Latest / The Vegan Report / Addressing Misconduct in the Animal Rights Movement. With Dr. Crystal Heath | Ep. 113
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report, my name is Ryan
- 0:02and in today's episode a conversation with the
- 0:06amazing Dr. Crystal Heath. You know Dr. Heath,
- 0:10she appeared a couple of times on the show. She
- 0:13is this brave veterinarian working hard to reform
- 0:17her profession and its institutions. But today
- 0:21we talk about something that has been impeding
- 0:24her advocacy work, we discussed bullying, personality
- 0:28cult manipulations, lies, toxic culture, fear
- 0:32-mongering, and more predatory, ugly behaviors
- 0:36she has encountered in some corners of the animal
- 0:39rights movement. The types of behavior that are
- 0:44endemic to every organization on earth from the
- 0:48Catholic Church to your local school board meetings.
- 0:51So it's no surprise that some parts of the animal
- 0:55rights movement suffer from them too. It would
- 0:58have been incredible if we were the sole exception
- 1:02to that scourge in all of human history. But
- 1:06we're not. In fact, next week, I will be releasing
- 1:09my interview with Gail Eisnitz, the first slaughterhouse
- 1:14investigator in the history of this movement.
- 1:17And in her new book, Out of Sight, she describes
- 1:21her experience with one toxic leader of the animal
- 1:24rights movement. And that happened back in the
- 1:291990s. The guy ended up in jail for life. It's
- 1:33a wild story. And all of this is very messy and
- 1:38uncomfortable to talk about. But as of now, there
- 1:42have been countless studies, books, movies, podcasts
- 1:45and articles written on this issue. We know a
- 1:49lot about it, including that it does not go away
- 1:54if we just ignore it. In fact, when we contribute
- 1:58to a culture of silence and tolerate these behaviors,
- 2:03we normalize them. and they multiply. I don't
- 2:07know whose role it is to make this movement safer
- 2:11for its activists, particularly the young girls
- 2:14that join it. Maybe we all have a small role
- 2:18to play. I know my role as a podcaster and journalist,
- 2:24amateur journalist, I give you that, is to report
- 2:27on this and inform you of this issue. You will
- 2:34find in the episode notes links to connect with
- 2:37Dr. Heat and discover her amazing work. If you
- 2:41are experiencing distress, you will also find
- 2:44a link to your local helpline. As always, share
- 2:49the episode with the vegans you know. Follow
- 2:52the show and don't miss next week's episode with
- 2:55Kale. Leave a good review. Thank you. How are
- 3:03you? I'm doing good. Happy to see you too. Happy
- 3:07to be here. Thanks for having me back. Wonderful.
- 3:10So we were talking about meeting and recording
- 3:13this episode on a very sensitive subject and
- 3:17on The lead up to recording this, I was thinking
- 3:21a lot about my experience of witnessing harassment
- 3:26on the workplace perpetrated against women. And
- 3:29I'll just tell the little story. My first summer
- 3:33job was basically surveilling a cycling road.
- 3:3712 kilometers long during an entire summer. And
- 3:41I had two coworkers who were women and they were
- 3:44girls. I was a boy. We were kids doing that job.
- 3:47And during that summer, I witnessed so many creeps,
- 3:52just being so indecent with my two colleagues
- 3:56and them. telling me about stories of what happened
- 4:01to them when I wasn't around was so shocking.
- 4:04It came from the users of that road, which you
- 4:08would not imagine that person was capable of
- 4:11taking their cell phone and taking pictures of
- 4:14a girl on a bicycle from weird angles. And yet
- 4:17here we have it. That experience opened my eyes
- 4:21on the different realities of man versus woman,
- 4:26particularly in the workplace. That's my perspective.
- 4:30That's my background on that. When I started
- 4:33working in the nonprofit world and the animal
- 4:35rights space, I had the expectation that I would
- 4:38be working with angels. Like, that's been generally
- 4:45the rule, but there have been a few notable exceptions
- 4:49to that rule. So on that note, I will let you
- 4:53tell your story. Yeah. First of all, I will say
- 4:56for legal reasons, the content provided is entertainment
- 5:00commentary and for informational purposes only.
- 5:04It does not constitute any legal, medical or
- 5:07professional advice and all views expressed are
- 5:10opinions. Well, based in part on publicly available
- 5:13information, no representations are made as to
- 5:17completeness or accuracy. Any resemblance to
- 5:20actual persons or events is purely coincidental,
- 5:24unless explicitly stated, it is not intended
- 5:27to assert definitive claims about any individual
- 5:31or organizations and viewers should conduct their
- 5:34own independent verification. But yes, in short,
- 5:39my story is I volunteered for one organization,
- 5:43thousands of hours. Right now, I am 44 years
- 5:46old. I was 37. when I started getting involved
- 5:51in this organization. And I too was very naive.
- 5:54I'm like, oh my gosh, I finally found my people
- 5:57and this is wonderful. They're doing such great
- 6:00and important work. And there were all of these
- 6:03allegations that came forward from one woman
- 6:06who was a teenager at the time when this leader
- 6:09who was at the time 10 years older than her,
- 6:12romantically pursued her, wrote a note to her
- 6:17mother. And this all was happening during a particular
- 6:21campaign. This came up and I was part of the
- 6:23team figuring out how to respond to this. I played
- 6:27a role of basically character assassinating a
- 6:31woman who spoke her truth and made this video
- 6:36explaining what happened to her because she wasn't
- 6:39vegan anymore, so she must be like paid off by
- 6:43the industry. And these allegations kept coming
- 6:47up. And I saw this person who was in a position
- 6:51of leadership had dated much younger activists.
- 6:55When I got involved, I was in a relationship
- 6:58with somebody for several years. And he came
- 7:00to one of the meetings and was like, this is
- 7:04really weird. And he wasn't vegan at the time.
- 7:07And so I'm like, no, it's hard to find vegans
- 7:10and they're all working together. So they get
- 7:14into romantic involvements with each other. I
- 7:17don't know. It makes sense. So this guy who was
- 7:20in a position of leadership had dated a couple
- 7:22of the much younger activists who were very,
- 7:26very young. But I'm like, oh, these things happen.
- 7:30dismiss him, who then became my ex -boyfriend.
- 7:33He actually did end up going vegan, so good for
- 7:36him, but broke up with him. I realized I love
- 7:40being single and not... being in a romantic entanglements
- 7:44with anybody. And so I was enjoying my life being
- 7:47single and helping animals. I'm a veterinarian,
- 7:51obviously, and I do a lot of activism started
- 7:53in my own organization to help support and empower
- 7:57veterinarians and veterinary students working
- 7:59to support animal advocacy campaigns. This guy
- 8:03who was in a position of leadership, his girlfriend
- 8:05who was significantly younger at the time, ended
- 8:08up breaking up with him. And he was very sad
- 8:11about it. And I'm like, yeah, that's tough. It
- 8:13happens. Then he started dating another young
- 8:16activist who looked very similar to her. So I'm
- 8:19like, OK, well, whatever. These things happen.
