Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP191: Lobster Boy
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Tanya and I'm Talia, and we are Crimes and Consequences,
- 0:18a true crime podcast. Hi, Talia, Ky, Tania, how
- 0:36you doing today? Okay, let's come on and we just not Can we
- 0:40just skip all that shit? All right, let's skip it. Is this
- 0:43a regular patron, This is a regular episode, So welcome back everyone.
- 0:48I'm doing great. Thank you for asking. So welcome back to another exciting
- 0:52episode of Rhymes and Consequences. Have you ever heard of Lobster Boy? I
- 0:57have in the book that's probably completely inappropriate, like in nineteen eighties called Freaks.
- 1:03Oh okay, you're talking about I always got the little hands that,
- 1:07yeah, that were like labster claws. Yes. Yes. His name was
- 1:11Grady Styles Junior, and he was born in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, nineteen thirty
- 1:15seven, and he would grow up, obviously to lead a very interesting life.
- 1:19He was known as lobster Boy. I know. He had a rare
- 1:25medical condition that ran and his family was genetic and the condition is called ectrodactyle,
- 1:30and it is commonly known as lobster claw syndrome. Like I said,
- 1:34it's genetic. It's very rare. And what it is. It causes extremities
- 1:40your hands, your feet or both to have malformation. They're like attached or
- 1:46something. You know. It's funny though the condition may not start in the
- 1:49womb, and it could develop later in someone's life. So how's that pass?
- 1:53I know, it's just bizarre. But for Grady, his symptoms were
- 1:57prenatal, so the middle parts of his hands and feet were missing. He
- 2:02had it both in his hands and feet. So what happens is like he
- 2:06had like a thumb and a pinky with like the rest of the fingers fused
- 2:09together together. So he had like it looked like a lobster claw, but
- 2:13he had all his fingers right, No, they were all fused together.
- 2:15It was like, well too big, you know, I get lobster claw.
- 2:21And like I said, his feet were exactly the same. So because
- 2:23his feet were disformed, he couldn't walk and he would use a wheelchair.
- 2:28Ok. Okay, for many people in the thirties and forties, this condition
- 2:32really hadn't been seen many times. Obviously, no internet no, even television.
- 2:38I mean, where do you see someone. I've never seen anybody not
- 2:40in person. It's rare. Yeah, it's rare. Grady was the sixth
- 2:46generation in his family to have this condition. Wow, right, so family
- 2:51members went back to like the eighteen hundreds, they still managed to find someone
- 2:53to love them. Yeah, exactly, the sixth generation. That's true.
- 2:59That's true. And Greedy was the fourth child of his father, Greedy Senior,
- 3:01and his mom Edna, and every offspring that Greedy Senior and Edna had
- 3:07they had the same condition, with exception of one of his sisters. So
- 3:12it's dominant. Yes. So rather than being ashamed or embarrassed about the family
- 3:15deformities, the Styles family capitalized on it and they were a side show America.
- 3:22I know, in a traveling carnival and you know, like you mentioned,
- 3:25you read a book called Freaks. They were commonly known as freak shows.
- 3:29But that's impropriate, that's inappropriate. Now. The family then continued to
- 3:35grow and produce more and more children that had this condition, like kind of
- 3:38like to continue to fuel the side show. Right. Oh yeah. They
- 3:44eventually developed a family circus known as the Lobster Family, and they became a
- 3:50prime attraction in carnivals throughout the early twentieth century. They were really popular.
- 3:53Lobster family, the Lobster family. Why not, Why not? Paula's going
- 3:58to make money. They can't walk, they can these are hands at well
- 4:00exactly his nineteen thirties. Yeah, it's nineteen thirties. And now even though
- 4:04I mentioned like most of his brothers and sisters had the condition, not all
- 4:09of them had them in both their hands and feet. But Grady did.
- 4:11Like I said when I mentioned, he had this wheelchair, and when he
- 4:15wasn't using the wheelchair, he would use his arms to pull himself across the
- 4:18floor. So he developed a really incredible upper body strength just because that's how
- 4:24he used to get around when he didn't have the chair. So I'm telling
- 4:28you, you know, his family is touring this circuit, this carnival circuit,
- 4:32and they spent their off season in a place called Gibsonton, Florida that
- 4:38was known as Showtown, USA, and it was the most popular hub for
- 4:43circus and carnival performers throughout the winter months, so they all seemed to flock
- 4:46there. I had no idea. I didn't either in case you're wondering,
- 4:49like how much money could they really make? This family did really well,
- 4:54the Styles family, they made about sixty to eighty thousand dollars per season,
- 5:00and the season would be only for about half a year. I mean it's
- 5:01a lot of money. What years like nineteen let's say it's nineteen forty and
- 5:06it's one point seven million dollars in today's money. So they did really when
- 5:12they didn't need more full time, no half the year. The nice thing
- 5:15about all of the carnival workers going to the city in Florida was because they
- 5:18were all there, they kind of got away from people like staring at them.
