Latest / Adventures Through The Mind / The Food Mushroom That Makes You See Little People | Colin Domnauer ~ ATTMind 208
Transcript
- 0:00And they were selling these blue staining bolete mushrooms.
- 0:03And they would say, if you undercook them,
- 0:06you will see little people.
- 0:08It lasts,
- 0:09you know,
- 0:10three to seven days.
- 0:11In some cases, weeks long.
- 0:12People are having these experiences.
- 0:15Well, after consuming the mushroom.
- 0:16Yes,
- 0:17yes.
- 0:17Wow.
- 0:18It's not like a few hours like psilocybin.
- 0:20One fellow said that he was eating lunch and that these little people started crawling
- 0:27across the rim of his bowl as he was eating soup.
- 0:30And then he would watch them jump into the bowl,
- 0:32go completely submerged into the soup,
- 0:35so like disappear,
- 0:36and then their heads would like pop up.
- 0:38And then he'd scoop them up with the spoon and they'd stay in the spoon as he lifted
- 0:41it to his mouth.
- 1:07Thank you.
- 1:16Hello and welcome back to Adventures Through the Mind.
- 1:19I'm your host, as always,
- 1:20James W.
- 1:21Gesso.
- 1:22This episode is going to feature an interview with Colin Dumnauer,
- 1:25ethnobotanist,
- 1:26at the Denninger Lab Natural History Museum of Utah.
- 1:30He discovered a mushroom
- 1:31that reliably induces Lilliputian hallucinations,
- 1:35effectively seeing tiny,
- 1:37hyper-realistic people
- 1:3910 to 30 centimeters tall
- 1:41that appear in your environment
- 1:43and obey the laws of physics.
- 1:45Oddly,
- 1:46this is not a, say,
- 1:48sought after drug.
- 1:49It's actually a widely popular food mushroom
- 1:53that you only experience these hallucinations
- 1:55if the mushroom is left undercooked.
- 1:57People are eating lunch at a hot pot restaurant
- 2:00and then three days later,
- 2:02they're in a Yunnan hospital
- 2:03suffering hallucinations of little people everywhere.
- 2:06This phenomenon has been observed
- 2:08across three different cultures
- 2:09in different geographical zones,
- 2:12all who have had the same repeating experience.
- 2:15This points to something in the activity of this mushroom
- 2:18that reliably produces these Lilliputian hallucinations.
- 2:23Today's interview with Colin Dumnour is going to explore this mystery,
- 2:27what we know and what we don't know about this popular food mushroom
- 2:30that causes us to see little people everywhere.
- 2:34Enjoy.
- 2:35Thank you,
- 2:36Amantara,
- 2:36for sponsoring this episode.
- 2:39Amantara is a credible source of legal psychoactive plants and extracts,
- 2:44most notably Amanita muscaria mushrooms.
- 2:47If you are personally curious to try some Amanita muscaria yourself,
- 2:53or you'd like to try any of their other products,
- 2:55you can check out Amantara at jamestabujesso.com forward slash A-M-E-N-T-A-R-A.
- 3:02amintera if you use the promo code attm22 you'll get 22 off your first order and now here's the
- 3:11episode colin domnauer welcome to adventures of the might thanks james thanks for having me
- 3:19So I became familiar with your work when an article you wrote for, I believe,
- 3:25the National Museum of Utah.
- 3:27Is that correct?
- 3:28Natural History Museum of Utah,
- 3:29yep.
- 3:30Yep.
- 3:31Went, I'm not sure how viral it went because we're all in our own little sort of algorithm reality bubbles,
- 3:37of course.
- 3:37But as far as my little reality bubble was concerned, a lot of people were very excitedly
- 3:43talking about this article you wrote on a mushroom that causes people to hallucinate
- 3:50little people.
- 3:51So that really struck my fancy and got me really curious,
- 3:55not just about the article
- 3:57itself, but to sit down and have a conversation with you.
- 4:00And I appreciate you being willing to
- 4:02jump on a call.
- 4:04Yeah,
- 4:05absolutely. I'm excited to talk more about it with you.
- 4:08Now,
- 4:09before we get into that mushroom in particular,
- 4:11why don't you tell me a little bit about the sort of wider field of your work and research,
- 4:18a little bit about your background,
- 4:20and then how it is that you got into studying the ethnobiology of psychoactive substances,
- 4:27and maybe also include a little description of what ethnobiology is.
- 4:32Right.
- 4:33So I've had sort of an unconventional pathway into this field. I spent most of my life and early college career studying astronomy and astrophysics.
- 4:37Okay.
- 4:44And then I sort of had a change of heart.
- 4:48when I went on a camping trip in British Columbia,
- 4:53and I remember distinctly walking into that forest there
- 4:56and being overwhelmed by the variety
- 5:00and diversity of mushrooms everywhere.
- 5:02I think at that time I'd probably never even noticed
- 5:05a mushroom growing outside,
- 5:07and here they were
- 5:08in a really mind-blowing abundance and diversity.
- 5:13got me really curious what these all were,
- 5:17what they were doing, what they might be used for.
- 5:20And it also was just really eye-opening that there's such beauty and diversity out in nature
- 5:29that I never recognized before.
- 5:31I think I'd spent most of my time,
- 5:34time,
- 5:34you know, in astronomy,
- 5:35pen to paper sort of inside.
- 5:38So that felt really like something I wanted to pursue more.
- 5:44So then I started looking more into mycology and that I suppose kind of naturally led into
- 5:52interest in magic mushrooms and more widely psychoactive substances.
- 5:57And so,
- 5:59yeah, in my last year as an undergrad,
- 6:01I did a voluntary honors thesis about the
- 6:03Yeah.
- 6:06archaeology of some psychoactive substance in South America.
- 6:10And I just really loved it.
- 6:11I was fascinated by my growing understanding of how deeply rooted these psychoactive substances
- 6:20have been throughout history and that there's a deep...
- 6:24relationship between humans and mind-altering experiences that I'd never really noticed before.
- 6:33And I really was fascinated by how the sorts of things they were talking about and saying from the results of these experiences were
- 6:45touched on the same sort of questions I was always interested in from a perspective of astronomy,
- 6:51these fundamental questions about really the nature of reality and our place in the universe.
- 6:57So it felt like a whole different doorway from the other side to answering these same questions.
- 7:03So that's sort of how I got interested in this field,
- 7:06The field of ethnobiology is, I guess,
- 7:08broadly defined as just the relationship between humans and nature,
- 7:13how people use plants,
- 7:16fungi,
- 7:17animals in a cultural context,
- 7:19how there is foods,
- 7:20medicines,
- 7:21drugs,
- 7:23or even more widely,
- 7:24it's like building materials and arts and things like that.
- 7:27So it's a wide interdisciplinary field.
- 7:29But yes,
- 7:30I'm mostly interested in the psychoactive substances.
- 7:35Hmm.
- 7:36And as a part of this,
- 7:38you know, this,
- 7:39the evolution of your work and this interest,
- 7:42you came across,
- 7:44uh,
- 7:45I'm not sure exactly how you came across this information, but you came across information about a mushroom that causes these very unique hallucinations.
- 7:55let's start with the technical details.
- 7:56Now you can kind of lead us in
- 7:58with how you became aware of
- 8:00that this mushroom exists if you like,
- 8:02but I want to go with the technical details
- 8:04of like,
- 8:05essentially,
- 8:06what is this mushroom?
- 8:07What do we talk,
- 8:08what is the mushroom we're talking about?
- 8:09Where is it found in the world?
- 8:11What sort of ecologies does it grow in?
- 8:14What kind of mushroom is it?
- 8:16Like,
- 8:16is it...
- 8:19saprophytic, is that the right word?
- 8:21Mushroom, the technical details of the thing.
- 8:25Right,
- 8:26so I first heard about this
- 8:28in an undergraduate mycology course.
- 8:31The professor very briefly just kind of flashed this up on screen.
- 8:35It was a paper written by a well-known mycologist
- 8:38named David Aurora.
- 8:40He was writing about his travels in Yunnan,
- 8:42China in the 1990s.
- 8:45And he was saying, it was just sort of an anecdotal paper about how he was interacting
- 8:52with locals at the market,
- 8:53and they were selling these blue staining boleet mushrooms.
- 8:57And they would say,
- 8:58if you undercook them,
- 8:59you will see little people.
- 9:01So he wrote about this.
- 9:04And yeah, the professor in the class I was taking at the time just mentioned this.
