Latest / Serves You Right / #39 Edward Slingerland: Why Society Needs Alcohol More Than You Think
Transcript
- 0:01Why is it that we even feel the need to get intoxicated?
- 0:05A question that I never thought we needed to ask until recently.
- 0:10Today I got to sit down and talk to Edward Slingerland, author of
- 0:13the book Drunk, How We Sipped, Danced, and Stumbled Our Way
- 0:18Into Civilization. We get to talk about why alcohol
- 0:22is possibly more than just a cultural indulgence.
- 0:27Together, we discover why drinking helps us bypass the
- 0:29brains control centers, how it has fueled creativity across
- 0:33civilizations, and so much more, including the dangers that
- 0:37distilled liquor pros and the rise of cannabis expect.
- 0:41To learn how alcohol unlocks creativity and connection in
- 0:45ways science is only starting to understand.
- 0:48Why Prohibition may have been doomed from the beginning, and
- 0:51the dark evolutionary twists that make liquor both
- 0:54indispensable, dangerous and, dare I say, delicious.
- 0:59Thank you for listening to Serves You Right.
- 1:01Without any further ado, here's Edward Slingerland.
- 1:10So, yeah, thanks for taking a moment and joining me today.
- 1:14I really appreciate it. Yeah, I started reading and
- 1:17trying not to try it too. So I know we're talking about
- 1:20drugs, but hey, I like, I am really enjoying it.
- 1:23It's wuwei like, yeah, yeah. You've got a couple of concepts
- 1:28that are like, I didn't even realize I was missing these
- 1:31ideas from my vocabulary. And now this is like it's right
- 1:36there and I see it the more I'm going around.
- 1:38Yeah, yeah, I know. That's like I say in the book,
- 1:40yeah, you know, my people, I know all all start using wuwei
- 1:44because it's clearly feeling a semantic space that we needed to
- 1:49have filled. So.
- 1:52And it helps you, and it does. Having a word for it helps you
- 1:54notice it. Yeah.
- 1:55And I think you said it was like schadenfreude, like, no one
- 1:58needs to have that concept explained.
- 2:00But once you hear it, you're like, Oh yes, yes, I've got it.
- 2:04And you and then you notice it more, right?
- 2:06Yeah. Everywhere, Yeah.
- 2:08How does someone who is versed in Eastern philosophy end up
- 2:12writing a book about alcohol? That's where I thought I might
- 2:15begin. Yeah, my colleagues wonder that
- 2:19too. It actually it's it's there's a
- 2:23Direct Line between the the themes I'm looking at drunk in
- 2:28my previous research. So 1 is this my academic work
- 2:34and Chinese philosophy, especially my early work focused
- 2:37on this concept of way or effortless action.
- 2:41This this idea of, you know, you want to get into the state where
- 2:44you're spontaneous, everything's coming naturally.
- 2:47You're not thinking about what you're doing, you're just
- 2:49relaxed. And, and when you can get to
- 2:51that state, they think you had this kind of charisma and
- 2:53everything works out well and you're successful.
- 2:57But the problem is as the the title of the, the trade book I
- 3:01wrote about this topic. Yeah.
- 3:03The paradox is how do you try not to try?
- 3:05There's this book trying not to try.
- 3:08There's this paradox involved in consciously trying to relax.
- 3:14If I tell you to relax, the part of your brain I'm activating is
- 3:19actually the part we're trying to shut down.
- 3:21So it's like if I say don't think of a white bear, you've
- 3:24now thought of a white bear. I've activated the concept.
- 3:27Instantaneously. So there's a direct.
- 3:28Yeah. So there's a, there's actually a
- 3:30direct paradox in, in trying to relax.
- 3:34And the early Chinese philosophers came up with the
- 3:37various types of tricks to kind of get around it.
- 3:40So do this ritual, you know, do ritual things, and eventually
- 3:45you'll forget about what you're doing, You know, natural
- 3:48meditate. They seem to be using meditation
- 3:50practices. But at one point, there's a
- 3:53passage in one of these Taoist texts where they compare a
- 3:56drunken person to someone who's in the state of Huawei.
- 4:00And it's clearly meant in that passage as an analogy.
- 4:04But that made me think it's actually kind of close.
- 4:09And it made me start thinking that maybe alcohol is a
- 4:14chemical, is a cultural technology we've developed to
- 4:18get around the paradox of trying not to try.
- 4:22So you're on a first date and I'm you're about to go out and
- 4:26I'm your roommate. And I say be relaxed, don't try
- 4:29too hard. That's not going to help.
- 4:32But if you go to the date and you start by having a glass of
- 4:37wine, that alcohol is going into your brain and doing what we
- 4:43want to get you into a state of spontaneity.
- 4:45It's down regulating your prefrontal cortex, cognate
- 4:48control centers. It's boosting these kind of
- 4:51relaxation and feel good chemicals in your body.
- 4:55So it's a kind of chemical trick that helps you get around the
- 4:58paradox of how do you try not to try.
- 5:01It's a tool for getting us into the state of spontaneity or
- 5:06relaxation. So that's a direct connection.
- 5:10And then the other connections from another line of my
- 5:13research, which is I think it was kind of looking at mysteries
- 5:17that are hiding in plain sight. So things that people, everyone
- 5:22does, we've been doing them forever.
- 5:25You show up in a new place and people are doing it, and you're
- 5:28like, yeah, of course. You don't even think about it.
- 5:30It's just of course people do it.
- 5:32Religion is one of those things, right?
- 5:34Everywhere you go, you see people worshipping invisible
- 5:37beings and sacrificing stuff to them and building huge monuments
- 5:41that have no use except to, you know, glorify these beings.
- 5:46And no one's ever, you know, I have a PhD in religious studies,
- 5:51so I study this stuff professionally.
- 5:53But we tend to talk about the variety of these practices and
- 5:57beliefs and not necessarily talk about like, well, why do people
- 6:01do this in the 1st place? Because it's puzzling, right?
- 6:04So it's, I'm interested in costly behavior that seems to
- 6:10have no practical purpose. And religion is the first of
- 6:13those things I I was interested in and what my, you know, people
- 6:19have argued this in the past, but my colleagues and I
- 6:21developed it into a kind of more rigorous, empirically validated
- 6:27model of just the functions of religion.
- 6:29So why these things actually have social functions,
- 6:32individual level functions that help them survive.
- 6:35And I started to think that maybe chemical intoxicants in
- 6:39general, but alcohol in particular is one of these
- 6:43things. It's one of these costly things
- 6:46that is surprising we do it. But probably it's because it has
- 6:51these functions that are they're paying for it.
- 6:54So what are those functions? And that's basically what drunk
- 6:57is about is trying to explore. Well, given how costly alcohol
- 7:02is physiologically, socially, economically, why is it that
- 7:08we've been doing it forever? Yeah, yeah.