- 5:23It's kind of like they you know, they truly got to community that
- 5:26they fit in. Yeah, exactly. During this time, while Grady grew
- 5:30up, he learned to write and he learned to shoot a gun. So
- 5:34it's very important things. It's physical. His physical limitations did not stop him
- 5:40from doing those things. Eventually, at some point, young Grady fell madly
- 5:44in love with another carnival worker named Mary Teresa. And I've seen it as
- 5:48Mary, and I've seen it as Maria, so I'm just going to call
- 5:50her Mary. She had run away from her home to join the circus when
- 5:54she was a teenager. She was a product of incest and she was physically
- 5:59abused by her parents. And even though she traveled with the carnival, Mary
- 6:02wasn't part of any act. She was just a staff member, so she
- 6:08wasn't part of the fight show unique about her, right right, She was
- 6:12just a regular worker. So Mary and Grady hit it off really well and
- 6:16they eventually got married. While married, Grady and Mary had two children,
- 6:21two daughters named Kathy and Donna. Their daughter, Kathy wasn't born with this
- 6:27lobster claw syndrome, but Donna was. Both children would become part of the
- 6:31carnival, joining the rest of the family. Since Donna wasn't born with a
- 6:36genetic condition, Grady actually favored her a little bit over her sister. As
- 6:42they grew up, Kathy was the apple of his eye. It's been said.
- 6:46At some point Grady began to drink heavily, and along with that he
- 6:50became abusive to his family. Yeah, he was an incredibly mean drunk and
- 6:58would use his upper body strength to his advantage while beating Mary and Donna.
- 7:03Because Kathy was his favorite, so he did not abuse her. And you
- 7:08know this is really kind of graphics. I'm just warning everybody. So Mary
- 7:12used an IUD. It's her form of birth control. I don't want to
- 7:15know this. During a fight, Grady used his claws. Stop, hands
- 7:21up. You know what I'm gonna say? Yeah, yeah, yeah,
- 7:25go ahead. He literally ripped the cud out of Mary's body. Oh my
- 7:30god, yeah, I don't. I don't understand it. I don't want
- 7:31to know. I just can't. I don't want to picture it. Just
- 7:34can you move forward? Oh? Absolutely? That was That was all I
- 7:38was going to tell you about that. My god, I'm just trying to
- 7:40give you, like the level of abuse this poor woman suffering. I can
- 7:44handle ahead being tapped off. I can't handle things like that. I know.
- 7:47He would choke her when they fought, and his hands were perfect for
- 7:51him to be able to just wrap around her knock and you know, do
- 7:56that. His hands weren't functionable enough to do much else. He became extremely
- 8:01dangerous to everyone around him due to his alcoholism. Takeaway his reel chair,
- 8:05then he's got a crawl. I'm not trying to be me, I know.
- 8:07And two things that I mentioned, the choking and the other thing that
- 8:11we won't get into that wasn't even the worst. Yeah, it wasn't even
- 8:16the worst of what he's done what he will go on to do his daughter
- 8:20Donna, And Donna was the one that was born with the syndrome. She
- 8:24fell madly in love with a young man named Jake Lane who was eighteen and
- 8:28she was sixteen. And Grady hated this kid from the beginning. Was he
- 8:35like your average Yeah, I believe so. I believe so. Like I
- 8:39didn't find anything that said that he had any sort of or anything right,
- 8:43Oh, she was actually fifteen years old. Excuse me. When she became
- 8:46engaged to Jack, they were planning their wedding and Grady felt the need to
- 8:52put a stop to this relationship altogether. He was like, nope. He
- 8:56asked Donna to break off the engagement, but she said, you know,
- 9:00she loved Jack so much and she refused to do what her father told her
- 9:05to do. So the reason why Grady despised him is because Donna was underaged.
- 9:09But on the day before his daughter's wedding, Grady met up with Jack.
- 9:13And there's two different versions of the story. One said that Grady invited
- 9:18Jack over under the ruse he was going to bless the marriage between Jack and
- 9:22Donna, And the other theory is that Grady went to Jack's home to give
- 9:26him the blessing. So I'm not sure exactly Okay, where this incident happened.
- 9:31Well, if anybody tries to marry my fifteen year old daughter, yeah
- 9:35there's gonna be a big problem. That means a different time. Yeah,
- 9:37it was a different time. The meeting happened in September of nineteen seventy eight,
- 9:41and before he even spoke to Jack, like when the two met up,
- 9:45Grady fatally shot Jack twice with his shotgun and it killed him instantly.
- 9:50Yeah, and the poor guy was loving her, loving his daughter, all
- 9:56her just the way she is as Grady, he figured if Dinna got married,
- 10:01she would leave and he'd no longer be able to control her. Or
- 10:03maybe she'd have babies and they'd have more little baby right. I don't know
- 10:09family, but he had issues like control of his family was his number one
- 10:15priority. When Dinna found out about the murder of her poor fiance, Jack,
- 10:20Grady gave her a devilish smile while saying, I told you I would
- 10:22kill him, Okay, like what I'd be scared of death of my dad.
