Latest / Rewire To Rise– Beyond The Mindset / The Hidden Cost of Outsourcing Your Thinking to AI | Just Pedersen
Transcript
- 0:00How do we create a safe and secure environment for students
- 0:03to fail when AI makes it so easy to always be right?
- 0:09Some of the early experience with AI simulations, they
- 0:12suggest the students are really willing to fail.
- 0:15AI has the potential to enhance our learning.
- 0:17It has the potential to inhibit our learning.
- 0:19You speak also about future literacy, right?
- 0:22Does that mean learning to use the tools or learning how to
- 0:26live without them? I use future literacy here in
- 0:30the sense of the 21st century skills framework that Trilling
- 0:34and Fidel has popularised, which basically says that there are
- 0:38sort of some, some skills that is commonly held to be necessary
- 0:42to function in today's society and future society in this
- 0:45century. And, and those skills, they
- 0:47include things like part of thinking about thinking.
- 0:50Oh, I love the word meter. Cognition for me at least is is
- 0:54just sort of, you know, remembering what sort of to
- 0:56accept and and what to push back is where I may also have a
- 0:59concern. Are they ready?
- 1:00Are they ready for, you know, metacognition?
- 1:03Are they ready for I agree for being self-directed.
- 1:06It comes back then to sort of, you know, the debate right now
- 1:09about, you know, the term artificial intelligence is, is
- 1:12AI intelligence. One of the reasons that this is
- 1:15being debated is we don't really have a clear definition of what
- 1:19makes us humans intelligent. If we believe, if we believe
- 1:22Marilla, that our intelligence, intelligence works in the way
- 1:25that sort of, you know, based on your prior experience.
- 1:33Hello to everyone. In our last episode with the
- 1:36Renee Larson, we explored in the strategic discipline required to
- 1:40navigate modern markets. Well, if Renee Larson gave us
- 1:45the map for the landscape, yes, Peterson is here today with us
- 1:49to give us the manual of the digital mindset by exploring how
- 1:54we use AI to augment our intelligence rather than failing
- 1:59into cognitive death. Hello, yes, hello and welcome.
- 2:04Oh, hello Marella, pleasure to be here.
- 2:06Yeah. Tell us a little bit about you,
- 2:08please. Well, sure.
- 2:11So when I'm not appearing on your podcast, I'm an associate
- 2:15professor with the Business Academy of Copenhagen.
- 2:20I'm also one of the editors of the Danish Niche Media AI
- 2:25Portal, which you know, as the name would suggest covers all
- 2:28things AI. And yeah, that's, I think is
- 2:34the, is the very brief version of me as most professors with
- 2:38the, with the business Academy. I, I used to work in business.
- 2:42So I've been a business consultant for some large
- 2:45consultancies like KPMG and implement.
- 2:50I've worked as a business developer for some large
- 2:54companies like BP and Austed, But you know, for the past
- 2:58decade or so I've been looking into sort of how to teach
- 3:04e-commerce and other new exciting technologies to young
- 3:08people at the two bachelor's degrees that I coordinate.
- 3:12So that's that's me, yeah. Wow, pretty interesting
- 3:16background I would say. Well, thank.
- 3:20You, you're welcome. You have moved from management
- 3:22consulting, as you just mentioned a second ago.
- 3:25To. Researching the deep mechanics
- 3:29of AI in education. What was the that red flag that
- 3:33made you realise we needed to look closer at how AI effects
- 3:38our brains? Yeah, yeah.
- 3:41So I mean, I think I've been, I've been teaching in the, in
- 3:47the e-commerce space for the past decade.
- 3:51And, and e-commerce is actually sort of, you know, where we had
- 3:55some of the first pregenerative AIS because we had the big AI
- 4:01Google and Google would like, you know, to find texts and
- 4:04humans would like to, you know, have their homepage be found.
- 4:07And very early on, some programs there rose that, you know, if
- 4:12you you had a product name like running shoes, well, you know, a
- 4:16computer could make a text that would mention running shoes in
- 4:20the way that Google liked it. Yeah.
- 4:22So we had smaller machines, you know, talking to the bigger
- 4:25machine and, you know, so the, you know, our homepage would be
- 4:28found. But these tools was where I got
- 4:31some very early insight into what we now know as ChatGPT, as
- 4:36Google Gemini and all those other great products.
- 4:39And I think sort of the red flag for me was when I saw that
- 4:49potentially within learning institutions, within the
- 4:53educational sector in Denmark, the premise is that we ask
- 4:58students to create works of knowledge and we we don't ask
- 5:02them to do that because, you know, we like them to, you know,
- 5:05slave and, and, and work, but because we recognize that the
- 5:08process of creating a work of knowledge requires you to
- 5:12develop an understanding. But all of a sudden with AI, we
- 5:16get a very, very easy way to create a work of knowledge that,
- 5:21you know, to the untrained eye will look, you know, great and
- 5:24top professional, but there's actually been no development of
- 5:28understanding in that. And that that's sort of your
- 5:31what the what made me, me pay attention.
- 5:35And I think sort of, you know, the point here is that I'm
- 5:39seeing a disconnect between outputs and understanding it
- 5:45used to be very tight and connected and it's it's not
- 5:48anymore. Well, we were going to talk
- 5:51about that as well. Well, again, you speak also
- 5:56about future literacy, right? Does that mean learning to use
- 6:01the tools or learning how to live without them actually?
- 6:06I mean, I, I use future literacy here in the sense of the 21st
- 6:12century skills framework for that the Trilling and Fidel has
- 6:15popularized, which basically says that there are sort of
- 6:19some, some skills that is commonly held to be necessary to
- 6:24function in today's society and future society in the century.
- 6:29And, and those skills, they include things like critical
- 6:32thinking, like creativity. They also include understanding
- 6:38IT. They also understand and you
- 6:40know, understanding AI and, and so basically what the framework
- 6:44does and, and I agree with this point is that it says there's
- 6:48something about being creative, thinking critically, and there's
- 6:52also something about understanding the tools that we
- 6:54have there. So I think for me, future
- 6:57literacy is about developing both judgements, own personal
- 7:03judgement, but also to know how AI works, how IT products work.
- 7:12And I think those are two different areas that need to be
- 7:16trained separately, but I think they're equally important.
- 7:21So looking at your research, do you think we are currently in a
- 7:27honeymoon phase with AI that it's blinding us to the long
- 7:33term cognitive costs? I'm curious.
- 7:36Yeah, Yeah. I mean, I think that sort of we
- 7:40are we're definitely right now in a phase right now where if
- 7:45you know a little about AI, you know relatively a lot compared
- 7:51to other people. So I think there's a lot of
- 7:54people. What do you?
- 7:55Mean by that? What I mean is, what I mean is,
- 7:57is that there's a lot of people who are using AI, but they're
- 8:01not thinking about how they're using it.
- 8:03They're not understanding the tool.
- 8:05And I mean, AI can, is, is is is a great tool because it allows
- 8:10you to do that. It allows you without having a
- 8:12deeper understanding of how it works, to sit down and use it.
- 8:16So it's very accessible, Yeah. But that also means that it's
- 8:21being accessed by a lot of people who are using it in a
- 8:25potentially long term disruptive way.
- 8:29Can you give us some examples as well?
- 8:30So far this to my understand that how they use it is
- 8:34destructive in that sense. Thank you.
- 8:36Well. I mean the, I mean I, I think
- 8:38sort of, you know, if we come back to the red flag in, in, in,
- 8:41in your, in your first sentence, you know, if, if I have a group
- 8:47of students and I asked them to write a report on the customer
- 8:51journey for a given product and they asked the AI to do it, you
- 8:56know, I will get a nice report. But what will the students have
- 8:59learned if I give them a good grade?
- 9:01They will learn well, track TPT can write great reports and that
- 9:05will be the sum of their learning.
- 9:07So this is fine if they think, if the students are thinking,
- 9:13you know, I don't need to learn about customer journeys, you
- 9:16know, stupid old professor, you know, let's just give him
- 9:18something. I get my diploma.