- 8:21And that lasted a couple of weeks and nothing
- 8:24came of it. And then he started romantically
- 8:26pursuing me. And I'm like, wait a minute, dude.
- 8:29First of all, like you've dated all these young
- 8:32people. And he's also telling me how he wants
- 8:34children and you married. And I'm like, I don't
- 8:36want any of that. I'm sterilized, I don't want
- 8:39children, but he started really pursuing me as
- 8:43it almost made me feel like I was the love of
- 8:46his life and finally he's done with dating younger
- 8:50women and maybe doesn't even want children and
- 8:53I'm showing him how fun life can be without having
- 8:57to worry about all of that. But he's also like,
- 9:00I don't know, I'm pursuing this person, this
- 9:03person potentially wants to have children with
- 9:05me. And I'm like, then go after them. But he's
- 9:08like, I want a relationship with you. This was
- 9:11during COVID too. I don't want to dismiss somebody
- 9:15who thinks that they found the love of their
- 9:17life. I'm willing to give it a try. I'm open
- 9:19minded. Looking back, I'm like, I have no boundaries.
- 9:24I allowed this to happen to myself. We did end
- 9:26up dating and quickly a bunch of red flags came
- 9:30up. He was talking to other women. I'm like,
- 9:32oh, this is not what I signed up for. But I work,
- 9:36I do all these things. I'd have little concerns,
- 9:40but whatever. And even going into this relationship,
- 9:43I was like, this will last a year. And telling
- 9:47you upfront, we can have this relationship for
- 9:49a year, but you want children. So after that,
- 9:52we'll break up and you can go find your wife
- 9:54and no hard feelings, whatever. And 10 months
- 9:57in, I decided to cut it off. I'm like, we don't
- 10:00have a romantic, emotional connection. I felt
- 10:03that from day one. He's doing important animal
- 10:06rights work. I like talking to people who do
- 10:09animal rights, but we don't really have chemistry
- 10:12or anything like that. And I can have a good
- 10:16time with pretty much anybody. But I felt that
- 10:19there were a lot of things he was being dishonest
- 10:21with me about, about who he was talking to. He
- 10:25was love bombing various people. I got a lot
- 10:28of gross feelings. And he was constantly talking
- 10:31to his ex -girlfriend. And he was claiming that,
- 10:35oh, he has no romantic feelings for her. But
- 10:38I'm like, you're spending more time talking to
- 10:40her. Taking care of her emotional needs than
- 10:44mine. So I don't Feel great about this broke
- 10:47up with him. It was a little it was emotional
- 10:49because it's always like emotional to end a relationship
- 10:52But it was a relief and I'm like we can continue
- 10:57doing activism together and no hard feelings
- 11:01Go on but then I He basically started romantically
- 11:08pursuing all of my friends and friends who were
- 11:12much younger than him who lived across the country
- 11:17and I had a heart -to -heart with him. I heard
- 11:20you were zoom chatting this person. She doesn't
- 11:23want kids and she's younger and she lives across
- 11:26the country. What are you doing? We argued about
- 11:28it a little bit, let it go. Then I hear another
- 11:30story of another young activist he was romantically
- 11:33pursuing and how she ended up filing a report
- 11:36against him. talk to him about that, then he
- 11:41was more aggressive and he's like, she wasn't
- 11:43who I thought she was. And I'm like, whoa, dude,
- 11:48you're all about assuming good faith and you're
- 11:52not really doing that here. Like maybe her feelings
- 11:55are valid and she felt like you were taking advantage
- 11:58of a situation. After I broke up with him, I
- 12:02started feeling like a chilling effect from the
- 12:04rest of the people in that area in the animal
- 12:07rights community, people not talking with me
- 12:09as much, not including me in various conversations
- 12:15and activism and all of this stuff. Other examples
- 12:18of when this happens, like Cesar Chavez. Now
- 12:22we're all aware of Cesar Chavez and the United
- 12:25Farm Workers and how he was romantically pursuing
- 12:29activists. Some were underage and getting people
- 12:34pregnant. And there's lots of different things
- 12:37about the United Farm Workers, these marriages
- 12:39that were formed, romantic pairings. And that's
- 12:45something that I saw with this activist group
- 12:46too. There was a lot of like, people trying to
- 12:52bring certain people together for romantic pairings,
- 12:56people marrying people from other countries to
- 12:59bring them over here. I dismissed it at the time.
- 13:02I'm like, oh, well, this is great. We're bringing
- 13:04together all the people who are passionate about.
- 13:07animal rights, not realizing the harms of this.
- 13:11Now people are brought over and they're stuck
- 13:13and when they see concerns or they become uncomfortable
- 13:16with the way things are run, their housing is
- 13:19dependent on this group, their income, it's hard
- 13:22for them to get a job, if their romantic relationship
- 13:25breaks up that harms their ability to stay here
- 13:28and then they have no community if they do speak
- 13:32out. People are brought from other areas to an
- 13:35area where all their friends and community are
- 13:38dependent on this activist group. And I saw that
- 13:41as a problem. The one reason I'm able to speak
- 13:46out about this is because I'm older, financially
- 13:49independent, had my own job and community. After
- 13:54all of this blew up, there ended up being a group
- 13:57chat. people started voicing concerns about this
- 14:01guy and what he was doing. Another woman who
- 14:03was in another country ended up calling the cops
- 14:07on an action. And somebody in that group chat
- 14:10ended up screenshotting that group chat and leaking
- 14:13it to the organization's leadership. And everybody
- 14:17in that group chat was character assassinated,
- 14:20ostracized, even though only one person took
- 14:23the action to call the cops. And this is something
- 14:27that this group and their leader does. They call
- 14:32the cops on their actions in order to get the
- 14:35cops there. There are various reasons to do this,
- 14:38showing that you're being extra transparent about
- 14:41what you're doing, but it also is a better photo
- 14:45op for the press. It gets more press attention
- 14:47when the police show up. So this person who ended
- 14:51up calling cops on action didn't see it as something
- 14:54that was necessarily harming the activists, but
- 14:57was doing it as a way to stop him from getting
- 15:02more publicity, but she didn't really understand
- 15:04what was going on. And the police state that
- 15:08exists in this country and how dangerous that
- 15:10can be. And she's also seen it done before. This
- 15:13blew up to him doing a live stream character
- 15:17assassinating me and saying, I am the reason
- 15:20that this woman called the cops. on this action
- 15:24was because of the lies that I was spreading
- 15:26about this person. This woman who did call the
- 15:29cops, she had her own issues with this group.
- 15:32She was romantically pursued by two men in leadership,
- 15:35both who were trying to marry her to get her
- 15:39to move to the city. And she didn't want to do
- 15:42that. And she found once she did not agree to
- 15:46do that, they kind of cut off communications
- 15:49and she felt used and she felt like she was potentially
- 15:53going to be trafficked to this country. I heard
- 15:56talking to other activists who were former organizers.