- 7:11And you know, as as you're talking about that, I was kind
- 7:15of thinking on the face of it, I always like to imagine aliens
- 7:18coming down and seeing us as a third perspective.
- 7:21And you say, you know, you, you look at these beings that are in
- 7:26love with being rational and productive.
- 7:30And that is true 80% of the time.
- 7:32They're doing a great job. They have organization and
- 7:35order, except for Friday, Saturday.
- 7:37And on those days they like to go out and they like to down
- 7:41regulate these parts of the brain, make mistakes, use a
- 7:44substance that makes them feel horrible the next day and is
- 7:47highly addictive. You're like, you're like, OK,
- 7:49there's, there is a paradox here.
- 7:51The same way I was like, it's a society that is, you know,
- 7:55convinced of law and order and proof and evidence, and they're
- 7:58in love with the scientific method.
- 7:59But about 50 to 60% of them every Sunday go and worship a
- 8:03being that they can't see. And yeah, it's like, OK, sure.
- 8:09Yeah. So that's the when you when you
- 8:11adopt an evolutionary perspective and look at human
- 8:13behavior, it gives you that alien perspective.
- 8:16So kind of from the outside what doesn't make sense and both
- 8:22intoxicant use and religion don't make sense unless you
- 8:27start to dig into what what the possible functions.
- 8:30And, and as you dig in, I, I wanted to pull up a quote that I
- 8:34found here. It was surprising to me.
- 8:41Yeah. So we we forget how ubiquitous
- 8:45it is, but you, you put in the book, alcohol is by far the most
- 8:50widely and abundantly consumed psychoactive agent in the world.
- 8:53Current estimates place the number of active consumers at
- 8:56over 2.4 billion people. And that's just alcohol.
- 9:02And, you know, you find all these other substances,
- 9:05everything from marijuana is the cava, I believe it was called
- 9:08for some of the like island societies.
- 9:14Yeah. Everyone finds some way to down
- 9:16regulate this at some point. It it's it seems to be not a
- 9:21bug, but a feature of who we are.
- 9:23Yeah. Yeah.
- 9:24So. Yeah, especially, you know, the
- 9:26Kava case is interesting because it's it's probably the case that
- 9:31my colleague Joe Henrik has a theory that they don't use
- 9:35alcohol in this part of Oceana because they have the reef fish
- 9:40there have a poison, singuiterra that comes from this allergy,
- 9:44toxic algae. And alcohol and singuiterra
- 9:49interact in a really bad way. So he thinks it's kind of a
- 9:52cultural adaptation that they don't use alcohol because of
- 9:56this, this danger from singuiterra.
- 9:59But it's interesting. They don't have alcohol.
- 10:01So they invent this kind of completely weird.
- 10:04They they chew this tuber and spit it into a bowl and let it
- 10:08ferment. And that's what they use because
- 10:11you need an intoxicant. So like in places where they
- 10:14don't have alcohol, they go to elaborate extents to figure out,
- 10:18OK, what else in our environment can get us messed up.
- 10:23So so it really suggests there's this ecological niche that needs
- 10:26to get filled and if alcohol's not there to fill it, people
- 10:30find something else. Yeah, yeah.
- 10:32And I mean, yeah, you, you have a lot of things.
- 10:34People licking toads. There's people are always going
- 10:38to find a way. Yeah.
- 10:39Yeah, yeah. No, I you know what I do like
- 10:43too. And I think that we should touch
- 10:45on the the way you approach alcohol use too.
- 10:49You're addressing a couple of the common theories of why
- 10:52alcohol may have hung around and may still be around, like the
- 10:55hangover theories. And I like that you slowly kind
- 10:59of disentangle those and say, I don't think that these really
- 11:03have a lot of weight. It seems like it's it's
- 11:07necessary. Do you do you mind touching on
- 11:08those a little bit and kind of explaining some of the?
- 11:12Yeah, so the, so the standard scientific story about why we
- 11:17consume, let's just talk about alcohol is is the hijack.
- 11:23They're all evolutionary mistake stories.
- 11:25The dominant 1 is the hijack story.
- 11:27So the hijack story is just ethanol happens to trigger a
- 11:32reward network in our brain. We figured that out, and so we
- 11:37pull the trigger as often as we can.
- 11:38So there's no good, there's no reason there's a connection
- 11:41between alcohol consumption and the reward.
- 11:44It's just some some trick. Kind of compare it to Twinkies
- 11:47and porn which I think is funny. No, no, actually, it's not like
- 11:50Twinkies. It's like, it's like porn.
- 11:52So, so, so, so masturbation or porn is a classic hijack, right?
- 11:59The orgasm is meant to be a reward for doing this really
- 12:02important evolutionary thing, which is getting copies of your
- 12:05genes into the next generation. But humans and other animals
- 12:09have figured out you can get it. You can get it lots of other
- 12:12ways, right? Wildly non reproductive ways.
- 12:17But in that case, it's evolution, you know, to
- 12:21personify evolution because it's easier to talk in intentional
- 12:24terms. It lets us get away with it
- 12:26because it's not costly, and the the reward thing works well
- 12:33enough that we're here to talk about it enough.
- 12:35Reproductive sex somehow still happens that the system works.
- 12:40Twinkies are an example of a mismatch.
- 12:43It's a different type of evolutionary mistake.
- 12:47Mismatch. Yeah.
- 12:49In a mismatch, it was adaptive at some point.
- 12:53So in the hijack, it was never adaptive.
- 12:55It's always been a mistake in the mismatch.
- 12:57It was adaptive in our evolutionary past, but it's not
- 13:00anymore. And so this taste we have for
- 13:03sugar and, you know, fat and all the things that are bad for us,
- 13:10that that actually was an adaptive taste back in our
- 13:13evolutionary history, because getting enough sugar and fat was
- 13:16always a problem. And so if you came across that
- 13:20kind of stuff, you should eat as much of it as possible.
- 13:23So it for most of our history as a species, that connection made
- 13:28sense. And it's only recently.
- 13:30We're industrialized societies, we have Twinkies and all this
- 13:34junk food and we have enough wealth that we can eat as much
- 13:36as we want. Then it becomes a problem.
- 13:40And so there have been mismatch theories about alcohol.
- 13:44So again, the dominant theory was just pure mistake, pure
- 13:47hijack. But there's this guy Dudley at
- 13:52UC Berkeley who had the called it the drunken monkey hypothesis
- 13:57that actually we developed this taste for alcohol because it was
- 14:01associated with fermented fruit and we could Ethanol is a pretty
- 14:06light molecule, so it travels long distances.
- 14:09You can. Basically you can smell it from
- 14:11far away. If you've ever been to a
- 14:12distillery or a brewery, yeah, for sure.
- 14:14Yeah, you can, You know that, you know that you can smell it
- 14:16for miles away, right. So, so his theory is that you
- 14:21could it was, he calls it at one point the dinner gong of the
- 14:25jungle. So we would be able to smell
- 14:27ethanol from a distance and track it down.