- 9:19You know, he gets his pay, Everybody's happy.
- 9:22Yeah. I would not, I would not
- 9:23generalize and I would not say that's the majority.
- 9:26I think it's the point that some students may have, but I think
- 9:29there's a lot of other students who don't have that point of
- 9:32view. And I think it depends, you
- 9:35know, on what topic, but I think that's one of the things I think
- 9:38it's fascinating about sort of learning and AI is that you're
- 9:43pushed much more into, you know, having to decide what learning
- 9:50you believe is relevant for that.
- 9:52But, you know, we'll get back to that.
- 9:54We'll get back to that later on. But I think sort of the bad
- 9:59usage of AI is if you use it way to, to, to create where you
- 10:06should be learning. And the, the strange thing about
- 10:10AI is you could also use it to learn.
- 10:13I mean, it's, it's, it's AI has the potential to be both a
- 10:18learning enhancer and a learning inhibitor, depending on how you
- 10:23use it. And that sort of comes back to
- 10:25sort of my point about that. I think there is something about
- 10:28AI literacy that is a very, very important part of future
- 10:34literacy. You mentioned also that AI often
- 10:37skips the thinking phase, so that's again because this is
- 10:41connected to what we have talked until this point and move
- 10:44straight to the apply phase. This is the tendency kind of
- 10:49what happens to a human mind that stop practicing the middle
- 10:52step. I mean, the, the mind is a
- 10:55muscle, you know, if, if we want the, if we want bigger ABS, you
- 11:00know, we go to the gym, we lift some weights.
- 11:03If you want the sharper mind, well, we, we train it not with,
- 11:06with weights, but with other, other, other exercises that are
- 11:10more suitable in that direction. But, but very basically, I think
- 11:14that's, that's the risk here. You know, that, that people
- 11:18would, will get lazy. And there's a growing body of
- 11:20evidence within the literature that seems to confirm this, that
- 11:27yes, people who you know, move into using AI in a unreflective
- 11:31way. They simply become less
- 11:36profession in in in syncing within the topic that they are
- 11:44using AI for. Is it possible to be an expert
- 11:49in something if you have used AI to bypass the struggle of
- 11:53learning it? No, no, it's not.
- 11:56I mean very, very clear, hard, absolute no.
- 12:02So expertise is is is is is something that's only achieved
- 12:08through wrestling with concepts, you making mistakes, revising
- 12:12judgments and, and, and sort of gradually, well, you know,
- 12:18building up your own judgments and and value calls around a a
- 12:24topic. If you're using AI to perform
- 12:29and you know to create without, you know your own thought
- 12:32process, your own learning, then that will not be a path to
- 12:37expertise. But it contimulated.
- 12:41I mean, strangely enough, we also have some studies that,
- 12:44that, that point out that in the workplace, the performance
- 12:51increase from using AI is the highest with less experience
- 12:56beginning untrained labor. So I mean, because they're just
- 13:03prompt and then, you know, they take the answer and they put the
- 13:05answer on. But I think this, this, this is
- 13:09something that carries a lot of risk, you know, because what if
- 13:12what they're passing on, you know, is, is, is wrong and you
- 13:15need somebody with experience to point that out in terms of
- 13:18performance. You know, AI can, can allow you
- 13:21to perform a task in which you do not necessarily have
- 13:28expertise. Yeah, which which is a weird way
- 13:31of using that word. But the usage of AI carries some
- 13:36risks. But, you know, I mean, the usage
- 13:39of building up expertise carries risks as well.
- 13:43But I think sort of, you know, you cannot, but just to to give
- 13:46a very clear answer, again, cannot be an expert without
- 13:50having, you know, put in the hours within.
- 13:54I think within basketball, you know, they say you have to make
- 13:571000 shots a day if you want to play in the pro league.
- 14:02Yeah, absolutely not. Not shoot.
- 14:05So the practicality still is still available also in this in
- 14:09the case of AI. Please correct me if I'm wrong.
- 14:13Definitely, Definitely, yeah. By the way, since we are talking
- 14:17about this US, I have another sample and a question also at
- 14:23the same time, in a professional environment, that means while a
- 14:28person, let's take myself, if I'm an employee that works for a
- 14:33company, it doesn't matter the size of the company, a small,
- 14:37medium, big, it doesn't matter. But either way, if I'm working
- 14:40for this company and I have the opportunity to use AI for that
- 14:45company, right? But I'm not an expert as such.
- 14:48OK, So I'm just I'm allowed to use AI doing my schedule in that
- 14:55professional environment. And I know that there are some
- 14:59legislations, at least in the in you that actually you have to
- 15:05give to your employees a specific training in regards in
- 15:10order for those employees to use AI also, because they have to
- 15:14protect the data of that company, the privacy and so many
- 15:18other elements that they have to be included in this topic.
- 15:21So what would say for in regards to this particular example?
- 15:26Well, I mean, I would, I would say that it's true that the EUAI
- 15:31Act mandates AI training, but it's a fairly new piece of, of
- 15:40legislation. And so I think what's not sort
- 15:44of been decided is how specific that training should be.
- 15:49Yeah. I heard about that, Yeah, that's
- 15:52why I'm asking to you as well. Yeah, yeah.
- 15:54And I mean, the answer is it's a good question.
- 15:58I mean, in GDPR, which was, you know, the the latest, greatest
- 16:04branding, thankfully, you there's, there's now sort of a
- 16:07fairly good understanding of, you know, what is that?
- 16:11And you know, what triggers fines, what triggers warnings?
- 16:17And, and how should we, how should we deal with that?
- 16:21And I think sort of, but you know, I mean, if let's, let's
- 16:24think of sort of the process that that went through right
- 16:27now. I think there's going to be a
- 16:30honeymoon phase where regulators, they're going to be
- 16:33focusing on advising on, on developing practices for, you
- 16:39know, for example, sort of what level of training would be
- 16:43required. And over the the coming years,
- 16:48you know, we'll see some sort of of framework emerge.
- 16:52I mean, one of the metaphors I like to use for AI is, you know,
- 16:57if we imagine, you know, that we had cars, but we had no
- 17:02regulation on driving, there was nothing called a driver's
- 17:04license. That that is the state of AI
- 17:08right now. It's a powerful technology.
- 17:09It's very potentially useful. It can lead to accidents, but we
- 17:15don't have sort of a practice around it.
- 17:17We're going to get there. We're going to get there, but
- 17:22it's it's a good question. You use the term cognitive debt
- 17:27just like financial debts, right?
- 17:30How do we eventually have to pay back the thinking we have
- 17:33outsourced to machines? Yeah, exactly.
- 17:39The thing is, I'm, I'm, I'm using this from from again, this
- 17:42is a term that's being thrown around at the in the literature.
- 17:44I mean, there's a researcher called Kasimna who I've I've
- 17:48started from and who I like to quote on this topic.
- 17:51But very basically, I mean, if if you are given a task by your
- 17:57employer and you're using AI to perform that, great.
- 18:02But you know, at a certain point, if you have to, let's say
- 18:07you, you know, your, your, your boss asks you for a presentation
- 18:10at what you can make, have AI, you know, write up a
- 18:13presentation or a white paper and you can send that off and
- 18:16your boss can think, OK, that's great.
- 18:18Now, if your boss then asks you to come in and do that
- 18:20presentation, that's when you have to pay the cognitive debt.
- 18:25That's when you have to sort of, you know, I mean, or you'll end
- 18:29up in the situation where you're standing there reading some
- 18:32words from a slide, that being exactly sure what, what, what
- 18:37they mean, Something that of course, has never happened to
- 18:39any educator in Denmark. But that's the cognitive debt
- 18:42that we have to be be mindful of when, when we are using AI, we
- 18:49are not to, to create something we're not learning.
- 18:52And I think, you know, I, I like to think of it as that's fine if
- 18:57our objective is not learning at.
- 18:59This point I have a question if you don't mind.
- 19:02Personally, I'm not a researcher as such, but I'm something else.