- 15:59They were all discussing, oh my gosh, what's
- 16:01this guy up to now? What is he doing? And this
- 16:04led to that. And then it was a great opportunity.
- 16:08for the animal rights movement to come together
- 16:11to defend this poor male leader who's being wrongfully
- 16:16accused of misconduct and smear and retaliate
- 16:19against all of the women who are voicing concerns
- 16:23about his behavior, which is something we love
- 16:26to attack women. We love to assume that all women
- 16:30who voice concerns about men are doing it because
- 16:34they're jealous, resentful, infiltrators, when
- 16:39statistically that's not the case. It's so very
- 16:42rare that men are accused of misconduct because
- 16:44The fact is when women do voice concerns, they
- 16:49suffer greatly, which is why so few women do.
- 16:53We know that the second we say anything, we're
- 16:56going to be attacked. We're going to have our
- 16:58motives questions. You were in a relationship
- 17:00with him, if he's so bad, and then you were friends
- 17:02with him after you broke up and you were friends
- 17:05with him all along. All of the women who were
- 17:09voicing concerns about him, he would say, even
- 17:12after That letter that I sent to her parents,
- 17:15she declined my advances. We were still friends,
- 17:19so I don't see what the problem is. She still
- 17:21wanted to be friends with me. She was still hanging
- 17:23all over me. And that's one of the things that
- 17:25he did when he was pursuing me was like, you
- 17:28can talk to any of my ex -girlfriends about me
- 17:32and they'll tell you all about me. I think he's
- 17:34hoping that I wouldn't call him on his bluff
- 17:36and I didn't because that's awkward. I'm not
- 17:38going to call your ex -girlfriends. But I talked
- 17:40to another woman who he pursued and she's like,
- 17:45oh yeah, he did the same thing to me. He was
- 17:46like, yeah, you can call my ex -girlfriends and
- 17:49talk to them about me. And she's like, of course
- 17:52I didn't do it, but that's how they operate.
- 17:54And we talk about harassment and abuse and we
- 17:58accept if it's physically forceful, then. Oh,
- 18:03okay. Yeah, for sure. He was wrong if he like
- 18:05physically forced you. But what about manipulating
- 18:08you love bombing, lying to you about his feelings
- 18:12for you and his relationships with other people?
- 18:17Shouldn't that be considered equally as bad?
- 18:21I'd love your thoughts on everything that I've
- 18:26said so far. I guess my first reaction to that
- 18:29is what about the MeToo movement? I remember
- 18:33when MeToo was happening, I was an activist for
- 18:37Oxfam, which is an international cooperation
- 18:39organization. There had been a whole awakening
- 18:43with humanitarian organizations about how the
- 18:47funds were used. We discovered, for instance,
- 18:50that some of Oxfam's employees were using the
- 18:54funds that were supposed to finance international
- 18:58cooperation missions to pay for sex parties and
- 19:03drugs and things of the sort. And that made the
- 19:07news. Then I found myself as an activist in the
- 19:10streets, making people sign petition, being asked
- 19:13about Oxfam scandals, like sexual scandals. And
- 19:18so they had a meeting with us talking about what
- 19:21is the best response to that. You know, at the
- 19:25very least, there was this awareness now of how
- 19:30prevalent this problem was and how it was touching
- 19:34not just Hollywood, but also the world of international
- 19:39cooperation, like the nonprofits of this world.
- 19:43But I guess there was no me too reform with the
- 19:46animal rights movement. There was like a little
- 19:49me to flare up that happened and this group seemed
- 19:53to take it very seriously. And these men who
- 19:57were accused were kicked out of the group. And
- 20:00this one guy, the leader makes a big show of
- 20:05how he defended women who were accusing this
- 20:08one male leader of misconduct. So I believed
- 20:12all that. It's almost like The veterinary profession,
- 20:16how we say, oh, yeah, there used to be welfare
- 20:18problems in the past, but now we take it very
- 20:21seriously. Meanwhile, we have ventilation shut
- 20:23down and pig slaughterhouse gas chambers and
- 20:25gestation crates and all things that are relatively
- 20:28new, horrifying things that the veterinary profession
- 20:30condones in animals because it's necessary. We
- 20:34don't like to do it, but this is the realities
- 20:36of things. how this guy has gotten so powerful
- 20:40that now he has like this team of minions. If
- 20:43there's ever like a Reddit post, there was a
- 20:46extensively reported legally fact -checked article
- 20:51about this and the misconduct. whenever anybody
- 20:57shares that on social media, instantly all of
- 21:01the minions flock to report it, to hide it on
- 21:05Reddit, any comments that are supportive of a
- 21:10post about the misconduct instantly get downvoted
- 21:13by throngs of minions. That's how these things
- 21:17work in all of these. organizations. I don't
- 21:20know if you've heard of Tim Ballard. He is the
- 21:23founder of Operation Underground Railroad, which
- 21:26was an organization that tried to save children
- 21:30from trafficking. And there's this movie about
- 21:33it called Sound of Freedom that came out. And
- 21:35he was a devout member of the LDS Church. My
- 21:38family is Mormon, so I can talk smack about the
- 21:41LDS Church a little bit. Multiple employees accused
- 21:45him of sexual misconduct, said that He was drinking,
- 21:48doing drugs and he would have these women play
- 21:52his partner and they would go to these seedy
- 21:55places and he would drink and do drugs in order
- 21:59to, he said, to endear himself to the child traffickers.
- 22:03And these were like all these undercover missions,
- 22:06but it was all an excuse for him to do all of
- 22:09this stuff under the guise of he's trying to
- 22:11save children. And when these women came forward
- 22:14to voice concerns about him, they were smeared
- 22:18and character assassinated. Oh, you're part of
- 22:21the liberal cause that wants to protect child
- 22:25traffickers. And this is the same thing with
- 22:28the animal rights movement. We don't believe
- 22:29that one of our leaders. could possibly be somebody
- 22:34who's nefarious in any way. I've seen so much
- 22:39and I've seen the manipulation. We are a group
- 22:41of highly empathetic people and really narcissistic
- 22:46men see us as sitting ducks to come in, become
- 22:51some kind of thought leader, raise money. Yeah,
- 22:55they're doing good work saving animals. And then
- 22:59anything you do against them, it's like, oh,
- 23:01you're preventing them from saving animals. How
- 23:04dare you? And the second you help them, I still
- 23:08have people from that group reaching out to me
- 23:10asking for veterinarians for their animals to
- 23:15go to who are rescued. If I say I'm not helping
- 23:20you, well, then they can easily smear me as she's
- 23:22not helping the animals like she's must be a
- 23:25bad person. And the second I do help them, it's
- 23:28like, see, she doesn't think we're that bad.
- 23:30She's helping us. You're put in this impossible
- 23:33situation where no matter what you do, they can
- 23:37use your actions against you. And that's exactly
- 23:39what they have done to me in a lot of different
- 23:43ways. They put activists in situations where
- 23:46no matter what they do, their actions can be
- 23:49used against them. I watched as people were smearing
- 23:52and character assassinating fellow activists.