- 10:28I hope someone went to the place. Well. Grady was arrested for
- 10:31Jack's murder and a child date was set with the jury consisting of six men
- 10:35and six women. Grady really didn't give a shit about the consequences, and
- 10:39he showed absolutely no remorse for what he did. The defense claimed that Jack
- 10:45Lane was shot twice in self defense. Grady said he feared for his life.
- 10:50He's disabled. He's disabled. He's disabled. How can I even choot
- 10:54a gun? Right? The defense went on to say that everyone involved,
- 11:00his family and the police got together to completely dramatize their stories since the shooting.
- 11:05Donna, the farmer bride to be. She was out of town,
- 11:09but somehow she was able to be in cahoots with the police to go against
- 11:13Grady, like we're all conspiring right. The prosecution told a jury that Grady
- 11:18had threatened to kill Jack on multiple occasions and that he went out to purchase
- 11:22the gun in order to follow through with the threat. He just really didn't
- 11:28want Donna to marry Jack. Donna testified against her dad, and she said
- 11:33that she was going to live with Jack, even though her father was against
- 11:37the underage marriage like she was going to probably run away. Says she didn't
- 11:41care about getting his blessing, so that's why this whole story is kind of
- 11:45jacked up. She was happy with Jack and she wanted to start her life
- 11:48with him as soon as possible. She also testified that after her father killed
- 11:52Jack, she said to Grady, I'll see you at your grave. Oh,
- 11:56and that's why she got out of town. Yeah. The defense claims
- 11:58that Anna should be ashamed of her testimony and then it caused the greatest hurt
- 12:03and shame for the Style's family. The defense attorney, his name was Anthony
- 12:07to Cello, told the jury to visualize all the love and compassion that this
- 12:13poor soul has for his children. It's really trying to play what was his
- 12:18self defense? What was Jack going to do? Well? He said he
- 12:20was in fear for his life and that it was Jack and Jack was going
- 12:24to attack him. I don't know all you just haven't have a gun,
- 12:26yeah, exactly. The attorney to Cello wanted the jury to feel sorry for
- 12:31Grady since all he really had was his family, even though he abused them
- 12:37and beat them at every chance he got and got drunk and blah blah blah.
- 12:39But before the trial began, Grady obtained a court order from the state
- 12:45of Florida to get custody of his children. What yeah, what I know.
- 12:50How did he get custody? I don't think he did. Oh he
- 12:52tried, Yeah, he tried. During the closing arguments, Assistant District Attorney
- 12:56Robert Paul Vinsler told the that the detectives thought that Grady would be found not
- 13:01guilty out of sympathy for his disabilities. One of the last statements said by
- 13:07the DA was that Grady has not led a happy life up to this point.
- 13:11It's not his fault all, yeah, he said, a really miserable
- 13:15life. The jury felt that the murder was premeditated, even though the defense
- 13:18said that the murder was due to love and compassion for his daughter. So
- 13:22Grady attended the verdict reading in his wheelchair, and he quietly cried as the
- 13:28jury foreman read that he was found guilty of third degree murder. That's amazing.
- 13:33The jury heard both sides and convicted Grady after deliberating for three whole hours.
- 13:37Three hours. Judge Thomas Harper postponed sentencing, which could have been between
- 13:43ten to twenty years in prison. But yeah, but Judge Harper did set
- 13:48Grady's bound to ten grand which is so he got out, yeah, about
- 13:52fifty thousand today because this was nineteen seventy nine. Before sentencing, Grady pleaded
- 13:56with the judge that there was no way that he could ever be in prison.
- 14:01There was not a single jail or prison at the time that was equipped
- 14:03to handle his disability and doing so, like putting him into prison, would
- 14:07be cruel, unjust, and unusual punishment. Okay, whatever. Yeah,
- 14:13Grady failed to mention at the time that he also hit cirrhosis of the liver
- 14:16from his kind of drinking, along with emphasima from years and years of smoking
- 14:22cigarettes. Oh and how old is he about this time? He's about fifty
- 14:26because he's born in nineteen thirty seven, so yeah, he's like maybe like
- 14:30fifty two. Okay. The court recognized a Grady's argument and they didn't have
- 14:35anything really to say, so the prosecution really didn't say much in rebuttal,
- 14:39there's lots of people that are disabled in prison. I know. But guess
- 14:41what, I don't want to hear it, do I? No, No,
- 14:46The judge didn't sentence Grady to prison time and What's Good gave him fifteen
- 14:50years probation. So he walked out a freeman and went home. Yeah,
- 14:56he shot and killed a man and he got to walk out a team.