- 19:06Do think that to a certain degree you can still learn by
- 19:11using AI. So to a certain degree, you
- 19:13still learn if you use it in a healthy way, if using in a
- 19:17constructive way, if you use if you know what are your limits
- 19:21and if you know what are the limits of that AI tool.
- 19:25That's not because they do have limits.
- 19:27That's the whole point as we as humans as well.
- 19:30So there are so many things and elements, important elements
- 19:34that has to be considered in regards to this topic.
- 19:38Because I think that people should know or remember at least
- 19:43that this is really truly a powerful tool.
- 19:46As you just mentioned earlier. That's the whole point.
- 19:48But being so powerful can also harm us, but also can do good.
- 19:52So we still there, there is that gap that other people still
- 19:58nowadays, they don't reflect upon that thinking that there is
- 20:01also a process in the middle. That means the process of
- 20:04learning also include that particular face, right?
- 20:07So that's why I wanted to stop you for a second, because it can
- 20:10be actually a tool to learn, but it depends how you, how you use
- 20:14it, the usage of that tool. Definitely, definitely.
- 20:19And one, one of the sort of terms that that I, I, I found in
- 20:24the literature, which I think is interesting, is the expression a
- 20:27pedagogical prompt. And a pedagogical prompt is when
- 20:30you try to prompt the machine to help you learn.
- 20:35And, and, and very basically, I mean, the premise for a
- 20:37pedagogical prompt would involve you writing something like,
- 20:40don't give me the whole answer straight away.
- 20:42Take me through the steps 1 by 1, you know, ask me questions,
- 20:47help me understand both sides of an argument before I proceed and
- 20:52stuff like that. But but sort of thank you for.
- 20:56Mentioning this, yeah. Yeah, Yeah.
- 20:58No, I mean, but, but I think sort of that that AI has has a
- 21:05huge potential in enhancing learning.
- 21:11And again, I think, you know, this comes back to one of the
- 21:14very first questions you asked, which is, is is sort of, you
- 21:17know, what is this future literacy?
- 21:19And I think part of it simply understanding that that AI can
- 21:23inhibit your learning, it can also enhance it.
- 21:26And yes, definitely these are sort of been the ways that you
- 21:28would do either of those two things.
- 21:30But that's why I would like to kind of sometimes dive into this
- 21:35particular matters because they are so very much important and
- 21:38there's so powerful to just know them and know the difference
- 21:43between what harm us and what actually do good to us.
- 21:46In a world where AI can give us the answer in seconds, how do we
- 21:52protect the value of that process?
- 21:55Since we were talking about that but.
- 21:58Yeah, we we simply refuse to confuse output with learning.
- 22:03Protecting the value of the process is simply recognizing
- 22:06that there is a process. Yeah, and being conscious about
- 22:09it. And I think that's also
- 22:11something that I think we should, we should go a little
- 22:14bit deeper into is, is this idea that AI forces us to be more
- 22:23conscious about how we do things.
- 22:25It's it's no longer just, you know, let's, you know, throw
- 22:29ourselves into it and do it. But you actually sort of need to
- 22:32reflect first. Wait a second, you know, what is
- 22:34sort of the framework for this and what are my goals here?
- 22:39And, and it requires us to be, to be self-conscious in a in a
- 22:44higher degree. Your research mentioned that
- 22:47people feel less ownership over work created with LLM.
- 22:53So if we don't own our work, do we eventually lose our sense of
- 22:58professional identity? Could happen that.
- 23:03Potentially, yeah. I mean, if we, if we believe
- 23:07that there is no longer a connection between outputs and
- 23:15and process, you know, is, is somebody then a painter because
- 23:23they've made some paintings. If they use the AI, if I go into
- 23:27Udio, one of the music AIS and creates a number of songs, am I
- 23:35now a musician? I, I would, I would rather say
- 23:40that AI allows us to create output outside of, of our
- 23:48profession of our expertise. It doesn't create expertise for
- 23:54us in, in that space. It doesn't make us an expert in
- 23:59in that, but it allows us to go in and and make something.
- 24:04So I think there's also something here about, you know,
- 24:08professional identity actually sort of becoming more narrow,
- 24:14more specialized. Definitely.
- 24:18If we can't recall or quote our own essay, are we actually
- 24:22becoming less literate while appearing more productive?
- 24:26Yes, I mean, this is the cognitive debt that you were
- 24:30asking about before, where we have a number of studies about
- 24:35students, students using AI to produce these essays.
- 24:40You know, people read those essays, great essays.
- 24:44And then when you ask sort of students about those essays, you
- 24:47know, well, you know, how would you, can you quote something
- 24:50from it? They can't as in, you know, only
- 24:5410% of them can mention the sentence that actually does
- 24:57appear in that essay that they handed in.
- 25:00And and again, sort of this, this is this is the disconnect
- 25:04between output and and learning that we're seeing.
- 25:09How do we train the next generation to use AI as this
- 25:13parent partner rather than the Ghost Rider?
- 25:17Yeah. And I mean this, this, I think
- 25:21this is the part of the of the 21st century skill framework
- 25:26that emphasizes having ICT skills or well, AI skills.
- 25:31So we make explicit learning goals about how to use AI as a
- 25:37as aspiring partner and we train ourselves in that if again, our
- 25:44goal is learning. Yeah.
- 25:46Is the passive reception of AI information the greatest threat
- 25:50to critical thinking in 2026? That's a good question.
- 25:57I mean, I think, you know, we should be wary of sort of
- 26:01assuming that we're we're just coming out of a golden age of
- 26:05critical thinking and then AI showed up and it ruined
- 26:08everything. Yeah, I think sort of, you know,
- 26:12that over reliance on AI seems to be able to use to reduce your
- 26:22critical thinking within the area that you're using AI for.
- 26:26Yeah. And then again, you know what,
- 26:29what will be coming from, you know, was, was, was was critical
- 26:33thinking perfect 200 years ago, 50 years ago.
- 26:39So I think there's always been threats to, I think humanity has
- 26:42always struggled with critical thinking.
- 26:44I think they continue to to struggle with it and I think
- 26:48this is one of the parts of the human condition that that
- 26:51fascinates me as an educator. A.
- 26:54Lot of words that books would dull through understanding.
- 26:58Is AI just the modern version of that fear, or is this shift
- 27:04fundamentally different? But I mean, strictly speaking, I
- 27:09mean, it was it was Socrates who voiced that concern, but he did
- 27:14it in Plato's writing because Socrates, you know, really was
- 27:19against writing and he never wrote anything himself.
- 27:23So. So all the information, well,
- 27:25most of the information we had about Socrates is, is from
- 27:29Plato's writings about what Socrates said.
- 27:33Yeah, I think there's, there's two of the main sources that
- 27:36that also seems to correlate a little bit with it.
- 27:38But they are describing Socrates as a much younger man, whereas
- 27:42Plato is describing as an oh, God.
- 27:44But but yeah, I mean, the argument, the argument from from
- 27:49Socrates was that if you're just reading something, you're
- 27:55getting sort of this dulled down, dumbed down understanding
- 27:58that is much less laden with information and and allows you
- 28:03much less to interact with it than if you're speaking with a
- 28:06person. And I think sort of this is a
- 28:09point that we would all agree on.
- 28:11I mean, right now, Marela, we're doing a podcast, right?
- 28:14I mean, we're not writing a text, sending it off to your
- 28:18audience. So we're doing a live discussion
- 28:21so that we in this dialogue can explore nuances.
- 28:24We can ask little questions here and there.
- 28:28So we believe, you know, we agree with Socrates and that
- 28:31point that, you know, the dialogue seems to be a more rich
- 28:34environment. I think that AI is is again, you
- 28:42know, also now a a new technology.
- 28:45And I think whether sort of, you know, it will dull through
- 28:48understanding, that will depend a lot on how we define true
- 28:53understanding. If we go back to Socrates, his
- 28:55argument was true understanding was your ability to engage and
- 28:59convince other people of your point.
- 29:03But but so and, and if if you agree with that definition of
- 29:06true understanding, well, you know, then reading could
- 29:09potentially tell that. Yeah, because it doesn't
- 29:14necessarily prepare you for how to engage in a debate.