- 23:55I made the mistake of screenshotting that and
- 23:59sending it to the people who they were talking
- 24:01about. They ended up sharing that screenshot
- 24:03online. And then, of course, I was attacked for
- 24:06how dare I break security culture that way. This
- 24:10organization has a no gossiping policy. You're
- 24:13gossiping in this chat. I'm protecting them by
- 24:18saying, look at what they're going to pursue
- 24:20legal action against you. You better be careful.
- 24:23you got to stop doing what you're doing. And
- 24:26I was attacked for sharing that information.
- 24:29Like they're allowed to share all the information
- 24:31about me. They're gossiping behind the scenes
- 24:33about me and what I'm doing. But the second I
- 24:38share information with other activists, this
- 24:40was another way I was attacked. He said, you
- 24:42can talk to all my ex girlfriends about me. But
- 24:45the second that after all this blew up and after
- 24:47I saw all the red flags and after I broke up
- 24:49with him, I did start Asking other activists
- 24:53in the community, have you been romantically
- 24:55pursued by any men in this group? Not even mentioning
- 25:00his name. And then when they'd ask me, like,
- 25:02who are you talking about? And I'm like, don't
- 25:04say anything but this guy. Then they would report
- 25:08back to him. Hey, did you know Crystal's going
- 25:10around asking women if they've... had any interactions
- 25:14with you and stuff. And then that got framed
- 25:17as crystals stalking him and obsessed with him.
- 25:21That's how these narratives get spun. And I thought,
- 25:25I'm the older woman of this group, this bunch
- 25:27of 20 year olds, I've got to protect them. Then
- 25:30I was attacked as somebody who's obsessed, a
- 25:33stalker, all of these things. It's so hard to
- 25:38address this misconduct when somebody is viewed
- 25:44by everybody as such a hero. And I've done a
- 25:48lot of good work for the animals. I've been attacked
- 25:50by the veterinary profession. And I have somewhat
- 25:54of a platform, but you shouldn't have to be famous
- 25:58in order to be believed. And that's where it
- 26:02stands right now. And I feel to this day, I'm
- 26:04not famous enough to be believed. And that's
- 26:08wrong. we should believe everybody. But another
- 26:11activist had her defense funding pulled. She
- 26:13was a co -defendant of this guy and their defense
- 26:16funding was pulled and she was smeared as somebody.
- 26:19I heard so many lies from people close to this
- 26:22guy that, oh, that co -defendant who had her
- 26:25defense funding pulled, she spoke to prosecutors.
- 26:28She was paid off. She was paid by the industry
- 26:33and she spoke to prosecutors because she was
- 26:36afraid. And she never did any such thing and
- 26:39she never got any money from the industry. The
- 26:42amount of mistruths that are out there about
- 26:46the people who voice concerns is just shocking
- 26:49and really disturbing. I don't know how we'll
- 26:51ever get the truth out because this podcast will
- 26:54air and he'll start a whole new spin campaign.
- 26:59to assassinate me, but I've already been denied
- 27:02funding from donors. I've been denied speaking
- 27:05engagements, so I've got nothing to lose. They're
- 27:09going to frame me as trying to make a name for
- 27:11myself off of this guy, which is why I will not
- 27:14mention his name, because I don't want it framed
- 27:17that way. person loves to be attacked because
- 27:22they love to play the martyr and they're very,
- 27:24very good at it. So they will continue any allegations
- 27:28of misconduct. Oh, that's the industry or it's
- 27:30a jealous, resentful activist. They're not getting
- 27:33as much attention as we are. So now they're trying
- 27:35to make a name for themselves by attacking us.
- 27:37How dare that's how it goes. I feel like there's
- 27:41no adults in the room and the animal rights movement.
- 27:43There's no HR. I wrote 50 pages of documentation
- 27:48of everything that this guy did. We had an internal
- 27:51reports team, sent it to the reports team, and
- 27:56months and months and months go by while the
- 27:59assassinations continue. Like everything continues
- 28:03to escalate while the reports team is trying
- 28:05to figure out what to do. They send their determination
- 28:09to the leadership and the leadership is like
- 28:12no we're not going to listen to you. The guy
- 28:14ended up stepping down which he said he already
- 28:17left leadership in 2019 but he apparently is
- 28:20like leaving again and the entire reports team
- 28:24ended up quitting and the group frames it as
- 28:27like well we're a volunteer organization and
- 28:29people come and go all the time it's had nothing
- 28:31to do with that. Meanwhile, the reports team
- 28:34told me they were afraid this man was going to
- 28:37sue them for holding him accountable for his
- 28:40actions, because that's what he does. So that's
- 28:43why you won't hear anything about this guy. You
- 28:46mentioned how this movement attracts many young
- 28:49people, mostly women, young girls. I've had young
- 28:54girls message me and their age being like, I
- 28:56want to be a guest on your show. And it's a no,
- 29:00you're, you're under age gain some experience
- 29:02as an activist then come back. But I have no
- 29:05interest for that. I guess my question is why
- 29:09is it so important to talk about this? I keep
- 29:12thinking what could somebody told me about this
- 29:16group and this person that would have resonated
- 29:21with me and rang true. And it was always the
- 29:24people who were voicing concerns seemed very
- 29:28angry and hostile. They weren't activists anymore,
- 29:32which now I understand why they aren't activists
- 29:35anymore. And I've seen now so many other people
- 29:38end up leaving the movement because of this,
- 29:42because it's like, oh my God, everybody's sharing
- 29:44his stuff. It's triggering to keep seeing people
- 29:49sharing that stuff and not sharing my work. So
- 29:52I understand why people leave. But I've also
- 29:55gone through this. I'm older. I've gone through
- 29:57this with the veterinary profession. It's the
- 30:00same dynamics that play with the veterinary profession.
- 30:03I am character assassinated by the veterinary
- 30:05profession as an animal rights extremist. But
- 30:09I do have little victories when I talk to people
- 30:12one on one. And I explain things to them and
- 30:15I'm very persistent and I show them the facts.
- 30:18They turn around and they believe me and they
- 30:20go, OK, I see what's happening here. And that's
- 30:23the same thing with the animal rights people.
- 30:25I talk to people one on one. I inform them about
- 30:29these are the dynamics that lead to this hero
- 30:33worship, this mentality that we have to protect
- 30:37certain people above other people above. quote
- 30:42unquote, lower level activists, because this
- 30:45person is doing more important work and we need
- 30:48to protect him. If we're not protecting the activists
- 30:50who are actually doing the work, he's the figurehead,
- 30:54but the people who are taking action, doing the
- 30:57work, risking their freedom, they need to be
- 31:00protected. They can't have their defense funding
- 31:02pulled. They can't be ostracized from their community.
