Latest / Aggressive Negotiations: A Star Wars Podcast / Issue 345: Book Club: The Threat Within
Transcript
- 0:00I'm going to regret this. Welcome to the NED party. Hi, this
- 0:08is Nick and Ostasu, story editor on Star Wars, The Clone Wars and
- 0:12Star Wars bad Batch. And you are listening to Aggressive Negotiations. Well,
- 0:21hello, and welcome to Aggressive Negotiations, a Star Wars podcast. And I
- 0:27am just one of your hosts here, Matthew Rushing. And of course you
- 0:31can tell my voice is much more Darth vaderish and teenage boyish all at the
- 0:38same time, and with me as he is always the one and only,
- 0:43beautifully built Jedi Master John Mills. John, it's a new year, and
- 0:50how are you celebrating? Well, I don't know how we got to a
- 0:54new year. I think it has something to do with how we hit hyperspace
- 0:57last time. I think we dragged along a few pergle And obviously the techno
- 1:00Union suit that you're wearing is not vocoding your throat quite right, so we're
- 1:07gonna have to twist a couple of those knobs and get there. Yes,
- 1:11the Union Army, is that your disposal count? Well, I'm glad you
- 1:21brought that up, because we are going to be in the prequel era as
- 1:23we finally wrap up the Jedi Apprentice series with the final book in the series.
- 1:29There are two specials then we may touch on later on, but we're
- 1:33wrapping up the main series and we're excited to do that. Before we do
- 1:37and dive into our review of The Threat Within. You can find us everywhere
- 1:42you get your podcasts. We would appreciate it, of course. If you're
- 1:46listening to this, if you would subscribe and please share us on social media
- 1:51with two your friends. You can follow us at the Jedi Masters and our
- 1:55entire network is at Joint nerd Party. We're on Facebook, at Facebook dot
- 1:59com, slash, We're on Instagram at the nerd Party, and we're at
- 2:01the nerd Party dot com where you can see all of the different shows that
- 2:05we do. And there's a lot of different stuff coming out of the Nerd
- 2:07Party, So we hope that you will check all that out. John,
- 2:12I think one of the things that I noticed about this book was the intention
- 2:16that Watson really has in trying to tie this series all together and really I
- 2:24think build on the fact that she has been playing with four years of Obi
- 2:30Wan and Qui Gon's life and this is the end of that four years,
- 2:37and that's one of the things I thought was really great about this book was
- 2:42the nice callbacks to the previous books that really accentuate the growth for these characters,
- 2:50and really, I mean, Watson put these characters through the ringer.
- 2:54What's tough with this is, you know how hard where I am about the
- 3:00idea that I should be able to jump into a sequel, whether it's book
- 3:05or movie, and just plug in and go. And I think that this
- 3:08book is struggling a little bit with that. But at the same time,
- 3:14I think that Watson does a good job, like you're saying, of tying
- 3:16everything back so that you get the sense of history even if you haven't read
- 3:20it. But at the same time, where I think a little bit of
- 3:25the connection struggles is that Watson makes reference to past stuff, but focuses a
- 3:36little too much on stuff that's more recent past. It doesn't have the feeling
- 3:40of complete callback the way that you might expect from somebody who's coming into a
- 3:46series and saying, Okay, this is the end of the journey sort of
- 3:50thing. But I don't want that criticism to be too pointed, because that's
- 3:57exactly where Rise of Skywalker goes off. The rate is it's entirely too focused
- 4:02on trying to cram everything into one giant callback soup, whereas if you go
- 4:12to Revenge of the Sith or Return of the Jedi, there's a sense of
- 4:16history, but they don't obsess over it. Luke doesn't really talk about being
- 4:21a moisture farmer in Return of the Jedi, and they refer to the fact
- 4:26that Vader and Luke have fought before, but they don't say, remember like
- 4:30when you got your hand cut off at Best Bin like, So it's not
- 4:33entirely obvious, and Watson, I think, does also a very good job
- 4:38of making sure that those callback moments are internal monologue as opposed to a clumsy