- 14:30And it tends to be associated with high calorie payouts.
- 14:34So a piece of fermented fruit has got a lot of calories.
- 14:37It's a nice, nice little package of calories for a primate.
- 14:41So he thinks we developed the stage for alcohol to adapt to
- 14:45eating fallen fruit on the jungle floor.
- 14:48And then it just becomes, you know, a problem.
- 14:51And again, in the modern world when we have, you know, it's
- 14:54gets fermented into these dangerous substances.
- 14:58So that's one theory. There's The Dirty water
- 15:00hypothesis that, you know, we didn't understand the connection
- 15:05of, you know, don't have your latrine next to the stream that
- 15:09you're drinking out of. And so water often was
- 15:11contaminated. If you take contaminated water
- 15:14and you ferment it into beer, it becomes potable.
- 15:19You can drink it. So that was a very prominent
- 15:24theory. The problem with that one, as I
- 15:26point out in the book, is that the other way to make water
- 15:28potable is just to boil it. And you have lots of people who
- 15:33boil water still drink alcohol and it's a lot easier to boil it
- 15:37than just then go through like ferment making beer, which is
- 15:41actually a multi step very difficult process.
- 15:44So yeah, I go in the book, these all may be playing some role.
- 15:48It's possible. Another theory, the the
- 15:52micronutrient theory is that when you take grain and ferment
- 15:58it into beer, the yeast had some micronutrients to it.
- 16:03So you get some vitamin B and some other stuff from beer that
- 16:07you wouldn't get from the same grain made into bread.
- 16:10And so some people have argued this is how the the people who
- 16:14were working on the pyramids survived because they were
- 16:17eating basically just plain bread.
- 16:19They didn't have a lot of vegetables or fruit, but they
- 16:23were also drinking beer. So maybe they were getting some
- 16:26micronutrients from the beer. And these all, I argue these all
- 16:29could have played some role, but there's no way any one of them
- 16:34is a complete explanation because there are other ways to
- 16:38get the same functions without the harm.
- 16:41So if you want micronutrients, you make a porridge or make a
- 16:44yogurt, you get the same functions without that, without
- 16:47the hangover. So yeah.
- 16:50So it's I think it's important to to kind of carefully walk
- 16:53through and debunk all of these alternative explanations.
- 16:57And if all these evolutionary explanations were true, as the
- 17:03modern world came around, as prohibition started to gain
- 17:07hold, we should have, you know, we needed it up until this
- 17:10point. But now we have the clean water.
- 17:12Now we have, you know, the the like we have the vegetables.
- 17:15We are we are good to go. You know, famously and
- 17:19historically, prohibition was not a great success.
- 17:22It, it did not go over well. Yeah.
- 17:26Yeah, yeah. So it, yeah, it doesn't explain.
- 17:29It also has trouble explaining the continued practice in the
- 17:33face of lots of resistance and an increasing awareness of the
- 17:38dangers of alcohol. We still turn to it even though
- 17:42I can pop a vitamin B supplement.
- 17:44Sure, if that's what you were looking for.
- 17:46Yeah, easier ways. So you you describe us searching
- 17:53after three CS you search we're basically we have a need to be
- 17:58creative, cultural and communal. Do you mind talking about those
- 18:01a little bit about how intoxicants fit into that mold?
- 18:07So yeah, so humans, other animals seem to get pleasure
- 18:12from from ethanol. So, you know, birds will seek it
- 18:15out, primates will seek it out. Humans are the only species that
- 18:21dedicates a significant amount of time and effort to carefully
- 18:24producing alcohol and making sure it's available.
- 18:27And one of my arguments is that's we need it as a tool
- 18:31because we're a weird kind of species.
- 18:33So we're a primate, but we our closest relatives are
- 18:38chimpanzees. They live in these small bands
- 18:42of mostly related people. They have some they're they're
- 18:46mostly all related genetically. They have some outsiders maybe
- 18:50who are part of their group, but it's a pretty small group.
- 18:53If they meet strangers, they kill them.
- 18:58You know they're not. They don't.
- 18:59They don't get along well with others.
- 19:01Which nowadays is not too far from some some groups on
- 19:04Twitter, but you know. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 19:07We've progressed a little possibly, but.
- 19:09Well, and, but that's very much still a part of our psychology.
- 19:12I mean, we are, we are chimpanzees at some level, but
- 19:17we've been domesticated by evolution in various ways.
- 19:21And some of those are genetic. So, you know, we've changed our,
- 19:24you know, we, there's, we look, we kind of, I call us the
- 19:28Labradors of the primate world because we, we look a bit like
- 19:31domesticated dogs just biologically we have neonatal
- 19:36features that make us look like, more like puppies than wolves.
- 19:41But some of them are cultural practices.
- 19:43And so I, I argue, there's this bunch of cultural practices we
- 19:47use to kind of figure out the trick of how you get primates
- 19:51who are selfish, want to favor their relatives, want to be
- 19:54aggressive to outsiders. How do you get them to live in
- 19:57large scale societies? Because if you look around at
- 20:00large scale societies, we're cooperating with strangers all
- 20:05the time and and usually strangers, often strangers we're
- 20:08never going to see again. We're incredibly friendly to
- 20:12outsiders. We were incredibly cooperative
- 20:16to people in the culture we live in who we've never met.
- 20:19How does that work? How did we make that transition
- 20:22from kind of small hunter gatherer lifestyle where we
- 20:26we're not that different from the way we lived as Japan, you
- 20:29know, chimpanzee relatives to living in New York or Cambridge,
- 20:34MA religions part of that answer so that we create these kind of
- 20:41fake communities through religion.
- 20:43We bond in various ways to ritual practices.
- 20:46But I argued that, you know, alcohol is one of these things
- 20:52that helps us become communal and cooperative.
- 20:55So we we face these cooperation dilemmas where the only way to
- 21:01really succeed is to trust another person.
- 21:04So these are economists call these prisoner dilemmas where
- 21:09you and I, we're going to get the best deal if we both
- 21:13cooperate, but I'm vulnerable to you defecting and kind of
- 21:18ratting me out. And so the only in prisoner's
- 21:22dilemmas, the only rational strategy is for me to rat you
- 21:25out first before you rat me out. And then we both get kind of not
- 21:29very good payouts. Humans actually solve prisoner's
- 21:32dilemmas in real life all the time.
- 21:34We trust each other even when we're vulnerable, trusting each
- 21:37other all the time. And one way we do that is
- 21:40alcohol. So, you know, alcohol has these
- 21:43functions. It's the two main ones I focus
- 21:45on are the down regulation of the prefrontal cortex.
- 21:50That's the the part of your brain that's in charge of
- 21:54cognitive control, suppressing things you don't want to do that
- 22:00are automatic, staying focused on task, being goal, thinking
- 22:06about future rewards outweighing present rewards.
