidden fees in school lunch
- 44:36accounts. That's a big one whenever you go check
- 44:38out for school lunch accounts. So anyway, there's
- 44:40a lot going on in these cases. I'm just going
- 44:44to mention two actually really quickly. These
- 44:46are a little bit we're seeing now combination
- 44:49of law violations in the cases. So it's not just
- 44:52a violation of the total pricing disclosure law,
- 44:54but that combined with the violation of California
- 44:56automatic renewal law, for example. So here's
- 44:59an example of a case here. You can see this is
- 45:04an advertisement and online advertisement for
- 45:06a monthly fee for whatever this service is a
- 45:11monthly membership price was disclosed. But whenever
- 45:15consumers checked out, and this arrow should
- 45:18be a little bit more over to the right, but there
- 45:20is also a recurring annual fee. I'm trying to
- 45:23put a mark around it, but under annual dues.
- 45:28And so the allegation there is like that was
- 45:30not disclosed. So again, we're seeing these combined.
- 45:34Another case trend is in shipping protection.
- 45:36So this is popping up in a lot of cases coming
- 45:39across our desks. This is a little bit of a dark
- 45:44pattern as well, but the consumer goes to check
- 45:47out. And in this example, a worry free delivery
- 45:53shipping protection. Program has been added.
- 46:00Pre checked. you know, already added into the
- 46:03checkout and that's, you know, an extra $9 .20
- 46:07charge that the consumer has to notice and see
- 46:10an affirmatively unchecked to check it out. And
- 46:13so this is alleged to be, you know, a hidden
- 46:16fee and maybe even a junk fee, frankly, because
- 46:19it's not clear what shipping protection really
- 46:21gets you. I think when you, you know, your credit
- 46:24cards will protect you. Retailers will often
- 46:27help you out if you're, if you're jackets in
- 46:30and get there if it got lost or misdelivered
- 46:33or whatever else. So, but this is a plus they're
- 46:37touting shipping is free. And, you know, free
- 46:40is one of those words. If you're going to use
- 46:42that word, if there's any qualifications or strings
- 46:45attached to that, you have to disclose them.
- 46:47So I think the shipping free exclamation point
- 46:50sort of multiplies the issue here. And another
- 46:53issue that we see sometimes on shipping is charges
- 46:58for expedited shipping or expedited handling
- 47:01and Sometimes there's no expedition. It's you
- 47:07know, we had a case where The expedited handling
- 47:11meant that that day your order got put in the
- 47:15FedEx cart first But FedEx came once a day so
- 47:20you paid to have your box be the first box in
- 47:23the cart, but the cart, everything got picked
- 47:26up at the same time, and it was a couple bucks.
- 47:29So, you know, it was clever, but too clever.
- 47:32And then also sometimes with expedited shipping,
- 47:34there's really, you know, there's no expedition.
- 47:37You get it at the same time. Again, it's just,
- 47:40you know, they've created a profit center to
- 47:42try and grab a little extra revenue, but it can
- 47:46really come back to bite you. Other state laws,
- 47:52and again, commerce is so National and even global,
- 47:56but it is worth just. Tracking other state laws
- 48:01that are that are. Effective or coming into effect,
- 48:04but again, we've. There's a lot of text here,
- 48:07but we try to highlight the pertinent parts,
- 48:08but total price disclosure laws Colorado. Again,
- 48:13making sure the total price is disclosed more
- 48:15prominently than any other pricing information.
- 48:17That's because a lot of people will put the total
- 48:19price really tiny and then put. The price without
- 48:23all the fees added in really big, so states are
- 48:26onto that and prohibiting it. Connecticut has
- 48:29a law that gives you some good. You know, it's
- 48:35some exclusions that are helpful. You know, the
- 48:401st, 1 there, you can, you can leave out things
- 48:43where. maybe the selections that you're going
- 48:45to go through can't be calculated in full until
- 48:48somebody is done with the order. So there is
- 48:50some effort, I think, to pay attention to what's
- 48:52going on here. Skipping here, I'm going to, Virginia,
- 48:56it's not listed here, but Virginia has something
- 48:59in it about variable pricing. So if you are charging
- 49:03something, electric vehicle charging is my best
- 49:06example here. But if you're paying per kilowatt
- 49:09hour to charge a car and you don't know how much
- 49:13of a charge, Somebody is going to take into their
- 49:16vehicle. You can, you know, the variable pricing
- 49:18is is is okay there. So. Minnesota again, you
- 49:24all will get these slides, but here's another
- 49:27guidance by the attorney general, but sometimes
- 49:30very helpful. Sometimes they have errors and
- 49:33actually we've we've caught them before and have
- 49:35had to tell them about them, but you can read
- 49:37the Minnesota 1. they've got. Very much the same
- 49:40type of thing they're giving you the. What's
- 49:43compliant and not compliant examples here. Very
- 49:48clear to see same thing here. Compliant not compliant
- 49:53on the right side. You can see you can. This
- 49:56is their example of using an asterisk to tell
- 49:59you that the fee that you've seen has a service
- 50:01charge of 5 % that has been added into it. And
- 50:06they're giving the total price, but below it
- 50:08telling you later that a service charge will
- 50:11be added. and not including that, and the price
- 50:14is not going to be compliant in Minnesota. The
- 50:17good news is there are all these state laws,
- 50:20but at the bottom they're pretty consistent in
- 50:24how they deal with these. It's better than say
- 50:25on privacy where you really do have some a patchwork
- 50:30of different regimes and even better than say
- 50:33on negative option marketing where, you know,
- 50:35there's differences on when you have to send
- 50:37certain post -transaction disclosures and certain
- 50:41statutes have additional disclosure requirements
- 50:45for longer term renewals, but, you know, at least
- 50:50so far the junk fee statutes are relatively consistent.