- 9:09how well this fact and said well nothing was really known about it other than these anecdotes
- 9:17and so that really caught my attention it sounded I mean at the time I remember thinking this can't
- 9:22be real it sounds like a fairy tale and if it is real then why do we not know more about it this
- 9:28seems amazing so I
- 9:31Yeah, I quickly realized very little or no research has been done on the topic since that early paper.
- 9:40And yeah, at the time,
- 9:42we really didn't even know these fundamental questions.
- 9:44What species is it?
- 9:46What is it?
- 9:47Where is it found?
- 9:47What is its lifestyle?
- 9:50But in the past,
- 9:51I'd say,
- 9:52five years or so,
- 9:53maybe 10 years,
- 9:54my research along with others has made a lot of good progress.
- 9:58So now we're fairly certain on the species that's causing this,
- 10:04because originally it was attributed to many different species.
- 10:08species of bullied mushrooms,
- 10:10which is a general term for a family of mushrooms that are easily
- 10:14distinguished by having like pores on the underside of their cap.
- 10:18But this family contains
- 10:20thousands of species worldwide.
- 10:22So it really wasn't known exactly what it was, but now we're
- 10:26fairly certain that it's a species called Lanmaua asiatico.
- 10:30So this is,
- 10:31it was described,
- 10:33actually originally described from a mushroom market,
- 10:37where it's been being sold for decades until science recognized it was actually a new species,
- 10:43which is funny.
- 10:44And that's actually not uncommon that people are selling and eating things that are undescribed species and about mushrooms.
- 10:53But yeah, it was thought to be endemic to Yunnan, China, which is the southwest province of China.
- 10:59Yeah.
- 11:02And it is a mycorrhizal species.
- 11:04So most bullies,
- 11:07most mushrooms in this family are mycorrhizal, which means they form symbiotic relationships with host trees.
- 11:14So the mushroom,
- 11:16you know,
- 11:16gets water and nutrients from the soil and its underground network gives that to the tree and the tree can give,
- 11:23in some cases,
- 11:24up to 50% of the energy it makes through photosynthesis to the fungus.
- 11:29So in that sense, the mushroom,
- 11:33or for that reason, the mushroom cannot be cultivated.
- 11:35It has to be grown with trees.
- 11:37And so for that reason, it's only been found and collected in the wild.
- 11:42So you really have to go to these places to get it.
- 11:44You can't grow it or distribute it like psilocybin mushrooms, for example.
- 11:50And then just in the past few years,
- 11:53I heard about very similar reports of people eating
- 11:56a type of wild bolete mushroom from the northern Philippines.
- 12:01And they were saying the same exact sorts of things that people,
- 12:05after eating this mushroom
- 12:06undercooked, would...
- 12:08experienced these hallucinations of seeing little people.
- 12:11And I thought,
- 12:11that's really weird.
- 12:12I mean, this mushroom sought to only be found in China.
- 12:15I wonder if it's the same thing or a different one causing the same effect.
- 12:19So I traveled there and in working with the local people and collecting mushrooms in the
- 12:25field with them and then bringing them back to our lab and doing research.
- 12:29DNA sequencing,
- 12:30we found that it's actually the same species,
- 12:32Lan Maui Asiatica.
- 12:34So this is the first known record that it occurs in the Philippines,
- 12:38which greatly expands its range.
- 12:40Probably it exists throughout Southeast Asia.
- 12:44But now we know it's used in two different cultures,
- 12:48and they independently report the same exact hallucinations,
- 12:51which gives us a good...
- 12:55I guess bolsters our confidence that there is some actual material basis to this phenomenon.
- 13:00It's not just a cultural act.
- 13:04So tell me more about this experience. You're saying that they see little people.
- 13:09What exactly does that mean? What are the... Can you care? What's the term something for? Can you...
- 13:14Give us like a general description of what people are experiencing.
- 13:19How big are these little people?
- 13:21Where do they see them?
- 13:22How real do they appear to be?
- 13:24And so on.
- 13:26Right.
- 13:26It's really bizarre.
- 13:29But this is actually a known psychiatric condition that has been documented recently.
- 13:34Well, it was defined in the early 1900s,
- 13:37but it's been documented throughout human history.
- 13:39And so it's called Lilliputian hallucinations.
- 13:43And it's the perception of seeing an abundant number of little people,
- 13:49often 10 to 30 centimeters tall,
- 13:52in one's environment and they are always described by people who have this syndrome as
- 13:59being rendered in exquisite detail they're three-dimensional they are interacting with real
- 14:07world objects and obeying the laws of physics you know falling like from gravity or climbing up
- 14:15chairs and tables
- 14:16And,
- 14:18yeah, there's a lot of bizarre attributes they have, but what's interesting is they are remarkably consistent across different cases.
- 14:29So people always say they're colorfully dressed.
- 14:33They are described various ways in different ways.
- 14:36cultures,
- 14:37of course, elves,
- 14:38clowns,
- 14:39fairies,
- 14:40dwarfs,
- 14:41harlequins.
- 14:43But they're often described
- 14:47as being sort of amusing or amicable,
- 14:51but not directly communicating with the observer.
- 14:56And
- 14:58Yeah,
- 14:59despite their consistency and how they appear to people,
- 15:06they can arise from a variety of different sources.
- 15:10So people who get the syndrome might be suffering from alcohol withdrawal.
- 15:14They might be having macular degeneration in old age.
- 15:18They might be having...
- 15:21neurological diseases like Charles
- 15:23Bonney syndrome.
- 15:24It's been reported from like almost
- 15:27a hundred different causes
- 15:29but it's not
- 15:31reliably reported from anyone
- 15:33except in this mushroom.
- 15:35It seems we finally have
- 15:37something that can reliably elicit this experience.
- 15:42So it remains unknown by psychiatrists and
- 15:46neurologists how this exactly works in the mind, the pharmacology of how it happens or the treatment
- 15:52of how to treat it effectively because we just don't know the mechanisms.
- 15:56But we're hopeful that
- 15:58perhaps a
- 15:59compound in this mushroom can be a real key,
- 16:05uh,
- 16:06window into understanding the mechanism
- 16:08of how this works.
- 16:10Hmm.
- 16:11Very curious.
- 16:12Um,
- 16:13so,
- 16:14I mean, with, with this syndrome being,
- 16:16you know,
- 16:17potentially arising from this huge
- 16:19spread of conditions,
- 16:21um,
- 16:22um,
- 16:22The next question I'm going to ask feels like it maybe makes more sense if we just sort of like,
- 16:28I mean, you can include all of that if you like, but it maybe makes more sense if we just think about it from the perspective of like the people consuming the mushrooms and having these experience,
- 16:36which is that.
- 16:38do people report these experiences being generally positive or generally
- 16:42negative?
- 16:42Like you said there,
- 16:44I can't remember how you said like whimsy or something like are these little
- 16:49people sort of,
- 16:50is it an enjoyable experience to interact with them of like wonder and awe?
- 16:54Or is it something like a little demons?
- 16:58I'm thinking like Hieronymus Bosch and that one famous painting,
- 17:01you know, these little demons everywhere.
- 17:03Or is it context dependent?
- 17:05Yeah.
- 17:06Right. I would say,
- 17:08at least in the case of China,
- 17:10it's described neither as something fearful to be avoided nor something awe-inspiring to be sought after.
- 17:18It is often recounted as an amusing experience.
- 17:23The people I spoke to all told stories with laughs and smiles on their faces,
- 17:28but it's not something they intentionally seek out or do recreationally.
- 17:34Now,
- 17:34that might just be a cultural attitude rather than a reflection of the drug itself.
- 17:42But it is worth mentioning also in the Philippines and in Papua New Guinea, which we haven't spoken about,
- 17:50but this phenomenon was also reported from...
- 17:54the indigenous people in Papua New Guinea.
- 17:57In all those three cases,
- 17:58it was never something intentionally consumed.
- 18:02There's no documented ritual or shamanic use of this mushroom.
- 18:08It's in all cases a very highly prized food.
- 18:13It's a very delicious mushroom.
- 18:15I have eaten it and I could say it's very tasty.
- 18:18But it's,
- 18:20the psychoactive effect is more of a occasional accidental side effect of undercooking it.
- 18:27So,
- 18:27you know, I think we could get into more of the symptoms,
- 18:31but one important thing worth mentioning is that it lasts,
- 18:35you know,
- 18:36three to seven days.
- 18:37In some cases, weeks long, people are having these experiences.
- 18:40Well,
- 18:41after consuming the mushroom.