- 4:46exposition between the characters. So if I read you correctly, what you're saying
- 4:51is is that the sequel trilogy feels like an episode of Family Guy where the
- 4:57dad's like, remember that time, and this even this book feels a little
- 5:03bit more organic in the sense that the callbacks that we're getting. Watson is
- 5:10using the storyline here to connect with a storyline that was very important and poignant
- 5:16for both Obi Wan and Qui Gone and had a huge impact on Obi Wan's
- 5:23growth. That's true, and so to do that. This really is again
- 5:30she's crafting this story on purpose to show us the way in which obi Wan
- 5:33handles this story is very different than the way he did in the in that
- 5:39you know first story, which you know, she's calling back to the melod
- 5:42To Dawn series of stories, where you know, obi Wan gets kind of
- 5:46wrapped up in what's happening on those planets. He actually leaves the Jedi Order,
- 5:50and then in leaving the Jedi Order kind of quickly realizes the utter mistake
- 5:56that he's made, and he's made the wrong choice and that what he thought
- 6:00was happening is not the right thing. And so it's so interesting because of
- 6:05course that's playing into and I don't have no idea how you really say these
- 6:12aliens' names the voriad Acts, I'm guessing, and you know, their whole
- 6:17planet is kind of going through that that same situation. Right, You have
- 6:20one group who they want change, they think they know how to make it,
- 6:27and they're they're doing these things to get the change, but even inside
- 6:31their group, they're disconnected from one another as to exactly how to make that
- 6:36come about. And that was again, I mean, I think Watson really
- 6:43shows and this is a short book, right, but in them in the
- 6:46amount of time, just a real deaft hand at connecting with the previous story.
- 6:51But I think also making a compelling news story that felt somewhat relevant to
- 6:59the world we live in too, agreed. I think that the and I
- 7:03was saying for Zydiac, but I have no idea how to pronounce it either,
- 7:09because there's a character named Narnia in it, and every time I saw
- 7:14it, I kept thinking Narnia. And then there's a character named Grath,
- 7:16and I kept saying Garth in my head and thinking of Wayne's world. So
- 7:21for those younger members of the audience, you might not remember Wayne's world,
- 7:25but other members of the audience do remember Wayne's world. So yeah, but
- 7:32it is it. It is a good type of story with what's going on
- 7:39on. I was gonna say V because that's the first letter in the alien
- 7:45planet names. So V four and V five are tense with each other,
- 7:49and the tension is being exacerbated by what are considered terrorist disruptions to worker productivity,
- 8:00which is at the corner of V four's whole culture, and loss of
- 8:05productivity is psychologically and economically devastating to them. So that's interesting. That's a
- 8:11complicated sort of concept to come at, and you find out it's because this
- 8:16counterculture movement that's going on on V four, which is then in itself splintering
- 8:20right as you're talking about here, and that I think is one of the
- 8:24things where this story maybe should have been two books instead of one. This
- 8:31feels like that specific aspect of the story gets a little bit of short shrift
- 8:37and could have been plotted out a little more. It could have been fleshed
- 8:43out more, basically because where you're looking at, the social commentary aspect of
- 8:48it maybe is reaching to the sort of the gen xers of the time struggling
- 8:56to find or even millennials struggling to find identity with their parents, but also
- 9:07a callback to the sixties where work is you know, people start reassessing whether
- 9:11work is really the most important thing, or whether we need to be enjoying
- 9:15life, that sort of stuff. It feels like that could have been fleshed
- 9:18out more, a little more intrigue and maybe a little bit more of a
- 9:22red herring, because I think V five gets short shrift as the perceived villain,
- 9:28specifically because with how short the book is Watson never really gets a chance
- 9:35to play with the tension or build it sufficiently. I would say, it's
- 9:41there, and then it goes away. It's just resolves a little too cleanly.