- 31:05We lose so many more people that way. The most
- 31:08dangerous thing that I saw is we lose a diversity
- 31:12of opinion and perspectives. That's the thing
- 31:15that was so concerning. I was the only one I
- 31:17felt like who pushed back against this person's
- 31:20ideas. And I was still relatively new to the
- 31:22movement. So I hadn't developed my own voice
- 31:24and opinions on a lot of things yet. I was still
- 31:27researching. I was still figuring things out.
- 31:29And so I didn't have the skills to push back.
- 31:32I'm still getting better at it. So I couldn't
- 31:35really give voice to my perspectives, but I tried.
- 31:38But it was viewed as, oh, she's hostile towards
- 31:41me, especially after I broke up with him. Oh,
- 31:44you're saying that only because you're hostile
- 31:46towards me. He would say this about his former
- 31:49girlfriend when we were in a relationship. He
- 31:51would say, she's only pushing back against my
- 31:54idea because she wants to prove that she's doesn't
- 31:58have to listen to me. And I'm like, you're all
- 32:01about assuming good faith. Remember, you're not
- 32:03exactly assuming good faith here. But yeah, he
- 32:06would frame. anything that I did as hostile to
- 32:09the point of I wrote a press release for one
- 32:12of the things and posted it in the chat. And
- 32:15I guess behind the scenes, he was like, I don't
- 32:19want Crystal to work on any of my press anymore.
- 32:22But nobody really told me. So I'm just like going
- 32:24along, doing my work like as normal. And then
- 32:27I post it in the chat and I get crickets. And
- 32:30then a few days later, I bump it and say, nice
- 32:32talk as a joke. When you say something and nobody
- 32:36responds and you say okay nice talk guys He was
- 32:39like he used that as evidence that I was hostile
- 32:42towards him. That's just how he could frame anything
- 32:46as Whatever he wants and people go okay, and
- 32:49that's what he surrounds himself with his sicko
- 32:52fans similar to Cesar Chavez he was affiliated
- 32:56with synon on and they had these sessions where
- 33:00a small group of people would come together and
- 33:04criticize one person and they just had to take
- 33:06it in order to show their loyalty. And if you
- 33:11push back, you're viewed as not accepting criticism
- 33:14or not accepting feedback. They did the same
- 33:17thing. And I saw there'd be these flare ups and
- 33:20a bunch of people would leave. But then the people
- 33:22who would apologize and say, oh, I was wrong
- 33:26for going against you. They would get elevated
- 33:29and pushed up and all of the people who were
- 33:34like no actually we disagree with your stance
- 33:38on this they were kicked out and it became a
- 33:41more and more insular group of sycophants that
- 33:45and there's no questioning of the thought process
- 33:50there's no pressure testing of the ideas. It's
- 33:54just like, oh, let's go for it. I could see how
- 33:56that can be actually very effective when you
- 33:58have a group of people who are unquestioning.
- 34:00I see no downside with doing some very bold action
- 34:04and you get a lot of people to do it. It ends
- 34:06up working out if you have a ton of people doing
- 34:08it, but then somebody might be facing trial and
- 34:12then they might be convicted. of things because
- 34:15your ideas and your arguments weren't pressure
- 34:18tested until the courtroom, which is a problem.
- 34:21They came back to me, asked me to testify in
- 34:24one trial, and I was like, I am shocked. You
- 34:27would ask me if I am such a liar and all of these
- 34:31things are being said about me. When people share
- 34:33my work on social media, they get messaged. Your
- 34:37activists say negative things about me, which
- 34:41has made people not want to share my work. just
- 34:43because they don't want to cause drama. So they
- 34:46just decide not to share my work. And so it's
- 34:48hard for me to get a platform because of all
- 34:51of this. So this attorney comes to me and is
- 34:53like, we want you to testify. And of course,
- 34:56like you don't have to if you don't want to.
- 34:58And I'm like, well, I just expect an apology
- 35:01if I'm going to testify. And I want assurance
- 35:03that my activism will no longer be harmed because
- 35:07of all of this. And they're like, well, we'll
- 35:09get back to you. And they're like, we don't actually
- 35:11need you to testify. I'm like, OK, fine. It's
- 35:13probably best if I don't. And then it was, oh,
- 35:16we do actually need you to testify because of
- 35:19blank blank. But the reasons weren't valid. I
- 35:22wasn't actually involved in the thing that they
- 35:26thought I was involved in, so I ended up not
- 35:29testifying. But in another instance, a group
- 35:34wanted to have me speak at a university. And
- 35:39the people in charge of that university were
- 35:42affiliated with this group. And so when I was
- 35:47asked to speak, they sort of Denied they gave
- 35:52excuses and finally somebody reaches out and
- 35:55is to them and is like I understand you don't
- 35:58want to have crystal speak because of this and
- 36:04The head of that institution said They kind of
- 36:12went back and forth. He said she demanded an
- 36:15apology and like as an I Was causing drama just
- 36:21by demanding an apology, you know before I would
- 36:24testify but then he's like, oh she can speak
- 36:27but letting a third party know about a private
- 36:31conversation that I had with an attorney that's
- 36:33not very cool and using that against me framing
- 36:37me in a certain way as somebody who is Causing
- 36:40drama because I wanted an apology. I mentioned
- 36:43earlier the age thing because I can't stop thinking
- 36:47about younger people being exposed to this. We
- 36:52have had a few years to discover what life is
- 36:55about. And by that, I mean, we have suffered
- 36:57from many things and we have acquired a few life
- 37:02lessons and we are conscious of what humanity
- 37:07looks like at its worst. And so we're prepared
- 37:11for that. kind of situation. But vulnerable people
- 37:15like children, teenagers, they're not prepared
- 37:18for that. They'll be eaten alive. That's the
- 37:21reality of it. And I feel that that's why this
- 37:24person is attracted. They don't know how to push
- 37:28back. They don't know how to question and they
- 37:31just like vet school like The vet students who
- 37:34enter vet school trust their professors and respect
- 37:36them and admire them and hope to be like them
- 37:38one day. Plus, they're paying a lot of money
- 37:41to go to vet school and like activists are paying
- 37:44a lot in our time and resources and energy and
- 37:46sometimes even legal risk to do this. It's hard
- 37:50to admit that the person in charge is actually
- 37:53engaging in very harmful behavior. That's why
- 37:56it takes older people like us. to speak about
- 37:59this. But if you go to animal rights conferences,
- 38:01you'll have all ages of men speaking and you'll
- 38:04have young women speaking. You will not see older
- 38:06women speaking at animal rights conferences.
- 38:09And that's a problem. I think that's ageism.
- 38:13Older women are viewed as not useful. Who controls
- 38:16the animal rights movement? It's men with their
- 38:18money. Men control access to capital and opportunities.
- 38:22The older women who are aware of these dynamics.
