Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: GB Energy up for anything, Reform's AR7 threats, and North Sea nuclear
Transcript
- 0:01Hello, and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:06podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:10the UK energy market. No, we're not planners, we're
- 0:14doers. That's what we are.
- 0:15And I really hope you leave that end at the start of the episode.
- 0:18Marvin, right? We're not planners.
- 0:23Reform is issuing threats to the renewable sector and nuclear is
- 0:28looking to stay afloat in the North Sea.
- 0:31But First off, my colleague Michael Barr has been speaking
- 0:34to GB Energy's CEO about how they are up for anything.
- 0:40But obviously we're going to have to speak to Michael to find
- 0:42out a little bit about that. So how are you today, Michael?
- 0:45I'm good, Ryan. I think I normally try to make
- 0:48sure that I ask how you're doing so our host isn't just left out.
- 0:53Oh, that's very kind. Yeah.
- 0:54No, do you know what I'd love to say?
- 0:56I'm doing great. The sun shining in Aberdeen,
- 0:58which is lovely. That happens roughly about 48
- 1:01hours a year. So it's nice that it's happening
- 1:03now. Unfortunately, I do have a bit
- 1:06of the sniffles, so you might hear me snorkering and coughing
- 1:10away throughout the episode. I'm going to try to minimize
- 1:12that as much as I can to to make the listening experience
- 1:16slightly easier. Well, hold on.
- 1:18If we're getting to complain about health conditions, I want
- 1:19to go back because I, I can. Oh well, but All in all, it's
- 1:25it's summertime, it's it's bright, it's nice.
- 1:28I'm getting some time out in the garden.
- 1:29What more can I want? You know?
- 1:32And now I touched on nuclear and that little intro as well.
- 1:34And a man is returning to the podcast.
- 1:38He's not been here in a little while, but it's we're going to
- 1:40find out if he's going to be like fishing and break us apart
- 1:44or he's going to be like fusion and bring us together.
- 1:47E Forward editor Ed Reed is joining us.
- 1:50How are you today, Ed? I'm good, Ryan, thank you for
- 1:53that very physical physicist opening.
- 1:57I really appreciate it. I, I, I can only hope that I can
- 1:59bring the spirit of scientific rigor that you're clearly
- 2:02looking for to the to the podcast today, but I will
- 2:05certainly do my best. You're giving me way too much
- 2:08credit. I googled 2 words before we
- 2:10started this. I should probably say I do know
- 2:13what fusion and fission meant. I didn't have to Google it
- 2:15before the episode, before anyone starts questioning my
- 2:18credentials too much. And Michael, we did speak at the
- 2:21top of the show about GB energy and you got to sit down with Dan
- 2:25McGrail, now full time CEO, not interim.
- 2:29He's fully committed to that job.
- 2:32What was he saying other than, as I joked, being up for
- 2:36anything? Yeah, so I spoke with GB
- 2:40Energy's Dan McGrail a a few months ago and I realized that
- 2:44we'd hit the the 100 days of his tenure.
- 2:47So I thought to myself, right, well, if presidents get 100 day
- 2:51like reviews, let's let's check in with Dan and see what he had
- 2:55to say. So, you know, first thing I had
- 2:57to do was because, you know, I'm going to butter up my, my
- 3:00interviews a little bit was congratulating him on the, the
- 3:02full time appointment. But I did make sure to ask him,
- 3:06does this change anything? Because let's, let's be fair,
- 3:09we, when GB Energy was announced, you know, we heard a
- 3:13lot of stuff from York and Meyer, who I think he was the
- 3:16first person to get appointed to, to GB energy.
- 3:20How many jobs is supposed to create?
- 3:22Because I think back then he was, he was number 1.
- 3:25He was the 1st. One, he was number 1.
- 3:27I feel like the number has fluctuated.
- 3:29I know there's something like 2000 jobs in Aberdeen, but it
- 3:32feels like that's a long way off.
- 3:34But it's probably about 15, five of those being janitors in the
- 3:38Aberdeen office. But I'm not sure.