- 9:45And it's even resolved in a sense off screen for lack of a better
- 9:48term, because gui Gon says, oh, I'll have to get them to
- 9:52be peaceful with their resolution, and then like a page later, it's like,
- 9:56well, it's a good thing those talks went well. It's like would
- 10:00have been nice to witness. I guess no, I do agree with you
- 10:03on that. I think that that part, you know, it did feel
- 10:07like the book if it had been, you know, even ten pages longer,
- 10:13I feel like you could have really gotten at a lot of the things
- 10:16that you're getting at one hundred percent, you know, I think the thing
- 10:22is you're talking through, you know, the different issues, and I love
- 10:26the way you kind of pulled in all the historical references because I one hundred
- 10:28percent think that all of that's in there, you know. The thing that
- 10:33really, I think it kind of shows that when you create a story and
- 10:41you use kind of timeless themes, the way that you can apply it to
- 10:46so many different time periods and I was thinking specifically, you know, with
- 10:50this group of kids on V five who are are use me V four and
- 11:01they are trying to disrupt the productivity of this planet who's completely driven by work
- 11:07and work alone to create free time, to create a you know, more
- 11:13than just one type of life, which is work. And you know,
- 11:18they're willing to go to more and more extreme measures as they go along to
- 11:28do so and to get their point across because they feel morally vindicated in their
- 11:33position. And and it just every big movement in history, whether it's been
- 11:41good or bad, has felt themselves to be morally vindicated. And the how
- 11:48far they're willing to go sometimes becomes a byproduct of that blindness that that can
- 11:56create. And I really appree siated that, you know, Watson gives a
- 12:01picture of that here in the book, because again it's it's as poignant as
- 12:07ever to see that, you know, what what really needs to happen is
- 12:13and I think the beauty of this I was thinking specifically of of, you
- 12:18know, the civil rights movement in the way in which there are two different
- 12:24sides. There's the violent side and the non violent side, and you know,
- 12:30basically having Obi Wan kind of stand up and give the type of speech
- 12:35and then be backed up by Qui Gone that you would kind of hear from
- 12:41you know, MLK Junior, which is an interesting thing to say, but
- 12:46like to say, hey, this isn't getting us anywhere, This violence is
- 12:50separating us. This that you're making the message harder to here, and what
- 12:56we really need is to sit down and to hear one another, to listen
- 13:00to one another and find a way to come to a solution that benefits as
- 13:07many people as possible. And you know, Qui Gon even talks about too,
- 13:13it's like that also means that you might not always completely agree, you
- 13:18know, and that also needs to be okay. So just the sheer gamut
- 13:24of things that Watson is kind of touching on in this book, I think
- 13:30is pretty astounding. And I'm with you in the sense that the only downside
- 13:37really to the book, I think is just that I just wanted there to
- 13:41be more of it, because I think the storyline and what she's created really
- 13:48kind of warrant, you know, being able to dive in a little bit
- 13:50deeper, and that you know, that's one of those things where it's like
- 13:56you read these books and it's almost like when you'd watch maybe a Clone Wars
- 14:01episode in meters wishing it was a two parter. You know, that's really
- 14:05how I felt. I'm weary, were there with you. I kind of
- 14:07felt that way in this book. Make it a little bit longer books as
- 14:11it's the end, or you know, just give this a two parter.
- 14:16I think two parter is the only way to really treat it and to give
- 14:20it all the space that it needs to breathe, especially with trying to wrap
- 14:22up Qui Gon and Obi Wan and get them to a certain point that's going
- 14:28to serve this story but also set the stage for the series to end and
- 14:33have somebody say, Okay, I can see this as the two characters that
- 14:35walk on screen at the beginning of the Phantom Menace, and here's well,
- 14:39I'll do sort of like the compliment sandwich thing, because in that sense,
- 14:45I see her taking Qui Gon and Obi Wan. I see them as those
- 14:50characters pretty much here, while at the same time leaving the room for there
- 14:58to be further adventures that I don't see. Just like a good Clone Wars
- 15:01arc, if you left it there, I'm fine, But if you suddenly
- 15:05came out with an episode that bridge between this and the other one. I'm
- 15:09also fine because you've taken them far enough without taking them right up to the
- 15:16moment of walking on screen in the Phantom Menace. That's awesome. Yeah,
- 15:22I mean, yeah, no, go ahead, go ahead, please.