- 29:19So I think sort of with AII think that that that is also
- 29:23something where a lot of people are saying it's harming
- 29:25education. Yeah, well, I mean, you know,
- 29:28depends on how we define education, on how we define
- 29:32learning. And I think sort of.
- 29:34How would you define education then?
- 29:36At this point, I'm going to ask you.
- 29:38Yeah, that's putting me on the spot, isn't it?
- 29:41So I mean, if I would define learning as establishing your
- 29:52own process that you can, you can, you're memorized.
- 29:58So for me, sort of memorization is fundamental to learning.
- 30:07We can't have competencies without having knowledge that it
- 30:10builds upon. Yeah.
- 30:12And expressing yourself is proven to be one of the best
- 30:18ways of memorizing stuff. I mean, that's why we are
- 30:23students, to do assignments. Yeah.
- 30:26Because, you know, if they have to articulate the answers
- 30:29themselves, they have to, you know, take some knowledge, put
- 30:32it through their heads, you know, and, and, and make sense
- 30:34that come out in the other side. And sort of in, in, in that
- 30:40sense. I, I would, I would tend to sort
- 30:44of, you know, agree with, with, with Socrates that, you know,
- 30:48more rich presentation is something that's easy to learn
- 30:51from. But I also think, I also think
- 30:53that there's a cost benefit element here.
- 30:57I mean, if we have, you know, a world class expert within a
- 31:01topic, if we were able to send that world class expert round to
- 31:06every single student in Europe and for him individually to
- 31:11explain his expertise to them, you know, that will probably
- 31:15give a better learning then then if, you know, the students were
- 31:21to read his book. But there's the cost of this,
- 31:24yeah. And I think sort of so I think
- 31:28books, codified information, AI generated information, I think
- 31:33it has a place. And I think it has a place
- 31:36because learning also needs to be cost effective.
- 31:39Yeah. Yeah.
- 31:41So at this point, how do educational institutions needs
- 31:44to rewire code and rewire their grading systems if the result no
- 31:51longer provides the learning? Yeah.
- 31:54That is a great question. Because I know at this point
- 31:59currently we, all the students and the teachers and those
- 32:03institutions as well are in still in this bubble of
- 32:09confusion. Let's confusion, if you allow
- 32:12me, from so many aspects because of AI.
- 32:15So yeah, but please tell us what you can.
- 32:19Yeah, yeah, yeah. One answer that I could give you
- 32:22is that education in, in most of Europe, Denmark, it's state
- 32:27owned, it's state financed and it's state regulated.
- 32:30Yeah. And that provides a great buffer
- 32:33because we get our money no matter what the learning
- 32:35actually happens. Yeah, Yeah.
- 32:39So, so we're kind of, you know, we're saved by the bell on that
- 32:43one. And strangely enough, sort of,
- 32:49you know, even if in the in the places in the world where there
- 32:52are significant private players, the result sort of kind of seems
- 32:57to be the same again, sort of. I think we should remember that
- 33:01education is a package that combines something about
- 33:07certification with learning with social coherence with a social
- 33:12network with sort of a Co branding with the institution.
- 33:18So it's a package deal of which learning is only one component.
- 33:22And so even if that component is is is at risk right now, well,
- 33:26you know, the other parts of the of the package are still there.
- 33:29But I see when I listen to sort of, you know, some of the steps
- 33:32that are being taken slowly within the Danish educational
- 33:36sector. And I think this is much the
- 33:38same across the rest of Europe. Gave us some example.
- 33:41With regards. Well, well, I mean.
- 33:45When I, when I look at sort of, you know, what's happening in in
- 33:48the educational sector right now, there seems to be an idea
- 33:51that we need to move away from writing as an assessment tool.
- 33:55OK, OK. And and.
- 33:58Potentially, potentially, I mean AI might mean that writing as a
- 34:03specific skill might in the long run die.
- 34:06I don't know, but but there's speculation about that.
- 34:10OK. But very basically because,
- 34:13well, in the sense Marilla that that if, if we have great AI
- 34:20transcription software, why would I ever need to write
- 34:23something down when I can just, you know, tell a machine what it
- 34:28needs to write down for me? Yeah, so, and I think that's one
- 34:32of the wonderful things about AI is it's erasing the boundaries
- 34:36that traditionally were between written expression, oral
- 34:38expression, non verbal expressions.
- 34:42It's it's sort of, you know, allowing us to move more
- 34:46seamlessly between those. Yeah.
- 34:50But if we come back to the to the, to the occasion, one of the
- 34:53things that I, I've, I've done at the at the educations that I
- 34:58coordinate is there's no longer any, any purely written exams.
- 35:02There's still are some institutions that have them, but
- 35:07they are fewer. Again, this, and I think this is
- 35:09because of the of the of, of the idea that, that the education
- 35:22sector moves very slowly. I also had had one of had a Dean
- 35:27that sort of explained to me at one point that, yeah, well, you
- 35:30know, written exams, you know, while they were probably
- 35:33unreliable, so were oral exams. And in general, sort of, you
- 35:37know, students got much the same grades, you know, So, you know,
- 35:41what was the bother really? Because I'm curious right now
- 35:47students are, because a majority of the students they do still
- 35:52like really use AI for so many different reasons while they are
- 35:56starting, right? Just put it like in the short
- 35:59term. But so at what point, like the
- 36:02teachers or the schools, the entities, the faculties actually
- 36:07allows or can check if that essay or that assignment or
- 36:12whatever task it was written, written by the the student or,
- 36:19you know, to what degree, they could know that or you as a
- 36:23teacher, you could know that. I'm really curious.
- 36:27Yeah. Yeah.
- 36:27I mean, I think there's a number.
- 36:29Of studies that that point to the fact that it's now been some
- 36:33years since we we were able to detect if something was written
- 36:39by an AI or written by a human. How do you do that?
- 36:42How do you detect? It I'm curious, well, I mean
- 36:45you, you ask an AI to. To assess it, I mean, OK, OK.
- 36:48I mean basically sort of. So you still stay in the loop.
- 36:53Well, I mean well. Basically sort of, you know,
- 36:59back before we sort of had, you know, but not the Internet, but,
- 37:04but if we go 20-30 years back, what we would see would
- 37:09platterization, as in students would copy, you know, pieces of
- 37:13text from books that they've written and put it into their
- 37:16assignments. Typically sort of you'd spot
- 37:19that as a professor by noticing, you know, that the text sort of
- 37:24seemed weird. I remember getting an assignment
- 37:29once from a student at CBS where in his methodology chapter, he
- 37:37explained how he himself personally had discovered what
- 37:42the difference between inductive and deductive ways of developing
- 37:46knowledge was, which, you know, is is would be great if he did
- 37:50that. But you know, you know what,
- 37:52where did you, what book did you find that in mate?
- 37:54And you know, some you have coded that.
- 37:57But, but, but sort of then we got into having IT tools for
- 38:02doing this and we had this, it was called platterization
- 38:05software. And there were a number of
- 38:07software programs that went in and, and you basically I just
- 38:12get a platterization score, you know, saying 20% of this seems
- 38:16to be of course, that was sort of, you know, an interesting
- 38:20tool because these tools were also accessible by students.
- 38:23So I'd get a lot of reports at exactly 20% because that was the
- 38:29cut off rate at which my institution said we're not going
- 38:31to investigate it. So, you know, basically somebody
- 38:35had written something and then, you know, they, they, they throw
- 38:37it into the plaverization machine and they'd see, OK, just
- 38:42one second. What is?
- 38:43The because I didn't know this part, I'm sorry.
- 38:45I'm just curious what is the maximum of the percentage that
- 38:49can be accepted varies by institution.
- 38:51So the institution that I teach at had sort of a rule of thumb
- 38:57that over 20% we should investigate, under 20% we
- 39:01wouldn't even investigate. Again, you know, this was driven
- 39:05a lot by sort of, you know, a cost benefits assessment.