- 15:00Yeah, an eighteen year old guy. So not long after the murder,
- 15:05his wife divorced him. Mary finally got out of abusive relationship, but this
- 15:09didn't stop Grady from marrying his second life and having two more children. What
- 15:15I know, how's this guy getting women? He's super sexy. I guess
- 15:20his drunken rage and abuse kept going and this caused his second wife to divorce
- 15:24him. Mary, his first wife, didn't mourn this divorce from Grady.
- 15:28She moved on quickly and she got remarried to a man named Harry Glenn Newman
- 15:33Senior. He also worked for the carnival. Oh, he was known as
- 15:37the world's smallest man. What stop it? What? Yeah, she married
- 15:43the world's smallest man. She married the world's smallest man. And well,
- 15:48he can't hurt her. I'm guessing, yeah, right, he's small.
- 15:50Yeah, he's probably small. And together they had two sons. One was
- 15:56Harry Glenn Junior, and he would go by Glenn Harry. Like I mentioned,
- 16:00he was a little person. He didn't have any physical deformities, which
- 16:03is okay. Yeah, his act in the side show was he was known
- 16:08to hammer nails and drive ice picks up his own nose with the hand.
- 16:12Oh my goodness, the ship and he did really well financially. Oh,
- 16:18I know I am in the wrong job being a lawyer. I know I
- 16:23needn't start figuring out how to put nails up a breeze fire or something.
- 16:27Right after the divorce of his second wife, Grady persuaded his first wife,
- 16:36Mary, who was married to Harry. She remarried him in nineteen eighty nine.
- 16:41Yeah. Why what was wrong with Harry? Don't know. I don't
- 16:44know if Harry passed away, I'm not sure. Okay, but she remarried
- 16:47Grady. Wow. No one in Mary's family or the Style's family knows how
- 16:52the hell he got hurt to marry him a second time. So Mary,
- 16:56along with Donna and Cathy, who were now adults, they all were one
- 17:00big, happy family. And one occasion, Grady's daughter Kathy was pregnant and
- 17:06she tried to intervene between a bad argument that was going on between her parents.
- 17:11She put Grady's wheelchair in between the two of them in an attempt like
- 17:15to calm things down, like separate them. But Grady got so enraged by
- 17:18this that he turned to Kathy and beat her so badly to the point she
- 17:22went into early labor. Thankfully, the baby survived and was born with lobster
- 17:26claw syndrome. Graedy became especially cocky after evading prison for killing a man and
- 17:33beating yeah his daughter. He knew he could literally get away with murder,
- 17:38and with this mindset, the beatings toward his wife and kids became much more
- 17:42severe. And this is when Mary finally finally had enough. She's like,
- 17:47fuck this, she was done, and she put a hit out on Greedy.
- 17:55They put a hit on someone I don't know. Mary put a hit
- 17:57out. I'm gonna tell you all about it. Okay, yeah, okay,
- 18:02this is questions. She paid her seventeen year old neighbor and fellow carnival
- 18:07worker. His name was Chris Wyant. She paid him a whopping fifteen hundred
- 18:12dollars to murder Grady. Mary she said, I hit my breaking point.
- 18:18I couldn't find a way out of living. So her son, Glenn,
- 18:22which was the world's smallest man's son, remember Harry. So her son,
- 18:26Glenn helped his mother come up with a plan that would get rid of Grady
- 18:30once and for all. The story is so fucked up. I know,
- 18:34I know, Okay, I didn't know all of this. Okay, Glenn
- 18:38would plan and help carry out the murder. So the young neighbor, Chris,
- 18:42the seventeen year old, he had a friend to buy him a thirty
- 18:45two caliber cult automatic pistol and this would be the weapon that Chris would use
- 18:49to shoot Grady. Everyone around the Styles family knew that Grady was a dangerous
- 18:55man who needed to be stopped. I'm not saying like you should murder someone,
- 18:59but he was pretty hated. And before I tell you more and what
- 19:03happened next, I can't wait. We're going to take a break. On
- 19:10the night of the shooting, which was to take place in November of nineteen
- 19:14ninety two, neighbor Chris peered into the window and he saw Grady watching TV
- 19:19in his underwear. Oh that's nice. Chris entered the Styles family trailer with
- 19:25his thirty two caliber gun and he shot Grady at point blank range, killing
- 19:30him instantly. Grady was fifty five years old. The police had a very
- 19:34long list of suspects to work through and ahole. Yeah, everybody hated him
- 19:40and they eliminated each suspect one by one. They knew he had lots of
- 19:44enemies. He was hard to get along with because he was just such an
- 19:47angry alcoholic. He'd get drunk and be pissed. He's a dad, Yeah,
- 19:52and he knew he could get away with so much shit, Like I
- 19:55mean, he could literally kill someone. He just had a terrible reputation.