- 3:40I'm honestly not entirely sure what the plans are.
- 3:43But I mean, maybe, maybe Dan gave you some insight.
- 3:46So you know, it when it when European came in, it was very
- 3:52obvious that there were big long term plans for for GB energy and
- 3:58you know, bringing in their CEO on a six month interim basis
- 4:01because what he was accounted from Google UK where he headed
- 4:04that up. It sort of felt a bit odd the
- 4:07long term planned short term CEO.
- 4:09But I asked him like, does this change anything?
- 4:11And you can you said no, because as far as he was concerned, the
- 4:14only way to deal with the position of CEO was to always
- 4:18treat it as a long term commitment.
- 4:21So based on that, let's be fair, 100 days isn't a huge amount of
- 4:26time in, in the life of, of GB Energy.
- 4:30But you know, by the sense of it, there's been a lot of
- 4:35progress being done. I don't think there's any
- 4:37announcements that can be made yet, but progress is being made
- 4:40towards those announcements. And I think one of the, the key
- 4:43ones that we're all really interested in is what is GB
- 4:48Energy going to put that money towards since in those hundred
- 4:51days we've had rooftop solar, that's what was it 200 million
- 4:55for rooftop solar across schools and hospitals.
- 4:59There was a big announcement for a we want to go into to nuclear
- 5:04for small modular reactors. I think that was 30% of their
- 5:078.3 million budget is going towards that.
- 5:11But investment in, I think specific projects and you know,
- 5:16we've, we've covered some, some scuttle, but the Green Volt from
- 5:20flotation energy environment, that's one of the, the potential
- 5:24projects they're eyeing. But it was also the, you know,
- 5:27back a few weeks ago when we were hanging out in Aberdeen
- 5:30together, Ryan, that Dan McGraw was talking about the importance
- 5:34of a Technology Strategy. You know, he said, he said the
- 5:38example of Orsted fat and fall and EDF, they'd made their,
- 5:43their names essentially off the back of 1 technology like
- 5:45offshore wind, nuclear, hydro. The Dan said what we, you know,
- 5:52we want to build something similar.
- 5:56So the big question is what are those areas?
- 5:58Ed, I heard you inhale. You've got an opinion.
- 6:01I do, I do have an opinion. I, I want to jump in and I want
- 6:04to ask, you know, obviously you can have essentially kind of,
- 6:07you know, picked out those three companies and said each one had
- 6:10like a sort of a specific technology that they were
- 6:12looking at. But it feels like cheap energy
- 6:14has got a lot more place to spend.
- 6:15So Ed Miliband just gave, as you said, about 30% of its budget to
- 6:21SMRS. So that's he's already lost like a big chunk of cash
- 6:24before he's even sort of started trying to, you know, get into
- 6:27thinking about it. He's doing rooftop soda, which I
- 6:29mean, thinks, you know, sounds good in sort of communities.
- 6:31I mean, I think there's kind of a commercial question there,
- 6:34like floating wind, they took kind of green hydrogen.
- 6:37It feels like he wants to do a lot of things with an ever
- 6:40diminishing amount of money. Yeah, that was definitely, I
- 6:44feel one of the the key points was, you know, as Ryan has said,
- 6:49GB energy is up for up for anything.
- 6:52But whether it can do everything, 8.3 billion isn't,
- 6:57isn't an insubstantial amount, but if you're trying to
- 6:59basically support every facet of the UK energy industry is
- 7:04nothing. So there's definitely.
- 7:07A question of a lot of cash for one place or tuppence for
- 7:12everyone. And it seems like with Ed
- 7:16Miliband's band strategy of giving nuclear 1/3 of the budget
- 7:19and rooftop solar was announced, it feels like it's tough.
- 7:22It's for everyone that they're going down, even though Dan's
- 7:25saying, oh, we're going to have this sort of technology focused
- 7:29strategy. So it is, I think are we going
- 7:33to see that maybe they've made their focus because I think, Ed,
- 7:37you said green hydrogen's on the agenda.
- 7:39I think he mentioned battery storage.