- 18:42Yes,
- 18:43yes.
- 18:44Wow.
- 18:44It's not like a few hours like psilocybin.
- 18:46So I think this long duration of action could be one reason why it doesn't have more recreational use.
- 18:47Yeah.
- 18:55It is,
- 18:58I guess, more,
- 18:59I don't want to say challenging,
- 19:03but more of a serious undertaking to be affected for that long.
- 19:07So,
- 19:09yeah.
- 19:12Okay, so I have two questions. Okay, I'm going to save the one that I had written down in a minute.
- 19:12And...
- 19:20Are people,
- 19:21when they come out of it, so obviously people know about this because it happens,
- 19:24accidental ingestion,
- 19:26and if it's lasting three to seven days,
- 19:28do you have to do that?
- 19:28do people come out of it disturbed by the experience
- 19:31or do they eventually acclimatize
- 19:34and they're like, oh, there's little people
- 19:36as they just go about their normal lives?
- 19:38I guess that ties into another question.
- 19:41How with it are people during this experience?
- 19:44If I think about...
- 19:45um,
- 19:46like as a case example,
- 19:48psilocybin,
- 19:49totally different drug,
- 19:50right?
- 19:51But when I am and others
- 19:54I have spoken to, and the reports suggest that when people are on psilocybin, there's a headspace
- 19:58to that.
- 19:59You're not thinking the same way. You're not conducting yourself in the same way.
- 20:03It changes how you
- 20:04behave,
- 20:05right?
- 20:06In a way that, you know, dose dependent and sort of individually
- 20:10dependent can be quite a significant alteration in how you conduct yourself in your life,
- 20:15right?
- 20:16Like in some respects, even to a safety issue of maybe not realizing that you shouldn't
- 20:21be outside without your clothes on in the winter or something to this effect, not to
- 20:26make a trivial characterization,
- 20:27but
- 20:28When people are under the effects of this mushroom, are they seeing little people everywhere, but they're otherwise totally with their normal cognitive capacities?
- 20:38Or is there an alteration there that the people in the community or in the tribe know like, oh, that's why he's here.
- 20:45They are just like wandering off,
- 20:48frolicking.
- 20:51He's with the little people or whatever.
- 20:53How with it are people?
- 20:55Right.
- 20:56So let's first talk about from an outside perspective. So culturally,
- 20:58Yeah.
- 21:02everyone,
- 21:03really on all three of those cultures,
- 21:06China,
- 21:06Papua New Guinea, the Philippines,
- 21:07people are familiar with this effect.
- 21:09It's not some obscure fact. It's well known.
- 21:13So when someone sees someone obviously affected by the mushroom, they kind of know that that's what's happening.
- 21:20but from a first person perspective
- 21:25I mean, I can't say for sure. I've never had the experience myself,
- 21:27but from people I've talked to and read about that have,
- 21:31it sounds like I've heard both ways.
- 21:34It could be dose dependent.
- 21:35So I've heard people who are just like eating a meal and they see the little people walking across the table,
- 21:42but they keep eating a meal.
- 21:44And then I've heard people who are completely out of it. They stumble slowly.
- 21:48uh sort of or like someone else stumbles upon someone who's like totally delirious and and
- 21:49um
- 21:54having these effects and sort of in their own world and so it could be dose dependent for sure
- 22:00we don't have any idea about what the dose is people are eating these mushrooms and who knows
- 22:06what quantities and it's it's not really like um regulated there's not like a
- 22:14a strict dose
- 22:17because it's all
- 22:19randomly consumed and used.
- 22:20So,
- 22:23I suppose both ways
- 22:26people
- 22:27can be more with it
- 22:28or out of it.
- 22:31And do people
- 22:35that during the experience when they're under the effects they recognize what they're seeing
- 22:40is a hallucination or is there a sense that what they're seeing is real i'm thinking in particular
- 22:43report
- 22:46to um like the tropane alkaloids um uh contained in plants like the tura people are having um
- 22:55I'm having a conversation with my dead grandfather over there in the corner,
- 23:02and we're having a lively conversation.
- 23:06It's absolutely 100% happening. They are alive,
- 23:09and I'm in my living room,
- 23:12and it's a Wednesday.
- 23:13But in actuality,
- 23:15I'm lying on a cot somewhere in the jungle,
- 23:20and it's the middle of the night,
- 23:22and I'm just kind of holding myself.
- 23:24I'm sitting up, I'm talking to the air as far as anyone else is happening.
- 23:28In the example of the tropanes here,
- 23:32So I'm genuinely convinced what I'm experiencing is real,
- 23:37like being in a non-lucid dream.
- 23:40Or I could have other experiences where,
- 23:43say on psilocybin, I'm seeing things happening.
- 23:46I'm like, I'm not certain that's real,
- 23:49even though I'm seeing it.
- 23:50Like I can be aware that this is a visual hallucination or distortion of perception.
- 23:55Do people report being fully immersed in the reality of the hallucination or are they conscientiously aware that what they're seeing,
- 24:00Yeah.
- 24:04well,
- 24:04depends on the culture I suppose is the assumption of how real it is, but that they're aware that what they're seeing is a hallucination that isn't necessarily happening,
- 24:14freestanding of their perception.
- 24:17Right.
- 24:18So I think people,
- 24:20you know, there's a lot of videos like on Chinese social media about these people who are experiencing this mushroom and they're like interacting with what appears to be the little people trying to pick them up and things like that. So I think they do seem...
- 24:35I mean, they're definitely appearing very real perceptually.
- 24:41These aren't like amorphous,
- 24:43nebulous figures.
- 24:47These are,
- 24:48like I mentioned,
- 24:48rendered in exquisite detail,
- 24:51very realistic,
- 24:51and grounded in the environment.
- 24:53So they certainly appear real, and I think people generally...
- 24:58at first think they're real because they
- 25:01appear to be so but
- 25:03yeah I think the knowledge
- 25:05that
- 25:07this effect can follow
- 25:09the consumption of this mushroom
- 25:10that is calmly eaten
- 25:13probably you know
- 25:15alerts them to the fact that what they're having is a hallucination.
- 25:21I mean, it's really hard to know exactly how they're feeling without,
- 25:27you know, a detailed interview or experiencing it yourself.
- 25:31I will say this,
- 25:32though.
- 25:34So there's been several hundred people...
- 25:37studied in Yunnan Hospital who have these effects
- 25:42after eating this mushroom,
- 25:43and they admit themselves to the hospital.
- 25:46And there's been some studies done,
- 25:48and they've looked at,
- 25:50well, just observational,
- 25:52but then they've also done some tests on FMRI studies
- 25:56of people affected by this mushroom.
- 25:58And they have found lower,
- 26:04changes in activity in the brain associated with like memory and language comprehension
- 26:11and they concluded from that as well as like a rudimentary test they gave these people that
- 26:17they were cognitively impaired and considered delirious.
- 26:21So it does seem to be more of a delirious so to say than like a
- 26:29classical psychedelic.
- 26:31But another study did write that people expressed,
- 26:35gave greater expression to inner thoughts and emotions.
- 26:39So maybe that is more similar to classical psychedelics.
- 26:42I think we're really at the very beginning
- 26:44of understanding the effects and...
- 26:47We can't really say anything for certain about characterizing what's happening.
- 26:52We don't even know what compound it is that's causing this. So there's a lot of unknowns.
- 26:57And again,
- 26:59just because this is something that's never intentionally consumed,
- 27:03we have no idea about the
- 27:05the differences in dosage or there's just so many conflating factors that just are not controlled.
- 27:13So it's, it's hard to, to make any statements of certainty about what's going on.
- 27:19And you said these little people are like,
- 27:23um,
- 27:24in high detail,
- 27:25exquisite,
- 27:26exquisitely high detail.
- 27:28Um,
- 27:28and people are picking them up,
- 27:30moving them.
- 27:31Even if I knew it was a hallucination,
- 27:33I feel at some point I'll be like,
- 27:34get away from my mouse.
- 27:36I'm trying to navigate my computer interface here.
- 27:42But are they stable in the sense that
- 27:46if I look at,
- 27:49okay,
- 27:49say there's one on my desk
- 27:50and I like pick it up.
- 27:51I'm just an example.
- 27:51Obviously we don't,
- 27:52you know,
- 27:53you said there's no,
- 27:54there isn't robust research here.