- 19:57Up until his death. He was still making money from the circus in the
- 20:00carnival, which I'm surprised because this nineteen ninety two, did they still have
- 20:06these sights that's so politically not correct. No, it's not. Maybe I
- 20:11know it doesn't seem right, but he did. The medical examiner noted in
- 20:15Grady's autopsy that he was shot in the back of the head. Surprise,
- 20:19with the police using their process of elimination, the suspects came down to Grady's
- 20:25family. Had to be someone in the family. When the surviving members of
- 20:29the Styles family were questioned by police about Grady's murder, not a single one
- 20:33of them denied that they really wanted to murder Grady. They knew that he
- 20:37would need to die in order for them to be free. Yeah, in
- 20:41order for them to be free. And you know that way, he couldn't
- 20:44hurt anyone else. They had to kill him. It seems like they could
- 20:47have found a different way. No, less obvious. I'm just saying,
- 20:51I don't know. Never mind, you're not gonna plan a murder. Mary
- 20:56said to the detectives that Grady was going to kill her and her family,
- 21:00and she believed that like wholehearted. I'm sure she knew they would be safe
- 21:07now that Grady was dead, and she thanked God that her family was alive
- 21:10and okay, and back then they were like with domestic violence and all that
- 21:15bettered wife syndrome that was still kind of new. Yeah, yeah, yeah,
- 21:19it's going to come into this story. Oh, I know, spoiler
- 21:22alert. Despite how true Mary's statement was to the police, when police questioned
- 21:27Glenn, he was forced to take a polygraph test, which he failed miserably.
- 21:33He was forced Yeah, apparently I didn't think they could. They can't
- 21:37know, but it took one. Okay, Well, after that, he
- 21:41was taken into an interrogation room and the pressure was applied, which he cracked
- 21:47some yeah, and he spilled the beans, confessing to the entire plan.
- 21:52During the confession, Glenn told investigators every step of the plan between him,
- 21:56his mother, Mary, and the neighbor Chris. He just spilled the scuts.
- 22:00After the confession, detectives drove back to Gibsonton to pick up Mary at
- 22:04her home. The police said that they spoke with Glenn and they needed her
- 22:08to come down to the police station to straighten out some facts. Oh shit,
- 22:14you know I need you to come. You know what, I'm sorry,
- 22:15I'm gonna need a warrant. Yes, Flora, go there. The
- 22:19informed her that Glenn made some statements that weren't really in her fever, and
- 22:25you know, they really needed her side of the story. But they also
- 22:29made sure that obviously Mary knew her constitutional rights. They read her her Miranda
- 22:33rights. Mary was visibly upset by all that was happening. On November thirtieth,
- 22:38nineteen ninety two, at ten thirty pm, Mary signed a consent for
- 22:42him, giving the police permission to interrogate her. The detectives then asked Mary
- 22:47to tell them what happened. So she told investigators that her husband was abusive
- 22:51to both her and her children. She told them Grady was an uncontrollable monster
- 22:56and would beat them with his clause what she called them. She said he
- 23:02would make her bleed by headbutting her. She proceeded to tell investigators that she
- 23:07had told her daughter Cathy about wanting to kill Gradies several months before it actually
- 23:11happened, and then when Glenn became aware, he knew someone that could help
- 23:15carry it out the neighbor. Mary said, did she wanted to make one
- 23:19thing clear there and then that she wanted to accept all the blame for the
- 23:23murder. She wanted her family to be left out of it. She told
- 23:26detectives that she gave Glenn the fifteen hundred dollars as payment to Chris for the
- 23:30murder of Grady. The detectives asked Mary if she had ever met Chris,
- 23:36and she told him, yeah, I have, but they never discussed the
- 23:38murder that she wanted done. The arrangement was between her and Glenn, so
- 23:44Glenn was the one that gave Chris the money to carry out the hit on
- 23:47Grady. About two weeks prior to the killing, Mary had told her daughter
- 23:51Cathy that the contract was off and that no murder was going to happen.
- 23:55Can you imagine these conversations. I called off the hit. Hey kids,
- 24:00what good news? Good news, We're not going to kill Mary was adamant
- 24:04with the detectives that Grady was supposed to be alive. It wasn't supposed to
- 24:08happen this way. Well wait, I thought she was taking the fall for
- 24:11it. But now she's seeing She's like, well, it wasn't supposed to
- 24:15happen. I mean, I agreed in the beginning, but then I now
- 24:18she's backing down. Yeah, but then throwing them under the bus. The
- 24:21police were like, well, you left the trailer just moments before Grady was
- 24:25murdered, so she happened to step out, and yeah, coincidentally he's alone.
- 24:30The detectives then asked Mary where she got the fifteen hundred dollars to have
- 24:33her husband killed, and she told detectives she made her own money by being
- 24:37a show girl and that she had her own finances show girl. I don't
- 24:42know, but Grady was fifty five, so she can't be that young.