- 7:43I was asking him whether there's any sections he's not going to
- 7:48look at. For example, I think he cited
- 7:50the example of onshore wind that in Scotland, very mature
- 7:54technology, very well advanced. We've got plenty of projects.
- 7:58Not so much in England. Obviously there's been a a ban
- 8:01there for a long time. So I don't know if onshore wind
- 8:04is a potential area they're going to look at.
- 8:07But yeah, it is a question of, OK, up for up for anything, but
- 8:12they're going to have to start making some, maybe some
- 8:15aggressive decisions on which places they're going to have to
- 8:19start parking their money soon or otherwise, like you say, just
- 8:24throw so little money at everything that it doesn't
- 8:27really work. Michael, did you ask him whether
- 8:30he had plans to employ more people from Siemens Energy?
- 8:34Obviously, he's got Jurgen Mayer.
- 8:36I mean, I feel like, you know, they found a rich vein of
- 8:40potential employees. I, I can say that I did not ask
- 8:44that that question. I don't know if that is the the
- 8:48secret plan to rebuild Siemens back in in the UK as a sort of
- 8:52secret Siemens takeover. Did it, didn't like an American
- 8:56do that with some bridge in England?
- 8:58But years and years and years ago and in the US, there's a
- 9:01bridge that was demolished brick by brick and reassembled in the
- 9:04state. Feel like that might be the the
- 9:06approach here. Just like, oh, we'll just keep
- 9:08pinching until eventually we've rebuilt it.
- 9:12Maybe it's a big work reunion. Siemens hasn't done badly as a
- 9:16company. I feel like, you know, no one
- 9:19would be upset if Britain had a, an engineering company or any
- 9:23company on the scale of Siemens. But yeah, maybe next time if I
- 9:27get another chat with him, I'll, I'll find how many more Siemens
- 9:30employees are going to be coming on board.
- 9:33I did ask, however, when they're going to be coming to Aberdeen
- 9:36and I'm afraid the Aberdeen opening is still very much as
- 9:40soon as possible, but I couldn't get a definitive date.
- 9:43So we're going to have to wait a little longer for for some of
- 9:47those those jobs to turn up in Aberdeen, it seems.
- 9:50I feel like the writing was pretty much on the walls for
- 9:53that, right? It was just, it feels very much
- 9:55like the wait for the the announcement of the Aberdeen
- 9:59office. It was like, oh, it's always
- 10:01going to happen in Aberdeen, but when was it going to be formally
- 10:03announced? Now it's a case of now we've
- 10:06just got to wait for them to tell us where they're going to
- 10:08base it. And you know, it's there'll be a
- 10:10continuous wait, but we'll see how that takes shape.
- 10:14Obviously GB Energy is very renewables focused, especially
- 10:17under the Labour government. However, reform seems to be very
- 10:22anti renewables. This week they've been issuing
- 10:25some threats, but stick around because after this break, we're
- 10:27going to tell you all about it. So the 7th allocation round is
- 11:10just on its way. We're awaiting the results of
- 11:13that, but Reform UK, the very controversial far right
- 11:18political group that's rising in the in the estimations for next,
- 11:24the next general election, has been issuing threats this week.
- 11:28It's been essentially saying, listen, your projects are going
- 11:32to be at risk, your investment's going to be at risk if you
- 11:35approve, if you go for a go for a CFD this this time around, and
- 11:41we're going to overturn your CFD if we, you know, become the next
- 11:46premiership. Now, again, Michael, you've been
- 11:48looking into this. We don't use the word threat
- 11:52very lightly, but it does feel like that's what this was.
- 11:55It was very much just, if you're going to apply for funding for a
- 12:00wind farm or whatever it might be, we're just going to pull
- 12:02that out from under you when we get in.
- 12:04And, you know, you're just going to have to be left with that.
- 12:07And I don't know, it just felt, it felt very, very bold from
- 12:13reform. But I suppose that's the one
- 12:15thing they know how to do is be. Bold.