- 39:13But The thing is, and, and just sort of to finish the part here
- 39:17is, is, is that nowadays with, with AII can't even run that
- 39:21test anymore. And I mean, the only things that
- 39:24we can really spot it with is if, if students, they forget to
- 39:28raise AI comments, like here is the list of eight points, you
- 39:33know, like, would you like me to advise?
- 39:35And, and we've had a couple of cases like that where students,
- 39:40I mean, it goes back to something to, to this thing that
- 39:43my father told me once that if you're, if you're dumb enough to
- 39:46cheat, you're so dumb, you're going to get caught.
- 39:48But I mean, but but, but but I mean, because that's just, I
- 39:55mean, well, I mean, dumb is perhaps also the wrong word here
- 39:59because it's an honest mistake. There was a case that was going
- 40:03around social media. The other days were with
- 40:06martyrs, this big Danish company, you know, on one of
- 40:12their product texts, they'd forgotten to, you know, erase
- 40:16the AI commentary. But but then again, you know
- 40:19martyrs, they have you know what the. 34 million products on
- 40:24their home page, you know, OK, they, they make a mistake once,
- 40:27you know, and people were saying, you know, this is a
- 40:29proof that made us. It's out of control there.
- 40:31They don't have processes. I would, I would say, I would
- 40:34think they have, you know, I would think that, you know, it's
- 40:38just one guy who, you know, was supposed to do a check and
- 40:41missed that one part there rather than anything else.
- 40:45But I think we're going to see a lot more of, of, of stuff like
- 40:47that from, from sort of degrading system.
- 40:50Yeah, Yeah. I mean, I mean, I think what I
- 40:56think I'd just like to interject in the final sort of to wrap
- 41:00that up is the grading has always been something that's
- 41:03been, you know, discussed, You know, what should we grade on?
- 41:07How should we grade? And so AI is coming into that,
- 41:15but you know, there was already huge debates about how to do it,
- 41:18why to do it. Should we move more to process?
- 41:21That's been the general trend over the last 50 years that we
- 41:25need to move more on to process and less on to the finished
- 41:30work. One of the interesting, one
- 41:32interesting sort of thing that I've seen is, is, is the
- 41:39Copenhagen Business School where I used to teach us an external
- 41:41lecturer. Not to be confused with the
- 41:43Business Academy of Copenhagen. They've added an assessment form
- 41:48called ongoing assessment, where basically a professor will
- 41:51assess you for your general appearance in the course, which
- 41:59is which is the the the concept that we agree upon.
- 42:03This, to be honest, honestly, I mean, I mean, they haven't, I
- 42:06mean. Don't don't misunderstand what
- 42:08I'm saying. I'm not saying they've changed
- 42:09all of the courses into that. I just say they added that as an
- 42:11option that if you have a course you can do this sort of grading.
- 42:15What I'd be really interested in is how they're ever going to
- 42:19handle complaints because A. Student has a legal right to.
- 42:24Complain. Yeah.
- 42:26So, I mean, if if I participate your course and you say I get
- 42:30the Grade 7, that's good. And I say, yeah, but why?
- 42:33Well, you know, you weren't there that day.
- 42:36Yes, I was. You just didn't notice him.
- 42:37Then it becomes very much like he said.
- 42:39He said sing. So looking forward to seeing the
- 42:42adventures there. How they end.
- 42:45Yeah. Yeah.
- 42:48It will be interesting, that's for sure.
- 42:50I mean things are changing. Change.
- 42:53It's it's good. I have been saying this so many
- 42:57times. Change is the only constant.
- 43:00Mirror exactly. I agree.
- 43:03Exactly. So I mean what?
- 43:04What? What?
- 43:06What would a machine never be able to replicate?
- 43:08I think I come back to the von Neumann theorem, where von
- 43:13Neumann, this mathematician guy who who lived a long time ago,
- 43:16he said if we can clearly define a problem, we can build a
- 43:20machine that can do that. I agree.
- 43:22I agree the. Keyword in his sentence.
- 43:24Is if so, if we are able to define, you know, a task, then I
- 43:35think a machine will be, will be able to replicate it.
- 43:39And it comes back then to sort of, you know, the debate right
- 43:42now about, you know, the term artificial intelligent is, is AI
- 43:47intelligent? And one of the reasons that this
- 43:51is being debated is we don't really have a clear definition
- 43:55of what makes us humans intelligent.
- 43:58If we believe, if we believe Marella, that our intelligence,
- 44:02intelligence works in the way that sort of, you know, based on
- 44:05your prior experiences in life, you will sort of weigh your
- 44:10different words and options and out of them choose a sentence
- 44:13and say that, well, then artificial intelligence is
- 44:17intelligence. If we believe intelligence is a
- 44:21codification and calculation of past experiences to point a way
- 44:26forward. Yeah.
- 44:28But if we define intelligence as something else, or if we define
- 44:31it as undefinable, then I think, you know, we come into a point
- 44:40where it might be possible that a machine would never be able to
- 44:47replicate it. I mean, there's, there's a
- 44:50Norwegian researcher called Ingstovska that I like to quote
- 44:54on AI and, and, and she's made the point that she believes that
- 44:58the current sort of investments in large language models is a
- 45:02dead end in terms of achieving general artificial.
- 45:06But I agree it makes sense. It has a logic, to be honest.
- 45:11Yeah, I mean, I mean. She's, I mean, this is again,
- 45:13sometimes people, they, they derive the ChatGPT as a
- 45:17stochastic parrot, you know, because it repeats words
- 45:21without, you know, understanding a meaning.
- 45:24And then, then, then, you know, we can look back in the mirror
- 45:28at ourselves and asks, well, you know, how many humans repeat
- 45:30words without understanding or reflecting, you know, so, so, so
- 45:36I think it's, it's, it's a difficult question to, to answer
- 45:41because I, I, I fundamentally, I think for Neumann was on to
- 45:45something. I think if we can, if we can
- 45:47define a problem, we can make a machine that can solve it.
- 45:50But can we, can we put creativity, critical thinking on
- 45:56a formula? If we can, we should, we will
- 45:59definitely have a machine that that will be able to, to do
- 46:03that. But what if we can't?
- 46:06And I think sort of some of sometimes when I see people, you
- 46:09know, attempting to do that, you know, the results are are weird.
- 46:14Yeah. I was listening to a guy called
- 46:18Paul Bradshaw, the other well, a couple of years back where he he
- 46:23teaches journalism. Yeah.
- 46:24And he'd built an anti bias machine where as a journalist,
- 46:28you put your article into it and then it would come up.
- 46:31And, you know, if you use the word like both immigrant, it
- 46:36would say, oh, oh, that's not the right word.
- 46:38We should say a person from who's fleeing war and climate
- 46:43change. And then he would say, my
- 46:45machine has reduced bias. How is like Paul, you know, come
- 46:50on. You simply took, took the bias
- 46:53in the article and replaced them with your own.
- 46:56I mean, a Chinese censor. He would love this system.
- 46:59Yeah. And I think sort of, you know,
- 47:04we should also be be careful about what we're trying to
- 47:07automize here. Yeah, something, I mean,
- 47:11especially sort of that statement, you know, let's try
- 47:13to automate buyers away that leads us into some interesting
- 47:19places. Yeah.
- 47:21Yeah. Well, this is.
- 47:22Such a long and wonderful, interesting discussion about
- 47:28intelligence as such, because it's so broad.
- 47:30And it should be taken from so many aspects and angles.
- 47:37But one of the things that we should who uses metacognition is
- 47:43the toughest and higher level of intelligence of such.
- 47:49And it's the ability to think upon your own thinking, right?
- 47:53So that means the ability, your ability to being aware of how
- 47:58you think and the process of your thinking, own thinking in
- 48:01order for you to take different actions and to decide
- 48:05differently in that sense. So I just make it like really
- 48:09short. It's so wonderful, it's so
- 48:11powerful and it's so simple to use and to use it in your daily
- 48:17life as well, because you can do that.
- 48:19Actually, just want to say and add something really wonderful
- 48:22in regards to what you were just talking because I think it's,
- 48:26it's really cool. So also for students to use if
- 48:29they want to, it's connected through the critical thinking.