- 24:47Well, whatever, whatever is good for her. Somebody spoke, you know,
- 24:51everybody likes different flavors to leave. That's what are you trying to say
- 24:53old ladies can't know they're sexy. I mean, yeah, absolutely, any
- 25:02as an old lady. Right. The detectives asked her, why didn't you
- 25:06just divorce Grady like she previously did? Well, why did you divorce him
- 25:10and remarry Grade? Yeah? Right. Mary said that he threatened to kill
- 25:14her if she did and the abuse was much worse than ever had been in
- 25:18the past. I believe it. Yeah, me too. That same day,
- 25:21Mary was charged with first degree murder and she was also charged with conspiracy
- 25:25to commit first degree murder. Her son, Glenn, was indicted with the
- 25:29same exact charges, so she wasn't going to get away with taking all the
- 25:32blame. Chris, the neighbor. He was taken into custody on December first.
- 25:37He was advised of his rights, and then he declined to make any
- 25:40statements and requested an attorney's hard yes. The detectives then went on the search
- 25:45for the murder weapon. They found a trailer that belonged to the guy who
- 25:48gave Chris the thirty two caliber cult gun, and they found the gun in
- 25:53the middle of a swamp like woods next to a palm tree. The gun
- 25:57was still loaded when it was taken into evidence. Chris was arrested and charged
- 26:03with first to re murder and conspiracy to commit murder. So all three of
- 26:07them were Yep, all three of them do the nature of the cold blooded
- 26:11crimes. All of them were held without bland. None of the three defendants
- 26:15took any sort of plea deal, and they all chose trial by jury.
- 26:18The state of Florida decided not to seek the death penalty in all three cases.
- 26:23The cases were assigned to Judge Barbara Fleischer, and she had a reputation
- 26:27of being sympathetic to abused women. Maria and Glenn were represented by a young
- 26:32criminal attorney named Peter Catania. He originally was only going to represent Mary,
- 26:37and he later took Glenn's case pro bonn He soon realized that the case was
- 26:41too large for one attorney. We have two mass Yeah, maybe these are
- 26:48murder you know charges here? Yeah, so we brought on another attorney.
- 26:52Would be kind of a conflict of interest like that to represent both of them.
- 26:56Yeah, I think they had separate trials. I don't know, I
- 26:59guess. He brought in another attorney named Arnold Levine to help. Levine was
- 27:03a well known attorney and the media loved him because he always represented like high
- 27:10profile cases and he won them a lot. He won the publicity. Yeah,
- 27:14he knew that this case was going to cost a lot of money for
- 27:17Mary, so he also took the case pro bono because a lot. Oh
- 27:22yeah, a lot often, so he didn't care. He got like free
- 27:25advertise it too. Mary and Glenn filed for battered spouse and child syndrome defenses.
- 27:33The battered wife syndrome had never been tried as a defense and a murder
- 27:37for higher case in Florida before, so Levine he had to prove that Mary
- 27:41feared for her life and was so intimidated by Grady that killing him was her
- 27:45only way out. He felt they could win the case without a doubt.
- 27:52The first of the trial, though, would be Glenn's detectives testified that Glenn
- 27:56failed the lie detector test. I don't think they could do that. It's
- 27:59not amissible. Oh and because they did it, because polygraph results can't be
- 28:03admitted as evidence, Judge Fleischer ruled a mistrial. Absolutely, that was really
- 28:10stupid of them. I know what they fucked that whole case. I mean,
- 28:14that's like law school first year. Yeah, hello, Chris the neighbor
- 28:19Chris Wyant. His trial date was set to begin in January of nineteen ninety
- 28:23four. His lawyer was court appointed and was not known to be the best
- 28:27like what marrying Glenn had. And he can't use that defense, No,
- 28:30he can't. Chris's mother, Janice, was present for her son's trial,
- 28:36along with Chris's six year old sister. I don't think that's quite a program.
- 28:38Why are you bringing a six year olds? Anyway? The prosecution touched
- 28:42on the fact that Chris didn't just shoot Grady once. He instead kept shooting
- 28:48and shooting and shooting. While sitting on the defense side of the courtroom.
- 28:52Chris showed no emotion or remarse for what he did. He felt that what
- 28:56he did was right in order to save the surviving members of the Stiles family.
- 29:00Assistant State Attorney Ron Haynes had a very strong case against Chris and portrayed
- 29:04him to the jury as a hired assassin and a person who was born to
- 29:08kill. Okay, the theatrics, Well, he's a hired assassin, though
- 29:12that's true. He related that there were two plans. Originally, one was
- 29:17to shoot Grady outside of a lounge in Gibsonton, but that didn't happen since
- 29:22Grady only went there during the daytime. The other was to make the murder
- 29:26look like a home invasion gone awry. That would have been a better idea.
- 29:30That would have been a better idea. Whitnesses were called by the prosecution,
- 29:33and one person in particular was Grady's neighbor, Marco Eno, who was
- 29:38the first person Mary went to with her murder for higher plot, but he
- 29:42declined, oh yeah, She's like, hey, you want to kill Grady.