- 22:10And it's a really important part of being a functioning adult is
- 22:14to have APFC. But it also can it's the thing
- 22:18that makes you defect in the, the prisoner's dilemma.
- 22:20You know, if you're being completely rational, you're
- 22:23going to defect. If if you can turn that down a
- 22:26little bit, you, you become a little less rational.
- 22:30You also are less able to lie. So I'm less able to trick you
- 22:35into thinking that I'm trustworthy when I'm not.
- 22:39I'm also getting these chemicals flooding my brain that make me
- 22:44less inclined to want to cheat you.
- 22:47Suddenly I really like you and I feel good about you.
- 22:50I feel good about myself. We get these endorphins and
- 22:52serotonin boosts from consuming ethanol.
- 22:57So, so the communal and cultural part you think about when people
- 23:01get together and have to make an agreement or just learn to get
- 23:06to know each other, learn to trust each other, the alcohol
- 23:10comes out and that's because people consciously are not are
- 23:15aware that it helps overcome barriers and get gets people to
- 23:19bond. And I and I talk about some good
- 23:22experimental evidence that that this is the case.
- 23:26And then the creative part. So we the other weird thing
- 23:29about us as a species is that we're completely dependent on
- 23:33technology. So humans could literally could
- 23:36not survive without technology. We biologically adapted.
- 23:40So our jaws and our teeth and even our our digestive system
- 23:45has adapted to eating cooked. Food we need.
- 23:48Fire, so we couldn't live. We need fire.
- 23:51And fire's a technology, right? You're not.
- 23:54A baby isn't born knowing how to make a fire.
- 23:58So we've actually biologically adapted to technology.
- 24:01And it's not just fire. We're completely dependent on
- 24:04tools for catching prey and for farming and doing all the things
- 24:08we do. And that means we're dependent
- 24:10on innovation because the environment's changing, probably
- 24:15more relevant, other groups are getting better technologies and
- 24:20we're competing with them for the same resources.
- 24:23And so there's a pressure on humans to be creative in a way
- 24:27there isn't with regard to any other species.
- 24:30You know, lions aren't like brainstorming.
- 24:33That's a better way to catch a gazelle.
- 24:34You know, just, they just do it the same way their ancestors did
- 24:37it. And so the the problem there
- 24:41again is the Pfc. So the prefrontal cortex is very
- 24:45good at A to B to C logical reasoning.
- 24:50There's good experimental evidence that it gets in the way
- 24:53of creative insights. So connecting A-Z, the brain,
- 24:59the pre FC gets in the way of us doing that.
- 25:03And This is why kids are really creative.
- 25:05So I talked about this child development worth showing that
- 25:07kids are super creative and we get less creative as we age.
- 25:12And I lay on top of this, our our declining ability to solve
- 25:17these creativity tasks matches exactly the maturation of the
- 25:21prefrontal cortex. So by the time we're in our mid
- 25:2320's, the PFCS fully developed and we suck at these kind of
- 25:27creative insight tasks. But the other The problem with
- 25:32kids is that they're not. They can't put their shoes on,
- 25:34Yeah. They can't put their shoes on.
- 25:37They invent stupid stuff that isn't useful.
- 25:41So the ideal solution to that problem would be make your mind
- 25:45childlike temporarily for a couple hours, come up with some
- 25:50great ideas, and then be an adult again so you can actually
- 25:54put those ideas into practice. And, and I argue that's
- 25:57basically what alcohol is doing. It's down regulating the Pfc.
- 26:01It's making us temporarily more creative again, the way we were
- 26:04when we were kids. But then we're still adults and
- 26:08we actually know what a good idea is.
- 26:10What's a bad idea? We know actually what the
- 26:12problem is that we want to solve.
- 26:14And so it's in This is why alcohol, I argue, has been
- 26:19associated with poets and artists and creative people in
- 26:23every culture I know of around the world, because there's, it
- 26:28makes perfect sense. There's a there's a huge
- 26:30experimental literature on Pfc and creativity.
- 26:34The the connection's very clear Pfc is bad for creativity.
- 26:38There's only one study that directly is using alcohol to
- 26:42enhance creativity, but it showed that if you get people to
- 26:46point O 8 BAC, so about two beers in, they do better on
- 26:52creativity tasks than than people who are sober.
- 26:55So. So there's some experimental,
- 26:57direct experimental. Evidence for this, which you
- 26:59have to presume is probably due to the difficulty of getting
- 27:03approved to bring. Subjects in it's 100.
- 27:06It's 100% due to that. I've tried to do, yeah, I tried
- 27:10to do a wine tasting study way back in the day on a different,
- 27:13more about taste, kind of how taste works.
- 27:17And we gave up after like a year of trying to get IRB approval.
- 27:20It's just really hard. So that's the that's one of the
- 27:22reasons. If you've been enjoying this so
- 27:29far, please take a moment hit that like button, subscribe,
- 27:33share with a friend. It being the world to me.
- 27:36All right, that's enough back to the talk.
- 27:46The whole thing that you just just walked us down.
- 27:50And so that is the central, like, I love the way you framed
- 27:54the ideas, Apollo versus Dionysus.
- 27:57I feel like that is the core of it.
- 27:59You know, an ancient Greek idea we have Apollo, the God of
- 28:04rationality and purpose and the prefrontal cortex, you could
- 28:07say, kind of guiding everything versus Dionysus, that wild
- 28:13connecting creative force that also has a dark side.
- 28:16And but it it, it's there. Yeah.
- 28:20I think I yeah, it was Nietzsche too that said that that it had
- 28:24that famous connection too, if I remember correctly.
- 28:27Yeah, yeah. He revived.
- 28:29He thought the Greeks were very wise and kind of seeing this
- 28:32dichotomy between Apollo and Dionysus, and he thought that
- 28:38his society was not celebrating Dionysus enough.
- 28:41So he's trying to revive one way to look at Nietzschean
- 28:45philosophy is trying to revive Dionysianism.
- 28:49Yeah, yeah, yeah. But yeah, you need both.
- 28:51And the Greeks were aware that you needed both.
- 28:55And they're also, you know, they're a little scared of
- 28:57Dionysis. Oh yeah, he was.
- 28:59Yeah, they. Worshipped him, but he had a
- 29:01dark. Side yeah, I mean, yeah, Oedipus
- 29:04the the bacchanal, they RIP apart someone and it yeah, they
- 29:09they were not afraid to represent the negative sides of
- 29:12anything. Yeah, yeah.
- 29:15Yeah, I think that's that's actually a good segue because I,
- 29:18I do appreciate that even though you have a thesis and you really
- 29:22investigate and really flesh out the positive aspects of alcohol
- 29:27that you don't shy away from what is undeniably some of the
- 29:30darker sides of intoxicants. Yeah.
