Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: ScotWind struggles, Kemi in Aberdeen, and Scotland surveyed
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:04podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:08the UK energy market. Well, there's been a string of
- 0:11cancellations for offshore wind projects since AR 7's
- 0:15announcement. Kemi Badenoch was up in Aberdeen
- 0:18just last week and we've got our fingers on the pulse for
- 0:23opinions on energy in Scotland. That's a lot to talk about if
- 0:26you're just me. Aberdeen featured lead Ryan
- 0:29Duff. But joining me this week is
- 0:31renewables reporter Michael Baer.
- 0:32How are you doing today, Michael?
- 0:34I'm doing great. How are you, Ryan?
- 0:35I'm not too bad. I kind of stumbled my way
- 0:37through my own, my own job title, but we're going to get
- 0:40through this. It's it's first thing in the
- 0:42morning when we record this. I feel like the fact that I
- 0:45speak in full sentences is probably good enough.
- 0:48Joining us as well is reporter Matthew Perry.
- 0:51How are you doing today, Matt? I'm doing quite well.
- 0:53I'm looking forward to Burns Night this weekend.
- 0:56I'm going to be going off to my first Kaylee, so that'll be
- 0:58exciting. Look at you going all native.
- 1:00Yeah, it's been here long enough.
- 1:02It's about time have. You brushed up on your dances.
- 1:05No, not at all. So I'm going to be surely
- 1:07embarrassing myself multiple times, but it's not the first
- 1:11time I've embarrassed myself on the dance floor, so it won't be
- 1:13the last. I assure you that as someone
- 1:16who's been to Kaylee's, everyone's going to be
- 1:17embarrassing themselves. There's going to be at least one
- 1:21weird old man who is insists on going proper Scotsman.
- 1:24Yeah. There's always someone who seems
- 1:26to know the dancers better than everyone else and is like trying
- 1:29to regiment it, but it's always a good time.
- 1:31And for some reason they always put the dashing weights origin
- 1:33at the end, which is the one where everyone runs at each
- 1:36other and kicks. Not a good, not a good idea to
- 1:38do when everyone's had a few drinks.
- 1:40Yeah. Right when people are the
- 1:41drunkest. Speaking of kicking off, that's
- 1:45not what's happening in the North Sea.
- 1:46I was wondering how you're going to segue that into offshore?
- 1:50It was a it was a tenuous like, But do you know what tenuous is
- 1:54also the reason why these projects aren't going ahead.
- 1:58That's tenuous chart Ed prices. What does it stand for?
- 2:02Michael, what does it stand for? Let's see transmission network
- 2:07usage of system. Oh, a brand of applause, please.
- 2:11I got that wrong by all means right in tell tell me off, but
- 2:15I'm pretty sure that is correct. We are flying into this 10
- 2:19minute section and we haven't even discussed what the news is.
- 2:22So, Michael, I'm going to ask you what's happening in the West
- 2:25of Orkney. So I think the first thing to
- 2:27say is that we're not of the current scuttlebutt is it's not
- 2:33cancelled. That I think the exact
- 2:36terminology that the project director whose comments have
- 2:40kind of spurred on this, the the stories is that investment has
- 2:46been paused in the in the project.
- 2:48So not cancelled. I think the term I used is
- 2:53stalled paused might be another one to, to use.
- 2:57But essentially this is not a new issue they've been facing.
- 3:01It is, as you mentioned to newest charges the you know, I'm
- 3:06not going to assume anything. I'm not going to assume any of
- 3:08our listeners, you know. So the crash course is that the
- 3:11newest charges are basically the charges the the UK makes to
- 3:17power providers to use the the network.
- 3:20And it makes sense when you think about it.
- 3:22It's based on the idea that the further the power has to travel,
- 3:26the more infrastructure you have to use, the higher the charges.
- 3:30Like I said, it makes sense, or rather it made sense when power
- 3:35was mostly being provided by coal plants kind of in north of
- 3:39England around population centers.
- 3:43But things have changed. We're now trying to roll out a
- 3:45lot of offshore wind power and obviously the north of Scotland
- 3:49that's got some of the best wind resources.
- 3:52So now it's ultimately creating a barrier to rolling out a lot
- 3:56of these projects. And West of Orkney has been for
- 3:58a long time one of the most vocal projects about the risk
- 4:01that these present. That is basically they push up
- 4:05the cost of of power. I think West of Orkney, they
- 4:08said it was about 30% essentially was adding to the
- 4:11cost of a wind farm, which when you consider these are billion
- 4:14pound projects, that's a substantial amount of money.