- 27:56But if I say I pick one up on my desk
- 27:58and say go away
- 27:59and I threw it
- 27:59and it followed the laws of physics
- 28:01and it went all the way over there,
- 28:02And I start working again that if I were to go over to where I threw it, I would find the exact same little person like waiting there, I don't know, rubbing its knee or something.
- 28:13Like, is it that level of stable that it like it's almost as if once you're in its reality,
- 28:18that reality itself is fully stable the way that if I were to go to the bathroom right now and you stayed on the call, I'd come back and it would be the same person waiting on the call.
- 28:27It appears to be so.
- 28:29A lot of the cases that people have described to me,
- 28:34I'll just give some examples to demonstrate.
- 28:37So one fellow said that he was eating lunch and that these little people started crawling across the rim of his bowl as he was eating soup.
- 28:47And then he would watch them jump into the bowl,
- 28:51go completely submerged into the soup, so like disappear,
- 28:54and then their heads would like pop up.
- 28:56And then he'd scoop them up with the spoon and they'd stay in the spoon as he lifted it to his mouth.
- 29:00So they seem to be remarkably stable and embedded in the environment like that.
- 29:05That is just wild.
- 29:07And it's not just one runaway board.
- 29:10Many different people have said this.
- 29:13In that David Aurora article,
- 29:14he was talking to a professor
- 29:17who was eating lunch at a place,
- 29:19and he said he lifted up the tablecloth
- 29:21and he saw hundreds of little people
- 29:23underneath the tablecloth.
- 29:24And then when he lifted it up higher...
- 29:26their heads would get stuck to the tablecloth and they would be dangling like that. So it's,
- 29:32again, I know nothing else like this where it's a sort of
- 29:37reality or environmentally embedded hallucination.
- 29:40It's not like a
- 29:42changing or in the same in a way that like many other visual hallucinations
- 29:49are I mean even even qualitatively different than a dream dream state
- 29:54which is constantly shifting despite it constantly feeling real and as logical
- 29:59in one frame to the next it being this costing
- 30:02constantly shifting mirage of,
- 30:05of things that once you're back to baseline or back to waking state,
- 30:08you're like,
- 30:08yeah,
- 30:08that made no logical sense at all.
- 30:11Um,
- 30:12I,
- 30:12I,
- 30:13did you watch the television show common side effects?
- 30:18Yeah,
- 30:18I did.
- 30:18I just recently got into that,
- 30:20like probably a few months ago.
- 30:22Now the,
- 30:23the reason why I rarely do I bring up TV shows on the show here,
- 30:26but,
- 30:27um,
- 30:28It is a for the listeners.
- 30:30It is a,
- 30:31in my opinion, very well done cartoon that appears to be very funny on the surface and is funny, but it's actually quite a serious ordeal once you get into it,
- 30:40that explores the discovery of a mushroom that when you give it to people basically cures all diseases,
- 30:48even death.
- 30:50And it looks like a little blue mushroom,
- 30:51very akin to,
- 30:52slightly different, but very akin to say a psilocybe salamensiata or a liberty cap mushroom with an extra little veil accent on it or something.
- 31:02And people have these experiences and so on and so forth.
- 31:07But so in every ways, it feels like it's coded as a psilocybin mushroom,
- 31:12but with this sort
- 31:13of it heals all disease issue.
- 31:15But then also,
- 31:16when you take it, you see little people coming up out of everywhere.
- 31:21And there's some important aspect of the little people that you see are part of the healing.
- 31:25And then there's some interesting narrative development later as to that reality that
- 31:30they're in and blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 31:32And it wasn't until I read your article that in my mind, I was like, oh, that's cute. They just took the ideas of psilocybin experiences and it is a medicine that can help this broad range of conditions and then amplified it and put it in the context of considering the corruptness of the pharmaceutical industry.
- 31:47And then also added this fun idea that you can see little people and realizing now that,
- 31:52oh no, there's genuinely this mushroom.
- 31:56that people have known about for a very long time
- 31:59that actively causes you to see little people.
- 32:02And so,
- 32:03anyways, I bring that up
- 32:04because if listeners don't already know,
- 32:06it's a very interesting show.
- 32:07And if you didn't already know,
- 32:08I felt like given the research you're doing,
- 32:11you would find it at the very least entertaining
- 32:14to watch this.
- 32:16Yeah, yeah. I mean, it's an interesting question. I mean, I haven't spoken with producers,
- 32:22but whether they got that inspiration from this psychoactive bully or something,
- 32:30you know, this is a deeply held association,
- 32:33I think, across human beings.
- 32:34folklore mythology of associating diminutive beings with mushrooms.
- 32:40Why is this? We still don't know.
- 32:44But it's curious now that appears we have discovered a mushroom which causes perceptions of little people.
- 32:52Yeah.
- 32:54Fascinating.
- 32:55Okay. I want to take a minute here and thank my patrons on Patreon.
- 32:58This podcast is funded by people like you.
- 33:01Yes,
- 33:01very periodically,
- 33:03there are some sponsors for some episodes,
- 33:05but what allows me to earn an income, to earn a living doing this podcast,
- 33:11this creative work, which is my full-time job,
- 33:13is people like you on Patreon.
- 33:16So thank you very much,
- 33:17patrons,
- 33:17for making this podcast possible for all of us.
- 33:20The people whose names are listed on the screen here
- 33:22on YouTube give significantly,
- 33:24and some of which for a long time,
- 33:26and their name in the credits are a special thank you to that.
- 33:29Their names are also in the description to this episode.
- 33:32If you were listening to this episode
- 33:33and you're finding value in it,
- 33:35You know, consider sending me a little something,
- 33:37something.
- 33:38It could be signing up for a monthly pledge on Patreon.
- 33:44It could be tossing me just a little tip,
- 33:46you know, like you would for a busker for a job well done.
- 33:49This podcast does require quite a lot of time and time.
- 33:53finances to maintain both on the investment side of the hardware and the ongoing subscription fees
- 34:01necessary to produce and host a podcast over time.
- 34:05And again,
- 34:06the time that goes into producing these
- 34:07episodes.
- 34:08I'm a one person operation here.
- 34:10I research,
- 34:12I find, I research,
- 34:14I record,
- 34:15I post
- 34:16produce,
- 34:16I social media, I do all of it. And it takes a lot of time and again, a lot of resources.
- 34:21If you find value in that,
- 34:24even just a couple of dollars would be great.
- 34:26Even if you imagine like,
- 34:28you know,
- 34:28you buy me a cup of coffee for a job well done,
- 34:32consider it something like that.
- 34:33Links to do so are in the description of this episode.
- 34:36Patreon, if you're looking to either follow me for free on Patreon's not-so-toxic algorithm,
- 34:42or if you'd like to leave a monthly pledge there,
- 34:45or if you want to leave me a one-time tip donation through Patreon,
- 34:48Ko-Fi or PayPal.
- 34:50And I really appreciate you doing so.
- 34:51I recognize that the world is a complex place
- 34:54financially and otherwise,
- 34:55myself included,
- 34:57and your decision to voluntarily contribute to the
- 35:02expenses of this show and to acknowledge my efforts in producing the show in that way,
- 35:08helping to make a podcast for all of us,
- 35:10is deeply,
- 35:11deeply appreciated.
- 35:12If you can't,
- 35:13that's all right.
- 35:14Please continue.
- 35:14Enjoy the show.
- 35:16Those who can do.
- 35:17And we all got a podcast.
- 35:18All right.
- 35:19So that's it for my little Patreon support break.
- 35:22Let's get back into this interview with Colin Dumnour.
- 35:26So it lasts for three to seven days.
- 35:28Do we have reports of people being injured by this experience?
- 35:32I mean,
- 35:33specifically on the psychiatric side of things.
- 35:37Is it like three to seven days goes by,
- 35:39the hallucinations wear off,
- 35:41whatever other cognitive effects kind of wear off, and they're like, well, glad that was over.
- 35:45Or do people have...
- 35:48Is there any sort of case reports of long-term psychiatric changes,
- 35:53either for the positive,
- 35:54people feeling like it was deeply healing or they learned a lot about themselves or so on and so
- 35:59forth, or negative in the sense that sort of maybe a prevailing sense of derealization or
- 36:06cognitive deficits that prevail for a long time afterwards?
- 36:08Do we have any reports of
- 36:10long-term effects on one side or the other?
- 36:13Right, so the best source of information for all this
- 36:16is again gonna be coming from Unan Hospital.
- 36:18They've probably analyzed approximately a thousand cases
- 36:22of people affected by this mushroom over the years.