- 50:58Okay, New York, New York had a proposed law.
- 51:02It did not make it through the last legislative
- 51:06session. They've got some. I have a complicated
- 51:09process where maybe if they have a chance to,
- 51:12to. Put something through in the fall, this particular
- 51:15law, if not, I think they have to get it reintroduced,
- 51:17but it's another sort of. You know, same type
- 51:23of thing, the, the clearing conspicuous disclosure
- 51:25of the total price. And you can exclude whatever
- 51:31you need to on the taxes and government fees.
- 51:35You will have these slides so you can read a
- 51:37little bit more about what is included or not
- 51:41to be included in the total price. There are
- 51:46some nuances to these. I'm not sure how material
- 51:49they really are at the end of the day, but. The
- 51:52mandatory feed is not include, for example, in
- 51:54New York 3rd bolt down any nominal fee for the
- 51:57purpose of preauthorizing a transaction. That
- 52:01is immediately refunded or renewed. This is sort
- 52:03of a nuanced thing, but we've all sort of made
- 52:05those charges where you're like, okay, why is
- 52:07there a dollar on my card? So, you know, they're
- 52:10they've been very specific about these types
- 52:12of things, but I'm sure that some of the issue
- 52:15with these laws is once they become effective.
- 52:18the practical reality of some of these things
- 52:20in certain contexts becomes a little bit challenging
- 52:22to deal with. So we do see that. There's a lot
- 52:27of other things on the horizon. Arizona, Connecticut,
- 52:30Hawaii have all been looking at bills. Len, I
- 52:34think you should talk about local. Sure. And
- 52:38local is a big deal now. I want to get to New
- 52:40York City in a second, but you know, at the state
- 52:42level, the states are spending more and more
- 52:44time enforcing these things. I mean, to the extent
- 52:46I just think there's a retreat by the federal
- 52:49government on some consumer protection issues,
- 52:52and junk fees may be one where there's not that
- 52:54much, but the states are all over it. I've talked
- 52:58about some of my experience, and there's a couple
- 53:00of specific things. California has, the governor
- 53:04has appointed Rohit Chopra, who's the former
- 53:06director of the CFPB, to be the consumer protection
- 53:10czar, and he is very aggressive. Am I experiencing
- 53:14someone hostile? to business. He's very suspicious
- 53:17of business, and he's going to be driving enforcement
- 53:22in California. We're seeing lots of people who
- 53:25used to work for the FTC or the CFPB go to state
- 53:28governments where enforcement is active. We're
- 53:31seeing people who used to be at the CFPB form
- 53:33law firms, and their clients are probably going
- 53:36to be state governments who are looking to recover
- 53:40in sort of a parents' patrii way. you know, for
- 53:46junk fees or public nuisances or whatever. And
- 53:50so I think you're going to see more and more
- 53:52enforcement at the state level. And now it's
- 53:56also even trickling down to the city level. Mayor
- 54:00Mondami, one of his advisors during his campaign
- 54:02was Lina Khan, who was the former chair of the
- 54:05FTC and teaching law school up here in New York.
- 54:12He appointed Sam Levine, who was the director
- 54:16of the Bureau of Consumer Protection at the FTC.
- 54:18As his director of consumer protection, they've
- 54:20issued some orders and creating a junk fee and
- 54:27subscription marketing task force. There was
- 54:29also legislation being considered in the city
- 54:34on junk fees. again, similar type stuff. So you've
- 54:40got to deal with this now at the federal level,
- 54:42the state level, and the local level as far as
- 54:45regulation. So this isn't going away, and it's
- 54:50going to be a recurring issue and requires some
- 54:53attention. OK. So. We do have some other examples.
- 55:02So you don't need a state price transparency
- 55:06law to bring a case. So we've made this point,
- 55:09but just to emphasize it, just a general unfair
- 55:13and deceptive acts and practices UDAP type of
- 55:17issue can materialize in these cases. So here's
- 55:21your example here, Illinois's Consumer Fraud
- 55:25and Deceptive Business Practices Act prohibits
- 55:28UDAP practices. quite generally, and there's
- 55:32a case here that you can take a look at if you're
- 55:35interested in this issue. But in this case, the
- 55:39allegation was that and. Back to the point of,
- 55:43like, trying to recoup your operating costs.