- 29:34You know, there is an addictive nature to a lot of mind altering
- 29:39substances that just does exist in part and parcel.
- 29:43And you know, going back to the evolutionary mismatch, we do
- 29:48have distillation now and that that is a step change in
- 29:52intoxication. Yeah.
- 29:54Yeah, it's a complete game changer.
- 29:57So yeah, that's one of my arguments.
- 29:58So I, you know, I talked about there's always been these dark
- 30:01sides, alcohol. Every culture I know of that
- 30:05uses it is also worried about these problems.
- 30:08So no, culture doesn't use alcohol.
- 30:12No, culture doesn't flirt with prohibition beliefs
- 30:15occasionally, right? Because they're aware that it's
- 30:17a dangerous thing. But two things have happened
- 30:22really recently, especially in the story I'm telling, a story
- 30:26that started 10 million years ago with these primate
- 30:28ancestors. This is yesterday.
- 30:33Distillation and isolation. Yeah, distillation.
- 30:37You know, alcohols always come with this built in safety
- 30:39feature, which is that natural fermentation can only get you up
- 30:43to whatever. I mean, historically we probably
- 30:46were drinking 2 or 3% ABV beers. Oh yeah, and maybe slightly
- 30:51stronger free wines. Maybe meat every once in a
- 30:55while, but you have to find the honey first, yeah?
- 30:58You have to find the honey and even that can't get very high.
- 31:01So there's a limit because you know, the yeast are producing
- 31:05alcohol, ethanol as a biological warfare weapon against bacteria.
- 31:12So they both, they both want this piece of fruit and the
- 31:16yeast get in there and start making alcohol, turning the
- 31:18sugar into alcohol to kill the bacteria because they can take
- 31:22it and the bacteria can't, but they can only take it up to a
- 31:26point. And so once you get up to about,
- 31:29you know, whatever yeast we've developed these yeast that are
- 31:32super Hardy because we want more and more alcohol.
- 31:34So we, we've pushed them up to about 16% ABV.
- 31:38That's kind of the record of what a yeast can.
- 31:40Survive Australian schiraz or something like Napa calves?
- 31:43Essentially, yeah. Super hot, hot climate, Red wine
- 31:47can get that high, but that's it, you know, you can't get
- 31:51higher than that. And that's what we've been stuck
- 31:54with that stuck with it. But it's a safety feature.
- 31:57It means that beers and wines aren't going to be too
- 31:59dangerously alcoholic. But with distillation, we
- 32:03completely disable that safety feature.
- 32:05And we, you know, we pull the alcohol out and concentrate it
- 32:09and then you can get, you know, 90 something percent ABV gins
- 32:13and vodkas. And, and I get in the book
- 32:16that's just a completely different drug.
- 32:18Even though it's still ethanol, it's in such a powerful form
- 32:23that when it hits our brain body system, all the natural defenses
- 32:28we have just are completely overwhelmed.
- 32:31And so, so just distilled liquors are scary and really
- 32:35dangerous and then isolation. So historically, we've always
- 32:42having private access to alcohol is unheard of.
- 32:47Historically, you always drink alcohol in a public setting,
- 32:51usually very carefully, ritually controlled.
- 32:54And if you look at these rituals, they're unconsciously,
- 32:59consciously designed to limit your alcohol consumption.
- 33:03You know, you can only drink when the cup comes around and
- 33:06it's, you know, it's the symposy arc.
- 33:09The host of the wine party is watering it down or making it
- 33:13stronger or waiting if people are too drunk.
- 33:16You can only drink when someone makes a toast.
- 33:18There's all these mechanisms for regulating even informally, we
- 33:23do this, you know, when we go to a pub and we order rounds of
- 33:26drinks. If I have alcohol abuse
- 33:31tendencies and I down my beer really fast and I want another
- 33:35one, I've got to wait until everyone else is.
- 33:38Done right, Edward, You. You want another beer, huh?
- 33:41Yeah, it'd be weird for me to be like, hey, excuse me, can I get
- 33:45an interim? People would look at me and and
- 33:47I'd know that people would look at me and so it would help
- 33:50restrain me. So when we're drinking in
- 33:53public, even if we don't have traditional kind of really
- 33:57formal religious rituals around it, we have informal rituals
- 34:02that help us control our drinking.
- 34:04And what's new is the fact that you can be alone in your house
- 34:08and have the local liquor store deliver a case of tequila to
- 34:12your door. On a Tuesday.
- 34:14And you could just on a Tuesday, you could just sit in front of
- 34:17the TV and drink as much as you want.
- 34:19And that we're not designed to deal with that.
- 34:24So, so the combination of these two things has made alcohol much
- 34:29more dangerous. And, and, and again, this is a
- 34:31recent development. So this ability to have private
- 34:34access to unlimited quantities of alcohol is new.
- 34:38So, so it, it's always been dangerous, but it's gotten more
- 34:42so recently, which means we have to be even one of my arguments
- 34:47is we need to kind of reintroduce these safety
- 34:49features. So be, try to avoid distilled
- 34:53liquor and, and try not, you know, don't drink alone.
- 34:59Just try to drink and use. And so I, I holed up as a model,
- 35:03the kind of southern European drinking culture where you know,
- 35:08Italy, Spain, most of France, you only you mostly drink wine,
- 35:14wine and beer. You always drink it with a meal.
- 35:18It's always a mixed group, you know, Parents, kids, everyone's
- 35:23around the table getting drunk. Drinking to the point of getting
- 35:27visibly drunk is shameful. You know you'd be embarrassed to
- 35:32slur your words or seem drunk. And when the meal is over, the
- 35:37drinking is over, like you don't drink away from the meal table.
- 35:42And these are mostly informal rules.
- 35:44No one kind of lays them out. But if you violate them, you
- 35:48find out very quickly that you violated them, as I discovered
- 35:51with my Italian relatives. But my ex wife's Italian, we'd
- 35:54spend a lot of time there. And so these help you and
- 35:59there's good data that so you know, Italy per capita alcohol
- 36:03consumption is really high. They drink a lot of alcohol.
- 36:07Their alcoholism rates are really low.
- 36:10But you take an Italian and you move them to New Jersey.
- 36:14Put them in the suburbs next. Generation same same genes.
- 36:18They start drinking like Americans, which is the northern
- 36:22drinking culture. Drink to get drunk.
- 36:25Big groups of dudes or women on their own getting drunk is the
- 36:29point. You're kind of expected to get
- 36:33dangerously drunk and throw up or and that leads to really high
- 36:38alcoholism rates and binge drinking.
- 36:40And so we can embrace cultures that help us drink safely, as
- 36:46opposed to ones that don't. No.
- 36:49And I, I think that you're kind of blanket out what I don't know
- 36:54if I'd say condemnation, but just cautionary note about
- 36:59distilled liquor is very on point because I like to think,
- 37:03you know, equivalents a shot of whiskey, say in a glass of wine,
- 37:08roughly the same amount of alcohol.