- 48:32That's why I'm think I'm saying this.
- 48:34So it can help a lot in many ways.
- 48:37You also talk about initiative and self direction.
- 48:40How does a student stay self-directed when an algorithm
- 48:45is suggesting their next move? But by by remembering.
- 48:51A suggestion is not a direction. Yeah.
- 48:54I mean, I think part of, I mean part of thinking about thinking
- 48:58of I love the word meter. Cognition for me at least is, is
- 49:02just sort of, you know, remembering what sort of to
- 49:05accept and and what to push back on.
- 49:07Yeah, but, but, but I think sort of this is where I may also have
- 49:13a concern because my students, you know, they are aged 21.
- 49:21And I think, you know, even when I look at them, you know, are
- 49:25they ready? Are they ready for, you know,
- 49:27meta cognition? Are they ready for, I agree for,
- 49:30for being self-directed. And I think, you know, some of
- 49:36them are. I think it's very important to
- 49:39remember, you know, that, that, you know, student body in, in
- 49:41Denmark. And I think that goes even more
- 49:44so for, for, for all other countries.
- 49:45They're not a homogenic group. They they are different people
- 49:48with many really different needs.
- 49:50And I think sort of this idea that AI pushes us into the
- 49:53driver's seat, you should also remember that's that's forcing
- 49:57us into it. And and that means sort of we
- 50:00can't just say, you know, oh, you know, this ended up stupid,
- 50:02but that was because the professor said, you know, of a
- 50:04stupid process. So stupid professor, if all of
- 50:07them, I'm being forced to make decisions all the time.
- 50:10There's a risk that this will stress some students out.
- 50:12Yeah, that makes sense. Yeah, totally.
- 50:15Absolutely. And I'm.
- 50:18I mean, you know, does this mean we need to sort of go at a
- 50:21slower pace or focus in a different way?
- 50:24That's that's one of the things that I myself, you know, I'm
- 50:26thinking about these these days. How do we create a?
- 50:30Safe and secure environment for students to fail when AI makes
- 50:35it so easy to always be right. I mean, I think.
- 50:40That's one of the interesting points because some of the early
- 50:44experience with AI simulations, they suggest the students are
- 50:48really willing to fail forward in AI simulations.
- 50:53Yeah, again, coming back to this point, you know, AI has the
- 50:56potential to enhance our learning.
- 50:57It has the potential to inhibit our learning.
- 51:01And narrow AIS that simulate a specific learning situation seem
- 51:08to be a great place to have students fail because the
- 51:12students don't experience a social cost of failing in front
- 51:16of another human. It's just, you know, a dumb
- 51:18machine. So I think there's, there's
- 51:22definitely, you know, a, a point here for, for, for AI to help
- 51:30him create, you know, that space.
- 51:35And I think that that question also, you know, is a great
- 51:38reminder that AI has this this dual nature in regards to
- 51:41learning what does Augmentin? Minds look like in a daily
- 51:45routine. How do you personally use air
- 51:49without losing your own thoughts?
- 51:52Yeah. I mean, I, I well, very
- 51:56basically I remembered to put timing on my calendar for
- 51:58learning. Nice.
- 52:00I mean you, I mean I'm, I'm, I'm a, I'm a learning professional
- 52:05before I get out now. But, but it also means sort of
- 52:08that I have to be conscious about what do I want to do?
- 52:13How does My Portfolio figure together?
- 52:17And, and sometimes then, you know, I go into production mode
- 52:21and when I go into production mode, you know, then I don't
- 52:25worry too much about learning. But I have to sort of, you know,
- 52:28remember that's the that's the conscious choice.
- 52:31Yeah, I was just talking in. My last episode with Roland
- 52:34Larson about this. He's also a teacher at the via
- 52:37University in Herning. He thinks, of course, he's not
- 52:41sure, but he thinks that because of AI reading a book, my really
- 52:45decreasing like physical physical book will decrease like
- 52:49a lot. And it might be might be that
- 52:52the case. But again, as we just said right
- 52:55now, through awareness, I decide that I'm going to read books,
- 52:58physical books. So this is 11 of among other
- 53:02things that I do add in in my personal process, as you just
- 53:06mentioned yours a second ago, feel the smell highlights a
- 53:12sentence or more or even the whole book.
- 53:14It's an experience as such, like immersive experience.
- 53:17That's the whole point. It's not just digital, it's not
- 53:20just shallow or until some point, but it gives you
- 53:24something more, at least for me. Yeah, Yeah, no.
- 53:28Then then I agree and I mean, I think one of the things that I
- 53:31started doing in order to keep my learning sharp is writing
- 53:34books. So you know, that's that's the
- 53:35next stage. Maybe again, coming back to sort
- 53:41of if I have to formulate sort of what will be and what will be
- 53:44sort of a 304 hundred piece of text.
- 53:49I I have to think a lot about the topic and that's sort of one
- 53:52of the ways where where I challenge myself.
- 53:55It's a good example also. And I think, I think the death
- 53:59of the physical book has been announced for a number of
- 54:05decades now. Yeah.
- 54:06And the strange thing is there's been sort of a dual thing
- 54:10happening. Yeah, there's been, on one hand,
- 54:15there's been sort of access to information through electronic
- 54:19means, but on the other hand, modern technology also allows
- 54:24you much more easily than before to write books, to print books,
- 54:29to publish books. I mean, you want to have a, a
- 54:32great layout for your book, an AI can do a reasonable job at,
- 54:38at that. Sorry to, to the people at the
- 54:41Green Day, you know who work with that right now, who I have
- 54:44a great collaboration with. If you're watching this, you
- 54:47know, I love you and I, I hope you stay.
- 54:48But but, but, but you know, the, it, the idea.
- 54:57My, my, my point here is that the process of publishing a book
- 55:01has never been easier and it's never been cheaper.
- 55:04It used to be sort of the publishing a book, you know,
- 55:07would, would, would set you back, you know, eighty 100,000
- 55:11crowns. And now I think, you know,
- 55:13publishing a book, I mean, well, 43000 crowns.
- 55:18That's, you know, should should get you started with with a
- 55:22basic version. If you want some that looks
- 55:24really fancy, maybe doubled. So books have never been cheaper
- 55:29to produce and and give out. And I see that a lot at at
- 55:32conferences these days where any consultancy company, you know,
- 55:36they'll stand and they'll have their little, you know, leather
- 55:38bound book. You know, this is my book on how
- 55:40to make e-commerce subscriptions.
- 55:42And you know, most of what's in those books, I mean, sometimes
- 55:46they're good. The subscription book by Morton
- 55:48Hansen that just we, we have that, you know, on that.
- 55:51We use that as part of our curriculum.
- 55:53So we think that 1 is great, but but but other times, you know,
- 55:57it's been very clear that sort of, you know, the book is meant
- 56:00to be given, it's not meant to be read.
- 56:02Yeah, I agree. Yeah, Yeah, Yeah.
- 56:03I. Also, it's the one page that's.
- 56:05Important is the is the front page.
- 56:07Yeah, I get the perception. That apparently nowadays this
- 56:12became like gaining out more authority as such.
- 56:17And this is kind of the must step to do or to have whatever
- 56:21to gain that piece of authority. And I'm not saying it's wrong or
- 56:26good or whatever, because I'm not here to criticize nobody.
- 56:29I'm not interesting in that. I have other things to focus on,
- 56:33not on that, but you're reviving to rise.
- 56:37Yeah, I get it exactly. But what?
- 56:39I'm trying to say is simply that it's a tiny bit shallow for me
- 56:44as how I am and who I am and how I live my personal life and
- 56:48professional life as well. For me, if something doesn't
- 56:51have depth, it doesn't have my attention.
- 56:55The our authority as a professional, you can build.
- 56:57You can build that authority in so many ways.
- 57:00Yes, indeed, it takes so much more time to have the result as
- 57:06such, maybe to say maybe why people professionals also might
- 57:11go towards so much towards this path on as you just said, the
- 57:15writing a book. I think that this.