- 4:17And this isn't the only wind farm that's that's been
- 4:20impacted, but it's, it's interesting that we last week we
- 4:22were speaking about AR 7. And Matt, you highlighted Energy
- 4:27Secretary Gillian Martin's comments around canoeist charge
- 4:33charges and how AR-8 would need to bring in reform because no
- 4:38Scotland project goes, it was approved and none of them got
- 4:41CFDS. Michael, I've heard you say on
- 4:44multiple occasions West of Orkney is the most advanced
- 4:48Scotland project. If any of them is going to make
- 4:51an impact by 20-30 targets, it's it's West of Orkney and it
- 4:56needed an allocation round seven CFD that hasn't happened and the
- 5:01project is they they're saying paused.
- 5:03You said stalled. We're avoiding Cancel, I say.
- 5:06Up a Creek without a paddle. What you know when it comes to
- 5:11that, You know what what does it mean for the rest of Scotland?
- 5:16It's. Definitely a bad sign, like you
- 5:18said, Scotland conspicuous by its absence in AR 7 W of Orkney.
- 5:23I think it was the first to get his offshore consents or put
- 5:26them in rather. I can't remember if they got the
- 5:29approval yet. But essentially, yeah, it was
- 5:31the leader of the pack. It was, it basically was the
- 5:36litmus test for whether Scotland could contribute to this rapidly
- 5:41closing 2030 target. And so the consensus is right,
- 5:45if West of Orkney not only didn't get in in time to
- 5:50essentially most put it on the most likely track to contribute
- 5:53to 2030, now it's stalled out, now it's waiting for
- 5:58transmission charges, then yeah, it does definitely put a bit of
- 6:02a massive question mark on whether Scotland will actually
- 6:07be most of the projects will come in on time.
- 6:09But I guess looking at sort of the, the, the grid planning and
- 6:14then timelines, do we think that potentially, you know, a lot of
- 6:18the projects, you know, where RWE projects and, and off the
- 6:21East Coast of England, where in the Uka lot more of the the
- 6:24power demand is? Do we think that this is sort of
- 6:26a prioritization of the, the Labour government to say, you
- 6:29know, these are the projects that are more likely to have the
- 6:33grid infrastructure in place. We, you know, get these off the,
- 6:37the running in 2026 with AR-7. Then we'll tinker again because
- 6:41we, we did see a lot of tinkering happening and lots of
- 6:44changes to AR 7 from previous rounds.
- 6:46We think the same will happen for ARA.
- 6:48And then we'll sort of see a kind of a, a pivot back towards
- 6:51the Scotland projects because, you know, it seems that, you
- 6:56know, standing down, I guess a lot of the staff from West of
- 6:58Walkney, it's it's fully consented.
- 7:00It's I guess it's probably not all that much to do until
- 7:03they've got ACFD and can make a final investment decision If I
- 7:06guess the changes that they they want to see do come in and ARA,
- 7:09it could be revived. But then that raises the same
- 7:12questions that we have in in the North Sea for oil and gas,
- 7:16right? You know, if you're, if you're
- 7:17an international wind developer and you're, you've got a project
- 7:21in the UK and you've got a project and say Portugal, say,
- 7:24you know, whatever, it doesn't matter.
- 7:27And that project is going ahead and this one isn't.
- 7:30Surely you've got to raise questions of where do you
- 7:33allocate funds and doesn't it just, wouldn't that just make
- 7:36the UK less investable? Potentially it could make
- 7:40Scotland less investable for, you know, for the moment, but if
- 7:44you look at what's happening elsewhere in the world, the US
- 7:47who what offshore wind developed want to put their money into the
- 7:49US right now. Germany and Denmark have had
- 7:53failed offshore wind rounds in in the last year.
- 7:56Australia is seeing a slew of cancellations.
- 7:59Equinor was pulled out of Vietnam.