- 29:47He's like, hey, can I get a cup of sugar? And
- 29:48then I have a question for you real quick. I gotta I gotta find
- 29:52out would you be interested in something? I got a business enterprise for you
- 29:56with the hell you want to make a few extra bucks. Eno was asked
- 30:00about the night of the murder. He lived nearby and heard everything that happened
- 30:03when the murder occurred. He said that around eleven PM he heard someone yelling
- 30:07and that Grady kept saying, get the fuck out, you son of a
- 30:11bitch. Then came four shots. He was the person who discovered Grady's body
- 30:15and he saw Chris leave the trailer after the shots were heard. During the
- 30:21witness testimony. Chris was described as seeming to be bored with the whole ordeal.
- 30:26I've been in court, yeah, and I've been bored too, but
- 30:30not with my own murder trial. Yeah. Medical examiner was called to testify
- 30:33and said that Grady was shot three times. Two shots were fatal. Either
- 30:37one of them could have been the kill shot. One of the bullets went
- 30:40straight through the brainstem and hid the base of his skull. The third bullet
- 30:44entered and chipped the skull and exited. Testimony throughout the trial only took about
- 30:48a day and a half. The jury hung on to every word from the
- 30:52prosecution's mouth, throwing closing arguments, and they deliberated for six hours. That's
- 30:56not good for Chris. On January twentieth, think ninety four, Chris,
- 31:00who was originally charged with first degree murder, was found guilty of second degree
- 31:04murder with a firearm in conspiracy to commit first degree murder. He was sentenced
- 31:10to twenty seven years in prison for his crime. Next trial was the main
- 31:14event the trial for Mary. Mary's attorney filed for a speedy trial, but
- 31:18what he didn't know was that Judge Fleischer her schedule was full for the next
- 31:23ninety dies, and she was supposedly the judge that was sympathetic to a speedy
- 31:30trial. They got a different judge, didn't they. Yep, they got
- 31:32a different judge. It was Judge m William Grayville, and he was known
- 31:37to be a real hard ass. During her trial, Mary cried quietly at
- 31:41the defense table. The prosecutor was Ron Haines. He presented a very similar
- 31:48case as he did with Chris, and Chris was called to the stand to
- 31:51testify against Mary. Oh wow, I know, he told why he only
- 31:56got twenty seven? He told the jury he was brought into the plan that
- 32:00Mary and Glenn had already cooked up. He went through with the murder while
- 32:05being high. This was a new detail in Mary's defense. Team did everything
- 32:08they possibly could to poke holes in the new alleged story. The state rested
- 32:14and it was time for the defense to make their case. Since the matter
- 32:16if you're high or not, I not diminished capacity. Of course, you
- 32:21know what you're doing. People are high out there, not mean Yeah,
- 32:27maybe he had to get high in order to do it. I don't know.
- 32:30Since Judge Fleischer had allowed the battered wife's defense that didn't mean that Judge
- 32:36Graybill was going to Mary first had to testify. For that to be admitted
- 32:40as a defense, she had to first admit that she arranged the killing and
- 32:45feared for her life. Mary said she couldn't fully recall specifics of what happened
- 32:50leading up to the murder. This was a problem because an order for the
- 32:52judge to rule the self defense, you know this battered wife syndrome, she
- 32:57had to describe in detail when she went through. Her attorney mentioned in a
- 33:00statement to the media that Mary's memory it had returned. Yeah, it's back,
- 33:06but it was because of trauma that she failed to recall that. The
- 33:10following day, Judge Graybell stated battered wife syndrome could not be used. Arnold
- 33:19Levine, her lawyer, now had to prove that Mary was in imminent danger.
- 33:22The defense called Harry Newman Senior, which was Glenn's dad, which was
- 33:28the smallest man, the world's smallest man. Yes. He told a jury
- 33:31that he had known Grady for over thirty years during their time working together in
- 33:36the carnival shows. He went on to say that Mary called him after Grady
- 33:40had thrown her out of the house one night and when he picked her up,
- 33:44she was covered in black and blue bruises from head to toe. He
- 33:46talked about how he and Mary wed after Grady and her got divorced. While
- 33:52the two of them were married, Mary's children with Grady lived with their father,
- 33:55and when she would try to send them stuff, he would send everything
- 33:59back. But you just said the word imminent, right, Yeah, and
- 34:04we know what that means as lawyers. Yes, immediate, immediate, instant,
- 34:08Yeah, when the murder happened, Yeah, she had been in immediate
- 34:12danger. Lastly, Newman told a jury about the time that Grady pulled out
- 34:16a sowd off shotgun and put it to Mary's head. Not only did he
- 34:21put the gun to her head, but he also hit her with the gun
- 34:23and tried to sexually assault her with the shotgun. Neighbors testified were Mary during
- 34:29her trial and said they would hear blood curdling screams coming from the Style's home
- 34:32on occasion. It was no secret that Greedy was a very abusive alcoholic,
- 34:37and he mistreated his family on a regular basis. He used his upper body
- 34:42strength to throw himself on the floor and would use his claw like fingers as
- 34:45weapons to choke slam and beat his family. He would target skin and eyes
- 34:51since his claws would tear right through them. Oh Man. Mary took the
- 34:53stand to testify on her own behalf. She has to yeah. She spoke
- 34:58about her previous home life before she ran away to join the carnival. She
- 35:02then spoke about how badly she was assaulted by Grady when they were first married.