- 38:25and who've spoken out, they're not asked to speak
- 38:28and they don't come to these conferences, which
- 38:30is the same thing with the AVMA, the American
- 38:32Veterinary Medical Association, all of the veterinarians
- 38:34who are. understanding that the AVMA is highly
- 38:37toxic and doing harmful things. They've all pulled
- 38:41their AVMA membership. They don't go to the AVMA
- 38:44conferences. I'm still a member. I still go and
- 38:47I'm a thorn in their side and I apply to be on
- 38:50committees and I submit comments on all of their
- 38:52policies. But those people who are aware of the
- 38:55problems and separate themselves don't do that.
- 38:57I don't know. They might be right. This might
- 38:59be a futile endeavor for me to continue to speak
- 39:02out and to go to conferences. and to talk to
- 39:05people. I might be fighting a losing battle,
- 39:07but I feel like I'm doing something at least.
- 39:10I might be planting some seeds. Well, you said
- 39:14that you said I'm doing good for the animals.
- 39:17You're doing more than good for the animals.
- 39:20You are addressing an essential segment of this
- 39:25whole machine of animal exploitation, which are
- 39:28the veterinarians. Who else is doing this kind
- 39:31of work? I feel like If I had to accept a level
- 39:35of toxicity from someone, it would be from you,
- 39:39from people who are doing truly essential work
- 39:42in order to advance this cause. But yeah, how
- 39:46do you address, because I've heard that before,
- 39:48how do you address this accusation that by exposing
- 39:53the misbehavior of some activists, you're actually
- 39:57harming the animals. It feels like now the animals
- 40:01are hostages of those people. And you can't expose
- 40:06or alert current or future activists without
- 40:11harming the poor animals. What do you make of
- 40:14that? I hope we can learn from Dolores Huerta,
- 40:17who finally spoke out about Cesar Chavez. This
- 40:21is needed to make our movement stronger. And
- 40:23the thing that allows men in power to get away
- 40:27with stuff and It kind of makes their behavior
- 40:30worse because there's no pushback. When they
- 40:34do do something wrong and it comes out, they
- 40:38have all of their sycophants celebrating them
- 40:40and protecting them. They're like, yeah, I'm
- 40:42in the right, no matter what I do is in the right.
- 40:46I had this man tell me other people say I'm not
- 40:49dating enough, you know, so their own. Toxic
- 40:54ideas are just continued to be celebrated without
- 40:58any scrutiny and that harms our movement. It
- 41:01makes it more polarized. It makes these groups
- 41:05more polarized creating more of this us versus
- 41:08them mentality and it harms collaboration. And
- 41:12this guy says he's no longer seeing all of the
- 41:15infighting because everybody is joining together.
- 41:18He creates more of a spectacle. more of a sense
- 41:22of urgency needed for whatever is happening.
- 41:25And then everybody's like, we all need to join
- 41:28together to help this cause because this is so,
- 41:32so important what they're working on. Nobody
- 41:34stops to question that. And then all of these
- 41:38resources are going towards this one cause and
- 41:43things like me addressing terminal labs and veterinary
- 41:46schools and trying to address the veterinary
- 41:50profession, which is responsible for legitimizing
- 41:55the worst practices. And if we directed resources
- 41:59to encouraging more activists to address the
- 42:03veterinary profession and debunk some of the
- 42:06myths that veterinarians are taught about these
- 42:08issues, we could dismantle all sorts of animal
- 42:12harm and exploitation. But all of our resources
- 42:16are focused on this person's campaigns. And we're
- 42:21not really diversifying our resources and we're
- 42:25all vulnerable when it all collapses. It's creating
- 42:28sort of a house of cards situation. And our movement
- 42:31is not strong if we cannot protect whistleblowers.
- 42:34Like that's the thing. If we cannot protect our
- 42:38own whistleblowers, what are we even doing? It's
- 42:42a movement based on hierarchy of moral worth.
- 42:45And aren't we as animal activists trying to dismantle
- 42:48all hierarchies of moral worth? And I hope we
- 42:52can continue having these conversations out in
- 42:56the open. And those of us who are talking about
- 42:59this aren't. silenced and retaliated against
- 43:02for daring having these conversations. When we
- 43:05can't talk about things, that's what harms our
- 43:08movement. I've had that conversation before,
- 43:10but I will bring it up again. You would have
- 43:13thought that a movement composed mostly of women
- 43:16would be impervious to those kinds of issues.
- 43:20How do we explain that it's not? Yeah, no, because
- 43:25we still are living under patriarchy and especially
- 43:30a movement built on you have to suck up to men
- 43:33in power if you want access to funding, speaking
- 43:36engagements, collaboration opportunities, resources,
- 43:40that still exists. And these systems create a
- 43:44lot of distrust among women. I know for me, I
- 43:50tried to talk to women about this. only to have
- 43:54them be like, tell me more and then go spill
- 43:56all the beans to men in power to suck up to him
- 44:00and to show their loyalty to him. And that's
- 44:03how they maintain their status under patriarchy.
- 44:06You don't know who to trust, but I think you
- 44:09do have to just be like, I'm going to. And this
- 44:12is a position of privilege as a white woman who
- 44:16is financially independent and has my own community.
- 44:19I can risk it. A 20 -year -old just making their
- 44:23way. Some of these 20 -year -olds might test
- 44:25the waters like, hey, I'm concerned about this.
- 44:29The amount of pushback you get will really keep
- 44:33you in line. You're like, OK, I'm not doing that
- 44:35again. I'm not. suffering that backlash that
- 44:38I faced just for daring broach this subject a
- 44:41little bit. So that's another reason why women
- 44:43aren't. Speaking up and plus to have this guy
- 44:47who is doing such great work for the animals
- 44:49He is romantically interested in me. Maybe he
- 44:52is a good guy and maybe this is my prince charming
- 44:56and all of that stuff That's hard to resist Finding
- 45:00true love is what something everybody wants and
- 45:03we want to believe it and we don't want to be
- 45:05like He does such a good job of the second year
- 45:08skeptical or like a little like oh, you're just
- 45:12not assuming good faith, you're not trusting.
- 45:15And you have to trust. And that's when I started
- 45:18addressing misconduct, voicing concerns, then
- 45:22it's like, he just doesn't trust. You're not
- 45:25trustworthy. You're not acting in a trustworthy
- 45:27way. And that feels bad when people are telling
- 45:31you they don't trust you like that. hurts. So
- 45:35I can see a lot of people just sort of internalizing
- 45:38and feeling like, am I the bad guy? That's what
- 45:41I felt like. Am I the bad guy? Am I the problem
- 45:45here? And most women, I think, take that and
- 45:49say, oh, I must be the problem. I'm going to
- 45:50behave better. I'm going to play the game. These
- 45:53are the rules. If I follow the rules, everything's
- 45:55fine. If I step out of line, it's me being bad,
- 45:59not showing good faith, not taking feedback,
- 46:02all of the things. Do you think it's more prevalent
- 46:05than we think? It's not only this person. In
- 46:10other corners of the animal rights world, there
- 46:12are other men like him or women in other toxic
- 46:17traits. I think it's all genders and there's
- 46:21books been written about this. I recommend everybody
- 46:23read Oppressive Liberation by Lisa Kemmerer.