- 36:26And everyone has recovered eventually.
- 36:31Now the timeframe for recovery can vary.
- 36:34Like I mentioned,
- 36:35it's usually around three days to a week.
- 36:38But they said there were some cases,
- 36:41I forget the exact percentage,
- 36:42but of people who that it lasted weeks for.
- 36:45And I think they said in one case,
- 36:47someone had to be admitted to like a psychiatric ward for a few months.
- 36:52But I mean,
- 36:53that percentage is probably very low.
- 36:55The vast majority of people do recover.
- 36:58They don't appear to have any long-term effects.
- 37:00So they did look at, that study looked at vital organ function and damage both during and after,
- 37:09and they found no changes in either any vital organs.
- 37:15So there's no damage physiologically,
- 37:17it appears,
- 37:18at least to the major heart kidney disease.
- 37:21liver, that sort of thing.
- 37:24And then there's also,
- 37:26of course, been no,
- 37:27well, not of course, but there's been no deaths
- 37:30reported from this mushroom, it's important to say.
- 37:34So it appears to be,
- 37:35you know,
- 37:36not super toxic in that sense,
- 37:39but the long duration of action
- 37:41is concerning.
- 37:43And again, we still don't know exactly the mechanism going on.
- 37:48As for the, you know,
- 37:50long-term positive effects afterwards,
- 37:53that hasn't been reported in the Chinese literature.
- 37:57But I think that might just be more of a cultural attitude because I think they don't,
- 38:03I mean, they're not using this for that purpose.
- 38:06And they might just be less inclined to report those sorts of things.
- 38:12I think,
- 38:13you know, as you know, a big condition in shaping the experience of a psychoactive
- 38:21substance is one set and setting as much as the drug is.
- 38:25So I think a lot of these questions about the effects and benefits or harms,
- 38:32we shouldn't
- 38:34think of them as just being attributable to the drug itself.
- 38:38it's going to be context dependent on the person and place and the way that they're using it.
- 38:43And so because this has only really been used in these East Asian cultures, which are very different from our culture,
- 38:52it's hard to say what differences the experience might have for folks like you and I.
- 39:00Yeah.
- 39:00yeah I think
- 39:01I don't know to what degree because I
- 39:04very much engrossed
- 39:05in the sort of cultural
- 39:08reality that I'm in
- 39:10here in Canada but
- 39:11there might be some level of
- 39:15analysis
- 39:16bias of like
- 39:18maybe because it's a
- 39:19drug in one way or another that they're not looking to report on positive effects.
- 39:24I don't know if that's the case, but I know that for quite a long time,
- 39:26even around here,
- 39:28you know, like maybe one of the reasons why this mushroom wasn't well studied for a long
- 39:31time is that it's really only been in the last...
- 39:35what,
- 39:3515 years,
- 39:3720 years max that the idea of, yeah, 15-ish years that the idea of researching
- 39:44and studying the positive value of psychedelic drugs is something other than career suicide
- 39:49for an academic.
- 39:51So maybe there's some of that too.
- 39:54This draws me to another question.
- 39:56So you're talking about the different cultures.
- 39:59There's three specific places that are known,
- 40:02right?
- 40:02This particular area in China,
- 40:05you said Papua New Guinea, is that right?
- 40:06And the Philippines.
- 40:09Now, I don't know what the...
- 40:10And you're going to have to pardon the terminology here.
- 40:12It gets slippery and I might end up saying things that come off kind of gross.
- 40:17But I don't know what the sort of...
- 40:19the cultural worldview is there or the degree of sort of like the global
- 40:25North modernity in the perception of what is real.
- 40:28Like,
- 40:28are these more like,
- 40:30is this in fairly modern cities in China and in the Philippines or are they,
- 40:38this stuff is happening more in more traditional villages,
- 40:42right.
- 40:42That are less sort of like fully adopted to the world.
- 40:46modern scientific industrial materialist worldview.
- 40:51I'm asking this because is there a sense that in any of these three,
- 40:59you know,
- 40:59cultural locations that these mushrooms and the experience that are happening
- 41:04are reflective of the,
- 41:08aspects of reality?
- 41:09Like, is there a sense of like,
- 41:10oh, of course you see the little people
- 41:12because there are,
- 41:14for example,
- 41:14going back to say like a Celtic,
- 41:17I believe like there are fairies
- 41:19or various other traditions
- 41:20that would say there are such things as demons
- 41:22and there are this and that.
- 41:24Do these cultures recognize these experiences
- 41:27as being reflective of a deeper layer of reality
- 41:29or are they...
- 41:32all kind of seen as like,
- 41:33oh, that's a hallucination.
- 41:35You saw the little people,
- 41:36ha ha ha.
- 41:38Welcome back to reality.
- 41:41I would say my understanding
- 41:43is that it's more of the latter.
- 41:45It doesn't seem to be embedded
- 41:47within a...
- 41:48certainly not a religious belief,
- 41:51but even more of a cultural belief system.
- 41:55It seems to be more understood as a side effect of this mushroom.
- 42:02Certainly in China,
- 42:03I mean, the places that I know it occurs are in major cities,
- 42:08but I mean, I haven't explored the more rural areas.
- 42:13villages,
- 42:14I mean, they probably are eating it.
- 42:17I mean, it's found throughout the province,
- 42:18and it's known they consume and eat wild mushrooms.
- 42:24And there's so many different ethnic groups in Yunnan.
- 42:29Again,
- 42:29looking at this from different cultural belief systems, we're probably still missing a lot,
- 42:34and there's a lot left to be discovered.
- 42:37In the Philippines,
- 42:38it is a very remote,
- 42:39small village in the mountains.
- 42:42And they know about it, and then they have a sort of folkloric word for these little people.
- 42:42So...
- 42:51They call them the Ansecitans.
- 42:53But there's not really a belief system around them that I know of.
- 42:58There could be.
- 42:59I just don't know about it.
- 43:03But I will say they're also sort of reluctant to talk about it.
- 43:07They talk about them when they're drunk and more loose like that,
- 43:12but it's not something that's commonly discussed.
- 43:15And then in Papua New Guinea...
- 43:18It was reported that,
- 43:19you know, people affected by this mushroom would sort of start running amok and behaving wildly and going off on their own.
- 43:27And it was from the perspective of the other people in the tribe, it was seen as more just like a fearful thing, like this person's kind of gone mad.
- 43:36And so the anthropologists studying this dubbed it mushroom madness.
- 43:42So you can see just from, I guess, the language that it's not really a sort of...
- 43:47communalized or ritualized substance it's more of a phenomenon that is
- 43:58sort of on its own and I don't think there's a belief system surrounding it
- 44:04hmm well i think uh something that i'm i'm thinking about right now is
- 44:10the saying of like well the genie's out of the bottle uh and that is that you know if if there's
- 44:16anything i've learned over the past uh 15 plus years that i've been involved in psychedelic
- 44:22culture and paying attention to the culture um
- 44:26And it's basically that there are a lot of people out there that are absolutely down.
- 44:32Like they are ready to try the weirdest,
- 44:35interesting,
- 44:36most interesting,
- 44:37newest stuff.
- 44:37And they're willing to gamble at all to go far out on wild stuff and then get on Reddit
- 44:43and talk all about their experiences.
- 44:46So there is likely coming down the pipeline,
- 44:49lots of anecdotal reports, I assume,
- 44:54but
- 44:54Now that said,
- 44:55let's slide back to the sort of more institutionalized research.
- 45:03You said that there isn't an awareness of the pharmacology of this thing.
- 45:07There's no clear understanding of the compound or compounds that's causing these hallucinations.
- 45:14There is some fMRI data.
- 45:18Do you, like, if you would say speculate or if anyone is speculating,
- 45:23So what could be the compounds?
- 45:27Are there specific compounds in these mushrooms that we don't know whether or not they're the psychoactive component,
- 45:33but they might be?
- 45:35Do we have a sense of like, we don't know what entirely it's doing, but we know these areas of the brain are areas that are being influenced.
- 45:42And so there's a hypothesis or speculation that it might be.
- 45:47this mechanism of action.
- 45:50Even if speculative,
- 45:52is there a sense
- 45:53of what we might be discovering
- 45:56once we start looking into the pharmacology
- 45:58of these mushrooms?
- 46:02Of course, this is all speculative. We don't have any hard leads right now about what it might be.
- 46:09Based off, you know, the effects and the symptoms,
- 46:13for example, the long duration of action and also something I didn't mention is the fact that after you consume this mushroom, it takes 12 to 24 hours before the effects occur.