- 8:00Like if you, if you are looking to develop an offshore wind farm
- 8:03way better than than the UK, really you can't develop one in
- 8:07China. There's you know, only Chinese
- 8:09companies are doing that there. So I, I, I think that the, it,
- 8:14it certainly is disappointing for a lot of the, the Scotland
- 8:16projects and I don't think this may necessarily not be the last
- 8:19we hear of that. I was looking through some of
- 8:21the out of Hebrides projects that we sometimes you know,
- 8:25forget about the likes of Haverde and Spiro Demaro and
- 8:29Telus out near, near Lewis. And I did see it Northland POW,
- 8:33which is a sort of Canadian listing listed company in their
- 8:36Q3 results, they'd said that Haverde which is the the
- 8:39floating project, they've de prioritized that Spiro and
- 8:43Namara, which is a fixed win that says that that's still
- 8:46going ahead, I guess. But we're following up with them
- 8:50to see what deprioritize means. But you know, I don't, I don't
- 8:53think this is certainly I imagine we're getting to the
- 8:55point of a big leasing around where the investors do start to
- 8:59reassess the money that they're putting into these these
- 9:01projects. And Michael, you know, you were
- 9:03reporting on just last week Jaron XVPS or swooping in to
- 9:09save Mona, which you know, seemed like it was going to
- 9:12going to disappear after ENBW announced that it was calling
- 9:17time on that project too. It seems like it's it's an issue
- 9:20that we're going to see in the headlines all this year, right?
- 9:22Yeah, I think, you know, when I was reporting on more than
- 9:26Morgan. So Mona last minute reprieve, it
- 9:28looked like it was sinking like you said, Jaron X came in Morgan
- 9:32sadly no one has come in to to save that.
- 9:35So it looks by all accounts that it is dead in the water.
- 9:39You know, I think we were definitely talking about because
- 9:42we also saw blithe that was cancelled right before that
- 9:45relatively small project. It was the feeling of right.
- 9:48These these are just the first. I think we are probably going to
- 9:51see quite a few projects either stalled, cancelled.
- 9:56The big question, I think, you know, the West of Orkney hangs
- 9:59on is right, they're pausing investment until transmission
- 10:02charges are reformed. Reform is on the cards, but it's
- 10:06coming towards the end of the decade.
- 10:08You know, I think we were at the the Holy Rood event last week
- 10:11and there was maybe a little bit of conflict between government
- 10:16and developers where they were talking about transmission
- 10:19reform. And then, you know, the
- 10:21government saying, right, you know, we're we're working on it
- 10:23is coming. And the developers like, yeah,
- 10:25we need it today. We literally we'd need it as
- 10:28soon as possible. This year is probably as as late
- 10:31as we can go. The sooner the better.
- 10:33So yeah, it's definitely a case that you look at West of Orkney,
- 10:39it's it's this is now holding up a pretty substantial investment
- 10:43for A2 GW offshore wind farm. Well, I think that's all we've
- 10:47got time for in this section. I feel like we could probably
- 10:49fill out the entire 30 minute program with just this because
- 10:53it is a massive topic. There are lots of jobs on the
- 10:57line both in the supply chain and in certain operations and
- 11:01maintenance side of things for these projects.
- 11:05It'll be, it'll be interesting to say the least how the
- 11:08Scotland leasing round proceeds and if by 20-30 we're calling it
- 11:13a success or a failure. But that does it for this
- 11:15section. So stick around, because after
- 11:18the break I've been speaking to Leader of the Opposition Cami
- 11:21Bat Knock. Be a part of the conversation
- 11:24shaping Scotland's investment future.
- 11:27The Scottish National Investment Bank Conference 2026, in
- 11:31association with Energy Voice and the Press and Journal,
- 11:34brings together investors, business leaders and policy
- 11:38makers who are driving economics, social and
- 11:41environmental impact across Scotland.
- 11:44This is your opportunity to hear directly from those deploying
- 11:48mission LED capital. If you're serious about
- 11:51investing with purpose, whether you're raising capital,
- 11:54allocating it, or shaping policy, this is the room you
- 11:58need to be in. Get your tickets online today.
- 12:02So the Leader of the Opposition Kemi Badnock was up in Aberdeen
- 12:06at 3T training services in DICE just last week alongside Shadow
- 12:12Energy SEC Andrew Bowie and we spoke about a plethora of things
- 12:17but mainly the AR 7 results as the conversation was hot on the
- 12:21heels of that announcement. And I asked Kemi, with news that
- 12:28the UK government believes that 2400 jobs can be created in the
- 12:31North East of Scotland off the back of the the winners, what
- 12:36would its government do differently considering there's
- 12:40been so much criticism? So Andrew can provide more
- 12:43details specifically on the contracts for difference.
- 12:47More broadly, what we're saying is that the strategy for Net 0
- 12:52is not working. Plans were put in place, very
- 12:56well-intentioned, but they're not working.
