Latest / MBA Training Marketing / The 95-5 rule: making the board case for brand spend
Transcript
- 0:00Host: Welcome to the Leaders Insights Podcast.
- 0:08Host: Today's episode, The 95, Five Rule, a playbook for CMOs who want to win the brand building
- 0:14Host: argument.
- 0:15Host: Most marketing budgets get shredded in the boardroom the second someone asks, what's
- 0:19Host: the return this quarter?
- 0:21Host: You're here to say that question is the problem.
- 0:23Host: Go.
- 0:24Expert: The question isn't wrong.
- 0:25Expert: It's incomplete.
- 0:26Expert: 95% of your potential buyers aren't shopping right now.
- 0:30Expert: That's the 95, five rule, when at any moment, roughly 5% of businesses are actually in the
- 0:37Expert: market to buy your category.
- 0:39Expert: And 95% aren't.
- 0:42Expert: Performance marketing, the ads that chase people who are already searching, only touches that
- 0:47Expert: 5%.
- 0:48Expert: So, if that's your whole strategy, you're fighting over the smallest possible pond and
- 0:53Expert: ignoring the ocean.
- 0:54Host: But the finance director loves that pond because you can measure it.
- 0:58Host: You spend a pound, you can trace the sale.
- 1:01Expert: Right, and that's the trap.
- 1:03Expert: Attribution, the tracing of a sale back to a specific ad, feels rigorous, but it mostly
- 1:08Expert: rewards the last click.
- 1:10Expert: Someone typed your name into Google, you paid to appear, you claimed the win, you
- 1:15Expert: didn't create the demand, you harvested it.
- 1:18Expert: The brand work that put your name in their head 18 months earlier gets zero credit because
- 1:23Expert: it's unmeasurable in the same tidy way.
- 1:26Host: That sounds like a convenient excuse for spending money you can't justify.
- 1:30Expert: It would be if the evidence weren't there.
- 1:33Expert: The B2B Institute, that's LinkedIn's research arm.
- 1:36Expert: So yes, they'd like you to buy LinkedIn ads, flag noted, worked with Professor John
- 1:41Expert: Dawes to establish the 95, five split.
- 1:46Expert: And it's held up across independent replication.
- 1:49Expert: And here's the part that should sting.
- 1:51Expert: Researchers don't choose the best option when they finally enter the market.
- 1:55Expert: They choose the option they already remember.
- 1:57Expert: If you're not in memory before the buying window opens, you're not on the list.
- 2:01Host: So how does a CMO actually make that case survive a board that wants numbers?
- 2:06Expert: You reframe the metric, stop reporting on this quarter's leads, and start reporting
- 2:10Expert: on what I'd call mental market share.
- 2:13Expert: The percentage of category buyers who can name you unprompted.
- 2:17Expert: That's measurable.
- 2:18Expert: It just takes a tracking study rather than a dashboard.
- 2:22Expert: Then you tie it to future revenue, SEMrush data, and they sell search analytics tools,
- 2:27Expert: so cross-check it against something independent.
- 2:30Expert: Suggests branded search volume.
- 2:32Expert: People typing your name specifically.
- 2:34Expert: Predicts pipeline six to nine months out.
- 2:37Expert: That's your leading indicator.
- 2:39Expert: You show the board the leak before the bucket's empty.
- 2:42Host: Give me a real company that got this right.
- 2:45Expert: Cloudflare.
- 2:46Expert: Boring infrastructure, security plumbing nobody wants to think about.
- 2:50Expert: They spent years being visibly useful and slightly funny in developer communities
- 2:54Expert: long before those developers had budget.
- 2:57Expert: By the time those engineers became decision makers, Cloudflare was the default.
- 3:02Expert: Compare that to the dozens of competitors who only ran conversion ads and
- 3:06Expert: are now indistinguishable acronyms.
- 3:09Expert: The gap wasn't product, it was memory.
- 3:11Host: What's the split then?
- 3:13Host: How much brand, how much performance?
- 3:15Expert: Les Benet and Peter Fields' work, published through the IPA,
- 3:19Expert: the UK's advertising trade body, and this one's genuinely independent of any
- 3:24Expert: software vendor, lands around 60% brand, 40% activation for most B2B firms.
- 3:31Expert: Not a law, a starting point, but most CMOs I meet are running 90,
- 3:36Expert: 10 the wrong way, and wondering why every year gets harder and
- 3:39Expert: every lead gets more expensive.
- 3:41Host: And when a CMO says, I don't have budget for both?
- 3:44Expert: Then you don't have a budget problem, you have a sequencing problem.
- 3:48Expert: HubSpot reckons acquisition costs have climbed sharply as everyone crowds
- 3:52Expert: the same 5%, though they sell the marketing software people use to crowd it.
- 3:57Expert: So take the exact figure with salt and check MIT Sloan Management Review,
- 4:01Expert: who've documented the same squeeze independently.
- 4:04Expert: You're paying a premium to compete for scraps.
- 4:07Expert: Brand investment is how you stop overpaying at the auction.
- 4:10Expert: One dry truth before we go.
- 4:12Expert: Performance marketing is a bit like turning up to someone's wedding to propose.
- 4:17Expert: Technically, you found them at the buying moment.
- 4:19Expert: You've also missed the entire relationship.
- 4:22Host: Give me the one thing to do Monday morning.
- 4:24Expert: Commission a single unprompted awareness study.
- 4:28Expert: Ask 100 category buyers to name brands in your space without prompting.
- 4:32Expert: If you're not in the top three, that's your board argument, written for you.
- 4:37Host: Sources for today's episode.
- 4:39Host: SEMrush, vendor, SEO analytics tools, HubSpot vendor,
- 4:44Host: CRM marketing automation, MIT Sloan Management Review.
- 4:49Host: That's it.
- 4:50Host: The CMO decision tools are live at mba-training.com.