- 46:16Right, so...
- 46:24of these psychoactive effects begin.
- 46:27People do report some GI symptoms,
- 46:29like one to six hours afterwards,
- 46:31but that recovers fairly quickly
- 46:33and doesn't seem to be too severe.
- 46:36But I think that long onset time
- 46:39could indicate that
- 46:41there is not a compound in the mushroom that's active,
- 46:45but something that's being metabolized in our body,
- 46:49and then after that whole metabolic process,
- 46:52it creates something that does have these psychoactive effects.
- 46:56Perhaps also it might not necessarily be something that's passing into the brain.
- 47:04Perhaps it's having a more peripheral effect and that could explain the long duration of action.
- 47:12There's some research that's been hypothesizing, you know,
- 47:19it's honestly beyond my expertise.
- 47:21I'm not like a pharmacologist,
- 47:23but,
- 47:23uh,
- 47:24suggesting that,
- 47:25you know,
- 47:26metabolic,
- 47:27uh,
- 47:28damage in like the gut could actually influence perception,
- 47:32uh,
- 47:33in like the brainstem and that you can have these sorts of,
- 47:38um,
- 47:40peripheral activities that actually affect have psychoactive effects without anything actually
- 47:46crossing it into the blood-brain barrier so i know this is just speculatives i mean there's so many
- 47:48uh,
- 47:53different explanations but i would say the fact that it has such unique pharmacodynamics of the long
- 48:01you know,
- 48:02duration and onset suggested something interesting and different from what we currently
- 48:08know.
- 48:09uh
- 48:10And it's worth mentioning,
- 48:11we've looked for psilocybin and ibotenic acid,
- 48:15which are the
- 48:15known psychoactive compounds in mushrooms.
- 48:17They're not in this mushroom.
- 48:19And so it is probably
- 48:22something new and interesting from a pharmacological perspective that could
- 48:27give new insight into understanding the relationship between our mind,
- 48:33body,
- 48:33and perception.
- 48:35And just to clarify for the listeners,
- 48:37psilocybin would be the active compound in what we call
- 48:40magic mushrooms,
- 48:40ibotenic acid being the active compound in the Amanita muscaria, the red mushroom
- 48:45with the white caps.
- 48:46Yeah.
- 48:47Right.
- 48:48Yes.
- 48:49Um,
- 48:49yeah.
- 48:52Okay. I'm not sure if it was kind of wrapped up in there. You said the fMRI, there was fMRI data for people who were sort of suffering from this intoxication.
- 49:02Did they clearly,
- 49:04they identified that certain areas of the brain associated, I think you said with language and something else were compromised.
- 49:10But is there a clear sense of what areas in the brain specifically seem to be altered by this effect?
- 49:21So I'd have to look more closely at the paper again. I don't know off the top of my head.
- 49:26But it appears that, yes,
- 49:29the regions I remember with memory and communication were impaired.
- 49:34And then...
- 49:36um yeah there's some heightened activity in some visual region which they said explains the
- 49:44the hallucinations which i i mean i'm sure the there's a lot more that that uh is required to
- 49:52explain this phenomenon than having activity in one brain region for sure but um uh yeah
- 50:01Yeah,
- 50:01I'm sorry. I don't know off the top of my head,
- 50:03actually,
- 50:04the exact regions of the brain.
- 50:05No problems.
- 50:07Let's take a short ad break here.
- 50:10Now, I have been interested in the Amanita muscaria mushroom for several years now,
- 50:16since,
- 50:16well,
- 50:17since maybe I was a kid playing Super Mario Brothers and seeing that interesting looking mushroom there.
- 50:23But for a number of years since I interviewed a woman named Amanita Dreamer back many, many episodes ago,
- 50:30about the benefits of the Amanita muscaria mushroom.
- 50:34I've also interviewed another person,
- 50:36Baba Masha,
- 50:37on microdosing Amanita,
- 50:38and I've been curious about that too for quite a while.
- 50:41However,
- 50:42I never followed through because it seemed like the landscape
- 50:47was questionable as to the kind of supply I was getting,
- 50:51and I wanted to be sure that if I did try this,
- 50:53I got it through a reliable source.
- 50:57I did and I underwent my first microdosing protocol with Amanita Muscario mushrooms and well I'll make a video about it when the time comes but the company that I got that Amanita from is called Ementera.
- 51:08I had such a positive experience with this company and with their products that I am well here we are with an affiliate arrangement and they have sponsored this episode.
- 51:19If you are personally curious to try some Amanita Muscaria yourself,
- 51:24or you'd like to try any of their other products,
- 51:27you can check out Amantera at jameswjesso.com forward slash A-M-E-N-T-A-R-A Amantera.
- 51:35If you use the promo code ATTM22,
- 51:39you'll get 22% off your first order.
- 51:42Links to this are going to be in the description to this episode as well as a reminder of the
- 51:47promo code there.
- 51:47But yeah, go check them out.
- 51:49And of course,
- 51:50hey,
- 51:51you know where the comment section is.
- 51:53If you try out their Amanita,
- 51:55I'd love to hear how it goes for you so you can comment
- 51:57below.
- 51:59For the reports of the mushrooms causing perception of little people,
- 52:03right, when you
- 52:03went to these different areas where those reports are, you discovered that, well, okay,
- 52:07so it's all the same species,
- 52:09right?
- 52:09You had also said that this family of mushrooms,
- 52:13that there are thousands of them,
- 52:16and that
- 52:17this sort of, I don't know if it's genus of mushroom, there's a lot of choice edibles
- 52:21in the midst of them.
- 52:23And I assume they are present in multiple different ecologies around the world.
- 52:28I mean,
- 52:28similar ecologies,
- 52:29obviously, because they're Michael Riesel,
- 52:30but in different locations
- 52:32around the world.
- 52:34Is there a sense that there might be more of these mushrooms,
- 52:39either that specific species unrecognized in different areas or different species within the same genus or family that might produce these same effects but are just yet unknown to the people where they grow?
- 52:56Right.
- 52:57It's a really good question and something that I'm really interested in.
- 53:01So to answer that, we first have to understand the diversity of species that are out there,
- 53:03Yeah.
- 53:08which for mycology is often a very nascent science.
- 53:12There's still a lot of
- 53:14discoveries to be made about just knowing what species exist.
- 53:18We're still discovering new things all the time.
- 53:22So I've been doing a lot of work on that in my PhD,
- 53:28you know, sort of getting a global
- 53:30survey of all the species in this genus and then doing full genome sequencing to understand
- 53:37all the relationships.
- 53:38Because if you understand the relationships,
- 53:40you can
- 53:41make more educated inferences about shared chemistry, for example.
- 53:48So we've done that and I've completed that.
- 53:50And it turns out the most closely related species to Lanmao Asiatica is a mushroom growing here in the Northeast North America.
- 54:02And it's called Lanmao pallidogrosia.
- 54:05And it's commonly collected.
- 54:07And I've heard from many people who have eaten it,
- 54:09but there's been no reports of these sorts of hallucinations from it.
- 54:14So this raises an interesting question.
- 54:17Are these mushrooms like actually hallucinogenic, but people are just overcooking them from that perspective?
- 54:28Or does this hallucinogenic compound, whatever it is, only exist in this one species in Asia?
- 54:35That would be sort of unique from a perspective,
- 54:40you know, comparing to psilocybin or erbotinic acid.
- 54:43Those compounds are more widespread in many species.
- 54:48So it remains to be seen whether, you know,
- 54:52this hallucinogenic bolete is many,
- 54:57whatever, this hallucinogenic compound is shared between many species or just found in one.
- 55:04Wow.
- 55:05Yeah, it is a very curious question.
- 55:08The idea that it could be only this particular compound, or maybe it's an entourage effect of a series of compounds within the mushroom,
- 55:16that it would exist just in one species as well. I mean,
- 55:19even...
- 55:20You know,
- 55:20psilocybin,
- 55:21like the biosynthetic pathway that helps generate it has been,
- 55:26it's across multiple genuses, I believe through horizontal gene transfer. But I had also read a paper recently that said that some other species apparently just independently produced a different pathway to create the same gene.
- 55:38molecule and various psychoactive DMT, for example,
- 55:41is in almost everything. And then
- 55:43there's all these different examples of, uh, I believe caffeine as well as it is in different,
- 55:48different plants that produced it, you know,
- 55:51develop the pathways to, uh, synthesize it
- 55:54separately. And that such a uniquely interesting hallucinogenic effect could be
- 55:59localized to just one particular mushroom is itself an incredibly interesting scientific
- 56:05discovery.