- 15:26So I was just going to say, because I think the beauty of you
- 15:30know, I talked a little bit about Obi Wan, but I think the
- 15:31beauty of this story is really what it does for Qui Gon and you know,
- 15:35putting him through the story that he's been with Tall losing her, and
- 15:43I just really loved the way in which he's struggling with this idea of Obi
- 15:48Wan growing up and knowing that sooner rather than later at this point, he's
- 15:52going to take the trials and they're not going to be together as a team,
- 15:56and him struggling a little bit with this idea of attachment that you know
- 16:03it and I think that there's there's something incredibly beautiful about that and and to
- 16:11kind of push that forward. The thing that it made me think was,
- 16:15you know, Dave Filoni has talked about the beauty of the duel of Fates
- 16:22fight and how it's really a fight for the soul of Anakin, because you
- 16:26know, if if Qui Gon survives, things are very different, and I
- 16:30think this book gives us the picture of why, because Qui Gon has that
- 16:37ability, I think to struggle a little bit more with attachment than Obi Wan
- 16:44does, who I think by the time we see him really, you know,
- 16:48especially in episode two, he's he's had his he's had his opportunities,
- 16:56right, but he's really fermented in to a man who is the quintessential of
- 17:03what the Jedi were called to be in that time period, you know,
- 17:06and and and not have as much of a struggle. And so that's where
- 17:11I was really appreciative of the work that Watson had done here. And I'm
- 17:17sure in some ways almost unintentionally, because you know, I don't think anybody
- 17:22at this time period really understood the complexity and the depth of Qui Gon in
- 17:30his journey yet, but to me that it really you know, reading it
- 17:36now, it felt really good to read. I definitely think that Watson has
- 17:45a in understanding of Qui Gon, and we've referenced us in previous books that
- 17:51we've discussed in the series where Watson has I would love to sit down with
- 17:56her and discuss and find out, did she have some sort of character bible
- 18:00that was handed to her, Because this is the Qui Gon I saw on
- 18:03screen. This is the Qui Gon that I defended, This is the Qui
- 18:07Gon that I fell in love with back in nineteen ninety nine. Throughout this
- 18:11whole series, I see him get there, and I see the aspects of
- 18:14him, and even the way that he speaks. I can hear Liam Neeson
- 18:15saying his lines. And to get back to sort of the meat of my
- 18:22compliment Sandwich, is that where this also could have benefited from a longer treatment,
- 18:30whether it's two books or ten more pages or what have you, is
- 18:34while the callbacks are all internal monologue, and I applaud that I would have
- 18:40liked more expository moments near the end of this arc with Qui Gon and Obi
- 18:48Wan stating things a little more plainly, because this is one of those things
- 18:53where it also could Slash should have set up a little more that not only
- 19:06are they at the point where Qui Gon's more mature and ready to let Obi
- 19:11Wan go, but there's still a little bit of friction between them when they
- 19:18find Anakin, because Obi wants to caught a little off guard about taking the
- 19:26Trials, Qui Gon is like, you know, I take I take Anakin.
- 19:30Skywalker's my Potowan, Well you can't you already have one? Yeah,
- 19:33obi want could take the Trials. And there's this split second where Obi Wan's
- 19:37like, oh, yeah, yeah, I can, right, yes,
- 19:41I'm ready for it. So do you see what I'm getting at where it's
- 19:47like it it's a little too friendly the way that they've wrapped it up.
- 19:51There should be a little bit more space for friction at the end of this
- 19:53arc. I think I completely get what you're saying, but I almost feel
- 20:00as though what it needed is to feel a little bit more like Obi Wan
- 20:07specifically as a character, is more attached to Qui Gon in this moment,
- 20:14because I think that's the almost the feeling you get in that scene, and
- 20:21at least that's how I always read it. In a Phantom Menace, he's
- 20:22like taken aback that he would just be kind of brushed aside, and it
- 20:26hurts his feelings because absolutely, you know they're a team, and so I
- 20:32think it's that and I don't know exactly how you do it, but you
- 20:36just need to convey somehow in the dialogue, this idea of obi Wan not
- 20:41quite being like, you know, Qui Gon's been realizing that obi Wan is
- 20:47going to be at that point, but that's not where Obi Wan is,
- 20:52and even almost in the Phantom Menace, that's not quite where he is.