- 37:10And you know, if you say that's a 5 oz glass of wine, you know,
- 37:14got five of those in a bottle. I can in a like course of a
- 37:18minute quickly do five shots. I wouldn't be happy about it,
- 37:21but I could. Yeah, it it would be hard to sit
- 37:24and drink a whole bottle like that is that is an hour's task,
- 37:29talking to someone over a meal And like, yeah, you have that
- 37:32natural rate limiter. You just, you can't drink wine
- 37:35that quickly, you know, beer even slower and it's a lower
- 37:38alcohol level. Yeah, beer even slower.
- 37:40So if you're, if you're drinking A2, 3% ABV beer, it's, it's
- 37:45physically almost impossible to get dangerously drunk, right,
- 37:51just because you're, it takes so long, just the volume you'd have
- 37:54to drink to get that amount of alcohol.
- 37:57And so that is, it makes it much safer.
- 37:59And that's why, you know, we read about these people building
- 38:03the pyramids. We're drinking beer all the
- 38:05time. We're like, wow, they must have
- 38:06been falling down drunk. But they didn't have, you know,
- 38:099% ABV triple IPA. They were drinking, you know,
- 38:15loggers. They were drinking 2%.
- 38:17Light loggers, essentially, yeah.
- 38:20Really light loggers. Yeah, what what they had in
- 38:22Oklahoma before they changed the low, low brew laws.
- 38:27Oh yeah, yeah. But those low brew laws, you
- 38:29know, they were annoying to kind of craft beer people, but
- 38:35they're not crazy laws, right? They they make sense.
- 38:39They do, They do. I'm also thinking, so it's
- 38:42something that I've heard and I don't have the attribution.
- 38:45I didn't know if it it would come up today, but I've heard
- 38:48that one of the biggest changes they've seen introducing kiosks
- 38:52for ordering at a fast food restaurants has been that the
- 38:57cultural sort of expectation is when you come to order and
- 39:02you're face to face with a human one person, you usually get 1
- 39:06hamburger. And one of the biggest changes
- 39:08they've seen when you don't have to face the social stigma
- 39:13ordering from a human is a lot of our larger like citizens are
- 39:18ordering two or more hamburgers. And so there is this unspoken
- 39:23power when you're dealing with human beings watching what you
- 39:25do, that this is a way we do things and you do it, even if
- 39:29you couldn't consciously point to that.
- 39:32When you remove the human, there it is.
- 39:34You know that's. A great example, yeah.
- 39:36Yeah, that's a really good example.
- 39:38I think that's why I've noticed. I mean, this is more relevant to
- 39:42alcohol, but it's the same phenomenon.
- 39:44Air, I'm Canadian. I have Canadian fly Air Canada a
- 39:50lot and Air Canada lounges vary now so they used to all be
- 39:56self-serve alcohol. So there's just like an open bar
- 39:59and you go get whatever you wanted liquor bottles out and I
- 40:04think partly because of excessive drinking they
- 40:07switched. Some of the lounges have
- 40:08switched to models where you have to go, the alcohol is still
- 40:11free but you have to go ask someone for it.
- 40:13There's a. Bartender.
- 40:14The slightest friction, yes. Yeah, the slightest.
- 40:18And it's not just even the friction, it's the social.
- 40:21It's really the social, right. Even if it was, I had to go to a
- 40:25kiosk and plug it into a machine and it had to give it to me.
- 40:29It wouldn't be the same as asking a person and Downing that
- 40:33glass of wine and going back like 5 minutes later and asking
- 40:37for another one. They're going to be like, OK,
- 40:41you're going to and you're not going to do it because you're
- 40:43going to feel embarrassed. So it is this social drinking.
- 40:46That's why social drinking is so much safer.
- 40:49Airports are a funny microcosm of that because even with the
- 40:54people around, so I I, I haven't flown extensively, but the few
- 40:58times I have, I will always see people even in the mornings at
- 41:02the bars having bruise. I wonder how much of that is
- 41:05that knowledge. You know, I'm, I'm sure there's
- 41:08a non trivial number of people that hate flying and using it
- 41:11for its medicinal effects, but how many people are taking an
- 41:16advantage of being in a scenario where there might be people
- 41:19there but the cultural norms are out anonymous and they'll never
- 41:23see them again? Yeah.
- 41:24They'll never see them again. You're you're in an anonymous
- 41:27space. You're taking advantage of the
- 41:31ambiguity about time zone. So yeah, it's 10 AM here, but
- 41:34maybe it's evening from where I came from.
- 41:38So you have a freedom to. And I think people kind of it's
- 41:42like a vacation from social norms, being in an airport.
- 41:46It's interesting. I had to take my shoes off.
- 41:49I deserve an IPA, You know it's. Yeah, exactly.
- 41:53Yeah. Yeah, one of the reasons I was
- 41:54glad to talk to you in the morning is I I probably would
- 41:57have had a beer if we'd done later when you suggested the AMI
- 42:01was like, that's probably good for the rest of my day's
- 42:03productivity. Yeah.
- 42:06Yeah, I did want to, you know, I, I wrote this down and I
- 42:10wanted to circle back because I thought it was a great example
- 42:14of, you know, that dichotomy of trying and not trying in the
- 42:19real world. So my, I have a cat or cat's
- 42:25name to talk about. But anyways, he got a little
- 42:29infection on his paw and so we have to give him pills, so
- 42:34steroids and antibiotics last couple days.
- 42:38He's a little fighter, so we have to wrap him up just to do
- 42:40it. Yeah, right.
- 42:42And you know, any day, at any time, if I had that door open
- 42:46behind me, he would be here in my lap.
- 42:48He is obsessed with coming up to me and rubbing on my leg.
- 42:53And like, I cannot get rid of this cat.
- 42:56And today, knowing that I had to catch him, I could not find him.
- 43:01I'm like digging apart the house.
- 43:03Like there is this thing in nature where if you are trying
- 43:07to do a thing, the thing that would normally happen all of a
- 43:10sudden is beyond your reach. You know, like, like that, that
- 43:14Apollo prefrontal cortex. I have to catch this cat.
- 43:17Impossible. I I haunted him for like 30
- 43:20minutes if and then I. And you're probably kicking and
- 43:23you're kicking off a different because you're going after him
- 43:26consciously. You're kicking off an energy
- 43:28that he can sense. And he's like, I'm out of here.
- 43:31About the time I started giving up and thinking I don't know if
- 43:34I'm going to get him, he just popped out and was like, yeah,
- 43:37yeah, hello, hello. Little talk about welcome to the
- 43:40party. Yeah, it's the same.
- 43:42It's the same as dating, right? You know you're trying to get a
- 43:45date and you can't get a date because you just kicked me off
- 43:48this. This trying too hard energy that
- 43:51that people don't like. So yeah, trying not to try was
- 43:54about why there's a connection between charisma and
- 43:58spontaneity. Essentially.