- 46:26The Animal Movement is another great book on
- 46:29this. It's very common, which is why I'm not
- 46:31talking about one man or one organization, because
- 46:35our movement is ripe for this. We have a group
- 46:38of highly idealistic, agreeable, empathetic women
- 46:44and men who want to do good work for the animals.
- 46:47And we are vulnerable to these sorts of characters
- 46:50to come in and take advantage of us. And so we
- 46:54do need to arm ourselves with knowing what the
- 46:57red flags are. But it's hard. It's like, oh,
- 46:59I finally found my friends. It's really hard
- 47:01to believe that this is bad and then what are
- 47:05you going to do? Are you going to turn away from
- 47:06them? Are you not going to take part in the action?
- 47:08That's so important. It's really hard. It took
- 47:11me being slapped in the face with it in order
- 47:15to wake up and it prevents all of us from having
- 47:18access to opportunities to engage in activism.
- 47:22That is more effective and bringing in voices
- 47:27of people who are going to be really smart about
- 47:31how we go about these things. We're throwing
- 47:33activists into situations of high risk without
- 47:38adequately interrogating what we're actually
- 47:41working on. And all this focus is on press and
- 47:43everything. And then it always becomes though
- 47:45people who are voicing concerns end up not making
- 47:48it about the man but the tactics that he's advancing
- 47:53and maybe the tactics are good but now I can't
- 47:57be involved in that kind of activism because
- 47:59that person is the face of it and so then it
- 48:03kind of creates this situation where it seems
- 48:06like everybody is against that tactic when really
- 48:10we're against the retaliation the character assassination
- 48:14the manipulation that this person is engaging
- 48:17in and harming of other activists and silencing
- 48:21of dissent. That's what we're concerned about.
- 48:26And I'm hoping more of us can join together.
- 48:30And if you have a problem with this guy, maybe
- 48:33you can join other groups. I'm policing myself
- 48:36because this is what he is ingrained in me. There's
- 48:39this feeling of I am now. Trying to take activists
- 48:45away from him and towards my own cause for selfish
- 48:48reasons and that's another Thing that has been
- 48:51perpetuated as a narrative. So I don't want to
- 48:53seem like I'm doing that. I hope all people join
- 48:56together I make no money off of the animal rights
- 48:58movement. All of this is volunteer. So I'm not
- 49:01like profiting from this but I do If you are
- 49:04involved in any sort of activism or action and
- 49:07considering being involved in various groups,
- 49:10check their 990 forms. You can look up in the
- 49:14United States, the group's name, look at their
- 49:17990s, look at how much money they are bringing
- 49:21in and how much money they have. And if they're
- 49:24asking you to fundraise for your own travel,
- 49:26expenses, legal fees, be like, what? You guys
- 49:31have millions of dollars. Why aren't you helping
- 49:35your activists who are doing this? Why are you
- 49:38cramming so many activists into an Airbnb where
- 49:41they all have to share rooms and such and potentially
- 49:45risk harmful sexual misconduct allegations? Why
- 49:50are they hoarding so much money? You should ask
- 49:54yourself, what are their plans with that money?
- 49:57I never got that impression from you. Truly.
- 50:00And I was never aware of that situation or other
- 50:04situations that found themselves on my radar.
- 50:07But now I've taken the habit of just Googling
- 50:11every guest that wants to come on the show and
- 50:15just doing quick Google search, you know, the
- 50:18name of the guests and then the word scandal
- 50:20and see what comes up. So I recommend people
- 50:26to do that. You know, that there's this LinkedIn.
- 50:28thing, you know, you choose your boss, not the
- 50:32job itself. So look up who your boss is. Same
- 50:36with, you know, animal activism. Look up the
- 50:39leader of your volunteer group or of the organization
- 50:42you want to be a part of. Look that person up,
- 50:46see if there are any scandals in the history
- 50:48of that person. Listen to that person speak.
- 50:51Does it sound cultish? Is that person charismatic?
- 50:55That's another trait that I've learned. that
- 50:59you need to avoid in life. Now, charismatic people
- 51:03make me a bit uncomfortable because of that.
- 51:06I always have that suspicion that maybe they
- 51:10have something to sell me that I don't want.
- 51:12There's this whole carrot and stick situation
- 51:15of you'll get all of this if you just follow
- 51:20the rules and do what is expected from you. And
- 51:24if you don't, you'll get all of those consequences.
- 51:27the oldest trick in the book, but then you need
- 51:31to choose what kind of person you want to be.
- 51:35And I think that's the most important thing.
- 51:39And I bring this up often. in this podcast, but
- 51:42having a spirituality of some sort is useful
- 51:46in so many situations, including this one. You're
- 51:50not looking for that greater thing in life in
- 51:54your activism. You already have that in bank.
- 51:58So there isn't this hunger for something more
- 52:01from life, an expectation that cannot be fulfilled
- 52:04from this world and from animal activism. So
- 52:09go look for the answers to your existential questions
- 52:12elsewhere than from people or groups of all sorts.
- 52:18Go get them from spiritual traditions. That's,
- 52:21I guess, my point. And finally, about the point
- 52:24on the prevalence of this. This is not the first
- 52:27leader that I've heard about having some problems.
- 52:32Some of them actually disappear without a word
- 52:34because there is money involved, there are What
- 52:38are they called? Non -disclosure agreements that
- 52:41are signed. So it's happening behind the scenes.
- 52:45But if one day you stop hearing about this important
- 52:50animal activist, you can, you know, wonder why
- 52:54maybe some actions were taken against that person
- 52:57for the greater good. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah.
- 53:02It's, I just want people to know that, Hey, I'm
- 53:04a friendly person. Once you are aware of misconduct
- 53:08and you have misconduct wielded against you and
- 53:11you suffer retaliation, you can feel all alone.
- 53:14I've felt that in the veterinary profession,
- 53:17facing the backlash for my activism, but now
- 53:20I've felt that in the animal activists space
- 53:24and feel very alone and not knowing who to trust.
- 53:29And so I want anybody else out there who is feeling
- 53:32the same way, know that I'm a person. who you
- 53:35can trust. And you can talk to about these things
- 53:39as long as I can trust you. And I know that you're
- 53:42not going to share anything to certain leaders
- 53:46about what I say. Well, that's a beautiful invitation.
- 53:50And yeah, I hope people reach out. Yeah, that's
- 53:54another great point. The loneliness feeling of
- 53:57being alone. Well, I'm here to Oh, thank you.
- 54:02Of course. And I'm happy to welcome you on the
- 54:06show, Crystal, whenever needed. Yeah. I'm not
- 54:10here for having the easy conversations. That's
- 54:13not what I set up this podcast to be. So, yeah.
- 54:17Thank you so much. Yeah. And we've got We've
- 54:20got lots of stuff coming with our campaign against
- 54:23terminal labs and veterinary schools. We just
- 54:25stopped WSU from ending the lives of eight horses.