- 56:05Yeah.
- 56:06Very cool.
- 56:07Yeah, so this actually gets to a very deep and interesting question.
- 56:11Why these molecules that have these psychoactive effects in us are so widespread in nature?
- 56:17And what does it mean if something like this psychoactive bully isn't?
- 56:22You know,
- 56:23our understanding of that is that these compounds are so widespread and have evolved multiple times because they have some ecological advantage or they provide some ecological advantage to the organism.
- 56:36Yeah.
- 56:40And so they're,
- 56:41through natural selection,
- 56:43they're highly valued from that perspective.
- 56:46If it didn't have an adaptive use,
- 56:50then it wouldn't be so widespread.
- 56:54So perhaps whatever is in this mushroom, if it is only found in this one species,
- 56:59it might be that it's not really serving an ecological function.
- 57:04This is more of a curious side effects it has in human nature.
- 57:09human brains.
- 57:10But yeah, if we look at most,
- 57:12I mean, every other mind-altering substance we find
- 57:16in plants or fungi,
- 57:18they have this effect in us, but they also have effects on animals or
- 57:24other organisms in the environment.
- 57:26And that is thought to be the reason why they evolved
- 57:29is for that function, whether that's defense or attraction or something else.
- 57:36But,
- 57:37yeah,
- 57:38like in the case of psilocybin,
- 57:40you're right.
- 57:40It's been horizontally transferred multiple times, but also independently evolved.
- 57:46So that suggests that it is serving some important use in the environment.
- 57:51Now, what that is, we still don't know in the case of psilocybin.
- 57:54But,
- 57:55yeah, it's a fascinating question,
- 57:56understanding the...
- 57:58why these things evolved,
- 58:00why they're so widespread.
- 58:02And I think it points to deep interrelationship
- 58:06between organisms and humans are just one
- 58:09of those organisms in nature.
- 58:12This also points to another question.
- 58:14You're talking about the different animals is that,
- 58:18as far as I understand,
- 58:19we have no clear evidence
- 58:21that psilocybin-containing mushrooms are eaten
- 58:24by any other mammal than humans.
- 58:27In the case of Amanita muscaria, we have examples of different animals eating it.
- 58:33Reindeer being a famous one. I don't know how true that is, or if it's just an invention of somebody looking for an excuse to pretend like Jesus was a, or sorry, it's not Jesus.
- 58:41That's a different claim. That's Santa Claus is a mushroom.
- 58:44But I know I've seen images of foxes eating Amanita muscaria.
- 58:48So,
- 58:50Do we have any reports of non-human animals consuming this,
- 58:57it's pronounced balit mushroom?
- 59:00Do we have any other evidence for that?
- 59:03Yeah, that's a really interesting question,
- 59:06getting into the sort of the ecological...
- 59:09role of this mushroom.
- 59:13Definitely no reports. I'm trying to think from all the collections I've made of this in Southeast Asia, if I've ever seen one with like damage,
- 59:21like teeth marks from something like a squircle or something. I don't think so.
- 59:25They seem to be usually intact.
- 59:29So,
- 59:30But I mean,
- 59:31who knows? I mean, there's not been much research or any research done on that question.
- 59:37So definitely something that warrants further study for sure.
- 59:42But yeah, then like other, other mushrooms you find in the environment are like...
- 59:49commonly damaged or almost completely eaten like porcini mushrooms like belitis edulis that's one
- 59:56that's like notoriously always damaged by by something either insects or animals so
- 1:00:02yeah it gets into an interesting question of why some mushrooms attract
- 1:00:08things eating them and others appear to ward them off.
- 1:00:13Yeah, and I guess maybe if we don't find any evidence of any animals eating these mushrooms at all,
- 1:00:19we could maybe start to hypothesize that whatever compounds are creating these hallucinations
- 1:00:26have already so effectively worked as a defense against being eaten that it's pretty much king of the hill in that respect.
- 1:00:34Yeah.
- 1:00:34this is great this has been super interesting um very curious stuff are you still following this uh
- 1:00:42this mushroom is this still your um area of research that you're you're forwarding and if so
- 1:00:49what what's next um with this research do do you or any teams you're involved with or teams that
- 1:00:55you know about have like next stage research to be done with this mushroom either on the
- 1:01:00uh,
- 1:01:02ethno biological or ethnocultural side of things or on the pharmacological
- 1:01:07side of things,
- 1:01:07or what's,
- 1:01:09what's progressing from here for you.
- 1:01:11And if it's not about that mushroom,
- 1:01:13what's progressing for you from here anyways.
- 1:01:16Right.
- 1:01:16Yeah, I'm still very involved in this research.
- 1:01:19It's really been the focus of my PhD and hopefully long after as well. It's such a fascinating area of exploration that I think we're just beginning to step into.
- 1:01:28As much as we've learned, I think there's still so much more to explore and it touches on so many different areas.
- 1:01:29Yeah.
- 1:01:34areas and fields of expertise.
- 1:01:37So,
- 1:01:38you know, I've really focused,
- 1:01:39I think, on the more
- 1:01:43ethnobiological side and sort of genetics and genomics,
- 1:01:47understanding the evolutionary
- 1:01:51context of this mushroom and how it evolves and sort of tracing the diversity and distribution of it,
- 1:01:58both
- 1:01:59across space,
- 1:02:00but also cultures.
- 1:02:02And that's something I want to continue for sure.
- 1:02:04I'm sure there's other species out there
- 1:02:07and they could give insight into how this compound,
- 1:02:10whatever it is, once we figure it out,
- 1:02:12how it evolved and how widespread it is.
- 1:02:15And also,
- 1:02:16I'm sure there's many more cultures out there
- 1:02:18that consume it and maybe even have some
- 1:02:22interesting knowledge or folklore about it that we've yet to document.
- 1:02:25I mean, the fact that we're in the 2020s and we're just now learning about this is crazy to me.
- 1:02:33And so there's still so much out there to learn.
- 1:02:36I think next steps are...
- 1:02:39you know, definitely focused on trying to understand what this active compound in the mushroom is.
- 1:02:46And we've been working on that for a few years.
- 1:02:48And there's other groups like in China also working on it.
- 1:02:51But we haven't gotten to it.
- 1:02:53It's been really challenging.
- 1:02:55We've narrowed down the bioactivity to...
- 1:03:01like a small candidate,
- 1:03:06small number of candidates,
- 1:03:07but to actually characterize them, we just need more material.
- 1:03:11So going back and collecting born mushrooms will be something of importance,
- 1:03:17but
- 1:03:18Yeah, I mean, we didn't really talk about that, but just testing these extracts in mice and noticing their behavioral changes has been really the method through which we've narrowed down on isolating bioactive compounds from the mushroom.
- 1:03:33Now, whether that bioactive compound is the same thing that's hallucinogenic in humans remains undone.
- 1:03:39We'll have to figure that out,
- 1:03:41but...
- 1:03:42I think once we can pinpoint an active chemical,
- 1:03:47if it is that simple, it might be more complex,
- 1:03:49like you mentioned synergistic effects or something,
- 1:03:52some metabolite or something like that.
- 1:03:55But if we could understand what the chemical is,
- 1:03:58then we can start looking at...
- 1:04:00at a lot of very interesting questions in neuroscience,
- 1:04:04pharmacology,
- 1:04:05looking at the genome,
- 1:04:07seeing how it's produced,
- 1:04:08and then finding traces of that genetic pathway across many other mushrooms.
- 1:04:13And there's just so many different disciplines that this touches on
- 1:04:17that are also beyond my expertise that I hope this awareness of this now,
- 1:04:22I think...
- 1:04:24very fascinating topic
- 1:04:26reaches more researchers
- 1:04:28and gets more attention
- 1:04:29than it deserves.
- 1:04:31And then the last thing
- 1:04:32I would just say is
- 1:04:34the historical cultural use
- 1:04:37is something I'm really interested in.
- 1:04:39How far back in time
- 1:04:40have people been
- 1:04:42using this or knowing about this phenomenon.
- 1:04:45You know,
- 1:04:46we,
- 1:04:47the first earliest missionaries
- 1:04:49in Papua New Guinea documented people
- 1:04:51eating this mushroom and having this mushroom madness.
- 1:04:54How many centuries or who knows how long
- 1:04:57were they doing that?