- 20:55Where. Yeah, he says he's ready to take the trials, but in
- 20:57some ways, I think there's there's kind of such a love and respect he
- 21:03has for his master that, you know, does that make any sense when
- 21:07for you to get at it? Does? I think at this point we're
- 21:11sort of like splitting hairs because that I have. I don't disagree with what
- 21:18you're saying there, but I think that obi Wan is caught off guard,
- 21:22and it would have been in the Phantom Menace, like it's not just their
- 21:26emotional relationship, but it feels like there's supposed to be a little bit more
- 21:30formality to somebody presenting somebody is ready to face the trials, sure, sure,
- 21:37yeah, and Qui Gon is perfunctorially just like, yeah, he can
- 21:40face the trials. It's totally cool, and that that is one of the
- 21:42things that catches obi Wan off guard. Is like oh wait, yeah right,
- 21:45yeah, sure, yes, I am well, and obi Wan being
- 21:48kind of a stickler for the rules anyway. Sure Like he's he's a slightly
- 21:53more rule based character, and so for him, I do not have the
- 21:57formality like you're saying. I think absolutely I get it. Yeah, it
- 22:03would be sort of like presenting somebody for some sort of degree, right and
- 22:07your teacher shows you know, you show up with your teacher and you're like,
- 22:11yeah, I gotta feel ready to graduate and everything like that, and
- 22:14the teacher's like, yeah, I give him the final exam. Sure,
- 22:18yeah, okay, great, as opposed to like, hey, I'm going
- 22:21to present you to the board to give your master's thesis right now, I
- 22:23think you're ready to do it, you know sort of thing. Anyway,
- 22:26All that's all higher education stuff, and I'm a very simple, simple man,
- 22:32so I don't even know how that works. But I think that what's
- 22:36fascinating about it, and this has happened to us repeatedly throughout this series,
- 22:41is the fact that Watson, with these short, little young adult books,
- 22:48gives enough for you know, two grown adults to sit there and go back
- 22:55and forth about this. And I think that what I really walk away with,
- 22:59knowing that this is as official book in the series, you know,
- 23:02outside those two special ones you referenced is the fact that I really want Watson
- 23:11to come back and get another time, get another turn with Qui Gon and
- 23:17Obi Wan, for Pete's sake, please, Like, I don't understand why
- 23:22you wouldn't. I yeah, I'm sure there are a number of reasons practically
- 23:26speaking and everything like that, but I read this book and the shortcomings,
- 23:33it feels like a more of a pitch for a larger story, and it's
- 23:42restricted by the format and the rules of the format that Watson has to play
- 23:47by for you know, contractual reasons or what have you. I I would
- 23:53love for this specific story, just like so many others in the series.
- 24:00Give Watson the chance to come back, update it, align it with you
- 24:03know, quote unquote canon a little more now that Clone Wars series has happened
- 24:08and everything, and get like a book out of this. I think the
- 24:12thing that I think about this is that you know, there's there's reference stories
- 24:19in the Clone Wars that I think should be told in this type of series,
- 24:25and specifically, you know, I think of the story of Qui Gon
- 24:29and Obi Wan on Mandelor and you know, Obie One's running and you know,
- 24:37love interests to team and you know, I think disappointed to me that
- 24:45nobody has ever picked up that storyline and created maybe a trilogy of stories because
- 24:52it's said in this time period, and I think that this time period is
- 24:56rife for storytelling. And obviously we're going to be getting John Jackson's Miller John
- 25:00Jackson Miller's The Living Force, which takes place in the prequel era with the
- 25:06Jedi Order at that time period before the Phantom Menace. But to me,
- 25:11you know, forget you know, High Republic kind of stuff. Give me
- 25:18those Jedi you know, this time period. And again, like I like
- 25:22this series shows there's so much storytelling to tell about these characters, especially like
- 25:30an Obi Wan and Qui Gon, that I think could only benefit fans.
- 25:37I think it would sell get like Gamebusters because fans love that kind of stuff.
- 25:42And it's a time period which you know, is Disney really ever going
- 25:48to touch that time period like that again ever? Probably not unless you did
- 25:53some sort of animated series. But I don't think that's gonna happen. And
- 25:56so, you know, just create this is the milieu that you play in,
- 26:04you know, with the books for the next few years, you know,
- 26:10It's funny because when you said you heard my reaction when you mentioned the
- 26:14High Republic, I can legitimately say that I had forgotten that the High Republic
- 26:21was going on. I know Acolyte is a series, it's coming together,
- 26:26it's going to tie into that time period. But it's legitimately something where I
- 26:34am. It's legitimately something where I think it underscores how much I agree with
- 26:40you that this still resonates coming back to it. How long has it been
- 26:47since these books have been written, right, It's been quite a while,
- 26:51And the fact that they still land, I think speaks very much the fact
- 26:57that this time period in THEA is still very rich and offers tremendous opportunity to
- 27:08the right author that wants to or can you know, run with it as
- 27:12it were. And again I'll continue my small little vocal campaign here in our
- 27:18little corner of the galaxy to say that I think Watson deserves that shot.