- 54:29That made a lot of news. And then, of course,
- 54:31WSU has attacked us as sending threatening messages,
- 54:36which is not what we're about. And those people
- 54:38who have done that have harmed our work. activists
- 54:43don't resort to threats of violence in order
- 54:46to get things done. Despite what WSU's statement
- 54:49says about how they're canceling the lab because
- 54:52of threats, do not feel emboldened that threats
- 54:55led to the closure of this lab. I think it was
- 54:57the thousands of professional messages that led
- 55:01them to close this lab. And now they're using
- 55:03threats as an excuse. But yeah, I'm glad that
- 55:07we're having this discussion about the patterns.
- 55:10that are harmful because I think a lot of groups
- 55:13base their organizing structure on groups like
- 55:17the United Farm Workers and looking at the history
- 55:19of how did they go about doing this and repeating
- 55:22those patterns that led to Cesar Chavez being
- 55:27enabled to commit this misconduct and nobody
- 55:31realizing that it was a harmful structure to
- 55:33imitate has now led the animal. advocacy space
- 55:37to repeat those same patterns. So I hope that
- 55:42we interrogate the patterns that we're repeating
- 55:45and the role models that we are following. understanding
- 55:49that the first thing we need to do is protect
- 55:52whistleblowers. We need to address misconduct,
- 55:56protect whistleblowers, allow them to share their
- 55:59stories and invite them to develop systems to
- 56:04protect those who lack power in our advocacy
- 56:07spaces. Yes. Here's an unpopular opinion. I think
- 56:11gossip is good. Yes. Thank you for saying that.
- 56:16I think, yeah. Yeah. There are there's harmful
- 56:19gossip, of course, like the type of gossip when
- 56:22leaders those in power are gossiping about their
- 56:25activists, those with less power. But when those
- 56:29with less power talk to each other and are sharing
- 56:32information like, oh, that guy pursued me romantically.
- 56:38And then hearing, oh, he pursued me, too. What
- 56:42did he say to you? Oh, he said those exact same
- 56:44words to me. He's pretty much got a game plan
- 56:46here. That's the sort of thing that we need to
- 56:49share. And any groups that have sort of anti
- 56:52-gossiping policies, that's meant to control
- 56:56the flow of information. It prevents coalition
- 56:59forming. And it's protecting leadership from
- 57:03scrutiny. And it's reframing any sort of descent
- 57:07as a moral failure. And that's one of the things
- 57:10that United Farm Workers was doing too. And we
- 57:13need to have a more open mind when it comes to
- 57:17our advocacy spaces. Not all gossip is harmful,
- 57:21especially when it's people sharing their stories
- 57:24of the misconduct of those in power. Yeah, it's
- 57:28I think an evolutionary human trait that we have
- 57:32developed because we're such social creatures.
- 57:34So it's there to protect us. It's there to keep
- 57:38our communities sane and healthy. And so no,
- 57:43that's not right to say, don't gossip. You should
- 57:47gossip. That's weird. Why shouldn't we be talking
- 57:52about certain topics? Don't we have freedom of
- 57:55expression? Yeah, there's one group has a manual
- 57:59that has a no gossiping policy and it talks about
- 58:02no gossiping because you don't want to be working
- 58:06on a high risk thing with somebody who's spreading
- 58:09gossip about you, but also don't do the things
- 58:12that people will gossip about. If you're doing
- 58:16things that people will want to gossip about,
- 58:18maybe you shouldn't be doing those things. And
- 58:20what's the thing that most people gossip about?
- 58:23The misconduct, the manipulation, the romantic
- 58:26pursuits of people. That's what we need to share
- 58:29with each other so that we all know if we engage
- 58:33in a romantic relationship with somebody, It's
- 58:36good to know that you're doing that with all
- 58:38of the information on the table. Would you really
- 58:41engage in a romantic relationship knowing that
- 58:43this guy is just going out and using all these
- 58:46lines on everybody and you're just the one who's
- 58:49gullible enough to fall for it? And that's what
- 58:51I realized. I was just gullible enough to fall
- 58:53for his game. For a certain time, it did not
- 58:57last too long, which is important to mention.
- 59:02And yeah, unless you are Einstein or some kind
- 59:05of genius, let's not tolerate such misbehaviors
- 59:10from our leaders. There are better people out
- 59:12there. I've talked to so many activists who are
- 59:15just the best. Why do we have to stick with the
- 59:20problematic ones who are not able to uphold the
- 59:25most basic, you know, moral principles? No, I
- 59:29said No to that. We have so many better choices
- 59:32and we are an international movement. We don't
- 59:36have to stick to US -based activists. If we want
- 59:40choice, we have so much choice from countries
- 59:44all over the world for leadership. But people
- 59:47right now, it's all the attention culture and
- 59:50the people that... get the attention are the
- 59:53people who manipulate our emotions the best and
- 59:56is that really what our movement wants to fund
- 59:59and focus on that's what social media is focusing
- 1:00:01on but it is these highs and lows this us versus
- 1:00:05them mentality that creates this group cohesion
- 1:00:09this idea that it's us against those evil forces
- 1:00:11out there and that's what the most toxic people
- 1:00:16capitalize on, and that's what makes our movement
- 1:00:18so vulnerable. The most important thing as activists,
- 1:00:20we need to arm ourselves against the manipulation,
- 1:00:23understanding the red flags, understanding how
- 1:00:26we are being emotionally manipulated and educate
- 1:00:29ourselves on these dynamics, these manipulation
- 1:00:33tactics that are used against us. Well said and
- 1:00:37have some kind of social media hygiene routine,
- 1:00:41some way to protect yourselves against the negative
- 1:00:44effects of social media. That's also important.
- 1:00:48Absolutely. Wonderful. So Crystal, did you want
- 1:00:53to add something before we stop the recording?
- 1:00:56Follow me on social media. Dr. Crystal Heath,
- 1:00:59Our Honor, www .ourhonor .org. Our Honor is on
- 1:01:03all the social media platforms. We're also on
- 1:01:05YouTube. Reach out if you have any questions,
- 1:01:09concerns, want to share your story. See Heath
- 1:01:13at ourhonor .org or info at ourhonor .org are
- 1:01:17my two email addresses. So please do reach out.
- 1:01:21And if you want to volunteer with us, we have
- 1:01:23lots of volunteer opportunities as well. Amazing.
- 1:01:26Thank you so much, Crystal. Thank you for your
- 1:01:28bravery. Thank you for speaking up. This has
- 1:01:31been a pleasure. It's always a pleasure to talk
- 1:01:33with you and hopefully this episode helps lots
- 1:01:37of people. Yes, thank you. Thank you for your
- 1:01:40show. Thank you everyone for listening. I kindly
- 1:01:43invite you to share this podcast with the vegans
- 1:01:46you know. Let's encourage more people to take
- 1:01:49action. Again, thank you so much for caring and
- 1:01:53I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.