- 12:58And what we should be doing is creating a new set of plans, a
- 13:01new set of strategies. That's what we're working on now
- 13:03in opposition. We're not the government
- 13:05anymore. Instead, what Labour is doing is
- 13:07doubling, tripling down, even accelerating
- 13:10deindustrialization. We can see that the grid is not
- 13:14able to cope with the with the mix at the moment, but they seem
- 13:17to be completely oblivious to what's going on.
- 13:20Andrew, you can say a bit more what?
- 13:21The auction round did this week was tires into paying record
- 13:24prices for offshore wind for the next 20 years.
- 13:27There's a price they're going to have to be paid even when the
- 13:28wind isn't blowing because we do not have the capacity to store
- 13:32or transmit the energy. It's going to be generated by
- 13:34these wind farms. At the same time, gas, which is
- 13:36now half the price, we're artificially and, and
- 13:40accelerating the decline in the North Sea.
- 13:42And these 2500 jobs that are going to be promised to Scotland
- 13:44are nothing when compared to the thousands of jobs every month
- 13:48that are going to be lost in the North Sea as a result of the
- 13:50absurd policies to shut down one of our best national assets,
- 13:55which is our North Sea oil and gas industry.
- 13:57So this entire energy policy from Labour government is, is
- 14:00flawed. It's not going to deliver for
- 14:01the country. It's going to deliver higher
- 14:03energy bills and more unemployment, and nobody wants
- 14:05that. I've got 2 two questions to come
- 14:08back to both views on Andrew while while I'm speaking to you,
- 14:10I'll jump on this one first. So you're you're essentially
- 14:14questioning Ed Miliband's homework here because he said
- 14:19the complete opposite in the announcement of the contractor
- 14:22difference. He would indeed, but he was
- 14:24saying that it was cheaper than you build gas.
- 14:27Now how how is the how are the Tories coming to 1 conclusion
- 14:31when I'm seeing industry players in the wind industry say the
- 14:34complete opposite if. You take out the carbon tax and
- 14:36the levies, then gas is roughly about half the price which we
- 14:41have just agreed to pay for the next 20 years, baked in the next
- 14:4420 years for offshore wind that's going to be generated.
- 14:47Everybody in the industry and industry watchers and
- 14:50commentators expect the gas price to fall even further over
- 14:52the next few years. So we will be paying an
- 14:53artificially high price to energy companies who are going
- 14:56to be raking in this money even when the wind isn't blowing.
- 14:59That's absurd. It's all going to be landing on
- 15:01the bills of British. Well, it's going to be landing
- 15:05for British bill payers and as an absurd situation to be when
- 15:08you've got other countries around the world who are able to
- 15:10deliver cheaper energy. It's not just leading to higher
- 15:12bills for consumers. It's looking to
- 15:13deindustrialization of this country.
- 15:15It's coming too expensive to even generate here in the UK.
- 15:18So Ed Miliband, I wouldn't trust Ed Miliband's homework as far as
- 15:23I could throw it. So it's it's nonsense.
- 15:25And Kemi, you spoke about working on an energy strategy
- 15:28there. Labour is working on an outdated
- 15:31model as you were describing. So what is the Conservative
- 15:34model? It is to use our energy
- 15:37resources. We start from first principles
- 15:40and our first principle isn't that we need to get carbon
- 15:44emissions down to 0, even if it means going back to the Stone
- 15:47Age. Our first principle is that we
- 15:50need to use our own resources. Energy security is part of
- 15:53national security. So our strategy is to make sure
- 15:56that we can be as self reliant and as self-sufficient as
- 15:59possible. So increasing those things, that
- 16:01means drilling in, in, in the North Sea.
- 16:04And we're also, you know, our energy policy is also linked to
- 16:09our foreign policy. We can see what's happening in
- 16:11places like Venezuela. We've heard what President Trump
- 16:15has in mind when it comes to Greenland.
- 16:17What is our government doing? Just sitting back and allowing
- 16:20things to happen. It's just not serious.
- 16:22So we have a chain linked view of policy.
- 16:25Energy policy is also closely linked to defence.
- 16:28We have a sovereign defence fund where we want to use our, you
- 16:31know, British based companies, British based businesses to
- 16:35support our defence industry. It's about having, you know, the
- 16:39first principles, thinking from A-Z through all the policy
- 16:41areas. Energy doesn't sit alone, but
- 16:44starting with making it easier for businesses in places like
- 16:48Aberdeen is number one. We have hit businesses with
- 16:51burden after burden after burden.
- 16:53If it isn't the energy profits levy, it's the jobs tax.
- 16:56If it isn't the jobs tax, it's some weird thing on on business
- 17:00rates and they are crying out for help.