- 27:23Let her come back and say, look look through the whole series. Can
- 27:26you turn this into a trilogy? Can you take the best of everything,
- 27:30put it in a blender. This is yours, this is your baby,
- 27:34Come in have at it. I'd love to see it and do it as
- 27:40adult novels right where you know you've got three hundred pages or more a novel
- 27:45to be able to really dig in. So now I couldn't agree with you
- 27:49more and I think, you know that really does lead me to as we
- 27:53wrap up this last book in the series, the official book in the series,
- 27:56where do you end up with the ratings for or the threat within?
- 28:02Well, as much as I enjoyed it, because of those shortcomings that we
- 28:04talked about, since we're working on a five point scale, because there will
- 28:10never be another scale, we thought four stars was it, it's five stars.
- 28:14Will nobody will ever go be crazy enough to go for six on a
- 28:18five star scale? This is a solid three, very enjoyable, and I
- 28:23read it obviously gave us something to talk about, but a little bit of
- 28:27frustration because there were just elements that could have been fleshed out better. What
- 28:33about you? Yeah, on good Reads, I gave this a four,
- 28:37but it's really I think a three point five, and I think for the
- 28:41very similar reasons that you gave. I really did enjoy the book, and
- 28:45I thought it was a good kind of wrap up, but in some ways,
- 28:49because it was the end I was wanting, I guess more, And
- 28:55I think that's a testament honestly to Watson and the fact that this whole time,
- 29:00I feel like almost every book, our one refrain has really just been,
- 29:06oh, man, I just could have more of this. And you
- 29:08know that's the thing where any good author, any good storytelling, kind of
- 29:15leaves you with that, right You're like, you can see yourself wanting more
- 29:18in it. And so you know, walking through the series has been a
- 29:25joy for me and I know and for you to the fact that to be
- 29:30in this time period with for us, you know, for me, oh,
- 29:33we won my favorite character. For you, Qui gone your favorite character,
- 29:37and to be able to spend this amount of time with him has been
- 29:41a real joy. So hopefully we'll get that opportunity there in the future.
- 29:45But you know, John, people did want to catch up with you and
- 29:48see the things that you're working on. Here in the year twenty twenty four
- 29:52and beyond, where will they find you. Well, here in the galactic
- 29:56year twenty twenty four. Big things are going to happen, just probably not
- 30:00to me, but you can reach out to me online as Kessel Junkie k
- 30:03E. S S E. L j u n Kie can find me right
- 30:07here on the network, co hosting a show called house Lights with Tristan Riddell
- 30:14and Darren Moser, where we look at the works of directors and segments of
- 30:18their careers and different topic areas and stuff like that. We have a time
- 30:22and I love to reference the appearances that I've made over on the six o
- 30:29two Club over on TFM, which is hosted by you, mister Matthew Rushing.
- 30:32So where can people find you out there? Well, you know,
- 30:37when I don't sound like a Darth Vader slash a frog. You can find
- 30:42me all over social media under the name Matters thingserpe to. Of course,
- 30:47here on the network, I also have AWL posts with Ray Kaufman talking about
- 30:51every single chapter of the Harry Potter series one chapter at a time. Got
- 30:56the six oh two Club there on the TFM network, and some great stuff
- 30:59coming up for this year, slowing down a little bit with for me getting
- 31:03into a new job. But I'm excited to say that the first episode of
- 31:07the year, it's going to feature none other than John Mills, so people
- 31:11are gonna want to check that out. You also find me doing the orb
- 31:15Wort five artificial tango saddle up, and literary treks and yeah that's pretty much
- 31:22it. So you know, John Wow, Jedi Apprentice is over. I
- 31:26hear the bells of the Jedi Temple ringing. I think it's time to go
- 31:32to the Room of one Thousand Fountains and hit a little notation, Master Rushing.
- 31:38Let's go meditate and hopefully that water doesn't make other things want to happen.
- 31:45Negotiations are closed. Join the Revolution, Join the Nerd Party.