- 57:18This comes back to sort of one of the other points that we we
- 57:20crossed on before that AI is lowering the barriers between
- 57:25different mediums of of communication.
- 57:27So Socrates, you know, if he was allowed today and he still
- 57:31believed sort of writing his shit, well, he could do a
- 57:34podcast, you know, he could, he could do a, a motivational
- 57:39speech. He could have a camera record
- 57:42him. He could have an AI put that
- 57:44into writing. Yeah.
- 57:46And all of a sudden, you know, even if he didn't care about
- 57:49writing, but if people wanted, you know, a written product from
- 57:52him, you know, he could take one of his speeches and relatively
- 57:56easy have that transmuted into a written product.
- 58:01So I think we're going to, you know, again, AI think is going
- 58:06to lower the barriers, is going to allow us to access as
- 58:09humanity some minds that we couldn't access before.
- 58:13I mean, we're Socrates. We were bloody lucky because
- 58:15what if Plato hadn't existed? Yeah, then we would never know
- 58:19about him, as you know, we'd never know about his
- 58:24philosophical teachings. But because Plato was there and
- 58:28wrote stuff down that Socrates allegedly said, then we have his
- 58:34sinkings and and we, you know, can consider him, you know, a
- 58:39foundational piece of, of, of Western philosophical Fort.
- 58:44But if Plato hadn't been there, I think this must have happened
- 58:48throughout history. There must have been great
- 58:49thinkers, you know, who were great orators, you know, in
- 58:53their time. And everybody looked up and said
- 58:55that guy, that guy is really sharp.
- 58:56If only more people, you know, had listened to him over, but
- 59:02now we're going to get them. And I think that's the good
- 59:05news. So in terms of sort of, you
- 59:07know, books, and I mean, I don't distinguish that much between
- 59:12between physical and ebooks, but but in terms of sort of
- 59:17codifying the knowledge, capturing it, I think that's
- 59:20going to happen to a much higher degree than it ever has before.
- 59:23So if you could change. One thing about how we introduce
- 59:28AI to the next generation, what would be well, I mean my.
- 59:33Learning is right now in, in sort of in, in, in these years.
- 59:37We simply need to introduce it. Yeah.
- 59:41And we need to teach people about what is this tool?
- 59:43What does it do? And I often like when I
- 59:47introduce it, to start out simply by explaining to my
- 59:51students how the system works. Because if they listen and they
- 59:55think about what I'm saying, then they'll arrive to the
- 59:57conclusion that I just presented to you.
- 1:00:01And if you want people to really believe in something, you need
- 1:00:03to sort of, you know, give them two pieces of Lego and have them
- 1:00:06put it together themselves. Yeah, I think that that that the
- 1:00:12majority answer to. Well, the first answer to your
- 1:00:14question is basically sort of, we just need to recognize that
- 1:00:16right now, students, workers in Denmark, they don't.
- 1:00:20There's a lot of gaps in your knowledge about AI, and it needs
- 1:00:23to be explained. It needs to be explored.
- 1:00:26And it's difficult because it's a moving target, but it needs to
- 1:00:29be done. The second part of your question
- 1:00:31is use the phrase, you know, how to introduce it to the next
- 1:00:35generation. Yeah.
- 1:00:37What is the next generation? I mean, when I teach, I, I do so
- 1:00:44to young adults between the age of 18 and 30.
- 1:00:49Yeah. And I found, you know, sort of
- 1:00:52that if I, you know, tell them how to use AI, they become more
- 1:00:55proficient with that. They become proficient at
- 1:00:57learning with AI and generally I'm seeing, I'm seeing fairly
- 1:01:01good results. There's also growing evidence
- 1:01:04that when somebody tries to do what I'm doing with kids in
- 1:01:09primary school settings, you know, so age 6 to 15, it fails
- 1:01:15horribly. So there's a study by, by a guy
- 1:01:19called Kristen Dalska at the University of, of Ormus who did
- 1:01:23sort of some experience with, with children in the middle
- 1:01:26school, So 4th to, to 6th grade and, and, and he basically found
- 1:01:31they were not able to challenge the AI.
- 1:01:33They were not able to distinguish between a suggestion
- 1:01:36and a direction. It was always taking a
- 1:01:37direction. And again, strange enough, this
- 1:01:40is really similar to how kids in that age respond to adults to
- 1:01:45human teachers. You know, if, if, if in your
- 1:01:47primary school you have a teacher who tells you something
- 1:01:49that's, you know, you die as adults would look at and say
- 1:01:51that's wrong, kids won't pick up on it.
- 1:01:54They won't, they have, they won't be able to challenge it,
- 1:01:57they won't be able to push back. They won't be able to sort of
- 1:02:00understand the nuance and and AI here is similar.
- 1:02:07So, so I mean, there's also here I think and very interesting
- 1:02:10question about when do we start introducing broad AI systems to
- 1:02:17kids because because getting the learning enhancement effects
- 1:02:22from the broad models seems to be quite difficult.
- 1:02:26What is the? One digital minds and shift that
- 1:02:31will determine who thrives and who merrily survives in the next
- 1:02:355 years. Yeah, and I.
- 1:02:39Think sort of deliberate use, you know, as I like to say, sort
- 1:02:44of if if we think about AI is putting us in the driver's seat,
- 1:02:50it's something about recognizing, you know, where do
- 1:02:52I want to go? What direction do I want to set
- 1:02:55for myself? What level of expertise do I
- 1:03:00want to achieve in certain areas?
- 1:03:04And and that sort of, you know, is, is a is a daunting
- 1:03:08proposition to put to people, you know, whoa.
- 1:03:10I mean, how should I know would be the logical arts back.
- 1:03:14Yeah. But, but you need sort of to
- 1:03:15have some processes to, to, to to figure that out.
- 1:03:19And I think sort of the winners that will be the people who use
- 1:03:22AI deliberately and have awareness of how it works
- 1:03:28exactly. Thank you.
- 1:03:30Thank you. Hallelujah as a leading.
- 1:03:35As a leader that a sales pitch for the for for for your Sunday
- 1:03:38show right exactly well at the. End of the day, if AI can do the
- 1:03:47work, what is the what is left for the human being to be?
- 1:03:54That's a great philosophical question.
- 1:03:56I mean, I mean, because, I mean, what does it mean to be to start
- 1:04:03with? What did it mean before AI?
- 1:04:06So I mean, well, we're talking about now.
- 1:04:10Yeah, Yeah. And I.
- 1:04:11Think, but I think sort of the the answer is much the same as
- 1:04:14before. I need what it means to to be is
- 1:04:20is one of the great questions. I mean, essentially we're coming
- 1:04:23back to the meaning of life. Yeah.
- 1:04:25Some of the things that that the research has pointed to is, is
- 1:04:31something like, you know, if you believe that happiness is a
- 1:04:33goal. Yeah.
- 1:04:34Well, then having meaningful relations seems to be the key to
- 1:04:40happiness. Yeah.
- 1:04:43But then again, you can argue the point of life is something
- 1:04:46else than individual happiness. Yeah, that's classical.
- 1:04:49That's a classical Western approach.
- 1:04:50Yeah. I think we should all be happy.
- 1:04:52Yeah, because it also leads us down some, some, some, some,
- 1:04:57some interesting places. I mean, the the one key life
- 1:05:00event that can make you more unhappy, much more unhappy than
- 1:05:03anything else in life. That's having a kid,
- 1:05:08statistically speaking. I love my kids.
- 1:05:10But, you know, I mean, I hope everyone does love their kids.
- 1:05:14But but but statistic people just become unhappy when they
- 1:05:17get kids. The the strange thing is the the
- 1:05:20single thing that if we don't do nothing.
- 1:05:23Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:05:25Well, the way you do it. So that's why you're laughing.
- 1:05:27But but, but, but, but, Varela, just to finish it off.
- 1:05:32Then then happiness research points to the single life event
- 1:05:34that will make you the most happy.
- 1:05:36That's having grandkids, OK. But.
- 1:05:40You see, you can't really get to 1 without the other.