- 17:02And you only need to see the unemployment figures.
- 17:04Since Labour came into office, unemployment has increased every
- 17:07single month. Every single month.
- 17:09This is crazy. So our strategy is one that can
- 17:12simply be described as common sense.
- 17:15On jobs figures, I mentioned the 2400 figure that Pierce Armour
- 17:20said yesterday for the North East of Scotland.
- 17:24When it comes to this flip flopping of signals, because
- 17:27bearing in mind it was the the Conservative government that
- 17:30introduced for different introduced legislation to, to
- 17:35make a legal mandate for net 0. It's a flip flop from your party
- 17:40to say that we're we're not going for that anymore.
- 17:43And to, to say these 2400 jobs that are being created off the
- 17:46wind, aren't you just kicking the can down the road by
- 17:49doubling down on oil and gas? It is a, it is a finite resource
- 17:52at the end of the day and it is something that will impact jobs
- 17:55in the North East of Scotland. Shouldn't we be building out the
- 17:59supply chain jobs the offshore? OK.
- 18:02So sorry, I will answer those two questions.
- 18:04It's a change in party policy. I am changing our party policy.
- 18:08It is not a change for me. I said from day one, even when
- 18:12they were announcing that legislation, this is not going
- 18:14to work, how are we going to pay for it?
- 18:16So I feel like I've been not just consistent, but right and
- 18:20and I've been proved right. And I think that that's why the
- 18:24sector can have confidence in me.
- 18:25I was never one of the people who was just chasing it because
- 18:28they thought it was a good headline.
- 18:29I did the right thing at the right time.
- 18:31I said it then so they can trust me now.
- 18:33I'm a consistent person. That's what you've got under
- 18:36conservative leadership today. I can't go into, I can't build a
- 18:39time machine and go back into the past.
- 18:41Good politicians and good politics is recognizing that
- 18:44when the facts change, you change your mind, not just keep
- 18:47going down the bad path. Now, in terms of a transition,
- 18:52yes, oil is a finite resource, so let's finish it.
- 18:55We can start with renewables in tandem.
- 18:59What's happening is that they're pressing stop on oil and gas and
- 19:03then hoping that renewables will work.
- 19:04That is a silly way to carry out a policy.
- 19:07If you do it right, then the renewables will, you know, in
- 19:12appropriate market situation, actually take over.
- 19:15You didn't need people to ban typewriters.
- 19:18Four computers became what were proliferating everywhere.
- 19:21That's what LYDG was doing now. Or let's ban the typewriters.
- 19:24Then it will force people to go and get APC.
- 19:26That is a stupid way of doing things.
- 19:28I'm very much against it and the entire industry is aghast at
- 19:32what's going on. And the real problem we have is
- 19:34that there is no one on the Labour front bench who's ever
- 19:36worked in a business. They don't understand it and
- 19:39that's why they're making these terrible decisions.
- 19:41Right. You talk about the supply chain.
- 19:42Supply chain are desperate for a change of policy from the UK
- 19:45government because they're seeing the jobs and the skills
- 19:47and the investment the UK and go to just about any other base in
- 19:50the country in the world where Ed Miliband is not in charge of
- 19:52energy policy, where they're still delivering oil and gas,
- 19:55still generating, still investing, still drilling, still
- 19:57exploring, including, by the way, in Norway.
- 19:59We're getting from the very same sea.
- 20:01We're preventing ourselves from getting it from this absolute
- 20:03nonsense. So that does it for our chat
- 20:05with Kemi Badnock and Andrew Bowie.
- 20:08But stick around because a familiar voice for long term
- 20:11listeners is returning at Alastair.
- 20:14Thomas from True North is going to speak about his firm's latest
- 20:17polling. Hello, I'm Ed Reid, the editor
- 20:22of E Forward. E Forward is a membership
- 20:24community that brings together the entire UK energy supply
- 20:27chain, every hub, every sector, every stage.
- 20:31Our aim is to deliver growth to the energy sector, working with
- 20:34industry and policy makers to unlock the UK's opportunities
- 20:37and advantages. This is the movement to secure
- 20:41increased investment, improved policy making and better
- 20:44collaboration by providing our members with visibility,
- 20:47influence and access. Join me Forward today.
- 20:53Hi, we have an energy voice out loud.
- 20:55Listeners, we have a special surprise here for you today.
- 20:58I'm here with Alistair Thomas. Many of you might remember him
- 21:02from the glory days of Energy Voice out loud when he was a
- 21:06major contributor to this podcast.