- 12:17You know, I feel like I've been like the the the Charlie Day
- 12:22meme, you know, when he's posing in front of his board with all
- 12:25of the pieces of paper and the red lines going, oh, Brian, I've
- 12:28been dying to talk to you about the reform letter all day.
- 12:31Going Please talk about the reform letter.
- 12:33Ed, I know that I've been talking to Ryan about this.
- 12:35Are you familiar with this story?
- 12:38I I have I have have seen it and I have have some thoughts, but
- 12:42I'm I'm I'm interested in your take Mark.
- 12:44You know, it's one of the ones that I'm going actually, how do
- 12:46we talk about this? Because the letter is so bold,
- 12:51like you say, bold and so strange, but it's so unlike
- 12:54anything that I would ever expect a political party to come
- 12:58out with. Because essentially the deputy
- 13:02leader of reform, Richard Tice, posted up that he has sent
- 13:06letters to a bunch of companies, including I think Octopus
- 13:09Energy, Centrica here, I'm throwing some off the top of my
- 13:12head, Orsted, Vattenfall, Scottish Power, SSE Renewables.
- 13:17I think I've lost count on my fingers.
- 13:19There were eight in total basically saying like you said
- 13:23that there will be political and financial repercussions if you
- 13:28bid your projects into AR-7 with those repercussions being the we
- 13:33are likely if we get in. And you know, that's a big if
- 13:37from a there's a big assumption there on Richard's part that if
- 13:41we get in and there's a reform LED government, we are just
- 13:44going to cancel those contracts. Just just on that, it's quite
- 13:48interesting I said, because they did say there's political risk
- 13:51as well. And from my standpoint, it's
- 13:54saying that you're going to remove your CFDE, remove the,
- 13:57you know, the funding awarded in AR 7.
- 14:01That's definitely a financial risk because obviously projects
- 14:04are built around the strike price that they agreed to under
- 14:06the allocation round. But political risk implies that
- 14:10there's a deeper threat there that's just not being made very
- 14:13transparent, right? We are used to the likes of
- 14:17Donald Trump making these kind of of threats.
- 14:21This I know this is this is we're going to match boldness
- 14:25for boldness here. But there is an almost mafia
- 14:29like element of what a nice wind farm you got here.
- 14:32Be a shame if anything happened to it.
- 14:34You know what accident happened. You're right.
- 14:38There is a sort of underlying threat beyond just that.
- 14:41We will. We will cancel this.
- 14:43I agree it's it is kind of unprecedented.
- 14:45I think it's like a fundamental it.
- 14:46It again demonstrates Reform has no idea how the energy system
- 14:50actually works. Ed, I'm going to interrupt you
- 14:53on that point because they included Octopus Energy and
- 14:56Centrica. Now I'm pretty sure Centrica and
- 14:59I'm almost definite Octopus Energy A has never been into an
- 15:02elephant. And has.
- 15:04No, there's no projects that they could.
- 15:08They're not a a project developer.
- 15:10So I'm not really sure why they were telling the companies that
- 15:14have never done that thing that they should not do the thing
- 15:17that they weren't going to do anyway.
- 15:19It's, it's pure style over substance, isn't it?
- 15:23It's pure like buying into like culture wars that they are
- 15:27seeing in America and they're saying, look, we can also do
- 15:31this thing where we come out against renewable energy and,
- 15:35you know, kind of reap those same benefits that that Donald
- 15:38Trump has, right? It it fundamentally doesn't
- 15:40understand how CFD's work. They don't know who The Who the
- 15:43players are. They don't know anything about
- 15:44it. But The thing is, it's not for,
- 15:47you know, people like Octopus, hey, because obviously they're
- 15:50not going to take part in AR-7. But also because even if, you
- 15:53know, they were, it's, it's not at all designed for those
- 15:56companies. It's to say to, you know, voters
- 15:59who were saying like, oh, energy bills are high, you know, so
- 16:02Richard Tice can say, look, the these, you know, these swine are
- 16:06stealing your money through these, you know, CFDS and we'll,
- 16:09you know, come in and sweep it all out.