- 1:05:42So, you know, if we prioritize again, you know, I was coming
- 1:05:45off from your question of, you know, what's left for human to
- 1:05:48be. And I mean, if we say the point
- 1:05:50is happy, you know, that leads to some interesting places.
- 1:05:53But yeah. Yeah.
- 1:05:55But I think sort of, you know, I mean, we've been pushed into
- 1:05:58this. We cannot undo technological
- 1:06:01process. Thank you.
- 1:06:02Exactly. So I think it's simply you need
- 1:06:07to realize that you need to make some decisions about sort of do
- 1:06:12something because anyway it. Will be here I mean.
- 1:06:16But I think also this is different for, for, for
- 1:06:18different professions. I mean, a, a gardener would look
- 1:06:23at this in one way, a knowledge worker like me, an educator, you
- 1:06:30know, I'm, I'm, I'm, I think in many ways much more rapidly and
- 1:06:34more directly exposed than somebody working with a more
- 1:06:39manual piece of labour right now.
- 1:06:44That may change. Yeah.
- 1:06:46But I think sort of, you know, the, the, but the basic, the
- 1:06:50basic question that sort of, you know, this poses to a gardener
- 1:06:54or to a professor is, is, is the same sort of, you have to sort
- 1:06:59of decide what you want and, and try to go for that.
- 1:07:06And I mean, I'm a little bit sort of unsure about the, you
- 1:07:11know, American self help coaches, the Tony Robbins of
- 1:07:15this world to say, you know, just, you know, set a clear
- 1:07:18goal. Is it?
- 1:07:19I agree with you. I have to be honest.
- 1:07:21Honestly, yeah, yeah, not because I mean, for me it's.
- 1:07:25More the dialogue about the goal that that's the important part,
- 1:07:30rather than sort of, you know, the actual goal that you come up
- 1:07:35with. It's the process exactly.
- 1:07:37Makes so much sense. Definitely.
- 1:07:39And I I mean. I think, you know, there's also
- 1:07:41something back here about not being, not being afraid of it.
- 1:07:45I yeah, I, I was, I was going on a walk with my my youngest son
- 1:07:50the other day and we saw a kid who was, who was even younger.
- 1:07:54He was maybe 4 years old. And he was in one of these
- 1:07:56running bikes, you know, two wheels, but no pedals, right.
- 1:07:59So he's using his legs, you know, and this little kid, he
- 1:08:02was running really fast and you could see the joy in his face.
- 1:08:04Yeah. You can see how happy he was.
- 1:08:06You can see he was like, oh, I'm going faster than I've ever gone
- 1:08:09before. Wow.
- 1:08:09This is great. But I mean, that's us humans and
- 1:08:14technology for you right there in, in a nutshell.
- 1:08:18I mean, we are as humans, we are effectively cyborgs in the sense
- 1:08:23that we are able to take a lot of different technologies and
- 1:08:26seamlessly integrated into a process.
- 1:08:29If you take a pen and paper, you start writing down process,
- 1:08:31you're integrating the pen and the paper into your sinking
- 1:08:34process. And, and, and we've been doing
- 1:08:38that for, for millennials and, and, and I think, you know, if
- 1:08:43we come back to sort of that question of why, why does humans
- 1:08:45end up becoming the dominant species on, on, on this planet
- 1:08:49as well? You know, probably because of
- 1:08:51our ability to that. And AI is, is the logical next
- 1:08:54step in, in that evolution where we integrated into ourselves.
- 1:09:00But as I think your question carries the point of it, it's
- 1:09:03important to to do so, you know, with care and to not forget who
- 1:09:09we are. Yeah, definitely absolutely
- 1:09:12agree. One last question, promise this
- 1:09:16section, I call it a note to your past self ritual.
- 1:09:20If you could go back and say something really strong and
- 1:09:26important to your younger version of yourself, what will
- 1:09:29will be the first thing that? Came back to my mind is I would
- 1:09:33like to go five years back and and find my younger self and
- 1:09:38say, listen, that hunch you had about getting into AI do it.
- 1:09:43So I mean, it's sorry, it's an easy choice, right but but, but,
- 1:09:47but that was the first thing that came to mind.
- 1:09:48I think it's been a fantastic interesting subject to get into.
- 1:09:56I think it's one where there's a lot of attention right now, and
- 1:10:00I think I can I can safely say that it's one where there
- 1:10:05actually should be even more. There are so many reasons I
- 1:10:07agree with. You here well I mean and I mean.
- 1:10:10We just had a election to the Danish parliament.
- 1:10:13Yeah. And, and AI was missing.
- 1:10:16It was not a topic. I mean, the, the different
- 1:10:18politicians they were presenting, they were pretending
- 1:10:20it didn't exist, basically. Seriously, I didn't know that
- 1:10:23part. Of that I mean, you had you.
- 1:10:25Had debates about should we have a new tax to tax the rich even
- 1:10:29more? Should we have, you know, do
- 1:10:32something about pesticides? That was some of the big topics,
- 1:10:37but not the EI. Though the the one guy.
- 1:10:40Who mentioned it was one on a fringe right party?
- 1:10:43And I mean, which just seems weird and, and I think sort of
- 1:10:49Denmark has traditionally prided itself of being, you know, the
- 1:10:52Uber digitalists exactly through digitalization.
- 1:10:56Saw an overview once of. Of the different European
- 1:10:58countries about how they were using digitalization within the
- 1:11:04legal system. And there was one European
- 1:11:07country that whenever people they've been sentenced you know,
- 1:11:10and they were supposed to serve time in prison, they sent out an
- 1:11:13e-mail or well, you know, the Danish E box system, you know,
- 1:11:17summoning people saying, you know, you need to show up at
- 1:11:20this prison that there was 1 country who did it
- 1:11:22electronically 1 you you can guess which one right?
- 1:11:27And, and there's also, and, and you can also guess which prob
- 1:11:30which country had the biggest problem of people not showing up
- 1:11:35to serve time in prison when they were summoned in country.
- 1:11:39Yeah. And, and I think sort of, you
- 1:11:41know, we, we've been digitizing a lot of places in Denmark with
- 1:11:44that sort of stuffing up and reflecting doesn't make sense.
- 1:11:47But the interesting thing is with AI it it seems we're not
- 1:11:52going fast. Yeah, I noticed.
- 1:11:55I had this perception probably I'm just supposing here, of
- 1:11:59course, because I don't have the data.
- 1:12:00So I really don't have the research as such.
- 1:12:03But just supposing that because Danny Mark always have been so
- 1:12:08digitalized as such as a country.
- 1:12:10And as you just said, like the literally 2 seconds ago,
- 1:12:13everything was so digitalized. Like literally 95% of my phone
- 1:12:19are apps while I'm living in Denmark.
- 1:12:22I just think probably it's kind of people that still have this
- 1:12:26feeling perception slash mindset.
- 1:12:29Probably that is always just something that we do regularly
- 1:12:34or usually in that sense. And probably they still stay in
- 1:12:39that perception. But again, we return to our main
- 1:12:43focus. AI is going so damn fast.
- 1:12:46And if you don't upgrade the systems, then you risk to kind
- 1:12:51of stay behind of the wheel. Yes, we have to get to the end
- 1:12:56of it. Thank you so, so very much for
- 1:12:58your time and willing to share with us so many important
- 1:13:01information regarding AI education students.
- 1:13:05Thank you so very much. It means a lot to me.
- 1:13:08Oh, thank you for having me. You're welcome.
- 1:13:11What a profound conversation with Used.
- 1:13:14If there's one thing to take away from today is that while AI
- 1:13:18can skip the doing, we must never let it skip the thinking.
- 1:13:21As we move forward into this automatic age, let's remember
- 1:13:25that our greatest asset isn't the speed of our prompts, but
- 1:13:29the death of our critical inquiry.
- 1:13:32If you want to reach out to Used, you can find him on
- 1:13:35LinkedIn Used, Kega Patterson. Please Super Rewire to write by
- 1:13:40subscribing to the channel. It will mean a lot to me.
- 1:13:43Until next time, stay sharp.