- 21:10And we're welcoming you back to tell us a little bit about some
- 21:14polling you've done with your new outfit True North, talking
- 21:18about attitudes people across the north of Scotland have to
- 21:23infrastructure. As we know, there's a Scottish
- 21:27election coming up in a couple of months and I get the feeling
- 21:31this won't be the last We'll see polls asking about people feel
- 21:36about offshore wind, overhead pylons, investment in the grid.
- 21:41And but can I just say in the first instance, welcome back,
- 21:44Alistair. How does it feel to be back in
- 21:46the hot seat? Did you miss us?
- 21:47Did you miss our listeners? Oh absolutely.
- 21:50I'm not sure I could classified in the cell as the glory days,
- 21:53the dark days of what people are saying, hearing my voice every
- 21:56single week. You.
- 21:57Know your dulcet tones were always, always a pleasure.
- 22:00To listen to, it's good fun to be back, but yeah, to take on
- 22:04what you you referenced there. So earlier this week we launched
- 22:08What the North Thinks from Stiffly Partnership.
- 22:11That's an attitude survey of, well, unprecedented scale and
- 22:15detail across the north of Scotland from the Highlands down
- 22:18to Parthink and Ross. And the data I think adds some
- 22:22nuance to the debate as you referenced for coming up to an
- 22:24election. And we don't see energy
- 22:27infrastructure really calming down in terms of being a very
- 22:30hot topic for that. And what it shows, you know, a
- 22:32clear base level of support for renewables and the onshore
- 22:36infrastructure, which are most that strong feeling that these
- 22:40aren't being delivered quickly enough and there are significant
- 22:42policy barriers in place. And the same study also feels
- 22:45support for domestic oil and gas production.
- 22:47So there's I think there's recognition there on requirement
- 22:49for oil and gas, the requirement for offer renewables.
- 22:52And and as you know, delivering A balanced transition means
- 22:55having both. Yeah.
- 22:56Now, I mean, we'll go maybe a little bit in the detail.
- 23:00And of course, you know, we saw you host a panel discussion to a
- 23:07crowded room at the Mark Cliff in Aberdeen about this earlier
- 23:11on in the week and really interesting engagement and lots
- 23:15of really high profile people from the industry there who I
- 23:18thought were really welcomed the the news.
- 23:21But you know what I mean. You know, there's been quite a
- 23:24few polls, you know, looking at, you know, Scots and their
- 23:29approach to, you know, their views on energy and, and what it
- 23:32all means. But to a certain extent, you
- 23:36know, I mean, we know that there's an election coming up,
- 23:39but what value is this? You know, just, you know, maybe,
- 23:44you know, particularly in Scotland where, you know,
- 23:47policymakers don't have, uh, don't have as much influence
- 23:51maybe over the energy policy as St.
- 23:54Westminster, uh, for example, uh, you know, kind of, that's
- 23:57where decisions on oil and gas taxation are made.
- 24:01That's where, uh, the amount of money allocated to, uh, CFDS
- 24:05funding, uh, offshore wind, uh, are made and umm, you know, so
- 24:10it just kind of seems like why, why, what do we need these polls
- 24:13to do and why are they valuable? Yeah, no, it's an excellent
- 24:18question. So I mean, I think this
- 24:19particular project comes down to a desire for for clear data for
- 24:23the public, for the industry and yes for government to showcase
- 24:28how people are are feeling about the energy transition in in the
- 24:31North and the Northeast. If you consider I guess most
- 24:34polls will take A-1000 person sample size Scotland wide and
- 24:39that is kind of standard industry practice.
- 24:41What we've got here, over 3000 people drilled down very
- 24:45specifically into these communities.
- 24:47As I say, this has never been done at this scale on this level
- 24:50before. So it's providing a really
- 24:52robust data set in terms of what the North really thinks on these
- 24:57issues. And I think why it's important
- 25:00is as a whole, a host of reasons.
- 25:02I think part of us about building consensus around the
- 25:04issues that stands face the moment.
- 25:07And I don't think we should underestimate, whilst yes, much
- 25:11of the decision making is reserved for Westminster and
- 25:13energy policy, the Scottish supply chain and indeed Scottish
- 25:17Government's Scottish policymakers, everyone has a
- 25:20role to play in recognizing some of the issues that put at hand
- 25:24and then leveraging that to get things changed.
- 25:27Because some of these issues are very deeply pertinent to the
- 25:30North, the Northeast specifically.