- 16:11It's it's it's just a total misunderstanding of
- 16:15misunderstands the energy system.
- 16:17But it doesn't misunderstand electoral politics, I suppose.
- 16:21Do you know, it's interesting you referenced Donald Trump
- 16:23there, because obviously this letter comes out the day after
- 16:26the BBC report that Donald Trump's going to be coming to to
- 16:30Aberdeen to be speaking to Keir Starmer and John Swinney.
- 16:33And he's going to be saying you've got to go for oil and gas
- 16:36and stop those windmills. And that's the thing I hate the
- 16:39most is they don't mail anything, Donald.
- 16:41They generate power, their turbines.
- 16:44Anyway, total, total tangent there.
- 16:47But it does feel like it's probably more of an SEO trick
- 16:51than anything else, right? It's like, oh, people are
- 16:53searching about British energy because Donald Trump's coming to
- 16:58the UK to speak to Scotland's two governments, to the UK
- 17:01government about energy, about oil and gas and about
- 17:05renewables. If they came to go renewables
- 17:08are shit and oil and gas is great.
- 17:10Then all of a sudden it, you know, they also appear in the
- 17:14same conversation. And I mean, Donald Trump is
- 17:18isn't without his supporters at this side of the pond either.
- 17:21You know, we can, you know, we can sort of joke about his use
- 17:26of language around wind turbines, But at the end of the
- 17:29day, when whenever he speaks about oil and gas and how we
- 17:32should be pursuing that, you do see some considerable levels of
- 17:38support for that type of talk online.
- 17:41So, you know, it does kind of also make sense to try and
- 17:44piggyback on that and try and say, oh, look, we're backing
- 17:47what you're saying. And that comes off the back of
- 17:50Nigel Farage coming up to Aberdeen a couple of months ago
- 17:53and describing net zero as quote nonsense.
- 17:56So it, it does just feel like that culture war thing.
- 18:01I think you're right. You've hit the nail on the head.
- 18:06It's definitely a feeling that what, however you want to slice
- 18:09it, that somehow clean energy is woke.
- 18:12And that is something that we fight against the you know, it's
- 18:17one of the things that they've talked about this that's I think
- 18:21it was Farage said that net zero was the next Brexit.
- 18:23They're really ramping up the idea that net zero is somehow
- 18:29going to be the the next place that they can essentially win
- 18:33their fight. Because I mean, look, we're, I'm
- 18:36talk, I'm talking skeptically about them becoming the next
- 18:39government. They, they won their last big
- 18:41fight, which was, which was Brexit.
- 18:44But it does make me think that, you know, we were quick to, to
- 18:47amass some reactions to, to this and they point out, look, people
- 18:51are overwhelmingly in favour of, of renewable energy.
- 18:57But I do remember there was a really click baity article I
- 19:00read about Arnold Schwarzenegger when he came out and said I see,
- 19:04I see some faces recognizing it when he said net zero was
- 19:08bullshit. His point being that net 0, the
- 19:11terminology that they use around it is, is the problem.
- 19:18And I do think that maybe that they've they've smelt a bit of
- 19:21an opening that most people are generally in favour of clean
- 19:25energy. That's the way it's talked
- 19:29about. There's almost an opportunity
- 19:31there to there's an opening for them.
- 19:34So I do feel it's, you know, if not something to get complacent
- 19:38about the although there is support for clean energy, I
- 19:41think it's definitely the a lot of places including, you know,
- 19:46energy voice, the energy press, you know, it's sort of that
- 19:52we're going to have to think very carefully about how we talk
- 19:55about things that there isn't maybe going to be a much bigger
- 19:58debate. It's interesting, isn't it?
- 20:00Because. Yeah, you do, you do sort of see
- 20:02this debate, but then it's also potentially a seat winner for
- 20:05them being anti or onshore when they're anti solar.
- 20:10Because you know, we often, we often speak about rural
- 20:13communities in particular impacted by yeah, solar farms
- 20:17going up in farm in farmland space or, you know, onshore when
- 20:21when turbines and locals are arguing about impacting the
- 20:24local landscape or pylons, you know, and let's face it, you
- 20:28know, transmission is a major part of the transition.