- 44:00You know why in social situations you tend to do better
- 44:03when you're not trying. And it has to do with this trust
- 44:06issue. We we really like it when people
- 44:08seem like they're relaxed and not not trying too hard.
- 44:12Sure, sure. Before, before we get too close
- 44:16to end, there was one other thing I think one of my favorite
- 44:20things that I've read in forever, and it was about
- 44:23Beowulf. Oh, yeah.
- 44:27I want to get the exact words here, though.
- 44:29Oh man, I'm trying to see where did I put that quote on.
- 44:35I'm sorry I'm derailing us. But Oh yes, the highest praise
- 44:41accorded to the legendary Viking Anglo-Saxon hero Beowulf was
- 44:45that he never killed his friends when he was drunk.
- 44:50Which apparently was rare for Vike.
- 44:52It's rare enough to to mention. Yes, that is, that is he has
- 44:57claimed to fame so. Yeah, yeah.
- 45:01No, I use that as I mean, so the Vikings come up in the book
- 45:05because, you know, they were the origins of kind of Northern
- 45:11European drinking culture. It was kind of drinking to get
- 45:13drunk, really binge drinking to the point that they not
- 45:21infrequently killed their friends while they were drunk.
- 45:26You know, I talk about the this account from an Islamic envoy
- 45:31who was sent to visit this Viking group in present day
- 45:35Eastern Europe and was just horrified by the just the way
- 45:39they get fallen down drunk. And yet they were pretty
- 45:44successful group, right? They actually, you know,
- 45:47conquered big swaths of Northern Europe.
- 45:49Some significant non trivial proportion of of Europeans today
- 45:54are descended from Vikings. So, so, you know, as a cultural
- 45:58group they did all right. They had a RIP roaring fun time
- 46:01doing it too so. Yeah, yeah.
- 46:04So they so clearly, you know, they were getting something
- 46:08functional out of alcohol despite, you know, these
- 46:11obvious, these obvious dangers and.
- 46:13You know, I think we'd be remiss if we didn't mention that since
- 46:16you brought up Islamic people, so Islamic people, the rise of
- 46:21Mormonism, there's this huge movement with the younger people
- 46:25that I'm even seeing in my restaurant of low to no alcohol
- 46:29consumption. So there is a a rising tide
- 46:34against at least this form of intoxicants.
- 46:37You know, I don't know if it's paralleling the increase in
- 46:42marijuana legalization. Oh, sure.
- 46:44Yeah. And I'm sure that's a huge I.
- 46:46Think that's got to be part. It's got to be part of it.
- 46:49So yeah, I get asked about this a lot.
- 46:51Yeah. Yeah.
- 46:52What's going on with whatever this new generation is called?
- 46:55Are they Z now? I don't know.
- 46:59I'm, I'm firmly in the millennial and I'm, I'm happy
- 47:01with it. I know what I'm called.
- 47:03Yeah. So people, people in their 20s
- 47:07are drinking less than than my generation did, than than your
- 47:11generation did. And I get asked about this a
- 47:15lot. I think part of it, part of it
- 47:18is the availability of alternate intoxicants.
- 47:21So a lot of the people who would be drinking or doing cannabis
- 47:25instead, and cannabis has a lot of advantages as a drug.
- 47:30So it's, it's not physically addictive.
- 47:34It is physiologically less harmful to you than alcohol is.
- 47:39So, so it's got some advantages. The reason it lost.
- 47:44So we've had cannabis for a really long time.
- 47:46Herodotus mentioned it, yeah. Yeah, yeah, it's been around
- 47:50forever, but it it lost the cultural evolutionary battle
- 47:56between intoxicants. Alcohol won, cannabis lost.
- 48:01And that's because cannabis has got some fatal problems as as a
- 48:06as a commonly used social drug. One of them is that it's really
- 48:10hard to dose. So, you know, if you ever try,
- 48:13like if you're smoking it, you have to know how to hold the
- 48:16smoke in your lungs. Different people doing that,
- 48:19different degrees. Don't worry, I remember college.
- 48:22Yes, now. Yes, yeah.
- 48:24And then eating it, you know, if you remember college, you know,
- 48:28the, the, the delay between when you eat it and when it comes on
- 48:31is so long. It's really, it's really hard to
- 48:34dose. And a lot of people overdose
- 48:36because they're like, oh, nothing's happening.
- 48:37And then and then crucially, it, it affects different people
- 48:42really differently. And so I've tried, especially
- 48:46living in Canada where it's been legal for a while and you know,
- 48:49you can get any type of specialty subtype of cannabis.
- 48:54People have always been, oh, try this strain.
- 48:57It all has exactly the same effect on me where it makes me
- 49:01feel really stupid and paranoid and then I fall asleep.
- 49:06Stupid, paranoid, slow, maybe a little anxious, yeah.
- 49:10Yeah, anxious. It makes me a little anxious and
- 49:12then I fall asleep. And so it's a terrible social
- 49:15drug. Whereas I had friends in college
- 49:17who, you know, would want to talk about philosophy or go out
- 49:19dancing and made them really social.
- 49:22And this is well documented that cannabis just has really
- 49:25different effects on different people, whereas alcohol is very
- 49:28consistent across individual. So I don't know why.
- 49:32So maybe it's a novelty thing. You know, cannabis is available
- 49:36now. It's kind of cooler to do
- 49:38cannabis. It's a reaction against, you
- 49:42know, our parents drugs. You know, we don't want to be
- 49:45like her parents. But I think part of it is also
- 49:48that we have new data on the physiological harms of alcohol
- 49:54that wasn't available 1015 years ago.
- 49:58And I've talked to you actually recently.
- 50:01You sometimes learn really cool things being on shows with other
- 50:05people. So there's a guy who's at
- 50:07Harvard who who thinks that this the claim that alcohol's impact
- 50:14on the body is net negative. He thinks that's wrong.
- 50:17If you really look at the data, that's not at all clear and it's
- 50:20being driven by this kind of neo prohibitionism.
- 50:23But in any case, the messaging that young people are getting is
- 50:28that, you know, forget about the cholesterol benefits, forget
- 50:31about the French paradox and two classes a day, how any alcohol
- 50:36consumption is bad for you. And so it's partly the public
- 50:40health messaging that they're getting too, I think that
- 50:44they're paying attention to more, I think, because their
- 50:46habits aren't as fixed, right? So I read that I'm like,
- 50:49whatever, I'm going to still have my wine with dinner.
- 50:52I'm not going to change that, but I'm old and I'm kind of
- 50:56fixed in my way. So I think it partly it's
- 50:58they're responding to this public health message and.