- 25:33The people that are affected by it need to recognise that first
- 25:36importance. I mean, I, you know, I don't
- 25:38need to, you know, dismiss it all.
- 25:40You know, the Scottish Parliament and as we know, you
- 25:43know, they're still maintaining, you know, this presumption
- 25:46against oil and gas, even though apparently we just recently
- 25:51spoke to John Swinney who said he's been begging, you know,
- 25:55practically to see changes to the EPL brought in sooner.
- 25:59Yet, you know, they still aren't really kind of fancy oil and
- 26:01gas. But anyway, enough about that.
- 26:04You know what I found interesting about the polling in
- 26:07particular. And it's it's particularly
- 26:09poignant to and it's an interesting thing to ask people
- 26:13because you kind of wonder if they really grasp it.
- 26:16So in a particularly, you know, charging for wind projects to
- 26:23connect to the grid. We know that in Scotland there's
- 26:27a huge problem, you know, in this geography because the
- 26:30further away the wind farm is out in the sea, the more the
- 26:35wind blows. But the further it is away from
- 26:37areas of population, so the more it costs, you know, developers
- 26:43to connect to the grid. So and you ask people about
- 26:45this. So tell me a little bit about
- 26:47that. And it's really actually
- 26:49extraordinary how people felt very strongly.
- 26:51It's one of the most strong. It's one of the strongest
- 26:54responses that we saw in the survey.
- 26:55Yeah, I'll just be quite clear. At one point we didn't ask
- 26:58people about this. We commissioned the poll.
- 27:00Sorry. Sorry, yeah, not at all
- 27:03Partnership. So just to be clear on that.
- 27:08But yeah, I think it's encouraging to see the level of
- 27:10recognition of this issue in the in the data.
- 27:13As you, as you referenced, transmission charges are a
- 27:15fundamental barrier to offshore wind development in this region.
- 27:19They're already undermining projects existing today and the
- 27:23announcement we saw this week with West of Orkney Wind Farm,
- 27:25that's a fully consented GW scale projects which will not
- 27:30proceed with a form of transmission charges.
- 27:32I think that really underlines the jeopardy that we're facing
- 27:35in this region at a time when we're trying to deliver off the
- 27:38wind at scale from the north. That's what the government
- 27:40wants. These charges send a signal to
- 27:44developers do not invest here. And so the government says that
- 27:47the reform could be as late as 2029.
- 27:49That's that's frankly time the energy transition does not have.
- 27:53We need to see action now to take away not to the next CFD
- 27:57round ARE to expect them to open up later this year.
- 28:01We need that I think for developers for the supply chain
- 28:04to really have the the confidence to to invest that to
- 28:07deliver. Absolutely.
- 28:08So I mean, I think we've probably already discussed this
- 28:12at length in other parts of today's podcast, but it just
- 28:15goes to show, you know, it really, it just really stinks.
- 28:20I think, you know, we won't see Scotland, you know, kind of
- 28:25reaching the full extent of its potential unless, you know, the
- 28:29UK does something about transmission charging.
- 28:32I mean, you know, anyway and often about that.
- 28:35But you know, another thing about your, these polls
- 28:40commissioned by True North and undertaken by, you know, the
- 28:43estimable mark diffly, one of the things that came out is that
- 28:48there seemed to be more support and understanding about, you
- 28:52know, the need for energy transition and, uh, amongst
- 28:55people who felt, uh, better informed about what was going
- 28:58on. But there's still a lot of
- 28:59people who felt that maybe they needed to be better informed,
- 29:02particularly about infrastructure and where it's
- 29:04going to be built. Umm, you know, we see a lot of,
- 29:08uh, you know, communities, uh, you know, around, you know, this
- 29:11area, you know, they, they get, they get, they go to a
- 29:14consultation meeting and they go, you know, what fresh hell is
- 29:17this? Umm, And you know, they get
- 29:19angry and maybe a bit afraid, and you know, there's still a
- 29:22lot of work there to be done. Maybe this kind of emerged in
- 29:25some of the polling in this issue, didn't it?
- 29:28Yeah, It's really interesting to see the correlation between
- 29:31those who feel better informed and those who feel broadly more
- 29:36supportive of projects. I think to your point though,
- 29:40you know, it's important to acknowledge and respond to
- 29:43concerns on renewable infrastructure as they arise.
- 29:46I think the projects that we see approved and succeeding are the
- 29:51ones that are doing all of that very well, meaningfully engaging
- 29:54with communities, delivering local jobs and investment and
- 29:58yes, you know mitigating concerns as they arise if there
- 30:02is a reasonable ability for them to do so.