- 20:31It's almost like they made those words rhyme on purpose.
- 20:34They obviously didn't, but it'd be very funny if they did when
- 20:37it comes to that as well. I suppose they are looking to
- 20:39these rural communities that are vocally against and kinda going
- 20:43Oh well maybe we can can make some headway there.
- 20:47But who's to say? They haven't quite targeted
- 20:51nuclear yet, which is the only other thing that Labour seems to
- 20:54stand for that they haven't went after.
- 20:57Unless Ed have they? No.
- 20:59No, no, I was going to say I the reform is, I mean, I remember
- 21:03seeing a, a, a, a press conference with them a couple of
- 21:05months ago and they were very keen about SNRS so.
- 21:09Oh well. So they're going to love this
- 21:11next segment. And if you stick around after
- 21:13the break, you're going to find out how nuclear might be on our
- 21:16waves. So nuclear seems to be coming up
- 22:15more frequently in the headlines than ever before, or maybe ever
- 22:20before in my time in energy journalism at least.
- 22:24And you've been looking at a really interesting concept of
- 22:29sort of floating nuclear. I've heard a floating wind.
- 22:32I've even heard a floating solar, which doesn't seem to be
- 22:34going anywhere. Floating nuclear is new to me.
- 22:38Yeah, it's, it's an interesting concept, isn't it?
- 22:40And I think, you know, obviously I suppose everyone is, is well
- 22:43aware of things like nuclear submarines, right.
- 22:47So in this sort of the military context, I feel that's probably,
- 22:49you know, it's pretty much as far as most people are aware of
- 22:53this as a, as a sort of a goer. But yeah, so I went along to a
- 22:56conference last week organized by Core Power, who are
- 22:59themselves developing a, a kind of a, a plan around floating
- 23:03nuclear. And, and they had a, you know,
- 23:04sort of a full, a full day of people talking about, I suppose
- 23:07there's sort of opportunities that we're seeing in, in terms
- 23:10of essentially moving nuclear reactors on, on, on onto the
- 23:15waves, as you say. So I think there were there were
- 23:17sort of two main kind of potentials that they talked
- 23:20about. So one was, you know, literally
- 23:22just like sort of floating nucleus.
- 23:24So essentially like a power barge.
- 23:26So, you know, you would have a essentially an SMR on a ship,
- 23:31you know, mauds next to an industrial area with a, you
- 23:35know, a wire literally linking up that that reactor to onshore
- 23:38demand, which I feel is, you know, possibly the sort of, you
- 23:41know, the the sort of the strongest sort of, you know,
- 23:43part. The second part was around
- 23:46nuclear powered ships, right. So this would essentially being
- 23:49using a, a, a nuclear reactor on a ship to, you know, essentially
- 23:54propel it across from A to B, which people were still quite
- 24:00interested in. But it feels to me like that is
- 24:02more of a stretch. I think there's, there was, you
- 24:04know, listening to the kind of the legal challenges and the
- 24:07insurance challenges. And so the, the, the public
- 24:10acceptance challenges, it feels like that kind of idea around,
- 24:14you know, using nuclear as a, as a, as a, as a sort of something
- 24:17to propel a, a civilian ship is a lot more challenging.
- 24:21So, you know, essentially you, because international
- 24:25regulations are so slow moving, you would need some sort of
- 24:28bilateral deal. So if say, the USUK were to
- 24:31agree sort of terms and you could, you could, you know,
- 24:34maybe sort of see somewhere in which these kind of ships could
- 24:37go from A to B. But I think there are a lot of
- 24:40questions around how you would do that and around, you know,
- 24:43other states you might feel, you know, you know, potentially
- 24:46impacted by any accident. And I think that's that's the
- 24:49thing, right? Everyone was so keen to say
- 24:52incredibly safe, you know, you know, thousands of years of
- 24:55nuclear operations, you know, with no accidents, which, you
- 24:58know, absolutely is a fairpoint. But the problem is, you know,
- 25:02when they do go wrong, that's when like that, that the kind of
- 25:07big question mark arises. And I think that's that's that's
- 25:09the real problem. It's it's the whole thing of
- 25:11like, why people are scared of flying, right?