- 1:04:58In China,
- 1:04:59people have been collecting
- 1:05:00and eating this boli for decades,
- 1:05:04maybe centuries.
- 1:05:05How long have they known about these little people?
- 1:05:08Has there ever been something
- 1:05:10a traditional use or ritual use that's perhaps now been lost or is just yet to be discovered
- 1:05:17um there is one very old daoist text that i found from the third century and in it he writes that
- 1:05:26there's a flesh spirit mushroom that if you consume raw you'll see little people and gain transcendence
- 1:05:33Well, that sounds really intriguing. And maybe that is talking about the same thing.
- 1:05:38So there's a lot of fascinating questions about the how deeply embedded this is in human history and culture and how influential it's been. We really don't know.
- 1:05:49Wow,
- 1:05:50incredible.
- 1:05:52I wasn't planning on asking this question, but something that you just said brought it up.
- 1:05:55You're testing extracts or extracts are being tested on animals.
- 1:05:59That's how you're getting your short list or something.
- 1:06:02Is there a clear sense that whatever the compound or compounds might be are...
- 1:06:10that they survive a drying process
- 1:06:12or that they're more fat-soluble or water-soluble?
- 1:06:17Is that clearly identified or is that still a mystery?
- 1:06:22So the active fraction that we found in mice
- 1:06:26was a polar compound, so water-soluble.
- 1:06:30But there might be other bioactive compounds in there.
- 1:06:35I mean, I think it's a mistake to...
- 1:06:38conflate a mushroom which is an organism with thousands of molecules and try and
- 1:06:46reduce that down to a single compound I think there's a lot of complexity that we're missing
- 1:06:51in that approach but but yes the the one behavioral bioactivity that we've been following
- 1:06:58has been a polar compound and then
- 1:07:01What was the other part of that question?
- 1:07:04Whether or not whatever,
- 1:07:05like these effects,
- 1:07:07so whatever compounds are a part of that effect,
- 1:07:07yeah
- 1:07:08that these effects are present,
- 1:07:10that whatever might be causing them survives a drying process.
- 1:07:14Right.
- 1:07:15Right, so we do know that if you cut this mushroom long enough,
- 1:07:21it's safe and you won't have any of these effects.
- 1:07:25restaurants in China typically set a timer for 15 minutes.
- 1:07:29If you're like having a hot pot, for example,
- 1:07:30with this mushroom and they say,
- 1:07:32don't eat until this timer goes off, but you'll see little people.
- 1:07:35But if you eat after, if you cook it long enough at a high enough temperature,
- 1:07:39whatever a compound is will break down.
- 1:07:41So it is definitely heat sensitive.
- 1:07:43The mushrooms that I got and collected in China,
- 1:07:47I freeze-dried immediately, refreshed,
- 1:07:49and then I freeze-dried them to preserve the chemistry.
- 1:07:52And then I immediately made extracts from those.
- 1:07:55So yeah, they are heat-sensitive and will break down upon cooking,
- 1:08:01for sure.
- 1:08:03But beyond that, I don't think we know much about the...
- 1:08:08about the compound.
- 1:08:09Awesome.
- 1:08:10Okay.
- 1:08:10So that all said again,
- 1:08:13Colin,
- 1:08:14super interesting.
- 1:08:15Thank you so much for coming on to the show.
- 1:08:18I'm really looking forward to seeing how your work progresses from here and
- 1:08:22learning more about this mushroom,
- 1:08:24both through your work and,
- 1:08:25and through,
- 1:08:26you know,
- 1:08:26it hit,
- 1:08:27it hit some sort of,
- 1:08:30cultural hotspot to get so popular,
- 1:08:32you know, a couple, a couple months back on, on social media,
- 1:08:34maybe it's going to find its way into sort of a cultural movement somewhere down the line.
- 1:08:38And we'll get information from all sorts of different places,
- 1:08:41but nonetheless,
- 1:08:42very interesting stuff.
- 1:08:43Excellent work.
- 1:08:44Thank you so much for being on the show.
- 1:08:46If
- 1:08:47There's anywhere you'd like to direct the listeners to either follow your work or if you are part of a particular lab you'd like to direct them towards or any way that they can follow you,
- 1:08:58learn more about your stuff or support what you're doing.
- 1:09:02Right. So I am on Instagram at eating underscore Gaia.
- 1:09:06And I post some updates about my research there from time to time and just random mushroom photos.
- 1:09:12So if you're interested in mycology generally, you can follow me there.
- 1:09:16And yeah, check out the Dentinger Lab, the Natural History Museum of Utah, if you're interested in pursuing research.
- 1:09:23more research in this field.
- 1:09:25And yeah, like you said, I think this has definitely gained a lot of
- 1:09:28cultural attention, which is great to hear because when I first heard about it, I was
- 1:09:32perplexed why it wasn't more known and interested by the public.
- 1:09:36So hopefully this attracts more
- 1:09:39research and attention so we can learn more about this deeply fascinating phenomenon.
- 1:09:45okay I'll make sure links to those are in the description of this episode
- 1:09:50Colin Dumnour thank you so much for coming on to Adventures to the Mind
- 1:09:55absolutely James pleasure to be here and talk with you it was fun
- 1:09:59and cut
- 1:10:00Okay,
- 1:10:01that was my interview with Colin Domnauer here on Adventures Through the Mind, episode 208.
- 1:10:07I hope you appreciated what you heard.
- 1:10:08If you want to follow up with Colin's work,
- 1:10:11say read the article we discussed or any of the other things that he mentioned there at the end, links to those will be in the description to this episode wherever you're checking it out.
- 1:10:20As you heard in the middle there, support for this podcast comes from you, the listener,
- 1:10:24via Patreon and voluntary donations through PayPal or Ko-Fi.
- 1:10:29Financially,
- 1:10:29this is an absolutely essential part of maintaining this podcast because although there are periodic sponsors,
- 1:10:35this show does not rely on sponsorships to produce something for you to enjoy.
- 1:10:41if financially supporting the show is not available to you to do so financially,
- 1:10:46I should say,
- 1:10:47then there's always the option of leaving a comment or a like or a positive review.
- 1:10:52Any kind of engagement does help the algorithm know that people care about this show
- 1:10:57and helps people who don't yet know that they could care about the show
- 1:11:01find the show helps it gets to their eyes and ears so please engage the content in that way
- 1:11:06also genuinely if you got something to say about it i'd love to hear it i do pay attention to the
- 1:11:10comments and i do reply to most of them so hit me up there on spotify or elsewhere and leave me a
- 1:11:16positive review would love that
- 1:11:17You could also subscribe to the show on whatever podcatcher you prefer so that you are aware when new episodes come out.
- 1:11:25Please do that.
- 1:11:26Most people who listen aren't subscribers,
- 1:11:28so you can be one of the lucky few that are subscribers and listen to the show,
- 1:11:33not just one or the other.
- 1:11:35If you want to follow me,
- 1:11:36release short clips from this episode or these episodes on Instagram,
- 1:11:41A-T-T-M-I-N-D podcast,
- 1:11:43atmindpodcast on Instagram.
- 1:11:45And I'm on the other social medias.
- 1:11:48Ultimately,
- 1:11:48I think social media is sort of toxic.
- 1:11:50Surprise,
- 1:11:51surprise.
- 1:11:52I'm sure I'm not breaking the intellectual bank for you there to say that.
- 1:11:56So I'm not on there too often.
- 1:11:58I prefer to release things through an email newsletter,
- 1:12:02which you can sign up for through telegram,
- 1:12:04basically things that don't rely on algorithms
- 1:12:07and sort of attention baiting to,
- 1:12:10to, to get you to see them.
- 1:12:11Those are also listed in the
- 1:12:12description,
- 1:12:13but follow me whatever way you're naturally inclined.
- 1:12:16And I appreciate that you
- 1:12:18listened to this episode all the way to the end.
- 1:12:20And I mean that genuinely,
- 1:12:21because I'm
- 1:12:22It is no guarantee in the world,
- 1:12:25in the constant deluge of content,
- 1:12:29and only a fraction of that being worth your time, and an even shorter fraction of that being able to hold your attention for the entire duration of anything longer than apparently at this point, three minutes.
- 1:12:42wow,
- 1:12:42if you made it all the way to the end here, it is truly an honor to have had your attention
- 1:12:46for that long. So thank you very much.
- 1:12:48And until the next episode,
- 1:12:50I've been your host,
- 1:12:50James Chesso.
- 1:12:51Take care and stay curious.
- 1:12:51Uh...