- 51:01You know, forgive me because I, I am steeped in the alcohol
- 51:05world. I I run a restaurant and I've
- 51:07got my Psalm certification is. I can't remember if this was you
- 51:11or someone else, but there's an argument too, that there is no
- 51:16level of driving that is safe. I think this is you, yeah.
- 51:20That's the argument. Yeah, where it's like, yes,
- 51:23technically if you drive you run the risk of dying the same as
- 51:27booze. But the government has never
- 51:30articulated like, therefore the citizens shouldn't drive.
- 51:33It's yeah, there's a clear benefit that you point out that
- 51:38driving is a good intrinsically that you can see, whereas
- 51:42alcohol needs a defender like you.
- 51:46It needs, we need to talk about the functions because the way we
- 51:49talk about it from a public health perspective is completely
- 51:52myopic. And it's just through this, it's
- 51:56purely through risk reduction and physiological effect
- 52:01language, which as I say, you know from a physiological
- 52:05perspective you shouldn't drive a car.
- 52:08You probably should try not to leave the house too often
- 52:11because it's dangerous. So you get hit by a car across
- 52:14the street, but we, you know, we don't wrap ourselves in bubble
- 52:17wrap and stay in our houses because we we're, we're not
- 52:21monomaniacally focused on reducing risk in other areas of
- 52:27our life, you know, like kayak, even though it's dangerous some
- 52:31level, it's only with regard to alcohol.
- 52:35And suddenly it's everyone's obsessed with gaining another,
- 52:39you know, two weeks of potential lifespan.
- 52:42And, you know, it's a weird way to think if if you told me for
- 52:47sure, you know, I would live two months longer if I never touched
- 52:52alcohol again, Like, OK, fine, I'll live two months shorter.
- 52:58I want to enjoy, you know, life without, you know, beautiful,
- 53:04cool climate Chardonnay with some fish, I mean, and.
- 53:07That. That would be sad.
- 53:09It's like all those experiments where they calorically restrict,
- 53:14you know, the level and it extends the lifespan.
- 53:16It's, it's like, it's true. But yeah, like, everyone hates
- 53:19it, Yeah. They hates it.
- 53:22It's like, yeah, no, it's true. It's very similar to this.
- 53:24You know, these mice studies where it's like, look, if you
- 53:26starve the mouse, it will live longer, but it's like, wow, that
- 53:31sucks. Yeah.
- 53:32That first part of the sentence is what I'm focusing on.
- 53:37I do wonder too. There is in my head a sense that
- 53:41you know it, that drive in this current reality we find
- 53:45ourselves that isolation. I wonder if marijuana is just
- 53:50uniquely suited to excel in environments where there's
- 53:53isolation. Where there's a non trivial
- 53:56number of people on weed that will just want to be alone.
- 53:59Where most people on alcohol want to go find people and
- 54:02party. Unless they're trying to hide
- 54:05their alcohol consumption. You know, it's like, you know,
- 54:08those drugs seem to be mismatched to our current
- 54:11reality, which might explain the rise of marijuana consumption.
- 54:14Yeah, that's interesting. Yeah.
- 54:16No, so the because I do think the kind of paranoid thing is
- 54:20quite common and the only, the only time I've ever enjoyed
- 54:24alcohol or sorry, cannabis is if I I occasionally like being home
- 54:31alone watching a stupid movie. It can be pleasurable where it
- 54:36doesn't matter that I feel stupid because there's no one
- 54:39else around. But you're right, it's in that
- 54:42case it's really an isolating drug.
- 54:44It's a drug that keeps you alone in your house in front of the TV
- 54:49rather than out at a pub talking to other people.
- 54:52So. Which is perfect for today.
- 54:55Yeah, yeah, I know. It's where I think, you know,
- 54:57restaurants are really important and bars are important.
- 55:02Yeah. I don't think public health
- 55:04officials, you know, so alcohol harms your your lifespan
- 55:10probably. It's data is unclear, but let's
- 55:13let's just accept that it's a net negative.
- 55:17The other thing that's really dangerous for your health, super
- 55:20dangerous for your health is loneliness.
- 55:22There's really good data on this.
- 55:25And so that's also not talked about that, you know, this was
- 55:28an issue in COVID, right? Where, you know, public health
- 55:31officials had to decide, well, can we still have bars and
- 55:34restaurants? And most of them said no because
- 55:38we want to reduce mortality from COVID.
- 55:41But especially once we had vaccines, I think that was
- 55:46actually just a medically incorrect decision because the
- 55:51harm and inflicted on people by loneliness and isolation
- 55:57probably far outweighed the dangers from COVID once we got
- 56:01to a certain level of of of protection from vaccines.
- 56:06Some people, it took years for them to come.
- 56:09I'm sure there's some people that still don't feel
- 56:10comfortable. Yeah, no, there's some people
- 56:13who wear masks in public and don't feel comfortable going.
- 56:16If a restaurant gets too crowded, they'll leave.
- 56:20You know, the effect of kids was awful because kids especially
- 56:24need that social contact. So I think that this is where I
- 56:28think the service industry doesn't do a good enough job of,
- 56:34of pointing out that you're not just delivering food and alcohol
- 56:38and providing this kind of short shot pleasure to people.
- 56:45You're providing A venue where people actually can socialize
- 56:49and be around other people. And, and we desperately need
- 56:52that, especially in places where, you know, especially in
- 56:56suburbs. So especially in places where
- 56:58people aren't mixing, If you live in a city and you're seeing
- 57:01people at the market and that's different, but in, you know,
- 57:05when people live isolated by themselves in suburbs, they need
- 57:08a place to hang out and see other people.
- 57:10Sure. All right, Edward, Slayerland,
- 57:14everyone trying not to try and drunk everyone.
- 57:16Go get those books. They're awesome.
- 57:19Anyone listening today, where should they follow you?
- 57:22Where should they find out more about what you do?
- 57:25I have a website, so just Edward slayerland.com and you can find
- 57:30out I have those two trade books and we're going to be working on
- 57:34a new one at some point. Exciting.
- 57:36Everything. All my interviews, newspaper
- 57:39articles is all on that site. Awesome well hey from an
- 57:44industry where I focus on just explaining to people what the
- 57:47booze is and why they should drink it with what they eat, it
- 57:50was super cool to explain, you know behind the scenes of why
- 57:54does it exist in the 1st place? So I was awesome getting to talk
- 57:58to you. So thank you for taking the.
- 57:59Time. Any titles?
- 58:01Thanks. Thanks a lot.
- 58:07All right, that's the end of the show.
- 58:08Thank you for listening to Serves You Right.
- 58:10My name is Andrew. If you have not, please hit
- 58:14like, subscribe, send to a friend.
- 58:16The more listeners we get, the more subscribers, the more cool
- 58:19guests we can get and the more cool things we can do.
- 58:23All right, that's it. Episodes of this podcast come
- 58:27out every Tuesday and Thursday, and we'll see you soon.
- 58:31Thanks.