- 25:13Yeah. Like, we've all heard like the
- 25:15new Superman movie came out, but this this past week.
- 25:18But, you know, we've all heard that Superman quote.
- 25:20But it's just statistically, it's still the safest way to
- 25:22travel. But when, when a plane does get
- 25:25involved in an accident, it's bad, right?
- 25:29So that's kind of what scares people.
- 25:32However, what I want to ask you is I was looking at Niso's
- 25:35report this week and I was looking at Hydrogen UK's
- 25:39hydrogen use case report. And one of the big things they
- 25:42were speaking about was shipping and how hydrogen should could be
- 25:47used and should be used for decarbonizing the shipping
- 25:51industry. Should the hydrogen sector start
- 25:54sweating yet again, as they have many, many times before, when
- 25:58they've come up with a use case and then something else has come
- 26:01along? Or do we think that nuclear is
- 26:04maybe just a bit too pie in the sky?
- 26:07I mean, I think there were a number of pies in this
- 26:10particular sky around. So it's a question of really of
- 26:12how high you want to reach. So I mean, I think look there,
- 26:15there there is a question mark obviously around around, around,
- 26:18you know, using nuclear and shipping.
- 26:20There is also of course the question around around, you
- 26:22know, hydrogen in terms of, you know, obviously as a sort of a
- 26:26bite, you know, maybe like a like a like ammonia or methanol
- 26:28to, to decarbonize shipping. Shipping obviously has signed up
- 26:32to net 0 by 2050 I believe. So that's kind of like a global
- 26:36challenge. I think that look, there's a big
- 26:38question mark whether the shipping industry will be able
- 26:40to reach that. You know, can you see a point at
- 26:45which we have enough hydrogen to essentially replace, you know,
- 26:49other fuels? Big question.
- 26:50I mean, I think you know, one of the one of the interesting, you
- 26:52know, somebody said to me, you know, I was kind of asking about
- 26:55the UK use case for for sort of floating nuclear.
- 26:59And she said, she said, you know, sort of like a private
- 27:02wire to, I don't know, like an like an onshore industrial
- 27:05facility. You know, obviously might be one
- 27:07way in which you could see floating nuclear develop and
- 27:11then possibly also using it to using using that nuclear power
- 27:16to drive an electrolyser. You know, if you know, if you've
- 27:19got that sort of intermittent load, you may not need all that
- 27:21nuclear power all the time. Surplus nuclear power could go
- 27:25into producing hydrogen. I can't remember what colour
- 27:28nuclear hydrogen it is, but I mean, you know, it might square
- 27:31that particular circle. It might.
- 27:33It might end up being floating nuclear underpinning hydrogen
- 27:37shipping. Ding Ding Ding Ding Ding.
- 27:39Here comes Michael Baer to tell you that it's Ruby Hydrogen.
- 27:43There we go. What an answer.
- 27:44What an answer. I think just because, you know,
- 27:47to keep the comic book superhero analogy running because of the
- 27:51Incredible Hulk, as soon as I think of nuclear or radiation in
- 27:54general, it's like it should be green.
- 27:56And then I went, oh, wait, that's the other big one.
- 28:00But nuclear has been making a lot of headlines as of late.
- 28:04And it's, it's an interesting concept, this idea of sort of
- 28:07having a barge that's producing for essentially these these
- 28:12industrial communities. Port Talbot was mentioned.
- 28:15Teesside was also mentioned at that conference.
- 28:19Is, is, do you see that as being a sort of the next big move for
- 28:23nuclear? Obviously SMRS are the big thing
- 28:26right now, and that kind of ties into what's happening here,
- 28:28right? I mean, yeah, I think, I think
- 28:30look, I think there is a there is obviously a question around
- 28:33around whether the UK wants to be involved in that, right.