- 35:07He hit her in the face so badly that oliver teeth broke. He
- 35:10would pour I know, he would pour steaming hot coffee on her. He
- 35:15walked from the Yeah, she should. He walked her around with a knife
- 35:20in her back, and he knocked her down the stairs while she was pregnant
- 35:22with one of their children. She talked about how badly Grady beat their children.
- 35:27She told the jury about how he ripped out her audd and that she
- 35:31was bleeding heaven when he threw her out of the house. Mary was questioned
- 35:36about if she had ever called the police when she and the children were abused,
- 35:39and she told a jury that when she called the police, they said,
- 35:42this is a domestic problem. I'm sure if you talk it over everything'll
- 35:45be fine, okay, and they left. Grady used to tell her I
- 35:49got away with murder once before. Yeah, I mean that in and of
- 35:52itself. It's scary. It's like I could get away with it again,
- 35:58not if I kill you first. Mary said she had a handwritten will because
- 36:01she thought that Grady was going to definitely kill her. She wanted everything to
- 36:06be in order for when she was finally murdered at his hands. Her daughter
- 36:09Cathy held the will for her just in case. The prosecution cross examined Mary
- 36:15and grilled her about her money, previous marriages, and the murder. Kathy
- 36:19was called to the stand to testify for her mother. The defense put up
- 36:22a great defense, but when all was said and done, Mary was convicted
- 36:25and knew it. Yeah, she had to be right right of manslaughter and
- 36:30conspiracy to commit murder, and she was sentenced to twelve years in prison.
- 36:36Glenn, it's not too bad. No. Glenn was convicted of first degree
- 36:39murder along with conspiracy to commit murder. I remember, and Chris the shooter
- 36:44was only convicted of a second degree he was sentenced. Glenn, her son
- 36:49was sentenced to life in prison with an extra twelve years added to his term.
- 36:53Oh if I was Mary Man When Grady died, the little tidbit about
- 37:00Grady before I'm done with the story. When he died, he was so
- 37:05disliked the funeral home couldn't find one person willing to be a pall bearer.
- 37:09Wow, I mean not one person. They're like, fuck you. Nope.
- 37:15Mary was released from prison in the year two thousand and she went back
- 37:20to her life in Gibsonton, Florida. Since her release, she wanted to
- 37:23stay out of the public eye, and her current whereabouts are unknown. Chris
- 37:28was released in two thousand and nine, and he also has been living off
- 37:31the radar. I'm not sure where he's at. His whereabouts are unknown.
- 37:35And unfortunately, Glenn died while in prison in twenty fourteen. Yeah, could
- 37:39have been that old. Couldn't have been that old? Wow, my sad,
- 37:44sad story. I don't even know what the fuck to say about this
- 37:46crazy stuff? Wild? Right the hell? What lots of twists and turns
- 37:52in that story? Hell, he thought it was just gonna be about one
- 37:57murder. Nope, it's about murder. I'm the murderer. I don't even
- 38:00know. I don't even know to say about the crazy twists and turns.
- 38:04I know it's wild. Thank you, to Lea for listening, and thank
- 38:07you everyone for joining us this week. Yes, if you haven't already subscribe,
- 38:12please hit that subscribe, follow and like us whatever, yeah, whatever
- 38:16it is, we don't know, do it all, just do it.
- 38:20Just do it. It's you know, it takes you like a millisecond.
- 38:22Yeah, and you can write a nice review somewhere too, not a bad
- 38:24one, yeah, because we'll fuck with you. We'll do a review,
- 38:29the fucking review, I know, right, we haven't done one in a
- 38:31while. We have to dig through them and see what we can come up
- 38:35with. We are on social media at Hardcore True Crime on Facebook and Instagram.
- 38:39And if you would like even more more stories from us, you can
- 38:45join our Patreon yep, it is patreon dot com, slash t NT crimes
- 38:51like Dynamite like Dynamite t NT. Or you can go to Apple Podcasts if
- 38:55that's where you listen, and you can subscribe there. It's the same episode
- 39:00yep, what else And if you subscribe, not only do you get extra
- 39:04episodes, but you get the weekly ones early at lease and ad free free.
- 39:08So check it out. Yeah, we have a website, crumbs consequence
- 39:12dot com. Yeah, take a gander, at that. Take a gander
- 39:15at who the fuck says I don't know my grandma. I don't know.
- 39:17I'm like god, I'm getting take a gander at that, so I don't
- 39:23know. This is all poppy cock getting old. So until our next episode,
- 39:30don't kill each other. Bye Bye,