- 30:06But yes, I mean, fundamentally, I think what this data shows us
- 30:09is there is a broad level of support across communities for
- 30:13this infrastructure. And yeah, the largest share
- 30:16believe it's not being delivered quickly enough.
- 30:19So that's again a question for government.
- 30:21No, indeed. Now of course there was, you
- 30:25know, questioning about, you know, people and how they felt
- 30:30about oil and gas. And I mean on, I think if you
- 30:34ask people, you know, kind of should we get meet demand for
- 30:41oil and gas from the North Sea or should we import it?
- 30:44It's kind of a no brainer, right?
- 30:46You know, I think, you know, that kind of gives us the
- 30:49obvious answer. And as it turned out, 87% said
- 30:52yes, they would like to see that demand met from domestic
- 30:55production in the North Sea rather than importing it from
- 30:58overseas. But does that, is that really,
- 31:02you know, widespread approval of, of continued use of oil and
- 31:06gas when there seems to be such a big shift in attitudes and
- 31:10acceptance of renewables, there's a big desire for people
- 31:13to see renewables. How do we square that circle?
- 31:15Well, I think it's, it's, it's not and it's not one or the
- 31:19other. I think we need to see offer
- 31:21renewables and delivery of oil and gas.
- 31:24I think both of them have share this unfortunate issue that they
- 31:28are constrained by policy. Clearly we've seen and you've
- 31:31reported on quite broadly the effects of the energy profits
- 31:34levy in terms of where the the UK continental shelf is today.
- 31:39We've know from the Nsta's latest resources and reserves
- 31:43reports that there is no potential out there, but it
- 31:45requires investments to to deliver.
- 31:48At the same time we've already talked about it.
- 31:50We have policy barriers to offshore wind as well.
- 31:54And, but what we've seen from the polling we've issued as from
- 31:58Mark Tifley this week, from the other data we've issued from
- 32:03Polo Commission, from surveyion last week, is that there is
- 32:06support for North Sea oil and gas both across Scotland and
- 32:11detailing into those communities across the North.
- 32:14In terms of the economic value that the oil and gas industry
- 32:17delivers. And support for, yes, domestic
- 32:20production as much as possible whilst we require it.
- 32:23And whilst it mitigates overseas imports, which you know, as as
- 32:27you know are coming to higher carbon footprints as indeed
- 32:31doesn't do the same thing in terms of stimulating our supply
- 32:33chain, stimulating our economy. I guess the point is we, you
- 32:37know, we need all these elements to deliver the transition.
- 32:39It's not one or the other. And I think the data shows the
- 32:42public recognizes that. It's interesting because I
- 32:45think, you know, maybe people who live around energy industry
- 32:50as we do here in the north and the Northeast, you know, it's
- 32:54something that I think, you know, people in other areas of
- 32:57the country could probably benefit from knowing from.
- 32:59So as a result, I think you know, as much as perhaps you're,
- 33:04you're here again today speaking to some converted already.
- 33:09It's really useful to try to get that message out and to just try
- 33:14to normalise it and to make sure that it stays on the agenda.
- 33:18So Alistair, any any final wise words before we sign off Is your
- 33:24what's the rest of your plan for the week?
- 33:26I'm going to try to get my toddler onto a regular sleeping
- 33:30pattern and at the same time, we're going to try to just get a
- 33:35bit more of this messaging out there because I think there's
- 33:37some important points around around what this can deliver
- 33:41for, for the north and northeast.
- 33:42And and yeah, that that's a nuanced issue, that transmission
- 33:45charges piece. Look, it's a it's a technical
- 33:47issue. It doesn't sound particularly
- 33:49sexy, but it's a really consequential one for Scotland.
- 33:51So it's good to see some acknowledgement of that, could
- 33:54see yourself and others reporting on on that issue.
- 33:57And so, yes, luck doing so going forward.
- 34:00Well, hopefully tenuous charging is easier to soothe than a
- 34:04toddler. All the best to you, Alistair.
- 34:07Pleasure to see you. And of course, we I'm sure we'll
- 34:09see you at non. Thanks for joining us.
- 34:11So that does it for yet another episode of Energy Voice Out
- 34:15Loud. But if you'd like to leave us
- 34:17any feedback, well, you can always drop us a five star
- 34:20review on your podcast platform of choice and let us know what
- 34:23you think on social media, in particular LinkedIn, and we will
- 34:27see you at the same time, same place next week.