- 28:35And I think like, obviously there are challenges looking at
- 28:38how hard it is to get, you know, sort of Sizewell going Hinkley
- 28:41Point, most expensive nuclear power plant ever made makes me
- 28:44think maybe this country, despite, you know, Ed Miliband's
- 28:47plans, might not be entirely ready for nuclear in that sort
- 28:51of sense. So I suspect if we're going to
- 28:54see, you know, nuclear power developing in this kind of
- 28:57floating context, we would see it in regions that maybe take a
- 29:01slightly more proactive approach to building our energy
- 29:04infrastructure. So obviously who might build it,
- 29:07maybe China, you know, delivering power, you know,
- 29:10somewhere in the APEC region who people who want, you know, plow
- 29:14power to plug in now essentially and are also keen on that sort
- 29:18of decarbonisation piece. So obviously, you know, sort of
- 29:21trying to pick a winner is always a bit of a challenge.
- 29:23But if I was a betting man, that's probably where I would
- 29:26see it rolling out. Before we rammed out this
- 29:28nuclear conversation, I just wanted to draw attention to the
- 29:32planning application side of things because just before we
- 29:36started recording this podcast, I published an article on an
- 29:39energy voice about fusion as opposed to fission.
- 29:44We had that conversation right at the top of the show and I'm
- 29:46bringing it back round. We're going full circle.
- 29:49Regulations around planning were updated today type of recording
- 29:55to essentially make it that fusion projects are subject to
- 29:59the same same sort of planning consent process as regular
- 30:07nuclear sufficient as well as onshore wind and solar that's
- 30:11under the nationally significant infrastructure project.
- 30:14Now we know Nottingham is progressing with fusion energy
- 30:19and I get Yorkshire as well as planning has got some plans in
- 30:26in the works when it comes to when it comes to the sort of
- 30:30overhaul. It does feel like the
- 30:31government's gonna go hell for leather.
- 30:33It's really sort of going for this, but I, I, I'd be
- 30:38interested to hear your views, Ed, in terms of, is there enough
- 30:43fusion projects in the UK for this to actually mean anything?
- 30:49Poor, that is. I mean.
- 30:51That is a question that I will have to admit that I know I have
- 30:54no answer to. I mean, I think, I, I think
- 30:57there's, there's a big question around how we drive innovation
- 31:00in this country. And I think obviously to get
- 31:03projects going, you need to have the ability to see them through,
- 31:08right. You can't just have
- 31:09universities, you need to be able to, you know, build them
- 31:12out. And that's kind of, you know,
- 31:13workforce question, that's kind of financing that's, and that's
- 31:17also obviously kind of permitting and regulations.
- 31:19So I think, look, I don't know about the, the particulars, but
- 31:22I would say that, look, if we want, you know, to establish the
- 31:25UK as a leading light in these new technologies, not just, you
- 31:29know, kind of new, new nuclear technologies, but also other
- 31:32ones. You know, there are a number
- 31:33around then we need to make it easier to build things.
- 31:36And obviously the, the government is trying to do that
- 31:38through the, the new planning bill.
- 31:40But we need to see progress. I mean, I think, you know, we've
- 31:42heard from Rachel Reeves, you know, how important growth is.
- 31:45It'd be good to to to see that borne out.
- 31:48Well, I think that does it for our nuclear chat today.
- 31:51And I think it's very safe to say, Ed, your return to energy
- 31:54voice out loud did serve more as fusion than fish.
- 31:58And you didn't bring us together.
- 32:00Wow, look at that. There we are.
- 32:02We've went full circle. Well, thank you very much for
- 32:05joining me, Ed, and thank you very much, Michael.
- 32:07But most importantly, thank you very much for listening.
- 32:10Now, I don't really have anything to tell you to go to
- 32:14this week. No events coming up.
- 32:15We're very much in that summer drought of events.
- 32:19So I'm just going to tell you to go out and enjoy the sunshine
- 32:22while we've got it and I'll see you at the same place, same time
- 32:25next week.