- 55:48The allegation here is that, you know, the business,
- 55:52instead of sort of factoring their operating
- 55:54costs and pricing, trying to pass it on. To the
- 55:58consumers and they, you know, they. They added
- 56:03surcharges on this was a restaurant type situation,
- 56:06but just added surcharges onto the. To the menu
- 56:09with the line item, we've all seen this too.
- 56:11Hopefully we're seeing less of it, but. You go
- 56:14to sit down at your restaurant and at the bottom
- 56:16and the fine print, you can see a restaurant
- 56:18surcharge of 3 .25 % is being added to every
- 56:21bill. And sometimes they'll tell you it's because
- 56:23the cost of food has gone up or the cost of gas
- 56:27for transporting the food has gone up, whatever
- 56:29it is. But all that is going to be rolled into
- 56:32these laws. And this one was just filed under
- 56:36again, General Illinois UDEP. Same thing with
- 56:40here's a. A few examples under California law
- 56:45and we're also seeing. There I would say these
- 56:49get very creative and if not nuanced in certain
- 56:52things. So the 1st, 1, you can see is a, was
- 56:56a class action for violations of the Americans
- 56:59with disabilities act discrimination, unjust
- 57:02enrichment on behalf of all consumers who purchased
- 57:05a beverages that contained non dairy milk alternatives
- 57:09and paid a surcharge for it. So. Paying the surcharge,
- 57:13I suppose, for this group of people becomes sort
- 57:16of an extra concerning issue to the plaintiff's
- 57:20bar. Same thing with the Dunkin' Donuts case.
- 57:25Unfair surcharge for drinks made with non -dairy
- 57:28milk alternatives. Similar with McDonald's. McDonald's
- 57:34was advertising like a breakfast. a breakfast
- 57:38meal that included orange juice in the picture.
- 57:41But whenever you went to go order with the orange
- 57:44juice, there was apparently an upcharge for getting
- 57:46the orange juice as opposed to maybe a soda or
- 57:49coffee. So that is just more examples of things
- 57:54that become lawsuit -worthy, which is probably
- 57:56almost everything depending on who you're talking
- 57:59to. We're at the very end, but Len, you want
- 58:07to wrap us up with some takeaways? Sure. So we
- 58:11tried to put together a list of what you want
- 58:13to remember and how to guide your guidance to
- 58:17your clients. Disclose all fees upfront. No surprises.
- 58:22I mean, total price upfront, most prominent price
- 58:26at the point that that price is first displayed.
- 58:33Choosing not to disclose a fee or include a fee
- 58:37because you think it's reasonably avoidable.
- 58:42Give it a straight face test. You can't sell
- 58:44cars without tires. Those types of things. Make
- 58:50sure you're staying up to date on the brand rules
- 58:52and federal and state laws on these things. Just
- 58:56following the car brand rules may not be enough.
- 59:01Doing credit card surcharging, you've got to
- 59:03be aware of what your processing cost is and
- 59:08stick to that. You can't pad it. There's also
- 59:10rules for Visa and MasterCard respectively as
- 59:14to what you can charge. If you're surcharging
- 59:19or prominently display that at the point of entry,
- 59:24check out receipts. Some states have specific
- 59:27requirements there. two -tier pricing, you know,
- 59:30the gas station model, make sure the prices are
- 59:33side -by -side, easier for people to decide.
- 59:37You know, service fee. You need to be very careful
- 59:43what that is, that if you're in a service -type
- 59:45business that implies it goes to staff. And,
- 59:48you know, sort of just general fees. that are
- 59:52stuck at the end of the transaction are really
- 59:56dangerous, but you also have to be very careful
- 59:58not to mislead them. I mean, you can't say something
- 1:00:00as a environmental fee if it just is being used
- 1:00:04to sop up some of your overhead. If fees are
- 1:00:07optional, do not use pre -check boxes. Make sure
- 1:00:10there's a genuine opt -in. Discount, reference
- 1:00:14pricing, advertising, back it up. You got to
- 1:00:19be able to show that something was sold at $75
- 1:00:21if you're using that as the reference price.
- 1:00:24And again, state legislation is fast moving here.
- 1:00:28This is something where there seems to be bipartisan
- 1:00:30support. So it's one of the things that in red
- 1:00:34and blue states, you're seeing these things.
- 1:00:36So you really got to pay attention. OK. Well,
- 1:00:40that brings us to the end of our program. And
- 1:00:45our contact information is here. If anybody has
- 1:00:47questions and would like to get in touch, we
- 1:00:50would be happy to try to answer. And we want
- 1:00:54to thank the Beverly Hills Bar Association for
- 1:00:56inviting us to do this webinar. We very much
- 1:00:59enjoyed it and hope you found it helpful. Sounds
- 1:01:03good. This concludes today's presentation. Thank
- 1:01:06you so much Ellen and Len for an excellent presentation
- 1:01:09today and thank you to our audience for joining
- 1:01:11us. Have a great day everybody.